POLISCOPE

The public record

MARTIN COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM

Tuesday, December 9, 2025 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Board of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 192,736 stored characters

Board meeting. This is our last meeting of the year. We are delighted that you ve joined us this morning. Uh, please join us for the invocation led by Reverend Singh, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance, which is going to be led by Deputy Andrew Ross. Good morning. Good morning. Thank you for inviting me. Let s unite in heart, mind and spirit. Creator of our glorious universe, author of all life giver of every good and gracious gift. Thank you for the life we have together. Thank you for our great nation, our home state of Florida and our beloved Martin County. Gracious one, as we celebrate the holidays in all of our unique and wonderful ways. We pray that you will grant us your peace Give us eyes to see your goodness and mercy in one another, whatever our faith social station or background. Lead us to welcome and greet one another as neighbors. And grant us the compassion, courage, and inner strength to care for one another, especially in our disagreements. MAY your loving spirit inspire us to strive not only for our own good, not only for the good of our friends or allies or supporters. But for the good of all. In this holy time, MAY your justice, mercy, and steadfast love, the rain down on this entire planet, and bless us all with life, liberty, and peace. Amen. Amen Be. Deputy Ross, would you lead us in the, in the pledge and then tell us about your, uh, army career, ma am. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Good morning. Good morning. Yes, I, I joined the military in 2000 with the 724th mp battalion out of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and then I was deployed to Bagram, Afghanistan in 2007 to 2008. Upon returning, I joined the 2nd of the 108th mp battalion out of Fort Jackson where I currently am an mp instructor, um, non-commissioned officer in charge at the debt in, um, by a Gun Club Road. And, and that s it s got 25 years. Thank you very much for your service. And now we have a special treat this morning. We have the children from the Gir Gertrude Walden Child Care Center, and they re going to sing Christmas carols to us. So please join us as we enjoy the children from Gertrude w Wall. Good morning, good morning. Oops Good morning. Yeah Yeah. Good morning. Good I bring you greetings from Gertrude w Wald and Child Care Center. This is our vpk class. Vpk is voluntary pre-kindergarten, so these are the kids that would be entering kindergarten in the fall. But this year Gertrude w Waldden Child Care Center is one of 7 rated excellent at the state level. On the treasure Coast. Elc serves serves Martin Indian River and Okeechobee County. So out of all the bpk programs in those three counties, they were only 7 that rated excellent and Gercha Waldden is one of those 7. We are very and I know as a former fifth grade teacher, it s very important that children enter kindergarten ready and that s what we strive to do every day. This past week we had the pleasure of going to ice at the Gaylord Palms, the kids had a great time. They sung at the city commission meeting yesterday and we are happy to be here today. Boys and girls, are you ready? Ok, good morning. So we re gonna do jingle bells first, ready? 123. Go bell jingle bell jingle all the way. Oh far it is. Right one la we GOD. Laughing on the way. The rain that is very by is right. Second daughter. A jingle bell jingle bell jingle Oh. Oh want to around her leg. Jingle be ll jingle bell jingle you top right, MISS Him a merry Christmas. 123, we wish you for this ple as ure and a happy New year. The time we right to. Your kids We wish you a merry Christmas and a happy. On this Friday, this same group will perform in the Nutcrack er at the Lierry Theater. We ve been doing this with a partnership with Florida Arts and Dance. I think this is maybe the 12th year, so they are performed two shows on Friday and a show on Saturday at the Liric, and we have kids that started with dance at Geritu Waldden that, Kylie James is now in the middle of high school and still dancing. So it s great that they get that experience and that exposure to keep it going. Alright boys and girls, are we ready for our last song. Star, we re ready tv 7 2nd delay, so. We see themselves yeah course my of Ready? Ok, boys and girls It s I a Please it. I f a I man. A Merry Christmas me. I. A good Merry Christmas You Christmas I police say. No I was respect your Christmas I. Your Christmas It s me. Go. Oh. What s That s true. That s very true. That s very very true. MADAM Chair, I make a motion to end the meeting. It s only gonna go downhill from now, I can promise you that. Oh, let see. We will begin our meeting with public comment. We have a preset at 10:30 of Parks and Recreation Master Plan, uh, at 5:05 or at the end of the meeting, we will have public comment, um, there s an additional item which is Department 4, which is discussion on the Stuart West Planned unit development which we will move up to the beginning of the meeting in order to accommodate our guests. Um, and there are no consent items that are pulled uh, so is there a motion? Oh, and also another preset is that the 9:15 we re all gonna say happy birthday to Commissioner Vargas. Happy birthday. Happy birthday. I ll move approval of the agenda. Second, there s a motion and a second to all those in favor, I oppose that motion passes unanimously. Uh, request to speak, we will, you ll each have 3 minutes to address us. The first request to speak for I have is from Deborah v Vigotsky, followed by Constantin Ale Alex Senko. Maybe. Morning in Good morning commissioners and county officials and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Deb Vigosky. My husband and I built our home in Stuart West in 2017, drawn to its equestrian nature and the long established character of this community. I actually come from a family of community service. My father was a town COUNCILMAN. My mother was a planning commissioner in Fairfax County, Virginia, a county that also experienced tremendous growth, especially during their tenure. Through them, I learned two things very early. First, while growth is inevitable, well planned growth is essential and second, that navigating community dynamics is one of the most challenging and often the most rewarding parts of public service. Your roles are incredibly important in the work you do for the county is truly appreciated. There are 2 items on today s agenda that affect Stuart West and Cobblestone. The first is the Martin County or Martin Martin Commerce Park project across Martin Highway, and the second is the Stuart West Pudd, which is currently in the pre-application status. I m not here to speak for or against the commerce Park project itself, but I do want to emphasize the importance of ensuring public safety, infrastructure keeps pace with planed growth. This Thursday, 2 days from today, marks 1 year since a devastating fire destroyed our home. Our car and its contents, and it took first responders 20 minutes to reach our home. My husband, golden retriever Champ, and I were thankfully unharmed, and we expect to be back in our home by JUNE 18 months after the fire. Having a fire station with emergency medical personnel across the highway would dramatically improve response times and protect both lives and property. Whatever decisions are ultimately made regarding the commerce park, I respectfully urge that the county prioritize establishing a fire rescue presence in this rapidly growing corridor. I also want to thank, um, Commissioner Campi and County Attorney Elise Elder for putting agenda item on to clear up some information that has been shared in our community. Um our association PRESIDENT, as well as some others have said that the county is requiring that our puppy changed, that commissioner Campi offered a discount to do that, and that animals that have resided safely in our community for decades would be removed. I want to clearly state my opposition to the proposed amendment to the Stuart West Pudd. By adding the undefined and broadened term of domesticated animals, it would authorize barnyard species such as chickens. Ducks, goats, pigs, a major shift in our residential zoning. Thank you again for your service and for your thoughtful attention to the needs of Stuart West Cobblestone as well as the entire county. Thank you. Thank you Constantin Alexsenko is next, followed by Rob Reinieri. Time to the agenda time to the agenda item or sure, sure. Rob Reinieri is next, followed by Sherry Wilson. Morning commissioners Rob Reneri, ceo for House of Hope, uh, couple things on your agenda today that I just wanted to touch base on. One is the discussion and hopefully uh approval to transmit the um the changes around accessory dwelling units, um. House of Hope has a housing committee that s had the opportunity to work closely with county staff on a lot of that. Uh, I just want to say that this will be a great tool to add to our toolbox. Uh, we have a serious lack of affordable housing, um, creating some accessory dwelling units will definitely help, uh, young people starting out in their careers, help seniors that are struggling to find affordable housing. Uh help women that are uh sort of moving on out of some of our local shelters, so it ll serve a great purpose in helping people to transition to safe housing and to get their footing back in in the community. Um, I also wanted to thank the staff for all of their hard work on this. Uh, every time we have the opportunity to work with your staff, it s always a pleasure. I also learn a lot. You have great team of experts, and I appreciate everything that they do. Uh, I wanted to also talk about Martin Commerce Park, um to me, the most exciting thing about that is going to be um the addition of more living wage and beyond jobs, um, for our work at House of Hope, it s one of the biggest challenges is trying to help our clients find uh employment that will allow them the opportunity to be able to pay all their bills, um, and to be able to live, work and play in Martin County. So we never have enough of those kinds of jobs. Anything that will, uh, safely and efficiently bring more of those opportunities to community as a win, so I appreciate your consideration on that as well. Thank you to all of you for all you do. Thanks for another great year in Martin County. We appreciate your service and everything that you do for our community. Sherry Wilson is next, followed by Kathy Jensen. Good morning, commissioners, and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Sherry Wilson and my husband Kermit and I moved to Stuart West just last year. I would also like to congratulate Elise Elder on her Martin County, uh, attorney. We appreciate the clarity and professionalism you ve brought to recent discussions. When we retired, we chose Martin County very intentionally. We were seeking an equestrian community, not a farm, one where we could enjoy our retirement with our animals, our two miniature horses, Oreo and Cinnabon and our beautiful Morgan horse Livia. Livia and our two puppies, Laney and Lucy, um, all lived there. Stuart West is home and it s where we plan to spend the rest of our lives. Before retirement, I spent decades as the top real estate agent in Loudoun County, Virginia, the most affluent county. In the country. Loudon is very similar to Martin County, a blend of farms, equestrian properties, rural estates, and suburban neighborhoods as a seasoned real estate professional. I have a deep respect for county authority, zoning orient ordinances, land use protections and the governing documents of homeowners associations and property associations. I m very familiar with pu d s and why they exist, why they were created and they were created thoughtfully and intentionally throughout my career, I have worked with people who absolutely did not want a homeowner association and others who very much did. When Kerin and I chose Stuart West, we did so because it s a deed restricted equestrian community with stable animals permitted but not barnyard animals. That distinction mattered to us and it still does. Unfortunately, a small but vocal group within our community is now attempting to change the very nature of our 40 year old equestrian neighborhood. They are trying to turn a residential equestrian community into a farm, including barnyard animals such as chickens, ducks, goats, and pigs and more. Kermit and I love our horses, but we purposely chose not to live on a farm. We do not want Stuart West to become something it was never intended to be. As someone who has spent a lifetime in real estate, I am well aware. Of the impact such as changes that changes can have on property values. It can lower property values and not only, uh, it can hurt homeowners, uh, and it can reduce the tax base that supports Martin, your time is up. Thank you. Uh, thank you. Um for letting me speak. Thank you. Kathy Jensen is next. Followed by Christopher Corey. Good morning. I would like to reserve my time at a later agenda time. Ok, for Stuart West Meadow Meadow Run, got it. And MISTER Alex Seko, are you Metal run or Stuart West? Ok. Christopher Corey is next. Followed by Rick Hartman Morning commissioners. So, uh, I apologize a bit if I look tired. I got in on the red Eye Fort Lauderdale at 10 A.M. Uh, yeah, listen, I ve been before you guys a few times now regarding this, um, today it looks like, you know, there s a lot of people here, uh, from Meadow Run and honestly I m, I m standing here and I didn t want to pack all 1600 of our members here, yeah, I don think you had seating for it. You know, we had 130 declarations, individual declarations, um, and honestly, you know, in the last two months, you know, I ve, I received a lot of pressure regarding this issue. Um, I guess that just kind of comes with how things go, uh, but to me it was disappointing that it was unrelated to the issue uh, and then late last night I got a, got a message from um sorry it was pretty emotional, but got a message that another one of our kids received their academic and um athletic scholarship to Flagler College that puts us well over 50 for the year. Spoke to another parent who their child reached a year off of adhd medication, and I ve been here before talking to you about our mission for that. Uh, so, kind of reinvigorated me on a few hours of sleep to come in here and basically say that, you know, I know that there s going to be a lot of, you know, redundant messaging about this gate and it would have been really easy for me to stand in front of you and go, I received a lot of pressure, guys you know, I m gonna remove my objection and our 1600 members objecting to this gate. But I really can t do that because ultimately all of these great things that our mission has done, um, that has made us very popular, which you re awawaware they re gonna tell you, you know, that, that we have a lot of members and we re managing that the best we can, but, uh, none of it really matters if they get hit by a construction truck. Just doesn t so thank you for your time and uh yeah, good luck today and you know, I know your job is very difficult, so thank you for your service. Thank you. Rick Hartman is next, followed by Cornelis Boy. Hammager Thank you. Good morning. Good morning, commissioners. My name is Rick Hartman. