POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, October 13, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 122,932 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch district one hopefully Curtis. District 2 and Council vice chair Brandi Gabbert district 3 on Mary. District 4 with that kind of way. Deborah big Sanders. And Council chair Gina Driscoll and district today Richie Floyd. >> Everyone will call to order the 10/13/2022 meeting of the year for the council we start of the roll call please ever you're not near him and what's your big Sanders. This cool air. Floyd there various here. >> Or indication today we're joined by a pastor vibe in this window of maximum Presbyterian Church. The invocation will be followed by the pledge of allegiance please join me in standing. >> Good and gracious GOD. Thank you once again for bringing the City Council together. As they gather to work. Held them collaborate well in mentions that impact our community is. We do not have time to waste on trivial issues which divide us. MAY we you 19 mission and purpose for the benefit of the people a beautiful city of St. Petersburg. Give them a descending mind. So that what they do and what they say we'll bring on the board results to our people strengthen them as they serve our community is bless them and keep them and bless their families and all their loved ones. This we pray in your holy name. The men. >> Thank you pastor for the beautiful indication, it's always such a pleasure to have you here with us as we begin our work for the city of St. Petersburg. Council members we end of the force for today's meeting we're adding item h one the committee the whole report from this morning's committee of the whole meeting with that entertain a motion for approval of a program that can we have a motion and approval. I'm sorry we have a motion is second to approve the agenda for today. Seeing that there's no request for discussion with the clerk punishing for voting. The members please enter your votes seeing none all council members have voted with the clerk please telling announced the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously. Thank you we have no consent agenda today sue. >> You will not find that on your agenda. Therefore will go to open forum if there is anyone who wishes to speak during the open forum portion of our meeting. If you could please approach the clerk's table with the yellow Kurds incomplete one. You'll be asked to speak at that time now with the clerk please read the the rules of open forum. MADAM Chair members of Council the public if you wish to address City Council on subjects other than public hearings a quasi judicial items listed on the agenda. Please sign up with the clerk on the individual wishing to speak MAY sign up, excuse me sign the open floor machine only city residents, owners of property business owners in the city or their employees MAY speak. All issues discussed and are open for must be limited to issues related to the city. St. Petersburg government. If you are speaking to an item on the agenda you MAY only speak once during the open form or when the item comes up on the agenda. In order to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address Council each individual will be given 3 minutes to speak and after which the microphone will be muted. If you wish to address to the council through the zoom meeting, you must use the raise hand feature but in the zoom app or star 9 on your phone at the time the agenda items address. When is your turn to speak, you will be unmuted an axe to state your name and address at the conclusion of your comments are when you reach through the 3 minute limit. 3 minute time limit you're immune to all raise hands will be lowered after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation use normal rules apply, including the 3 minute time limit on comments. The requirement that any presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum is live public comment is disrupted my violations of the rules of decorum that shares authorized to accept public comment by alternate means including email only and chair we have to be speaker signed up for open for one call them by twos and go to the podium. You have 3 minutes to address City Council. Once you get to the microphone state your name and address for the record. First 2 speakers John Schreiner in Maxine I believe Kaufman what I the pony and you have 3 minutes to address City Council. >> John Schreiner to 5058 Street North Saint Pete 3, 3, 7, 1, o regarding the traffic and a gas plant 86 acre disaster. The City Council and the Welsh administration dared tell we the people of Saint Pete, how much money was invested spent in law supporting the baseball stadium since the mid 1980's have you seen the current financial is for this Tropicana fiasco. You know how much money was lost and financing tax breaks or grants. The city giveaways are socialism. But it's ok since its corporate socialism to benefit your campaign donors. You know the city still owes millions on this catastrophe to have a clue how much the city spent on upkeep maintenance and cite support like fire police ems and sanitation for the events yet last year happy you voted out new proposals and are doing so again this year as you don't have a clue. This is a clear and present danger to the voters. Do your ignorance negligence or incompetence. If you do know tell us by the end of business. But you can't do it you do not know. I have a clue. I made a Freedom of information request to the kriseman administration. They sent me 10,000 pages of mostly irrelevant data which meant kriseman is Gophers were hiding easy answers. A source admitted to 400 million higher dollars which I believe is ignoring other expenditures in lost tax revenue just 400 million doesn't consider the current value of the so-called investments and expenses, the net present value would be over $500 million today. More than the cost of the new stadium. It's a Tampa Bay rays won a stadium, let them pay for the stadium. Why don't kriseman is Tony's give me this information why the City Council the Welsh administration want to remain blissfully ignorant and culpable. Some say there's goodwill generated for the city. The only good will generated just for your campaign donors, your banking developer contractor in real estate buddies who benefited immensely and are frothing at the mouth over 86 acres of prime downtown property. It gets even worse. The Welsh administration is fully surely considering 99 year leases or the outright sale of saying peach crown jewel, this is dumb and Dumber why because the moneyed interests want to fire sale is city property using our public Treasury to spend privatized by corporate bankers across the us all public Treasury has been privatized by bankers except the state on public Bank in North Dakota. The state of North Dakota also publicly owns North Dakota mill and elevator company. Both for over a 100 years basically your campaign donors in Tampa Bay rays have 31 access to our public Treasury kind of like their own personal atm sponsored by taxpaying residents. Forbes magazine says publicly financed sports stadiums again the taxpayers lose. I'm calling on the mayor and City Council to get these answers, do your jobs for the people of Saint Pete, not for your campaign donors and said why don't you consider it makes to screen enterprise zone with truly affordable housing. >> Maxine Kaufman to banyan Bay drive St. Petersburg 3, 3, 7, 0, 5, I am the executive director of the Jewish Federation, and a resident of St. Petersburg. Addressing the issue of the vote this morning, 4. The empty seat on City Council district 7. I wrote each one of you and expressed my concern I will read the email that was sent each of you and as well as the mayor's office. >> As a resident of the city of St. Petersburg and the executive director of the Jewish Federation of Florida's Gulf Coast. I'm writing to express my deep concern regarding the candidacy of brother John Muhammad for the vacant district 7 City Council seat. Because of MISTER Muhammad's documented vocal and public support of Louis Farrakhan. And he's openly anti Semitic views. I urge City Council to conduct a full and complete betting before a vote is taken to install MISTER Muhammad into the vacancy supporters of MISTER Muhammad. Supporters of MISTER Farah Khan and he's he filled messages are not representative of our great city and have no place in city government. I and the Jewish community of St. Petersburg and Pinellas County. