POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Historic & Environmental Preservation Board (HEPB)

Tuesday, July 7, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Miami Historic & Environmental Preservation Board denied a request to install an asphalt shingle roof on a contributing structure in the Palm Grove Historic District. The board determined that the applicant failed to provide sufficient engineering evidence to support the claim that the existing structure could not support a traditional tile roof, and upheld the district's historic preservation guidelines.

Why it matters

This decision reinforces the enforcement of historic district design standards, requiring property owners to adhere to original material guidelines unless they can prove significant structural or financial hardship.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Historic & Environmental Preservation Board (HEPB) — July 7, 2026 - 2:52 PM

Showing the first 24,000 of 231,005 characters. The full document is at the source.

july 7th meeting of the historic environmental preservation board. I ask everyone to please stand for the pledge of allegiance and remain standing to be sworn in by staff. Allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation under GOD. Indivisible. >> with liberty and justice for all. Good afternoon. If you intend to testify, please remain standing. Raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony you will give will be the truth and nothing but the truth? Thank you. >> you MAY be seated. MAY I. >> start with the attendant? Yes, please. Okay. Calling. >> board. Attendants for chair william hopper here. Uh, for vice chair lewis prieto. E munoz. >> calling. >> member najib campbell here calling member christopher cauley here calling. >> member. >> elvis fuentes calling member julie. O'dell here. Calling member john perez. Here calling member robert powers here, calling member hugh ryan calling member jordan trachtenberg okay. And we do have quorum. I did receive a request from member vice chair lewis prieto munoz he is requesting an absence waiver. Thank you. Is there a motion to approve? So moved. Second. Second. >> thank you. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. Motion carries. Is there a motion to are there any additions or corrections to the minutes of JUNE 2nd 2026? If not is there a motion to approve? So moved. Thank you MR. Second. Second. Thank you. There's a motion and a second to approve any discussion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. Motion carries and we're on to discussion items. So if it pleases the board we'll have the discussion items at the end of the agenda. It does about updates. I'm sorry. It does. >> how about monthly updates. Uh so a few updates I'll try to keep things brief. Um interviews are scheduled actually for tomorrow for the principal planner position. So hopefully we'll have someone um in that position sooner rather than later. Um site visits um have been scheduled and continue to be scheduled uh regarding the grants program, uh so we are working with community development on that. Um I do want to let the board know that uh, the planning department is going to be have a having a board and committee member training event in AUGUST .Uh, if you haven't received your invitations yet, you should receive them shortly. Um, I think they were approved this morning. >> it was just in the email. Yes. >> so that will be um AUGUST 18th um at 8:30 A.M. In jose marti park. Um there'll be it's basically a morning and afternoon uh program there'll be some ethics training and then some breakout sessions, um that you can select from. Um so please put that on your calendar. We're looking forward to having a really good day. Um, for all the board and committee members, uh, to be there. And those are my updates at the moment. Okay. >> thank you. We'll move into the public hearing part of the agenda. Uh, staff will announce this item and then the applicant or appellant will come forward, give your name and address for the record. We'll start then with the staff report after which the applicant or appellant MAY respond when they have completed their presentation I will open up to the public for questions or for comments. I'm sorry doctor hopper we need to a few announcements from uh city attorney's office. I beg your pardon? All that for a second. Yes, MR. Attorney, I beg your pardon. No worries. Any person who's alive pursuant to chapter two, article six of the city code must register with the city clerk, comply with related city requirements for lobbyists before appearing before the historic and environmental preservation board. A person MAY not lobby a city official, board member or staff member until registering a copy of the code section about lobbyists is available in the city clerk's office or online on municode.Com. The agenda for this meeting and materials for the items on the agenda were published and made available to the board in advance of the meeting. The materials are also available online@miamigov.Com. Please silence your cell phones and other noise making devices. Any person with a disability requiring assistance, auxiliary aides or services for this meeting MAY notify the hearing board liaison. Any person MAY be heard by the board through the chair and pursuant to the public notice for not more than two minutes on any proposition before the board unless modified by the chair when addressing the board, the member of the public must first state his or her name, address and what item will be spoken about when the board takes action or votes on any proposition, it shall do so by a roll call vote to be recorded and included in the record. Thank you. Thank you. So after the staff report and the response by the applicant or appellant, members of the public will have an opportunity to comment on the item. I would ask you to keep your comments brief to two minutes or less after everyone has had a chance to speak, we'll close the public hearing and open up to the board for questions or comments and we'll have a vote and proceed to the next item. I believe we're on to item number one. Calling item number one file id 19168 a resolution of the miami historic and environmental preservation board pursuant to section 23-6.2, subsection b four