POLISCOPE

The public record

KEYBISCAYNE (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Regular Council Meeting December 10, 2019

Tuesday, December 10, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Regular Council Meeting December 10, 2019

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

Official minutes publish outcomes and identify speakers and the topics they addressed.

People and votes

Commissioner Betty Sime Conroy

1 statement

  1. Statement

    Commented on Sam Kissinger.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

MINUTES REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2OI9 COUNCIL CHAMBER 560 CRANDON BOULEVARD 1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL OF MEMBERS: The meeting was called to order by the Mayor at 6:00 p.m. Present were Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Allison McCormick (arrived at 6:30 p.m.), Kathleen Petros, Ignacio Segurola, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and Mayor Michael W. Davey. Councilmember Edward London was not present. Also present were Village Manager Andrea Agha, Village Clerk Jennifer Medina and Village Attorney Chad Friedman. 2. INVOCATION: Father Andrzei Folton from the Saint Agnes Catholic Church provided an invocation. 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: The Mayor led the Pledge of Allegiance. 4. BRIEF COMMENTS BY COUNCIL: The Mayor thanked the individuals involved with coordinating a wonderful Winterfest event that took place last weekend and also, acknowledged the participants and community volunteers appreciated at the State of the Village Address and Volunteer Appreciation Ceremony on Thursday, December 5th. Lastly, the Mayor wished everyone a Happy Holiday and addressed the public regarding the importance of demonstrating support to those whom may be going through a difficult timi during ihir holiduy season. 5. AGENDA: The Manager requested to pull Items 8D and 11D1. Councilmember Petros requested to pull Item 11A5. Councilmember Segurola requested to pull Item 1146. There were no objections by Council to the agenda changes. 6. PUBLIC COMMENTS: The following speakers addressed the Council: Bill Durham, 230 Sea View Drive, commented on the State of the Village Address and

December 10, 2019 Volunteer Appreciation ceremony; H. Frances Reaves, 251 Crandon Boulevard, and Mary Tague, 610 North Mashta, commented on their appreciation for the Village Council; Cecile Sanchez, 260 Cypress Drive, commented on the great execution Civic Center Village holiday decorations; Don Elisburg,177 Ocean Lane Drive, commented on Stormwater; Robert Vernon, 475 Ridgewood Road, commented on safety study Crandon and Betty Sime Conroy, 785 Crandon Boulevard, commented on Sam Kissinger. 7. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS: At this time, Councilmember Petros requested the addition of a discussion regarding the I lth Annual Southeast Florida Regional Climate Leadership Summit attended by both Councilmembers Petros and Lauredo as Item llAT. Also, the Clerk requested to defer Item 8A to the next regularly scheduled Council meeting. There were no objections by Council. At this time, Item 7A was heard. Councilmember Lauredo presented a certificate of appreciation recognizing Jose Llanes, Key Biscayne's Winn-Dixie Retail Director, for his dedication and tireless efforts supporting the Village's great quality of life. At this time, Item 78 was heard. Edward Ng from The Conadino Group presented the Council with the Pedestrian Safety Study for Crandon Boulevard. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding the Pedestrian Safety Study for Crandon Boulevard. It was the consensus of Council to direct the Manager to focus on a solution for the intersection located on Crandon Boulevard and Grand Bay. Councilmember Lauredo made a motion to focus on a prudent and expedient solution to improve pedestrian safety at the Crandon Boulevard/Grand Bay intersection. The motion was not seconded. It was the consensus of Council to direct the Manager to increase police patrolling at the Crandon Boulevard/Grand Bay intersection, especially during night hours. 8. CONSENT AGENDA: Mayor Davey made a motion to approve the following consent agenda. The motion was seconded by Councilmember McCormick and approved by a 6-0 voice vote. The vote was as follows: Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Allison McCormick, Kathleen Petros, Ignacio Segurola, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and Mayor Michael W. Davey voting Yes. Item 8A was deferred earlier in the meeting 2of6

