POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Commerce and Tourism · Closed Captions

Wednesday, February 4, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Commerce and Tourism — Closed Captions

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Transcript or captions textCommerce and Tourism — Closed Captions

Showing the first 60,000 of 102,962 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> The Committee on Commerce and Tourism will now come to order. Rita, please call the roll chair Leek here. Vice Chair Arrington Senator Bracy Davis here, Senator Davis, Senator Deciglie Senator Mayfield, Senator MacLEAN Senator Smith. Senator Wright. Senator Yarborough a quorum is present. Thank you. Please. Silence all electronic devices and anyone wishing to speak before the committee should complete an appearance form and hand it to a member. The sergeants office. Should you select to waive your speaking time? Your position will be included in the committee records pre show Senate Bill 1456. Temporarily postponed by request of the sponsor. We will move first 2 tab, 3 Senate Bill 1236, by Senator Russell Center. So you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Good Morning members SB 1236. Is the employers receiving economic development incentives from state agency bill. This legis State Jean ensures the right to a secret are private ballot ELECTION on union representation for workers employed and corporations and entities receiving taxpayer-funded incentives in the state of Florida. Without the protection of a private ballot vote on unionization union can be certified after turning in a simple majority of support cards to the employer, even if those cards were collected from employees under duress. The states of Tennessee, Georgia and Alabama have all passed similar taxpayer and worker protections to ensure private ballot unions access for employees at state subsidized companies. And that is the bill. I will also say after some discussion with one of my colleagues, there was an issue of neutrality that came up that also included in this bill. And what neutrality is just as a function of definition is the ability of the employer to discuss union matters before the vote. I believe this is just purely a transparency issue. It allows both sides to be heard by the workers and something that we should do in a state that the holds freedom. So dear, another point of contention for this bill was any adjudication by the attorney general was to be final. And we're going to modify that if you all see fit move this bill forward. So it would follow current law in an appeal process and that Mr. Chairman is the bill. Thank you, members. Are there any questions of the sponsor? Any questions of the sponsor seeing no questions. I have a question for you. Welcome to the committee. You're recognized for questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, thank you. Senator Massullo. I'm curious about in Inc force meant on the bill. We're we're on the amendment right? Are we on that link them to there? There is no amendment if you're on swear on Senate Bill 1236, okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So my question is still around the enforcement. So walk us through the authority that I think the attorney general has in your bill too investigate. >> Violations of the law. And why are we using the office of the Attorney general for enforcement? Senator Russell? >> Thank you, chair. Well, these are companies that are getting tax incentives from the state. So we believe that turn in general would be the into the king entity. And as you as you see in our direct to line one, 42 with the bill itself and which reads, the attorney general's findings are final. 2 men that to the processes of appeal there currently in law. Any further questions understood. Yeah, yes, Mister Chair, thank you. >> So I have questions about how this bill might conflicts with federal law. So my understanding is that National Labor Relations Act, you know, really Gover governs the private sector late labor relations. And they they actually the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that states in particular can't regulate conduct in areas that Congress intended to to, to leave open for free play of economic forces as it relates to union organizing. So is there is there concern about a potential preemption from the federal government that this is in conflict with that Senator Massullo Senator Muscle? >> Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you for that question. Senator Smith. First of all, we're not requiring anything in this particular bill to any private entity. The NLRB, the in our allows registration to a union by both secret ballot or we're just saying that if we're going to give tax incentives, we will choose those companies that have unionized through secret ballot because we believe that gives the workers the most protection and is as transparent as far as the process. Just as someone who voted for you or someone who voted for me or someone who voted for governor or someone who's going to vote for our president next president. >> Just real quickly. And this is just a reminder to the to the senators and members of the committee. If you have to be somewhere else, please make sure you check in with us because sometimes you walk out with a score and then we have stopped the process. If you don't want to check in with us before before walking out, that would be great. Senator Smith, you're recognized for question. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you, Senator Massullo on the on the and the incentives part. I know that there is a definition in the bill, particularly around economic development incentive, but it it feels like the definition is is quite broad. I'm curious, would the definition in here of economic development incentives with that cover sales tax breaks that are our sweeping and and broad in nature that that lots of businesses benefit from from like Senate tax packages and things that we do here in the legislature does it include expedited permits? Doesn't include infrastructure improvements. Like what? What types of economic development incentives are you envisioning are included within this definition. If you have any examples. Senator Russell. >> Thank you. Mister Chair you gave to that would be into that wouldn't be okay. An expedited permit without a tax incentive would not necessarily be. Let's give you the example of an affordable housing project where they're using both state and federal tax credits for that project. That project would would be incorporated in in this structure. This bill shouldn't move forward. Thank you, Mr. Chair. >> I know that some big companies in particular, Microsoft, 18 t a lot of automakers that they have currently to have neutrality agreements with their with their workforce. My understanding is that neutrality agreements are prohibited under your bill. >> And if they're not prohibited, okay, their authorized. We want neutrality agreements. >> Okay. So you do. You want the neutrality agreements. So what this bill would it reject companies applications for Florida economic development incentives? I mean, are they just not authorize if they have this? I'm trying to understand how that plays in here. You're recognized chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you again for the question. >> The bill basically states that if the state is going to seek to give an incentive that's defined by the language to a particular entity entity would have to follow the precepts of this bill, which would include unions. They if they are unionized by secret ballot and you have a neutrality agreement. >> Thank you. And just it just a clarification because I want to make sure that I'm not confused about the bill. My understanding is in order for a company to be eligible for economic development incentives, you're seeing employers must sign agreements stating that they will not sign neutrality agreements with labor organizations. But I just heard you say that they're required to that. They're authorized to have a neutrality agreement. Help me understand the discrepancy there. You're recognized and it may be on me one 0nd. Let me just thank you, Mr. Chair Senator Smith. Can you get back to you with that answer? Absolutely. And and I think I can answer it for. >> Our chair may have to recuse align. 