POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Regular Meeting

Wednesday, September 18, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 74,975 characters. The full document is at the source.

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; 2) experts who testified during quasi-judicial hearings were accepted as qualified to do so in their respective fields of expertise; and 3) added attachments are referenced in red as “ADDED ATTACHMENT”. 1) CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL City Council Members Present Teresa Heitmann, Mayor Terry Hutchison, Vice Mayor Staff Present: Jay Boodheshwar, City Manager Matthew McConnell, City Attorney Patricia Rambosk, City Clerk Gary Young, Deputy City Manager/CFO Leslee Dulmer, Deputy Planning Director Stephen Beckman, Director of Building Services Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director Natalie Hardman, Natural Resources Manager Others Present: David Wildman Sofia Christodoulou Alexander Hill Mary Doveas-Pitzi Anna Christodoulou Richard Schroeder Charles Work Scott Kiley Ashley Jenkins Wendie Aston Jay Kohlhagen Rob Stoneburner Garey Cooper Ana Payero Patrick Hill Stravroula Stacy Kostoulas Clay Brooker Mark McLean Norman Trebilcock Carl Barraco Greg Myers Berne Barton Ray Christman Bill Kramer Linda Penniman Beth Petrunoff Assistant City Attorney Ralf Brookes Erica Martin, Planning Director Dan Ohrenstein, City Engineer Jessica Hernandez, Deputy City Clerk Jessica Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Alison Bickett, Deputy City Engineer Ed Bliss, Plans Review Engineer Ciro Dominquez, Police Chief George A. Helm, III Charissa Dines Christian Andrea Andrew Rath James Frazitta Peter Carroll Jenna Heiderman Robert Schiff Dan Lennon Blake Benjamin Sean Mayo Jaye Semrod Allen Keller Charles Brown Jr. John Allen Nancy Carlson Jeff Hardigan Alberto Castellon Liliana Maguire Tom Fillingim Ken Crooker

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 2 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 2) INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE David Wildman, Pastor at Grow Church, gave an invocation. Council Member Petrunoff subsequently led in the Pledge of Allegiance. 3) SET AGENDA City Manager Jay Boodheshwar announced Time Certain Item 13.J (Executive Session for DiMaria, Peter v. City of Naples, Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims, OJCC Case Number 11-00212FJC) at 12:30 p.m. He noted that Item 12.A would be considered immediately following Item 13.J and that a corrected Resolution had been distributed in advance of the meeting that day for Item 7.B. City Manager Boodheshwar noted that following the publishing of the agenda, staff subsequently received additional correspondence for Items 11.A and 11.B, and that a motion would be necessary to add them to the meeting record when each item is heard. MOTION by Christman to SET AGENDA subject to accepting corrected Resolution for Item 7.B and considering Item 12.A immediately after Time Certain Item 13.J; seconded by Petrunoff and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 4) ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS City Manager Jay Boodheshwar announced that Former Police Chief Gary Young, who served in the Police Department from 1963 through 1979, had passed away the previous day. He offered condolences to Mr. Young’s family and Mayor Heitmann subsequently offered a moment of silence. 5) PUBLIC COMMENTS Public Comment: The following individuals urged for the removal of Sodium Fluoride from the City’s drinking water: Sofia Christodoulou; Alexander Hill; Mary Doveas-Pitzi and Anna Christodoulou ceded their time to Richard Schroeder, who also urged City Council to approve and adopt a Healthcare Freedom Resolution and Healthcare Freedom Bill of Rights Ordinance similar to Collier County. Wendie Aston; Jay Kohlhagen; Ana Payero; Parick Hill; Stravroula Stacy Kostoulas; and Scott Kiley and Ashley Jenkins also expressed support for a Healthcare Freedom Resolution and Healthcare Freedom Bill of Rights Ordinance. Mayor Heitmann noted that City Council had an item on an upcoming agenda to discuss water quality and said that the contents in the City’s drinking water would be discussed at that time. Charles Work introduced himself as a democratic candidate for the Florida State House of Representatives District 81. He stated that, if elected, he would advocate for Home Rule, environmental issues such as water quality and availability, insurance reform, and the restoration of women’s reproductive rights. Rob Stoneburner, member of the North Naples Rotary Club, informed the City Council that the Naples Crab Beer Fest had raised over $112,000 for charity, bringing the events total donations to $800,000 since its inception in 2012. He noted that the events 2025 application would soon be presented for the Councils consideration and encouraged approval of it. Garey Cooper advocated for the continuation of the Naples Youth Council, noting that the teacher who previously led the program had recently retired. In response, City Manager Jay Boodheshwar confirmed that the Naples Youth Council program would continue, and a new teacher had been assigned to lead it. He also noted that he met with the President of the Youth Council to discuss expanding the program to include legislative processes and initiatives. Additionally, he said the Youth Council expressed interest in assisting the City Council in advocating for Home Rule, including participating in a visit to Tallahassee. Handout (S. Kiley/Added Attachment) APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA MOTION by Christman to APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA; seconded by Petrunoff and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 3 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff- yes, Heitmann-yes). 6) MINUTES 6.A) Approval of the August 19, 2024, Workshop Meeting Minutes, the August 21, 2024, Regular Meeting Minutes, and the September 4, 2024, Special (Budget) Meeting Minutes. Agenda Memorandum August 19, 2024 Workshop Meeting Minutes August 21, 2024 Regular Meeting Minutes September 4, 2024 Special (Budget) Meeting Minutes 7) RESOLUTIONS 7.A) RESOLUTION 2024-15451 - A Resolution Approving the Fourth Amendment to the Agreement for Purchase and Sale of Goods Between The City of Naples and Motorola Solutions, Inc. for Maintenance and Support Services for the Premierone Records System for the Period Beginning October 1, 2024 and Ending September 30, 2027, in the Amount of $172,998; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Fourth Amendment to Agreement and Purchase Order Therefore; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution Motorola 4th Amendment - 08-03 FY25 PA CC B waiver 4th Amend Sec Maint Support Agreem No. 1394 Motorola NPD_09-04-24 Motorola Agreement Renewal 2024-27 Motorola 3rd Amendment 9-27-2021 Motorola 2nd Amendment 9-05-2018 Motorola 1st Amendment 12-21-2016 Motorola Original Agreement 2015 7.B) RESOLUTION 2024-15452 - A Resolution Waiving Competitive Bidding; Approving a Purchase Order to Motorola Solutions for 12 Vigilant License Plate Recognition Cameras, Mounting Hardware, and Camera Licensing, Utilizing Sourcewell Contract 101223 as a Cooperative Purchase in the Amount of $150,987.34; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Purchase Order; and Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution Piggyback Agreement Motorola Naples PD L5F Fixed Sites Proposal Prop. Opening Record-Public Safety Surveillance 101223 Cooperative Purchasing Request Form - Motorola Motorola Contract 101223 Motorola 101223-MOT Pricing Doc Comment and Review-Public Safety Surveillance 101223 Board Resolutions Proof of Publication-Public Safety Surveillance 101223 Prop. Eval.-Public Safety Surveillance 101223 Corrected Resolution (Staff/Added Attachment) 7.C) RESOLUTION 2024-15453 - A Resolution Approving an Agreement Between The City of Naples and Safeware, Inc. in the Amount of $29,095 for the Purchase of A Skydio X 10 Suas Aircraft; Waiving Competitive Bids and Utilizing Omnia Contract No. 4400008468; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Agreement; And Providing an Effective Date. Title of Resolution not read. Agenda Memorandum Resolution Vendor Piggyback Agreement Safeware Quotation 8) OTHER 8.A) CLERK TRACKING 2024-00105 - Approve an Extension of the Fourth Amendment to Interlocal Agreement Between Collier County and the City of Naples Governing the Use of City of Naples Beach Parking Facilities and Parks and Recreation Programs Extending the Expiration to September 30, 2025.

