POLISCOPE

The public record

LAUDERDALEBYTHESEA (BROWARD COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Town Commission

Tuesday, January 12, 2021 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Town Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 99,492 characters. The full document is at the source.

TOWN OF LAUDERDALE-BY-THE-SEA TOWN COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES Jarvis Hall 4505 Ocean Drive Tuesday, January 12, 2021 6:30 PM 1. CALL TO ORDER Mayor Chris Vincent called the meeting to order at 6:35 p.m. Also present were Vice Mayor Alfred “Buz” Oldaker, Commissioner Edmund Malkoon, Commissioner Elliot Sokolow, Commissioner Randy Strauss, Interim Town Manager/Development Services Director Linda Connors, Assistant to the Town Manager Neysa Herrera, Town Attorney Susan Trevarthen, Finance Director Lucila Lang, Municipal Services Director Ken Rubach, Town Engineer Jay Flynn, HR Manager Lisa Slagle, Public Information Officer/IT Administrator Steve d’Oliveira, and Town Clerk Tedra Allen. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG 3. INVOCATION Rabbi Benzion Singer gave the Invocation. 4. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, DEFERRALS OF AGENDA ITEMS Interim Town Manager/Development Services Director Linda Connors advised that Item 8a, the Town Manager Report, would be postponed until the next Commission meeting due to time constraints. Mayor Vincent advised that the Commission held a special meeting on Friday, January 8, 2021, at which the previous Town Manager’s contract was terminated. He thanked Interim Town Manager/Development Services Director Connors for her efforts to provide a smooth transition until a new Town Manager is hired. 5. PRESENTATIONS None. The following Items were taken out of order on the Agenda.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 2 of 14 6. PUBLIC COMMENTS Mayor Vincent advised that both written and video public comments on Item 12a submitted in advance of tonight’s meeting would be limited to three minutes in the interests of time and fairness. Public comments submitted which address Item 12a would be read following the presentation on that Item. At this time Mayor Vincent opened public comment. Town Clerk Tedra Allen read the following public comment: • Michael Ferrara, resident, congratulated the Commission on the recent demolition of the former Holiday Inn structure; he asked if there are plans to beautify the area around the Hibiscus Portal With no other individuals wishing to speak at this time, Mayor Vincent closed public comment. 7. PUBLIC SAFETY DISCUSSION a. AMR November & December 2020 Report (Chief Brooke Liddle, AMR) Vice Mayor Oldaker made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Malkoon, to approve the report. Motion carried 5-0. 8. TOWN MANAGER REPORT a. Town Manager Report (Neysa Herrera, Assistant to the Town Manager) This Item was deferred to the January 26, 2021 meeting. 9. TOWN ATTORNEY REPORT None. 10. APPROVAL OF MINUTESDocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 3 of 14 a. December 8, 2020 Town Commission Meeting Minutes (Tedra Allen, Town Clerk) Vice Mayor Oldaker made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Malkoon, to approve. Motion carried 5-0. 11. CONSENT AGENDA None. 12. OLD BUSINESS a. El Mar Design (Linda Connors, Interim Town Manager / Development Services Director) Interim Town Manager/Development Services Director Connors clarified that the Town is not proposing removal of the median from El Mar Drive. It is moving forward with this project because meetings were held in fiscal years (FY) 2014 and 2016 regarding the condition of this roadway. The community has made it clear that they want lighting, sidewalk, and drainage improvements to El Mar Drive. She emphasized that any decision made at tonight’s meeting will not result in immediate action upon the project. The decision before the Commission tonight is approval of a typical design, which would give consultants EDSA the ability to move forward with a clear understanding of what that design would look like from Pine Avenue to Palm Avenue. If approval is granted, EDSA will bring back a more specific design for the Commission’s review at the end of March 2021. This time frame will allow for seasonal residents to provide input. The earliest date at which construction might begin is no earlier than April 2022. At this time Mayor Vincent opened public comment on Item 12a. Seasonal resident, spoke in favor of maintaining current median plantings. She did not favor a standard design. Larry Behar, resident, felt the plans provided by EDSA took the community’s interests into consideration, and recommended their approval. Byron Lavan, resident, stated that he favored no changes to El Mar Drive except improvements to the sidewalks and drainage.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 4 of 14 John Helmer, resident, suggested that only the sidewalks and swales on El Mar Drive be improved. Sam Caruso, resident, suggested that many residents do not perceive a number of the roadway’s existing conditions as problematic, which contributed to their opposition to the plans. Charles Shaman, resident, did not believe the sidewalks or drainage on El Mar Drive were in need of significant repairs. Caral Ann Sharkey, resident, supported Plan 1, as it increases green space and provides wider sidewalks; she recommended adding a botanical garden at the Town’s southern gateway. Cristie Furth, resident, opposed EDSA’s plans for El Mar Drive, and recommended postponing the project until Staff and residents can work together. Wes Shelton, resident, spoke in favor of Plan 1 submitted by EDSA, which proposes improvements and amenities for pedestrians, cyclists, residents, and visitors. Pat Krumanacker, resident, noted that the existing sidewalk is in need of repair and better lighting, but felt there were no documented safety issues. Kelly Byron, resident, recommended against changes to El Mar Drive in order to preserve the Town’s small-town charm. Ted Taft, representing the board of directors of the Leisure Mar Condominium, emphasized the need to maintain the Town’s small-town atmosphere. Nick Boar, resident, asked the Commission to make no significant changes to El Mar Drive. Paul Novak, resident, recommended retaining two lanes of vehicular traffic and a center median, 8 ft. sidewalks, and lighting improvements. Nancy Demko, resident, was not in favor of increased parking or changes to the El Mar Drive median and recommended retention of green space.