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to you. I want to speak to you on Martin Commerce Park, and I wasn t going to come this morning. I ve lived in Stuart West for around 20 years, but I had to meet a tractor driver this morning, further west. So I coming back on 7:14 and one of my fellow residents came out of the neighborhood and it it was really kind of scary. So what I m really in favor with the Martin Commerce Park is the is the fire station out there that would save us 500 to $6000 on our homeowners insurance and a stop light, at least a caution light I, I don t know how many people get out on 7:14 early in the morning or late in the evening. It s horrible. So a stoplight there that dashed the capital or Martin Commerce Park is gonna pay for would be a really benefit to us. So thank you for your time. I hope you approve them. Have a good day. Thank you. Cornelis p Pamai followed by Benjamin Sharfee. Good morning, commissioners My name is Cornelis Parmier. I m the PRESIDENT Of Stuart West pua. I thank you for the opportunity to respond to statements you have recently heard from 4 Stuart West residents. I ve previously addressed the misinformation that was disseminated by MISS Troba. First, all 4 speakers have not provided you with a shred of evidence. I have 6 copies here that provide solid evidence of everything I m, uh, going to say, MISS Alan continues to assert that this board wants to allow chickens in Stuart West t This is false. A message from the PRESIDENT To the community clearly stated that chickens and other barnyard animals are prohibited under our government documents. It has been clearly communicated with Stuart West residents that aligning the pud with the county is necessary. Despite his written notices, MISS Otund continues to circulate misinformation You have been told that the PRESIDENT Has been recalled. I m standing here before you as PRESIDENT Of Stuart West poa. MISTER Graven and other challenged board through three separate recall efforts. All three were dismissed by legal counsel for failing to meet statutory and procedural requirements. The court will decide on this next year. MR. Griffin filed a complaint with the Florida bar Association against counsel. That complaint was dismissed. He then filed a second complaint with higher ups. That was dismissed. And if that was not enough, they he filed another one against an associate of Blo and Scarpa that was also dismissed. MISTER Haynes has raised objections to the pud. The documents I have provided to the commission clearly explained the reason for the pud alignment. Furthermore, the allegations that theor was never offered a fee reduction is false. This claim is directly contradicted by the written communication from Planner Peter Walden, a copy of which I have included in this review for you. Relevant portions have been highlighted. The county would surely have refused a preliminary pud application if it was not necessary. In it was in the meantime approved. John Sinnott would not have sent us an invitation to submit a final pud as a next step. Lastly something is very wrong with many individuals in our community. If I feel compelled to wear a body cam for security reasons. I thank you for your attention. I wish you happy holidays. I appreciate all you do for Martin County and your services, and a happy New Year. Thank you. Can I leave this here with Benjamin Sharfie is next, followed by Joshua Mirro. Good morning, everybody. I m Ben Chafee. Um I m here to speak on behalf of not, not necessarily myself or Jacob Community Center. Jacobbini Cener is just to the east of Leighton Farm. Leighton Farm is between, uh, uh, I mean, uh, Meadowon Um, we are between citrus and Leighton Farm. Uh, 8 years ago I started this program called jcc Jacob Community Center. Jacob was my father on his behalf, and the purpose of Jacob Community Center is to have people like Chris and uh kids that come out there of all ages and we have soccer program full school programs for uh people and kids at Kotri center, soccer, indoor soccer soon. And school for all ages, in fact, my uh fiancee s, uh, uh uh nephew goes to school there. It s a great school and Chris Corey, and Vicky did doing a great job and we are just to uh south of them. Uh, currently in Meadowons there something 500 to 70 homes uh over there. I don t know the exact count. And all these homes were built with the idea that that gate was closed. There was no traffic. They, the traffic that is, uh, proposed to go there. It s not a good idea, and I ll explain the reasons for that. I opened up the road with a uh uh aide of MR. Crisda and Donaldson to open up the road where it ended all the way to the end of Leighton Farm at a cost of over $3,200,000 adding, uh, drainage and uh whatever need necessary to open that road for safe use. Leyton Farm Road is not a safe road. It s 18 ft wide at the best. And right now fpnl if you guys have been there lately, they re adding additional they re moving their telephone, the power lines from the east side, from the west side of the road to the east side, making the road even narrow but another 18 to 20 inches. Two cars cannot go side by side without one pulling over and when you pull over, especially during rainy season, there s a very good chance to go into the ditch. I was one of them. I went up in a dish and had to be called to be pulled out. Because that trailer tractor passed by me. I had no option except go to the site unfortunately, I slid over. From 7:14 coming in, there is no traffic light. There is no street lights. There is no divider line. It s a single lane road essentially. There is at nighttime it s pitch dark like if you tried to go that 5 o clock when I go pick up my son-in-law, my stepson. When I go pick him up, they re idio is dark. It s very dangerous road. The idea of having tractor trailers to go through that road to get to the backside to uh medal run is just not a good idea. You need to wrap it up, ok. Uh, so there is again no traffic that when all this if a trailer tractor comes in accidentally to our street. He has to back all the way up because the original place for them to turn. Your time is now up again. There s a lot that they d say. The last thing I want to say is safety, safety over convenience and profit. This is about profit, making money, so the tractor trailers can bring additional loads. Your time is up. I m sorry. I must cut you off. Joshua Mirin is next, followed by Carol Zolton. Good morning, Commissioners. Good morning, MISS Elder. Uh, my name is Joshua Myron. I m general counsel on behalf of the Jacob Community Center and MR. Sharpie. Um, obviously I m here, uh, relative to the medal runs application to revise its site plan. Uh, I just wanted to be clear if our position, as you well know, because I believe you ve received a letter from me is that we believe this is a situation of convenience over safety, and that s ok. The meal run, uh, residents would like to have the convenience of having another entrance. Again, that s ok, but not at the expense of what we consider to be safety. The safety is the fact that MR. Shapi mentioned the streets of Leighton Farms Avenue are not meant for heavy traffic and, uh, they were never intended to be so. In fact, the original site Plan of which they re trying to amend from 20 years ago that was approved by this particular county and presumably approved by the county um staff at that time, specifically delineated that there would be no traffic, excuse me, no entrance from that community onto Southwest Leighton Farms Avenue that was done for a reason, except for emergency access vehicles and as you think you well know, they already have an emergency access gate. It s what we call the north gate Interestingly enough, it doesn t come up, no one discusses it. I think it s as a result of the fact that the poa s PRESIDENT Lives next door and they just don t want to use it, notwithstanding that, because this is about safety and not to be uh um uh uh. Because this is about safety, we want to make it clear from the jcc s perspective we have absolutely no objection whatsoever to allowing that gate to exist for the benefit of first emergency responders and emergency access use when the applicant was here the first time before the rehearing was granted. They carried on about emergency access time and safety. I agree it would reduce the safety. Notwithstanding the fact that they have a gate already that they choose not to use to the extent that this board made it the appropriate decision to allow them to open this gate, I would at least ask that it be allowed to open only for emergency access use only. I also wanted to test that MR. Sharfi indicated we submitted a video to the board that that helped to try to visualize. It was a random video taken by MR. Shay trying to visualize the amount of traffic in the people that come and go on that on those streets on a day to day basis. Obviously MR. Corey mentioned there s a school and there s also soccer, uh, soccer clubs, um, during the afternoon there s a inc incredible amount of traffic and MR. Shary had an opportunity to take a picture of a child walking through the street and unfortunately or fortunately because he was going slow enough, uh, the child obviously wasn t injured, but it also it also illustrated the fact that it was not enough for two-way traffic. 30 seconds if I MAY. This came up for a rehearing. It was already unanimously denied once. I don t know why it came up for a rehearing, but it was championed by Commissioner Vargas and MR. Campi. Uh first of your career, MR. Campi, you said they had never been done before. It s now coming back up again. I d ask you to please deny it. Thank you so much. Thank you. Carol Zolton is next, followed by Jesse Fulton. Good morning, commissioners, and thank you again for the opportunity to speak. My name is Carol Zolan, and I m a resident of Stuart West, a deed restricted pod residential community here in Martin County. Last week, I addressed two topics the request to deny the proposed amendment to add domesticated animals and the ongoing issue of barnyard animals, specifically chickens and ducks being kept in residential zoning, despite the county s clear prohibition. You were gracious with your time, and today I m here to focus on one essential follow-up, code enforcement. We currently have a resident in Stuart West who was claiming to keep emotional support chickens. As an animal lover, I want to be clear. This is not about penalizing inno innocent animals. It is about protecting the integrity of our zoning laws and ensuring they cannot be bypassed through improper or non-validated esa claims. Under the Fair Housing Act, huud guidance and Florida law, emotional support animals are limited to traditional household companion species, dogs, cats, rabbits, and similar animals, poultry, livestock, and barnyard animals including chickens and ducks are not recognized ESAs. Esa status requires documentation from a licensed medical or mental health professional with a legitimate therapeutic relationship with the individual. What does not qualify includes a certificate purchased online, a form letter from a website without a clinical relationship, a self-declared emotional support chicken. Any attempt to use esa language to circumvent the zoning laws. If code enforcement accepts documentation that fails to meet huud, fha, or Florida statutory requirements than any resident in any residential zone neighborhood could keep goats, pigs, roosters, duck, or other livestocks simply by downloading a document from the internet that would undermine Mar Martin County s carefully structure d zoning framework in placed code enforcement in an unattainable position Additionally, if someone did have a legitimate esa, that is a species not permitted under zoning. That situation would require formal county approval and hoa approval and Stuart West, to our knowledge, neither has been requested nor granted. So my two respectful questions today are these how does Martin County enforcement evaluate esa claims when the animal in question is a prohibited barnyard species. And once code enforcement responds to a complaint, what insurers follow through, including removal of noncompliance structures such as coups and fines until prohibited animals are removed. Our community is simply asking for clarity, consistency, and confidence that Martin County s zoning ordinances which protect not only neighborhood character but also property values and public health cannot be circumvented through improper esa claims or documentation that does not meet legal standards. Thank you, commissioners, for your time and for your continued dedication to preserving the integrity and quality of life in Martin County s residential communities. I ve given you facts unlike our recalled PRESIDENT. Jesse Fulton is next, followed by Darlene Van Riper. Good morning, commissioners. Uh, so my name is Jesse Fulton, and I to speaking today on behalf of Jacob Community Center in the surrounding community. Now my role is not gonna reargue the site Plan amendment itself where the safety issues that were raised by my colleagues, MR. Sharfie and MR. Myron. My purpose is to address how we arrived here today and the concerning procedural history that has put us all back in this room. Now on OCTOBER 7th, this board held a fully noticed, properly conducted public hearing. Metal Run, their hoa PRESIDENT, and even their former hoa PRESIDENT Were all present. The evidence was presented. The testimony was taken, County staff spoke, the public spoke. And after that hearing, everything this board, every after hearing everything, this board unanimously voted to deny the application. It wasn t split it wasn t uncertain. It was unanimous And if you recall, Commissioners Hetherington and Hurd. Each of you had voiced legitimate concerns regarding metal runs repeated and purposeful violations of the master site Plan and the notices of violations that had been issued at that time. Two weeks later, without notice to the public, without any communication to the surrounding community without any factual change in circumstances, Meadowun suddenly appeared at this meeting on OCTOBER 27th, fully organized, coordinated, and prepared to lobby for a rehearing. This was not a casual question that they raised at the podium. They arrived with talking points, members in attendance