POLISCOPE

The public record

HOLMES BEACH (MANATEE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Commission Regular Meeting

Tuesday, April 8, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

City Commission Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

10 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (10)

1. Approval of Minutes

2. New Business

3. New Business

4. Ordinance 25-08 was approved for First Reading.

approved

Police Pension Board Appointments — unanimous

approved

Ordinance 25-08 Non-Conforming Structures — unanimous

approved

Storm Maintenance Work Order — unanimous

passed

Appointments to the Police Pension Board of Trustees

passed

Authorize Work Order for Storm Maintenance

passed

First Reading - Ordinance 25-08 - Non-Conforming Structures

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

1 MINUTES City of Holmes Beach City Commission Regular Meeting April 8, 2025, 2:00 p.m. Patricia A. Geyer Commission Chambers 5801 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach FL 34217 Present: Commissioner Oelfke, Commissioner Schaefer, Commissioner Soustek, Commissioner Whitmore, Chair Diggins Staff Present: Mayor Titsworth, City Attorney Augello, City Clerk Johnston, Chief Tokajer, Director of Development Services Minor, Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya Also Present: Code Compliance Chief Thomas, Code Compliance Officer Brown, Digital/Media Strategist McDonough, and Project Manager Gorman _____________________________________________________________________ 1. Call to Order; Pledge of Allegiance; Moment of Silence Chair Diggins called the meeting to order at 2:00 p.m. 2. Roll Call 3. Approval of Minutes Moved by Commissioner Schaefer Seconded by Commissioner Soustek Approved March 25, 2025, Regular Meeting and Work Session Minutes. Motion Approved 3.a Regular Meeting - March 25, 2025 3.b Work Session - March 25, 2025 4. Commission Reports Commissioner Oelfke The City had a successful Hazardous Waste Cleanup. All bins that collected the items have been removed. The beach ends are being reviewed with Waste Pro to make sure they have the appropriate bins. There will be cleanup and reconstruction of those areas to determine if additional dumpsters are needed with the potential of pads being required. Chief Tokajer explained that a bin would not be added (except for a temporary dumpster bin during a holiday), but additional trash cans may be added. The City is partnering with Waste Pro the Tuesday after Memorial Day for a beach cleanup.

2 The Street Sweeper has been operating three days per week. Commissioner Soustek Attended the April 7 Sunshine, Records, and Ethics training sponsored by the City. She thanked the City for sponsoring the training stating it was well done and one of the most enjoyable classes she had attended. Commissioner Schaefer A memo discussing his meeting with representatives from Gloria Dei was provided to the City Commission. Commissioner Schaefer reported that a resident on 56th Street had complained about an odor as part of the sanitary sewer project. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya had reported that the odor was a result of the County's work in replacement of a water line. He reported that the County approached the City one and one-half years ago about improving the waterlines due to their age. He was unsure if they will be upgrading the lines but will research to find out. Pursuant to the agreement between the City and County, the County does not have to ask when doing work in the City. However, the City does want the system replaced and does enter the information into the Citizenserve software for documentation purposes. No permit is required. The City was originally informed the work would be completed in January or February 2025. Project Manager Gorman has been in coordination with the County. The County has now informed the City that a major part of their project will be completed this month and finalized mid-May. The water table had to be lowered in the area to do the work resulting in the ground water causing the sulfur smell to naturally occur. Chair Diggins Announced that Manatee County performed a trial run with the water taxi to see if they could utilize the boat slip owned by Jake Spooner near Waterline. After reviewing, Chair Diggins was informed that the boat would be able to get into the slip but would not have been able to get back out of it. Manatee County is looking at other options - use of a smaller boat or utilizing the Kingfish Boat Ramp. The only current water taxi landing area on the Island is in Bradenton Beach. 5. Mayor's Report City Flag Mayor Titsworth announced that Holmes Beach will be celebrating its 75th anniversary this year. Noting there is no official Holmes Beach flag, she asked that the City Commission to be a part of supporting its final design. Digital/Media Strategist McDonough presented a YouTube video announcing the new flag prototype. Information was distributed to the City Commission to include the flag design and color symbolism which has been attached as part of the official record. Code Compliance Chief Thomas and Code Compliance Officer Brown unfolded and presented Holmes Beach's new flag. Mayor Titsworth stated once receiving the City Commission's support banners with the new design will be placed on all City light poles. Happy anniversary shirts and hats will be made, along with other ideas being coordinated by Digital/Media Strategist McDonough. Small flags on sticks will be thrown out during parades, flags will be available for sale, etc.