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 4 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Agenda Memorandum Extension to Fourth Amendment to Interlocal Agreement Original Interlocal Agreement - CON Beach Parking First Amendment to Interlocal Agreement Second Amendment to Interlocal Agreement Third Amendment to Interlocal Agreement Fourth Amendment to Interlocal Agreement END OF CONSENT AGENDA 9) PUBLIC HEARINGS None. REGULAR AGENDA 10) ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT AGENDA None. 11) LAND USE MATTERS 11.A) RESOLUTION 2024-15454 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Site Plan Petition 22-SP21 for the Development of Naples Square Encore, a New Three-Story Mixed-Use Development on Tract C-2 of the Naples Square Planned Development on Property Owned by WSR Naples Square Commercial, LLC., A Florida Limited Liability Company and Located at 192 Goodlette-Frank Road, More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Penniman / familiar with the site but had not had contact; Barton / familiar with the site and had contact with the petitioner and the President of the Homeowners’ Association; Christman / familiar with the site, had a conversation with a representative of the Homeowners’ Association, watched the pertinent Planning Advisory Board (PAB) Meeting, and received numerous emails; Kramer / familiar with the site and watched the pertinent PAB Meeting; Petrunoff / familiar with the site, met with a couple of residents of Naples Square, spoke with the petitioner, watched the pertinent PAB Meeting, and visited the site after several rain events to observe conditions; Hutchison / familiar with the site, received emails, had spoken with residents about the matter but had not had contact with the petitioner, and said he would keep an open mind; and Heitmann / familiar with the site but had not had contact with the petitioner’s agent, and read emails that were received. City Attorney McConnell stated that several communications and documents had been received by staff after the agenda was published and asked whether City Council wished to include them in the meeting record for that day. MOTION by Petrunoff to INCLUDE additional correspondence received by staff after the publication of the agenda until 8:30 a.m. that day in the meeting record; seconded by Hutchison and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Clay Brooker, Attorney at Cheffy Passidomo, P.A., reminded City Council that this item had been continued from the August 21, 2024 City Council Regular Meeting. He stated that he represented WSR Naples Square Commercial, LLC, in a request for Site Plan approval for the development of a mixed-use building within the Naples Square Planned Development (PD) on property located at 192 Goodlette-Frank Road and named the Encore. He utilized an electronic presentation to provide a historical background, and an overview of the prior Site Plan approval under Resolution

