POLISCOPE

The public record

LIVERMORE (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Decisions publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission

Tuesday, December 16, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

DECEMBER 16, 2025 Minutes PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES PLANNING COMMISSION DECEMBER 16, 2025 ________________________________________________________________ REGULAR MEETING 1. CALL TO ORDER – The regular meeting of the Planning Commission was called to order by Chairperson Yolanda Fintschenko at 7:05 pm, held in person at 1016 S. Livermore Avenue. ROLL CALL – Present: Chairperson Yolanda Fintschenko, Vice Chairperson Tracy Kronzak and Commissioner Jacob Anderson, Commissioner Nadine Horner, Commissioner Charity Steele. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chairperson Fintschenko led the Pledge of Allegiance. 2. OPEN FORUM Chairperson Fintschenko opened the public comment period. Joe Maraspini, representing Nor Cal Carpenters Union Local 713, discussed standards for safety, skills, leadership, and ethics. There were no more speakers, and the public comment period was closed. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR - NONE 4. PROJECT REVIEW – NONE 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS 5.1 Hearing to consider a request for Vesting Tentative Tract Map, Site Plan Design Review, and certification of an Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project, a for-sale 115-unit residential condominium project located at the northeast corner of South Livermore Avenue and Pacific Avenue. Recommendation: Staff recommend the Planning Commission adopt Resolutions:

PLANNING COMMISSION Minutes DECEMBER 16, 2025 1. Certifying the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and directing the Planning Manager to file a Notice of Determination with the Alameda County Clerk; 2. Approving Vesting Tentative Tract Map (VTTM) 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004; and 3. Approving Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006. Associate Planner Jennifer Ackerman presented the staff report. Nicole Geary, representing the applicant, Swenson Builders, explained the proposed Builders Remedy project, including improvements based on public input, goal for a high-quality residential community that complemented the surroundings and provided new opportunities for families to remain and live in Livermore. In response to Vice Chairperson Kronzak, Associate Planner Ackerman and Project Manager Florentina Craciun, LSA Associates, explained that the Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) analysis was based on impacts from the proposed project and the Level of Service Analysis (LOS) was based on the 60% vacancy rate of the existing development; and explained that the traffic analysis occurred in the CEQA review. In response to Commissioner Horner, Associate Planner Ackerman confirmed that the landscape island was conditioned to be moved 50-feet to the west to allow additional buffering of headlights. Chairperson Fintschenko opened the public comment period. Cathryn Villasenor stated she would miss the pet store, gym and Cypress Trees and suggested consideration of adequate emergency room infrastructure. Jason Lowery discussed the easement on Cabrillo Avenue, which was ignored by the project; suggested bollards for added traffic safety, remediation of the dry cleaner; and indicated support for the project based on the need for the location to be revitalized and the design. Mary Perner expressed disappointment in the exclusion of ground floor businesses; questioned how the affordable units would be monitored for continued affordability; expressed concern about traffic; and suggested new lighting intersection of Pacific and Dolores. There were no more speakers, and the public comment period was closed. Associate Planner Ackerman and Mark Pilarczyk, representing Swenson, confirmed that there were no easements on title. In response to Commissioner Horner, Associate Planner Ackerman referenced the