3 Mayor Titsworth presented the idea of the City sponsoring an old-fashioned carnival with rides for the 75th Anniversary festivities. If the City is unable to find someone that would bring in a carnival, the festival would then be like the previous Sleigh Bell Social event. Having the script and video from the Holmes Beach play presented 25 years prior, Mayor Titsworth also would like the Holmes Beach play to be reenacted. She has been in discussions with the Historical Society but may need to find a school to assist with its production. Commissioner Schaefer said after seeing the flag, he felt the emphasis and colors were perfect. He said it further embellishes the projects the City is involved with. Chair Diggins agreed, stating it was beautiful. Key Royale Drive Parking Mayor Titsworth, Chief Tokajer, and Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya recently met with Key Royale homeowners. The homeowners relayed the message that they love Key Royale Drive the way it is currently. It was felt they would be losing too much property in the front if the City were to take back the right-of-way. Their homes are already close to the street so they asked if the City would allow them to police their streets themselves. They agreed to speak to the landscaping personnel and asked the Chief to give them a couple of weeks before the Police Department began issuing tickets. The residents' major concerns were about the continued speeding on that street and wanting speed tables added. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya is currently looking at the number of speed tables it will take to make an impact - potentially two or three. The property owners are happy with the sidewalk as is and prefer utilizing the available City funds for installing speed tables. Chief Tokajer confirmed that they have been doing good at keeping trucks and trailers off the road. The area is between 66th Street to the Key Royale bridge. Mayor Titsworth stated the City can order more 'Park with all tires off the road signs'. AMI Elementary Mayor Titsworth attended the third and fourth grade play on weather at the AMI Elementary. She was informed by the new principal that the school already has a waiting list for kindergarten roundup. 5.a Proclamation - National Public Safety Telecommunicators Week Mayor Titsworth read and presented the Proclamation to Chief Tokajer. 6. Comments by the Public Commissioner Whitmore was noted arriving at 2:32 p.m. Jim Kihm, 502 69th Street, noting it had been seven months since the 2024 storms, questioned the status relating to the replacement of the Memorial Benches. Mayor Titsworth explained that the City is presently in a holding pattern while determining the bench inventory. She stated the City cannot continue to replace benches in perpetuity and staff should have a recommendation at the April 22, 2025, meeting. Staff are proposing to replace, at the requestors' cost, any of the benches purchased within the past 10 years. Commissioner Whitmore agreed that if the citizen pays for the bench, the City will replace it at the citizen's expense. She was in favor of keeping the Memorial Bench program.

