Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Committee

ROLL CALL PUBLIC PARTICIPATION WORKSHOP Workshop Topics STAFF COMMENTS MEMBER COMMENTS PUBLIC PARTICIPATION ADJOURNMENT Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Committee Wednesday, October 21, 2026 at 3:00 PM City Commission Chambers 214 Sams Avenue, New Smyrna Beach, Florida 32168 Pursuant to Florida Statutes 286.0105, if an individual decides to appeal any decision made by the board, agency or commission of the City of New Smyrna Beach with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, a record of the proceedings will be required and the individual will need to ensure that a verbatim transcript of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. Such person must provide a method The City of New Smyrna Beach October 21, 2026 1

for recording the proceedings. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact the City Clerk’s office in person or by mail at 210 Sams Avenue, New Smyrna Beach, Florida 32168, (386) 410-2630, prior to the meeting. The City of New Smyrna Beach October 21, 2026 2

THE CITY OF NEW SMYRNA BEACH - CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE WORKSHOP TOPICS October 21, 2026 Background: 1. Overview of Turnbull Bond Referendum by either the Natural Lands Manager or City Attorney. 2. Overview of the land acquired by the Natural Resource Manager. 3. Discussion of types of uses allowed by Conservation Zoning and Future Land Use by Development Services Director. 4. Public Involvement led by Development Services Director and/or Natural Resource Manager Fiscal Analysis: TBD Strategic Plan Item: Yes Staff Report Created By: Ralph Miller - Natural Resource Manager Attachments: Resolution 29-18 Bond Referendum.pdf 2018-11-06 Sample-Ballot w Turnbull Referendum.pdf Acquired Properties.pdf FCT#18-021-ff19 Turnbull Creek Watershed Preservation Project.pdf 259 F.S. - Land Acquisitions for Conservation or Recreaton.pdf 253 F.S. - State Lands.pdf City Conservation Zoning.pdf 3

1 2 RESOLUTION NO. 29-18 3 ·A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE 4 CITY OF NEW SMYRNA BEACH, VOLUSIA COUNTY, s FLORIDA, SUBMITTING TO REFERENDUM A QUESTION 6 TO THE REGISTERED ELECTORS OF THE CITY OF NEW 7 SMYRNA BEACH FOR THE ISSUANCE OF GENERAL 8 OBLIGATION BONDS FOR THE PURPOSE . OF 9 FINANCING THE ACQfilSITION OF LANDS ALONG THE 10 TURNBULL CREEK WATERSHED IN THE PRINCIPAL 11 AMOUNT OF NOT EXCEEDING FIFTEEN MILLION 12 DOLLARS ($15,000,000), TO BE HELD ON NOVEMBER 6, 13 2018; PROVIDING FOR A NOTICE OF AN 14 ADVERTISEMENT OF THE BOND REFERENDUM 15 ELECTION TO BE PUBLISHED IN ACCORDANCE WITH 16 FLORIDA STATUTES; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTING 1 7 RESOLUTIONS; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. 18 19 WHEREAS, the· Constit;ution, the City Charter and applicable 20 laws of the State of Florida authorize and empower the City of New 21 Smyrna Beach to adopt this Resolution; and 23 WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of New Smyrna Beach 24 has determined that development of land along the Turnbull Creek 25 watershed has the potential to pollute the waters of the Turnbull 26 Creek, Turnbull Bay, Spruce Creek, Indian River, and Atlantic 27 . Ocean, and eliminates wildlife habitat and natural areas, and that 28 it is in the best interest of the residents of the City to prot~ct 2 9 these lands; and 30 31 WHEREAS, the City Commission, based on the foregoing 32 findings and studies performed by the City's staff and consultants 33 and based on requests for such action by the citizenry, b~lieves 34 that it is necessary to finance all or a portion of the cost of 35 iand acquisition along the Turnbull Creek watershed, together with 36 costs incidental t1t,ereto; and 37 38 WHEREAS, the City Commission finds it to be in the best 39. interest of the City to issue its General Obligation Bonds, in one 40 or more series, in the aggregate principal amount of not exceeding 41 t'ifteen million dollars ($15,000,000) for the acquisition of .land 42 along the Turnbull Creek watershed; and 43 Page 1 of 5 RBS 29-18 BORD REFERENDUM - $15,000,000 August 14, 2018 4

44 WHEREAS, it is necessary an¢!. essential to call and to hold 45 a bond referendum submitting the issuance of such Bonds for, the 46 approval or disapproval of the residents. who are qualified electors 47 within the City; and 48 49 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE 50 CITY OF NEW SMYRNA BEACH, FWRIDA: 51 52 53 54 55 56 SECTION 1: Findings. The hereby ratified and_ confirmed hereby ma?e .a specif;ic part hereof. foregoing "Whereas" clauses are as being true and correct and are of this Resolution upon adoption 57 SECTION l: Bond Referendum. That a bond referendum is hereby 58 ordered to be held in the City on the 6 th day of November, 2018 to 59 determine whether or ~ot there shall be issued the Bonds of the 60 City in the aggregate principal amount of not exceeding fiiteen 61 million dollars ($15,000,000) for the acquisition of land along 62 the Turnbull Cr.eek watershed maturing within 30 years from the 63 date or respective dates of issuance of said Bonds and bearing 64 interest at a rate or rates not exceeding the legal maximum rate 65 of interest. The Bonds will be issued for the purpose of financing 66 the costs of land acquisition for areas along the Turnbull Creek 67 watershed and to pay the costs of issuing the Bonds, together ~ith 68 all other costs incidental thereto, for which the full faith and 69 credit and taxing power of the City shall be pledged. The payment 70 of the principal of and interest on the Bonds shall be payable at 71 - such t·imes and in such manner as shall be determined by subsequent 72 proceedings of the City Commission. The Bonds shall be ,payable 73 from ad valorem taxes levied and collected in the City (without 74 limitation as to rate or amount) on all taxable property in the 75 City sufficient to pay principal of and interest on such Bonds as 76 the same become due and payable. The City may also apply other 77 legally available sources of revenues. 78 79 SECTION 3: Municipal Purpose. That the acquisition of land 80 along the Turnbull Creek watershed will be for a valid municipal 81 purpose and therefore, accordingly, subject to approval of the 82 issuance of the Bonds by the qualified electors of the City, the 83 financing of the costs of such land acquisition through the 84 issuance of bond_s is hereby authorized and approved. The Turnbull 85 Creek land acquisition will provide a special benefit to the City 86 by protecting the City's water quality and preserving wildlife 87 habitat and natural areas. Page 2 of 5 RES 29-18 BOND RBFBRBNDOM - $15,000,000 August 14, 2018 5

