POLISCOPE

The public record

DUVAL COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

2025 Value Adjustment Board

Thursday, April 16, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

2025 Value Adjustment Board

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Thursday, April 16, 2026 11:30 AM City of Jacksonville 117 W. Duval Street Jacksonville, FL 32202 Agenda Council Chamber, 1st Floor City Hall 2025 Value Adjustment Board Council Member Will Lahnen, Chair - Excused Council Member Rahman Johnson - Temporary Appointed Chair School Board Member Charlotte Joyce Council Citizen - Shirley Dasher DCSB Citizen - Dominic Cummings Value Adjustment Board Clerk: Jason R. Teal

2025 Value Adjustment Board Agenda April 16, 2026 Order of Business 1 Approval of February 12, 2026, Monthly Meeting Minutes - ACTION ITEM (Meeting minutes were emailed to VAB Board Members for review on 4/14/2026) 2 Public Comments - ACTION ITEM • Explanation of Public Comments (VAB Attorney will provide explanation as necessary) 3 Deferral Requests from Petitioners – None received 4 Deferral Requests from PAO - ACTION ITEM • 38 Petitions Total (list attached) – Ownwell (representative for various property owners) 5 Previously Deferred Recommended Decisions • VAB # 2025-000277 – Property Tax Alliance Group (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000972 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000973 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000974 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000975 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000976 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000977 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000978 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000979 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000980 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000981 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000982 – My Exemption Check (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-000999 – Steven Vockell, Petitioner • VAB # 2025-015001 – Casey Vockell, Petitioner (On list for non-payment tax denials) • VAB # 2025-015017 – Steve Goldwasser, Petitioner 6 Consideration of Special Magistrate Recommended Decisions - ACTION ITEM 7 Mandatory denial (by April 20, 2026), of non-finalized petitions for delinquent taxes per FL Statute 194.014 (VAB Attorney will provide explanation if necessary) - ACTION ITEM Page 1 of 2

2025 Value Adjustment Board Agenda April 16, 2026 • VAB # 2025-001383 – Spencer Fletcher • VAB # 2025-001561 – Albacore Jax LLC • VAB # 2025-001574 – Ryan, LLC, Brian Roland (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-001872 – Oriola Lukaj • VAB # 2025-002051 – FirstPointe Advisors, LLC (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-002707 – Ownwell, Inc. (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-002783 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002785 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002786 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002787 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002788 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002789 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002791 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002792 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-002793 – Judy Ann J. Keeter • VAB # 2025-004367 – Ryan, LLC c/o Bob Hole (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-015001 – Casey Vockell (representative for property owner) • VAB # 2025-015034 – Daniel Chery Other Business • Proposed Amendments to Chapter 12D-0, FL Administrative Code Update (VAB Attorney will provide explanation; memo attached) Announce date of next 2025 VAB meeting: Thursday, May 14, 2026, at 11:30 AM City Hall, 1st Floor, Council Chambers Adjourn OTHER ITEMS MAY BE ADDED TO THIS AGENDA AT THE DISCRETION OF THE CHAIR Page 2 of 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 33,050 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> good day, I'd like to call to order this 2020 the Value Adjustment Board meeting for Thursday, SEPTEMBER 16th 2026. And we will start with introductions. I'll make the excuse goals after the introductions. But we'll start with introductions to my left. >> Good morning, everyone. My name is Charlotte, Joyce School board member for District 6. Good morning. Walk Johnson City Council district 14 representing Jacksonville City Council. Good morning. I'm sure league Asher, the citizen appointed Council board didn't. And I'd also like to recognize our chair. I am the temporary chair for this meeting. Our chair will laden is unable to be here today. His absences excused. >> Also, the school board appointed Citizen member Dominic Cummings has also been granted an excused absence. So it's just U.S. 3 here today we'll continue down on the other side. >> Heather Poker and chief of Value Adjustment Board. Jace until council secretary and that clerk. Aaron board legal counsel. Thank you very much. And we will be going according to the agenda with the orders of business that are there. >> entertain a motion by the way, please forgive me. I did not recognize. And I know she's in the audience, we should the property appraiser like the property appraiser. Joyce Morgan is here in the audience think and her team. Thank you. And former member of this kind of the city council, I should say right? Let's move forward. The order of business, entertain, entertain a motion for the approval of the FEBRUARY. 