POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

June 13, 2023 4:00 PM - Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Wednesday, June 14, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

June 13, 2023 4:00 PM - Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

>> OKAY. WHY DON'T WE GO AHEAD AND CALL OUR MEETING TO ORDER. I APOLOGIZE FOR BEING TARDY, I JUST GOT BACK FROM OUT OF COUNTRY 45 MINUTES AGO. AND CASSIE DOESN'T DRESS ME THAT FAST. I CAN'T. SO -- FIRST THING THAT WE'LL DO IS ROLL CALL. >> HERE. COMMISSIONER HATCH: GOEDERT: HERE. COMMISSIONER GREENE: HERE. COMMISSIONER MIDDLETON: HERE. COMMISSIONER PARTIN: HERE. >> VERY WELL, IT WILL TAKE US TO ITEM TWO APPROVAL OF MINUTES, WE HAVE NONE. ITEM THREE, ANNOUNCEMENTS. >> NONE FOR ME AT THIS TIME. NONE, CHAIR. >> VERY GOOD WITH THAT, WE'LL DO OUR ANNUAL ELECTION OF OFFICERS. SO AFTER OUR TERMS HAVE OFFICIALLY GONE FROM MAY FIRST TO APRIL 30TH. SO THE FIRST MEETING THAT WE HAVE AFTER THAT DATE, WE HOLD OUR ANNUAL ELECTION OF OFFICERS, SO WITH THAT, WE NEED TO APPOINT. I NEED A MOTION ON THE FLOOR FOR A CHAIRPERSON AND A VICE CHAIRPERSON. DON'T EVERYBODY SPEAK AT ONCE HERE. >> CAMERON, DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS SERVING A SECOND TERM? >> I FELT THAT I HAD A LOT OF MEETINGS. >> DID YOU? >> NO. I'M A GOOD BELIEVER OF A ROTATION PROCESS. I BELIEVE THAT THERE'S OTHER COMMISSIONERS THAT NEED TO BE MOVED FROM VICE CHAIR TO CHAIR ROLE, I THINK THAT EVERYONE DID -- COMMISSIONER MINOR. >> I WILL (INDISCERNIBLE) AND LUKE MINER FOR VICE CHAIR MAN. >> DO WE HAVE A SECOND? >> SECOND. >> ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE MOTION? SEEING NONE, THOSE IN FAVOR? >> (MULTIPLE SPEAKERS) AYE. >> ALL RIGHT. WITH THAT THE MOTION PASSES. CONGRATULATIONS CHAIRMAN, VICE CHAIR MAN. AND UM, WHY DON'T WE GO AHEAD AND SWITCH SEATS, SOUNDS GOOD. LET'S LEAVE THEM IN CASE. (MULTIPLE SPEAKERS) >> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER MIDDLETON FOR YOUR SERVICE THIS PAST YEAR, AND I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME OUR NEWEST PLANNING COMMISSIONER, MR. GREG BALKOVEK. WELCOME. ALL RIGHT. UNDERSTANDING THAT WE HAVE A COUPLE OF PEOPLE THAT NEED TO RECUSE ON UM, B FIVE ONE. I'M GOING TO SUGGEST THAT WE UM, SWITCH THE ORDER AND BRING FIVE B TWO UP TO THE TOP AND THOSE WHO NEED TO RECUSE NEED TO GO AHEAD AND EXCUSE THEMSELVES FROM NOW. AND IF ANYONE WISHES TO ADDRESS THE PLANNING COMMISSION ON ANY ITEMS DURING THIS MEETING, PLEASE FILL OUT THE BLUE SPEAKER FORMS, THEY ARE LOCATED IN THE BACK. AND SUBMIT THEM TO THE CLERK UP HERE. ALL RIGHT. WITH THAT, UM, WE DON'T HAVE CONSENT CALENDAR, AND WE DON'T HAVE SO LET'S MOVE ON TO THE FIVE B TWO WHICH IS THE TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION IN THE MAP EXTENSION E X 2023602 BY RIDGE LINE FOR THE TENTATIVE SIX DIVISION MAP MAPS-2017-00328, TO DEVELOP THE VISTAS SUBDIVISION,UNITS 3 AND 4, CONSISTING OF 65 LOTS ON 47.7 ACRES. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 555 QUARTZ HILL ROAD. >> OKAY. SO LET'S GET STARTED, THANK YOU COMMISSIONERS FOR SHOWING UP. SO THE ITEM HERE TODAY IS SUBDIVISION MAP EXTENSION SUBDIVISIONS UNITS, THREE AND FOUR. THE LOCATION OF THE VISTAS IS IN THE NORTH WESTERN PORTION CITY LIMITS ALONG COURT HILL ROAD, THE SIZE IS 47.7 ACRES AND DIVIDED TO 65 LOTS DIVIDED TO 65 FAMILY HOMES, AND IT IS OPEN SPACE DISTRICT IN FLOOD PLAIN OVERLAY DISTRICT. SO SOME BACKGROUND, THE ORIGINAL SUBDIVISION MAP WAS A GLOVED IN 2017. IT ALLOWS US TO TWO EXTENSIONS UP TO THREE YEARS EACH. AND THE MAP EXTENSION WAS IN NOVEMBER 2020 AND THIS IS THE SECOND EXTENSION FOR THE SUBDIVISION MAP. SO TYPICALLY WITH THE MAP EXTENSIONS, THE CITIES HAVE CONSIDERED IF THERE'S ANY CERTAIN EXTENSIONS THAT WOULD WARRANT THE DENIAL OF THE MAP, AND SUCH HAVE AFFECTED THE ADVERSE IMPACT IN THE ENVIRONMENT, AND AT THIS TIME, THE STAFF IS NOT IDENTIFIED ANY SIGNIFICANT CHANGES THAT CAN WARRANT THE DENIAL OF AND THE TENSION BEING CONSIDERED. AND NO CHANGES ARE BEING PROPOSED UNDER CONSIDERATION OR ANY GENERAL PLAN OF VISIONS AFFECTING THE MAP, STAFF IS NOT AWARE OF ANY ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES, FOR THE MAP APPROVALS, MITIGATION MEASURES OR CONDITIONS, AND THEREFORE STAFF RECOMMENDS THE APPROVAL OF TENTATIVE MAP EXTENSION 2023006002. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, ANY QUESTIONS FOR STAFF? >> THE ONLY QUESTION THAT I HAVE ON THIS SINCE 2017 OBVIOUSLY FIRES HAVE BEEN MORE PREDOMINANT IN THIS AREA. AND I SAW NO CHANGE AS FAR AS THE MANAGEMENT PLAN, AND HAS THERE BEEN ANY GENERAL CHANGES FOR THAT. FOR THE WIDE OPEN AREAS OTHER THAN THE ONE HUNDRED FEET? >> I CAN ADDRESS THAT. CURRENTLY THE CITY IS WORKING ON A VEGETATION MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE THAT LENDS TO THE COUNCIL AS INFORMATION ITEM AND THAT HAS NOT BEEN ADOPTED AS OF YET. >> AND THAT WASN'T A CONSIDERATION IN THE RENEWAL OF THIS PLAN? >> WHEN THAT VEGETATION ORDINANCE COMES IN, THOSE REGULATIONS WILL APPLY. >> THANK YOU. >> YOU'RE WELCOME. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> ALL RIGHT AT THIS TIME, UM, I WILL OPEN UP THE PUBLIC HEARING. IF ANYBODY WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT ON THIS, PLEASE SUBMIT A BLUE SPEAKER CARD. MR. LEDGER, ARE YOU SPEAKING ON THIS ITEM? OKAY. >> ALL RIGHT. MR. LEDGER YOU'RE UP, SO DON'T SIT DOWN. >> YEAH, I JUST HAD A QUESTION, I DON'T KNOW IF STAFF CAN ANSWER THIS. AND IN LOOKING AT A GOOGLE MAP OF THE PLACE, HAVING WALKED DOWN THE PROPERTY LINE, WHERE (INDISCERNIBLE) PROPERTY AND THE TWO DIVIDE, THERE'S A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT OF DIRT AND GRADING TO WHAT LOOKS LIKE AN OPEN SPACE AREA, SO MY QUESTION TO STAFF WAS, WAS THERE FILL PUT IN THE OPEN SPACE AREA UP THERE AND I KNOW THAT THEY HAD A LOT BELOW IT. AND UM, JUST WITH MY MEASUREMENTS, YOU KNOW, WITH LITTLE METERS GOING FROM ONE MAP TO THE OTHER. SO THAT'S MY QUESTION TO STAFF, OTHERWISE, AT ONE TIME IN THE PAST, I WAS CONSIDERED ABOUT A RARE PLANT THERE. BUT IT ONLY COMES UP AT THE EDGE OF THE PROPERTY. THAT'S MY QUESTION IF YOU CAN -- >> MY RECOLLECTION IS THAT THERE MAY HAVE BEEN SOME FILL PUT IN WITH THE OPEN SPACE AREA, IN RELATIONSHIP TO ONE AND TWO. AND PARTICULARLY WHEN WE WERE LOOKING AT PROVIDING A TRAIL ALONG THE CREEK, SO THAT MAY HAVE BEEN ACCRUED AT THAT TIME BUT IT'S BEEN TIME SINCE ANYONE HAD WORK DOWN THERE. >> ALL RIGHT IS THERE ANYONE ELSE WANTING TO ADDRESS THIS ITEM? OKAY. SEEING NONE, I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMISSIONERS FOR CONSIDERATION. >> I'LL MOVE FOR APPROVAL. >> ALL RIGHT. I HAVE A MOTION, ANY OTHER DISCUSSION BEFORE -- >> I WOULD SECOND THE MOTION. I THINK THAT THE PRECEDENT IS CLEAR ON HOW THE STAFF AND THE CITY AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAS HANDLED THIS BEFORE, WE CERTAINLY NEED MORE HOMES, AND I THINK THAT IT'S GREAT FOR THIS TO GIVE ONE MORE THREE YEAR EXTENSION, ONE MORE SHOT. >> ALL RIGHT. WE HAVE A MOTION, AND WE HAVE A SECOND. ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION? ALL RIGHT. THEN I WILL CALL FOR A VOTE, ALL OF THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE. >> AYE (MULTIPLE SPEAKERS) ANY OPPOSED. >> IT PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THANK YOU. >> GOING BACK UP TO THE TOP HERE. FIVE B ONE, WE HAVE A COUPLE OF FOLKS THAT WE NEED TO RECUSE. >> MR. CHAIRMAN, I SERVE IN THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE COMMUNITY REVITALIZATION AND REDEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION. AND THAT IS POSED TO BE THE GENERAL CAN PARTNER SO I'LL BE RECUSING MYSELF. >> THANK YOU. >> MR. CHAIR, I WILL HAVE TO RECUSE MYSELF. I LIVE WITHIN A 6 HUNDRED FOOTNOTE IDENTIFICATION AREA THAT WAS SENT OUT. >> OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> WE WILL WAIT FOR UM, THEM TO LEAVE AND THEN WE'LL GET STARTED. >> MR. CASTRO YOU'RE GIVING THE PRESENTATION THIS EVENING? >> I AM. ALL RIGHT. SO THIS IS FOR THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION, P D 023736 BY DAN CO GROUP. A ?RM-9-PD? RESIDENTIAL MULTIPLE-FAMILY DISTRICT ? TAKE IT AWAY. >> THANK YOU, MR. HATCH. THANK YOU TO EVERYONE IN ATTENDANCE. >> SO THE PROJECT IS OUTLINED HERE IN RED, AND IT BOUNCES UP ALL THE WAY TO PLACER STREET ACROSS THE STREET FROM HOLIDAY. SO HERE'S HOW THE ZONING OVERLAYS ON THE PROPERTY SO YOU HAVE THE PROJECT SIDE ON THE R M NINE P D, SO THAT'S THE RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY DISTRICT. I KNOW THAT IT'S A MOUTH FULL, SO THERE'S A TRIANGULAR PIECE TO NORTH OF THAT, WHICH IS THE RSP SINGLE THREE UNITS PER ACRE DISTRICT. >> SO HERE'S A COUPLE OF PICTURES OF THE SITE, THERE'S THE CROSSWALK RIGHT IN FRONT OF HOLIDAY MARKET THERE AND A VACANT UNDEVELOPED LAND OUT THERE. AND WE HAVE A UM -- OVERHEAD CLOSER OVERHEAD TAKEN FROM 2020. I COULD HAVE USED A MORE RECENT OVERHEAD BUT IT'S A DRY ONE AND THIS LOOKED A LITTLE BIT NICER. >> SO THE PROPOSAL IS FOR 6 FOUR-UNIT APARTMENT PROJECT FOR LOW-INCOME HOUSEHOLDS, THE UNITS ARE SPREAD ACROSS SIX BUILDINGS AND EACH BUILDING WILL HAVE A PATIO OR A BALCONY DEPENDING ON WHICH STORY IT'S ON. AND IN ADDITION TO THE SIX BUILDINGS, IT'S A COMMUNITY BUILDING IN THE CENTER ALONG THE CENTER IN THE -- AROUND THE MIDDLE PORTION. BUT THE POINT IS THAT IT'S GOING TO HAVE A COMMONS ROOM, A KITCHEN, A NON-COMMERCIAL KITCHEN, A LAUNDRY FACILITY, AND EXERCISE ROOM AND OFFICE SPACE WITH COMPUTERS, AND THAT'S FOR THE RESIDENTS TO USE, AND IN ADDITION TO THE INDOOR COMMUNITY SPACE, THERE'S AN OUTDOOR COMMON AREA. THAT INCLUDES A PLAYGROUND, PERGOLA, BASKETBALL -- IN TERMS OF THE COLORS, THESE ARE ALL COLOR ELEVATIONS FOR THE FOUR BUILDING TYPES BEING PROPOSED. AND THE TOP LEFT THERE ARE FROM A COMMUNITY BUILDING AND TO THE RIGHT OF THAT. FOR THE FOUR UNITS, ONE BEDROOM BUILDING. AND THE OTHER TWO BUILDINGS ARE THE MAIN STAYS OF THE BUILDINGS USED FOR THE HOUSE. HERE ARE IN MORE PICTURES OF THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN CONCEPTUAL. IF YOU LOOK AT THAT, THAT'S ON PLACER TO THE RIGHT HAND SIDE WINDOW THERE. AND SAME THING FOR THE PICTURE THERE. AND WE'RE LOOKING ALONG PLACE HE, TO WHAT IT WILL LOOK LIKE. IS AND THE PICTURE TO THE BOTTOM LEFT, IS LOOKING AT IT IT. IF YOU'RE LOOKING DOWN TO THE SOUTHWEST. THAT STREET DOESN'T EXIST RIGHT NOW, THE STREET THAT'S ON THE FRONTAGE THERE. WE'LL GET TO THAT IN A MINUTE, BUT THAT'S ON PIPER WAY EXTENSION THAT CONNECTS TO THE SAN FRANCISCO THERE WE'LL LOOK AT THAT TO THE BOTTOM LEFT CORNER. SO ACCESS AND UTILITIES TO THE PROJECT WILL COME FROM THE PROPOSED EXTENSION OF PIPER WAY, AND THAT'S HIGHLIGHTED THERE IN YELLOW, AND THAT EXTENSION WOULD COME UP FROM SAN FRANCISCO AND EXTEND TO THE PROJECT SITE. AND IF YOU GET TO THE SEWER GRAVITY FEED, AND THE SEWER NEEDS TO TIE IN UP THE STREET TO ALLOW THE PROPER DEPTH FOR THAT TO WORK. AND THE MAJORITY OF THE UTILITIES THERE ARE COMING THROUGH PIPER WAY. ONE OF THE OTHER BENEFITS OF THIS EXTENSION IS THAT IT PROVIDES SECONDARY ACCESS TO THE NEIGHBORING HOMES THERE UPON DEVELOPMENT OF THE PARCEL TO THE LEFT OF IT ON THIS PICTURE. BUT TO THE NORTH WEST, AND WHEN THAT PARCEL HAVES THEY WILL BE REQUIRED TO CONNECT BOTH SEGMENTS OF PIPER WAY AND GIVE FULL SECONDARY ACCESS THERE. AND THAT'S IMPORTANT THERE. BECAUSE IT'S IN A HIGH FIRE SEVERITY ZONE AND IN CASE OF AN EMERGENCY IT PROVIDES AN ADDITIONAL EXIT POINT IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD, AND THAT'S A REQUIREMENT FOR NEWER SUBDIVISIONS TO HAVE THAT IN THE ARTERIAL ZONE. AND THIS PROJECT BRINGS THAT CLOSER TO THE REALITY TO THE EXISTING HOMES OUT THERE THAT CURRENTLY ONLY HAVE ONE ACCESS POINT TO PLACER STREET. AND IN ACQUISITION OF THAT REQUIRED RIGHT-OF-WAY AND DEDICATION OF THE CITY STANDARDS STREET IN PIPER WAY ARE IN THE CONDITIONS OF THE APPROVAL, SO THAT'S REQUIRED OF THE PROJECT. SO STATE LAURA ALLOWS MORE UNITS PER ACRE THAN THE CITY'S GENERAL PLAN AND THE LOW-INCOME DEVELOPMENT. AND 41 UNITS WILL BE ALLOWED IN THE PROJECT SITE FOR THE ZONING ORDER INDEPENDENCE, TO GET TO THAT 62 UNITS TOTAL, WHICH IS 43 MORE UNITS ALLOWED FOR THE BASE ZONING, A 65 PERCENT DENSITY IS REQUIRED. THE PROJECT IS TO BE ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE. AND IT MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS, AND IN ACTUALITY, IF THEY RESERVE, IF I'M REMEMBERING THE NUMBER CORRECTLY, IT'S 8 VERY LOW-INCOME UNITS, IT MAKES THE MARKET RATE PER STATE LAW, SO THE FACT THAT IT IT'S ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE IT GOES TO -- IT ENSURES THAT THIS EASILY MEETS THE STATE REGULATIONS TO GET THAT DENSITY BONUS TO 55 PERCENT. SO THE GENERAL PLAN DESTINATION FOR THE PROJECT SITE THERE, THAT'S BROWN ON THE SCREEN. IS RESIDENTIAL SIX TO TEN UNITS PER ACRE. AND THAT HIGHER DENSITY ALONG WITH THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT AND THE PLANNED OVERLAY IS IN PART THERE ON PURPOSE TO MEET WITH THE DEVELOPMENT 11 H. AND THAT'S IN DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY THROUGHOUT THE COMMUNITY. ESPECIALLY THROUGH PLACER STREET AND DOWNTOWN MAJOR COMMERCIAL AREAS AND NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL AREAS, IT TAKES ALL OF THE BOXES, AND CLOSE TO DOWNTOWN AND CLOSE TO A STOP, AND NEXT TO A COMMERCIAL AREA THAT SERVES THE NEIGHBORHOOD SHOPPING CENTER THERE. AND HISTORIC -- THE HISTORY ON THAT IS TO TRY TO GET SOME OF THE MULTI-FAMILY TO SPREAD IT OUT FOR THAT MORE, UM WORKING WORK FORCE HOUSING ISSUES I SHOULD SAY. SO IN ADDITION TO THAT THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY FOR THE ZONING ORDINANCE SO THAT THE CITY HAD ANOTHER LAYER OF DISCRETION TO ENSURE THAT IT FITS THE CHARACTERISTICS. AND TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S NOT SOMETHING HALF HAZARDLY INSTALLED TO HAVE A CHANCE TO GUARANTEE WITH THE SURROUNDING DEVELOPMENT. SO THAT DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY DISTRICT IT ALLOWS THE RELAXATION FOR DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS IN EXCHANGE FOR EXCELLENCE IN PROJECT DESIGN AND THAT'S ONE OF THE STATED PURPOSES IN THE ZONING ORDINANCE. AND A SECOND PART DISTRICT IS TO FACILITATE THE DEVELOPMENT FOR LOW-INCOME HOUSEHOLDS. SO THIS PROJECT MEETS THE PURPOSES. THE PROJECT UTILIZES GOOD DESIGN AND IT AVOIDS LONG AND BROKEN FACADES. I'M SURE THAT YOU CAN PICTURE THE LONG APARTMENT BUILDING DESCRIBED AS HAVING LONG AND BROKEN FACADES LIKE THE P D OVERLAY IS TRYING TO AVOID THAT, AND IT DOES. THE FACADES PERFORMED ARE BICYCLE END UP, AND THERE'S BALCONY AND PATIOS AND VARYING ARTICULATIONS, AND IT GIVES IT A RESIDENTIAL FIELD, AND THERE'S A LOT OF COLORS AND TEXTURES. UM, SO WITH ALL OF THAT, THE PROJECT ACHIEVES THE INTENT OF THE P D DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT, AND MAKING IT COMPATIBLE WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD. AND AS FOR TRAFFIC THERE WAS A TRANSPORTATION IMPACT STUDY DONE FOR THE PROJECT AND THE PROPOSALS EXPECTED TO HAVE 23 A M PEEK HOUR TRIPS AND 29 P M PEEK HOUR TRIPS. TO OPERATE IN ACCEPTABLE LEVELS, AND ALL STAY WITHIN THE ACCEPTABLE LEVELS, AND CAN THE STUDY CONCLUDED THAT IN FURTHER ANALYSIS WILL BE CONCLUDED WITH REGARDS TO TRAFFIC. THE NEW PIPER WAY WILL BE PRESERVED WHERE IT IS FOR THEIR REMOVABLE. AND THEY ARE PROTECTED TO STAY FOR THAT AREA. AND ANYWAY'S, THERE'S A UM, PROPOSED LANDSCAPE PLAN THAT DOES SHOW 47 TO 50 GALLON TREES, SO THAT'S REALLY 57 INSTEAD OF 