POLISCOPE

The public record

PIEDMONT (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Decisions publishedPartial coverage

Park Commission Meeting

Wednesday, November 1, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Park Commission Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

City of Piedmont

Park Commission Agenda

Wednesday, December 6, 2023

5:30 p.m.

City Council Chambers, 120 Vista Avenue, Piedmont, CA

Call to Order

Public Forum This is an opportunity for members of the audience to speak on an item not on

the agenda.

Regular Agenda

1. Approval of Park Commission Minutes for November 1, 2023

2. Consideration of Recommendation to Remove (1) Liquidambar Street Tree on Park Way

3. Update on Opportunities to Memorialize the Sidney and Irene Dearing Family History at the

Triangle Park at the Intersection of Magnolia and Wildwood Avenues

4. Update on Arbor and Earth Day 2024

5. Update on Heritage Tree Nominations for 2024

6. Monthly Maintenance Report: Park, Open Space, and Street Tree Update for the Month of

November 2023

Announcements, old business and consideration of future agenda items

Adjourn

Materials related to an item on this agenda submitted to the Park Commission are available for public inspection in the Public Works

Department during normal business hours.

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please contact

the City Clerk at (510) 420-3040. Notification at least two business days preceding the meeting will enable the City to make

reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. [28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II]

In accordance with G.C. Sec. 54954.2(a) this notice and agenda were posted on the City Hall bulletin board and also in the

Piedmont Police Department on December 1, 2023.

Showing the first 24,000 of 28,916 characters. The full document is at the source.

City of Piedmont Park Commission Agenda Wednesday, November 1, 2023 5:30 p.m. City Council Chambers, 120 Vista Avenue, Piedmont, CA Call to Order Public Forum This is an opportunity for members of the audience to speak on an item not on the agenda. Regular Agenda 1. Informational Report: Status of the Preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan 2. Update on the Removal of Liquidambar Street Tree at 416 Park Way 3. Update on City Park Projects a. Dracena Park Drought Related Tree Removals and Replanting b. Bottlefilling Station at Beach Field 4. Update on Opportunities to Memorialize the Sidney and Irene Dearing Family History at the Triangle Park at the Intersection of Magnolia and Wildwood Avenues 5. Update on Arbor and Earth Day 2024 6. Monthly Maintenance Report: Park, Open Space, and Street Tree Update for the Month of October 2023 Announcements, old business and consideration of future agenda items Adjourn Materials related to an item on this agenda submitted to the Park Commission are available for public inspection in the Public Works Department during normal business hours. In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please contact the City Clerk at (510) 420-3040. Notification at least two business days preceding the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. [28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II] In accordance with G.C. Sec. 54954.2(a) this notice and agenda were posted on the City Hall bulletin board and also in the Piedmont Police Department on October 27, 2023.

City of Piedmont CALIFORNIA MEMORANDUM DATE: TO: FROM: SUBJECT: November 1, 2023 Park Commission Kevin Jackson, Planning & Building Director Pierce Macdonald, Senior Planner Informational Report: Status of the Preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 1 RECOMMENDATION This is an informational report on the status of the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan (MCSP). Staff recommends the Commission receive staff’s report and presentation and entertain a discussion about the Commission’s priorities related to the park and open space improvement goals set forth by the City Council. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY On March 20, 2023, the City Council adopted Piedmont’s 6th Cycle Housing Element (Housing Element), comprised of several policies and over seventy programs that the City will deliver to advance the development of a Regional Housing Needs Allocation of 587 housing units at all income levels during the 2023-2031 cycle. One of the more significant programs in the Housing Element is Program 1.L, which calls for the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan for City-owned parcels that total an estimated 18 acres in the Moraga Canyon area and the Moraga Avenue roadway that intersects them (“Study Area”). On July 17, 2023, the City Council approved an agreement with JZMK Partners (JZMK) for services related to the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan, and staff and the consulting team met the following week to launch the project. The first steps in the process are underway, including existing conditions analysis, neighborhood and stakeholder engagement, and an online survey. At this early stage of the process the intent of this report is to introduce the City Council’s goals and objectives for the project; present the project schedule; clarify the Park Commission’s role; and glean any priorities the Commission may have related to the City Council’s goals for parks and open space in the study area. During the Commission’s meeting, staff will also provide a slide presentation consisting of a summary of the information in this report. In addition the slide presentation will include early findings of site conditions and results of an online survey.

