POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Virginia Key Beach Advisory Board

Tuesday, October 27, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Virginia Key Advisory Board convened to discuss update items, including the Rickenbacker Marina referendum proposal, the city's application for a mooring field, and the proposed Miami Seaquarium redevelopment. Board members passed resolutions urging the City of Miami to request that Miami-Dade County delay the Seaquarium lease consideration until a transparent public process is completed, and established general policy recommendations regarding future marina dredging depths and boat sizes.

Why it matters

The board's advisory resolutions influence local city and county policy regarding land use, public access, environmental conservation, and infrastructure development on Virginia Key. These actions impact local residents, recreational users, and regional traffic flows.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Virginia Key Beach Advisory Board — October 27, 2026 - 5:33 PM

Showing the first 24,000 of 97,069 characters. The full document is at the source.

meeting of OCTOBER 27th. We're going to get started in a few minutes with some notes on the requirements for lobbyists and then we'll move to the pledge of allegiance. We have some excellent informative speakers here tonight, so we hope everybody will know more about some of the issues facing virginia key park and virginia key. Um can we we'll hear from rafaela lobbyist. Note rafaela. I'll take care of that chair the city attorney. No problem. Should any person desire to appeal any decision of the miami virginia key advisory board with respect to any matter to be considered at this meeting, that person will need a record of the proceedings and MAY need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, including all testimony and evidence upon which any appeal MAY be based. Any person who receives compensation, remuneration. Remuneration or expenses for conducting lobbying activities is required to register as a lobbyist with the city clerk prior to engaging in lobbying activities before city staff boards, committees or the city commission. A copy of the applicable ordinance is available at the office of the city clerk miami city hall. >> located at 3500 pan american drive, miami, florida 33133. Thank you. Thank you very much. We'll move on to the pledge of allegiance. To the flag of the united states of all. Call to. >> order and request. >> for absence waiver. Peter erlick here. Nicholas lopez jenkins here. Luis casamayor here. Larry gautier here. Lauren janedis here. Steven liner. Christopher norwood. Monty trainor. Alejandro martinez estevez here. And daniel lopez on behalf of parks. Any minute. >> minutes. >> approval. Nothing anything to be approved no um. Do we need a swear? >> do we have a quorum tonight? Yes, we have quorum today. Oh that's wonderful. I want to thank everybody every board member who's here particularly some new board members. Um I think the second meeting for chris norwood he's on my left and lauren first meeting for for lauren and lauren you're representing tropical audubon society and um larry's here larry's representing dade heritage trust which is a fantastic organization in our community with a great history. You want to make any comments larry? No. >> just glad to be here and looking forward to serve. Thank you so much. And we also have um um let's see anybody else? Anybody else new in the room rafaela new board members. Okay. Do you need to do a swearing in of the public or anybody? Is that necessary? Most of our items are for discussion. Yeah we don't need to have the swearing in of the public. Okay. Um so we do have an agenda items and various discussion items for the virginia key advisory board. Um .Very nice to welcome our new members. Um the next meeting date will be. This year I. >> believe it'll be december 21st DECEMBER 22nd DECEMBER 22nd coming up. Um, let's see now the items that are substantive to be discussed today um are an update on the request for proposals for the rickenbacker marina site which is a referendum question that's being voted on by voters now through next week, the end of the election election season for this year. Um is there any comments from city staff on anything happening with the rickenbacker marina site? Anything that we're unaware of anything new. So there's an existing. Litigation at the moment so we would recommend that this matter not be discussed. Litigation rickenbacker. Marina site. Correct there's. >> a litigation regarding the the marina um if if you don't mind who's the. >> who's the plaintiff on that. I'm not sure I'm aware of that. Rickenbacker the the. Existing or an. >> affiliated entity. The current current. >> tenant correct. An affiliated entity of the. Is there anybody here from the rickenbacker marina or anybody here would like to speak on that item? That's the rickenbacker. >> marissa marina site referendum question. MR. Chair, it's my second meeting and I just want to understand