POLISCOPE

The public record

PALMETTOBAY (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

87th Avenue Bridge Task Force Meeting

Wednesday, March 10, 2021 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

87th Avenue Bridge Task Force Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Agenda

87th Avenue Bridge Task Force Meeting - Wednesday, March 10, 2021

Page 1 of 1

87TH AVENUE BRIDGE TASK FORCE VIRTUAL MEETING

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 10, 2021 – 5:30 PM

MEETING AGENDA

1. Roll call and acknowledgement of task force members

2. Approval of Minutes

a. February 24, 2021

b. March 3, 2021

3. Public Comments, including comments submitted by form

4. Discussion of Agenda Items:

a. Continuation of the preparation of position paper for the TPO

Meeting scheduled for March 18, 2021

5. New Business

6. Adjournment

Showing the first 24,000 of 60,852 characters. The full document is at the source.

. >> good evening everybody. This is carmen baker and I am the chair of the eighty seventh avenue bridge task force meeting held today wednesday March 3rd twenty twenty one and I'm going to start with our roll call and acknowledgment of our task force members marcellus in here and joseph morelli here in al ferguson here. Thank you very much. And we are going to go ahead and start with public comments for Madam Clerk if you can assist us at the last meeting and that's going to include comments submitted by form. Good evening. Eighty seventh avenue bridge task force those listening the public comments that have been submitted by form will be read in the order they were received. They will adhere to the two minute time limit and any and all public comments received by forms that arrive after five thirty four P.M. Of tonight's meeting will remain part of the record and will remain part of the meeting minutes chris pearson one seven two two zero sw eighty fourth avenue pomerol bay. I fully support the bridge being built there are thirteen other bridges over this canal with no increase in crime or decrease in property value. What makes this one so vulnerable and different from the others exactly nothing. Stop wasting time and a step eighty seven avenue galloway road is a county line arterial road that connects to four other arterial roads for dispersement traffic which coincidently leads directly to schools, hospitals, grocery markets in urgent care centers . Chad heferen seven four nine zero sopwith from meadowbank. I appreciate the county's efforts to complete the grid in metal bay but I'm curious as to why the council continues to oppose it. I have heard a variety of reasons none of which are rooted in facts or expertize. Furthermore, recent polls done in twenty nineteen and this year have shown that residents support it. Why go against what the majority of the residents want ? Look this is not an issue of convenience or of property values or traffic. This is mainly about safety cut through traffic affects more of palmetto bay than a bridge will affect the resident of eighty seventh avenue. We have been suffering for years with band-aid solution like speed bumps and stop signs and nothing has worked. We have small residential streets flooded with levels of traffic that were not designed for journalists. I want many blind corners, narrow streets and houses close to the roads. Eighty seven has always been designed for completion. We should hear no more from detractors who have no experience or expertize what the bridge will do and listen to the experts the numerous studies. Please stop opposing the bridge and help provide relief to the majority of the residents suffering from the lack of greed completion their voice eighty seven twenty sw one fifty feet palmetto bay this common serves to register my opposition to the southwest eighty seventh avenue bridge connector. As we all know the residents north of the canal oppose this connection for many different reasons. We have fought this connection for almost 20 years. What has changed to now construct this bridge? Nothing but an odd godly increase in traffic from the south due to overdevelopment it is highly detrimental to our neighborhood since traffic will gridlock on eighty seven as it approaches southwest fifty second street. Therefore many drivers will divert through residential streets to escape just this morning and time on one fifty second street was backed up almost to eighty seven the avenue and that is without all students being back in school outing thousands and thousands of additional cars from the south is extremely short sighted and is not the solution gaining a few extra minutes to only sit further along eighty seventh avenue is lunacy ruining our neighborhood and affecting thousands of residents is unfair. More accidents will occur as drivers divert and gridlock. Eighty second avenue this connector bridge is not supported by our village and has been rejected previously by the tpo the manner in which this proposed by the nonelected district a commissioner to the pcc was done citing public knowledge center support. I moved here to be part of a small government so underhanded like this would not happen. >> I object to this connector bridge carpe demaio's one fifty four one zero sopwith eighty ninth avenue. Palmetto bay yes two bridges I live in area in this area for sixty three years. Many changes and many more residents. I remember eighty seventh avenue first opening from one sixty three to southwest one eighty four street what a difference also remember seventy second avenue opening from one twentieth to one twenty fourth street that was huge my road connection really does help many people you seventy second to use one and think nothing of it close this road and see I many cut through neighborhood side streets open main streets enough already rick meyers one fifty four one zero sw eighty ninth avenue palmetto bay build the bridge we were told forty years ago bridge was going up it's time it takes at least one hour or longer for morning and afternoon commute. Most of those north of the bridge have no idea what is really happening. Nicole hefty eighty seven hundred sw one fifty five terrace palmetto bay. I am opposed to building the bridge on eighty seventh avenue at southwest one sixty three