88 89 90 91 92- SECTION 4: Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Project. the Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Project is more described in Exhibit A hereto. That fully 93 SECTION 5: One or More Series. That the Bonds may be issued 94 all at one time or in part in one or more series from time to time 95 as the.City Commission may in its discretion hereafter determine 96 by subsequent proceedings . 97 98 SECTION 6: Voter Approval. That the Bonds shall not be 99 issued for the Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Project ·unless 100 such Bonds authorized for the project are approved at the bond 101 referendum. by a majority of the qualified electors of the City 102 voting in such election all in the manner provided in the 103 Constitution and the statutes of the State of Florida. 104 105 SECTION 7: Polling Locations. That ·polling locations or 106 places shall be determined by the Supervisor of Elections for 107 V_olusia County, Florida, and all qualified electors of the City ioe who vote in said election.shall vote at said designated polling 109 places. The polls shall be opened on the date of said bond 110 referendum from seven o'clock a.m. until seven o'clock p.m. on the 111 same day, and, in the case of early voting, at such times, on such 112 days prior to the date of said bond referendum and at such polling 113 locations or places as determined by the_ Supervisor of Elections 114 for Volusia County, ,Florida. Only the duly qualified electors of 115 the City will be permitted to vote in said bond referendum. 116 117 SECTIONS: Publication of Notice. That the City Attorney 118 shall prepare and give notice of the bond referendum by causing 119 appropriate Notice, to be published in accordance with the 120 provisions of Section 100.342 of the Florida Statutes, at least 121 twice, once in the fifth week and once in the third week prior to· 122 the week in which the referendum is held, provided the first 123 publication shall take place at least thirty (30) days before the • 124 date fixed for election in The Daytona Beach News-Journal, a 125 newspaper of general circulation within the City. The -City 126 Attorney shall secure from the publisher of said newspaper an 127 appropriate affidavit of proof that •said Notice. has been duly 128 published, as herein set forth, and said affidavit shall be made 129 a part of the record of the City Commission. 130 131 Page 3 of 5 RES 29-18 BOND REFERENDUM - $15,000,000 August 14, 2018 6

132 SECTION 9: Voting Device. That the . vote at· said bond 133 referendum shall. be by such voting device/equipment {the 134 "Device"), as approved by the Florida Department of State pursuant 135 to the Florida Election Code, comprising Chapter 101 of Florida 136 Statutes, and in each polling place there shall be at least one 137 such Device. It shall be the responsibility of the Supervisor of 138. Elections for Volusia County, Florida, to have prepared and 139 furnished to the inspectors said Devices in such numbers as shall 140 be required to carry out the intent of this Resolution, and to 141 have prepared and approved by the proper authorities for use in 142 said Devices such ballots {or mechanical ballot record) as shall 143 be •necessary to conduct the e1ection of the qualified electors of 144 the City relative to the question of whether the issuance of Bonds 145 in the aggregate principal amount of not exceeding fifteen million 146 dollars {$15, ooo, 000) shall be approved to finance the cost of the 14 7 Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Proj e·ct and to pay the costs. of 148 1ssuance of the Bonds, together with all other costs incidental 149· thereto. B.allots in the same general form as hereinafter described 150 shall be available to absentee voting. 151 152 SECTION 10: Form of. Ballot. That the ballots to be issued 153· in said· bond referendum shall be substantially in the foll~wing 154 form: 155 156 157 BALLOT 158 TURNBULL CREEK WATER QUALITY, WILDLIFE HABITAT, AND 159 NATURAL AREAS PROTECTION BONDS 160 161 . To protect water quality by preventing pollution in Turnbull Creek and Bay, Spruce Creek, the 16 2 Indian River, and the Atlantic Ocean and preserve wildlife habitat and na~al areas from 163 development by acquiring land along Turnbull Creek, shall the City of New Smyrna Beach issue 164 general obligation bonds at rates not exceeding the maximum legal rate, maturing within 30 years, 16 5 not exceeding $15 million payable from ad valorem taxes with full public disclosure of all 16 6 spending? 167 168 169 170 171 YES, FOR BONDS NO, AGAINST BONDS 1 72 SECTION 11: Canvassing of Returns. The return of the votes 173 cast at said election shall be made to and canvassed by the County 174 Canvassing Board, which shall certify the results to the City Page 4 of 5 RES 29-18 BOND REFERENDUM - $15,000,000 Augutt 14, 2018 7

175 Commission, and the City Commission shall declare the result and 176 have the same recorded in the minutes of the City Commission. If 177 a majority of the votes cast at such election in respect to the 178 issuance of such Bonds shall be "For Bond," such issuance shall be 179 approved, and then the Bonds, the issuance of which shall be 180 • thereby approved, may be issued as hereafter provided by the City 181 Commission and the Charter. 182 183 • 184 ·185 186 187 SECTION 12: Election in Accordance with Florida Law. That said .bond referendum shall in all other respects be held and conducted in the manner provided in and by the-laws of the State of Florida. 188 SECTION 13: .Saving Clause. Should any section or provision of 189 this Resolution or portion hereof, any paragraph, sentence, or 190 · word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be • 191 invalid, such decision shall not affect the remainder of this 192 Resolution·. 193 194 SECTION 14: Conflicts. That all other resolutions or parts 195 thereof that are in conflict with this resolution are hereby 196 rescinded and repealed. 197 198 SECTION 15: Effective Date. That ·this resolution shall take 199 effect immediately upon its adoption . .200 201 202 203 2 04 APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: 205 206 207 208 209 210 CITY ATTORNEY 2.11 l I212 DATE: ~1-7..............l......f _______ 213 Page 5 of 5 RBS 29-18 BOND REFERENDUM - $15,000,000; August 14, 2018 8

' . • EXHIBIT A Turnbull Creek Land Preservation Proiect Turnbull Creek is a part of the Turnbull Canal System that was placed on the National Register of Historic Places on August 24, 2007 and is an estuarine waterway located in the west side of the City of New Smyrna Beach. The flow in Turnbull Creek is to the north into Turnbull Bay. Turnbuli Creek terminates at its intersection with Spruce Creek. Spruce Creek flows east to the Halifax River approximately two miles north of Ponce Inlet. Due to Turnbull Creek's proximity to the Halifax River and Ponce Inlet, it is tidally influenced. State Road 44 ess~tially bisects the Turnbull Creek watershed and helps to delineate the transition of Turnbull Creek from an estuarine waterway. At this point in time, there are large swaths ofland that are undeveloped in this environmentally sensitive area, as can be seen in the picture below. The City has a unique opportunity to acquire this land in order to protect this watershed area. Preserving this land would help diminish the potential for polluting the waters of the Turnbull Creek, Turnbull Bay, Spruce C~k, Indian River, and Atlantic Ocean, and the destruction of wildlife and habitat areas from development. The goal of the project is to conserve as much land in this area as is feasible. 9

TARGET PARCELS NEAR TURNBULL CREEK • SOUTHERN SECTI ON 10

The Within and Foregoing Resolution No. 29-18 as introduced and read before the City Commission of the City of New Smyrna Beach, Florida, at its Regular Meeting held at City Hall in said City on August 14, 2018. Motion was made by Commissioner Reiker, and seconded by Vice Mayor McGuirk, that said Resolution be adopted. A roll-call vote of the City Commission on said motion to adopt the Resolution resulted as follows: COMMISSIONER JACOB D. SACHS MAYOR JAMES W. HATHAWAY VICE MAYOR JASON MCGUIRK COMMISSIONER RANDY HARTMAN COMMISSIONER JUDY REIKER Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Whereupon, the Mayor of the City of New Smyrna Beach, Florida, hereunto set his official signature, duly attested by the City Clerk, and has ca ed the Official Seal of said City to be hereunto affixed for the purpose of authen • 1ty and as is required by law. - . (OFFICIAL SEAL) As City Cl City of Ne each, Florida yor of the City of New Smyrna Beach, Florida RESOLUTION NO. 29-18 11