DECEMBER 16, 2025 Minutes PLANNING COMMISSION notice of preparation, notice of availability, and neighborhood meeting notifying the neighbors that rear access would be removed. Planning Manager Riley stated staff could provide a reminder to neighbors about access being closed off. Commissioner Horner commended staff on the communications and concurred that a reminder was appropriate. Commissioner Anderson confirmed the Commission’s roll in reviewing the EIR; suggested separate votes on the EIR certification and project approval; and suggested modifying the statement on the bottom of Page 423 to “potential for increased VMT.” Project Manager Craciun explained why the finding in the Final EIR was made. In response to Vice Chairperson Kronzak, Mr. Pilarczyk stated the AC units would be located on the end caps of the buildings. Project Manager Craciun explained that the application would have to show compliance with land use thresholds including location of AC units and noise evaluation during project approvals. ON THE MOTION OF VICE CHAIR KRONZAK, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER ANDERSON AND CARRIED ON A 5-0 VOTE, THE PLANNING COMMISSION ADOPTED THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION: Resolution 34-25 Certifying the final Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project and adopting California Environmental Quality Act Findings, and a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, with Exhibit B, Section 6-2 amended to read “may increase VMT.” Commissioner Steele acknowledged the concerns raised by the public and work done by staff and the applicant to mitigate the issues; and expressed preference for ground floor commercial. Commissioner Horner expressed appreciation for the project revitalizing a key piece of property in Livermore; and discussed the benefits from the project. Mr. Pilarczyk anticipated construction to begin in early 2027. Commissioner Anderson recognized the work of staff; and discussed the necessary tree screening between the neighbors and the roads; high quality exterior design; suggested cleanable and slip resistant flooring in the pool house; flaws with the project which the Builders Remedy prevented the Planning Commission from mediating; agreement with concern for lack of commercial opportunities; loss of low rent commercial space and locations for small businesses; frustration with the Active Transportation Plan and loss of safe bike ways; setbacks; purpose of building higher density including commercial spaces, walkability and bikability; and ability to address concerns with only a few units being lost. Vice Chairperson Kronzak commended staff and the applicant for the completeness of the EIR, which would ensure the site was environmentally clean; and discussed the desperate need of housing in California; frustration with the

PLANNING COMMISSION Minutes DECEMBER 16, 2025 process; the State usurping the City’s ability to make community appropriate developments, since it delayed certification of the City’s Housing Element; and limitation of the Planning Commission doing its job. Chairperson Fintschenko referenced the benefits from the project; concurred within the need to creatively encourage commercial spaces that would support walkable, livable and vibrant communities consistent with the goals of high-density housing and active transportation plan; and addressed the benefit of revitalization, correction to the bike parking, and one phase for development. Associate Planner Ackerman explained that street naming would occur prior to final map approval and the Building division and Fire Department would ensure the pool met all Health and Safety requirements to prevent drowning. ON THE MOTION OF COMMISSIONER HORNER, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER STEELE AND CARRIED ON A *4-0-1 VOTE, WITH VICE CHAIR KRONZAK ABSTAINING, THE PLANNING COMMISSION ADOPTED THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION: * “Per section 26.3 of the adopted Planning Commission Rules of Procedure; Vice Chair Kronzak did not announce their intention to abstain from the vote at the beginning of the item; therefore the abstention must rule in-favor of the motion; therefore the final official vote is 5-0.” Resolution 33-25 Approving Vesting Tentative Tract Map (VTTM) 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004 And Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006 for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project. 6. MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION – NONE 7. MATTERS INITIATED BY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF – NONE 8. ADJOURNMENT – at 8:40 pm to a Regular Planning Commission Meeting on Tuesday, January 6, 2026 at 7:00 pm, Civic Center Meeting Hall, City Council Chambers, 1016 S. Livermore Avenue.

PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA TUESDAY, DECEMBER 16, 2025 PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING – 7:00 PM MEETING PARTICIPATION INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND AT THE END OF THE AGENDA IN PERSON INFORMATION: CIVIC CENTER MEETING HALL CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1016 S. LIVERMORE AVENUE Yolanda Fintschenko, Chair Tracy Kronzak, Vice Chair Jacob M Anderson, Commissioner Nadine R Horner, Commissioner Charity L Steele, Commissioner Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. OPEN FORUM In conformance with the Brown Act, no Planning Commission action can occur on items presented during Open Forum. To provide public comment, please submit a speaker card. When your name is called, walk to the lectern to address the Planning Commission. Comments are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person, per item. The Chair may reduce the amount of time based on the number of persons wishing to speak. Open Forum will conclude after 30 minutes; however, if there are additional speakers, Open Forum will reconvene after Matters for Consideration. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar items are considered routine and are acted upon by the Planning Commission with a single action. Members of the audience wishing to provide public input must submit a speaker card. 4. PROJECT REVIEW 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS 5.1 Hearing to consider a request for Vesting Tentative Tract Map, Site Plan Design Review, and certification of an Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project, a for-sale 115-unit residential condominium project located at the northeast corner of South Livermore Avenue and Pacific Avenue. Recommendation: Staff recommends the Planning Commission adopt Resolutions: 1. Certifying the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and directing the Planning Manager to file a Notice of Determination with the Alameda County Clerk; 2. Approving Vesting Tentative Tract Map (VTTM) 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004; and 3. Approving Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006. Staff Report Attachments: 1. Location Map 2. Staff Analysis 3. Neighborhood Mixed Use Zone 4. Proposed Plan Set ROLL CALL Commissioner Charity Steele Commissioner Nadine Horner Commissioner Jacob Anderson Vice Chairperson Tracy Kronzak Chairperson Yolanda Fintschenko PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025

