POLISCOPE

The public record

GULFPORT (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Virtual Meeting

Tuesday, June 2, 2020 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Virtual Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Gulfport Florida City Council Virtual Meeting Tuesday, June 02, 2020 City Hall - 2401 53rd Street South, Gulfport, Fl 33707 6:00 PM AGENDA Call to Order Invocation given by Vice Mayor Michael Fridovich Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call 1. Public Comment 2. City Manager Report 3. City Attorney Report 4. City Clerk Report 5. Consent: 5.a. Consider approval of the Council Meeting Minutes of May 5, 2020. EXHIBIT: Item 5.a - Minutes 05-05-2020.pdf 5.b. Resolution No. 2020-31: A Resolution authorizing a budget amendment to recognize proceeds received from Pinellas County Fire & EMS Administration for the purchase of fire rescue radios. EXHIBIT: Item 5.b - Memorandum.pdf EXHIBIT: Item 5.b - Resolution No. 2020-31.pdf EXHIBIT: Item 5.b - Resolution No. 2020-31 Exhibit A.pdf 6. Ordinances: None 7. Resolutions: None 8. Discussion: 8.a. Proposed Fiscal Year 2020-2021 Operating & Capital Budgets 1

EXHIBIT: Item 8.a - Memorandum.pdf EXHIBIT: None.pdf 8.b. Utility Assistance EXHIBIT: Item 8.b - Memorandum.pdf EXHIBIT: None.pdf 8.c. Filling of Board Vacancies EXHIBIT: Item 8.c - Memorandum.pdf EXHIBIT: Contact City Clerk's Office.pdf 9. Council Comments/Informational Reports 10. Adjournment Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the City Council with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purposes may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The law does not require the City Clerk to transcribe verbatim minutes; therefore, the applicant must make the necessary arrangements with a private reporter or private reporting firm and bear the resulting expense. Any person with a disability requiring reasonable accommodation in order to participate in this meeting should call (727) 893-1012 or fax a written request to (727) 893-1008. 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 43,507 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> All right. Welcome, everyone. Our invocation will be given by Councilman Paul ray. Followed by the pledge of allegiance. Follow us by rising. >> I wanted to read -- this is a letter that I responded because I was unable to make it because of my high-risk category. In this month of pride and after the pulse mass certificate, the community as a whole show support for all and as aspects of life. Including the blm movement. My hopes are that we will see great strides and change across our country. Implementation close to the massive gap. >> thank you, Councilman. >> (Pledge of allegiance) >> all right. Thank you very much. Roll call please. >> council member brown. >> here. >> council member ray. >> all right. We have a couple presentations this evening. First is from andrew burnham. Regarding our utility rates study. >> good evening. Mayor and council. >> welcome. >> thank you. I do believe that you're going to share the powerpoint presentation. >> getting that now. Stand by. >> we will mute ourselves and then we can ask questions. >> I appreciate that and it is a brief presentation so we should be able to move through it and get to discussion items. Really what the revenue sufficiency analysis that we perform dates back a couple years. Where we have helped jim and his staff look at the storm water utility and perform a revenue analysis. Capital needs, existing resources, the process determines do we have enough money to cover projected cost requirements because operating as an enterprise fund to be self-sufficient. Base fees and usage rates. There are moving parts that can change each year. We developed a process to take into account those future needs based occur rent information and trends and understanding of agencies practices and plans so that you can really put a telescope on your process and continue to make current decisions with an understanding of long-term impacts. As we embarked on this analysis we identified three challenges for the enterprise fund that are going to be present as we move forward in time. First our continued increases in wholesale cost from the city of saint petersburg. Just recently they had a budget and taxation meeting identified the preliminary increases for next year a reduction on the water rate which is good. We were forecasting a modest increase. So the net is similar level of expense. The water being lower but saw sewer a little bit higher. Our provider of those wholesale water as well as waste water for the community. Somewhere between two and a half and seven and a quarter percent in a year. They continue to address their own infrastructure and requirements for the services that they provide. The second challenge is that our capital improvement cost. It bullet points together and for the covert project and we have other higher costs. Some additional sewer rehab. So if you want to go to the next slide. So we're seeing more pressure financially this year because of the capital spent versus last year. But we're able to look at similar levels that we were forecasting last year to sustain the system. We're able to rebound on those