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 5 of 14 Tom Lutzy, resident, was not in favor of pull-outs for delivery vehicles. Jeff Yocom, resident, requested that the El Mar Drive project be kept simple, focusing on sidewalk repairs and preventing speeding. Stuart Dodd, resident, recommended improvements only to drainage, lighting, safety, and swales on El Mar Drive. Barbara Cole, resident, felt the proposed changes to El Mar Drive would run counter to the Town’s mission statement, policies, and branding. Alex Fenech, representing EDSA, showed a PowerPoint presentation on the El Mar Drive project. Existing conditions of the roadway include an 8 ft. right-of-way, a sidewalk approximately 5 ft. wide, 25 ft. of driving lanes and buffers, and a 20 ft. median. At a certain point, drainage/lighting improvements and sidewalk mediation can trigger the need for a Code-compliant design. The industry standard for this trigger is improvement of 50% of a facility: for example, if 50% of the sidewalks are improved, the entire sidewalk must be made Code-compliant. Mr. Fenech pointed out that if the Town wishes to maintain the same character of the roadway, with two lanes, a median, and a perimeter sidewalk, the requirement for Code compliance would trigger a specific type of design. He strongly emphasized that this design is not proposed for El Mar Drive. At present, the roadway does not meet Broward County development requirements, which include wider sidewalks and a clear zone separating traffic lanes from pedestrian circulation. The dimensional layout of the project is based on a combination of Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), Broward County, and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Code standards. Mr. Fenech pointed out that no clear zone currently exists: the implementation of this component presents a dimensional challenge. FDOT requires a 6 ft. clear zone, which provides a minimum of 6 ft. of separation between vehicular traffic lanes and pedestrian circulation. This component must be implemented into any modification of El Mar Drive as a safety standard. The El Mar Drive project was discussed by the City Commission in 2014 to address deteriorating sidewalks, lighting, and drainage. Mr. Fenech advised that the following safety and infrastructure concerns have been identified: • Catch basins below the road surface, which can create tripping hazards for pedestriansDocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 6 of 14 • Deteriorating sidewalks and adjacent asphalt, which contribute to hazardous walking conditions • Proximity of signage to traffic lanes • “Alligator cracking” of asphalt, which deteriorates the roadway surface • Encroachment of utility poles on the eastern 5 ft. sidewalk • Deterioration of curbs • Drainage impeded by poor grading along the median and other areas • Unsafe conditions created by poor lighting Mr. Fenech noted that while EDSA is mindful of the public comments regarding pull-out areas for delivery vehicles, a survey of businesses, hoteliers, and condominiums along El Mar Drive raised this issue as a concern. He encouraged continued discussions to refine how stacking issues on El Mar Drive might be alleviated. In addition, drainage issues, including standing water, are apparent on El Mar Drive after even a light rain. Mr. Fenech recalled that EDSA presented three design concepts to the Town’s residents, businesses, and Commission, identifying Option 1 as their preferred design. This option would expand the median from 20 ft. to 22 ft. and represent a 9% increase in green space from Palm Avenue to Pine Avenue. The use of pull-outs for service vehicles in this option is still to be determined. Option 2 is similar to Option 1, but includes a service lane. Option 3 was developed in response to the community’s desire to keep two lanes of traffic. This option was not recommended by EDSA. Mr. Fenech continued that banners were printed in September 2020 and a survey was conducted, which showed significant support for Option 1. Mr. Fenech briefly reviewed the details of Option 1, which would expand the sidewalks to 9 ft. in width. It also considers the possibility of a bike or multi-use lane of roughly 4 ft. and would include a 2 ft. valley gutter to provide a clear zone of 6 ft. Traffic lanes would remain 12 ft. in width, which would allow for circulation around a stalled or emergency vehicle. The median would increase to 22 ft. In Option 2, the sidewalk width would remain the same and the multi-use lane would expand to 8 rather than 4 ft. and include the clear zone. Travel lanes would be reduced from 12 to 10 ft., with a slight reduction in the median width. Option 3 would reduce the median by 60% or more and would include a bike lane and clear zone. The construction timeline for the proposed project would be as follows: • Upon design selection, EDSA returns with a more detailed design in March 2021DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 7 of 14 • Construction would begin in April 2022 If necessary, construction could be postponed for up to one year in order to align this phase with the season. EDSA would work closely with the Town and the selected contractor to minimize the impact of construction on residents, businesses, and visitors. Mr. Fenech concluded that EDSA’s recommendation is Option 1, and emphasized that this is only a concept: the design team would continue to study it and provide more detail. Commissioner Strauss reiterated that Option 1 would actually increase the El Mar Drive median by 9% rather than decrease it. He added that moving forward with a design concept at this time would not rush the project into construction, and there is sufficient time to review details more closely and make changes if necessary. Commissioner Sokolow requested further clarification of what removal of the 19 proposed service vehicle pull-outs would mean. Mr. Fenech explained that EDSA’s concern is without regulation, these vehicles could block the bike lane and/or sidewalk, creating a hazard for pedestrians as well as other vehicles backing out of parking spaces. At present, most of these vehicles park against the median in the second lane. Vice Mayor Oldaker was not certain that delivery vehicles would require the accommodation of a number of pull-out spaces. He suggested that the community may not yet have a clear understanding of the proposed project. Mr. Fenech advised that there are three key aspects to the project: • Sidewalk improvements • Drainage improvements • Addition of lighting He reiterated that the work necessary to accomplish any one of these three goals would trigger the requirement for Code compliance, which would not permit the roadway’s current dimensional profile to be retained. Commissioner Malkoon asked if the standards to which Mr. Fenech had referred were best practices or true Code requirements. Town Engineer Jay Flynn confirmed that these are legal requirements, noting that if improvements do not meet these standards, the Town could be exposed to liability.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 8 of 14 Commissioner Sokolow commented that the individuals advocating for an “option 4” which would make only drainage, sidewalk, and lighting improvements may not fully understand that these changes alone would be sufficient to trigger a Code upgrade. Mayor Vincent pointed out that there is no requirement at this time for the Town to make any improvements at all, which is also an option. At this time Mayor Vincent reopened public comment. Written public comments were read by Town Clerk Allen, Finance Director Lucila Lang, and HR Manager Lisa Slagle. Kevin Mahoney, resident, opposed the three proposed designs for El Mar Drive, which he felt did not address the issues raised by residents during the public input process. Linda Aaronowitz, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Suzanne Maurice, resident, expressed concern with the proposed designs for El Mar Drive and asked that no changes be made. Harry and Patricia Neal, residents, requested that no changes be made to El Mar Drive except basic maintenance. Leslie and Judith Cole, residents, requested that no significant changes be made to El Mar Drive. Renee Oneal, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Constantine Xanthos, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive other than sidewalk repairs. Jim Mendillo, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Sean Scott, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Robert and Peggy McHale, residents, felt no changes should be made to El Mar Drive except sidewalk repairs and installation of additional lighting. John Walsh, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive other than necessary repairs/improvements. Steve and Debbie Hartley, residents, felt no changes should be made to El Mar Drive.