POLISCOPE

The public record

HUNTINGTONBEACH (ORANGE COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

1721113200 07/16/24

Tuesday, July 16, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

1721113200 07/16/24

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 128,935 stored characters

of my. Uh Thank. Wow Some kind of The meeting of the City council Public financing authority to order City clerk, MAY I have the roll call, please. Councilmember Mosier, Councilmember Bolton Mayor Pro Teim Burns, Mayor Vandermark, CouncilMember McKeon Councilmember Strickland is absent. Councilmember Calmick, I d like to announce that pursuant to resolution 2001-54 Councilmember Strickland s requested permission to be absent with no objections, the minute minutes will reflect permission was granted. Also pursuant to charter section 309, our City attorney Michael Gates has requested permission to be absent tonight and sitting in the meeting his, in his place as senior deputy City Attorney Connor Highland. Thank you. City councilmember comments, would anyone like to make a comment? Councilmember Calmic Uh, thank you, Mayor. Um. So, uh, I honestly wish I wasn t here tonight, um, I am contracted covid, uh, like a week and a half ago, which was the reason I wasn t at the meeting on Monday, um, we d actually had a vacation scheduled, but um. Fortunately, I guess that got canceled uh on Wednesday, um, at about 6 o clock in the morning, uh, I was woken up by my son, uh, thrashing against this crib as he was having a febrile seizure. Um, we had to call 911 and um our friends at the fire department arrived, and I like to thank uh the crew of Huntington Engine 42, Captain Kevin Shanahan, acting engineer Jeffrey Nair, firefighter paramedic Scott Styles firefighter paramedic Seth Adams, ambulance operator Aaron Lewis, and ambulance. Operator David McCarter, uh, for coming and helping my son and my wife to a certain extent on getting them to chalk in a very efficient manner and making sure that uh my son was ok and he came home that that afternoon and uh I d like to thank uh Captain Eric Blaska for going to pick my wife and son up at the hospital because I was at home in quarantine with covid, um, and we re unable to go get him, um, or get them so I d like to thank again, um, from the bottom of my heart our uh our friends and family here at the fire department and uh all of our ems. Staff for that so thank you so much. Thank you. Councilmember Bolton. Thank you. So the people do not yield their sovereignty to the bodies that serve them. That s a quote that I think many folks in this room could agree with. Uh, the people insist on remaining informed to retain control of the legislative bodies that they have created. These two sentences are in the introduction of the Brown Act, the state s government transparency law, government transparency flows from the same values, the people sovereignty and local control. Uh, that are often cited uh to justify the importance of charter cities and home rule. Imagine that. I hope the City government will be consistent in its regard for the values of the people s sovereignty and local control. Thank you. Go ahead. Thank you. I want to begin by acknowledging the terrible events that took place over the past weekend. And to reinstate that political violence has no place in our society. And it is never the answer to our differences. My heart goes out to all of the victims and their families during this very difficult time. Our calls for unity. Must be sincere. And rooted in a shared commitment to truth and understanding. It is only through honest dialogue and a collective effort to address the root causes of violence and division that we can hope to build a more united and compassionate society. This means implementing concrete actions and policies that foster genuine community engagement and bridge building. One such effort was our now defunct community cafe. Which sought to bring neighbors from all parts of our community together in conversation to build understanding and connections. Unfortunately, the successful initiative was canceled by the current council majority representing a missed opportunity to promote and work toward the very unity we so desperately need. Additionally, the decades old human relations Committee and formerly the Human Relations Task Force, whose vision was for Huntington Beach to be a community where all people feel respected, valued, and free from discrimination and violence was also dissolved by this council majority. This committee s mission was to inspire and promote mutual understanding, respect, safety, and the well-being of all in our community through education and engagement. Honest calls to action include reinstating programs like the community cafe and the Human Relations Committee and committing to policies that address the underlying issues of hate and division. We must go beyond words and take tangible steps to create a safer and more inclusive community for all. Thank you. Yeah ok, good Councilor Mary McCann. Thanks, Mayor. I just want to make some comments on the air show. I to update the community, so the actions of the, the previous council majority. Actually led to the litigation of the air show. Um, did you know that they had over 10 months to find an amicable solution in order to prevent litigation and refuse to even meet with the applicant. Did you know that there was even a meeting set up with the applicant and then that, then this that uh acting City manager along with members of the City council and the City participants actually no show to that meeting. They could have put their personal differences aside and shown leadership to find an amicable solution, concessions, etc. For the benefit of both parties. But instead decided to not even meet after several attempts by the applicant. Was this because of personal animosity, politics, poor business acumen, incompetence, we MAY never know. This is another mess and not that we had to untie from the previous City council. Because of the lack of leadership animosity and desire to find an amicable solution to avoid litigation. The air show is not coming back unless the settlement was reached. It was over, it was finished. The air show creates $120 million economic impact our local economy over three non-summer days. If you have been questioning the economic impact report by destination analysts, but they re one of the top firms to perform economic impact reports for several large events and companies like the Byron Nelson pja, the nba nba All-Star game, the la Marathon, the Firestone Grand Prix, Lauder and Life Festival, and a 2018 us Open is surfing, amongst others. People have disputed the report that the air show brings in the reported 3. $3.7 million to our local economy in tax revenue, but the implant method used in economic impact report is also used by several other large events and companies like and it is the global standard. The Johnway Airport uses it every year for their annual economic impact report, and Boeing also uses implant for estimated economic impact reports for development, like I don t know a future manufacturing plant. To say the air show doesn t bring in money to our local economy or is a non-zero amount is absurd. If people can t agree that the number is 3.75 million. I think it s safe to say that we can all agree that the air show brings in at least $1000 dollars in tax revenue. In 2022 and 2023, the City brought in $53 million in sales tax revenue, which is slightly over $1 million per week. The City also brought in 14.4 million in hotel tot tax revenue are roughly $300,000 per week for a total of $1.3 million in sales tax and tot per week. The air show, of course, contributed to that 1.3, and every retail business owner I ve spoken to from restaurants to sandwich shops to liquor stores, all say the air show weekend is their biggest weekend of the year by far. And it s not even close. They all stated that their business is actually increased at least 25% during the air show. With all that, it s safe to say that our show at least brings in $1,000,000 in tax revenue over three non-summer days. If the air show is here for 30 years, bringing in at least $1000 per year with a $4.9 million settlement amount. Yes, 4.9%, not 7 million. That s a 500% return on our investment. Most people get excited about a double digit roi, let alone a 5. 100% return. The $4.9 million in damages we pay is even spread out over 6 years, which still allows the economic impact to to to the City to be a net positive. The air show also brings an ancillary ancillary economic benefits with global attraction, it brings in over 700,000 visitors, 86% of which said they will return to the City, which means more economic impact from the money they spend. Other large scale events have seen how successful the air show has been on City Beach and I also want a part of that. Darker Ways was a huge success. And we are currently working with other large events on City Beach. This is our premier event and also the premier event on the west coast, which brings an immeasurable amounts of free marketing that puts Huntington Beach on the world stage. The free market that springs to City is massive. I understand the heartburn regarding the concessions provided in order to reach a settlement, but cities provide concessions to large scale events all the time because of the large economic impact these larger events create. Most cities often offer in-kind support in the form of ins infrastructure improvements, traffic management, public safety, and other public services for the large scale events. Kalmick Conon International, San Diego Invests in Public Safety, traffic Management, infrastructure, America s Cup in the City of San Francisco. They invest in uh waterfront improvements. They spend millions on upgrading peers, enhancing public. Spaces, improving transportation, Coachella, the Rose Bowl, the Rose Parade. They, they invest heavily in hosting the n Rose Bowl game and a tournament of roses. They allocate funds for security, traffic control, public services, the la Marathon, the City of la spends more than 500,000 controlled traffic, Clod streets, patrol the route, and also the Department of Water, uh chips in another $12,112,000 a year. And Australia, the Gold Coast Air Show, that City is paying $1.7 million per year for 5 years plus they are covering $500,000 in public safety costs. It was so. Successful that that City in Australia has committed another 700,000 a year to continue to grow the event. These events bring economic impact to these cities, otherwise the cities wouldn t do it. We also passed gate fees last month for each ticket sold At-Large events that will help offset public safety costs. The settlement is unique, and that is not just an outflow of money, but rather allows us to recoup our damages by the income it will bring into the City over multiple years and commits this premiere event to the, to be continue to be held in our City for years to come. These concession. Are a baseline, and there will be opportunities to work with the applicant to create more beneficial terms for both the City and the air show. It s easy to play Monday morning quarterback and nitpick the settlement, but this is the danger of politicizing lawsuit settlements because not everyone is operating with all the facts and variables that led to this decision. Navigating litigation and legal settlements is one of the hardest jobs we have to do as City council members as we have to weigh the risks and the cost benefit analysis in order to make a decision that is in the. Best interests of the City and the taxpayers. If we politicize every lawsuit, we would significantly damage the city negotiating position and thereby damage our ability to be successful in the many lawsuits a City has to deal with. Every council member up here was involved in the many closed door meetings during the various rounds of settlement negotiations and to say so, otherwise it s patently false. Again, if true leadership, business acumen, and prudent decision making was exercised by the previous City council majority. This lawsuit would have been prevented. Thank you. Ok, moving on to supplemental communications. Do we have any supplemental communications for this portion? Yes, we do, Mayor. We received 4 email communications regarding the short term rental program update. Public comments pertaining to Study Session, do we have anyone signed up to speak? Yeah, we have 7 signed up to speak. I m gonna go ahead and call everyone s name. Catherine Levisur. Jean Young. Katie I or I, I m sorry if I said that wrong. Gregory Kelly. Terry Hudgins. Phil Larson. At this time, the City council will receive comments from members of the public regarding any topic including items on the Study Session agenda individuals wishing to provide a comment on items MAY do so in person by filling out a request to speak form and delivering it to the City clerk. All speakers are encouraged but not required to identify themselves by name. Each speaker MAY have up to 3 minutes unless the volume of speakers warrants reducing the time allowance. Please note that the Brown Act does not allow discussion or action on topics that are not on the agenda members of the public who would like to speak. Directly with a council member on an item not on the agenda MAY consider scheduling an appointment by contacting the City council s administrative assistant at 714-536-5553 or emailing the entire City council at City.Council at Surf City-hb.Org. For speaker, go ahead. Good afternoon, Mayor Vander Mark and council members. My name is Catherine Leviso. I am a. Honey to Beach resident since 1999. I ve rented my home on Airbnb since 2015 and I have been passionately vocal. Uh, advocating for tax and regulated short term rentals in Huntington Beach and Sunset Beach for the last 7 years. I ve been permitted to operate a short term rental since the existing program rolled out in 2021 and I m currently in the process of renewing my str permit for the 3rd time. Which is almost like applying for my initial permit. It s that arduous. I m also the point of contact for Huntington Beach Short-term Rental Alliance and a volunteer Airbnb community leader for Orange County. The, um, this, these roles put me in front of a lot of hosts. The feedback I get from hosts in Huntington Beach and my own personal experience in applying for an str permit is so frustrating that it leaves many hosts angry at the City for making the permit process so difficult. It can t be good for staff either. If I was greeting the City. And this is hard because I m always trying to be positive, but if I was grading the City right now for the current short-term rental program I give the City a d minus. That is bad. Um, there are many opportunities for automation in the permit process from collection and remittance of tot and TBed to, um, applying for the permit, um, the City doesn t even send out reminder notices to renew our permits, which leaves us all in fear. That we re gonna lose the opportunity to renew our permits. We get a reminder for to pay the, the, get the business license. We get a reminder to, to pay our tot and t bed, but we don t get a reminder to renew our permits, and I know someone in Sunset who lost their ability to short term rent because their permit expired. So like by the time you get your permit, like a few short months later, you have to go through the whole thing again. It s, it s bad. It s really bad. So the last thing I want to say is, uh, that that s on the Study Session to concentrate unhosted short term rentals in the downtown area. I don t think that that s smart. I think the short term renals should be dispersed through the City so that, you know, it just, it just spreads out. It s not all concentrated in one area, allow all the City to participate in the tourism economy. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Next speaker, Hi, my name is Jean Young, and I m actually not from Huntington. I m from Bixby Knowles section of Long Beach, but Long Beach recently, 4 years ago, uh, went through an ordinance development process for short term rentals, um, i also represent Long Beach hosts in a hosting club we have in Long Beach with close to 400 members now. So I m really encouraged that Huntington Beach is studying and looking at. The short term rental program. Um, I feel that in looking at your presentation and had many valuable insights, but, um, the, the proposed cap of 200 unhosted permits is arbitrary and it doesn t really reflect the dynamic nature of the housing market, I think. Um, when Lisa Wise consultants, um, worked with the City and did a lot of public meetings and workshops and hearings on short term rentals they had suggested that that number be tied to a percentage of housing stock, whether it s you decide it 0.5% or 0.75 or 1%. So that would give you a little bit more room for flexibility, for flux with the Olympics in 2028 and the idea that you MAY. Captures some water sports, um, and tourism as a result of that. Um, I also feel that short term rentals should be dispersed throughout Huntington as they are in Long Beach. Now we had one small section that recently opted out, um, involving just actually 3 properties in that area, but, but, um, you can have hosted and unhosted, and there is a cap of 800 unhosted in Long Beach, but in various sections of Long Beach, so it they re not just concentrated. In the coastal zones or in the downtown area, and I think that s good because it allows small host operators, the opportunity to engage in that business and it brings a multiplier effect to their neighborhood where they have little extra money for property taxes for upkeep for their property to maintain their property and then they are able to spend that if they go to a local restaurant, the restaurant. Owner is able to give their child piano lessons, let s say, and then, uh, you know, on, onward and onward, the money, it creates an infusion of money in the local economy, so I don t think that should be focused or concentrated in just 11 or two, sections of Huntington, but I would recommend that it be spread throughout the City. And then I would encourage you to have a voluntary collection agreement. With all online travel agencies, um, so that the collection of tot or the transient occupancy tax could be seamless. Next speaker. Hi, I m Katie. I m a 17 year resident of Huntington Beach, and I also have an active str permit. I m here tonight, um, I m happy to see that you guys are talking about short term rentals and possibly the expansion of short-term rentals. I am in favor of expansion of short-term rentals. I think we have a really low number here in Huntington Beach, around 200. Uh, we are hosted and I think we are in the minority that are actually hosted short term rental. Uh, I m requesting tonight, as you guys talk about the. Expansion or possible expansion of the ordinance to consider adding adding 80 years, um, to the ordinance. When the ordinance was passed back in JANUARY of 2021, there was very few ADUs built at the time. I think a lot of that had to do with covid, uh, during covid, the City of Huntington Beach shut down and planning permits were really hard to get, so I think there was a backlog. I think since then, yes, you ve seen some ADUs built in the City. Um, I don t know what the number would be if people are even interested in a short term rental, but I ll tell for my property currently I can rent out my main house and live in my adu and have 8 guests. 8 guests, 8 cars, 8 trash noise, all of that kind of stuff. I live in a quiet neighborhood in the non-coastal zone. And I think a better approach for my neighborhood would be to rent out my 8du and live in my main house, still keeping it hosted. I m a fan of it being hosted in the non-coastal zone. I think a cap is good. Putting a cap on short-term rentals, um, raising the cap. There s no cap now but raising it and capping it probably would be something good for the City to look at. Um, and I m just looking, thinking that we need to think outside the box. You all are talking about large events the City hosts. The City hosts a ton of large events. We only have 200 short-term rentals, which means if the hotels are full, those short term rentals are full, people are going to Costa Mesa, Laguna Beach, and elsewhere and giving their tot tax there instead of bringing it to hb. I think that just like, um, Huntington Beach doesn t want Sacramento how to tell us how to do our business and how to run our City. I think the same is true in the neighborhoods. Let Owners decide what property if I have two structures on my property, let homeowners decide what is best for my community and my neighborhood, and I appreciate your time and thank you for the consideration. Thank you. Next speaker. Hello, my name is uh Greg Kelly. I m a resident of Huntington Beach. I have a uh hosted, um, str near Beach and Adams. Um, I want to address the importance actually of, uh, having the, uh, Short term rentals because, uh, as you probably know, most, the average American can t stay at the h at the Hilton, or say, which run around $500 a night. Our short term rentals allow the middle class people to be able to stay in Huntington Beach. Sure. There s another, there s other hotels that can stay back at like, uh. Was the Huntington Suites, the Best Western, the Starlight Inn, which aren t really that nice of hotels at all before you get to nicer hotels, you ve got to be 5 miles away from the beach. So I feel we do actually fit a service that, uh, uh, a niche that is actually not addressed. If we didn t have short term rentals. You would have a large percentage of people that would want to go to a beach community and go somewhere else. Um, one other thing I want to address is, um, the taxes, uh, approximately, I assume we have around 200, um, short-term rentals. That means you have 200 people submitting 200 checks 4 times a year. That s about 800 different transactions in other cities, Airbnb and Verbo, they allow Airbnb and Verbo to collect. Taxes for the host and you would get 4 checks a year. One from Airbnb, one from Verbo 4 times a year. You wouldn t have to do and it s you would have a computerized list, you would have 11 company actually running it, and that s all I have to say. Thank you. Next speaker. My name is Phil Larson. I m currently renewing my str permit. Uh, since I started doing, uh, short term rentals in Huntington Beach. It s allowed me to retire with and pay my bills without having to use my retirement money. So a big plus for me and also I ve had people from all over the world before the pandemic come to my place to stay, which is a house, um, and it s, it offers something that hotels don t, which is everything keep all the kids together in one place, I d have to get 2 or 3 different rooms on top of which it s much, much, much more affordable for them. So it s been great for my guests also during uh covid, then I had uh the international traffic stopped and then I had people from California all over California coming. Same thing with families and they all express the same thing. It s like the perfect solution for them. To come and stay as a family affordably. So I also agree. With what Catherine was saying about, uh, it being very complicated process and to get the permit and to renew it so as I said I m in the process of renewing now so if that could be streamlined that d be great. Same thing with the tax situation. I would rather you guys get it without me having to send it like automatically. I think that would be great also. I d like the option to be able to do unhosted as well as hosted. I ve never had a single complaint of any kind since I started doing STRs and I think that that s because I m very carefully selecting what people that I ll let come and keeping an eye on uh what they re doing. So everything s worked out really well for everybody so far. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Yep, hi there. I m Terry Hudgins from Huntington Beach, and I ve gone through the uh the updated study, uh, that s going to be discussed or presented or what have you, um. Couple of comments here, uh, from the standpoint of the complaints. And there s a table. There s no page numbers here, but the complaint detail page 7, at least the way I ve numbered them shows just a significant uh Difference between unhosted and hosted properties that are part of this program and that unhosted properties have less. Less problems, less complaints, less everything associated with their management. So hosted properties and all the rules and all the regulations and all of the requirements are not buying peace of mind. Peace of mind or a performance index or indicator that it s getting us anything. It s The unhosted properties are doing better by the numbers here. Secondly, with regards to the numbers, I think we need a Uh, a denominator to put these incidents in perspective. These incidents on page 7 cover 2.5 years. 2.5 years in the worst category is for a a home, a hosted property with no one on site. That s the, that s 105 incidents over 3,,,, 2.5 years now I think a better indicator of what s going on here is if we took those numbers and put it in a denominator. With a decent denominator in there that s a complaints per 1000 room nights. Or what, how many nights are we seen actually rented by the vrba vrbo, uh, and, and the other entities in here because that s available to us. You have a consultant that we re paying for right now called uh I don t know gob something or other, and they re performing some kind of service. That I m not sure what service that is, but they re supposedly performing a service for us. Well, there s gotta be a better measurement. Of the incidents per something. I mean, I can go to the hotel, you can go to Hilton, Hyatt, and Passa, and you can get room nights. You can get how many incidents per room night and that s a true measure of the turnover of the people that are going through the property. But we have no Uh, denominator here. Which I think I m done. Thank you. Next speaker. Hi, my name is Roger Bloom. I ve been in Huntington Beach resident since 1975. Full disclosure, I, uh, have a hosted, um, uh, short term rental, it s, uh, we have a, a townhouse that s, um, divided into two and on the other side of the wall, we have our, uh, short term rental. We also have a unit in the back over the garages this monthly. Um, My concern, and I don t know where you are in the process on this I just kind of got a notice about this meeting and I looked at the the staff stuff and, uh, my concern is that the City seems to be um moving full speed ahead with unhosted. Um, short term rentals, and that concerns me a lot. Um, again, full disclosure, I run a hosted rental and you can, people can say I m a hypocrite if you want, but, uh, my experience on our block is that my hosted rental has never been a problem for anybody. Half the people on the block don t even know it s there and there was an unhosted illegal unhosted rental on the block for quite a while and everybody knew it was there and everybody hated it. Now, um, that was an absentee owner up in Pasadena, ok, we had monstrous problems with parties of, uh, weekends,,, 545 cars would descend on the neighborhood, take up all our parking. Each one was like 1 or 2 people in it. They go in. This thing was advertised in the headline on Airbnb I was having a hot tub that was in the headline, hot tub Paradise or whatever it was, and they just partied all weekend. My children, my daughters. Bedrooms, uh, opened out into the backyard which, um, you know, and then there was a fence and then there was the backyard with the hot tub. Uh, they were exposed to, um, high volume conversations that would make a sailor blush. Ok, and um it was just a nightmare and it was a nightmare. I worked with City staff and code enforcement. They were very good, um, very cooperative with me, but they were very constrained on what they could do. But they were finally able to get it shut down after a very long time. I think that Um, allowing unhosted rentals, um, just for the sake of money. Uh, for the City is sacrificing residents quality of life, um, to solve the fiscal problems that you all got yourselves into and I don t know who did it. I don care who did it. Um, but what I m saying is, um, if you want to put it on the backs of the residents quality of life to raise some money. I have some ideas. Ok? You could put a fence around Huntington Central Park and charge everybody $5 to go in. You d make a ton of money. It might, you know, hurt the quality of life a little bit, but you d make a ton of money and you know the fence with the barbed wire on it, not too aesthetic, but hey, you d make some money you can charge, you could, um, institute a program of fireworks permits. Somebody could pay 100 bucks, they could shoot off any damn firework they wanted to any time, day or night. You know, it might help, it might hurt the quality of life a little bit, but City would be making some money. And here s the one that you know you guys really might want to go for, you could charge a uh vote fee for the members to vote. 2 That concludes public comments. Thank you. Moving on to study staff, please introduce your report. Good evening, Mayor and council members. My name is Jill Boss, Deputy. Director of Community development and I m here to provide an update regarding our short term rental program. As you MAY recall, City staff presented the last update about our short term rental program earlier this year in MARCH, a summary of the information presented includes that we have over 200 str permits issued citywide collected just under $1000 in tot in 2023. And since the program s inception, we have seen a decline of unpermitted STRs from over 860 in 2020 to 135 in 2023 as well as the decline in complaint calls. This update will provide additional information that was requested by council, including. Best