Phone: (386) 736-5930 Fax: (386) 822-5715 Email: elections@volusia.org (Correo Electrónico) Web site: www.volusiaelections.org (Sitio Web) Lisa Lewis, supervisor of eLections 125 W. New York Avenue, DeLand, FL 32720-5415 Check your Voter Registration & Vote-by-Mail Ballot Status: Voters may verify the status of their Voter Registration or Vote-by-Mail Ballot by accessing the Department of Elections Web site: www.volusiaelections.org. Verifique el Estado de su Registro de Votante & su Papeleta de Voto-por-Correo: Los electores pueden verificar el estado de su Registro de Votante o Papeleta de Voto Ausente a través del Internet del Departamento de Elecciones: www.volusiaelections.org. United States Senator Senador de los Estados Unidos (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Rick Scott REP Bill Nelson DEM _____________________________ Write-In / Por Escrito Representative in Congress District 6 Representante en el Congreso Distrito 6 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Michael Waltz REP Nancy Soderberg DEM Ron DeSantis REP Jeanette Nuñez Andrew Gillum DEM Chris King Darcy G. Richardson REF Nancy Argenziano Ryan Christopher Foley NPA John Tutton Jr. Kyle “KC” Gibson NPA Ellen Wilds Bruce Stanley NPA Ryan Howard McJury _____________________________ Write-In / Por Escrito Governor and Lieutenant Governor Gobernador y Gobernador Teniente (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Attorney General Fiscal General (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Ashley Moody REP Sean Shaw DEM Jeffrey Marc Siskind NPA Chief Financial Officer Jefe Oficial Financiero (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Jimmy Patronis REP Jeremy Ring DEM _____________________________ Write-In / Por Escrito Commissioner of Agriculture Comisionado de Agricultura (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Matt Caldwell REP Nicole “Nikki” Fried DEM Only eligible voters residing in State Representative District 24 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito del Representante Estatal 24 pueden votar en esta carrera. State Representative District 24 Representante Estatal Distrito 24 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Paul Renner REP Adam Morley DEM Only eligible voters residing in State Representative District 25 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito del Representante Estatal 25 pueden votar en esta carrera. State Representative District 25 Representante Estatal Distrito 25 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Tom Leek REP Kathleen “Katie” Tripp DEM Joseph “Joe” Hannoush LPF Only eligible voters residing in State Representative District 26 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito del Representante Estatal 26 pueden votar en esta carrera. State Representative District 26 Representante Estatal Distrito 26 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Elizabeth Fetterhoff REP Patrick Henry DEM Only eligible voters residing in State Representative District 27 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito del Representante Estatal 27 pueden votar en esta carrera. State Representative District 27 Representante Estatal Distrito 27 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) David Santiago REP Carol Lawrence DEM State Senator District 14 Senador Estatal Distrito 14 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Dorothy L. Hukill REP Melissa “Mel” Martin DEM Only eligible voters residing in State Senate District 14 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito del Senador Estatal 14 pueden votar en esta carrera. Circuit Judge 7th Judicial Circuit, Group 15 Juez del Circuito Circuito Judicial Séptimo, Grupo 15 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Linda L. Gaustad Ryan Will Nonpartisan No Partidista Justice of the Supreme Court Juez de la Tribunal Suprema Yes / Sí No / No Shall Justice Alan Lawson of the Supreme Court be retained in office? ¿Sera el Juez Alan Lawson de la Corte Suprema ser retenido en oficina? Fifth District Court of Appeal Tribunal de Apelación del Distrito Quinto Yes / Sí No / No Shall Justice Eric Eisnaugle of the Fifth District Court of Appeal be retained in office? ¿Sera el Juez Eric Eisnaugle de la Corte de Apelación del Quinto Distrito ser retenido en oficina? Volusia Soil and Water Conservation District Seat 1 El Distrito de Conservación de Tierra y Aguas de Volusia Escaño 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) William Bliss Derrick Orberg Volusia Soil and Water Conservation District Seat 3 El Distrito de Conservación de Tierra y Aguas de Volusia Escaño 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Beth James Wesley Wayne Wilson Jr. Christine Wilt Volusia Soil and Water Conservation District Seat 5 El Distrito de Conservación de Tierra y Aguas de Volusia Escaño 5 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) J. Mark Barfield Andy Kelly David Schaefer West Volusia Hospital Authority Group A, Seat 1 La Autoridad de Hospital de West Volusia Grupo A, Escaño 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) John M. Hill Voloria Manning West Volusia Hospital Authority Group B, Seat 1 La Autoridad de Hospital de West Volusia Grupo B, Escaño 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Webster Barnaby Dolores Guzman West Volusia Hospital Authority Group B, Seat 2 La Autoridad de Hospital de West Volusia Grupo B, Escaño 2 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Michael Ray Kathie D. Shepard County Council Member District 1 Miembro del Consejo del Condado Distrito 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Barbara Girtman Pat Patterson Only eligible voters residing in County Council District 1 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Consejo del Condado Distrito 1 pueden votar en esta carrera. County Council Member District 3 Miembro del Consejo del Condado Distrito 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Michael J. Arminio Deborah A. “Deb” Denys Only eligible voters residing in County Council District 3 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Consejo del Condado Distrito 3 pueden votar en esta carrera. School Board Member District 1 Miembro de la Junta Escolar Distrito 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Al Bouie Jamie Michele Haynes Only eligible voters residing in School Board District 1 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Junta Escolar Distrito 1 pueden votar en esta carrera. School Board Member District 5 Miembro de la Junta Escolar Distrito 5 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Ruben Colon Melody Johnson Only eligible voters residing in School Board District 5 may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Junta Escolar Distrito 5 pueden votar en esta carrera. General Election November 6, 2018 - Sample Ballot Elección General 6 de noviembre 2018 - Papeleta de Muestra The City of Daytona Beach La Ciudad de Daytona Beach City Commissioner Zone 1 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Danny Fuqua Ruth Trager Only eligible voters residing in Zone 1 in The City of Daytona Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 1 de La Ciudad de Daytona Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner Zone 3 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Quanita May Amy Pyle Only eligible voters