POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Event, Code Enforcement Board

Thursday, September 3, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The transcript describes the Code Enforcement Board reviewing numerous property violation cases, discussing compliance deadlines ranging from 3 to 120 days, and addressing lien mitigations for property owners who brought distressed properties into compliance.

Why it matters

Property owners face steep daily fines ranging from $150 to $1,000 for unremedied building, sanitation, or zoning violations, while those who remediate code infractions can apply for substantial lien mitigations.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Captured actions

1

Recorded outcomes

0

Source artifacts

2

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 11, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 116,784 stored characters

liberty and justice for all. Please remain standing. Be sworn in. >> thank you. Do you solemnly swear or affirm the testimony you are about to give? Is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth? Thank you. >> you MAY have a seat. Do you solemnly swear? Do you solemnly swear and affirm you will translate from english to spanish and spanish to english to the best of your ability. Thank you. Good afternoon. >> buenas tardes necesitan ayuda en espanol or a vamos a la juramento. Ahora si la verdad toda la verdad y nada mas la verdad. Okay. Do you solemnly swear and affirm that you will translate from english to korean creole to english to the best of your ability? Thank you. Most of all. Les anglais avec anglais. No merci beaucoup. All right. Um. Yeah. MR. Williams present. MR. Rodriguez present. MR. Galan. Present. >> MR. Madonna. Oh, sorry. Oh, sorry. MR. Miller. MR. Moshi, we have quorum. You forgot me. You forgot. You got two folks you forgot. I think. Ulysses present. Oh, sorry. And MR. Galan present. Thank you. >> I heard [Laughter] Somebody from the audience say PRESIDENT, listen to me, all right? Sorry. >> all right. No problem. >> good evening. Most of you are here today for the first time. There's a small number of you that are here from mitigation. When your case is called, please come up to the podium. State your name and the address you're here on behalf of. Let the board know whether you're guilty or not guilty of the violation. If you plead guilty to the violation, the city will inform the board in a summary fashion as to what the violation is. They'll make a recommendation for the amount of days you need to cure the violation. The board will vote unanimously to give you the amount of days that the city recommends or more days or less days. However the board votes and they'll apply a per diem violation if you don't comply by the date given. If you're a first time violator with a residential property, it's up to $250 per diem if you're a first time nonresidential commercial property, it's $1,000 per diem if you are a repeat violator if you're a residential repeat violator it's $500 maximum and if you're a nonresidential commercial repeat violator it's up to $5,000. If you plead not guilty, the city will put on its case. You will put on your response to the city and the vote will go. The board will go through a similar process vote and give you a per diem uh and a time to comply. Uh, if you don't have a power of attorney by this point, you MAY want to come and see me if you're not the owner or the managing member of the property or a licensed florida attorney, if you're here for mitigation, there's a chart, there's the chart. There MAY be a chart we'll find it that tells you what the city can and can't do for you as far as mitigation, the board is bound by that chart. They cannot go lower than what that chart permits. So take a look at it if you're waiting uh we'll be calling mitigations first. Um all orders of the board are available to the 11th judicial circuit court of florida within 30 days. One last thing. If you the few cases that we have that are on for mitigation when you're done that the board determines what your mitigation amount is. Come over here and wait for me in the corner so I can give you your copy of your order so you can take with you and payment instructions and at the podium there is a piece of paper if you're here for the first time. Once a board gives you the time to comply, it tells you how to request an extension of time. Are the papers there? Yeah for extension of time. I'm sorry. Yes up there. Okay. >> so take that paper with you and it'll tell you how to ask for an extension of time. All right. Good evening everyone. We're going to try to get everybody out of here pretty quickly. Uh, can we get the cases? I see we have a special appearance so we want to do that after mitigations. I understand that rachel MAY have some special requests. >> I see there's one special appearance. You don't so I can call mitigations and [Laughter] I know. No worries, I just. [Laughter] I'm good. >> I don't whatever I'm good. All right we'll go straight to mitigations okay. You do you mitigation sounds great great mitigation if the special appearance clicked in we can take that after that and then do the whatever you want to do. I'm fine. Mitigation. >> yeah. >> let's get out of the way. Page 146 property address 1121 northwest second street. Case number 00066081. This is a vacant lot. The lane ran to $64,000. The minimum is 7500 even I mean 75 64,000. I know my brain. I got to get back into the swing of things. Uh so even um 20% of 64,000 is over more than 7500. So the minimum is 7500. Great. >> good evening. State. State your name and address for the record. Good evening. My name is pablo calatrava. I'm the manager of the new corporation that owned the property since last year. Thank you for your time. First of all, no problem. And the reason of my appearance here is that to the best of my knowledge, by the time that this violation occurred there was a single family home there, you know, so I would like to put that in consideration. Okay. >> let me check let me check and see. Hold on. Maybe. And how soon after you got the notices for violations did you comply? Yes sir. >> I don't know how soon afterwards. I bought the property in last year you know so right now I try to put it in compliance with all the all my means. You know I bought pictures from today. Gotcha. >> so you bought the property with the violations? Yes, I bought it on the court. Thank you. Looks like it was an empty lot. Just an empty lot. No previous use of. >> the I have pictures. I MADAM If you put the address in. >> I'm looking at the pictures from OCTOBER 4th of 2023. Okay. >> no because when you see in the internet you see the old structure that was there because it was demolished by the city. I paid for the demolition after I bought the property right. >> well it still MAY have owed money on a demolition. >> yeah yeah yeah I it was clear. That this property was cited for the empty lot being overgrown to maintain the lot and fail to register a lot. So it's 7500. There was not a structure on the property when it was cited. Got it. So there wouldn't be it wouldn't be able to revert to being a single family home. Okay so the so the best we can do today. Thank you. The best we can do today is mitigate it down to 7500 okay from the 64,000 okay okay. Thank you very much. Can I get a motion please? Yeah. >> move to reduce it to 7,502nd second. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Wait for your paper here. Okay. >> yeah. You're welcome. Next case. Um this was recently added on is add on three case number c 2018 022910. This is a mitigation. >> is a mitigation okay this is a reset from last JULY sir acosta. This is 4101 northwest 11th place. Yes okay this property is a vacant lot. The lien ran to $363,300 I remember and we're back and the minimum is 7500. Can you state your name and address for the record? Frank acosta 705 southeast 13th circle, homestead, florida. Gotcha. >> and so any any background on this other than the the lien amount and what we could do on it or is it immediate previous use was the. >> I'm going to make sure right now since it's an add on it says work without a permit. So yeah because we don't have anything to look at so. It looks like it was a single family home. [Laughter] Lucky you. Um single family home with homestead but it wouldn't have now. So when it was cited it was a single family home. Therefore prior to it becoming a vacant lot its past use was as a single family home. Therefore they are eligible for a minimum of 10,000 which is more than the 7500 or by unanimous vote down to zero. Yeah. >> the question. What's what's the use of the property now it's a vacant lot okay. And you guys are selling it or it's going to be your home. You're going to be living there. I have all the information you asked. You got to move the mic to the. >> I have all the information you asked before here if you'd like to see. >> you got it all done. Got it all done. I rolled the dice. All right good job. Okay thank you. Thank you. You're going to be living there and you're getting ready to process plans for a new property a new house. That's going to be that's correct. That's going to be your homestead. Homestead property I moved to uh bring it down to zero. Can I get a second please? Second what second oh thank you. All in favor I thank you sir for your. Thank you very much. You're welcome. Next case. Sometimes it pays to come back. It does. Sometimes it does pay to come back. Right. Um this is add on two property address 3101 southwest fourth street case number c 2021 004165. Okay. >> you know you know I promise everybody we'll be out of here by six. >> this is 3101 southwest fourth street. This is a single family home with homestead exemption. The lien ran to $88,250. The minimum would be $5,000 or zero with or down to zero with the unanimous vote. Good evening. Good evening. State your name and address for the record. >> let me. Yes. >> see. >> okay. I have a power of attorney. She's my aunt never had children. She's a widow 87 years old. Okay. >> do we have