12th Monthly meeting minutes. It's been moved and second that will be interred and that approve the meeting minutes all in favor. I all oppose. Okay, guys, haven't. Thank you. And will move forward into public comment. We have several public comment cards if there are needs for public comment. At the end, we will go back. But at this time I will start public comments with that. Tiffany, I believe the last name is Pinkstaff. Tiffany Pinkstaff. Thank you again. Good day. >> And Tiffany with office General Counsel and I'm the attorney for the property appraiser. We recognize that today's agenda is quite lengthy and is asking a lot of you guys to do some work. And that's in part because of deferral request. So on. This is Morgan and I just wanted to have an opportunity to to just kind of give you a preview with regard to the petitions that were followed by my exemption. Check. >> This is a the scenario. Is this. You you purchase a home in 2025. >> From owner that claimed Homestead. >> During the closing amongst all the other documents. You signed a letter of authorization stating that the previous homeowner can go and petition the just value of the property for the 2025 tax year in your name. The letter of authorization does not specify in fact, which are authorizing them to do is to go and petition to increase the just value of the home. The seller, then petitions the valve under your name to increase for purposes of increasing their portability to their new Homestead. Our office believes that the petitioners to not have legal standing to request and increase in market value because they're not the current owner of the property. And they're not. The person that's responsible for payment of that year's taxes. So in this instance, the 2025 taxes, we're asking the board to consider a policy that was adopted by the Miami-Dade that board back in 2021. Where that petitioners who are requesting an increase in market value must be the current owner of the subject property. Not only on the date of the filing of the petition, but also on the date of the hearing. And basically that obtaining written authorization from the new property owner allowing the previous owner to follow that petition or to move forward on a previously filed petition does not cure the situation. The dr has already issued 2 opinions directly on point on this one is in MARCH of 2017. The other is in MAY of 2021. This is in your materials that you received in preparation for today's meeting. Basically, the Dor found there's no legal basis for an to continue to maintain a petition on property that they don't currently own. And 2 previous home Hempstead under cannot get written permission from the current owner allowing them to file a petition for portability purposes. So normally we would ask the vab if they were uncomfortable adopting a policy or denying a petition you know, maybe you should go to to Florida Department of Revenue and asked for an opinion on this here we take the position that that's actually not necessary because there's already 2 opinions on point as contained in your materials. Thank you. Thank you. Our neck speed speaker is honorable choice market. >> Good morning. Good morning, MISTER Chair and good morning to eye participants and to our staff. Good morning to each of you. It's always good to be back here in the chambers. So I want to continue what our attorney just talked about. Just shedding a little light on the situation from the perspective of property owners, as she said, and in, please keep in mind that this absolutely has no value my office and to my staff. These partitions are not brought by the current owners. And that is what we're talking about today as the petition is actually paid for. By the former owner. There is a letter some station and I do have that letter is being used by my exemption check. And you might have been in some of information that you have there. But there is a letter of authorization that signed by the current owner. But this letter is very vague and it does not specify that the previous owner is actually seeking an increase, which could result in the current owner of the property, not the prior owner having to pay more taxes. Last but not least regarding the properties with renovations, that additional value has only then reflected in the just value. The special magistrate did not change the assessed value which should have gone up over the cap which would result in taxes. So again, not speaking. For value to our office at all. But just speaking about the current owners, thank you so much. Thank you, MR. Graham. And before we move forward you have a question, I think I am in the right posture to do this based on what they MR. Are. >> Is there some kind of action that you recommend that is taken by the board or requested opinion? Let me just say directly, I generally agree with their legal position. I think they're correct. And that's been the case for. >> At least a few years in Florida. However. I'm familiar with the Miami-Dade, memo issued by their attorney. We more kid asked me to issue a similar memo. Just advising what my legal opinion is and the board could adopt that. Make it sort of a formal legal opinion of the board. If they're asking for more of a local procedure. And across the board, something that the clerk essentially would administer because that's what practically speaking, what happened. I don't think that's proper. The board has authority to adopt local procedures. But those are more within the discretion sort of in between the rules. If that makes fleshing out the details of more procedural matters. I don't think it's quite proper for the board to having across the across the board procedure. On a case like