POLISCOPE

The public record

BERKELEY (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Independent Redistricting Commission Regular Meeting - 02/28/2022 (English)

Monday, February 28, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Independent Redistricting Commission Regular Meeting - 02/28/2022 (English)

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Listen to audio

Showing the first 60,000 of 214,220 characters. The full document is at the source.

Monday, February 28, 2022 AGENDA Page 1 INDEPENDENT REDISTRICTING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING Monday, February 28, 2022 6:00 PM Commission Members: D ISTRICT 1 – T ERRY N ICOL D ISTRICT 5 – W INSTON R HODES D ISTRICT 2 – J ESSE SUSSELL D ISTRICT 6 – ELISABETH W ATSON D ISTRICT 3 – LISA M. T RAN D ISTRICT 7 – RANA C HO D ISTRICT 4 – C URTIS W. HANSON D ISTRICT 8 – ANDREW FOX AT -LARGE – DELORES C OOPER AT -LARGE – LUPE GALLEGOS-D IAZ AT -LARGE – CARLY MICHELE ALEJOS AT -LARGE – R ONALD K. C HOY AT -LARGE – SHERRY SMITH PUBLIC ADVISORY: THIS MEETING WILL BE CONDUCTED EXCLUSIVELY THROUGH VIDEOCONFERENCE AND TELECONFERENCE Pursuant to Government Code Section 54953(e) and the state declared emergency, this meeting of the Independent Redistricting Commission will be conducted exclusively through teleconference and Zoom videoconference. The COVID-19 state of emergency continues to directly impact the ability of the members to meet safely in person and presents imminent risks to the health of attendees. Therefore, no physical meeting location will be available. To access the meeting remotely using the internet: Join from a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone, or Android device: Use URL https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81566315346. If you do not wish for your name to appear on the screen, then use the drop down menu and click on "rename" to rename yourself to be anonymous. To request to speak, use the “raise hand” icon on the screen. To join by phone: Dial 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (Toll Free) and Enter Meeting ID: 815 6631 5346. If you wish to comment during the public comment portion of the agenda, press *9 and wait to be recognized by the Chair. Written communications submitted by mail or e-mail to the Independent Redistricting Commission by 5:00 p.m. the Friday before the Commission meeting will be distributed to the members of the Commission in advance of the meeting and retained as part of the official record.1

Monday, February 28, 2022 AGENDA Page 2 AGENDA Roll Call Public Comment on Non-Agenda Matters Minutes for Approval Draft minutes for the Commission's consideration and approval. 1. Minutes - February 17, 2022 and February 19, 2022 From: Independent Redistricting Commission Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Commission Action Items The public may comment on each item listed on the agenda for action as the item is taken up. 2. Selection of Final Map for official approval on March 16, 2022 From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Review the Amber Version 2 map currently under consideration and approve the map for final official adoption by the Commission on March 16, 2022. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 3. Review of Draft Items for Final Report From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Review the draft letters and materials provided by the Report Drafting Subcommittee and provide comments. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Subcommittee Reports Subcommittees may provide verbal reports on their activities and discuss topics under their purview with the full commission. To take action on a subcommittee item, the topic must be agendized on the commission’s Action Calendar. Information Reports – None Items for Future Agendas and Meeting Calendar • Discussion of items to be added to the next scheduled meeting calendar • Discussion and possible modifications to the meeting calendar Adjournment2

Monday, February 28, 2022 AGENDA Page 3 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This meeting will be conducted in accordance with the Brown Act, Government Code Section 54953. Any member of the public may attend this meeting. Questions regarding this matter may be addressed to Mark Numainville, City Clerk, (510) 981-6900. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Independent Redistricting Commission regarding any item on this agenda are on file in the City Clerk Department at 2180 Milvia Street, 1st Floor, Berkeley, CA and are available upon request by contacting the City Clerk Department at (510) 981-6908 or redistricting@cityofberkeley.info. Written communications addressed to the Independent Redistricting Commission and submitted to the City Clerk Department will be distributed to the Commission prior to the meeting. Communications to the Independent Redistricting Commission are public record and will become part of the City’s electronic records, which are accessible through the City’s website. Please note: e-mail addresses, names, addresses, and other contact information are not required, but if included in any communication to the Independent Redistricting Commission, will become part of the public record. If you do not want your e-mail address or any other contact information to be made public, you may deliver communications via U.S. Postal Service to the City Clerk Department at 2180 Milvia Street. If you do not want your contact information included in the public record, please do not include that information in your communication. Please contact the City Clerk Department for further information. COMMUNICATION ACCESS INFORMATION: If you need ASL or Spanish translation services, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at (510) 981-6908 or redistricting@cityofberkeley.info at least three business days in advance of the meeting. To request a disability-related accommodation(s) to participate in the meeting, including auxiliary aids or services, please contact the Disability Services specialist at (510) 981-6418 (V) or (510) 981-6347 (TDD) at least three business days before the meeting date. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I hereby certify that the agenda for this meeting of the Independent Redistricting Commission was posted at the display case located near the walkway in front of the Maudelle Shirek Building, 2134 Martin Luther King Jr. Way, as well as on the City’s website, on February 24, 2022. Mark Numainville, City Clerk Communications Communications submitted to the Independent Redistricting Commission are on file in the City Clerk Department at 2180 Milvia Street, 1st Floor, Berkeley, CA and are available upon request by contacting the City Clerk Department at (510) 981-6908 or redistricting@cityofberkeley.info or may be viewed through Records Online.3

4

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 1 INDEPENDENT REDISTRICTING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING MINUTES Thursday, February 17, 2022 6:00 PM Commission Members: D ISTRICT 1 – T ERRY N ICOL D ISTRICT 5 – W INSTON R HODES D ISTRICT 2 – J ESSE SUSSELL D ISTRICT 6 – ELISABETH W ATSON D ISTRICT 3 – LISA M. T RAN D ISTRICT 7 – RANA C HO D ISTRICT 4 – C URTIS W. HANSON D ISTRICT 8 – ANDREW FOX AT -LARGE – DELORES C OOPER AT -LARGE – LUPE GALLEGOS-D IAZ AT -LARGE – CARLY MICHELE ALEJOS AT -LARGE – R ONALD K. C HOY AT -LARGE – SHERRY SMITH PUBLIC ADVISORY: THIS MEETING WILL BE CONDUCTED EXCLUSIVELY THROUGH VIDEOCONFERENCE AND TELECONFERENCE Pursuant to Government Code Section 54953(e) and the state declared emergency, this meeting of the Independent Redistricting Commission will be conducted exclusively through teleconference and Zoom videoconference. The COVID-19 state of emergency continues to directly impact the ability of the members to meet safely in person and presents imminent risks to the health of attendees. Therefore, no physical meeting location will be available. To access the meeting remotely using the internet: Join from a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone, or Android device: Use URL https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81072988964. If you do not wish for your name to appear on the screen, then use the drop down menu and click on "rename" to rename yourself to be anonymous. To request to speak, use the “raise hand” icon on the screen. To join by phone: Dial 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (Toll Free) and Enter Meeting ID: 810 7298 8964. If you wish to comment during the public comment portion of the agenda, press *9 and wait to be recognized by the Chair. Written communications submitted by mail or e-mail to the Independent Redistricting Commission by 5:00 p.m. the Friday before the Commission meeting will be distributed to the members of the Commission in advance of the meeting and retained as part of the official record. Page 1 of 105

