POLISCOPE

The public record

MANATEE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

July 28, 2026 - Regular Meeting — Transcript

Wednesday, July 29, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

July 28, 2026 - Regular Meeting — Transcript

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

YouTube captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Jul 31, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 519,322 stored characters

Welcome to a meeting of your Manatee County Board of County Commissioners representing District 2. Amanda Ballard representing District 3. Tal Sadique representing [music] District 4. Mike Ron representing District 5. Dr. Bob McCann representing district 6 at large. Jason Bearden representing District 7 at large. George Cruz. [music] The county administrator is Charlie Bishop. Time is set aside at the beginning of each meeting for citizens to speak on any issue. [music] Citizens are asked to limit their comments to three minutes. >> [music] >> Today's meeting is brought to you with closed captioning. [music] July 28th, 2026, a regular meeting of the board. Welcome. Couple of quick announcements this morning. We'll begin with our pledge and prayer, but I'll move up proclamations starting with item four to recognize Judge Gilbert Smith Day and then we'll get back to the order of things. The as far as the commissioner agenda items are concerned. At the last meeting before our break, Commissioner McCann graciously agreed to defer one of his items. So, I'll begin the commissioner agenda items with the item number 67, update to Manatee County pedestrian safety ordinance for unincorporated areas of the county. So, we'll just start with the commissioner agent items at 67. Take it from there. And with that, I'll go ahead and call up Reverend Brock Patterson from Longboat Island Chapel for the invocation today. Thank you very much for coming, pastor. Please rise if you're able. And the pledge of allegiance will be led by the Boys and Girls Club. >> Let us pray. Gracious God, we give you great thanks for this day, for the blessings that you have already provided and for the beauty that we are able to experience here in Manatee County. Lord, I ask your blessings upon all of those who have been taking care of us, Lord. especially our our men and women who serve in fire rescue, law enforcement, medical personnel. Lord, they're busy at work keeping us safe and healthy. And we thank you. Ask your blessings upon them and upon their families and of all those who are serving in the armed forces wherever they may be, especially those in harm's way. We ask your blessings upon them and their families. And finally, oh Lord, we ask your blessings here. Your blessings of peace, your blessings of wisdom. We look to you because you have it all and we're doing our very best to lead in our community. So, thank you for trusting us and honoring us with that uh with that great thing. We pray all of this, Lord, in your holy name. Amen. Amen. Oh. To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> Please be seated. And thank you to the Boys and Girls Club for coming out today. We appreciate that. Speaking uh to what Reverend Patterson said about first responders, just wanted to briefly acknowledge and thank the county EMS, the fire district of Bradenon, the city of Bradenon for the emergency rescue uh earlier this week of uh the senior citizens uh housing at uh the at the apartments just in East Bradon. So thankfully no one was hurt. We thank God for that. And so we're our staff well city and we're coordinating with the this this the county is coordinating with the city of Bradenton to help relocate some of those individuals and work with the senior living facility. So just wanted to thank our first [clears throat] responders for that. So with that we'll begin with proclamations but um Mr. Parnell can you please provide up brief updates to the agenda sir >> announcements to the updates? >> Yes sir. All updates were published with the online agenda. Additional public comments were received after publishing for various items including general public comments for items 6 60 61 65 66 and 68. >> Thank you sir. May I have a pro uh a motion to approve proclamations? >> Motion to approve. >> All right, that's mo motion by Commissioner Ron, seconded by Commissioner Mckim. I'll get you next time. All in favor, please say I. >> I. All oppose. All right, that passes. Commissioner George Cruz will present the first proclamation of the of the day, Judge Gilbert Smith Day. And if anyone from the 12th Circuit Court would like to come on up with Judge Smith and friends, family, please do. >> Fellow Kanians, you can jump in there, too. I know you're out there. There you go. We're heavily weighted towards one side of the [laughter] trying to herd judges over here. >> All right, everyone comfortable where they are? All right, welcome to all of our our judges and our newest judge. Welcome. So whereas Judge Gilbert Smith is a lifelong public servant with his involvement in leadership, integrity, and commitment to Manatee County, his service has shaped both its legal community and its broader civic landscape for decades. And whereas throughout his distinguished judicial career, Judge Smith has earned a reputation for fairness, wisdom, and unwavering dedication to justice. His work on the bench reflects not only a deep understanding of the law, but also a genuine respect for the people and the community. And whereas his leadership spans numerous civic and nonprofit organizations, including his role as president of the Braden Kuanas Club and the Manatee Chamber of Commerce's legislative affairs chairmanship. He has led with humility, collaboration, and responsibility. And whereas Judge Smith is a dedicated mentor, investing his time in guiding young professionals, supporting aspiring attorneys, mentoring youth, and encouraging those at pivotal moments in their lives. He is also a recent recipient of the Kent C. Schultz Award by the Leadership Manatee Alumni Association. And whereas a respected historian and author, Judge Smith has made an enduring contribution to preserving the region's story. Works include Lawyers and Legends of Manatee County, second edition. And in celebration of Bradenon Quanis' 100th year, he wrote Champions of Children, volumes one and two, of which I personally own signed copies of both. Now therefore, be it proclaimed by the board of county commissioners of Manatee County, Florida, that July 31st, 2026 shall be known, designated, and set aside as Judge Gilbert Smith Day in Manatee County, Florida, adopted with a quorum present and voting this Tuesday, July 28th, 2026, and signed by our chairman, Tal Sadik. Judge Smith, congratulations on a successful career and a well-deserved retirement. >> [applause] [applause] >> Um, I'm so u honored and humbled by this uh before this board which I'll reflect on in just a minute. But my uh wife Anita, my daughter Shannon, and my grandson Zeppelin are here with me. And it's so special for them to to be here as well as all my colleagues on the bench um that are here and also a special uh breakfast group that I have uh and Kuanas members for those that are that I began working for Manatee County probably in 1970 and uh drove dump trucks. I um for the highway department uh did a number of other things before I became administrator of the Manatee County work release program in 1974. And so I have a long history and I have a love for Manatee County and I want to thank all of you uh