practices presenting connections between complaints for noise and unhosted STRs and reporting on revenue potential. Although this map was shared with the council last time, it s reused as a reminder that of the 200 plus STRs permitted in the City, over half of the SDRs are within the coastal zone and downtown areas as shown by the dark blue heat circles. To highlight some of our current requirements. They include allowing an unlimited amount of hosted str citywide hosted being that the property owner resides on site, allowing unhosted in Sunset Beach, as per the mou agreement when Sunset Beach was annexed into the City and STRs were given a limited amount of time to get a permit by 2022. And any STRs would have to be hosted from here on out. Um, only one str per operator. We do have a $1000 fines for each confirmed violation, and there s a three strikes rule within a 12 month. Period. And then all listings must have a City issued str permit number. For best enforcement, best practices, many agencies that either permit short term rentals or prohibit them contract with a third party vendor. Staff has reached out to staff of other str programs and met with str vendors. The service is provided by the third-party vendors vary, first and foremost is monitoring where they track hundreds of rental listings, websites for unpermitted STRs and in some cases vendors will also send out compliance letters on behalf of the jurisdiction, notifying the host or owners. Of their illegal STRs. They offer around the clock support via phone and web as well as recording and documenting complaint calls and online portals for permitting registration tax collection and reporting. The two highlighted bullet points are services that are not currently provided by our current vendor and improvements to capitalize on, uh, moving forward with a potential new vendor. One of the services we use with our Govos vendor is monitoring as shared earlier, there has been an overall decline of unpermitted STRs. Though that number fluctuates throughout the year as rental listings tend to pop up in the summer or when the weather is good or during special events. One thing that I d like to highlight is that with or without the program unpermitted STRs are happening in the City and in other cities. So it s a matter of really deciding how to regulate these. Mm Um, this is just a visual snapshot of the unpermitted STRs as of NOVEMBER last year where the concentration is in the downtown area or coastal zone, but unpermitted STRs do pop up sporadically citywide. With regards to our current permit holders, we do receive some complaints with the top two categories being no owner on site and noise. And these numbers cover a 3-year span. In consideration of all the calls to code enforcement. These numbers are overall lower than other reported citywide issues. In total, we have about 156 violations documented over the three-year course of the program with concentrations near downtown and within the coastal zone. Though they do occur citywide. Since it was requested to provide connections between no owner on site and noise violations, the next two slides will visually map where these have been confirmed. Um, For the new owner on site, we had 36 reported and 14 of them were within the old town town lots or downtown coastal areas. For the noise violations, we had 26 reported and 12 of them were within the downtown areas. There are a variety of coastal cities that have short term rental programs in several cities that do not. The comparison chart shows that the restrictions and ordinance vary, and it s really up to the jurisdiction of how they want to regulate. Some restrictions include defining the types of rental units such as homestays are hosted, where the host or owner lives on site, primary where the host or owner lives on site for a majority of the council of the calendar year, but rents out the house for like 90 days or during the summer, non-primary whole host. Rental, which is similar to our unhosted definition. Other limits include locations such as restricting to certain residential zones, districts, coastal areas, applying a maximum cap of the number of STRs in a given area or a combination of both. Acknowledging that our current inventory of STRs are concentrated within the coastal zone, downtown rha Lotts and Sunset Beach, the following slides are provided to show the actual tot that was collected in 2023. The coastal zone as depicted here encompasses approximately 12,000 units and as of the end of last year, we had about 38 permitted STRs. Of that amount, 24 were active, meaning they reported at least 1 25% of tot and the City received over 157,000 in tot for an average annual. Uh, per unit of $6,291. In Sunset Beach, which encompasses approximately 650 units, 48 STRs were permitted as of last year and 34 had remitted tot payment for a combined total of $281,000 in an average per unit of 8200. 77. In the town law and an old town areas also known as, uh, the state, the state and City streets that were numbered streets. Uh, we have approximately 5790 units. Uh, we permitted 54 STRs and and 37 were active and paid a total of $209,000 in tot for an average of 56, 54. This slide is a summary of the actual tot revenue from 2023 within the three areas and charts the differences. Considering that a majority of rentals are unhosted in Sunset Beach. Sunset Beach has the highest reported tot collected in 2023 and highest annual average. To note these three areas, coastal zones, Sunset Beach, and Old Town make up 66% of the 2023 actual revenue citywide. The row at the bottom provides an estimate of the potential tot revenue using the actual average amounts from the first row. So for example, if the program is expanded to allow, let s say 200 unhosted STRs. Based on the lowest average tot of $5600 and the town lot areas and the highest average of 8200 in Sunset Beach. The estimated tot revenue is within the range of 1.1 million to $1.6 million. Scenario is presented to capture the amount of unpermitted STRs that we currently have in the City or, or how it ranges. This range of potential revenue estimates are conservative as these amounts are based on hosted and some unhosted STRs. If the program were expanded, the conversion of existing hosted STRs would also potentially increase revenue. As you MAY recognize from the data presented tonight, not all scr holders are actively reporting or remitting to address these deficiencies, we look at, we re looking at ways to update the program. Um, These are options that council could consider, enhancing the online portal, our current software vendor has some limitations in staff has met with other vendors that offer additional services that can improve our registration and tax remit process and create a user-friendly experience, active reporting. Um, offering enhancements that scrub and search, uh, listings and documenting them and following bookings and rental rates. Under this program, we can consider a use it or lose it. Policy requiring the SDRs must actually remit for a minimum time frame each year by applying a cap. It can control where unhosted rental units can occur. And in tandem with the use it or lose it policy, ensure that permit holders must remit tot or their permits will be canceled or not renewed. This option could essentially reward the good operators and sort out the bad operators. Um, introducing a waitlist and an auditing components or controls to help ensure compliance and refine the program in steps. As part of this option, it MAY also involve annual evaluations of the overall program in addition to tot audits. With all it said, some of these options would involve an update or revision to our current ordinance and policies, including adding language regarding caps on total number of permits, any locational restrictions, allowances for unhosted STRs and associated enforcement requirements on tot activity and potential requirements for noise monitoring devices within the STRs or exterior surveillance cameras. This concludes staff s presentation. I m available for questions and then I also have here Jimmy, our code enforcement Manager, Collin, our treasury Manager and Steve, uh, our deputy Director of Community development as well as Joyce Sachs and Alisa Backstrom for the city s treasurer s office. Thank you. Thank you. Um, do any council members have questions? Councilmember Calmick, thank you. Um, thank you, Steph, for bringing this back with some recommendations and some updates. Um, I really appreciate all of that. Um. And a couple of initial questions are when you first apply for your str permit, you get 2 years, right, for the price of 1? That s correct. Ok, so you, you only have to renew after going into your 3rd year, effectively? Ok. Um, you know, I really, the policy that we brought forward back in 2021 was a very conservative incremental approach, and I think a lot of the strategy here is trying to balance property rights with um uh rent the rental market and taking uh attainable units off, off the market, and that was one of the things I don t want to do is to take. Rental units or for sale units that, um, uh, farther away from kind of where something would be considered affordable or attainable, um, off the market and trying to get to an sdr, um, and that s been kind of the policy shift here. I think the rest of this, the policy discussion has been short-term vacation rentals have been a part of Huntington Beach forever, um, and how do we best capture and regulate uh existing um business use, I would say. Um, and I think the initial policy. Uh, I think has shown as successful in bringing down the total number of um Of unpermitted, um. STRs and I think a lot of this is to Was to take a look at well what are we, what cats are we chasing still, and it seems like a majority of a very high threshold to prove are folks that are operating unhosted str and I spoke with uh over the last couple of years, spoken with a lot of residents that have, um, either bad actors or good actors in their neighborhood and the bad actors for the unhosted one is they ll have notes inside that that if the City knocks on your door, tell them that I m, you know, at the grocery store or tell them that Bob lives, you know, Bob s here, or tell them you re Bob, um, and you re the host and We d have no physical description of the permit or a picture of the person on the permit to know whether or not um that s not true. And so I think obviously some enforcement mechanism there, but I think the idea of a cap is really important here if we were to move forward, uh, baby steps, I think are really important here that there s nothing to say, you know, the Olympics is. 4 years out, um, that we can t come back next year and evaluate if we make some small changes um going forward that we can then expand that or contract that, um, we could, you know, lower the cap after that and and basically randomly not renew 100 permits, I m assuming, um, but I know that the coastal zone is going to be, is gonna be forthcoming and we need to get I think ahead of that. And I think bringing folks that are operating. That still want to operate an str unhosted and still are, even though we have the regulation are taking the enormous amount of code enforcement time to try to manage that. So why not bring again the overall policy was to try to bring folks that are doing something that has happened in Huntington Beach forever and ever, into the fold so that we can tax and regulate them in a better manner. Um, there was a, uh, uh, when that, um, speaker that asked a question about um. Changing our moratorium on using ADUs for STRs, um, in my understanding that that s actually not legal under state law anymore? Could staff comment on that? That correct, uh, adu state law does require that ADUs be rented for periods longer than 30 days. So since STRs are essentially defined as Rentals less than 30 days, it would disqualify, and that is does that grandfather an existing? 8DUs that have been issued permits or is that not retroactive so you cannot rent out an adu even if it was, you know, 100 or 50 years old now as a str. Well, the way that we ve been applying it is there is some grandfathering in prior to that, the date that that was in in effect. So 2020 was when that legislation came the state law came into effect in 2020 that particular requirement. Ok So Bernards went into effect in 2021. Yeah, our ordinance went into effect in early 2021. The state law, I think, passed in 2020, went into effect early 2021, so essentially when they kind of coincided so when our law when when our ordinance went to an effect for short term rentals, it was applied to essentially all ADUs that were built 2020 and earlier so. Alright, and so the state law didn grandfathered in everybody that was already there. Ok, they already had permits, got it. Um, so yeah, I think, um, I, I think that this is, I think this is a good baby step forward. I think all the staff recommendations are, are worth exploring and bringing back uh with an ordinance, um, I think having exploring a third party to handle taxes and auditing and things like that are are going to be really important to streamline the process to make sure we re actually getting our tot, um, and a room night metric, I think one of the speakers brought that up. I think some of this data is a little hard to consume to find. Correlative data and I think understanding, you know, ok, there s 100 violation, 105 violations over 3 years, but I think the correct metric is over how many room nights or how many stays, stay nights, um, is that number of cud because 105 complaints over. Uh,, 22 years,,, 2.5 years is not a lot of complaints, um, and I think that that was really the metric of doing baby steps as we move forward here, um, and obviously we don t want to change communities and we don t want to do this, but we want to definitely balance um. Um, we want to, you know, balance property rights here that folks own these properties and are, are, you know, want to be able to exercise their rights, buffers would have been the only thing I d like to see a little bit more information on potentially. Uh, I know that we d kind of discussed that potentially at the last meeting on how to make sure we don t end up with. Three unhosted STRs right next to each other. Um, and so that would be, you know, so that somebody doesn t, you know, yeah, you ve got a hotel row row, so I d be interested to see what best practices are for buffers for other cities, um, if this were to come back, so that s all I have. Thank you. Any, uh, anyone else? Councilmember Bolton. So thanks to the staff for all of the work that you ve done and you ve actually answered a couple of the questions that I already have. I did want to ask about um automated collection of taxes, which um I think a couple of folks raised. Had you looked into that and do you have a sense for how efficient that would be if we adopted that? We did look at that. We ve also spoken to some