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 2 MINUTES Roll Call: 6:06 p.m. Present: Alejos, Cho, Choy, Cooper, Fox, Gallegos-Diaz, Hanson, Nicol, Rhodes, Smith, Sussel, Tran, Watson. Public Comment on Non-Agenda Matters – 0 speakers Minutes for Approval Draft minutes for the Commission's consideration and approval. 1. Minutes – January 27, 2022 regular meeting Action: M/S/C (Rhodes/Tran) to approve the minutes of January 27, 2022. Vote: All Ayes. Public Hearing The public may comment on each item listed on the agenda for action as the item is taken up. 2. Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing to discuss, review, and provide direction on the draft city council district maps. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Action: 21 speakers. Discussion held. The Commission requested that staff prepare an analysis of two potential changes to Amber Map Version 2 prior to the February 19, 2022 meeting, including: 1) Moving a portion of the District 4/District 7 boundary from Fulton Street to Ellsworth street; and 2) Using Dwight Way as the northern border of District 3. Commission Action Items The public may comment on each item listed on the agenda for action as the item is taken up. 3. Review and Approval of Table of Contents for Final Report From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Review and approve the table of contents for the final map report to accompany the final map. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Action: 0 speakers. Discussion held. The Commission directed that the draft letters to the community and the City Council be included in the February 28, 2022 agenda packet for review. Page 2 of 106

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 3 Subcommittee Reports – None Subcommittees may provide verbal reports on their activities and discuss topics under their purview with the full commission. To take action on a subcommittee item, the topic must be agendized on the commission’s Action Calendar. Information Reports – None Items for Future Agendas and Meeting Calendar • Discussion of items to be added to the next scheduled meeting calendar o Review of Letters to Public and Council in Final Report • Discussion and possible modifications to the meeting calendar o None Adjournment Action: M/S/C (Gallegos-Diaz/Cho) to adjourn the meeting. Vote: All Ayes. Adjourned at 9:05 p.m. I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and correct record of the Independent Redistricting Commission meeting held on February 17, 2022. ______________________ Mark Numainville City Clerk Communications Communications submitted to the Independent Redistricting Commission are on file in the City Clerk Department at 2180 Milvia Street, 1st Floor, Berkeley, CA and are available upon request by contacting the City Clerk Department at (510) 981-6908 or redistricting@cityofberkeley.info or may be viewed through Records Online. Item #2: Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps 105. Henry Norr 106. Yes Duffy 107. Mary Lou Van Deventer, Urban Ore Inc. 108. Ben Gould 109. Nina Zurier 110. Chris Horgan 111. Amy Hill 112. Steven Donaldson 113. Toni Mester 114. Marc Treib 115. Jane Franch Page 3 of 107

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 4 116. Adam Fuchs 117. Lucy Smallsreed 118. Jill Korte 119. Joan Baylie & Jim Mullins 120. Lindsey Anne Supplemental Communications Item #2: Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps 121. Stephanie Allan 122. Jack Kurzweil 123. Tom McMIllan 124. Daniel Tahara 125. Alfred Twu 126. Sally Nelson 127. Elana Auerbach 128. Rob Wrenn 129. Kelly Hammargren 130. Pamela Blotner 131. Peggy Mendelson 132. Summer Brenner 133. David Fielder 134. Jean Tepperman 135. Toni Mester 136. Sarah Bell 137. Mona Bernstein & Mark Lempert 138. Arnold Kessler 139. David Ushijima 140. Julianna S. Dickey 141. William Bogert (2) 142. Nancy Schimmel 143. Linda Franklin 144. Deejay Imortal 145. Ned Himmel 146. Yolanda Huang 147. Mary Ann Fabbri 148. Mary White 149. Sheila Goldmacher 150. Diana Bohn 151. Cindy Shamban 152. Carol Benioff 153. Kinga Chomicz 154. Phil Allen 155. James Loza 156. amtaylor 157. Daniel Caraco 158. Rebecca Tracy Page 4 of 108

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 5 159. Stefanie Guynn 160. Harald Leventhal 161. Suzanne Stewart 162. Zelda Bronstein 163. Commissioner Ronald Choy 164. Mary Rose 165. Alyse Jacobson 166. Steve Kamman 167. Shirley Dean 168. Margaret Goodman 169. Janice Murota 170. Andrew Page 171. Jon Stewart 172. David Clore 173. Jonathan Cohen 174. Sandra & Karl Bemesderfer 175. Anita Barrows 176. Patricia Edwards 177. Ginny Garrett 178. Patrick Sheahan 179. Holly Scheider, McGee Spaulding Neighbors in Action 180. Janet Stromberg 181. John Blaustein 182. Nina Torcoletti 183. Holly Scheider (2) 184. Carolyn Scarr 185. Margo Smith 186. Hali Hammer 187. Linda Olivenbaum 188. Nico Calavita 189. Barbara Cleveland 190. T.F. Tierney 191. Donna Mickleson 192. Dan Feinberg 193. Michael Weber 194. Andrea Mullarkey, SEIU 1021 - City of Berkeley - CSU/PTRLA 195. George Lippman 196. Phoebe Thomas Sorgen 197. Edward Opton (2) 198. Elizabeth Ozol 199. Barbara Schick 200. Charlene Woodcock 201. Thomas Luce 202. Michael Katz 203. Cary Sanders 204. Vincent Casalaina Page 5 of 109

Thursday, February 17, 2022 MINUTES Page 6 205. Greysonne Coomes 206. Ivan & Sarah Diamond 207. Cate Leger 208. Theo Posselt (Berkeley Neighbors for Housing and Climate Action, District 6); Ben Gould (Berkeley Neighbors for Housing and Climate Action, District 4); Grayson Peters (More Student Housing Now, District 7); Libby Lee-Egan (North Berkeley Now!, District 1) 209. Ben Gould 210. Carla Woodworth 211. Chimey Lee 212. Berkeley Tenants Union 213. Janice Schroeder 214. Winston Burton 215. Larry Snyder Page 6 of 1010

Saturday, February 19, 2022 MINUTES Page 1 INDEPENDENT REDISTRICTING COMMISSION SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES Saturday, February 19, 2022 10:00 AM Commission Members: D ISTRICT 1 – T ERRY N ICOL D ISTRICT 5 – W INSTON R HODES D ISTRICT 2 – J ESSE SUSSELL D ISTRICT 6 – ELISABETH W ATSON D ISTRICT 3 – LISA M. T RAN D ISTRICT 7 – RANA C HO D ISTRICT 4 – C URTIS W. HANSON D ISTRICT 8 – ANDREW FOX AT -LARGE – DELORES C OOPER AT -LARGE – LUPE GALLEGOS-D IAZ AT -LARGE – CARLY MICHELE ALEJOS AT -LARGE – R ONALD K. C HOY AT -LARGE – SHERRY SMITH PUBLIC ADVISORY: THIS MEETING WILL BE CONDUCTED EXCLUSIVELY THROUGH VIDEOCONFERENCE AND TELECONFERENCE Pursuant to Government Code Section 54953(e) and the state declared emergency, this meeting of the Independent Redistricting Commission will be conducted exclusively through teleconference and Zoom videoconference. The COVID-19 state of emergency continues to directly impact the ability of the members to meet safely in person and presents imminent risks to the health of attendees. Therefore, no physical meeting location will be available. To access the meeting remotely using the internet: Join from a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone, or Android device: Use URL https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87810843440. If you do not wish for your name to appear on the screen, then use the drop down menu and click on "rename" to rename yourself to be anonymous. To request to speak, use the “raise hand” icon on the screen. To join by phone: Dial 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (Toll Free) and Enter Meeting ID: 878 1084 3440. If you wish to comment during the public comment portion of the agenda, press *9 and wait to be recognized by the Chair. Written communications submitted by mail or e-mail to the Independent Redistricting Commission by 5:00 p.m. the Friday before the Commission meeting will be distributed to the members of the Commission in advance of the meeting and retained as part of the official record. Page 7 of 1011