the power of attorney? Yeah, I gave it. >> to show the power of attorney, but that's that's the property owner giving her authority to speak. >> yeah. No no no. But I was just curious. Yeah, I gave it to him. All right. Thank you. Um well you see the violations that were actually issued in 2021 um at that point I was not in miami. I was not aware of the violations and when I came back to oh actually my cousin that passed away from cancer, she reached out to him and he was going to try to help her, but he passed away and I never knew about it. Okay. I take care of her through cameras and stay with her now twice a week to help her out. Okay. And at that point going through the mail I come across um a form from the letter from the city of miami. Yeah. And when I read it I almost freaked out. I said dear, do you know about this. The violation I'll let them know the violation was just for extra concrete and was for that side carport just the aluminum that's what the violation was. So I don't know if you guys want to take it from there. Yeah hold on real quick. >> she lives at the property right. That's her homestead. >> she is my aunt. Yes. Okay. >> can I get a motion. >> move to zero. Thank you. >> second. Second. >> all those in favor? Hi. >> thank you. Okay. >> yeah. >> just wait for your paperwork over there. Thank you so much. >> thank you so much for taking care of you. GOD bless you all. Thank you. GOD bless you as well. Yeah no no no. Page 158 property address 3377 southwest 29th terrace case number 00015188. Good evening. This is the line ran to $671,500. This is a homestead exempt duplex property. So the minimum is $5,000 or down to zero by unanimous vote. State your name and address for the record. My name is ramirez and I represent navarro. Navarro property holdings llc, the owner of that company. The new owners don't have exemption but the old owners did right? Yeah so. So but we're looking at the new owners so yeah I'm sorry we're looking at the you're representing the new owners. Well the current. >> owner the current owners. The current owners. Yeah it doesn't have. Homestead exemption sorry. Yeah there is no home so the minimum is $10,000 but it can go down to zero as low as zero with a unanimous vote my ear. Thank you. >> so I just want to bring up a few points in relation to this file. Uh the violation was back in JUNE of 2022. The first notice of violation was JUNE 8th of 2022. We did not get the actual affidavits when we got the city documents. The affidavit from the inspector at the time that posted or states in that affidavit that they posted this JUNE 8th letter on the door was not until JUNE 9th knowing that the correction timeline was only provided to JUNE 10th. So essentially one business day to correct this violation at this property. These were the alleged violations right? Remember those but these are serious situations too. So okay. So in relation to this violation it wasn't anything that had to do with the actual building the structure. It wasn't a fire. It wasn't something with hazardous it's essentially the emergency. It's 2401 emergency plans and emergency preparedness measures required essentially the little roadmap to showcase the emergency exits. We believe that that was the violation. That's what stated in the letter. But there's some inconsistencies in relation to those letters as well as the photos that the city took and saved as far as their evidence, although we have the letter JUNE 8th and the affidavit that states that that inspector specifically put that JUNE 8th letter on the door on JUNE 9th, the photos don't reflect that the note was posted until JUNE 11th after the time to correct the issue. On top of all of that, there were some other issues with the summons as well as to why my client could not attend the mitigation hearing or the actual violation hearing the first time in relation to that letter it's dated JUNE. Are you speaking to why they couldn't attend the meeting? I'm sorry. >> are you speaking to why they couldn't attend the the board hearing? Correct. >> okay. >> so the notice of violation summons to be able to attend a JUNE 21st hearing date was dated JUNE 13th. Mhm. But the problem is the affidavit of the inspector that says they put that JUNE 13th on the door states that they did it on JUNE 9th, not JUNE 13th. So it becomes an impossibility. How does one post a letter that did not exist at the time they're alleging it existed? In addition to that we refer back to the photos. The photos suggest JUNE 11th as far as posting of the notice of violation and the summons being posted JUNE 13th. So I don't know what happened there and I'm not saying anything nefarious happened. Perhaps there was a mistake. The inspector posted these notices then went back to the office drafted and forgot to take the photos. They came the weekend took those photos regardless my client just did not have the notice and I would like to share a little bit of a of her background. If I MAY say the notices were actually the posting is a courtesy the certified mailings went out so and that's what's required. So that brings me to that next point that I was going to bring up in relation to the certified mailing. The affidavits both say that it was my first class mail. The ups tag usps tag suggests certified, but yet there's no tracking history on any of the letters sent in addition. To that you mean there's no tracking number? >> that's because it's from 2022. Usps only holds information for two years so if you pull those numbers up you're not going to be able to find it online. Understood. >> I'm not saying that it wasn't sent. Right and all that's. Required to do is be sent it's a mailbox rule right? Yeah. >> and that's why I'm the reason. I'm not alleging. No I know you're not doing it but see I have to listen very closely because when when you say something that the city didn't do its job, we pay attention to that. And then we also got to make sure we're being doing our due diligence. And that's why that follow up question meaning that you sure there's no tracking number because it expires after two years. So these are the we just have to listen very closely to what you're saying understood. we're not saying you're saying anything either. We're just listening very closely understood. And by no means is my argument here today suggesting in any way that the city did not do its job. We believe that they did do their job. The problem is it goes back to the notice and reasonableness of that notice if these letters were mailed out JUNE 9th as the affidavit suggests, providing a JUNE 10th correction time frame is a one business day so those letters had to have been sent next day just for a client to receive it at that P.O. Box if we let if the P.O. Box would have been received at that time. So after the violation after the hearing that was missed this issue stayed dormant until APRIL of this year. There was another inspection on APRIL 1st which was brought up to my client's attention that hey, you still have this violation and you're racking up daily fees. As soon as she was actually physically made aware of that notice I'm not suggesting that she was required to have notice just her position. She immediately took steps to take care of it by the by APRIL 8th it was complied with. By APRIL 9th the city had confirmed. APRIL of what this year 2026. Yes that's why the fine is so high. So that's why we're here today. We wanted to bring up the notice issue uh both the city of miami web well the city of miami website on the facts section says that reasonable time, even though it's not defined generally is about 30 days. Our issue was well we were provided one business day at best. So no matter how minor the issue was of that violation to cure one business day and I believe it landed on a friday where this correction had to be made, I don't believe that was just sufficient time because even when my client was brought up to speed in APRIL of this year, it still took her about seven days to get it done and she did get it done. We're in full compliance now in relation to what we're here on today. So that's why we're requesting mitigation here. >> so to be clear it's not a minor issue right. Um these laws were all enacted after the numerous deaths up in broward county at the nursing home. Correct. And these are alfs operated out of home. You're supposed to treat it as a single family home. That's why the you know, or duplex and that's why um, for purposes of these type of mitigations, they do get the consideration to be mitigated as a single family home or duplex that's not homestead exempt. So ten 0000 is your option. Um again it's not minor to comply with the law should the power go out to have the required electrical backup hook up with your propane tanks that have to be delivered. None of this is minor. Also under the code if you have a regular violation you generally do get 30 days when you have a life safety violation and that's what this was a life safety violation then you are we are not required to abide by the 30 days also at the hearing even though they did not appear at that JUNE hearing, they were still given two months to comply. That order was mailed again to the owner. Um and so you know, I'm assuming I'm guessing they're not receiving their mail but they had until AUGUST 5th to comply. So it's not like then they had the hearing right and then they were told no. Um so they had all of those notices. There's no record of contact to the city uh for requesting of a reset that they received it they didn't know we always generally reset those if somebody has an issue legitimately that they bring. Furthermore there's 30 days to appeal. No appeal was given to appeal the notice. So any notice argument now is already waived. They failed to appeal. We know that they did receive it. We know that they're admitting that it was posted on the property. They knew it was posted on the property so they had notice if it was late. Obviously the you have 30 days to appeal it. They also had 60 days or so to or just under 60 days to comply. That didn't happen. On