BACKGROUND Moraga Canyon Specific Plan Study Area As shown in Figure 1, the City owns four parcels (comprised of APN 050457901900, 050457908000, 048A700200303, and 050457906100) totaling roughly a little more than 18 acres on both the north and south sides of Moraga Avenue near Red Rock Road. North of Moraga Avenue are two parcels totaling approximately 13.65 acres that contain Coaches Field and Kennelly Skate Park recreational facilities, the Public Works corporation yard, two small parking lots, and open space on sloping terrain. South of Moraga Avenue are two parcels totaling approximately 4.85 acres that provide an open space area known as Blair Park. The study area abuts Mountain View Cemetery to the north, and single-family residential neighborhoods to the east, south and west. Figure 1. Study Area Housing Element Program 1.L As provided in the 6th Cycle Housing Element adopted by the City Council, the primary objective of Program 1.L is to accommodate at least 132 dwelling units. The full text of Program 1.L Specific Plan is provided in Attachment 1 to this report. While it is noted that the City’s Housing Element has yet to be certified by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (“HCD”), the development of the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan as theAgenda Report Page 2

City’s path forward is not in question. The only comments regarding Program 1.L are HCD’s request to revise the timeline to include a date for the issuance of building permits and a date to evaluate progress and identify alternative sites for housing should the Program’s success be determined unlikely. Consequently, it is concluded that implementation of Program 1.L aligns with the City’s compliance with State law. Goals of the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan When adopting Piedmont’s 6th Cycle Housing Element the City Council included a set of goals in Program 1.L for the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan. As summarized below, the goals will lead to a plan that would: a. Develop from a robust public engagement process that might include surveys, flyers, media posts, open houses, design charettes, study sessions, stakeholder meetings, and other methods of engagement; b. Result in the subdivision of parcels and development standards that are attractive to builders of housing at all income levels, and providing at least 60 units of housing affordable to households earning less than 80 percent of the area median income (AMI) (i.e., 20 low-income units, 20 very low-income units, and 20 extremely low-income units), and at least 72 units of housing affordable to households earning more than 80 percent of the AMI; c. Result in the identification of a site for the development of at least one affordable housing project that qualifies for Piedmont’s allocation of $2.2 million from the Alameda County Measure A1 low-interest loan program, and that leads to the County’s approval of the funds for an affordable housing project on the site by December 2024; d. Improve public safety in regards to design standards for structures in an Wildland Urban Interface Area; e. Improve pedestrian, bicycle and vehicular safety in the Moraga Canyon roadway, and design for safe evacuation routes in developed areas; f. Include recreation facilities including but not limited to: a) sports field(s) sized for under- 14 soccer and youth baseball/softball with batting cages, artificial field turf, and ballfield seating; b) a skate spot; c) a picnic area; and d) parking for these facilities; g. Provide a modern Public Works corporation yard; h. Address the supply of all public utilities to new housing and City facilities in a manner consistent with public safety standards and Piedmont Climate Action Plan goals and programs; i. Provide a comprehensive landscape plan prioritizing to the extent practicable fire safety, open space, native trees, hiking trails and significant viewsheds; j. Provide a program for implementation including General Plan amendments, regulations, design standards, infrastructure projects, and financing measures necessary to implement the specific plan; and k. Provide an evaluation of the economic feasibility of the plan; l. Provide a fiscal analysis of potential expenses and revenues (both one-time and ongoing) for the consideration of the City of Piedmont and Piedmont Unified School District. Potential revenue sources include but are not limited to property tax, sales tax, capital facilities fees, school impact fees, traffic impact fees, affordable housing fees and park fees. Revenue sources to (re)cover the cost of preparing the Specific Plan should be considered. Specific Plan Preparation and Benefits Several benefits are anticipated with the preparation of a specific plan for the study area at this time. The Governor’s Office of Planning and Research has published The Planner’s Guide toAgenda Report Page 3