5. Transportation Analysis 6. T4N Zone 7. Letter to Existing Commercial Tenants 8. Resolution - CEQA 9. Exhibit A - Final EIR 10. Exhibit B Pacific and Livermore CEQA Findings 11. Exhibit C - Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan 12. Resolution - Project 13. Exhibit A - Conditions of Approval 6. MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION 7. MATTERS INITIATED BY PLANNING COMMISSION AND STAFF 8. SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIALS 8.1 Supplemental materials received prior to the meeting. Staff Report Attachments: 1. Supplemental Materials 9. ADJOURNMENT To a regular Planning Commission meeting on Tuesday, January 6, 2025 at 7:00 pm, Civic Center Meeting Hall, City Council Chamber, 1016 S. Livermore Avenue. 10. HOW TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING You can participate in the meeting in a number of ways: Open Forum is an opportunity for the public to speak regarding items not listed on the agenda. Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To address the Planning Commission you must submit a speaker card to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of that item. Please note that the Planning Commission is prohibited by State law from taking action on any items that are not listed on the agenda. However, if your item requires action, the Planning Commission l may place it on a future agenda or direct staff to work with you and/or report to the Planning Commission on the issue. Public Hearings - The topic of the hearing is typically summarized by staff, followed by a presentation by the applicant, and then questions from the Planning Commission. The Chair will then open the hearing to the public and offer an opportunity for public comments. Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To address the Planning Commission, you must submit a speaker card to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of the presentation of the item. Other Agenda Items are also open for public input including Consent Calendar or Matters for Consideration items. These comments are also subject to the 3-minute limit. Special Meetings, Workshops - The public will have the opportunity to address the Planning Commission regarding the item that is the subject of the special meeting or workshop. Public Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025

comments are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. Submission of Comments Prior to the Meeting: Email Comments may be submitted by the public to the Planning Commission Liaison (planning@LivermoreCA.gov). Items received no later than 12:00 pm on the day of the meeting will be provided to the Commission and available on the City website prior to the meeting. These items will NOT be read into the record. eComments may be submitted by the public using the eComment link here. Comments may be up to 1000 characters in length and will be accepted up until 6:00 pm the day of the meeting. These items will NOT be read into the record and are viewable by the the Commission and the public upon submittal. Submission of Comments During the Meeting: Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To submit a comment in person, you must complete a speaker card for each item. Speaker cards are available in the Civic Center Meeting Hall lobby. Indicate on the card the item number you wish to comment on and submit the card directly to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of the item. Please note that the Planning Commission is prohibited by State law from taking action on any items that are not listed on the agenda. However, if your item requires action, the Planning Commission may place it on a future agenda or direct staff to work with you and/or report to the Planning Commission on the issue. If you would like to deliver written materials to the Commission as part of your public comments, please provide 8 copies of to the Planning Commission Liaison with your speaker card. The Planning Commission Agenda and Agenda Reports are prepared by City staff and are available for public review on Friday evening, three days prior to the Planning Commission meeting at 1016 South Livermore Avenue, Livermore. The Agenda is also available on the City’s website, http://livermoreca.gov/agenda. Under Government Code §54957.5, any supplemental material distributed to the members of the Planning Commission after the posting of this agenda will be available for public review at City Hall, 1052 South Livermore Avenue, Livermore, and included in the agenda packet available on the City’s web site at http://livermoreca.gov/agenda. PURSUANT TO TITLE II OF THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (CODIFIED AT 42 UNITED STATES CODE SECTION 12101 AND 28 CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS PART 35), AND SECTION 504 OF THE REHABILITATION ACT OF 1973, THE CITY OF LIVERMORE DOES NOT DISCRIMINATE ON THE BASIS OF RACE, COLOR, RELIGION, NATIONAL ORIGIN, ANCESTRY, SEX, DISABILITY, AGE OR SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE PROVISION OF ANY SERVICES, PROGRAMS, OR ACTIVITIES. TO ARRANGE AN ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS PUBLIC MEETING, PLEASE Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025