47 AND 34 TO 24 INCH CHINESE STASH PROPOSED IN THE LANDSCAPE PLAN. AND IN ADDITION TO THAT, UM, THERE'S A PROPOSAL TO INCLUDE IT IN THIS PROPOSAL SAVING ONE TREE, AND THAT'S TREE 52 FROM THE INVENTORY TABLE DONE FROM THE PROJECT SITE. AND SO I WANTED TO NOTE THAT THERE'S A CONDITION THERE ABOUT THE MANNER -- OF STANDARDS TO SEE HOW WE PROTECT THE TREES AND DEVELOPMENT IN GRADING TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE PROTECTED IN THE LONG-TERM. IN THIS CASE, IT CAME TO STAFF'S ATTENTION ONCE IT HAS BEEN COMPLETED, AND THOSE STANDARDS NEED TO BE COMPLETED FOR THAT PARTICULAR TREE. BECAUSE THEY ARE TOO CLOSE TO BUILDINGS, SO STAFF RECOMMENDS UM, AMENDING CONDITIONS 16 TO REMOVE THE 16 OUT TO 16 B. SO THAT THE PERIMETER IS DEFINED AS BEING THE ACTUAL PERIMETER OF THE TREE, AND NOT 6 FEET BEYOND THE PERIMETER TREE. SO A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE PROJECT'S LANDSCAPING CONDITIONS. SO THE LANDSCAPING CONDITIONS REQUIRE A SHADE TREE FOR EVERY INCH OF SQUARE FOOTAGE THAT CONCLUDES 23 FEET FOR THE PROJECT. THAT YIELDS 35 TREES, AND THE ONE PER FOUR PARKING SPACES THAT STANDARD WAS USED IN THE CONDITIONS OF THE APPROVAL, INSTEAD OF THE ONE TYPICAL INTERIOR LIVING SPACE AND THAT THE TREES ARE CALCULATED FROM RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT. AND THAT WAS TO FACILITATE THE HIGHER DENSITY. DEVIATION FROM THE STANDARDS FROM THE RESIDENTIAL CHAPTER, FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY THAT ALSO ALLOWS US TO WAIVE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS. SO THAT'S THOUSAND THE NUMBER OF TREES REQUIRED FOR THE PROJECT WHERE WE ARRIVED AT. SO THAT YIELDS 61 TREES REQUIRED FOR THE PROJECT, AND THE PROJECT PROPOSED TO ARRIVE AT 91. AND THAT DOESN'T COUNT ON THE TREES BEING SAVED WHICH COUNTS TWO FOR ONE. FOR SAVING THAT TREE. THE PROJECT IS CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT FOR THE CLASS CAN TWO EXEMPTION AND THE FINDINGS FOR THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THE STAFF REPORT. THIS IS THE SUMMARY OF HOW THEY MEET THE FINDINGS FOR THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT. AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE ZONING ORDINANCE, INCLUDING 1826 RESIDENTIAL DENSITY BONUS, AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE GENERAL PLAN AS WE DISCUSSED. IT IS ADEQUATE TO SIZE AND SHAPE TO THE PROPOSED HOUSING PROJECT, THE HOUSING SITES FOR THE 6 FOUR-UNIT COMPLEX. AND THE DEVELOPMENT WILL HAVE ADEQUATE ACCESS AND THAT'S REQUIRED. SO THE PROJECT WILL HAVE ADEQUATE ACCESS. AND THEN IT WILL HAVE PUBLIC SERVICES AS DISCUSSED EARLIER. AND IN ACTUALITY IT WILL WORK ON IMPROVING PUBLIC SERVICES TO OTHERS BY BRINGING THAT PIPER WAY CONNECTION TO THE CURRENT -- WHERE IT'S CURRENTLY OUT TO SAN FRANCISCO STREET. AND IT WILL IMPROVE PUBLIC SERVICES TO OTHERS. THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT WILL BE COMPATIBLE WITH EXISTING RESIDENTIAL LAND USES AND IN CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA AS DISCUSSED AND IT DISPLAYS IN AND LENGTHS AND IN DESIGN, AND IT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTERISTIC OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD, AND WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT THIS BUT THE PROJECT ADEQUATELY TALKS ABOUT THIS. THE PIPER WAY WILL PROVIDE FIRE SUPPRESSION FOR THE SERVICES AND IT MEETS STANDARDS FOR FIRE TRUCK ACCESS. AND THERE'S CONDITIONS FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENTS. AND ENSURING THAT THE FIRE DEPARTMENT CAN DO THEIR JOB. AND IT'S NOT IN THE FLOOD PLAIN AND THERE'S NO 0 PERCENT SLOPE THERE'S NOTHING PROHIBITED IN THE SLOPES. AND TAKING THE PROVISIONS BY PROVIDING HIGH QUALITY AND AFFORDABLE AT THE SAME TIME. SO AT THIS POINT, UM, STAFF RECOMMENDS THAT THE COMMISSION DETERMINE THAT THE PROJECT IS CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT UNDER SEQA. AND DETERMINED THAT THE FINDINGS ARE IN EVIDENCE, AND THE PLANNED APPLICATIONS WITH THE AMENDED CONDITION 16 TO ADJUST THE PERIMETER BOUNDARY AROUND THE PERIMETER TO BE SAVED. >> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY QUESTIONS FOR STAFF FROM THE COMMISSION? MR. BALKOVEK. >> YES, I HAVE A QUESTION, UM, THERE'S A CHANGE -- CHANGES BEING CONTEMPLATED FOR PLACER FURTHER DOWN. HAS THERE BEEN ANY DISCUSSION ABOUT WHAT IMPACT THAT MAY HAVE ON THE TRAFFIC IN THIS AREA? IN REGARDS TO DEVELOPMENT. >> COMMISSIONER, ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THE STRIPING DOWN PLACER? >> YES. >> WE HAVE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, JOSH ANTHONY TO ADDRESS THAT QUESTION. >> THIS MIC WORKS. HERE WE GO. IN THE RECENT STUDY FOR THE PLACER RE-STRIPING, WE INCLUDED THE POTENTIAL DEVELOPMENTS WITHIN THAT STUDY. SO ALL OF THE CHANGES THAT WERE APPROVED BY COUNCIL INCLUDED THIS, SO WE SHOULD HAVE NO IMPACT, THERE'S NO ADDITIONAL VEHICLES THAT WERE THOUGHT OF OR PLANNED OUT IS INCLUDED IN THE IMPACT ANALYSIS. AND WE DID NOT HAVE ANY NEGLECT IT TIFF OUTCOMES (INDISCERNIBLE) (SPEAKING AWAY FROM MIC) >> THANK YOU. >> ALL RIGHT. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> YES. COMMISSIONER PARTIN. >> THE ACCESS POINT PIPE HE WAY, THAT'S A PROPERTY NOT OWNED OR CONTROLLED BY THE DEVELOPER? >> WHICH DIRECTION? >> THE PIPER WAY ACCESS, THERE'S A PORTION OF IT IT NOT CONTROLLED. >> OKAY. SO THE -- SO IT'S A LITTLE SUPER COMPLY INDICATED. THERE WAS -- >> GOOD. >> (LAUGHTER). >> SO IN REALITY -- SO IT THIS LAND RIGHT HERE IS WHERE PIPER WAY IS PROPOSED TO BE PUT IN, IT WILL COME DOWN THROUGH HERE. AND THROUGH THE PROJECT SITE AND ALONG. ON OLD MAPS IN THE CITY, THIS IS DESIGNATED TO THE STREET CALLED BRUSHARD WAY, IT CAME TO LIGHT THAT IT WAS NOT THE CITY OF RIGHT-OF-WAY, EVEN THOUGH IT WAS A PAPER STREET, IT WAS NEVER FORMALLY OR PROPERLY DEDICATED. THERE'S NO PRESCRIPTIVE EASEMENT FOR THAT SEGMENT, SO WHAT THAT MEANS IS IF YOU SEE RIGHT HERE, THIS LINE IN THE BACK OF THE HOUSES IS ACTUALLY THE CENTER LINE THAT GOES DOWN (INDISCERNIBLE) SO THE PROJECT SITE ACTUALLY OWNS HALFWAY DOWN TO THIS CORNER RIGHT HERE. AND THEN FROM THERE TO SAN FRANCISCO STREET ON THAT HALF OF THE PROPERTY TO THE EAST HERE OWNS THAT PART MUCH SO THESE PROPERTIES HERE OWN UP TO THE HALFWAY. TO ACQUIRE THE RIGHT-OF-WAY TO UTILIZE THE SPACE THAT THEY DON'T OWN, AND RIGHT NOW THEY DO OWN THIS HOUSE SO THEY OWN THAT RIGHT AWAY, AND THE TWO PARCELS AND THERE'S A PENDING AGREEMENT FROM THE OWNER OF THIS PARCEL. AND SO UM, SO -- LIKE I SAID, ADEQUATE RIGHT AWAY IS CONDITIONED FOR THE APARTMENT. AND IT SEEMS THAT ADEQUATE RIGHT-OF-WAY AT HAND. >> AND IF THERE'S A PROBLEM IT WILL GO TO EMINENT DOMAIN. >> THEY CAN PETITION COUNSEL FOR THAT. AT THIS POINT, THAT UM -- >> IS THAT ME? (BAD AUDIO) >> UM, WITH THE ACQUISITION IN THE HOUSE AT THE CORNER, THEY ACTUALLY WOULDN'T NEED TO DO THAT, THAT GIVES THEM MORE RIGHT-OF-WAY OPPORTUNITY BUT SINCE THE REPORT WAS GIVEN, THERE'S MORE EASE OF WAY IN THAT RIGHT-OF-WAY, IMMINENT DOMAIN IS NOT NEEDED AT THIS POINT. >> THANK YOU. >> ALL RIGHT ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> COMMISSIONER MIDDLETON. >> YES, IF I MAY, THIS IS MORE FOR ASSISTANT DIRECTOR ANTHONY, I READ UP ON THIS BEFORE IT WAS COMING FOR COUNCIL, ON REGARDS TO THE PLACER REID -- WHAT WERE THE PEEK TRAFFIC NUMBERS HERE AT THE HIGHEST POINT WHICH I THINK THAT WE'RE DOWN TOWARDS WEST CHEST THEY ARE AREA DOWN PLACER. IS IT 14 INCH? >> ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THAT -- >> I THINK THAT IT WAS 14, 8 AND IN TERMS OF -- THE GENERALLY ACCEPTED CAPACITY FOR A ONE LANE IN EACH DIRECTION IN THE CENTER LANE FOR ABOUT 18, 0 THOUSAND. >> 18 TO 20 THOUSAND WOULD BE THE NORMAL AMOUNT THAT YOU WOULD ALLOW VARYING