positions in 22 and 23 rather quickly. So we're continuing to look at and recommend for your system an eight percent increase for water and sewer rates. Seven percent in 23. It was kind of taking into account those capital improvement costs. Things will level off. So there is a light at the end of the tunnel. Once we gotten our revenue streams and make sure we have adequate reserves. For storm water we're recommending a plan to add a dollar to that service fee. To continue to get to those revenues for providing operate and go expenditure requirements necessary. These things will combine. Making sure that we have adequate resources in reserves to address cash flow issues or unforeseen expenses. We're looking at round numbers an ending balance of one month operations expenses a similar level in 21 and 22. And in fact if you go to the next slide I do have a multi year financial picture for the enterprise fund. I can help make sense of it for you. So that the top line, the water and sewer rate increases are identified for 21 and 22. As the top box with the red boarder indicates in the arrow we're looking at inflation increases thereafter. The storm water that percentage continues to a dollar increase in the user fee each year. What that does if you drop down revenues versus expenses that black line the revenues that we have coming in cover the cost of the services provided which is the orange line. We need to have that black line covering or exceeding that orange line to make sure we're balancing our checkbook if you will. Our end of year balance is the top chart operating fund. This is where we're trying to achieve a three months operations maintenance target. Those number right side dipping a little bit. However as I mentioned fiscal years 22 and 23 they do recover after the implementation of those identified increases. And a big driver in that dip, cip spending. We do see higher near term capital expenses associated with the project and the important sewer line projects. In the future we have ongoing renewing replacement beyond those large projects that we're funding with the srf funds going forward. That is ape screen capture of what our financial plan looks like. It is a little bit tight with these projected increases. In consideration with the economic conditions, we felt that that was an acceptable consequence. Given that we will get to a positive -- back on track with in a couple of years. So I did have a couple bill calculations if you go to the next slide. Before I get to those. I want to remind not only yourselves but also on your constituents that these levels of increase are very common. When I go through local bill comparisons I can identify the levels of increases that they're anticipating and they're going to range between 4 and 8 percent a year. For some communities it is double digit increases. Much more than say a normal basket of goods to a household. That goes up at about two percent a year. It is typical to see water and sewer average increases between 4 and 7 percent per year. With the amounts fluctuating depending upon the challenges that you're dealing with. The long enter term they're going to be lore than what we anticipate seeing. Also locally. So on the next slide what this means for a typical customer. Very common bill within the community is for the 2,000 gallons or less. We identified what that bill is today for fiscal year 20 and we included garbage recycling. So you can see that $75.25 today. With the increases for water, storm water and increase for garbage and recycling. I would go up to $80.37. About a five dollar increase on that typical bill. We also looked at a higher bill on the next slide. That overall increase looking at the bottom line for the level of service would be $8.60 after you add everything up. As I mentioned we did compile local rate comparisons to put your bill into context. Until the tampa bay region. If you look at typical water and sewer bill at 2,000 gallons you can see gulfport many of these agencies have approved rate adjustment plans. So tampa has approved a multi rate ordinance after completing master plans that calls for about a seven increase. We're helping with the utility rate study now. Hillsboro county is contemplating now with a cpi increase to cover their costs. Clear water has a plan approved. Saint pets is looking at a little over five percent. Safety harbor they're in a five year plan, this is the last year of it. So again putting context to what we're talking about here what you're facing in the near term. What we see nationally and locally with your neighboring communities. We did the same chart at 4,000 gallons to give you a comparison. You can see that even at 4,000 gallons many communities are dealing with similar challenges. It is a tight range generally speaking on the cost including a couple of our neighbors. The last one is storm water comparison. We're seeing a particular amount of pressure on storm water bills. Capital needs and part driven by sea level rise impacts. Going to be going to public hearing to implement a new storm water fee. Springs is going up 50 sent a year. Many entities that are on 13 or $14 a month. They have a high level of service and done recent rate adjustments that got to a