POLISCOPE

The public record

OAKLEY (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Jan 26, 2021 - 06:28 PM

Tuesday, January 26, 2021 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Jan 26, 2021 - 06:28 PM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 126,806 stored characters

>> Welcome. It's 6:30. Oakley California council acting as successor agency to the Oakley redevelopment agency and the special meeting of the Oakley public finance authority. Please join me in roll call. Pope -- present. Meadows -- here. Fuller -- here. Williams -- on the phone. Thank you. We'll do the pledge of allegiance. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Chief are you there to give us the update from the east Contra Costa fire protection district? >> I am mayor Higgins, can you hear me? >> We'll see if we can turn you up a little. >> I can turn my cell phone up if that helps. >> That was perfect. >> Well thank you mayor Higgins and fellow council members and welcome to the new faces. I'm sorry I can not see you. These times of all things COVID obviously present their own challenges. Here we are. Let me introduce myself for those of you on the line. My name is Brian helmet from the Contra Costa fire protection district. And I've had the privilege of serving since 2017. I'm given the opportunity to give you an updated state of the district. And once I conclude I'll provide you with opportunity questions if you have any and I'll do the best I can to address them. So let me just jump right into this. I'm going to be respectful to the fact in regards to our history, because I know many of you that are there tonight and the council whom I'm presenting to. You guys know our history. But I am going to hit on particulars that I think are relevant and important for the latter part of my presentation. For the history I want to focus on is the east Contra Costa fire protection district we cover 250 square miles. We serve residents and as well as up to about 150,000 when you include the businesses and people that visit our area. We serve Brent wood Oakley and discovery bay march creek Morgan territory. It's a pretty large footprint. Be able to do that we currently have three fire stations, one in Brent wood, one in Oakley one of in fire bay that's currently staffed today.and historically we know we have existing 3-station deficit that is really evolved over the past couple of decades. And it comes down to the impacts of not addressing effectively to increase fire services as growth has continued to move forward. We also know, if you look at the general plan of Oakley and the city of Brent wood and Contra Costa county that over the next 20 plus years we would need to add an additional three stations for a total of nine. And we'll be discussing one of those components later here tonight. The district has been working on a growth problem for the past two to three years. And we address that by impact fees as I stated that's on the agenda started discussion tonight. And we're working with the city of Brent wood and the county. We've updated the fees there and working with the city of Oakley to do the same. In April of 2021 the fire district is looking to move forward with implementing a district wide community facility district and we call those CFDs. And we greatly appreciate the city of Oakley of being a trail blazer in regards to working to seek developers to voluntarily participate in CFDs. And there's many of which over a dozen, which is greatly appreciated by the district. And we were working for and to once we get ours established to bring future developments into the districtwide CFD. So with CFDs and impact fees we know we're going to be able to responsibly address our growth challenge which will not further compound our existing service level deficit. And so, as we work to address our service level deficits, this gets to the big problem how we do that. The district for about two years has been working and exploring all alternatives in lieu of a tax or assessment. We have been working with the city and the land use agencies and most recently. And I'm happy to report is historically we've tried many times approaching the concept of consolidation. Consolidation with Contra Costa fire specifically which is our neighboring partner agencies. And historically nondiscussion starter. The district financially operationally we just had too many gaps and we were just too far away from it being a viable option to work and/or entertain the concept of consolidation. We reengaged the take over to ensure we were doing our due diligence. We started reexploring one last time back in July of 2020. The concept of consolidation with Contra Costa fire protection district. We got the approval from the fire board to explore and do what is called the phase one of the consolidation process. That took us all the way through December. And I'm happy to report that the findings that were produced showed that there was economy. That there's economy of scale due to the size of Contra Costa county fire protection district. They have over 26 closer to 28 fire stations today. And the cost of doing business, there's just economies of scale in any business. As you add additional stations, the cost of doing that business decreases and with us only having three, our cost per station comes at a higher rate. So in turn what the phase one feasibility study showed us is that the Contra Costa fire protection district could potentially provide five stations with paramedics. And we currently offer EMTs. Paramedics are advanced life support. Our firefighters are base support. Shows that through consolidation we may be able to see five stations paramedic which is really encouraging. Now with that being said that's a large brush stroke. Did you guys get that background too? You guys getting feedback? >> Yes. >> All right. Let's see if we can pause it there for a second. All right. Sounds like we got it muted. Okay. And so, with the phase one being favorable, staff sought approval from the fire board to go in what is called a phase two process. That's what we were currently in that's approved starting December. The phase two process reanalyzes the phase one process deeper dive. It double checks gaps in regards to sustainability. And if so how it's addressed. We know we have a three station deficit. How would we get to those three stations. What the which is the ultimate decision maker in any consolidation to process. This phase 2 process will take us up until July of 2021. But we're also looking to try to get a draft or a sneak peek of these findings in April of 2021 to where the fire board Contra Costa county fire protection fire board can make a decision point saying if things hold and present themselves with the draft due if they're positive that we'll agree to go into the Lasco process, which is phase three in July of 2021. So again, in July of 21, if things are favorable, the fire board of east Contra Costa would do a resolution of intent to dissolve and absorb into Contra Costa fire. And the Contra Costa fire would have to annex into their organization. And we would have many reports and justifications to state why that decision is being made and they would be presented to Lasco which was started in July. And in a perfect world -- and I want to stress is this -- in a perfect world, it's going to to take us to the July date much less get through the 6-month process through public hearings looking at what occurred in phase two. The findings in phase two and make sure they hold water. And again, not only is Contra Costa county fire, myself, our staffs and we have consultants working with us. We're confident that what we present will hold. But we need to make sure that again the findings are going to be favorable. The Lasco process will take no less than six months. In a perfect world. So that brings us all the way until January of 2022. And January of 2022 if Lasco approves through all the processes that they need to do through the strike of the gavel, the east Contra Costa fire protection district will be annexed into the Contra Costa county fire protection district. There is still work to be done once the gavel is done. Although Contra Costa county fire potentially can have full authority over east Contra Costa fire January 22. The fire board will remain intact for maybe two, four, six months. We don't know as of yet. Because they'll still have to remain in place to make sure they transfer all authority and real property through the legislative body of the board. And once those business practices are complete, then they will be dissolved. And we're anticipating if the consolidation process goes into phase two and it's successful with final approval in phase three that the fire board may be intact until July of 2022. That is the update and the timeline. And I do want to say I sympathize and I respect there's a lot there. This is a conversation starter. I am available not only to the council but something else I want to stress on that I think is of valuable importance in this conversation. Is why are we looking at doing this? No. 1 is that we obviously want to provide the highest level service with the revenues that we have. And we want to be able to find the most wise way to be able to address any remaining service level deficits which we'll continue to explore. But the services we provide are response times. And response times are very critical component of what we do. Today the east Contra Costa fire district as I stated has only three stations. Consolidation could potentially bring five stations. What's important to understand we are guided by statutes and by laws. But we also lean heavily upon recommendations to the national fire protection association called interPA. And they have different guidelines and one of which is NFPA1710. And NFPA1710 clearly identifies recommended and desired level of response that you should have not only if in a suburban but also urban and rural settings. We know that by looking at those guidelines that we are not anywhere near what we need to be. Today we are finding that our response times within the city of Brentwood and Oakley our response times average 7 minutes and 30 seconds. And within the rural areas in the unincorporated areas of our jurisdiction, you can find 17 plus minutes. And concerning about that is that the 17 plus minutes is double the response times. And the 7 minute and 30 seconds of travel time we have is also concerning. Because what we need to strive for is to have to be on scene eight minutes from when the time a call was received 90% of the time according to NFPA1710. And I don't want to get technical, but here's the point. The point is our response times are double what they should be. By adding two additional engine companies we believe that we're going to be able to address two thirds of that problem statement. And then we have to identify the means of which we can address the other third of those response times. So we believe that we're on a tap plan to be able to erase our existing service deficit. But it may take us from two to three years potentially through the consolidation process. And here's the call to action. What I really recommend and encourage -- and I want to say this respectfully. And please do not take this out of context. The city of Oakley's council and their staff do this now. You guys are engaged. But I ask for those that are listening your constituents and the people that put you in positions that you're in that they don't to monitor and watch not only what we're doing as a fire district as there is a very long road ahead and this process proves to be favorable which is phase one, it is going to take community support to continue to work through this. So again, my mission at the direction of our fire board is protect life, property, with the highest and environment with the highest level of service we can. And I think we're finding very innovative and creative way of doing that today without any potential further assessments and taxes. But it is going to take all of us to get there and it is going to take some time. So I will hit pause and I will conclude my report to you here tonight. But I'm available to you for any questions. So thank you. >> Council. >> Poke -- thank you. >> Chief. I just want to congratulate you on your progress so far in consolidation for years since before I was on council I thought consolidation was a good idea. And when I got on council and served on fire board was told that it was impossible. And so, it appears that you are embarking and actually looking like you're going to accomplish impossible. So congratulations. What can we do to help? I read in the paper -- I think it was Brentwood council passed some resolution in support. Is there something like that that we can do or something else that we can do to help support and promote consolidation? >> I really appreciate that question for looking at support. So yeah, actually tonight I'll be leaving here but trying to manage dual springs per se to be back for the impact discussion. But Brentwood is putting in front of their board a resolution of support into the concept of consolidation. I think it's really important that the communities continue to say what they want and desire. The community does have a voice. And so, continuing to support the consolidation process through resolution continue to be actively engaged and communicating in these processes is highly encouraged. Again, you guys -- when I say you guys -- it's the elected board even the staff to some degree, you are stakeholders. The citizens are stakeholders. And we want to hear where they stand. So I do agree with you. Listen, I think that equally too consolidation being impossible in April of 17 I was cautioned stepping on to the titanic as the captain and knowing that it was going to be going down that we couldn't get where we were going to go. But it has been all of us collectively. Not only your time on the board. Other elected previously in the minimum where we are moving forward. The answer is yes being vocal. Yes being supportive and yes being engaged and resolution very great medium to be able to do that. I think Brentwood has set a good model to follow as a recommendation. >> Thank you. Mayor, might be out of order right now. In case I forget later on request for future agenda item and I request we have a resolution in support of consolidation. >> Yes, poke however it's already there on February's agenda. >> Councilmember Fuller. >> Like I've said to you I've been in one burning building. And I will not be in another one. So I congratulate on dedication and service give us a response. I appreciate it. I do have a few questions. And I guess I'm going to start with -- well, I'll start with maybe the worst news first is yesterday I listened to your audit report. And it listed four substantial deficiencies. My concern is, "how do you believe Lasco is going to respond to that audit in terms of consolidation? >> Yeah, I think that's a fair question. And so, let me hit it like this. We are very transparent in regards to the way in which we do all of our business. And most important financially. I think that is what we're measured by the way in which we do business. And as you stated that meeting was held publicly. But I do also want to state very sincerely that there is nothing to be alarmed with. And let me explain to you as to why. What's important to keep in perspective with audits is, they're a snapshot in time. And the audit that we looked at in regard to the 18, 19 financial year is a snapshot of things that were done and/or not done adequately or the organization did not have policy. But by no stretch represents who east Contra Costa fire is today. I will never insinuate No. 1 we're a [indiscernible] organization. No. 2 that over the past four years since I've been in here we have added to our administrative staff to not only be more efficient, to be more transparent, and to address the many challenges that we have had. The meeting yesterday -- again, the audit has already been approved. It actually was approved I believe a month or so ago. Don't hold me to that, but it was within the last quarter. The audit was approved. But even internal controls and findings are presented to us. And actually just for clarity, the auditor that has done our audits for the past two years, we have been requesting the previous years findings. And they presented us two years worth of their findings in one shot. And again, I welcome it, because what yesterday was was us walking through each one of those findings, identifying No. 1 that we are aware of it. No. 2, the actions of which we have in place to correct it and/or when it was corrected. And to move forward. So to directly answer your question council member fuller is, I do. It will be a non-issue when we get to Lasco. We continue to refine our operational administrative practices daily. And we will. I think just being humans involved in the process, we have checks and balances. We have a tremendous amount of accountability. We're transparent. But there will be findings every year that are intended to ensure that we're refining and getting to the best practices. And I'll tell you as long as I've served here in the capacity of any organization, we are going to strive not to only meet the standard but work to be the standard. And so, again, authenticity two years ago we were not who we were then. We had a lot of things to correct. But we still have many things to move forward. I think we're in good shape. I appreciate the question. I hope that's clear. If you would like to further discuss and dig deeper I do welcome that too. >> I have heard several times listening to your meetings and discussions ECCFPD is putting together their own CFD. Putting together their own CFD -- they're anticipating putting out their own special district tax for approval with the ECCFPD residence. Can you explain that a little further? Especially how you're going to -- >> I know it can be confusing. Again, we use the two components of impact fees, which are a one-time fee. They're charge developers to purchase future buildings to build future buildings and buy apparatus. We call those capital expenditures. The impact fees that developers pay when they pull permit, they're done incrementally and they come in. Those monieseses are very very restricted. And that only can be used for capital expenditures for future growth. They can't be used to address past or existing deficiencies. They're all about growth challenges. And that is our three-station deficit and the apparatus where we know as we look forward over the 20 years. CFD are community facility districts. Very much focused towards -- they are focused towards the ongoing operations of the fire district. Developers, they would when they pull that permit just when they pay that one-time impact fee, they would be taking the responsibilities that community facility district and that assessment where you put on that specific parcel. And it would reoccur on annual basis. And the owner owns it until they sell the property. The property owner would find it on their tax roll. Having assessment to them. And it would be transferred to the homeowner. It would reoccur indefinitely. Now the reason is because impact -- sorry CFDs are utilized to pay for the ongoing operations for the people in the station to be able to provide the services to us. Now, our statutes, we are governed by statutes mandated. 1987 fire protection law statute. And in the statute it very clearly says the fire district shall not impose impact fees. And we have to work with our land use agency. Oakley, Brentwood and to implement those impact fees. That's why it's in front of you tonight. That's why the fire district cannot do that independent of you. Now CFDs, we have been working and we do have a developer in place and we're going to be moving those proceedings. We already opened up the public hearing. We have some complexities that we're working through. We're going to be opening it back up in April to try to get it established. Now in the interim as we're working to establish our community facilities district, again, they'll be applied to all future development to pay for increased services due to their impacts. And again, we didn't do that to source it. We have been working with our land use agencies. And right now the one agency that is a trail blazer on this is the city of Oakley. They have conditions and voluntarily many let's say a dozen plus and it's more than a dozen. Exactly I don't have it off the top of my head six of which are already starting to produce in the very near future revenues for the district. And we're continuing to do that process until we can establish ours in April. And then the goal would be is that in lieu of individual land use agency establishing their own, they would be forwarding them as a condition and be placed into the fire district. It's a very complex process. It's a very long process. It's well overdue. And again, we've had some setbacks, but we are again positioned well for April. And I'll continue providing you an update next quarterly update. That's where we are today. >> Two more questions. There in your December meeting, my understanding is one point you said forming the CFD -- at least I heard going back listening to the tape that consolidation is a reality. There was also consolidation is probable. And in the process you're expanding into a squad. But in addition you're expanding personnel so and hiring personnel so that you can be ready when the consolidation takes place to move firefighters into the position rather than having to lag behind and bring them in. Am I misunderstanding that or where are you in the? >> There's a lot there. And it's a blend of a couple of different initiatives and things. And let me work to provide clarity on all of those. So in regards to semantics -- and I need to be very careful. And this is something I've been called on multiple times very specifically to how I categorize consolidation. I use the word probable. I use the word if. And I get criticized and I understand the optics and how it is seen from the public perspective. Wait a minute, you keep saying probably. Phase one study seemed to be so favorable why are you using words like probable and using the word if? And I say this before and I think what I need to say is, what I need help from those that listen to me communicate my legitimate authority as fire chief. I'm not the legislative body. I do not have the authority to be able to approve to move to phase two, to phase three. I make recommendations no differently respectively than the city manager does to you. Furthermore if our fire board does a resolution of intent, it still takes Lasco through recommendations of the respective agency, bass and also the consultant and also the fire board with the other fire board. And the public hearing that occur. They ultimately are the legislative body that have the decision to make it to enact it. So for me to misrepresent and speak in absolutes would be misrepresentation of our situation. So I hope that clarifies that component. Now in regards to the F staffing there's multiple things going on. With consolidation, we have two separate things going on. Because measure X is the countywide house and sales tax measure that occurred. When that passed the fire board directed staff myself and my staff to create and identify the fastest way to use one-time money and make it sustainable through measure X to hire and get into company in place as soon as we possibly can. Now understand that conversation is independent of running parallel with the consolidation process. So we have analyzed and reported out to December meeting that we looked at the pathway to hire. And get people hired independent of consolidation process and what we found was the earliest opportunity and available academy is Contra Costa fire academy. Now where we are is, I'm -- we're running dual processes right now. And I am building what is a contingency plan. It's a plan B. If this process goes off the tracks, I need to ensure that no matter what in October of this year Contra Costa fire is holding an academy. We won't know until April on an interim process of the sneak peek of what is to come in July. We will be able to make executive decisions. When I say we, it's myself and Contra Costa fire chief of saying, "Do you want to take these initiatives on and hire and put people into your fire academy? Or do I need to hire people and place them into the academy? In any way an engine needs to be staffed in 22. That is a daily conversation. And we'll be reporting and finalizing that approach in April. Furthermore, we are using existing personnel and trying to be as innovative as we can to create service levels in the interim. And I requested from the board. Although I could not produce an engine company prior to March of 2022. Is really the same path. What we can do is use existing personnel on a day-to-day check-in basis on a voluntary basis to help staff potential 2-person squad company. It's a medical based engine company. It will be an overtime assignment. But we need to take into consideration the impact of COVID, workers comp and people on vacation and/or unrelated COVID sick leave and when the bodies are available we will work to staff a 2-person engine company. The board authorized and I got approval of that. We are on the implementation process. We believe we'll be rolling out that program as of March wine. But there's policies we've got in place. Trainings in place. Got to build dispatch. And that's that we anticipate will be online in March of 2022. So there is complexities. And I am working and trying to provide clarity and updates to the monthly meetings. And respectfully I think from what I've heard and please correct me if I'm wrong I believe you've been assigned liaison in regards to monitoring our meetings. And I do welcome post meeting either phone calls or follow up to clarify, because I mean I'm engaged in this all day long. I'm managing and trying to move this forward on a daily basis. But by no stretch is it easy. And I hope that my narrative provides clarity if not further confusion, because it is confusing. But I believe that we're on the right path today. >> One last question -- I attended virtually your January meeting. And I was highly impressed with the MOU and the manner fair manner that you submitted it. It was obvious that yourself and Mr. Montgomery and the ECCFPD staff and the city staff work very diligently to try to reconcile differences and develop an MOU. You are very fair to say ECCFPD was not getting everything they thought they would. In settlement it seemed the best. And you presented it. The board balked at it. And the reason was they did not want to sign off on it and provide a waiver of future -- how can I say it? Future encumbrances against the city that they would waive all future encumbrances with the city and accept it. I did not hear what they substituted in. They word Smithed it from the dais. Can you tell us what they substituted in? >> What I want to do respectfully. I'm going to tread lightly. And I want to respect your staff and your legal council. And again this is an item which is going to be discussed here tonight. But what I will do is talk at a very high level in generalities. And again, it isn't to be vague. But it is to respect my position in this conversation. Yes. We have been working. And I think that, you know, the lead-in to this what I think is the most important take away of this is, your staff -- your legal council, the collaboration and the cooperation that we've had in the past couple of months has been fantastic. And we continue to reinforce working relationships, productivity, efficiency, and it's been producing very good things. Now in regards to the MOU and understanding of the languages claim. The district had -- there's claims we know about. There's things that we're aware of and what I presented to my board was an MOU where it said that we would waive all past officially all claims. Everything in the past is going to be forgiven and the board in layman's terms essentially said that they were more comfortable identifying the things that they're aware of. Very specific things. And they didn't want to waive past things that they weren't aware of. And again, that's very general. And so, again, I report to and I execute to the best of my ability the direction of the voice of the board. Not any one board member but the collective voice of my board. And I would say we are continuing to communicate and we're working through and I feel we're making positive progress for my respective legal council and yours. And it's been -- we're finding and working towards common ground. And I would like to leave that there as I believe that it will be the collective findings. And the results will be produced in a meeting to come respectfully to your staff and legal council. I hope that gives you at least a 50,000 foot descriptive that I think is fair and appropriate. >> Thank you chief. Thank you for your candor. Thank you for being here. Thank you for professionalism again. And thank you mayor Higgins for the opportunity. >> Council member meadows. >> Thank you, Chief Helmick. This is Aaron Meadows. >> Good evening. >> I'm pleased to see that consolidation was considered again. And pleased to see the outcome of the phase one study. Where would the fifth station be located? >> Yeah, so again, I need to tread lightly, because that would be -- you know, I'm not going to be -- when consolidation occurs I will not be the fire chief. And it is still too early to say exactly what my capacity would be. And so, but again, that would be told. But I will tell you at a very high level the phase one study very clearly pointed towards station 55 would be the next station that