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this critical issue. I understand that there was some misconstrued blatantly. False comments made by MISTER Muhammad this morning regarding a a an employee of the Federation. I don't think that that is a very good way to start his seat on City Council with lies and misrepresentation. >> And speaker MADAM Chair, Stuart burger. In a minute this for the record. Council members. Thank you. My name is Stewart burger and I am the staff person that was mentioned this morning. And I'm here because I'm very very upset with what happened this morning. My words were misconstrued. I am the community relations Council associate at the Jewish Federation of Florida's Gulf Coast and I'm here to say that the Federation does not support a man who was shown past support of minister Farrakhan. A man who time and time spoken out against the Jewish community and many other minority groups while brother John has made himself available to us. Neither I nor any other staff member at the Federation of been in direct contact with him. I did mention private conversations with a 3rd party that I perhaps meet with with him in the future because part of my job is interfaith relations and part of interfaith relations is creating bridges. But I in no way said that I support. What happened this It's been a great lesson for myself. You have to have be very careful with private job with other people in no way in no manner devices say that the Jewish Federation supports the nomination of brother John Muhammad. In fact the federation's led the charge to make sure that the City Council carefully vets a person who once counted himself as a member of MISTER Farrakhan's army. And it's clearly documented that that's what occurred. So again thank you for allowing me to speak I just wanted to set the record straight of what happened this morning. And I hope sincerely that you do the right thing. Thank you. More chair, all right. Thank you will close have been form and go on to awards and presentations one item in this category today, Andy won the proclamation. Appointing Gloria me. As a lawyer for the city of St. Petersburg say that that for the proclamation today, we're joined by our American welts. Thank you MADAM Chair council members of the public and our great Saint Pete staff it's great to be here. You MAY have noticed we're joined by many leaders from a wonderful arts community today. And that's because we have a very important announcement coming up. I'd like to ask the list Davis our director of arts culture and tourism and MISS Gloria Munoz. Good to see you all again. The city of St. Petersburg has declared itself a city of riders to fulfill that mission the city's first poet laureate was named in 2009 and Lewis stealing the show already and you know it's going The first person so honored was Peter mine que who now serves as poet laureate for the state of Florida. He was followed by Helen Pruitt Wallace in 36. He completed her term leaving a legacy of excellence and collaboration. Today I'm excited to share that the city of St. Petersburg has selected its 3rd poet laureate Gloria Munoz she is the city's first Hispanic poet laureate, and I'm so proud to be part of this historic moment. Gloria is here today with her family and friends to receive this proclamation which reads as follows. Whereas Gloria Munoz is a proud daughter of Colombian immigrants who raced for the love of books in every form. She's a dedicated teacher of creative writing and literature and an advocate for multi-lingual literacy and writing and whereas Gloria is an award-winning poet and essayist an author who writes across genres for adults and children, including a bilingual poetry collection Coppola to it. Poetics chap book a novel in verse and other works in progress. Gore has worked with literary and arts organizations across the city and the Tampa Bay area. And as a mentor to rising riders with a desire to build bridges between diverse communities. A poet and other creative pardons. And whereas Gore is a recipient of honors including the Academy of American. It's Ambrosio prize the muse literature award the creative Pinellas professional artists grant. The St. Petersburg arts alliance. Jim Ralston Memorial Grant and alumina multilingual writing award and whereas Gloria is the co-founder of the bilingual songwriting team cica co-founder of the film organization pitcher productions and for the law moose us let next mentorship for non-binary and female let next offers and whereas Gloria is a sister a life partner. And a mother to her daughter Luna whom she considers to be the most remarkable pom of all. Councilmember never fix. Sanders, I found out she's also a gift that is so I just thought I'd let you know that. Now therefore I can of 2 Welch mayor of the city of St. Petersburg Florida do hereby proclaim Gloria Munoz as an export Lori for a term of 4 years in the city of St. Petersburg let's give up. >> Hi everyone thank you so much for being here to all my Family arts, organizers and leaders who I consider my dear dear men Thus the love in this room is incredible and thank you to Mayor and to Celeste Davis for making room for poetry and for the Arts in our community. I'm going to read up on today and this poem was written as part of the same p arts alliance murals in mind project which is a collaboration. That supported by the community Foundation of Tampa Bay and it's one that links visual Rinne and performing arts with mental health awareness in our community. And this poem is written in conversation with Cecilia Lou as is mural the blue hour which is downtown you MAY have seen its its newer. And it's a pall mall just say briefly I was writing. Right before the hurricane. >> And. It speaks to the aftermath of a storm. We're split in 2 gazing toward the deeper blue. We whether what comes we hold fast stay. The course but would we ignore the neon if this moment was our last. I know I know it's crossed to bring up last especially now when we're supposed to spread hope because what else is there than hope. We learned to carry both early on holding each shoe lace before we loop and not our loss with hope isn't this what we do by we I mean the living again and again and again like skipping records of broken hearts. We try. We must because we are made of something like Stardust we wake to the watermelon Don. We giggle