in a strategy to undo the denial. Meanwhile, aside from myself and MISTER Corey, the soccer facility, not a single resident from the surrounding community was present because none of us had any reason to believe that the OCTOBER 7th decision, which was unanimously rendered, would be up for reversal, and it was only by luck that we were notified the day before the meeting that this, uh, that meadow run would be appearing before this commission. And yet somehow despite the absence of new evidence and despite the absence of the applicant s disclosure of their own hoa s leadership s prior participation, the board voted to grant this rehearing, as MR. Myron stated, MR. Campi, you stated this was a first in your career, and Commissioner Vargas, you keep your comments to the board as a whole, please. What you and commissioner, uh, Vargas, who did not attend the OCTOBER 7th hearing, did not hear the testimony, did not participate in the original vote. This process, frankly, has left the surrounding community feeling blindsided, unheard, and wondering why a unanimously denied application gets a second opportunity when nothing material changed. And let me be absolutely clear on one point. Metar runs claimed that they were unaware of the OCTOBER 7th meeting is simply not credible. The hoa PRESIDENT Was there. The former hoa PRESIDENT Was there. Their legal representatives were involved for months to now rely on we didn t know it s not only accurate, it is the misrepresentation of the board into this public. At the end of the day, procedural fairness matters. Public trust matters in the integrity of this board s decision matters. A unanimously decided matter should not be undone simply because one applicant is persistent in organized enough to lobby for a second time is up. Thank you and we urge. Darlene Van Riper is next, followed by Michael Holman Good morning. I m gonna give you a break, a completely different subject matter Um, I m Darlene Van Riper speaking on behalf of your 75-year-old taxpayer watchdog organization, The Martin County Taxpayers Association. The mcta would respectfully like to make 4 suggestions for your priority lists for the upcoming years. First, the sheriff and the sheriff prior have reported that due to legislative mandates, they need more room to house mentally challenged inmates. A mental health, health facility costing at minimum $60 million must be a regional project. The surrounding counties should be approached with a plan for them to share the responsibility. This is certainly not unheard of. For example, we share the medical examiner regionally. Second, the wild success of the golf course and cafes has been touted time and again. An indirect cost study of various parks and recommend amenities such as these should be performed to determine if they should become enterprise funds. Third, the cra program should be retooled toward completion of major infrastructure projects instead of dealing with the minutiae of private businesses and properties. The department has been successful with the big rejuvenation product projects in Ryo, Hobe Sound, and Map Road, but we must be wary of mission creep. And finally my favorite the Marty should be phased out. And the commission should enlist proven successful programs such as United Ways and others to facilitate transportation for those in need. In the meantime, limits should be put on the number of trips a rider can take in a day. We don t want this to become a mobile homeless shelter. Also, there should be a sunset date for this free fare experiment. Otherwise, it will continue to be the boondoggle it has proven to be. These are conversations to be had in 2026. The Martin County Taxpayers Association looks forward to its ongoing relationship with the commissioners in the new year. Thank you and merry Christmas. Michael Holme and his next, followed by Vincent Dacchino. Good morning. Good morning. Uh, my name is Michael Holman. I own a business in Martin County. We do a lot of business in Martin County also am a resident in Meadows Run, so I figured he d come in and get my 2 cents here. Um, I m gonna come at you from a little bit of common sense. So they have 1600 members in the soccer field that s almost right behind my house. I hear the noise all the time. It s ok. It s a good thing for the community. I, I approve of what they re doing. I think it s great. For our, we have 91 homes, 40, maybe 50 are built out. We do an average of 10 a year. So 91 resident or 91 homes times 2, 182, 182 cars coming down that road is somehow going to change everything. And half of those people are still going to use the front gate. Half the construction vehicles are still going to use the front gate. So this is going to be a very, very minuscule amount of people going down that road. And the, the kickback that we re getting for opening up that gate is just, uh, beyond me So it forced me to come out, you know, I m a longtime resident in Martin County, pay my taxes, and I, I just think it s wrong that we re being, uh, subjected to that kind of, you know, thing. So that s it. Thank you very much thank you Vincent Dacquino is next, followed by Matthew Height. Good morning So I am here to speak in favor of the rear gate as well. Uh, they, uh, Sharfi, Team Sharfie, jwcc addresses talks about security, often, um, I as a builder, I m a business owner. I live in Meadow Run. I am more than happy to work with jwcc and come up with sincere, uh, common sense, logical safety options that we can do. We can put speed bumps, we can have um. Barriers put up so the kids walking out at a soccer stadium or the school are forced to walk off the road. Um, there s quite a bit of measures that we could take to address safety if safety is truly the issue and not trying to be steamrolled by jwcc because they wanna own that end of the street. They wanna own Martin County. They wanna own Leighton Farms Road. We could work together. They re either with us or against us. We want to work together to make sure it s safe for everybody, uh, Metalun has a handful of traffic coming out from the back, uh, whether it was construction trucks or resident traffic. Again, it s a minuscule to the amount of traffic that they bring in. If they were so concerned about safety, how come they didn t mention, how come they weren t so concerned when they were doing all their construction. I didn t see any cops in the street directing traffic. I didn t see anybody out there helping uh escort kids. They plowed their trucks in and out of the development all day long so where were they concerned about safety then? So I wanna work with jwcc and I just because someone has a lot of money that doesn t give them the right to steamroll the county, the residents of Meadow Run, and that s it. Thank you. Matthew Height is next, followed by Carol who are Dietz. Thank you. I m here to speak on the metal run. Issue yet again. I apologize for you having to endure this process and the misinformation that gets thrown around here for us, yes, it s a convenience issue, but it s also a safety issue. It s both. It s a small community. It public road and this is flexing This is I paved the road, so I own the road and you re going to listen to me. That s what this is. There you ll you re gonna get some more information so I don t have to get into the details of it, but I mean, we did a traffic study for this purpose I mean, 2000 cars go up and down that road. How many are we offering to add to that number? And the zoning, I, I heard some zoning terms today. Uh, this is ar 5 ar 5, I know you guys all know what that is. So in an ar 5 zoned area, we have approximately 1500 cars coming to a soccer stadium. Ar 5 So where are the 1600 people? They don t live there. There are 13 houses, 13 residents, legitimate residents. On Leighton Farms Road. So, how many are we gonna add to this? It s a 2nd gate. Not a 1. We have young drivers. We have elderly It s a convenience issue for them. I d much rather have the kids learn to turn out into traffic onto Leighton Farms Road than I would. Southwest Citrus. It s dangerous. It s a racetrack. The sight lines aren t great It s dark So why are we here I mean, this seems to be a whole lot to do about nothing. We have lawyers. Money time spent letters sent I mean, we re a small community we ve gone through all the steps that are required. We follow the rules and it s a public road. That we want to share We don t own the road, we don t claim to own the road. We ve gone through the steps we have approvals we ve done everything we need to do. We don t build things that aren t permitted We don t skirt the rules. We don t pay fines in lieu of permits. So I just ask that you take that into consideration and grant the request for the pud master site Plan uh, revision. Thank you very much. I appreciate your time. Thank you, Carol Howard Dietz is next, followed by Bobby Moran. So I m here for a happy thing. Ok, thank you, commissioners for the record. I m Carol Howard Dietz, and I wearing two hats this morning. One is the local staff coordinator for Toys for Tots, and the other is the PRESIDENT And ceo of the United Way of Martin County. I m here to share a couple really great updates and things that are happening in our community. First, I d like to invite each of you to stop by the United Way Holiday Project that s happening at the Martin County Fairgrounds. We re in full setup mode. Right now, getting ready for more than 9 00 families that are registered to receive toys, stocking stuffers, food, books, balls, and a holiday meal. And yes, you heard, excuse me, yes, you heard me correctly, registered. That s very important to us. We work with Salvation Army and House of Hope to make sure that we re not helping the same families. That way we can stretch the limited resources that we have in this community even further and help more families in need. We can t do this project without supporters and sponsors, and I want to take a moment to speak about one of those sponsors, Ashley Capital. They don t just write a check they help us and they volunteer and they show up. And this year we re starting a new literacy initiative right at the Holiday Project. It something we re really excited about because it opened stores for children and families in a whole new way. When companies like Ashley Capital invest locally, they re not only supporting programs. They re investing in stronger families, brighter futures, and a more educated community with partners like them, United Way is able to help more families and people in our community with the tools that they need to succeed. We re grateful for all of our supporters, but today we just wanted to give a special thank you to Ashley Capital for their leadership and their continued support of Martin County nonprofits. Thank you. Happy holidays, and hope to see you at the fairgrounds to give you a tour. Bobby Moran is next, followed by Thomas Ellender. Good morning. I loved her dress. Did you notice this eye glass. Anyway, please allow our neighborhood Meadow Run to use the public country County road, Leighton Farm Road, which we had been using for 20 years. Just recently, jcc decided we should not use it. I strongly believe that every subdivision should have two entrants and exits, especially with the growth in our area is experiencing growth equals more traffic, more traffic equals more accidents that shut down roadways. Also, storms are becoming more severe, increasing the possibility of fallen trees and debris blocking the road. In fact, the last hurricane, a tornado went through our neighborhood, damaging several homes near our front entrance? What if our entrance had been hit. Also with the drought conditions that are becoming more of the norm. Fires are afeared. The residents of the subdivision on 714 and I-95 recently experienced the scare of one way in and out as a huge fire was advancing towards them. An alternate route in and out is imperative, just like a house, you must have an in and an out. Two ways in two ways out, granting us permission to use our back gate does not add excessive amount of traffic on Leighton Farm Road. For the many years that we were using the back gate, the traffic that we created must have been very light, unnoticeable, since jcc didn t notice we were using the road since they keep saying we d just begun using it. Most of our residents choose to use the front gate as the main entrance exit. As for these reasons, I stated I filled two entrance exits are important. Ps if jcc and the soccer facility are so concerned about the children s safety. Why isn t there a safe parking lot provided for them. Thank you very much for your consideration. Thank you. Thomas Ellender is next, followed by Clive Campbell. Hello, my name is Tommy Lander. I m a native Minnesotan that can you get it in my, my slang there, but um and bought a piece of property in metal run two years ago. Uh, with the idea of moving down first as a vacation home and then settling permanently down here. Uh we did our research on the property and basically the reason that we were interested in the property is we re avid RVers, ok, so I had a long discussion with the the former hoa PRESIDENT About access on that back gate because currently we cannot get our motorhome in the front gate without taking down trees and everything else. Uh, had an attorney research it too with the former hoa PRESIDENT. It was basically explained to me that as long as it wasn t used on a daily basis, we could have access back there and that would be maybe 34 times a year in and out. Ok. Uh, our house was finished in AUGUST. Uh, we went through some additional expense, adding a big rv garage on the house. And then I come to find out that I might not be able to get my rv in the property. So this is obviously a big concern of mine, uh, because of the additional expense that, you know, that I put into the property. And uh you know, as well as some of the safety issues too that some of my neighbors are talking about. So I would just add that you know, if that gate could get be kept open. For the benefit of using you know, that back gate for, for those purposes and emergency purposes certainly, uh, I would greatly appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Clive Campbell is next, followed by Tom Pine. Good morning Good morning. My name is Clive Campbell. I actually live, uh, on the back part of the metal run and I built my house in 2021 through to 2023. And during this construction time, uh, is the same time the park across the street from Leighton Park was building theirs and s the back gate was open at that time, they were also building heavy machine bringing in heavy machinery. To date, they are still big and bringing in heavy machinery because it s right in front of me and I see it right there. So yet they re complaining about heavy machinery coming down the road, Leyton Farms, but yet they re building, bringing in heavy machinery. So there s a little contradiction of a