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 5 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 2021-14639. Attorney Brooker explained that the petitioner sought to revise the original plan by reducing the commercial intensity, removing the proposed restaurant and outdoor dining uses, decreasing the commercial square footage by approximately 60 percent, and lowering the building height. Additionally, he stated the petitioner would prohibit any restaurant requiring a grease trap or commercial oven. He noted that the revised Site Plan, while only requiring 51 parking spaces by Code, would provide 67 spaces. Mark McLean, National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to review the proposed plans which included an overall Site Plan of the Naples Square PD, parking accommodations for the entire PD as well as the proposed project, first floor plans for the proposed commercial space, second and third floor plans for the proposed residential units, a roof plan, elevation plans, various three dimensional renderings, aerial images, and a waste management plan. Norman Trebilcock, President and Traffic Engineer at Trebilcock Consulting Solutions, presented the Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) covering background traffic, trip generation for the PD’s existing and proposed developments, the current and future adjacent roadway network, and peak season as well as ante meridiem and post meridiem traffic conditions. He also reviewed intersection traffic volumes and capacity analyses. Traffic Engineer Trebilcock stated that the traffic analysis for intersections along 3rd Avenue South showed that all vehicular movements would operate at an acceptable Level of Service (LOS), both with and without the traffic generated by the project, and that turn lane improvements were not recommended at the project access points. Carl Barraco, Engineer at Barraco and Associates, Inc., continued the presentation to review the Stormwater Master Plan. He said the proposed Plan satisfies City and Southwest Florida Water Management District stormwater requirements. He noted that he had visited the site after a significant rainfall event in June of that year and observed that the entire Naples Square development functioned as designed, with no flooding or standing water on the site. Christian Andrea, Landscape Architect at Architectural Land Design, reviewed the proposed Landscape Plan, noting that over 50 plant species would be installed to complement the building and linear park located along Naples Square. In response to Council Member Christman, Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer stated that the linear park was part of a required easement located over the Linear Public Park Easement Area adjacent to Goodlette-Frank Road, when the PD was approved, and that it was later expanded north and south from 1st Avenue South to 5th Avenue South. In response to Mayor Heitmann, Attorney Brooker confirmed that the easement had already been dedicated to the City, and that Naples Square is responsible for its maintenance and repair. In response to Council Member Christman, Architect McLean said the linear park provides approximately nine percent of open space. Council Member Christman noted that several residents had raised concerns regarding the lack of green space and asked whether the petitioner had considered exceeding the minimum lot requirements. In response, Attorney Brooker said there are no maximum lot coverage requirements beyond setback requirements, in which the proposed building adheres to the required setbacks. Council Member Petrunoff inquired how the project aligns with the Comprehensive Plan’s Future Land Use Element (FLUE) policies regarding green space. Attorney Brooker responded that the FLUE policies were considered during the creation of the PD, and the proposed project complies with the original PD approval. Architect McLean confirmed to Council Member Christman that the sidewalk along 12th Street South would not be reduced in width. Additionally, Architect McLean clarified to Mayor Heitmann that the sidewalk would be made of pavers, with the owner responsible for maintaining the portion from the building to the linear park, while Naples Square would maintain the portion considered part of the linear park. In response to Council Member Christman, Architect McLean confirmed that a total of 860 parking spaces are required for the entire PD and that 863 would be provided upon completion. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Architect McLean confirmed that the Naples Square PD does

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 6 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. not draw from the parking pool that is part of the D-Downtown’s on-street parking program but instead meets its requirements within the PD itself. Attorney Brooker clarified that the project does not rely on any spaces from the Citys forthcoming 1st Avenue South Parking Garage. Architect McLean also clarified that the building’s parking garage includes exclusive access to dedicated parking spaces for residential units. He then utilized the first-floor plan to illustrate the designated public parking areas. Vice Mayor Hutchison and Mayor Heitmann raised concerns about potential traffic congestion with the upcoming opening of the Gulfshore Playhouse, particularly at the intersection of 3rd Avenue South and Goodlette-Frank Road. Traffic Engineer Trebilcock stated that there were no plans to install a traffic light at the 1st Avenue South and 12th Street South roundabout but noted that directional changes would be implemented with alternative routes available. He also highlighted the Citys plan to upgrade existing roundabouts, which would increase capacity and improve pedestrian traffic flow. Vice Mayor Hutchison argued that drivers would likely turn onto 1st Avenue South to access the parking garage, leading to traffic stacking on Goodlette-Frank Road. Traffic Engineer Trebilcock responded by noting that the Gulfshore Playhouse traffic study had already been incorporated into the project’s analysis. Attorney Brooker emphasized that it would be unfair to hold the current project responsible for the traffic impact of the Gulfshore Playhouse, which had been approved by the City Council with knowledge of its traffic generation as well as the full build-out of the subject project. He assured that the LOS for the Citys roadways would be maintained. Architect McLean added that the traffic study for the Gulfshore Playhouse included 17,000 square feet of commercial and restaurant space, which has since been reduced to 6,825 square feet of retail and office space in the current proposal, resulting in less traffic than initially anticipated. Traffic Engineer Trebilcock then reviewed Section II of the TIS, outlining peak hour and peak season traffic conditions for the project and comparing them to the Gulfshore Playhouse traffic study. Council Member Barton asserted that the traffic generated by the proposed project would be minimal, with the Gulfshore Playhouse being the primary contributor to traffic in the area. He agreed that the reduction in commercial space in the current proposal improved previously anticipated traffic conditions. In response to Mayor Heitmann, Attorney Brooker explained that 12th Avenue South was privately owned before the approval of the Gulfshore Playhouse. However, the City Council requested that the owner grant an easement over the avenue to allow public access to the Playhouse. Attorney Brooker confirmed that the Naples Square Property Homeowners’ Association is responsible for maintaining the easement, and the agreement requires maintenance to meet or exceed the City’s LOS standards. Council Member Petrunoff expressed concern about the potential negative impact of traffic on residential areas. Attorney Brooker explained that the mixed-use zoning supports both business and residential uses, emphasizing that these uses are designed to complement and support each other within the development. Vice Mayor Hutchison raised concerns about flooding issues during rain events, particularly along 10th Street South. Engineer Barraco assured that stormwater runoff from the new development would not contribute to these flooding problems, as all stormwater would be retained onsite, treated, and discharged at a controlled rate in accordance with the City’s stormwater requirements. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Engineer Barraco confirmed that a water pump is not planned for the project. Council Member Barton argued that the new development would improve current flooding conditions by upgrading the property’s stormwater system. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Attorney Brooker stated that the petitioner had agreed to prohibit any restaurant requiring a grease trap but requested flexibility to allow a less intense use, such as a coffee shop.