when waves Crest over our backs and paint a steal for a moment, letting a steal a little bit of life back just for us. Like when we watched the sun plunge and cool the peach parachute sky down with it landing somewhere under or on the other side of us. And with our toes in sand made of million year old rocks. We stand in the Corpus killer swirls there is no better afterglow to brace for darkness. As we did last night and the night before and before we gasped when we see the moon. It outlines our edge is making us our own source of light. To no one in particular or to everyone out once. >> I just want to I just would like to mayor Welch and everyone involved in this decision because I see in front of us great literary moments. So we photo with all these folks that would take forever so we do want to grab them with the family would you want to join us for that one that ensures you are looking absolutely. >> We usually do is a group at them. >> We didn't know until you to weigh in. See it over to pick up a new thing. >> I was right I in the hole. We've got more work to do so. Thank you MADAM Chair. Thank >> Well now recess, a city Council to convene a cra to take up item Siri to regarding the neighborhood planning program. We have staff ready. A little bit on the noise. >> hello City Council good to see you all again. I am here today to talk about the new proposed neighborhood planning program for the South St. Petersburg cra my name is cast human and ski I am an development coordinator for the city. So a lot of you have been briefed on this so you know that some of this information will look familiar. But nonetheless we're going to go through it again does tell you next slide. I want the next slide. Area. >> On the side to turn on. >> So today we're looking administration's request is for an agency recommendation as a and the City Council eventually City Council action. Approval of adoption of the neighborhood planning program as a tax increment financing program of the South St. Petersburg cia. We're also asking for the approval of the use of tax increment in order to fund neighborhood planning efforts as part of this program approved the use of tipped to fund public infrastructure projects that are consistent with the goals and objectives accepted neighborhood plan so essentially to implement the plans approve the use of tif to fund that's easier to see a few of these attempts to fund the implementation of neighborhood traffic plans. Allowed in a state of amendments procedures these would be nothing that would substantially change the program in any way shape or form and then find the use of tax increment financing to implement the neighborhood planning program as consistent with the intent of the South Petersburg redevelopment plan. So this program essentially has proposed provides funding to support eligible neighborhood associations with in South St. Petersburg community redevelopment area in planning and implementing revitalization activities that can expand our neighborhood organizational capacity and engaged community engagement and then of course along with the goals of the plan which is reducing blight improving public infrastructure increasing neighborhood level amenities and that the neighborhoods ask for and then strengthening neighborhood image and identity. So you'll see in the program that is in your backup documents a lot more quotes than this related to consistency with the redevelopment plan but essentially the plan did call for reinvigorating neighborhood associations creating a this program to help neighborhood associations implement their neighborhood plans and construct infrastructure manatee and saying that we wanted to work with neighborhood residents on identifying their future needs and then there's some more quotes throughout the program document. I also want to say that in the program document you'll see we talk a lot about how this aligns with other historic city plans such as vision 2050 the complete streets implementation plan the ios app so we're really trying to make sure that this is an implementation mechanism. For city plans in general. So for some historical These are historic neighborhood associations in the South Petersburg cra the black line represents the cra boundaries. All of the blue lines represent the historic neighborhood boundaries. Now some of these neighborhoods are no longer active. But they were located in the South St. Petersburg cra this is the same information a table for those of you who prefer tables to maps. This also shows you what neighborhood plans were done in the South Petersburg Sierra in the past. And you'll notice that a lot of these dates are in the early 2 thousands or the 1990's. So the intent of this program is to really help reinvigorate neighborhood planning as a way to help neighborhoods their priorities and collective shared vision. So this program essentially has 3 different program features and I'm going to run through each of these individual early but this is kind of the If you hear me using these These are the 3 the program features so the neighborhood planning funding the neighborhood project implementation funding and the neighborhood traffic plan implementation funding. So neighborhood plan funding kind of has already mentioned we really want to help expand organizational capacity engage, but we really want the neighborhoods developed their shared vision collectively identify their priorities that will most improve their quality of life. Funding can be used towards developing new neighborhood plans updating existing neighborhood plans and then being really intentional with community an organizational capacity, especially in those neighborhoods that might not have super active neighborhood associations. How can we best support them and meet them where they are in the planning process. So the goal is that all neighborhood associations will update their plans on a regular schedule as long as we're for this program and that would be maybe every 10 years. The city is going to work with the different neighborhood associations to determine the timelines for neighborhood planning. Developing a plan to intentially engage neighborhoods without active neighborhood associations. We're currently working on that is how we're going to really help everyone get ready for this type of program and then for considerations here you'll see that we listed some data I'm in for a day to inform framework of how we're going to kind of prioritize moving forward so we started polling data on blight such as code violations vacant and boarded crime data we started some data on investments in momentum's by neighborhood on building permits we already have the age of the last plan affordable housing data and consideration proximity to major redevelopment so this external pressures and then of course we're at what has mentioned really where are the neighborhoods and who is ready to launch a neighborhood planning effort and who needs really help organizing themselves more. So that's kind of how anticipate prioritizing for this first year. We're anticipating will be bringing the budget forward soon over into spring probably about 3 neighborhood plans to start along with some community engagement work. So the neighborhood plan acceptance process I I just wanted to talk about what an accepted neighborhood plan is because you'll see that term throughout this document. So first we with the plan development with the neighborhood Association