glass house here. In addition to that, I agree in reference to the children, everybody wants safety for the children, but put in a parking lot If the, if you re going to be zoned for agricultural and have soccer field and have 1600 people come in there, you got to accommodate it with the parking lot. So if it s a safe, true safety issue, put in a parking lot. They do that with schools. They have school zones, you could actually have, we could actually discuss additional safety terms as um Vincent uh mentioned earlier. We re open to that, um, in addition to that, there was something mentioned in from a typical homeowner that I cannot have a guess into my house unless they go down Leighton Farm because all the gps takes them back to the back gate. So every new guest that I have to my house has to drive to after they go to Laketon Farm entrance because all the GPSs take them back there because my house is towards the back of the development. They have to drive another 4 miles just to get to my house. So it s not only convenience, if it s a safety issue, let s address the safety issue. I is there a, there s only one entrance. I agree with the young lady that uh spoke earlier. You do need a second emergency back entrance and also from uh residential homeowners standpoint, it will be nice to have guests come to my house and be able to come the way they normally are supposed to come. All right, thank you. Thank you. Tom Pine is next, followed by Robert Burfield, Barfield. Good morning. Good morning, commissioners. My name s Tom Py. I ve been a resident of Martin County for over 50 years. My photos could stay up while i speak. I would appreciate that greatly. In the spring of 2020 the Corona virus hit the United States and, and just a short time sitting in sitting in restaurants was turned upside down. So in order to keep their doors open, towns and cities across the country allowed restaurants to use public sidewalks as their own and put tables and chairs outside. This was accepted practice across the treasure Coast. As the virus waned, waned along the Cresure coast from Hobe Sound to Sebastian. The owners of restaurants pulled their chairs and tables off the public sidewalks and business returned to normal. Except for one community. The downtown Jensen Beach area, where local business community still has this to this day totally control of the Pie book sidewalks with their chairs and tables. This can only happen because our county government had decided that the American with Disabilities Act doesn t apply totowntown Jensen Beach area. So whether you use a cane or a walker or even a wheelchair, you are not welcome in downtown Jensen Beach. There are no open sidewalks for you to use. But wait, that s not enough to satisfy all the restaurant owners in downtown Jensen Beach. These showed photos show one restaurant owner using cones to close off one spark one parking space. So his front entrance is more visible from the road with a rear board advertising beer, wine, and liquor to go. These cones closing parking spaces on downtown area are quite common on Thursdays starting around 20 to 3 P.M. That s when some of the vendors for jam and Jay claimed their spaces. It be nice to have that kind of power to control parking spaces on a public road with absolute immunity from code enforcement. Is today going to be that day when our County commissioner discussed the slimy use of the consent agenda in Martin County for the past 20 years. This is why our county taxes go up almost every year. It s not the budget, it s the slan that gets approved behind closed doors. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Uh, MR. Pine, our camera was not working, so if we could get copies of those pictures, we ll scan them and give them to the board. P Robert Barfield is next, followed by Carrie Clements. Morning commissioners, appreciate uh all you do for, uh, our community protecting, uh, our way of life. My name s Robert Barfield, long term resident, more than 40 years here in Martin County, uh, current resident of Palm City. I m here in support of, uh, the Martin County Commerce Park, uh, additionally, um, I had the responsibility to help gain uh financing for, uh, businesses as I am in the financial industry. Many of uh the companies that come to my office are looking for expansion and places to go, and currently there s no industrial space in Martin County for them to go and expand. Uh, we know that, uh, companies that want to expand are vital to the successes of our community long term both industrial, uh, business owners and office without places for them to go potentially for them to leave. Therefore, losing taxpayer revenue, um, Martin County Commerce Park will provide up to 1. 1 million square feet of Class a, uh, industrial space, which is needed here in the community. The park is ideally located in western Martin County, uh, easy access, uh, to I-95, uh, and the Turner Park Turn Park and therefore does not need to come through, you know, the main part of Martin County and others. Uh, the park will not only spark economic growth in the region, but is expected to generate millions of dollars in uh in annual revenue, uh, to Martin County through, uh, Adorum property tax intangible personal property tax. Additionally, I think it s vitally important for us when we re looking at developers to pick the right developers. There s merchant builders, those builders typically will develop, sell the properties off. There s also long term developers that will develop properties and hold them. They typically will provide a better product, construction cost, materials, uh, they will want better quality because they long-term view, uh, is a longer term horizon and a better return for them. If you look at Ashley Capital they have had significant experience in building long term projects, long term whole projects, do they generally do not sell their projects. So they have tremendous amount of investment in that. I would say Ashley Capital and Rick, I ve met Rick many times, um, you know, he knows what he s doing in these developments, has a long-term view. He will have significant dollars, millions of dollars invested before regenerates dollar 1 of revenue. This type of developer ones that we want here in Mart County. Carroll talked about, uh, Ashley Capital, uh, Jill Morasso, Ryan, and Rick, uh, being involved in the community. I will tell you I m at numerous community, uh, events both here in Martin County and on the Treasure Coast. There had never been a time that I haven t been there that one of these individuals is there not only in person, but in, but investing dollars. So those are the type of developers that we want here in Martin County. So I think the park is built going to be built in the right place. I think it helps us uh with continuity evolve businesses that want to grow and stay here in Martin County. And so I think this is a great project for us to have here in Martin County. Appreciate your time. Thank you Carrie Clements is next, followed by Craig Clements. I m here on Metal Run and just a little bit. Or for metal run, um, jcc Community Center, like my other neighbors said they have construction equipment coming into their back gate area. If they were so concerned about safety for the children. They would build a parking lot. There is no parking lot. There is nothing for the kids, they just come out, all the cars for the parents are parking everywhere um I just wanted to say that most communities do have a front and rear gate for safety um, and that s all I need to say. Thank you. Thank you. Craig Clements s next, followed by Henry Bush. My time to the PRESIDENT Of the association, so she has a little more time. Can t do that. Can t do that, but. Can that? No. Ok. I agree with my wife, um, we definitely need a back gate. The back gate was there when we bought the property. We thought the back gate went with the association. Um, it s been there for 20 years. It s been open for 20 years. There s heavy trucks going in and out that road every day, even though our gates closed. Where our house is under construction. We ve had a lot of trouble with the trucks trying to come in the front gate, tearing up the trees, um, getting trusses in was almost impossible um, as a safety issue I agree it wonderful that those kids get to play soccer out there, but there s no parking lot for them. The cars are parked in the street. The kids are walking in the street in between the cars somebody s gonna get hurt there by us or somebody else. They need to do something about it. Thank you for your time. Thank you Gerald Kifel is next, followed by Ken Haynes. Ger Gerald Kiefel? Oh, I m sorry, Henry ok, Henry Bush. Ok, please come forward, followed by Gerald Kiefel. Good morning. Good morning. You MAY have guess, my name s Henry Bush. Um, my wife and I early in 2025 discovered this wonderful community that a lot of you have called home for a long time and we ended up purchasing home in Stuart West on MAY the 1st of 25. Um, we sort of escaped out of Miami Beach where I have a general construction company. I ve done that my entire life. Developed a lot of properties uh in Miami, Miami-Dade County over the last 30 years and just wanted to kind of give a slightly maybe fresher perspective of what we ve discovered moving into the community, uh, the discourse about this item before you all for the pud. Is seems to be very motivated by slight minority group of people that um unfortunately I think MAY have been less than truthful when someone standing here just a little while ago, declaring themselves PRESIDENT. We, there s been a recall, 3 actually, and um, as a developer I ve created a lot of associations. I ve set on a lot of boards. I ve seen all the documentation for this recall. It is it is, it s clear that this recall will stand. It s just they ve chosen to go down legal path, um, it gets heard in JANUARY, so I guess a request is if possibly not to move on this issue one way or the other. I think it will come very clear, uh, in early 2026 of the fact of what I m saying that that that people representing themselves as the decision makers are not actually the decision makers. He s very, very clear. Thank you. Thank you Gerald Kiefel is next, followed by Ken Haynes. Good morning, everyone. Thank you for your time. My name is Gerald Keith, and I m speaking today regarding Stuart West. I ve lived in Stuart West since 2003 and recently written all of you and met with a few of you personally. Um regarding the pud change. I m compelled today to speak because there s a lot of information regarding the pud change within our community and all the misinformation around it, um, the change is not desired by a majority of the community members, the board members pushing it are misleading the community on the reasons for the change. The board members pushing it have been recalled or illegitimately appointed. The law firm representing the hoa on the pud change has been fired by the Tru board. In preparing for this meeting, I thought long and hard about how I could convey what has happened in our community over the last 9 months and 3 minutes. Since there s not enough time to go over all the details, I found it more helpful to explain what has happened in the smoker behind it. Furthermore, Commissioner Campi and County Attorney Lise Elders have seen a majority of these false claims, and they know the truth. I encourage you all to reach out to them for additional information. So how did we get here? As I mentioned, I ve lived in this community since 2003 and it is a wonderful place to live and raise a family, as with all HOAs that have been disagreements here and there but I ve never witnessed what has happened in our community since a small group representing a tiny fraction of our community gained the control of the board with a 4-3 majority. This group has been pushing to expand the animals currently allowed in the neighborhood from equestrian animals. Currently horses, donkeys, and zebras and their offspring to farm animals such as chickens, goats, cows, pigs, and etc. Almost immediately found the election, the newly elected majority of the board fired the hoa s legal counsel and and replaced it with one that appears to be working for them, not in the interest of the whole community. While they will de ny this, I have a plethora of written information. Shortly thereafter they decided to allow chickens in the neighborhood based on an informal petition which is not allowed for our governing documents or our pud that upset a number of residents who reached out to the county and it was determined that chickens and other barnyard animals are not allowed, not allowed according to our pud, in addition to our government documents. That is when the false narrative began stating we need to change the pud or the horses, donkeys, or other equine animals could be reordered to be removed by the county. Those statements were supposedly made by county attorney Elise Elders. I ve reached out to her directly. Those statements are untrue. There were other false statements claiming that that we re we we re informed by the county that our pud needed to change to align with county rules. These statements are also untrue. I have this in writing or you can talk to her yourself. When the community got wind of these events or recall effort was initiated to recall these board members while enough votes were collected to certify the recall. It wasn t certified by the board Majority or the hoa attorney. Right. The outcome of the recall is now in the courts. In a nutshell, our community has been seized by a small group with a hidden agenda working for a small group of residents have continued to break the rules. While they claim this is to bring clarity and protect the equine animals their actions speak otherwise. Their trick is to change the animals allowed from stable animals to domesticated animals, sir, your time is up. Thank you. Thank you, Ken Haynes is next, followed by Ted Johnsick. And MISTER Johnsick is the last request to speak for my that I have if you would like to address us, please fill out one of these forms, get it to the bailiff. Good morning, commissioners. Um, I hope I do this properly. I just got out of the hospital, so I m not at my best. Two things one, I wanna praise Ashley Capital, uh, for the public benefit portion of their proposed change here today of the new traffic light which we desperately need. And also the land donated for a future firehouse, which we also desperately need. I think most companies would never go to that extent uh to help the the surrounding community with public benefit. Uh, the other reason I m here today, and I hate to do both because I can t really speak enough to each. Uh, the Stuart West, this uh pre-application for a pud change. To allow domesticated animals, which I spoke last week. That is the Trojan horse, the board that has been hijacked, as many have spoken. The other members that hijacked t