94. Yes, certainly tralee agreement means an agreement signed by the employer and the Union which the employer agrees to conditions, including but not limited to committing not to speak to the employees about union issues. I was incorrect. You are correct. They cannot have that in place. >> Thank you for the clarification. I want to make sure that that I didn't get it wrong because those those large companies that I had mentioned, Microsoft, TNT, they currently do have neutrality agreements that would be not allowed under your bill for them to be eligible for an economic development incentive. So is it prospective for new incentives in the future or is it retroactive that they would if you have to pay back economic incentives they received in the past? How does that work? Senator Russell? >> Thank you. Chair. I think you would only pertain to what happens after this law was enforced. Okay. There's no provision in the bill that talks about retroactivity. Senator Smith. >> Gotten questions. Thank you, Mister Chair. Thank you, members any further questions. Senator Engine. >> Thank you, Chairman. Good. Good morning. I was said good afternoon. Good morning, Senator Massullo, appreciate or conversation earlier and just following up with a few other questions. Thank you, Senator Smith for the neutrality question of that, something we had discussed beforehand. So glad for the clarification on that. >> Are there. Do you have Senator, any examples where a company that recognized a union, the card check basically failed to meet the economic development goals of their incentive agreement? >> Thank you, chair. No, but that were truly isn't the purpose of the bill. The purpose of the bill is that the the state wants to be sure that employees that are actually within that particular company have been able to vote for the union, the secret ballot. Senator and 2. >> Thank you, chairman. I also saw something Senator Massullo that said that the bill allows any person or entity to file a complaint and there's not a requirement that they have a connection to the employer. The workers involved. Are we, I guess, worried that, you know, outside forces or maybe like a business competitor could file a complaint, Tim, a sickly kind of trigger or start an investigation to maybe. >> Tie up or stop a a competitors incentive. >> Senator Russell, thank you, Mr. Chair. No, we don't have a concern about that. Any further questions, members, any further questions seeing? No further questions. There are a number of appearance forms. I'm gonna ask you all because we have so many appearance forms of so many people speaking that if somebody said something in front of you, that's very similar to what you're saying. Feel free to waive. Try to keep your comments to something that is unique and we'll try to move through these as quickly as we can. The first first one I have is checked both speaking for or waive speaking. So I guess it's my choice. George means. Next up, we have David Osborne speaking for. You're recognized. >> Thank you so much. And thanks to the committee for considering this important issue. Given that we have a lot of speakers here. I think I'll just address some of the issues that I've heard so far this morning, namely issues raised by Senator Smith over here. So preemption, the nlra, the National Labor Relations Act, a federal law that generally comers in this area card check and neutrality these these are actually methods by which companies and unions can avoid and or be procedures. And so there is no preemption issue. What this bill would do is provide incentives that would encourage an employer to make a choice and to make the choice. That is actually the one set forth by the NLRB, which is a secret ballot election. Us about examples of tax incentive programs. I think the analysis cover some of this on Page 9 and they've got high impact, performance incentives, capital investment tax credits. A number of those I think would be helpful in understanding how for this might go neutrality agreements to let me address that and a trial agreements, something union would like to secure from employer before they begin the process of unionization. But it's not really neutral. And that's I think part of that confusion here. It's really it it ensures that the employer will be quiet and not share any of its views on the matter. But the union is allowed to recruit, make promises. And with card check actually course individual employees into signing cards and deprive them of a secret ballot election. So it's actually more of a one-sided. I'm kind of mechanism not neutral. And then finally we talked about whether this would be a prospective measure or not line 158 of the bill talks about this applying only to agreements entered into after July 2026. So on no issues there as well. I'm happy to cover anything else on the bill if you have any questions. Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. Next up, we have Ross most speaking against while he's coming up. We have Derek Tabor, Schaffer waiving in support. You're recognized, sir. >> Thank you for having us here today. I've got a a lot of thoughts on this bill. I'm not seeing a direct benefits attacks player, but I am seeing that this could have negative repercussions on businesses that look to employee highly skilled individuals were great pay and benefits. And the fact that this bill could possibly reach out 20 years retroactively to hurt a company in the future really seems like we're limiting possible growth. Just doesn't really seem like a good stance force. But appreciate you hear me out on this. Thank you. Thank you very much, sir. Next up, we have Andy Starling speaking against Starling. >> We also have looks like Jeanne Ford waiving against you're recognized, sir. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yeah. Echoing what sort of love for the said. A big concern I have is on growth from my understanding read the bill that there's a 20 year provision for a call back and that ties a prime contractor to the actions a subcontractor may take. They can do one job 15 years ago that got over 5 million dollars in incentive. And then this subcontractor 15 years down the road, get right to unionize and to do a voluntary card check off the stage to give back to a prime contractor. That was they worked with 15 years ago and have no other further Bill did business dealings with and it could and tried to report recall that that money from them. And I just think that that is a that is setting of red tape and lawsuit and almost like a to tear bidding system to wear a general contractor just out of fear of will future lawsuit could be they would choose not to use skilled local union labor because they don't want future litigation and try to get those things of the they don't want to lose money in the future. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Next up, we have doctor Rich Templin. >> We're waiting. We have Thomas. I think it's owes us a second waiving against good morning, Mister chairman. Hoping maybe in the future you can set up like a punch card for how many times we appear and commerce because my punch card would be full. Yeah. >> And I want to say at the outset, I apologize that I did not can opportunity speak with the bill sponsor. I think he knows the respect and admiration I have for him. And so I do apologize for that is a complex issue and we've been trying to boil it down. But the interplay between federal law, the NLRB, state law, public private, it's complex and and the cheers to the staff analysis because you guys did a fantastic job on that and I apologize. I did not silence my electronic device related to rule number one. Yes, sir. Wow. Yeah, right. But I don't want to get into the complex. The I want to talk for just a second about governing philosophy governing philosophy of the majority in the Legislature for over 10 years, we fought over Preemptions where local governments asked their contractors to make agreements and their subcontractors to pay higher wages, better benefits. And those preemptions were were pushed under the governing philosophy. That government should not tell businesses how to operate. Government should not tell businesses how to operate. We should not weaponize government funding so that the government can control private businesses, that that's what I heard for 10 years. Those preemptions of all pass that issue is finished. But imagine my confusion when now it appears the governing philosophy is if there is taxpayer money involved, government money involved, the government can now tell a private business owner how to operate their business because that's exactly what this bill is doing. Business owners enter these card check agreements with labor organizations because they think it's best for their business. They think it's best for their employees, a variety of reasons, but it's their choice. It and somebody mentioned choice a few minutes ago. This bill actually eliminates choice. It literally says, hey, if you're gonna get any state money, you can't do this, even though you might think it's best for your business, invest for your workers and best for you. So we would ask you to vote no on this legislation just to be consistent with the governing philosophy. I've heard out of this chamber for over a decade that we do not want government interfering with the operations of private businesses. And that's exactly what this legislation does. And I hope that you all remember that remember that governing philosophy, because if we're going to, if we're going to turn it on its head, if we're going to say, oh, it's OK for government to tell private business owners how to operate. I've got a whole bunch of suggestions for you and I'd love to share. So thank you, Mr. Chairman very much in that. I hope you don't take my punch card. >> Thank you. Next up, we have Nicholas Pan, Johnny and a reminder audience members you in particular maintain the decorum. There's no clapping or any kind of. Yeah. Thank you. We're waiting here. We've got Ryan's comet waiving against. You're recognized, sir. Good morning, senators. Thank you. >> My name is Nick and going from the free city of Gainesville Senate Bill 1236. Punishes contractors who want to use skilled labor to help complete jobs around the state. Not only will this hurt the contractors, mostly the smaller ones, but also thousands of workers in Florida who want to work. Essentially this is big government telling private businesses what to do. Let the free market decide who to hire free burdensome government regulations. It's bad for workers. It's bad for employers. It's bad for Florida. Please vote no. Thank you, sir. >> Next up, we have Shane trembling speaking against while he's walking up. We have Janet looks like Moody waiving against you're recognized, sir. Thank you, chair. >> So I work as a journeyman electrician in Jacksonville, Florida. My livelihood relies on the success of our local contractors to secure work for us. If this bill were to pass, our contractors be punished simply for trying to find are trying to use the local workforce that works under collective bargaining agreement. That's been voluntary recognized as such. This bill is a direct attack on my livelihood. Furthermore, a critical part of workforce development and Jacksonville is are registered apprenticeship programs. I'm a product of an apprenticeship program. Was life changing for me. These programs with thousands of men and women to work, provide them with competitive skills, valuable career and enable them to support their families. This bill would greatly hurt these apprenticeship programs by reducing the amount of good on us work being made available to them, whether they're local contractors, building trade workers apprentices. This bill has many victims and virtually no beneficiaries that I can see. I urge you to vote no on this bill and allow or local contractors to compete and secure us work. Thank you. >> Thank you, sir. Next up, we have Theresa King speaking against while we're waiting. Christina Underwood waves Michael Greenan waves against Glenda. >> Waves against thank you for the weather was very helpful recognized. Thank you, Chair Lake and committee members. Good morning. My name is Theresa King. I am a charter memoir meant trying by a registered apprenticeship program through the contractors who come to utilize our services for skilled labor and the skilled labor is second to none with in our union trades, we are trained safely. We are trying to save the contractor money but putting a job in right the first time the right way. Small contractors that come to us for our skill. Labor should not be penalized because they want to use skilled labor and to utilize and self reinvest back into the apprenticeship program. So they have a rotating new workforce at all times to build the state of Florida. Arif, true back on track after job is done just because the intent of the bill may say that you used an opportunity for card checks. We don't do card checks with the contractor. Are unions do that? Then we do not penalize the contractor that works in their home community in there. Districts stay. They train vocal. They were local. We were want local skilled craftsmen to be able to live and work in their area and the and or it says says specifically that our rights under the Constitution should not be taken away from us. I want very much so to talk with you truly an honest conversation with no duties and no ours behind our name strictly policy. And how can we? >> Have you understand who we are and who we represent is the workers and those small contractors generate money in that community to help these individuals have homes, the ability to buy cars even when their child gets 16 years old. >> They're able to do that with the health care and pension. That does not supersede an incentive that was given by using state funds when we can do the job right the first time and don't have to come back. >> It costs the community more money and back orders in change orders. I say this is the first committee stop and in that committee stop. I'm I am also I was a forty-year first-year apprentice. Risking I'm gonna ask you to bringing in for. I'll bring it in. Like if it was not for the private sector. I don't know that I would have been able to change careers and have 6 wonderful