the other hand they have come into compliance which is excellent right. Um and so I believe you guys have already dealt with these in a very particular way, all of them the same way I'm not stepping on your toes again it's the minimum is ten 000 or all the way to zero. And thank you for the background and the coloring of that history there. So yeah, we deal with this all the time. We know what it is and so all that wash your client is looking for and is your client's going to be moving. So is it still operating. As operating as an alf. >> to this? Understood. Just one last thing and please correct me if I did not receive it via email when I requested the documents that final enforcement notice I don't know if within that file it's provided the the tracking number or proof of actually sending. I don't know if that's the case when it comes to that because the JUNE 8th and the JUNE. >> those aren't certified mail. Those are just regular mail. Yeah. >> okay. Yeah I can tell you that's just regular mail. That's not a certified mail. Gotcha. >> any questions? Yeah. >> when your client purchased the property was he aware of the violations? So that's a little bit of a back story because the house was purchased when she was still with her with her ex-husband. They own the properties 5050 there was a divorce in between. Husband retained 1% of interest in that property until the property is paid off as part of the divorce agreement that 1% controlled the P.O. Box controlled essentially the mailings. The registered agent? Yeah. >> um, we believe there was some miscommunication there perhaps who didn't attend doesn't matter. We're not making excuses. Understood? >> that's what we're here today for the mitigation now she owns it 100%. It's still working as an a l f right at the time this violation occurred I believe she got 100% of it in DECEMBER or NOVEMBER of 2022. Is it a duplex? It's I believe yes a duplex with. One duplex. Give me one second. Okay. >> yes. >> it's a duplex. Duplex okay. It's a duplex. >> is she living on the property as well or. >> no, it wasn't a it wasn't. >> a no it's just an a l f so it's it's it's treated just like any other duplex or single family home because they're required to live in a family setting so you don't treat it any differently even though it's operated as an a l f. How many residents I mean how many tenants. I don't know the intricacies of the business because she is just essentially a landlord. Okay, the l f as the business that rents the property. >> they can have one per room as far as I know. Okay. >> I mean I, I would make a motion to reduce it to $10,000. Second second that. Second on that. Any other discussion? All those in favor? Aye so discount of 661,500. Thank you very much. More than welcome. Page 155 property address 1701 northwest 19 avenue case number 000021. 880 what page okay. Good evening. This is a single family home. It's now owned by a corporation. Okay. Uh, it does not have homestead exemption. The lien ran to $193,250. So the minimum is $10,000 or down to zero by a unanimous vote. >> but it does not have homestead exemption. No. >> it's now owned by 1701 northwest 19th avenue llc. gotcha. >> good evening. >> good evening. >> state your name and address for the record. My name is joseph mader. >> okay. And my sister. My name is janet katz. I'm the owner of the property. Okay. >> good evening. >> good evening. All right. You want to tell us why you. >> good evening, your honorable panel. Your honor. Um, I to tell you the truth that I'm a little terrified standing here before you this evening. Um, a it all started when we purchased the property in in JUNE 22nd. I wrote the things so please bear with me two minutes just so I could not forget things. So um I made I'm a real estate broker in broward county and um I convinced my sister uh to purchase a property for her retirement home in miami. Uh, it had been an abandoned a severely abandoned and neglected property for approximately two years. Um, and she did not create these conditions and she never ignored them. Um, from the beginning she worked in good faith to rescue and rehabilitate the property. When did she buy it? In JUNE. JUNE MAY 2022. Uh, when on JUNE there was this big. And her name is um. I'm sorry her name. The janet katz. Okay. >> all right. >> so she's been the. Owner the whole time. Just changed from her name to corporate names. Right. >> okay. She lives in new york. >> all right. >> I just wanted to make sure that she was the owner and she was the owner. Okay. At the time. What initially appeared to be a cleanup project became an overwhelming financial and emotional ordeal. Major plumbing, roofing, structural problems were discovered squatters that we had to remove by a swat team, law enforcement assistants, contractors accepted deposits and disappeared without completing work. Despite every setback, my sister did not walk away. She borrowed approximately $230,000 .She has two pace loans one hero, one pace and another private loan um to correct the property satisfied the city requirements. Today the property is fully compliant. All permits are closed. All final inspections have been approved. There is no open safe structure order. There is no occupancy restrictions or violation notices. The property is safe, compliant and ready for occupancy. My sister received no financial benefit from this delay. On the contrary, she assumed she she assumed tremendous debt and suffered significant financial hardship while trying to save the property. The continuing penalty is preventing her from moving forward with prospective tenants in adding another financial burden as she already done everything required to bring the property into compliance. This was never a case of an owner refusing cooperation or deliberately ignoring the law. I've been in contact with officer aquino the whole time I thought she would be here today. This was it. My sister is trying to protect her retirement. Correct. The severely distressed property overcome an unexpected crisis after another. The purpose of code enforcement has been now accomplished. The violations have been corrected, the permits are closed and inspections are approved and property ready for occupancy. We respectfully ask the magistrate to consider the complete document history um or extraordinary financial sacrifice and her good faith efforts to bring the property into full compliance. Please allow her to move forward. We respectfully request all accumulated monetary fines to be waived reduced um mitigated subject only a and I have so much so much more to to add. [Laughter] Um we even have an arborist report. Uh your attorney is there still um violations rachel is there still violations on the trees? Well you wouldn't be you wouldn't be here today if there was. I don't know. Well that's not necessarily the case I don't know no because you're here on this I don't know that's for another time to discuss. That's not for here. Or now. You're looking for mitigation right? Yes. Okay. You put out a significant amount of money to to correct everything. Absolutely. >> all right. >> let me see what the board thinks about what they want to do with this. What's what's the current status of the property? Is she renting it is it empty. No it's vacant now. It's been vacant for three years. We we've been full efforts into. Retirement income. Making it yeah to bring it you know, close permits and it was plumbing and electricity and and the whole house is all new with with okay. And what's what's your plan with the property you're planning to move there and retire or are you going to rent it or. Ultimately is it livable? Can anybody live in that property now or is the property livable ?Yes, somebody lives there. >> full compliance. I mean I. >> I get a motion. I yeah. Yeah, I mean I would make a motion to reduce it to zero. I'll support it. Yeah I'll second that motion. Thank you. >> so I have a motion zero a second. All those in favor. Aye. Thank you for your paper over there. Okay you want to. Wait you guys. Thank you for coming. This took a big toll on the whole family for three years. We understand. It's come to an end. Thank you. Well, appreciate. Add on one property address for 885 northwest seventh street. Case number ce2021005031. This property is a vacant lot. It was here in JULY. There were two other. It has two other connecting lots that were on this one wasn't on it yet because for some reason it just it wasn't complied even though it was complied. So we needed to get it complied so we could put it on. They had the bankruptcy going on anyway. It was $447,250. The minimum was 7500. The other two lots were lowered to 7500. >> got it. Get your name and address for the record. Good evening. My name is martin mccarthy. I represent seven of blue lagoon one and two and caroline weiss the managing member. Okay. >> and so you're okay with the 7500 mitigation. I am, sir. >> thank you very much. Can I get a motion? Yeah. >> move to reduce 7,502nd. >> all those in favor? Aye. Thank you. >> thank you very much. Appreciate your time. Thank you rachel. Thank you. >> next case. The next constituent has two cases on one on page 149 property address 301 north east 58th street case number 00058004. The second one is on page 152 property address 301 north east 58th street. Case number 00080857. Good evening. Good evening. How are you? All right. >> you state your name and address for the record. My name is dennis. My apologies. I had a terrible accident and I have metal plates and screws so I apologize for not speaking clearly. Okay. Um, maybe we can help you with some questions real quick. Right. >> so the lien, uh, on the, uh oh four case went to $220,750 on the 57 case went to $344,000. Um this is a triplex now. It's an empty complete flat lot. Um have you completely. Yes. >> everything's gone. Everything is gone. Let me check. Hold on, I got it. Go here where's I built there's I built yeah yeah. No don't worry. Are we just when did. >> this get we have our it's final okay I guess the last time I looked at it it wasn't final yet. Okay so all right