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FINAL MINUTES 12/9/2025 9:00 AM MINUTES COMMISSION CHAMBERS 2401 SE MONTEREY ROAD, STUART, FLORIDA 34996 Don G. Donaldson, P.E., County Administrator Elysse A. Elder, County Attorney Carolyn Timmann, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Sarah Heard, Chair Edward V. Ciampi, Vice Chairman Eileen Vargas, District 1 Stacey Hetherington, District 2 J. Blake Capps, District 3 Children from the Gertrude Walden Child Care Center will sing! CALL TO ORDER 5 - Commissioner Stacey Hetherington Commissioner Eileen Vargas Commissioner J. Blake Capps Chair Sarah Heard Vice Chair Edward V. Ciampi Present: Invocation ~ Reverend Anil K. Singh, Trinity United Methodist Church of Jensen Beach Pledge of Allegiance ~ Deputy Andrew Ross, U.S. Army Veteran APPROVAL OF AGENDA MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Hetherington, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve the agenda. The motion carried by the following vote: Page 1 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: COMMENTS Public (9:05 AM) - Please limit comments to three minutes. Debra Vigotsky addressed the Board regarding the importance of public safety in Stuart West and the need for a fire station [DEPT-4 and PHQJ-2]. She is opposed to the proposed PUD amendments. Rob Ranieri spoke in support of affordable housing and Martin Commerce Park [PHQJ-2]. The following members of the public addressed the Board regarding the proposed Stuart West PUD amendment: Sherry Wilson, Cornelius Pameijer, Carol Zolton, Henry Bush, and Gerald Kiefl. The following members of the public addressed the Board regarding the Meadow Run rear access on Leighton Farms Road: Benjamin Sharfi (JCC owner), Christopher Corey, Joshua Miron (JCC council), Jesse Fulton, Michael Holeman, Vincent D'Aquino, Matthew Hight, Bobbie Moran, Thomas Elander, Clive Campbell, Carrie Clements, and Craig Clements. The following members of the public addressed the Board regarding Martin Commerce Park [PHQJ-2]: Rick Hartman and Robert Barfield. Darlene VanRiper suggested legislative priorities to the Board on behalf of the Martin County Taxpayer Association [MCSO Mental Health Pod; CRA retooling; phasing out MARTY]. Carol Howaart- Diez shared updates on behalf of Toys for Tots and United Way. She invited everyone to attend the United Way's holiday project at the Martin County Fairground. Ms. Howaart-Diez recognized sponsor Ashley Capital. Tom Pine addressed ADA compliance in Downtown Jensen Beach regarding sidewalks. He spoke about the consent agenda. [Photos were submitted for the record.] Ken Haines thanked Ashley Capital for their charity and spoke in opposition to Stuart West amendments. Ted Jonczak addressed the Oasis Brownfield remediation comprehensive planning report [PHQJ-1]. Commissioners AM Commissioner Vargas noted the success of the Taste of Jensen. She requested follow up on the sidewalk issue referenced during public comment. County Administrator Don Donaldson advised he will review the issue with CRA and Code Enforcement staff. Page 2 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