December 10, 2019 The approval of the November 19,2019 minutes of the Regular Council Meeting. A CAPITAL PROJECT AUTHORIZING RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE PURCHASE OF BALLISTIC HELMETS FROM FEDERAL EASTERN INTERNATIONAL, LLC; PROVIDING FOR AUTHORIZATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Item 8D was deferred earlier in the meeting. 9. ORDINANCES: The Clerk read the following ordinance on first reading, by title: AN ORDINANCE OF THE VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, AMENDING SECTION 2-2I *DEFENSE OF OFFICIALS IN ETHICS MATTERS'' TO PROVIDE FOR THE COST OF DEF'ENSE OF AN ELECTED OFFICIAL AS FURTHER PROVIDED HEREIN; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. The Mayor made a motion to adopt the ordinance on first reading. The motion was seconded by Councilmember McCormick. The Mayor opened the public hearing. There were no speakers present. The Mayor closed the public hearing. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding this ordinance. The ordinance was adopted on first reading and approved by 6-0 roll call vote. The vote was as follows: Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Allison McCormick, Kathleen Petros, Ignacio Segurola, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and Mayor Michael W. Davey voting Yes. 10. RESOLUTIONS: The Clerk read the following resolution, by title: A RESOLUTION OF' THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF' KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, URGING OUR U.S. SENATORS AND REPRESENTATIVES TO PASS THE ENERGY TNNOVATION AND CARBON DTVTDEND ACT (H.R. 763) TO LEVY AN ANNUALLY INCREASING REVENUE-NEUTRAL FEE ON THE CARBON IN FOSSIL FUELS AT THE POINT OF PRODUCTION OR IMPORTATION AND RETURN A DIVIDEND TO ALL AMERICANS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Councilmember Lauredo made a motion to approve this resolution. The motion was seconded by Mayor Davey. The Mayor addressed the Council recommending approval of this resolution. 3 of 6

December 10, 2019 The resolution was approved by a 6-0 voice vote. The vote was as follows: The vote was as follows: Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Allison McCormick, Kathleen Petros, Ignacio Segurola, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and Mayor Michael W. Davey voting Yes. 11. REPORTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: The following items were discussed: Mavor and Councilmembers. The Mayor addressed the Council regarding a status update on the Chief Resilience Officer position description. At this time, Item 11A2 was heard. Councilmember Segurola addressed the Council regarding a Council's Internship Program. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding a Council's Internship Program. Vice Mayor Moss addressed the Council requesting a straw vote to establish a Council Internship Program. There were no objections by Council. At this time, a straw vote of the Council was taken and failed by a 2-4 straw vote. The vote was as follows: Councilmembers McCormick and Ignacio Segurola voting Yes. Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Kathleen Petros, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and Mayor Michael W. Davey voting No. At this time, Item 1lA4 was heard. Councilmember Segurola addressed the Council regarding the 2020 Boat Show and Beyond. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding the 2020 Boat Show and Beyond. The Manager addressed the Council regardingthe 2020 Boat Show emergency action plan. At this time, the Manager's report was heard. Item 1lDl was pulled earlier in the meeting. The Manager addressed the Council providing an update on the beach renourishment feasibility study. It was the consensus of Council to direct the Manager to schedule a presentation at the next regularly scheduled meeting regarding a status update for the beach renourishment feasibility study. The Manager also addressed the Council reporting a total of I72 homes not yet connected to the sewer system. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding the number of homes not yet connected to 4of6

December 10, 2019 the sewer system At this time, Item 11A3 was heard Councilmember Segurola addressed the Council requesting to review the draft letter to the Florida Attorney General concerning Stormwater and provide comments to the Attorney by the next regularly scheduled Council meeting. There were no objections by Council. It was the consensus of Council to direct the Attorney to collect Council's feedback and bring back the draft letter to the Florida State Attorney for Council consideration at the next regularly scheduled Council meeting. Item 11A5 was pulled earlier in the meeting. Item 11,4'6 was pulled earlier in the meeting. At this time, Item 11A7 was heard. Councilmembers Petros and Lauredo addressed the Council reporting on the experience at 1lth Annual Southeast Regional Climate Leadership Summit. Village Attorney. The Attorney did not submit a report. Village Clerk. The Clerk addressed the Council regarding the proposed 2020 Village Council meeting schedule. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding the proposed 2020 Village Council meeting schedule. Councilmember Moss made a motion to change the April 7,2020 to a Regular Council Meeting and schedule the Community Group Budget Workshop on June 16, 2020. The motion was seconded by Mayor Davey. At this time, Councilmember Lauredo addressed the Council regarding the allowable number of absences by Council pursuant to the Village Charter. At this time, the Attorney addressed the Council regarding the allowable number of absences by Council pursuant to the Village Charter. The Manager addressed the Council regardingthe 2020 Budget preparation timeline. There was extensive discussion by Council regarding the 2020 Budget preparation timeline. The motion was approved by a 6-0 voice vote. The vote was as follows: Councilmembers Luis Lauredo, Allison McCormick, Kathleen Petros, Ignacio Segurola, Vice Mayor Brett G. Moss and 5 o.f 6