on the board of county commissioners for what you do. It's not an easy job. It's uh much like what we do at times, but you have such an um vast amount of authority uh that you have to use uh for the citizens of Ant County. So, I want to thank each one of you for this uh recognition and I uh and God bless to all of you as well as everybody here that came here to uh to be with me. And this was a surprise. So, I didn't realize that until about an hour ago. So, thank thank you very much. [applause] >> Judge Smith, what can be said? F first of all, this is probably the best kept secret in the county. And this literally was a countywide secret. So, I'm surprised we managed to keep it that way. But, thank you for for your tireless work. And I'm I'm newer to the community, but I've heard so many great things. And you're in my district, so I heard many more things. But I want to thank you for your tireless work advocacy and work on and off the bench for children, for mentoring youth, for chronicling legal history, which one of the my favorite things just reading about local history. And to see you have not just one book, but two volumes was really nice. Um, and on that note, Janine Ach sends her best wishes. She couldn't be here, but her and the city of Bradon. So, I just want to thank you very much for your contributions in the community and I know you're not going to stop member of Kowanas and many other organizations, but thank you for your service. >> Thank you. >> Anyone else on the board? >> Go ahead, >> Judge Smith. You uh as an attorney in in your courtroom for a few years, I saw firsthand uh the the way that you administer justice in Manatee County. And I will say everything that was said about you is true. um you know unwavering in in the pursuit of justice but al and also your knowledge of the law but also so much respect for all the people involved in the system. Um which sometimes you know falls by the wayside for some people but but never for you. Um and I I appreciate your your support mentorship. Um, and also I will say my my eldest daughter actually reads Lawyers and Legends of Manatee County. She loves it. She will like take it up to bed with her [laughter] and look through it, which I mean that's a pretty ringing endorsement from from an eight-year-old. So, it's a popular book in our house. >> Thank you very much. Thank you very much, >> your honor. Thank you so much for your service to Mante County. I'm thank thankful I didn't have to ser stand in front of your bench but the way the way you lead the way you mentor the way you treat everyone with respect no matter who they are appearing for you or the people around you. I've got to know you over time and I just appreciate your friendship. I appreciate everything that you do. Um you know hopefully this isn't retirement. Hopefully this is just the next chapter and congratulations on this day being named after you. We're just You'll be missed on the bench, but we hope you stay around. Thank you, your honor, for everything that you do. >> Thank you very much. >> Make sure I see you on the board. >> All good. >> No. >> Thank you very much, Judge Smith. We greatly appreciate it. [applause] >> I think we'll have some photos there, so please stick around for that. All right, with that we'll move on to the next proclamation, ADA awareness month, presented by Commissioner Bob McKinnon. This is a proclamation by the board of county commissioners, Manatee County, Florida. Whereas the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 was signed into law on July 26, 1990, establishing landmark civil rights protections in advancing equal opportunity, accessibility, and inclusion for individuals with disabilities. And whereas individuals with disabilities contribute significantly to the social, cultural, educational, civic, and economic vitality of Manatee County, strengthening our community through their talents, leadership, and achievements. And whereas creating accessible and inclusive environments benefits all residents and reflects our community's commitment to participation, independence, dignity, and equal access for all. And whereas ADA awareness month provides an opportunity to celebrate the progress achieved through the ADA and to promote continued awareness, inclusion, and accessibility throughout Manatee County. Now therefore, be it proclaimed by the board of commissioners of Manatee County, Florida, that July 2026 shall be known, designated, and set aside as ADA awareness month in Manatee County, Florida. The board encourages all residents to promote accessibility, inclusion, and equal opportunity for individuals with disabilities. This is adopted with a quorum present and voting this Tuesday, July 28th, 2026. Board of County Commissioners, Manatee County, Florida. Signed by our chairperson, Talcadik, Chair, Commissioners, County Administrator, County Attorney, Carmine Demilio, Deputy Director, Property Management. Uh, first, thank you for recognizing ADA awareness month. I'd like to uh call up Alex Palmer. He's our ADA compliance coordinator. He's going to say a few words. And Alex uh recently he's now officially uh certified as ADA coordinator for Manatee County. Alex, >> thank you. Carmine. >> Good morning. My name is Alex Palmer. I am the ADA coordinator for Many County Chair, commissioners, county administrator, county attorney. On behalf of Many County, thank you for recognizing ADA awareness month and reaffirming our commitment to accessibility and inclusion and equal opportunity for all. The American The Americans with Disability Act is more than a law. It is a promise that everyone deserves the opportunity to participate fully in their community with dignity and independence. As ADA coordinator for Main County, I am proud of the progress we've made, but I also recognize that our work is never complete. Accessibility is an ongoing commitment that requires listening, learning, and working together with our residents. Thank you again, the board of county commissioners, for your continued support for accessibility and inclusion. Together, we will continue building Manty County where everyone has an opportunity to live, work, play, and thrive. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. [applause] I would also like to say before we're done, I'd like to give a special shout out and thanks to Pat Simmons who comes here every meeting so that she actually tells us about disabilities and what we need to do to make that inclusion possible. Thanks again for your [applause] >> Thank you very much and congratulations on the certification and we thank Pat for her advocacy for our citizens with disabilities. Like to go ahead and go a little bit back start with awards starting with the presentation of retirement award to Keith Lockach EMS District Chief Public Safety Department. Please come on up. family. >> Good morning, Commissioner. Sean Dwire, EMS chief. got a bunch of people behind me. But um the way I wanted to kind of start this when I thought about Keith um when young EMTs and paramedics enter the workforce, they look for specific individuals, paramedics and EMTs that they want to emulate. They look for qualities such as poise, professionalism, uh tact, someone who's skilled, someone who's intelligent, knows the protocols, and Keith had that. Today he's hanging up a stethoscope, which is a hard thing for a paramedic to do. He spent time with us for over 30 years. He designed our patch that we are in our arms, came up with acronyms that I can't tell you that I know all of