residing in Zone 3 in The City of Daytona Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 3 de La Ciudad de Daytona Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner Zone 5 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 5 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Katienna Brown-Gardner Dannette Henry Only eligible voters residing in Zone 5 in The City of Daytona Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 5 de La Ciudad de Daytona Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. City of Daytona Beach Shores Ciudad de Daytona Beach Shores Mayor Alcalde (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Lorraine Geiger Nancy Miller City Council Seat 4 Consejo de la Ciudad Escaño 4 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Michael Politis John Schmitz Municipal Referenda Referéndos Municipales Yes / Sí No / No Amendment to limit persons to two terms on City Council An amendment to amend the City Charter to limit persons to election or appointment to no more than two terms on City Council regardless of when the terms are served. This amendment defines a term as more than half of a full term. Enmienda para limitar a las personas a dos términos en el Concejo Municipal Una enmienda para enmendar la Carta de Ciudad para limitar a las personas por elección o nombramiento a no más de dos términos en el Concejo Municipal, independientemente de cuándo se cumplan los términos. Esta enmienda define un término como más de la mitad de un término completo. Referendum Number 1 Referéndum Número 1 Yes / Sí No / No Charter amendment limiting persons to two terms as Councilmember applies to current and former Councilmembers An amendment to amend the City Charter to apply the amendment limiting persons to serve only two terms (if it is adopted) to current and former Councilmembers and would include prior and current terms served in applying the limitation. Enmienda a la carta limitando a las personas a dos términos como Miembro del Concejo se aplica a miembros del Consejo actuales y anteriores Una enmienda para enmendar la Carta de Ciudad para aplicar la enmienda que limita a las personas a servir solo dos términos (si se adopta) a los miembros actuales y anteriores del Concejo y incluiría los términos anteriores y actuales en la aplicación de la limitación. Referendum Number 2 Referéndum Número 2 City of Ormond Beach Ciudad de Ormond Beach Mayor Alcalde (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Rob Bridger Bill Partington City Commissioner Zone 1 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Kathy Maloney Johnson Dwight Selby Only eligible voters residing in Zone 1 in the City of Ormond Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 1 de la Ciudad de Ormond Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner Zone 2 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 2 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Only eligible voters residing in Zone 2 in the City of Ormond Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 2 de la Ciudad de Ormond Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. Joe Dugan David W. Glasser Troy Kent City Commissioner Zone 3 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Sandy Kauffman Susan S. Persis Only eligible voters residing in Zone 3 in the City of Ormond Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 3 de la Ciudad de Ormond Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner Zone 4 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 4 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Only eligible voters residing in Zone 4 in the City of Ormond Beach may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en la Zona 4 de la Ciudad de Ormond Beach pueden votar en esta carrera. Barry W. du Moulin Rob Littleton David J. Romeo Town of Pierson Pueblo de Pierson Town Council Seat 1 Consejo del Pueblo Escaño 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Lambert James Anderson James T. Peterson City of New Smyrna Beach Ciudad de New Smyrna Beach Mayor Alcalde (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Lisa Martin Russ Owen City Commissioner Zone 1 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Peggy Belflower Michael Kolody City Commissioner Zone 2 Comisionado de la Ciudad Zona 2 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Travous Dever Jake Sachs Municipal Referendum Referéndum Municipal Yes, For Bonds / Sí, Para los Bonos No, Against Bonds / No, Contra de los Bonos Turnbull Creek Water Quality, Wildlife Habitat, and Natural Areas Protection Bonds To protect water quality by preventing pollution in Turnbull Creek and Bay, Spruce Creek, the Indian River, and the Atlantic Ocean and preserve wildlife habitat and natural areas from development by acquiring land along Turnbull Creek, shall the City of New Smyrna Beach issue general obligation bonds at rates not exceeding the maximum legal rate, maturing within 30 years, not exceeding $15 million payable from ad valorem taxes with full public disclosure of all spending? Turnbull Creek Calildad del Agua, Hábitat de Vida Silvestre, y Áreas Naturales Bonos de Protección ¿Para proteger la calidad del agua por la prevención de contaminación en Turnbull Creek y Bay, Spruce Creek, el Indian River, y el Océano Atlántico, y preservar el hábitat de la vida silvestre y las áreas naturales del desarrollo mediante la adquisición de tierras a lo largo de Turnbull Creek, deberá la Ciudad de New Smyrna Beach publicar bonos de obligación general a tasas que no excedan la tasa legal máxima, vencimiento dentro de 30 años, excediendo no más de $15 millones pagaderos de impuestos ad valorem con la revelación pública completa de todos los gastos? City of Oak Hill Ciudad de Oak Hill City Commission Seat 1 Comisionado de la Ciudad Escaño 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Mike Arman Linda C. Hyatt City of Edgewater Ciudad de Edgewater Mayor Alcalde (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Mike Ignasiak Mike Thomas City Council District 1 Consejo de la Ciudad Distrito 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Rocky Dorcy Christine Elaine Power City of DeLand Runoff Election Ciudad de DeLand Elección de Desempate City Commissioner Seat 5 Comisionado de la Ciudad Escaño 5 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Markesha James Kevin Reid City of Deltona Ciudad de Deltona Mayor Alcalde (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Santiago Avila Jr. Heidi K. Herzberg City Commission District 1 Comisionado de la Ciudad Distrito 1 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Loren King Willie Thomas Stephens Only eligible voters residing in District 1 in the City of Deltona may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito 1 de la Ciudad de Deltona pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner District 3 Comisionado de la Ciudad Distrito 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) H. Lester Carrero Maritza Vazquez Only eligible voters residing in District 3 in the City of Deltona may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito 3 de la Ciudad de Deltona pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner District 4 Comisionado de la Ciudad Distrito 4 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Robert “Bob” McFall Ruben Munoz Only eligible voters residing in District 4 in the City of Deltona may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito 4 de la Ciudad de Deltona pueden votar en esta carrera. City Commissioner District 5 Comisionado de la Ciudad Distrito 5 