BASED ON GEOMETRY BASED ON THE GEOMETRY BASED ON THE USAGE RESIDENTIAL, AND 18 TO 20 IS ABOUT WHAT OUR CONSULTANT EVALUATED IN THAT AREA. >> AND SECOND QUESTION IS WITH REGARDS TO THE (INDISCERNIBLE) I ACTUALLY TRIED TO FIGURE THAT OUT FOR YEARS AND YEARS AND YEARS AND IT STARTS HERE, AND IT GOES ALL THE WAY UP THROUGH AND IT GOES OVER NEXT TO INCLUDING THE PERTINENT TO THE WATER TOWERS RIGHT? FOR PUBLIC WORKS. AND IT GOES DOWN THE HILL, AND IT GOES ON THE HILL ONLY, THROUGH BUENA VENTURA TO LAKE SIDE AND THERE'S ONE THERE, FROM REGISTER ON THE FAR END, AND OBVIOUSLY, THIS WILL NEVER BE USED AS A STREET THROUGH THERE EVER FOR ANY PURPOSE, HAS THIS KIND OF STARTED A BIT OF A UM -- HOW WOULD YOU PUT IT? JUST A START TO REDOING THE RIGHT OF WAY DEDICATION OR ABANDONING THAT? BECAUSE THAT MAP IS ON EVERY RECORDED MAP ALL THE WAY THROUGH THERE, AND IT'S ON SEVERAL AP MAPS THERE. AND THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THAT WE SEE ANYBODY DONE ANYTHING TO CORRECT THAT. AND IT'S A WEIRD THING TO HAVE ON THE WEST SIDE OF TOWN, DOES THIS START AT ANY MOVEMENT TO START TO REASSIGN TO TAKE CARE OF THAT RIGHT AWAY. OR LACK THERE OF? >> MY FOCUS HAS BEEN ON THIS SPECIFIC AREA OF (INDISCERNIBLE) WAY. I CAN EXTRAPOLATE THAT THERE'S A QUESTION FOR THE CITY SURVEYOR. BUT UM, IN TERMS OF BEING ON A MAP, I MEAN MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THOSE LINES ARE SIMPLY -- I SHOULD PROBABLY NOT SPEAK TO THE QUESTION SINCE I DON'T KNOW HOW TO ANSWER IT PROPERLY. >> WHAT I MAY SAY IS THAT IT WAS BROUGHT UP TO LIGHT FOR AN ISSUE. WE JUST DEALT WITH IT FOR THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT. I DON'T KNOW IF IT GOES FURTHER BEYOND TO WHAT YOU DISCUSSED. I THINK THAT IT'S SOMETHING THAT YOU CAN LOOK INTO. AND IT'S COME UP BEFORE, AND A CONTINUING ISSUE. SO I ENDED THIS FOR THE COMMUNITY SURVEYOR. >> AND IF I MAY EXTRAPOLATE FOR A LITTLE BIT. THE PROPERTY LINE IS ON THE MIDDLE OF (INDISCERNIBLE) WAY. SO IT'S MOW OF THE MAP NOT SHOWING SOMETHING. AT LEAST IN THIS CASE, NOT BEING ANY KIND OF PROBLEM WITH THE TAKE OR ANYTHING, AND THE PROPERTY IS NOT REALLY WITH THE PROPERTY OWNERS, AND IT'S DOWN THE MIDDLE OF THE LINE S AND IT'S NOT REFLECTED ON THE MAPS PROPERLY. >> UNDERSTOOD. AND WITH REGARDS TO THAT, I WAS CURIOUS WITH THE TRAFFIC AND CIRCULATION PORTION I DON'T KNOW IF ANYBODY FROM W TRANS HERE FROM THE COMPANY THAT DID THE TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY, I THOUGHT THAT IT WAS ODD FOR THE 23 A M, AND 23 P M PEEK HOUR TRIPS, GIVEN THE NUMBER OF UNITS WAS LOW AND ROOMS PER UNIT ETCETERA. IT SEEMED LIKE A LOAD OF A NUMBER, IS THERE A REASON FOR THAT? >> I DON'T KNOW, THAT'S WHAT THE STUDY SITED. AND FOR THE HOTELS AND STUFF FOR THE NUMBERS TO BEING SIMILAR, THOSE ARE THE PEEK HOURS, BUT IF ANYBODY ELSE WANTS TO SPEAK ON THAT. >> DO WE HAVE THE TRAFFIC CONSULTANT HERE? >> PUBLIC HEARING? >> OKAY. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. >> WOULD YOU MIND FLIPPING TO THE TREE SLIDE REALLY QUICK? >> WHICH ONE? >> THE NEXT ONE. >> WOULD YOU LIKE THE LIGHTS DOWN SO YOU CAN SEE THAT BETTER? >> I CAN SEE IT BETTER, I DON'T KNOW ABOUT MY OTHER COMMISSIONERS. IS THAT A -- >> OKAY. OKAY. UM, SO IT SAYS 91 TREES PROVIDED, CAN YOU BACK UP ON THE MAP FOR ME FOR THAT. >> ABOUT THE TREES PROVIDED? >> YEAH. >> THE TREES PROVIDED ARE -- SORRY THAT I ZOOMED AWAY FROM THE SLIDE. >> SO THIS GRAPHIC RIGHT HERE IS ACTUALLY THE COLOR LANDSCAPE PLAN, SO THIS IS SCREEN SHOTTED FROM THE GRAPHIC PART OF IT. BUT THERE'S A TABLE IN THIS PLAN THAT SPECIFIES EXACTLY WHICH TREES ARE INCLUDED ON THIS PLAN. SO THIS IS -- THAT'S WHERE THE 91 COMES FROM, AND THAT'S WHAT THEY ARE SHOWING IN THE PROPOSED PLANTING PLAN HERE. SO THIS IS UM, BESIDES THIS, THIS IS WHERE IT IS COMING FROM. >> DOES THE 91 INCLUDE OUR FAVORITE TREE THERE? >> YES, IT DOES. >> SO THE 91 DOES INCLUDE THAT THERE? >> YES. >> TEN OF THEM, BUT THEY DON'T INCLUDE IT IN THE OTHER COUNT THAT YOU'RE DOING PREVIOUSLY? >> 24 INCH WHICH IS BIGGER THAN THE 15 GALLON. IS THAT HOW I UNDERSTAND THAT? >> AND HOW MANY TREES ARE BEING REMOVED? TOTAL OR JUST OAKS? >> TOTAL AND THEN OAKS, IF YOU CAN BREAK THEM BOTH DOWN. >> I DON'T THINK THAT I HAVE THE TOTAL NUMBER BUT THE OAKS IS 27 AND THERE ARE 33. >> 33 INCLUDING THE GREAT PINES OF CHINESE PISTACHIOS OUT THERE. ALL RIGHT. AND THEN I HAD A QUESTION ON THIS. THAT I HOPE THAT MR. (INDISCERNIBLE) CAN SPEAK TO. ANY QUESTIONS? >> YES, I REMEMBER LOOKING AT THE TREE PLAN. WE'RE SAVING 52 TREES, SO AT LEAST -- IS THAT RIGHT? >> SO THE TREE, UM, SO THE TREE INVENTORY TABLE I'M NOT SURE WHY BUT THEY STARTED IT AT NUMBER 20 THERE'S NO TREE 19 OR BELOW. >> GOOD. GOOD. KEEP US THINKING. THANK YOU. >> IT ALSO JUMPS FROM 52 TO 79 IN THE NUMBERING OF TREES. >> I DID THAT, BECAUSE I'M SHOWING THE TREES THAT ARE INCLUDES IN THE HOUSING PROJECT ITSELF, AND THAT DOESN'T INCLUDE PIPER WAY WHICH IS OFF OF THE ACTUAL PROJECT SITE. >> THOSE WERE WITH THE TREE POSITIONS TO BE PRESERVED? >> THE TREE'S CONDITION TO BE PRESERVED ARE THE ONES THAT ARE NORTH. THE ONES NORTH ON THE -- >> THE R S THREE PARCEL THERE. THE TRIANGULAR PARCEL. THOSE ARE CONDITIONED TO REMAIN BECAUSE THERE'S NO DEVELOPMENT TO BE REMOVED. AND THE OTHER ONES ARE IN THE PATH OF PIPER WAY, AND THOSE ARE NOT INCLUDED IN THE TABLE. >> AND THAT'S IN THE 53 TO THE 78? >> 53 THROUGH, UM, I DON'T HAVE IT WITH ME. I BELIEVE THAT IT'S 53 THROUGH 93 OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. >> SO THOSE -- PACKING WITH THE PAGE 57. >> THERE'S THREE TABLES, AND THERE'S A FEW TREES THAT ARE ON THE TABLE THAT ARE AFFECTED BY THE ACTUAL PROJECT SITE. AND THE TREES ARE NOT IDENTIFIED ON PACKAGE PAGE JUST FOR CLARITY FOR THE COMMISSION. THE TREES THAT ARE NOT SHOWN THERE ARE THE TREES THAT ARE TO BE SHOWN FOR FUTURE DEVELOPMENT. >> THAT'S CORRECT. >> INFLATED FOR REMOVABLE IN ORDER TO PUT THROUGH PAPER LANE. SO YOU CAN THINK OF IT, IT'S A GROUP OF TREES, FOR THE HOUSING PROJECT, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SEEING. THERE'S A GROUP OF TREES. THOSE ARE NOT INCLUDED DO YOU HAVE THAT TOTAL NUMBER? >> SO JUST TO BE CLEAR THE TREES UM, 53 THROUGH 78 THAT ARE NOT LISTED AND THE GAP ON PAGE 57, AND THOSE FOR SURE ARE ON PIPER WAY THAT IT WILL GO THROUGH, BUT THEY WOULD BE REMOVED WITH THIS PROJECT BECAUSE THAT'S THE CONDITION OF THE APPROVAL BECAUSE HOWEVER THEY ARE NOT INCLUDED HERE. >> THERE ARE NUMBER OF TREES NORTH OF PIPER WAY ON RESIDENTIAL PARCEL TO THE NORTH THAT ARE NOT INCLUDED IN PIPER WAY AND TENSION. ANY OF THE TREES THAT THE PIPER WAY EXTENSION COMING THROUGH, ANY OF THE TREES THAT WOULD BE OF THAT RIGHT-OF-WAY WOULD BE REMOVED OF THE CITY STANDARD TREES TO BE REMOVED. BUT THEY ARE NOT LISTED ON PAGE 57; IS THAT CORRECT? >> I WANT TO SAY, BUT ON PAGE 57. CORRECT, NOT LISTED ON PAGE 57. >> I APOLOGIZE, I CONSIDER THOSE NOT -- THEY SEEM -- I DON'T WANT TO USE THIS TERM USUALLY, THEY SEEMED LIKE THEY WERE NOT TREES THAT WERE VERY NEGOTIABLE TO CITY STANDARDS. >> GOT IT. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> ALL RIGHT. AT THIS TIME I WILL OPEN UP THE PUBLIC HEARING, AND I HAVE A LOT OF BLUE CARDS HERE. IF YOU WANT TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, FILL OUT THAT BLUE CARD, AND BRING IT ON UP. AND FOLLOWED BY KELLY. HELLO, MY NAME IS WYATT PAXTON. I LIVED AND OWNED SEVERAL PARCELS IN THE AREA AND SO I EXPERIENCED THE HEAVY TRAFFIC THAT'S IN THE AREA AND THE TRAFFIC STUDY SHOWS THE LITTLE TO NO DETAILS TO HOW THEY CAME TO 308 TRIPS A DAY AVERAGE WHERE THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS SHOW 150 CARS PARKED THERE. AND THOSE VEHICLES LEFT ONCE A DAY AND CAME BACK THAT WOULD BE 3 HUNDRED, THAT WOULD NOT BE THE NORMAL LOAD, AND IT SHOWS THAT THE PIPERS BEING EXTENDED TO SAN FRANCISCO STREET AT THAT INTERSECTION DOWN TO THE CORNER ABOUT 160 TO 180. SERVING OVER 65 PARCELS ALREADY. AND WHAT THE PLANNER INDICATED IS THAT EXTENDING PIPER WAY TO PROVIDE AN ADDITIONAL EXTENSION, TO SAN FRANCISCO, WHICH IS ALREADY HAZARDOUS TO THIS POINT. THE PARCEL THAT WE OWN AT THE END OF COTTON WOOD AND PLACER HAS BEEN IMPACTED TWICE RUNNING STRAIGHT UP IN THE YARD. SO UM, THE PROJECT SHOWS THE DOUBLE THE NUMBER CREATING THE SAFETY HAZARD, AND THE NEWLY ONE FROM PIPE HE, AND THE OTHER ONE THAT I CAME ACROSS WERE THE AGENDA REPORTS THAT WERE CONSISTENT WITH THE AGENDA PLANS, BUT TWO PARAGRAPHS DONE, AND FIVE OTHER TIMES THAT'S NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE OTHER PLANS AS THE LIMITATIONS YOU'RE GIVEN A BONUS BECAUSE IT'S LOW-INCOME HOUSING OF 50 PERCENT INCREASE AND NOT ADDRESSING THE SAFETY HAZARD IN THE UNLOADING. IF YOU HAVE BEEN IN THAT AREA BEGINNING ON PLACER IN THE MORNING, YOU CANNOT MAKE A LEFT-HAND TURN THERE FOR SEVERAL STREETS, AND YOU'RE DUMPING SIDEWALK OFF THAT APARTMENT THAT GOES ACROSS THE CROSSWALK THAT'S ALL NOT CONTROLLED. SO IT WILL BE COMING ACROSS PLACER. IS AND ANOTHER ISSUE THAT TALKS ABOUT AS MAINLY FLATTENED LEVEL, IT IS NOT. THE SLOT GOES FROM ONE END TO THE OTHER. WHERE'S THE RANGE WATER DRAINAGE GOING TO IN, HOW IS THAT ADDRESSED? IT WILL AFFECT THE LOT NEXT TO IT NOT DEVELOPED. AND ANOTHER ITEM THAT I THOUGHT OF AT THE LAST MINUTE AS PART OF MY DUTIES IS THAT I MANAGE AIRPORTS, I SEE NOTHING UP HERE TAKEN TO THE A LACK FOR REVIEW BECAUSE HIGH DENSITY IN THE OVER FLIGHT PROGRAM WOULD BE REQUIRED TO BE APPROVED. THE GREEN ENERGY CODE WILL REQUIRE YOU TO PUT SOLARS IN THIS AREA. NONE OF THAT IS ADDRESSED IN THIS STAFF'S REPORT. IS IT CONSISTENT OR NOT CONSISTENT. THAT'S WHAT MY QUESTION IS. SO IN CONCLUSION, IS IT THIS WHAT YOU WANT FOR THE COMMUNITY TO HAVE IN THIS AREA. WE NEED APARTMENT AND HOUSING IN THIS AREA BUT TO DOUBLE IT BECAUSE OF THE TERM OF LOW-INCOME HOUSING AND THEN BEAUTIFUL THE EXTENSION OF PIPER IS ONLY THEIR DRIVEWAY AND IT DOESN'T SERVE ANY OF THEIR RESIDENTS EXCEPT FOR THE RESIDENTS OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND IT PROVIDES A DOUBLE LOAD TO SAN FRANCISCO. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> ALL RIGHT. NEXT UP, WE HAVE KELLY (INDISCERNIBLE) AND FOLLOWED BY DAVID LEDGER. >> THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION AND LETTING THE PUBLIC SPEAK ON THIS MATTER. I LIVE ON SAN FRANCISCO STREET WHERE SESTA COMES IN. SO JUST -- I HAD A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS, AND I WAS WONDERING WHAT KIND OF CONSIDERATION IS GIVEN TO THE TRAFFIC CONGESTION DURING THE SCHOOL HOURS BECAUSE MANSANITA SCHOOL IS ON DURING THAT AREA, AND IT'S VERY CONGESTED. I'M WONDERING IF ANY STUDIES ARE DONE DURING THE SCHOOL HOURS IN REGARDS TO THAT, AND UM, ALSO, UM, JUST TO REITERATE WHAT THE GENTLEMAN SAID EARLIER, MAKING A LEFT-HAND TURN FROM SAN FRANCISCO OFF TO PLACER SIMPLE POSSIBLE. SO WHAT MOST PEOPLE DO IS THEY TAKE U B A STREET AND THEN IT HOOKS INTO PLEASANT SOFT THAT'S SOMETHING TO CONSIDER AS WELL AS FAR AS TRAFFIC AND UM -- I -- THE GENTLEMAN EARLIER WAS REMARKING THAT HOLIDAY MARKET IS RIGHT THERE. IF I'M LOW-INCOME I'M NOT SHOPPING AT HOLIDAY MARKET. IT'S REALLY EXPENSIVE. AND I WOULD BE CURIOUS TO HOW MANY PEOPLE IN THAT HOUSING LOW MARKET UNITS WILL SHOP THERE. WHO QUALIFIES FOR THIS LOW-INCOME HOUSING? WHAT'S THE INCOME THRESHOLD? ARE THEY GOING TO HOUSE HOMELESS? PEOPLE WHO MAKE LESS THAN 50 THOUSAND A YEAR, WHAT'S THE THRESHOLDS, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW THAT. AND UM, THAT'S ALL I HAVE FOR RIGHT NOW, AND I REALLY APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU FOR LISTENING. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT. DAVID LEDGER FOLLOWED BY MIKE. >> GOOD AFTERNOON, COMMISSIONERS. I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO TALK TO YOU TODAY, I'M REPRESENTING THE ENVIRONMENTAL ALLIANCE, MY NAME IS DAVID LEDGER, WE'RE NOT FOR OR AGAINST THIS PROJECT, ONE THING THAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IS THE PRESERVATION OF NATIVE OAK TREES, AND SO THAT'S WHAT I'M HERE TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT THAT. AND AS YOU ALL KNOW THE CITY COUNCIL HAS A WILL -- FORMED TREE COMMITTEE TO COME UP WITH THREES THAT SHOULD BE MITIGATED FOR. AND IT WAS VOTED FIVE TO ZERO TO HAVE THAT, AND HE WAS APPOINTED BY MAYOR (INDISCERNIBLE) SO IN THE CITY THERE'S A PROCESS NOW GOING ON TO RECOGNIZING THE IMPORTANCE OF NATIVE OAK TREES AND THE TREE COVER FOR THE HEAT ISLAND EFFECT. AND OAK TREES ARE IMPORTANT FOR WILD LIFE. SO IN MARCH OF 2023 THE PERMIT ON CLEAR CREEK ROAD BECAUSE OF IN ISSUES WITH THE MAP IT WASN'T REALLY CLEAR HOW THE MAP WAS AND THE TREES. THE DEVELOPER AGREED TO A RATIO OF FOUR TO ONE AND THEY WOULD PLANT FOUR NEW ONES AND IN 15 GALLON CONTAINERS. AND PART OF THAT AND SHASTA VIEW THEY HAD TO MITIGATE AND REQUIRING THEM TO MITIGATE FOR ALL OF THE BLUE OAKS. AND SOMETIME, I DON'T KNOW HOW BUT THE DEVELOPER THOUGHT THAT BECAUSE THE CDFW RECOMMENDED THREE FOR ONE. AND THEY EVEN INTERRUPTED ME AVENUE SPEAKING TO THE COMMISSION. FOR THE WAREHOUSE DISTRIBUTION CENTER IN WAREHOUSE ROAD, THERE'S A LOT OF MAY TIFF TREES ON THAT. AND ONE OF THEM WAS 54 INCHES IN DIAMETER, AND HAVING ALL OF THE TREES REPLACED HAD TO BE NATIVE TREES, AND THERE'S NO REAL MITIGATION BUT WITH THE CALIFORNIA OAKS AND WRITING A LETTER IN OPPOSITION. SO THERE'S A PROCESS AND IT HAS BEEN GOING THROUGH FOR MITIGATION FOR THIS PROJECT, BECAUSE SOME OF THE TREES THAT ARE SUPPOSED TO BEING PLANTED ARE SMALL, NOT JUST A CRATE -- AND ALSO, YOU JUST LOSE THAT FOR THE BLUE OAKS. AND I WOULD URGE YOU TO REQUIRE FOR A MITIGATION ON TWO TO ONE FOR THEM TO BE REMOVING THAT IN THE PARCEL. >> OKAY. THANK YOU DAVID. >> ALL RIGHT. MIKE (INDISCERNIBLE). >> GOOD AFTERNOON OR GOOD EVENING, MIKE (INDISCERNIBLE). WITH THE FIRM OF MIKE SAWYER. I WOULD LIKE TO ADD THAT MCKENZIE IS HERE, WHO IS ALSO ONE OF THE SPEAKERS, AND SHE CAN FILL IN SOMETHING THAT I WON'T BE ABLE TO. TRAFFIC, WE WORKED WITH A NUMBER OF TRAFFIC ENGINEERS IN THIS COMMUNITY. SO STUDIES HAVE BEEN DONE FOR VARIOUS TYPES OF PROJECTS WHETHER THEY ARE APARTMENT TO INCUR AND TO HAVE A MUCH SMALLER TRAFFIC VOLUME FOR THE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DIVISIONS. THESE ARE THE NUMBERS THAT THEY ARE USING AND WE CAN PROVIDE THAT DATA TO PLANNING IF YOU LIKE, BUT I THINK THAT IT'S PROBABLY DISCUSSED IN THE STUDY. SO ANY WAY THAT'S WHERE THE NUMBERS COME FROM, FOR THE STUDIES DONE IN THE PROJECTS LIKE THIS AS FAR AS, THE TREE ISSUE. NOT TO BEAT A DEAD HORSE, BECAUSE OF THE DENSITY, WE'RE SAVING ONE TREE IN THE AREA OF DEVELOPMENT AND SO DANNY BROKE IT OUT THAT WAY, AND THE TREES WITHIN THE PIPER WAY EXTENSION, UM, ARE ALSO NOT BEING SAVED, AND BY THE WAY, THE EXTENSION IS UNIQUE IN THE WAYS WHERE A LOT OF THE TIMES THEY ARE EXTENDING THE PIPER WAY IN THIS PROJECT, PIPER WAY IS NOT NEEDED. AND THAT'S REALLY NOT THE CASE. PIPER WAY EXISTS TO THE WEST AS A DEAD END ROAD, THAT CURRENTLY SERVICES A NUMBER OF SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HOMES, AND THEY HAVE ONE WAY IN AND ONE WAY OUT. AND THAT'S WHAT THE FAMILY HAS GONE THROUGH IN THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS, THIS EXTENSION IS ALONG WITH ANOTHER PROJECT TO THE WEST THAT IS LOOKING TO BREAK GROUND FOR THIS SUMMER. TO CREATE A LOOP SO THE PEOPLE THAT ARE IN THE HOMES IN THE BACK HAVE TWO-WAYS IN AND OUT OF THEIR HOMES WHICH IS VERY VERY IMPORTANT IN THESE HIGH FIRE HAZARD AREAS. AND I THINK THAT DRAINAGE WAS ADDRESSED, I'M NOT SURE TO THE SUBJECT ON