POLISCOPE

The public record

PUNTAGORDA (CHARLOTTE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Code Enforcement Board

Wednesday, April 23, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Code Enforcement Board

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

CITY OF PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING MINUTES APRIL 23, 2025, 9:00 A.M. 120 LAISHLEY COURT PUNTA GORDA, FL 33950 MEMBERS PRESENT: Adele Higgins, Chair Kathleen Antona, Joseph Comeaux, Keith Johnson, Ronald Muschong, Carl Rich MEMBERS ABSENT: Robert Engelhart, Mark Hatala CITY STAFF PRESENT: Rachel Barry, Zoning Official; Frank Coppinger, Code Compliance Officer; Nick Falkner, Code Compliance Supervisor; Ashley Omelanski-Carney, Executive Assistant, Daniel Lewis, Board Attorney; Deputy City Clerk Falkner; Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder CALL TO ORDER Ms. Higgins called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. 1) APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.A March 26, 2025, Meeting Minutes. Exhibits: Cover Page March 26, 2025, Minutes Mr. Muschong MOVED to approve the March 26, 2025, minutes, SECONDED by Mr. Johnson. AYE: Antona, Comeaux, Higgins, Johnson, Muschong, Rich ABSENT: Engelhart, Hatala MOTION CARRIED. 2) NEW BUSINESS NOTE: Item 2.A was heard after Item 2.G. 2.A Board Training Exhibits: Cover Page Annual Member Training - Code Enforcement Board Deputy City Clerk Falkner provided training regarding Board member responsibilities, highlighting quasi-judicial public hearing processes and the Sunshine Law. Mr. Muschong questioned if the quorum was affected when a member recused themselves from a vote. Deputy City Clerk Falkner replied affirmatively.

Mr. Muschong questioned what the appropriate action would be if there was not a quorum for a hearing during a recusal. Mr. Daniel Lewis, Board Attorney, advised the hearing in the scenario should be continued. Ms. Higgins questioned if it was appropriate for the Board to ask for updates on continued hearings and those on appeal, such as the Emerald Lake case. Mr. Lewis replied 30 days from the date the order was signed was the designated timeframe for appeal of a Compliance Order by the Board, noting due process could be affected if the Board requested updates on a Compliance Order that was not final. He recalled the Emerald Lakes Case, noting same may come before the Board again. He clarified asking for a status update regarding the court case was acceptable; however, status updates regarding the alleged Code violations were not appropriate. Mr. Comeaux questioned what actions a Board member could take if they observed a Code violation, suggesting they could act as private citizens. Deputy City Clerk Falkner replied Board members could not act as private citizens to file Code complaints nor could complaints be submitted anonymously. Board Attorney Lewis clarified that Board members could submit code complaints but were not permitted to issue violations or notices of hearing to bring a case before the Board. Mr. Comeaux questioned if it was appropriate to ask if a case had been opened for observed violations. Mr. Lewis replied affirmatively, stating observed violations were considered ex parte communications and should be disclosed on the record. He advised the Board not to look into pending cases, noting same could affect due process. Ms. Antona confirmed with Deputy City Clerk Falkner that respondents were able to call witnesses to provide testimony so long as they informed City staff in advance of the hearing. Ms. Antona questioned how the respondents were notified of same. Ms. Rachel Barry, Zoning Official, suggested the language in the Notice of Violation could be updated to reflect same. Ms. Higgins questioned if the City could waive the requirement for advance notice of witnesses. Mr. Lewis replied affirmatively, noting the City was able to present their case as they saw fit. Ms. Higgins suggested City staff meet with interested parties, such as neighbors, who attended Board meetings to bring their point of view to the Board. Mr. Lewis advised public comment was not allowed during enforcement-related judicial proceedings, noting staff could call neighbors as witnesses if they felt they had relevant testimony. Ms. Antona questioned what steps the Board should take when a respondent’s witness was providing irrelevant testimony. Mr. Lewis replied leeway should be provided to ensure due process, noting the Chair could request the scope of testimony remain on the subject of the violation. NOTE: The meeting recessed at 10:37 a.m. and reconvened at 10:41 a.m. Deputy City Clerk Falkner continued the training. Mr. Rich questioned if it was in the Board’s purview to raise concern for public safety.