the order of business. Um are we are is it the is it the um is it. Customary to allow the public to speak before we. Discuss our items? If so then we should just allow the public to come up and speak on on whatever the agenda items are and then we can have a discussion about the items. >> uh, as as it relates to as outlined in the agenda. Um um chris we've done it both ways. Sometimes board members speak first and sometimes if they're experts or people that are heavily involved in specific issues from the public, sometimes they speak first because they have information that will help the board members. So there isn't a set answer for that. We've done it both ways. Well okay. Um then I think for efficiency. Purposes we should hear from the public um as on whatever items that are on our agenda has been properly noticed. Advertised and things of that nature correct. And so the public knows what's on our agenda and if they want to speak on particular items they can come speak on the particular items and then after they speak then the board can have a. Discussion on the items that's here on our agenda. That's fine. So we're finishing up this item on the rickenbacker marina request. >> for proposals. Do you have any comments on that particular item? Uh well I want to hear from the public first. >> and. >> then. >> after hearing from the public I would like to go through the agenda that well that we're going to do it one item at a. >> time though. Um is there anybody from the public that would like to speak on the. MR.. MISTER Chair with all due respect if that's what we're going to do, I would like us to take a vote on that. Because my understanding is that when we have an agenda, the public speaks for whatever amount of time that we decide and then after they speak we then have our discussions on individual items. If we're not going to do that, I would like that to be a decision of the board and so I will make a. Motion that I would like to make a motion that we allow the public to speak and then after the public speaks we then can go through the the agenda and have our. Discussions. >> there. In that order. That would be my motion. Um does anybody like to second that motion? Um I don't see a second at the moment. Okay. Um let's see. So if nobody's here to speak from the public on the rickenbacker referendum question, we'll move on to the next item which is an update. >> on the city's application for. 195 mooring. Sorry MISTER Chair, you had asked me to come. >> speak. On this item so I'm I can do that if. >> you'd. >> like. Which the rickenbacker item it's up on the screen. Oh oh, um, that would be great. Um, laura reynolds is here and she has a presentation. >> and she's got I guess she it's online so we can MISTER Chair, I understand that this is the order that we're going to do things and I'm fine with it. I still want to. Understand what that order is. So are we going to invite everyone who wants to talk about this item to. >> speak for a set amount of time? Is that what we're going to do? Yes. Traditionally we've had members from the public will come up and speak. Usually they have excellent information that helps the board members come to conclusions and learn more about the issues affecting virginia key park in this case, um laura reynolds has some information that would be pertinent to us now we're this is just merely for discussion because we don't have a an item that we're voting on tonight, but we are this is. >> an opportunity for us to hear from a member of the public that has some. Information I. And I agree with you I want to hear from all of the people from the public and I don't I'm not trying to to I want to hear from whomever wants to speak on this item. And so I don't want it appear that we're. >> only letting. >> one. Person speak on a particular item. I mean, no, I think the right thing to do for me just from a process perspective and I'm not trying to halt anything here. I just want to know the process and whatever the process is, let's follow it. So if we have people that's going to we're going to go through every item, then everyone should be given a certain amount of time to speak on that item and then we move on to the next item. And so can we establish some sort of procedure that is equal to. Everyone here so that we can, you know, move everything forward? Well look, laura reynolds was at the podium because she was working on her computer and getting hooked up. That's fine. And and. >> she just notified us that she does have some permission on the item. MR. Chair, can I speak for a second? Is that all right? I think what you're asking for is what we do every time you know from being here we we go through each item, we let anybody speak as long as they want. We don't even give them a time frame. They can be here all night and we'll be here all night if that's what they require. So I think we've we've been working on that premise that you're which I'm excited that you're engaged and you want that but that's exactly how we do. But I think everybody has to speak