them or what they mean anymore, but he came up with them. Um, we thank him for his service. Those standing here beside you today, Keith, are so proud to of you, so proud of your service. Um, the citizens that you served. We watched you battle to save lives in this community and Keith, we can never say thank you enough for that. So thank you. You should be proud of yourself. Your family should be proud of you and I know they are. Thank you. [applause] Thank you. I appreciate this uh this county giving me a career. Um, I'd like to also thank my wife for being with me because in this job and we go out as uh as paramedics and go out into the world and uh into this county and provide care, use work as a partnership. And uh I always said when I'm out there with my partner, I've got a partner back at home, too. So, I'd like to thank my wife uh for staying with me. My uh have a beautiful daughter and son also that uh now I wouldn't say follow my footsteps, but my my son's a deputy sheriff in Sarasota and my uh daughter's a nurse. So they've uh they're kind of continuing that public service. So uh I just want to thank uh the county for giving the opportunity. The relationships I've made both working and personal are going to uh stay with me for a lifetime. So uh I thank the county for giving me 31 and a half years of of giving my service. Thank you. [applause] >> I've heard great things about you, sir. the at one point or another someone on this board and someone in the audience has has had their life touched and impacted positively by EMS and by you know probably by you honestly. So I'd just like to thank you and the incredible work and dedication to the county that you have and all that you've sacrificed and your family as well. I mean the work of EMS is difficult. I've looked at I look at the numbers at a high level. I talked to our staff at length about where the needs are, how they're growing. They're not stopping and it's tough the calls you get. So I just want to thank you very much and for your leadership in in the county in EMS. Thank you, sir. [applause] All right. Next, we'll begin with the presentation of the two thou of the team member of the month for July 2026. Please come on up. >> Good morning, Mr. Chair, commissioners, deputy county administrator, county attorney, Molly White, director of sports and leisure services. I'm proud to present to you the July 2026 team member of the month, Miss Shenoa Shanoa Shawl. Uh, and behind me today is your county librarian, Annie Slavic, who would like to say a couple words. >> Thank you, Molly. Just want to begin by saying that the county uh team member of the month is not about the best employee with the best EPE. It's much more. As Charlie Bishop said and pointed out, it's a peer award. It's how her peers recognize what she does around the library. It is about the esteem that her peers have for a colleague who exemplifies wellestablished traits that elevate their colleagues and the people they serve to the better. It's an important reminder that it's far better to illuminate others than to merely shine yourself. Shoa shines in so many ways, but more importantly, she illuminates all those around her. Yes, Shenoa works hard. Yes, she's extremely proficient at cataloging. Yes, she's dedicated at her daily duties. And yes, she selflessly pours herself out every minute of her working day. But it is her attributes of perseverance under stress, helping those around her joyfully and humbling, humbly striving always to become better, which light up and lift up those around her. The team of six you see behind you who work alongside Shenoa in technical services have long known that they belong to a galvanized and committed team where everyone pitches in, everyone labors hard, and everyone acutely feels it when any one of them is missing. Up until now, knowledge [clears throat] of this impressive group has been self-contained secret. Thanks to this public character of this award and to Shenoa, it is now an open secret. Thank you, Charlie. Thank you, Molly. Thank you, commissioners, for honoring Shenoa today. for by honoring her, you honor the entire technical services staff, you honor the Manatee County Library, and you honor the sports and leisure department. Thank you, Shenoa, for illuminating what it means to serve the public and your peers selflessly. You are a credit and an inspiration to everyone in this esteemed chamber who labor alongside you to serve and promote the common good. Like to award you award [applause] >> I don't think he wants to say anything. Thank you. >> Just going to run away like that. Come on. [laughter] >> Well, so many of us are champions of our library system, Commissioner Balor. Well, all of us. Um, and I heard you had a pretty significant hand in the selfch checkout system that we use, which I feel is like state-of-the-art, and the app itself, which I use very frequently to access all manner of resources. So, thank you very much for making a difference in the lives of everyday citizens in the county. And as a quick plug, you know, just 30% of our our residents are actually library card holders. Do you guys know that? I ran the numbers the other day. Well, actually, our staff did, so thank you for that. But I encourage everyone to to go to the library and grab a library card. Check out the services. There's tons of free stuff out there you can access. You don't need to buy on Amazon. I mean, you can. and it's up to you, but it's it's right there in the library system and the digital books and so many great people like Shano work there make a difference and we really appreciate that. So, thank you very much. [applause] >> Oh, you can't see. Okay, so just very very quickly, Andy, that was beautiful. Maybe we should always have library services to to present our employee of the month awards because that was that was poetic. That was a really lovely tribute. Um, I will just uh echo what what Commissioner Sadiq said. Seriously, even if you don't regularly rent paper books, there are so many amazing online and research tools that the library has available for you that I utilize all the time. They're truly fantastic. Um, you can you can access um ebooks, all kinds of things like that. So you don't have to go physically into the library to enjoy the resources. And believe me, there is something there that you want and will use. So if you don't have a card, sign up. >> Thank you very much. >> [applause] >> All right. Next up, we have presentations. Very exciting set. I always look forward to it. It's my second year hearing them. We'll hear the presentations from the 2026 summer internship program, their capstone projects. earlier this just before the start of the summer they be they were a very bright group of students that spread across so many different departments working on incredible projects. So go ahead. >> Good morning. >> Tell us more. >> Kate Rucker, HR director. Yes, this is a very exciting program. It is the highlight of our summer. This group is no exception. This year we did pilot a program with our skilled trades with our high schoolers and we did have um in two of our departments, our road highway maintenance division and public works hosted two high school interns to learn the trades. Uh they are not not able to be here today. I'm sure they're keeping our roads maintained and beautiful right now. Uh Camden Red from Manatee High School, Benjamin Lewis from Palmetto High School. uh they did a eight-week program that uh again did learn skills on the job training that the