we have well-defined noticing procedures prak immunity services Department to make sure that people are aware that these neighborhoods are working on the neighborhood plan will likely be hiring neighborhood consultants that will work alongside city staff and working with the neighborhood residents to develop their plan. There's lots of neighborhood meetings they're not properly noticed there's online engagement that draft or that plan is then submitted to the city and review by city administration essentially making sure that everything is legal and consistent. The neighborhood except their plan and that it goes the community the cpc for consistency with the comprehensive plan and as part of this program it would also go to the south Petersburg cac for recommendation of acceptance as eligible for this program and then finally ago to you all. For to make sure that you have seen the plan and accept that the feature of this. The program is the neighborhood project implementation is this is really where can we use e r a tif dollars to fund some of the efforts of neighborhood plans and so I want to first start off by saying that this is tif funding that we're talking about through this particular program that that does not mean that we're not going to be looking for other money other places to fund these fund the implementation of plans which we already deal. So the purpose of this is to really make sure that we're not just creating what a planner would call their worst nightmare plan on the shelf we want to implement these plans these neighborhoods work really these plans and they should be able to implement them and so this is going to create a formalized process for neighborhoods to request to funding for their priority projects within a bread plans. Help us improve public facilities increase neighborhood amenities that improve quality of life. The eligibility criteria and the program is essentially that you need to have that accepted neighborhood plan they need to be recognized active neighborhood Association that of course our general things of it needs to be in a cra boundaries that needs to be consistent with the accepted neighborhood plan Amanda has of course be consistent with everything as far as you know commercial corridors and complete streets administrative policies go. Project types that fit under project implementation we kind of a bucket of these in the 4 major themes and there's project types under each of these themes in your backup documents the program has a bunch of tables and that's kind of laying out the next few slides that you'll see tables one through 4. But essentially the project types boil down to beautification states giving placemaking multi-modal transportation ability parks, green spaces, recreational facilities, you know bigger bucket of community development and neighborhood safety. So I'll go through these a bit quick, but you can see in the document essentially their while to find that state furniture streetlights public art creative placemaking replace keeping. Street trees in Planters and then historic preservation would be in this first bucket. Our second bucko the multi-modal transportation ability this is a lot of those themes that you find out of our complete streets plan but implemented on the neighborhood level so things like traffic calming the neighborhood says that that is their priority their kids are playing in the street they want to slow down traffic. They're able to get to go through this program to potentially get funding for that pedestrian facilities such as sidewalk expansion. Bicycle facilities multi-modal on public parking facilities and bus stop improvements, things like shade and lighting and ada improvements. We also parks green space and recreational facilities this could include new parks, this could include Park expansions this could trail improvements include playgrounds exercise owns maybe a neighborhood really want some signage along the walking trail in their Park. They say that that's their priority then that would be applied for project and then we also have community development and neighborhood safety said these could be things like Sept had crime prevention through environmental design assessments and design strategies to address a neighborhood identified issue community-based urban agriculture and improving access to healthy food. One of my favorite project types fencing and other buffers and that environmental assessments are brownfield remediation and that's a priority of the They'll be able to move forward with that. So the process we're outlining for project implementation. I'm I'm saying that we're probably not going to get to this in the first But we need to develop a pre application process staff is working on developing the application and the administrative procedures. The application period will allow eligible neighborhood associations to submit applications that pre application would be a more discussion between neighborhood associations and the city staff to say like hey in our supplant Weise we identified sidewalks and you say ok and staff to be like ok, but where so that they're able to really define the scope of their own to have a really good staff review we're going to have objective criteria similar to what I mentioned before a blight public private investments housing type data informed approach and strengths and weaknesses style evaluation. We've got or review with determining the budget in priority order the recommended projects and then this will come through to you again through the annual budgeting process or budget amendment. The cdc recommendation and ultimately City Council approval of funding of these projects. And then finally there's neighborhood traffic plan implementation for those who aren't familiar neighborhood traffic plans have historically been something that we've done as a city for a long time out of our transportation and parking services Department. These are essentially very resident driven traffic, calming So this would essentially allow us to fund implementation of those plans and there's a well-defined process listed on the city's website. But essentially if neighborhoods are asking for traffic calming it's been it included into a neighborhood traffic plan. This would allow us to say hey let's look for Syria tif dollars and again it would go through the budgeting process to you assuming that you know. This request is made. Once again our administration request is to approve this program approve the use of tif to fund the neighborhood plans fund implementation of these plants are public infrastructure projects funding from station a road traffic plans and essentially find that this is consistent with our redevelopment plan and I want to thank you all for your time today. Council members any questions. Council member months nary. Thank you, MADAM Chair, thank you for report Cassidy and the one on one meeting so it in the back of a tour of talks about how neighborhood cost about a $100,000. What can you. On on page 4 of the report. It talks about. Funding MAY be allocated towards community engagement and organizational capacity. Can you talk about how much of a $100,000 plan would be used for that. Is he doing just that. Council chair members of City Council Tue., a hot community services director. Thank you for your question. Our discussions economic development staff about these dollars. The 100,000 is really targeted towards the development of neighborhood plan