4 Mayor Titsworth confirmed that though the Memorial Benches would be considered City property, they were not insured. Unfortunately, the City would be unable to pay to have the benches replaced. A staff proposal will be presented at the next meeting to review staff's recommendations. 7. Unfinished Business None. 8. New Business 8.a Appointments to the Police Pension Board of Trustees Moved by Commissioner Schaefer Seconded by Commissioner Whitmore Approved reappointing Dan Hardy to serve on the Police Pension Board. New two- year term expiring April 1, 2027. Motion Approved Moved by Commissioner Schaefer Seconded by Commissioner Whitmore Greg Kerchner was selected to serve on the Police Pension Board for a two-year term expiring April 1, 2027. Motion Approved 8.b First Reading - Ordinance 25-08 - Non-Conforming Structures Development Services Director Minor read the Ordinance title. Development Services Director Minor referred to his staff report and explained the details and purpose for the Ordinance. The next step will be for the Planning Commission to review the Ordinance for consistency with the Comprehensive Plan. He noted there were many property owners who will benefit from the Ordinance revision. City Attorney Augello explained that with the approval of Ordinance 25-08 for First Reading it will fall under "zoning in process" which allows staff to implement the Ordinance language. Those that are sitting with their letters in abatement will not be punished if they do not meet the deadline. Moved by Commissioner Soustek Seconded by Commissioner Oelfke Ordinance 25-08 was approved for First Reading. Motion Approved 8.c Authorize the Mayor to execute a Work Order between Digging Deep Construction, Inc., and the City of Holmes Beach for City of Holmes Beach Storm Maintenance in the amount of $49,658.00. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya presented the City Commission with a revised Work Order to add the location of 63rd Street at Holmes Blvd. He explained that City staff have been finding some damage to the Stormwater system due to aged infrastructure and the neighbors in that area had noticed the pipe was not working.

5 Neighbors will be notified prior to work beginning, however, at this time there is no specific timeframe to begin work. An explanation relating to damage and replacement was provided. Digging Deep will resurface where the pipe will go across the street. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya stated there will be additional replacements at other locations coming forward. Commissioner Whitmore asked that maps to include compass directions be included with the Work Orders going forward. Action: There was unanimous consensus to authorize the Mayor to execute a Work Order between Digging Deep Construction, Inc., and the City of Holmes Beach for City of Holmes Beach Storm Maintenance in the amount of $49,658.00. 9. Announcements 10. Questions and Comments 10.a Questions and Comments from Mayor and City Commission Commissioner Whitmore Commissioner Whitmore announced she arrived late at the City Commission meeting due to participating in a Webex session with Representative Will Robinson. The topic addressed was that the Legislators are trying to make criteria harder for Statewide petitions. The Bill has been through the House and will be heard by the Senate next. She also plans to speak to Senator Boyd prior to his voting on the Bill. Further explanation followed. Commissioner Schaefer Commissioner Schaefer asked for an update relating to the fencing on the tennis courts, baseball field, and restoration on the City park. He said it was very important that the community be provided full accounting of what was and was not recoverable. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya reported that the City's Consultant has estimated the City's loss from the hurricanes at $9.2 million. Of that amount one-half of it is 100% reimbursable. One-fourth is 75% to 85% reimbursable such as sidewalks, roadways, etc. Mayor Titsworth stated some of the funds have been transferred from the Stormwater Maintenance budget. Any costs over what will be reimbursed can be taken from contingency. The Reserve funds for storms would be a last resort. She pointed out budget discussions are coming UP, and the main objection is to keep the Storm Reserves solid. She wants to continue adding money into that line item. She felt the Stormwater Assessment will be discussed soon. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya stated the dunes were all destroyed after the 2024 hurricanes. The County has spent time and effort on the beaches so discussion about beach nourishment with be forthcoming. Discussion continued about the City's excellent ability to obtain a line of credit if needed. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya announced that the next step is to address the City Field and that it will be regraded. He stated there are currently a lot of holes in the field that staff will be repairing along with contracting for irrigation which falls under the pre-storm debris hauler's agreement for repair work.