CONTACT THE ADA COORDINATOR AT ADACOORDINATOR@LIVERMORECA.GOV OR CALL (925) 960-4170 (VOICE) OR (925) 960-4104 (TDD) AT LEAST THREE (3) BUSINESS DAYS IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING. Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025

Showing the first 24,000 of 984,255 characters. The full document is at the source.

PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA TUESDAY, DECEMBER 16, 2025 PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING – 7:00 PM MEETING PARTICIPATION INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND AT THE END OF THE AGENDA IN PERSON INFORMATION: CIVIC CENTER MEETING HALL CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1016 S. LIVERMORE AVENUE Yolanda Fintschenko, Chair Tracy Kronzak, Vice Chair Jacob M Anderson, Commissioner Nadine R Horner, Commissioner Charity L Steele, Commissioner Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025 1

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. OPEN FORUM In conformance with the Brown Act, no Planning Commission action can occur on items presented during Open Forum. To provide public comment, please submit a speaker card. When your name is called, walk to the lectern to address the Planning Commission. Comments are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person, per item. The Chair may reduce the amount of time based on the number of persons wishing to speak. Open Forum will conclude after 30 minutes; however, if there are additional speakers, Open Forum will reconvene after Matters for Consideration. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar items are considered routine and are acted upon by the Planning Commission with a single action. Members of the audience wishing to provide public input must submit a speaker card. 4. PROJECT REVIEW 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS 5.1 Hearing to consider a request for Vesting Tentative Tract Map, Site Plan Design Review, and certification of an Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project, a for-sale 115-unit residential condominium project located at the northeast corner of South Livermore Avenue and Pacific Avenue. Recommendation: Staff recommends the Planning Commission adopt Resolutions: 1. Certifying the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and directing the Planning Manager to file a Notice of Determination with the Alameda County Clerk; 2. Approving Vesting Tentative Tract Map (VTTM) 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004; and 3. Approving Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006. Staff Report Attachments: 1. Location Map 2. Staff Analysis 3. Neighborhood Mixed Use Zone 4. Proposed Plan Set ROLL CALL Commissioner Charity Steele Commissioner Nadine Horner Commissioner Jacob Anderson Vice Chairperson Tracy Kronzak Chairperson Yolanda Fintschenko PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025 2

5. Transportation Analysis 6. T4N Zone 7. Letter to Existing Commercial Tenants 8. Resolution - CEQA 9. Exhibit A - Final EIR 10. Exhibit B Pacific and Livermore CEQA Findings 11. Exhibit C - Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan 12. Resolution - Project 13. Exhibit A - Conditions of Approval 6. MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION 7. MATTERS INITIATED BY PLANNING COMMISSION AND STAFF 8. SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIALS 8.1 Supplemental materials received prior to the meeting. Staff Report Attachments: 1. Supplemental Materials 9. ADJOURNMENT To a regular Planning Commission meeting on Tuesday, January 6, 2025 at 7:00 pm, Civic Center Meeting Hall, City Council Chamber, 1016 S. Livermore Avenue. 10. HOW TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING You can participate in the meeting in a number of ways: Open Forum is an opportunity for the public to speak regarding items not listed on the agenda. Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To address the Planning Commission you must submit a speaker card to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of that item. Please note that the Planning Commission is prohibited by State law from taking action on any items that are not listed on the agenda. However, if your item requires action, the Planning Commission l may place it on a future agenda or direct staff to work with you and/or report to the Planning Commission on the issue. Public Hearings - The topic of the hearing is typically summarized by staff, followed by a presentation by the applicant, and then questions from the Planning Commission. The Chair will then open the hearing to the public and offer an opportunity for public comments. Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To address the Planning Commission, you must submit a speaker card to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of the presentation of the item. Other Agenda Items are also open for public input including Consent Calendar or Matters for Consideration items. These comments are also subject to the 3-minute limit. Special Meetings, Workshops - The public will have the opportunity to address the Planning Commission regarding the item that is the subject of the special meeting or workshop. Public Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025 3