so for both of them it's a vacant lot. Mhm. It was a triplex before. Um since I bought it for the first time it was a duplex the moment I closed the loan. I've never collected a paycheck. It's okay. >> the minimum is $7,500 per lot. It's going to be cheaper than the other way anyway, right? That's all I'm just making minimum 7500 each. Gotcha. >> is that better? Yes. >> yeah. >> I would love to just show what had happened to the place squatters all the time removing windows, removing doors hadn't had electricity for three years. I got chased with a machete. The police came five times. It's been the worst experience of my life. If I could show you the pictures and the dates everyone would be. We can understand I understand. Terrified so. So um it's a it's a great thing to know that I don't have a headache anymore but I've been still paying the loan since the moment I purchased it. Yeah. >> and MADAM Attorney, there's no mechanism to consolidate these right. They have to be separate. >> no it's separate. >> it has to be okay. Violations then I would move to reduce 5800 4 to 7500 and case 8085 7 to 7500. All those in favor. Aye all right. Thank you very much. You're more than welcome. You wait for your paperwork there. Okay. Thank you. Okay. >> no more mitigation. I do have this last special appearance on checked in. They checked in? Yes. Okay. On page 161 property address 7000 northeast ten court case number 00121510. Hold on, hold on one second. Oh yeah. We're we're being told she doesn't have standing. Oh, then it can't be heard. No it can't be heard. >> let's move on. All right. Just call the um to be heard. So just for the record she advised me that she is the prior owner. She doesn't have a power of attorney and I explained to her that the current owner has to give her a power of attorney even though the violation. Is occurred while she was the owner. Right. >> so the violation is with the property, not with the owner, correct? Correct. Thank you. >> and ma'am, when you get that authority come on I'm going to give you my card when you get something from that other person please email me so that we can put you on a quicker calendar. So when you come back you can get it done. Yeah we'll do the same thing. Very special appearance. Yeah we can do another one but um to be hurts. Thank you. So this attorney has two cases on the calendar. The first one is on page 70 property address 1074 northeast little river drive case number 00153504. The other one is on page 112 property address 1076 northeast little little river drive case number 00169130. Good evening, good evening. State your name and address for the record. Sir daniel leon yep. Uh, I'm here on behalf for the property at 1074 northeast little river drive and 1076 northeast. >> and how does the property plead? We're going to plead guilty. Okay. >> I don't know if we want to do both of these cases together. Do you want to just. We could separate them or put them together either however you. Just for the sake of time if it makes sense to. >> do it we can do them both for time purposes. >> are you pleading guilty to the other case as well? Yes. Thank you for the record. Um so just to just for a little background there's been um it's been a you know, sort of an ongoing issue. Hopefully things will settle down now, um as of today, um well prior to today some of the platform had been removed, one was still remaining counsel and I had a discussion earlier today and then one of the other ones went down that wasn't from a platform but was a personalized website, uh, for both of the both of the properties because it kind of goes together. Correct the 1074 property which is on that's the one thing I didn't write down here the 1074 property. Little river. Yeah is on page 70. Correct. >> and the 1076 property I'm just gonna write it here. 112 is 112 so on the 1074 property that is a repeat violation property from a APRIL of 2025 case under case number 00120558. So I just needed to put that on the record. I have spoken with counsel in advance. There's also counsel was here for um one of the neighbors and I don't know if he wants to I believe he did want to come up and just address you for a little bit after we discuss certain things which um I know that you generally do allow people to do that. Yes. In this particular instance I just want to go through what we discussed that um it's going to be a finding of guilt. There's going to be a 30 day compliance date on this but it's going to be a little different. So probably going to have to do a specialized order for it. Okay. Um but for both of them it's going to be the 30 days for the 1074 property. It would be a which is the repeat violation property. It would be $1,000 a day for the 1076 property because it is a home being used in a commercial fashion, it would be a $500 a day per diem fine. Now the caveat being that at 30 days the city will be reviewing everything that's online as well as with not just this neighbor, but there's a couple of other neighbors that have been in contact with the city to see what's going on on the property to make sure things are going we MAY not comply on day 30, but if nothing's going on we certainly won't file a noncompliance and we're going to make sure that it continues in that fashion since we've had the previous issues right should obviously after that 30 days something happened that shouldn't be happening will be coming back here on a report status, um, with them to have them come here and discuss irreparable harm fines as well at that point. Is that for the 1076. >> that's for both of the properties right? So this is going to be for both of the properties. But the 1074. 1074 and the 1076. >> but the 1074 is already a repeat. The 1076 is the repeat. So 1074 we tend to try to send a message for repeat violators right? Well that's it would be right. That's where the $1,000 a day will you know certainly come in whatever you you know whatever else I know council wants to address you as well. I just sort of wanted to give you the parameters. It's a little different than normal but as you know sometimes we get certain of these cases that have those issues and we sort of um you know, we we try to fashion something to keep everybody on the ball and also create a cooling down period, but also knowledge that um, this, you know, this case isn't just going to automatically close out so that we have to build a whole new case. Right? Right. If if if they because that happens too often. Correct. Um and obviously we have something from 2025. So rather than allowing that to occur this case will remain open and it MAY MAY remain open 30, 60 or even 90 days after that initial 30 days just as a watch we wouldn't file an affidavit of noncompliance unless they were not in compliance. Correct. But that case will remain open. Both of them would remain open so that if something does happen we will come back here and we will move for um further sanctions. Thank you for. >> that from the board. And I think maybe that's a an easier way to go about things with something like this and it it sort of. Maybe keeps it around for, you know, maybe 4 or 5 months to, you know, see what what goes on but at least something and then if you would we do have the neighbor who's who's come here um also to to address you. Thank you. Um do you want to do you have anything you want to say? I mean I think I think MISS Dooley is okay is that everything the you know the the one of the things is that 1076 they do live on that particular property so they will be complying with anything dealing with miami 21 okay. And anything dealing with the property but that. All right. >> no problem. Right. >> we have discussed certain things and I will put on the record that council did let me know and I this is this is the attorney for um MR. Castell faber-castell I will make sure I said it correctly MR. Faber-castell um that there is a sweet 16 party that's going to be happening at which address. Then 1076. At 1076 which is his. >> niece. Resident okay. Just it's his daughter. Daughter oh I'm sorry. Okay. That was. >> my all right. Um and so we just said let them know the date that way we're going to know you know what's understood. Yeah. >> and MADAM Attorney, just to be clear. So the fines would only trigger if an affidavit of noncompliance. That's correct. >> but we're going to. >> run the court. For the 1074 property. >> we're running. >> the clock. The fines would revert back to their original date of violation and that would be um on JANUARY 27th of 2026. Thank you. So let's say time went by and we're 60 days out and something happens. Then we have an issue of whether or not or 28 days from now there's some crazy rental going on. Um and we file an affidavit noncompliance it would run a thousand days starting. JANUARY starting JANUARY 28th of 2026. And one last question before I allow them to speak here. Um do we have the ability now seeing that you've introduced it in this manner to keep these type of cases open longer than 60 days and the reason why I'm asking that is because folks take down websites, they take down listings, they do all of the little runaround stuff and then when they think no one is looking they pop it right back up or they do it on another website. And I know our inspectors are really good at finding them. And so instead of closing out cases like we just mentioned, the fact that it's still open longer, maybe we set it for 120 days and anything happens in between we revert right back because that's intentional. That's right. I do think I do think as a board you have the authority. To do that. Yeah. Um and to try to fashion remedies that not only will work for the people who are the owners of the properties and would also work for the the people around those properties too that maybe to try to provide a little extra assurance that there is a mechanism to return to should there be an issue or maybe even for a violating property owner to be able to come back and go, oh absolutely not. That's not what happened and here's here's everything that was going you know what I'm saying? So