POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Planning Advisory Board

Wednesday, June 11, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Naples Planning Advisory Board met to review property development petitions, including a request to elevate a flood-damaged home and a proposal for a subdivision replat. The board recommended approval for the elevation project and began hearing a case regarding property line adjustments.

Why it matters

The board's recommendation to allow a home elevation sets a precedent for how the city manages nonconforming properties seeking to improve flood resiliency following recent hurricanes.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. It is noted for the record that: 1) all documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; 2) added attachments are referenced in red as “Added Attachment”; and 3) Alternate Member Cooper acted as a voting Member for Item 7C. 1) Call to Order Chair Coughlan called the meeting to order. 2) Roll Call Board Members Present: Daniel Barone Patrick Coughlan, Chair John Crees William Kapler, Vice Chair Gregory Fowler Andrew Mair Scott Schultz Garey Cooper, Alternate Member Board Members Absent: Amy Lockhart, Non-Voting School Board Rep. Staff Present: Andrew Dickman, Assistant City Attorney Andrew Dickman, Assistant City Attorney Erica Martin, Planning Director Jeffrey Brammer, Senior Planner-Long Range Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Petitioners and/or Agents: Clay Brooker Kathleen LeTart Noel Davies Thomas Scangarello Norman Trebilcock Others Present: Julie and Bill Kapler 3) Pledge of Allegiance Chair Coughlan led the Pledge of Allegiance. 4) Changes to the Agenda None. 5) Public Comment None. 6) Approval of Minutes MOTION by Mair to APPROVE the May 14, 2025 meeting minutes; seconded by Crees and unanimously carried, all Members present and voting (Barone- yes, Crees-yes, Fowler-yes, Kapler-yes, Mair-yes, Schultz-yes, Coughlan- yes). 2025-0514 pabr minutes 7) Public Hearing(s) 7.A) PETITION 25-N3 - A Resolution Determining Nonconformity Petition 25-N3 Pursuant to Section 46-35 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Naples, to Allow for the Expansion of a Nonconforming Single-Family Residence and Guest House on the Property

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 2 Located in the R3T-12 Multi-Family District, Owned by Kathleen LeTarte, and Located at 794 9th Street South; More Fully Described Herein; Providing Findings and Conditions; and Providing an Effective Date. Chair Coughlan read the title of the Item. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an oath to those intending to testify; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Cooper, Mair, Barone, Kapler, Coughlan, Crees, and Schultz / no information to disclose; and Fowler / visited the property. Clay Brooker, Attorney at Cheffy Passidomo P.A., utilized an electronic presentation to provide an overview of Nonconformity Petition 25-N3, identifying that the request was to allow for a vertical expansion of the single-family residence and guest house. Responding to flood damage incurred from Hurricanes Ian and Milton, he explained that the owners were requesting to raise the first floor of the single-family residence 5 feet to achieve an elevation of 10.6 feet under the North American Vertical Datum of 1988 (NAVD), and to raise the bottom floor of the guest house 7.2 feet to achieve an elevation of 12.1 feet NAVD. Attorney Brooker noted that the current structures were a legal non-conformity, with both structures encroaching on the front yard and side yard setbacks. Senior Planner-Long Range Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and provided an overview of the staff report and the conditions contained therein. He noted a scrivener’s error in the first condition of the proposed Resolution, stating that there was no horizontal expansion. He then explained that the expanded stairway for the guest house will be internal and will meet the setbacks; however, the main house stairway will encroach no more than three feet into the front yard setback, which is permitted by Naples City Code. Senior Planner Brammer stated that staff mailed letters to neighboring property owners regarding the petition, and staff received seven letters of support. He stated that staff reviewed the petition against the criteria in Section 46-35(c) of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Responding to questions, Planning Director Erica Martin stated that although these were the first structures being raised in the neighborhood, other residences within the City were also being raised for resiliency. Member Mair recommended keeping the mention of “horizontal expansion” in the first condition of the proposed Resolution, noting that the staircase will be extended further into the setback, regardless of whether it is allowed by Naples City Ordinance. Member Schultz suggested raising the property higher. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Crees to RECOMMEND APPROVAL of Nonconformity Petition 25-N3; seconded by Kapler and unanimously carried, all Members present and voting (Barone-yes, Crees-yes, Fowler-yes, Kapler-yes, Mair-yes, Schultz-yes, Coughlan-yes). 25-N3 Staff Report 25-N3 Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Warranty Deed Survey Aerial Architectural Plans - Main House Architectural Plans - Guest House Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Correspondence Affidavit of Sign Posting Affidavit of Sign Posting 2 Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 7.B) A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Appeal of an Administrative Decision 25-AA1 Relating to the Replatting of an Approximately 0.48 Acre Property Located at 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South and an Approximately 0.48 Acre Property Located at 45 5th Avenue South. Petition withdrawn. 25-AA1 Staff Report 25-AA1 - Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest - Ocean Breeze 131 LLC Affidavit of Authorization Ocean Breeze 131 LLC