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Donald Freeman Victor M. Ramos Only eligible voters residing in District 5 in the City of Deltona may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Distrito 5 de la Ciudad de Deltona pueden votar en esta carrera. Yes / Sí No / No Referendum for Community Center Construction Bonds Shall the City of DeBary, Florida, fund construction of a community center facility for civic, social, educational, and recreational activities for City residents, and all capital and land acquisition costs associated therewith, by issuing general obligation bonds not to exceed $12,500,000 bearing interest not to exceed the maximum legal rate, maturing within 30 years, payable from a levy of ad valorem taxes on all taxable property in the City. Referéndum Para Bonos del Construcción para Centro Social ¿Deberá la Ciudad de DeBary, Florida, financiar la construcción de un centro social para actividades cívicas, sociales, educativas y recreativas para los residentes de la ciudad, y todos los costos de adquisición de capital y de la tierra asociados a los mismos, emitiendo bonos de obligación general que no excedan los $12,500,000 con intereses que no excedan la tasa legal máxima, vencimiento dentro de 30 años, pago de un aumento de impuestos ad valorem a todas las propiedades sujetas a impuestos en la ciudad? City of DeBary Municipal Referendum Ciudad de DeBary Referéndum Municipal City of DeBary Ciudad de DeBary City Council Seat 3 Consejo de la Ciudad Escaño 3 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Howard Gates Patricia Stevenson City Council Seat 4 Consejo de la Ciudad Escaño 4 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Phyllis Butlien Eugene G. Kowalski VOTE-BY-MAIL BALLOT • All registered and eligible voters in the county may choose to vote by mail. • Simply visit volusiaelections.org or call 386-736-5930 to request your vote-by- mail ballot. PAPELETA DE VOTO-POR-CORREO • Todos los votantes registrados y elegibles en el condado pueden optar para votar por correo. • Simplemente visite volusiaelections.org o llame al 386-736-5930 para solicitar su papeleta de voto-por-correo. ELECTION DAY • Tuesday, November 6, 2018 • 7:00 am - 7:00 pm • Voters must vote at their assigned precinct of record. • Voted Vote-by-mail ballots cannot be turned in at precincts. DÍA DE ELECCIÓN • martes, 6 de noviembre 2018 • 7:00 am - 7:00 pm • Los electores deben votar en su precinto asignado en el archivo. • Las papeletas de voto-por-correo votadas no pueden ser entregadas a los precintos. EARLY VOTING • October 27 - November 4 • 7 am - 7 pm • Voters may cast a ballot prior to Election Day at any designated Early Voting Site. • Voted vote-by-mail ballots may be accepted at any designated Early Voting Site prior to Election Day. • The five Early Voting Sites are listed below: VOTACIÓN TEMPRANA • 27 de octubre - 6 de noviembre • 7 am - 7 pm • Los electores pueden votar una papeleta antes del Día de Elección en cualquier sitio de Votación Temprana. • Las papeletas votadas de voto-por-correo pueden ser aceptadas en cualquier Sitio de Votación Temprana designada antes del Día de Elección. • Los cinco lugares de Votación Temprana se enumeran a continuación: Deland Area: County Administration Bldg. 123 W. Indiana Avenue Deltona Area: Deltona Regional Library 2150 Eustace Avenue Daytona Beach Area: City Island Library 105 E. Magnolia Avenue Ormond Beach Area: Ormond Beach Regional Library 30 S. Beach Street New Smyrna Beach Area: New Smyrna Beach Regional Library 1001 S. Dixie Freeway City of Orange City Ciudad de Orange City Council Member at Large Miembro del Consejo la Silla General (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) O. William “Bill” Crippen Gaea Nunez City Council Member Seat 4 Miembro del Consejo de la Ciudad Escaño 4 (Vote for One / Vote por Uno) Kellianne Marks Anthony Pupello Only eligible voters residing in Seat 4 in the City of Orange City may vote in this race. Solamente los votantes elegibles que residen en el Escaño 4 de la Ciudad de Orange City pueden votar en esta carrera. Districts Distritos Polling Location Sitio de Votación VOTER INFORMATION CARD • The Voter Information Card, although no longer used as a form of identification to vote, is a useful tool as it contains your voting precinct, polling location and district representatives. TARJETA DE INFORMACIÓN ELECTORAL • La Tarjeta de Información Electoral, aunque ya no se utiliza como una forma de identificación para votar, es un instrumento útil tal como contiene su precinto de votación, sitio de votación y los representantes de los distritos. All Early Voting Sites and Precincts are accessible for persons with disabilities. Todos los Sitios de Votación Temprana y los Precinctos son accesibles para personas impedidas. Prior to voting, the voter shall be required to present a current and valid picture and signature identification. For a listing of acceptable photo and signature identifications, visit volusiaelections.org or call (386) 736-5930. Antes de votar, el votante deberá presentar una identificación actual y válida con fotografía y firma. Para obtener una lista de las identificaciones aceptables de foto y firma, visite volusiaelections.org o llame al (386) 736-5930. Page 1 of 2 Pagina 1 de 2 For Amendments, refer to Page 2. Para las Enmiendas, refiérase a la Página 2. RACE NOT COUNTED ESTA CARRERA NO CUENTA NEED A RIDE TO THE POLLS? Ride for Free with your Voter Information Card! Votran is offering free transportation to registered voters travelling to the polls on Election Day. ¿NECESITAS UN PASEO A LAS ENCUESTAS? ¡Monte por Gratis con su Tarjeta de Información Electoral! Votran está ofreciendo transporte gratis a los votantes registrados que viajan a las urnas el Día de Elección. 12

#115 #116 #109 #102 #95/96#93/94/108 #80/91 #69/77 #68 #59-#67 #37State of Florida, Vantor State Road 44State Road 44 Pioneer TrailPioneer Trail Pioneer TrailPioneer Trail Otter Lake Otter Lake Turnbull CreekTurnbull Creek Turnbull CreekTurnbull Creek Paige AvenuePaige Avenue Paige AvenuePaige Avenue RoadRoad JungleJungle Jungle RoadJungle Road Wildwood DriveWildwood Drive Otter BoulevardOtter Boulevard Multi-Use TrailMulti-Use Trail Multi-Use TrailMulti-Use Trail Bay DriveBay Drive Old Mission RdOld Mission Rd: 0 750 1,500375 Feet Legend Acquired Property Waterbody ACQUIRED PROPERTIES As of 10/21/2026 S. Walker DriveS. Walker Drive13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

