POLISCOPE

The public record

BREVARD COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Brevard County Board of County Commissioners

Thursday, December 11, 2025 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

The Brevard County Board of County Commissioners held a public hearing to discuss zoning changes and land use amendments for several properties. Key items included a request for a zoning classification change in District 1 and a proposal by City Pointe Landfall LLC to amend land use designations and rezone property for a residential development project.

Why it matters

Residents should care because these decisions determine how land in their community is developed, affecting local density, traffic access, and environmental protections.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

18

Recorded outcomes

17

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

17 captured items have a publicly linked outcome. These 5 are the clearest resident summaries in the record.

Search all 18 meeting actions
  • Item H.1.

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

    approved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the future land use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4, application number 24SS00009, located in Titusville. Trina Gilliam stated Items H.1. and H.2. are companion cases and they are generally read into the record together, but the Board has to make a separate decision. Chair Altman read into the record Item H.2., City Pointe Landfall LLC requests a change of zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing Binding Development Plan (BDP) to PUD with removal of the existing BDP, located in District 1. He noted he will have staff provide a summary. Ms. Gilliam advised she would like to read the application numbers into the record; Item H.1., the Small Scale Amendment, the application number is 24SS00009, located in District 1; and Item H.2., City Point Landfall, under application number 24PUD00003, is also located in District 1. Kim Rezanka, Law Firm of Lacey Rezanka, stated she is there on behalf of City Point Landfall, the owner and developer of the project; she has with her David Bassford with MVB Engineering, the engineer of record, if the Board has any questions; she feels as though she has given this presentation four times; because of the last comments that were heard, she worked with staff and they are changing the future land use from requesting RES-4 to RES-2; the reason that had not been done prior was because they did not think they could do that because part of the land was in the coastal high hazard area and because of spreading the density; they were not sure they were able to do that with the size of the houses clustered the way they were; working with the Planning and Development Director, Billy Prasad, and Ms. Gilliam, they had determined and opined that it could be changed to RES-2; and with the density bonus provided in the Comprehensive Plan, Policy 1.8, they could ask for the density bonus of 2.5 to keep the 23 units they were requesting. She went on to say what she has provided the Board is exactly what is in the staff report, and it was previously provided on November 24 or 26 and it is in Legistar; it is nothing new, she just thought it might be easier to see it up close in this document; page two is the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that is being requested with the PUD zoning; it shows the zoning currently is EU; page three shows the existing future land use of RES-1 and the RES-4 to the east and little bit of RES-2, will all now be RES-2 if the Board approves it; RES-2 is exactly what is to the north in the Parkchester subdivision; and the houses are compatible in sizes, that is what the engineer was able to do. She continued by saying it takes the wetlands of RES-4 and makes them RES-2; it hopefully helps some of the neighbors with the idea knowing that all the applicant is really trying to do is 23 units; if the PDP is never built, it is RES-2 and it is RES-2 all the way to the river, so it protects the wetlands to some extent; there was a request to put that in private conservation, but it was not large enough to put in private conservation, so they could not do that, but it will definitely be in a conservation tract, the wetlands to the east; and the next page is just showing the wetlands area and the temporary impacts. She noted there is going to be an elevated bike path through the wetlands as an amenity for the residents; the last page is just the overlay to show the houses next to the houses, where the stormwater ponds are, and the wetlands that will be protected; as the Board may recall, the residents have been very engaged, very vocal; they have asked that they remove the townhomes, and that has been done; and they had asked for no access on Parkchester and that access was removed, with the only access being from US 1. She stated the residents did not want any access on Indian River Drive; at one point there was a little parking area as an amenity, but it has been removed from the PDP; and the remaining issue which they have addressed is the RES-2. She mentioned there are concerns of flooding and stormwater, which has been discussed several times by the engineer of record, Bruce Moia for MVB; again, that is something that has to be engineered; this is just zoning so any flooding issues would be addressed during the plat stage; and with that, she is asking that the Board approve the request of RES-2, and then the small parcel of 1.94 acres of CC on the west against US 1, and then the remaining 10.94 would be RES-2. She commented with that, she would request the Board approved the PDP and the PUD request with the waivers; the last page the Board has, has a waiver request and that is dealing with the perimeter of the subdivision because they have to deal with some canals and some drainage, and that is why they ask that the waiver be accepted with the PDP; there will still be a buffer and they will still commit to whatever type of buffer that is necessary to make it compatible; they have indeed put in the PDP, towards the east side, the requirement of an opaque buffer that was requested by Mr. and Mrs. Hous; the Board will see on the PDP, page two, it says “225 feet of an opaque buffer” and that is to buffer homes that would be adjacent to their home; that is in there and would be a requirement of any plat going forward; they will answer any questions; they would ask the Board to approve the RES-2, find that it is compatible because it is next to RES-2 so they could use the density bonuses to achieve the 23 units in the PDP; and she would ask that she be allowed to respond to any comments. Commissioner Adkinson stated this is kind of the same question she has asked before; and she inquired what the buffer to the northwest side between the houses is going to look like. Ms. Rezanka stated that it is going to be an opaque buffer; and she does not know exactly if it is going to be a fence or foliage that one cannot see through. Commissioner Adkinson asked if it will be opaque all the way across the entire back. Ms. Rezanka explained it will be; the applicant has only committed to the fence towards the area against the Hous’ property; and if the Board wants to make that a condition of an opaque fence or buffer the entire way, the applicant would certainly accept that. Commissioner Adkinson stated she was just thinking about if they are leaving the native trees that are already there. Ms. Rezanka replied unfortunately, because there is an elevation difference and there is a ditch through between the properties, those trees will likely have to come out; they intend to save them, but they do not know because all the engineering has not been completed; there have been some elevations done; by the way, they all have fences there already; however, if the Board wants a condition that they have an opaque buffer the entire length against Parkchester, they can do that. Commissioner Adkinson commented for her the opaque thing is not as important as the actual trees and things that are going to be lost; and she asked if the applicant would consider if they had to take out a big deciduous tree, putting a decent sized one back in there. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively; and she added if the Commissioner wants to make a condition that like-trees go back in, they can do that and make it a condition of the PDP. James Sudermann stated he lives just south of this project; he was happy to see the new addendum number two from staff; there were several pieces of that he would like to comment on; in light of the new alternative proposal submitted by City Pointe Landfall on December 25 and the new staff comments addendum number two he would like to voice the following, while they recognize that the latest proposal from City Pointe Landfall does not preserve the original existing BDP that they have, he keeps asking for it, it does address to a greater or lesser extent, most of the remaining ongoing concerns with density growth potential, stormwater and groundwater discharge issues, wetland preservation, and roadway flooding; if the Board were to adopt all of the conditions, staff comments, and applicant offers outlined in addendum number two, and the City Pointe PDP, their 2025, 1126 applicant alternative proposal that he thinks was just handed out, Beverly and himself would be willing to accept them as something they could live with; but be assured that he and Beverly only represent themselves in this and cannot speak for the rest of their neighbors who have fought with them so long and hard to get this Board and this developer to listen and respond to all of their comments. He stated specifically to grant their support, they would like to see application of the RES-2 future land use map designation on the entire 10.94 acre residential portion of the property; they would like to make sure that a ban is imposed on all residential land use on the wetlands; staff comments also mention that a Public Works engineering evaluation of the outfall pipes across the Indian River roadway and of possibly raising the road should be performed, they would also like to see that memorialized here; as suggested by staff, they talk about creating a new BDP which incorporates at least the following provisions, any future change to the PDP will be considered a substantial change and require Board approval for the change; overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property and overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subjective property; the new BDP should conduct a ground water analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; dedication of up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County Maintenance and roadway projects along the north Indian River Drive; and finally the provision that says the future land use designation is to revert if the final development plan are never filed. He added he would like to reiterate if all the provisions and comments from this new staff addendum are included, he and Beverly could live with it. Chair Altman stated he noticed, and it may just be an oversight, Mr. Sudermann left out one portion in his comments, as he was following along with him, and it is the one that says preferably without the 25 percent density bonus based on FL1 Policy 1.8., if limited to 21 units, he did not hear that. Mr. Sudermann apologized and stated he did skip that; that is true they definitely appreciate the RES-2; if they had a preference they would like to see it be without the 25 percent density bonus which gets them to a potential of 25, although with the PUD being approved, that would just limit it to 23; he did make a comment here, it says, if limited to 21 units, the developer could incrementally increase the lot size of the small southern lots, which are pretty small, and or could donate a portion of the southside property as an access path to 1800s pioneer cemetery, which has been landlocked now for decades; and that would be a nice gesture. Greg Burroughs stated just to reiterate what the previous speaker has just said, really the main thing being looked at is the wetlands and how that is going to affect any runoff that goes down into the river, anything from the soil, and obviously, from the grasses, fertilizers, and things like that that could end up in that river going straight down; he does appreciate the two units per acre; he is not sure how that is going to affect, without any RV storage in the front; he would not mind seeing a turning lane dedicated into that neighborhood so that the three lanes which have been reduced to two right in front of that property do not cause any bottlenecks or any more accidents; and he thanked the Board for its time. Diane Burroughs stated she wanted to reiterate along with Mr. Sudermann; she thanked the applicant for the consideration for reducing it from a RES-4 to a RES-2; and she asked to continue to keep in mind the conservation area, the flooding, and those very serious issues that are currently happening in that area, and how this is going to impact it. Sandra Kennedy stated she lives about one-half mile north of this project; no matter how many public hearings and how many residents complain about this project, the criteria are set in the rules and regulations that are applicable to this Board; and they are binding. She continued by saying the applicant has not met the requirements for a variance; City Pointe Landfall’s application does not meet the criteria for a zoning variance, even limited, and the County Commissioners must reject the application in its entirety; not once have they addressed the community, the neighborhood; their title is City Pointe, City Pointe is a community that stretches from a little bit north of 528, around City Pointe Road, all the way to at least Blacks Road and really beyond; it is along Indian River Drive which is basically at sea level in this area; this is not the Indian River Drive portion that is on bluffs in Cocoa, it is sea level; and there is already flooding problems that need to be addressed. She went on to say one of the Board’s criteria that absolutely must be met before any variance can be given is that they must not increase or cause flooding to the community; they have failed that one right away; their recent change, which she received late last night while she was preparing for this hearing, was that they were giving the Board another paragraph on what their flood control plan is; basically, they had nothing to say but what they had said before; they plan a series of ponds that they are going to allow to overflow; that is their strategy, ponds that overflow; they are going to go down to the wetlands and those wetlands are not sponges, not dry, and they do not need to be appropriately wetted, they are soaking wet; and there are ditches that run along Indian River Drive that are constantly full. She stated their capacity for more water does not exist; they are going to cause flooding; not only that, but their project, it does not abut the full wetland, it only abuts a portion, less than half of the wetland, and the other portion of the land that is a lower elevation to them, is going to get flooded out, and it is residential property; there are no ditches in front of those people’s houses because it is not in an appropriate location like it is in front of that wetland; they do not have a flood control plan; they say they are going to use offsite flooding systems and that just means a ditch; she is between US 1, City Pointe Road and basically, Blacks Road or further north, and the Indian River Lagoon; this is their community, the whole entire thing is large homes on large lots; all recent developments since the 60s has been single homes on an acre or two homes on an acre; they are blowing that out of the water; they are trying to say well Parkchester is to the north, but that is not the community; and she asked why they have titled their company name as City Pointe. She noted Parkchester is a remnant from the past; it is what the Planning and Zoning rules and regulations were trying to get away from, which is strip all the trees down and try to put a whole bunch of homes crammed in; that is not bad if it is on flat land, but it cannot be done in environmentally sensitive lands where there are live oak hammocks on a slope; US 1 is like 75 feet or so and it is like a giant waterslide that goes down to Indian River Drive; and the open spaces are needed to absorb the water; the community, they go around saying, Parkchester and all these small communities, and this little property here is .2 of an acre, and they talk about the industrial area way across, but that is a different zone and not the neighborhood, so they do not match the neighborhood; they do not meet the County’s criteria to receive this; they are not even a Planned Unit Development (PUD) and they are not entitled to exceed or to get that bonus; now with that bonus, they would be getting more than they have ever sought before; and they are not a planned community that is fully encompassing everything that the community would need, it is a very small strip of land. She reiterated it is not a PUD, they are not entitled to a bonus, they need to stick to the regular zoning like the rest of the community. She asked the Board to follow the law. Chair Altman noted he has a question for staff; Ms. Kennedy used the term variance; and he asked if this is a variance or a zoning change. Ms. Gilliam replied no, sir, it is a zoning change in a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment. Chair Altman asked so they do not use the variance… Ms. Gilliam interjected by saying criteria. Ms. Kennedy stated the criteria are for rezoning; she does not know the difference between rezoning and variance; she is a construction lawyer not a land development lawyer; but the County’s own criteria says for rezoning it has to meet this criteria; it is flooding that has to be met before and compatibility to match the entire community; the other thing, their PUD, they have to hide that extra density within the community so that it cannot be seen from the rest of the community; that is the only thing that would allow them to do it; and this is such a small strip of land so there is no hiding anything. Chair Altman stated he now understands her point. Commissioner Goodson asked in their proposal for dry retention ponds on the hill that eventually get to the wetlands, are they required to store 100 percent of the water for 24 hours; and he asked if that is correct. Chair Altman stated before they take a motion or vote, he will let Ms. Rezanka have an opportunity to close, she might want to hear this first. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, stated he will let Darcie McGee, Environmental Policy and Resilience Administrator, answer this. Ms. McGee advised they are not going to be required to hold 100 percent of their water on site based on State stormwater standards; they have to meet certain criteria to hold, and she believes it is a 25-year storm; that then gets held to treat for water quality; then there will be eventual discharge that will go through the system that they show on the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that goes down through the pond down to the wetlands and then out to the river; and that does not account for the volume, just the rate and the water quality treatment. Commissioner Goodson asked as far as staff, how much water it thinks is going to occur that goes through the wetlands to the river. Ms. McGee advised there is no way she could answer something like that; she thinks in the package, if this is correct, there was a where the engineer had previously talked about maintaining the volume and the rate of flow; and that would be something he could engineer. Mr. Bernath commented that is correct; Mr. Moia had previously advised that they agreed to engineering concerns about ensuring post-development stormwater discharge rate and volume for the site; because this is just at the zoning stage, staff has not seen anything and cannot confirm that it meets it; but that is what he has agreed to. Commissioner Goodson stated of course everyone agrees that City Pointe Road intersecting Indian River Road has always been low; and he asked if that is correct. Mr. Bernath replied affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to read off addendum number two, the concessions that he thinks are fair or he is willing to accept. Mr. Prasad advised he will start with one that he thinks somebody had mentioned today and Ms. Rezanka had brought up last time that he does not think is appropriate, and that would be the automatic reversion of the land use if the PDP was not recorded; staff does not think that there is any legal mechanism to implement that and that is why it was left off the Agenda Report for Board consideration; he just wanted to explain why the public would not hear him say that; for the conditions that the applicant had agreed to, he will add one that they mentioned today which is for like trees as part of the waiver request for disturbing the buffer; beyond that, an overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, an overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conducting a groundwater analysis by identifying any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; and they have volunteered to offer to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive. He noted staff would suggest that if the Board is looking to implement those conditions that it do so and ask for it to be implemented through a BDP. Commissioner Goodson asked if this gets approval and it is built, how staff will govern the discharge of water. Mr. Prasad explained that would be done through the site plan process; and the applicant would have to demonstrate that they are meeting all of the conditions through various analysis. Commissioner Goodson asked if the applicant would be liable down the road, six months after the project is done, to make sure they do not put too much water into the Indian River Lagoon. Mr. Prasad stated the BDP will carry with the land; he would also say that under the County’s Code that the maintenance of discharge is typically on the private entities; and it could be enforced in the future. Ms. Gilliam advised the Board she has one other condition and that is to memorialize in the BDP that any future changes to the PDP be considered a substantial change and be brought back before the Board. Mr. Bernath advised he would like to add one more; and he does not know if it was agreed to during the last meeting, but staff had asked for the 50 feet of total right-of-way that is proposed to be dedicated, that the applicant also agree to mitigate those wetlands in the granted right-of-way, otherwise that will become a future County cost. Commissioner Delaney stated she wanted to disclose that she had a meeting with the Twin Lakes Homeowners Association and she did drive past the neighborhood, by the location to see the conditions last night; there have been a lot of concessions made with this project and she really appreciates that; she feels like the developer has tried to work with the community; if this was in a different area it would be harder for her to say no; but this area is so unique and there is a constant of running water throughout this area. She went on to say even the drainage pipes; being next to them it sounds like a shower all the time; that is just the ground water, it is not because there is even any rain; she is extremely concerned about the density of this project for this location because it is just so fragile; then on top of that, there is the issue of low-lying Indian River Drive; people’s vehicles are getting ruined, people are getting trapped on their streets, and one resident had told her that they had to rent a car because they did not want to damage their own vehicle; District 1 is experiencing a lot of flooding and a lot of property damage; her concern is that it is going to hit a boiling point at some point to where this is going to be a Countywide problem because the County is going to have to start buying houses from people if not careful; Volusia County has had to deal with this; she does not want to see that happen here in Brevard County; and she is very concerned that if the County does not keep this BDP and keep the density low in this area that the County is going to have huge problem. She mentioned just in general she believes that a person should do their due diligence when buying property; it sounds like the applicant knew what they were buying and knew it had a BDP on it; it is not right for the whole neighborhood to have to be affected by this when the property owners knew what they were purchasing; it is not like somebody pulled the wool over their eyes; and that is kind of where she is at. Chair Altman stated there is another card that got mixed up with other cards. Bill Gower stated this keeps coming back; the people who bought this property knew there was a binding contract on it; what he sees is basically they threw everything against the wall to see what would stick, make the people happy, and see what they could get away with; after a meeting they would say there is no reason for people to come to the next meeting; there were 100 of them when it started out and they were told they did not have to go to the next meeting because they were just going to postpone it, and that is why the people have dwindled down in size; he has lived there since 1989; he knows how wide that property is and by the time one puts a road through the middle for two lands, then houses and driveways, that is a lot of water that is being added to that property and no place to go; when he talked to the guys that did the survey, his property sits lower than anybody else in regards to it, and he does get flooded out when it rains; and he is on the upper side not on the lower side like some other people. He reiterated basically, they threw everything against the wall to see what sticks; if the Board approved something today, what makes this guy not go sell to somebody else and the next guys say they go away with that, let them go ask for more; and that is all he has to say. He commented that paperwork that was passed up there, he did not see any of it from the developers. Chair Altman advised he thinks what was provided by the applicant is the same as what is in the Board packet online.
  • Item H.2.