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 7 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Recess: 11:09 a.m. to 11:25 a.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. Council Members made ex parte disclosures, stating they had nothing additional to disclose, except for Vice Mayor Hutchison, who noted that he had a conversation with Greg Myers during recess, during which Mr. Myers expressed concern that the City had not complied with the Code’s LOS annual reporting requirements since 2016 and emphasized that those requirements must be addressed before the Council could make a decision on the matter. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer reviewed the staff report, which covered the background of the PD, including the dedication and expansion of the linear park easement, an overview of the proposed project, and changes made to the original development plan. She also addressed parking regulations, staffs analysis, review, and sufficiency letter, as well as the Design Review Board (DRB) and PAB reviews of the petition, noting that the PAB recommended denial. Deputy Planning Director Dulmer then reviewed staff’s proposed conditions of approval outlined in the Resolution, offering a modification to Condition One to include language prohibiting grease traps and to allow restaurant uses similar to a coffee shop. In response to Council Member Christman, Deputy Planning Director Dulmer confirmed that staff found the petition to be sufficient with the standards and criteria of approval pursuant to Section 46-33(g) of the Land Development Code and Section IX of the Naples Square PD (Ordinance 2021-14658), subject to staff’s recommended conditions. Throughout the discussion, City Attorney McConnell, Planning Director Erica Martin, and Deputy Planning Director Dulmer responded to questions concerning allowable uses and maintenance of the linear park, the 12th Avenue South access easement, amendments made to the PD, parking standards and calculations, Comprehensive Plan policies, LOS criteria and annual reporting and permitted uses for the commercial space. In response to Council Member Penniman, Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett provided a history of the existing roundabouts, noting that they were installed before current standards were introduced. She explained that in 2021, staff met with the developer and Naples Square residents to discuss potential modifications and improvements. She said based on feedback, staff worked with Traffic Engineer Trebilcock to develop a conceptual design focused on improving pedestrian access and traffic flow, though the cost and proportionate cost share between the City and the developer had not yet been determined. Deputy City Engineer Bickett also stated that staff would collaborate with residents before finalizing project plans. She confirmed that the developer expressed interest in contributing to a crosswalk installation across Goodlette-Frank Road, as requested by Naples Square residents. City Engineer Dan Ohrenstein further confirmed that staffs analysis determined that the City’s adopted LOS for the roadway syst em and intersections would be maintained. Plans Review Engineer Ed Bliss responded to questions regarding the City’s review of the proposed stormwater management plan. He said the project does not meet the current stormwater Code, but it did meet the Code’s stormwater regulations at the time the PD was approved. However, later in the discussion, Engineer Barraco, contended that the project does meet current Code requirements and said that Mr. Bliss may not have reviewed the most recent additions to the system or the reduction in commercial space. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Plans Review Engineer Bliss confirmed that the impervious area had not increased with the expansion of the linear park. In response to Vice Chair Hutchison, City Attorney McConnell clarified that the PD would need to comply with current Code requirements if it were amended, as this would require the PD to be rezoned. However, he confirmed that the PD was not being amended at this time and that only the site plan for the Encore project was under consideration.

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 8 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Public Comment: Tom Fillingim President of Naples Square Condominium Association Building No. Three and Naples Square Property Homeowners’ Master Association, stated that he had met with the petitioner’s representatives to discuss developing a stormwater maintenance plan to ensure the property remains in pristine condition and the system functions properly. He acknowledged that the HOA is aware of its responsibility for the linear park and noted that the four buildings have a shared agreement and budget for maintaining the park. Mr. Fillingim said he was unaware of the proposed changes to the roundabouts and expressed opposition to such changes. Instead, he suggested installing crosswalks and speed bumps near the roundabouts and opposed any modifications that would involve tearing up landscaping or sidewalks. Greg Myers (sworn separately) said the entire PD should be amended and that the City is required to update its LOS standards on an annual basis prior to approving any new project. Liliana Maguire was not present when called. Council Member Kramer expressed support for the project in its entirety. He explained that during the PAB review, a member had made a motion to continue the petition, but that motion failed, leading to the PABs denial of the petition. Council Member Kramer outlined some of the reasons provided by PAB members for the denial and questioned whether those reasons would hold up in court. He noted that the petitioner had agreed to pay a proportionate share of the conceptual roundabout improvements, considering it a responsible condition. Council Member Kramer then proffered a motion to approve the Resolution, but further discussion ensued. Mayor Heitmann expressed the view that the project does not meet LOS standards, noting that the City had not updated them on an annual basis. She also argued that the project did not comply with the Future Land Use Element policies regarding green space and raised concerns about parking, density, intensity, and the evolution of the PD, stating that the project does not align with the Citys char acter or vision. Vice Mayor Hutchison and Council Member Petrunoff also voiced opposition to the proposed project, highlighting discrepancies between staff and the petitioner’s analysis regarding whether the project met current stormwater requirements, as well as expressing the view that the petition did not comply with the Comprehensive Plan in several areas. Council Member Christman reiterated staff’s analysis that the project meets the required standards of approval. He asserted that the absence of an updated LOS report does not mean the Council has failed in its responsibility to maintain LOS. Council Member Christman cautioned against denying the petition solely due to the lack of an updated LOS, suggesting that if that were the basis, all projects would need to be denied. He asserted that the project would be the least intense portion within the PD. Council Member Christman recommended adding a condition requiring the petitioner to demonstrate compliance with current stormwater requirements before a building permit is issued. Council Member Kramer amended his motion as reflected below and Council Member Christman seconded the motion. MOTION by Kramer to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15454 subject to the following changes: 1) amending Condition No. 1 to prohibit any business requiring a grease trap(s) and/or restaurants with outdoor dining; 2) amending Condition No. 3 to require an appropriate pedestrian crosswalk to be installed at or near the roundabouts; 3) amending Condition No. 4 to require the petitioner to pay a proportionate share; and 4) adding a condition to read as follows: "At the time of permitting, the petitioner will provide the necessary details to demonstrate that the stormwater system complies with the current stormwater regulations.". Motion seconded by Christman and carried 4-3, all members present and voting (Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Petrunoff-no, Penniman-yes, Hutchison-no, Heitmann-no). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Staff Report Application Deed Disclosure of Interest Survey Overall Site Plan Unit Allocation Site Plan Architectural Plans Landscape Plans Civil Plans TIS Section 1

