POLISCOPE

The public record

JUPITER (PALM BEACH COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting (2024-09-10)

Tuesday, September 10, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Jupiter Planning and Zoning Commission met to discuss a variance request for a fence at 708 Weldwood Road. The commission failed to reach a majority decision on both a motion to deny and a motion to approve the request, leaving the matter unresolved.

Why it matters

The property owner at 708 Weldwood Road is seeking a variance to keep a fence that exceeds the town's six-foot height limit, a request that remains pending after a deadlocked commission vote.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

TOWN OF JUPITER PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FINAL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 10,2024 7:00 P.M.

CALL TO ORDER:

Chair Kevin Kirn called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.

ATTENDANCE:

Chair Kevin Kirn; Vice Chair Richard Dunning; Comm. Beth Kelso; Comm. Karen Vinson; Comm. Dan Guisinger; and Comm. Cynthia Blum 2nd Alternate (voting member); John Sickler, Director of Planning & Zoning; Garret Watson, Principal Planner; Peter Meyer, Senior Planner; Thomas Baird, Esq., Town Attorney; and Michael Schneider, Secretary.

MINUTES:

The minutes from the August 13,2024 meeting will be considered at the next regular meeting.

SWEARING IN:

Secretary Michael Schneider conducted the swearing-in of witnesses for all quasi-judicial items on the agenda.

CITIZEN COMMENTS: None

REGULAR AGENDA:

A. OLD BUSINESS: None.

B. NEW BUSINESS:

1. 708 Weldwood Road - Variance request to Section 27-1326(b)(2) to increase the side yard fence height from six feet to six feet and eight inches, on a 0.22 $ \\pm $ acre property, located at 708 Weldwood Road. (PZ 24-6106)

Disclosures: Comm. Vinson disclosed that she went to the site, spoke to the homeowner, and spoke with staff. Vice Chair Dunning disclosed that he drove by the site and spoke to staff. Comm. Kelso disclosed that she walked the site and spoke to staff. Comms. Guisinger and Blum both disclosed they had driven by the site.

(Acting as the Zoning Board of Adjustments)

Commissioners asked questions of the Applicant and Staff:

Comm. Blum expressed that she struggled with how so many things don't meet the criteria laid out by staff and she doesn't understand how the contractor didn't mention getting a permit for the changes they made. Mr. Schreurs replied that there was no conversation of an amended permit or resubmitting. Comm. Blum asked if this was a professional fence installer and Mr. Frogner stated that the contractor was from a licensed fence company. Mr. Frogner mentioned the staff report noted bringing in fill but that Mr. Schreurs did not raise the grade but rather that he leveled a slight berm 3' from the sidewalk. Mr. Frogner stated that was the reason for installing the block so he could make a putting green that matched the level of the existing yard and pool.

Comm. Kelso asked why the section of open fence on the west side of the driveway was in a provided photo but now it is missing. Mr. Frogner stated that removing this panel was a decision by the Town Engineer as Mr. Schreurs didn't have a 45-degree visibility angle. Comm. Kelso asked why the fence wasn't planned to be flush with the gate or to move the gate further out. Mr. Schreurs replied that the five feet represents the limited access and landscape easement and that, per Town requirements, the gate is not allowed but the fence can be on the easement. Comm. Kelso asked if anything triggered in the applicants mind when the fence permit showed the fence at grade and the contractor said that an additional structure must be put in that wasn't on the original permit. Mr. Schreurs responded by saying he was told that the fence wouldn't be inspected so he built it the way it stands today and never thought he would need another permit. Comm. Kelso asked staff how finials and lanterns are accounted for in the 6' fence height limit. Mr. Watson replied that the height is based on the main panel and decorative features can extend beyond handle this in the same manner as other hearings. Vice Chair Dunning continued that he wishes something could be done, but if he were to approve this variance against staff recommendation, it would be setting a precedent and that he is not in favor considering the evidence presented.

Comm. Guisinger stated the permit showed the fence post being buried 3' in the ground with concrete. He asked if that occurred and if the fence was built sitting on top of the block or if the post was buried down in it. Mr. Schreurs noted that the fence post was in the ground through the concrete block and that every post has rebar and concrete and there was concrete poured into the cinder block. Comm. Guisinger then asked if it was correct that the applicant stated that he didn't realize he would need a permit to "put the block in and deviate from the permit." Mr. Schreurs replied that that was correct.