this, really, it comes down to a case by case legal issue when it comes up and it does pretty much every year the magistrates should deal with accordingly, pursuant to the law. And like I said, generally agree with their position. It's not that I take issue with so. I'm happy to do that. I can say that it's since I've been council starting last year. It's come up a handful of times at least I've more or less for did the same opinion. Each time the question's been asked consistent again with with the position they're taking. And we and I'm happy to make that more of a a formal thing. I don't think that additional formal memo. Saying that. But beyond that, I don't think it would be quite proper and probably not necessary either. Thank you for that. You have is going to ask about to the clerk. Do you have opinion or where you think we should call here? >> To the chair? If I ask Mr, or question. As those that would be more appropriate for. >> For that type of a procedural analysis to be done at at the property Appraiser's office on the intake of these types of applications and that essence, they would deny on the procedural ground that the person asserting the petition is doesn't have standing to do it now, obviously, that would still come to the bad, but it would be on a case-by-case basis because they would appeal to that really more where this type of analysis would need to happen is is kind of on the front end with with the property appraiser's office. I think that would be within their discretion to I suppose, reject an application, honest understanding it's not the right person filing or entity. So yes, that that I think would be within their discretion. That's outside of the board's purview. Like council set. It could still come before the board. If they appeal that rejection or denial. So it MAY not make much difference to the board in that case. But again, I really think this is it's an important issue. I don't think that there's. I don't think it would be quite proper to have. A local procedure, which is really the only thing that it could be other than just that, you know, standing guidance from council that the board has formally adopted, which I think the distinction I'm gonna make there. If it's a local procedure, that is a defined thing with in chapter 12 to 9. Those are limited in scope. Scope is in terms of what the board's allowed to do. Obviously, board counsel can issue legal opinions. That's one of the primary responsibilities and duties of the job. So and according that, >> according MISTER Woods recording to and I'm prolong this you just have a question staff and this morning. But according to the memo about rule 12, the 9 it says that the subject decisions do not comply with that rule. That was one of the things that was stated in a memo that was being staff provided so that so I just want to make sure that we are doing what we can do to make sure that people's needs are heard as well. But also that we're following the law. So where it comes up, I on a practical level >> sometimes it can lead to results that policy basis. One person might not agree with. So there's a few different things that that can happen. If a petition is filed by the current owner and that current owner remains the owner on the day of the Vab hearing. That's really the end of the analysis. That's a proper that's proper. As far as standing is concerned. The underlying purpose of that petition, maybe it's not to the current owners benefit. They maybe see But frankly, that's not the vab is concerned in this in if the just whatever the just value is, what it is and what the vab, I think it should be concerned with. And and really all that baby can be concerned with is whether standing as proper on those 2 dates. And I do agree that those are it does happen. They do have to have standing on both those states. Are authorization in my opinion is not enough. A letter saying you can file it. No, but if it's filed in the current owner's name. That's really the end of the analysis and west. It's found to be fraudulent or something but weren't really getting into understood. >> Ms Morgan is paying staff and I know been improper. But I wanted to ask someone from your team is there's a recommendation that you have specifically have obviously reading memo based on what you've heard from the council and the clerk is their recommendation. That something we need to maybe meet with, applying for to come up with some substantive thing that we can do to make sure that we're working properly. >> Thank thank you for the for the question. I understand, MR. Solid surges position as well. I think where the confusion, I think might be coming in is that. It's my understanding that when you when you file a petition, I guess electronically, the petition is do populated in some regards from the camera system that the property appraiser maintains. So if. My exemption check files a petition on behalf of previous owner. The petitioner will be auto populated with the current owner. So on its face, it looks like the current owner is the petitioner. But in fact, the current owner is not the petitioner. >> Its the former owner represented by my exemption. Check by virtue of this letter of authorization which is not legal. So that's I think that's where part of the problem comes in because we did challenge in advance or we tried to challenge in advance. These petitions going forward before they were is set for hearing. But that request was denied. So then we went back and said, well, can we have a hearing with both an attorney magistrate and a special magistrate then because now we have a legal question and