Saturday, February 19, 2022 MINUTES Page 2 MINUTES Roll Call: 10:02 a.m. Present: Alejos, Weissman (for Cho), Choy, Cooper, Gallegos-Diaz, Hanson, Toub (for Nicol), Rhodes, Rosenthal (for Smith), Sussell, Watson. Absent: Fox, Tran Public Comment on Non-Agenda Matters – 9 speakers Public Hearing The public may comment on each item listed on the agenda for action as the item is taken up. 1. Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing to discuss, review, and provide direction on the draft city council district maps. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Action: 29 speakers. Discussion held. M/S/C (Rhodes/Gallegos-Diaz) to remove the Violet Map from consideration. Vote: Ayes – Alejos, Choy, Cooper, Gallegos-Diaz, Hanson, Toub, Rhodes, Rosenthal, Sussell, Watson; Noes – None; Abstain – None; Absent – Weissman, Fox, Tran. Commission Action Items The public may comment on each item listed on the agenda for action as the item is taken up. 2. Review and Approval of Table of Contents for Final Report From: Independent Redistricting Commission Recommendation: Review and approve the table of contents for the final map report to accompany the final map. Contact: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary, (510) 981-6900 Action: 0 speakers. Discussion held. No action taken. Subcommittee Reports – None Subcommittees may provide verbal reports on their activities and discuss topics under their purview with the full commission. To take action on a subcommittee item, the topic must be agendized on the commission’s Action Calendar. Information Reports – None Items for Future Agendas and Meeting Calendar • Discussion of items to be added to the next scheduled meeting calendar o None Page 8 of 1012

Saturday, February 19, 2022 MINUTES Page 3 • Discussion and possible modifications to the meeting calendar o None Adjournment Action: M/S/C (Gallegos-Diaz/Rhodes) to adjourn the meeting. Vote: Ayes – Alejos, Choy, Cooper, Gallegos-Diaz, Hanson, Toub, Rhodes, Rosenthal, Sussell, Watson; Noes – None; Abstain – None; Absent – Weissman, Fox, Tran. Adjourned at 1:10 p.m. I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and correct record of the Independent Redistricting Commission meeting held on February 19, 2022. ______________________ Mark Numainville City Clerk Communications Communications submitted to the Independent Redistricting Commission are on file in the City Clerk Department at 2180 Milvia Street, 1st Floor, Berkeley, CA and are available upon request by contacting the City Clerk Department at (510) 981-6908 or redistricting@cityofberkeley.info or may be viewed through Records Online. Supplemental Communications 1 Item #1: Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps 216. Ranko Yamada 217. Catha Worthman 218. Louise Rosenkrantz 219. Elliot Halpern 220. Meghan Schwartz 221. Virginia Browning 222. Zipporah Collins 223. Catherine Hutchting 224. Mary Behm-Steinberg 225. Fan & Jim Albritton 226. Alexander Stec 227. Lloyd Lee & Lynanne Jacob 228. Charlotte Dickson 229. Erin Diehm 230. Barbara Fisher 231. Ellen Hahn 232. Sylvia Chapman 233. Elizabeth Koller 234. Thomas Mulvihill 235. Sarah Miyazaki Page 9 of 1013

Saturday, February 19, 2022 MINUTES Page 4 236. Janice Ching 237. Sharon Maldonado 238. Andy Katz 239. Allen Wagner 240. Firouzeh Nourzad 241. Bob Young 242. Robert Marsh 243. Ron Saturno & Stan Lusardi Supplemental Communications 2 Item #1: Discussion, Review, and Direction on Draft City Council District Maps 244. George Porter 245. Ellen Meltzer 246. Dale Rose 247. William Roberts 248. Tine Munson 249. Jonathan Bailey 250. Linda Franklin 251. Marian Snyder 252. Deebie Symmes 253. Philip J. Jimenez 254. Mark Lowe 255. Russ Greene (2) 256. Chris Gilbert (2) 257. Thomas Luce 258. Linda Currie 259. Michaela Parks 260. Catherine Lazio 261. Gordon Wozniak 262. Ruth Phillips 263. Diane Quimby 264. Jan Knecht 265. Lisa & Tim Goodman Page 10 of 1014

City Clerk Department 2180 Milvia Street, Berkeley, CA 94704 ● Tel: (510) 981-6900 ● TDD: (510) 981-6903 ● Fax: (510) 981-6901 E-Mail: redistricting@cityofberkeley.info Website: http://www.cityofberkeley.info/redistricting February 28, 2022 To: Independent Redistricting Commission From: Mark Numainville, Commission Secretary Subject: Selection of Final City Council District Boundary Map for Adoption on March 16, 2022 The recommended action for the Independent Redistricting Commission (IRC) for the February 28, 2022 Public Hearing is to select Amber Map Version 2 as the final draft map and request that staff agendize Amber Map Version 2 for formal adoption at the March 16, 2022 meeting. The information below is provided as background on the map development process and the public participation and decisions that have resulted in the final draft map. Development of Draft Maps On January 10, 2022, the IRC created a Map Drafting Subcommittee and appointed Commissioners Rhodes, Nicol, and Alejos. The IRC also established the following themes to be used in the development of the first set of draft maps: Themes to be prioritized in all draft maps a. 10% Maximum Population Variance b. Contiguity c. Communities of Interest/Neighborhoods d. Use major arterial streets as boundaries where possible e. Correct the features of the 2010 map for Councilmember residences f. Include at least one compact student district in every map Page 1 of 4215

Selection of Final City Council District Boundary Map February 28, 2022 for Adoption on March 16, 2022 Page 2 Themes to be included in one or more draft map variation: a. Single, north-south West Berkeley district b. Topography/Transit Access/Wildfire Risk c. Two different maps with different configurations for two student majority districts d. A map that has a high level of continuity with the existing boundaries that includes changes only as required by the six mandatory criteria above Working with staff, the Subcommittee created four draft maps that responded to the full range of the IRC’s direction. Each draft map was given a non-numeric designation for the purpose of identification. The draft maps also include narratives explaining in detail how they were developed. The four draft maps are listed below in alphabetical order: Designation Description Amber Map Consistency Map with Changes Made Only to Address Universal Criteria West Berkeley (Two Districts) Blue Map Two Student Districts (East-West) West Berkeley (One District) Maroon Map Two Student Districts (North-South) West Berkeley (Two Districts) Orange Map Consistency Map with Changes Made Only to Address Universal Criteria West Berkeley (One District) At the IRC public hearing on January 27, 2022, the Commission received public comment from 31 speakers and reviewed dozens of new written communications from the public regarding the four draft maps. Based on community input and the IRC deliberations, the Commission acted to advance a modified Amber Map to the February 17 public hearing and requested that a new map be created for evaluation. The Commission also added Commissioner Fox to the Map Drafting Subcommittee. The requested changes to the Amber Map modify the District 3/District 8 boundary on Adeline Street to better unify the community around Ashby BART in District 3. This revised map is named Amber Map Version 2. The new draft map (Violet Map) uses the Amber Map as the base map and moves the portion of the Northside Neighborhood south of Le Conte Avenue into the student-focused district, modifies the boundary between District 3 and District 8 to prevent division of the community near Ashby BART, adjusts District 4 in consideration of students and renters, and further creates two student/renter-focused districts in a side-by-side orientation. Page 2 of 4216