point where storm water rates are capturing the cost of providing service. Many systems that are kind of towards the left hand side haven't gotten to fees yet and many are in part paying parts of operations out of the general fund or other resources until they can get these fees up to fully cover the cost of providing the service. So that's relevantly it on the last slide. A bit of a recap. We're looking at a similar recommendation that we identify as projection for last year for this year. Eight percent for the utility rates. We're at a downward trajectory. We're recommending continuing for the storm fee of a dollar. Take into account any challenges, capital spending requirements to make sure that we account for any potential changes in wholesale rates. It is an important part of the process to make sure we're doing the best job we can to give you the information, to man major the utilities. So hopefully we have done a good job working with jim and cheryl. I would like to turn it over for questions and discussion. >> all right. Anyone have any questions? >> I have one. >> yes. >> I just wanted to make sure that those projections cover all of the capital projects that we have planned right now. And expenses that we have now in our budget and allocated. >> yes. I can defer to jim about the details about what is included. We did take into account capital improvement programs. So we have the 21 operating budget forecast as well as the identified five-year improvement program. I'll let jim go into the specifics on that. >> thank you. Yes. What we're looking at in the first two years of the capital improvement is relate today two projects mainly. Plus our ongoing improvements. The first two is the covert phase two and the sanitary sawer bypass project that we agreed to as part of our previous issues. What we'll do is offset primarily the bypass project involving the loan fund which we'll then include as we go further out funded by the state appropriation of $300,000 which we received. We have had discussions with the gulf course in the fact that we're looking at do we create something more aesthetically involved or do we do a simple slip line. That's where we saw the increase in the original estimate of our capital improvement plan. This puts us up tethered to the consent order with the environmental protection program. Manhole repairs. We just did smoke testing. We have phase one repairs. Phase two. And then we'll move to the lateral program further out. That's the funding in place on our five year plan which we'll bring to you and you'll see yes we meet the necessary spending as required by both consent order and also our settlement agreement. >> okay. And if the yacht club opts for the more aesthetic version, would they pay the difference or we just have to do that? How does that work? >> we would pay the difference. That's where in the crease is. We estimated it to be in the 500 or $600,000 range. Because work is that was estimated when there was no work. Now until one hundred thousand dollars more. What we look at is we're going to have further conversations. It would be our responsibility. The easement is there. It was brought forward to look at this price. Council will have that opportunity before they improve the construction. We do have $300,000 that we have to utilize in the next fiscal year. >> okay. >> would you remind everyone why we're raising the water rates because we don't have a choice because of saint pete. We have a lot of new people. So can you explain to us that there is a 25 percent surcharge that saint pete puts on. We have to pay the 25 percent. We don't have a choice but to deal with saint pete. >> correct. We and Mr. Burnham can speak to this. This eight percent increase has also taken into consideration what the 25 percent wholesale surcharge that was levied on you last year. As we smoothed it out early on, approximately three and a half years ago during the budget process. We identified that your increases were going to be substantial. A plan that brought those into compliance, but yes you're correct. That's the only store in town. We have looked at in the past the cost associated can you buy it from the county. The county had one or two things and this was, they wanted your sawer system to be completed you would absorb that. At that time it was over $5 million. >> thank you. >> any other questions for Mr. Burnham? Thank you for the update. >> I'm happy to be of service. Thank you. >> mayor, at this point I would like direction from council if we should plan on bringing forth the July 21st meeting the ordinance enacting these recommended rate increases. >> in order to keep the incremental advances going that's been the idea from the start is that rather than the 1 or 2 increases that we -- I'm open to hear what council says. I don't think we should abandon that track. Otherwise we end up with big surprises. We need to get square on this incremental plan. >> I agree. >> we made it over the hard part. It levels out and it will be much easier to take. So I agree with the plan. >> there you go. Thank you. All right. Our next item we have a presentation from michael bauer. >> if you can raise your hand I want to make sure that I see you on here. I have a kate bauer. I