POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Meeting Name, City Commission Budget Workshop

Tuesday, July 23, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Meeting Name, City Commission Budget Workshop

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

People and votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget By Department and Fund -1- 07/23/24 MINUTES OF THE SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION WORKSHOP MEETING OF JULY 23, 2024 PRESENT: Mayor Liz Alpert, Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch, Commissioners Erik Arroyo, Kyle Scott Battie, and Debbie Trice, City Manager Marlon Brown, City Attorney Robert Fournier, and City Auditor and Clerk Shayla Griggs ABSENT: None Prior to the commencement of the meeting, Deputy Financial Administration Director Dawn Murray, Financial Administration Department, distributed to the Commission an enlarged printed copy of the Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan (Fiscal Years 2025-2029) spreadsheets, which are in the Proposed Fiscal Plan – Fiscal Year Ending September 30, 2025, Budget Book (Budget Book) and distributed a printed copy of the PowerPoint presentation to be displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Budget Workshops Fiscal Year 2024-25.” 9:01:57 A.M. The meeting was called to order by Mayor Alpert at 9:01 A.M. 1. PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION RE: PROPOSED FISCAL YEAR 2023-2024 BUDGET BY DEPARTMENT AND FUND (AGENDA ITEM I.1) Financial Administration Director Kelly Strickland and Deputy Financial Administration Director Dawn Murray, Financial Administration Department, came before the Commission. 9:02:15 A.M. Ms. Strickland stated that the presentation will commence with Internal Service Funds which include Fleet Services, Information Technology, Equipment Replacement, and Self Insurance and referred to a PowerPoint presentation displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Budget Workshops - Fiscal Year 2024-25” and slides entitled “Internal Service Funds,” and “Total Proposed City Budget” displayed on the Chambers monitors as follows: TOTAL PROPOSED CITY BUDGET Expenditures 2023-24 2024-25 Increase Percent Adopted Budget Proposed Budget (Decrease) Inc./(Dec.) General Fund 97,455,278 106,900,125 9,444,847 9.69% Special Revenue 46,488,001 39,888,038 (6,599,963) -14.20% Debt Service 7,970,916 7,998,462 27,546 0.35% Enterprise 97,901,289 113,287,333 15,386,044 15.72% Internal Service 28,964,750 29,904,892 940,142 3.25% Trust Funds 7,933,279 7,666,066 (267,213) -3.37% Total $286,713,513 $305,644,916 $18,931,403 6.60% 9:04:08 A.M. 38) Fleet Services – Tab 42 Director Douglas “Doug” Jeffcoat, Public Works (PW) Department, came before the Commission. Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the proposed Budget for Fleet Services and referred to a slide entitled “Fleet Services” as follows:

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -2- 07/23/24 FY2024-25 Proposed Budget: Beginning Fund Balance: $947,857 Revenues: $5,825,335 Total Expenditures: $5,689,567 Ending Fund Budget: $1,083,625 9:05:13 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat presented and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Fleet Services.” 9:06:22 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and Ms. Strickland. 9:09:51 A.M. Question posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and Mr. Jeffcoat left the Dais. 9:10:13 A.M. 39) Information Technology Department - Tab 43 Director Herminio Rodriguez, Information Technology (IT) Department, came before the Commission. Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the Budget Issues for the Information Technology (IT) Department and stated that IT provides technology needs throughout the City and each departmental fund is charged according to the formula for technology, communications, software, maintenance, et cetera and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Information Technology” as follows: FY2024-25 Proposed Budget: Beginning Fund Balance: $286,396 Revenues: $5,754,270 Expenditures: $5,874,668 Ending Fund Balance: $165,998 Budget Issue(s): Cyber Security Modules (2) PC Software: $125,000 Application Support Administrator Salaries/Wages: $110,740 Computer Support Specialist I: $9,092 9:10:58 A.M. Mr. Rodriguez provided a brief overview of the Budget Issues and referred to slides displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Budget Issue – Cyber Security Modules (2),” “Budget Issue – Application Support Administrator,” and “Budget Issue – Computer Support Specialist I.” 9:14:06 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Mr. Rodriguez and the City Manager. 9:23:56 A.M.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -3- 07/23/24 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the proposed IT Budget and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Information Technology” and Mr. Rodriguez left the Dais. 9:24:18 A.M. 40) Equipment Replacement Fund – Tab 44 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the proposed Budget for the Equipment Replacement Fund and stated that this fund is a mechanism to save money for future equipment purchases and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Equipment Replacement” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $7,093,248 Revenues: $1,720,336 Total Expenditures: $1,078,651 Ending Fund Balance: $7,734,933 Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Ms. Strickland and the City Manager. 9:29:04 A.M. 41) Self Insurance Funds Combined – Tab 45 Human Resources Director Stacie Mason, General Manager Domique Anderson, and Risk Manager John Powers, Human Resources (HR) Department, came before the Commission. Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the proposed Self Insurance Funds Combined Budget and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Self-Insurance - Combined” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $7,579,192 Revenues: $15,073,088 Total Expenditures: $17,262,006 Ending Fund Balance: $5,390,274 9:29:56 A.M. Ms. Mason stated that there are six different funds under the umbrella of Self-Insurance Funds and provided a brief overview of the proposed Worker’s Compensation Budget and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Worker’s Compensation” as follows: 1. Worker’s Compensation Beginning Fund Balance: $394,505 Revenues: $2,018,187 Total Expenditures: $2,254,796 Ending Fund Balance: $157,896 9:31:02 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Ms. Mason, Ms. Strickland, and Mr. Powers. 9:34:20 A.M. Ms. Mason continued, provided a brief overview of the proposed General and Fleet Liability Budget, and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “General Fleet Liability” as follows:

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -4- 07/23/24 2. General and Fleet Liability Beginning Fund Balance: ($343,791) Revenues: $1,510,970 Total Expenditures: $1,159,690 Ending Fund Balance: $7,489 9:35:19 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Ms. Mason and the City Manager, and Commissioner Trice provided input. 9:39:05 A.M. Ms. Mason left the Dais, and Director Douglas “Doug” Jeffcoat, Public Works (PW) Department, came before the Commission, and left the Dais, and Ms. Mason returned to the Dais. 9:40:42 A.M. Commissioner Trice provided input regarding auto insurance carriers offering discounts for electronic monitoring to reduce costs and Ms. Mason provided input. 9:41:54 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo continued to pose questions addressed by Ms. Mason and the City Attorney. 9:44:44 A.M. Ms. Mason continued further, provided a brief overview of the proposed Law Enforcement Death Benefit Budget and Group Medical and Dental Budget and referred to slides displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Law Enforcement Death Benefit” and “Group Medical And Dental”. 3. Law Enforcement Death Benefit Beginning Fund Balance: $560,098 Revenues: $9,500 Total Expenditures: $0 Ending Fund Balance: $569,598 4. Group Medical and Dental Beginning Fund Balance: $6,824,592 Revenues: $12,484,431 Total Expenditures: $14,717,109 Ending Fund Balance: $4,591,915 9:46:13 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Ms. Mason and Ms. Anderson, and Commissioner Arroyo commended the HR Department. 9:52:49 A.M. 5. Law Enforcement Liability Beginning Fund Balance: $143,787 Revenues: $150,000 Total Expenditures: $230,411 Ending Fund Balance: $63,376