usually these would only be before a special magistrate on the actual valuation issue. And we were denied that request because technically and I think MR. Or is right. There's nothing in the rules for the statute that says an attorney magistrate would hear this issue of standing or jurisdiction, if you will. So both of those avenues were not possible for us. And so that's why we've come in said, well, Miami-Dade has this policy. We're basically they're not setting for hearing these petitions that are, in fact, filed on behalf of prior owners to increase value. That was really what we were recommending that board consider. In the future. We wouldn't kind of have this. That, you know, cart before the horse issue. Where the petitioner reflects that it's the current owner, but it's not. Understood. Is there know, Heather, you want to doubt recognize you and also if there's anything from the board members, okay. >> photo. >> We are okay with. MAY be getting together proposing something. However, at that, this is more of a discussion for the organizational meeting to kick off the year. We're at the end now. I I agree there are issues for next, but I think that it should start next year in the 2026 year. And we need AUGUST. Whoever's on the board, this can be something we can maybe try and figure out together and go forward that way. >> I was just I thank you for bringing was cold. And I was just going to say, while it was an interesting question were obviously at the end of this year and with all due respect, I don't think we should wait until AUGUST. Whoever's going to be on the board, back or not. I believe that's in the essence of continuity so that things are done. If you could get together with the property appraiser's team and maybe find something to make a recommendation so that all with sir and Everybody can kind of look at it apart. Put it together. Make sure it Thanks for the discussion. And I think that we found something. Yeah, that that's a good solution. Moving forward. We are at item number 3 on the agenda, which is the deferral request from petitioners. 9 have been received so we can move on to item 4. Item riff for other deferral requests. There are 38 petitions total. The lists are in the agenda and there the representatives for various property owners is on. Well, with that list, I believe I need to move too excited. Entertain a motion to accept the list, MR. 2. >> I apologize. Was the chair of going back to item number 2. Is that those the only 2 public comment cards that you received. That's all I saw more somewhere down. And I just wanted you to confirm that there yes, yes, that is all the public comment cards that have been recent que ser. Yes. And I, you know, Mr just to make sure I will ask again at the end of the On to item number 4, I believe please correct me if I'm in the right posture, I'm not the right posture that we need have a motion to accept the deferral requests. I think this is what did. You want to weigh in on that. These these are. Simply new requests that have already been received and briefed. It was done on an expedited basis so we could get them at least before the board for this meeting. >> It's up to the board, but I would suggest maybe the property appraiser would like to present on these briefly. Thank you. That, of MADAM Property Appraiser, do you have any presentation you or your team, any presentation based on the different requests? >> Again, tough keeping staff office General counsel for the property appraiser. >> these deferral requests. >> Our in regard to what we consider to be inconsistent decisions that were rendered for similarly situated properties where the same special magistrate found that the property appraiser lost the presumption of correctness without any findings that actually s# # poor. Did that conclusion? We recognized, by the way that that I know. I know we've put a burden on the value adjustment board you know, requesting the deferral of 38 petitions. But it's all the same exact issue. We're concerned not so much about the actual valuation changes themselves because they're pretty much us what we're concerned about is a more systemic issue with regard to these arbitrary value reductions for this one particular special magistrate. Basically there were 151 petitions that were filed by this tax rep don't Well Inc. On behalf of 150 different property owners right and different properties of those 151 see it was 57 properties. The petitions were granted. The remainder were denied. We are only challenging 38 of those. 57 based upon how the decisions were actually rendered. Florida administrative code states that for each petition special Magistrate shot produce a written recommended decision that contains findings of fact conclusions of law and reasons for upholding or overturning the property appraiser's determination, conclusions of law must be based on findings of fact, for each of the statutory criteria for the issue under administrative review. Findings of fact, must identify the corresponding admitted evidence or lack there of recommended decision shall contain sufficient factual and legal information and reasoning to enable the parties to understand the basis for the decision and show otherwise meet the requirements of law. We laid out in our memorandum to the board various examples. One of that examples is this idea that we didn't meet the presumption of correctness because we didn't consider present cash value. But the magistrate doesn't in any way. Explain how by a preponderance of the evidence we didn't meet the presumption of correctness or why are you know what the factual basis was for us? Not