comments are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. Submission of Comments Prior to the Meeting: Email Comments may be submitted by the public to the Planning Commission Liaison (planning@LivermoreCA.gov). Items received no later than 12:00 pm on the day of the meeting will be provided to the Commission and available on the City website prior to the meeting. These items will NOT be read into the record. eComments may be submitted by the public using the eComment link here. Comments may be up to 1000 characters in length and will be accepted up until 6:00 pm the day of the meeting. These items will NOT be read into the record and are viewable by the the Commission and the public upon submittal. Submission of Comments During the Meeting: Speakers are limited to a maximum of 3 minutes per person. To submit a comment in person, you must complete a speaker card for each item. Speaker cards are available in the Civic Center Meeting Hall lobby. Indicate on the card the item number you wish to comment on and submit the card directly to the Planning Commission Liaison prior to the start of the item. Please note that the Planning Commission is prohibited by State law from taking action on any items that are not listed on the agenda. However, if your item requires action, the Planning Commission may place it on a future agenda or direct staff to work with you and/or report to the Planning Commission on the issue. If you would like to deliver written materials to the Commission as part of your public comments, please provide 8 copies of to the Planning Commission Liaison with your speaker card. The Planning Commission Agenda and Agenda Reports are prepared by City staff and are available for public review on Friday evening, three days prior to the Planning Commission meeting at 1016 South Livermore Avenue, Livermore. The Agenda is also available on the City’s website, http://livermoreca.gov/agenda. Under Government Code §54957.5, any supplemental material distributed to the members of the Planning Commission after the posting of this agenda will be available for public review at City Hall, 1052 South Livermore Avenue, Livermore, and included in the agenda packet available on the City’s web site at http://livermoreca.gov/agenda. PURSUANT TO TITLE II OF THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (CODIFIED AT 42 UNITED STATES CODE SECTION 12101 AND 28 CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS PART 35), AND SECTION 504 OF THE REHABILITATION ACT OF 1973, THE CITY OF LIVERMORE DOES NOT DISCRIMINATE ON THE BASIS OF RACE, COLOR, RELIGION, NATIONAL ORIGIN, ANCESTRY, SEX, DISABILITY, AGE OR SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE PROVISION OF ANY SERVICES, PROGRAMS, OR ACTIVITIES. TO ARRANGE AN ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS PUBLIC MEETING, PLEASE Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025 4

CONTACT THE ADA COORDINATOR AT ADACOORDINATOR@LIVERMORECA.GOV OR CALL (925) 960-4170 (VOICE) OR (925) 960-4104 (TDD) AT LEAST THREE (3) BUSINESS DAYS IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING. Livermore Planning Commission Agenda December 16, 2025 5

PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT ITEM NO. 5.1 DATE: December 16, 2025 TO: Chairperson and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Steve Riley, Planning Manager SUBJECT: Hearing to consider a request for Vesting Tentative Tract Map, Site Plan Design Review, and certification of an Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project, a for-sale 115-unit residential condominium project located at the northeast corner of South Livermore Avenue and Pacific Avenue. RECOMMENDED ACTION Staff recommends the Planning Commission adopt Resolutions: 1. Certifying the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and directing the Planning Manager to file a Notice of Determination with the Alameda County Clerk; 2. Approving Vesting Tentative Tract Map (VTTM) 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004; and 3. Approving Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006. DECISION TYPE Quasi-judicial SUMMARY Swenson Builders submitted a preliminary application to the City of Livermore for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project (Project) in March of, 2023. The Project consists of the redevelopment of four parcels commonly known as the Livermore Town Center located at the northeast corner of Pacific Avenue and South Livermore Avenue (see location map, Attachment 1). The Project includes the demolition of the two existing commercial buildings and associated landscaping and parking lot. The site would be redeveloped with 115 three- and four-bedroom townhomes spread across 15 two- and three-story buildings, a clubhouse, pool area, and landscaped open space that includes an approximately 8,870 square foot interior park. Seventeen (15%) of the townhomes will be low- and moderate-income units. The proposed project would also include new pedestrian and vehicle access via existing streets, new internal roads, off-street parking spaces including guest, Americans with Disabilities Act, and electric vehicle spaces, a new flashing beacon at the northern crosswalk at Palm Avenue and South Livermore Avenues, improved bicycle lane on South Livermore Avenue, striped parallel public parking to facilitate efficient off-site parking, and a new bus shelter at the existing bus stop on Pacific 6