updates. One of the part of the strategy to prepare neighborhoods was our involvement really encourage more engagement and it probably in different ways so we wouldn't necessarily be using. The 100,000 specific for engagement to prepare those neighborhoods, but more so to focus that towards the neighborhood plan updates. We are talking about the you know the potential for. Other activities our office has the neighborhood mini grants we make available to our associations or individuals groups of individuals that are trying to reorganize so that they can gather so just money might not be Funding source to be able to do that but we do have some other mechanisms because we will be engaged and working with the neighborhood since that's what I mean that's what our primary function is. Okay and I'm just looking for a number if the neighborhood plan cause been and it does say a $10250,000 for neighborhood plan. How much money would go into this. It would be a 100 and it typically for the consultants to do a neighborhood plan update its its about a $100,000 and that specifically to go to the consultant versus the activities for the neighborhood, the activities with the neighborhood plan update. What actually be that engagement with the notifications and things go out and we gather that's it that's not specific to the neighborhood that really to the consultant. >> So that would be ok thank you. The last paragraph on that page talks about a proposed budget has not been propose when when would we see that. The proposed budget I can allow her to answer that question. I don't council We are tentatively scheduling the budget to come to you on Nov. 10th. Recommendation we made by the cac at their Nov. 1st meeting. We're proposing at this 0.600 thousand looking to to 3 plans. And then have money available for engagement efforts for those neighborhoods that are I'm not quite ready to go through the planning effort that we think there and. Important position within the city are within the cra that we need to promote the engaged in efforts and planning efforts. >> Councilmember fig Sanders. Thank you. Susie actually insert my first question I wanted to make sure that we're not using these dollars in place of the many green it. So that just goes back to the original neighborhood plant there are some plans that have been out there for 01:00am in the past them. 2 dues on it for a while and I'm sure going through the updating process we will see this some of those MAY no longer be needed. My question is though say they've been out there for a while hopefully they will be given privatization going into the new date of the next plan moving forward pending their relevance as to 10 years later. How we're going to do that so kind of guide me as to how we're going to be financially. Support those that have been out there for a while especially since we don't have a current budget are we going to be used other funding sources other than these tip dollars because they are not going to fit into the umbrella of many Grant. >> Your where we do have other funding we if neighborhoods are interested in projects and for example, maybe there's something that was in the neighborhood at the time they MAY not have been ready to bring that plan for words, but after whatever discussion are ready to do that they can also apply for neighborhood partnership. Grant. However, as we go through this process with economic development staff to update those plans. We also have separate dollars. For neighborhood enhancement so there MAY be opportunities. For us to provide additional monies, depending in terms of the timing of the book dollars budget. We MAY be able to go ahead and do that and the example and counsel I will be back before you shortly. We Campbell Park neighborhood plan update that has just come through the South for their review and has already been through cpp say so we already have as part of our budget and our penny dollars monies to begin the implementation we have about 50,000 and we have been working with our storm water. Crew to sidewalks so we want to be able this will actually give us a the ability to test some new processes because this the neighborhood plan update for the Campbell Park neighborhood is also down with a consultant. The difference between a consultant and having staff do it in-house. We don't have as much time to be able to work out the details to have a a a pretty good budget estimate in terms of what those project costs are. So one of the things that we will be doing on Campbell Park is actually going to the assessments the processes and more importantly, the engagement of residents that MAY be impacted by any proposed. Maybe coming forwards to ensure that. Yes, this is really what they want. And also to confirm that it's actually needed that there was during the presentation that was questioned about sidewalks as that sidewalk needs come forward in the future with this particular program. The neighbor we're not going to rely on just the neighborhood to say this is wants that we need the sidewalks were already if all you waited and assessed, and to really to have a better estimate so as you as cra have an opportunity to review the budget you should have a fairly good estimates and locations in terms of where those improvements will occur okay, thank you so much and so my question thank you chair. Thank you. >> It's a council member month scenario, I I had another the question. On the second on the last page of the resolution. It talks Now be it further resolved paragraph. That the City Council will allow administrative amendments to the procedures of the planning program without formal Council approval. We just need to ask the question can you define administrative amendments. Yes, so had some negotiations right now this program can be funded by both city and county Tenn so you'll see in the tables one through 4. We have where it's there's an access as city test where there's an exit says counties happen sometimes is a little notation that says one to 3 for the very specific situations where the county has agreed upon funding with their tip dollars. So one of the things that could come up as an administrative amendment would be allowing us to use more County money towards more things as we continue those conversations in the future. We would not change the project types we would not change anything really about the process it would be things like allowing us more money or creating administrative procedures so that we can actually even do the program we have to create an application we have to create a pre application process so just be those types of normal things that we have to do in order to execute a program. >> All right, thank you, thank you, MADAM Chair. >> On this You care to have numbers and as that term with the neighborhoods listed. Yes and there are that it says are partially within this area boundaries. How will the fun new work for those neighborhoods that are completely in the cra West so in the program documented South we do address Stott on the program essentially states that will consider how much of their boundaries in the cra. So for instance, Bartlett Park I believe is like 94% of the cra they're in the cra so we might be able to say we're going to fully fund that but you're only 3% in the cra we're not going to give you a 100% of the money towards your neighborhood plan right that they still need to do a plan so where are the rest of the money come from. And that could