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -5- 07/23/24 The Commission recessed at 9:53 A.M. and reconvened at 10:04 A.M. Human Resources Director Stacie Mason and Acting General Manager Dominique Anderson, Human Resources Department, came before the Commission. 10:04:30 A.M. Ms. Strickland stated that the City’s Trust Funds have decreased by approximately $260,000 or by -3.37%; that there are two Trust Funds: 1) Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) Plan and 2) 401(a) Defined Contribution Plan – General Employees, and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Total Proposed City Budget” as follows : TOTAL PROPOSED CITY BUDGET 2023-24 2024-25 Increase Percent Adopted Budget Proposed Budget (Decrease) Inc./(Dec.) General Fund 97,455,278 106,900,125 9,444,847 9.69% Special Revenue 46,488,001 39,888,038 (6,599,963) -14.20% Debt Service 7,970,916 7,998,462 27,546 0.35% Enterprise 97,901,289 113,287,333 15,386,044 15.72% Internal Service 28,964,750 29,904,892 940,142 3.25% Trust Funds 7,933,279 7,666,066 (267,213) -3.37% Total $286,713,513 $305,644,916 $18,931,403 6.60% 10:05:01 A.M. 42) Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) – Tab 46 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the proposed Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) Fund and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB)” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $50,028,392 Revenues: $50,028,392 Total Expenditures: $7,592,373 Ending Fund Balance: $45,724,432 10:06:13 A.M. Ms. Mason provided a brief overview of the proposed Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) Budget and Ms. Mason and Ms. Anderson left the Dais. 10:08:38 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Ms. Mason, Ms. Strickland, and the City Manager. 10:12:59 A.M. 43) 401(a) Defined Contribution Plan – General Employees – Tab 47 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the 401(a) Defined Contribution Plan-General Employees Fund and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “401(a) Defined Contribution Plan-General Employees” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $42,976

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -6- 07/23/24 Revenues: $80,000 Total Expenditures: $73,693 Ending Fund Balance: $49,283 10:13:33 A.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs provided a brief overview of the 401(a) Defined Contribution Plan- General Employees Fund. 10:14:15 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by the City Auditor and Clerk and Ms. Strickland. 10:15:26 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Trice were addressed by the City Auditor and Clerk. 10:16:25 A.M. Ms. Strickland presented the Debt Service Fund section, provided a brief overview, and referred to slides displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Debt Service Funds,” “Total Proposed City Budget,” “Bond Ratings,” “Governmental Debt Service Funds Funding Source & Purpose,” “Debt Service – Ad Valorem,” “Debt Service Funds– Governmental,” and “Proprietary Debt Service Funds Funding Source & Purpose,” and stated that the Debt Service in relation to the Expenditure Budget did not change much from FY2023-24 to FY2024-25 since the City has not had any new debt issues. 10:21:16 A.M. Ms. Strickland concluded and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Debt Service – Proprietary Funds” as follows: Principal: $6,357,437 Interest: $1,687,083 Total: $8,044,520 10:22:00 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by the City Manager and Ms. Strickland and a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Governmental Debt Service Funds Funding Source & Purpose” was referenced. 10:24:06 A.M. Question posed by the Vice Mayor was addressed by Ms. Strickland. 10:24:49 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Trice were addressed by Ms. Strickland. 10:25:47 A.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the Bobby Jones Golf Course Debt Service and Ms. Strickland and Commissioner Arroyo provided input.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -7- 07/23/24 10:26:45 A.M. City Manager Brown requested and Director Lucia Panica, Development Services (DS) Department, came before the Commission to address questions posed yesterday regarding the collection of tree removal violation fines and the Vice Mayor posed questions addressed by Ms. Panica and the City Manager. The Commission recessed at 10:37 A.M. and reconvened at 10:45 A.M. Director Douglas “Doug” Jeffcoat, Public Works (PW) Department came before the Commission. 10:45:37 A.M. Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the 5-Year Capital Improvement Program (CIP) funding sources which are Special Revenue Funds and stated that this section will commence with the Penny Sales Tax. 10:46:02 A.M. 44) Penny Sales Tax (Phase I, II, III, AND IV) – Tab 24 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the Local Option Sales Tax (L.O.S.T), also called the Penny Sales Tax and stated that the Referendum for Penny Sales Tax IV is currently being worked on and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Penny Sales Tax (I, II, II, IV)” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $1,699,797 Revenues: $12,787,500 Total Expenditures: $13,766,364 Ending Fund Balance: $720,933 10:47:17 A.M. 45) Multi-Modal Transportation Impact Fee – Tab 25 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview of the Multi-Modal Transportation Impact Fees and referred to a slide entitled “Multi-Modal Transportation Impact Fee” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $21,414 Revenues: $600,000 Total Expenditures: $180,324 Ending Fund Balance: $441,090 Projects/Initiatives: ATMS Project $100,000 Alderman MURT and US301 56,000 $156,000 10:48:01 A.M. 46) Gas Tax Fund – Tab 26, and $0.05 Local Option Fuel Tax – Tab 27 Ms. Strickland provided a brief overview and referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Gas Tax, Local Option Fuel Tax” as follows: Revenues: $1,700,000 Total Expenditures: $1,963,440 Ending Fund Balance: $59,460