Mr. Lewis advised properties that had been deemed a hazard to public safety would go before City Council to request action on same, noting those determinations should be presented by staff; however, the Board could provide stricter time frames for compliance if they felt a case warranted same. Mr. Muschong confirmed with Mr. Lewis that telephone participation by a Board member did not count towards a quorum. 2.B HEARING-25-87353- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Frank Coppinger Respondent: William Dominick Marsella III Address of Violation: 509 Palm Ave. Violation of Chapter 26, Section 1.4 No Permit Violation of Chapter 26, Section 1.5 No Permit Violation of Chapter 26, Section 1.10 No Permit Exhibits: Cover Page 25-87353 509 Palm Ave Ms. Higgins called Case 25-87353 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. She then confirmed the respondent was not present and entered a plea of not guilty on their behalf. Mr. Frank Coppinger, Code Compliance Officer, stated a January 30, 2025, inspection found a fence had been installed on the property without the proper permits. He displayed photographs of the subject property and reviewed the City's efforts to bring the property into compliance, indicating an April 22, 2025, inspection found a fence permit had been applied for but a final inspection had not been performed. He concluded by submitting case costs in the amount of $15.93. Ms. Antona questioned when the fence permit had been applied for. Mr. Coppinger replied the application was dated March 20, 2025. Ms. Higgins questioned who was responsible for scheduling the final inspection. Mr. Coppinger replied same was the responsibility of the respondent. Mr. Rich MOVED to find the City had presented a prima facie case, SECONDED by Ms. Antona. AYE: Antona, Comeaux, Higgins, Johnson, Muschong, Rich ABSENT: Engelhart, Hatala MOTION CARRIED. Ms. Higgins questioned why there were 3 code violations noticed. Mr. Nick Falkner, Code Compliance Supervisor, replied each was relevant in regards to obtaining a permit with the City. Ms. Antona MOVED to find the respondent guilty, to issue a Cease and Desist Order for any future violations, to order the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, and to require payment of case costs incurred in the amount of $15.93 within 14 days, subject to a fine of up to $250 per day plus applicable interest, SECONDED by Mr. Rich. Mr. Falkner stated a final inspection was scheduled for this date according to Building department records. AYE: Antona, Comeaux, Higgins, Johnson, Muschong, Rich ABSENT: Engelhart, Hatala MOTION CARRIED. 2.C HEARING-24-86638- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Nick Falkner

Respondent: Jesus T. Garcia & Anne M. Suris Address of Violation: 470 Bal Harbor Blvd. Violation of Chapter 26, Section 8.11(a) Property Maintenance Roof Exhibits: Cover Page 24-86638 470 Bal Harbor Blvd. Ms. Higgins called Case 24-86638 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. Mr. Falkner requested the hearing be continued to the May 28, 2025, meeting, indicating the respondent had obtained a roof permit. Consensus of the Board was to continue the hearing. 2.D HEARING-24-86858- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Frank Coppinger Respondent: 24/7 Automotive Performance LLC % Christopher Chase Address of Violation: 415 Cooper St. Violation of Chapter 26, Section 8.5 (b) (2) f Fence in Disrepair Violation of Chapter 26, Section 8.10 Multiple Axle Trailer Violation of Chapter 9, Section 9-2 (a) Outside Storage Exhibits: Cover Page 24-86858 415 Cooper St. Ms. Higgins called Case 24-86658 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. Mr. Falkner requested the hearing be continued to the May 28, 2025, meeting, noting the respondent was working towards compliance with staff. Consensus of the Board was to continue the hearing. 2.E HEARING-24-86868- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Nick Falkner Respondent: Curtis L. & Sheri Fullom Address of Violation: 2489 Flora Ln. Violation of Chapter 26, Section 8.11(a) Property Maintenance Roof Exhibits: Cover Page 24-86868 2489 Flora Lane Ms. Higgins called Case 24-86868 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. Mr. Falkner requested the case be dismissed as the property had come into compliance. Consensus of the Board was to dismiss the case. 2.F HEARING-24-86332- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Nick Falkner Respondent: Nancy Hoagland-Morrisey Address of Violation: 1640 Via Bianca Violation of Chapter 26, Section 3.13 (n) (1), (2), (3), (4), (5) Fences, Walls, Hedges Exhibits: Cover Page 24-86332 1640 Via Bianca