Commissioner Capps shared he attended all 3 parades and the Hobe Sound Singing Christmas Tree event. Chair Heard attended the Annual Women's Christmas event. Vice Chair Ciampi reminded everyone that Music in the Park will be this Saturday from 6-8 pm. Commissioner Hetherington announced she attended all of the holiday events. She wished all a Merry Christmas. PM Commissioner Vargas requested a demonstration on the check registry and a follow up on street vendors and sidewalks. County Administrator Don Donaldson demonstrated how to use the check registry. Commissioner Capps suggested taking a further look into Brownfield designations. Vice Chair Ciampi reminded everyone that Music in the Park will be this Saturday 6-8pm. He wished everyone a happy and healthy holiday season and New Year. Commissioner Hetheringinton wished residents a Merry Christmas. Chair Heard offered best wishes to all. County Administrator AM County Administrator Don Donaldson acknowledged the children from Gertrude Walden Child Care Center. PM County Administrator Don Donaldson thanked everyone for a great year. CONSENT AGENDA MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Capps, seconded by Vice Chair Ciampi, to approve the consent agenda. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: ADMINISTRATION Page 3 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

CNST-1 CONTRACTS THAT MEET THE THRESHOLD FOR BOARD APPROVAL Agenda Item: 26-0009 This item was approved. CNST-2 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS’ APPROVAL OF WARRANT LIST FOR DISBURSEMENT VIA CHECKS AND ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS TO COMPLY WITH STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS Agenda Item: 26-0015 This item was approved. CNST-3 NOTED ITEMS Agenda Item: 26-0018 This item was approved. CNST-4 BOARDS AND COMMITTEES STATUS REPORT Agenda Item: 26-0019 This item was approved. CNST-5 ADOPT A PROCLAMATION CELEBRATING THE LIFE AND LEGACY OF REVEREND DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. Agenda Item: 26-0311 This item was approved. CNST-6 ART IN PUBLIC PLACES HOBE SOUND LIBRARY MURAL PROJECT RECOMMENDATION Agenda Item: 26-0300 This item was approved. CNST-7 REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF THE STATE HOUSING INITIATIVE PARTNERSHIP (SHIP) AFFORDABLE HOUSING INCENTIVE STRATEGIES REPORT SUBMITTED AND APPROVED BY THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE (AHAC) Agenda Item: 26-0313 This item was approved. INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CNST-8 REQUEST APPROVAL OF A CONTRACT WITH MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS FOR ACS Agenda Item: 26-0308 This item was approved. Page 4 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