would staff the most recently constructed station on Cypress and prevention personnel but it is not staffed with the engine company. And so, the goal would be in March of 22. Continued conversation I've heard up until now would be station 55. The second station we are working with Brentwood to construct what is station 51, which is currently planned and located to be at empire and grant, which is behind pioneer school. So we're working on building that station. And in the interim if it was not constructed, the preliminary discussions are that we would run a dual company -- two companies out of one house out of station 52 in Brentwood, the existing station in john moor and ball forand they would transition into station 51 once constructed. I do want to throw the asterisk these are the tentative discussions when and if consolidation occurs it is not my executive decision. But I believe that that is the current plan. >> Chief, what is the current timeline on station 51?? >> So there's a couple of things that we're doing. Station 51 -- we are working on multiple property transfers within the city of Brentwood. Historically the city has worked with the fire district and led the construction project that we've done as we did with old 93 now station 53 on O'Hara and Brentwood. Station 52 -- I'm sorry in Oakley. And 52 in Brentwood and the county out in discovery bay. We are taking -- the district is taking responsibility not only of getting the land existing properties but the land and the project at 51. Those transfers are occurring live as we speak. So it's going to take us about a year and a half and you know two years to be able to realistically get it built. But there's another thing another step that I'm taking. We've done this once before. I want to make sure the conversation isn't steal. We are looking at potential consolidation station location future stations of Contra Costa county fire. Reassuring the location where it needs to be. I'm fairly confident it's going to hold. But I would anticipate as we approach April and May we're going to queue up and get process reinitiated. But right now it's property transfers, transferring authority. Transferring fees from Brentwood. If you recall we just had our impact fees approved from Brentwood a couple of months ago. And they also transferred the administrative rights and the funds to the district for us to do said project. And so, we're finishing the administrative transfers and processes and we're going to work. The next update I have better solid time frame. But hopefully in April I'll be able to identify take a year and a half or two years typically. >> And I think you said Contra Costa is looking up that location? >> We're looking at everything. Yeah, we are already running parallel at this point. I'm making sure that any long-term strategic decision and really that's what I do, right? The decisions I make six months 18 months 24 months are being executed today by those that are reporting to me. And I'm collaborating on all things strategic in regards to hire. Purchasing apparatus can take one year to two years. I'm at this point double checking our math and making sure we have a very inclusive process and I don't work in a silo to ensure that decisions I make now don't have unintended consequences post January 22 consolidation were to occur. And so, not only, you know, you guys impact fees if there's revenue deficit how do we do it. Our procurement process. Station location. Apparatus procurement. All of it. We're working to collaborate. >> Perfect. Thank you, Chief Helmick. >> Council member Williams, do you have any questions? >> No, I just want to thank Chief Helmick for being on this call. Appreciate it. And thank you for my fellow council members getting all the questions asked. >> More than my pleasure looking forward to coming back. >> So chief, I just have one more. Chief how many current board members live in Oakley? >> How many current board members? >> On the east Contra Costa fire district? >> Pop quiz. We had two. And I'm doing math. I think today we did not have any. >> Okay. Thank you. >> I think we had two and I'm confident two moved. I'm doing the math real quick. No. We do not have any today. We had two. We don't have any today. >> Well, at some point will that be rectified? >> Well, there are election processes. The next election process will be in November of what -- 22? With that being said, if consolidation occurs, the board will be dissolved by July of 2022 prior to the November election, right? And so, but that is the election processes at this point. So it would have to be through the November elections and/or consolidation, which creates a whole another layer, because they have their own Board of Directors, right? And so, those are things which have not been discussed as of yet. >> All right. Thank you for your time chief. We appreciate it. >> And I'll be here for later discussion. So thank you. >> Thank you. >> All right. Moving on. We're coming up to public comments. And our first public comment is Tim our finance director is here to share an update on award we won. >> I'm sorry, say that again, mayor? Oh, okay. Yes. Can I take this off? Yes, I do want to announce that recently we were notified that the city is receiving the operating budget excellence award from the California society of municipal finance officers. So there's a long list of items that we get scored on. And we scored highly. Received the highest award, which is the award of excellence. And this is the first time that the city of Oakley has applied for. And we did receive that award. So for the 2021 budget, which is our current fiscal year, we do have an award winning budget. We've had 20 years of award winning financial statements, which is very -- I'm very proud to follow in the footsteps of those that have come before me. It reflects well the professionalism of those that have helped to manage the city. I'm proud to be a part of that. And we have received -- we received the 20th cap award while I was here. We've applied for the 21st. Hopefully we'll have there will be a 20-year lag between the calf award and budget award. But for the next 20 years let's hope we have both of those awards coming to the city. So reflects on the professionalism. It reflects on the quality of financial reporting. I'm proud to be a part of that. >> Thank you to you and your team. That means there's no money missing. There's been no discrepancies. There's no errors? >> There were no discrepancies. There was no $20 million missing from the budget. The detail was all there in the budget. I would be more than happy to sit down with anybody to review the award winning documents that the city of Oakley has. And point out the differences between citywide budgets and general fund budget. And because general fund budget doesn't match to the citywide budget doesn't mean there's $20 million missing. It just means you're comparing apples to oranges. >> Moving on to public comments. We have one from Brian Scott. Brian, are you on the line? I am not hearing Brian at this time. He does have one that will be read into the minutes. Consent calendar. Anyone have anything they'd like to hold from the consent calendar? >> Are you done with public comment? >> Oh, no -- public comments. >> Okay. Yeah. Public comment. >> Oh yeah and that was on for the 7.1. Did you want to -- because that's a public comments are not something that's on the agenda. So when we get to 7.1 Conan we'll call you. >> Okay. Sounds great. Thanks. >> All right. Thank you. Last call for public comments anybody else? All right. Hearing none I'm moving forward, not coming back. All right. Consent calendar. Anyone have anything they would like to pull? Council member Williams no? Anyone like to move approval? >> Move approval. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Okay. We have a first by vice mayor and second by council member meadows. All in favor -- we'll do a roll call vote. Vice mayor poke -- aye. Council member meadows -- aye. Council member fuller -- aye. Council member Williams -- aye. And the mayor says aye. Moving on to e public hearing. 4.1. Resolution approving a fee setting regarding a fire facilities fee introduction and waiver of first reading of an ordinance amending chapter 9.2 of the Oakley municipal code considering the fire facilities impact fee and resolution authorizing the city manager to execute an administration agreement with the east Contra Costa fire protection strict concerning the fire facility fee. City attorney Mr. Cole. >> thank you madam mayor members of the council. There actually will be only one item take action on tonight as set forth in the staff report. And I will cover that. Just as a basic background. I think the chief did a fantastic job of providing background. And certainly I'm not going to cover the ground he eloquently covered. Just as a general matter the city does charge a variety of impact fees. And as the chief mentioned, we are a land use agency. So the city government we wear many hats, one of which is that we decide land use issues within our jurisdiction. And as part of that, there are requirements under CEQA. General mitigation concepts that require the city to consider all of the impacts of new development on a wide variety of areas. So you look at natural resources. You look at land use. You look at biological impacts. Wetland impacts. You get very specific. But one of the main areas of impacts that must be addressed are impacts on public safety. And the chief did an excellent job of walking through basically some of the economic issues that are involved in providing fire protection services. And one of the things that the city must address is land use agency is impacts on fire services both in terms of capital impacts or capital needs. So building a new station, buying a new fire apparatus, trucks, the like. But also with operational costs. And that's you heard the chief talk about CFDs. But what we're talking about tonight are the capital impacts of fire services and those are paid through impact fees. Impact fees are governed by a law that is known in some circles as AD1600. That is the legislation that enacted what we know as the mitigation fee act, which is the formal name of the statute that was enacted by AD1600. So you'll sometimes hear mitigation fee act. You'll sometimes hear the fee act. And you'll sometimes hear AB1600. But basically what this requires is that the city adopt a fee study whenever it decides how to fund the services or improvements that need to be made that are caused by new development. And what has to be established is a nexus, which is basically the cost of service being covered by the charges that are imposed on new development. And I'll save the discussion, because you'll receive a fee study that the chief alluded to earlier. I don't want to get into that discussion, because that will be covered fairly significantly at your next meeting. But basically city must charge a fee. And the practice has been for the city in recent years to collect that fee of all new development and then to remit that to the district. There's actually an agreement that parties entered into when station 55 was entered or was executed or was built. And that actually has a process whereby the city is now transmitting the funds to the district, and the district is then administering those for its purposes for the capital purposes for which the fee is collected. So that's somewhat of a long winded summary. And supplements that are basic summery I provided in my staff report. And that gets us to the items as agendized. So I want to talk about the items that appear on the agenda. And then focus on really the only item we're asking the council to take action on tonight. There is the fee study that has been referred to several times by me, by the chief, by others has actually been in print I believe since March of 2020. And it has been presented to the Brentwood city council and the Contra Costa county Board of Supervisors. And the city is going to be considering that fee study as well. And in fact, did a workshop on that fee study in August. Much like the workshop you're going to have tonight about the planning commission, the fee study was presented in that format. Not for approval but for comment. And again, we will get to that, but basically the adoption of a fee study and a resolution approving the fee study requires a public hearing under California law. A public hearing is not unlike what we're doing now or what we do for any other agenda item. But it requires us to publish a newspaper notice in the legal newspaper, which in this case is the east bay times. So we have published a notice. And the reason that your agenda carries the actions that were noticed is because we needed to make sure that the noticed actions appeared on the agenda so in theory anyone who wants to comment on those items can. But we are in fact asking the council tonight to continue the approval of the fee resolution and to continue the associated administration agreement, because we are basically tinkering with some very, very small level details at this point. We're at I guess the engineers talk about 95% plans or 98%. Whatever. We're basically at that level right now. And it's just a matter of getting those small final details approved and presented to the council. And we will be doing that at your next meeting. So one of the actions that we would like the council to take tonight is to continue the hearing on the fee resolution and the administration agreement until your next meeting. The reason we ask you to do that on the record is because that way we do not have to go back and publish another newspaper notice. So, if you continue something on the record, then it is appropriate to basically just call that item at your next meeting without us having to go back and publish what is a 15-day notice in the newspaper. So you know at this point we might not be able to make the deadline for the first meeting of February if we had to go back and publish in the newspaper. What we are asking tonight -- and I'll finally after a very long winded presentation get to the only item we're asking the council to address and that is what really is I call a clean up item for our city code. So our city code has a variety of sections that govern the fee, the various fees that are collected from development. And if you go into the chapter and title where these code sections appear, you'll see each of our fees are called out and has a separate set of regulations, one of which is a chapter devoted entirely to the fire impact fee. All we are doing with the proposed ordinance that is presented for your introduction tonight is just clarifying what is already the practice with the station 55 agreement. Which is that the city will remit the revenues received from developers for new construction that basically are collected for fire impact purposes. The capital purposes. And that there will be an agreement between the parties that governs the city's transmittal of those revenues and the districts receipt and expenditure of those revenues. And again, we have an agreement that will be presented to you. And it's basically ready to go. It's the same thing essentially that was presented to Brentwood and the county. So really this is a clean up item. Some of you are new, but I think you know the ordinance approval process. When an ordinance is presented, it goes through I call it a 2-step process. The first process is the introduction of the ordinance. And we do something called waiving the first reading. Technically under the code we're supposed to read the ordinance into the record. That is sort of archaic historic practice, which made sense in the era before computers and the Internet. But is really somewhat of an anachronism. And so, we talk about waiving the first reading. And introducing the ordinance. And then at your next meeting, we will waive the second reading, because you had to read the ordinance both times. And then we will ask you to enact the ordinance. The one caveat is that there can not be any substantive change between the introduction, the first reading, the waiver of the first reading and the enactment, which is the waiver of the second reading. So between now and our next meeting we cannot make any substantive changes once you introduce the ordinance. And so, it's a 2-step process. If you follow state legislation, I believe each house you have to read the legislation three times in each house in each chamber. So it's not unlike -- I don't remember from high school civics how you have to do it in Congress. But there are similar requirements. So really the only action we're asking you to take tonight is to introduce the ordinance, waive the first reading. It's a very simple ordinance. I'm happy to answer any questions. It's really just intended to codify what we're already doing. What's already governed by the station 55 agreement. I do note that there was correspondence received on behalf of discovery builders this afternoon. And that has been provided to the council and is now part of the record. I do want to mention that the correspondence that you've received other than the cover letter that was dated today's date has been presented to the previous council. We've had a couple of iterations of these fire district matters. Fire district fee matters. And so, all of those have been received in previous council meetings. And so, what you received today was really just a cover letter that included some reports that discovery builder had obtained from consultants that provided comments on the fee study that the district performed. It is our preference not to delve into those today. The reason again being that we're only focusing on just the introduction of this ordinance. This clean up ordinance. I do note that the fire district will be presenting comments in response to the letter you received today. The district did provide commentary in response to discovery builders sort of package of letters when those same letters were presented to the county and to Brentwood and the district did provide its responses I understand the district will cooperate with the city to provide those so that they get included with your packet along with my staff report. And so,, you know, I will let the council know that you will have a response to all of these assertions. And there is one comment -- the cover author -- the attorney representing discovery builders makes you should not take tonight's action, which is to simply introduce the ordinance. And I think that's a little over the top. All we're doing with tonight's action is codifying the transfer of revenues from the city to the district. That has technically not anything to do with with the sufficiency of the fee impact report, three of the substantive challenges that are being made in those letters do not relate to what really is just a clean up item. And so although the author of that letter does ask that you not take tonight's actions, I think that's again a little over the top. And unnecessary. I think you can take the action and yet still give thoughtful consideration to the points. That party has made as well as the responses that the district is going to provide. And again, I note that there's a 2-step process. So ultimately you'll make the decision, the final decision to approve this ordinance at your next meeting if you introduce it tonight. So I've talked long enough. I will stop and I'll be happy to answer any questions. >> Questions from council? >> Do we know how many districts we have in the city? Can you tell us our finance director? How many special districts are we collecting money for? Do we know the total amount? >> I think maybe just clarify the question. Like a special district such as east Contra Costa fire? Or we have separate funds that govern lighting landscaping district. >> How many? >> There are about 32 of those. >> About 32. And about how much money. >> It's a good question. If they're just the district themselves probably 3.5 million. >> What's that? >> 3.5 million for those lighting landscaping districts. Again, that isn't related to the fire district. >> No, no, I'm asking 32 -- I'm saying that if you're following up on the question is I was listening to the finance report yesterday, the audit yesterday. And one of the questions that kept coming up is the district says they don't know how many CFDs fire districts there are or how much money. I've heard mayor Higgins mention 20 million. I've heard you 2.5. We may have 32. >> Let me clarify -- and the finance director used the word apples and oranges. If you're talking about the community facilities district, we have two of those dedicated to fire. And then we have one of those that is dedicated -- more than one CFD. One dedicated to parks and landscaping. So again, we're kind of mixing definitions here. And I want to answer your question council member. Related to the fire district, we have two CFDs and have annexed somewhere on the order of 16 or 17 developments into those CFDs. Fire CFDs. >> Okay. Well, you've answered my question. I'm getting an idea why they said they don't know how many districts there are exactly how much money is involved. So thank you. >> Don't forget your light council member fuller. Any other council questions? Council member Williams. >> I'm good thank you. >> Thank you. >> All right. Hearing no questions from the council, and we do have our public comments from Paul balding the third that is read into the minutes. I'll close the public hearing and we can deliberate. Is there any deliberation? >> Council just so we're clear the two requested items are No. 1 to continue on the record the fee administration agreement and the fee resolution to your next meeting of the action No. 1 or you can do that in No. 2. But the other action would be to waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. >> Okay. Let's see if I have this right. Continue the fee administration and to waive the first reading of the ordinance? >> It would be to continue the fee administration agreement and the fee resolution to your next meeting that would be one action. And then the other action would be to waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. >> Council member fuller you have your light on. >> Yes. Thank you. My concern is over the time I've been liaison. Over the time I've been sitting on the council is, I'm detecting a conflict of interest between the ECCFTD board and what is transpiring. The ECCFTD board has four members from Brentwood and one from the county. We don't have in Oakley don't have any. I've gone to several ECCFPD meetings virtually and talked with the members. And I'm continually hearing complaints about Oakley. And I'm continually hearing the praises about Brentwood. They are encountering money out of their own pockets when they pass fees and it comes to them. So that is a consideration. Also there's some political interests that's involved should they go on to the future that they've saved Brentwood. There was even one aspect shortly after all the acrimony started where director Smith said we ought ECCFPD have a tiered response that Brentwood could be assured of a proper response time. And Oakley, because it wasn't paying its share, would get what was left over if they could be there. So I am concerned about how this is going forward. I'd like the idea of recording the special funds. I have this year and over again yesterday that ECCFPD does not know how many districts we have. CPDs or how much money is involved. I'm hearing confusion here and how much money is involved and back and forth. So I'm glad our finance director is here, because I would really like to see when the budget comes in a breakdown of all the districts and how we're spending the money in each district. So each district member can read their own budget and see how much money they paid into it. And then see what services they're going to. Under the special taxes. But I would like to see that. But during this time I'm continuing hearing that we aren't carrying our share. They should be and I think we're in a dangerous position as to a future special tax election. Because that would be 100% of the ECCFTD, which is all of Brentwood, all of Oakley and all of the county. And I would hate to see campaign saying, "well Brentwood is doing its share and county is. So they ought to vote for it to make sure Oakley has its share -- pays its share." That could put us in a very vulnerable position and end up not only our members paying an impact fee and measure X fee tax but also another fee brought on by a special tax election. That bothers me. I really am for consolidation. I am really seeing this come about. I believe in what chief helmet is moving forward. But I am concerned how that report's going to hit Lasco. This is the second year, second audit report that they've had serious substantial deficits in their audit report. I am concerned that all this consolidation is going to go to Lasco. They're going to take one look at that report and say thanks a lot, but we're not going to inherit fiscal management and what your deficits may be because of it. So I'm just here. I am -- I believe that we as Oakley should be looking at our own fire department. I'm not sure that that's the best alternative. But I think it's the least of the problems that may be developing. I don't want to go through here another year. Add more taxes to our citizens. Bring more impact fees to our developers. Continue on in hearing how we are not doing our share. And then getting down to Lasco and they're saying no. And then we're left with it. I am willing to fund a consultant, because ECCFPD is taking an immense amount of time. Not only I'm experiencing it. One comment out of director Smith saying I didn't have it right cost me 15 hours of additional work to listen to tapes and go through things. It's the same way in the city. So I'm willing to hire an outside consultant to come in to review and see if the city should have its own fire department and we not approve anything until we have that report. Even if it means putting it off February ninth vote. >> Thank you council member. >> With respect mayor Higgins if I may. This is chief helmet. Can I please speak couple of items please? >> Sure. >> And again, I just want to make a couple of items clear that I'm here. Our legal council is here and the engineer that put the fee schedule together is also here. I just want to put a couple of items in the appropriate context. And listening to council member fuller it is respectfully concerning and I don't believe it's a fair representation of where the district is and/or where our problems lie. The reason I want to state this is that look, we are -- we now have access to, and the city has done a great job in the last couple of months giving us access to the engineers of whom created the CFD. And just to be clear -- and I would love to have the finance director either confirm or deny my accuracy on this. The fire district has CFD. CFD218 -- multiple properties have been annexed into that. And there's another safety CFD which I believe is police. To be clear is, we have been working through many historical challenges in regards to fact finding and understanding. The city's legal council respectfully they're your council their staff, my council and my staff. We are focused on getting impact fees corrected. But I want to make it very very crystal clear that the city, the city's legal council, they've given us the pathway to work with the engineers to gain clarity on how many CFDs they are, when the revenues are going to be coming into the district. And that is not the cities obligation at this point. We're working collaboratively together. But we have how many CFDs they are understanding the fee schedule of how we arrived at the commercial rate, the residential rate. We understand the. But the CFDs are secondary priority. Because we're working on getting the impact fees. And working through the complexities with the 55 agreement and the MOU. And it's just taking and doing this in bite sizes collectively and working with each other. So understand the confusion around the CFDs. There was more confusion than where there is today. But the district has a very clear path of mining it out. But it's a work flow process right now. And right now we collectively -- the city and the district are working on impact fees. And then the district will further work with the city to understand the exact number of CFDs, the number of parcels that have been annexed into, how many of them are residential industrial commercial. What's the rate of which they're at. At what point. Money transferred to the fire district. It is a separate but yet parallel and equally important process for doing impact fees first. So we have clear communications now. We have a clear pathway and we're working through that. And secondarily again, I would be happy to report back in regards to the audit findings. But respectfully, the audit -- we do not have -- we are making huge strides and we're doing great things. And I can work on validating to your council I'm sorry that we are making great progress and it's going to be a non-issue when we get to Lasco. But you know what? I think that behaviors and actions mean more than words. And I'm confident behind what I'm saying. And I'll mine that out. But again, respectfully, placing the impact fees are needed. And I also want to provide a little bit of context and clarity. Look, where we worked three months ago, two months ago is not where we are today. And to put into context director Smith -- and I want to be careful here speaking on behalf of respective board members is, there were actually two items that were discussed by the fire board. And when there was the potential that we felt and it could have been misperceived. It could have