Selection of Final City Council District Boundary Map February 28, 2022 for Adoption on March 16, 2022 Page 3 The Subcommittee produced two new maps as follows. Designation Description Amber Map Version 2 Consistency Map with Changes Made Only to Address Universal Criteria West Berkeley (Two Districts) Violet Map Two Student/Renter Focused Districts (East-West) West Berkeley (Two Districts) Both the Amber Map Version 2 and the Violet Map adhered to the universal criteria of: 1) Maximum of 10% population deviation; 2) Contiguous districts; 3) Maintain Communities of Interest and Neighborhoods; 4) Use major arterial streets as boundaries where possible; 5) Correct the features of the 2010 map that accounted for prior Councilmember residences; and 6) Include at least one compact student district in every map. Amber Map Version 2 The revised version of the Amber Map responds to community input and Commission direction by moving the border between District 3 and District 8 from Adeline Street eastward to Shattuck Avenue. Moving the boundary to Shattuck Avenue returns the Ashby BART east parking lot, Ed Roberts Campus, and St. Paul AME Church into District 3. The corresponding population change does not adversely affect the required deviation percentage for either district or the overall city map. There are no changes to Districts 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, or 7 in Amber Map Version 2 from the original Amber Map. The Amber Version 2 Map contains a renter population of 78.6% in District 4 and 94.5% in District 7. Violet Map The Violet Map responds to the direction of the Independent Redistricting Commission to create a draft map that uses the Amber Map as the base map with changes in the Northside Neighborhood and the Downtown area to focus on student and renter populations. The Subcommittee attempted to include the portion of the Northside Neighborhood south of Le Conte Avenue into the student-focused district; however, the cascading effects into other districts presented other challenges. It was determined that drawing the border one block south of Le Conte Avenue on Ridge Road would achieve much of the IRC’s objective and facilitate population balancing in other surrounding districts. Moving a portion of Northside Neighborhood and the Foothill Dormitory into District 7 lead to changes in the District 5/District 6 border. The border moved from Spruce Street to Arlington Avenue north of the Marin Circle. This change then lead to District 5 moving Page 3 of 4217

Selection of Final City Council District Boundary Map February 28, 2022 for Adoption on March 16, 2022 Page 4 south into District 4 to Hearst Avenue. And finally, this change caused District 4 to move slightly south into District 3 and east into the Southside Neighborhood. As with the Amber Version 2 Map, the Violet Map modifies the boundary between District 3 and District 8 to prevent division of the community near Ashby BART. The border between District 3 and District 8 moves from Adeline Street eastward to Shattuck Avenue. Moving the boundary to Shattuck Avenue returns the Ashby BART east parking lot, Ed Roberts Campus, and St. Paul AME Church into District 3. The Violet Map contains a renter population of 79.0% in District 4 and 90.7% in District 7. At the February 17 public hearing, the Commission requested that staff prepare an analysis of two potential changes to Amber Map Version 2 prior to the February 19 meeting, including: 1) Moving a portion of the District 4/District 7 boundary from Fulton Street to Ellsworth street; and 2) Using Dwight Way as the northern border of District 3. This analysis was sent to the commission and posted to the IRC website in advance of the February 19 special meeting. In order to allow for greater public access and more availability to the public, the IRC scheduled a special meeting on Saturday, February 19, 2022. At the February 19 meeting, IRC heard from 29 members of the public during public comment. The Commission reviewed the additional analysis provided by staff on the potential changes to the Amber Map Version 2 and discussed options for drafting the changes in advance of the next meeting. Ultimately, the Commission decided that there was not compelling testimony on the record to initiate such changes in the maps. The commission also voted to remove the Violet Map from consideration and send the Amber Map Version 2 forward in the process to the February 28 public hearing for final adoption “as-is.” Staff has created an updated document based on IRC action on February 19 and posted the update at all locations where the draft maps are posted - the Central Library, the ASUC Student Union in the Martin Luther King, Jr. Building, and the South Berkeley Senior Center. Updated ledger-sized map binders are available at all branch libraries and the Civic Center Building at 2180 Milvia Street. The public may continue to email written comments to redistricting@cityofberkeley.info Commission consideration. Of course, the public is invited to provide verbal testimony at the February 28 public hearing. Next Steps Upon selection of Amber Map Version 2 as the final map, staff will create an ordinance and final map for review at the March 16 meeting. In addition, the Report Drafting Subcommittee will work with staff to finalize the public report in time for publication in the March 16 IRC agenda packet. Page 4 of 4218

Selection of Final City Council District Boundary Map February 28, 2022 for Adoption on March 16, 2022 Page 5 Attachments: 1) Amber Map Version 2 Book 2) Community of Interest Matrix 3) Public Map Matrix Page 5 of 4219

Mapping Berkeley Communities: Redistricting by the People Draft City Council District Map: “AMBER MAP Version 2”Published February 10, 2022 Contact the Independent Redistricting Commission: redistricting@cityofberkeley.info | (510) 981-6900 2180 Milvia Street, 1 st Floor, Berkeley, CA 94704. To obtain additional redistricting information and view the draft maps in an interactive online map, please visit www.cityofberkeley.info/redistricting AMBER MAP – Version 2 Consistency Map with Changes to Address Universal Criteria West Berkeley (Two Districts) The Amber Map responds to the direction of the Independent Redistricting Commission to create a draft map that has a high level of continuity with the existing council district boundaries and includes changes only as needed to meet the six universal map criteria. The universal criteria are: 1) Maximum of 10% population deviation; 2) Contiguous districts; 3) Maintain Communities of Interest and Neighborhoods; 4) Use major arterial streets as boundaries where possible; 5) Correct the features of the 2010 map that accounted for prior Councilmember residences; and 6) Include at least one compact student district in every map. Version two of the Amber Map also responds to the Commission direction to adjust the border between District 3 and District 8 near Ashby BART. The Amber Map follows the Commission direction by making the following noteworthy modifications: ● Move the border between District 3 and District 8 east from Adeline Street to Shattuck Avenue to include the Ed Roberts Campus, the Ashby BART east lot, and St. Paul AME Church in District 3. ● Unify the Westbrae Neighborhood in District 1; ● Unify the Poets Corner Neighborhood in District 2; ● Unify the LeConte Neighborhood in District 3; ● Unify the Lorin Neighborhood in District 3; ● Unify the Halcyon Neighborhood in District 8; ● Unify the Bateman Neighborhood in District 8; ● Unify the Willard Neighborhood in District 8; ● Unify Lower Spruce/Arch Street with the Northside Neighborhood in District 6; ● Move the census block that contains the International House from District 8 to the existing student district (District 7); ● Correct map features for prior Councilmember residences in District 4 and District 7; ● Maximize the use of the major arterials, University Avenue, Telegraph Avenue, Sacramento Street, Spruce Street, Oxford Street, and Cedar Street, as council district boundaries; ● Commission direction on topography/wildfire risk/transit access is reflected in higher elevation neighborhoods contained in two council districts (6, 8). Page 6 of 4220