PARKS AND RECREATION CNST-9 NAME THE NEW BEACH FRONT CAFÉ AT JENSEN BEACH THE “SEA TURTLE BEACH CAFÉ” Agenda Item: 26-0280 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.9 This item was approved. PUBLIC WORKS CNST-10 ADOPTION OF A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING AND APPROVING UTILITY EASEMENTS AND/OR SIDEWALK EASEMENTS FROM OWNERS OF APPROXIMATELY 48 PARCELS FOR THE GOMEZ/PETTWAY POTABLE WATER MAINS INSTALLATION PROJECT IN HOBE SOUND Agenda Item: 26-0282 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.10 This item was approved. CNST-11 REQUEST THAT MARTIN COUNTY GRANT A UTILITY EASEMENT ON COUNTY-OWNED PROPERTY TO THE CITY OF STUART FOR USE BY THE REACH CENTER AT MARTIN COUNTY AIRPORT, WITHAM FIELD Agenda Item: 26-0304 This item was approved. BOARD AND COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS B&C-1 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR DESIGNATIONS Agenda Item: 26-0218 Administrative Service Coordinator Donna Gordon introduced the item to the Board. Office of Community Development Director Susan Kores assisted with Board questions. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to appoint Michael Readling as the CRA Chair. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: Agenda Item: 26-0218 MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to appoint Cynthia Hall as the CRA Vice Chair. The motion carried by the following vote: Page 5 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PUBLIC HEARINGS PH-1 PUBLIC HEARING AND FINAL ASSESSMENT RESOLUTION FOR THE CORAL GARDENS WASTEWATER MUNICIPAL SERVICE BENEFIT UNIT Agenda Item: 26-0072 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.13 Utilities and Solid Waste Technical Services Administrator Leo Repetti presented the item to the Board. Assistant County Attorney Frank Moehrle assisted with Board questions. The following member of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Dustin Bishop. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Hetherington, seconded by Vice Chair Ciampi, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PH-2 PUBLIC HEARING TO ADOPT NOTICE OF INTENT RESOLUTION REQUIRED BY SECTION 197.3632, FLORIDA STATUTES FOR SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS Agenda Item: 26-0279 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.14 Utilities and Solid Waste Senior Project Manager David Duncan presented the item to the Board. Assistant County Attorney Frank Moehrle and Utilities and Solid Waste Director Sam Amerson assisted with Board questions. Chair Heard solicited public comment; none was heard. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Hetherington, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PH-3 ADOPTION OF A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE SURPLUS DISPOSITION OF COUNTY OWNED PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF SW MARTIN HIGHWAY AND SW PALM CITY SCHOOL AVENUE IN PALM CITY Agenda Item: 26-0306 Page 6 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.15 Senior Assistant County Attorney Sebastian Fox presented the item to the Board. Public Works Director Jim Gorton assisted with Board questions. Chair Heard solicited public comment; none was heard. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PH-4 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER TRANSMITTAL OF COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 25-04, ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS, A TEXT AMENDMENT Agenda Item: 26-0094 Growth Manager Planner Amy Offenbach presented the item to the Board. Comprehensive Planning Administrator Clyde Dulin and Senior Assistant County Attorney Sebastian Fox assisted with Board questions. The following member of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Mary Gavin. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 3 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Capps, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: 2 - Commissioner Vargas, and Chair HeardNay: PUBLIC HEARINGS QUASI-JUDICIAL PHQJ-1 PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A REQUEST BY THE PALMS OF HOBE SOUND, LLC TO DESIGNATE A BROWNFIELD AT 9450 SE GOMEZ AVENUE Agenda Item: 26-0240 Ex parte communication disclosures were provided by the Commissioners. There were no interveners. The participants were sworn in by the deputy clerk. COUNTY: Growth Management Senior Planner Jenna Knobbe provided staff's presentation to the Board. Comprehensive Planning Administrator Clyde Dulin, Deputy Director Peter Walden, Senior Assistant County Attorney Sebastian Fox, County Attorney Elysse Elder, and County Administrator Don Donaldson assisted with Board questions. Page 7 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

The following County exhibits were filed for the record: (1) agenda item/staff report and (2) Jenna Knobbe's resume. APPLICANT: Cobb Cole Attorney Michael Sznapstajler and Jessica Gow provided the applicant's presentation to the Board. The following member of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Mary Gavin. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Capps, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to approve the designation. The motion was withdrawn. Agenda Item: 26-0240 MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Capps, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to file and receive the agenda item and its attachments. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PHQJ-2 REQUEST FOR REZONING APPROVAL TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (PUD) THROUGH A PUD ZONING AGREEMENT FOR THE MARTIN COMMERCE PARK PROJECT, F.K.A MARTINGALE ESTATES SUBDIVISION, INCLUDING A MASTER AND PHASING PLAN (M164-010) Agenda Item: 26-0232 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.12 Ex parte communication disclosures were filed by the Commissioners. There were no interveners. Affidavits were filed for the record. The participants were sworn in by the deputy clerk. COUNTY: Growth Management Principal Planner Brian Elam provided staff's presentation to the Board. Growth Management Deputy Director Peter Walden, Senior Assistant County Attorney Sebastian Fox, and County Administrator Don Donaldson assisted with Board questions. The following County exhibits were filed for the record: (1) agenda item/staff report and (2) Brian Elam's resume. APPLICANT: Gunster Law Firm Land Use Attorney Bob Raynes addressed the Board on behalf of the applicant. Lucido and Associates Senior Partner Morris Crady provided the applicant's presentation to the Board. Kimley Horn Traffic Engineer Stephanie Guierra and Richard Morton with Ashley Capital assisted with Board questions. The following applicant's exhibit was filed for the record: (1) revised legal description. Page 8 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

The following member of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Troy McDonald. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: DEPARTMENTAL QUASI-JUDICIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT DPQJ-1 REQUEST FOR REVISED FINAL SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR MEADOW RUN AT FOX GROVE SUBDIVISION, F.K.A., FOX GROVE (F084-007) Agenda Item: 26-0231 RESOLUTION NO. 25-12.11 Ex parte communication disclosures were filed by the Commissioners. There were no interveners. Affidavits were filed for the record. The participants were sworn in by the deputy clerk. COUNTY: Growth Management Principal Planner Brian Elam provided staff's presentation to the Board. Growth Management Director Paul Schilling, Deputy Director Peter Walden, County Engineer Michael Grzelka, Senior Assistant County Attorney Sebastian Fox, and County Attorney Elysse Elder assisted with Board questions. The following County exhibits were filed for the record: (1) agenda item/staff report and (2) Brian Elam's resume. APPLICANT: Attorney Krista Storey with Polymath Law addressed the Board on behalf of the applicant to provide legal context. Shawn Mackenzie with Mackenzie Engineering and Planning presented the applicant's presentation to the Board. The following applicant's exhibits were filed for the record: (1) applicant's powerpoint presentation, (2) Shawn Gregory Mackenzie's resume and (3) Christopher Meninger's resume. The following members of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Kathy Jensen and Konstantin Alekseyenko. MOTION: MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Vargas, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve staff's recommendation. Page 9 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: DEPARTMENTAL ADMINISTRATION DEPT-1 OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET ITEMS WHICH REQUIRE BOARD APPROVAL Agenda Item: 26-0025 RESOLUTION NOs. 25-12.16 through 25-12.19 OMB Director Stephanie Merle presented the items to the Board. The following items were approved: (1) FY26 Transportation Alternatives Set-Aside Program (TA) through FDOT for Palm Lake Park Sidewalk Connectivity Project, (2) FY2026 Florida Safe Routes to Schools Infrastructure Grant for NE Rosetree Drive Sidewalk Project, (3) FY2025-26 State Funded Emergency Management Accreditation Program Grant, and (4) State of Florida FY26 EMS Trust Fund Grant. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Hetherington, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: DEPT-2 CONTRACTS THAT MEET THE THRESHOLD FOR BOARD APPROVAL $1 MILLION OR GREATER Agenda Item: 26-0031 Chief Procurement Officer Krysti Brotherton presented the item to the Board. The following item was approved: (1) Construction Contract Award for Coral Gardens Vacuum to Sewer. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Hetherington, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to approve staff's recommendation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: PARKS AND RECREATION DEPT-3 PARKS AND RECREATION SYSTEM MASTER PLAN Agenda Item: 26-0281 Parks and Recreation Director Kevin Abbate introduced the item to the Board. Deputy Director Kevin Kerwin, Senior Assistant County Attorney Melissa Pietryzk, and County Administrator Don Donaldson assisted with Board questions. BerryDun Manager Art Page 10 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

Thatcher presented the master plan to the Board. The following member of the public addressed the Board regarding this item: Tom Pine. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Hetherington, to approve quarterly meetings for Parks and Recreation. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: Agenda Item: 26-0281 MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chair Ciampi, seconded by Commissioner Capps, to adopt the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. The motion carried by the following vote: 5 - Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Vargas, Commissioner Capps, Chair Heard, and Vice Chair Ciampi Aye: COUNTY ATTORNEY DEPT-4 DISCUSSION ON THE STUART WEST PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT Agenda Item: 26-0374 County Attorney Elysse Elder provided background and presented the item to the Board. Growth Management Director Paul Schilling assisted with Board questions. PUBLIC - PLEASE LIMIT COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES. There were none. ADJOURN The Board of County Commissioners December 9, 2025 meeting adjourned at 4:55 p.m. _________________________ _________________________ Carolyn Timmann, Clerk of the Sarah Heard, Chair Circuit Court and Comptroller Board of County Commissioners /lp Minutes approved: Page 11 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

_________________________ This document may be reproduced upon request in an alternative format by contacting the County ADA Coordinator (772) 320-3131, the County Administration Office (772) 288-5400, Florida Relay 711, or by completing our accessibility feedback form at www.martin.fl.us/accessibility-feedback. Page 12 of 1212/9/25 FINAL MINUTES

Agenda textBoard of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM

Board of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM — 1765267200 12/09/25

Showing the first 24,000 of 192,736 characters. The full document is at the source.