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 9 of 14 Tim Spesick, resident, expressed concern with the proposed changes to delivery truck parking on El Mar Drive, and recommended that trucks be parked on the same side of the road as the delivery location. Shelley Kirchner, resident, requested that no changes except necessary improvements be made to El Mar Drive. Irena Xanthos, resident, asked that no changes be made to the median or traffic flow on El Mar Drive. Susan Walker, resident, expressed concern with parking on El Mar Drive if changes are made to the traffic lanes. She was in favor of sidewalk and lighting improvements only. Cynthia and Raymond Mattia, residents, was not in favor of changes to El Mar Drive other than sidewalk repairs, turtle-friendly lighting, and drainage improvements. Sharlene [last name not provided], resident, did not want changes made to El Mar Drive. Raymond Robin, resident, opposed any changes to El Mar Drive. Cathy Menniti, resident, asked that El Mar Drive be left “as is.” Marissa Greenberg, resident, stated a preference for no or very few changes to the roadway. Bengt and Monalisa Pettersson, residents, asked that only required regular maintenance be performed on El Mar Drive. Bill and Mary Davis, residents, opposed any reduction to the El Mar Drive greenway or removal of trees or shrubs. Chiefswife@728@comcast.net, requested that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. John Capitumini, resident, requested that the El Mar Drive median be left as is. At this time the Commission and speakers took a brief recess and reconvened at 9 p.m.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 10 of 14 Christina Archila, resident, opposed any changes to El Mar Drive and saw no issue with the current practice for service vehicles. Don Troutman, resident, was not in favor of changes to El Mar Drive. Sally Musser, resident, requested that no changes be made to El Mar Drive or its median, and asked if the public could see the projected costs of the proposed options. Victoria Weidenthaler, resident, did not feel the proposed options for El Mar Drive met residents’ needs. She recommended that pavement repairs and undergrounding of utilities be prioritized as improvements. Jeff Creary requested that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Richard Mueller, resident, stated that he supported no changes El Mar Drive. Jamie Leblanc, resident, opposed changes to El Mar Drive other than repairs to sidewalks. Mr. and Mrs. Donald Tjarksen advised they were not supportive of any changes to the El Mar Drive median. Lynn, resident, was not in favor of changes to El Mar Drive. Paul Clifford, resident, recommended that no changes be made to El Mar Drive. Alena Alberani, resident, opposed parking spaces for service vehicles on El Mar Drive. Kevin Kelleher, resident, asked that Staff and the Commission be permitted to move forward with what is best for the Town, even if it is not what many individuals want. Hanna Hempstead, resident, felt El Mar Drive should remain as is. Lois Schmatz, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive except “what needs to be fixed.” Stephen Courtney, resident, objected to any changes that might impair the safety of El Mar Drive.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 11 of 14 Dean Hively, resident of Sea Ranch Lakes, opposed any changes to El Mar Drive or its median. Roger Lucas, resident, asked that no changes be made to El Mar Drive other than repairs. Comment forwarded by Alex Fenech resident, asked that damaged sidewalks on El Mar Drive be repaired and that the roadway be made one lane in each direction. Darren Smith, resident, spoke in favor of no major changes. Jim Van Damme, resident, felt the multi-use character of El Mar Drive should not be changed. mosull8235@aol.com requested that only repairs be made to El Mar Drive. Debra Marten, resident, did not want changes made to El Mar Drive. Bob and Sheri Kimball, resident, wanted no major changes to El Mar Drive. Becky Weist, resident, recommended no changes to El Mar Drive. Chris Dietrich, Sr., resident, opposed changes to El Mar Drive. Shelley Hagerty-Rahn, resident, felt no changes other than repairs should be made to El Mar Drive, and described the roadway as sufficiently safe already. Marie Briggs, resident, requested that El Mar Drive remain two lanes in each direction and was in favor of necessary upgrades to the sidewalk, and opposed other changes. With no other individuals wishing to speak at this time, Mayor Vincent closed public comment. The Commissioners discussed the presentation and public response, with Vice Mayor Oldaker recommending more public outreach by both the Town and EDSA. He pointed out that the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic prevents any action on the proposed project in the near future. He felt the issue should be postponed and revisited after the 2021- 2022 budget process is complete.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 12 of 14 Commissioner Malkoon recalled that the Town had opted to undertake the proposed El Mar Drive project itself rather than partnering with the Broward MPO, as the Town has a successful record of implementing roadway projects of this nature. He also suggested that the project be postponed until after the Town’s budget process is complete and an open forum or workshop meeting can be scheduled to meet with the public. He was not in favor of moving forward with any option at this time. Commissioner Sokolow observed that some members of the community may have been misinformed by individuals acting as “activists” with regard to the proposed plans, who have cast aspersions on both the Town Commission and the design team. He emphasized that tonight’s presentation, like previous presentations, have clarified that there are no plans to remove or reduce the median or make other drastic changes. Commissioner Sokolow continued that the existing state of the sidewalks, road, and swales on El Mar Drive constitute hazards. He was in favor of proceeding with EDSA’s recommended design, Option 1, rather than postponing the project further. He reiterated that individuals fearing changes to the median have been misled, and strongly emphasized the need to move past this misinformation. Commissioner Strauss noted that while most public comment focused on the preservation of green space and was not in favor of significant design change, individuals also expressed support for sidewalk repairs and improved lighting and drainage. He pointed out that these improvements are the primary intent of the El Mar Drive project, and noted once again that construction would not begin for over one year. Vice Mayor Oldaker noted that while all three plans proposed by EDSA include lighting, drainage, and sidewalk improvements, they also include changes to traffic and bicycle lanes. He again recommended that this choice be postponed until it can be ensured that the public better understands what is proposed in the designs. Mayor Vincent recalled that the project was first proposed in 2014 with the intent of making repairs to sidewalks, drainage, and lighting. Since that time, it has continued to evolve to include other changes as well. He felt the majority of public comments at tonight’s meeting showed that the public does not fully understand the project. For this reason, he was not in favor of moving the project forward, particularly during a time when the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic affects residents, businesses, and the Commission. He felt Staff’s attention is better focused on recovery efforts at this time.