scales that could benefit state of Florida. Please allow us to have a conversation moving forward on how we can help you build this state with skilled manpower and or the private sector. Thank you. Thank you. Next up, we have Larry Downes Junior. >> We're waiting on Mr. Brown Downs. We have Derek the benik waiving against. We have John Meeks waiving against Amy Smith. Waiving against you are recognized, sir. >> Thank you much, Larry. Down Junior Plumbing LLC because fecal matters. All right. It does. I I try to anticipate things are going to happen in the committee meeting. I didn't see that one coming. Well, listen, I'm I'm I'm a 4th generation of 3rd generation master plumber for generation plumber. My 2 sons are Palmer's also so 5 generations. And like, like the the gentleman said of a few up, you know, I thought we were about limited government limited, but it seems like every time there's another bill come, it's about more government and more overreaching, more nanny state telling us what we can do, what we can't. I don't know if you all know this or not, but for over a decade for every 5 tradesmen, the dire retire, there's 2 replacement here in the United States. You know, my my wife's a math and science teacher. And and so you think these people are good at math? I mean, I don't know how we're going to keep our the existing structures. We have maintained if we don't get some more of it and every low that Mike is another barrier. Also business owner, Larry Downes Junior Plumbing, LLC for Generation Business owner. You know, so what we're talking about here is more Reg. One more encroachment. Let's just say that lets you something nice, more encroachment on our freedom to be able to do whatever we want. If you look through all that, all the House bills and all the Senate, bill's, it's just reeks of more and more government, you know, overreaching and you all know it. We all know it. Everybody knows it would just don't know how to stop it because people can't say no. They just can't say no. And I don't know if it's a lobbyist. I mean, we know we know a little bit about that. But I'm just saying in general and speak on that I'm here. But please just stop making laws. We got enough already. I think we've got enough. Thank you. Next we have Richard. >> Second toes waiving against forgive me if I mess that up, we looked like we have George E Botelho waiving against Gordon long half are waiting waiving against Dillard any Abbott waiving against and that concludes our appearance card members. We're in debate. Is there debate Senator Smith in debate. Thank you, Mister Chair. >> So and I also want to apologize to Senator Massullo for not having the opportunity to have a real dialogue about this bill before the committee with so many pills being heard. This bill feels a lot like a union busting bill, although it feels like a very creative union busting bill. And I say creative because I'm coming from the perspective that I feel like the Legislature has done a very good job of union busting in the past. And I wasn't sure that there would be much left on the table to do that. And that's why I say that this feels like creative Union busting because I just didn't imagine that that this would be a thing that could be done. I think that on the issue of the neutrality agreement, I think it's important to to understand what we're talking about. So we're taking away the ability of employers to enter into these neutrality agreements if they want to be eligible for the economic development incentives and just so that we're all in the same page neutrality agreement is a voluntary contracts that the employer enters into with employees where the employer is is choosing not to speak on union matters and they're doing this for a number of reasons. They want to respect the rights of union workers. I don't want to run the risk of being perceived as being anti union. If they do speak on the matter because that can disrupt and otherwise harmonious workplace environment that they have and and have the freedom to to not speak and maintain that neutrality right now by coming in and saying that we're prohibiting these neutrality agreements. The bill is compelling employer speech in the form of their freedom to not speak and be neutral, which is a violation of their First Amendment. I know that you're planning an amendment. The provision around the attorney general's involvement in enforcement on the bill. I've seen this trend and other bills this session. And while we haven't seen the amendment yet, I have to vote on the bill as currently written. And and I think this this at maybe new trend of bills being proposed in the legislature right now where we're putting the enforcement in the office of the attorney General Feet feels like it will be political enforcement of the issue where the attorney general will then who is going to be a political actor regardless of who's elected to that position. Currently, I'm an elected that they're getting it weaponize enforcement to go after political enemies. And in many cases, those political enemies are unions. So I don't know if if the amendment is going to be a removal of that language of the attorney general's involvement or if it's just going to be a modification. But I am I am very concerned about that provision and that trend in bills that we've seen unrelated to this one, but also in this one this legislative session. So I'm gonna respectfully vote no on this bill today, but look forward to working with the senator Mesilla to see what can be done to improve the Bell. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Yarborough in debate. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair just briefly, Doctor Massullo. You're very thoughtful and all the bills that you bring to us all support the bill today. But I am taking into account what all of our speaker said today and appreciate that. They all came to give their input. You also have a very thoughtful house sponsor. And I see that's just starting its way through the process, too. So I know they'll be a lot of a lot of additional discussion. I'm hearing you have an amendment. So look forward to working with you on that. I know you give it the attention that it needs. Thanks. >> Senator Bracy Damien, thank you very much. Davis in debate. >> Okay. Thank you so much, Mister Chair. I think it's interesting. I the gentleman came and talked about all he wants a small government and usually that is the position of the majority party with small government. But here we are. I wasn't able had to present a bills. I was unable to ask questions. But there's something that I heard today that I would love Senator, for you to address in your close. The gentleman came to the microphone and said this is a direct attack on my livelihood. And we know that we are in affordability crisis. Even still we know that Floridians are having a hard time making ends meet. So I'd love for you just to address that when you have Floridian saying that this is a direct attack on my livelihood for the sponsor to address that statement in his close. Thank you. >> Thank you. Any further debate seeing no further debate. Senator Pizzo, you're recognized to close. >> Thank you, Mister Chair and I I want to thank all the individuals that came and testified. And, you know, I want to say something about what this bill is intended to do and what it's not intended to do. It's not intended to control how businesses operate. It's intended to control how the state actually operates. So this is regulation for us, the state and how we choose subcontractors