about a certain item. I don't think we just let anybody speak and then we don't have any any control. We go through the items they can speak against the item and then the board responds as necessary. So I'm sorry to jump in on that but it's just my experience as I've been here about a little bit over a year. So I don't know if that clarifies anything or if that helps, but everybody has a chance. >> to speak. Nobody here is forbidden from speaking. Ever since I have been here. The chair I understand that that's been the process in the past. Um I don't think that's an efficient way and I don't think that's a fair way for the public to engage a public body. For me personally, I think that if we want the public to. Participate. >> then we provide. Everybody the same amount of time to speak. If that's the process we're going to go with every item, that's fine. I would think a better way would be to do it before then, but the body doesn't want to do that that's fine. But if the body is deciding that it wants to go through every discussion item and allow the public to speak, then the public should know that they have a certain amount of time to speak and anybody can speak on the on the item that's so I just want to establish whatever the process is. Let's establish it as a body and let's move forward. So if the body wants to do it this way then then then that's fine too with me, I just want to. >> make my voice known that that's not the way I think it should happen. Yeah okay, I appreciate it. And lewis um added some facts to the record which is we've never really had time limits in the past and it's never really bothered us because nobody speaks overly. >> long but let's let's move on so that we can we can get get in. Well MR. Chair, I would like a vote on that as well. So if we're going to allow everybody to have any time to speak, let the body make that let's vote on that and that'll be our. Procedure and it's very. >> well known and established. That's the way we're going to proceed. All right. Is that your motion? I'm not making. >> a motion if you want to say you want to make the motion go right ahead. I don't I'm not going to make a motion on that. i'm just we're just going to continue going as we have for the last ten years. Well I think isn't it important that there is process and procedure when we're dealing with the public and people. Speaking isn't that important to I mean I don't know. No I appreciate your comments but we've. >> never been hindered by our process in the past. So what you're saying is that the public can come here and they can speak however much time they want. Uh there is no limitation. Uh, if somebody wants to take 20 minutes they can do that. If someone wants to take one minute they can do that. And that's how this body is performing. Uh, as a as as a as a as an advisory board you since we've been established somebody speaking over the. >> long. >> has never. >> been an issue on any at any of. >> our meetings. Okay. >> I promise not to speak too long. Thank you. You're under you're under pressure. Thank you very much MISS. You want to identify yourself for the record, laura? Yes, yes. Laura reynolds with friends of biscayne bay and we just have some new. Information I think to share with you all. About the. Rickenbacker marina development. Proposal that's out for voter referendum. And I think it's important I'm going to skip through some of these. Slides. >> uh, to to go through it and the the new. Information is really the dredging. Impacts and it wasn't clear, uh, from, you know, the. Proposal that there would be dredging in fact, the, uh, virginia key llc group said there would be no. Dredging. >> uh, in several. Interviews and what we found in their own report and by the way, the average depth there is four feet um, five feet being the blue area, which is the. Deepest uh point and at this time the the largest vessel that's there is. 90ft with a draft of. 5.6 and there's one of those boats okay on the end the very end of the pier, what they're. Proposing in phase two and it's in their own. Report and we've sort of highlighted it here even though it's hard to read um is you know, it will take. Approximately 36 to 48 months. But the second phase is. Absolutely maintenance dredging and that second phase would allow them to go to 8 or 9ft which is. Double the size of the marina now depth wise. And so this is something that. Really is ringing alarm bells for friends of biscayne bay because this is going to affect the aquatic preserve and the critical wildlife area. So we wanted to bring this to your attention on this. Particular issue prior to the vote. So it's out in the open and it's clear that that's the. Proposal in their own report. So maintenance dredging I think is code for regular dredging. Um they already have the rfp that allows them to go to 8 or 9ft. And so this is the new piece of information. The other thing is if you look at this image in their own. Report. >> you can see how large the vessels are that they're trying to. Attract uh to this area. You