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 13 of 14 Commissioner Sokolow made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Strauss, to proceed with starting further design of Option 1. Motion failed 2-3 (Mayor Vincent, Vice Mayor Oldaker, and Commissioner Malkoon dissenting). Vice Mayor Oldaker made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Malkoon, to reconsider this [Item] at the first meeting in October for discussion, with the design team to continue public outreach. Motion carried 5-0. 13. NEW BUSINESS None. 14. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS Commissioner Strauss urged the public to remain safe and wear masks. 15. ORDINANCES 1ST READING None. 16. ORDINANCES 2ND READING None. 17. RESOLUTIONS – PUBLIC COMMENTS a. Resolution 2021-02 – A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN OF LAUDERDALE-BY-THE-SEA, FLORIDA, APPROVING A GRANT AGREEMENT FOR THE FUNDING OF $19,233.00 THROUGH THE BROWARD COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020 / 2021 FOR THE SENIOR CENTER ACTIVITIES PROGRAM; AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE APPROPRIATE TOWN OFFICIALS TO EXECUTE THE GRANT AGREEMENT; AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF TOWN FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT OF $64,367.00 TO COVER THE REMAINING COSTS OF THE PROGRAM; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT, SEVERABILITY, AND FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE (Lucila Lang, Finance Director)DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Lauderdale-By-The-Sea Virtual Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Page 14 of 14 At this time Mayor Vincent opened public comment, which he closed upon receiving no comment. Commissioner Malkoon made a motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Oldaker, to approve. Motion carried 5-0. 18. QUASI JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARING None. 19. ADJOURNMENT With no other business to come before the Commission at this time, the meeting was adjourned at 9:44 p.m. __________________________________ Mayor Chris Vincent ATTEST: ____________________________________ ___________________ Town Clerk Tedra Allen DateDocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5 1/27/2021

Town Commission Meeting January 12, 2021 Public Comments 1.) Luis and Ana da Costa, resident (126 words) Taking into account the opportunity that you gave for the LBTS residents to send comments about the El Mar Drive Streetscape Project, please consider the following: Taking advantage of this repair, we suggest the removal of all the huge electrical poles and the electrical cables going underground, like already done in the El Prado Park area. We presume this would bring a certain economy to the allocated funds to spend in one of the actual three project proposals. There are innumerous streets in our beautiful city with very poor nightlights. Maybe the eventual savings with less expensive works in El Mar Drive could help to improve this or other proposals from other residents. We thank you for all your work and dedication to our fantastic city. 2.) Bill Smith, resident (273 words) My name is William Smith and I live at 4445 El Mar Drive. I have been coming to LBTS and spending most of the winter here for over 10 years. I am quite concerned to the different proposals as none of them seem appropriate and will negatively impact the best feature of this residential road (the median). I previously chose one of the options in the surveys presented but should have commented that none would be my choice. The traffic density on el mar drive is so low that the need for more asphalt is not justified. The existing 2 lanes work fine as they exist for both vehicular and bike traffic. That also includes the need for vendor parking. The highest use by far is pedestrian traffic. The need to improve, repair, replace significant areas of the sidewalks and related drainage swale would be a welcome improvement. Landscape enhancement or decorative lighting could be a welcome addition as well. But adding a dedicated bike lane that causes the need for vendor parking areas is a substantial concession to the aesthetic of El Mar Drive. The existing median is already interrupted numerous time with cross streets, turn arounds, el Prado parking etc. Further Deletion of green space and adding asphalt seems extremely short sighted and significantly and negatively impacts the residential feel for the street. The premise for the proposed work is improvements to el mar dr. Trading landscaped areas for asphalt is not an improvement. Let’s put the emphasis on legitimate areas of need but not try to fix something that’s not broken. Thank you for your review of resident comments.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

3.) Dan Darnell, resident (314 words) I can't know what is in your minds or what you are thinking. I only know what it looks like from the outside. What it looks like is that you are facing a difficult decision and you are looking for the perfect solution (there isn't one) that will please everyone (you can't) or at least will please most of the people (you'll never figure that out because it's a moving target). You keep delaying the decision, hoping that it will become clear what you should do. I believe each time you delay, each time you try a new poll, you make the problem and decision harder. You have allowed whole movements to form to try to influence you to their POV. These movements and these polls only muddy the waters. None of the polls taken are remotely scientific, no movement truly represents the majority, and no amount of public discussions will result in a perfect ranking of the choices. Most LBTS residents (any group of people) are easily swayed by whatever they read or hear last. If decisions are going to be made by polls, what do we need commissioners for? This is a case where you should rise above all the noise of the debate, controversy, and movements you have unintentionally created and do what we elected you to do - be forward thinking leaders. Put aside what everyone thinks is the right solution and do a serious analysis about the future of LBTS. Consult city planning experts such as you have with EDSA, look at what other small towns are doing, and consider our unique setting. What future do YOU believe LBTS should be moving towards? Be the leaders we elected you to be! Instead of focusing on what works best today, select a plan that best serves the town for the next 20 years and allow that plan to become perfect. 