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 9 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. TIS Section 2 Vehicle Tracking Exhibit Crosswalk Exhibit EOPC Goodlette Crosswalk ERP No 11-103253-P (Application No 221027-36409) Solid Waste & Recyclable Refuse Generation Calculations Commercial North Plat Letter of Sufficiency Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting - PAB 6.26.24 Affidavit of Sign Posting - Council 8.21.24 Affidavit of Sign Posting - Council 9.18.24 Correspondence thru 8.6.24 Petitioner Presentation 1 of 2 Petitioner Presentation 2 of 2 Correspondence (Staff/Added Attachment) 13.J) Executive Session DiMaria, Peter v. City of Naples, Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims, OJCC Case Number 11-00212FJC. City Attorney Matthew McConnell announced that City Council would enter into Executive Session to discuss settlement negotiations or strategy related to litigation regarding Executive Session DiMaria, Peter v. City of Naples, Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims, OJCC Case Number 11-00212FJC. The following individuals were in attendance during the Executive Session: Mayor Heitmann, Vice Mayor Hutchison; City Council Members Barton, Christman, Kramer, Penniman, and Petrunoff; City Manager Jay Boodheshwar; City Attorney Matthew McConnell; Assistant City Attorney Ralf Brookes; Attorney George A. Helm, III; and Charissa Dines from Dines Court Reporting. Executive Session from 1:44 p.m. to 2:26 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. Agenda Memorandum Public Notice 13.K) Any Action Needed Following the Executive Session DiMaria, Peter v. City of Naples, Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims, OJCC Case Number 11-00212FJC. No action was announced. 13) NEW BUSINESS 13.A) CLERK TRACKING 2024-00105, 2024-00106, 2024-00109 - Consider Appointing One Director to the Carver Finance Board of Directors, Two Members to the Code Enforcement Board, One Alternate Member to the Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Board, One Member to the Moorings Bay Citizens Advisory Committee, and Recommending One Member for Appointment to the Collier County Contractor’s Licensing Board. City Clerk Patricia Rambosk overviewed the agenda memorandum for the City Council’s consideration of appointing one director to the Carver Finance Board of Directors, two members to the Code Enforcement Board, one alternate member to the Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Board, and one member to the Moorings Bay Citizens Advisory Committee. City Clerk Rambosk noted that City Council would not recommend appointing a member for appointment to the Collier County Contractor’s Licensing Board that day since one applicant had withdrawn and the remaining applicant was unable to attend the September 16, 2024 Workshop Meeting to be interviewed. City Clerk Rambosk then reminded City Council that interviews for current member Martin Lamb and new applicant Lee Davidson for the Carver Finance Board of Directors were held during the Workshop meeting that week. Following a brief discussion, Council Members thereby completed their ballots, after which City Clerk Rambosk reviewed the rankings for the record and announced the results of the final ballot. The following motion was proffered. MOTION by Petrunoff to APPOINT Martin Lamb to the Carver Finance Board of Directors for a three-year term commencing September 15, 2024 and expiring September 14, 2027; seconded by Christman and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). City Clerk Rambosk then reviewed the applicants for the two vacancies on the Code Enforcement Board, noting that City Council had interviewed current member Steven Greenwald and new applicant Lee Davidson. During the discussion, Mayor Heitmann raised concerns about a

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 10 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. potential conflict of interest with Mr. Davidson serving on the Board, as he is employed by Davidson Engineering and may serve as the assistant project manager for the Naples Beach Hotel (Four Seasons Hotel). Following further discussion, the City Council agreed to table one of the two appointments and seek clarification from the Ethics Director Michael Murawski on the matter. MOTION by Christman to APPOINT Steven Greenwald to the Code Enforcement Board for a three-year term commencing September 19, 2024 and expiring September 18, 2027; seconded by Barton and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). City Clerk Rambosk then reviewed the applicants for the Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Board (CRAAB), noting that City Council had interviewed new applicants Lee Davidson and Christopher Shucart. During the discussion, City Council agreed that clarification was needed to determine whether there could be a conflict of interest with Mr. Davidson serving on either board. Council Member Petrunoff raised concerns about recent code compliance issues related to Mr. Shucart’s business property and expressed the view that these matters should be resolved before he seeks appointment. Following the discussion, City Council agreed to table the appointment and reached the following consensus. Consensus reached to continue the appointment of an alternate member to the CRAAB following an opinion from the Ethics Commission as to whether there would be a conflict of interest for Lee Davidson and to readvertise the vacancy. City Clerk Rambosk noted that the City Council had interviewed current member Bill Broderick for the Moorings Bay Citizens Advisory Committee. Following a brief discussion, the following motion was proffered. MOTION by Petrunoff to APOINT Bill Broderick to the Moorings Bay Citizens Advisory Committee for a three-year term commencing October 6, 2024 and expiring October 5, 2027; seconded by Kramer and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Carver Finance Board - Lee Davidson Application Carver Finance Board - Martin Lamb Application Carver resolution 1980-3514 Code Enforcement - Lee Davidson Application Code Enforcement - Steven Greenwald Application Code Enforcement Board 162.05 Fla. Stat. CRAAB - Lee Davidson application CRAAB - Christopher Shucart Application CRAAB code Moorings Bay - Bill Broderick Application Moorings Bay - Marcy Kramp Application 2017-14069 Moorings Bay Resolution Contractor’s Licensing - Jennifer Cassidy Application Contractor’s Licensing - Henry Johnson Application Contractor’s Licensing Board Code Sec. 22-165 Final Ballots for Carver (Staff/Added Attachment) 11.B) DENIED - A Resolution Authorizing a Temporary Use Pursuant to Section 46-39, Approval of Temporary Uses; Special Event Activities, of the City of Naples Code of Ordinances, to Allow for a Temporary Dining Tent Including HVAC and Associated Kitchen, Cooler, and Employee Break Room Modular Trailers on the East Side of Gordon Drive on the Property Owned by Port Royal Club, Inc., a Florida Not For Profit Corporation, Located at 2755 Gordon Drive, During Construction of the New Beach Club on the West Side of Gordon Drive; and Providing an Effective Date.