potentially come through the neighborhood partnership grant program. The motion is second to approve item Siri to and that there's no further requests for discussion with the clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes seeing that all. Council members have entered their votes could deplete good cause the clerk please. Telling announce the vote. And I'm sure the motion to adjourn on item c 2 passes union. Thank you we'll adjourn asiri reconvene a City Council and take up item. He won in reports which is to compete companion to this. The resolution approving the neighborhood planning program move approval. I can we have a motion and a second to approve item e one. Seeing that there's no request for discussion with the clerk please open the machine for voting. MADAM Chair that I have for the record that's correct. It's item f 1, 1, >> Sorry it's an incorrect and MAY she here was the one in this ef one on the f one team. >> Mountain air with the second mile. Riverdance correct. Yeah. Council members please and she votes. Councilmember fig seniors, you Thank you see now council members of over the country. Stein announced the votes. I'm sure the motion to approve agenda item f one passes unanimously. Thank you thank you, thank you very much. Earlier I skipped over and items are going to go back to reports and take up item f 2. 2022 us agreement. Good afternoon. Should we wait or really thinking ahead. Appreciate you having us appreciate the request to for more comprehensive review the This is a good idea I think that will help out a lot of How we got where we are today and some of the complexities that exist and why some of the positions we take now are so important to to maintain so this is meant to perk council member mountain areas request the kind of a comprehensive overview of the history of system specifically through the lens of less first responder agreement and again focusing on what changes in the 22 into agreement and then give you a little break brief update on how you messes as working in St. Petersburg overall so a jump right in the Pinellas County ems system is a a consolidated uncoordinated countywide ems system by statutory authority Board of County commissioners Axa's the ems authority and will cover a little bit more with their authority. What powers they have is that you must authority that board is receives advisement from the medical control board who's responsible for the clinical oversight in the system. The medical control boards and 11 member board of physicians. Health care, administrators and care providers that offer clinical oversight, so for instance when the medical director wants to implement a new medical protocol in the system. He has to get approval through the medical control board for that as well the em ems advisory councils, another advisory board and the system that the part of the legislation. It's a 15 to 24 member body. There's currently 24 members. On the body now and they provide system oversight from a qualitative standpoint so system improvements go through that. A group for changes in the system come through that group. The budget always discussed inside of that group as well that's representative so there's just a citizen representative for all of the county Commission districts. There's medical representatives Saint Pete holds a single see honored as well that's that's the fire chief or their designee Clearwater holds a single seat on the fire chief is designee and then there's representatives from the other first responder agencies law enforcement ambulance. Fire chiefs Association. That also served on that board. The administrative arm of the Pinellas County ems authority is the Pinellas County safety emergency services office. And that's essentially the office that takes care of all the administrative logistical and support functions of system administrate the contracts they administer the budgets. They come from materials and supplies in partnership with the ambulance Continuing medical education. And as minister in contracts, they're the ones who that's the offer that we we deal directly with the as contractors so the 3 main categories of contractors in the system are they less first responder contractors, those of the 18 fire departments that provide a lesser response. We are one of the ambulance contractor who provides the transport arm of the system there's only one of by design that's what makes us a public utility model and then the office of the medical director, so the medical direction in the system. It's by means of contract as well and then the medical director's role is to provide the medical oversight for the system. The medical directors actually would empowers paramedics by statute to perform medicine out in the street we actually operate under the license the. Expanded scope of practice or delegated scope of practice from the medical director. The system budget so this is not to St. Petersburg this is the Pinellas County ems system is made up of several different chunks. So there's the funding for less first responders again those are the 18 fire departments to provide a less response primarily. It's about $66 million for fy 23. It's an increase of 5.8% of 3.6 million over fy 22 those dollars are funded entirely from the ad valorem tax of that 3.6 million increase in a less respond agreement from 23 start from 22 to 23. Saint Pete accounts for 53% of that. I think that's a very salient point we're talking about 18 agencies. Saint Pete's consuming 53% of the new funding that fiscal cycle. The ambulance budget is 61 million. It excludes medical supplies they manage the. A medical supply warehouse is a part of their function. And the ambulance arm is funded entirely by user fees. So the ems millage or the tax dollars that the public pays doesn't fund the England time but all it strictly goes to the Ellis first responder arm and then the county administrative oversight. The county overhead costs about 14.1 million we talked about Couple weeks ago. And then the county maintains and ems reserve fund balance fy 23 beginning fund balance to be 62.7 million. So if you aggregate the full value of the Pinellas County ems system it gets just upwards of about a 140 million. With the taxpayers paying for that is let's first responder cost about 66 million. So they're really getting a $140 million system at about $0.47 on the dollar so it's a it's a tremendous value to the community for sure that fund bounce seems like a big number if we all remember back to 2000 8, 9, we started hit a pretty serious recession. The fund balance is what kept a lot of our services hole until took the economy about 4 years to start recovering some of those values so. That's that's been a good thing to have force. Let's first responder side of the system. Collectively our role and responsibility to pull this right out of what is the current still 39 agreement, the response of a nail us first responder unit are these are less resources to an ems incident. On spawn seen patient care fire personnel. The continuation of patient care when contractors companies so were the contractor right so when our personnel ride with the sun star ambulance to the hospital to help continue care with a patient transport these are extremely ill patients extremely critical patients. The extra hands. We often right in with the ambulance company to help maintain that continuity of care and then the episodic transport of patients to medical facilities in extraordinary circumstances, so that's a part of our normal scope now and that defines the responsibilities of a less first responders. There's 18 agencies again fire departments to provide a list first responder services. Collectively that accounts for there's a less units in this Pinellas County system 78 of those units are County funded which means the county is paying for the paramedic on that unit. And they've authorized unit to operate as a county funded unit. There are 24 contractor funded lsu, nuts and all that simply means this is the county has not acknowledged that that unit is necessary to meet the level of service. It's it's something the agency chooses to operate for the benefit their own community. But it's not necessary to meet the level service so the county doesn't pay for the paramedic community but they do still fully support those units with materials and supplies and equipment. So the county still has to approve the unit to operate because they control what's called a certificate of public necessity, public need and necessity. 