THIS TIMEFRAME. BUT WE'RE ALSO REQUIRED TO MITIGATE FOR WATER QUALITY AND WATER QUANTITY SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE ANYMORE IN THE POST DEVELOPMENT STATE. THIS IS NO EXCEPTION WE'RE DOING THAT AS WELL. FOR THE WATER DETENTION AND THE WATER QUALITY MEASURES. I'M JUST GOING TO GO OUT A LITTLE BIT IN A LIMB BECAUSE WE HAVE DONE THESE PROJECTS WITH OTHER LOCAL DEVELOPERS. MY OTHER QUESTION IS WHO'S GOING TO LIVE HERE FROM WHAT I HAVE SEEN IN OTHER HOMES. A LOT OF THEM ARE SINGLE MOMS WITH KIDS, AND YOU KNOW, THEY ARE NOT HOMELESS BUT THEY NEED A PLACE TO LIVE, THEY NEED AN AFFORDABLE PLACE TO LIVE WHERE THEIR KIDS CAN THRIVE AND THESE PROJECTS NOT REALLY BECAUSE OF THE CITY'S P D BUT BECAUSE OF THE FUNDING MECHANISM ALL REQUIRED TO PROVIDE RECREATIONAL AREAS, AND ONE FOR SMALLER CHILDREN AND ONES FOR THE GOOD FOR NOTHING TEENAGERS. DID I SAY THAT OUT LOUD? THESE ARE INCORPORATED IN THIS PROJECT. I LIKE THE IDEA OF NOT TAKING PEOPLE THAT ARE LOW-INCOME AND JAMMING THEM IN ONE AREA, BUT INCORPORATING INTO AN OPPORTUNITY AND HELPING THEM TO BE SUCCESSFUL. IF THERE'S ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER THOSE. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> UH-HUH. >> AND MCKENZIE, DO YOU WANT TO SPEAK? >> AND FOLLOWED BY TIM WRIGHT. >> GOOD AFTERNOON PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBERS, MY NAME IS MCKENZIE DIBBL. I'M REPRESENTING THE PROJECT, AND I AM EXCITED TO BE HERE. WE STARTED IN 2021 WITH THE PURCHASING CONTRACT THAT WE SIGNED. AND WE DESCRIBED EARLIER IN TERMS OF ACCESS AND SEWER LINES BUT WITH A LOT OF HARD WORK, WE HELPED TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEMS, AND WE'RE ON OUR WAY TO GETTING A PROJECT, AND I THINK THAT I WON'T GO INTO MUCH INTO DETAIL. LIKE I SAID EARLIER, IT WILL BE ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE FOR PEOPLE, FOR THE PEOPLE IN SHASTA COUNTY. I WANT TO THANK D D H ARCHITECTURE. WE HAVE DONE 2 PROJECTS WITH THEM SO FAR AND THEY DO FANTASTIC WORK. AND A HUGE THANK YOU TO MIKE (INDISCERNIBLE) WHO HAS BEEN WONDERFUL IN HELPING US OUT WITH THE SEWER ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN SOLVED AS WELL AS THE CHALLENGES WITH ACCESS, AND I ALSO WANTED TO SAY THANK YOU TO DANNY AND LILI WITH THE CITY WHO HAVE BEEN RESPONSIVE AND PROFESSIONAL TO WORK WITH. AND WE'RE EXCITED ABOUT THIS PROJECT AND WE ALREADY HAVE 16 UNITS OF PROJECT BASE VOUCHERS AWARDED WITH THE AUTHORITY. SO THIS ENTITLEMENT PIECE IS THE NEXT PIECE OF THE PROJECT TO UNLOCK IT. AND AS WELL AS RECEIVE THE TAX CREDIT. SO UM, THAT'S PRETTY MUCH WHAT I WANT TO SAY, I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME. IF YOU HAVE ANYMORE QUESTIONS FOR ME, LET ME KNOW. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, VERY MUCH. >> I WANTED TO AGREE WITH THE GUY FOR WHAT HE SAID. I HAVE TWO YOUNG TEENAGERS WHO DRIVE AND I HATE THAT THEY HAVE TO NAVIGATE THROUGH THAT AND MAKING IT WORSE. I DON'T KNOW HOW IT IS A BENEFIT OR A+ THAT THE PEOPLE THAT LIVE THERE DON'T HAVE CARS AND PRETTY QUICK WAYS OUT OF DOWN WITH NO CARS, IF THAT NUMBER IS SO LOW THAT DOESN'T AFFECT TRAFFIC IT'S NOT IN KEEPING WITH THE OTHER THINGS GOING ON IN THE AREA. IT'S HARD TO THINK OF A REASON THAT WOULD HAPPEN OTHER THAN THE DEVELOPERS MAKING MONEY OFF OF IT. THAT'S IT. THANK YOU, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE WHO WISH TO ADDRESS THE COMMISSION. ALL RIGHT. I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING, AND I'LL BRING IT BACK FOR QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. COMMISSIONER MINOR. >> YEAH, THANK YOU. A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS. AND ONE THE DEVIATION QUESTION BROUGHT UP CURIOUS IF UM -- IF THERE'S ANYTHING THAT WE HAVE MISSED OR NEED TO DO IN REGARDS TO THE PARK NEARBY. NEXT ONE IS A POSSIBLE DUMB QUESTION, AS I WAS LOOKING IN THE MAP, THIS DOES ABUT TO THE STREET ITSELF, THERE'S A GREAT REASON WHY WE DON'T HAVE AN EXIT DOWN ON PLACER. BUT IT WILL WOULD BE NICE TO KNOW ABOUT IT. >> ACCESS TO PLACER IS WAIVED. AND TRANSPORTATION AND PUBLIC WORKS DOESN'T WANT A BUNCH OF ACCESS DOWN PLACER. BECAUSE IT HAS A LOT OF OUTLETS THERE. AND THAT'S ONE OF THE REASONS WHY IT PUNCHES OUT. VERY CLOSE TO PLACER. SO THAT PIECE -- IF THAT ANSWERS THAT QUESTION SUFFICIENTLY FOR YOU. AS FOR THE AIRPORT, UM, THERE'S A CONDITION THERE FOR UM RESIDENTS TO SIGN, UM, BASICALLY, UM, A RECOGNITION THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE AIR NOISE. THAT'S TYPICAL, AND *CHUSTINA RANCH OFF RANCHO THERE. WITH REGARDS TO THE AIRPORT ISSUES THERE, I'M NOT AN EXPERT THERE BUT IF THEY WERE TO INTERFERE THERE IT, THAT THAT CONSIDERATION WOULD TRUMP THE CONSIDERATION FROM THE STATE I WOULD IMAGINE. AND UM -- I DON'T KNOW WHAT OTHER AIRPORT THINGS NOT REMEMBERING SPECIFIC EXAMPLES THERE. >> (SPEAKING AWAY FROM MIC) (INDISCERNIBLE). >> I'M SORRY, PUBLIC COMMENT IS OVER BUT THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER MINOR, DID THAT ANSWER YOUR QUESTION? >> JUST SO THAT WE CAN GET A CHANCE TO -- AN AIRPORT LAYOUT PLAN -- SO DURING THE REVIEW IN THIS SAMPLE, THEY REVIEWED IT, CORRECT? >> YES, IT WAS ROUTED TO ALL OF THEM. >> SO THE AIR FORCE MANAGER WENT THROUGH THAT, AND APPROVED THE RECOMMENDATION, THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY ABOUT THIS JUNCTURE. THE AIRPORT'S DIVISION HAS REVIEWED AND PROVIDED COMMENTS AS THEY SEE FIT, THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM COMMISSIONERS? >> COMMISSIONER GREEN. IS IT POSSIBLE TO REVISIT THE TREE SITUATION JUST TO SPEAK TO MR. LEDGER'S CONCERN I KNOW THAT WE HAVE GONE OVER THE WAY TRUNK OF TREES AND WHY THAT IS SPECIFICALLY RELATED TO THE BUILD OUT. AND I'M SPEAKING TO THE 25 BLUE OAKS SPECIFICALLY ON THE LIST FOR REMOVABLE IN THE BUILD-OUT SECTION, AND WHEN I ADD UP THE TREES THAT ARE BEING ADDED. I COME INTO 21 OF A VARIOUS OAK BEING ADDED WITH SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER NUMBERS OF NON NATIVE SPECIES BEING ADDED. SO WE DON'T EVEN HAVE A ONE TO ONE REPLACEMENT ON THIS SPACE, EVEN IF WE GIVE CREDIT FOR THE TWO TREES OR THE ONE OAK BEING SAVED. WE STILL DON'T COME FROM ONE TO ONE. >> MY UNDERSTANDING FOR THE TREE ORDINANCE IS THAT IT IS NOT A REQUIREMENT. >> ARE YOU SPEAKING TO JUST THE PLANTING OF THE NATIVE SPECIES OR JUST NUMBERS? >> OF THE NATIVE SPECIES. AS DANNY MENTIONED IN HIS PRESENTATION HERE. BECAUSE OF THE M P D, WE HAVE A PLAYED THE LOWER STANDARD HERE, BECAUSE THE ZONING CODE ALLOWS IT. THAT'S WHY WE PLACED ONE TREE AND IT GETS YOU TO THE 61 TREE REQUIREMENT. I DO BELIEVE THAT WE'RE AT A ONE TO ONE. >> WE'RE STILL SLIGHTLY UNDER ONE TO ONE ON THE NATIVE SPECIES. THERE'S 25 BLUE OAKS BEING REMOVED. AND THERE'S 21 BEING REPLACED. WE HAVE 91 PLANTINGS. >> FOR THE PROJECT. AND I'M SPECIFICALLY SPEAKING TO THE NATIVE, TO THE OAKS. >> RIGHT, SO THIS CALCULATION DOESN'T TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE SPECIES. IT IS NOT A REQUIREMENT FOR THE SPECIES OF A ONE TO ONE PLANTING. THEY ARE PLANTING 30 TREES IN TERMS OF THE 50 GALLON TREES. THEY ARE PLANTING MORE THAN WHAT'S REQUIRED, 27 OAK TREES. >> GENERALLY FOR THE COMMISSION, WE HAVE A RESIDENTIAL BONUS PROJECT, IN ORDER TO PROVIDE MORE HOUSING, WHICH IS A GOAL AND POLICY OF THE GENERAL PLANNING AND THE LACK OF HOUSING IN THE AREA. AND THE TRADE OFF FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION TONIGHT IS THAT THERE ARE LESS TREES BEING PLANTED. AND IF WE IMPOSE THE ONE TREE PER FIVE HUNDRED SQUARE FOOT REQUIREMENT. WHICH IS WITH THE BOUNDS OF THE ORDINANCE. BUT BECAUSE IT'S A P D AND A RESIDENTIAL BONUS IN PLAY, AND STAFF RECOMMENDS BEFORE YOU ALL, IS A LESSER ACCOMMODATION FOR THE HOUSING UNITS. WE CANNOT HAVE