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 11 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Jessica Hernandez administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Council Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Kramer / familiar with the site and had spoken to individuals of both parties; Petrunoff / met with and spoken to individuals of both parties and stated that she is a member of the Port Royal Club. In response to City Attorney McConnell, Council Member Petrunoff affirmed that neither she nor any of her family members were an employee, officer, or board member of the Port Royal Club, that she had no equitable interest in the Port Royal Club or any right to share the Club’s profits or losses, that her membership in the Club conveys no proprietary interest and does not concern her business or financial interests other than her dues, that she was not offered or promised any discount on her dues in exchange for her vote or anything of the like; Hutchison / familiar with and had visited the site, had spoken with residents within and outside of Port Royal, had received numerous emails, had met with City staff, and stated that he had kept an open mind on the matter; Christman / familiar with and visited the site multiple times, had met with several of the Port Royal Club’s members, residents and representatives; Barton / familiar with the site, received emails, and had several telephone conversations with individuals of both parties; Penniman / visited the site, received letters, emails, and telephone calls, drove the street contiguous to the site to determine potential noise impacts, and spoke with numerous individuals of both parties; and Heitmann / familiar with the site, had spoken with residents both in support and opposed by telephone and through email communications, and reviewed the petition with staff. In response to City Attorney McConnell, the following consensus was reached. Consensus reached to include additional correspondence received by staff after the publication of the agenda until 8:30 a.m. that day into the meeting record. Clay Brooker, Attorney at Cheffy Passidomo, P.A., said he represented the Port Royal Club in a request to approve a Temporary Use to provide dining services to members during construction of the new Port Royal Clubhouse on the west side of Gordon Drive on property located at 2755 Gordon Drive, located within the tennis and fitness center facility area. He said the Club’s board elected to move forward with 70 percent of its members supporting the proposed concept while making every effort to address the concerns of those who oppose it. He thereby utilized an electronic presentation to overview an aerial of the tennis / fitness center facility, the proposed site plan, and the dining tent floor plan. He noted the following seven conditions offered by the Port Royal Club: dining hours will be limited to 5:00 p.m. until 10:00 p.m.; no parking will be permitted along the streets, adding that Port Royal security will assist with enforcement thereof; the tent’s hard walls will contain two inches of inside insulation for sound attenuation, mechanical equipment such as the HVAC will be located along the west side of the tent and trailers so that the sound emitted will be blocked from the East; activity will not occur outside of the tent and trailer areas; there will be no outdoor live entertainment; and there will be no additional exterior lighting installed than what currently exist on property. Andrew Rath, Engineer at Davison Engineering, continued the presentation to review the proposed site plan and proposed temporary uses, which included a temporary dining tent with HVAC, along with modular trailers for a kitchen, cooler, and employee break room, all located on two of the nine existing tennis courts. He explained that the tennis court immediately to the west will provide screening for the proposed tent, and the trailers will be placed on the tennis court immediately north of the western court. Engineer Rath confirmed that no modifications to vehicular access are proposed, and the existing parking layout will remain to maintain circulation around the site. Additionally, he noted that the request includes provisions for 22 new parking spaces in the central lawn area and valet parking south of the tent. Norman Trebilcock, Traffic Engineer at Trebilcock Consulting Solutions, reviewed the parking and demand analysis, noting that it was conducted in accordance with the City’s off-street parking

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 12 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. requirements under Chapter 50 of the Code of Ordinances. He explained that the total demand for parking is 139 spaces, but after evaluating the uses and performing a demand analysis, it was determined that peak demand for the tennis center and fitness facility occurs in the morning hours. He said with the additional 22 spaces, a total of 120 parking spaces will be provided, including 48 spaces allocated for valet parking. Peter Carroll, Principal at ADG4, explained that his company helped design the temporary layout for the Port Royal Club focusing on minimizing neighborhood impacts. He reviewed key features of the dining tent, including steel beams, insulated walls, a glass entryway, modular flooring, a fire suppression system, and fire-rated materials. Mr. Carroll also reviewed utilities for grease traps, noting that plumbing, and electrical systems would be underground, with HVAC units screened by Clusia plants. Mr. Carroll then described the modular kitchen facilities, explaining that three trailers would be combined to form a kitchen equipped with dishwashing, cooler, and freezer systems. He noted that an additional trailer would serve as staff accommodations and a break room. Finally, Mr. Carroll provided an overview of the waste management plan and pest control services. Planning Director Erica Martin provided a background and reviewed the staff report. She noted that although the Port Royal Club currently had a Temporary Use to offer dining service on 2900 Gordon Drive during the Club’s pre-demolition phase, it had submitted a new request to offer dining service on the tennis / fitness center facility side during construction. Planning Director Martin noted that the Port Royal Club requested that the new Temporary Use be approved with an expiration date of June 1, 2027, or upon the opening of the reconstructed beach club, whichever occurs first. She further noted that pursuant to the Florida Fire Prevention Code, structures that are in place for more than 180 days are considered permanent structures and are required to meet all regulations that apply to a permanent structure. In response to Council Member Barton, Planning Director Martin explained that a tent had been previously approved, but compliance issues onsite required its removal. She clarified that a building permit would be required for the new tent, and any construction and maintenance must adhere to the approved site plan. Public Comment: Jenna Heiderman, Executive Director, Port Royal Club Homeowners’ Association Board of Directors, read a letter of support on behalf of Dick Del Bello. The following individuals expressed opposition and/or concerns regarding noise, pest nuisances, odors, possible decrease in property values near the proposed site, hours of operation, restricted use of the property, and / or the length of time of the Temporary Use: Bob Schiff; Dan Lennon; Blake Benjamin; Sean Mayo, who also read a letter on behalf of Marie Cooney; and Allen Keller. The following individuals expressed support: Jaye Semrod; and John Allen. Charles Brown Jr. was not present when called. During discussion, Attorney Brooker confirmed that the proposed dining room tent would operate Tuesday through Sunday. In response to Council Member Barton, Attorney Brooker stated that the Club had not considered further limiting the days of operation but said the Association would consider any recommendations by the Council in that regard. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Attorney Brooker said the dining room tent could be used for small gatherings, such as birthday parties. He noted, however, that special events would require approval by City Council under a special events application. In response to Council Member Penniman, James Frazitta, Property Manager at ADG4, provided manufacture information relating to equipment decibel levels. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, City Attorney McConnell stated that the Code has limited criteria for a temporary use and unlike a conditional use, it does not have certain standards of approval that must be met. He also confirmed that the temporary use would be approved as an