yeah. Um that might provide a better um option for that correct. I think it's out it is outside it's not I'm going to say it's outside the norm but we have our normal operation of regular things but we also have cases that are different like those cases correct. Those were handled in a different fashion. Because they had their own hearings. Everything else was going on with fire here you know certain violations when zika was very high we had a very different process for businesses that had a lot of open water, standing water and especially tire companies, things like that. So I do think that you do but it has to be within the bounds of compliance notice and due process. Well thank you for that because if if not I was going to get clarity from commission and I was going to at least mention it that maybe this is a mechanism. If we can if we can actually handle that here, I would like to make a motion. We can but before we do anything. >> no nothing you have to make a motion to add that it's just it's just if it's part of your ruling that's [Laughter] How it will be addressed. I think your counsel is nodding his head. Yeah yeah. Gotcha. >> but let me. Just as an extra also I mean the real they've already been listed for months now to be long term leased you know for for a year plus. >> I gotcha. We're trying to. No no I got you we're just using this as a. No no absolutely. Taste test case. Gotcha MADAM Attorney. Good evening. My name is marianne ruiz. I represent MR. Faber castell who's been the one behind a lot of violations because the property is directly across from his home. Okay. And this is another neighbor. Thank you for the record, we would love if you would issue fines now for the repeat property. That would be wonderful. The city has done a fantastic job and in getting here today and preparing and there was a slideshow and everything ready had they not pled guilty on the property. So we would gladly accept at least a repeat violation of a fine of some sort on the repeat violation. I think you mean an irreparable harm. Fine. Yes. >> in addition to everything else that that was discussed and we very much appreciate your questions and and concern on the issue. And if MR. Faber castell wanted to say a couple of words. Yes. >> yeah. >> you're members of the board. MADAM Attorney, thank you very much for the opportunity to speak before you here. Um I'm going to keep it somewhat brief but I'll put it in a structure of three things. Um one is the scale that this is not just a case of home sharing renting out a small apartment. These are two large waterfront properties with recurring people coming in every weekend luggages commercial boat charters even on the website of the owner that's how it's marketed concierge services events. Um so it's substantial, you know at 3500 dollars a day, you know, for a weekend both properties $20,000 a weekend. So that's the scale. The second topic is the continued noncompliance despite your efforts, the violation letter of JANUARY 2026 with the request to comply by JANUARY 28th that has not happened. It's not just my observations. It's also the publicly available information, the bookings, everything we've we've seen that. And so that has not led to lasting compliance and that's that's all I want is for these properties to come into compliance. And lastly and most importantly to me personally is the impact and the impact not only for the neighborhood but for me is very real. Um, I bought my property a year ago was the biggest joy for my wife and since this has been happening it's been a big significant source of anxiety stress, frustration for her and it's been very difficult and maybe one small personal example, you know, it's a waterfront property. My my son's biggest passion is fishing and he loves fishing off the dock and um, when we moved there he was very excited to do that but with numerous encounters of strangers and intoxicated individuals coming off of charter boats, he doesn't enjoy doing that anymore. And I can tell you as a father there's nothing more heartbreaking than to see your son not enjoy doing something that he once really loved to do. So I ask you just to consider what whatever decisions you make to ensure um that you know it is meaningful because um it the scale is substantial and I think it needs to be a measure that the only sensible outcome is compliance and not doing this because it has an impact on families in the neighborhood. Thank you very much sir. Did you want to put something on record as well? Sure. >> just very briefly ross romans 1133 belle meade island drive and I also own other properties on the island I lived in 1133 belle meade island drive. One of the reasons that we moved out was because of his actions continuously for I can't tell you how many years I believe we're going back. I mean many, many years he's running a full straight on business. I live through it. I saw the charters. I saw the different bachelorette parties. You know all this he's been doing this for that long. My concern as a resident somebody you know, long term miami resident is you guys say you're going to find him but quite frankly he's getting $4,000 a night. Okay. He's making very likely a million and a half dollars a year or something in that range off of this business. One other thing I want to get on record they said that he lives in the one thing that it's separate. Okay, that MAY be so but more often than not he's renting it out. So I don't consider that I want to be very crystal clear during on belle meade island we had the petrosa case. Okay. And I'm sure you guys. Can't go back. We can't you need to stick with from JANUARY of 2026. That's fine to. Now the bottom line is we're never going to go away. He's never going to be able to do this without me personally. I'm willing to spend whatever it takes. He's willing to spend whatever it takes. You have ruined people's lives sir. You do not address them. I understand but. >> I apologize. Thank you, I apologize. All right. Ruined literally ruined my some of my family's life that we had to move out of the house because of him. Okay. >> thank you, thank you thank you for that. And thank you. Um, inspector um, see, MADAM Attorney, this is why I was asking about having it kept open because you know, we found ourselves as a board having where a case has gone to the 11th circuit it's come back we didn't articulate certain points or due diligence and it's like you know, we're faced with residents who are coming before us, you know, having dealt with not just a one off but a repeat like a repeat repeat. And so this is a situation where we're just like, you know, um, wanting to keep that open is I think it's something that could strengthen down the line what we're trying to do. And because if this does go back to JANUARY of this year 28, then that's more than what an irreparable harm fine would be and there's no mitigation to that. So that is correct. Yeah [Laughter] So I'm just talking to the attorney. >> right no that's. Me I wasn't saying anything. I will say something. You know he's. The only difference and I know you mentioned the the appeal that we discussed a few months ago. The only difference here is that it appears he's taking responsibility for it. So he's admitting to the underlying facts that give rise to the violation, which is one of the issues that the appellate court had with the prior airbnbs. If you want to impose any irreparable harm, you have to make findings above and beyond his admission of guilt. >> I agree we definitely understand that. But here's the thing you know everybody does when they are caught they do come before a magistrate or judge or whatever and everybody wants sympathy at that point, but no one was thinking about it when it was going on. Right. And so I understand exactly what you're saying, but that's why we as the board when we have residents that come out before us and telling their stories about what they're living through, that's the other side of the story that no one gets told. And so we have to respect that. We have to appreciate those those those comments as well. And so it's just a matter of going beyond just what an irreparable harm fine is. It's like what sends a message? What says it's not accepted at all in the city of miami. So it's good conversation to have. It's good to see on both sides. I'm glad to understand that you know, they're acknowledging certain things but they're not the only ones and I don't want their example to be something that you know, says it's okay as long as we, you know, become heartfelt about what we're doing wrong and acknowledge it, that's okay. But there's consequences for that too though. So there's one thing I want to address and I was thinking about it after I was nodding my head and it's this concept of keeping a code enforcement case open in possibly perpetuity. Correct in perpetuity. >> not in perpetuity. >> I understand I'm just I'm I'm putting it out there because I want to verify that whatever you guys do is at least sustainable and will deliver what the message so to speak that you know, you're trying to send the violator and I don't want a challenge to something. I want to make sure I just want to verify it. I agree I don't think there's anything inappropriate of what you're doing right now, but I want to make sure that if you want to continue to do this as a possible tool. Yeah. >> that there's parameters and we follow those parameters. >> I would love to get more conversation on that as well because I think it is something that we considering what tools we currently have considering what the law has said based on other different court rulings, you know, our hands are kind of tied in some regards but then in others we can do certain things too. And so I know the residents that are watching that are listening, you know, they're petitioning their commissioners to do something as well. So this is the body that MAY be able to do it. Inspector or. What is it? Yeah. >> so what do we want to do with this one here? What's the recommendation. We have that. So so if if you want to consider um