Specific Plans, which provides detailed information about the requirements and content of specific plans, but in sum, a specific plan includes text, maps and diagrams which specify the following: • The location of land uses, including open space, within the study area. • The location of major infrastructure needed to support the land uses in the plan. • Standards and criteria by which development will proceed. • Implementation and financing measures necessary to carry out the items listed above. A specific plan is a tool the City of Piedmont can use to maintain local control in a geographical area and ensure that the design of this development is consistent with community expectations. Proceeding with the preparation of the Moraga Canyon Specific plan now provides several benefits, including: • Maximizing opportunities for community and stakeholder input in the fall when Piedmont residents are more likely to be available, and throughout the process; • Ensuring that the project meets the timeline approved by the City Council and thereby demonstrate the City’s compliance with State law; • Enabling the City to meet the deadline of December 31, 2024 and to secure approval by the Alameda County Board of Supervisors for the use of up to $2,100,000 of Measure A- 1 Bond funding for an affordable housing project prior to the diversion of funds to other jurisdictions. Tentative Moraga Canyon Specific Plan Schedule Provided below is a tentative schedule for the MSSP. Staff expects modifications to be made to the schedule as the plan develops, including the addition of public engagement events. July 2023 Project Kick-off Aug-Sep 2023 Existing Conditions Analysis Sep-Oct 2023 Online Survey Oct 2023 Neighborhood Engagement Oct-Nov 2023 Alternatives Development November 30, 2023 Community Workshop (review of alternatives) Jan-Feb 2024 Joint Study Session of City Council & Planning Commission Feb-May 2024 Specific Plan Development Jun-Jul 2024 Presentation of Specific Plan to City Council and Park, Recreation and Planning Commissions Jun-Sep 2024 Environmental Impact Report Completed Oct-Nov 2024 Recommendations by Park, Recreation and Planning Commissions Consideration for Adoption by City Council DISCUSSION Role of the Park Commission During the MCSP Planning Process Piedmont City Code Section 25.5, Powers and Duties of the Park Commission, states that the Commission shall consider and make recommendations to the City Council on matters affecting the beautification, planting, litter control, development, uses, acquisition and disposal and maintenance of all parks, park improvements, park memorials, street trees, parking strips (i.e., the portion of the street right-of-way between the sidewalk and curb) and other planted areasAgenda Report Page 4

owned or controlled by the City. The City Council has committed to the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan as described above. During this initial information-gathering stage of the planning process the Commissioners have the opportunity to consider the goals and objectives the Council has established and, in conformance with City Code Section 25.5, informally indicate any priorities related to the goal to provide a comprehensive landscape plan prioritizing to the extent practicable fire safety, open space, native trees, hiking trails and significant viewsheds. During the Commission’s discussion, staff will take note of priorities and concerns articulated by the Commissioners to help inform the draft alternatives to be presented at the November 30th Community Workshop. The Park Commission also has a role as the MCSP nears completion. After the City Council has selected a concept plan to be developed into a specific plan and all the objectives and elements of a final Moraga Canyon Specific Plan are nearing completion, the Park Commission has the responsibility of reviewing the Plan and make a recommendation to the City Council as provided in City Code Section 25.5. NEXT STEPS As noted above, the existing site conditions, the results from the online survey, and information gathered during the neighborhood meeting, stakeholder interviews, and the November meetings of the Park and Recreation Commissions will inform the development of alternative concept plans for the MCSP study area. The alternative concept plans will be presented and discussed during a Community Workshop to be held at Veterans Hall on Thursday, November 30 th , from 7:00 to 9:00 p.m. The results of the Community Workshop will be presented to the Planning Commission and City Council during a study session to be scheduled in January or February 2024. Ultimately, the information gathered, the results of the community engagement, and the remarks of the three Commissions will be considered by the City Council when it directs staff and the consulting team to develop a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan based on a selected concept plan. A final draft MCSP is expected to be completed and considered for adoption during the second half of 2024. ATTACHMENTS A Pages 6-8 Program 1.L Specific Plan, from City of Piedmont 6th Cycle Housing Element Related Document City of Piedmont 6th Cycle Housing Element, Adopted March 2023, Revised August 2023Agenda Report Page 5