6 The gazebo currently has no power so a licensed electrician will be hired for repairs to the electrical line and will be billed to the debris hauler. Chair Diggins said last year he had mentioned adding landing lights on the City field for the Medivac helicopters. He felt with the City field repairs this would be a good time to add them. Chief Tokajer explained the process when one of the helicopters lands on the City Field noting the Police Department has lights there and makes the field accessible. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya stated the City also has portable lights if needed. Commissioner Whitmore asked if there was still a well in the field and if the City still had the lightening protectors both paid for by Rex Hagen. Public Works Director/City Engineer Kamiya reported that a fencing company will begin replacing the fence at the shuffleboard court the very next day. They will continue with the wind screening at the tennis court, fencing of the pickleball court, and the basketball court until each are complete. Speed Zone - AMI Elementary Chief Tokajer reported that the contract with Red Zone is still ongoing. An electrical permit with the City is required. Once the program begins the City will begin the public education process. The program will only be enforced in the mornings and afternoons when the flashing lights are on. The school zone has been moved to meet Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) criteria. He hopes the equipment will be installed within the next 30 days. Discussion continued relating to the enforcement of the school zone cameras in Bradenton and Palmetto, versus Manatee County. Gloria Dei Mayor Titsworth announced that she toured the Gloria Dei church with Development Services Director Minor, Building Official Schwartz, and Inspector Drees after the renovations and was very impressed. She hopes the City can come up with the funding to save the building. The City will be getting its own appraisal for purchasing the property. She gave examples for the use of the Gloria Dei property if purchased, such as green space, soccer, farmer's markets, a sanctuary place for weddings and concerts, art festivals, etc. It will be dependent on the type of funding that can be utilized. She said it would have to be built to today's elevation requirements to use the building as an Emergency Operations Center or for Public Works operations. She wants to keep it in its current state and plans to pursue Tourist Development Council (TDC) funding. Commissioner Schaefer referred to his Commission report noting that to the City's benefit we have the right of first refusal prior to opening the sale up to the public. He recommended staff begin assessing all acquisition costs to include any repairs, modification of the facility to meet the City's purpose, and programming efforts. The information will be needed before determining funding, grants acquired, etc. to move forward. Director of Development Services Minor stated once the City has an appraisal it can be used as a negotiating point. The City will then decide what bucket of funding to pursue based on the determined use of the property. He felt the City is in the beginning stage right now. He extended the offer to request access to the building for each of the City Commissioners to individually look at the building.

7 The property is zoned Public / Semi-public Use and is three separate parcels that will not be sold separately. Discussion continued. Commissioner Oelfke suggested if the building were to be utilized as a multi-use facility, offices could be rented out to recover the costs. Director of Development Services Minor stated it could be opened to as many people as possible. Examples included the AMI Chamber, City Commission meetings, and Turtle Watch. Commissioner Schaefer stated that the property's attorney realized up front about the zoning and that when the church approached the City for a rezoning it was rejected. The attorney has handled all sales throughout the State of FL and favors on the side of the City. Commissioner Soustek encouraged the Commissioners to look at the purchase as a long-term benefit. She noted when former City Commissioner Billie Martini wanted to buy Grassy Point there was no use for it at that time. Since that time the benefits have outweighed the purchase. She asked that the City Commissioners not be afraid of the cost. 10.b Questions and Comments from City Attorney None. 10.c Questions and Comments from Staff Chief Tokajer There has been a 77% reduction in crime over the past 13 years in Holmes Beach. Chief Tokajer said the reduction is a result of how he polices, and that the City has its own Dispatch Center that will reduce the response time. He thanked the City Commission for recognizing the dispatchers with a Proclamation. Director of Development Services  AMI Turtle Watch is hosting a training in Holmes Beach on Wednesday, April 16, 2025.  Sea Turtle Training to be held in Pinellas on April 23, 2025.  To date 2,217 Building Permits have been issued since the 2024 Hurricanes, 47 demolitions, and 5,464 inspections.  1,675 active Vacation Rental Certificates  Waste Pro tonnage for March - 330 Commercial and 265 Residential  The number of unrepaired Vacation Rentals will be researched by Development Services Director Minor 10.d Questions and Comments from the Public and Press None. 11. Adjournment Chair Diggins adjourned the meeting at 3:46 p.m.

8 _________________________ Stacey Johnston, MMC, City Clerk _________________________ Minutes Approved

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Commission Regular Meeting — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9ade1e063cb53bca18d90b6344104768. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record