can bring them over. Hold on one second. Can you hear us? >> mike? You're muted. >> Mr. Bauer? >> I'll send him a text. >> or not. >> if we catches up we'll try to get him back on. Let's move to public comment. So let's move on to this point. Let's open public comment. We'll start with the ones that have been sent ahead of time. And then we'll move to the hands that are coming up afterward. >> I received two public comments. The first is from ann hum frees. Would you please install more trash containers on beach boulevard. And the other public comment is from stewart mckinney. In light of recent national developments I believe our cities permitted procedures need to be reviewed. I don't think it is a necessary for a police to restrain somebody by a choke hold. This maneuver was permitted by the minneapolis police. Such a procedure is lethally dangerous. I asking that you strike that from the city procedures. And that was all that I had mayor. >> okay. Do we have anyone calling in? >> raise, I have one raised hand. Karen? Can you hear us? >> I think I can. Can you hear me? >> yes. >> super. So really tonight I just wanted to say thanks for a couple of things. I really wanted to thank all of the homeowners that have taken this downtime to improve their properties both homes and their actual landscaping. When I came to gulfport I thought this city was so charming. I think it is more charming now. But it looks cleaner in addition to being charming. Of course when I say charming, clean I'm not taking about the trash. That is much worse. But the overall look of the homes is great. People are doing a great job. The second person I wanted to thank, I believe clay with public works. I have a real thing about making sure our storm water drains stay clear and aren't clogged. I saw a couple that were trouble some and I called them with in 24 hours had he a crew out there who cleaned them all out. So with the heavy downpours we didn't have any flooding. >> thank you. I see we have Mr. Bauer. >> yes. >> thanks for being with us. >> you're on mike. >> all right. Waiting for the powerpoint to come up. >> you were saying detecting problems. >> mine is looking good now. I see the slide up and the council members. >> all right. Great. So what I want to do is share with you some of my experiences over a decade long manager with the city of naples. And how they May pertain to gulfport. Next slide, please. >> so naples is basically situated as a -- most of the portion of the city, the bay is totally with in the city limits of the city of naples. Next slide please. On the left is a picture of naples in the 50s, in the center of that is a large forest. What that has become a huge development was a multi million dollar houses and we lost about 70 percent of the mango forest. 80 percent of oysters and 90 percent of sea grass beds. Next slide. So what we have been trying to do is work on getting some of these natural systems back. The sea grass beds are not comparable to gulfport with its great sea grass. And we were trying to work on that. Next one please. The other one was oysters. They are gone and they're great filter feeders, clean the water. Provide all kinds of nooks and crannies for sea creatures. The big issue is the storm water. The state of florida considers it to be the number one (Inaudible) In the state. We have a lot -- this picture is after the main storm waterfall from the city on a typical summer rain storm. The kind of water that was going in was incredible. Next, please. So when I got there people would tell me that naples bay was polluted. I established a water quality testing program. Wince a month we would look at nutrients and fertilizer levels, copper. A number of pollutants. Above that line you're considered polluted for nitrogen. A lat of fertilizer running into the bay. Similarly with bacteria. We were constantly above the state limit for bacteria. Next one, please. And the one that surprised us was copper. We couldn't figure you are out. Next please. And again we were trying to go deal with habitat restoration in this case people in naples hated (Inaudible) And we tried to restore them and we tried some planning. Through sustained research. And we tried this experiment where we roped off a county park to see what happened in we excluded people. Sure enough we grew (Inaudible). They were returning. So we knew we could bring them back if we convinced people that they were a good thing and not a bad thing and you can manage them. The other big issue was getting oysters back in the bay. We did a number of programs including boys and girls club and help us fill bags with oyster shells. So we put these out and next one, what we found out is that we could grow oysters and we were successful at that. The loss of 80 percent and the fact that they're filter cleaners. They clean out the pesticides and fertilizer. With sea grass that is a different story. They're -- to water quality. All we could do is measure the water quality of the bay. Next please. So what we found, we had the issue with copper. Trying to figure out what the problem was. We ended up graphing it with at mounts of copper but also the location. The two red spots stood out. There was a high quality concentration. Why in