cities that do implement that. There s pros and cons to everything, right? So, um, the con would be and what we ve heard from the Airbnb and vrbo as well is that when they do collect that, they only provide that information in a lump list. We re not able to discern who in specific individual properties are actually remitting. We just get the lump amount, um, so it, but it is seamless because. It just goes through the platform and then on top of that, you d also have to make sure you re also collecting those that don t use those platforms. So there would be still some manual ribbons for, um, the permit holders. Ok, that s very helpful. Thank you. Councilmemb Moser, thank you. Most of my questions and thoughts have kind of already been mentioned by the previous two council members. Um, one of the, um, owners spoke earlier, um, with regards to not getting reminder notices, um, but getting reminders kind of about other things. Can you speak to that? We do send out notices through our system. My understanding is that they, they go out 30 days before it expires as well as 15 days before it expires. So the only flaw I could see is if the email is incorrect because we do have individuals renewing their permits. So to a certain degree, it s working for several, uh, permit holders. So I think we would need to isolate the particular situation and see and look into that directly. And our, our reminders are all via email. That s correct. Ok. I think that the important thing is to make sure um that we are able to enforce, and I know, uh, Jimmy has been working hard to do that, um, and also to audit. So if we are going to proceed with any expansion or even not, um, that I would want to make sure that whoever is, um, currently or is expanding into this that we are able to, um, Enforce and that we are always responsive. Um, you know, I have spoken to residents who have had, you know, I think, particular residents who have had complaints over time, and my recommendation as always, um, because oftentimes it s on the weekend when I think we have fewer resources, um, is to keep complaining, basically, so that there s documentation, um, but we of course would want people not to have to continue to complain, but hopefully get that quick response. So, um, anything that we can do to make things, um. Better enforcement, um, more efficiencies, um, you know, making sure that we re auditing, I think is important. Um, also what was mentioned, um, is if we do look at doing this caps are I think are important. Um, I, it was interesting about the uh the state law, um, because I didn t realize that with regards to the ADUs. So thank you for letting us know about that. And then finally, I think it is important for everything that we do that the one gentleman mentioned, um, of having that denominator, having the ability to really, um, you know, Understand the metric instead of just like a number and even tying it to things that s helpful, um, to be providing better measures. So, um, that s all I have for now. Thank you. Council member um McKeon. Thank you staff for uh putting all this together and all the research, uh, for me this is a very, very sensitive to this as it relates to quality of life, um, incidents and disturbances. So Jimmy, can you kind of walk through For me, if I was gonna consider any kind of expansion, I would like to understand um how code enforcement could have like a rapid response team. When there is a quality of life disturbance, noise, parking, so could you kind of walk the community through if we were to expand this, what that would look like and then maybe touch on um how like a lion s share of your reporting is for currently, uh, non-hosted units and maybe they ll be if we went um allow non-hosted units that might free up your time for these, you know, rapid response. Can you kind of walk through those details? Uh, yes, absolutely be happy to, um, we are a 7 day operation and code enforcement. So every time we get a complaint, we do a follow up on the complaint, either the same day or the very next day, um. In terms of the current situation where there s a noise complaint, let s say it s at 2 o clock in the morning. Uh, we do have the hotline set up. People can call that number and they can be connected to the live operator. There s a script of how we created this, this response where the operator will contact the owner, have the owner respond within one hour to correct the noise issue, we get that report the very next day and we do follow up on that. If the operator cannot get a hold of the designated owner. And the script will promptly operator to contact hbpd non-emergency number to have patrol respond and the officers will respond to that situation, and we do follow up and get the reports the very next day as well, uh, based on police response. What s, I mean, what do you think s the fastest you could? Get to the get to the scene if there was a complaint like that. Um, we, we do not work uh late evenings or midnight to 6 o clock, but I would say uh if if the event is occurring, I d say 10 P.M. We can respond to it by the very next morning, early morning, um, and we ll get those reports to follow up on. I mean like if there s a disturbance and. Noise, etc. I mean, how quickly it could I guess the City address that or get to that property to try to remedy the situation like could the police get there within 30 minutes? I mean, you guys, that s why I m talking about like a rapid response is if there s more STRs in the community in the City, and now it s creating quality of life disturbances. I would like to understand how what a rapper response would look like if someone is complaining because their neighbor, you know, there s noise complaints or it s disturbing their quality of life. How quickly could the City get to that property to address that situation, do you think? Captain Garcia could take that one. Yeah, after I was once the we get the call we can respond within a few minutes depending on the call volume obviously but something at 2 in the morning we can respond within 5 to 10 minutes. And we ll take care of the problem at that time um whether we get information or give them a first response if it s a party call and then I m working with Jimmy, they will get notified that we responded as well and then they can follow up the next day. I guess how could the community. No, the non-emergency number to call, right? So it s not tying up like 911 and I mean I m, I trying to kind of war game out potential pitfalls if I m a neighbor and this happens in my, in my neighborhood, you know, who do I call, how quickly it can it be resolved, even if it s not an emergency number, it will still place the call on our computer for officers to respond. I meant more like an education in the community of like what, what is a non-emergency number to call, right? So they know, I mean, I, you know, I know that s probably hard to get out to everybody, but just something to thinking. I m just Realistically trying to envision problems that will occur if we raise the cap and then we go to pursue potentially non-hosted. Obviously there s gonna be more and I m very sensitive to the quality of life issues that could occur. So I just want to understand how what a rapid response would would look like to remedy that situation. In Castle McKean, if I MAY just add to that. So right now, um, the subject property they have to notify the neighbors every year with a renewal permit. So the requirements are uh two neighbors to the left, 2 neighbors to the right, 3 directly in front of the subject property and 3 behind them. Each and every time they do their renewal, they have to submit a letter to the neighbors. We asked for a copy of that certified mail. On that letter, there s a phone number for code enforcement with instructions what they can do to report noise violations. Um, they just Call the number, the hotline, push option 3 for the 24/7 operator, and then we get those reports the very next day as well just to, to respond to that. Um, so the neighbors are well aware, uh, each and every year when the permits renewed, uh, they get that same information, that same letter with a phone number on how to reach and file a complaint. Perfect. What about um Like parking, like how would you, are there any kind of parking requirements with the permits, the str permits, I mean, are, are guests allowed a certain number of cars is that a detail currently that exists? The operator has to provide a parking plan to the City when they submit an application for a permit, um, uh, it s typically on-site parking on the, on the driveway that s required. Ok, so enforcing that, I would imagine the same thing, right? Like if a neighbors complaining about multiple cars I could obviously be an enforcement mechanism. Yes, ok. You think that s tough to enforce? It depends on the nature of the parking violation, like what, that s what I m saying like if they re only allowed on-site parking where they re parking in the street. I m just envisioning again disturbing the quality of life. There s unhosted rental. The guests have 3 or 4 cars. They re chewing up parking on the street. They re not in the driveway. Like what, what happens in that situation? So that that s a little more complex. Yeah, I d like to look into that and then be able to get back to you with that one. Ok, that s good. Um, we talked about last time auditing, uh, where are we currently guys on the auditing which I know that s we re almost done, right? Because I think there was an issue with uh I don t know, whatever, a couple of months ago about, you know, self reporting and we re trying to do an audit to see. What s currently existing in our SDRs, has that been completed? Are you speaking of auditing the revenues or auditing the number of STRs. The latter, ladder and then also, yeah, like which ones aren t and so which are not, how many are not reporting and potentially like like lost revenue that we re not receiving right now if they were permitted, so kind of bring in those, those unpermitted out of the shadows, if you will. We are not currently going through the audit program, but with one of the vendors that or with one of the new vendors, if we select, they could help us, um, complete that auditing. Of existing permits as well as potentially the expansion of it. So we would need some assistance in that realm. And what about the, would the vendors be able to Scan, I guess the third party um Airbnb vrbo to see how many are non permitted like a legal STRs if we were to expand it, is that something that s easily obtainable where they can do a cross reference? Yes, based on the current demonstrations we received from the potential vendors, they are, they have the capability of doing that. Ok, cool. And then Lastly, um, Lastly, uh, I like the buffer idea and then for me like if we re gonna, when you guys bring this stuff back, I d be interested in exploring this, but only as a pilot program, so like a 12 month, uh, from whatever maybe later this year, whatever the expansion is, and then capture one full summer season and then come back and see what that looks like before we would agree to maybe make this more permanent. That s it. Ok, thank you for the report. Um, we are now going to reconvene the regular meeting of the City Council Public financing Authority, City clerk, MAY I have the roll call, please? Yes, Councilmember Moser. Here, Councilmember Bolton, Mayor Pro Tem Burns near Vandermark CouncilMember McKeon Councilmember Calm. I d like to, uh, report that pursuant to resolution 2001-54 Councilmember Strickland has requested permission and if no objections are received will be granted permission to be absent from tonight s meeting. Any objections? All right, and also our City attorney Michael Gates pursuant to Charter Section 309 has requested permission to be absent and in his place attending tonight is senior deputy City Attorney Connor Highland. Thank you. Tonight, uh, the Pledge of allegiance will be led by our Huntington Beach police captain Oscar Garcia. Please stand for the Tri allegiance. Ready, begin. I pledge allegiance. My life To the Yeah. Yeah. Our invocation will be delivered by our Huntington Beach Police and fire chaplain Bob Ewing. Would you please bell with me? Almighty GOD, we come into your presence with grateful hearts for this great nation and City in which we live and serve. Father, I thank you for this council who serves so faithfully the needs of our people. Grant them wisdom tonight as they make decisions that impact each of us. Thank you for City staff who aid in the decision making and the implementation of those decisions. Thank you for our public safety agencies, and I ask that you watch over and protect the men and women who serve so diligently. Father was less than 2 weeks ago that we gathered to celebrate our independence. What a great day it was as we honored and remembered the occasion of JULY 4th, 1776 and the subsequent years. Yet Father, by the end of that day, evil had reared its ugly head and brought sorrow and anguish into our City. And then our nation watched this past Saturday when evil once again struck. Father, I ask for comfort and healing for those who were impacted by those acts of lawlessness, including our fire and police. Members that showed up Eternal GOD whose perfect kingdom no sword is drawn, but the sword of righteousness. No strength known but the strength of love and peace. MAY you mightily spread your spirit that we MAY all live under the banner of that love and peace. MAY we in gentleness and love, check the hasty answer. Choke back the unkind word, and thus short circuits some of the bitterness and the unkindness is sometimes overwhelms us. I ask this of you, o GOD, who alone can give us the grace to so act. I thank you, Father, for your presence with us today. In your most holy name, Lord, I pray. Amen. Thank you. Announcement of supplemental communications. Do we have any supplemental communications? Yes, Mayor, for consent calendar item 9, a memo received from Lieutenant Toby Archer regarding a pricing adjustment to the agreement with all City Management services, Inc for crossing guard services. I suppose that will, um, um, The supplemental communication will adjust the recommended action. I ll reflect that in the record and also for ordinance for introduction, item 11 email communication received regarding the proposed amendment to the pipeline franchise agreement with Cardinal Pipeline lp. Thank you. Awards and presentations Chief Haberley, please proceed with the presentation. McCoy. I m here for Chief Haberle. It s my pleasure to introduce, uh, battalion Chief Doug Leach. He manages our junior Lifeguard program and he s gonna introduce the group. Thank you, council. I just wanted to briefly introduce some guests that are with us this evening. Um, this is the 2024 edition of our legacy Junior Life Art Exchange with New Zealand. Um, this exchange has been happening since about 1979. It s an opportunity for the youth of