Amber Map - Version 2Page 7 of 4221

Amber Map - Version 2Page 8 of 4222

Fields List Field Description District Number assigned to district (1 through 8) PPA_Population PPA = Population Deviation Deviation from ideal number of people (15,554) in each district if population was distributed exactly equally among the eight districts. % Deviation PPA_Hispanic_Origin % PPA_Hispanic_Origin PPA White % PPA White PPA AfAm Population – African American %PPA_AfAm PPA_AiAn Population – American Indian and Alaskan Natives % PPA_AiAn PPA_Asian % PPA_Asian PPA_HoPI Hawaiian/Pacific Islander %PPA_HoPI PPA_Other % PPA_Other PPA_CVAP _19 CVAP = City Voting Age Population % PPA_CVAP _19 Hispanic_Origin_CVAP % Hispanic_Origin_CVAP PPA_NH_Wht_CVAP _19 Non-Hispanic White % PPA_NH_Wht_CVAP _19 PPA_NH_Blk_CVAP _19 Non-Hispanic Black % PPA_NH_Blk_CVAP _19 PPA_NH_Ind_CVAP _19 Non-Hispanic American Indian % PPA_NH_Ind_CVAP _19 PPA_NH_Asn_CVAP_19 Non-Hispanic Asian % PPA_NH_Asn_CVAP _19 PPA_NH_Hwn_CVAP _19 Non-Hispanic Hawaiian/Pacific Islander % PPA NH Hwn CVAP 19 ACS 14-18 HU Occupied Housing Units Occupied ACS 14-18 Owner occupied % ACS 14-18 Owner occupied ACS 14-18 Renter occupied % ACS 14-18 Renter occupied ACS 14-18 HH Median income Household Median Income ACS 14-18 Median Age “ACS” = American Community Survey Page 9 of 4223

District: 1 Field Value District 1 PPA_Population 15757 Deviation 203 % Deviation 1.31% PPA_Hispanic_Origin 2291 PPA_Hispanic_Origin 14.54% PPA_White 7980 % PPA_White 50.64% PPA_AfAm 1549 % PPA_AfAm 9.83% PPA_AiAn 48 % PPA_AiAn 0.3% PPA_Asian 2388 s'- % PPA_Asian 15.16% PPA_HoPI 67 R I :r ""' % PPA_HoPI 0.43% PPA_Other 171 % PPA_Other 1.09% PPA_CVAP_19 10813 % PPA_CVAP_19 68.62% ispanic_Origin_CVAP 1205 ispanic_Origin_CVAPL 11.14% \)t;l\\/loRSl1'1 \/ I � NH Wht CVAP 19 6594 �_NH_Wht_CVAP_19 60.98% r A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 834 A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 7.71% A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 20 A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 0.18% A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 1661 A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 15.36% NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 14 -NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 0.13% 14_18_HU_Occupied 6282 18_Owner_occupied 2902 18_Owner_occupied 46.2% ©2021 CALIPER 3388 53.93% 1125399 ACS 14-18 Renter occupied % ACS 14-18 Renter occupied ACS 14-18 HH Median income ACS 14-18 Median Age 514.02Amber Map - Version 2 Page 10 of 4224

District: 2 Field Value District 2 PPA_Population 15785 Deviation 231 % Deviation 1.49% PPA_Hispanic_Origin 2691 PPA_Hispanic_Origin 17.05% PPA_White 6748 % PPA_White 42.75% PPA_AfAm 2794 % PPA_AfAm 17.7% PPA_AiAn 41 % PPA_AiAn 0.26% PPA_Asian 2071 % PPA_Asian 13.12% PPA_HoPI 57 % PPA_HoPI 0.36% PPA_Other 179 % PPA_Other 1.13% PPA_CVAP_19 11043 % PPA_CVAP_19 69.96% ispanic_Origin_CVAP 1474 ispanic_Origin_CVAPL 13.35% � NH Wht CVAP 19 5276 �_NH_Wht_CVAP_19 47.78% r A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 2708 A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 24.52% A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 4 A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 0.04% A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 906 A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 8.2% -NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 141 -NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 1.28% 14_18_HU_Occupied 6275 18_Owner_occupied 2414 18_Owner_occupied 38.47% ©2021 CALIPER 3863 61.56% 929633 ACS 14-18 Renter occupied % ACS 14-18 Renter occupied ACS 14-18 HH Median income ACS 14-18 Median Age 450.23Amber Map - Version 2 Page 11 of 4225

Amber Map - Version 2Page 12 of 4226

Amber Map - Version 2Page 13 of 4227

Amber Map - Version 2Page 14 of 4228

Amber Map - Version 2Page 15 of 4229

\:;\ __,__l'\£1'RS1i>S/� � --�� %f �� c\-\JXNNll'I� ) District: 7 ©2021 CALIPER Field Value District 7 PPA_Population 15405 Deviation -149 % Deviation -0.96% PPA_Hispanic_Origin 3638 PPA_Hispanic_Origin 23.62% PPA_White 4946 % PPA_White 32.11% PPA_AfAm 435 % PPA_AfAm 2.82% PPA_AiAn 6 % PPA_AiAn 0.04% PPA_Asian 5492 % PPA_Asian 35.65% PPA_HoPI 2 % PPA_HoPI 0.01% PPA_Other 73 % PPA_Other 0.47% PPA_CVAP_19 10577 % PPA_CVAP_19 68.66% ispanic_Origin_CVAP 1890 ispanic_Origin_CVAPL 17.87% � NH Wht CVAP 19 3877 �_NH_Wht_CVAP_19 36.66% r A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 304 A_NH_Blk_CVAP_19 2.87% A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 0 A_NH_Ind_CVAP_19 0% A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 3858 A_NH_Asn_CVAP_l9 36.48% _NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 0 _NH_Hwn_CVAP_19 0% 14_18_HU_Occupied 2098 18_Owner_occupied 119 18_Owner_occupied 5.67% 1982 94.47% 202115 ACS 14-18 Renter occupied % ACS 14-18 Renter occupied ACS 14-18 HH Median income ACS 14-18 Median Age 115.36Amber Map - Version 2 Page 16 of 4230

District: a ©2021 CALIPER Field District PPA_Population Deviation % Deviation PPA H. · - ispanic_Origin PPA H. · - ispanic_Origin PPA_W-h�it_e_j__ % PPA_White PPA_AfAm % PPA_AfAm PPA_AiAn % PPA_AiAn PPA_Asian % PPA_Asian PPA_HoPI % PPA_HoPI PPA_Other % PPA_Other PPA_CVAP 19 . % PPA_CVAP=19 ispanic_Origin_CVAP ispanic_Origin_CVAPL �_NH_Wht_CVAP 19 �_NH_Wht_CVAP --1-9 -+-- - rA_NH_Blk_CVAP=19 A_NH_Blk_CVAP 19 A_NH_Ind_CVAP-19 A_NH_Ind_CVAP-19 A_NH_Asn_CVAP-19 A_NH_Asn_CVAP-19 _NH_Hwn_CVAP_-_19 -+- - NH_Hwn_CVAP-19 14 - - 18 - HU_Occupied 18_Owner_occupied 18_Owner_occupied Value 8 15427 -127 -0.82% 1661 10.77% 9098 58.97% 452 2.93% 18 0.12% 2903 18.82% 23 0.15% 109 0.71% 13035 84.49% 1226 9.41% 8483 65.08% 375 2.88% 49 0.38% 2352 18.04% 30 0.23% 5801 2391 41.22% 3418 58.92% 1370912 ACS 14-18 Renter occupied % ACS 14-18 Renter occupied ACS 14-18 HH Median income ACS 14-18 Median Age 459.19Amber Map - Version 2 Page 17 of 4231