Excerpted from the City of Piedmont 6th Cycle Housing Element “Program 1.L: Specific Plan As described in Appendix B, Section B.3.1, the City owns four sites (comprised of APN 050457901900, 050457908000, 048A700200303, and 050457906100) totaling about 18.25 acres on both the north and south sides of Moraga Avenue near Red Rock Road. The City of Piedmont has the ability to subdivide the parcels and declare them to be surplus under the Surplus Land Act (SLA- California Government Code §54222 et seq.). The intent of this process would be to facilitate the development of below-market-rate housing to help meet the demand for affordable housing in the City. In order for the City to meet its RHNA requirements, these sites need to accommodate at least 132 housing units at all income levels. Given the size of the site, existing constraints, and the desire to preserve the existing public uses (open space, recreation, and City Corporation Yard), the area will be planned using the specific plan process outlined in Government Code §65450 et seq. This process requires the orderly development of the area, including the following: phasing; subdivision; adequate infrastructure; identification of financing; protection of amenities and City facilities; and production of affordable housing. The goals of the specific plan are as follows. The first goal is to enable construction of housing at a minimum of 132 units, on portions of the site, totaling approximately 3.5 acres of land, yielding a minimum of 60 units of housing affordable to households earning less than 80 percent of the area median income (AMI) and a minimum of 72 units affordable to households earning more than 80 percent of the AMI. In addition, specific plan goals include improved safety. New habitable structures shall be built to meet fire code requirements for Wildland Urban Interface Areas. The specific plan must include replacement and/or modernization of existing Public Works Department facilities, offices, storage areas, vehicle storage areas, etc., so that service capacity is maintained or increased, and so that the facilities meet current building and fire code requirements. The specific plan must include recreation facilities, including but not limited to an under- 14 soccer field, youth baseball/softball field, batting cages, artificial field turf, ballfield seating, a skate spot, a picnic area, and parking for these facilities. The specific plan must provide all public utilities to new housing and all City facilities to be constructed within the specific plan area in a manner consistent with public safety standards and Piedmont Climate Action Plan goals and programs. The specific plan must include improvements to pedestrian and vehicular circulation, as determined necessary by the City Engineer, to provide safe pedestrian, bicycle, and motor vehicle movements, ensure safe evacuation routes, and provide optimal emergency response. The goals of the specific plan include a comprehensive landscape plan for areas planned for development. The landscape plan shall prioritize to the extent practicable: fire safety and the preservation of significant open space, scenic views, and native and heritage trees. Density in the plan area will be determined at the time of plan development, and couldAgenda Report Page 6Attachment A

range from 40 to 60 dwelling units per acre, including housing for seniors, disabled persons, single-parents, low-income families, and/or people requiring supportive services. This program requires an amendment to the City’s General Plan and the preparation of a specific plan to accommodate the density and create development standards for the unique site conditions. The required amendments would be reviewed by the City Attorney for conformance with the City Charter and other legal requirements. If it is determined that it is infeasible to develop this site during the planning process, the City will consider utilizing other City-owned properties as alternative sites (See Appendix B). The City will apply for grants and other funding sources to help fund the planning and development of affordable housing in this area. The City could also leverage local, State, and federal affordable housing funding sources. The City issued a request for proposals (RFP) seeing professional services for the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan on January 23, 2023. Proposals were received on March 13, 2023 and contract execution and project kick-off are expected to occur by the end of July 2023. There are no known impediments to the development of housing within the study area. The scope of services detailed in the RFP include but are not limited to the following: • Detailed guidance on phasing and subdivision that accommodates the 60 units of lower-income housing and 72 units of above moderate-income housing identified for the study area in Housing Element program 1.L and the Sites Inventory (Housing Element Appendix B), and that prioritizes and expedites the identification of a site for the development of affordable housing that meets the criteria and timelines to secure Alameda County Measure A-1 funding. (The due date for the City to gain County approval of a project using Measure A-1 funding is December 31, 2024.); • The preparation of a surplus land declaration; • A program of implementation measures including regulations, programs, infrastructure projects, and financing measures necessary to implement the Specific Plan; and • An evaluation of the economic feasibility of the Specific Plan. Necessary entitlements and the issuance of building permits will occur during the planning period and will be specified through the Specific Plan process. As noted in Appendix F, any new housing in Piedmont represents increased access to opportunity and housing mobility, as the City is considered to be “highest resource” throughout. The Specific Plan will promote housing choice and affordability, given that it includes measures to provide housing for below-market rate households, which will help overcome existing patterns of income segregation within the Bay Area and East Bay region. The City will also determine appropriate partnership opportunities in order to ensure successful implementation of this program and adequate funding for the development of affordable housing. Proposals would be reviewed and approved by the City Council. • Objective: Develop a specific plan to accommodate at least 132 dwelling units at a density of 40 to 60 dwelling units per acre affordable to a variety ofAgenda Report Page 7Attachment A