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

    Moved by Katie Delaney · Seconded by Kim Adkinson

    approved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, application number 24PUD00003, and tax account number 2411252, located in District 1. Commissioner Delaney asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to assist her with the motion. Chair Altman asked if needs to be reread into the record. Mr. Prasad explained if it is said all the conditions outlined in the Agenda Report with the addition of some of the ones that were heard today, which is as part of the waiver request that would have to be approved as part of this application, like for like trees; then also mitigate any wetlands within the 50 foot right-of-way should they have to be dedicated… Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they cannot agree to that because it impacts their ability to mitigate. Chair Altman asked which one that was; and he asked that Ms. Rezanka come up and clarify that. Ms. Rezanka stated it was asked that the 50 foot right-of-way that is being dedicated, that they take on the responsibility for mitigating the wetlands; and she explained they cannot do that because it impacts the wetlands on the site because it would all be done at the same time; they only get 1.8 percent to impact; therefore, they cannot agree to that. Chair Altman stated so they are going to give up the land… Ms. Rezanka reiterated they are not agreeing to… Chair Altman interjected by saying mitigate somebody else’s land. Ms. Rezanka stated they may agree later on, but right now they cannot because they have to mitigate their own; and that was not something that was listed that she has agreed to. Ms. Gilliam asked if staff could make a comment. Ms. McGee stated she just wants to add that when talking about the dedication of the 50 foot right-of-way, they had talked about that not counting against their 1.8 percent because that would be to the benefit of the County for that 50 feet; that would not count against the other wetland impacts for the 1.8 percent for the applicant; but again, the mitigation being part of that cost. Mr. Bernath agreed, and stated he would just add that if they do not do it now, that is County right-of-way, and the taxpayers are going to be doing it if it ever decides to widen that road. Chair Altman inquired if the County owns it, would it not be the County’s responsibility to mitigate for widening the road, that is the public benefit to widen the road; if they have given up that right-of-way it would be the public's responsibility to mitigate for the public good of building the road; he understands their point, they are giving up the land and now they have to mitigate; he does not know; but he agrees with the applicant on that, he does not think that should be a requirement. Mr. Bernath stated he does not know if they will agree to it, but buy credits for mitigation. Ms. Rezanka noted she does not have the authority to do that or to spend her client’s money who is not in attendance to agree, when he told her not to agree to that; and at this point she cannot agree to it. Chair Altman commented they are basically giving land. Ms. Rezanka stated they are giving land that would have to be taken by imminent domain at a valuable price. Chair Altman commented and a lot of legal costs so he appreciates her doing that. Mr. Prasad stated so with that said, the conditions would be as outlined in the Agenda Report, if the Board would like he will restate them but he has already stated them before, it would be for like for like trees, and work for the County to add potential treatments to shore up the shoreline along the Indian River Lagoon. Chair Altman stated on the issue of clearing, because he is not for clearing land as much as possible, but he has seen a lot of projects where some of which he voted on to preserve the native buffer, but if one goes back and the buffer is dead because when one does the improvements of the property, it affects the drainage, just a little soil on some of those trees kills it; and he agrees with not having to be able to go and it would have been a healthier, more attractive buffer if it was replanted, so he supports that. He mentioned that he does have a question, and he asked when it is said like for like trees is that species or size because there are some very large trees there. Mr. Prasad explained he thinks they are looking for similar type and size of trees, but he would defer to Ms. McGee whose Department implements that. Ms. McGee stated like for like can work depending on how big the lots are and what that buffer is; they may not be able to put back the same number of oak trees that may crowd out or may interfere with the buildings or structures. Chair Altman commented he worries about their ability to do the size too. Ms. McGee stated that is kind of a tough one to apply at permitting because if they take out a 20-inch oak they would not put back a 20-inch oak, they are going to be smaller ones. Chair Altman mentioned he has been by the site many times; he does not think a tree survey has been done; and he is just concerned with saying like for like, the size should not be a requirement. Mr. Prasad stated perhaps similar within reason. Chair Altman stated okay, that is good. Ms. McGee noted they like to make it specific to help staff apply it when it gets to permitting; she does not know if Mr. Prasad can put language in there to negotiate with Natural Resources Management for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a good buffer; and she asked if that would be acceptable. Chair Altman stated he likes the word mature. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just add one more thing, they were talking about PDP conditions, if the Board could just include to memorialize that in a BDP. Commissioner Delaney stated the motion would be to change the zoning from EU and RP with an existing BDP to a PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, but to add another BDP, including the things the Board has spoken about; she asked if she needs to read out all of those; and what does she need to say with the PDP. Mr. Prasad stated as part of the zoning approval, the Board would be approving the PUD with the conditions specified to be memorialized in a PDP. Commissioner Delaney made that motion. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a Change of Zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP and approval of the PDP; approved a waiver to Section 62-2883(d) requiring an undisturbed 15-foot buffer around the perimeter of the project with the condition that any vegetation removed shall be replaced with reasonable similar vegetation in consultation with Natural Resources Management Department for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a buffer similar to its natural state; and making the PUD subject to the following conditions, which are to be memorialized in a BDP: an overall reduction of rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, overall reduction of volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conduct a groundwater analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly, applicant voluntarily offers to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive, and the applicant to work with staff on shoring up/improving the shoreline on the Lagoon. (24PUD00003).
  • Item H.3.

    Jacob Foune requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (25S.14) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2. (25SS00008) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