and contractors that will get incentives from our taxpayers because our our particularly purview is how to spend those taxpayer dollars. The main intent of this bill is to look at those unions that have either and a card type ballot, a secret ballot. And we would prefer those that have a secret ballot because we believe those individuals have and an course choice in the matter of being a union, the issues of neutrality and the issues of subcontractors or something that I've heard very loudly and I will work to make sure people are excluded as far as apprenticeships. There's the small subcontractors, the individuals that have come up here today to feel that we are trying to address their livelihood because that is definitely not the intent of this bill. It's not my intent and it's not the intent of what the legislation wants to actually advance. So I would ask for your favorable support today and I will give you my promise that we will make this into a product that does exactly what it's intended to do, which is just to allow the same type representation for the people that work with the state in these incentives as we have when we vote for absolutely anybody in office. Thank you. Please call the roll on Senate Bill 1236. >> Senator Bracy Davis. Now Senator Davis, Senator Deciglie Senator Mayfield. Yes, senator MacLEAN Senator Smith know Senator Wright. Yes, senator Yarborough. Yes. Senator Arrington. No. >> Yes. By your vote show. Senate Bill 1236, reported favorably. Thank you. Committee. Hope you have a great day. Thanks or same to you. Next up, we'll take up tab one committee substitute for Senate Bill 198 by Senator Rouson Senator Rouson. You are recognized to explain the bill. Thank you very much, Mister Chairman and thank you members for hearing this bill Senate bill. 198 is about protecting Floridians, especially seniors from a very real and growing form of fraud via the use of cryptocurrency kiosks, which physically resemble ATM's. People are being victimized by scams with their and instructed to withdraw large sums of cash and deposit it into cryptocurrency kiosks. Once that cash is converted into cryptocurrency and sent oftentimes to an overseas crypto wallet, the money is gone right now. There is significant lack of oversight of these kiosks. That lack of guardrails makes these chaos, the tool of choice for scammers. The bill creates a new part in chapter 506, Florida statutes to regulate these kiosks. It requires kiosk operators to register with OFR Office of Financial Responsibility and Disclose the physical address of each chaos operating in the state. They also required to have documented policies for the use of blockchain analytics to detect fraud. The bill also requires mandatory fraud warnings to customers. This will be displayed on the machine before a transaction. Secondly, daily transaction that months of $2000 per day for new customers per Calendar Day defined as an account best in 7 days old and $10,000 per day for existing customers. It requires detailed electronic receipts. It requires fund refund protections for first time transactions involving non us wallets. When fraud is reported with the police report or affidavit, the refund must be issued within 72 hours. And the kunst customer must notify the business and law enforcement within 60 days and provide a police report or notarized affidavit without action. The scams will continue to grow and more Floridians will be will lose their savings with no recourse. This is not an anti crypto bill. It does not ban cryptocurrency. It does not restrict lawful investment or target industry itself. Our goal is to make sure that Floridians who choose to engage with cryptocurrencies can do so safely without fear of scams or exploitation. This bill closes a loophole that bad actors are exploring through unregulated kiosks and that's the bill. >> Thank you, Senator members. We're in questions or questions of the sponsor. Any questions of the sponsor seeing no questions of the sponsor. There are some appearance forms. First up, we have Eric Baker speaking for information. Always walking up. We have Christopher Hodge. Christopher waiving in support. >> Good morning, Chairman Leek Vice Chair Arrington members of the committee. My name is Eric Baker. I'm the director of advocacy for Sit. She Action Fund. We're a non-profit, non-partisan digital asset policy organization. And I'm here today to speak in support of SB 198. innovative approach to protecting Floridians for cryptocurrency fraud with respectfully while also respectfully suggesting a targeted amendment to better balance consumer protection with consumer financial access. First, let me be clear. This is a strong Bill. Florida is poised to become a national leader in Crypto kiosk regulation in Senator Rouson deserves recognition for crafting a bill that takes fraud prevention seriously without stifling innovation SB 198. Get several critical things right that many states MS the mandatory blockchain analytics requirement. This requires operators to screen transactions against known criminal wallet addresses. This is a cutting edge approach and will prevent fraud before it happens. According to a third-party study from Trm Labs, 98.8% of the volume of cash to crypto transactions are indeed legitimate. And with the increase in blockchain, tracing technology that percentage of fraudulent transactions should only decrease from there. This is the future of compliance in Florida would be ahead of most states by making it mandatory. Second, this 72 hour refund a provision. This is real consumer protection here with with teeth. This cooling off period gives victims time to realize that they have been scammed and and request a full refund. Now, law enforcement tells us that most most victims of fraud recognize that something nefarious has happened within the first few hours. So this provision recognizes that that distinction. 3rd, the receipt requirements transaction ashes, Wallet, addresses and refund policies on every digital receipt gives victims and law enforcement the tools they need to properly investigate any misuse and potential fraud. And lastly, the registration framework is also really well designed to that said there are 2 key areas that this where this bill could be improved. And I hope this committee could consider modest amendments. Currently, the bill imposes a permanent 10,000 a dollar daily limit on all existing customers. This is more restrictive than necessary and punishes existing users keeping permanent strict limits after the high-risk period is almost like requiring a 25 year olds to retain their learner's permit when driving on the street instead of getting a full driver's license, it assumes all customers are permanent fraud risks, which isn't necessarily supported by the data fraud overwhelmingly targets new users who don't understand how cryptocurrency works and could be the victims of fraud. After someone is completed several transactions, the risk profile changes dramatically and it restricts legitimate use cases for Floridians. A regular lead transact in cryptocurrency. A small business owner may be buying crypto currency every week or someone sending remittances back to family. These aren't fraud victims. There informed users who are using these kiosks is a real cash, a crypto service. And this bill also possess seven-day, new customer period. It may be minor, but we believe the data supports a five-day new customer period. More accurately when fraud is highest. Ultimately this bill is strong and will protect. Protect Floridians will allowing the