feedback was phenomenal. They would our uh hiring managers would hire them tomorrow if they could if they didn't have to go back to school in August. So um also uh Cattown, our animal welfare division with community and veteran services hosted to high schoolers. Um Amelia Bastian, she is here today from Manatee School of the Arts. If you would mind standing, that would be great. Thank you so much. And Sophia Gaglaniano from Parish Community High School. They worked uh in the cat town uh learning how to uh adoption work and maintaining the and socializing of our of our fines. So, thank you so much for your experience this summer. Our summer internship projectbased program is a 10-week program where interns come and and work with our departments and are mentored by our county staff in completing projects. Not only do they complete important projects that leave a lasting impact uh for the for the county workforce. Uh they learn professional development skills, networking opportunities, and many of them come back and and become full-time employees. So again, we're super proud of this group. All 10 of our interns are here today. Okay, I'd like to introduce them one by one. Two will be um presenting to you their um capstone project. Morgan Lynch, move on by standing. She was mentored by Susan Barfield from development services. Her project was exe executive order extension processing. Marco Feliz mentored by Tuli and our public safety department health services community gap assessment project. Jared Wheeler mentored by Susan Barfield from development services. He worked on the transportation planning and roadway links project. Justice Schaefer mentored by Eric Berg, property management department. His project was ArcGIS indoors data collection. Gabby Casanova mentored by Jerome Pitman in our HR department. Her project was county mentorship program development. Chase Shapiro mentored by Wad Waderson Olay development services. His project was SOP and business process review. Arthur Dorvo mentored by Rob Shanebrook development services. Project was improving the public comment process for board meetings. Hudson Knap mentored by Alex Palmer, property management. His project was ADA GISnapping. Kyle Rodriguez mentored by Justin Allen in property management. His project was facilities asset data collection and asset management support. and he was partnered with Allan Hernandez Valdez again mentored by Justin Allen Allen and uh the same project. Thank you all so much for your work. All projects were phenomenal. Today we have two that we will highlight. Uh the first being Hudson Nap property management ads GIS mapping. Thank you. [applause] Thank you and good morning. It is an honor and pleasure to be with you today. My name is Hudson Knap. I'm a senior at Florida State University. I'm under the mentorship of Alex Palmer in property management. And this summer, I've had the pleasure of working and developing a GIS transition plan for ADA compliance. Not only is the transition plan an important legal requirement to fulfill the federal law requirement, but it also helps us to roadmap improvement of barriers and this go this work goes to increase the safety and accessibility for everyone within the county. Financially, the transition plan is also important because having a thorough, well done transition plan allows the county to be eligible to apply for community development block grants through the US Department of Housing and Urban Development. And funding is really the name of the game with a project like this. To put it simply, the more money we have, more projects we can do within a year. Sooner these projects get done, the less it will cost us over time as we fight a battle with inflation. Now the project consisted of three phases. Inventory, internal GIS building and then a public access portal. We started by taking 59 reports from 59 different properties. Those reports were done by a third party vendor, Banesh, and we input all the data that they give us into an inventory system. From there, we put those reports onto a GIS map so we can visually represent what the transition plan looks like. And once that was completed, we began looking forward of how can we make this accessible to the public as a tool for them to see what is accessible and also track our progress as we move forward completing these projects. The first part of the inventory process was doing a prioritization. We took the cost estimate and the vendor recommendation given to us, broke them down into three rankings of high, moderate, and minor priority with a majority of our work being in that minor or moderate range. Additionally, we can also track our progress within the inventory system in three phases as well. We have planning, active progress, and completed. Currently, 49 projects are in planning, meaning they're under desktop review. If we need to order parts, we are looking at that or if we need to contact a vendor and get a quote, that is also what is going on. And this is the intent that we are starting these 49 projects within the next few weeks. Then 39 projects are in progress, which means they're actively under construction. And 620 have been completed thus far, which is roughly 20% of everything we've given we've been given. And to put that 20% into context, the red line represents the total number of projects over the past eight or so years with the reports. So we receive these reports in bulk, many properties at a time, hundreds of projects at a time. Obviously, we cannot work on those projects until we receive them. And the green line represents the work that we've done so consistently working in the last six years since COVID roughly a hundred a year moving forward and closer. Eventually that red line will flatten out as the number of projects we will receive will be maxed and we'll be continue to work towards that progress. So the percentage will continue to go up. However, just as a disclaimer, 100% is a goal. However, it's not entirely possible with the way that ADA stands. It can change on a dime. If they wanted to update the code tomorrow, they can. That would affect the properties we've already been given, and it would also affect projects we've already done previously. So, it's it's just what it is, but we are consistently moving forward, and that's the goal and the scope of this project. Lastly, this is what the inventory system looked like last year during my internship. So the pages on the left were in binders printed black and white and each page was a project and could you imagine scrolling through those? So there was an Excel process at the time. However, over the last year the team has been working to update it, make it more organized so that way we can run analytics and do all the categorization we need. But it still does not offer that full context. And I'm sure even looking at it now, it's kind of an eyesore as you can see. So this is what we had previously prior to the internship this summer and this is what we have now. So we took all that information and moved it directly into GIS so we can visually see what's going on. So this will help direct staff of what we've already done, what we're working on and the concentrations of work that we need to go to next, telling us where we should work. Um this will impact your districts as we can see okay maybe we did something here in this district we should go to the next district and work there. And this is a completed project as it stands right now with the intent that it is updated continuously over time as