terrace. It will encourage more commuter traffic through quiet neighborhood street which is not inacceptable or appropriate solution to traffic congestion . Zac hoover eighty seven hundred sw one fifty fifth terrace pomerol bay I'm opposed to the bridge because it would ruin the quiet neighborhood and cause more accidents to the residents as well and causing major inconveniences for the residents who lived here for a very long time. Deloney hefti eighty seven hundred was one fifty feet terrace pomerol bay I am opposing a bridge because it will make eighty seventh avenue a lot louder and busier which could be dangerous for small children or adults walking around no additional public comments are received at this moment I would like the record to reflect that the comments have come in after five thirty four of this meeting will remain part of the record and will be part of the meeting minutes. >> thank you. And is there anybody waiting to speak? Yes. Good evening members. I do have a sponsor waiting in the virtual lobby in this vehicle for amendments for discovering yourself state your name and just for the record good afternoon. My name is beatrice hermann one seven two five one sw eighty six seven. first of all I want to thank all of you for taking time from your busy schedule to be part of this and represent us and fight for us. Thank you very much. I disagree with one of the previous speakers that say the majority of residents obey when the breach is he is very, very wrong. I live in palmetto bay since nineteen eighty seven and every time this comes up we all are not in agreement with that. This is now the bridge is going to cost more than before and only three million dollars from our taxpayer money and they don't have really of everything that's going to be done so I oppose the bridge. The other thing I went to to say is that this and I said it before but I went to re-emphasize this that is done by computers do not reflect what goes on in our neighborhoods. The proof is the two circles that were supposed to clear our problem and they made it worse and 13 that I went to call today everybody's attention is I don't know if you hear the news that commissioner commissioner korolyov of miami has closed the streets in his district because of the problem . Exactly what do we have? They took him to court and the judge gave went with him that he can close those streets because of what's it can happen in that in that direction. So maybe tomorrow they should look into closing 87 avenue between one eighty four and one sixty only for palmetto residents that way we avoid all this trouble if they build a bridge fine was going to use the bridge that will be the best solution. The other solution will be to get us one north all the time going north that the county has to do that on. When is the peak hours north just one line coming south and in the afternoons which are around like they do it all over the united states and the world . Thank you for your time. Those were my comments . That speaker is Miss Meadowland roman strollin listen meet yourself state your name and address for the record evening . My name is madeline roman. I live in ninety three eighty three thousand four hundred eighty seven st. From first and foremost despite my opposition to this task force this task force position I do appreciate the fact that you guys have taken the time to try and address something whether or not it's been what the majority of the residents want is up for debate and I say that speaking in light of the last comment in addition to that I want to mention that it's probably known already that many of us in palmetto bay do not feel as we have been represented in district three and considering that the village has taken this particular stance and to hear what our district three representatives said today in front of that board was beyond appalling if that is what our district commissioner within the village believes that there is no traffic issue as she stated on the record in front of the pond in front of the county that we have a bigger problem than just the bridge. It's about time that everyone understand that this bridge is needed. Additionally to joe carollo, he's also stated that he would consider actually seceding from the county to create their own county is that what the village of palmetto bay is going to do next because that's where he's going. So just consider that as you sit there and you listen to closing off one hundred and eighty fourth street, everybody else in the district, that's just ludicrous. Thank you and have a good speaker is caroline the dalkia this pavelka make yourself state your name and I just for the record , this airline your unmuted state your name and address for the record , hey, it appears that she's having technical difficulties. I do not have anyone else in the virtual lobby with their hands reached. >> thank you, Madam Clerk. So next on the agenda so the public comments are closed but if anybody else comes in please ,Madam Clerk, give us the option to to reopen if necessary. But in the meantime can move along with our agenda. We have the approval of the minutes for February 24th and March 3rd. so do I have a motion to approve the minutes? I'll tell you I'm you and you will you muted Madam Clerk that you have to on mute them again . They're mute themselves. Can you hear me now? I can hear you now. Yeah I'll put in the motion ok do I have a second. I'll second all those in favor I I so that passes and that is for both February 24th and March 3rd I ok so now we can have the discussion regarding the the position paper joseph would you like to catch us up on the progress for the position paper. >> ok is it good or is it completely out of are we able to maybe respond a little bit to what some of the people just stated on the call and we want to do that later. We don't have to but I would like the opportunity to let me see what we can do is we could let's see where we are with the paper and definitely if you want to spend some time and it's and if it's ok with everybody else we can we can choose to do to do that. But I think that we can focus on the position paper and let's leave in case I do also pass anything that we need to catch up because remember we have an hour and a half for