as and you asked the question and and they did bring up an irreparable harm fine. Yeah for um for 1074 you've obviously heard testimony with respect to um what's going on we would need to put on specifically what's happening with 1074 I believe that's that's one away from. Um from the neighbor's house. Yeah it's 1076 is in between MR. Faber castell house and 1074 right. Um we can certainly um I was showing you those documents um if you wanted to do that the requirement is based upon the gravity of the violation the action taken by the violator to correct it and then any previous violations that that have been committed. So those are your three findings. Um for that I think there have been issues in the past as um um as your counsel said with respect to um you know, the difference in pleas, but I think also the difference in amounts correct. You know, um we had some of them that automatically went to the top and so I think that that was something that the appellate court just kind of thought that seems a bit much. Yeah. Um to be you know, somebody walks in and then boom, it's $15,000 see you later, you know that kind of thing. So I think that that was um I think that that was was an issue but those are the three factors. Five would be reasonable. Um like. That MADAM Attorney on the 1074 property. So I. >> can violations prior to JANUARY 2026 correct. Which is what's causing it to be a repeat offender. So the right so the case was. Hold on a second it should be can. Can I ask one question with the attorney from the. So this violation is from JANUARY 28th. Are you aware of any other events that have gone on since then? Yes. >> so that's all I needed. Right. >> so I'm going. >> to that's all I needed. This is the property. This is the I'm going to show you um it's everything's already yeah we have a plain guilt so yeah just so you can identify the property the red dot you can look at your screen that's it that's 1074. Mhm. Uh I've got this to the right. That's MR. Faber castillo's property and that's 1076. So these are the two properties. The repeat violation property is 1074 property. Yeah the one wherein um the property owner states is his residence is the property. So the property was cited in um on JANUARY 27th of 2026. So we can certainly take you to photographs from MAY of 2026. Um these are photographs that were provided by um our neighbor that have been verified. We have from MAY 28th through 31st we have. >> the I'm sorry what is this? I can't see this. These are the photographs of people coming and going from 1074. Since the since. After they asked about after yeah after JANUARY. After you first. Of 2026. >> for the repeat. We have MAY then we have a JUNE 4th through JUNE 7th. This for 1074 1076. This is 1074. This is 1074. It looks like some guy. This is 1074. It looks like some guy appear to be throwing something at one of the cameras right? >> we can't even tell. That property is the 1074 property the blue roof. So in other words so since the notice of violation which made it now a repeat it's also still been continued activity since the notice. Based on the time stamps and the dates on the pictures. >> that were provided these photographs this is the first time that I see. These are from our inspector. These are these are from the city the city. >> these are city. So this is from this is a part of the um documents that were submitted. This is by by the inspector. Now we have we have we have photographs from inspectors. We have photographs from the neighbors as well okay. Which and this is. These are neighbors photographs. This is the neighbors photographs. This is so with times of background right. Hold on wait we're not we don't want to do this right now what what we're what we want to do is because I'm trust me what I'm what I'm trying to establish here is that if you acknowledge what you've already said that you guys are guilty and you're going to stop doing it. Yes, we're already in. Compliance then watch this then in 60 days, 90 days there's no repeat anything going on we'll close it out right. We might push it to 120 days just for the sake of right and we'll close it out. But should something happen on the 110th day right the fine goes back to JANUARY. That's fair. >> as $1,000 a. >> day we understand. That's our irreparable harm right there. Okay okay. So we're trying to find a balanced approach to this and understand that you want to be compliant. And so we want to hold you to that so we don't we're not trying to do this back and forth thing. We're just we're trying to find the best way forward but we're serious about what we're saying because [Music] Some of us want to just do irreparable harms and every single time you come we stack it with irreparable harm every single time. We understand. Yeah and that's fine. Yeah. And we would address it at a separate hearing. Correct if something were. To happen. >> yeah we don't want. >> to because we've had issues also with. These if you're saying you're serious. >> about our neighbors. >> we push it out 120 days and you're doing an event the next week you're not serious and that's and that and that will let the us know. So when we do the things that we need to do, we will have all of the the reasoning that the 11th circuit court is asking us to provide to say why we're doing what we're doing. Okay. >> and that's fine. I just want to understand I just got it just also for the record, there's been issues with this particular neighbor. It's kind of a little bit of a personal vendetta and there's issues that have. >> we understand. But if you. But if you're doing the activities. We've called the police and so I just and that's fine. >> no, we understand that. But if you're doing the activities that they're saying you're doing and they're taking pictures of it, that's fine. That's that's another thing. >> so we'll we'll gotcha. Okay. >> what's our recommendation? Is it still the I'm at a minimum. Just [Laughter] Once more and then everybody else will be able to get on with their lives. But thank you. The people who are being sometimes cases take longer than others. Um for page 70 the 1074 property it's a finding of guilt the minimum 30 days um but as long as 120 days uh $1,000 a day right? Yeah. Okay .The one it's 112 I believe the 1076 property 112 on page 112 is a finding of guilt, right? Again, 30 days that could go as long as 120 days with a $500 per diem. Right. Should anything occur during those time periods? Uh, we know we know that the daughter's not the niece the daughter's sweet 16 party is going on. Let them know. Um, other than that, if something does go on, uh, we will bring it back immediately to um the board. And we'll. >> start at the next at the next available the next hearing date it will come back right. Okay. >> anybody any unreadiness. All right I get a motion. Yeah move as stated. Second all those in favor? Aye. >> thank you thank you. Thank you. And for the audience thank you for working with us on this one. This is just a particular thing that happens. And so you know. I want to. Appreciate your understanding. Page 40. Property address 1681 southwest 10th street case number 00159273. Good afternoon. Your name and address for the record? Ramon gutierrez, 6081 south 10th street, miami, florida. >> how does the property plead? I'm sorry. >> how does the property plead? Guilty. >> guilty. Thank you very much. Inspector l smith, southeast office. What I need to do. [Laughter] This is for the remodeling. Yes, ma'am. Okay. >> wait. >> you just dm'd me. Oh, wow. Let me pull this one up for you. Yeah, just. Have they started permitting process yet? Yes. >> okay. >> how much time do you think that they need? Um, 120 days. So ma'am, I'm working with the contractor. We already submitted the permit to the city of miami. Uh, I have the the the work permit number. It should be a number of uh 2 or 3 weeks so I'm working on it to get it resolved. I get a motion. So we'd recommend um. What's the reside at the property ma'am? Do they reside at the property? Yes I live there. Okay so my daughter's. Okay so the recommendation would be 120 days to start. If you need more time take the piece of paper. Don't forget to request the extension of time. Yeah for sure and then it would be 150. Thank you. >> so move for a finding of guilty. I had a question. What was it? Yes. >> unofficially request an extension to get this resolved. That we're giving it to you right now. Yeah yeah right. >> I didn't. >> hear it. There's another paper there if you want more more time. Yeah. >> you're going to get 120 days from today. Thank you. Put in your phone a little reminder an alarm to go off in 110 days tomorrow starts day one to remind you if you don't have your affidavit of compliance from inspector smith that you need to request for extension of time first and then just email bomb her for like days and days and days and. See what's up. Okay okay motion. >> yeah. Move for a finding of guilt 120 days to come into compliance and $150 fine thereafter. Second all those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Next case. That's it. >> page 22. Property address 1345 southwest 17 terrace. Case number 00150096 hamilton. Uh, paul c collins. Paul collins going once. 1345 southwest 17th terrace. On twice. Pass it. Pass next case. Thank you sir. Next case. Page 38. Property address 3695 west flagler street. Case number 00157993. Good evening sir is this cvs? Yes thank you. You want to good evening. Good evening. State your name and address for the chin. Thank you. Owner of the property.. >> okay great. >> and this is the manager of the cvs hector torres who got to speak on my behalf. Understood. >> it's the property guilty or not guilty? Are we guilty or not guilty? You're guilty. Thank you. You said yes or no? No, I. Said no. >> oh, so you're not guilty. Guilty. All right so we're going to put on our case okay to show you what you did wrong okay thank you inspector. Inspector please state your name for the record. Inspector aguilar. With the north office. >> all right. Did you put did you put together pages one through 132