    approved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jacob Foune for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment, 25S.14, to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2, application number 25SS00008, and tax account 2000804, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is a companion application and he will need to read into the record Item H.4., as well, or she can read it into the record for him. Chair Altman advised Ms. Gilliam to go ahead and read it into the record. Ms. Gilliam stated Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to SR with removal of the existing BDP and in addition of a new BDP, under application number 25Z00037, located in District 1. Jacob Foune stated he bought this land, submitted permits, got everything accepted and started building; he already has concrete block done and all inspections have passed; he has had his trusses sitting for nearly six months; he and his wife have spent their life-savings on this and just want to continue; he relied on the County and did everything as he should; and to clear one thing up from the last meeting, he is an employee for a very reputable air conditioning (AC) company and he does not work for Minnick. He noted he does new construction HVAC for many small builders in Brevard County, including Minnick. Pat Ramer stated what she wants to address has already been spoken about many times here and that is the density; increasing density in this area, which is already prone to flooding, is only going to make the problem worse; every time the Board approves a variance or a zoning change to increase the density, it is increasing the chances of flooding in that area; people are suffering right now; during the last 2025 calendar year, they have had six flooding events in that particular area; she understands the house has already started to be built, it is significantly higher than the property behind it; and it is going to cause flooding to that other property. She asked the Board to consider that as it look at this request. Michael Biegler stated he has lived at 4125 Golden Shores for 22 years; he has lived in Brevard County for 61 years, and doing construction for 40 years; he has worked for many contractors throughout the State of Florida, some very big ones; he has never heard anything like what he is going to talk about in his entire career; Scotty Minnick is a contractor who sold 0.54 acres to Jacob Foune; alterations were done to the lot which violates the condition of the BDP, Section 62-2102 Brevard County Code of Ordinances, which states that no person shall separate the lot in a manner which violates the law; but the land was unlawfully split and an unlawful permit was given anyway. He continued by saying they would have all been at the public hearing along with Clifford McKnight of 3900 Golden Shores, on November 17, if they were notified, but the notification only went out to a few people that live within 500 feet; the letter was deceiving to most of the elderly who received it; it states that the land change was for 6.24 acres, not 0.54 acre, and that is not right because for many years the residents have been paying taxes, living on Golden Shores, and a lot longer Scotty Minnick and the applicant Jacob Foune, who is trying to unlawfully split land and build a house with an unlawful permit on 4060 Golden Shores Boulevard, which is going to be the launching site for McKnight, Minnick whatever construction it is, and other builders so they can break up property into smaller sections to build more houses and make more money; there was situation that took place right beside him on 3.10 acres; the Code Enforcement was called and they stopped it because the law was being broken; sad to be said, the guy that owned the land died and his heart sunk for him and he cried for him; it was just a small little thing that man had to take care of, but he had over three acres; but everyone is not talking about three acres, two acres, or even 6.24 acres, it is under acreage, and the people do not want it out there. He commented that just does not make sense to anyone who is in attendance today; he was just notified about this this week; they are law abiding citizens that have been living in Mims and Scottsmoor area for many years who voted for the County officials to represent the people and uphold the law; and he hopes this Board does its job and votes no for a law that has been broken. Stephanie Knight stated the proposed change alters the established character of this neighborhood where every residential lot is an acre or more; she initially chose to build there in a low density area relying on the zoning regulations that were put in place to preserve this area for herself and her kids; those standards should be upheld by the Board and all employees of Brevard County Zoning, Brevard County Property Appraiser, and the Brevard County Permitting; allowing permits for substandard lot sizes is only inconsistent with the zoning requirements, but raises serious concerns about accountability with the permitting process; when unlawful or improper permits are approved, especially using taxpayers resources, it enables and reinforces the very practices that created the issue; each time Commissioners vote in favor of these applicants, it further empowers that Department to continue using permits that do not comply with the law; and this request is incompatible with the current development plan and undermines the long-standing character of this community. She added approving this would set a troubling precedent, opening the door to further expectations that could gradually transform the area into a disorganized, higher density landscape, precisely what many residents sought to avoid in that area; zoning regulations should not be modified to accommodate negligence or oversight on people who work for the County, instead enforce, and accountability must be prioritized; granting variances under these circumstances only complicates matters and signals to other builders and property owners that non-compliance will be excused; this seems to be a problem within departments, that they need to be addressed and corrected so this does not keep happening; and she is confident if the department was audited it would find multiple unlawful permits such as two properties on Todd Lane, this one on Golden Shores, and there were problems with two properties on Aurantia where squatters decided to try to take over property and it was approved at the Appraiser’s Office until the owner of that property got wind of it and had to fight to get the property back; and the Property Appraiser’s Office should know that in order to take over property people have to be there for seven years, and they were they were there two months. She continued by saying Mr. McKnight asked her to read this because he could not be in attendance; and she read, “Dear Commissioners, I’m writing on behalf of numerous residents of Golden Shores Boulevard in Mims regarding the removal of the existing BDP, along with the new land, land use request is inconsistent with the current development plan and undermines the character of our community. This change sets a concerning precedent that could transform our area into disorganized urban landscape, something many of us sought to avoid when we chose to live here. Even with the proposed half-acre variance, this rezoning should not proceed. The Brevard County property website lists that parcel as .45 acre contrary to the .51 acre indicated by the new survey. Additionally, the houses directly behind the parcel located at 4070 Golden Shores Boulevard has a driveway running right through the proposed property, not on an easement. This situation raises significant concerns about access that impacts the actual usable acreage of the lot. We emphasize, the current zoning regulations should not be adjusted to accommodate the negligence and oversight of your department. And this discussion is occurring after construction had progressed to a quarter completion due to the breakdown in the planning process. It is critical that accountability is enforced rather than granting variances that would complicate situations and set again, a precedent for other properties and builders. Notably the contractor responsible for the construction is also the seller of the property who is a realtor. He should have known better and given his experience building homes in the area, he should have been fully aware of the zoning regulation and BDP. Our community cannot support such extensive changes and strongly implores that the current BDP remain intact. Thank you for your attention in this manner and we hope that you will consider our concerns and seriously prioritize the integrity of our community.” She stated she does feel for the person who bought the property, but Mr. Minnick knew as he was the one who did the BDP and he should have known not to sell it to that gentleman, and it should not be the taxpayers that have to suffer for the County’s mistake that its employees made in the permitting office. The Board recessed at 6:24 p.m. and reconvened at 6:36 p.m. Sean Bohannan stated he has been a resident for a couple of decades; his parents have been here over 70 years; they moved to Mims specifically because they wanted to leave South Florida and that urban environment to go to a rural environment; the reason this really hurts him is because he lives in the home that Francis Threckle and her husband who donated the property under which Titusville City Hall sits today, and she built on Golden Shores, the Horseman’s Association; here it is now where he has to spend over two years coming in front of the Board dealing with everybody involved, all the unelected public officials and that, just to be able to build a house for his aunt that is 82 years old, and it is on six acres; everything was perfectly done, and it had to be redone multiple times; he has nothing against this person, he does not know him or anything; but it gets down to the point if he wanted to live in a high density area that is where he would have moved and spent the money. He went on to say he has spent tons of money, but he is not going to go into money, because it really does not matter; they have done that, if it is trimming 100-year old oak trees, preserving things, setting up roads, paving things, they have done everything and by the book; and then this pops up, it is done illegally, against Code, against enforcement, and here it is asking for an exception. He noted whoever sold it to him, they are who should be responsible, it certainly should not be others; his road is like a washboard, half of the weeks they do not even come out and grade it; he is out there with his tractor and box blade grading the darn thing; it is oh, it rained or oh, it has not rained enough, or whatever; and they are not going to pave, not bringing in septic, not bringing in water, and not bringing in natural gas, that is fine, he knew that and accepted it by having his own standalone propane, his own four wells, all of which are permitted and licensed, and everything documented. He mentioned this is just beyond the pale, it absolutely is; he does not mean to get on a high horse, or to be loud or obnoxious, he knows he can be that way sometimes, but he is trying to refrain from that; he expressed his appreciation for the Board’s time, and hopes it takes into consideration the people who have spoken and spent millions of dollars, only to see this abomination, which was illegally done; yes, there should be auditing and the audits need to go back to all of these things, all of the exceptions, and the people who did that and are not elected officials would be held accountable; and if the elected officials will not do it, then the next election is coming. Beth Brycki stated she lives on April Lane, one street over from Golden Shores; her family moved to Brevard County, Mims specifically, because that community is rural and they absolutely love it; they have only been there a couple of months, but the really love the community and have been involved since they got there; that is like the heart of the community, the bigger lots and the rural area; her fear is that concessions are made for existing rules as to how big lot sizes are; she is afraid that sets a precedent for that to continue happening in the future; she is fearful of that happening and continuing; and she hopes that the Board votes no. Ken Harrison stated he lives on Gandy Road in Mims and lives in that area; he has been in this County his entire life, in Mims 67 years, and 54 years on his property that is near this; this came directly from staff comments, what he is going to repeat here, it was what staff found wrong; he read, “In this particular place, the applicant is subject to Code Enforcement due to the actions of a predecessor in interest who improperly split the property into a substandard lot violating Section 62-2102 of Brevard County Code”; he continued reading, “The original BDP stipulated that the developer/owner shall limit development to one single-family residence and may be further restricted by any changes to the Comprehensive Plan or land development regulations. Subsequently, the property was sold and split into two lots of .54 acre, and .89 acre on April 27, 2020. The .89-acre property was sold on October 22, 2021, and the .54-acre property was sold to the applicant on June 4, 2024. These actions violate the conditions of the BDP and Section 62-2102 Brevard County Code of Ordinances alteration of lot, which states that no person shall sever any lot in such a manner that a violation of any of the provisions of this Chapter would be created on any new or altered lot, including their uses or structures. Subsequent to this unlawful split, a permit for a single-family resident was issued in error. This permit should not have been issued because the lot is a substandard lot, as a result of the split. Upon discovering the error, a stop work order was issued by the Brevard County building official. Administrative Policy number 7, proposed use shall not cause or substantially aggravate any substantial drainage problem on surrounding properties or significant adverse and unmitigatable impact on significant natural wetlands, water bodies, or habitat for listed species. Environmental constraints, Natural Resources Management Department has identified that the subject property is located within a mapped Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) special flood hazard area, Zone A. The Board may wish to consider if the requested is consistent with the comprehensive plan and compatible with the surrounding area. In addition, the Board should reconsider the request based on the facts and circumstances surrounding the actions of a predecessor in interest, which resulted in the subject property