this so we May have time we can we can talk about some can you are you ok with that? Marshlack and we are waiting to see what joseph has for us and then go back to them or have you guys hear about it? It was just it was just going to be like I just wanted to state something would just go ahead as person so we can do it later. It's ok joseph so so thank you . I agreed marcello we should have a little bit of time just for a general discussion but to talk about the the reports we're writing et cetera they were they were sent to the county manager. >> he should have sent those to everyone. Did everybody receive a copy? Yes, I know there was a powerpoint and Ms. Word I believe the city manager took some of the information and consolidated down to a one page summary statement executive summary which was very nice, very nicely worded. So I think I'll I'll back incorporate that into the into the actual word document it was written very well. I did not receive much feedback . I received a little bit of feedback, a lot of it sort of just typos and I didn't get much feedback on content approach things of that nature so I wouldn't mind hearing at the beginning maybe just an overview of what we think the paper is. It got the right tone, the right language and I'd also like to hear from nic kind of the editorial piece how are we editing is am I going to create the final edit is is the the city or the village actually doing the final edit piece and we do need to issue this and send it out this week I think to give to give everybody that's receiving it a chance to review it and read it . You don't want to deliver this you know the day of the meeting we need and you don't want delivered on the weekend because no one's going to read it. So it kind of has to go up pretty pretty soon and I feel ok about it. It's not perfect. It's a little bit rough around the edges. I'm just concerned just about the present ability of it and whether nic could talk to us a little bit about just the editing process and present ability and then if anybody could talk about content and and whether they feel we got it right or missing something. So with that I'll open the floor to anybody that's got some comments. Well go ahead algy. Ah I I thought the paper was really long. I don't know how much they're going to take our paper. I think we should get to the point as we have some points that are very clear of why not to build. I felt like it was very long winded but anyhow I also got from the meeting today that I was at the tpk meeting they approved the bridge to go ahead to the next step, write unanimously. So that is not that doesn't bode well for us. Right. And one of the things that I got from that meeting is that there's no really other solutions. there's no there's a lack of solutions besides the bridge . People think people think that there's no other way to do it and at this point maybe it's late in the game but I feel like we need to make other solutions part of the you know ,we May lose this thing so we need to be realistic and put some other solutions in there to run by. That is my name is there is recommendations there's a section of recommendations towards the back. Maybe it should be moved. I know it's like that's heads towards the back and it's like super hard to read and it's like oh man I stopped reading it halfway through because I was like who's going to actually read this from the tpo ? You know like they have already read our studies. Our position paper is I think low priority to them. You know, I think we need to be very clear and concise about our points and offer alternative solutions that are also very clear. But what I think is true I think your points well made. Let's get to the point of front and early and I think then there's a lot of supporting documentation that goes with it but I don't think it's really about the supporting documentation and it's there it's to demonstrate that we we've we've spent time and effort here really analyzing us . I would like to talk a little bit about the meeting this morning because maybe that has some context to how we position this paper would be ok. Yes, of course. Yes. Go ahead. One of the big things that came out I got two points that kind of came maybe more but one of the biggest point which is all that which is contextual which is all about is there alternatives? That was one of the big things . Well, the question was asked to our commissioner has anybody presented alternatives to the bridge and unfortunately her reply was no, no one's given alternatives. That really was completely incorrect because multiple alternatives are given in the in the in the discussion that was insu the hour before. So I'm a little bit concerned that our commissioner is not even looking for alternatives when those alternatives are already on the plate, are already in the works and they're slated to be completed by twenty twenty three. So so I think we have to really talk about alternatives and demonstrate that we have put alternatives forward. I know we have and I know there in the paper and I guess we have to make that more vocal so people can actually see it the other the other piece that comes through is I feel there's a huge amount of misrepresentation. I mean we're calling this an arterial roadway and then when you read through the documents there, it's not an artillery roadway but actually the the the change order document that's going in and asking for funding is is saying it's a primary collector or something like that. But that's only for the road that s of one sixty eight when you look at the road that's north of the canal it's basically designated as a street so in that in the what f F.D.A. Dade county plan for designations of roads it is really designated as a street but it's being it's being presented as some massive arterial roadway that that must go through. So there's a lot of misrepresent in in a lot of the documentation that's been submitted. It gets down in the weeds and that's hard to make a case to that. But but I think that's part of it. So some of the stuff that came out yeah, I think there was support there was support for our position at least there was support that the process was not correct. There was support that it should have been vetted through the through the