Ms. Higgins called Case 24-86332 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. Mr. Falkner request the case be dismissed due to compliance. Consensus of the Board was to dismiss the case. 2.G HEARING-24-86866- CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER- Nick Falkner Respondent: Brit Properties LLC Address of Violation: 821 W. Marion Ave. Violation of Chapter 26, Section 16.5 (c) (1) Demolition Requirements Violation of Chapter 26, Section 16.5 (g) Demolition Requirements Violation of Chapter 9, Section 9-2 (h) Tall Grass and/or Weeds Exhibits: Cover Page 24-86866 821 W Marion Ave. Ms. Higgins called Case 24-86866 and identified the parties thereto, the subject property, and the violations noticed for hearing. She then confirmed the respondent was not present and entered a plea of not guilty on their behalf. Mr. Falkner stated a September 17, 2024, inspection found the demolition permit requirements had not been met, and there were tall grass or weeds throughout the property. He displayed photographs of the subject property and reviewed the City's efforts to bring the property into compliance, indicating an April 22, 2025, inspection found the violations remained. He concluded by submitting case costs in the amount of $28.62. Mr. Rich confirmed with Mr. Falkner the shadow box fence and concrete driveway had to be removed and the property had to be sodded or seeded to meet the requirements of the demolition permit. Ms. Higgins confirmed with Mr. Falkner that all the mailings had been returned undelivered. Mr. Rich questioned if the property would go into the lot mowing program. Mr. Falkner replied the property was ineligible for same in its existing condition. Ms. Higgins questioned when the demolition permit had been obtained. Mr. Falkner reviewed the permit history, noting the Building Department had performed a final inspection on April 15, 2024. Mr. Rich MOVED to find the City had presented a prima facie case, SECONDED by Mr. Comeaux. AYE: Antona, Comeaux, Higgins, Johnson, Muschong, Rich ABSENT: Engelhart, Hatala MOTION CARRIED. Ms. Higgins questioned where the mailings had been sent. Mr. Falkner replied the mailings had been sent to Brit Properties LLC at 6424 Seventh Avenue North, St Petersburg Florida. Mr. Comeaux questioned if staff had been in contact with the property owner. Mr. Falkner replied affirmatively, noting the property owner indicated their intent to rebuild; however, same was required within 6 months of the demolition. Mr. Rich MOVED to find the respondent guilty, to issue a Cease and Desist Order for any future violations, to order the property be brought into compliance within 60 days, and to require payment of case costs incurred in the amount of $28.62 within 30 days, subject to a fine of up to $250 per day plus applicable interest, SECONDED by Mr. Antona.

Mr. Rich noted his reason for selecting a 60-day timeframe for compliance was due to the length of time permitting could take. AYE: Antona, Comeaux, Higgins, Johnson, Muschong, Rich ABSENT: Engelhart, Hatala MOTION CARRIED. 3) UNFINISHED BUSINESS There was none. 4) STAFF COMMENTS Mr. Falkner noted the City hired contractors to maintain properties that had been deemed a hazard to public safety. 5) MEMBER COMMENTS Mr. Muschong questioned why both the City Attorney and Board Attorney attended Board meetings. Deputy City Clerk Falkner replied same was done to ensure due process, noting the City Attorney was present to advocate for the City’s case and the Board Attorney was present to advise the Board. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 11:24 a.m.Chair Board Recorder

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Code Enforcement Board — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9b31fc5167590a0707f65169ac6bbeca. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record