households, including seniors, disabled persons, single-parents, low-income families, and people requiring supportive services. • Timeframe: o Award contract for professional services for the preparation of the specific plan and kick off project by July 2023. o Apply for available grant funding by December 2024. o Begin subdivision of site and Surplus Land declaration timed to be completed concurrent with Specific Plan adoption. o Prepare specific plan with the goal of completion by the end of 2025. o Adopt specific plan, General Plan amendments (See Program 1.P), and associated development standards by 2025. o Pursue goal of entering into exclusive negotiating agreement with development partners by the end of 2026. o Issue building permits by the end of 2027 (if an agreement is finalized with developers by 2026). o Identify alternative site(s) by June 2027 (if no agreement is finalized by the end of 2026). • Responsible Agency: Planning & Building Department, with direction of City Council and Planning Commission.”Agenda Report Page 8Attachment A

HortScience│Bartlett Consulting ● Divisions of The F.A. Bartlett Tree Expert Company 2550 Ninth Street Suite 112, Berkeley, CA, 94710, 925.484.0211 ● www.hortscience.com October 25, 2023 Nancy Kent City of Piedmont 120 Vista Avenue Piedmont CA 94611 Subject: Sweetgum assessment 416 Park Way Dear Ms. Kent: You requested that I evaluate the health and structural condition of three sweetgums (Liquidambar styraciflua) located at 416 Park Way. I visited the site on October 20th to review tree conditions. This letter summarizes my observations, assessment, and recommendation. Description of the Trees Each of the trees had been topped for line clearance. As a result, crowns were one-sided with lateral branches extending towards and over the residence. Trunk diameters ranged from 21 to 38 inches. Overall vigor was good with few dead or dying branches. Trees #98 and 99 had fair structure, whereas tree #97 had poor structure. Lateral branches of tree #99 turned upwards to form a candelabra shape (Photo 1). Branch attachments were narrow, crossing, and were poorly formed. A large girdling root was present extending a third of the way around the tree. Tree #98 had a 21-inch diameter trunk, the smallest of the group. It appeared to have stronger, wider lateral branch attachments (Photo 2) than the other two trees. Large, heavy limbs extended over the house. Tree #97 had a cavity with decay on the street side (Photo 3, next page). A 12 ft. long wound was present on the house side, resulting from the failure of a scaffold branch (Photo 4, next page). Response growth indicated the presence of internal decay, potentially extending into the main trunk. Photo 1. Tree #99 was closes to the southwest corner of Park Way and Masa Ave. Lateral branching was poorly formed turning upright. Photo 2 (middle). Branching of tree #98 had fair structure.

416 Park Way Assessment City of Piedmont October 25, 2023 Page 2 HortScience│Bartlett Consulting ● Divisions of The F.A. Bartlett Tree Expert Company Recommendation I recommend removal of tree #97. The tree had poor structure and a history of branch failure resulting in decaying cavities and wounds. I am not aware of any arboriculturally sound treatment or techniques to further mitigate these defects without compromising the tree’s structure. The tree’s condition will not improve. Decay will only worsen, increasing the likelihood of fail

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Park Commission Meeting — Minutes
  • Park Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 95f351430de093d90d4636f542b6e95e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record