know, they're over. 80ft and you can see that those two new slips, those two new piers if you will jet out. 600ft beyond where it is today. So you might only have two new slips, but the area and size of those slips are much bigger. So remember biscayne bay is a shallow. Estuary and this is really catering to mega yachts. And so we wanted to put that on the record. >> for you all to consider. Thank you. Um MISS Reynolds just a quick question. Sure. You're referring to the drawings that were submitted by the. >> winning bidder the joint venture of rci and. >> suntex is. >> that right? That's correct. This is from their own report. Yep. Virginia key llc I think is the name that they that they use. Thank you very. >> much for showing us these drawings. Any questions or comments from me? I have a question. Is that the the. Existing. Tenant or that's the winning bidder. >> that's coming in? No this is the one that's out for voter referendum the winning yes or no correct. >> that we are voting on that's based on. 2017 filings. >> so so if we say yes we. Get those two extra slips. If we say no we do not get the turks. Is that what you're saying? If you say yes we don't know what you're going to get but this is in their proposal. Um if you say no you can go back to the drawing board and come up with what you really want. So we we. Recommend that you. >> vote this down. Okay. >> thank you thank you thank you peter thank you laura, I would propose that we pass a resolution. Opposing the rickenbacker marina llc. Uh, this dredging. Information is extremely. Troubling and a lot of other. >> aspects of the marina are troubling as well. Stephen thank you very much. Let's hear from the other board members and then we'll come back to you if you want to make a resolution. Thank you. >> um laura um [Laughter] Thanks laura I just I, I was wondering I have a question for you. Um you mentioned that biscayne bay aquatic preserve and there could be impacts has. >> the aquatic. >> preserve. Responded about this project at all? Not that I know of. I think during the process where they would then apply for a. >> permit they. Would but at this point they don't have an application before them. Okay so no. And um but I will say one thing there has been a lot of. Discussion about this area not being aquatic preserve or that area not being aquatic preserve and I want to make it clear that the aquatic preserve act, whether it's public or private land chapter. 1818 applies. Period full stop. So whether it's owned by the state, it's owned by the county or it's not you know, it's not even owned by the public. The. >> aquatic preserve applies. Thank you. Any other questions from any board members? Um laura thank you very much for the research. Um we'll go back to steve. Do you want to would you like to make a proposed. Yeah. I'd like to propose a resolution. Opposing uh, the current uh. Marina as uh the city take a position opposing the the current marina the. The referendum referendum three all right, so. >> you'd be asking the voters to vote no, ask the city to. >> yes, take take a position asking the voters to vote no, which would mean the city would . >> go. >> back to the drawing board and possibly there'd be a new rfp.. >> correct in the future. Um. Our city attorney could. >> probably flesh this. >> out a little more thoroughly. The city attorney is that clear? So right for the record. So it would be a. Resolution opposing. The the award of the marina. >> to the. >> new. >> the the top ranked bidder. Yes. >> I guess it's. Saying the same thing steve is saying slightly differently but so to be clear it wouldn't be requesting the commission to take any particular action. >> because at. >> this. >> point it just depends on the vote. So. Yeah um it would just be. >> opposing the. >> steve would be a recommendation to. >> voters to vote no. Correct are correct and and and the city to take that position as well whether they will or won't uh not I don't know the. Legalities if. >> they have taken that position or they can they take that. Position that the city cannot. Use because of the resources it would be. >> electioneering to try and sway the vote one way or the other. It's up to the voters to decide at this point. So so. >> our recommendation to the vote that would be our recommendation to the voters. All right. Is anybody any board member have a second for steve's motion? Actually I'll second it. Okay. We have a we have a second then we'll we'll have a vote on the. Item um discussion. Yes. >> so well let's discuss it. >> MR. Norwood. Certainly. >> um so the item is to um for this advisory board to make a. Recommendation to the public to. Oppose a a election. Um I, I don't think that that I would be very uncomfortable taking a. Position as a public body on a on an election. Um I, I believe that the the city can't even take a. Position on this item officially. And so we are a body of the city. So how could we take a. Position on an issue that the city we are not a separate. Institution from the. We are a part of the city