Comm. Vinson asked whether the homeowner or the fence company pulled the permit. Mr. Schreurs said that he did. Comm. Vinson asked why the fence company didn't do it as normally the company will pull its own permit. Mr. Schreurs stated that Roger Held told him an owner/builder permit would be "quick." Comm. Vinson asked staff if the language on the permit stated that the fence has to follow the contour of the property or if there were to be gaps at the bottom, and also if there were any exceptions in the rules about that in the permitting process. Mr. Watson replied that there weren't specific regulations. He continued that there were examples in the back of the applicant's justification statement about grades and how that's a situation where staff would apply reasonableness to it when the grade is not being artificially raised, but clarified that this case differs from that scenario. Comm. Vinson asked if that was because it was artificially raised and Mr. Watson replied "yes". Comm. Vinson asked if this situation has been going on for two years or only a couple months. Mr. Watson stated that the issue was noticed within two or three weeks of the construction

Chair Kirn referred to an architectural drawing on Page 6 showing a footer detail and he asked if that was included as part of the original permit, because it clearly shows the maximum height. Mr. Watson responded that the architectural drawing was not part of the original permit. Mr. Frogner confirmed that the architectural drawing was done after the fact, because the Town said there was block foundation under the fence and they spoke with their architect who said that the block is not structural foundation. Mr. Frogner stated that he went to Doug Koennicke, the Town Engineer, and Doug told him "You don't need that." He continued saying the document was kicked out, but he did submit it.

Public Comment: None

* * *

Deliberation by Commission Comm. Vinson stated that she is conflicted.

Comm. Guisinger stated he can't move past the fact that all seven provisions have not been satisfied and that he's inclined to deny the request for the variance.

Comm. Dunning stated that with six of the seven criteria not being met, he doesn't want to set a precedent that would not be in line with previous decisions.

Comm. Kelso stated that she would be for approving the permit, because it is a unique property located between the high school and aquatic center and receives a heavy flow of traffic several different times per day. She concluded by stating she is in favor of approving it with additional landscaping per staff's recommendation in the staff report.

Comm. Blum stated that the gap beneath the fence can be taken care of in several different ways.

Chair Kirn stated that the commission is required to vote based on the objective criteria and he wouldn't be able to support approval if 6 of the 7 criteria are not met.

Motion: Vice Chair Dunning moved to recommend denial of the variance request, seconded by Comm. Guisinger. Motion failed with a 3-3 vote. Comms. Kelso, Vinson and Blum dissented.

Discussion: Town Attorney Baird reminded the commission to make clear the basis of the motion on all proposed motions. He explained that the board of adjustments responsibility is to look at the facts, consider the presentations by the two parties, and to decide based on whether or not the criteria have been met.

Motion: Comm. Kelso moved to recommend approval of the variance request with a height of 6'8" from grade, based on the unique situation of being located between the pool and high school that causes abnormal residential traffic, seconded by Comm. Blum. Motion failed with a 3-3 vote. Comms. Kirn, Dunning, and Guisinger dissented.

2. Inlet Village Market - Small-scale planned unit development (SSPUD) and site plan application to construct a 3,433 square foot two-story building with retail and accessory residential, on a 0.15 $ \\pm $ acre property located at 1025 Love Street. (PZ 22-5252 and 5253)

Town Council consideration: October 15,2024

* * *

Disclosures: Comm. Blum and Comm. Guisinger disclosed that they drove around the property. Comm. Kelso disclosed that she walked the site, spoke with Peter Meyer, and spoke to the neighbor to the south of the property. Vice Chair Dunning and Comm. Vinson disclosed that they spoke with staff and drove by the property.

Applicant presentation: Zach Ciciera, Land Planner with Cotleur & Hearing presented to the commission. Rick Gonzales, Project Architect; Donaldson Hearing, Landscape Architect with Cotleur & Hearing; and Jim Burg, Property Owner, were also in attendance.

Staff presentation: Senior Planner, Peter Meyer, reviewed the staff report.

Commissioners asked questions of the Applicant and Staff:

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting (2024-09-10)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9930cbcaaeed220a3576e1686a3a12dd. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record