being turned into a substandard lot." He stated the last paragraph is his; furthermore, the residents are concerned that an unlawful split of the property and the resulting zoning change due to the unlawful split of the property could possibly leave Brevard County complicit and condoning of an unlawful zoning action. He went on to say as far as the maps, one can see on the first one, the little yellow square, and that is the property in question; the property right next to it was SR; they were one lot before the illegal split; looking at this map, they are the only SR in the entire area, everything else is something larger; it is not that these are large lots; a lot of this area has one acre minimums; the people do not want it to go below one acre; and the next map is the Future Land Use and the entire map is RES-1. He mentioned the proposed land use for this one lot would be RES-2, totally inconsistent with the neighborhood and the character of the neighborhood; the very last map is flood zone A that runs through the center of this property; the property behind it will be affected by flood waters; lastly, this contractor is known to do this on purpose working through the department through either strong arming them or whatever means to get what he wants; and he did the same thing on Todd Lane which is one-quarter mile away, where one of his electricians does all the houses, split a lot to a substandard size, built a house on it, and then got permission after the fact, there is a pattern of it through multiple departments. Jerrad Atkins speaking for Scottsmoor Community Association, stated several people have taken the wind beneath his wings so he is going to truncate this a little bit; there was a meeting with a group of concerned citizens this week regarding this particular application; everybody pretty much agrees with the former Board that was here, prior to this Board, that the density needs to be limited and retained as it is in Scottsmoor; there was a small area study that was promised in 2019 and 2020 that did not happen; had it happened, there might be some more data to support that; this particular lot was rezoned in 2019; at that time the County zoning and this Board assigned a BDP to which the owner agreed disallowing the exact thing that happened, that he put in place; a few words from the staff report include unlawful, substandard, and violation, those are not good words to have in a staff report if approving an application like this; and at the zoning board meeting, the applicant spoke stating he bought the lot from Scott Minnick. He continued by saying the applicant stated he works with Scott Minnick, so people know that is the builder who split the lot; he would also agree with someone who spoke earlier that an audit or an investigation should be conducted to see why this continued to happen in this town; a couple things that the Board may be familiar with, is no constitutional or Harris Act property right to increase planning allowances under Florida Law, the purchase of land is generally subject to the existing zoning or environmental restrictions, there are no property right to change them, Freidland V. Hollywood, Florida third District Court of Appeals 1961, and upheld again in Ellen V. Miami, Florida third District of Appeals, 1959; reverse those, the other one upheld the first one; and he knows the Board has those statutes but he just wanted to give a friendly reminder. Ed Ostopovich stated the gentleman he wanted to have up here today could not show up for various reasons, medical being the biggest one; he does spend a lot of time in Brevard County, he basically does a lot of construction in Brevard County; his whole point was a hand written letter on some calculations and verbiage that he uses on a daily basis; he uses a standard 3,000 square foot home; when one has that he or she has a square footage footprint so to speak, even with the driveways, garages, carports, and things of that nature; he is just going to use that as an example; a 3,000 square foot home having one inch of rain per hour at 6,230 gallons per inch of rain per house; and with that being said, it can use this and he can hand this off to the Board and go from there. He went on to say he is in attendance because he wants to oppose the building from further continuing on; in the early 90s he came to this area, after being born and raised here, straight out of the Air Force; he literally wanted to live out in the country, the suburbs, shoot, raise his kids, hunt, ride four wheelers like everyone else does, and things of that nature; what is happening today is not an ideal living situation because it has turned into a suburbia nightmare; people are starting to see homes developed on top of each other, the high density areas starting to increase; the traffic is increasing as people are well aware of; and they do not want an HOA scenario, they already deal with seasonal snow birds in Titusville. He added Mims has kind of a cushion for having some elbow room. He continued by saying when he first moved here he purchased a one and one-half acre lot; the average home to be built on was one to five-acre parcels for anyone to purchase; it was all zoned and cut up that way from the civil engineers back in the 60s; there again, like-minded, everybody wanted that expansion to have some elbow room and they do not want the high density in that scenario; based on what is being dealt with, today’s laws and rules are being bent to accommodate so-called errors by contractors, realtors, and title companies, are starting to affect the residents big time; and they are starting to pay the price. He stated literally flooding issues so profuse that last 20 years, they have not seen anything like this in the last five years; Commissioner Delaney is well aware of what he is talking about; using that number he pointed out earlier, there was almost three feet of rain in a one-month time frame in Mims and the water did not recede for almost three weeks; that is not an exaggeration, and it was to the point where wildlife was literally coming up in the dry land areas, pigs and deer looking for things to eat; he is pointing this out to the simple fact that there are hogs tearing up property, and there is a really bad problem right now and they are trying to mitigate that scenario; but it is not going to happen until the water recedes properly. He mentioned all he knows is that the maintenance on those culverts, especially through I-95, the box culverts have not been touched or addressed; people have actually put their eyes on them and they are overgrown and impacting the water flow to the St. John’s, going west, and not to mention the flow problems through the east; as a registered voter in District 1, he wants these mismanaged overlooked areas to be audited as well; he wants more of the community to feel comfortable with what the Board does as a whole; the people trust the Board and brought them to be their voice; Commissioner Delaney is District 1’s voice right now; the people want the Board to understand this whole community is really exhausted by what is happening up there through growth and development and the continued passing or exemptions of said parcels; and other than that he appreciates the Board's time for hearing the people’s voices. Commissioner Goodson stated he hears him and understands what he wished and why he moved to Mims, and asked if Mr. Ostopovich is aware of the Farmington Development and what they are proposing. Mr. Ostopovich commented he is very aware; he had stumbled across it when he started his own personal and private distillery; he has been in front of this Board before trying to get zoning squared away; and he has a functioning and legal distillery on his private property through ATB and the Feds. Commissioner Goodson stated that is great and he thinks the Board should open up hog hunting and it would be even better with liquor. He commented the Farmington issue being proposed, maybe in 10 years they will start developing that; and he asked what Mr. Ostopovich thinks of that. Mr. Ostopovich advised they are opposing that as well; they do not like the large, even large than what is in Viera, he has seen all of the plat maps, as he stumbled across it; it made him nauseous to think that they moved there for this and it is going to be taken away, probably not in his lifetime; but his kids are going to have to deal with growth and expansion. He stated this is a sensitive water area and the St. Johns would not allow this; and he wonders who is getting paid in that scenario. Commissioner Goodson noted Mr. Ostopovich made a comment about the 95 culverts; and he asked if he understand that those are Department of Transportation (DOT). Mr. Ostopovich replied he does understand that, but asked if the Board has the voice to get them on the horn and tell them they are drowning down here. Commissioner Goodson stated if one knows anything about DOT, that is kind of like blowing smoke; they are slower than heck; but it is not their fault. Mr. Ostopovich noted he does understand regulations and what the Board is up against, right now the people are focused on one little thing; and if it can turn the tide and start going by laws and upholding that, they would really appreciate the efforts. Chair Altman advised he will give the applicant time to close; and he asked if there are any questions from the Board. Commissioner Goodson asked if this gentleman bought it from a realtor who was shady, or whatever, and did not know what he was buying, then a permit was given by the County, where is his justice. Outburst from the audience stating in the title company. Commissioner Goodson asked if the title company would be guilty, he does not know. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, stated he does not even know if he obtained title insurance, that would depend; and he asked Mr. Foune if he obtained title insurance. Mr. Foune replied he did. Attorney Richardson asked if he has filed a claim with his title insurer. Mr. Foune advised he has not. Attorney Richardson noted that he probably should do that quickly if he has not already; and he is not going to give legal advice but if he has title insurance, that is an issue. Commissioner Goodson asked if Mr. Foune works for the person who sold it to him. Mr. Foune stated he works for a company that does work for him; and he does HVAC all over Brevard County and he is a builder that they work for. Commissioner Goodson asked right now, how much money Mr. Foune has spent honestly, for the cost of the lot and what he has done so far. Mr. Foune responded by saying about $100,000. Commissioner Goodson stated and there is probably another $100,000 to finish it. Mr. Foune replied, at least, yes. Commissioner Goodson asked if he has spoken to the realtor about this. Mr. Foune stated he has not. Commissioner Goodson asked why not. Mr. Foune asked if he means the realtor he bought the property from. Commissioner Goodson responded affirmatively. Mr. Foune stated he spoke with the land owner, he did not have a realtor. Commissioner Goodson inquired if the land owner said, “tough luck or I do not care, I did it and it was legal and the County approved it, yada, yada.“ Mr. Foune stated he would reckon; and basically, he relied on the staff at the County to turn everything in and he got everything approved. Commissioner Goodson stated if he knows anything about life it is to not rely on anybody, check and double check. Mr. Foune commented he is starting to learn that. He stated one of the things is that the homeowners around the area were not notified of this meeting or anything; everything has been posted in front; the County has put signs out there; in the middle of October they put out there the amount of acres is .54, he is not sure why that has changed; that is what he has been aware of the whole time; for the flooding, he has already started building; if he can continue and put his culvert in and everything to Code, obviously that would help; and then about there not being enough land, there is two properties on Golden Shores that are less acres than what he has, one is .51 and one is .44; and it is also said that his house is higher elevation than the neighbor behind him, it is actually the same height and everything is to Code. He reiterated that he has done everything to Code, it has all been inspected, and everything has passed. Commissioner Feltner stated he has comments so he will wait until after the questions. Chair Altman asked if Mr. Foune is using a builder or is this owner building. Mr. Foune stated it is all owner builder. Chair Altman asked who drew up his plans, if he used an architect or an engineer; and he noted he thinks he is required to have an engineer for the hurricane. Mr. Foune stated yes, working construction he has friends that have helped him out; and everything has been owner builder and he has used other people’s plans. Chair Altman clarified that he did not use an architect to draw the plans. Mr. Foune advised he did not, it was a previous plan that had already been used. Chair Altman asked if they had been stamped by an engineer. Mr. Foune responded affirmatively. Chair Altman asked if he knows who that was. Mr. Foune advised he does not know off the top of his head. Chair Altman asked when Mr. Foune submitted his plans to the County, if he had any idea what he was requesting was illegal. Mr. Foune replied no, he did not. Chair Altman asked if he basically relied upon the County; and what made him think he could build on this lot. Mr. Foune stated he saw other properties that were around the same amount of land. Chair Altman asked if he assumed it was buildable. Mr. Foune stated there has been a couple new houses that have been built on that street in the last year or two; he put AC in them; and he figured there would not be a problem. Chair Altman asked how many square feet his house is. Mr.Foune replied 1,600. Chair Altman asked if it is one story or two story. Mr. Foune answered by saying it is one story. Commissioner Adkinson commented he said he did not have a real estate agent, that he just bought it from the owner; he does have title insurance so that is good; and presumably when he went to the person whom he bought it from and said he just got told this is an illegal lot, and she asked what the response was that he received back. Mr. Foune he responded by saying basically nothing, to figure out what the County’s solution would be; and he was also told by the County that it would be resolved in a day or two when he initially received the phone call, so he did not really think much of it. Commissioner Adkinson stated but the owner likely had an idea that he or she was doing something that was not okay and just led Mr. Foune to believe that it was okay. Mr. Foune responded he would assume so.
  • Item H.4.

    Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP. (25Z00037) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

    Moved by Katie Delaney · Seconded by Tom Goodson

    approved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jacob Foune for a change of zoning classification from SR with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP for application number 25Z00037. There being no further comments or objections, the Board continued the request by Jacob Foune for a change of zoning classification from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP, to the February 5, 2026, Zoning meeting.
  • Item H.6.

    Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU. (25Z00024) (Tax Account 2101970) (District 1)

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Katie Delaney

    approved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Thomas Dahn for a change of zoning classification from RR-1 to AU, application number 25Z00024, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU under application number 25Z00024, located in District 1. Thomas Dahn stated he and his wife are wanting to open a commercial agricultural produce business to sell fresh organic produce to the public; they bought an acre of land next to their current land to do that; they have combined the properties to make the land larger; and they are now asking to rezone to AU to do the business. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Thomas Dahn to change the zoning classification from RR-1 to AU for application number 25Z000024, located in District 1.

Recorded votes

12 recorded votes3 split

Split votes (3)

City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

Motion: Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, application number 24PUD00003, and tax account number 2411252, located in District 1. Commissioner Delaney asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to assist her with the motion. Chair Altman asked if needs to be reread into the record. Mr. Prasad explained if it is said all the conditions outlined in the Agenda Report with the addition of some of the ones that were heard today, which is as part of the waiver request that would have to be approved as part of this application, like for like trees; then also mitigate any wetlands within the 50 foot right-of-way should they have to be dedicated… Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they cannot agree to that because it impacts their ability to mitigate. Chair Altman asked which one that was; and he asked that Ms. Rezanka come up and clarify that. Ms. Rezanka stated it was asked that the 50 foot right-of-way that is being dedicated, that they take on the responsibility for mitigating the wetlands; and she explained they cannot do that because it impacts the wetlands on the site because it would all be done at the same time; they only get 1.8 percent to impact; therefore, they cannot agree to that. Chair Altman stated so they are going to give up the land… Ms. Rezanka reiterated they are not agreeing to… Chair Altman interjected by saying mitigate somebody else’s land. Ms. Rezanka stated they may agree later on, but right now they cannot because they have to mitigate their own; and that was not something that was listed that she has agreed to. Ms. Gilliam asked if staff could make a comment. Ms. McGee stated she just wants to add that when talking about the dedication of the 50 foot right-of-way, they had talked about that not counting against their 1.8 percent because that would be to the benefit of the County for that 50 feet; that would not count against the other wetland impacts for the 1.8 percent for the applicant; but again, the mitigation being part of that cost. Mr. Bernath agreed, and stated he would just add that if they do not do it now, that is County right-of-way, and the taxpayers are going to be doing it if it ever decides to widen that road. Chair Altman inquired if the County owns it, would it not be the County’s responsibility to mitigate for widening the road, that is the public benefit to widen the road; if they have given up that right-of-way it would be the public's responsibility to mitigate for the public good of building the road; he understands their point, they are giving up the land and now they have to mitigate; he does not know; but he agrees with the applicant on that, he does not think that should be a requirement. Mr. Bernath stated he does not know if they will agree to it, but buy credits for mitigation. Ms. Rezanka noted she does not have the authority to do that or to spend her client’s money who is not in attendance to agree, when he told her not to agree to that; and at this point she cannot agree to it. Chair Altman commented they are basically giving land. Ms. Rezanka stated they are giving land that would have to be taken by imminent domain at a valuable price. Chair Altman commented and a lot of legal costs so he appreciates her doing that. Mr. Prasad stated so with that said, the conditions would be as outlined in the Agenda Report, if the Board would like he will restate them but he has already stated them before, it would be for like for like trees, and work for the County to add potential treatments to shore up the shoreline along the Indian River Lagoon. Chair Altman stated on the issue of clearing, because he is not for clearing land as much as possible, but he has seen a lot of projects where some of which he voted on to preserve the native buffer, but if one goes back and the buffer is dead because when one does the improvements of the property, it affects the drainage, just a little soil on some of those trees kills it; and he agrees with not having to be able to go and it would have been a healthier, more attractive buffer if it was replanted, so he supports that. He mentioned that he does have a question, and he asked when it is said like for like trees is that species or size because there are some very large trees there. Mr. Prasad explained he thinks they are looking for similar type and size of trees, but he would defer to Ms. McGee whose Department implements that. Ms. McGee stated like for like can work depending on how big the lots are and what that buffer is; they may not be able to put back the same number of oak trees that may crowd out or may interfere with the buildings or structures. Chair Altman commented he worries about their ability to do the size too. Ms. McGee stated that is kind of a tough one to apply at permitting because if they take out a 20-inch oak they would not put back a 20-inch oak, they are going to be smaller ones. Chair Altman mentioned he has been by the site many times; he does not think a tree survey has been done; and he is just concerned with saying like for like, the size should not be a requirement. Mr. Prasad stated perhaps similar within reason. Chair Altman stated okay, that is good. Ms. McGee noted they like to make it specific to help staff apply it when it gets to permitting; she does not know if Mr. Prasad can put language in there to negotiate with Natural Resources Management for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a good buffer; and she asked if that would be acceptable. Chair Altman stated he likes the word mature. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just add one more thing, they were talking about PDP conditions, if the Board could just include to memorialize that in a BDP. Commissioner Delaney stated the motion would be to change the zoning from EU and RP with an existing BDP to a PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, but to add another BDP, including the things the Board has spoken about; she asked if she needs to read out all of those; and what does she need to say with the PDP. Mr. Prasad stated as part of the zoning approval, the Board would be approving the PUD with the conditions specified to be memorialized in a PDP. Commissioner Delaney made that motion. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a Change of Zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP and approval of the PDP; approved a waiver to Section 62-2883(d) requiring an undisturbed 15-foot buffer around the perimeter of the project with the condition that any vegetation removed shall be replaced with reasonable similar vegetation in consultation with Natural Resources Management Department for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a buffer similar to its natural state; and making the PUD subject to the following conditions, which are to be memorialized in a BDP: an overall reduction of rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, overall reduction of volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conduct a groundwater analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly, applicant voluntarily offers to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive, and the applicant to work with staff on shoring up/improving the shoreline on the Lagoon. (24PUD00003). | Matter 8448 | Moved by Katie Delaney | Seconded by Kim Adkinson

Total

1

No
1

How they voted (1)

Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada (Monica Pritchard) request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1. (25Z00036) (Tax Account 2005444) (District 1)