December 10, 2019 Mayor Michael W, Davey voting Yes It was the consensus of Council to schedule a Police Policy and Procedures Town Hall Meeting on January 14, 2020 at 6:00 p.m. and a Strategic Planning Session on Saturday, February 8, 2020. Village Manager. The Manager's report was heard earlier in the meeting. 12. OTHER BUSINESS/GENERAL DISCUSSION: There was no further business discussed. 13. PENDING BUSINESS/PENDING LITIGATION: A list of pending business/pending litigation was presented to the Council. 14. SCHEDULE OF FUTURE MEETINGS/EVENTS: A schedule of future meetings and events was presented to the Council. 15. ADJOURNMENT: The meeting was adjourned at9:43 p.m Re sp e c tfu I ly s u b mitt e d : ef Village Clerk Approved this 28th day of Januarv. 2020: r Michuel W. Davey Mayor IF A PERSON DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE WLLAGE COANCIL WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT A MEETING OR HEARING, THAT PERSON WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND, FOR SACH PARPOSE, MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLADES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 6 of 6

Showing the first 24,000 of 115,912 characters. The full document is at the source.

Village Council MichaelVl Davey,Mayr Brett Moss, Vice Maltor Luis Lauredo Edward London Allison McCormick Katie Petros IgnacioJ. Segurola VITLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2019 6:00 P.M. 1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL OF MEMBERS 2. INVOCATION: FATHER ANDRZEJ FOLTON SAINT AGNES CATHOLIC CHURCH 3, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE BRIEF COMMENTS BY COUNCIL AGENDA: APPROVALiDEFERRALS/ADDITIONSiDELETIONS SUB STITUTIONS/WITHDRAWAL PUBLIC COMMENT: There is a (3) minute time limit for each speaker during public comment. Your cooperation is appreciated in observing the (3) minute rule. If you have a matter you would like to discuss during public comments, a request form is available ot the entrance of the Council Chambers, please fill-it in and return it to the Village Clerk prior to the start of the meeting. When your name is called, please come forward to the podium, STATE YOUR NAME, ADDRESS, IF YOU ARE A HIRED CONSULTANT OR VILLAGE EMPLOYEE AND/OR IF ENGAGED IN LOBBYING ACTIVITIES AND/OR REPRESENTING AN ORGANIZATION FOR THE RECORD. 7. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS: SPECIAL RECOGNITION: JOSE LLANES, WINN DIXIE GENERAL MANAGER (COUNCILMEMBER LAUREDO) PRESENTATION BY JOSEPH M. CORRADINO FROM THE CORRADINO GROUP REGARDING PEDESTRAIN SAFETY STUDY FOR CRANDON BOULEVARD TAB 1 88'West Mclntyre Street . Suite 2OO . Key Biscayne, Florida 33L49 . (3O5) 365-5506. Fax (3O5) 355-89L4 MISSION STATEMENT:..TO PROVIDEA SAFE, QUALITY COMMUNIfi ENVIRONMENT FORALL ISLANDERSTHROUGH RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT., 4 5 6. A. B. www.keybiscayne.fl . gov

VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE CONSENT AGENDAz (Consent agenda items are those which are routine, do not require discussion or explanation prior to Village Council action, or have already been discussed and/or explained and do not require further discussion or explanation. Items can be removedfrom the consent agenda by the request on an individual Council member for independent consideration provided such request is made during the approval/deferrals/additions/deletions substitutions/withdrawals segment of the meeting, prior to the vote on the consent agenda.) 8 A OCTOBER 29, 2OI9 MINUTES (REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING) TAB 2 NOVEMBER 19, 2019 MINUTES (REGULAR COLINCIL MEETING) TAB 3 A CAPITAL PROJECT AUTHORIZING TAB 4 RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE PURCHASE OF BALLISTIC HELMETS FROM FEDERAL EASTERN INTERNATIONAL, LLC; PROVIDING FOR AUTHORIZATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (VILLAGE MANAGER) RECOMMENDATION: Approval D A CAPITAL PROJECT AUTHORIZING TAB 5 RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE PURCHASE OF AR-15 SBR RIFLES FROM SABAL ARMS, INC.; PROVIDING FOR AUTHORIZATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (VILLAGE MANAGER) RECOMMENDATION : Approval B. C. MISSION STATEMENT "TO PROVIDE A SAFE, QUALITY COMMUNITY ET.IVIRONMENT FOR ALL ISLANDERS THROUGH RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT.'

VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE ORDINANCES: (NO LATER THAN 7:30 P.M.) A. FIRST READING: 1.) 10. OPEN FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS (SECOND READING TO BE DETERMINED) RESOLUTIONS: 9 AN ORDINANCE OF THE VILLAGE OF KEY TAB 6 BISCAYNE, FLORIDA, AMENDING SECTION 2.2I (6DEFENSE OF OFFICIALS IN ETHICS MATTERS'' TO PROVIDE FOR THE COST OF' DEFENSE OF AN ELECTED OFFICIAL AS F'URTHER PROVIDED HEREIN; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (COI.INCILMEMBER SEGUROLA) RECOMMENDATION: Council discretion A RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COLINCIL OF TAB 7 THE VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE, FLOzuDA, URGING OUR U.S. SENATORS AND REPRESENTATIVES TO PASS THE ENERGY INNOVATTON AND CARBON DIVIDEND ACT (H.R. 763) TO LEVY AN ANNUALLY INCREASING REVENUE.NEUTRAL FEE ON THE CARBON IN FOSSIL FUELS AT THE POINT OF PRODUCTION OR IMPORTATION AND RETURN A DIVIDEND TO ALL AMERICANS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (MAYOR DAVEY) RECOMMENDATION : Council discretion I1. REPORTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: A. MAYOR AND COUNCILMEMBERS l.) CHIEF RESILIENCE OFFICER POSITION DESCRIPTION UPDATE (VTLLAGE COr.rNCrL) 2.) VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE COUNCIL INTERNSHIP PROGRAM (COLINCILMEMBER SEGUROLA) 3.) STORMWATER QUESTION FOR THE FLORIDA ATTORNEY GENERAL (COUNCILMEMBER SEGUROLA) 4.) 2020 BOAT SHOW AND BEYOND (COUNCILMEMBER SEGUROLA) A MISSION STATEMENT "TO PROVIDE A SAFE, QUALITY COMMI,JNITY E},IURONMENT FOR ALL ISI,.ANDERS THROUGH RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT."

VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE s.) POTENTIAL GREEN SPACE EXPANSION AT THE END OF HARBOR DRIVE (COLINCILMEMBER PETROS) 6.) WASTEMANAGEMENT(COUNCILMEMBERSEGUROLA) B. VILLAGE ATTORNEY l.) NONE C. VILLAGE CLERK 1.) PROPOSED 2O2O VILLAGE COUNCIL MEETING SCHEDULE TAB 8 D. VILLAGE MANAGER (NO LATER THAN 8:00 P.M.) 1.) DATES FOR POLICE POLICY AND PROCEDURE TOWNHALL TAB 9 2.) ONGOTNG PROJECT UPDATE TAB 10 12. OTHERBUSINESS/GENERALDISCUSSION A. NONE 13. SCHEDULE OF FUTURE MEETINGS/EVENTS: A. TO BE DETERMINED 14. ADJOURNMENT MISSION STATEMENT .TO PROVIDE A SAFE, QUALITY COMMI.JNITY ENVIRONMENT FOR ALL ISLANDERS THRoUGH RESPoNSIBLE GoITERNMENT,"

VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE I ANY PERSON WISHING TO ADDRESS THE VILLAGE COANCIL ON AN ITEM ON THIS AGENDA IS ASKED TO REGISTER TryITH THE WLL,AGE CLERK PRIOR TO THAT ITEM BEING HEARD. PRIOR TO MAKING A STATEMENT, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME, ADDRESS, IF YOA ARE A HIRED CONSULTANT OR WLLAGE EMPLOYEE/FORMER VILL.AGE EMPLOYEE AND/OR IF ENGAGED IN LOBBYING ACTIWTIES AND/OR REPRESENTING AN ORGANIZATION FOR TIIE RECORD. II. IN ACCORDANCE IYITH THE AMERICANS IT/ITH DISABILITIES ACT OF 1990, ALL PER,SON,S WHO ARE DISABLED AND WHO NEED SPECIAL ACCOMMODATIONS TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCEEDING BECAUSE OF TIUT DISABILITY SHOALD CONTACT THE OFFICE OF TIIE WLI-AGE CLERK, 88 WEST MCINTYRE STREET, KEY BISCAYNE, FLORIDA 33149, TELEPHONE NUMBER (305) 365-5506, NOT L,ATER THAN TWO BUSINESS DAVS PRIOR TO SUCH PROCEEDINGS. NI. IF A PERSON DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE VILL./IGE COUNCIL WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT A MEETING OR HEARING, THAT PERSON WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND, FOR SACH PARPOSE, MAY NEED TO ENSARE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED (F.5.286.010s). IV. IN ACCORDANCE WITH VILLAGE CODE SECTION 2-161, ADOPTING SECTION 2-11.1(s) OF THE MAMI.DADE COUNTY CODE,ANY PERSON ENGAGING IN LOBBYINGACTIWTIES,AS DEFINED THEREIN, MUST REGISTER AT THE VILL,AGE CLERK'S OFFICE BEFORE ADDRESSING THE COUNCIL ON THE ABOVE MATTERS OR ENGAGING IN LOBBYING ACTIVITIES. MISSION STATEMENT "TO PROVIDE A SAFE, QUALITY COMMUNITY ENVIRONMENT FOR ALL ISIJNDERS THROUGH RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT.''

VILLAGE OF KEY BISCAYNE Village of Key Biscayne 2019 Village Council Meeting Schedule 6:00 P.M. 1.) 2.) 3.) 4.) s.) 6.) 7.) 8.) +anuary+S;:0++ Februarl-5#0]9 W Maren+9r20+9 Aprit9r20+9 A.pri}3e;20Jg l\/f^-, 11 1n1 () e.) ltl,ne+5;4+9 B{*d€€ffiSop 10.) +Y**g;q+g 11.)@ +s++udge+++earing 12.) @ 2nd+udge$Hea#ing LILqJ -L) -VLt 1 3.) 14.) 1s.) 16.) ge*eger+St+g+g €'et*erry;m+g Nevemger++;:g+g BeeemUe++g;:gl9 +une++;+Ofg 1. September Budget Hearings subject to change due to Miami-Dade County School Board and Miami-Dade County Commissioners Meeting Schedule. THE ABOVE MEETINGS ARE HELD IN THE COANCIL CHAMBER, 560 CRANDON BOULEVARD AND ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE. ZONING MEETINGS AND SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETINGS WILL BE SCHEDULED ON AN AS NEEDED BASIS. PLEASE VISIT www.keybiscayne.fl.gov TO WEllt THE MEETING SCHEDULE. MISSION STATEMENT "TO PROVIDE A SAFE, QUALITY COMMUNITY ET.IVIRONMENT FOR ALL ISLANDERS THROUGH RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT."

TAB 1 \

:ID Prepared by: The Corradino Group, lnc. 4055 NW 97th Avenue, Suite 201 Miami, FL 33178

Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: BACKGROUND: ............. EXISTING CONDITIONS: Physical Conditions..... Traffic Control Devices. DISCUSSION:................. Crosswalks:............., RECOMMENDATIONS:... Engineering Enforcement................. Education Encouragement............ Evaluation List of Figures Figure 1 - Location Map........... Figure 2 - Pedestrian ............. Figure 3 - Sign Figure 4 - Crash Locations on Key Biscayne Figure 5 - Pedestrian Survivability................ Figure 6 - Field of Vision Tables Table 1 - Pedestrian Crossing Separation Table 2 - Pedestrian Crossing Separation Appendices Appendix A - Existing Sign lnventory Appendix B - Master Sign Plan Appendix C - Cost Estimate .2 .5 .6 .o .7 .9 11 13 13 16 16 17 17 ..2 ..6 ..6 ..9 10 10 12