all to order our meeting with the turnbull creek preservation board. >> it's time for us to start our meeting. >> if you could please call the roll chair author and present vice chair weston PRESIDENT Member hartmann and welcome new members sullivan. >> PRESIDENT Thank you. >> let the record show that member werner is absent. >> that's the first item on our agenda is our public participation. I recognize those who have to bring something to our meeting. Anyone would like to speak. We ask that you simply give us your address and name. When you come up to the podium and you have three minutes. Would anybody like to address our board and discuss some ideas or things that you'd like to bring up to our attention? >> no one wants to talk to us. >> yeah. Hello. >> welcome, nick schultz. 1016 dylan circle. So dylan circle is a loop off of bay drive. So I just wanted to address without having all of the facts of the kayak launch just kind of wanted to express my personal concerns and the concerns of that I've discussed with my neighbors around us. First and foremost is the condition of the road both bay drive and dylan circle which would be somehow affected by increased traffic on bay drive. They're just going to be inhabitable to drive around dylan circle. So as it stands now me and evan is here and a couple of our other neighbors personally maintain the road at least from williams on the north side of bay from williams to the corner where bay turns around and dylan circle loops off of that. >> and then dylan circle itself I mean to the tune of probably $6,000 a year between the maybe three of us that contribute money and then four of us they contribute track to work. >> it's takes a lot to do especially in the rainy season right now. I mean it's it's in bad condition on the part that we're able to maintain. >> I don't think that from the corner of where bay and dylan meet on the east side down from there all the way down bay drive to where it meets pioneer trail. I don't think they have the means or the ability to maintain that road and so driving that road especially this time of year I mean it's there's probably three foot deep divisions and transitions in there. The other concern would be we have a increasing homeless population around there. We have. So I work I own to construction company so I leave early sometimes and come home late sometimes from work. And we've had a increasing amount of transit bicycle traffic up and down williams that we never had before. There's a on the corner of william owens and pioneer trail. There's a property there now that has a rv that seems like a permanent fixture now. And there's a lot of transient bicycle traffic in and out of that. I mean when I leave for work when I have a concrete pour at four in the morning is probably the busiest time for that bicycle traffic so you can gather from that if you will. >> and my concern would be if we put this park there that public access that would attract that same population in there. I know like in the river there's some homeless camps that kind of arise on the islands. They can be a little bit more secluded. My concern would be they would use that kayak launch to use as a home base to go from there out to the island and maybe make camp out there where they were. They would be on a uninterrupted more or it would be more difficult to get to them. So I think those are my major concerns and the foremost concern being the condition of the road. If we could answer the other questions and maybe figure out a way for the city or county to participate in that road maintenance, I don't think that I would have a huge problem with the kayak issue there but super. >> thank you. My concerns. >> all right. Thank you very much. Anyone else like to address the board? please state your name and your address please so that we have that for our records. >> when you get up to the microphone so that we have you on there. >> I am done. Paulette brewer 850 bay drive. Okay. >> I'm trying to keep up with what's already been one of my concerns is I bought property on that side of the road three houses south of where you are the flooding that happens and it doesn't have to be hurricane flooding. >> it can be we just just this last the northeaster that clogged up everything when they talk about the storm surge. >> everybody thinks the beach but this community experience a storm surge. >> we are like our own little environment when everybody else is in the 38 degrees in the morning and we're in the 28 degrees in the morning just we're just a pocket in that in includes the property you're on. >> but what I wanted to talk about was that every property owner on the creek side actually owns all the way to the middle of the main channel . >> the best map I've found of that is through the property appraiser's office on the on the online and it shows everybody's how far out and they actually have the island that they island or islands that they own have a property number that affixes to the main part of their property. >> so by doing this you're exposing them to I was me at one point them to people having access to their backyard. You know we all worry about our front yard but for them it's going to expose them in their backyard. Years ago I came home from work one day and two little girls on a canoe were out there trying to write my horse. I mean that's just things that happened. >> we had boat motors stolen out of the backyard. We've had things happen. So where your property is they have to cross a couple other properties to get out to a place. Has anybody been out there? >> mm hmm. Oh, so yeah, you have. >> have you been out there in the last month? Yeah. Oh my GOD. >> you've mentioned the road that that's a deterrent for people actually to be out there. >> but I really wanted to talk about how you're going to expose the people and it's not just down there but when you get up into the dillon circle area there on the main channel. >> so if the people make it to the main channel with their vessel there are right there at their back doors. >> I know it's public. I mean rick perry and rights and all that stuff and people have the right to use that stuff. >> but I don't know what what the solution is. And the other thing is that at low tide I wouldn't get in that water at all. >> so that's all I have to say. Thanks for anyone else would like to speak to us. This is if you'll state your name and your address for us. >> my name is everett brewer and I'm at 850 bay drive for over 30 years. This is two houses down from me. You just heard my wife. What are the concern about is on bay drive? >> we own to the center of the road and there's no government grading or anything like that. So by allowing these people to come in on private property, shouldn't we get some kind of relief for maintaining the road that they're tearing up and that's pretty much because we do on to the middle of the road. So they're driving on private property to get to the city for . >> thank you. Thank you. I thank you for coming. >> yeah, thanks for having us. Evan doyle live at 1001 039 dillon circle. I've lived out there for about 15 years. My wife has lived there for about 40 years on dillon circle so we've been there for a while. >> I echo everybody's concerns quality of the road potential increased criminal activity. And the one thing I can speak to is since I've been on dillon circle I've really tried to engage the city and the county to try to get some sort of assistance out there because we are very much on our own in terms of maintaining the property which I understand it's a private road but I think a lot of us have experienced very quick denial with any help and any assistance from the city or the county. And so I think we would certainly like to see some sort of assistance with the road. Most of us seem like we're not fully opposed to the idea of recreation although when this was originally voted on it wasn't billed as a recreational opportunity was billed as a conservation opportunity. So I'm not going to call it a bait and switch but certainly we're here for a different reason than what was initially intended. But as homeowners in this area and myself and nick again being a few of the people that help maintain the road, it's quickly getting to the point where we are financially not able to continue to maintain the road and certainly down the bay drive and it's it's getting worse and worse to the point where if I was on bay I'd be concerned about emergency services responses and things like that. So I think there's some work that can be done. I think there's a partnership opportunity here but we would certainly like to see the city step up and make it to where we