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -8- 07/23/24 Budgeted Expenditures for 2024-25: Various Transportation Equipment and Maintenance Items $839,752 Transfer to the General Fund for Street Sweeping 60,000 Transfer to the General Fund for Engineering - ATMS 25,000 Transfer to General Fund for Transportation 905,506 Transfer to General Fund for Traffic Signal Technician 89,611 Transfer to General Fund for Project Engineering 43,571 Total $1,963,440 Revenues: $1,060,000 Total Expenditures: $1,100,000 Ending Fund Balance: $395,358 Budgeted Expenditures for 2024-25: Street Reconstruction $450,000 Bridge Replacement 200,000 Intersection Improvements 400,000 ADA/Pedestrian Signalization Curb and Gutter Construction 50,000 Total $1,100,000 10:49:11 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat provided a brief overview of the Budget Issues and referred to slides displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Budget Issue – Street Sweeper Replacement” and “Budget Issue – Vac Truck.” 10:49:58 A.M. 47) Tourist Development Tax – Tab 28 Ms. Strickland referred to a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Tourist Development Tax” as follows: Beginning Fund Balance: $275,654 Revenues: $1,371,000 Total Expenditures: $1,375,693 Ending Fund Balance: $270,961 10:50:41 A.M. Questions posed by the Mayor regarding the Multi-Modal Transportation Impact Fee were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager. 10:53:20 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor about the City’s policy regarding the use of the Tourist Development Tax for the beaches and Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall (VWPAH) and whether the funds have ever been used for VWPAH were addressed by the City Manager. 10:55:24 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Trice were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 10:57 A.M.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -9- 07/23/24 10:58:47 A.M. City Manager Brown requested Staff send the Commission an electronic copy of the Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan (Fiscal Years 2025-2029). 10:59:28 A.M. City Manager Brown stated that Staff is presenting the CIP in a new format and questions will be taken after each section. 10:59:44 A.M. 48) 5-Year Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Mr. Jeffcoat referred to the Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan (Fiscal Years 2025-2029), provided a brief overview of the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) and stated that the first 11 pages are related to the Budget Book; that the additional four pages details each one of the Capital Improvement Projects by Expenditures and is what will be referenced and displayed on the Chambers monitors. 11:00:20 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat continued, provided a brief overview of the June 28, 2024, Interoffice Memorandum included in the Budget Book and stated that the proposed five-year CIP consists of 79 projects totaling over approximately $178 million and the proposed changes, projects removed and added, are detailed in the Interoffice Memorandum; that this is the first year the Commission will be approving the Surtax IV Extension, which was approved by voters in November 2022 and the projects had an estimated revenue of 15 years for approximately $191 million. 11:04:17 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat referred to the additional four pages of the Five Year Capital Improvement Plan (Fiscal Years 2025 -2029) displayed on the Chambers monitors and stated that questions are open for page 1 of 4 and City Manager Brown read the projects listed under Environmental. 11:05:48 A.M. Questions posed by the Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat. 11:06:41 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager. 11:10:21 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager, and City Engineer Nikesh “Nik” Patel, Engineering, PW Department, came before the Commission. 11:14:12 A.M. Question posed by Commissioner Trice was addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -10- 07/23/24 11:15:03 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Battie were addressed by Mr. Patel and the City Manager provided input and the Vice Mayor posed questions addressed by Mr. Patel and Commissioner Battie provided input. Mr. Patel left the Dais. 11:20:55 A.M. Mayor Alpert sought Commission questions regarding the section entitled “Public Safety” displayed on the Chambers monitors. 11:20:56 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager provided input. 11:22:12 A.M. Mayor Alpert sought Commission questions regarding the section entitled “Public Health” displayed on the Chambers monitors and none were received. 11:22:48 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat provided a brief overview of the section entitled “Transportation Infrastructure” displayed on the Chambers monitors and sought Commission questions for Transportation Infrastructure on page 2 of 4. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left the Chambers at 11:27 A.M. 11:30:35 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the Vice Mayor spoke in favor of prioritizing the undergrounding of power lines which was addressed by the City Manager. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs returned to the Chambers at 11:31 A.M. 11:36:24 A.M. Commissioner Trice spoke to prioritizing the undergrounding of power lines and also recommended with regard to the 12 th Street Complete Street, for the City to consider creating an alternate evacuation route between US 41 to US 301 which would move along 10 th Street, up Orange Avenue for two blocks, and then to 12 th Street. 11:39:41 A.M. Questions posed by the Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager provided input. Commissioner Battie left the Chambers at 11:41 A.M. 11:43:11 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat continued to provide a brief overview of the section entitled “Transportation Infrastructure (Continued)” on page 3 of 4 displayed on the Chambers monitors and stated that the topic is open to questions.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -11- 07/23/24 Commissioner Battie left the Chambers at 11:45 A.M. Mayor Alpert passed the gavel to the Vice Mayor and left the Dais at 11:45 A.M. 11:45:20 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo spoke in favor of having more funding for Alley Beautification. 11:45:31 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat, the City Manager, and Chief Transportation Planner Alvimarie Corales, Engineering, PW Department, who came before the Commission. 11:50:31 A.M. Question posed by Commissioner Trice was addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager provided input. 11:51:47 A.M. Ms. Corales left the Dais. Mayor Alpert returned to the Dais at 11:51 A.M. and the Vice Mayor passed the gavel back to the Mayor. 11:51:47 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat provided a brief overview of the section entitled “Neighborhoods” on page 3 of 4 displayed on the Chambers monitors, the City Manager provided input, and stated that the topic is open to questions. 11:52:46 A.M. Question posed by Commissioner Trice was addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat. 11:52:46 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat, the City Manager, Senior Transportation Planner Corinne Arriaga, Engineering, PW Department, who came before Commission, and Chief Transportation Planner Alvimarie Corales who returned to the Dais, and Ms. Corales and Ms. Arriaga left the Dais. 11:54:59 A.M. Commissioner Trice spoke in favor of individuals purchasing streetlamp posts and placing them on sidewalks in front of their homes and posed a question addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat. 11:57:12 A.M. Question posed by Commissioner Trice regarding Affordable Housing was addressed by the City Manager. 11:58:37 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by the City Manager.

Workshop Re: Proposed FY 2024/25 Budget by Department and Fund -12- 07/23/24 11:59:16 A.M. Mr. Jeffcoat provided a brief overview of the section entitled “Parks and Recreation” on page 4 of 4 displayed on the Chambers monitors and the City Manager provided input. 12:02:04 P.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat, Director Jerry Fogle, Parks and Recreation, who came before the Commission, and the City Manager. 12:09:33 P.M. Commissioner Battie spoke to whether there is some type of creative funding sources particularly for the parks mentioned by the Vice Mayor where the developers can assist with a public/private partnership. 12:10:18 P.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Trice in regard to The Bay Park Improvements were addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat and the City Manager. 12:12:18 P.M. Mr. Fogle left the Dais. 12:12:21 P.M. Mr. Jeffcoat provided a brief overview of the section entitled “General Government (Public Facilities)” displayed on the Chambers monitors and stated that the topic is open to questions. 12:14:32 P.M. Question posed by the Mayor was addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat. 12:15:02 P.M. Question posed by Commissioner Trice was addressed by Mr. Jeffcoat, and Commissioner Arroyo posed a question which was addressed by the City Attorney, and Commissioner Trice spoke to the topic. 12:18:14 P.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Executive Director Mary Bensel and Facilities Manager Jerry Sheffer, Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall (VWPAH), who came before the Commission, the City Manager, and Ms. Strickland. 12:21:04 P.M. City Manager Brown stated that this is the end of the FY2024-25 Budget Workshop, and the request is to commence today’s Special Sarasota City Commission Meeting at 2:00 P.M. 12:21:18 P.M. 2. ADJOURN (AGENDA ITEM II) Mayor Alpert adjourned the Sarasota City Commission Budget Workshop of July 23, 2024, at 12:21 P.M.

WORKSHOP CITY COMMISSION MEETING CITY HALL 1565 First Street Sarasota, Florida July 23, 2024 City Commission Chambers 9:00 AM I. AGENDA ITEMS: I.1 Presentation and Discussion Re: Proposed Fiscal Year 2024-2025 Budget by Department and Fund I.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf Budget Presentation_FY25.pdf FY25_Proposed Financial Plan.pdf II. ADJOURN Meeting Notice 7-22-24 and 7-23-24 Budget Workshop Notice.pdf City Commission Rules of Procedure CC.RulesofProcedure.AdoptedApril15-2024.pdf Items Received at the Meeting Five Year Capital Improvement Plan.pdf AGENDA CALL MEETING TO ORDER MEETING NOTICE CITY COMMISSION RULES OF PROCEDURE ITEMS RECEIVED AT THE MEETING 1