IN-PERSON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION: Members of the public are welcome to attend City Council meetings in person. Alternate ways to view meetings live or on-demand include: livestreamed on HBTV Channel 3 (replayed on Wednesday at 10:00 a.m. and Thursday at 6:00 p.m.); live and archived meetings for on-demand viewing accessed from https://huntingtonbeach.legistar.com/calendar, https://bit.ly/SurfCityTV, or the City's YouTube Channel at https://www.youtube.com/cityofhb, or from any Roku, Fire TV or Apple device by downloading the Cablecast Screenweave App and searching for the City of Huntington Beach channel. PRESENTATION MATERIAL: Presentations/AV materials shall be submitted to staff no later than 9AM the day of the meeting to PublicPresentations@huntingtonbeachca.gov. Members of the audience and speakers shall not wear or display signs that obstruct the view of other audience members. Signs shall remain with the holder and shall not be placed in adjacent seats or in common areas. PUBLIC COMMENTS: Individuals wishing to provide a comment on agendized or non -agendized items including Study Session, Closed Session, and Public Hearing, may do so in person in the City Council Chambers by completing a Request to Speak form delivered to the City Clerk. Sign-ups to Request to Speak will begin in person 30 minutes prior to the start of Study Session, Closed Session, or Regular City Council Meeting, whichever comes first. Sign-ups will be accepted until the commencement of the public comment period. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION: Members of the public unable to personally participate in the meeting but interested in communicating with the City Council on agenda -related items are encouraged to submit a written (supplemental) communication to the Council via email at SupplementalComm@Surfcity-hb.org. Supplemental Communications are public record, and if received by 9:00 AM on the day of the meeting, will be distributed to the City Council prior to consideration of agenda-related items, posted to the City website, and announced, but not read, at the meeting. Communications received after the 9:00 AM deadline will be incorporated into the administrative record. Members of the public are also welcome to communicate with the City Council (and staff supporting Council) at City.Council@surfcity-hb.org. MEETING ASSISTANCE NOTICE: In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, services are available to members of our community who require special assistance to participate in public meetings. If you require special assistance, 48-hour prior notification will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements for an assisted listening device (ALD) for the hearing impaired, American Sign Language interpreters, a reader during the meeting and /or large print agendas. Please contact the City Clerk's Office at (714) 536-5227 for more information. AGENDA City Council/Public Financing Authority Tuesday, July 16, 2024 Study Session - 5:00 PM Council Chambers 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL GRACEY VAN DER MARK, Mayor PAT BURNS, Mayor Pro Tem RHONDA BOLTON, Councilmember DAN KALMICK, Councilmember CASEY McKEON, Councilmember NATALIE MOSER, Councilmember TONY STRICKLAND, Councilmember STAFF ERIC G. PARRA, Interim City Manager MICHAEL E. GATES, City Attorney ROBIN ESTANISLAU, City Clerk ALISA BACKSTROM, City Treasurer