Motion: Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada for a change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada, being represented by Monica Pritchard, request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1, under application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Monica Pritchard stated they have a property in Mims; it is two lots side-by-side that are basically family property; they have inherited this lot form their mother who has passed; Ms. Walsh and her husband live next door; and they would like to request a rezoning from SU to RR-1 in order to potentially do a flag lot so they can split the parcel, where Ms. Canada can own the front half and Ms. Walsh can own the back half. She continued by saying Ms. Walsh’s eventual goal is that maybe her children will take care of her and they may build on the back parcel; obviously, there is a septic moratorium; she is in no rush and she does not care if she can never build on it and just has to keep a horse there or something; but because it was inherited together, they would like to separate the two, give the sister the house on the front, and have Ms. Walsh keep the back end. Commissioner Delaney stated the idea of splitting lots in this area is concerning; and she cannot support this right now, especially since they do not have a need to build at the moment. Ms. Pritchard stated what she thinks they really need is to separate the interest; while they are sisters, they obviously have different children, different heirs, and things like that; while they both inherited the property together, she thinks they both want to keep it as family properties; it is a unique situation and she understands Commissioner Delaney’s concerns and that this is not popular in her District right now; however, while considering the larger concerns of the community, there are also individual needs of the property owner. She continued to explain the lots are conforming; it is going to be over an acre on each; she does not have any immediate plans for any of this it is just legally in order to separate it, make it fair for the two of them, she would like to keep the vacant land portion, which right now, her horses will just graze along with her property that is right next door; her sister will get to keep the house; she reiterated she understands this is not popular in District 1; she has heard all of the flooding concerns and things like that; but in this individual situation, it is not adding to the flooding concerns; and she has no immediate plans to build, but in order for her heir, should something happen to her and her husband, be able to inherit that piece of land without their cousins complicating things further, this is what would be necessary. She noted it would be a rezone in order to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked if the applicant would be willing to do a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to say no building. Ms. Pritchard asked if that means ever. Commissioner Delaney explained a BDP eventually could be changed with the direction of the Board. Ms. Prichard stated the goal would be that her kids could eventually one day when the time is right, maybe when these flooding issues are resolved, the septic moratorium is lifted, that they could potentially build there one day; and she would have to discuss that with her client because that is not something that she had anticipated. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way to do that in a BDP or whatever that says that there will not be any building for three years as a means to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked Morris Richardson, County Attorney, if there are any other options for this family. Attorney Richardson stated he is hesitant to give advice that borders on legal advice; and if the ultimate goal is to build on the property this seems to be the path. Ms. Pritchard stated they are part of the Mims community; they have livestock and all those things; they understand Commissioner Delaney’s concerns; they are over here nodding with their neighbors, doing all those things; they get it; but while Commissioner Delaney is considering all of that, this is their individual property; it is between two family parcels; and the lots are appropriately sized. She commented there is a septic moratorium and she does not know how long that will continue, it sounds like a long time based on the testimony that she has heard tonight; they are not intending on doing anything any time soon; when they do they will go through all of the proper channels again, retain counsel again, and the Board will have the opportunity again to hear this because they will need permits and all of those things. Chair Altman asked if Ms. Pritchard is an attorney or just a legal representative. Ms. Pritchard replied yes, she is. Chair Altman asked if this is part of any sort of estate planning and what they are trying to plan for the future. Ms. Pritchard responded affirmatively saying they are planning for the future; currently her and her sister own it; they were not sure what they wanted to do with it; in order for them to separate out, her sister wants to keep the front half; her sisters heirs will be able to inherit the front half; and she get to keep the back half. Chair Altman asked about the size of the individual lots. Ms. Pritchard again stated they will be over an acre, the parcel is 2.94 acres. Commissioner Delaney asked what the Future Land Use is for this. Ms. Gilliam replied it is RES-1. Commissioner Feltner responded it is just one acre to build. Commissioner Delaney and Chair Altman both answered yes. Commissioner Adkinson states he would like to point out that Planning and Zoning actually recommended approval of this 11:2 after some pretty decent discussion. Ms. Pritchard reiterated that she understands exactly what the concern is; but she thinks in this individual case, due to the uniqueness of this and the fact that they live next door, she would say that this ameliorates some of those concerns. Commissioner Feltner asked if they are going to essentially be almost equal 1.5 acre lots. Ms. Pritchard stated they are almost equal; on the application, the surveys that they submitted show what was intended eventually. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way that Commissioner Delaney will be comfortable is they can only have one home per each one and one-half acre lot for each lot in the future. Ms. Pritchard responded she is pretty sure that is the way it is already that someone can only have one home. Commissioner Feltner asked if it is one acre to build. Ms. Pritchard stated yes, and she thinks one can have maybe an accessory building which would be a barn, which may be of interest to them; but that is not the intention right now; she also is not sure that her children are ever going to move to take care of her; and she would say if the Board wants to do a BDP with maybe three years that would be fine with them because there are no immediate plans for this, but for estate planning purposes they would like to make it clean. Commissioner Feltner asked if it would be not a building permit for three years. Ms. Pritchard responded no building permit for three years would be fine with them; she reiterate there is no immediate plan to build on this; however, they are both older and they are getting their affairs in order and things like that. Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, stated he is trying to think it through; the proposed lot split is attached to the Item on the Agenda, but that is for conceptual purposes at this point; and he is trying to think about how to map the BDP in the future and the actual description of the land because would it be across the whole property, so the BDP could say the house could be on the entire property with no more than one unit across the entire parcel for the next three years, subsequent to that there could be two units on the parent parcel. Ms. Pritchard stated they are going to apply for a flag lot after this because that is the whole point, to change the zoning to apply for a flag lot; and as long as this does not impede that then… Attorney Richardson stated they just need to record the BDP along with the zoning action because the zoning is going to paint the whole property, not just the flag lot because that lot has not been created yet, that is going to tail; the Board has to bring the BDP back, under the Code, within… Mr. Prasad advised it is 120 days. Attorney Richardson continued by saying 120 days, so if she could create that before. Mr. Prasad stated then staff could have that BDP and she could come back just applying for to the southern lot. Ms. Pritchard stated sure. Ms. Gilliam stated just for clarification regarding a barn on a vacant property; two points, staff cannot do the flag lot application until the rezoning is approved and the properties are recorded in that configuration; and two, she had mentioned having a barn on the property and one cannot have a barn without a primary structure. Ms. Pritchard stated they were saying that there could not be more than two structures so she understands that they cannot have the barn, it is an accessory; and she understands that. Ms. Gilliam responded that she just wanted to clarify that. Attorney Richardson stated that is about no more than one primary residence on the entire property for three years; and he thinks they will have to put the BDP on the entire property with that limitation because it is sort of a standoff; he was thinking they could do the split and then record the BDP, but they will not be permitted to do that until the zoning is in place; and zoning will not go into place until the BDP is recorded. He noted it is a circle so staff can paint the BDP over the entire property; it is going to allow what they already have; it will not prevent what they have or an accessory structure on the other lot or anything like that. Ms. Pritchard stated there are no plans that she is aware of to build an accessory structure on the other lot, so there is no… Attorney Richardson interjected saying it could not be done on the new lot without a primary dwelling. Ms. Pritchard stated correct. Attorney Richardson stated if she is comfortable with a BDP and she has authorization to represent the entire property, staff is going to have to put the BDP in place over the entire property, not just the new flag lot. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to explain her vote; she knows the applicant is part of the community and she hopes she hears her heart in this because this situation is very unique; she knows they are not trying to flip it to sell to a random person, but for her she made a commitment to people to not increase density in this area; but she is just one of five, so she will not be able to vote for this today. Commissioner Adkinson made the motion. Mr. Prasad stated he thinks staff understands that; and the BDP will come back to the Board with the final terms. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada to change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, with a BDP on the entire property stating no building for three years, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. | Matter 8480 | Moved by Kim Adkinson | Seconded by Rob Feltner

Total

1

No
1

How they voted (1)