Shayla Griggs City Auditor and Clerk Notice to the Public The City of Sarasota is committed to providing qualified disabled individuals an opportunity to participate in meetings of the City Commission. The City of Sarasota prohibits discrimination in all services, programs, or activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, sex or gender, marital or familial status, religion, sexual orientation, veteran status, or genetic information. Persons with disabilities who require assistance or alternative means for communication of program information such as Braille, large print, audiotape, etc., should contact: The City of Sarasota ADA Coordinator, Jake Brown, at (941) 263-6299 or by email at adacoordinator@sarasotafl.gov. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in a meeting should contact the ADA Coordinator at (941) 263-6299 at least two business days prior to the date of the meeting as to the nature of the auxiliary aids and/or service necessary. Every effort will be made to provide such aid or service to the extent that they are reasonable, do not result in undue financial or administrative burden, and do not alter the fundamental nature of the meeting. Consideration will be given to the individual's preferred aid or service. However, alternatives may be provided if in the City's determination such alternatives provide an effective means of communication. For the benefit of individuals utilizing hearing aids with a T-coil, the City Commission Chambers and SRQ Media Studio are outfitted with a Hearing Induction Loop for enhanced hearing assistance. Proceedings will be electronically recorded. Should an individual feel that a verbatim transcription of the proceedings may later be needed, said individual has the burden and expense of arranging for same. Copies of the electronic recording may be purchased from the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk. 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 184,287 characters. The full document is at the source.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION BUDGET WORKSHOP TUESDAY, JULY 23, 2024, 9:00 A.M. DISCLAIMER: THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER. 09:01:53 [ SOUNDING GAVEL ] 09:01:55 >>Mayor Alpert: GOOD MORNING. 09:01:57 I'M GOING TO CALL TO ORDER THIS TUESDAY, JULY 23rd, CITY 09:02:01 COMMISSION BUDGET WORKSHOP. 09:02:06 AND IT'S 2024, JUST IN CASE YOU ARE WATCHING IT TWO YEARS 09:02:09 FROM NOW. 09:02:10 THANK YOU. 09:02:13 >>Kelly Strickland: GOOD MORNING. 09:02:14 MY NAME IS KELLY STRICKLAND. 09:02:15 I'M DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL ADMINISTRATION. 09:02:16 WE'RE ON DAY TWO OF OUR BUDGET WORKSHOPS. 09:02:19 WE'RE GOING TO PICK UP WHERE WE LEFT OFF FOR THE INTERNAL 09:02:21 SERVICE FUNDS. 09:02:22 IN YOUR WORKBOOK, THIS IS THE GREEN TAB, CLOSER TO THE BACK. 09:02:29 INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS ARE USED TO PROVIDE GOODS AND 09:02:33 SERVICES FOR THE DEPARTMENTS OF THE CITY. 09:03:04 >>Shayla Griggs: YOU ALL KEEP GOING. 09:03:12 [NO AUDIO] 09:03:23 [NO AUDIO] 09:03:31 >>Kelly Strickland: OUR INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS HAVE 09:03:33 INCREASED $940,142. 09:03:36 AND WE HAVE FOUR INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS WHICH INCLUDE FLEET 09:03:42 SERVICES. 09:03:43 THIS IS THE GARAGE THAT THE CITY USES FOR THE CITY'S FLEET. 09:03:47 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY THAT PROVIDES ALL OF THE INFORMATION 09:03:51 TECHNOLOGY FOR THE CITY. 09:03:52 THE EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND, WHICH IS THE FUND WHERE WE 09:03:57 PUT FUNDING TO REPLACE OUR EQUIPMENT AND REQUIRED PERIOD OF 09:04:03 TIME. 09:04:03 AND THEN OUR SELF INSURANCE FUND, WHICH IS A COMBINATION OF 09:04:06 SEVERAL. 09:04:06 WE'LL GO THROUGH EACH OF THESE. 09:04:08 THE FIRST INTERNAL SERVICE FUND THAT WE'LL TAKE A LOOK AT IS 09:04:12 FLEET SERVICES. 09:04:13 AND THAT IS ON TAB 42. 09:04:17 THIS FUND IS STARTING WITH A FUND -- OH, AND BEFORE I GET 09:04:24 STARTED ON INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS, THE IDEA FOR INTERNAL 09:04:28 SERVICE FUNDS IS TO BREAK EVEN BECAUSE THEY ARE PROVIDING A 09:04:32 SERVICE FOR VARIOUS DEPARTMENTS WITHIN THE CITY. 09:04:35 WE WANT TO CHARGE JUST THE AMOUNT THAT WE NEED TO PROVIDE 09:04:38 THOSE SERVICES.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:04:39 AND MOST OF THE REVENUE COMES FROM THE OTHER DEPARTMENTS. 09:04:43 THEY ARE PAYING INTO THESE FUNDS. 09:04:45 SO THE FLEET SERVICES WE'RE STARTING WITH A FUND BALANCE OF 09:04:50 947,000. 09:04:52 OUR REVENUES ARE 5.8 MILLION. 09:04:55 OUR EXPENDITURES ARE 5.6 MILLION LEAVING AN ENDING FUND 09:05:00 BALANCE OF A MILLION 83. 09:05:03 THIS HAS 6.3 FTE IN IT. 09:05:08 I'LL TURN IT OVER TO MR. DOUG JEFFCOAT TO CONTINUE. 09:05:13 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: GOOD MORNING, MAYOR AND COMMISSIONERS. 09:05:15 DOUG JEFFCOAT, FOR THE RECORD, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR. 09:05:18 THIS IS THE GARAGE. 09:05:21 WE DO THE REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE OF ALL THE FLEET, EXCEPT 09:05:23 FOR PART OF THE PDs STAFF. 09:05:28 BUT THIS ALSO INCLUDES THE FUEL ISLAND. 09:05:31 WE PROVIDE 24-HOUR SERVICE IN REGARDS TO FUEL FOR THE 09:05:35 SERVICES. 09:05:36 ONE THING IN REGARDS TO THE FUND BALANCE THAT WE DO WORK ON 09:05:41 ACCUMULATING FOR IS THE REPLACEMENT OF TANKS AND THINGS OF 09:05:45 THAT NATURE. 09:05:45 SO AS OPPOSED TO THE IDEA OF WAITING AND HAVING THAT LARGE 09:05:52 EXPENSE ONE YEAR TO HAVING TO ALLOCATE THAT OUT, WE DO TRY 09:05:57 TO BUILD A FUND BALANCE TO GO TOWARDS THOSE TYPE OF 09:05:59 PROJECTS. 09:06:00 THE BIGGEST EXPENDITURES INCREASES IN THIS BUDGET ARE 09:06:03 RELATED TO FUEL AND TO THE PARTS, AND THEY ARE BETWEEN 3 AND 09:06:09 10 PERCENT TOGETHER IN REGARDS TO THE INCREASES THIS YEAR. 09:06:11 HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE IN REGARDS TO 09:06:14 THE FLEET. 09:06:18 >>Mayor Alpert: COMMISSIONER ARROYO. 09:06:18 >>Erik Arroyo: THANK YOU. 09:06:19 GOOD MORNING. 09:06:22 I ASKED THIS QUESTION BEFORE AND I WOULD LIKE TO HASH OUT 09:06:28 WHAT MY THOUGHTS ARE ON IT. 09:06:30 WHAT ARE THE REASONS THAT THE POLICE DEPARTMENT DOES NOT GO 09:06:32 GET OUR FLEET SERVICES FROM OUR FLEET SERVICES? 09:06:37 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: THIS GOES BACK TO THE PURCHASING OF THE 09:06:39 VEHICLES THAT THEY ARE PURCHASING IN REGARDS TO IT. 09:06:42 THEY ARE ALSO BUYING THE MAINTENANCE PLANS FOR THOSE. 09:06:45 SO THEY ARE GOING DIRECTLY TO WHEREVER -- YOU KNOW, SUNSET 09:06:51 CHEVROLET IS THE LOCAL ONE THEY ARE USING AS IT RELATES TO 09:06:54 IT. 09:06:55 THAT'S REALLY THE REASONS BEHIND THAT. 09:06:57 IN THEIR PURCHASING PROCESS, THE WAY THAT THEY ARE BUYING 09:06:59 THEIR VEHICLES, THEY ARE BUYING THESE LONG-TERM MAINTENANCE 09:07:02 AGREEMENTS SO THAT THEY ARE GETTING THOSE SERVICES PAID IN 09:07:06 THROUGH THOSE VEHICLES IN THE PURCHASE VERSUS ON A REGULAR 09:07:10 BASIS COMING IN. 09:07:11 >>Erik Arroyo: LET'S SAY THEY DIDN'T BUY THOSE LONG-TERM 09:07:14 MAINTENANCE CONTRACTS, THAT COULD BE DONE IN HOUSE. 09:07:17 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: IT WOULD BE DONE IN HOUSE. 09:07:19 BUT AS WE DISCUSSED IN THE PAST, WE WOULD HAVE TO INCREASE