4.) Hannah Gutner (124 words) Good afternoon, I would like to submit a public comment for the El Mar Streetscape Project. My name is Hannah Gutner. I live at 1550 NE 43 St Oakland Park, FL and visit LBTS regularly. I am expressing my support for Option 2 on the Streetscape Project, with wider bike lanes. On that note, while biking to LBTS today I noticed the two large fish shaped bike racks on either corner of El Mar Dr and Commercial were removed. I cannot emphasize enough how disappointing it is to see the opportunity for a more bike friendly part of town presented by COVID reducing street size being ignored. Please reinstall these bike racks and widen the bike lanes on either side of Commercial. Thank you. 5.) Jose Gonzalez Bello, resident (111 words) Dear Commissioners and Mayor: Respectfully, we disagree with the proposed El Mar Project. For us, El Mar Drive is the "lungd" of LBTS and also, a sanctuary for thousands of birds who make it their sleeping habitat. We invite you to take a walk along with your children on El Mar Dr. right before dawn and you will experience the most amazing event, thousands of birds waking up and singing at the same time (Mother Nature at its best). This happens in front of the Oriana Condominium.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Please don’t destroy our beauty and let’s keep all of the green spaces we still have, love our town the way we do ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6.) Bill McGarrity, resident (13 words) I agree with Option 4, fix what needs fixing and keep the median 7.) Paul Myles, resident (151 words) My family are 50-year residents of Lauderdale By the Sea. As to the El Mar project, do not ignore the obvious. Approx. 650 people responded to the EDSA Design Firm online design poll. That is 10% of the total full time resident population. That clearly means 90% of the full-time residents, just do not care!! Factor the 650-person response compared to full time and winter residents, that is a 7% response. Thus, 93% of the total population just do not care! Why spend millions if 93% of the people just do not care or have not voiced some need for change to El Mar Drive? Upgrade the sidewalks for safety reasons. Use the millions saved to upgrade parking around Anglin Square or put the millions in the rainy-day fund for some unknown future emergency need/project. Money spent should be for the benefit of the entire city, not 650 people. 8.) Doreen and William Cameron, residents (332 words) To LBTS Commissioners We first visited Florida in 1974 when we drove from our home in Pennsylvania. After visiting Orlando for 3 days, we had no plans for the rest of our 2-week vacation other than to hit the beach, so we simply drove down to Miami and worked our way back northwards. We saw nothing in Miami or Ft. Lauderdale that made us want to stop, then we came across a brand-new Howard Johnsons hotel (now the Plunge)! We loved the rooms where we could walk out onto the beach, the charming little town and its restaurants and even Sea Ranch Mall just across the street. Exceptional! Since then, we have returned with our children, several times, to stay for a few days before cruising. When my daughter’s college roommate (who coincidentally lives in Coral Springs) got married, I suggested she use that hotel for her guests, which she did. Lauderdale by the Sea is truly a unique little seaside resort. Little did I know back in 1974, having traveled the world several times, we’d retire here! Congratulations, the town is even better than it was back then! This year I’ve sorely missed the many many hours we spend at Jarvis Hall on a multitude of activities. When the survey came out regarding El Mar renovation I puzzled over the options. I don’t remember what I picked, but I do remember not feeling great about my choice. Then I happened upon the “Option 4 Group” while taking my daily walk on El Mar where I usually bump into friends. I assumed they were township employees pushing one of the options and was delighted to discover their simple quest, “just fix what needs fixing”. How simple and satisfying is that! El Mar, like everything else about LBTS is perfect the way it is, other than a much-needed upgrade of course. I hope you will do just that. Deleting some of the green median for 19 truck parking pull- offs doesn’t seem an improvement.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

9.) Stuart Kreitzer, resident (162 words) I'm an LBTS homeowner and a daily user of El Mar for a variety of activities. I run the full length of the street in the morning and walk, bike, or inline skate in the evening. I love doing these activities close to the beach, however El Mar is in poor shape for any type of exercise -- even walking. Limited and narrow sidewalks force people into the street where they dodge bikes and cars. The road is particularly unfriendly to tourists walking and biking from hotels to the downtown. We need wide sidewalks and an adjacent bike path for safety. A single lane for vehicular traffic is not only sufficient but will also serve to calm traffic. I prefer option #2 of the 9-20-2020 proposal with a 9' sidewalk, 8' bike lane, and 10' traffic lane. The median pull-offs are a great compromise between maintaining a landscaped median and accommodating the many walkers, runners, skaters, and bikers that use El Mar. 10.) Tom & Sue Hawkey, resident (231 words) Hello, My husband and I became permanent residents of LBTS five years ago. I have been visiting LBTS for over 40 years and my husband and children for 35 years. We don't understand why the city came up with the three different proposals for El Mar when there is nothing wrong to begin with. My husband is a quadriplegic in a wheelchair and we walk El Mar all the time with our two dogs. We stopped and looked at the proposals in the parking lot and we were not impressed. We were told that they would be more accessible friendly but until we try it out there is no guaranteeing that. We have been told that the wheelchair would be no problem in public areas before and find out that's not the case. Federal disability requirements have hardly been updated since the ADA was established and therefore have not kept up with custom equipment like my husband has. Thus new is not always better. The town's proposals are going to make walking a nightmare with traffic. It's a mystery to me why public officials feel the need to change a good thing that works. El Mar is definitely a big part of the charm of LBTS. Tourists tell us that all the time. Please do the maintenance needed and leave it the way it is. We choose plan 4. Thank you, 11.) Ann Byers (148 words) Lauderdale by the Sea has a retro-beach flavor that has captivated residents and visitors for generations. Take a moment and read the sentiments carved in the bricks at the Pavilion and you’ll see lifetimes of joyful memories shared in this seaside village. Blissful reminders of “mom & pop” & boutique hotel stays, family celebrations, restaurants & shops, the beauty of the ocean... a small town embrace where all are welcome! While appreciating the improvement concepts put forth to reimagine El Mar Drive, I ask that you consider an additional plan:DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Please entertain preserving this beloved drive for generations to come by improving the landscaping, sidewalks and lighting while leaving the median intact. El Mar Drive just needs a bit of TLC, not redevelopment. These enhancements are uncomplicated and would spare unnecessary expense, extensive reconstruction, noise and business disruption. Help to maintain this small slice of paradise! Thank