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 13 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. overlay to the Conditional Use for the tennis / fitness center facility. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Nancy Carlson, President, Port Royal Club Homeowners’ Association Board of Directors, New Year’s Eve was historically the Club’s largest event. She said the proposed dining was an important amenity to provide to members during the reconstruction of the clubhouse, especially to its elderly community who are unable to travel to restaurants. Jeff Hardigan, General Manager at the Port Royal Club, responded to questions regarding food deliveries, maintenance of equipment, and last call and staff departure times. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Mr. Carroll confirmed a hurricane plan is in place for the tents deconstruction. He estimated the structures would be installed by year-end and that it takes 48 hours to deconstruct the tent. Attorney Brooker and Mr. Carroll addressed additional hurricane plan questions. Director of Building Services Stephen Beckman explained that staff alerts the community and construction sites to secure property when a storm approaches, following Code requirements. He noted that temporary structures are typically deconstructed based on manufacturer wind-speed recommendations, which are lower than hurricane levels. Director Beckman emphasized that securing property is the owners responsibility. Ken Crooker, Owner at Party Time Rentals, recommended deconstructing the tent at 60 mph winds, though it can withstand up to 95 mph. City Council discussed various concerns related to the proposed Temporary Use, including noise impacts on neighboring properties, additional parking, food deliveries, hours and days of operation, the hurricane plan, the size and capacity of the dining tent, the expiration date, code compliance, the temporary change of use for the property, and the limited criteria for approving the use. The majority of Council Members opposed the proposal, but Council Member Kramer expressed support, highlighting the importance of providing a dining option for elderly residents of Port Royal. Ensuing discussion, the following motion was proffered. MOTION by Hutchison to DENY RESOLUTION 2024-15455; seconded by Christman and carried 6-1, all members present and voting (Hutchison-yes, Penniman-yes, Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-no, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Application Application Cover Sheet and Specifications Disclosure of Interest Deeds - 2755 Gordon Drive Aerial Site Plan Parking Demand Analysis Valet Parking Plan Petitioners’ Credentials Public Notice Mailing Addresses Planning Department Credentials Affidavit of Sign Posting Correspondence Correspondence read into Record (S. Mayo/Added Attachment) Recess: 5:01 p.m. to 5:52 p.m. It is noted for the record the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. 12) OLD BUSINESS 12.A) Review of Revised Design Review Handbook. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar requested that the discussion of the Design Review Board Handbook be postponed until the October 14, 2024 Workshop Meeting. He noted that a discussion regarding boards and committees is also scheduled for that date, and it would be beneficial to address both topics during the same meeting. MOTION by Penniman to CONTINUE ITEM 12.A until the October 14, 2024 City Council Workshop Meeting; seconded by Hutchison and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Design Review Handbook - Current Design Review Handbook 2.0 - Proposed Staff Memorandum to Planning Advisory Board Design Review Handbook - Presentation