industry to operate responsibly. And with just a couple modest adjustments, it it would strike the perfect balance. So I encourage this committee to Advance SB 188 and show that Florida Florida is on the cutting edge of protecting consumers. Thank you, Mr. Record. Next up, we have David Garner speaking for the bill and we have Brian joggers waiving in support. >> You're recognized. Thank you. Chair ranking member members of the committee. I'm David Carter. I'm assistant vice president of the Florida Bankers Association. We represent community Banks, State chartered national Banks. I'm going to keep it brief for you guys today, but I'd like to thank the sponsor for this good Bill. We have found that our customers, especially vulnerable adults, are being scammed us and large sums of money through VC case. And this bill will help stop that fraudulent activity. So thank you. Thank you very much, sir. Next up, we have Karen Murillo speaking for. You're recognized. >> As you can see from some of the red shirts in the room behind me, AARP is here to proudly support Senate bill 198. And we ask for your favorable support as well. We thank Senator Rouson for filing this very good bill which protects older Floridians because older Floridians are being targeted on a daily basis and are losing millions of dollars every year. Florida has the second most second highest number of crypto ATM's across the state in the nation. And with over 3,000 of these operating without any daily transaction limits or consumer protections in place, we see older Floridians losing their life savings in a matter of a single transaction or a handful of transactions. If you look up anywhere in the news, you can find the headlines. Vietnam veteran last year and of the year who lost over $50,000 in a single transaction before law enforcement intervened and stopped him from putting in any more money. A retired teacher losing her life savings and now in danger of losing her home because of crypto ATM fraud. These stories are not the exception. They're happening on a daily basis. And daily transaction moments, including for existing users are the only way to reduce or minimize the impact to these frogs are having on older Floridians, Floridians of all ages, but especially older Floridians. When we talk about a daily transaction limit for existing users, think about your own bank and the policies that have been put in place to protect us at bank ATM's. There are limits in place for a reason sending somebody in the middle of the night to a smoke shop downtown with $10,000 or more in cash to deposit it into one of these kiosks is already a dangerous situation. So caps of this nature are essential to protecting older Floridians. We ask for your favorable support of this Bill. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Members. We are now in debate. Is there debate debate Senator Jen debate. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair Senator Rouson, thank you so much for bringing forward this really good Bill. Thank you for accepting my co-sponsor request. We've definitely gotten complaints from the community in situations that this is happened to not just our seniors but other individuals and just really appreciate you looking at a way to to help cut down on this. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Senator Wright in debate. Thank. Thank you very much, Mister Chairman. I too. Thank you for bringing this bill forward. This is this situation is causing a lot of additional work for a law enforcement agencies trying to and the staff so of cash money and it's happening way too often. So I think your your bill is very necessary and I'm certainly going to be up on it today. Thank you for doing this. Thank you. Any further debate seeing no further debates. Senator Rouson, you're recognized to close on the bill. >> I'll save most of my remarks for hopefully when this bill hits the floor. But it's not often that we have industry come in front of us and ask for regulation. And this is something that has been happening in our communities. And I want to give a shout out to Kimberley Druggy, formally with TBA connecting with Kim, a community leader in South Hillsborough County that brought this to my attention and all Deputy Sheriff Jeff Mary of the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office. Thank you with that. I close. >> Thank you, sir. Please call the roll on committee substitute for Senate Bill. 190. >> Senator Bracy Davis. Yes. Senator Davis, senators diciglie Senator Mayfield. Yes, senator claim. Yes, senator Smith. Yes. Senator Wright. Yes. Senator Yarborough Senator Erin Tenn. Yes. Chair leek. >> Yes by your vote. Please show committee substitute for Senate Bill. 198 reported favorably. Thank you very much. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Members. We will now move to tab 4 Senate Bill 1356, by Senator Garcia. Senator Garcia, you're recognized. Thank you, chair. >> Thank you so much for the opportunity of presenting Senate Bill 1356, which is a work in progress. So where do I start in my district? And I'm sure many other districts dogs are bred and sold with no oversight, often in very inhumane conditions living in filthy basement with barely enough food and water. This bill aims to end this practice and protect our pops. The rules in this bill that that is a work in progress, address spacing and sanitation for cages and pens, access to clean water limits on breeding frequency for female dogs, proper shelter for females and leaders. And the rules must be verified by the Board of Veterinary medicine for effectiveness. Also, local governments can adopt stricter standards. If that should be the case. The bill creates consumer protection for pet sales and financing. Agree agreements when financing the financing agreements must be terminated without penalty. If the animal is returned, the financing turns must be disclosed to the consumer before the sale in all animal and the all of the animal records are verified and there must be a mandatory three-day waiting period before signing financing agreements. Violations of the financing terms are first-degree misdemeanor and considered unfair trade practices under Chapter 501. Finally, this bill mandates dog breeder registration. If it requires breeders must register with the Department of Business and Professional regulations every 2 years. And then to show compliance with this management practices violation of the best management practices, including overcrowding, unsanitary conditions over breeding lack of water and exposure to extreme temperatures trigger criminal penalties and placement on a public animal abuser database. The bill has an amendment, sir. >> Thank you. Members. Are there any questions on the bill before the amendment will get ample opportunity to ask questions against almost rate to the amendment is one Amendment Amendment bar Code 6, 9, 5, 2, 1, 2, by Senator Garcia. You're recognized to explain the amendment. >> Thank you, chair. This basically removes the section of the bill. It requires the Department of Agriculture and consumer protections to have oversight of local animal shelters. Are there questions on the amendment seeing no questions on the amendment. >> Are there appearance forms on the amendment seeing no appearance forms? Is there debate on the amendment seeing no debate on the amendment. Senator Garcia, you're recognized to close on the amendment includes all in favor of the amendment signify by saying Yea, the amendment is adopted. We are back on the bill as amended. Are there questions on