AGENDA July 16, 2024City Council/Public Financing Authority 5:00 PM - COUNCIL CHAMBERS CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL Moser, Bolton, Burns, Van Der Mark, Strickland, McKeon, Kalmick CITY COUNCIL MEMBER COMMENTS (3-Minute Time Limit) The Mayor will facilitate a voluntary opportunity for members of the Huntington Beach City Council to individually make brief comments to the public. Please note that the Brown Act does not allow for lengthy comments, discussion, or action on topics that are not on the agenda. ANNOUNCEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATIONS PERTAINING TO STUDY SESSION ITEM(S) (Received After Agenda Distribution) PUBLIC COMMENTS PERTAINING TO STUDY SESSION ITEM(S) (3-Minute Time Limit) At this time, the City Council will receive comments from members of the public regarding any topic, including items on the Study Session and/or Closed Session agendas. Individuals wishing to provide a comment on item(s) may do so in person by filling out a Request to Speak form delivered to the City Clerk. All speakers are encouraged, but not required to identify themselves by name. Each speaker may have up to 3 minutes unless the volume of speakers warrants reducing the time allowance. Please note that the Brown Act does not allow discussion or action on topics that are not on the agenda. Members of the public who would like to speak directly with a Councilmember on an item not on the agenda may consider scheduling an appointment by contacting the City Council's Administrative Assistant at (714) 536-5553 or emailing the entire City Council at city.council@surfcity-hb.org. STUDY SESSION 24-4981. Short Term Rental (STR) Program Update 6:00 PM – COUNCIL CHAMBERS RECONVENE CITY COUNCIL/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY MEETING ROLL CALL Moser, Bolton, Burns, Van Der Mark, Strickland, McKeon, Kalmick PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE INVOCATION In permitting a nonsectarian invocation, the City does not intend to proselytize or advance any Page 1 of 5