Minutes of the Joint Meeting of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Oakley Public Financing Authority held January 26, 2021 1) OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Mayor Sue Higgins called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California. In addition to Mayor Higgins, Vice Mayor Randy Pope and Councilmembers Aaron Meadows and George Fuller were in attendance. Councilmember Anissa Williams joined the meeting via teleconference. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Mayor Higgins) Mayor Higgins led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. 1.3 Update Provided by Fire Chief Brian Helmick, East Contra Costa Fire Protection District East Contra Costa Fire Protection District (ECCFPD) Fire Chief Brian Helmick provided an update to the Oakley City Council via teleconference. He shared history regarding the ECCFPD and explained additional fire stations and impact fees are needed to address growth. He mentioned in April 2021, ECCFPD is looking to move forward with implementing a district-wide community facilities district (CFD) fee. He thanked the City of Oakley for being a trailblazer to seek developers who voluntarily agree to be part of CFDs and shared that currently more than a dozen developers have agreed. He mentioned ECCFPD believes CFDs and impact fees will responsibly address growth and service level deficits. He added that ECCFPD has looked at all options in lieu of a tax. He explained that historically, ECCFPD explored consolidation many times with Contra Costa County Fire Protection District (CCCFPD), but it was not previously a viable option as there were too many gaps; however, ECCFPD re-explored consolidation with CCCFPD and in July 2020, the ECCFPD Board approved to move forward with a Phase I feasibility study. He mentioned the Phase I study findings show economy of scale for consolidation, including that East Contra Costa County could potentially have 5 stations with paramedics rather than EMTs. He shared that with the Phase I study being favorable, the ECCFPD Board approved the Phase II process which began in December 2020. He explained that the Phase II process reanalyzes the Phase I process to identify any gaps that may impact sustainability as well as any deficits. He added that the Phase II process also involves preparing an application to LAFCO. He shared that the Phase II process will go until July 2021, but ECCFPD is looking for draft by April 2021 to present to the CCCFPD Board to consider moving forward with the LAFCO process in July 2021 if all is favorable which would be Phase III. He explained the ECCFPD Board would have to approve a resolution of intent to absorb into CCCFPD and the CCFPD Board would have to approve to annex into ECCFPD. He mentioned the entire process, including the LAFCO process, could take until January 2022, and if approved by LAFCO, there would still be work to be done; the respective Boards would remain in place to