the bill as amended questions on the bill as amended seeing no questions on the bill as amended. There are appearance forms. First up, we have George Tummies speaking against against information sense or you're a little bit of everything down. There you go. >> Chairman members, thank you for your time today. Appreciate it. My George to me to represent pet land and we have tend franchise stores in Florida playing over 234 Floridians are store still nearly 9,000 puppies a year. Many of which are probably the homes of your friends and family Pentland is committed to improving animal welfare and to sourcing animals solely from USC licensed breeders. We applied my good friend, Senator Garcia for filing legislation seeks to put an end to puppy Mills. A goal that my client wholeheartedly supports and for willingness to meet with us. And listen to my many concerns, our client support group, overwhelming provisions of this bill. It's probably to the tune of about 80%. And so and that speak directly to the issue of improving animal. Well, for, for example, we support requiring the peace be source from reputable breeders, requiring the disclosure to the consumer of all medical exam to medications administered to the puppy prior to sale and retention of sales record for 7 years. These are all things that my client does today. However, therefore provisions in the bill that will speak to briefly. We have serious concerns over that. We've shared with the senator, for example, the first one, the bill imposes a three-day waiting period before a customer can take a puppy home. If he didn't, he he or she intends to finance the purchase. The general consensus among veterinarians in experts is that you want to minimize the time that a puppy is kept in a store. And once that puppy has bonded with a perspective family, it's preferable to take that puppy home so they can begin the process of bonding and socialization requiring that a puppy be kept an additional 3 days runs counter to that to that concept. It also creates a space issue for my clients in as much as we're unable to accept any new deliveries of new puppies. Well, that three-day waiting period is in effect. That would say in my research, the only other instance where Florida imposes a three-day waiting period is in Section 7.90, point 0, 6, 5, 5, where we put it on when you're buying a firearm and you're waiting for a background check. So essentially we're treating the purchase of a puppy, the same as if we're buying a gun, which to us makes a little very little sense. So we would respectfully request the removal of that three-day waiting period. The other provision of the bill with concerns over is current requirement that before we can sell an animal that we have to contact the shelter and make available space in our stores at our costs or the concerns is these are not our dogs. What if that dog bite somebody who's responsible for that? It's kind of like requiring Neiman Marcus is set aside for space at our cost to so products from target and they get to keep the proceeds then make a lot of sense. Another provision is current law, has we currently we're one of 20's, 22 states as a Florida Lemon law. It works well. It was intended to eliminate litigation under the provisions of the of current law. Consumers are provided reimbursement for that. Mary cost up to the cost of that sick puppy. This bill removes the cap and provides for unlimited reimbursement, which we think it's going to incentivize litigation to put it in perspective. 0.6, 1%. So less than one percent of all puppies purchase are subject to the floor dilemma law, which tells us that it's working. The last point is the bill, we believe incentivize litigation by making violations of any of its provisions, an unfair deceptive trade practice, which subjects reputable puppy Stuart, but pet stores to trouble damages and punitive damages. Attorneys fees, this is really did go to the issue of animal welfare. Billy just increases the cost on reputable pets or so for those reasons, those are concerns. We will look forward to continuing to work with Senator Garcia's this bill moves forward. Thank you for that. Thank you. Next up, we have Larry John Downes junior speaking against while he's coming up. We have Diana Ferguson waiving in support. We have Ellen Boggan off waiving in support. >> We have Brandon Johnson waiving against Mr. Downes you're recognized Larry Downes Junior Plumbing LLC because fickle matters anyways. We kind of pay for this show. We might as well try to make the best of it. I could speak on every item and this whole town. I mean, it's amazing. >> We don't encourage. I know. I know. I know. Even among town in Pensacola, they're like, oh, Larry, to yeah, after that, tell us we're doing too much. Yeah, I guess. But anyways, I mean, think about this which are doing is adding more and more red tape, which is something the Republicans talk about all the time. Well, friends, I'm a libertarian friends or Republican there, but they're doing great. Mike. Do you know what they're doing? They're all up there in lockstep. And it just imagine my agent, the amount of overreach not only which are trying to do here on the state level but the county and city level. I am boat. >> You know how many Mr. Downes if you could talk about the matter is of this particular time but it well where you're talking generally and philosophy. Appreciate it. But I know locus on this bill, if you could and try to bring it in for landing. Yeah. Alright, anyways, it goes too far. It goes too far. We've got we've got to stop making laws just to make laws is too much. And and every every love fact somebody and then somebody has to regulated and then somebody has to pay for that and then and then somebody gets a down and you can bring it in for land. I'm I'm bringing it in. I've only been here in a minute, but I heard intended of her on the every bill so far. It's not my intent. Our intent is good. I'm not saying you 10 a good saying that there's all kinds of problems. They come with good intentions and sometimes it's best to leave the freedom up to us. We don't need everything legislated, ridge-like, regimented, regulated and and to every extent. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Doubts that concludes the appearance forms we're in debate members. Is there debate Senator action in debate? >> Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you, Senator Garcia for bringing forward this bill and looking to work on this issue. This is an epidemic in the United States with how many animals are euthanized each year in our shelters. I think I saw in Florida that in 2023 almost 50,000 animals where Houston AISD which put Florida 4th in the nation for the amount of euthanasia. This is not a one thing is going to fix this. This is something that we have to come out from different angles and I appreciate you taking on and really appreciate that amendment. My worry was our local shelter does a good job. So appreciate you for that amendment to and just want to remind everybody adopter shop responsibly. Please thank you any further debate. >> Members, you may notice that this is one of a couple of bills that that has a similar subject matter. Expect those bills will will come together at some point time as it moves forward. But with that, Senator Garcia, you are recognized to close. >> And once again, I appreciate the opportunity to to this. I agree. It is. It's a difficult situation in particular with with our animals, dogs and cats. But it has been the wild wild west when it comes to dog breeding in