Avenue. The Project requires approval of a Vesting Tentative Tract Map - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004, and a Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006, and certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report. The site is currently zoned as Neighborhood Mixed Use. The applicant is utilizing the Builder's Remedy provision under the Housing Accountability Act (Government Code Section 65589.5) to waive certain land use requirements and development standards (see further discussion below). The project does not include a commercial component, which would otherwise be required under the current zoning designation. In addition, the Project will deviate from the height, side street setback, and density requirements. These deviations are allowed by state law under the Builder's Remedy provisions. The Project is subject to the Conditions of Approval (Attachment 13), which addresses infrastructure, design standards, and mitigation measures identified in the FEIR. DISCUSSION BACKGROUND The Project site at the northeast corner of Pacific Avenue and South Livermore Avenue was once a successful shopping center with a Nob Hill grocery store as the anchor tenant. Some tenants remain today, but the center is largely underutilized. The shopping center, known as Vineyard Shopping Center, was built in 1959 with a 17,000 square foot Lucky grocery store as the anchor. The Lucky store closed in 1980 when their new store opened in the downtown between First Street and Railroad Avenue. In 1983, the property owner, Carl N. Swenson, Inc., completely remodeled the center and added 10,000 square feet to accommodate a Nob Hill Grocery store. Nob Hill subsequently added approximately 3,000 square feet to reach the current size of approximately 30,000 square feet. In 2002, Nob Hill moved to its current location at 919 East Stanley Boulevard, and the anchor tenant space has been vacant since. Several of the fifteen smaller tenant spaces adjacent to the former grocery store still have active businesses. On the eastern edge of the existing shopping center is the Bingo Ranch, and on the southeastern corner of the center is the Oak Door lounge and the former Emil Villa’s restaurant. The remainder of the site consists of a parking lot with trees in landscaped islands. The westernmost parcel at 900 S. Livermore Avenue was once a Union Service Station that was constructed in 1959. It was demolished in approximately 1988.Three underground storage tanks (USTs) (two 10,000-gallon gasoline tanks and one 500-gallon waste oil tank) were removed from the project site by the early 1990s. The site was re-designated as Neighborhood Mixed Use in 2003 as part of the adoption of the current 2003-2025 General Plan (this 2003 designation encouraged but did require mixed use - neighborhood commercial combined with residential - on the site). The site was re-zoned in 2010 to a new version of Neighborhood Mixed Use (NMU) (Attachment 3), which requires that once the site is redeveloped, it is required to have a mix of residential and commercial uses. The details of these zones will be explained in the zoning section. Initial Project Proposal Swenson Builders, the owner of the four parcels that comprise the entire 6.54-acre site, applied for a mixed-use project in October of 2021. The proposal was for 92 townhomes and flats, and approximately 18,000 square feet of commercial space split between two buildings that would face South Livermore Avenue. The proposed commercial space was less than required of the Neighborhood Mixed Use (NMU) 7