transfer all authority and property, then dissolve which may not occur until July 2022. He mentioned ECCFPD is looking to do this to provide the highest level of service with its budget as response times are critical and the consolidation can potentially provide 5 stations. He shared that ECCFPD looks to National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) guidelines and its guideline number 17-10 provides recommended and desired response times of which ECCFPD is not anywhere near where it needs to be; ECCFPD response times average 7 minutes, 30 seconds in the cities of Oakley and Brentwood, and in more rural areas it is 17 plus minutes. He commented that ECCFPD needs to strive for 8 minutes; the current response times in rural areas are double the recommendation. He mentioned 2 additional engine companies would address 2/3 of response times and it would need to find a mechanism to address the other 1/3 over the next few years and possibly through the consolidation process. He concluded with the call to action: ECCFPD needs community engagement and community support. He mentioned ECCFPD wants to protect life and property at the highest service level and it will take some time to get there; it is looking at an innovative approach to try to accomplish this. Vice Mayor Pope congratulated Chief Helmick for his progress on consolidation. He mentioned for years before he was on the City Council he thought consolidation was a good idea and when he served on the ECCFPD Board consolidation was deemed impossible. He inquired what the City Council can do to help to support and promote consolidation. Chief Helmick mentioned the City of Brentwood is presenting a resolution of support for consolidation. He shared the community has a voice; the City of Oakley can continue its support through a similar resolution and through continued conversations and engagement. Vice Mayor Pope inquired if he can request a resolution of support for consolidation now as a request for future agenda items. Mayor Higgins responded he could, but it is already scheduled to be on the next meeting agenda for February 9, 2021. Councilmember Fuller congratulated Chief Helmick on his dedication and service. He shared he listened to the ECCFPD audit report and it mentioned that the audit report contains 4 substantial deficiencies. He inquired how Chief Helmick believes LAFCO will respond to the audit in regard to consolidation. Chief Helmick responded that the ECCFPD is being responsible and transparent, it held a public meeting regarding the audit, and there is nothing to be alarmed about. He mentioned it is important to keep in perspective that the audit is a snapshot in time, but does not accurately represent ECCFPD today. He explained that over the past 4 years, ECCFPD has added to its administrative staff to be more efficient, transparent, and to address many challenges. He mentioned the audit was approved in the last quarter and internal controls and findings provide 2 years’ worth in 1 shot. He shared that ECCFPD walked through those findings, recognized them and addressed correcting them; they strive not just to a standard but to be the standard. He concluded that the audit reflects ECCFPD 2 years ago which is not ECCFPD now. Councilmember Fuller commented that he heard ECCFPD is putting together its own CFD and is anticipating its own special district tax with approval of ECCFPD residents. Chief Helmick explained the following: One-time impact fees (capital expenditures) charged to developers are done incrementally and are restrictive toward capital projects for future growth; whereas CFDs focus on ongoing operations. He mentioned developers would be required to