Florida. And it causes a many, many problems as the gentleman stated. But breeding for-profit without regard for animal welfare isn't just bad business. It's animal cruelty. And we wanted to see how we can take various bites at the apple to try to mitigate this issue. One of them in particular big problem in Miami-Dade County are the backyard breeders, right? So we want to take a good ambitious and take a and actually put them under the microscope and see what we can do better. Retail stores taking a closer look at them. And also once again, seeing how weekend help our local animal shelters, which is where most of these animals and up. So the bill addresses the supply issue with breeders safety net with shelters and the demand consumer protections for you and the humane standards we should have for these animals. So the bill basically is about protecting the animals from cruelty and protecting consumers from fraud and hidden costs. It sets clear standards and forces accountability and ensures transparency and once again is a work in progress and I ask for your favorable favorable support. Thank you. Please call the roll on committee substitute for Senate Bill 1356. Senator Bracy Davis. Yeah. Senator Davis, Senator Deciglie. >> Senator Mayfield, Senator MacLEAN Senator Smith. Yes, senator Wright. Yes. Senator Yarborough. Yes. Senator into yes. Chair leek. >> Yes. By your vote show committee substitute for Senate Bill 1356. Reported favorably members. I'm off to present a bill. So I'll hand the gavel over to Senator Burton. Senator. >> Thank you. And best of luck to you, Mr. Chair and senators. Next up, we're going to go to Tab 6 which is SB 1720, to an application stores by Senator Calatayud Senator Calatayud. You're recognized to explain the bill. Thank you. Madam Chair, Senate Bill 1722. is related to app stores. Officers treat minors as adults capable of consenting to complex digital agreements. Children are pushed to accept terms granting access to sensitive data without parental consent. At 8 ratings are often inaccurate undermining parental control. Safety and privacy disclosures are difficult for parents to find at the moment. Download this particular bill requires AB stores to verify user ages requires verifiable parental consent for minors. Prohibits enforcement of contracts against minors without parental consent requires notice to parents of material at changes and clear disclosure of app content authorizes civil action by parents are minors grants enforcement authority to the Department of Legal Affairs and allows penalties for non-compliance. That is the bill. Madam Chair. Thank you. Members having the bill expands. Are there any questions seeing? No questions. We do have some appearance forms. First up, we have Larry Downes speaking against and then after Larry will be Julie Barrett and there you are recognized. Thank you very much. Let me tell you who I am again. All right. >> This is this just more. It's more. And I'm just trying to exercise my First Amendment rights here, which is which a lot of these bills comment hinder, including, you know, several here today. You know, sometimes you may not think that I'm getting to the actual agenda item, but I am so a matter of perspective, sometimes it takes people like me a little bit longer to get around to that to pulling it all together. You know what I mean? So please give me an opportunity to before shut me down anyways. How far have we come in the land of the free home of the brave? How far have we come from? Patrick Henry? Give me liberty or give me death if it will save one life. I mean that that's that's a that's a it's a big it's a huge contradiction of what our country was founded upon. It was founded on the basic principles of liberty, not own a unlimited nanny state government. This is a parent's responsibility. See here Uars government. You're taking the position of apparent again. Well, we've got to take care of these children because, you know, kinda act like, you know, in particular. But the whole government system acts like these children are y'all of raise 3 children. I've done a fine job. There's going to be parents who do really good and parents who do really bad. Guess what? That's live the or Lowe's, you'll create more problems you create. There's even there's even a quote, forget who doesn't. But it's a country with too many laws as a country with too many problems. I don't think we got problems are all the all the legislation, all the regulation, all the Reg amending of our lives. Dlc, more problems today are less. Do you see more poverty today or less? Do you see more homeless today or less? Real simple answer. Thank you. >> Thank you, Larry. And next up, we have Julie Barrett is speaking against and then after Julie will be Justin Hill. Julie, you are recognized. >> Thank you. Good morning chair and members of the committee. I didn't expect to be back so soon. But Alabama has a similar bill that just passed unanimously through the House. And I heard last week the sponsor was presenting it to the Senate. And he mentioned that it passed unanimously and no parents spoke out with concerns. So I am here today as a mother of 4 from Sarasota to bring you my concerns. I fled Washington State for the free state of Florida because of their anti parent laws. And what happened to my twin daughters in Washington. I care very much about protecting children and parental rights. This bill claims to protect children and empower parents. But it does neither if passed Senate Bill 1722. Will require every Floridian not just minors to hand over government ID, biometric data or other sensitive information just to download an app, add up interest and even grander love this bill because it shifts responsibility from the apps to the app store think or the app store as a door to a house. The bill locks that front door but at least all of the windows and the back door in the garage door wide open. Once the child gets permission to download an app, all of the in-app dangers are still there. So parents get a false sense of security and citizens give up sensitive personal data and children are not protected data. Security and privacy are major concerns with this policy. When you require identity identity verification for every user, you create massive centralized pool of highly sensitive information including government ID's birthdates addresses by a metric markers parental relationships and this data must be collected, stored transmitted and protected. We have seen repeatedly that no system is immune from breaches, not hospitals, not credit bureaus, not state agencies. Yet this bill will force millions of Floridians into a verification system with no clear standards for data, retention and deletion storage or breach notifications. Parents already have the tools they need. Apple's family sharing and Google's family link allow parents to prove every download set. Time limits, restrict content and monitor activity. Met. His own expert testified last week in Alabama on this very same policy about how she uses the tools with her 6 year-old the tools exist and they work and they don't require all Floridians to hand over their identity to big tech or the government. Supporters like the digital Childhood Alliance will claim that this bill truly empowers parents with oversight and closes a loophole in child protection us

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Commerce and Tourism — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 93cfe9de63b75aae8b8480f10082ff72. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record