Board meeting. This is our last meeting of the year. We are delighted that you ve joined us this morning. Uh, please join us for the invocation led by Reverend Singh, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance, which is going to be led by Deputy Andrew Ross. Good morning. Good morning. Thank you for inviting me. Let s unite in heart, mind and spirit. Creator of our glorious universe, author of all life giver of every good and gracious gift. Thank you for the life we have together. Thank you for our great nation, our home state of Florida and our beloved Martin County. Gracious one, as we celebrate the holidays in all of our unique and wonderful ways. We pray that you will grant us your peace Give us eyes to see your goodness and mercy in one another, whatever our faith social station or background. Lead us to welcome and greet one another as neighbors. And grant us the compassion, courage, and inner strength to care for one another, especially in our disagreements. MAY your loving spirit inspire us to strive not only for our own good, not only for the good of our friends or allies or supporters. But for the good of all. In this holy time, MAY your justice, mercy, and steadfast love, the rain down on this entire planet, and bless us all with life, liberty, and peace. Amen. Amen Be. Deputy Ross, would you lead us in the, in the pledge and then tell us about your, uh, army career, ma am. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Good morning. Good morning. Yes, I, I joined the military in 2000 with the 724th mp battalion out of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and then I was deployed to Bagram, Afghanistan in 2007 to 2008. Upon returning, I joined the 2nd of the 108th mp battalion out of Fort Jackson where I currently am an mp instructor, um, non-commissioned officer in charge at the debt in, um, by a Gun Club Road. And, and that s it s got 25 years. Thank you very much for your service. And now we have a special treat this morning. We have the children from the Gir Gertrude Walden Child Care Center, and they re going to sing Christmas carols to us. So please join us as we enjoy the children from Gertrude w Wall. Good morning, good morning. Oops Good morning. Yeah Yeah. Good morning. Good I bring you greetings from Gertrude w Wald and Child Care Center. This is our vpk class. Vpk is voluntary pre-kindergarten, so these are the kids that would be entering kindergarten in the fall. But this year Gertrude w Waldden Child Care Center is one of 7 rated excellent at the state level. On the treasure Coast. Elc serves serves Martin Indian River and Okeechobee County. So out of all the bpk programs in those three counties, they were only 7 that rated excellent and Gercha Waldden is one of those 7. We are very and I know as a former fifth grade teacher, it s very important that children enter kindergarten ready and that s what we strive to do every day. This past week we had the pleasure of going to ice at the Gaylord Palms, the kids had a great time. They sung at the city commission meeting yesterday and we are happy to be here today. Boys and girls, are you ready? Ok, good morning. So we re gonna do jingle bells first, ready? 123. Go bell jingle bell jingle all the way. Oh far it is. Right one la we GOD. Laughing on the way. The rain that is very by is right. Second daughter. A jingle bell jingle bell jingle Oh. Oh want to around her leg. Jingle be ll jingle bell jingle you top right, MISS Him a merry Christmas. 123, we wish you for this ple as ure and a happy New year. The time we right to. Your kids We wish you a merry Christmas and a happy. On this Friday, this same group will perform in the Nutcrack er at the Lierry Theater. We ve been doing this with a partnership with Florida Arts and Dance. I think this is maybe the 12th year, so they are performed two shows on Friday and a show on Saturday at the Liric, and we have kids that started with dance at Geritu Waldden that, Kylie James is now in the middle of high school and still dancing. So it s great that they get that experience and that exposure to keep it going. Alright boys and girls, are we ready for our last song. Star, we re ready tv 7 2nd delay, so. We see themselves yeah course my of Ready? Ok, boys and girls It s I a Please it. I f a I man. A Merry Christmas me. I. A good Merry Christmas You Christmas I police say. No I was respect your Christmas I. Your Christmas It s me. Go. Oh. What s That s true. That s very true. That s very very true. MADAM Chair, I make a motion to end the meeting. It s only gonna go downhill from now, I can promise you that. Oh, let see. We will begin our meeting with public comment. We have a preset at 10:30 of Parks and Recreation Master Plan, uh, at 5:05 or at the end of the meeting, we will have public comment, um, there s an additional item which is Department 4, which is discussion on the Stuart West Planned unit development which we will move up to the beginning of the meeting in order to accommodate our guests. Um, and there are no consent items that are pulled uh, so is there a motion? Oh, and also another preset is that the 9:15 we re all gonna say happy birthday to Commissioner Vargas. Happy birthday. Happy birthday. I ll move approval of the agenda. Second, there s a motion and a second to all those in favor, I oppose that motion passes unanimously. Uh, request to speak, we will, you ll each have 3 minutes to address us. The first request to speak for I have is from Deborah v Vigotsky, followed by Constantin Ale Alex Senko. Maybe. Morning in Good morning commissioners and county officials and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Deb Vigosky. My husband and I built our home in Stuart West in 2017, drawn to its equestrian nature and the long established character of this community. I actually come from a family of community service. My father was a town COUNCILMAN. My mother was a planning commissioner in Fairfax County, Virginia, a county that also experienced tremendous growth, especially during their tenure. Through them, I learned two things very early. First, while growth is inevitable, well planned growth is essential and second, that navigating community dynamics is one of the most challenging and often the most rewarding parts of public service. Your roles are incredibly important in the work you do for the county is truly appreciated. There are 2 items on today s agenda that affect Stuart West and Cobblestone. The first is the Martin County or Martin Martin Commerce Park project across Martin Highway, and the second is the Stuart West Pudd, which is currently in the pre-application status. I m not here to speak for or against the commerce Park project itself, but I do want to emphasize the importance of ensuring public safety, infrastructure keeps pace with planed growth. This Thursday, 2 days from today, marks 1 year since a devastating fire destroyed our home. Our car and its contents, and it took first responders 20 minutes to reach our home. My husband, golden retriever Champ, and I were thankfully unharmed, and we expect to be back in our home by JUNE 18 months after the fire. Having a fire station with emergency medical personnel across the highway would dramatically improve response times and protect both lives and property. Whatever decisions are ultimately made regarding the commerce park, I respectfully urge that the county prioritize establishing a fire rescue presence in this rapidly growing corridor. I also want to thank, um, Commissioner Campi and County Attorney Elise Elder for putting agenda item on to clear up some information that has been shared in our community. Um our association PRESIDENT, as well as some others have said that the county is requiring that our puppy changed, that commissioner Campi offered a discount to do that, and that animals that have resided safely in our community for decades would be removed. I want to clearly state my opposition to the proposed amendment to the Stuart West Pudd. By adding the undefined and broadened term of domesticated animals, it would authorize barnyard species such as chickens. Ducks, goats, pigs, a major shift in our residential zoning. Thank you again for your service and for your thoughtful attention to the needs of Stuart West Cobblestone as well as the entire county. Thank you. Thank you Constantin Alexsenko is next, followed by Rob Reinieri. Time to the agenda time to the agenda item or sure, sure. Rob Reinieri is next, followed by Sherry Wilson. Morning commissioners Rob Reneri, ceo for House of Hope, uh, couple things on your agenda today that I just wanted to touch base on. One is the discussion and hopefully uh approval to transmit the um the changes around accessory dwelling units, um. House of Hope has a housing committee that s had the opportunity to work closely with county staff on a lot of that. Uh, I just want to say that this will be a great tool to add to our toolbox. Uh, we have a serious lack of affordable housing, um, creating some accessory dwelling units will definitely help, uh, young people starting out in their careers, help seniors that are struggling to find affordable housing. Uh help women that are uh sort of moving on out of some of our local shelters, so it ll serve a great purpose in helping people to transition to safe housing and to get their footing back in in the community. Um, I also wanted to thank the staff for all of their hard work on this. Uh, every time we have the opportunity to work with your staff, it s always a pleasure. I also learn a lot. You have great team of experts, and I appreciate everything that they do. Uh, I wanted to also talk about Martin Commerce Park, um to me, the most exciting thing about that is going to be um the addition of more living wage and beyond jobs, um, for our work at House of Hope, it s one of the biggest challenges is trying to help our clients find uh employment that will allow them the opportunity to be able to pay all their bills, um, and to be able to live, work and play in Martin County. So we never have enough of those kinds of jobs. Anything that will, uh, safely and efficiently bring more of those opportunities to community as a win, so I appreciate your consideration on that as well. Thank you to all of you for all you do. Thanks for another great year in Martin County. We appreciate your service and everything that you do for our community. Sherry Wilson is next, followed by Kathy Jensen. Good morning, commissioners, and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Sherry Wilson and my husband Kermit and I moved to Stuart West just last year. I would also like to congratulate Elise Elder on her Martin County, uh, attorney. We appreciate the clarity and professionalism you ve brought to recent discussions. When we retired, we chose Martin County very intentionally. We were seeking an equestrian community, not a farm, one where we could enjoy our retirement with our animals, our two miniature horses, Oreo and Cinnabon and our beautiful Morgan horse Livia. Livia and our two puppies, Laney and Lucy, um, all lived there. Stuart West is home and it s where we plan to spend the rest of our lives. Before retirement, I spent decades as the top real estate agent in Loudoun County, Virginia, the most affluent county. In the country. Loudon is very similar to Martin County, a blend of farms, equestrian properties, rural estates, and suburban neighborhoods as a seasoned real estate professional. I have a deep respect for county authority, zoning orient ordinances, land use protections and the governing documents of homeowners associations and property associations. I m very familiar with pu d s and why they exist, why they were created and they were created thoughtfully and intentionally throughout my career, I have worked with people who absolutely did not want a homeowner association and others who very much did. When Kerin and I chose Stuart West, we did so because it s a deed restricted equestrian community with stable animals permitted but not barnyard animals. That distinction mattered to us and it still does. Unfortunately, a small but vocal group within our community is now attempting to change the very nature of our 40 year old equestrian neighborhood. They are trying to turn a residential equestrian community into a farm, including barnyard animals such as chickens, ducks, goats, and pigs and more. Kermit and I love our horses, but we purposely chose not to live on a farm. We do not want Stuart West to become something it was never intended to be. As someone who has spent a lifetime in real estate, I am well aware. Of the impact such as changes that changes can have on property values. It can lower property values and not only, uh, it can hurt homeowners, uh, and it can reduce the tax base that supports Martin, your time is up. Thank you. Uh, thank you. Um for letting me speak. Thank you. Kathy Jensen is next. Followed by Christopher Corey. Good morning. I would like to reserve my time at a later agenda time. Ok, for Stuart West Meadow Meadow Run, got it. And MISTER Alex Seko, are you Metal run or Stuart West? Ok. Christopher Corey is next. Followed by Rick Hartman Morning commissioners. So, uh, I apologize a bit if I look tired. I got in on the red Eye Fort Lauderdale at 10 A.M. Uh, yeah, listen, I ve been before you guys a few times now regarding this, um, today it looks like, you know, there s a lot of people here, uh, from Meadow Run and honestly I m, I m standing here and I didn t want to pack all 1600 of our members here, yeah, I don think you had seating for it. You know, we had 130 declarations, individual declarations, um, and honestly, you know, in the last two months, you know, I ve, I received a lot of pressure regarding this issue. Um, I guess that just kind of comes with how things go, uh, but to me it was disappointing that it was unrelated to the issue uh, and then late last night I got a, got a message from um sorry it was pretty emotional, but got a message that another one of our kids received their academic and um athletic scholarship to Flagler College that puts us well over 50 for the year. Spoke to another parent who their child reached a year off of adhd medication, and I ve been here before talking to you about our mission for that. Uh, so, kind of reinvigorated me on a few hours of sleep to come in here and basically say that, you know, I know that there s going to be a lot of, you know, redundant messaging about this gate and it would have been really easy for me to stand in front of you and go, I received a lot of pressure, guys you know, I m gonna remove my objection and our 1600 members objecting to this gate. But I really can t do that because ultimately all of these great things that our mission has done, um, that has made us very popular, which you re awawaware they re gonna tell you, you know, that, that we have a lot of members and we re managing that the best we can, but, uh, none of it really matters if they get hit by a construction truck. Just doesn t so thank you for your time and uh yeah, good luck today and you know, I know your job is very difficult, so thank you for your service. Thank you. Rick Hartman is next, followed by Cornelis Boy. Hammager Thank you. Good morning. Good morning, commissioners. My name is Rick Hartman. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to you. I want to speak to you on Martin Commerce Park, and I wasn t going to come this morning. I ve lived in Stuart West for around 20 years, but I had to meet a tractor driver this morning, further west. So I coming back on 7:14 and one of my fellow residents came out of the neighborhood and it it was really kind of scary. So what I m really in favor with the Martin Commerce Park is the is the fire station out there that would save us 500 to $6000 on our homeowners insurance and a stop light, at least a caution light I, I don t know how many people get out on 7:14 early in the morning or late in the evening. It s horrible. So a stoplight there that dashed the capital or Martin Commerce Park is gonna pay for would be a really benefit to us. So thank you for your time. I hope you approve them. Have a good day. Thank you. Cornelis p Pamai followed by Benjamin Sharfee. Good morning, commissioners My name is Cornelis Parmier. I m the PRESIDENT Of Stuart West pua. I thank you for the opportunity to respond to statements you have recently heard from 4 Stuart West residents. I ve previously addressed the misinformation that was disseminated by MISS Troba. First, all 4 speakers have not provided you with a shred of evidence. I have 6 copies here that provide solid evidence of everything I m, uh, going to say, MISS Alan continues to assert that this board wants to allow chickens in Stuart West t This is false. A message from the PRESIDENT To the community clearly stated that chickens and other barnyard animals are prohibited under our government documents. It has been clearly communicated with Stuart West residents that aligning the pud with the county is necessary. Despite his written notices, MISS Otund continues to circulate misinformation You have been told that the PRESIDENT Has been recalled. I m standing here before you as PRESIDENT Of Stuart West poa. MISTER Graven and other challenged board through three separate recall efforts. All three were dismissed by legal counsel for failing to meet statutory and procedural requirements. The court will decide on this next year. MR. Griffin filed a complaint with the Florida bar Association against counsel. That complaint was dismissed. He then filed a second complaint with higher ups. That was dismissed. And if that was not enough, they he filed another one against an associate of Blo and Scarpa that was also dismissed. MISTER Haynes has raised objections to the pud. The documents I have provided to the commission clearly explained the reason for the pud alignment. Furthermore, the allegations that theor was never offered a fee reduction is false. This claim is directly contradicted by the written communication from Planner Peter Walden, a copy of which I have included in this review for you. Relevant portions have been highlighted. The county would surely have refused a preliminary pud application if it was not necessary. In it was in the meantime approved. John Sinnott would not have sent us an invitation to submit a final pud as a next step. Lastly something is very wrong with many individuals in our community. If I feel compelled to wear a body cam for security reasons. I thank you for your attention. I wish you happy holidays. I appreciate all you do for Martin County and your services, and a happy New Year. Thank you. Can I leave this here with Benjamin Sharfie is next, followed by Joshua Mirro. Good morning, everybody. I m Ben Chafee. Um I m here to speak on behalf of not, not necessarily myself or Jacob Community Center. Jacobbini Cener is just to the east of Leighton Farm. Leighton Farm is between, uh, uh, I mean, uh, Meadowon Um, we are between citrus and Leighton Farm. Uh, 8 years ago I started this program called jcc Jacob Community Center. Jacob was my father on his behalf, and the purpose of Jacob Community Center is to have people like Chris and uh kids that come out there of all ages and we have soccer program full school programs for uh people and kids at Kotri center, soccer, indoor soccer soon. And school for all ages, in fact, my uh fiancee s, uh, uh uh nephew goes to school there. It s a great school and Chris Corey, and Vicky did doing a great job and we are just to uh south of them. Uh, currently in Meadowons there something 500 to 70 homes uh over there. I don t know the exact count. And all these homes were built with the idea that that gate was closed. There was no traffic. They, the traffic that is, uh, proposed to go there. It s not a good idea, and I ll explain the reasons for that. I opened up the road with a uh uh aide of MR. Crisda and Donaldson to open up the road where it ended all the way to the end of Leighton Farm at a cost of over $3,200,000 adding, uh, drainage and uh whatever need necessary to open that road for safe use. Leyton Farm Road is not a safe road. It s 18 ft wide at the best. And right now fpnl if you guys have been there lately, they re adding additional they re moving their telephone, the power lines from the east side, from the west side of the road to the east side, making the road even narrow but another 18 to 20 inches. Two cars cannot go side by side without one pulling over and when you pull over, especially during rainy season, there s a very good chance to go into the ditch. I was one of them. I went up in a dish and had to be called to be pulled out. Because that trailer tractor passed by me. I had no option except go to the site unfortunately, I slid over. From 7:14 coming in, there is no traffic light. There is no street lights. There is no divider line. It s a single lane road essentially. There is at nighttime it s pitch dark like if you tried to go that 5 o clock when I go pick up my son-in-law, my stepson. When I go pick him up, they re idio is dark. It s very dangerous road. The idea of having tractor trailers to go through that road to get to the backside to uh medal run is just not a good idea. You need to wrap it up, ok. Uh, so there is again no traffic that when all this if a trailer tractor comes in accidentally to our street. He has to back all the way up because the original place for them to turn. Your time is now up again. There s a lot that they d say. The last thing I want to say is safety, safety over convenience and profit. This is about profit, making money, so the tractor trailers can bring additional loads. Your time is up. I m sorry. I must cut you off. Joshua Mirin is next, followed by Carol Zolton. Good morning, Commissioners. Good morning, MISS Elder. Uh, my name is Joshua Myron. I m general counsel on behalf of the Jacob Community Center and MR. Sharpie. Um, obviously I m here, uh, relative to the medal runs application to revise its site plan. Uh, I just wanted to be clear if our position, as you well know, because I believe you ve received a letter from me is that we believe this is a situation of convenience over safety, and that s ok. The meal run, uh, residents would like to have the convenience of having another entrance. Again, that s ok, but not at the expense of what we consider to be safety. The safety is the fact that MR. Shapi mentioned the streets of Leighton Farms Avenue are not meant for heavy traffic and, uh, they were never intended to be so. In fact, the original site Plan of which they re trying to amend from 20 years ago that was approved by this particular county and presumably approved by the county um staff at that time, specifically delineated that there would be no traffic, excuse me, no entrance from that community onto Southwest Leighton Farms Avenue that was done for a reason, except for emergency access vehicles and as you think you well know, they already have an emergency access gate. It s what we call the north gate Interestingly enough, it doesn t come up, no one discusses it. I think it s as a result of the fact that the poa s PRESIDENT Lives next door and they just don t want to use it, notwithstanding that, because this is about safety and not to be uh um uh uh. Because this is about safety, we want to make it clear from the jcc s perspective we have absolutely no objection whatsoever to allowing that gate to exist for the benefit of first emergency responders and emergency access use when the applicant was here the first time before the rehearing was granted. They carried on about emergency access time and safety. I agree it would reduce the safety. Notwithstanding the fact that they have a gate already that they choose not to use to the extent that this board made it the

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdread text
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM — Minutes
  • Board of County Commissioners on 2025-12-09 9:00 AM — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9a7f93c0a2b1f36c0ad987433e886ea6. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record