join CFDs and the annual assessments pass to property/ homeowner purchasers and remain on the property indefinitely to pay for fire services. He explained law indicates ECCFPD cannot impose impact fees and that is why cities help to charge impact fees; however, ECCFPD does have ability to impose CFDs. He shared ECCFPD is working with land use agencies such as Oakley which has more than a dozen voluntary CFD properties, which will provide revenue for ECCFPD until ECCFPD establishes its own in April. Councilmember Fuller commented his understanding from the ECCFPD December Board meeting is that he heard consolidation is a reality and he also heard it is probable, and that ECCFPD is expanding its personnel to have firefighters in place when consolidation occurs. He inquired if he is misunderstanding what is happening. Chief Helmick commented it is semantics; he often uses the words “probable and if”. He explained he is not the legislative body with authority to make decisions; he can only make recommendations; the ECCFPD Board has approval authority. He also shared that LAFCO must approve so for him to speak in absolutes would be to misrepresent the situation. He explained with consolidation, the ECCFPD Board directed staff to identify the fastest pathway to use Measure X funds and hire to get an engine crew in place quickly; the conversation was independent and parallel to the consolidation process. He mentioned they found CCC Fire Academy is the fastest way to proceed for expanding crews. He shared he is building a Plan B contingency plan and will know more in April to be in position in July to take next steps toward having an additional 9 firefighters, but either way they need an engine staffed by April 2022. He shared ECCFPD is using existing personnel and being as innovative as can be to increase service levels thus, the 2 person squad which the ECCFPD Board authorized is in the implementation process and it may be in place by March 2021 which will be a bridge to a 4- person engine company which they anticipate will be on line in March 2022. He indicated Councilmember Fuller has been assigned as the City’s liaison to ECCFPD and he welcomes post meeting follow up calls to provide clarity. Councilmember Fuller commented he attended a virtual January meeting and was impressed with the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU). He commented it was obvious Chief Helmick, City Manager Bryan Montgomery, ECCFPD staff and City staff worked very diligently together. He mentioned it was presented to the ECCFPD Board and the Board did not want to waiver all future encumbrances against the City, but he did not hear what was substituted in. He asked if Chief Helmick could explain why the Board did not want to accept the waiver and what was substituted in. Chief Helmick mentioned he cannot go in to specific detail, but will try to provide general comments. He shared that legal counsel and staff collaboration and cooperation have been fantastic over the past couple of months and they have enforced productivity and efficiency. In regard to the MOU, he mentioned ECCFPD is aware of present claims and the MOU presented indicated ECCFPD would waive all past claims. He shared the Board didn’t want to waive past claims they were not aware of. He mentioned ECCFPD and the City are continuing to communicate and make positive progress with their legal counsel to work toward common ground. Councilmember Fuller thanked Chief Helmick for his candor and professionalism. Councilmember Meadows commented he is pleased to see consolidation was considered again and he is pleased to see the outcome of the Phase I study. He inquired where the 5th staffed station will be located.

Chief Helmick mentioned he will not be Fire Chief when consolidation occurs. He responded the Phase I study suggested the 5th station to be staffed at existing station #55 located at Cypress and Bethel Island Road; it is not currently staffed with an engine company, but the goal would be to have it staffed by March 2022. He mentioned ECCFPD is working with Brentwood for a 2nd Brentwood station to be located at Empire and Grant and preliminary discussions are that they would run a dual company out of same house in the beginning and then station #52 would transition to station #51 once it is constructed. Councilmember Meadows inquired what the current timeline is on station #51. Chief Helmick responded that ECCFPD is working on multiple property transfers in Brentwood and funds required for station #51; he anticipates it will take a couple of years. Councilmember Meadows inquired if Contra Costa County is also looking at this station. Chief Helmick responded that ECCFPD is collaborating on all things strategic to ensure decisions made now do not have unintended consequences once consolidation occurs if approved. Councilmember Williams thanked Chief Helmick for being on the call and thanked the City Council for asking questions. Mayor Higgins inquired how many current ECCFPD Board members live in Oakley. Chief Helmick responded that there were two ECCFPD Board members, but today they do not have any. Mayor Higgins inquired if this will be rectified at some point. Chief Helmick responded that it will be addressed again through the November 2022 election unless the Board dissolves in July 2022, prior to the November 2022 election, if consolidation is approved. Mayor Higgins thanked Chief Helmick for his update and time. 2) PUBLIC COMMENTS Finance Director Tim Przybyla announced the City is receiving an operating budget excellence award from the California Society of Municipal Finance Officers (CSMFO) for fiscal year 2020/2021. He mentioned the City scored highly and it is the first time the City has applied for and received the award. He mentioned the City has had 20 years of award-winning financial statements (CAFR awards) and has applied again. He expressed he is proud to be part of it as it is a reflection of the professionalism and management of the City. Mayor Higgins thanked Mr. Przybyla and his team. She inquired if there were any discrepancies or errors found during the audit or any money missing. Mr. Przybyla confirmed no discrepancies were found and no $20 million was found missing. He added he would be willing to point out differences in the citywide budget and general fund

budget to anyone who wishes to have the conversation. He explained it is comparing apples to oranges between funds and just because the amounts do not match, it does not mean money is missing. Mayor Higgins mentioned Brian Scott submitted written comments. When he was called upon there was no reply. Mayor Higgins mentioned his comments will be made part of the record. 3) CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve Minutes from the Regular Joint City Council/City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held January 12, 2021 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Accept Report Out of Closed Session Memo (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 3.3 Approval of the East Cypress Road Precise Alignment Plan for East Cypress Road between Knightsen Avenue and Bethel Island Road (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Director of Public Works/City Engineer) 3.4 Approval of Contract Amendment #1 with F.J. Kennedy and Associates, Inc. for On-Call Consulting Services Related to the Clean Water Program and City Surveyor Services for Fiscal Year 2020/21 (Kevin Rohani P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.5 Acceptance of the Arco Service Station Project Offsite Improvements located near 2160 Laurel Road (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.6 Traffic Order pertaining to No Overnight Parking & No Parking for Vehicles over 7’ along 1315 and 1371 Main Street (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.7 Consideration of a Resolution Approving a Recognized Obligations Payment Schedule (ROPS) and Administrative Budget for the Fiscal Year of July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022 (Tim Przybyla, Finance Director) 3.8 Short-term extension of Lease Agreement with Mulehead Growers, LLC for the vineyard property located at 1785 Walnut Meadows Drive in Oakley (APN 037-141- 006)(Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) It was moved by Vice Mayor Pope and seconded by Councilmember Meadows to approve the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) 4) PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Resolution Approving a Fee Study Regarding a Fire-Facilities Fee; Introduction and Waiver of First Reading of an Ordinance Amending Chapter 9.2 of the Oakley Municipal Code Concerning the Fire-Facilities Impact Fee; and Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute an Administration Agreement with the East Contra Costa County Fire Protection District concerning the Fire-Facilities Fee (Derek Cole, City Attorney)

City Attorney Derek Cole commented that Fire Chief Helmick did a fantastic job covering the background of ECCFPD so he would not go into detail on the same discussion. He mentioned there is only one item for consideration this evening (to waive the first reading and introduce an ordinance to amend Chapter 9.2 of the Oakley Municipal Code). He explained that generally, the City charges impact fees as a land use agency and under CEQA, the City has to consider mitigation of the impact of new development. He mentioned natural resources, land use, biological impacts, wetland impacts and impacts on public safety are all things that are considered. He mentioned there is also the impact on fire services for capital needs (i.e., stations, trucks, and apparatus) and service (operational) costs covered by CFDs. He indicated this discussion concerns AB 1600 impact fees, also known as the Mitigation Fee Act, which requires the City to adopt a fee study when it decides how to fund services/improvements to be made caused by new development. He explained a nexus must be established for the cost of services in relation to the charges imposed on new development; the City must charge a fee. The practice has been for the City to collect the fee and remit it to ECCFPD and the existing agreement for station #55 dictates that fees go toward capital purposes for which the fees are collected. He mentioned the fee study referred to has been in print since March 2020 and has been presented to the CCC Board of Supervisors and City of Brentwood City Council. He added that the City of Oakley hosted a workshop in August for public comment. He explained that adoption of a fee study and resolution approving the fee study requires a public hearing and staff must publish a notice in the newspaper. He indicated staff has published a notice and needs to make sure the noticed action appears on the agenda so anyone who wishes to comment on the item can. He mentioned staff is asking the City Council to continue approval of the fee resolution and associated administration agreement to the next City Council meeting because the parties are tinkering with small final details. He mentioned one action is he wants the City Council to continue the hearing on the fee resolution and administration agreement to the next meeting on the record so another newspaper notice does not have to be published. He mentioned staff is asking the City Council to introduce and waive the first reading of the ordinance to clean up the City code to expressly clarify what is already being practiced with the station #55 agreement; the City will remit revenue received from developers to ECCFPD for fire impact capital purposes and there is an agreement between the parties for those revenues. He explained the ordinance approval process; when an ordinance is presented, it is a 2-step process: 1) the ordinance is introduced and the first reading is waived, and 2) the second reading is waived and the ordinance is enacted. He mentioned the caveat is that there cannot be any substantive changes between the first and second enactment. He mentioned that the ordinance will codify what the parties are already doing and what is covered by the agreement. He noted Discovery Builders submitted a letter this afternoon of which content has been provided to the Council at previous meetings and is made part of the record; it has the same information discussed in previous Council meetings, but what is new is the letter contains reports Discovery Builders has obtained received from consultants with their comments on the fee study ECCFPD performed. He also noted ECCFPD will be presenting comments in response to the letter as it has done previously. He indicated he will ask ECCFPD to provide comments to include in the Council meeting packet with the staff report. He suggested the Council not take action tonight on the other items. He concluded that this action codifies the transfer of revenue from the City to ECCFPD; it does not affect other items. He opined that the Council can take action tonight and take into considerations points made in the letter and responses ECCFPD will provide to take appropriate action on the ordinance during the next meeting. Councilmember Fuller inquired how many special districts exist.