AGENDA July 16, 2024City Council/Public Financing Authority faith or belief. Neither the City nor the City Council endorses any particular religious belief or form of invocation. 24-4962. Huntington Beach Police Chaplain Bob Ewing ANNOUNCEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATIONS (Received After Agenda Distribution) AWARDS AND PRESENTATIONS 24-5053. Chief Haberle to welcome the New Zealand Lifesaving Team followed by a special Haka performance to Council PUBLIC COMMENTS (3-Minute Time Limit) At this time, the City Council will receive comments from members of the public regarding any topic, including items on the open session agenda. Individuals wishing to provide a comment may do so in person by filling out a Request to Speak form delivered to the City Clerk. All speakers are encouraged, but not required to identify themselves by name. Each speaker may have up to 3 minutes unless the volume of speakers warrants reducing the time allowance. Please note that the Brown Act does not allow discussion or action on topics that are not on the agenda. Members of the public who would like to speak directly with a Councilmember on an item not on the agenda may consider scheduling an appointment by contacting the City Council's Administrative Assistant at (714) 536-5553 or emailing the entire City Council at city.council@surfcity-hb.org. While the City Council welcomes public involvement and supports and defends free speech, the City Council rejects comments from anyone that are discriminatory, defamatory or otherwise not protected free speech. Those comments will not inform nor be considered by the City Council and may be cause for the Mayor to interrupt the public speaker. Such public comments will not be consented to or otherwise adopted by the City Council in its discussions and findings for any matter tonight. COUNCIL COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT ANNOUNCEMENTS Councilmembers may make brief announcements on any appointments made to a board, committee, or commission. Councilmembers may not discuss or take any action on these announcements. Announcements are limited to 1 minute. AB 1234 REPORTING Per AB 1234 (Government Code Section 53232.3(d)) Councilmembers who attend a meeting, conference, or similar event at the expense of the City must provide a brief report of the meeting, conference, or similar event during the next regular City Council meeting. Reports are limited to 1 minute. OPENNESS IN NEGOTIATION DISCLOSURES Page 2 of 5