Event, Code Enforcement Board — Date, September 3, 2026 - 4:55 PM

Showing the first 24,000 of 116,784 characters. The full document is at the source.

liberty and justice for all. Please remain standing. Be sworn in. >> thank you. Do you solemnly swear or affirm the testimony you are about to give? Is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth? Thank you. >> you MAY have a seat. Do you solemnly swear? Do you solemnly swear and affirm you will translate from english to spanish and spanish to english to the best of your ability. Thank you. Good afternoon. >> buenas tardes necesitan ayuda en espanol or a vamos a la juramento. Ahora si la verdad toda la verdad y nada mas la verdad. Okay. Do you solemnly swear and affirm that you will translate from english to korean creole to english to the best of your ability? Thank you. Most of all. Les anglais avec anglais. No merci beaucoup. All right. Um. Yeah. MR. Williams present. MR. Rodriguez present. MR. Galan. Present. >> MR. Madonna. Oh, sorry. Oh, sorry. MR. Miller. MR. Moshi, we have quorum. You forgot me. You forgot. You got two folks you forgot. I think. Ulysses present. Oh, sorry. And MR. Galan present. Thank you. >> I heard [Laughter] Somebody from the audience say PRESIDENT, listen to me, all right? Sorry. >> all right. No problem. >> good evening. Most of you are here today for the first time. There's a small number of you that are here from mitigation. When your case is called, please come up to the podium. State your name and the address you're here on behalf of. Let the board know whether you're guilty or not guilty of the violation. If you plead guilty to the violation, the city will inform the board in a summary fashion as to what the violation is. They'll make a recommendation for the amount of days you need to cure the violation. The board will vote unanimously to give you the amount of days that the city recommends or more days or less days. However the board votes and they'll apply a per diem violation if you don't comply by the date given. If you're a first time violator with a residential property, it's up to $250 per diem if you're a first time nonresidential commercial property, it's $1,000 per diem if you are a repeat violator if you're a residential repeat violator it's $500 maximum and if you're a nonresidential commercial repeat violator it's up to $5,000. If you plead not guilty, the city will put on its case. You will put on your response to the city and the vote will go. The board will go through a similar process vote and give you a per diem uh and a time to comply. Uh, if you don't have a power of attorney by this point, you MAY want to come and see me if you're not the owner or the managing member of the property or a licensed florida attorney, if you're here for mitigation, there's a chart, there's the chart. There MAY be a chart we'll find it that tells you what the city can and can't do for you as far as mitigation, the board is bound by that chart. They cannot go lower than what that chart permits. So take a look at it if you're waiting uh we'll be calling mitigations first. Um all orders of the board are available to the 11th judicial circuit court of florida within 30 days. One last thing. If you the few cases that we have that are on for mitigation when you're done that the board determines what your mitigation amount is. Come over here and wait for me in the corner so I can give you your copy of your order so you can take with you and payment instructions and at the podium there is a piece of paper if you're here for the first time. Once a board gives you the time to comply, it tells you how to request an extension of time. Are the papers there? Yeah for extension of time. I'm sorry. Yes up there. Okay. >> so take that paper with you and it'll tell you how to ask for an extension of time. All right. Good evening everyone. We're going to try to get everybody out of here pretty quickly. Uh, can we get the cases? I see we have a special appearance so we want to do that after mitigations. I understand that rachel MAY have some special requests. >> I see there's one special appearance. You don't so I can call mitigations and [Laughter] I know. No worries, I just. [Laughter] I'm good. >> I don't whatever I'm good. All right we'll go straight to mitigations okay. You do you mitigation sounds great great mitigation if the special appearance clicked in we can take that after that and then do the whatever you want to do. I'm fine. Mitigation. >> yeah. >> let's get out of the way. Page 146 property address 1121 northwest second street. Case number 00066081. This is a vacant lot. The lane ran to $64,000. The minimum is 7500 even I mean 75 64,000. I know my brain. I got to get back into the swing of things. Uh so even um 20% of 64,000 is over more than 7500. So the minimum is 7500. Great. >> good evening. State. State your name and address for the record. Good evening. My name is pablo calatrava. I'm the manager of the new corporation that owned the property since last year. Thank you for your time. First of all, no problem. And the reason of my appearance here is that to the best of my knowledge, by the time that this violation occurred there was a single family home there, you know, so I would like to put that in consideration. Okay. >> let me check let me check and see. Hold on. Maybe. And how soon after you got the notices for violations did you comply? Yes sir. >> I don't know how soon afterwards. I bought the property in last year you know so right now I try to put it in compliance with all the all my means. You know I bought pictures from today. Gotcha. >> so you bought the property with the violations? Yes, I bought it on the court. Thank you. Looks like it was an empty lot. Just an empty lot. No previous use of. >> the I have pictures. I MADAM If you put the address in. >> I'm looking at the pictures from OCTOBER 4th of 2023. Okay. >> no because when you see in the internet you see the old structure that was there because it was demolished by the city. I paid for the demolition after I bought the property right. >> well it still MAY have owed money on a demolition. >> yeah yeah yeah I it was clear. That this property was cited for the empty lot being overgrown to maintain the lot and fail to register a lot. So it's 7500. There was not a structure on the property when it was cited. Got it. So there wouldn't be it wouldn't be able to revert to being a single family home. Okay so the so the best we can do today. Thank you. The best we can do today is mitigate it down to 7500 okay from the 64,000 okay okay. Thank you very much. Can I get a motion please? Yeah. >> move to reduce it to 7,502nd second. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Wait for your paper here. Okay. >> yeah. You're welcome. Next case. Um this was recently added on is add on three case number c 2018 022910. This is a mitigation. >> is a mitigation okay this is a reset from last JULY sir acosta. This is 4101 northwest 11th place. Yes okay this property is a vacant lot. The lien ran to $363,300 I remember and we're back and the minimum is 7500. Can you state your name and address for the record? Frank acosta 705 southeast 13th circle, homestead, florida. Gotcha. >> and so any any background on this other than the the lien amount and what we could do on it or is it immediate previous use was the. >> I'm going to make sure right now since it's an add on it says work without a permit. So yeah because we don't have anything to look at so. It looks like it was a single family home. [Laughter] Lucky you. Um single family home with homestead but it wouldn't have now. So when it was cited it was a single family home. Therefore prior to it becoming a vacant lot its past use was as a single family home. Therefore they are eligible for a minimum of 10,000 which is more than the 7500 or by unanimous vote down to zero. Yeah. >> the question. What's what's the use of the property now it's a vacant lot okay. And you guys are selling it or it's going to be your home. You're going to be living there. I have all the information you asked. You got to move the mic to the. >> I have all the information you asked before here if you'd like to see. >> you got it all done. Got it all done. I rolled the dice. All right good job. Okay thank you. Thank you. You're going to be living there and you're getting ready to process plans for a new property a new house. That's going to be that's correct. That's going to be your homestead. Homestead property I moved to uh bring it down to zero. Can I get a second please? Second what second oh thank you. All in favor I thank you sir for your. Thank you very much. You're welcome. Next case. Sometimes it pays to come back. It does. Sometimes it does pay to come back. Right. Um this is add on two property address 3101 southwest fourth street case number c 2021 004165. Okay. >> you know you know I promise everybody we'll be out of here by six. >> this is 3101 southwest fourth street. This is a single family home with homestead exemption. The lien ran to $88,250. The minimum would be $5,000 or zero with or down to zero with the unanimous vote. Good evening. Good evening. State your name and address for the record. >> let me. Yes. >> see. >> okay. I have a power of attorney. She's my aunt never had children. She's a widow 87 years old. Okay. >> do we have the power of attorney? Yeah, I gave it. >> to show the power of attorney, but that's that's the property owner giving her authority to speak. >> yeah. No no no. But I was just curious. Yeah, I gave it to him. All right. Thank you. Um well you see the violations that were actually issued in 2021 um at that point I was not in miami. I was not aware of the violations and when I came back to oh actually my cousin that passed away from cancer, she reached out to him and he was going to try to help her, but he passed away and I never knew about it. Okay. I take care of her through cameras and stay with her now twice a week to help her out. Okay. And at that point going through the mail I come across um a form from the letter from the city of miami. Yeah. And when I read it I almost freaked out. I said dear, do you know about this. The violation I'll let them know the violation was just for extra concrete and was for that side carport just the aluminum that's what the violation was. So I don't know if you guys want to take it from there. Yeah hold on real quick. >> she lives at the property right. That's her homestead. >> she is my aunt. Yes. Okay. >> can I get a motion. >> move to zero. Thank you. >> second. Second. >> all those in favor? Hi. >> thank you. Okay. >> yeah. >> just wait for your paperwork over there. Thank you so much. >> thank you so much for taking care of you. GOD bless you all. Thank you. GOD bless you as well. Yeah no no no. Page 158 property address 3377 southwest 29th terrace case number 00015188. Good evening. This is the line ran to $671,500. This is a homestead exempt duplex property. So the minimum is $5,000 or down to zero by unanimous vote. State your name and address for the record. My name is ramirez and I represent navarro. Navarro property holdings llc, the owner of that company. The new owners don't have exemption but the old owners did right? Yeah so. So but we're looking at the new owners so yeah I'm sorry we're looking at the you're representing the new owners. Well the current. >> owner the current owners. The current owners. Yeah it doesn't have. Homestead exemption sorry. Yeah there is no home so the minimum is $10,000 but it can go down to zero as low as zero with a unanimous vote my ear. Thank you. >> so I just want to bring up a few points in relation to this file. Uh the violation was back in JUNE of 2022. The first notice of violation was JUNE 8th of 2022. We did not get the actual affidavits when we got the city documents. The affidavit from the inspector at the time that posted or states in that affidavit that they posted this JUNE 8th letter on the door was not until JUNE 9th knowing that the correction timeline was only provided to JUNE 10th. So essentially one business day to correct this violation at this property. These were the alleged violations right? Remember those but these are serious situations too. So okay. So in relation to this violation it wasn't anything that had to do with the actual building the structure. It wasn't a fire. It