2021 Redistricting Community of Interest Forms # Date Received District Submitted By COI Summary General Geographic Region Approx Location for Map Pin Approx Location Comments COI Themes Reference or Endorsement to Submitted Map? If Y, which one? Is COI mappable? (Y/N) Boundary Change Requested by Submittter (Y/N) Boundary Change Recommended by Cx (Y/N) Rationale for Recommendation by Cx Notes 1 7/19/2021 7 Raina Zhao on behalf of ASUC UC Berkeley student body District 7, south of UC Berkeley campus. Most students live within 1 mile of campus. 2490 Channing Way, 94704 STUDENT REPRESENTATION YES STUDENTS SHOULD BE GROUPED TOGETHER 2 7/20/2021 2 Joanna Louie Infrastructure; crime; pollution South west Berkeley 2995 San Pablo Ave, 94702 NEIGHBORHOOD EQUITY; CRIME NO 3 7/20/2021 5 B. Yoder Safety concerns Ada Street between Ordway and Acton. Ada between Acton and Sacramento, folks on Acton and on Ordway from Hopkins to Rose, a few folks on Hopkins just below and just above Orway. 1400 Ada St, 94702 NEIGHBORHOOD COHESIVENESS; SAFETY YES MAINTAIN COI 4 7/20/2021 5 Margot Dashiel Close proximity; neighborhood area Ada street 1400 Ada St, 94702 NEIGHBORHOOD COHESIVENESS YES MAINTAIN COI 5 7/21/2021 5 Joe Berry Demographics; Development Lower hills, near Marin/Arlington Circle. 2100 Marin Ave, 94707 AFFORDABLE HOUSING; HOUSING EQUITY NO 6 7/21/2021 5 John Gardening, art, music, food, being outdoors Ada Street between Ordway and Acton. 1400 Ada St, 94702 NEIGHBORHOOD COHESIVENESS YES MAINTAIN NEIGHBORHOOD CONTIGUITY 7 1 Prateek Haldar High quality schools, development at North Berkeley BART, affordable housing, creation of bike lanes, improving vibrancy of Hopkins/Gilman shopping/restaurants Bound by Hopkins Street on the north, Sacramento on the west (or San Pablo) MLK on the east, and Cedar on the south. 1359 Rose St, 94702 HOUSING EQUITY; HOUSING DEVELOPMENT; NO BERK BART NO 8 7/28/2021 5 1546 Milvia Gerrymandered out of District 4. Neighborhood/block split in 2 Milvia at District 4/5 - split the 2 sides of the block and put in District 5 1450 Milvia St, 94709 COUNCILMEMBER RESIDENCY; NEIGHBORHOOD SPLIT YES BOUNDARIES SHOULDN’T BE DRAWN BASED ON COUNCILMEMBER RESIDENCY 9 7/28/2021 None Helping each other- sharing tools, offering rides, celebrating wins, informing each other about noisy construction, or house repairs Tilden Park to the east and south, grizzly peak to the west and Cragmont to the north 50 Whitaker Ave, 94708 (Unclear geographic location. Selected Grizzly Peak Park address.) NEIGHBORHOOD DESCRIPTION NO 10 7/30/2021 8 Vincent Casalaina Crime reduction, maintaining characteristic housing (single-family or single family + ADU), transit Willard neighborhood. Telegraph/Parker & College/Ashby. 2730 Hillegass Ave, 94705 IMPROVED RESOURCE/SERVICE EQUITY; TRANSPORTTION; CRIME; SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING YES 11 8/16/2021 5 No name (kktompkins@gmail.com) Beautification, Solano Ave corridor development, property crime Far north Berkeley adjacent to Solano Ave to Albany border in the west. 1559 Solano Ave, 94707 NEIGHBORHOOD DESCRIPTION; CRIME NO 12 8/20/2021 2 No name Schools, garbage; effects from nearby homeless population Fourth & Fifth, from Dwight to Addison 800 Bancroft Way, 94710 NEIGHBORHOOD SAFETY; HOMELESSNESS NO 13 8/26/2021 None No name clean air, affordable low density housing, transportation networks that dont smash thru our neighborhoods, slow streets, public safety, litter and street trash, childcare, parks, trees, community green space north west berkeley - west of San Pablo to University 1529 Sixth St, 94710 NEIGHBORHOOD EQUITY/SERVICES; INDUSTRIAL ACTIVITY/ DEVELOPMENT/POLLUTION NO 14 8/26/2021 1 nan@essentialbusinessbehaviors .com Families, safety, community North Berkeley BART, Adult school on Virginia, Rose St. on other side of Cedar- Rose Park, San Pablo Avenue, Cedar Street 1201 Virginia St, 94702 HOMELESSNESS; NORT BERK BART; HOUSING DENSITY NO 15 9/12/2021 3 No name More racially mixed than North or Central Berkeley Corner of Parker and McGee 1700 Parker St, 94703 RACIAL DIVERSITY; PROPERTY VALUES NO 16 9/12/2021 None No name International Coastal Clean-up month; Disaster Relief Cmmittees; Food/beverage committee; Clean-up committee B/W West Berkeley and North 1720 Eighth St, 94710 Changed it to James Kenney (Unclear geographic location. Picked an intersection in Northwest Berkeley neighborhood for pin.) AFFORDABILITY; INCLUSION; WATERFRONT CLEAN-UP NO If YES, entire Commission will assess what considerations there are for applicable boundary/district changes Attachment 2 - COI Matrix.xlsxPage 1 of 17 Page 18 of 4232