new reports come in and as we change the statuses of projects. This is a better portion or a better look at a specific property within that GIS map just for context. So this is Lakewood Ranch Park where we are currently working. So 44 projects are in progress or in planning sorry 26 are in progress, 50 have been completed and 72 have not yet been started. And then this is an even closer look at what we're looking at on the internal version when identifying the points. We have access to blueprints for our facilities and this allows us to be pinpoint accurate when identifying where projects are and this helps with our efficiencies that I will note soon. The GIS portion allows us to visualize work of similar nature. So there's no more searching through spreadsheets. If someone like a vendor or a staff with the county was to go work on these projects, they don't have to ask themselves where am I going? What am I doing? What am I working on? It is all right there. They have the information and the visual capacity to see what they need to do. Additionally, they can make concise work orders moving forward and be more efficient. We can see if there's say five sinks within a building, let's do one work order, five sinks at one time. or if there are many trades surrounded by say four different parks in the same area, we can look by trade, make one work order, and it will be much cheaper moving forward. This helps with our economies of scale. As I mentioned, the the more efficient we are with our money, the more we can get done. The sooner we get it done, the less it will cost over time. Additionally, GIS allows for us to have a digitalized process that updates records and keeps all of our information. So that way, if personnel ever does change over, we are not losing anything important. Lastly, once that was completed internally, we began looking at how can we make this accessible to the public so they can use this tool. This is a current prototype of what that may look like. I say prototype as it is developed. However, it still has to go through a final cleaning and approvals, but this is what we assume it to look like if it is published. So, it gives live statistic updates on based on your zoom level of where you're looking. that will tell you the total number of projects, the percentage of the status of projects, and even uh the categories broken down by trade. So, if I was interested in looking at what projects are under the bathroom category, I can click that and that will bring up and filter out any projects not associated with that category and I can see the statistics for that category itself. And this becomes important if you were to look at a single property. If you are interested as a public, maybe I want to go to Lakewood Ranch Park and see what bathrooms are accessible to me. This will allow them to see what is accessible, what's going to be accessible in the near future and what may not be currently. Additionally, you can click on individualized points and it will bring up the full work assessment and all the information for full transparency. So, it will tell you things such as the job description, priority, if it has been completed, what date it was completed on, uh, what ADA code it may violate, and it'll also give you the cost assessment. This is important for many reasons. So, as I mentioned with being able for the public, if they want to go somewhere, they can ahead of time look and see what is accessible to them and if something is not appropriate, accommodations can be made. It also allows the county to be transparent with our flaws and showcase that we are working on them and trying to get them completed. A part of that full transparency is we offer full description of that work as well. Unfortunately, with a project of this scale, it does have a cost associated with it. So, between 59 reports we've currently received, 3,232 projects have been identified, bringing the total estimate to $4.7 million to complete these projects. However, that 4.7 million has taken course over the last nine years, and since then, inflation has been a thing. Rise of goods and labor has factored into this. While we cannot tell you the exact dollar amount we expect it to be, we would estimate the real cost to be a few hundred thousand to a few million more. With that, there are four recommendations that we would make moving forward to help with this. The first is to make that public access portal, get it cleaned up and available for the public to see. Next is to do work by the site. So instead of doing five work orders across five sites to complete 10 projects, you can do one work order 10 projects at a time at one site. And it was much more efficient, faster process and cheaper. And that goes in the next part is working fast as these costs will continue to grow over time. The way that the numbers currently stand with the ADA budget set aside, just to complete the projects we have been given so far, it would take over 25 years to complete. So, we would recommend increasing the budget through efficiencies like this process or looking into a grant opportunities because again, the sooner this gets done, the less it will cost. Lastly, do what you can inhouse, but recognize that vendors do need to be hired for special projects such as boat docks or bridges. And with that, I conclude and I thank you for the county for having me for a second year. And we'll now open the floor to any questions. [applause] As a technology guy, I really enjoy this kind of presentation and I like the use of technology to solve boring problems because those are the kinds of problems. Not that this is boring, I'm not saying that. But for example, we the the project that you mentioned with GIS, our staff went to present that in California recently and won an award for it. I also was in New Orleans presenting this at National Association of Counties. um similarly received an award. Rob Burke somewhere around here. No, he's not. But to to really showcase the value of some of the work that you're doing here, when 2024 hit the storm season and our disaster recovery debris team, well, the the vendor came to the county. They have to they're not from here, most of them. So, they have to figure out what what information do you have? Do you have maps? Do you have streets? You have do you have a map like this that shows me where all my infrastructure and all the the needs are? and they said that Mante County is one of the few counties in the state that has an extensive GIS program like this. So that was that enabled us to be the first or second fastest submitter to FEMA for reimbursements in the state out of 67 counties. That's awesome. Um so the project that you've you've described here with mapping out accessibility needs will inform our decision- making for where we can fund these kinds of projects. So I'd like to thank you for your continued work. Um, everyone has probably touched the GIS map at some point. If you just Google a particular project, Upper Many River Road, 75th Street West, the animal shelter project, you'll notice in the link it says GIS and it's got all this information. You can sign up for alerts. So, please check that out. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. [applause] Our next project is by Arthur Dorville. He will be presenting on improving public comment process through board meetings. You're good to go. >> Good morning everyone. My name is Arthur Dorville and it is an honor and pleasure for me to be here. It was it was also a pleasure and honor for me to work this summer with development services um as a summer intern. I was working as a business system analyst uh more precisely with the agenda team and my project was on public comment understand and document the process. At each meeting public comment takes place and every resident has three minutes. Every public comment becomes part of the official public record. But a lot of people only see those three minutes. Very few understand and see the hundreds of steps and hours behind those three minutes. So today, I would like to take you behind the curtain. Imagine you're a resident. You care deeply about an issue affecting your neighborhood. So you decide to speak up. You submit a written comment or you register to speak live. What happens next? Well, one resident has more than three channels to sub more than five channels to submit their written comment and every single one of those channels will eventually converge into manual work for the agenda team. a manual work. They will have to validate each of them, process, combine, compile, publish and they have to do it for every single one comment and all that before every meeting. Let's have a closer look. Here's the issues that we've identified with the current process and they all boil down to no standardization. This is actually what it looks like. Overwhelming, isn't it? You don't have to focus on every single boxes, but take a look on the overall picture. This right there is exactly what the agenda team has to go through every day, every week before every single meeting. And here's what the numbers are saying. For every single submission, the manual touch points can go up to 18. The intake channel available is more than five. The team members per meeting is averaging 6.5 hours. The team members per year can go up to three to four months worth of work. And the estimated annual labor cost can go up to $20,000. And I would like to mention that those numbers are only for the agenda team without taking without taking into consideration the other departments or other entities implicated in this process. This was my project. understand and document the process, but having to work every single day at the office every week seeing the agenda team having to go through the same process every day. I've realized something. Documenting the problem wasn't enough. if I had the opportunity to document the problem, I also had the opportunity to help solve it. So, I went ahead and contacted 10 different municipalities. And here's what we've learned from them. The first thing is that standardized intake improves operational operational efficiency. The second point is that policy drives efficiency way more than technology. The third point is that successful counties they reduce the manual decision making and invest that more into the process and the policy. And the fourth my favorite technology supports the process and not define it. And if we can summarize everything, what we've learned from those counties teaches us that here at Manatee County, the gap is the policy and process and not the technology because we have the technology to help solve this. This is what it could look like. Remember this is what we have. This is how it could look like. What we have what it could look like. Well, okay, Arthur, that was a lot. What are the changes? What are you suggesting? how this process can be different to that one. Well, thank you for asking. I've built a solution that might be new but efficient and it can be divided by two different jobs. The f the first one is an automation system that can do or replicate the exact same steps that the agenda team has to go through for hours in a matters of seconds or minutes. The second job is with one single form, not only will we'll be able to track and collect every single public comment, but we will also be able to give the chairman a live dashboard for the people that registered to speak live. So questions like who is speaking next, how many comments remain and how much speaking time left or even better which agenda item drew the most participation or attention for this meeting. They are all be answered and let's take a closer look to what the new numbers are saying. What this process gains us is a 72% reduction of the manual torch points. A 93% of reduction by the hours. Let me say that again. a 93% of reduction on the hours, an estimation of $15,000 annually has savings. And I would like to remind you that these numbers are only for the agenda team. No clerk's office, no commissioner aids, no managers, chose the agenda team. Today, we are asking leadership to decide on a few things. Immediately confirm the official agenda item type labels. Publish a firm submission deadline. define late comment handling rule because yes, sometimes you receive the comments when the when the meeting is already in process, is already in session. Adopt an official single intake channel. Align retention schedule with the clerk of court. standardize speaker signer process that will help us in the future to do things like publish live status to the public. Expand the analytics for meeting planning or even better formalize data governance ownership. And here's how how we look to implement this project. The first phase is a policy update. that will be working. The phase two is a prototype that has already been built. The phase three which is the pilot and training. The phase four is the county roll out and phase five is future enhancements. And yes, we can we can add AI in it. Ladies and gentlemen, dear commissioners, public comment is not just another business process. It is one of the most direct ways that the residents can communicate with their local government. And if we can make that communication clearer, faster, more transparent, and less burdensome for the people who make it possible, then we're not just improving our process. We are strengthening trust, reliability, maintaining the relationship between the county and the people it serves. And I believe, yes, I believe this is exactly what doing work that matters looks like. Thank you. [applause] Thank you, chair. First off, young man, I want to say what a heck of a presentation you gave today. >> [applause] >> Next thing I'd like to say is you're exactly right. Technology acceptance model, sociote techchnical systems, uh, dynamic capabilities means nothing unless we can create public value to society. If we can't create public value and the society rejects it, technology doesn't even doesn't even matter, right? So what you said there was spot on. I appreciate the presentation you gave today gave today and I'm impressed by what you brought to the board. Thank you. >> All the glory be to God. >> Hallelujah. [applause] >> I just have one question. When's the next meeting we can have this implemented for? [laughter] >> Somebody I I'm calling everyone. I'm calling somebody out. We're getting an answer. I was going to ask what does it look like? >> You showed us several times. >> Yes, sir. >> I think that uh bringing this down is very good. The only negative impact I can see with something like this is how many jobs could be cut. >> I think uh thank you for the question. But I think that the correct question should be how many hours will we be able to invest in assisting the public when they have to put their comment? How many hours that we'll be able to invest back into them so they can feel heard so they can feel seen. This is what the question I believe should should be. And also I would like to say that we are not telling the public