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 3 Disclosure of Interest - Hamilton Kenneth and Karen Affidavit of Authorization Hamilton Kenneth and Karen Warranty Deed - 45 5th Ave S - Ocean Breeze 131 LLC Warranty Deed - 450 Gulf Shore Blvd S - Hamilton Location Map Credentials - Planning Department Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Withdrawal Email - Davies 6-5-2025 7.C) PETITION 25-SD1 - A Resolution Relating to a Subdivision Replat; Approving and Accepting the Preliminary and Final (Record) Replat for Property Located at 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South, Containing Approximately 0.48 Acres, Owned by Kenneth C. and Karen B. Hamilton, and Property Located at 45 5th Avenue South, Containing Approximately 0.48 Acres, Owned by Ocean Breeze 131, LLC, More Fully Described Herein; Requiring Recording; Approving Subdivision Petition 25-SD1; and Providing an Effective Date. Chair Coughlan read the title of the Item. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an oath to those intending to testify; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Mair / received an email to set up a meeting with the petitioner, but they did not meet; Barone / had a brief meeting with the petitioner’s attorney, who reviewed the presentation; Crees / familiar with the property and had a virtual discussion with the petitioner’s representative; Schultz / visited the property; Kapler / visited the property and had a conversation with the petitioner’s attorney; Coughlan and Cooper / no information to disclose. Member Kapler stated that, under the opinion of the Independent Ethics Commission’s Executive Director, Michael Murawski, he would recuse himself from this hearing, noting that he owns an adjacent property. He completed a Form 8B Memorandum of Voting Conflict for County, Municipal, and Other Local Public Officers, both of which have been included in the meeting packet. Member Kapler removed himself from the dais, and Alternate Member Cooper acted as a voting Member for this hearing. Noel Davies, Attorney at Davies Duke PLLC, utilized an electronic presentation to provide an overview of a subdivision replat. He explained that the petition proposed to move the northern property line of 45 5th Avenue South southward, therefore decreasing the lot size of 45 5th Avenue South and increasing the flag lot at 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South. Planning Director Erica Martin testified on behalf of the City and provided an overview of the staff report and the conditions therein. She explained that both properties are single-family lots, and although both properties are located in the R1-10 Zoning District, 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard also has a portion of the property located in the R1-15 Zoning District. Planning Director Martin informed the Board that a subdivision replat in this manner would normally be an administrative approval, but due to 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South being a flag lot, the replat must be reviewed by the Planning Advisory Board and approved by the City Council. She notified the Board that staff mailed 268 letters to neighboring property owners and received one email in response with concerns about what may be placed in the newly annexed space. Planning Director Martin stated that staff reviewed the petition and found that it was substantially consistent with Section 54-4 of the Land Development Code, but did not meet the criteria for a minor subdivision due to the expansion of a flag lot. Discussion ensued, and Planning Director Martin confirmed that construction had begun at 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South, and the approved plans currently did not indicate any development on the proposed additional portion. She stated that the City did not have plans identifying when the flag lot was created, noting that residents historically were able to obtain approvals for replats through the Collier County Property Appraiser without approval from the City, but could identify its boundaries as far back as 1973. Responding to Member Barone, Attorney Davies stated that although plans were in the design phase for the additional area of 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South, the intent was to place a circular