City Manager Bryan Montgomery requested clarification regarding the types of special districts, indicating there are approximately 32. Councilmember Fuller inquired how much money. City Manager Bryan Montgomery there is probably $3.5 million in districts not related to ECCFPD. Councilmember Fuller commented that ECCFPD doesn’t know how many districts exist for fire and Mayor Higgins mentioned it is about $20 million. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented that there are 2 CFDs dedicated to fire and 1 CFD dedicated to parks/landscaping, so maybe definitions are being mixed. He indicated with the 2 CFDs for fire, 16-17 developments have been annexed into those. Mayor Higgins mentioned the comments/letter submitted on behalf of Discovery Builders will be made part of the record and hearing no other comments, she closed the public hearing. City Attorney Derek Cole mentioned the action for the motion is to 1) continue on the record for the fee resolution and agreement, and 2) waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. Councilmember Fuller expressed concern. He mentioned during his time sitting on the City Council and serving as its liaison to ECCFPD, he identifies a conflict of interest between the ECCFPD and CCCFPD boards. He expressed his belief that there is no representation for Oakley, he is hearing complaints of Oakley and praises for Brentwood, and he believes fee conflicts and political interests are involved. He indicated Director Smith suggested a tiered response; Brentwood could be ensured proper response times and Oakley would get what is left over if not paying its share. He shared he likes the idea of reporting special funds. He mentioned ECCFPD doesn’t know how many districts are involved or how much money is involved so there seems to be confusion; therefore, he wants to see a breakdown in the budget of each district and how much money is collected for each district so people in each district can see how much is being paid into it and what services the money goes toward. He mentioned he is continuing to hear Oakley is not carrying its share and he is concerned it will go in the direction of a future special tax election. He explained it could put Oakley in a vulnerable position to pay impact fees, Measure X tax, and potentially another fee brought upon by a special tax election. He indicated he is in favor of consolidation, but concerned about how LAFCO will take to the audit since it shows 2 years of substantial deficits which they won’t want to inherit. He commented Oakley should look at its own fire department. He mentioned he doesn’t want to add more taxes to residents and more impact fees to developers and hear that Oakley is not doing its share. He added if LAFCO rejects the consolidation then Oakley is stuck with it. He added that ECCFPD is taking an immense amount of time. He shared he is willing to hire an outside consultant to see if Oakley should have its own fire department even if it means delaying past February 9. Chief Helmick indicated it is not a fair representation where ECCFPD is today and where the problems lie. He mentioned the City has access to the engineers whom created the CFDs. He mentioned ECCFPD has CFDs and it has been working through many historical challenges, but the City and ECCFPD staff are working together; the City has given ECCFPD the pathway and they have the number and rates. He mentioned CFDs are a secondary priority; impact fees are the priority and the parties are working together. He mentioned he believes there is confusion around CFDs which is becoming clear, but collectively the City and ECCFPD are working on

impact fees and then will address CFDs. He explained they are separate but parallel processes, but they have clarification and are working together. He added ECCFPD has taken the audit findings and is making huge strides. He expressed belief that deficits will be a non-issue when it gets to LAFCO. He explained where ECCFPD was 2-3 years ago is not where it is today. He mentioned items discussed by the ECCFPD Board may have been misperceived. He shared there was discussion regarding impact zones for agencies that paid for continued growth and they discussed adjusting resources accordingly, but Board discussion is different than Board action. He added that Board policy is in place to work with land use agencies for responsible growth through impact fees and CFDs. He cautioned the Council from getting caught up on past Board discussions that have not materialized. He indicated the items discussed were not policy the ECCFPD Board adopted. He mentioned ECCFPD has looked at all options and he strongly cautioned the City Council to investigate its own fire department. He mentioned ECCFPD already has studies available and knows Oakley would need 5 stations; ECCFPD is on the path to try and provide more service through consolidation. Vice Mayor Pope indicated the discussion has moved far from the proposed action. He inquired if the ECCFPD Board President is an Oakley resident. Chief Helmick responded that there were two Oakley representatives on the ECCFPD Board, but he believes both have relocated to Brentwood. He indicated ECCFPD has had multiple discussions and make decisions for the district as a whole. Vice Mayor Pope inquired if the ECCFPD Board has moved to wards. Chief Helmick responded the ECCFPD Board has not moved to wards. Vice Mayor Pope inquired if there is a plan in place to move to wards after the 2020 census results are available. Chief Helmick responded that it is not currently in discussion. It was moved by Vice Mayor Pope and seconded by Councilmember Meadows to continue the resolution regarding the fee study and MOU agreement to the next regular City Council meeting to be held February 9, 2021, and to waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. AYES: Higgins, Meadows, Pope, Williams. NOES: Fuller. (4-1) 5) REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Fiscal Year 2020/2021 2nd Quarter Report on the Capital Improvement Program (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Public Works Director/City Engineer Kevin Rohani presented the staff report. Mayor Higgins inquired if the indicators will be like the ones that used to be on Empire to go to the park. Mr. Rohani responded that those have been discontinued. He explained these indicators are at eye level and flash so they are very visible and can be seen in advance of crosswalks and at crosswalks.

Mayor Higgins inquired if the City is still receiving SB1 funding. Mr. Rohani confirmed the City is still receiving SB1 funding and is using it toward street resurfacing projects. He mentioned a design project will be brought forth in February. Mayor Higgins mentioned Ironhouse Sanitary District (ISD) is doing a lot of roadwork off O'Hara Avenue. She inquired when the project will be complete and if City staff is inspecting any of it. Mr. Rohani confirmed City staff has been working with ISD for months and inspects the project. He mentioned a separate company has been hired by ISD to inspect as well. He indicated it is an ongoing project which he anticipates will be completed in another month or so. 5.2 Consideration of Approval of Concept Plan for Renovations to the Civic Center Park (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Public Works Director/City Engineer Kevin Rohani presented the staff report. Councilmember Fuller commented he believes the park will enhance the community. He inquired if the additional seating with the amphitheater will offer visibility to the stage. Mr. Rohani explained the drawing shared is a conceptual design and there will be visibility from all areas. He mentioned the angle of seating on the conceptual design can be tweaked for visibility. Vice Mayor Pope commented a tree is shown in the sight line from the new benches to the amphitheater. He indicated shade is needed, but perhaps the tree could be moved to the side for visibility. Mr. Rohani explained staff is planning to move trees once everything else is situated. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented the trees could be there but could be trimmed up to provide a shade canopy so the edge of the seating may still be useable. Vice Mayor Pope suggested to move the picnic tables and the angle of the playground could be shifted a bit. He also suggested to provide fencing on the street side near Main Street to prevent children from running into the street and on the side where the no-mow grass is located to prevent children from running on the landscape grass, but to leave it open otherwise. He added that the location of the sequoia tree in the conceptual drawing doesn’t afford to the option of it being a holiday tree because it is surrounded by the no-mow grass. Mr. Rohani responded he will take note. He shared that staff has researched the tree extensively to replicate the previous holiday tree, yet to survive Oakley’s hot summers and this species came highly recommended; it was found at a Yuba City nursery. Vice Mayor Pope suggested a pathway so people don’t trample the landscape grass. He commented that he loves the concept. Councilmember Meadows commented he also likes the concept and agrees with comments made regarding the sightlines to the amphitheater. He mentioned he is okay with the amphitheater, but suggested moving the tables closer to Norcross. He also suggested if it will be a holiday tree to be sure to leave enough room to access to decorate.

Councilmember Williams agreed with comments made regarding visibility and accessibility. Mayor Higgins thanked Mr. Rohani for his report. 6) REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager City Manager Bryan Montgomery reported that Governor Newsom lifted the shelter in place order and staff continues to refer residents with inquiries to the County website, ccchealth.org, for the latest updates. He mentioned Oakley's cases per thousands are in the top 3rd in the County. He shared there is a new State website regarding the vaccine rollout, www.myturn.ca.gov; and people can sign up for updates to know when and where they are eligible to receive the vaccine. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency (b) Requests for Future Agendas Councilmember Fuller reported he attended multiple ECCFPD meetings and an ISD meeting where flow charts were shared for projects for approval, there was discussion regarding purple pipe water, ISD is updating its policies for natural disasters, ISD discussed its General Plan, and had discussion regarding monitoring well water. He also reported he attended a Delta Protection Commission meeting where the Delta Protection Plan was discussed. He encouraged everyone to look at it as it addresses climate warming and flooding. He mentioned the Commission is looking at ways to extend trails to the Oakley Logistics Center and discussed economic sustainability on the Delta. He mentioned he and Supervisor Burgis were present. Councilmember Meadows reported he attended the Highway 4 Bypass Authority and Fee and Finance Authority meetings last week as well as the League of California Cities (now Cal Cities) training. Councilmember Williams reported she attended the League of California Cities (now Cal Cities) training and will attend most of her meeting tomorrows. Mayor Higgins reported she attended an ad hoc fire meeting with Councilmember Williams where they got Vice Mayor Pope’s agenda request item. Mayor Higgins reminded the City Council when Councilmembers have future agenda requests, they need at least 2 Councilmembers to support the request to utilize staff time to address the request. There were no future agenda items requested.

7) WORK SESSION 7.1 WORK SESSION - Oakley Planning Commission (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Community Development Director Joshua McMurray presented the staff report. He explained the purpose of a planning commission, the history of Oakley’s Planning Commission, its authority in relation to the City Council’s authority, the appointment process, the additional cost to have a planning commission, and the additional time projects may take for review and approval. He mentioned in 2020, 17 planning projects were brought to the City Council, 6 of which could have been approved by an independent planning commission; the others would have required City Council approval. Conan Moats was called upon for public comment. He thanked the City Council for moving in this direction. He mentioned planning commissions are recommended by the Institute for Local Government. He commented that planning commissions have potential to save the City money if planning is done properly, it can set expectations for growth, and it improves economic development and quality of life. He mentioned planning commissions provide a forum to reach consensus with more stakeholders having a say in decisions that are made and power sharing with different bodies is important. He commented that maybe in 2009 when Oakley’s Planning Commission was dissolved it made sense for that time, but now there is so much development it is important to have a planning commission in place which he hopes will move forward with some sense of urgency. Councilmember Fuller commented that Cal Cities says the best way to develop trust is not to worry about streamlining. He inquired how the planning officers organization views planning commissions. Mr. McMurray responded the American Planning Association is the national planning organization. He shared he believes it is a jurisdictional choice and while the idea of a planning commission is universally accepted, not one size fits all jurisdictions and it must be appropriate. City Manager Bryan Montgomery added that it depends on the quality of the planning commission and how capable its members are trained to handle items. He mentioned he has experienced that the City Council regretted at one time having a planning commission and often appealed decisions made by the planning commission. He mentioned if its members are trained and educated, a planning commission can be helpful, but if not, it can deter growth for months or even years. Councilmember Meadows inquired if the 17 projects during 2020 that Mr. McMurray mentioned were residential or commercial. Mr. McMurray responded that subdivisions need City Council approval by state law, whereas a planning commission can approve designs and permits. Councilmember Meadows commented that the cost for a planning commission is $50-$100k which is not in the current budget. He inquired if the City would look at it in the 2021-2022 budget.