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 14 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. 13.B) RESOLUTION 2024-15456 - A Resolution Approving an Interfund Loan From the Cash Clearing Account and Investment Account of the City to the Stormwater Fund in the Amount of $27 Million to Provide Short-Term Funding (Not to Exceed 180 Days) in Anticipation of Issuing Bonds in FY 2025 for the Stormwater Outfall Project; Establishing Terms and Conditions for Repayment; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. Deputy City Manager/CFO Gary Young explained that the proposed interfund loan would provide short-term funding in anticipation of the City issuing bonds in FY 2025 for the Stormwater Outfall Project. He noted that although the loan would not exceed 180 days, the funds would likely be needed for around 20 days. Deputy City Manager/CFO Young added that the loan terms include an interest rate of 2.67 percent, consistent with the City’s most recent bond issuance. Public Comment: Greg Myers stated that he had not yet researched whether the City met all legislative requirements for loaning itself money from other funding sources but planned to do so. He expressed the view that certain development projects should have been charged to fund the Stormwater Beach Outfall Project, rather than using taxpayer dollars. Additionally, he emphasized that a professional analysis to determine Level of Service (LOS) is necessary before conducting a concurrency analysis on any development project. MOTION by Penniman to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15456; seconded by Kramer and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Penniman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Resolution 2024-15407 Stormwater Outfall Project 13.C) APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15457 - A Resolution of the City of Naples, Florida, Establishing Its Intent to Reimburse Certain Expenditures in Connection with Various Capital Improvements Projects, as More Particularly Described Herein, Incurred with Proceeds of a Future Taxable or Tax-Exempt Financings; Providing Certain Other Matters in Connection therewith; and Providing and Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. Deputy City Manager/CFO Gary Young explained that the proposed Resolution will declare the City’s intent to reimburse certain expenditures prior to the issuance of bonds, which allows those expenditures to be tax-exempt under Internal Revue Service (IRS) rules. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Christman to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15457; seconded by Petrunoff and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Penniman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Kramer-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution Resolution 2024-15407 Stormwater Outfall Project 13.D) APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15458 - A Resolution Approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement Between the City of Naples and Zambelli Fireworks Manufacturing Company to Provide for Two Fireworks Shows During Fiscal Year 2024-2025, in the Amount of $72,500; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar introduced the item, explaining that while the request is to approve two fireworks shows for FY 2024-2025, Police Chief Ciro Dominguez had requested a discussion regarding the City’s New Year’s Eve fireworks celebration. City Manager Boodheshwar noted that holding a fireworks show requires the use of a barge and incurs significant staffing and overtime costs to ensure safety during the event. Police Chief Dominguez expressed concerns about the New Year’s Eve fireworks, citing strained police resources due to increased traffic, drinking and driving, and large gatherings. He recommended canceling the New Year’s Eve show but approving the Fourth of July fireworks,

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 15 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. which are more family-oriented. Police Chief Dominguez noted last year’s New Year’s Eve show reflected staffing costs of $141,100, and he proposed reallocating part of those funds to hire 10- 12 additional officers for New Year’s Eve patrols, focusing on key areas and noise complaints and allowing remaining funds to be used elsewhere. Council Member Christman supported canceling the New Year’s Eve fireworks, noting it attracts more visitors than residents and originally started through donations before becoming City funded. Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director Chad Merritt confirmed the vendor contract expired that month, and recommended that City Council approve the resolution without the New Year’s Eve show. City Attorney McConnell stated that the resolution and contract would be amended accordingly. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Kramer to APPROVE RESOLUTION 2024-15458 subject to authorizing the City Manager and City Attorney to amend the Resolution and contract to remove the New Years Eve Fireworks; seconded by Barton and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Petrunoff-yes, Hutchison-yes, Christman-yes, Barton-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Heitmann-yes). Agenda Memorandum Resolution 2nd Amendment Agreement - September 2024 (Unsigned) City Fireworks Agreement - 2024-2025 Cost Schedule City Fireworks Agreement - Resolution 2023-15177 City Fireworks Agreement - First Amendment (2023) City Fireworks Agreement - Second Renewal (2022) City Fireworks Agreement - First Renewal (2021) City Fireworks Agreement - 2018 13.E) DENIED - A Resolution Approving a Valet License Agreement and a Right-of-Way Permit Application #PRRW2401702 With Standard Permit Conditions and the Right- of-Way Operational Plan for Five Star Valet of Collier, LLC. D/B/A 5-Star Valet to Provide Valet Services at the Warren Restaurant Located at 111 10th Street South; Authorizing the City Manager to Execute the Valet License Agreement and the Right- of-Way Permit Application; and Providing an Effective Date. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the title of the Resolution. Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett explained that Five Star Valet submitted a public right-of-way application to request a valet service location for the Warren restaurant at 111 10th Street South, Unit 104. She noted that initially, the request was for exclusive service to Warren patrons, but after discussions with staff, Five Star Valet agreed to serve all visitors of the Collective building. Deputy City Engineer Bickett outlined the proposed Operational Plan, which includes a pickup area and valet stand along 10th Street North, utilizing two on-street parking spaces. She provided details on traffic flow and parking arrangements. She noted that Resolution 2023-15240 granted approval for two on-street parking spaces, and explained that Five Star Valet would only be permitted to use public parking spaces in the garage, as described in Resolution 2017-14083. Alberto Castellon, Senior Vice President at Five Star Valet, stated that the Warren Restaurant wished to provide valet parking to be available at its entrance, which would require two on-street parking spaces. He said currently, cars are received in the parking garage but there is no signage directing patrons. Council Members expressed concerns about the valet company using two on-street parking spots, which could create additional congestion. Mr. Castellon responded that valet parking is a luxury service desired by the Warren, with no more than 20 cars parked at a time and 169 public spaces available in the garage. Vice Mayor Hutchison suggested installing wayfinding signage on 10th Street South to direct patrons to the valet parking location. Council Member Christman questioned the effectiveness of additional signage and stated he had no preference on the use of

City Council Regular Meeting – September 18, 2024 – 8:32 a.m. 16 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. the two parking spaces. Council Member Kramer remarked that it was difficult for him to oppose the request when other valet companies had been authorized to use rights-of-way. Public Comment: Greg Myers expressed opposition, stating that the Council does not have the authority to allow private companies to utilize public parking spaces. He argued that developers should design their properties with greater setbacks to accommodate outdoor dining and valet services. Deputy City Engineer Bickett confirmed that the license agreement and City Code grant the City Manager the authority to revoke valet use if any issues arise. In response to Mayor Heitmann, Deputy City Engineer Bickett stated that she believed the City could allow signage on both sides of the streets, provided that visibility remains clear. Vice Mayor Hutchison observed that valet signs in various locations should be removed when valet services are not in operation. He suggested that Five Star Valet work with staff to create an improved signage and traffic management plan, which Council Member Christman supported. Deputy City Engineer Bickett confirmed that the proposed license agreement includes re

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Regular Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9c57463abfbdf8eff34fb5a7c23a5377. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record