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 4 driveway as well as garages with habitable space above toward the proposed southern property line. Public Comment: Julie and Bill Kapler stated that if a residence was built on 45 5th Avenue South, it would be at least 45 feet from their property, due to the 20-foot driveway and 25-foot setback. Concerned about the impact of the new development and the replat, Ms. Kapler requested that a 45-foot buffer be codified to ensure adequate separation between her property line and any structures on the new parcel. Responding to questions, Attorney Davies stated that construction commenced on the original lot first, and then the opportunity to purchase 45 5th Avenue South was brought to the petitioner’s attention. He informed the Board that he could not commit to imposing a 45-foot setback without discussing it with the petitioner, noting that there could be a negative impact on the property value and resale. Regarding the Kapler family’s concerns, Attorney Davies noted that he reached out on June 10th to resolve their concerns, and at that time, the Kaplers asked for a 40-foot setback. He further affirmed that the petition complied with the Naples City Code as presented and that any construction would be at least 20 feet from the Kaplers' property line due to the setback and easement. Following a brief discussion regarding the process, Chair Coughlan proffered a motion to recommend approval, and Member Crees seconded. Following a brief discussion, Member Barone proffered an amendment that was approved by the mover and seconder; the following motion was then made. MOTION by Coughlan to RECOMMEND APPROVAL of Subdivision Replat 25- SD1 for property located at 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South and 45 5th Avenue South, subject to the added condition that the petitioner will include on the replat of 450 Gulf Shore Boulevard South lot, a required setback for vertical construction from the northern property line, applicable to the conveyed portion of the new property, of which the dimension of the setback is to be determined through meaningful dialogue with the adjacent property owner at 40 4th Avenue South to mitigate any adverse effects of the requested subdivision replat prior to City Council consideration of this petition; seconded by Crees and carried 4-3 (Fowler-yes, Kapler-abstain, Schultz-no, Cooper-no, Barone-yes, Crees-yes, Mair-no, Coughlan-yes). 25-SD1 - Staff Report 25-SD1 - Resolution Subdivision Application Disclosure of Interest - Ocean Breeze 131 LLC Affidavit of Authorization Ocean Breeze 131 LLC Disclosure of Interest - Hamilton Kenneth and Karen Affidavit of Authorization Hamilton Kenneth and Karen Warranty Deed - 45 5th Ave S - Ocean Breeze 131 LLC Warranty Deed - 450 Gulf Shore Blvd - Hamilton Location Map Survey 450 Gulf Shore Blvd S - Current Survey 45 5th Ave S - Current Proposed Survey 450 Gulf Shore Blvd S - After Lot Split Proposed Survey 45 5th Ave S - After Lot Split Survey of Portion to be Conveyed to 450 S Gulf Shore Blvd Traffic Circulation and Trips Analysis Credentials - Planning Department Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Correspondence Kramer Ethics Opinion (Staff Added Attachment) Form 8B Memorandum of Voting Conflict for County, Municipal, and Other Local Public Officers (Kramer Added Attachment) 7.D) PETITION 25-CU4 - A Resolution Determining Conditional Use Petition 25-CU4, Relating to a Conditional Use Pursuant to Section 50-102(b)(2) of the Code of Ordinances, City of Naples, to Allow Required Parking Within 600 Feet of a Lot to Accomplish Shared Parking on Property Owned By Hygate Properties, LLC., and

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 5 Located at 1795, 1801-1841 9th Street North, More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. Chair Coughlan read the title of the Item. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an oath to those intending to testify; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Cooper, Mair, Barone, Kapler, Coughlan, Schultz / no information to disclose; Crees / familiar with the property; and Fowler / visited the property. Thomas Scangarello, Professional Planner at Scangarello LLC, utilized an electronic presentation to provide an overview of a petition requesting the allowance of shared parking between the property owners of 1795 9th Street North and 1801-1841 9th Street North (Moorings Park Plaza) by utilizing 63 spaces at Moorings Park Plaza, 10 spaces at 1795 9th Street North, 11 spaces at a City owned lot adjacent to a linear park, and 10 spaces on Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) property that was being leased to the petitioner, totaling 94 parking spaces. Planner Scangarello confirmed that approval of this shared parking configuration will address all the required parking for both properties involved, as well as one additional space required for a separate companion petition for outdoor dining at Charred, a restaurant located within the Moorings Park Plaza. Noting that a petition was presented to City Council in 2023 and was denied, Planner Scangarello presented a proposed circulation plan within the parking lot, identifying that it will address City Council’s concerns of congestion, traffic circulation, and safety, as well as address the concerns related to the Outdoor Dining petition. He asked that language be added to the resolution that only live plants would be installed around the outdoor dining area as a condition of approval. Senior Planner-Long Range Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and provided an overview of the staff report and the conditions contained therein. He confirmed that the Conditional Use petition was required to facilitate Outdoor Dining at Charred restaurant, which had been filed as a separate petition that will be sent directly to the City Council for approval. He confirmed that 84 parking spaces were required for all commercial spaces previously mentioned, using the shared parking, and that this proposed petition will generate 94 shared parking spaces. Senior Planner Brammer stated that staff applied the criteria found in 46-34(d) of the Land Development Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. Member Crees suggested that the City consider increasing the $10.00 lease agreement fee. Norman Trebilcock, Traffic Engineer at Trebilcock Consulting Solutions, identifying that he was involved with the creation of the lease agreement, stated that it was the result of neighbors on Mandarin Road voicing their concerns regarding the parallel parking in the right-of-way. Responding to those concerns, the petitioner moved the right-of-way parallel parking behind the Moorings Park Plaza on Mandarin Road to the newly built, city-owned parking lot and beautified the area with landscaping. Member Mair identified the difficulty of parking in front of Charred restaurant if patrons entered via the southern entrance. Vice Chair Kapler suggested making the southern entrance an exit only. Planner Scangarello offered the shared parking spaces to the south, or to exit the property and circle back to the northern entrance. Although Alternate Member Cooper expressed the view that this proposal was for the greater good, he suggested all spaces be converted to angled parking to encourage front-end parking. MOTION by Kapler to RECOMMEND APPROVAL of Conditional Use Petition 25-CU4; seconded by Barone and carried 4-3, all Members present and voting (Fowler-yes, Mair-no, Schultz-no, Kapler-yes, Barone-yes, Crees-no, Coughlan-yes). 25-CU4 Staff Report 25-CU4 Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Warranty Deed Survey Aerial Site Plan Parking Calculations - REVISED Petitioner - Cover Letter