2 pc on ice. Good afternoon. So they have to prove it but then you know that the agency helps with the funding on it for people of the 102 units 67 rls engines, 35 or a less rescue or medic units now you'll see some of the nomenclature rescuing a medic unit. The only difference between msu rescued American it's a cad designation a rescue as a transport capable vehicle. A medic unit is a non transport capable vehicle. So they have the same function develop delivering a la service. They're there for the ems mission. But the medic units run clear waters medic units their suburban sars are those Johnny. Roy's that abc run around the non transport capable oil us unit. It's not related to their schedule. It's related to the type of vehicle is the designation between a rescue truck. Total the county funds about a 107 not about they fund 107 positions. Now all this assumes the fy 20 feet 3 enhancements in the system. Now those 127 possess a 107 positions as are seats. There's a staffing multiplier to account for the shift so each one of those 107 seats. You have multiplied by anywhere from 3 to 4.5 depending on the department to tell you how many actual people that accounts for the system so the system has about 350 to 400 funded paramedics. Of the Ellis first responder agencies only 11 agencies have staffed rescue vehicle. So those again are the patient transport capable vehicles. 26 staffed 24 hour rescue units in total again that's assuming the why 13 improvements that's why you see for St. Petersburg there's 11 we've 10 for very long time I think since 1990. And we had we didn't we certainly do have the lion share of those There's only for 6 seed 8 medic units in the system on transport people ems only units for those are 24 hour. Because they are the primary Ellis unit at those stations. And then there are 4 people time units 3 of those are in St. Petersburg and one in largo now. The ambulance provider the primary transport arm of the system so we're going to think about that 911 transport piece of course they do that but they also do all the non-emergent transport work this is moving patients out of the hospital into rehab facilities or nursing facilities are moving patients from those facilities back into the hospital or moving them among even hospitals for procedures. They also provide all the critical care transport services whether those are adult or pediatric so this company also staffs the ambulance out of all children's that does all the pediatric a critical care transfers in the region. And they do it you must event standby so high school football games races, special events throughout the county we partner with them regularly on our major events for extra staffing resources. They provide and maintain the ambulance fleet. Even though the county owns the If they're able to provide or ever leave. They operate decentralized medical supply warehouse. They operate the mass communication center so this is the calm center that dispatches all the ambulances also handles all the scheduled transfers and the non-emergency work. Those were that's where all those requests go from hospitals are again long-term care facilities. They deployed dynamically so they're not station based. They deploy the hubs mission North mid and south of and then those units migrate throughout the day to follow where the demand is actually predictable. So it's you know to say how many ambulances are day to the next question would be what our the date you want to know will tell you how many are on that day but that he could day at the highest appointment they would deploy 65 ambulances over top of less first response there. Overall this is what partnered consolidated system accomplishes this is f y 21 the county puts us in for a graphic on their It's great the updated every year. A 231,931 ems response is this makes the system one of the busiest in the country, it's a huge system when you look at it that consolidated level 68 fire stations, 65 in England says the day on top of that. 186,000 emergency response is 52,000 non emergency responses, 184,000 patient. Transports that's the total those aren't all emergent that succumb combination of your emergent and non-emergent patient transports and then overall the community in Pinellas County sees 7 half minutes response time 92% of the time. So here's just a timeline to kind of take through where we started and where we got today and I'll share some of the day I I've I've mentioned this to some of you individually. I I don't envy the position or in to try to understand such a long complex history in a complex system in the small sound bite to get in and that's a huge challenge. We've gone through this deep dive into the history of the system a number of times most the time when we're in a dispute with the county. Or when there's additional questions here and every time we dig into its earned another little piece that we find another little piece we find a little peace because there is so much later on here so we try to really can drill it down boil it down to the important salient moments in time. The system actually started back or it started to grow back in 1976 things in 1974 St. Petersburg fire rescue begin to develop delivering dms as their own ems system. So we had a medical director we had our own certificate of public convenience and need if I got it right that time. And we actually the city contracted with 3, 3, separate England's providers to help with the transport works our transport work then was was episodic as well also in 1974. There is a legislative effort and legislation passed to empower a task force to evaluate countywide ems and what that might look like. And again that started 1974 obviously took some For that to get any traction in a really got traction in 1978 when there's a Sentinel event where a young man on a bicycle was critically injured and just outside of a neighboring jurisdiction did not get an ems response and ultimately died. And that proved to be the catalyst that drove the public outcry that finally pushed the policy makers to get this County wide ems system established that led to war for special act which was passed in 1980 that state statute 80. Bash, 5.85. A little record correction. I think when I was here 2 weeks ago I kept saying 85 is were kind of all the litigation happen because I tend to get that 5.85 mix-up with 89 which is when the litigation happened so those statute is 85 