so I would be I would wonder if our. >> city attorney would need to do a little bit more research to see if that is even possible. Yeah, I was I was just trying to look into that right now I think that that does require a little bit of research since we are since the cab is. >> a a agency of the city. So let me let me look into that a little bit. We are an advisory board of the city. Right. But do you think that that the item as. >> as. Drafted. >> was was too strong for this board to vote on? So so again. Essentially the city cannot take a. Position on on these items because it's up to the voters right. And we can't use city resources. Um so as this as it pertains to this particular board, I need to do a little bit more digging but most likely um you know, the point is well taken. It is an advisory board of the city and we are using city resources here. So it's something that we need to I just need to verify before I give you a final answer. So we have a motion and a second would either of you like to. >> withdraw your motion. I can I can I add it is our job to. Advise the best use of virginia key. And uh my position is and I hope the rest of this board will join me that this marina as proposed is not in the best interest of virginia key the the uh the digging that's uh the dredging that we now know needs to happen and will will happen. Uh, we we also know that the current, uh, lease. Parameters are are are dated are dated and they don't reflect current market conditions. We also have, uh, we've, we've had information that the current or the. Proposed. >> uh, winner of this rfp the court ordered, uh, tenant has had numerous. Violations at other. Properties and has not been good stewards of their marina. All right. MR. City attorney, can is it possible for us to vote without having it our voting. >> as a as a formal resolution can we vote informally on this item? I would just request that you leave this for later maybe defer you know, hold on. >> to it. >> until maybe later in the meeting so that I can have an opportunity to do the research and get back to you. Steve, do you mind if we hold off on this lewis all right. I'm okay. Thank you very much. Certainly incredibly important item to virginia key park. Um it's been getting a lot of publicity but let's we'll move on to the the next item on our agenda and our city attorney can do some research. Um, there's we want to discuss the request for the city or we would like to get an update on the city's application for 195 mooring. Is there a city executive that can provide some information on the status of the city's application for 195 mooring? Oh, and I just would like to show everybody a copy of the miami herald. This is a cover story dated SEPTEMBER 4th right around the time of I think our last meeting and the headline is virginia key is getting targeted for redevelopment and a wonderful aerial picture of the historic marine stadium basin and also another picture of the proposed 195 mooring that were provided to us by some wonderful advocates for virginia key basin. So um it was very, very nice for the herald to put this on the front page. Is there is there a city executive here to give us an update on where that application stands? Raphael somebody some knowledge on that item. MR.. MR. Department head. No. No update. Um okay. Um and then before the board discusses this item we'd like to I'd like to hear from the public. I see um a hand has been raised. Roger. >> good evening. Roger bernstein. Um. I live in the city of miami. I'm not speaking on behalf of the city, but I can say that after the meeting of this board, uh, district two commissioner pardo had an open meeting in this very room with very good attendance and come and cederberg who are the engineers who had laid out the mooring field, presented their plan and explained how it would come about and how it would be used. Um members of the public were allowed to speak. I had five minutes to talk about changes in state law which have given more power to miami-dade county to regulate its own waters before that law changed anything having to do with the waters here had to be regulated in tallahassee by the fwc. This is a liberalization. The county is actually moving forward. I think today they MAY have passed on second reading a no anchoring area for the waters of the county. So the message that I delivered at that public meeting was let's slow down here. We're looking at a plan from 2024 with 195 mooring anchors and it's no longer necessary to build that big in order to keep the intruding vessels out of the basin. And as you can see from that picture in the herald which I think was taken in AUGUST of this year, the basin is empty of vessels because of very good enforcement by the city marine patrol and fwc. That's wh

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Virginia Key Beach Advisory Board
  • Virginia Key Beach Advisory Board — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 94a3394945db2f139892af4d347c732f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record