zone, with the applicant citing that market forces couldn’t support more commercial space than the proposed 18,000 square feet. In the fall of 2022, Planning and Economic Development Staff held a meeting with Swenson’s team and shared a vision for a wine country gateway commercial theme that featured a small market where residents and visitors could purchase fresh and prepared foods. City Staff expressed the importance that this location was a critical area to provide commercial space for the availability of food due to the existing surrounding neighborhoods. A commercial site anywhere adjacent to the proposed development is currently infeasible as adjacent parcels are not zoned for commercial spaces. The former proposal had fewer units, commercial space, and no pool. The applicant withdrew their incomplete mixed-use proposal and submitted a new application under the Builder's Remedy section of the Housing Accountability Act in March of 2023. The revised proposal has 23 more units, includes a pool and clubhouse, and no commercial space. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The proposed project would result in the demolition of the existing commercial buildings on the project site, and the construction of 15 residential buildings totaling 115 units, pool area and associated pool equipment enclosure, and clubhouse buildings totaling approximately 1,577 square feet, landscaping, paseos, guest parking, and an interior park. The proposed project would also include new frontage improvements such as curb, sidewalk, gutter, and streetlights. The proposed pool equipment and clubhouse buildings would be located in the center of the project site, directly north of the entrance driveway on Pacific Avenue. Buildings 1 through 15 would consist of 98 townhouses in three-story buildings and 17 townhouses in two-story buildings. The two-story buildings would generally be located along the northern boundary of the project site, and the three-story buildings would be intermixed in the center and along the southern boundary. The proposed two-story townhouse units would include three bedrooms and would be an average of approximately 2,038 square feet in size. Meanwhile, the proposed three-story townhouse units would include four bedrooms and a balcony and would be an average of approximately 2,169 square feet in size. The two-story townhouses would be a maximum of approximately 29 feet 8 inches in height to the top of the roof, and the three-story townhouses would be approximately 36 feet 8 inches in height to the top of the roof STAFF ANALYSIS For a complete Staff Analysis, please review the attached Staff Analysis memo (Attachment 2). In the attached analysis, staff concludes by recommending the Planning Commission adopt the resolutions to certify the FEIR and approve the project entitlements. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION A Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) has been prepared for the project in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (available online at https://www.livermoreca.gov/departments/community-development/planning/environmental-documents); see Notice of Availability of a Final Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project. The attached Staff Analysis discusses the contents and mitigation measures contained in the FEIR. Staff recommends the Planning Commission certify the FEIR and direct the Planning Manager to file a Notice of Determination with the Alameda County Clerk. 8

ATTACHMENTS 1. Location Map 2. Staff Analysis 3. Neighborhood Mixed Use Zone 4. Proposed Plan Set 5. Transportation Analysis 6. T4N Zone 7. Letter to Existing Commercial Tenants 8. Resolution - CEQA 9. Exhibit A - Final EIR 10. Exhibit B Pacific and Livermore CEQA Findings 11. Exhibit C - Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan 12. Resolution - Project 13. Exhibit A - Conditions of Approval Prepared by: Jennifer Ackerman Associate Planner 9

Cabrillo Ave Arbor Ave East Ave Brennan Way Arbor Ct Bower Ct McLeod St 8th St 7th St Dolores St S Livermore Ave S Livermore Ave Palm Ave Carmen Ave College Ave Pacific Ave F i r e L n C a r r i a g e C o m m o n Riesling Cir Vintner Pl Riesling Cir S G St Cabrillo Ave Arbor Ave East Ave Brennan Way Arbor Ct Bower Ct McLeod St 8th St 7th St Dolores St S Livermore Ave S Livermore Ave Palm Ave Carmen Ave College Ave Pacific Ave F i r e L n C a r r i a g e C o m m o n Riesling Cir Vintner Pl Riesling Cir S G St MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LIVERMORE CIVIC CENTER COMMERCIAL SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL & SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LIVERMORE HIGH SCHOOL SINGLE & MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 4000 200 Project Site Boundary Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project Aerial Photograph of the Project Site and Surrounding Land Uses LSA ¢ iATTACHMENT 1 10