location was an 89. But that statute that established the ems system that we know today for the most part. It also empower the county to pass the rest of referendum to establish a special you mess taxing district and that referendum the overwhelmingly is about 75% of the vote the past so really 19 81 was the start of the system today first time the war was levied money was collected and distributed out of the fire departments. And over the series of the next years. That was really just done with the funding agreement by budget line item review and negotiation. There are agreements from 81. Through to 87, but they're very baseline that's it's we're going to we're going to report we're going to call and you'll find this according to our submitted budget they're not as robust is the dream is that you guys have seen today. This is what the special act established created a county wide ems authority to establish uniform standards so that's one of the authorities that gave the bocc Levy collect and dispersed have a lower taxes making enter into agreements employ people this is a key point Sue and be sued to put that in there because that proves to be valuable later on. Established Pinellas County Board of County commissioners as the governing body of the county wide ems authority and it created an ems Advisory Council we did talk about that Council already provided budget language for the adoption of a county wide us special taxing district which we cover, but it did establish a 1.5 milk cap for that district. It also was based on the fact that the existing municipal ems departments so that would be St. Petersburg could not be abolished without consent. That's a key point for when we get to the litigation phase of the history. And we're in a mess was already provided full reimbursement a reasonable customer costs would have to be provided. So in 1988. The county following some work. And research with some consultants try to develop a uniform ems contract. They wanted to put all same contract. I kind of reference that still a desire there's to have everybody on the same contract. And that uniform contract developed a very complex and what ultimately was ruled to be arbitrary funding formula that would have drastically reduced funding and actually change the deployment methodology in St. Petersburg it would remove the mess from our rescue vehicles. But on the backs of of Ryan Ellis engines, it was a substantial change and that same year the county passing the MS. Ordinance 88 staff dash 12 which really laid out a lot of the other elements of the system that still exist today. In 1988 all many of the other agencies signed the county's uniform agreement the city would not agree to signing that agreement because of the fundamental changes that would have created in our system. In 1988 the county contracted with its first single source transport provider so up until 1988 there was multiple and lets companies working inside the system. That's the first year we drove down to one ambulance company and they begin doing business has some star. So the county owns the trade name sun on that corporation. They hire contractors to operate so in 1988 that was a medic one. It's been amr it's been paramedics plus now today, it's paramedics Florida which is essentially a subsidiary that x plus account bought out. It's great for the public because they only ever see one brand even those different per year. In 1988. Because the city refused to sign the county's contract. The county filed suit against the city to try to force them to sign the contract. In 1988 then same year the county filed a temporary motion for relief and then they went ahead and file a counterclaim for clear taurean injunctive relief and that trial was held in 1988. Put this picture here this is one of the news articles, this is little inside joke will share with you of our command staff you guys are from sure for what chief cancel your training chief. Chief can see has a knack of always making it in all the big pictures. So we tease him about that you can see going to be up front and center officials so as I was digging through the archives and I found a picture and lo and behold there's a young rich can see in the background. I realize he's had this town for many many more years than we ever anticipated. That's him with hair actually in the background. So it was issued in Feb. 19 89 and it found what's really saying is in the red big points that found that the agenda of the authority the judge actually stated this in the judgment was the privatization of the MS. Within the city. So had the St. Petersburg not prevailed at this judgment. We MAY need to be having this conversation that could be a private ems service serving the community here in St. Petersburg today. It acknowledges Saint Pete was a legacy MS. Provider meaning we're in the business before this legislation and we're been in the business after the legislation so are not easily got rid of. It noted that the customary practice of establishing funding was based on line item budget negotiations. It determined that the proposed funding formula the authority was trying to implement was arbitrary capricious and unlawful I love that word capricious I I thought that was an interesting word to put on it like pickle right that make any sense held that the millage cap to not limit the reasonable and customary costs just because the millage cap was there didn't mean that they could use that to try to tell us what are reasonable customer caution. It also ruled that its its authority and power did not allow to try to circumvent chapter 8585 which was a special act. They couldn't intruder control the city's fire ems department they couldn't force the city to seize provide ems they could require us to use a less engines if we want to that's fine but we couldn't be compelled to do it because it wasn't our model coming into the system. They ruled that Saint Pete's not obligated to enter contracts relationship for ems funding and they ruled the authority must fund the reasonable customer cost of the ems the city's ems department. So following that judgment. 1989, the county filed an They didn't like being told that their funding for Miller was arbitrary and capricious with the ultimate leave that appeal was dismissed. In 1989 through cooperation of the city and the county a second special act was filed that updated the initial special act and the exchange and that was that the authority it codified that the authority has the ability to establish the ems levels of service provided that those levels cannot be reduced below what they were in 1989. For Petersburg in 1989 that was 9 stand-alone rescue vehicles. In 1989 Saint Pete signed our first uniform, a less contract. It was unique in separate to Saint Pete only because it contained items in it that we're the outcome of the litigation that the city had won. That contractor mean in force for 10 years. In Pinellas County signed a second their second uniform contract with the 17 other fire agencies again Saint Pete did not sign that contract because it didn't have the provisions and that of protection that resulted from the lawsuit. In 1999. Saint Pete signed its second contract again that was unique and separate because of the and some of the language that we have and some of those things are what will

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9085c636aaed9d23753e22d071a3d439. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record