City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded that the recruitment and training process would take it into the next fiscal year. He mentioned the mid-year budget review will be presented in February and it shows that it has been a good financial year so he believes the funds exist. He added that $50-$100k depends on the quality of the planning commission; the cost could increase if multiple meetings are conducted to approve items. Councilmember Meadows inquired if the City Council can appoint planning commissioners if it can also unappoint them. City Manager Bryan Montgomery explained the City Councilmembers are the elected officials and in his opinion and experience, more authority should be with the City Council and a planning commission should give its recommendations. He mentioned it is easier to give away authority than take it away so the Council might consider giving the planning commission recommendation authority to begin with then reassess its authority after a year. He added that depending on the timing of meetings, an agenda packet may have to go out every week for Council and planning commission meetings, but the money appears to be available if the Council wants to move forward. He mentioned staff attending meetings are mostly salaried so some care may want to be taken as to not burn out staff. He explained salaried staff does not get overtime; therefore, other staff may be needed to backfill other duties. Councilmember Meadows inquired how long it would take to put a planning commission in place. Mr. McMurray responded that he has a draft schedule that depends on variables. He mentioned in late February or early March staff could bring the item to the City Council for consideration of approval and if approved, staff could go through the application process to provide a June interview. He suggested a two-step interview process involving an ad hoc subcommittee to review applications and select final applicants to be interviewed by the City Council. He suggested it may be July or August before an independent planning commission would be seated and trained. Councilmember Meadows inquired how planning commissioners would be appointed, at-large or by districts. City Attorney Derek Cole responded that the City Council can appoint an at-large body for a planning commission even if the Council is in districts; it is not obligated to have planning commission districts. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented that Oakley is a small community; if district-based and there are 5 finalists, 2 of the 5 may live close together which means there may be very capable candidates who may not be able to be on the planning commission because of their residential proximity to another commissioner. He explained it can be at-large, but when voting, proximity between commissioners might be a consideration when choosing applicants with similar qualifications. Vice Mayor Pope shared that he was not on the City Council when there was a planning commission, but he recalls it was a rogue commission in that all of its approvals and denials came back to the City Council anyhow for decisions. He mentioned the City Council is elected to make decisions and if a planning commission is not elected, it is bureaucratic. He mentioned he proposed the planning commission be brought back when he was elected to the City Council

and he didn’t have the City Council’s support and that is where the hybrid Citizen Planning Advisors was created. He inquired how many Citizen Planning Advisors the City currently has. Mr. McMurray responded there are currently 5 Citizen Planning Advisors and 2 of them regularly comment. Vice Mayor Pope commented it is disappointing that there is push for a planning commission when there must be people who will be active in and willing to serve on a planning commission. He expressed concern that a planning commission may look like just a puppet commission if the City Council can unappoint planning commissioners if it does not like their approach or decisions. He mentioned if the Council decides to go forward with a planning commission, he wants to take time with the appointment selection and training. He added if a planning commission does not have approval authority, there isn’t value to have it and if the people really want it, they could be a planning advisor. He proposed the planning commission could meet on the second City Council meeting night rather than double up on meetings; the second Tuesday of the month could be for Council meetings and the fourth Tuesday of the month could be for Planning Commission meetings. He mentioned he is now torn about having a planning commission as the Council serves as the Planning Commission and he explained there is a lack of planning advisors now so he is not sure there is so much demand. He mentioned the Planning Commission used to be a step to the City Council; but the commissioners need education and experience before they get on the Planning Commission. He explained that he doesn’t want this to be the place where they make their first mistakes which may impact residents and businesses. Councilmember Williams expressed concern regarding redundancy as a planning commission would provide another set of eyes. She suggested a study to determine if there is interest and engagement. She mentioned she had never heard of the Citizen Planning Advisors until now and she would have more confidence if results showed there is interest. Mr. McMurray responded staff can perform a survey, but for someone to express they are interested is different than signing up for a 4-year term. City Manager Bryan Montgomery added it is a commitment to block off time for each meeting. He mentioned staff can get a survey out in the next week and include both options in the survey to see if more people are interested as an advisor or committed to be involved as a commissioner. He mentioned if Planning Commission meetings are held the second meeting of the month, there would be a huge time savings and it would also allow time to go to Council for approval at its next meeting. Mayor Higgins inquired if there are any ordinances that say commissioners can’t be a member of another board or agency. Mr. McMurray explained that would be at the direction of the City Council. Mayor Higgins mentioned the Council would need to look at who would make up the ad-hoc committee, pre-interview and interview for finalists. Councilmember Fuller commented he is hearing there is an alienation of trust and he believes what has been happening is that the City is notifying the public at the last minute then saying there is no other choice. He explained a planning commission allows an idea to be released early and allows feedback from the community which he believes would be good for business.

He gave an example of the 7-Eleven at O’Hara and Empire which involved a 6-hour hearing regarding alcohol sales. He mentioned the 7-Eleven may have a high turn-over of business even without alcohol sales, but it may have wanted to hear from a planning commission and address community concerns before it built the store. He also mentioned Diablo Water District (DWD) was upset because it wasn’t there for a zoning and construction process. He mentioned a planning commission brings together staff and the public. He mentioned it may not be possible to quantify cost, but the City can amend its budget, and look at the quality of people in Oakley (the people who trust the Council to make sound decisions and who will maintain integrity and ethics for selection to a commission). He expressed he understands it is one more step in the project process, but expressed he is not convinced businesses wouldn’t want to hear what the community wants before coming here. He added that the City’s Planning Department is professional, but he wants to keep it in sync with the community and a planning commission would carry it forward. He announced Cal Cities training is offered in mid-March for planning commissioners and he is confident people can also obtain training through staff. Mayor Higgins commented that the Council seems to like the idea of the survey to see if people want to commit to a 4-year term. She mentioned she does not want to rush it. She explained that the City may need ordinances to establish how to do things as well as qualifications for commissioners. She mentioned staff can get it set up, but it takes time and may go into 2022. She added she likes the idea of at-large and it sounds like commissioners would be working their way in this year, but starting in 2022. Vice Mayor Pope expressed he is in favor of outreach and suggested the survey address at what level would people would be interested in and if they could commit to 1-2 meetings each month and time to review documents. He suggested if they cannot commit, perhaps they consider being a planning advisor and the pool of applicants received for the planning commission can be the citizen advisors. He suggested outreach to determine if the City can obtain enough applicants to staff a planning commission with the best selection, not just do it to do it. He mentioned more eyes on a project makes it better, but he wants to do it right for the benefit of residents and keep it streamlined for people with project applications. Councilmember Meadows suggested the survey should not be rushed, but rather well thought out in terms of what the Council needs and the information it is looking to get back from the survey. He commented that the 5 City Councilmembers are elected and ultimately responsible for planning decisions. Mr. McMurray suggested staff can issue the survey and report back by the second Council meeting in February on results. Mayor Higgins inquired if the City Council wants to see the survey before it is issued. Vice Mayor Pope indicated it is not a Brown Act violation if staff sends the survey to the City Council and Councilmembers comment individually. He explained this would include all of the City Council, not just a select few. City Manager Bryan Montgomery suggested staff can bring it back or Mayor Higgins can resolve any issues and staff can send to the City Council before release. Vice Mayor Pope indicated he wants to see the survey advertised well, including a press release, through Oakley OnDemand, and via social media.

Mayor Higgins announced the closed session item. 8) CLOSED SESSIONS 8.1 CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-ANTICIPATED LITIGATION Significant Exposure to Litigation Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2) One Potential Case. 8.2 Report Out of Closed Session (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 9) ADJOURN There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:55 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk

Showing the first 24,000 of 153,163 characters. The full document is at the source.

AGENDA REGULAR JOINT MEETING OF THE OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY AND SPECIAL MEETING OF THE OAKLEY PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY Tuesday, January 26, 2021 6:30 PM Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California 94561 BE ADVISED that this meeting will be live-streamed on the City's website at www.oakleyinfo.com. Due to the order of the County Health Officer, no one will be allowed to attend the meeting in person. How to Participate: Telephone: You may participate via telephone by calling (925) 809-9201 and using Conference ID#: 921207. Please call or text (925) 787-8454 with any difficulties with the call-in number or ID. The meeting host will call on you when it is your turn to speak. Please mute your phone until then. E-mail: Public comments can be submitted until 5 p.m. the day of the meeting by completing an online comment form through the City's website, https://www.ci.oakley.ca.us/agendas-minutes-videos-archive/ . Comments will be distributed to the City Council via email and summarized in the meeting minutes. Please indicate on the comment form if you wish to speak during the meeting. Public comments are pu MISSION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley exists to build and enhance a quality community and to serve the public in a friendly, efficient, responsive manner. VISION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley will be recognized as a model of civic participation and a vibrant Delta community where families live, work, play, shop and visit. Agendas are posted in Oakley at Oakley City Hall-3231 Main Street, outside the gym at Delta Vista Middle School-4901 Frank Hengel Way and outside the Library at Freedom High School-1050 Neroly Road; agendas are also posted on the City’s Internet Website www.ci.oakley.ca.us. A complete packet of information containing staff reports and exhibits related to each item is available for public review prior to an Oakley City Council and/or City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the 1

Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority meeting at Oakley City Hall, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Oakley City Council, Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency or Oakley Public Financing Authority regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection, during regular business hours, at the front counter in the Main Lobby of the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Agendas may be picked up at the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561 for no charge. To request information regarding placement on the City’s agenda e-mail distribution list, please contact us at (925) 625-7000. We provide social media options to stay connected to City Hall through Facebook, Twitter, Next Door and Instagram. Other opportunities to connect with City Hall include Engage In Oakley, Oakley OnDemand on the city's website; and by emailing info@ci.oakley.ca.us. Constant Contacts. Please contact us at (925) 625-7000 for additional information or at www.oakleyinfo.com. If you have a physically challenging condition and require special accommodations, please call the City Clerk’s office at (925) 625-7013. Please keep cell phones/electronic devices turned off during the meeting. Please be advised that City Council meetings are video recorded and attendees may appear on video. Members of the public may address the Council on items of interest that are within the City’s jurisdiction. Public comment on items not listed on the agenda will be heard under the Public Comments section of the agenda. In compliance with State law, the Council may not take action on an item that is not specifically listed on the agenda. If you would like to speak on any agenda item, please fill out a blue speaker card available in the lobby and submit it to the City Clerk prior to the agenda item being called. The Mayor will call you by name to the podium to hear your comments and you have up to 3 minutes to speak. 1.OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Mayor Higgins) 1.3 Update Provided by Fire Chief Brian Helmick, East Contra Costa Fire Protection District 2.PUBLIC COMMENTS 2

At this time, the public is permitted to address the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority on non-agendized items. PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES. In accordance with State Law, however, no action or discussion may take place on any item not appearing on the posted agenda. 3.CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar items are typically non-controversial in nature and are considered for approval by the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority with one single action. Members of the audience, Staff or the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority who would like an item removed from the Consent Calendar for purposes of public input may request the Mayor remove the item. Members of the public should submit any Speaker Cards related to the Consent Calendar in advance of the Consent Calendar being considered. 3.1 Approve Minutes from the Regular Joint City Council/City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held January 12, 2021 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Minutes 011221 3.2 Accept Report Out of Closed Session Memo (Derek Cole, City Attorney) Memo 3.3 Approval of the East Cypress Road Precise Alignment Plan for East Cypress Road between Knightsen Avenue and Bethel Island Road (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Director of Public Works/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Draft East Cypress Road Precise Alignment 2. Resolution 3.4 Approval of Contract Amendment #1 with F.J. Kennedy and Associates, Inc. for On-Call Consulting Services Related to the Clean Water Program and City Surveyor Services for Fiscal Year 2020/21 (Kevin Rohani P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Resolution 2. Amendment No. 1 3.5 Acceptance of the Arco Service Station Project Offsite Improvements located near 2160 Laurel Road (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Resolution 3

3.6 Traffic Order pertaining to No Overnight Parking & No Parking for Vehicles over 7’ along 1315 and 1371 Main Street (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Traffic Order #21-01 2. Resolution Approving Traffic Order #21-01 3. Petition from property owners along Main Street in favor of a parking restriction 4. Photos - 1315 and 1371 Main Street 3.7 Consideration of a Resolution Approving a Recognized Obligations Payment Schedule (ROPS) and Administrative Budget for the Fiscal Year of July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022 (Tim Przybyla, Finance Director) Staff Report 1. Resolution 2. Recognized Obligations Payment Schedule for Fiscal Year 2021/2022 3. Administrative Budget 3.8 Short-term extension of Lease Agreement with Mulehead Growers, LLC for the vineyard property located at 1785 Walnut Meadows Drive in Oakley (APN 037-141-006)(Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) Staff Report 1. Site Map 2. Resolution 3. Proposed short-term lease extension agreement 4. Existing lease agreement 4.PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Resolution Approving a Fee Study Regarding a Fire-Facilities Fee; Introduction and Waiver of First Reading of an Ordinance Amending Chapter 9.2 of the Oakley Municipal Code Concerning the Fire-Facilities Impact Fee; and Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute an Administration Agreement with the East Contra Costa County Fire Protection District concerning the Fire-Facilities Fee (Derek Cole, City Attorney) Suggested Action: 1) Open the Public Hearing, 2) Receive the Staff Report, 3) Receive Questions from the City Council, 4) Receive Public Comments, 5) Close the Public Hearing, 6) Deliberate, 7) Summarize the Deliberation, 8) Direct that the Resolution and Administration Agreement be considered for adoption on February 9, 2021, and 9) Waive the First Reading and Introduce the Ordinance. Staff Report 1. Ordinance 4