2021 Redistricting Community of Interest Forms # Date Received District Submitted By COI Summary General Geographic Region Approx Location for Map Pin Approx Location Comments COI Themes Reference or Endorsement to Submitted Map? If Y, which one? Is COI mappable? (Y/N) Boundary Change Requested by Submittter (Y/N) Boundary Change Recommended by Cx (Y/N) Rationale for Recommendation by Cx Notes If YES, entire Commission will assess what considerations there are for applicable boundary/district changes 17 9/14/2021 6 No name Context (scale & mix), distant views, especially of the bay and the coastal hills; mainly a residential area with single-family homes, many with secondary units, typically with backyards and gardens; could see a mix of smaller vehicles and better transit, but it needs to be phased in , grandfathering older residents who depend on cars. Streets could be rethought. Filling every backyard with an ADU or building out single- family sites would be a mistake, but a thoughtful mix would be fine. Same comment about the Shattuck corridor - do't overload it. Some density but not a view- blocking wall. Oxford Street and east. Odd situation where three districts overlap and near neighbors are represented by Hahn, Harrison, and Wengraf, whose districts differ substantially. District 6 should take in the north Shattuck corridor. We are closer to Thousand Oaks (Hahn) than the west side of Shattuck (Harrison) in interests, I sense. 1600 Oxford St, 94709 HOME OWNERSHIP; VIEW PRESERVATION; DISTRICT BOUNDARIES (5&6); MAINTAIN SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING YES MAINTAIN COI 18 9/23/2021 2 Veronica Latinos with long history of home ownership and multiple generation households 5th street and San Pablo, between University and Dwight 920 Allston Way, 94710 SERVICE ALLOCATION; RACIAL EQUITY; HISTORICAL LATINO NEIGHBORHOOD; RESOURCE EQUITY; MULTIGENERATIONAL LIVING NO 19 9/27/2021 2 Sheryl public safety, education, beautification San Pablo Park neighborhood, West Berkeley, Left Bank are all names used for D2 2501 San Pablo Ave, 94702 HOMELESSNESS; INDUSTRIAL POLLUTION; DIVERSITY; PUBLIC SAFETY NO 20 9/28/2021 2 Ms. Ty Crime reduction, clean streets (eliminate illegal dumping), affordable housing South Berkeley 3100 Adeline St,94703 (Unclear geographic location. Selected park near Sacramento and Fairview.) FORGOTTEN NEIGHBORHOOD; ILLEGAL DUMPING; CRIME; AFFORDABLE HOUSING NO 21 9/28/2021 3 Ayanna Davis Berkeley Black Community, State of Black Berkeley My community of interest is South West Berkeley beginning at Cedar and 4th Street and ending at 62nd and Adeline. West Berkeley, South Berkeley, Loren District 2546 Tenth St, 94710 (Large geographic location. Selected an address central to the described area.) HOUSING/RESOURCE EQUITY; POVERTY; FOOD INSECURITY; HEALTH/ECONOMIC EQUITY; HISTORICAL BLACK NEIGHBORHOOD YES No, MAINTAIN DISTRICT 3 UNDERFUNDED? 22 9/29/2021 1 James Public safety (homelessness/mentally ill people) Gourmet Ghetto 1549 Shattuck Ave, 94709 (Unclear geographic area. Selected address in North Shattuck neighborhood.) PUBLIC SAFETY; HOMELESSNESS; MENTAL ILLNESS NO 23 9/29/2021 3 No name diversity in ppl and architecture. nice flat and walkable, close to SF, Oakland, easy access; South Berkeley 3075 Adeline St, 94703 (Unclear geographic area. Selected address near streets named in COI form.) HOMELESSNESS; CRIME; ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; RESOURCE EQUITY; DIVERSITY NO 24 10/2/2021 4 No name Safe neighborhood (walkable/bike friendly); traffic concerns, homelessness/littering, UC Berkeley take over of town. Central Berkeley between Sacramento and downtown. 2246 McGee Ave, 94703 PUBLIC SAFETY; TRANSPORTATION SAFETY; HOMELESSNESS; RELATIONSHIP WITH UCB NO 25 10/8/2021 5 north Shattuck Environment, trees, city upkeep, art, ease of shopping, parking, good food, lovely parks, socializing, access to BART. Marin Circle to University Avenue, from Grizzly Peak to Sacramento streets. Name provided: North Shattuck 1444 Shattuck Pl, 94709 Changed the pin to the Safeway in North Berkeley TRANSPORTATION; FIRE SAFETY/EVACUATION; ROADWAY CONDITIONS; HOMELESSNESS YES DISTRICT 5 26 10/16/2021 8 Elizabeth Elmwood District 2703 Stuart Street, 94705 None See map See map MAP 27 10/16/2021 2 Ben Gardella Strawberry Creek Park Alston, Sacrameto, Sacramento and Dwight Street Name provided: Poet's Corner 1314 Bancroft Way, 94702 MAINTAIN COI; NEIGHBORHOOD CONTIGUITY; PARK YES MAINTAIN DISTRICT 28 10/16/2021 2 Heather Clauge Strawberry Creek Park University to Dwight, Sacramento to San Pablo Name provided: Poet's Corner 1298 Bancroft Way, 94702 PARK/RECREATION; HOMELESSNESS; COI NEIGHBORHOOD CONTIGUITY YES MAINTAIN DISTRICT Attachment 2 - COI Matrix.xlsxPage 2 of 17 Page 19 of 4233

2021 Redistricting Community of Interest Forms # Date Received District Submitted By COI Summary General Geographic Region Approx Location for Map Pin Approx Location Comments COI Themes Reference or Endorsement to Submitted Map? If Y, which one? Is COI mappable? (Y/N) Boundary Change Requested by Submittter (Y/N) Boundary Change Recommended by Cx (Y/N) Rationale for Recommendation by Cx Notes If YES, entire Commission will assess what considerations there are for applicable boundary/district changes 29 10/17/2021 2 Douglas Smith Families raising young children, retirees and elders aging in place, multigenerational housing--all of whom patronize the businesses along the San Pablo and University corridors and make use of primary parks like San Pablo Park, Strawberry Creek Park & Aquatic Park. Neighbors band together to monitor safety & crime, pedestrian/bike safety, working closely with our new Councilmember Taplin. There is a cohesive atmosphere which underscores a sense of this being a true community of individuals, looking out for each other. South to San Pablo Park, the 9th Street Bike Boulevard to the west, north to University Avenue, and east to Sacramento Street. University Avenue does seem to be a true dividing line and an appopriate boundary between D2 and D1; somehow San Pablo does not divide the Community. Name provided: Poet's Corner 1312 Bancroft Way, 94702 MULTIGENERATIONAL HOUSING; PARKS & RECREATION; SAFETY; CRIME YES MAINTAIN DISTRICT 30 10/17/2021 1 No name Preserving residential character of neighborhoood for livability. Safety of residents (crime prevention and optimal traffic/pedestrian flow). Diverse demographics. San Pablo to the west, University Avenue to the South; Shattuck to the East; and Vine to the north. Name provided: Northbrae 1619 Edith St, 94703 TRAFFIC/TRANSPORTATION SAFETY; POPULATION DENSITY; NEIGHBORHOOD LIVABILITY; ZONING; INADEQUATE REPRESENTATION YES PRESERVE RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER 31 10/18/2021 2 No name commitment to Family, school, community events, shared political affiliations, diverse cultures, mixed low and middle income housing and proximity to shopping. We enjoy our Great walking and biking score! From the Bay to Sacramento Street; from University to Bancroft. Connected to neighbors, particularly on Byron Street and Cowper. Name provided: Poet's Corner 2228 San Pablo Ave, 94702 TRAFFIC CONTROL; STREET PAVING; DENSITY; ECONOMIC DEV; FERRY; MIXED HOUSING YES MAINTAIN DISTRICT 32 10/18/2021 2 Ariel Smith-Iyer Appreciation for diversity; common interest in contining to be a place for all in the neighborhood. Strawbery Creek Park is an important community meeting place; area surrounding the park, Corp Yard, and bowling green vacant lot should remain together to collectively decide the future of the space. San Pablo to Sacramento; University Avenue to Dwight Way. Name provided: Poet's Corner 1302 Bancroft Way, 94702 TRASH COLLECTION; PARKS & RECREATION; OVER POPULATION; ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; DIVERSITY YES MAINTAIN DISTRICT 33 10/18/2021 2 No name Traffic and speeding West Berk Flat Lands between Sacramento & San Pablo. 2500 Bonar St, 94702 Incomplete boundaries; selected address at intersection of Dwight Way & Bonar Street. TRANSPORTATION SAFETY; SERVICE ALLOCATION; TRAFFIC SAFETY NO 34 10/26/2021 No name Communities of interest that previous cycles of redistricting have dismissed: I. Prospect Street is a community of interest currently split between District 7 and District 8. The east side of Prospect is in District 8, and the west side is in District 7. Both sides of the street should be in the same district. Both sides of Prospect Street have more in common with Southside than with Panoramic Hill or Elmwood-Claremont. 7.Clark Kerr Campus is in District 8. The students who live there have more in common with Southside than with Elmwood-Claremont. 8. Redwood Gardens, a senior housing facility located on the Clark Kerr Campus, has more in common with Elmwood-Claremont neighbors than with students and should be considered a community of interest separate from students' community of interest. 9. Faculty housing on Clark Kerr Campus is a community of interest that has more in common with Elmwood- Claremont than with students. 10. The blocks within Dwight- Waring-Derby-Telegraph have more in common with Southside than with Elmwood-Claremont. 11. I House and the student co-ops behind it are in District 8. The residents of these dorms have more in common with Southside than with Elmwood-Claremont. 12. The blocks within Cedar-Oxford-Hearst-Arch are part of Northside and not split between District 5 and District 6. Northside should extend to Walnut, maybe even Shattuck. 13. The blocks within Sacramento- Ashby-California-border are in District 2. They should be in District 3. 14. The blocks within University-Acton-Allston-Sacramento are part of Poet's Corner, which is in District 2. 15. Part of Cragmont is in District 6,.and part is in District 5. 16. The blocks within Fulton- Dwight-Dana-Channing are in District 4 and should be in District 7. 17. Using Ellsworth as the border between District 3 and District 7 and District 8 is wrong. Fulton is a better border, and Shattuck even better. 18. Codonices, in District 6, has more in common with Live Oak than the Berkeley Hills. 19. The "hat" of District 4, where Jesse lives, should be in District 5. 20. The "dog leg" of District 7, where Kriss lives, includes parts of LeConte and Willard that should 2180 Milvia Street, 94704 Not specific to one address or area; used Civic Center address as a general location, None See map See map MAP Attachment 2 - COI Matrix.xlsxPage 3 of 17 Page 20 of 4234