AGENDA July 16, 2024City Council/Public Financing Authority Councilmembers must publicly disclose any meetings or communications with City employee associations, related to the negotiations of labor agreements. Disclosures are limited to 1 minute and must be made by the next regular City Council Meeting. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT CONSENT CALENDAR (Items 4-9) City Clerk 24-4954. Approve and Adopt Minutes A) Approve and adopt the City Council/Public Financing Authority regular meeting minutes of July 2, 2024; and, B) Approve and adopt the City Council/Public Financing Authority special meeting minutes of July 8, 2024. Recommended Action: Police 24-4665. Approve and authorize the execution of a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Huntington Beach Police and Community Foundation (HBPCF) Approve and authorize the City Manager execute the "Memorandum of Understanding between the Huntington Beach Police and Community Foundation and the City of Huntington Beach.” Recommended Action: 24-4906. Approve and authorize execution of agreement with the City of Costa Mesa for Public Safety Helicopter Services Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the "Services Agreement for Public Safety Helicopter Support Between the City of Huntington Beach and the City of Costa Mesa.” Recommended Action: 24-4937. Approve and authorize execution of an agreement with the City of Irvine for Public Safety Helicopter Services Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the "Services Agreement for Public Safety Helicopter Support Between the City of Huntington Beach and the City of Irvine.” Recommended Action: 24-4918. Approve and authorize execution of an agreement with the City of Page 3 of 5

AGENDA July 16, 2024City Council/Public Financing Authority Newport Beach for Public Safety Helicopter Services Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the "Services Agreement for Public Safety Helicopter Support Between the City of Huntington Beach and the City of Newport Beach.” Recommended Action: 24-4929. Approve and authorize execution of a contract agreement with All City Management Services, Inc. (ACMS), for Crossing Guard Services Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute “Agreement Between the City of Huntington Beach and All City Management Services, Inc. for Crossing Guard Services” for a three-year term beginning on June 30, 2024. Recommended Action: ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS 24-42610. FY 2023-2027 Strategic Plan - Biannual Progress Update #2 Receive and file the FY 2023-2027 Strategic Plan - Biannual Progress Update #2. Recommended Action: ORDINANCES FOR INTRODUCTION 24-47111. Approve for introduction of Ordinance No. 4230 to authorize execution of an Amendment to the Pipeline Franchise Agreement with Cardinal Pipeline, L.P. for the operation and maintenance of a pipeline system for the transportation of oil, gas, and other hydrocarbon substances A) Approve for introduction of Ordinance No. 4230, “An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Amending Ordinance No. 4008 which Granted an Oil Pipeline Franchise”; and, B) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the “Amendment to Franchise Agreement between the City of Huntington Beach and Cardinal Pipeline , L.P.” Recommended Action: ADJOURNMENT The next regularly scheduled meeting of the Huntington Beach City Council/Public Financing Authority is Tuesday, August 6, 2024, in the Civic Center Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California. INTERNET ACCESS TO CITY COUNCIL/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY AGENDA AND STAFF REPORT MATERIAL IS AVAILABLE PRIOR TO CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AT Page 4 of 5

AGENDA July 16, 2024City Council/Public Financing Authority http://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov Page 5 of 5

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • 1721113200 07/16/24

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 96d386a1c618b5cf8c70e230bc598697. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record