that they would not be able to contact their commissioners. We're not keeping them from doing that. We are putting a process and a workflow that will help us be more transparent, earn back or earn their trust and together we will be able to continue making Manatee County as the best place to live, play, and work. Thank you. >> Thank you. [applause] On a serious note, you're absolutely right. the the process flow mapping, the user experience that research UX work that you've done here. The people get frustrated when they when when they interact with something and it doesn't work. Whether it doesn't matter if your internet's out, if your iPhone screen's freezing, or if the public comment page is difficult, confusing to navigate and and we've known this for a while. So, I was very excited to hear that this is a project that we were working on because many of the many of the projects in the internship cohorts uh have been executed. The sidewalk project, the mapping of that, for example, we built sidewalks with that. So, I'm very excited to see this move forward. I like everything about it. So, I'm just looking forward to seeing can we get this done by end of the year because, you know, as you're seeing in the audience today, we have now more than ever more engagement, which I really like, in local government. People are realizing that federal and state doesn't work and you can't drive to DC or Tallahassee for it, but you can easily show up to a county commission meeting or a city council meeting. So, the challenge for us, it's incumbent upon us to ensure that we can make sure [clears throat] with with the amount of hours we have in the day that they're heard and ensuring that our technical systems are up to par is critical. So, I'd like to see this come be implemented by end of the year that we're not running short of meetings and we have tons of tons of content that people are very anxious to be involved with. So, thank you very much for the project, Kate. Appreciate the work here, but let's get a date going. And Mr. Bernell, go ahead, sir. >> Yeah, I will just say we we love this. That's why we selected the one this to be one of uh the presentations uh to the board and uh we feel like Nicole's already uh looking at this uh >> Thank you. >> to bring back to the board. So yeah, we'll get rid of those paper cards. >> Thank you, sir. [applause] >> All right, Kate, was there anything else? >> No. >> All right, we'll go ahead and take a 10-minute break and be right back. For anyone that might be outside or in the overflow, our our deputies are directing people in. So once the CEO opens up, you can come on in and you participate. Wonderful. All right. We'll start with the request by commissioners to pull items from the consent agenda. I'll start by pulling the budget item resolution. Would anyone else like to That was 13. Okay. I have 8 19 32 33 and 35. >> Okay. We'll start from the top. We have 8 13 70 10 19 32 33 35. >> Correct. >> Perfect. All right. >> Okay. We'll hear public comment on consent minus those items. So that'll be just this is just for the consent portion. Let me run through the quick procedure real quick. We have a lot of new folks. We'll start with the comment on the consent agenda which is everything under item H up until what's a couple of pages till I get to L. So if you have sorry I so if you have any comments about that portion of the meeting you can provide public comment there and the typical the rule will be that we usually implement is please come up state your name county of residence and you have three minutes to speak on on anything uh for consent or for that particular topic. So for anyone wanting to provide public comment on consent because I don't have anyone signed up the comments will be for all the rest of the items minus 8 13 8 10 13 70 19 32 33 and 35. So please come on up. >> Good morning commissioners. Mark Salaji from the concerned citizens for Cortez coalition. My comments are around uh consent agenda item 46, which is the extension of the first amendment to the right of entry agreement for SEMA construction uh to use the former seafood shack property for the staging area. Uh I'm very delighted today to be in front of you to basically just say thank you. So, uh, at the June 16th PCC meeting, we shared our comments with you regarding our concerns about the proposal that was being presented around the staging area and using 4.9 acres of that space. Uh, after you listened to our comments and after deliberation, you instructed the planning teams and see to go back and revise the proposal uh, before they presented the final version to you. On July the 10th, uh the CCC board members were invited to attend a call with the planning commission members and uh with SEMA to hear what they were proposing, what they were thinking about for those revisions. And we were delighted to see that they had taken a lot of our input into consideration uh and that they were incorporating that into their planned revisions. and and frankly we supported everything that they wanted to do uh which continues to try to keep the majority of that uh construction related activity to the south side of the current property. Uh we can't say enough about how much we appreciated the fact that they proactively reached out to engage with us and to get our feedback on that. uh it meant a great deal to us and we particularly wanted to come today to thank you each and every one of you for encouraging them to do that because frankly open communication with with that there is nothing that we can't accomplish together. This doesn't have to be adversarial. Uh so we were very pleased to see also that those items were incorporated into the plan and we wanted to also say today that with this proposal to extend uh the right of entry agreement for another 60 days so that they can finalize uh those plans. We absolutely fully support that as well to give them the time and we hope that they'll continue to engage with us as they move forward to those final plans. So thank you very much. >> Thank you sir. And if you stick around, I just have a quick update for you after. >> For the record, Glen Jabina at District 4, Manatee County. Item 24, acceptance of resived economic development. This is a very vague uh wordage that says above above average wage. Anybody know what that is? It's 2306 an hour. Who can live on 20 2306 an hour? You can't. So when they say above, it could be 10 cents and they would fall within this wheelhouse. If you're going to say above, then it should be 15 or 20 bucks above that starting from the person that's running the line to office help. Anybody? Oh, we we add it in together. You know, the president makes a million, our line workers make 15. In theory, we're above the average wage. This is a bad this is a bad plan. The wordage is terrible. It needs to spell out what the living wage is in Manatee County and it's sure to hell in 23 bucks an hour. Andrew Griffin, Manatee County activist and advocate. And um I'd like information on uh 15. Uh this is the adoption of resolution R-26-094. There were reports that were provided to you guys uh for and against um getting this uh loan and those were not part of the agenda. And I think that that needs to be I mean this is $110 million. Granted, it's a revolving um amount and um it's for specific my understanding for specific work that needs to be done around this county according to whoever K P K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K R G, whatever their names are. And then um I'd also like