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:07:22 STAFFING LEVELS TO DO THAT. 09:07:24 WE ARE AT A STAFFING LEVEL NOT -- NOT INCLUDING THOSE 09:07:29 ADDITIONAL VEHICLES. 09:07:30 >>Erik Arroyo: YOU WOULD ALSO HAVE TO PROBABLY REDUCE THE 09:07:32 COST OF THE SERVICES TO MATCH WHATEVER THEY ARE PAYING. 09:07:36 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: WE'D HAVE TO TAKE A LOOK AT IT IN 09:07:38 REGARDS TO COMPARISON PURPOSES. 09:07:39 I WILL TELL YOU, AND WE'VE LOOKED AT THIS IN THE PAST AND 09:07:42 DISCUSSED IT IN THE PAST, THERE ARE DEFINITELY THINGS THAT 09:07:45 THE VENDORS ARE DOING A LITTLE CHEAPER THAN US, BUT THEN 09:07:48 THINGS WE'RE DOING CHEAPER THAN THE VENDORS. 09:07:50 >>Erik Arroyo: I DON'T SEE US AS COMPETING VERSUS THE 09:07:54 VENDOR. 09:07:54 REGARDLESS, US USING AN INTERNAL FUND TO GET INTERNAL 09:07:59 SERVICES IS STILL KEEPING THE MONEY WITHIN THE CITY AS 09:08:01 OPPOSED TO MONEY GOING OUT. 09:08:03 OKAY. 09:08:04 I JUST WANTED TO POINT THAT OUT. 09:08:08 MY POSITION HAS NOT CHANGED. 09:08:10 THERE'S SOMETHING TO DO THERE. 09:08:12 WHAT ARE YOUR ANTICIPATED -- YOU DON'T HAVE ANY NEEDS 09:08:21 BECAUSE IT'S GOING TO BE A WASH IN TERMS OF THESE. 09:08:26 ARE YOU COMFORTABLE WITH THE LEVEL OF PERSONNEL THAT YOU 09:08:28 HAVE NOW? 09:08:30 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: WE ACTUALLY HAVE ONE POSITION THAT WE 09:08:32 HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO FILL IN A YEAR IN REGARDS TO ONE OF OUR 09:08:35 MECHANICS. 09:08:36 THAT'S OUR BIGGEST ISSUES RIGHT NOW IS BEING ABLE TO ATTRACT 09:08:41 MECHANICS TO COME TO WORK IN THIS TYPE OF ENVIRONMENT. 09:08:45 >>Erik Arroyo: WHY DO YOU THINK YOU'RE NOT ATTRACTING THE 09:08:47 MECHANICS? 09:08:48 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: TWOFOLD IN REGARDS TO IT. 09:08:51 SALARIES ARE ONE OF THE BIG THINGS IN REGARDS TO IT. 09:08:53 THE TYPICAL WORKING CONDITIONS THAT WE'RE FACED WITH VERSUS 09:08:56 IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR IS ANOTHER ONE. 09:08:59 >>Erik Arroyo: HOW MUCH DOES THAT POSITION PAY THAT YOU ARE 09:09:02 WAITING TO FILL? 09:09:03 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: I APOLOGIZE. 09:09:04 I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE AMOUNT IS. 09:09:08 >>Erik Arroyo: OKAY. 09:09:08 WE'RE NOT MAKING ANY TRANSFERS FROM ANY OTHER FUNDS TO THIS 09:09:18 EXCEPT THE ONES THAT USE IT, RIGHT? 09:09:20 >>Kelly Strickland: EVERY FUND THAT DOES USE IT TRANSFERS 09:09:23 INTO THIS FUND. 09:09:24 >>Erik Arroyo: DO THEY TRANSFER AHEAD OF TIME IN 09:09:26 ANTICIPATION OF WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO USE UP THAT YEAR? 09:09:29 >>Kelly Strickland: WE BUDGET A MONTHLY ALLOCATION, AND THEN 09:09:32 ALSO WHEN THEY PURCHASE GAS OR SOMETHING, THAT IS A DIRECT 09:09:35 CHARGE TO THE FUNDS. 09:09:36 IF YOU LOOK IN THE GENERAL FUND IN THE UNCLASSIFIED, YOU'LL 09:09:41 SEE A FLEET ALLOCATION.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:09:44 THAT'S THE GENERAL FUND'S PORTION THAT THEY PAY INTO HERE. 09:09:47 >>Erik Arroyo: OKAY. 09:09:48 ALL RIGHT. 09:09:48 THANK YOU. 09:09:50 >>Mayor Alpert: VICE MAYOR. 09:09:51 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: JUST A FOLLOW-UP ON COMMISSIONER 09:09:54 ARROYO'S COMMENTS, THE POLICE DEPARTMENT, THEY DO GAS UP 09:09:58 HERE. 09:09:58 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: THAT IS CORRECT. 09:09:59 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: THAT IS THE ONE THING THAT THEY DO 09:10:02 THROUGH THIS. 09:10:03 JUST WANTED TO POINT THAT OUT. 09:10:04 THAT'S IT. 09:10:06 >>Mayor Alpert: OKAY. 09:10:07 NO OTHER QUESTIONS. 09:10:07 THANK YOU. 09:10:08 >>Douglas Jeffcoat: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 09:10:13 >>Kelly Strickland: OUR NEXT FUND IS TAB 43, INFORMATION 09:10:16 TECHNOLOGY. 09:10:16 THERE ARE 18 CURRENT FTE AND BUDGET ISSUES FOR TWO 09:10:23 ADDITIONAL FTE. 09:10:24 I WANT TO POINT OUT THAT ONE OF THE REQUESTS, THE BUDGET 09:10:27 ISSUES, IS JUST A CHANGE IN IT FROM A CONTRACT EMPLOYEE TO A 09:10:31 FULL-TIME. 09:10:32 SO TOTAL OF -- 09:10:34 >>Mayor Alpert: SPEAK UP AND INTO THE MICROPHONE, KELLY. 09:10:36 THANK YOU. 09:10:38 >>Kelly Strickland: THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY FUND IS AN 09:10:40 INTERNAL SERVICE FUND. 09:10:41 IT PROVIDES TECHNOLOGY NEEDS THROUGHOUT THE CITY. 09:10:44 EACH FUND IS CHARGED ACCORDING TO A FORMULA FOR THE 09:10:48 TECHNOLOGY, COMMUNICATIONS, SOFTWARE, MAINTENANCE, 09:10:51 ET CETERA. 09:10:51 I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MR. HERMINIO RODRIGUEZ, AND HE CAN 09:10:57 TALK MORE ABOUT IT. 09:10:58 >>Herminio Rodriguez: GOOD MORNING. 09:10:59 MY NAME IS HERMINIO RODRIGUEZ. 09:11:01 I AM THE I.T. DIRECTOR. 09:11:02 I DO HAVE THREE BUDGET ISSUES. 09:11:04 I'LL GO THROUGH THOSE THREE. 09:11:05 THE FIRST BUDGET ISSUE IS AN APPLICATION SUPPORT 09:11:08 ADMINISTRATOR. 09:11:08 THAT'S AN FTE POSITION. 09:11:11 AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE LEARNED FROM THE WORK DAY 09:11:14 PROJECT IS HOW IMPORTANT IT IS TO HAVE SOMEONE BE HIRED 09:11:17 BEFORE THE PROJECT COMPLETES AND ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO WORK 09:11:20 WITH THE CONSULTANTS TO ACTUALLY UNDERSTAND HOW A SYSTEM IS 09:11:23 BUILT SO WHEN THE SYSTEM GOES LIVE, WE CAN BE IN A POSITION 09:11:26 TO ADD VALUE. 09:11:27 THIS ROLE WILL ALSO HANDLE SECURITY. 09:11:30 THAT MEANS THE USERS WILL HAVE EXACTLY THE PERFECT AMOUNT OF 09:11:35 SECURITY, ACCESS -- SORRY THAT THEY NEED FOR THE