ATTACHMENT 2 PLANNING COMMISSION MEMORANDUM 1 TO: Chairperson Fintschenko and Members of the Planning Commission DATE: December 16, 2025 PREPARED BY: Jennifer Ackerman, Associate Planner REVIEWED BY: Stephen Riley, Planning Manager SUBJECT: Staff Analysis: Hearing to consider a request for Vesting Tentative Tract Map, Site Plan Design Review, and certification of a Final Environmental Impact Report for the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project (Project), a for-sale 115- unit residential condominium townhouse project located at the northeast corner of South Livermore Avenue and Pacific Avenue. STAFF ANALYSIS REVIEW PROCESS The Planning Commission’s role in reviewing the Project is to hear public testimony, review the record evidence, and make the findings for the following:  Certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR). As the Lead Agency, the City determined that the preparation of an EIR is appropriate for the proposed Project. The EIR has been prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The Draft EIR evaluated the potential environmental impacts associated with implementation of the Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes Project and is discussed in further detail below and can be found with all other EIR related documents such as the Initial Study, Draft EIR, and Final EIR for this Project on the City's Environmental Documents Website (https://www.livermoreca.gov/departments/community- 11

ATTACHMENT 2 development/planning/environmental-documents). See link titled Notice of Availability of Final Environmental Impact Report for Pacific and Livermore Avenue Townhomes. The EIR concludes that all potential environmental impacts can be mitigated to a less-than-significant level, and the Project will not result in any significant and unavoidable impacts. The Planning Commission’s role is to consider the adequacy of the EIR.  Vesting Tentative Tract Map 8701 - Subdivision (SUB) 23-004.The proposed Vesting Tentative Tract Map will subdivide the Project site to create lots for each building, and lots for the internal private streets, park, and landscaped common open spaces. The map also identifies all necessary public improvements and utility layouts to serve the development. The Planning Commission is asked to review the development plans for General Plan consistency of the subdivision and make the findings for approval.  Site Plan Design Review (SPDR) 23-006. The SPDR is for the review of the proposed site design, building layout, architecture, and landscape. The Planning Commission is asked to review the development plans and related discussions in the report and make the findings for approval. Housing Accountability Act and Builder’s Remedy The proposed Project is a residential development consisting of 115 townhome units on a 6.54-acre site, located on a site designated for mixed-use development under the City’s General Plan. Swenson Builders (he “Applicant”) submitted a preliminary application for the Project during a period when the City did not have a Housing Element that had been found by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to be in substantial compliance with State law. Accordingly, the Project is subject to the “Builder’s Remedy” provision of the Housing Accountability Act. Although the City was actively working towards such certification, the City’s Housing Element was not found to be in compliance by HCD until March 24, 2023, after the Applicant’s preliminary application was filed. This is the only Builder’s Remedy application the City received during that period. The primary purpose of the Builder's Remedy is to encourage and enforce housing production in California, particularly by holding local jurisdictions accountable for planning for housing. It is a mechanism designed to counteract the housing shortage by addressing local non-compliance with State housing laws. 12

ATTACHMENT 2 Under Government Code Section 65589.5(d), when a jurisdiction does not have a substantially compliant Housing Element, a local government may not disapprove a qualifying housing development project, nor may it condition approval in a manner that would reduce the project’s density, unless the City makes a written finding, supported by a preponderance of the evidence, that the project would have “specific, adverse impacts upon the public health or safety” that cannot be mitigated. The fact that the project is inconsistent with the General Plan or zoning standards is not a permissible basis for denial under the law. With respect to the proposed Project, the inconsistencies include:  The proposed density of approximately 17 dwelling units per acre exceeds the General Plan’s allowable range of 12–15 units per acre when developers choose to exceed the baseline density and comply with City's Transferable Development Credit Ordinance.  The side street setback exceeds the 15-foot maximum by a range of 5-20 feet.  The height of the buildings exceeds the maximum height permitted under the current T4N zoning.  Not proposing any of the required retail commercial space in the Project. However, the City must process the Project notwithstanding these inconsistencies, unless it can make the health and safety impact findings. Also, the Project is subject to the City’s design standards in effect at the time of application. The Applicant has worked cooperatively with staff to achieve a high-quality design PROJECT SITE CONTEXT The approximately 6.54-acre site is located at 2930 Pacific Avenue in Livermore, Alameda County, California (Assessor’s Parcel Numbers [APNs] 98A-412-106-5, 98A

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission — Minutes
  • Planning Commission
  • Planning Commission — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 939a13e348f49485657bf87e4bad17d3. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record