you 12.) Maureen Smith, resident (119 words) Dear Lauderdale by the Sea Town Commissioners, My husband and I have owned a condominium on El Mar Drive since 2013. We are seasonal residents from the Boston area and had rented in LBTS for several years before our eventual purchase. This town appealed to us for many reasons; one in particular was the pedestrian- friendly design of El Mar Drive. We enjoy the attractive plantings in the well-kept median that runs the length of the street as well as the pet-friendly nature of the area (available dog waste disposal bags and trash bins). We would like to see El Mar Drive remain pedestrian friendly and green. We support Plan #4 - just make sidewalk repairs where needed. Thank you, 13.) David Peck (98 words) I’m writing this in response to the proposal of the “renovation” of El Mar Drive. To change the topography of El Mar Drive would be a HUGE injustice! In my opinion to change this iconic street would be the equivalent of paving over Central Park in New York! El Mar Drive is the reason people come to LBTS. To commercialize El Mar Drive for a monetary cash flow is ludicrous. Plus, the cost to do such an injustice would take decades to recoup! Also, to lose tourist revenue would be a big mistake! Please leave it as is! Thank you, 14.) Deborah Palmer, resident (169 words) My name is Deborah Palmer and I have lived in the Caribe for over twenty years. We walk El Mar daily and I can’t understand the need to make such drastic changes to something that is so beautiful and unique. This is a residential area. Truck pull-offs into the median are not necessary if you leave well enough alone. Yes, the sidewalks and drainage need attention, but a whole redo of the street is a big waste of time and of tax-payers money, as I am sure the funding you have available will not cover the expenses to be incurred. We were all asked for our input on how we used the drive, now listen to our input on how we DON’T need to make such extreme and costly changes to our neighborhood. I don’t feel making any decision on something that so strongly impacts us all should be made at a time when we cannot meet in person to fully discuss everyone’s feelings on the matter.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Thank you. 15.) William & Mersine Hennessey, resident (28 words) We urge LBTS commissioners to approve El Mar Drive improvements consisting of repair to existing sidewalks and increased street lighting. Please leave the median as is. As an LBTS resident who uses El Mar Drive on a regular basis, I wish to let you know of my feelings about the median. Specifically, changes in the median will destroy the currently delightful character of El Mar Drive on a permanent basis. I would like to see the median remain as is. Improvements along the drive should take the form of better sidewalks and enhanced lighting. Thank you, 16.) Sophia Roth, resident (81 words) Hello, I'm a resident of Lauderdale by the Sea. I run or walk most days on El Mar and really enjoy the median and the landscaping as it is now. I'm asking that you just fix what needs fixing and leave the beauty as it is now. By taking away the median, you will make LBTS just like any other beach town and it will lose it's appeal. Please consider the residents aka taxpayers when you make your decision. Thank you. 17.) Doug Frens, resident (45 words) Dear city commissioners, I want to go on record stating my support for not making the median any narrower than it is now. I support new sidewalks and drainage updates. I ride my bike there weekly and love the median just the way it is. 18.) Jim Dinverno, resident (141 words) My wife and I have lived at 4318 Elmar for over 6 years and often walk the Elmar 1.8 mile loop! We STRONGLY recommend Elmar be reduced to one-way lanes on each side of the greenway (one-way with prominent signage) We also like the version that has separate and adequate lanes for walkers and bike riders with cutouts for limited truck deliveries! Recommend the current greenway be kept intact as much as possible and all the pavement and drains be leveled! Also recommend parking on El Mar within 100 feet of Commercial be eliminated as it is a danger to pedestrians! Speed bumps or warnings of virtual speed bumps (yellow paint with signs) are needed to slow down constant speeders! We are unable to attend but are willing to discuss further as this is important and needs to be done right! 19.) Michael Ferrara, resident (149 words) I live on Garden Ct, off Sea Grape Dr south of Commercial. Just a few words complimenting the Mayor and Town Commission on their work regarding the El Mar Drive Streetscape Project. It was thorough with several opportunities for the community to provide input between multiple townDocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

meetings and surveys. It is always hard trying to satisfy all the residents. I think you and the design firm did a terrific job with the final result. I may not agree with everything but the plan makes long overdue repairs and improvements. It also modernizes the look and feel of El Mar while maintaining the qualities we love. Most importantly, you gave everyone the opportunity to participate and be heard. There was a great response to the surveys and large participation. The majority, many silent, have spoken. It’s a great result and plan. I appreciate the approach you took. Wanted to send a separate note from the one I just sent on the El Mar Drive Streetscape Project. Thank you for the overall handling of the COVID-19 crisis. You’ve done a great job keeping the beaches and businesses open while maintaining public safety guidelines. The leadership of the Mayor and Town Commission is much appreciated. Also, congratulations on getting the Holiday Inn demolition done. It’s so nice being rid finally of the eyesore. We live on Garden Ct. off Sea Grape south of Commercial. So while we appreciate the eyesore being gone and the excellent progress on the El Mar Streetscape Project, we are disappointed with the conditions of the Hibiscus Portal. Are there plans to clean up the piles of sand and add more sea grass on the left side as you enter the beach? It’s been in this condition since before the pandemic. Also, anything else that could be done to beautify the area a little would be much appreciated. Understand there is probably nothing you can do, unfortunately, about the poor conditions of the properties on each side of the portal but the portal itself is arguably the least attractive of all the portals. I know you are already aware but just wanted to reinforce that the crosswalk put in on Hibiscus and A1A is literally useless. We walk across regularly and cars never stop. A light pedestrians can push, something, needs to be added to the signage. Drivers simply do not realize it’s a crosswalk. Thank you for your consideration to the above. Thank you! 20.) Thomas Kuecks, resident (17 words) I choose Plan #4 - Leave El Mar Alone - Just Fix What Needs Fixing. Thank you. 21.) Robert Noll, resident (117 words) Dear LBTS Town Officials, As a resident who resides at The Caribé, I am deeply concerned for the amount of money that is being allocated to "enhance the beauty" of El Mar Drive. All that needs to be accomplished is the repair of drainage issues, sidewalk repair work, and the accountability of dog owners to pick up feces their pets drop and the trash they leave behind. We currently have a beautiful landscaped area rich of mature shrubs, green grass, and palm trees that do not need to be ripped out and replaced. This "pandemic" has taken a toll both physically and financially for many LBTS residents who DO NOT WANT TAX INCREASES to just make our town "look pretty". Regards, 22.) James & Anne Giannella, resident (80 words) This is James &Anne Giannella, taxpayers, 235 Codrington Drive. We are vehemently opposed to any of the proposals for El Mar. Please leave this beautiful street as it is. We view this as anDocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