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:11:38 APPLICATION. 09:11:39 THE SECOND PART WOULD BE CARE AND FEEDING OF THE 09:11:41 APPLICATION. 09:11:42 THAT MEANS MANAGING UPDATES, ALSO WORKING WITH INTEGRATIONS. 09:11:45 THIS SYSTEM WILL INTEGRATE WITH WORK DAY WITH A NEW 09:11:48 APPLICATION COMING DOWN THE ROAD CALLED CITY WORKS. 09:11:51 AND ALSO WITH THE IVR SYSTEM, WHICH IS HOW OUR CITIZENS USE 09:11:54 THE PHONE SYSTEM TO GET -- TO PAY OR TO GET BALANCES. 09:11:58 THIS POSITION WILL ALSO WORK ON REPORTS, CREATING AND 09:12:01 MAINTAINING AND MANY OTHER THINGS THAT IT WILL DO. 09:12:06 THE SECOND PART, AS KELLY MENTIONED, IS CONVERTING CONTRACT 09:12:10 SERVICE DESK EMPLOYEE TO AN FTE ROLE. 09:12:14 THE SERVICE DESK IS A CRITICAL POSITION THAT WE HAVE, AND 09:12:18 THIS WAS DONE TO MANAGE THE FIRST WORK DAY HIRE. 09:12:23 THE THIRD BUDGET ISSUE IS ACTUALLY TWO CYBERSECURITY 09:12:27 MODULES. 09:12:29 THE FIRST IS CALLED NDR. 09:12:31 THAT'S NETWORK DETECTION AND RESPONSE. 09:12:33 WHAT THAT MEANS IS WE HAVE A LOT OF SECURITY TO KEEP THE BAD 09:12:39 GUYS OUT, BUT IF THEY DO GET IN, ONCE THEY ARE IN THE HOUSE, 09:12:43 WE DON'T HAVE A LOT. 09:12:44 SO THE NDR, WHAT IT WOULD DO IS, IT WOULD ACTUALLY BASELINE 09:12:49 NETWORK PERFORMANCE, AND IF IT SAW COMPUTER A DOESN'T TALK 09:12:54 TO COMPUTER C, BUT IT'S SENDING A LOT OF DATA TO COMPUTER C 09:12:58 ON A WEDNESDAY, A RED FLAG WOULD GO UP AND WOULD LET US KNOW 09:13:01 THAT SOMETHING BAD IS HAPPENING IN THE NETWORK. 09:13:04 THAT IS THE SECOND PART. 09:13:05 THE FIRST PART. 09:13:06 THE SECOND PART IS CALLED SINGULARITY IDENTITY. 09:13:10 THIS IS FOR, I HAVE TO SAY A BAD WORD, CROWDSTRIKE, THIS IS 09:13:15 OUR VERSION. 09:13:16 NOT CROWD. 09:13:17 THIS IS OUR VERSION OF CROWDSTRIKE, AND IT WOULD BE A MODULE 09:13:21 THAT WOULD AUDIT THE DATABASE WE HAVE FOR ALL CITY 09:13:24 EMPLOYEES. 09:13:25 WHEN CITY EMPLOYEES USE THEIR ID AND PASSWORD, THEY CONNECT 09:13:28 TO THIS DATABASE. 09:13:29 AND SINGULARITY IDENTITY WOULD AUDIT THIS DATABASE IN REAL 09:13:33 TIME AND IF SOMEONE GOT MORE ACCESS THAN THEY NEEDED IT 09:13:38 WOULD ALERT US. 09:13:39 WHAT THE BAD GUYS DO, WHEN THEY PENETRATE A NETWORK, THEY 09:13:44 SIT IN FOR ABOUT THREE TO SIX MONTHS AND THEY START CREATING 09:13:47 IDENTITIES IN THIS DATABASE. 09:13:48 IT WOULD ALERT US. 09:13:49 WE HAVE VISIBILITY INTO THIS DATABASE. 09:13:52 THOSE ARE THE TWO MODULES FOR THE THIRD BUDGET ISSUE. 09:13:56 WITH THAT, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE THREE 09:13:59 BUDGET ISSUES OR ABOUT THE I.T. BUDGET AS A WHOLE. 09:14:03 >>Mayor Alpert: COMMISSIONER ARROYO. 09:14:05 >>Erik Arroyo: YES. 09:14:06 THANK YOU FOR THAT. 09:14:09 ARE THERE ANY PROJECTS THAT YOU THINK ARE CRITICALLY