those spots? It turns out was right where the storm water out was there. There was copper coming into naples bay through the storm water system throughout the city. Next please. And we still couldn't figure out why we were having this copper issue. The city has over 20 lakes. They've been there for many years. During the summer the water heats up. They have low oxygen levels and there is a lot of fertilizer. Perfect condition for algae. People threw copper sulfate. Now we had to figure out a way to control the copper so people would not put copper sulfate in there. We had a resolution saying that nobody could apply copper sulfate. They consider copper to be a pesticide and cities cannot regulate it. Next one please. So we started planting shorelines that would take up the fertilizer before it got into the bay. Which is the main food for the algae, was not working well. So we had to try something else. We wanted to get that fertilizer out and we came across this floating island concept. We planted native vegetation on these rubber mats. Put them out in the water and next one, with these mats did was put these roots do you think and take up the nutrients and so the water would flow off the land and the mats would take the nutrients. Next please. So there is a picture of the island with those little pots with in a few weeks they were, we knew they could work for removing nutrients from the water. The other problem was the oxygen. And we put in a few air raters, they went on the bottom, the bubbles would come up providing oxygen and circulating the water. Fountains don't really work. They don't circulate the water. Putting oxygen back in the water which the algae didn't like. Next please. Here is what happened. One of the first major lakes was covered and we put in? Air raters. With in a few weeks we had the lakes cleaned up. We knew we were changing the quality of the storm water. Next. And again we had some residents calling us and trying to do this. This was a bond where we put in air raters and here is what happened. It worked. They took nutrients and put oxygen back. The algae disappeared. So now people didn't have to put copper in. Next please. That's not all that we did. There is also a major storm water to the north. The red line indicates where water would run out. We planted vegetation and arrange it so the water would flow into the mangroves and get the nutrients and pollutants out of the water. We did the ditch along the side. Diverted water. Planted it with vegetation that would take up some of the nutrients. And overflow into the main groves before it reached naples bay. Just a view of how it looked mature and flowing into the bay. Next please. The only problem with that is it dealt with a little bit of the city and we weren't concentrating -- getting the pollution before it went into the storm water system. We came up with this concept of rain gardens throughout the city that businesses and residents and city government could do. To try and improve storm water quality. So what was the rain garden. It is a flowered landscape florida friendly vegetation. Cleaning it up before it gets into the storm water system. So we started building this. It is just a depression where water would flow through and filter through the dirt and into the ground water. The vegetation on the side, the fertilizer coming in and allowing water to drain through and cleaning up the water before it got into the storm water system. Next. Paragraph one of the local churches had a big problem with storm water run off. They enlisted a local landscape company who donated plants. The naples high school track team came in and planted the plants. Next slide. Created this vertical rain garden. This was done in half a day. As it would happen the next night it poured and this area took the water off the packing lot put it into this depression, cleaning the water before it got into the storm water system and held it in there. Next. A year later this is what that looked like. A beautiful landscape feature that is easy to create. So in this case this was my office building. 30,000 square foot roof and the water would come off. We built this little system to take that water and clean it up before it got into storm water system. Next please. We planted it with native vegetation. And we created a nice landscape feature. This was a boy scout project. Out of that first rain garden and cleaned it up more before it went into the storm water system. So this is what the boy scouts created and in a few months we had a system like this that was taking fertilizer out before it got into naples bay. This caught on. We built another rain garden there publix, we worked with them. Then created a nice landscape feature and cleaned up the water. Next. And again this is another part of that publix rain garden. We worked with the browny troop that made a rain garden. You can see where the water permeates through. Next please. Again at a visitor center this is how it looked. Created a rain garden the

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Virtual Meeting
  • City Council Virtual Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 902c471909a9e3c9ea4b41d0cba91ec8. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record