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The Corradino Group (Corradino) has been requested to prepare a traffic engineering study to review pedestrian safety along the Crandon Boulevard corridor, and to provide recommendations for improvement, following a tragic crash wherein a twelve-year-old girlwas severely injured at a designated crosswalk at East Heather Drive and Crandon Blvd. The limits of the study are Crandon Blvd. from The Towers crossing at the south end to Harbor Drive/Ocean Lane Drive at the north end. The purpose of this study is to provide a critical examination of pedestrian safety along Crandon Blvd. with respect to the existing physical conditions of the corridor and the use of traffic control devices. The study also includes recommendations for actions that can be undertaken to improve safety for pedestrians. Crandon Boulevard is the main highway therefore, bisecting the city. There is a heavy concentration of pedestrians, bicycles, local and tourist vehicles along the corridor. The Village of Key Biscayne has implemented bicycle lanes throughout, and pedestrian features at every signalized intersection. Mid- block crossings supplemented with high- emphasis pavement markings, patterned pavement, pedestrian warning signs, and in two locations, Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) installations are also in place. The Village has clearly demonstrated a high level of concern and have taken positive action to protect its most vulnerable road users (pedestrians and bicyclists). There are 13 pedestrian crossing locations along Crandon Boulevard. Nearly 30,000 vehicles per day use the road which, with a speed limit of 30 mph, operates at a Level of Service E, indicating heavy congestion. There have been 192 crashes on Crandon Blvd during the five-year period from 2013 and2017;36 of which involved 14 pedestrians and 22 cyclists. This is about 7 crashes per year involving pedestrians and cyclists. While the total number of crashes are statistically low, the bicycle and pedestrian crashes are seven times the expected value. Despite the liberal implementation of pedestrian traffic signals, warning signs and pavement markings, there may be no traffic control devices that can provide the necessary protection for pedestrians and bicyclists from a negligent and careless driver. Although there is significant concern over the incident involving the twelve-year-old victim, on an overall historical/statistical basis, additional devices such as pavement markings, traffic signs and RRFBs have only been in place for a short period, so there is insufficient evidence to measure their effectiveness. 2 Figurel-LocationMap

As part of this analysis, numerous techniques were considered to evaluate the most appropriate measures to improve the safety performance of the corridor with respect to pedestrians and bicyclists. Among the techniques that were evaluated included: . Reduction of the speed limit . Reorganization of signage . Repositioning of Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons . Reconsideration of marked crosswalks less than 660 feet in spacing . Elimination of crosswalks at certain locations o lncreased pedestrian head start and crossing times in each signal phase . Exclusive pedestrian phasing (pedestrian scrambles) . Pedestrian count down signals where not in place . Lightingimprovements . Zero tolerance enforcement policies . Street safety education campaign . Potential encouragement campaign . Regular monitoring of progress Corradino has conducted a thorough study of the Crandon corridor considering the pedestrian crash to determine additional measures that can be taken to improve safety. Based on the results of our study, experience and the latest in highway safety research, the following are our recommendations: 1. Petition Miami-Dade County to lower the speed limit on Crandon Boulevard to 25 mph. 2. Perform maintenance on landscaping to eliminate sight distance blockage on pedestrians and traffic signs. 3. Conduct traffic counts to include vehicular, pedestrian and bicycle counts to determine if the following crossings can be eliminated: a. Grapetree Drive b. Seaview Drive c. East Enid Drive d. Grand Bay DriveA/illage Green Way 4. lmplement a Master Sign Plan to guide the proper layout of signs along the corridor and eliminate duplicity. 5. Add "Cross Only at Crosswalks" signs along the sidewalks to reinforce safe practices. 6. Adjust traffic signal phasing and timings to reduce pedestrian conflicts. 7. Consider all-way-red signal phasing with diagonal crosswalks (pedestrian scrambles). 8. Update lighting systems to provide better lighting on pedestrians. L Consider installing red-light cameras at all signalized inteisections to reduce red-light running. 10. Allocate additional funding for enforcement efforts. 11. Equitably enforce traffic laws on pedestrian and bicyclists as well as motorists. 12. Seek legal advice on the ability of the Village to add fines to the issuance of warnings. 13. Provide special instruction to children attending Key Biscayne's K-8 Center on safe practices for walking and biking, and the meaning and use of RRFBs. 3

14. lnstall variable message signs at the Village limits listing the number of crashes, fatalities and injuries during a given time period. 15. lnstall additional radar speed feedback signs along the corridor. 16. lnvestigate the possibility of offering incentives to safe drivers via electronic monitoring means. 17. ln addition to "Safe Routes to School" consider adding "Safe Routes for Seniors" and "Safe Routes to Play" programs. 18. Allocate additional resources for monitoring and tracking traffic crashes. 19. Consider adding CCTVs along the corridor to monitor crashes and operations. 4