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:14:13 UNDERFUNDED RIGHT NOW? 09:14:20 >>Herminio Rodriguez: I HAVE ALL THE SUPPORT I NEED. 09:14:22 I ACTUALLY NEED MORE TIME TO GET ALL THE PROJECTS DONE, BUT, 09:14:25 NO. 09:14:28 >>Erik Arroyo: HOW DO WE DETERMINE WHICH PROJECTS WE 09:14:31 PRIORITIZE AND WHICH ONES WE DON'T IN TERMS OF MOVING 09:14:33 FORWARD? 09:14:35 >>Herminio Rodriguez: ON THE I.T. SIDE, IT'S WHAT IMPACTS 09:14:41 MORE STAKEHOLDERS. 09:14:43 ANY VULNERABILITIES OR ANY GAPS THAT WE SEE IN THE NETWORK 09:14:46 WITH CYBER OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT. 09:14:49 WE HAVE SOMETHING CALLED OUR DIGITAL JOURNEY. 09:14:51 THE UTILITY BILLING PROJECT IS STEP NUMBER TWO. 09:14:53 WE FINISH WORK DAY, AND STEP NUMBER THREE WOULD BE AN ASSET 09:14:57 MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND A WORK ORDER SYSTEM FOR PUBLIC WORKS, 09:15:00 UTILITIES, AND PARKS AND REC. 09:15:02 AND THEN THE LAST PART OF THIS WOULD BE SOMETHING FOR 09:15:06 DEVELOPMENTAL SERVICES TO UPDATE THAT ROLE. 09:15:08 AND THOSE FOUR PIECES ARE WHAT WE'RE CALLING OUR DIGITAL 09:15:12 JOURNEY. 09:15:13 IT'S A MULTIYEAR PROJECT. 09:15:15 >>Erik Arroyo: THESE TWO NEW POSITIONS, ARE THEY ENOUGH -- 09:15:19 ARE THEY ENOUGH TO COVER THE WORKLOAD THAT YOU'RE GETTING IN 09:15:22 THE DEPARTMENT? 09:15:24 >>Herminio Rodriguez: WE BELIEVE SO. 09:15:26 WE'RE CONSTANTLY BRINGING IN NEW SOFTWARE FROM ALL THE 09:15:28 DEPARTMENTS BECAUSE THERE IS A MAJOR SHIFT IN I.T. WHERE 09:15:32 YOU'RE MOVING FROM AN ON-PREM DATA CENTER ROLE TO A MORE 09:15:37 CLOUD ROLE AND THAT IS A TOTALLY DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENT. 09:15:40 REALLY, THE ROLE OF I.T. IS MOVING FROM TURNING THE WRENCH 09:15:43 IN A SERVER IN A DATA CENTER TO REALLY MANAGING VENDORS, 09:15:47 MANAGING DATABASES, AND MANAGING INFORMATION THAT YOU CAN NO 09:15:51 LONGER PUT YOUR HANDS AROUND SOMEPLACE ELSE. 09:15:56 >>Erik Arroyo: IS 125,000 IN CYBERSECURITY SUFFICIENT FOR 09:16:00 WHAT WE NEED? 09:16:03 >>Herminio Rodriguez: FOR RIGHT NOW -- 09:16:04 >>Erik Arroyo: JUST HAD A $500,000 ASK FOR A STUDY. 09:16:08 THAT'S WHY I'M KIND OF WONDERING -- 09:16:11 >>Marlon Brown: COMMISSIONER, AGAIN, THIS IS NOT THE FIRST 09:16:13 YEAR WE BUDGETED FOR CYBERSECURITY. 09:16:15 SO THIS IS ONGOING EFFORTS. 09:16:18 ONGOING ACQUISITION OF OTHER SAFETY MEASURES TO PROTECT -- 09:16:24 >>Erik Arroyo: COMPOUNDED BASED ON WHAT WE HAVE. 09:16:27 >>Herminio Rodriguez: CORRECT. 09:16:27 THESE TWO MODULES THAT WE'RE GETTING ARE ADD-ONS TO MODULES 09:16:31 WE BOUGHT IN PREVIOUS YEARS. 09:16:33 IT WILL GIVE US ADDITIONAL CAPABILITY. 09:16:35 I REALLY FEEL THE CITY HAS BEEN VERY, VERY SUPPORTIVE WITH 09:16:38 CYBERSECURITY AND THAT'S WHY -- I DON'T WANT TO SAY IT, 09:16:40 DON'T WANT TO KNOCK ON WOOD -- WE'VE BEEN DOING OKAY. 09:16:43 >>Erik Arroyo: LOOK, PUBLIC SAFETY AND CYBER SAFETY 09:16:47 PRIORITIES SHOULD BE A PRIORITY OF OUR CITY.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:16:51 BUT ALSO, END-TO-END INTERFACE IMPROVEMENTS WHEN IT COMES TO 09:16:56 THE END CUSTOMER RESIDENT SATISFACTION. 09:16:59 I KNOW WE'VE TAKEN TREMENDOUS STEPS, ESPECIALLY BY THE 09:17:04 ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT, PUBLIC WORKS AND THE REST OF THE 09:17:06 CITY IN TERMS OF INTEGRATING ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND 09:17:11 THESE ADVANCEMENTS IN TECHNOLOGY. 09:17:13 WHAT ARE WE DOING TO IMPROVE THAT END-TO-END USER SERVICE 09:17:21 LEVEL, IF YOU WILL? 09:17:21 IF YOU WANT, I CAN BE MORE SPECIFIC. 09:17:26 CAN EVERY SINGLE FEE THAT ANYONE CAN PAY BE PAID ONLINE? 09:17:30 >>Herminio Rodriguez: WE HAVE WORKED A LOT WITH 09:17:32 DEVELOPMENTAL SERVICES. 09:17:34 WE ONLY HAVE A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF FINITE TIME AND RESOURCES. 09:17:38 WE PARTNERED WITH HUMAN RESOURCES AND FINANCE TO DELIVER 09:17:41 WORK DAY. 09:17:42 WE PARTNERED WITH DEVELOPMENTAL SERVICES TO BRING OUR SITE 09:17:45 PLANS ONLINE, AND IT JUST -- THERE'S SO MUCH TO DO THAT 09:17:51 DIGITAL PATH, THERE'S SO MUCH TO DO. 09:17:54 AND WE WORK WITH THE DEPARTMENTS TO SEE WHERE THE GAPS ARE 09:17:58 AT AND THAT'S WHERE WE APPLY OUR RESOURCES. 09:18:00 I THINK WE'VE DONE A REALLY GOOD -- I THINK WE'VE REALLY 09:18:03 TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF THE RESOURCE THAT WE HAD AND MADE THE 09:18:06 HEADWAY THAT WE HAVE. 09:18:07 IT'S A LONG ROAD AND THERE'S A LOT OF WORK TO DO, BUT THERE 09:18:11 IS A LOT OF STUFF HAPPENING AT THE CITY. 09:18:14 WE'RE DIGITIZING. 09:18:15 YOU MENTIONED A.I. 09:18:17 WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A.I., THE REASON WHY WE DON'T HAVE A.I. 09:18:20 OR ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RIGHT NOW IS BECAUSE WE ARE IN A 09:18:24 SEPARATE CLOUD. 09:18:25 IT IS CALLED A GOVERNMENT CLOUD. 09:18:27 MICROSOFT HAS NOT ENABLED THEIR AI CALLED COPILOT FOR THE 09:18:31 GOVERNMENT CLOUD YET. 09:18:32 I JUST CAME BACK FROM A CONFERENCE. 09:18:34 THEY ARE SAYING THE LATEST WOULD BE SEPTEMBER, IS COULD BE 09:18:37 AUGUST. 09:18:37 ONCE WE DO THAT, THEN WE WILL GET A.I. FIRST FOR THE 09:18:41 DEPARTMENT HEADS AND THEN LATER ON TO EACH. 09:18:43 BUT OUR GOAL IS TO HAVE A.I. FOR EVERY USER AT THE CITY 09:18:47 WITHIN A YEAR OR TWO. 09:18:48 AND THAT'S GOING TO BE TRANSFORMATIVE TO SAY THE LEAST. 09:18:53 >>Erik Arroyo: I AGREE. 09:18:54 WHEN DO YOU THINK WE'LL GET TO A POINT WHERE EVERY SINGLE 09:18:57 FEE WE CHARGE CAN BE PAID ONLINE? 09:19:00 >>Marlon Brown: COMMISSIONER, IF I MAY, THE ABILITY TO DO 09:19:01 THAT, WE'RE GETTING THERE. 09:19:03 WE'RE ALMOST THERE. 09:19:03 AS YOU KNOW, WE HAVE A NUMBER OF RESIDENTS WHO STILL LIKE TO 09:19:06 PRESS THE FLESH. 