attempt to waste millions of taxpayer resources for a result that will not be beneficial to the community. If you have too much in taxpayer funds - please lower the tax rate. Many taxpayers and renters can hardly handle the burden as it is. Respectfully submitted 23.) Joan Carino, resident (200 words) My name is Joan Carino and I’m an LBTS resident, my family has owned our home since 1972. We love this town because it’s unique. It has a small-town feel, low-rise buildings, it’s family and pet friendly, a place to walk to the beach and or restaurants and feel safe and relaxed. El Mar Drive is the oldest and most beautiful street in Lauderdale-by-the-Sea. It is one of the reasons we consider ourselves lucky to live here. It has never been a commercial street. The hotels along El Mar enhance its beauty. People and the places to stay here have co-existed in peaceful harmony for years. Your current plan for El Mar would take away our beautiful wide median and force pedestrians and dog walkers into the street in order to go around the trucks. There should be a fourth option but you have taken away the voice of the residents! No truck parking on El Mar, leave the wide median and pave the sidewalks. If you need one lane of traffic to allow room for a bike-lane, so be it, but PLEASE don’t change the character and beauty of one of the “best little beach towns” in the country! 24.) Maurice Carino, resident (179 words) Mr. Mayor, Commissioners, During the November 10, 2020, Town Commission meeting, a storm water master plan update was presented by Ken Rubach, Public Works. The presentation summarized the tens of millions of dollars needed to upgrade LBTS's storm water system. During the meeting comments were made that LBTS is experiencing increased rainfall. Once predicted as a 100-year event is happening more often. During recent rain storms, many streets experienced flooding that took days to drain. Coupling these storm drainage issues with rising sea water, it seems prudent that available financial resources be dedicated to higher priority projects like those presented in the storm water review. The proposed modifications to El Mar do not rise to the priority level of those associated with flooding streets and properties. Nor does it appear that the citizens of LBTS, in general, support any of the proposed El Mar modifications. It is logical to have minor repairs needed on El Mar, such as sidewalk repair, be made in substitution of the three expensive proposals and that financial resources be dedicated to higher priority projects. 25.) Ellen Warburton, resident (50 words) Commissioners: Please adopt/vote for Plan 4, I believe this option will continue to allow residents the ability to continue with the lifestyle and environment that drew us to this town and the reason we love our home in Lauderdale by the Sea. Thank you for taking my opinion into consideration.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

24.) Herb Young, resident (85 words) I'm a resident of sea ranch lakes c and I enjoy walking El Mar drive everyday. I don't think it needs a major redesign, just a little touch up, maybe fix some streetlights that may be out or patch a couple minor sidewalk cracks. Installing more prominent bicycle lanes will only encourage more bicycle clubs and you should ask yourself, have you ever seen a bicycle stop at a stop sign? Let's keep them on A1A where they won't run stop signs and cause accidents. 25.) Elizabeth Vienna, resident (127 words) My husband and I have been owners of a condo in Starlight Towers for 23 years now. Every morning we take a two mile walk to LBTS center on Commercial rest on the square and walk back. As we turn off A1A onto El Mar Drive it is such a relief to walk down the street with the charming medium. There are always walkers, joggers, bikers, dog walkers to say hello. It is like you have become a part of the small town of LBTS. Always courteous drivers without the fumes of A1A. Do not take away that charming and relaxed part of our town. Save the parking for parking lots on A1A. Leave El Mar Drive to the walkers, joggers, bikers and dog walkers to enjoy 26.) Les Byron, resident (words) I vote for Plan 4 where the median is not affected. 26.) Kevin Mahoney, resident (897 words) To Whom It May Concern: I am writing to oppose the three proposed designs for reconfiguring El Mar Drive. But before I get into my questions regarding the proposed designs and describe my preferred approach, I want to express some disappointment with the process that has led us to this moment – a moment when so many oppose the recommended plans. In the summer and fall we were surveyed on the things we as citizens wanted. But the plans that were produced, rather than showing how the plans matched and addressed our needs, seem to have been forged based on code-required factors like requirements for sidewalk width when sidewalks are replaced, or the necessity of clear zones of a certain width, that should have been revealed in advance so people could tailor their preferences to what the Town would even consider. The plans sometimes seem to be window-dressing pretending to observe citizen input while really just calling code requirements (e.g., clear zone = Bicycle path) by a different name. It would have been helpful to know the decision rules in advance including the fact that the Town would not approve a plan where people could walk in the street. When some of the questioners at the demonstration asked why people couldn't continue to walk in the street given the low volume of traffic (currently 1000 vehicle trips a day) the answer was, "Because walking in the street is illegal". With social distancing requirements, people walking dogs in the median strip, and some peoples' obvious preference to walk in the street, does anyone think walking in the street will stop? Why are there no signs forbidding walking in the street now? I appreciated the chance to view life-size images of current options but I was left with more questions than answers, even after speaking with the Town official at the demonstration. I am one of those who wear the SAVE THE MEDIAN shirts. I am still not convinced one can't just fix the sidewalks, meet clear zone requirements, and leave the median strip alone.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