BACKGROUND Engineering principles, particularly those in the Highway Safety Manual, (HSM) explain that "nominal safety" means compliance with standards and a minimum standard of care, whereas "substantive safety" goes beyond nominal safety to the actual performance of a roadway (either existing or expected) as determined by crash frequency and severity. To achieve substantive safety, one must conduct a common-sense examination of field conditions, application of the latest highway safety research, and continued monitoring to achieve a measurable improvement in safety performance. Note that substantive safety is a function not only of the basic characteristics of the road, but also a function of maintenance, law enforcement, and other resources we choose to devote to its operation. Key Biscayne desires substantive safety on its roadway network. Florida State Statutes ($) Chapter 316.130 (7Xb), requires that "The driver of a vehicle at any crosswalk where signage so indicates shall stop and remain stopped to allow a pedestrian to cross a roadway when the pedestrian is in the crosswalk or steps into the crosswalk and is upon the half of the roadway upon which the vehicle is traveling or when the pedestrian is approaching so closely from the opposite half of the roadway as to be in danger." The driver of the motorcycle who severely injured the twelve-year-old girl was cited with felony reckless driving. The comments noted on the citation further noted that the motorcyclist was driving at a high rate of speed and "weaving in and out of traffic". The Federal Highway Administration's Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), Section 2A.01 states "The functions of signs are to provide regulations, warnings, and guidance information for road users. Words, symbols, and arrows are used to convey the messages. Slgns are not typically used to confirm rules of the road;' The Pedestrian Traffic sign (W11-2) is officially designated as a Warning Sign to "call attention to unexpected conditions on or adjacent to a highway, street, or private roads open to public travel and to situations that might not be readily apparent to road users. Warning signs alert road users to conditions that might call for a reduction of speed or an action in the interest of safety and efficient traffic operations. " ln addition to standards for application, specific guidance from the MUTCD, Section 2A.04 on the use of signs indicates that "Regu/atory and warning srgrns shou/d be used conseruatively because fhese srgns, if used fo excess, tend to lose their effectiveness." 5

EXISTING CON DITIONS: Field reconnaissance and a thorough inventory of Crandon Blvd was conducted during July 2018 to identify the physical conditions and the locations and types of traffic control devices implemented along the corridor. With a reported annual average daily traffic (AADT) of 29,500 vehicles per day, Crandon Blvd operates at Level of Service E. A complete inventory of existing physical conditions is provided in Appendix A. Physical Conditions The alignment of Crandon Blvd is largely curvilinear, which contributes to sight distance limitations in certain areas, such as on the northbound approach to North Club Drive. Eight-foot sidewalks are located behind a landscaped green space adjacent to the curbs on both sides of the road. These landscaped areas between the curbs and the sidewalks includes trees of varying calipers, the smaller of which are sometimes in bunches, and shrubbery in the range of 3-4 feet tall. While this provides a safe refuge area for pedestrians between intersections, the landscaping located at the corners often obscures pedestrians waiting to cross (Figure 2). Similarly, low-hanging branches on the trees in the landscaped areas combined with questionable placement also obscures some roadway signs (Figure 3). ln general, there is an overabundance of signs along the corridor that compete for drivers' attention along with traffic signals, heavy traffic, and the substantial presence of pedestrians and bicyclists (see Appendix A). A four-foot (4') bicycle lane is marked and signed on both sides of the roadway, and vehicular travel lanes are approximately 11 feet in width. All the major (non-driveway) intersections have been reconstructed using patterned pavement. 6 Figure 2 - Pedestrian Can you spot the pedestrian? Figure 3 - Srgn