2021 Redistricting Community of Interest Forms # Date Received District Submitted By COI Summary General Geographic Region Approx Location for Map Pin Approx Location Comments COI Themes Reference or Endorsement to Submitted Map? If Y, which one? Is COI mappable? (Y/N) Boundary Change Requested by Submittter (Y/N) Boundary Change Recommended by Cx (Y/N) Rationale for Recommendation by Cx Notes If YES, entire Commission will assess what considerations there are for applicable boundary/district changes 35 11/3/2021 1 Phil Allen By the looks of things in my part of D-1, this is a townish and family (dwellings) area of the city. I see family activity and the retail and recreational which sustain them. There is no overt presence of UC students; they seem to be elsewhere. Retired friends gather here, internet junkies there. San Pablo Avenue provides a traditionally gritty 'home' to a constant presence of lost and forgotten citizen/ghosts and their movable social spots. My 'felt' boundaries, running from close-by San Pablo/Delaware as center, are: Addison (south); 9th St. (west); Gilman (north), indeterminate (east). Names provided: Cutthroat Corner or Almost Oceanview 1740 San Pablo Avenue, 94702 Incomplete boundaries; selected intersection of San Pablo/Delaware. RETURN TO PAST; HOMELESSNESS; MENTAL ILLNESS; ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; FORGOTTEN CITIZENS NO 36 11/6/2021 5 Barbara Ann Yoder I am part of a vibrant neighborhood group established probably in the 1980s, when former fire chief Bill Brock and his wife initiated annual gatherings during National Night Out. For the last 13 years since I moved to Ada Street, our neighborhood group has worked together sharing safety concerns and looking out for each other. We currently have 65 households in our group. We are in touch via email. We meet annually. We know each other by name. We have a neighborhood earthquake cache and a neighbor on Ordway offers trainings. All of Ada Street below Sacramento should be in District 1, where we used to be. When the lines were redrawn, they went right down the middle of our street. As a neighborhood we are impacted by development plans at N. Berkeley BART, Ruth Acty School traffic and events, Cedar-Rose Park events, traffic on Hopkins and the Ohlone Greenway—all in District 1. We should be rejoined with District 1. Our neighborhood group currently includes 65 homes along Ada Street from Ordway to Acton and about halfway up the next block toward Sacramento. It includes most homes on Ordway from Hopkins to Rose, several homes on Rose and on Hopkins that back to Ada between Ordway and Acton, and most homes on Acton from Hopkins to Ada. Everyone in these blocks are welcome in our group. When you redraw the lines, if a street needs to be split down the middle, it shouldn't be a quiet short street like Ada; it should be a busy through street with double yellow lines, like Hopkins from Ordway to Acton. Also, if Ordway between Hopkins and Ada is split down the middle, it too should be reincorporated into District 1. 1400 Ada St,94702 Appended to COI Form #3 (submitter's first COI form) NEIGHBORHOOD CONTINUITY; TRAFFIC SAFETY; BART; RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER YES REJOIN ADA ST TO DISTRICT 1 37 11/8/2021 3 Carl McPherson Students & Renters There is considerable overlap between renters and students, and we are concentrated in the areas around Berkeley main campus and the two BART stations. As I look at the maps already submitted, I think that Alfred Twu’s “Compact Donut” map does a good job of collecting the main student populations into 2 districts on the southside and the areas just west and north of the main campus. It’s unfortunate that we don’t have 9 districts to work with, as I think—for population balancing purposes—Alfred Twu’s map is unable to extend far enough North-South along the Shattuck corridor or far enough south on the Telegraph corridor to create 3 renter/student districts (Southside, Northside and “Westside”). Stephen Young’s excellent map (which has several nice innovations, including taking the hillier parts of current Districts 5 and 6 and combining them into a single district) creates a district for the 1947 Center Street, 94704 (Unclear geographic boundaries; selected 1947 Center Street as central location). ADD ANOTHER STUDENT DISTRICT; UP-ZONING (HOUSING DIVERSITY); PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION YES STUDENT REPRESENTATION Attachment 2 - COI Matrix.xlsxPage 4 of 17 Page 21 of 4235

2021 Redistricting Community of Interest Forms # Date Received District Submitted By COI Summary General Geographic Region Approx Location for Map Pin Approx Location Comments COI Themes Reference or Endorsement to Submitted Map? If Y, which one? Is COI mappable? (Y/N) Boundary Change Requested by Submittter (Y/N) Boundary Change Recommended by Cx (Y/N) Rationale for Recommendation by Cx Notes If YES, entire Commission will assess what considerations there are for applicable boundary/district changes 38 11/8/2021 4 David Ushijima The community in this neighborhood is tied together not only by our geographical proximity and walkability of the neighborhood but our shared interest in many activities that are within walking distance in the nearby Downtown and Theatre districts. Also because of our close proximity to the University, we also share the common interests of cultural and intellectual events held on the UC Berkeley campus. Dwight Way (south), University Avenue (north); MLK (east), Sacramento (west). Name provided: Spaulding-McGee tract. Please do not break up this community by drawing lines which would bisect the natural geographic boundaries of this community. 1700 Bancroft Way, 94703 CULTURAL ACCESS; RELATIONSHIP WITH UCB YES NEIGHBORHOOD CONTIGUITY DIST 4 39 11/12/2021 4 Stephanie Allan As a resident of the Flatlands since 1969, I have a strong interest in how District 4 is drawn or redrawn. When I first moved here, the neighborhood bounded by Shattuck/University/Sacramento/Dwight Way was primarily a working class area, predominantly white, but with some black families on Jefferson and Spaulding. It was a fairly tight community, located between the student/University area to the east, the historic black community to the west. There were lots of families here and a lot of kids. My son grew up & went to Washington school in this area. I worked hard to build a tot lot on Roosevelt and get a barrier at Channing & Roosevelt as well as a stop sign on McGee. (Pedestrian safety is still a major worry here, though) The housing used to be affordable. No longer, of course, like the rest of Berkeley. My neighborhood on Channing Way has been affected by the homeless crisis. Because we have a free box on Channing, between Roosevelt & McGee, we get a lot of homeless traffic from Downtown. Also, until we, reluctantly, agreed to have parking restrictions, the streets were jammed with UC students' parking. We supported making Channing Way a bike street although the condition of the road makes biking hazardous. The park area on the Ohlone strip was a great addition to the area. Aside from the park at Washington (where I participated in the redesign and addition of a regulation size basketball court when I was chair of the remodel committee) and the Tot Lot on Roosevelt, there isn't a lot of open space in our neighborhood. Civic Center Park was for so many years not a hospitable space. There is still a great deal of drug dealing going on there, probably migrating down from Shattuck. While muc

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Independent Redistricting Commission Regular Meeting - 02/28/2022 (English)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9317730c2dfb1f65e9373788d841998e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record