The width of El Mar is pre-determined so it seems we are dealing with a zero sum game, i.e., if you give more space to one aspect you need to take it from others. There seem to be three elements, SIDEWALKS, SO-CALLED BICYCLE LANES, and THE MEDIAN (which would need pull-outs if El Mar had only a single lane for traffic in each direction). Let me take each in turn: A) SIDEWALKS. The proposed sidewalks are 9 ft wide in Options 1 and 2 and 8' in Option 3. When I asked "why?", I was told that when sidewalks are redone they have to come up to ADA standards. But ADA standards are 5 ft. In fact sidewalks can be 3 feet wide if they have passing lanes at intervals. So why the extra width? I hope it is not because of those ugly cement poles (that hold the wires and cables) sticking out into the sidewalks. If that is the reason, ADA rules say the obstruction can be moved. (Wouldn't it be nice if those ugly wires were underground like they are near Commercial Blvd?) Maybe the power company would reconsider in light of ADA rules? B) BICYCLE LANES. When I mentioned that there already was a bicycle lane in front of the Courtyard Villas (on the east side of El Mar north of Datura), the Town spokesperson answering questions said I was wrong. I wasn't wrong. When I said it probably isn't used because it doesn't go anywhere and, with so few cars on El Mar, you don't need a bike lane. I went on to suggest that even if they put a bike lane on the full length of El Mar it doesn't go anywhere especially heading south on Palm to A1A south. I suggested that bike lanes belong on busy streets like A1A the way Ft Lauderdale does. The woman answering questions said all your points are irrelevant. We have to leave this space anyway so why not call it a bike lane. I thought one of the purposes of the redesign was to address bikers' wishes? (Option 2 has two bike lanes but that seems even more unnecessary given the low traffic volume). MEDIAN STRIP PULL-OUTS. (which cut 9-ft into the median in Options 1 and 2) Other than near Commercial, there appear to be 10 pullouts (2 of which are large) north of Commercial and only 8 (all of the smaller size) south of Commercial. Am I correct? I asked why? Take a look at how many abandoned, dilapidated, half-built, or open space properties are on El Mar south of Commercial. I asked the Town spokeswoman if they really knew what would be needed south of Commercial given the number of unoccupied properties. She claimed they had good estimates. I asked why, once again, does the north side of town seem to get more attention? All the woman said was that they needed to plan for the pull-outs before construction because it would be quite difficult to add any later. I would suggest that Town officials table these El Mar Re-Design plans. At the very least, I feel the need for transparency on what the decision rules are for acceptable plans. It seems the Town already knew, or had a very good idea of, what options would be recommended. 27.) Linda Aronowitz, resident (18 words) My husband and I love walking and biking on El Mar Drive. Please don’t change this beautiful area!DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

28.) Suzanne Morese, resident (151 words) As a 20+ year resident of LBTS, I've seen a number of changes. Some pluses (landscaping and design, cleanliness, parks, etc.) and some minuses (over-ride district, out of area contract for parking, etc.) None of these, however, will impact the charm and uniqueness of our town as the plans for destruction of the serenity of EL MAR DRIVE. Whether ending a day of work or just leaving the shopping and traffic of Ocean Drive and proceeding to El Mar -- one takes a breath of fresh air and is overcome with a feeling of peace. Ah-Ah!! How rare today to find this so close to home! I implore you to leave EL MAR as is. We have major thoroughfares now jutting through LBTS -- Commercial Blvd., and AIA. Please leave EL MAR as a walking, jogging, biking thoroughfare with its greenery, cool, clean air and a minimal traffic flow. Please, Please! 29.) Perry & Patricia Miele, resident (281 words) I am writing to you regarding the upcoming meeting on January 12th, and for my note to be submitted and read at the January meeting. Thank you and very much appreciated. "I choose Plan #4 - Leave El Mar Dr. Alone - Just Fix What Needs Fixing" and keep maintained We bought our home’s here in the Town of LBTS, at VBS community Three and half years ago. (We loved the Historic and beautiful landscaping of El Mar Drive) this is why our family own three condo’s at VBS, My wife and I, My Brother and my Cousin). We choose the Town of LBTS and VBS on El Mar Drive for its beautiful historic low rise properties, its main street with local independent restauranters, and shops. Most of all the beautiful and historical El Mar Drive with the park, and its wide center median landscaping, gardens, and Palm Trees. It would be heartbreaking and unconceivable to tear up a beautiful and historical El Mar Drive. Especially when it currently works beautifully for everyone, and there are no documented safety concerns or serious flooding issues that I have heard of, nor that I have seen. I am on my balcony at VBS everyday looking down and up El Mar Drive and have never seen any issues. All I see is family’s taking a walk, jogging, biking and having fun in the park. Sometimes beautiful historical things, and tranquility is right in front of us, and parts of our world should stay frozen to in time – this is El Mar Drive. Thank you very much for reading my note in the meeting – Leaving Historic El Mar Drive as it is and basically maintained. 30.) Leslie & Judith Cole (words) Dear Commissioners, It is with great trust and confidence that you will listen to the residents and guests of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea and consider our wishes to preserve our magnificent greenway. As residents, we walk daily on the peaceful and scenic thoroughfare known as El Mar Drive.DocuSign Envelope ID: 8BF45A8A-78DE-41FE-BC52-9D8ED4CE9DB5

Significant changes to the tress, grass, open spaces, and natural beauty will destroy the tranquility and serenity of this unique part of our town. The attractive qualities of LBTS are centered in its welcome and intimate atmosphere. As we walk, there are never issues with safety regarding trucks, vehicles, and pedestrian traffic. It would be devastating to remove the lush environment in lieu of additional parking and increased vehicular traffic. Notwithstanding appropriated grant monies and government fundings, is incumbent upon the town planners to heed the input and concerns of those most impacted by such significant Changes. Please preserve our amazing El Mar Drive! Thank you for your consideration to this matter. 31.) Renee Oneal, resident (106 words) We love our el mar Drive just the way it is. Do not change it. Stop wasting my taxes on projects that are not broken. I am a tax payer of LBTS for the last 28 years. I hate to see you waste our money. Spend the money on more open portals to the ocean. Please do not change El mar drive. I enjoy riding my bike in the bike lane and would not feel safe with only one lane. Stop wasting our tax payers money on projects that are not needed. Take the money and provide a portal on the ocean for residents to. 32.) Constantine Xanthos, resident (82 words) During my eleven year residency in our community, I have made daily use of El Mar as a pedestrian. In my opinion, this street is the town's single biggest attraction other than the beach. Its calm, its greenery, its birdlife and its suitability for walking add tremendous value to the area. Any change that would impinge on the median, or change the flow of traffic, would detract from it. I support making no changes to El Mar other than repairing the sidewalks. 33.) Jim Mendillo, resident (34 wor

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Town Commission — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8ff70d8627fde8ed0e921dd525edf57a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record