5.REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Fiscal Year 2020/2021 2nd Quarter Report on the Capital Improvement Program (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 5.2 Consideration of Approval of Concept Plan for Renovations to the Civic Center Park (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Civic Center Park Renovation Concept Plan 6.REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency (b) Requests for Future Agendas 7.WORK SESSION 7.1 WORK SESSION - Oakley Planning Commission (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Staff Report 1. Powerpoint Presentation 2. Institute for local Government - The Planning Commissioner's Role 8.CLOSED SESSIONS 8.1 CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-ANTICIPATED LITIGATION Significant Exposure to Litigation Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2) One Potential Case. 5

8.2 Report Out of Closed Session (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 9.ADJOURN 6

Minutes of Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority held January 12, 2021 1) OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Vice Mayor Randy Pope called the meeting to order at 6:32 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California. He shared that Mayor Sue Higgins was absent due to illness. In addition to Vice Mayor Pope, Councilmembers Aaron Meadows, Anissa Williams and George Fuller were present. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Mayor Higgins) Vice Mayor Pope led the Pledge of Allegiance. 2) PUBLIC COMMENTS Vice Mayor Pope called for comments. An unidentified caller commented to Councilmember Fuller that she understands he was recently was asked to leave Oakley Rotary because he wouldn’t stop telling lies about fellow members. The caller indicated Councilmember Fuller made a statement during his campaign about former Mayor Romick and City Manager misdirected that $20 million. The caller requested Councilmember Fuller provide a response at some point and inquired how he plans to return this money now that he is on the City Council. Vice Mayor Pope explained a response cannot be provided during the meeting from a Councilmember because the item is not agendized. The caller mentioned she would be fine with a response posted on the City's website. 3) CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve Minutes from the Special Meeting of the Oakley City Council held December 8, 2020 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Approve Minutes from the Regular Joint City Council/City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held December 8, 2020 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.3 Adopt a Resolution Continuing the Declaration of the Existence of an Emergency Affecting the Public Health and Safety due to the Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic (Bryan H. Montgomery, City Manager) 7

3.4 Appointment of City Council Standby Members for Newly Elected Councilmembers in the Event of a Declared Emergency (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented that Councilmember Meadows brought to his attention that there is a type error in the minutes; under City Manager Reports; “painting” should be revised to “paving”, and the resolution in item 3.3 indicates a vaccine is not yet available which should be omitted. He mentioned staff will make the changes administratively if approved. Vice Mayor Pope inquired when Police will receive vaccines. Chief of Police Dean Capelletti responded that partners within the County will begin receiving vaccines this week and Oakley will likely be end of next week. It was moved by Councilmember Fuller and seconded by Councilmember Meadows to approve the Consent Calendar with the revisions identified by Councilmember Meadows. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0) 4) PUBLIC HEARINGS None. 5) REGULAR CALENDAR None. 6) REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager City Manager Bryan Montgomery reported that staff will continue to refer the public to the Contra Costa Health Services website for the current vaccine distribution schedule. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Fuller reported he virtually attended the East Contra Costa Fire Protection District (ECCFPD) Board meeting and it was decided that ECCFPD will consolidate with Contra Costa Fire Protection District (CCFPD). He mentioned within a year they anticipate to consolidate; in the process they are starting to expand personnel, enhance response time, and initiate a squad of two firefighters to fill in gaps. He also reported he attended the Diablo Water District Board meeting where Paul Seger was elected Board President. He mentioned the Board expressed concern regarding the ARCO station; the new set of directors are concerned about the gas line being located close to the creek and he relayed this information to Mr. Montgomery. He mentioned while they approved it, they would like to be kept in the loop early regarding these matters. He shared that on December 15, he watched women contest 7-Eleven’s ABC license 8

and they were well prepared; he believes their angst could have been resolved with review of the matter by the City having a planning commission. He also reported he attended the Contra Costa Mayors Conference where Mayor Higgins was elected to a position and where he was appointed to the Delta Protection Commission. He shared he failed in the LAFCO election. Councilmember Meadows reported he attended the Transplan meeting in December where he was elected Chair and Supervisor Burgis was elected Vice Chair and the Board chose 2 member representatives to the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA); regular members are Joel Bryant from City of Brentwood and Lamar Thorpe from City of Antioch. He also reported he was appointed by Cal Cities to the Governance, Transparency and Labor Relations Policy Committee and they have a meeting this Friday. Councilmember Williams reported she attended the Transplan meeting and the Tri-Delta Transit Board meeting where it was approved to research autonomous vehicles. Vice Mayor Pope reported he attended a Habitat Conservancy meeting where he learned there is resolution to long-involved litigation regarding a fee dispute. He commented the resolution is a win-win for developers using the program and for protecting space for critters. (b) Requests for Future Agendas None. 7) WORK SESSIONS 7.1 Discussion Regarding the Train Platform Project (Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) City Manager Bryan Montgomery shared that the staff report covers basic components and history of the train platform project. He mentioned in 2014, staff and the San Joaquin Regional Rail Commission had a discussion and the Commission included in a business plan the need for a more adequate and functional train platform in East Contra Costa County. He shared that staff worked with the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA) and received a grant in 2015 to conduct a study which is available on the City’s website; it evaluated various sites, benefits and impacts of a railway in Downtown Oakley, and staff worked toward implementing the vision. He shared transit line maps of the train routes that could potentially be covered in its network. He mentioned the grant that was received by the San Joaquin Joint Powers Authority (SJJPA) included a component that is contingent upon the City performing as outlined in the PDA study and the Downtown Specific Plan. He shared that Amtrak is a partner with SJJPA and while the platform is intended to provide a commuter rail to Oakland, it will also be part of a nationwide network for travel. He shared the basic layout of the platform and how it ties into the Downtown Specific Plan. He explained it is SJJPA’s project, it received grant funding, and it is now coordinating agreements to lead up to the design of platform. He clarified this is not a station, but rather a platform with awnings for shade, and he is not certain if kiosks are still planned to be included as ticket sales are moving toward online. He mentioned the project should be underway next year and will carry hundreds of passengers each day from Oakley and its surrounding areas. He commented that there is an existing site in Antioch, but SJJPA believes this is a better and more visible location. Vice Mayor Pope requested Mr. Montgomery address the new station street. 9

Mr. Montgomery shared that the access road would happen in phases; O'Hara Avenue goes north and in the 1st phase a loop would be created on the eastern side from Second Street to O’Hara Avenue and the other connection would be in a future phase. He mentioned a parking lot is under design which includes a private building to be constructed next to the Guanatos building. City Attorney Derek Cole addressed options the City may have in regard to the shaded blue area that Mr. Montgomery shared in his presentation. He mentioned that planning for the project dates from 2014 and the City Council can continue to provide support if it wants the project; if it doesn’t want the project, the law prohibits the City’s legal authority to do so. He shared that the Interstate Commerce Commission Transportation Act of 1995 provides that railroads belong to the Federal government which has created a Surface Transportation Board to regulate use by private and public rail carriers; local government cannot interfere with use, activity, transport, or construction of facilities on railroad property. He explained that if every city could pass laws regarding railroads, there would be chaos for railroads to navigate through each city. He also shared there are some limited laws for local government to request information. He commented that it may or may not be the Council’s pleasure to move forward, but at this stage, the City does not have authority to tell the SJJPA what to do or not to do regarding the shaded blue area. He explained the City has the ability to make a request, but has no legal authority. Councilmember Fuller requested confirmation that the parking lot and Gateway Plaza will be constructed with Main Street funds that were originated and transferred from the City’s General Fund. Mr. Montgomery responded that it is the designated funding source. He mentioned that while there are conceptual designs for Gateway Plaza it is not under design with construction plans, but the parking lot is. Councilmember Fuller inquired if the City decides not to use the funds, if it could move the $3.5 million back to the General Fund or another capital project fund. Mr. Montgomery responded that may not be the exact figure; however, the City Council could direct staff to move funds to a capital account but an operational account may not be wise because they are capital project funds. He mentioned when the SJJPA grant was submitted, it acknowledged the work mentioned by the City to support the platform which SJJPA believes is an important part of receiving the grant funds. He shared that although there is no formal agreement, the City told them it would build these things and it is in all of the city planning documents. He mentioned the City can redirect funds and not do the work to support the platform, however, as a professional, he would want to speak with the SJJPA to let them know and apologize. Councilmember Fuller inquired if the City could suspend construction of the parking lot and Gateway Plaza until SJJPA gives a written start date when the train will stop in Oakley. Mr. Montgomery responded that as improvements of the parking lot and roadway get closer in proximity to the platform, the City will need to know the grade of platform before the City portion can match up to the platform to meet ADA requirements; therefore, the City is waiting anyhow; construction is not imminent as much of the details would need to wait until the City has the information it needs. 10

Councilmember Fuller requested Mr. Montgomery address the Diablo Water District (DWD) pipeline on the railroad property. Mr. Montgomery explained that the pipeline is located on BSNF property. He shared that much like the Antioch platform and many platforms in their network, the platform will be right up against the track. He mentioned the water line is on the southern edge and as the City gets closer to design the main platform will likely be away from the pipe line, but it is a DWD decision whether or not to relocate it. He mentioned the platform is 700 linear feet and it is possible the platform will not be on top of the water line; however, it may be under pedestrian access walkways in which they are similarly located in other places. Councilmember Fuller inquired if a statistician has looked at the commercial impact of the project. Community Development Director Joshua McMurray responded that in 2015, reputable and experienced consultants including Perkins and Will, Fehr and Peers, and Economic Planning Systems; they studied the project and provided a detailed analysis over 4 months. He mentioned they concluded there are positive benefits of having the station in its proposed location; it would fuel ground-floor retail and lower density, mid-rise residential. Councilmember Fuller inquired if Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) was ever brought into City discussions about the project. Mr. Montgomery responded he is not aware of a City meeting with BART; however, BART has representation at Contra Costa Transportation Authority meetings and is aware of the project. Councilmember Fuller inquired what is involved to move a homeless encampment should it come along. City Attorney Derek Cole responded that the first question to answer is whether the property is public or private. He explained if it is private property, Police can work with the property owner’s consent to remove an encampment; however, if it is public property, pursuant to the Boise case, people who unlawfully camp on public property can be removed, but they must be given an opportunity to seek available public shelter; if none is available, they cannot be removed. He added if they have been offered public shelter and refuse it, they can be removed. Chief of Police Dean Capelletti mentioned Police provides a 72-hour notice for homeless to move their items and if they are not moved within that time, the City removes the items and holds the items for 90 days; however, they try to avoid this happening and usually when Police speaks with them, they move along. He indicated that homeless in Oakley seem to be local and are offered services. Councilmember Fuller suggested the property could be redesigned. He inquired if the train platform doesn’t go in, if the City could scale back the parking lot a

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Jan 26, 2021 - 06:28 PM — Minutes
  • Jan 26, 2021 - 06:28 PM

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 99a4b88dcc20ec1be03bfd2479e4915a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record