considering present cash value. And generally speaking, you know, considering it is not the same thing is having to do an entire, you know, workup of it. It you can consider that while the property wasn't sold in the previous year and therefore present cash value isn't the appropriate standard. Instead, we're looking at cops for market value as a substitute for present cash value. So. Basically that it's kind of hard to prove a negative. But we're stating that these decisions were improperly issued, that they're invalid under the law and so we would ask that the petitions be tonight. So at this point, I do think, though, you when we come back, my question is assuming that this would >> to be a final decision made on meeting at the 14. The committee on the 14. Is that correct? I defer defer this and maybe it's to the clerk of out If we defer this today based on the recommendation is made from your office. Does this mean that they would come back with a since it's deferred not denied that they would have a final recommendation for the meeting on the 14. I think that it could cause delays why we tried to get it before the board today. Understanding that it's it's not an ideal. >> The timing is not ideal. But the board does have both sides positions, their briefs so the board can take these up today if the board would like to defer at the board, can we need to have taking up? And a subsequent meeting, though? >> I'm looking at the memo that you're under 18 memo that says that you recommend was that deferral for the previous meeting. >> That's the previously deferred ones under sta. That was and I think 3 of them MAY be understood, MR. You're recognized. Thank you, MR. Chair just to remind the board that were required to be finished with this year by JUNE And so there's one meeting between now and that's the MAY 14th meeting. But everything has to be wrapped up by JUNE. 1st, thank Marquardt. So since it was previously deferred, I will certainly entertain motions the other members of the board. If they're in the statement, you have. >> Please, you're recognized. >> Pinkstaff from what I read, it seems that this magistrate utilizes the property appraiser system sometimes and then sometimes not that's accurate. Yes, Kai because that seems to be a problem specially if it's with just one magistrate. That's something I guess we can take a flight thank you. Thank you, MR. Are recognized. Just suggestion. That's, of course, the board's discretion. But >> in my opinion, the the recommended decisions were probably legally compliant. It's arguable. That's for that reason. I don't like arguable. I'd rather it be clearly compliant leave. No doubt. My suggestion would be to remand the decisions back to the special magistrate basically to further develop his findings. And wherever that leads, the outcome is leads it. If it changes the outcome, that's fine. If not, that's also fine. As long as he basically supports his conclusions. With analysis based on the evidence. That is my suggestion to the board. Thank MR. Something was wanted to confirm that I just checked with misspelling or there is sufficient time to do that and still meet the JUNE first deadline. So that is something that I think is is within the ability to still meet the required statutory deadlines. >> I will entertain a motion if there's one. >> So MR. Joyce has chair Joyce moved to remand this back to the special magistrate. But I want to I don't know that it's proper for me to add, but I want to make sure that it's on the record that it will be done, that we will have that back by 14th Meeting for The MAY 14th meeting second, all in please respond by saying Aye. The post, right? The ayes have it and we can move forward. Thank you, chair on that list. We could just You're required to give directions to the to the magistrate. That's the purpose of the rim and is is to further develop the order in order to articulate the necessary requirements under the factual basis for the support, the decision as required by the Florida statute so that so that would be the directions back to the magistrate. I would wreck as as the clerk is said to the magistrate, please ensure that we are flushing out those decisions that are made and based on what MR. Call with your said, which you can view on the meeting, but ensuring that we do have a definitive answer. >> Number one, and number 2, it should be able to be on the MAY 14th agenda of the Value Adjustment Board meeting so that we can stay within compliance and have everything done by the JUNE first deadline thank you, MR. Clarke, right. Let's move on to item number 5, which of the previously deferred recommended decisions. And I just want to make sure I'm in the right posture with this. I need to go through each of the need to accept the ones that there on the spreadsheet or do we go through each action item? What is the huge action item? These are should be days basically do with the same as the previous one. Right. Brief. We will run through the action items starting with again item number 5. The first one is 2025. 2, 7, 7, which is the property Tax Alliance group. It is a previously the tougher decision. And I think I need to have a motion of correctness of woods or to accept us the recommendation. This is basically before the board for decision on the property Appraiser's request. So again, it if the property appraiser.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • 2025 Value Adjustment Board
  • 2025 Value Adjustment Board — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 90737e5665ed5c37cba29ae95feb0d09. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record