community. It should have it shouldn't get to that state with that kind of rancor between sides when it gets to the tpl that should have been sorted out a long time ago and people should have come to grips with the final solution. So but I mean the the Chairman Was overwhelmed by the amount of commentary that was coming and I think their pushback was you didn't do your homework, you didn't do the job right. You didn't get that. You didn't get the community involved and now you're putting this you're putting this piece of the smelly piece of trash on my desk and you're asking me to deal with it and I think there's some support there that the process has been completely wrong. So that's my take on the meeting. Did you did you walk away with that to lj? Yeah, I got the vibe that a couple of people didn't necessarily think that the process was fully the way it should have been. But I also felt like they were going to push it through and they were going to use that and I felt like when you have it voted on unanimously, you know there was one gentleman on the board who said that he had received an enormous amount of emails and I'm going to guess that they're probably from pro bridgers to be honest . But he said he didn't even know the area and he had looked on google maps, you know, and I got the vibe that they were kind of going to go with the chair of the meeting twice said like, oh, danielle, I applaud you for bringing this thing to vote and bringing it to issue. I got from the meeting that they were supporting it. They did it unanimously and I don't know if the outcome will be any different in a week. You know, we're dealing with a committee of the people who are making the decision normally they don't go against their own committee so I just think that our emphasis should be very quick and concise why we think the bridge will fail and then offer other alternate that we can do right now like us one in the morning has got to have one hour of dedicated late timing to move towards north northbound traffic and then in the afternoon it's got to have one hour of dedicated time to southbound traffic and like we're all lights are green at the same time. This is a at least if bridge gets built we need to make sure that they do everything else also to make traffic flow in our in our village the bridge alone we all know it's not going to work. So at least if they do build we need to be on I think the forefront of asking for everything else to be known. Also traffic light time into the village and traffic light timing on us one but yeah, I don't know I took away that they're probably going to do the same thing next week. >> ok, what about you marcello ? What you want to you want to talk about this topic? Do you want to talk about something that was mentioned you met you said you have something to say about one of the comments that was made and maybe it's on point pretty good. Well, there's a couple of things. First of all, I agree with what john was saying as well as joseph. I was a part of the meeting this morning and look, politically it's it's always the same thing. You've got one person that is responsible for a particular district and if they feel very strongly about it, everyone else is going to go along with because they don't know what the situation is in that area. So if one person feels very strongly everyone else wants to rubber stamp it. So unless it's a county issue that affects everybody, they just tend to rubber stamp whatever that person in that district wants. So it is it is absolutely an uphill battle and I think that a big thing is again this is not a this is not a legal kind of court dispute. We're having a unbelievable amount of detail is going to have an overwhelming sway in deciding the outcome. It's a political process. It's always been a political process and we need to treat it as such. It's the court of public opinion and that's what we need to focus on and it needs to really be in my opinion, you know, we need to talk about you know, here's why we're opposed to it here and here are all the solutions. Here's what we need to focus and and and focus on the fact that higgins was not elected and that we believe that if she was elected that she would lose based on the fact that the majority of people are against this bridge and to allow the voters to decide in two years and then try to offer as many solutions as we can for them to to try those first before we destroy all these neighborhoods . So that's that's the first part of what I want to say. The other part I wanted to say that, you know, there's a lot of people and I keep hearing this comment over and over again and it really it's bothered me quite profusely this notion that somehow people in district one district to do not understand or do not respect the trouble that district three is going through with traffic to me is beyond absurd and I can't say why they keep saying it. Everybody is feeling it, ok? Everybody's feeling it. And this idea that somehow this rinky little bridge idea is going to help anybody is is patently absurd if they want something to really improve in their lives just like I do, we all want the roads to have less traffic so we can all get around better. You got to get them off the roads completely not make it easier for people to travel to have these streets and get off of us one I just don't understand how people don't see that and to me I think that is just going to be the biggest thing. And and and if this bridge does go through then whoever is going to go up against higgins and carver for that matter when that comes up because obviously all of us doing I mean she obviously selected higgins for a very specific reason but it's very clear to me that she's going to have to defend that when she goes, you know, when she runs in two years and i think that it's going to cost the election. I really do because I believe the reason this has failed for forty years is the vast majority of people do not want it. They do not want a district. And

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • 87th Avenue Bridge Task Force Meeting
  • 87th Avenue Bridge Task Force Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 90246bb75cca94b630b04f6cc48a49ca. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record