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 6 Resolution - ROW Improvements - 2017 Temporary Use Agreement - 2017 Temporary Use Extension - 2021 FDOT Lot Use Agreement - 2023 Proposed City Parking Agreement - 2023 Resolution - City Council Denial - 2023 Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 8) Comprehensive Plan Update Planning Director Erica Martin informed the Board that Johnson Engineering remained in the data- gathering phase for the Comprehensive Plan Update but had developed a Public Involvement Plan (PIP) that will be presented to City Council at its June 16, 2025 meeting. She stated that she would provide the presentation materials via email to each Member and invited comments. Responding to Member Crees, Planning Director Martin stated that the PIP includes various public engagement opportunities, such as a survey component and public meetings. Member Fowler expressed concern that the Board will not review the presentation prior to City Council, emphasizing the Board’s role in overseeing and providing recommendations regarding the Comprehensive Plan. Memorandum Naples 2045 Comprehensive Plan Update progress 6-11-2025 9) Traffic Study Update Planning Director Erica Martin referenced two memos from Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett, informing the Board that the Streets and Stormwater Department will provide a Traffic Study update in the fall and will invite the consultant to attend and address questions. Vice Chair Kapler and Member Fowler expressed concern that an update would be presented to City Council at its June 16, 2025 meeting, before the Board would be afforded an update. Member Fowler asked to have the information presented to the Board first to advise the City Council. Member Mair agreed and noted that the Traffic Element was a large and impactful part of the Comprehensive Plan, but that staff and Johnson Engineering were not at fault for the preliminary update being presented to City Council first. Chair Coughlan emphasized that the Board remains ready and willing to fulfill its responsibilities related to the Comprehensive Plan, including the Traffic Study. PAB Update - Downtown Traffic Study 2025-06-04 6-11-2025 PAB Traffic Study Update - revised 10) Public Comment None. 11) Correspondence and Communication Assistant City Attorney Andrew Dickman provided information to the Board regarding the differences between quasi-judicial hearings and legislative hearings; overviewing the historical background of quasi-judicial items, ex parte disclosures, and various types of testimony. He stated that he will email information regarding the Bert Harris Act, property rights, Senate Bill 250, and the pending Senate Bill 108 to each Member. Questions were answered throughout the presentation. Responding to questions by Member Schultz regarding fees, Assistant City Attorney Dickman stated that petition filing fees must be related to direct costs and reasonable indirect costs incurred by the City, and they cannot be used for revenue or be punitive. He stated that the Ordinance regulating the filing fees could be amended to reflect the most current direct and indirect costs. Additionally, Assistant City Attorney Dickman mentioned that impact fees were imposed on petitions to address the repercussions a development would have on infrastructure, for example. Chair Coughlan suggested discussing impact fees at a future meeting and suggested that the City Council consider increasing the filing and impact fees.

Planning Advisory Board Regular Meeting – June 11, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 7 12) Adjourn 10:50 a.m. ___________________________________ Patrick Coughlan, Chair ______________________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Minutes prepared by: _____________________________________ Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Minutes Approved: 09/10/2025.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Advisory Board

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9ab266f7ff5ab4a9956eb996a71f0d50. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record