as a community are benefiting as a result. >> terrific. Thank you. Is your property county or city? >> so I have both. I have a property that's in the county and I have a property that's in the city there. They're contiguous. Mm hmm. But we have one parcel that's agricultural where we keep our cows and then we the our home is is in the city and we've been in the city since 2015. >> and I actually did pass out something that has information on how to annex into the city because it's been a benefit to us. Our taxes have gone down. We've seen better services with the city in terms of law enforcement and then also just pulling permits and stuff like that. >> a lot easier to deal with the city than the county. Thank you. Great. Thank you. >> all right. Hi. Welcome. Hi. My name charlie collins 1059 dillon circle. >> I spoke to this gentleman here a couple of days ago and he was telling me that you will have more like 3 million left to buy properties. He also told me I'm not looking to buy our properties. Is that is that true? So you're not going to buy our properties? >> not unless you want to sell them. Okay. I'll sell it to you for the right price. I don't have a problem with that. but we have order and you have a park over there and I spoke to him about that. Why aren't you using that? Why don't you make that the long term? Why would you bring them in right in our neighborhood? >> I mean I don't understand that. Would you allow that? I don't think I would. You know I live on the corner down there at the point. Now here's another problem you're going to have to address and I hope maybe you address it or you all look at it. But the boats hall asked on that place I live on the corner. I now have a sandbar over here right out my sliding glass doors in the house because they come around here so fast they don't see the other people coming around that point and there's going to be a bad accident and one of these kayakers is going to eat it. >> so it's something needs to be looked at. I'm all about the roads. I quit doing the roads while ago because it's just too expensive and then everybody wants to ditch how you do the road so I don't do it. But kayakers, you need to look at law enforcement needs to come in there. >> I've never seen no law enforcement in there on the canals so I mean never unless there's an emergency or something like that a plane goes down or something like that. >> but those were my questions. I just need to know for sure because you know, you're one thing and then something else is done. >> so down the road they change their mind well, we want to do this well, we want to do that. >> you know, it's just like in an annex in and I because now I don't see the point but why not use the other park? >> I've why would you come into that neighborhood when you got it on order you got paved roads, daughter. And I'm definitely big on on the roads being fixed so those are my concerns. >> noted. Thank you. >> anyone else? Hello for having us. >> my name is john laureano live at 641 bay drive. >> I'd like to show you my phone. There's no gas around this. That's a coquina rock. That's about 700 pounds that last week somebody coming around the corner hit to knock that off its foundation. People are speeding going way too fast. We have forces down our street. >> you guys are right down our street. >> somebody is going to get killed. >> hopefully it's not one of your guys is kids. That's all I got to say. >> thank you for very often for that back. >> anyone else, any other any speakers and to . >> good afternoon. I'm tom copper and I live at 1069 golden circle. I actually lived at 1016 before i moved around the circle. >> you've got a few things that you got to keep in mind because if you are going to do that and you're going to have to help maintain the roads and everything else since I've lived out there we used to have hurricanes. You know what happens? You know I'm 40 some years. I have 44 years we've been out there and hurricanes used to be out here and they'd come through and maybe we'd get two feet of water. That's it. Now with all the developments that's been going on west of us, it all in coming into the creek itself and also from the sugar mill and down in the side where the bridges coming off the williams I can tell you what when I built this house I built it above the standards are supposed to be brought in 101 hundred truckloads or the large truckloads of shell and dirt and and everything to build the house and get it up way above the standards. Well, when I first built that house 20 some years ago, I lived on it before it a double wide. It would only come up maybe 2 or 3ft up in the creek on that side. And now like when he and ian came through in the last storm after that came through it was almost five feet high. Now another thing you got to take in consideration I'm on really the higher side but I'm on where the drain goes down past it and empties into the creek. Now if you're going to maintain these roads and everything else and you've got to be careful if you're going to build on them too because there is don't drive all the way it gets flooded over sometimes 4 or 5ft in different places. So that's something you keep in consideration also because you know, it's not like a regular area because you know it flooded clear all the way up into wayne avenue up by the golf course and such. >> it never used to do that. You know, it just we've just built so much and that used to be land and would absorb the water and everything else and now it's got no place to want to run that away and most of it from 44 and west of us it all runs towards the creek and it's just something taking consideration and I am also concerned about the safety for and different people coming into the area. >> if you do make that a kayak place and you just built a really nice one of us one just the other day that's that's a beautiful place and it's great fishing up in that area too. But you know just keep in mind that everything that you are going for that there's going to be a lot for you to bite off and and it's really a very unsafe for different issues. And thank you. Thank you. >> thank you. I did see someone else wanting to come up. Yes. >> good afternoon. >> thomas overstreet 19 64 jungle road. I have the 17 acres here that's just south of the larger parcel that you guys purchased back in about 2019 2020 I believe. You guys made an offer on my property. You previously purchased property on jungle road in between highway 44 seven and a half acres. It's right the tn turnbull creek. Three and a half acres of that seven is underwater and in the creek you guys paid $109,000 an acre for that $106,000 an acre. And then recently in JULY you purchased 1.65 acres directly across the street from my property for $200,000. That's $90,900 an acre. You guys made an offer a lowball offer on my property at $50,000 an acre and I'd like to sell the property to you but you've got to come up and pay a reasonable price for it. This property MAY solve all your problems. I'm directly across from that larger parcel that would give you access to the creek from my property. It's also set up like a park like setting. So if you guys want to consider I've submitted my offer to tony of a of a counteroffer and I haven't heard anything back. So I'm waiting to hear back from you if I don't hear anything. I do have developers have 17 acres as prime property people are calling me to buy it. I originally bought the property in 2015. I was going to set it up to have music festivals. I started a tree farm back in there and I'm wanting to be