09:19:08 SO IN TERMS OF PAYING A PARKING TICKET, PAYING A DEVELOPMENT 09:19:12 SERVICES FEE, UTILITIES. 09:19:14 >>Erik Arroyo: THEY ARE NOT EITHER-OR.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:19:16 I UNDERSTAND. 09:19:16 BUT WHAT I'M SAYING IS WE INCENTIVIZE PEOPLE COMING IN AND 09:19:22 PAYING IN PERSON AS OPPOSED TO PAYING ONLINE. 09:19:25 WE GIVE A DISCOUNT PAYING IN PERSON IN 24 HOURS. 09:19:29 >>Marlon Brown: WE'LL DOUBLE CHECK THAT. 09:19:32 >>Erik Arroyo: I WOULD LIKE TO DOUBLE CHECK THAT. 09:19:33 I'VE GOTTEN PLENTY OF TICKETS. 09:19:35 [ LAUGHTER ] 09:19:35 I AM FAMILIAR WITH THIS PROCESS. 09:19:39 >>Marlon Brown: I'LL DOUBLE CHECK ON THAT. 09:19:41 IF YOU PAY WITHIN 24 HOURS, BUT I'LL CHECK TO SEE WHETHER 09:19:45 IT'S ONLINE OR IN PERSON. 09:19:47 WE SHOULDN'T INCENTIVIZE PEOPLE TO COME IN. 09:19:49 MAYBE IT'S A GOOD THING. 09:19:51 WE WANT TO SEE PEOPLE -- 09:19:54 >>Erik Arroyo: I HAVEN'T BEEN TO PAY ONE SINCE WE MOVED. 09:19:58 WHO KNOWS. 09:19:59 I MIGHT GET A TICKET JUST FOR FUN TODAY AND SEE. 09:20:03 >>Marlon Brown: WE'RE WORKING TOWARDS BECOMING MORE 09:20:05 AUTOMATED IN TERMS OF FEE PAYMENTS, ET CETERA. 09:20:09 >>Erik Arroyo: THANK YOU TO THE I.T. DEPARTMENT. 09:20:11 I KNOW YOU WORK VERY, VERY HARD. 09:20:13 YOU WON TEAM OF THE MONTH AND WON ALL SORTS OF ACCOLADES 09:20:17 FROM THE STATE AND THROUGHOUT OTHER MUNICIPALITIES AND 09:20:21 COUNTIES. 09:20:21 NOW, A COUPLE MORE QUESTIONS. 09:20:24 WHEN IT COMES TO OUR SMART CITY INITIATIVES, IS THAT 09:20:32 SOMETHING THAT YOU SEE MOVING FORWARD SLOWLY, QUICKLY? 09:20:35 IT'S LIKE A 30-YEAR PLAN, 40 YEAR? 09:20:40 >>Herminio Rodriguez: IT'S BEING LED BY PUBLIC WORKS. 09:20:43 WE'RE PARTNERING UP WITH PUBLIC WORKS AND WORK REALLY WELL 09:20:46 WITH PUBLIC WORKS. 09:20:47 IN ORDER FOR US TO HAVE THE INFRASTRUCTURE TO BE ABLE TO 09:20:51 STAND UP SMART CITY, WE HAVE TO LAY FIBER THROUGHOUT THE 09:20:54 CITY. 09:20:55 AND THAT'S VERY, VERY EXPENSIVE TO DO. 09:20:57 WE'RE PARTNERING UP. 09:20:59 ONCE WE HAVE FIBER THROUGHOUT THE CITY, THE PLAN WOULD BE TO 09:21:02 PUT AN ACCESS POINT, LIKE YOU WOULD HAVE AT YOUR POINT AND 09:21:05 EACH OF OUR INTERSECTIONS, REALLY COVER THE WHOLE CITY WITH 09:21:08 WIRELESS. 09:21:09 ONCE YOU DO THAT, THEN SOMETHING CALLED IOT, INTERNET OF 09:21:14 THINGS. 09:21:14 THESE WOULD BE BEACONS. 09:21:16 THEN WE CAN BASICALLY ADD CONNECTIVITY TO EVERYTHING IN THE 09:21:19 CITY. 09:21:20 WE CAN TRACK EVERYTHING. 09:21:21 AND THEN THAT WILL BRING US TO A SMART CITY WHICH IS 09:21:25 REAL-TIME ANALYTICS AND DATA COMING IN SO WE CAN MAKE 09:21:29 DATA-DRIVEN DECISIONS IN REAL-TIME. 09:21:32 THE INITIAL PATH TO GET THERE IS BASICALLY COVERING THE 09:21:35 ENTIRE CITY WITH FIBEROPTIC CABLE.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-23-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/24/2024 11:59:47 AM] 09:21:37 OTHERWISE, THE TELECOMMUNICATION COST NEGATES THAT. 09:21:41 WE'RE WORKING WITH PUBLIC WORKS TO DO THAT. 09:21:43 I THINK WE'RE CLOSE TO HAVING FIBER AT EACH OF OUR 09:21:46 INTERSECTIONS. THAT WOULD BE THE FIRST PHASE. 09:21:48 >>Erik Arroyo: WIFI IN THE PARKS AS WELL. 09:21:51 >>Herminio Rodriguez: YES, WE WILL LEVERAGE THAT 09:21:53 INFRASTRUCTURE AS WELL. 09:21:54 >>Erik Arroyo: THAT'S CONTINUING. 09:21:55 THAT'S ONGOING. 09:21:55 >>Herminio Rodriguez: WE DID A BETA AND -- 09:21:59 >>Marlon Brown: THE COMMISSION GAVE US FOUR PARKS TO KIND OF 09:22:01 WORK ON TO TEST TO SEE HOW IT'S GOING. 09:22:04 WE JUST FINISHED THE LAST ONE WHEN? 09:22:06 >>Herminio Rodriguez: IT'S BEEN A COUPLE OF MONTHS. 09:22:07 >>Marlon Brown: GIVE US SOME TIME TO SEE HOW THAT'S WORKING 09:22:10 AND WE'LL COME BACK TO THE COMMISSION TO SEE HOW WE CAN 09:22:12 EXPAND THIS. 09:22:13 >>Erik Arroyo: WE HAD BOBBY JONES PENDING UNTIL IT WAS 09:22:15 FINISHED. 09:22:16 I THINK NOW MAY BE A GOOD TIME TO EXPAND THAT WAY. 09:22:19 >>Marlon Brown: CAN YOU NAME THE PARKS WE HAVE WIFI? 09:22:23 >>Herminio Rodriguez: ARLINGTON, BAYFRONT, MLK AND THERE'S 09:22:27 ONE MORE -- 09:22:28 >>Mayor Alpert: FIVE POINTS, I THINK. 09:22:30 >>Herminio Rodriguez: NO. 09:22:31 PAYNE. 09:22:34 YES, PAYNE. 09:22:35 THANK YOU. 09:22:36 AND THE TENNIS COURTS OF PAYNE AS WELL. 09:22:42 >>Erik Arroyo: ASIDE FROM ONE OTHER DEPARTMENT, YOU ARE IN 09:22:45 CHARGE OF THE ENTIRE I.T. FOR THE ENTIRE CITY, IS THAT 09:22:47 CORRECT? 09:22:48 >>Herminio Rodriguez: YES. 09:22:49 >>Marlon Brown: NO, NO. 09:22:50 >>Erik Arroyo: ASIDE FROM ONE OTHER DEPARTMENT. 09:22:52 THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. 09:22:53 THAT'S MY QUESTION. 09:22:55 >> YES. 09:22:55 >>Erik Arroyo: YES, OKAY. 09:22:56 WHEN WE DO, AND THIS IS A WHEN, NOT AN IF, BECAUSE THIS IS 09:23:01 THE WAY THE WORLD IS GOING. 09:23:02 WHEN WE DO INCORPORATE THE INTERNET OF THINGS IN HERE, THERE 09:23:05 HAVE BEEN SOME AWARD-WINNING PROGRAMS. 09:23:07 I SEE THEM IN BARCELONA AND ALL OVER THE WORLD WHERE THEY 09:23:10 ACTUALLY ALLOW THE PUBLIC TO USE THE INTERNET OF THINGS AND 09:23:13 YOU KIND OF, YOU KNOW, THE CITY BECOMES A HUB, IS THAT 09:23:16 SOMETHING THAT CAN SAFELY BE DONE WITHOUT US COMPROMISING 09:23:19 OUR SECURITY? 09:23:21 I KNOW YOU'RE VERY, VERY, VERY, VERY, VERY CONSERVATIVE ON 09:23:24 THE -- 09:23:25 >>Herminio Rodriguez: SEGMENTATION, SEPARATING CITY TRAFFIC 09:23:29 FROM PUBLIC TRAFFIC, THERE ARE TOOLS TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT

file:///C/Users/JJohnso

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Meeting Name, City Commission Budget Workshop — Minutes
  • Meeting Name, City Commission Budget Workshop
  • Meeting Name, City Commission Budget Workshop — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9213abaf419c01a45b1592ae72cf8274. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record