THAT DENSE OF A PROJECT AND PLANT AS MANY TREES AS PERHAPS BOTH SIDES WOULD LIKE. THERE'S A GIVE AND TAKE AND THAT'S WHAT'S BEFORE YOU TONIGHT FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> OKAY. I HAD ONE QUESTION, JUST IN TERMS OF UM, THE SAFETY CONCERNS THAT WERE BROUGHT UP IN TERMS OF THE PEDESTRIAN ACCESS. WHAT PLANS IF ANY ARE ADDRESSING THAT ISSUE? >> SO THE PROJECT DESIGN HAS PEDESTRIAN ACCESS DOWN BY THE CROSSWALK. SO THAT CROSSWALK HAS AN ISLAND BETWEEN BOTH DIRECTIONS OF CAR TRAVEL. IT SEEMS TO ME THAT IT'S BUILT OUT TO BE ABLE TO HANDLE SAFELY A LOT OF PEDESTRIANS CROSSING. THANK YOU. >> SO THAT CROSSING RIGHT THERE IS AN ENHANCED CROSSING, AND THAT'S A STANDARD FOR THE CITY WHENEVER WE SEE HIGH VOLUME PEDESTRIAN AN. SO WAY BEFORE THE PROJECT WAS DONE WITH THE RESIDENTIAL IN THE AREA GETTING PEOPLE FROM THE RESIDENT IT THE HIGHWAY. THEY PROBABLY WON'T GO TO A HOLIDAY BECAUSE IT IS EXPENSIVE. BUT WE DON'T REQUIRE IT IN OUR GUIDELINES. BUT GETTING OVER TO THE SHOPPING CENTER FOR WHATEVER NEED IF IT IS NOT HOLIDAY, IT IS -- >> IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE BASED ON THE TRAFFIC STUDY WHICH I DO QUESTION AND I DO UNDER MR. (INDISCERNIBLE) EXPLANATION, I DO SEE THE 28 A M AND 9 P M TRIPS, IT DOESN'T SEEM REALISTIC WITH THE NUMBER OF UNITS AND PARKING SPACES IN MY MIND. ARE WILL PLANS ESPECIALLY FOR THE -- DURING SCHOOL TIMES. ARE WILL PLANS TO PUT IN A TRAFFIC LIGHT FOR THE SAFEGUARDS FOR THE FUTURE. >> THAT WOULD BE CLOSE, AND THAT WOULD NOT NEED A SINGLE WARRANT, AND HOWEVER IN THE CITY, WE'RE CURRENTLY UNDER CONTRACT WITH A CONSULTANT, AS ANOTHER STEP, PASSING IT TO OPTIMIZE THE SIGNAL AT PLEASANT SO THAT WILL ENTAIL DIFFERENT TIMES OF DAY, AND THE OTHER IMPACTS THAT CAN BE CAUSED IN THE OTHER AREA CAN BE MITIGATED WITH A NEW SIGNAL PLAN THERE, AND WE'RE LOOKING AT BUENA VENTURA COURT STREET. >> COMMISSIONER MIDDLETON? >> YES, THAT'S INTERESTING, IF YOU CAN FOLLOW UP ON THAT. OVERALL, I THINK THAT THIS PROJECT IS WELL DONE, WELL THOUGHT OUT, AND WELL DESIGNED. TRAFFIC IS THE MAIN CONCERN THAT I HAVE. THAT STRETCH OF PLACER IS -- >> IT IS DIFFICULT IN AND OF ITSELF I WAS BACK HERE, AND SENIOR HOUSING, AND WE DID ADD A MEDIAN AGENCY A CONDITION OF APPROVAL, AND WE HAVE A FIRE STATION, AND SEATED TRAFFIC IS TOUGH. WE HAVE SAINT JOSEPH SCHOOL AROUND THE CORNER THERE. AND WE DO HAVE HOLIDAY AND I'M NOT IN FAVOR OF THE REDUCTION TO THE NEW STRIPING OF PLACER. MY FEAR IS WHAT YOU'LL SEE IN PEEK HOUR IN THE MORNING AND IN THE AFTERNOON, AND I THINK THAT SOME OF THE SPEAKERS SPOKE TO THAT, AS THEY ARE HEADING UP THERE. IT IS BACKING UP DOWN THE HILL ON PLACER. AND I HAVE SEEN BLOCKAGES ON ORANGE, AND THAT'S NOT COUNTING FOR THE SEWER ROAD BEING DONE. I JUST HAD NEW TIRES DONE. BUT WITH THAT, WE'LL BE SEEING A NEW BACK UP THERE S AND MY FEAR IS THAT I HAVE SEEN IN REGARDS TO TRAFFIC, IT BACKS UP AND IT COMPRESSES, IS AND IT CAUSES FRUSTRATION. EVERYBODY IS LOOKING DIRECTLY INTO THE SUN AS YOU'RE DRIVING UP TO THAT STRETCH. AS I RECALL THAT AND USING A TECHNICAL TERM FOR THAT CROSSWALK, I BELIEVE THAT IT'S CALLED A PORK CHOP. AND THAT'S THE CROSSWALK, THAT'S CALLED A PEDESTRIAN REFUGE ISLAND, AND THEY CAN BE SOMEWHAT PROTECTED. AND THE PORK CHOP IS THE WAY TO GO WITH IT. AND THE TROUBLE WITH THAT, IS THAT PEOPLE ARE HEADING WEST, IN THE EVENING HOUR, TO TURN LEFT IN THE HOLIDAY THREE-CARS BACK IN LANE. WHICH WE NEVER EVERYBODY APPROVE. AND IT WAS I BELIEVE A CONDITION OF THE APT GRANT TO FUND THE PLACER ROAD WIDENING, AND MY QUESTION TO YOU IS WITH REGARDS TO PLEASANT. CAN I TRAVEL THE STRETCH SO I KNOW IT? SOMEBODY COMES UP FROM PLEASANT APPROACHING PLACER, THEY MAKE A QUICK RIGHT-HAND TURN ON RED AND REALLY PROPER CALIFORNIA ROLE ON RED. AND TO GO RED, IS AND IT WAS PLACID IN BOTH DIRECTIONS. IS THAT ONE OF THE IMPROVEMENTS THAT YOU'RE MAKING TO MAKE? BECAUSE THAT CORRIDOR AND TRACKS STOP AT PLEASANT, AND I UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN ABOUT NOT BEING ABLE TO GET ON ON PLACER PERIOD AND IT'S CUT THROUGH THE TRAFFIC WHICH I'M LOOSE ON AS THE COMMISSIONER, AND I REALLY SEE AS A CONCERN IS THAT GOING TO BE AN ISSUE WITH PLACER. >> LET ME QUESTION IT CORRECTLY. SO THAT ONE COMING ON TO PLACER, IS THAT GOING TO RIGGER A STOPPAGE PLACER TO ALLOW PLEASANT TO EITHER MOVEMENT? >> IS IT GOING TO ALLEVIATE IT? TIMING IS CRITICAL, WHEN WE GET FROM ONE TO ANOTHER. FOR ANY OF THOSE AND IT WILL MAKE SENSE THE RIGHT HAND TURN IS ON RED, IS AND NOW YOU HAVE A PROBLEM, AND IT WILL BACK UP. AND I LOOKED WAY FURTHER DOWN, AND IT WILL BE TOUGH TO GET ON PLACER. I DON'T KNOW HOW THE NEIGHBORHOOD THERE CAN DO IT. I THINK THAT THE NEIGHBORHOODS ARE BROUGHT UP WITH THE LEGITIMATE CONCERNS. HE WITH HAVE TO HAVE THEM, WE HAVE A CRISIS IN THIS TOWN. IN TERMS OF THIS, BECAUSE I KNOW THAT IT WAS GRANT FUNDED ESSENTIALLY THAT CROSSWALK I MEAN, I WOULD ALMOST SEE THE PEDESTRIAN TRAFFIC GO UP TO BUENA VENTURA OR DOWN TO PLEASANT WHERE THERE'S A SIGNALIZED LIGHT. WHAT'S THE PROVISION ON REMOVING THE DRAW BACK. >> I DON'T HAVE AN ANSWER FOR YOU TONIGHT. BUT I CAN LOOK THAT UP. IN REGARDS TO THE TRAFFIC THAT WE'LL BE SEEING ON PLEASANT, ALONG THAT TIME, THAT INTERSECTION USES RADAR DETECTION. SO IT'S AN IMAGE THAT DETECTS THE VICK. SO THOSE TIMERS ARE SET FOR CERTAIN TIME LIMITS THAT YOU HAVE TO BE IN THAT DETECTABLE ZONE FOR THAT TIME TO RECOGNIZE THAT YOU'RE THERE. WE DO THIS YOU KNOW, THEY WILL BE TWO SECONDS, THREE SECONDS, AND SOME OF IT AS AN EXAMPLE. SO THAT IF A PEDESTRIAN IS WALKING ACROSS, AND WALKING THROUGH THAT ZONE IT DOESN'T PICK THEM UP SO THAT IT WONT BE THE RIGHT TURN ROLLER, WITH THAT SIGNAL OPTIMIZATION THERE. THERE'S A SPECIAL CARE TAKEN TOWARDS THE TIME THAT SCHOOL TRAFFIC IS IN PLACE AND DIFFERENT -- WE CAN RUN DIFFERENT SIGNALS. EVENING PEEK IS WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT. I AM A DAILY DRIVER MYSELF OF THIS CORRIDOR. AND WE DEFINITELY SEE THE ISSUES THERE. FOR THE WEST BOUND TRAFFIC IN THE MORNING FOR THE TRAFFIC LETTING PEOPLE OFF THE PLEASANT. AND THE OTHER THING IN DOING ALL FOUR OF THESE INTERSECTIONS IS THAT IT CREATES PLATOONING WHERE VEHICLES BUNCH UP, YOU GET THEM ALL BUNCHED UP IN A LIGHT, SO YOU SEE GROUPS OF CARS GOING AND IT ALLOWS YOU TO MAKE A PROPER LEFT TURN AND OR USING THE LEFT-TURN LANE TO MAKE WHAT HE CALL A TUBE MOVEMENT OUT OF THE SIDE STREET, SO UTILIZING THAT CENTER TURN LANE WHEN TRAFFIC COMING IN ONE WAY IS CLEAR AND WAITING FOR TRAFFIC TO GO THE OTHER WAY TO COMPLETE THE MERGE SO HAVING THE CENTER TURN LANE PROVIDES THAT, WHICH IS AN EXISTING AND IT SHOULD BE UTILIZED IN THAT MANNER, WE DON'T SEE A LOT OF PEOPLE UTILIZING IT IN THAT WAY THOUGH. >> GOOD. EXCELLENT, I DON'T KNOW IF WE SHOULD TALK TO OUR P D ABOUT THE ROLLERS, THEY ARE NOT HERE. >> DO YOU HAVE A COMMENT? >> IS THERE ANY COMMENT DOWN FOR BUENA VENTURA TO 299 FOR THE SIGNIFICANT LARGER AND FASTER PACE LIKE THOROUGH FAIRS AS OPPOSED TO BRINGING THEM DOWN PLACER AS OPPOSED TO THE FORMAT AND ALSO THE ARTERIES OF THE NEIGHBORHOODS THAT YOU'RE DRIVING THROUGH? >> A CONSIDERATION TO MAKE IN OF THE SIDE STREETS WHAT WE WITH CALL A RIGHT IN AND RIGHT ON. GOOD WE HAVE SO MANY PEOPLE COMING IN FROM FURTHER OUT THAT ARE PROBABLY HEADING TO -- ULTIMATELY HEADING TO I FIVE AND ARE WE LOOKING AT PUSHING TRAFFIC BY THE BIGGER STREETS OUT TO THE HIGHWAY FASTER RATHER THAN BRINGING THEM DOWN PLACER AND THE DOWNTOWN BUT MOSTLY THROUGH THE NEIGHBORHOODS. >> UNFORTUNATELY WE CAN'T PUSH TRAFFIC THE WAY THAT WE WANT IT TO GO AS MUCH AS WE TRY AS TRAFFIC ENGINEERS. WE PROVIDE DIFFERENT ROUTES FOR THEM TO GO. AND IT IS UP TO THE DRIVER FOR THE FASTEST RUT TO THE DRIVER'S DESIGNATION. AND TRAFFIC MITIGATION METHODS SO THAT PEOPLE WITHIN THAT ROAD SAYING THEY DON'T WANT TO DRAW THAT ROAD BECAUSE ONE OF THE THOUGHTS, OR ONE OF THE POTENTIAL OUTCOMES OF THE THREE LANE SESSION OF PLACER TAKING IT IT DOWN A ROUTE. WE WON'T KNOW THE DATA UNTIL THE ACTUAL ROADWAY IS COMPLETE. IS AND WE HAVE TIME FOR PEOPLE TO SETTLE IN. THERE'S A COOLING PERIOD TO WAIT. SO WE WAITED THAT TIME TO SEE WHERE VEHICLES ARE STARTING TO MAKE THEIR WAY AT THAT. BUT WE -- AS MUCH AS WE TRY TO DIRECT THE PEOPLE, WE FOR THE MOST PART, WE'LL GO WHATEVER WAY THEY SEE FIT TO BE THE BEST. >> THANK YOU. >> ONE FOLLOW UP QUESTION THAT I DIDN'T HEAR ADDRESSED WAS BROUGHT UP FROM A SPEAKER WAS DRAINAGE AND STORM WATER -- CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT? >> YEAH, SO THE SITE WILL DRAIN, UM, THERE'S A UM, IT WOULD DRAIN SOUTH, IT ALREADY PRETTY MUCH DRAINED SOUTH, BUT THE SITE DESIGN MADE THE PROJECT DRAIN SOUTH AND IT WILL MUCH RATHER HAVE IT ON PLACER. UM -- SO YEAH, IT WITH DRAIN PROPERLY. >> SO IT WOULD DRAIN TOWARDS PLACER? >> IT WOULD DRAIN MORE TOWARDS THE NEIGHBORING UNITS AND IT WOULDN'T BE IMPACTED BY STORM WATER. >> NO. >> OKAY. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR -- WE'LL BRING IT BACK AND I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S A WAY TO UM DEAL WITH SOME OF THE ISSUES IN THE MOTION BUT I'LL CONSIDER A MOTION AT THIS POINT. >> COMMISSIONER? >> A COUPLE OF OBSERVATIONS AND NOT REALLY QUESTIONS, BUT UM, I THINK THAT THERE DOES NEED TO BE SOME TRADE OFFS AND THAT'S WHY WE HAVE DENSITY BONUS THAT HITS LOW-INCOME HOUSING HAVING GONE THROUGH A FULL CYCLE ON ONE OF THESE PROJECTS SPENDING YEARS ON IT AND THIS IS JUST THE ENTITLEMENT ASPECT OF IT ALONG WITH THE FINANCING AND OBTAINING THE TAX CREDIT AND NECESSARY VOUCHERS THAT YOU GOT. AND WHAT IT DOES IS, IT SUPPLIES A WELL NEED AND IT'S INCOME QUALIFIED. IT MEANS SOME DIFFERENT THINGS, IT'S VERY COMPETITIVE TO GET INTO SOME OF THESE FACILITIES AND UM, BOTH THE PLANNING THAT TAKES PLACE AND HOW THEY QUALIFY FOR THE TAX CREDITS, FOR EXAMPLE, BEING IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO RAPID TRANSIT IN STOPS CORRIDORS. THAT'S THE MATRIX OF HAVING THIS APPROVED. FROM THAT STAND POINT I THINK THAT THERE'S SOME TRADE OFFS THAT ARE NECESSARY IN GETTING THESE TYPES OF PROJECTS APPROVED. I WOULD LIKE TO COMPLIMENT THE DESIGN OF THE PROJECT AND HOW IT LOOKS AESTHETICALLY FROM PLACER IS AND FROM THE ABUTTING NEIGHBORHOODS, I THOUGHT THAT THE DESIGN WAS EXCELLENT AND FIT INTO THE CHARACTER WELL. A LOT OF THE DISCUSSION WENT ALONG THE LINES OF THE TRAFFIC AND TRAFFIC STUDIES. I'M NOT A TRAFFIC ENGINEER, BUT I DID ASK STAFF TO RECEIVE A COPY OF THE TRAFFIC STUDY WHICH IS MORE THAN 8 HUNDRED PAGES OF THAT TODAY AND WAITED THROUGH IT TO LOOK FOR POTENTIAL RED FLAGS. AND NOT BEING A TRAFFIC ENGINEER IS ONE THING BUT UM, I WOULD IMAGINE THAT IT WOULD BE AVAILABLE TO ANY AUDIENCE MEMBER THAT WANTED TO SEE IT BY REQUESTING IT TO OTHER STAFF. MY MAIN PROBLEM THAT I HAD WITH UNDERSTANDING THE ACCESS POINT NOW IS THE STACKING PROBLEM. FROM PIPER WAY TO PLACER IN THAT SHORT DISTANCE IN COMBINING LOCAL AREA TRAFFIC WITH WHATEVER TRAFFIC IS ACCUMULATED BECAUSE OF A RESULT OF THE PROJECT. AND I ASSUME BASED UPON UM, THE TRAFFIC STUDY THAT WE'RE SUFFICIENTLY HANDLING. ALTHOUGH I DID NOTE THAT ONE OF THE AREA RESIDENTS HAVE SEEN PROBLEMS THERE AND I DON'T KNOW IF THAT CAN POSSIBLY BE FURTHER ADDRESSED. OTHER THAN, I'M OVER ALL IN FAVOR OF THE PROJECT. >> ALL RIGHT. WAS THAT A MOTION OR JUST A COMMENT. >> HE WAS WAITING FOR COMMENTS. >> COMMISSIONER BALKOVEK. >> I LIVE ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THAT LOCATION. SO WHEN I'M COMING INTO THE SOUTH PART OF TOWN, I GO OUT BUENA VENTURA. I THINK THAT PEOPLE WILL ADJUST THE DRIVING HABITS A BIT. >> COMMISSIONER GREENE? >> I'M READY TO MAKE A MOTION. >> PLEASE. >> I WOULD MOVE TO APPROVE AS PLANNED THE UM, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT P D 2023736 FROM DAN CO GROUP. >> DOES THAT INCLUDE THE AMENDMENT TO 16 I BELIEVE A AND B? >> FOR TREE 52 YES. >> I HAVE A MOTION, DO I HAVE A SECOND? >> I WOULD SECOND THAT MOTION. >> MOTIONED AND SECONDED, ANY FURTHER DISCUSSIONS? ALL RIGHT ALL OF THOSE IN FAVOR? >> AYE. ANY OPPOSED? ALL RIGHT IT PASSES. THANK YOU. GREAT PROJECT. >> ALL RIGHT. MOVING TO UM, COMMISSION CONSIDERATION. SEEING NONE. UM, THEN I'LL MOVE TO NUMBER 7 PUBLIC COMMENT FOR NON-AGENDIZED MATTERS AND THEN PURSUANT TO THE BROWN ACT, THE PLANNING COMMISSION CANNOT TAKE ANY ACTION ON ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. BUT IF THERE'S ANYBODY WISHING TO ADDRESS THE COMMISSION FEEL FREE TO FILL OUT A BLUE SPEAKER CARD. ALL RIGHT SEEING NONE, WE'LL MOVE ON TO NUMBER NINE. DIRECTOR'S REPORT. >> YES, GOOD AFTERNOON, GOOD EVENING COMMISSION I HAVE A FEW ITEMS FOR YOU. WE HAVEN'T MET SOMETIMES, I'LL GIVE YOU A FEW UPDATES, SO PROJECTS THE RIVER FRONT. WE DID MEET WITH THE CONSULTANTS LAST ANY, AND I WAS IN THE INTERNAL MEETING. AND WE HAD A KICK OFF MEETING. MS. (INDISCERNIBLE) AND I ATTENDED. GOOD TO SEE YOU, AND THEN WE DID A WALK IN TOWER WITH THE SOUTH RIVER FRONT AREA CONSULTING TEAM, TO GET THE BOOTS ON THE GROUND TO GET A FEEL FOR A PRODUCTION AREA, AND IF WILL BE KICKING OFF A REALLY ROBUST COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT IN NORTHERN RIVER FRONT GROUPS, AND WE'RE JUST GETTING STARTED BECAUSE IF YOU HEARD OR HAVE FRIENDS THAT ARE ASKING. AND NOW WE'RE GOING TO BEGIN THE NEXT THREE TO SIX MONTHS COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT STAKEHOLDER OUTREACH. AND THE GENERAL PLAN IS PROCEEDING. AND WE HAVE ADMINISTRATIVE DRAFT. AND STAFF IS REVIEWING THAT NOW, MAKING SURE THAT IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE DRAFT GENERAL PLAN, AND WE EXPECT THAT TO GO OUT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS, HOPEFULLY BEFORE THE MONTH OF JUNE IS OUT. AFTER THAT, WE PLAN TO DO URBAN ROOMS AND STAKEHOLDER OUTREACH AND STAKEHOLDER MEETINGS AND WE'LL HAVE A BRIEF PRESENTATION DURING THE 45 DAY PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. MOSTLY TO PROVIDE PUBLIC OUTREACH TO THE COMMUNITY. I HAVE A TREE ORDINANCE OUTREACH COMMITTEE NEXT STEPS AND WE HAVE A NEXT MINUTE OUTREACH TO ATTEMPT TO BEGIN DIVING INTO THE ORDINANCE BY THE NEXT MONTH TO BEGIN MAKING REVISIONS, HAVE IT BEFORE YOU IN THE FALL. AND THEN LASTLY, I WOULD JUST OFFER THAT NEXT WEEK AT CITY COUNCIL COMMISSIONER BENNER WILL BE HONORED FOR HIS TIME SERVING IN THE COMMISSION. AND THE SHORT TERM ORDINANCE RENTERS IS MAKING IT'S WAY. THANK YOU FOR THAT PROJECT. THAT WILL BECOME LAW AFTER THAT SECOND READING. SO STAFF WILL BE WORKING ON HOW TO IMPLEMENT IT, AND BEGIN EXECUTING ON THAT NEW LANGUAGE, THAT'S ALL I HAVE AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS, IF YOU HAVE ANY BEFORE ME. >> WHEN DO WE EXPECT THE (INDISCERNIBLE). >> I'M HOPING END OF THIS MONTH, EARLY PART OF JULY. >> SO A MEETING. A PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING TO BE HELD IN JULY OR AUGUST? >> JULY, AUGUST, I WOULD SAY AROUND THAT WINDOW. WE'RE CLOSE, TRYING TO FINISH UP EDITS BY THE END OF THIS WEEK. AND IN TERMS OF PENCILLING IN FOR THE CALENDAR AND THE SUMMER PLANS AND EARLY AUGUST, FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING JUST FOR STAKEHOLDER OUTREACH FOR A GENERAL PLAN UPDATE. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? AND I WAS REMISS, AND I SKIPPED NUMBER EIGHT. ANY COMMENTS HERE? ALL RIGHT THEN, UM, I'LL MOVE TO ADJOURN. THANK YOU.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • June 13, 2023 4:00 PM - Planning Commission - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 91730ac2c823b3c0f65a478f5a46454a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record