um information on 26. Now, there is we know that there was damage out at at the African-American cemeteries, and we know that there's grants to help um manage this, but I think because of the importance of this cemetery, I think this needs to be pulled and explained to the public. Not that we're go, you know, obviously it's a grant. We want any money we can get from anybody to help clean up the cemetery, but I think it's important for um the community to hear what we're doing. So, with that, uh thank you. Have a great day and God bless. >> Thank you, ma'am. Is there anyone else to speak on like to comment on consent? Just please come on up. Good morning. Tracy Washington, Manatee County NAACP president. Um I'm here to get some information on number 26 as well. Um just trying to find out about the funding um that's supposed to be allocated. um trying to find out is the county owning the cemetery now and um if they don't own the cemetery, how are we getting funding from the county and then other organizations are able to come and apply for the funding? I'm kind of confused on that part. So that was my only question. Thank you. >> Thank you. Anyone else for consent? Okay, seeing none, I'll just briefly comment on a couple of those things and then I'll accept motions to approve consent. The there's no one on the phone that had their hands raised. Uh item 24, it was the economic incentive item. Apologies if I'm jumping around here. Yeah, economic incentives. So, this is the product of probably work since April. So we actually eliminated all the cashbased incentives because we felt it's just not valuable. If you're we you should we shouldn't be the public should not be paying a company to bring jobs. That's their literally their job to do that. So that's and the data did not support that it was leading to meaningful outcomes, job creation. So the what this really shows is the incentives that provide cashbased grants to companies to relocate or expand uh and hit certain employment numbers that with certain salary numbers. We're we've gotten rid of all those because in in few count it just doesn't work. We have 10 plus years of data to show it. What you also see there is a is a shift to focus on apprenticeships. So if someone is looking to relocate to the county, they first need to make a commitment to work with Career Source Sunost, the local our workforce board and create those jobs by virtue create the apprenticeship which will create the the training pathway for for individuals in the county and then you can apply for that. So you have to show that you're you've already relocated here. can hire people. You can work to get an apprenticeship accredited by the state, get people going through it and create a pipeline of opport of jobs in the trades. So that's what that's really incentivizing is the creation of apprenticeships. It's no longer a model of providing cash for jobs, which is a terrible model. So I think this is a good step forward. And then we're also providing well considering it's not a guarantee property tax abatement for manufacturing companies to come here. We all know we want to bring manufacturing back to the US. So in short, the idea is if you're a manufacturing firm, um, think advanced manufacturing like robotics. I just toured a facility in Pittsburgh that does cool stuff there. So robotics, clean manufacturing, then we'll consider the property tax abatement, but it's not guaranteed and there's a lot of data behind that. So you don't just show up and say, "I'm going to manufacture spoons and get free no taxes." It's not going to happen. So that's what that is. Um, I think I covered generally that quickly on 26. Sorry I didn't get to your call again, Miss Washington, last night, but I did find out last night. No, we don't own the cemetery. The cash the grant from the state for $75,000 at Adams and Rogers Cemetery is to repair the outer fencing. So, when staff went in and cleaned up the property, just like with um with Old Memphis, the property owners property, it's the cemetery is literally built with homes behind it and or in front of them. So the the cemetery fencing is damaged and to make a short story of it that needs to be repaired and so this grant from the state allows us to do that but we do not own the cemetery. The county does not. So but we'll continue to maintain it annually. So that's that. Um I don't have anything else. Does anyone have any comments? If not then I'll entertain motions to approve consent minus the items discussed. I'll quickly summarize those again. List those. 8 10 13 19 32 33 35 and 70. So you're making a motion to approve consent minus those items. >> Motion to approve. >> I'll second. That's a motion by Commissioner Ballard, seconded by myself to approve consent minus items [clears throat] 8, 10, 13, 19, 32, 33, 35, and 70. Why don't we do a voice vote on that one? All in favor of the motion, please say I. I all opposed. >> All right, that carries unanimously. >> All right, now we will go to citizen comments for future agenda items and then after that we'll go back to the items pulled and the regular agenda. So bear with me if there's any confusion. Please reach out to staff. Happy to help. >> Oh yeah, you're right. I apologize. We'll go to the advisory board updates very briefly from government relations. Good morning, chair, commissioners. Brett Anderson, government relations manager. Um just wanted to let you all know final presentation for the government efficiently government efficiency lays on committee. We have each committee member here who's going to present a different section of their slide and I'll kick it over to Dave. >> All right. Well, good morning everyone. Again, uh for the record, my name is uh David Otterness, Manatee County resident, uh and I am the chair for the government efficiency liaison report or committee. And uh we're happy to provide this report to help better Manatee County to be more efficient. That's one of our main goals. Just a brief overview on the government efficiency liaison committee. We were appointed by commissioners as of last summer. Our first meeting was in uh July of last year. Our main points of topics were to identify the information and research the information that Manatee County did provide to the state of Florida during the month of July. We had roughly I'm going to say uh 10 people from the state of Florida that were auditors that were up in the ninth floor conference room. I was able during that time to meet and introduce myself to all those auditors. They ever had any questions, we were there as community advocates to be able to provide that information to them. Our main topics were to de develop procedures, goals, and identify targets that can help this board and future boards make better decisions down the road. So what did we do as a committee? We really wanted to focus on the efficiency. We wanted to look at the tasks at hands. So each of us identified four mer main areas of interest that dealt with or that dealt with spending trend analysis our purchasing synergy ILAS which is interlocal agreements overall procedures and today we are here to provide our final report our committee me members I've already introduced myself we have Jeff Covert Don Berg and John Centinary so there are currently fo

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • July 28, 2026 - Regular Meeting — Transcript

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 91a41417ab9c8cc5cb0fb8d9f633c681. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record