wasn't something with hazardous it's essentially the emergency. It's 2401 emergency plans and emergency preparedness measures required essentially the little roadmap to showcase the emergency exits. We believe that that was the violation. That's what stated in the letter. But there's some inconsistencies in relation to those letters as well as the photos that the city took and saved as far as their evidence, although we have the letter JUNE 8th and the affidavit that states that that inspector specifically put that JUNE 8th letter on the door on JUNE 9th, the photos don't reflect that the note was posted until JUNE 11th after the time to correct the issue. On top of all of that, there were some other issues with the summons as well as to why my client could not attend the mitigation hearing or the actual violation hearing the first time in relation to that letter it's dated JUNE. Are you speaking to why they couldn't attend the meeting? I'm sorry. >> are you speaking to why they couldn't attend the the board hearing? Correct. >> okay. >> so the notice of violation summons to be able to attend a JUNE 21st hearing date was dated JUNE 13th. Mhm. But the problem is the affidavit of the inspector that says they put that JUNE 13th on the door states that they did it on JUNE 9th, not JUNE 13th. So it becomes an impossibility. How does one post a letter that did not exist at the time they're alleging it existed? In addition to that we refer back to the photos. The photos suggest JUNE 11th as far as posting of the notice of violation and the summons being posted JUNE 13th. So I don't know what happened there and I'm not saying anything nefarious happened. Perhaps there was a mistake. The inspector posted these notices then went back to the office drafted and forgot to take the photos. They came the weekend took those photos regardless my client just did not have the notice and I would like to share a little bit of a of her background. If I MAY say the notices were actually the posting is a courtesy the certified mailings went out so and that's what's required. So that brings me to that next point that I was going to bring up in relation to the certified mailing. The affidavits both say that it was my first class mail. The ups tag usps tag suggests certified, but yet there's no tracking history on any of the letters sent in addition. To that you mean there's no tracking number? >> that's because it's from 2022. Usps only holds information for two years so if you pull those numbers up you're not going to be able to find it online. Understood. >> I'm not saying that it wasn't sent. Right and all that's. Required to do is be sent it's a mailbox rule right? Yeah. >> and that's why I'm the reason. I'm not alleging. No I know you're not doing it but see I have to listen very closely because when when you say something that the city didn't do its job, we pay attention to that. And then we also got to make sure we're being doing our due diligence. And that's why that follow up question meaning that you sure there's no tracking number because it expires after two years. So these are the we just have to listen very closely to what you're saying understood. we're not saying you're saying anything either. We're just listening very closely understood. And by no means is my argument here today suggesting in any way that the city did not do its job. We believe that they did do their job. The problem is it goes back to the notice and reasonableness of that notice if these letters were mailed out JUNE 9th as the affidavit suggests, providing a JUNE 10th correction time frame is a one business day so those letters had to have been sent next day just for a client to receive it at that P.O. Box if we let if the P.O. Box would have been received at that time. So after the violation after the hearing that was missed this issue stayed dormant until APRIL of this year. There was another inspection on APRIL 1st which was brought up to my client's attention that hey, you still have this violation and you're racking up daily fees. As soon as she was actually physically made aware of that notice I'm not suggesting that she was required to have notice just her position. She immediately took steps to take care of it by the by APRIL 8th it was complied with. By APRIL 9th the city had confirmed. APRIL of what this year 2026. Yes that's why the fine is so high. So that's why we're here today. We wanted to bring up the notice issue uh both the city of miami web well the city of miami website on the facts section says that reasonable time, even though it's not defined generally is about 30 days. Our issue was well we were provided one business day at best. So no matter how minor the issue was of that violation to cure one business day and I believe it landed on a friday where this correction had to be made, I don't believe that was just sufficient time because even when my client was brought up to speed in APRIL of this year, it still took her about seven days to get it done and she did get it done. We're in full compliance now in relation to what we're here on today. So that's why we're requesting mitigation here. >> so to be clear it's not a minor issue right. Um these laws were all enacted after the numerous deaths up in broward county at the nursing home. Correct. And these are alfs operated out of home. You're supposed to treat it as a single family home. That's why the you know, or duplex and that's why um, for purposes of these type of mitigations, they do get the consideration to be mitigated as a single family home or duplex that's not homestead exempt. So ten 0000 is your option. Um again it's not minor to comply with the law should the power go out to have the required electrical backup hook up with your propane tanks that have to be delivered. None of this is minor. Also under the code if you have a regular violation you generally do get 30 days when you have a life safety violation and that's what this was a life safety violation then you are we are not required to abide by the 30 days also at the hearing even though they did not appear at that JUNE hearing, they were still given two months to comply. That order was mailed again to the owner. Um and so you know, I'm assuming I'm guessing they're not receiving their mail but they had until AUGUST 5th to comply. So it's not like then they had the hearing right and then they were told no. Um so they had all of those notices. There's no record of contact to the city uh for requesting of a reset that they received it they didn't know we always generally reset those if somebody has an issue legitimately that they bring. Furthermore there's 30 days to appeal. No appeal was given to appeal the notice. So any notice argument now is already waived. They failed to appeal. We know that they did receive it. We know that they're admitting that it was posted on the property. They knew it was posted on the property so they had notice if it was late. Obviously the you have 30 days to appeal it. They also had 60 days or so to or just under 60 days to comply. That didn't happen. On the other hand they have come into compliance which is excellent right. Um and so I believe you guys have already dealt with these in a very particular way, all of them the same way I'm not stepping on your toes again it's the minimum is ten 000 or all the way to zero. And thank you for the background and the coloring of that history there. So yeah, we deal with this all the time. We know what it is and so all that wash your client is looking for and is your client's going to be moving. So is it still operating. As operating as an alf. >> to this? Understood. Just one last thing and please correct me if I did not receive it via email when I requested the documents that final enforcement notice I don't know if within that file it's provided the the tracking number or proof of actually sending. I don't know if that's the case when it comes to that because the JUNE 8th and the JUNE. >> those aren't certified mail. Those are just regular mail. Yeah. >> okay. Yeah I can tell you that's just regular mail. That's not a certified mail. Gotcha. >> any questions? Yeah. >> when your client purchased the property was he aware of the violations? So that's a little bit of a back story because the house was purchased when she was still with her with her ex-husband. They own the properties 5050 there was a divorce in between. Husband retained 1% of interest in that property until the property is paid off as part of the divorce agreement that 1% controlled the P.O. Box controlled essentially the mailings. The registered agent? Yeah. >> um, we believe there was some miscommunication there perhaps who didn't attend doesn't matter. We're not making excuses. Understood? >> that's what we're here today for the mitigation now she owns it 100%. It's still working as an a l f right at the time this violation occurred I believe she got 100% of it in DECEMBER or NOVEMBER of 2022. Is it a duplex? It's I believe yes a duplex with. One duplex. Give me one second. Okay. >> yes. >> it's a duplex. Duplex okay. It's a duplex. >> is she living on the property as well or. >> no, it wasn't a it wasn't. >> a no it's just an a l f so it's it's it's treated just like any other duplex or single family home because they're required to live in a family setting so you don't treat it any differently even though it's operated as an a l f. How many residents I mean how many tenants. I don't know the intricacies of the business because she is just essentially a landlord. Okay, the l f as the business that rents the property. >> they can have one per room as far as I know. Okay. >> I mean I, I would make a motion to reduce it to $10,000. Second second that. Second on that. Any other discussion? All those in favor? Aye so discount of 661,500. Thank you very much. More than welcome. Page 155 property address 1701 northwest 19 avenue case number 000021. 880 what page okay. Good evening. This is a single family home. It's now owned by a corporation. Okay. Uh, it does not have homestead exemption. The lien ran to $193,250. So the minimum is $10,000 or down to zero by a unanimous vote. >> but it does not have homestead exemption. No. >> it's now owned by 1701 northwest 19th avenue llc. gotcha. >> good evening. >> good evening. >> state your name and address for the record. My name is joseph mader. >> okay. And my sister. My name is janet katz. I'm the owner of the property. Okay. >> good evening. >> good evening. All right. You want to tell us why you. >> good evening, your honorable panel. Your honor. Um, I to tell you the truth that I'm a little terrified standing here before you this evening. Um, a it all started when we purchased the property in in JUNE 22nd. I wrote the things so please bear with me two minutes just so I could not forget things. So um I made I'm a real estate broker in broward county and um I convinced my sister uh to purchase a property for her retirement home in miami. Uh, it had been an abandoned a severely abandoned and neglected property for approximately two years. Um, and she did not create these conditions and she never ignored them. Um, from the beginning she worked in good faith to rescue and rehabilitate the property. When did she buy it? In JUNE. JUNE MAY 2022. Uh, when on JUNE there was this big. And her name is um. I'm sorry her name. The janet katz. Okay. >> all right. >> so she's been the. Owner the whole time. Just changed from her name to corporate names. Right. >> okay. She lives in new york. >> all right. >> I just wanted to make sure that she was the owner and she was the owner. Okay. At the time. What initially appeared to be a cleanu

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

1 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 1 of 1

Browse by category1 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Event, Code Enforcement Board
  • Code Enforcement Board — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • A medium- or high-grade, non-procedural agenda-item analysis for the meeting digest
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.
  • Low-grade, ungraded, procedural, or superseded items remain in the complete agenda inventory rather than the meeting digest.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 92d019a273e3cd52b527ef8560e81ad0. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record