of the city code of ordinances approving or denying a special certificate of appropriateness to permit the installation of an asphalt shingle roof to a contributing structure within the palm grove historic district located approximately at 536 northeast 65th street, miami, florida 33138 further incorporating the analysis in the attached staff report entitled exhibit a with the following findings. I believe the applicant is present. Please give your name and address for the record. Good afternoon. Um genesis najera my mom beatrice najera 536 northeast 65th street, miami, florida 33138. Thank you. >> we'll start with the staff report. Uh, preservation historic preservation planner karina gonzalez de mendoza. I request the staff analysis be accepted into the record. So done. So for this particular for this particular item the house as we see in the historic photo and then a tax card originally had a flat tile roof um as such we recommended that it be restored to tile um they would like to change it to um to asphalt shingle in amber uh as the roof has been and as it was when it was designated as a contributing structure when the district was designated as palm grove. Um so. Um the proposed undertaking wouldn't alter the existing structure and such. Uh, with our guidelines we do say that it should be restored as um as a flat tile although the property was um designated contributing uh with the historic district. Um and it was deferred with the intention for the applicant to be able to look into the pricing of the materials. So while we recommend denial in accordance with the guidelines, uh, we do look for the board to make their own determination and if they were to determine as such we do propose a standard conditions recommended were they to approve it. Do you want to read those conditions or you just want to leave them in case. Uh basically that the conditions would be where the board chooses to approve it, that the site should be developed in accordance with the plan submitted as part of it, that the resolution be submitted in the building permit and that manufacturers brochure or color photograph of the materials would be submitted with it um and complying with the requirements of all other departments and agencies the city of miami. Thank you. Thank you. Would you like to respond to the staff report? Yes. >> I have some folders to pass around from the last time that we met on MAY like um I did my due diligence of getting I did my due diligence of getting more quotes and yeah, I'm going to pass it over. Okay. >> be sure and give one to the lady over on the right. Yes. Thank you. Okay so good afternoon. Thank you all for your time today. Um my name is genesis najera. I'm here on behalf of my family my mother and my father jose najera um regarding our property 536 northeast 65th street miami florida 33138 following the board guidelines through during our last meeting in MAY I completed the requested due diligence. I gather multiple roofing estimate from different company attempted to contact district six commissioner office and comply with all supporting documents to review. I have provided each of you a folder to include this information within the folder you will find multiple quotes for both shingle and roofing system licensed contractor. You will also see documentation from the company where we're working with those contract we ultimately had to cancel this decision was made due to significantly increase costs beyond our budget as well as concern regarding the recommendation to work on a holiday without proper permit. For these reasons we chose to terminate our relationship with the company. Additionally, you will find an inspection report indicating that the current structure does not have the capacity to support a roofing system without substantial structural reforming reinforcement. The cost associated with these reforms is significantly beyond what we can afford at this time. We also experience unexpected financial burden including the cost of canceling the prior contract and replacing air conditioning system. Um because of the compressor failed requiring replacement, these expenses have further limited our ability to move forward with more costly option. Um although I have made several attempts to contact district six commissioner office um I did today go in because she had a walk in appointment and I did speak with her. Um yeah, so I did speak with her. She did recommend us to apply for the home rehabilitation program. She said that I could take long as not not now that you know they're accepting application. I did tell her that um that even though if it's still raining it's still leaking the roof and we need to we need to try to get this resolved as soon as possible. I know that last time you guys did give us a permission that if there's any emergency we have the option to repair it. But my mom already wasted $1,800 to try and get someone to repair and it's still leaking. We've already been in this situation since SEPTEMBER trying to get the approval from the city. I know that last month we had to meet with you guys in MAY and then thank GOD we had the opportunity to meet with you guys to get today. It's just that it's going to take a year and we trying to get the solution as to get this resolved as in to have the permission to put shingle. Um and yeah, that's all I have to say. Is it. I was trying to also get um another opinion from an engineering to give us another inspection report. But unfortunately if you could see the last two pages one was charging us a 50 and another one was charging us 1600. So at this point since we had the inconvenience of the a c that we had to replace and to and to cancel the contract with the company that was representing us, we had to pay with a credit card $5,000 because they because on MAY when we left here they said, oh, since the house is already paid, just let's do it on a holiday that the city is not available on memorial day and let's get this I can help you out with the roof. So we didn't want to proceed that way because we preferred getting permission than doing it the way of not getting permission. Um and that's all I have to say for now. Okay. >> thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone from the public who wishes to speak on this item? Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing. Open it up for the board for questions or comments. Um how are you? Good. >> you um. We'll start with this. Oh sorry. Did you want to go in another direction? >> no that's okay. Okay. >> thank you. Um I, I remember this item um and bob you'll have to jump in at sometime soon after I'm finished speaking but your presentation slightly confused me um I remember this agenda. I remember that the end the if I recall if I recall properly I could make a mistake but I'm trying to recall properly that um the decision was made that there are funds available. There were some there were some announcements made on that side of the room that you know, funds are available and you'll be able to apply. I think MR. Powers also made some kind of commitment of some sort and um that was supposed to be the the solution um your presentation I'm not sure if it touched on that issue and that issue failed or it didn't work and then what happened after and so if you don't mind you MAY have mentioned this but because you were going in different directions, I couldn't follow exactly what you were saying based upon the end of your agenda the very last time you were here in MAY. So what happened with the with the the next stage that we all approved. The next stage of speaking to see if we could get financial help? Um there might have been multiple steps or three that we agreed to and um I'm just asking what what happened the next because. So we got the we got quotes from three other company from shingle and tile. But before I start to interrupt before I get to the quotes what happened to the solution which was the um the application and the commissioner's office had some funds available. I'm starting to recollect now what happened to that. Okay. >> so meeting with today with christina keen she did say that there is um a home rehabilitation program but that that's not available now that I will have to apply and wait until next year. Um and she also sorry. No no go. Ahead and she also I did told her that today I had the meeting with you guys like with the city. Um she just told me to also let her know about the results she also did told me um yeah to let you guys know that since my mom when she bought the property before andrew that's the last time that they repaired a roof and it was shingle. Um also in the documents in the folder you could see that there's other addresses. Hold on, hold on we're going away from okay I was going to keep track so I can follow. So the solution which I've heard the last agenda that these funds were available they're actually not available mhm I'm asking you. >> that's not available to um to to apply for the funds at this time. No I'll have to apply for next year. >> so we're were we misled at the last meeting or or what because that was a point that was made that um these funds are available. We don't want any body missing anything or missing opportunities and we were given some kind of words that these funds are available. So um you when you mentioned you spoke to the commissioner you said the words today twice. Did you literally mean you spoke to her today? Yes, today I ate in the morning I did the line to speak with her at nine. Okay, fine. >> did you speak to her prior to that? No, because after MAY I didn't have the chance to meet with her in person. So they said that today, JULY the 7th at 9 to 12 she had availability to do walk in and then from two 2 to 445 but before then I was trying to email I emailed the um. Um ford the the assistant of her to try to have communication with someone she was going to forward the email to um a person named diego florence I think and she never did so she so then um I ended up calling and the representative told me that she has a walk and I could go in today and try to speak with her about the situation. So let me let me get this straight. Um after the MAY meeting was at the beginning of MAY. Mhm. You did not speak with the commissioner? No one second. Okay. Or any of her representatives to fulfill what we agreed to until this morning. Mhm. Yeah. >> so I try. >> to reach acceptable. Okay. >> no, I try reaching out to her. >> I'm not saying it's your fault but that's that's not acceptable. We we agreed to something and then the first time you speak so either there was um lack of effort on your part or on their part but we we'll get to the bottom of it. Mhm. >> as you can see there's phone conversation. I try reaching out to her if you want me to show you from MAY I could show you from me trying to have a conversation where it's just that there's no way to speak with her directly. You have to go through someone through her assistant. So until now that they're like okay, she have availability on JULY the 7th coming early in the morning and try to and to see if you could speak with her. Okay. >> I have. I have. >> some questions. Yes sir. I've been trying to kind of process the information that was given to us. Please make sure you have your mic. Yes. >> sorry. Okay. Um I have a few questions. Yes. And uh, maybe you can confirm or correct me here. Okay. Based on the price difference of the shingle versus the concrete tile without including any reinforcement seems to be somewhere around $10,000, am I correct? I think I reviewed a couple of quotes. Um yes. Like there was one that was 3000 and other ones like 20 yeah one company. >> and then there was another one that was around 9 or $10,000 correct? Yes. I just wanted to establish that. Okay. Well um I also see that in one of these estimates there is there's something there's a line item that says reinforced existing frame trusses to support tile roof load carrying slash loading material by hands included. And it says 1760. And then underneath that says engineering service I assume that 1760 is related to an engineering analysis for the cost of an engineering analysis. So that yes, that quote was from the representative that my mom did with the group that was representing us that when we told her after what happened with MAY meeting she said, okay, give us a quote please how much will be with tile roof with the structural reformation ?And she gave us that quote that will be over 100 either 140,000 to 160 000. Yeah. >> but but I'm asking about the line item that says 1760 above around the