Traffic Control Devices There are six (6) intersections with Crandon Blvd controlled by traffic signals: 1. West Mashta Drive 2. Westwood Drive/Eastwood Drive (N. Club Drive) 3. West Mclntyre StreeUGalen Drive 4. Sonesta Drive 5. Key Colony 6. Harbor Drive/Ocean Lane Drive There are also traffic signal indications on a mast arm northbound at the Key Biscayne Fire Rescue Department which preempts the signal at West Mclntyre StreeVGalen Drive. The traffic signals at West Mashta Drive and at the Fire Rescue Department have no pedestrian traffic control signals, and the traffic signal at Sonesta Drive has no traffic control signals for the north-south pedestrian movement on the west leg, although this leg is a commercial driveway. ln addition to the signalized intersection locations noted above, there are seven (7) unsignalized, marked pedestrian crosswalks on Crandon Blvd: 1. The Towers Crossing (E-W crossing South leg only) 2. Grapetree Drive 3. Seaview Drive 4, East Enid Drive 5. West Enid Drive/Sunrise Drive 6. Grand Bay DriveA/illage Green Way 7. East Heather Drive Table I provides the locations of all pedestrian crossings along with the distances between them. Table 1 - Pedestrian Crossing Separation Distance Between Pedestrian Crosswalks From Distance (ft) To Arthur Lamb Jr Blvd 654 Grapetree Drive Grapetree Drive 7U Seaview Drive Seaview Drive 288 W. Mashta Drive W. Mashta Drive 638 East Wood Drive/West Wood Drive East Wood Drive/West Wood Drive 222 East Enid Drive East Enid Drive 245 West Enid Drive/Sunrise Drive West Enid Drive/Sunrise Drive 2s2 West Mclntvre Street/Galen Drive West Mclntvre Street/Galen Drive 254 Grand Bay Drive/Village Green Way Grand Bay Drive/Village Green Way 640 East Heather Drive East Heather Drive 670 Sonesta Drive Sonesta Drive 510 Key Colonv Key Colony s68 Harbor Drive/Ocean Lane Drive 7

Allthe crosswalks along the Crandon Blvd corridor have been supplemented with "high emphasis" pavement markings and pedestrian crossing signs. ln addition, pedestrian crossing signs are posted at all crosswalks as well as advance warning signs; unsignalized crosswalks have advance stop bars with "Stop Here for Pedestrians" signs. Bicycle lane signs are posted throughout the corridor, as are signs for speed limits, turn restrictions, traffic signal photo enforcement (at Mclntyre/Galen), one-way traffic, keep right, bus stops, parking restrictions; library, information and Village Hall directional signs. ln some locations, "Yield to Pedestrian" signs have been posted on the side streets, and in-roadway "Stop for Pedestrians in Crosswalk" signs. There is only one sign in the corridor that reads "Cross Only at Crosswalks" located in the median just south of Westwood/Eastwood Drive (N. Club Drive). A complete inventory of all roadway signs has been prepared as Appendix A to this report. Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons (RRFBs) have been implemented on the mainline for the unsignalized intersections at West Enid Drive/Sunrise Drive, and at East Heather Drive. The RRFBs are posted on the near side and the far side crosswalks, as well as the medians, and are activated concurrently from any of the pushbuttons. These installations should remain. 8

DISCUSSION A four-year history of the most recently available crash records (2013 - 2017) for the Crandon Blvd corridor indicates that there were 192 total crashes. A more in-depth analysis of these records indicate there were 36 crashes involving 14 pedestrians and 22 bicyclists (See Frgure 4). Of these, there was one fatality, three serious injuries, 16 non- incapacitating injuries, eight possible injuries, and eight involving no injuries. There were three crashes of this type in 2013, eight in 2014, 11 in 2015, seven in 2016 and seven in 2O17. Based on these statistics, the average number of total crashes is 38.4 crashes per year including 7.2 pedestrian and bicycle crashes. There is a concentration of pedestrian and bicycle crashes at Harbor Drive/Ocean Lane with 8 crashes, and Grand Bay Drive with 6 crashes. Figure 4 - Crash Locations on Key Biscayne xry Brr.nyrt A Highway Safety Manual analysis was conducted for Crandon Blvd using spreadsheets developed by the National Cooperative Highway Research Program (NCHRP) under project number 1738. Using the Empirical Bayes method to account for regression to the mean, the total number of crashes expected for Crandon Blvd is 47.6 crashes per year including 1.0 pedestrians and 0.4 bicyclists. While the actual history of total crashes (3B.4lyr.) over the four years studied is less than that expected using HSM procedures (47.6lyr.), the number of pedestrian and bicycle crashes (7.21yr.) is much higher than expected (1.4/yr.). This is undoubtedly the result of the heavy concentration of pedestrians and bicyclists present in Key Biscayne. The HSM analysis indicates that the calculated rate of 1.4 crashes per year involving pedestrians and bicyclists would result in fatalities, whereas the historical average rate along Crandon is 0.2 fatalities. This is a clear indication that the 30-mph speed limit and possible vigilance of residents contributes to a lower than expected number of fatalities among pedestrians and bicyclists. Pedestrian safety is extremely critical when considering that between 2011 and 2014, inclus

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular Council Meeting December 10, 2019 — Minutes
  • Regular Council Meeting December 10, 2019

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9b1dc928da341c72e832b590d97f0de6. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record