for the city use but again I have to sell it to the highest and best use. So if you guys don't want to do it then I don't have another choice and I'm not going to sell it to a lowball offer. So if you'll reconsider, I'm all ears. >> okay. Which parcels is that? Is it off? >> it's off of mission. No, sorry. Which was which parcel were 17 1964 jungle road. >> it's 117. Okay. >> there's an article on the front page of hometown news to my surprise that you guys wanted to buy my property. So you put that out there to try to quell everybody that's in here complaining about the properties that you're buying that you don't want to get serious about my property. >> why is that? >> thank you so much for your time and take a look at it. Thank you. Anyone else? >> I'm johnny dale. I live at 659 bay drive and I echo the same concerns as everybody that's been up here road maintenance park is built hypothetically. What is that going to bring into how much traffic? Where are they going to enter? >> I live off of pioneer side of bay drive and the road is in horrible shape on a regular basis even though we did have a guy that does drag it forth and I just put in $1,000 with the shell and it's gone from the last to rain so it's it's something that we I feel that we need to understand how the city is going to work on bay drive, what kind of traffic we can expect based on your guys's analysis because it's not going to be easy. I don't think and half of bay and dillon is in the city the other half is in the county so that proposes another issue. So we're not all in the city and I hopefully you guys can come up with a solution. Let us know what you're going to do sooner than later possible. >> thank you. Thank you . >> lisa hoffman 745 bay drive. My husband and I have a and our family have lived on bay drive for about two years now and we've seen the road get increasingly worse condition even just this year than it has been before. >> so I just want to reiterate what everyone else here has said which is the road is a major concern and bringing in more traffic on the road is just going to exacerbate that already poor condition of it as well as putting the increasing the maintenance burden on the private owners for public access to this property. So I think you know, from a pragmatic standpoint I'd like to know what the city can do to help bridge that gap and to help, you know, resolve the issue of the the road maintenance and also provide the owners on the road with a better understanding of what what the property's going to be used for and how it would be maintained. I wasn't even didn't even think about the concerns that people said about homeless people. But I think that's a valid one especially given that it's an isolated property in the midst of private property. And so there is an act currently there is no police presence out there because it's private property and so I think if if annexation is the way to get the road issue resolved and get the police enforcement that's needed to ensure everyone's safety, then we would like the city to take the lead on you know, on on those efforts and getting the property owners out there to have that opportunity to an extent so that all of these issues can be addressed together with, you know, a collaborative discussion on the use of the property. The other thing I'd like to add is you know, we have a son with special needs. My we are worried about, you know, being emergency services being able to get to us and my husband contacted the county about it and they said it's the city, it's the city's responsibility to maintain the road and to make sure that the the the vehicles can get to an emergency response can get to you and as it stands now, you know, we don't really have a clear answer from the city as to whether anything will be done. >> so we would like that information. Thank you. Are you are the nsp utilities? >> we are and we're on the city trash to the city picks up our trash. >> they don't pick up the recycling anymore but they did and we have utilities out there through the city. So yeah, I mean I feel like we're we're we're on city services but we're not getting the full benefit of the city is support and maintenance. >> so I think that's where we'd like and as you guys know this property is right in the middle of the city. I mean this isn't on the outskirts. This is at the very heart of new smyrna and so we just like you know, to have the same support and protections as the rest of the residents of the city do. >> thank you. Thank you . >> good afternoon. Steve gunter 140 temple street. I'm on the canal but my mother in law and her twin sister are 94 and they live right there on dillon circle and I'm their daily I got to say the term will creek land preservation should stay preservation. >> I think they need to take that property plan it out with a lot of florida indigenous plants put some more trees in there, let the wildlife come in there and take over nest, leave that shoreline so that all the marine habitat can be much healthier and as one gentleman and you guys have no control over but I plan on getting a hold of the f c w in those other marine departments because the boat traffic in there is horrendous and there's baby manatees and whatnot and they just use it as a playground and it's just destroying the bank along the terminal creek there. >> but if you plant that out and actually keep it preservation as your title claims, I think you'll make everybody a lot happier and that bay drive for sure right now because I was there yesterday and it it's like a motorcycle crash track or something yeah I mean you could even go down through there on a motorcycle it's so bad and surely if emergency had to respond they don't have a hard time coming off pioneer trail and going down that road. I suggest any of you try to drive down through there with your car right now and it's just you'd be bottoming out in areas so anyway please just keep it a preservation. >> thank you. Thank you. Anyone else seeing no one else out there that wants to speak to us today we will continue with our workshop topics. I'm going to point over to staff comments on any all right. The primary purpose of today is to get general feedback on what you want to see if anything on all the 250 acres that we've bought throughout terminal properties. >> so that's working all right . We'll stand at the podium and thanks tony . >> so before we open the floor for comments as to what you would like to see done on the other properties, we basically will brief history of the program how we got here and where we go from here. >> so let's turn to race properties which were between jungle road and pioneer trail. >> they were the primary impetus of getting the whole bond issue passed. 2016 developer came in, wanted to develop 400 lots on this property and everybody went up in arms and wanted to stop it. So there were many workshops and discussions on how to stop this development and the consensus was that the best way to do it would be for the city to purchase the property. >> so that evolved into a resolution and to create the bond referendum and basically as you can read on there the commission determined that the development of long term bull creek has the potential to pollut w the waters of the creek and downstream waters, eliminate wildlife habitat and natural areas . So the commission that resolution passed and it went on the board you know the election in NOVEMBER 2018 and it passed 75% to 25%. So the actual language of the bond referendum again was to protect the water quality by preventing pollution