middle of that there's a line item that says 1760. So it's sorry it's the one that just says estimate roof tile roof and structural frame reinforcement doesn't have a title. So I'm wondering if if that is referring to engineering services. Yeah there's a line item underneath. Roof carrying let me ask my mom one second um martina de cuando estamos en cuanto a ser de lo siento. Pero aqui en esta seccion donde se reform existing frame trustee to support tile roof load carrying load material como esta tira maybe engineering can you even. Know pero esta es otro engineering poner como a otro otra cosa parte. MR. Perez. Yes okay okay. Am I allowed through the chair to ask him a question? Yes. >> okay so I think the distinction. Microphone what microphone I got I got to make sure I'm hearing everybody. Okay so. Through the playback. Through the chair so the thing about this is this is that if you put on a tile roof today, they use an entirely different system than they use because I watched them take my tile roof off every tile on my roof was concreted down. They no longer use concrete to put those tiles down. So that's lighter number one. The concrete that they use to put on the roof is lighter. So a lot of these engineering things go away because that's a thing that they should even talk about. Okay that's number one. Okay not only that those houses were built when they were built because I have a 1947 home a block over from you a [Laughter] Fourplex. I know your house. I know that house like because I photographed it when we became a historic district. So. They had tons of stuff. They had it in my house, my house. They took off the original roof from 1947. So from 1947 until 2022 that roof stayed on that house. That's the difference about a tile roof compared your mothers now are going to replace a roof twice and she's at she's the same she's a little bit older than me. So the thing about it is the price difference trying to 9 or $10,000 that you're trying to like say that's more expensive that roof will last. We'll both be in the ground by the time that roof needs to be replaced. I'm just telling you. So if you put on a tile roof and the argument that the engineers are making through the two. MR.. I don't think is true. I think it's a baloney thing and that that you have to spend 140,000 or 180,000. No. Now if it's the picture where so much of that flat roof is gone and you have to replace all the joists across is is that what we're talking about? No no no no. Okay then I'll stop talking. Thank you very much. I just wanted to kind of so I see here 1760 and then I looked at this document which correct me if I'm wrong what I understand by this is that this is another um another quote to evaluate the roof which is $1,600 am I correct? Yes. Okay. And then. And then there was one of a 50. Okay I didn't I didn't. Try to get another um inspection report. And then I want to reference this one this one actually I remember um referencing the first time that you came here okay and it I'll ask the same question did this this analysis by the s h science p says that they have done the necessary analysis to determine if the roof frame has the capacity to use roof tile instead of using shingle according to the analysis my question would be could we see the analysis? This roof frame does not have the capacity to withstand roof tile system. The roof frame must be reinforced to be able to withstand the additional load of the tile. So again what would this reinforcement be if this engineer made the determination that this cannot hold it, then they have to have an idea of what could hold it or I mean something along the lines of this wood rafter space at 16in on center if that's the determination if they could say well if it was 12in on center this would be fine. But this is a little bit vague for us to be able to analyze objectively. And then the other question is um yeah, if if this engineer performed the necessary analysis to determine that the roof frame does not have the capacity, what would it need to be? So it's that's one aspect of it. And then the the assertion that in order to to go from this for the contractor or a contractor to say, you know what the solution MAY end up being ripping off the entire roof to be able to hold this up is in my opinion an exaggeration. And then let's say even if that were true, the idea that it would cost between 140 to $160,000 to replace an entire roof is also a gross exaggeration. Now I understand that sometimes you know there's some leeway in the way people like to present their case, but in my opinion I don't think it's serving you as the applicant because it's so far out of the realm of reality at least in my opinion, that it's very hard for me to take it at face value. And so I would lean I don't know if everybody else agrees here I would lean towards, you know, requesting that you bring specific evidence of how this roof cannot hold the roof tile. So another report. Sorry to interrupt another report from another engineering. >> no no no this report is is very vague in saying we analyzed it. There's no backup behind this. Usually a full analysis would have backup calculations and proof of how they claim that they did the analysis but there's nothing really showing it um saying it does not comply because of this specifically and should you have to do this this would be the approach to take and then from there perhaps you could have somebody uh provide a cost estimate of those specific instructions that the engineer would provide. It's very common on on projects. I think based on that I suspect that this 140 to $160,000 number would be you'd see that it's that's not the case I suspect, but I think that would give us the tools to analyze this a little bit more objectively as I mentioned. Um, so I realize that performing this or hiring one of these engineers to to provide this, I realize it's a cost and I'm sensitive to that, but we as a board are put in a position where we have to, you know, protec

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Historic & Environmental Preservation Board (HEPB)
  • Historic & Environmental Preservation Board (HEPB) — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9537516bc226b9fd309d9939af77e977. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record