Katie Delaneyno

City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

Motion: Ms. Rezanka stated she wanted to thank Mr. Sudermann for his comments as they have tried to work with the residents; Mr. Burroughs asked about a turn lane and if FDOT says it is necessary, certainly that would be put in; she does need to point out that right now water is just sleeting off of this property with no treatment, no nothing; this will retain the water, it will treat it, and it will be better than it currently is, after this is developed; the County has ensured this, Mr. Bernath, by asking for these conditions to which the developer has agreed, reduce the volume of storwater to better control runoff, reduce the rate of stormwater discharge which will improve what is going on with the water leading to Indian River Drive, and they have agreed to like trees for like trees; this is not a BDP, these are all conditions of the PDP; they do not usually do a BDP, they are willing to do it, but usually they do not do a BDP with a PDP for a PUD; and any changes to the PDP, that is part of the County’s Code and if it increases density, but any changes could be a change to the road, so she would ask that not be a conditional ask, to just follow the Code. She continued on to say if the PDP is changed in a substantial way determined by Mr. Prasad, then they will have to come back; she does not want that to be part of it; if the Board puts it in there then they will agree to it, but it is already in the Code and she does not think it is necessary; all the flooding issues are engineering issues and Mr. Bernath, Ms. McGee, and Ms. Gerena will be reviewing all of these; those are all plat issues, site plan issues; no one can prove a negative at this point, but based upon what staff has required, it is going to be a better condition for flooding and stormwater than it is currently; with that she would ask the Board to approve the alternate request to RES-2, find that it is compatible because they are doing like-size houses, RES-2 to RES-2 to allow the density bonuses to 23 units, as 23 is demanded by the PDP which governs it, and if not it is just a RES-2 all the way to the river, and takes in the wetlands that right now has RES-4. She reiterated she is asking the Board to approve RES-2 and the PDP, with the waiver. Chair Altman commented Ms. Rezanka may have addressed some of this towards the end of the presentation, but maybe she could elaborate further; one of the big questions that has been brought up to the Board is that there was an agreement for a BDP and now that is being changed, so people are feeling like that is sort of a bait and switch or that the developer is going against the commitment of the land owner; and he asked what is the reasoning for going with the change. Ms. Rezanka replied as she mentioned in the October meeting, this has really been a troubled piece of property; it has been in and out of foreclosure, back and forth between owners, it has not been developed, and there are challenges to the land with the wetlands, the sloping, and with access; this really is a challenging or troubled piece of property; a BDP was agreed to in 2008; in 2008 it was kind of the crash of the market, or the beginning of it, so she believes they just took whatever they could get; regardless, it has not been developed; it is only the seven acres in the center, so there is other developable land that is RES-4 and in theory could put another 12 units on it as is; they could have the 12 and the seven which is 19; it is just like a change of zoning, it could not be built that way; and it is not feasible to be built that way when they add in all the stormwater and all of the other requirements of subdivisions that were not the same in 2008. She continued by saying the costs of construction have doubled in the last five years; it was not feasible for the owner in 2008; her client bought it in 2021 and it was not feasible for him; basically, he is asking for a rezoning, removing the BDP is really just a rezoning action; she has said the reasons why the applicant wants to do it; and basically, it is the conditions of the property. Chair Altman stated he knows he looked at the original BDP that is in the packet; and he asked if the original BDP preserved the wetlands, the river. Ms. Rezanka explained all it did was limit the seven acres to seven units. Chair Altman asked if it limited access to River Road. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not recall that, but they are not going to Indian River Road. Chair Altman noted there are some advantages. Ms. Rezanka explained there was a limit that they could not access Parkchester and it did not really define what that meant; Parkchester has a road that goes directly into the property, the applicant’s property dead ends; that was her interpretation of what cannot access Parkchester, but the neighbors thought it meant that they could not access that road, which is a public road; but that was the access, it was not Indian River Drive, one cannot access Parkchester; and they have taken of access to Parkchester. Commissioner Delaney asked if Ms. Rezanka thought it would be extremely expensive to mitigate this property to the point where they could build to that capacity, if they were to build the 12 houses on the RES-4 portion, and if that is really realistic. Ms. Rezanka explained what she is missing is there are three acres that is not wetlands and still RES-4, that is between the wetlands and RES-1. Commissioner Delaney stated but she would still have to account for the stormwater and all of that stuff. Ms. Rezanka commented all she is saying is the allowable density right now in her opinion is 19 plus the commercial; she is asking for 23; that does not include the wetlands; and the staff report says something else, but she disagrees with the staff report. Commissioner Feltner stated they are going to have to do a lot of work to this property, there is no doubt; there is expense in getting this ready; he asked in ideal market conditions, how much are they asking for each one of these homes; and he explained he is asking that because nearby neighbors sometimes say they do not want these cookie-cutter houses. Ms. Rezanka replied based upon the developers, it is $450,000 to $600,000; and she does not know about this, but what she knows from other developers that are developing similar products, that is the sale price, between $450,000 and $600,000. Commissioner Goodson asked if Ms. Rezanka would be agreeable to everything that Mr. Prasad quoted would be attached to this permit. Ms. Rezanka responded in the affirmative. Commissioner Goodson asked if that is okay with Mr. Prasad. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just ask for one clarification from the Board; and he believes Ms. Rezanka just said that she prefers not to have the condition that any change to the PDP come back to the Board, and that is completely at the Board’s discretion whether it prefers to keep the typical, which is an substantial change that would come back to the Board, or if it wants any changes come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson asked Ms. Rezanka how she would agree with that. Ms. Rezanka noted she thinks the Board should stick by its Code, and Ms. Gilliam is who stated that not Mr. Prasad; she would prefer it not be added in there; they will accept it; but to her, she thinks there is a Code and because any change as, she said, could change the location of the road, and that to her should not have to come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson stated he thinks within reason, staff is not talking those changes; and he asked Mr. Prasad if that is correct. Ms. Rezanka pointed out he said any change. Mr. Prasad noted the way it is written, and this was mentioned at the last Board meeting and that is why it was put in there, it does say any change; and he would say if there is some middle ground that the Board wants to consider, it can do that as well. Chair Altman stated there might be a change that is better for the land and the neighborhood. Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they could take out two units and they would have to come back. Chair Altman continued by saying and they would not want to come back to do that because they would have to do this, so he is fine with having some flexibility there. Commissioner Goodson stated he is too. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, asked if it is staff’s preference to have these conditions memorialized in a BDP as opposed to conditions for the PDP. Mr. Prasad explained staff prefers it to be both; and the conditions of the PUD memorialized in a BDP because it is easier to track internally and transparent for the public because when they look at the map they will see the PUD with the PDP and can easily see those conditions. Ms. Rezanka apologized that she missed that, and she stated she is not used to that for a PDP, but that is fine. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to bring up what one of the residents said, that the reason why there is not a lot of people here tonight is because they have come out over and over and over again; the neighborhood still has not changed; the couple people who have come up and said that they could live with this, is not because they are happy about it; in District 1 there are still hundreds of people who are not living in their homes right now because of the flooding that it has incurred this year; it is frustrating to her that all of this is being overlooked in her opinion, from what she sees happening right now; this is her District and she knows what her constituents want and need; nobody is guaranteed a rezone, it is not a property right; and this is going to dramatically change this community regardless of what they are going to say about controlling the stormwater. She continued to say she has not seen one neighborhood in District 1 where a new neighborhood goes in next to an old neighborhood and flooding did not happen, not one; if the rest of the Board members want this in his or her own neighborhoods that is fine, but District 1 elected her to speak for them and they do not want this; she understands the rest of the Board may not like her, or her style, but this has nothing to do with her, it has to do with the people; she is asking the Board to please do what it has historically done in this County and listen to the District Commissioner, where the people have elected her to speak for them; and with that, she would like to make a motion to deny this request. Chair Altman advised the motion dies for lack of a second. Commissioner Delaney asked Ms. Rezanka if the developer would be willing to do any kind of shoreline shoring up in this area. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not know what that means; she is sure they can put in that they will work with the staff to do what they can in that area because they do own property; and that can be a binding condition to work with the County to work on shoring up the shoreline on the riverside. Commissioner Delaney stated some of the areas, obviously, not right on their property but around it, some of the owners have put more fill or whatnot, coquina rocks and stuff; that seems to help in those areas; and she does not know if they are willing to do that. Ms. Rezanka advised the developer is because they did talk about that; staff needs to come up with a comprehensive solution that everyone can help and do the same thing; and they are certainly willing to help with that. Commissioner Feltner asked if that is something that they would have to go to BDP for when on the edge of the river. Ms. McGee advised they would have to get a permit from the State and get a permit from Natural Resources as well, although Natural Resources does not allow sea walls, but they can do coquina, slope revetments, native vegetation, living shoreline, so there are other strategies that could be used. Commissioner Feltner asked for clarification that they will not run into issues with the County. Ms. McGee commented it depends on what they propose, but yes, they should be able to get a permit from the County. Commissioner Feltner noted he is not asking for a commitment. He stated there are other property parcels along there that have these treatments that they could potentially duplicate. Ms. McGee advised they can probably do better; sometimes staff sees when people do their own thing maybe it is not as fortified as it could be if it is properly engineered and has filter cloth and mangroves, and that sort of thing; and they do encourage that sort of thing. Commissioner Feltner asked and some of those other things, DEP has signed off on, maybe in the last few years. Ms. McGee responded affirmatively. Commissioner Feltner commented he just does not want false hope that they will do something and then they run into a problem with DEP. Chair Altman stated that is a good point; this property when it makes a transition, the lots have been sold or it reaches a certain threshold, it goes into a homeowners association, he would assume, and he thinks the St. John’s now requires that, so they are responsible for maintaining the stormwater; they also own, and it is probably part of the amenity to the project, they have a pedestrian access they can literally walk to the river, so that is their property on the river; if the shoreline starts to fail or even jeopardizes the road, they would probably have a duty to maintain it, would they not; and he asked who that responsibility would fall on. He commented he knows they may have a desire, but he never thought of that, one who owns property on the river and if it is eroded and the road is threatened, who is responsible for going on that property to protect the road. Mr. Bernath stated it depends on who actually owns and then any maintenance conditions; he may be missing something, but he was not aware that this goes all the way to the river; in which case they may provide the recommendations that Commissioner Delaney had just suggested; but ultimately, if it is impacting a road then it would be a public cost; and he would add that staff needs to be very careful, a revetment system could actually wind up trapping the water and making it worse; and they are in the process right now of doing a major study for that road and there is not an easy solution. He noted he has said this before, but the actual solution is about $1 billion; there is also lots of private properties that staff would have to even figure out how to overcome that; the big issue is how to keep the water out; it is not necessarily the stormwater that is going down the hill as much as it is the waves over topping; the road is very low as was mentioned earlier; and now if it is raised up, whether it is some sort of revetment system or someone builds a great big wall, someone has to raise the road. He continued by saying if one raises the road, it has to move utilities, and move all the connections to all the houses and road system; and that is where the billion dollars comes in. Chair Altman asked when he said a billion if he meant the entire River Road. Mr. Bernath advised the study focused on 9,000 linear feet, which he would suggest the juice is not worth the squeeze at that point. Chair Altman stated if that is an issue he is sure that the County will deal with St. Johns permitting and homeowners would probably want to keep that as nice as they possibly can. Commissioner Delaney stated there is obviously a lot in this motion so if staff could help, what she is looking for is, and she inquired if the applicant would be amenable to not doing the bonus density, doing 21. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively. Commissioner Delaney asked if the Board could move to approve with all of the things that staff has said, plus working with staff to shore up the shore line there. Ms. Gilliam stated first there has to be a motion on Item H.1. for the Small Scale Amendment, then H.2. when that motion is made he or she can add all that. Mr. Prasad stated what he is hearing is the motion is to CC and RES-2 without the finding required for the density bonus. Commissioner Delaney noted that is correct. Commissioner Delaney moved to approve and Commissioner Feltner seconded. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 25-22, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”; setting forth the fourth Small Scale Plan Amendment of 2025, 24S.11 to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI(E), The Future Land Use Appendix; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date; approved changing the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4 and NC to CC and RES-2 (24SS00009). | Matter 8447 | Moved by Katie Delaney | Seconded by Rob Feltner

Total

1

No
1

How they voted (1)

Katie Delaneyno
Unanimous votes (9)

Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP. (25Z00037) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU. (25Z00024) (Tax Account 2101970) (District 1)

Dick Holdings, LLC (Vaheed Teimouri) requests a CUP for a private heliport in AU zoning classification. (25Z00033) (Tax Account 2317013) (District 2)

Leslie Bishop requests a zoning classification change from RU-1-7 to SR. (25Z00034) (Tax Account 3008078) (District 3)

Paul & Cheryl Pearson (Steve Totty) request a zoning classification change from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6. (25Z00035) (Tax Account 2611660) (District 4)

Jay Steinke and Grant Steinke request a zoning classification change from GU to AU. (25Z00038) (Tax Account 2504763) (District 2)

Linda M. Muenz & Erran L. Muenz, Jr. request a zoning classification change from GU to AU. (25Z00040) (Tax Account 2313962) (District 1)

Alexis Raul and Rosemary Estevez DeJesus request a zoning classification change from BU-1 with a BDP to BU-1 with removal of a BDP. (25Z00003) (Tax Account 2004581) (District 1)

Jacob Foune requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (25S.14) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2. (25SS00008) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

Money

People and votes

Katie Delaney

Open person dossier

6 motions · 4 seconds · 3 recorded votes

  1. MotionItem H.2.

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  2. MotionItem H.4.

    Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP. (25Z00037) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  3. SecondItem H.6.

    Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU. (25Z00024) (Tax Account 2101970) (District 1) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  4. SecondItem H.7.

    Dick Holdings, LLC (Vaheed Teimouri) requests a CUP for a private heliport in AU zoning classification. (25Z00033) (Tax Account 2317013) (District 2) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  5. SecondItem kH.8.

    Leslie Bishop requests a zoning classification change from RU-1-7 to SR. (25Z00034) (Tax Account 3008078) (District 3) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  6. SecondItem H.9.

    Paul & Cheryl Pearson (Steve Totty) request a zoning classification change from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6. (25Z00035) (Tax Account 2611660) (District 4) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  7. MotionItem H.12.

    Linda M. Muenz & Erran L. Muenz, Jr. request a zoning classification change from GU to AU. (25Z00040) (Tax Account 2313962) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  8. MotionItem H.5.

    Alexis Raul and Rosemary Estevez DeJesus request a zoning classification change from BU-1 with a BDP to BU-1 with removal of a BDP. (25Z00003) (Tax Account 2004581) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  9. Motion

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  10. Motion

    Jacob Foune requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (25S.14) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2. (25SS00008) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  11. Recorded vote

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) - Voted no on the motion “Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, application number 24PUD00003, and tax account number 2411252, located in District 1. Commissioner Delaney asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to assist her with the motion. Chair Altman asked if needs to be reread into the record. Mr. Prasad explained if it is said all the conditions outlined in the Agenda Report with the addition of some of the ones that were heard today, which is as part of the waiver request that would have to be approved as part of this application, like for like trees; then also mitigate any wetlands within the 50 foot right-of-way should they have to be dedicated… Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they cannot agree to that because it impacts their ability to mitigate. Chair Altman asked which one that was; and he asked that Ms. Rezanka come up and clarify that. Ms. Rezanka stated it was asked that the 50 foot right-of-way that is being dedicated, that they take on the responsibility for mitigating the wetlands; and she explained they cannot do that because it impacts the wetlands on the site because it would all be done at the same time; they only get 1.8 percent to impact; therefore, they cannot agree to that. Chair Altman stated so they are going to give up the land… Ms. Rezanka reiterated they are not agreeing to… Chair Altman interjected by saying mitigate somebody else’s land. Ms. Rezanka stated they may agree later on, but right now they cannot because they have to mitigate their own; and that was not something that was listed that she has agreed to. Ms. Gilliam asked if staff could make a comment. Ms. McGee stated she just wants to add that when talking about the dedication of the 50 foot right-of-way, they had talked about that not counting against their 1.8 percent because that would be to the benefit of the County for that 50 feet; that would not count against the other wetland impacts for the 1.8 percent for the applicant; but again, the mitigation being part of that cost. Mr. Bernath agreed, and stated he would just add that if they do not do it now, that is County right-of-way, and the taxpayers are going to be doing it if it ever decides to widen that road. Chair Altman inquired if the County owns it, would it not be the County’s responsibility to mitigate for widening the road, that is the public benefit to widen the road; if they have given up that right-of-way it would be the public's responsibility to mitigate for the public good of building the road; he understands their point, they are giving up the land and now they have to mitigate; he does not know; but he agrees with the applicant on that, he does not think that should be a requirement. Mr. Bernath stated he does not know if they will agree to it, but buy credits for mitigation. Ms. Rezanka noted she does not have the authority to do that or to spend her client’s money who is not in attendance to agree, when he told her not to agree to that; and at this point she cannot agree to it. Chair Altman commented they are basically giving land. Ms. Rezanka stated they are giving land that would have to be taken by imminent domain at a valuable price. Chair Altman commented and a lot of legal costs so he appreciates her doing that. Mr. Prasad stated so with that said, the conditions would be as outlined in the Agenda Report, if the Board would like he will restate them but he has already stated them before, it would be for like for like trees, and work for the County to add potential treatments to shore up the shoreline along the Indian River Lagoon. Chair Altman stated on the issue of clearing, because he is not for clearing land as much as possible, but he has seen a lot of projects where some of which he voted on to preserve the native buffer, but if one goes back and the buffer is dead because when one does the improvements of the property, it affects the drainage, just a little soil on some of those trees kills it; and he agrees with not having to be able to go and it would have been a healthier, more attractive buffer if it was replanted, so he supports that. He mentioned that he does have a question, and he asked when it is said like for like trees is that species or size because there are some very large trees there. Mr. Prasad explained he thinks they are looking for similar type and size of trees, but he would defer to Ms. McGee whose Department implements that. Ms. McGee stated like for like can work depending on how big the lots are and what that buffer is; they may not be able to put back the same number of oak trees that may crowd out or may interfere with the buildings or structures. Chair Altman commented he worries about their ability to do the size too. Ms. McGee stated that is kind of a tough one to apply at permitting because if they take out a 20-inch oak they would not put back a 20-inch oak, they are going to be smaller ones. Chair Altman mentioned he has been by the site many times; he does not think a tree survey has been done; and he is just concerned with saying like for like, the size should not be a requirement. Mr. Prasad stated perhaps similar within reason. Chair Altman stated okay, that is good. Ms. McGee noted they like to make it specific to help staff apply it when it gets to permitting; she does not know if Mr. Prasad can put language in there to negotiate with Natural Resources Management for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a good buffer; and she asked if that would be acceptable. Chair Altman stated he likes the word mature. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just add one more thing, they were talking about PDP conditions, if the Board could just include to memorialize that in a BDP. Commissioner Delaney stated the motion would be to change the zoning from EU and RP with an existing BDP to a PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, but to add another BDP, including the things the Board has spoken about; she asked if she needs to read out all of those; and what does she need to say with the PDP. Mr. Prasad stated as part of the zoning approval, the Board would be approving the PUD with the conditions specified to be memorialized in a PDP. Commissioner Delaney made that motion. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a Change of Zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP and approval of the PDP; approved a waiver to Section 62-2883(d) requiring an undisturbed 15-foot buffer around the perimeter of the project with the condition that any vegetation removed shall be replaced with reasonable similar vegetation in consultation with Natural Resources Management Department for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a buffer similar to its natural state; and making the PUD subject to the following conditions, which are to be memorialized in a BDP: an overall reduction of rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, overall reduction of volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conduct a groundwater analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly, applicant voluntarily offers to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive, and the applicant to work with staff on shoring up/improving the shoreline on the Lagoon. (24PUD00003). | Matter 8448 | Moved by Katie Delaney | Seconded by Kim Adkinson”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  12. Recorded vote

    Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada (Monica Pritchard) request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1. (25Z00036) (Tax Account 2005444) (District 1) - Voted no on the motion “Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada for a change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada, being represented by Monica Pritchard, request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1, under application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Monica Pritchard stated they have a property in Mims; it is two lots side-by-side that are basically family property; they have inherited this lot form their mother who has passed; Ms. Walsh and her husband live next door; and they would like to request a rezoning from SU to RR-1 in order to potentially do a flag lot so they can split the parcel, where Ms. Canada can own the front half and Ms. Walsh can own the back half. She continued by saying Ms. Walsh’s eventual goal is that maybe her children will take care of her and they may build on the back parcel; obviously, there is a septic moratorium; she is in no rush and she does not care if she can never build on it and just has to keep a horse there or something; but because it was inherited together, they would like to separate the two, give the sister the house on the front, and have Ms. Walsh keep the back end. Commissioner Delaney stated the idea of splitting lots in this area is concerning; and she cannot support this right now, especially since they do not have a need to build at the moment. Ms. Pritchard stated what she thinks they really need is to separate the interest; while they are sisters, they obviously have different children, different heirs, and things like that; while they both inherited the property together, she thinks they both want to keep it as family properties; it is a unique situation and she understands Commissioner Delaney’s concerns and that this is not popular in her District right now; however, while considering the larger concerns of the community, there are also individual needs of the property owner. She continued to explain the lots are conforming; it is going to be over an acre on each; she does not have any immediate plans for any of this it is just legally in order to separate it, make it fair for the two of them, she would like to keep the vacant land portion, which right now, her horses will just graze along with her property that is right next door; her sister will get to keep the house; she reiterated she understands this is not popular in District 1; she has heard all of the flooding concerns and things like that; but in this individual situation, it is not adding to the flooding concerns; and she has no immediate plans to build, but in order for her heir, should something happen to her and her husband, be able to inherit that piece of land without their cousins complicating things further, this is what would be necessary. She noted it would be a rezone in order to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked if the applicant would be willing to do a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to say no building. Ms. Pritchard asked if that means ever. Commissioner Delaney explained a BDP eventually could be changed with the direction of the Board. Ms. Prichard stated the goal would be that her kids could eventually one day when the time is right, maybe when these flooding issues are resolved, the septic moratorium is lifted, that they could potentially build there one day; and she would have to discuss that with her client because that is not something that she had anticipated. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way to do that in a BDP or whatever that says that there will not be any building for three years as a means to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked Morris Richardson, County Attorney, if there are any other options for this family. Attorney Richardson stated he is hesitant to give advice that borders on legal advice; and if the ultimate goal is to build on the property this seems to be the path. Ms. Pritchard stated they are part of the Mims community; they have livestock and all those things; they understand Commissioner Delaney’s concerns; they are over here nodding with their neighbors, doing all those things; they get it; but while Commissioner Delaney is considering all of that, this is their individual property; it is between two family parcels; and the lots are appropriately sized. She commented there is a septic moratorium and she does not know how long that will continue, it sounds like a long time based on the testimony that she has heard tonight; they are not intending on doing anything any time soon; when they do they will go through all of the proper channels again, retain counsel again, and the Board will have the opportunity again to hear this because they will need permits and all of those things. Chair Altman asked if Ms. Pritchard is an attorney or just a legal representative. Ms. Pritchard replied yes, she is. Chair Altman asked if this is part of any sort of estate planning and what they are trying to plan for the future. Ms. Pritchard responded affirmatively saying they are planning for the future; currently her and her sister own it; they were not sure what they wanted to do with it; in order for them to separate out, her sister wants to keep the front half; her sisters heirs will be able to inherit the front half; and she get to keep the back half. Chair Altman asked about the size of the individual lots. Ms. Pritchard again stated they will be over an acre, the parcel is 2.94 acres. Commissioner Delaney asked what the Future Land Use is for this. Ms. Gilliam replied it is RES-1. Commissioner Feltner responded it is just one acre to build. Commissioner Delaney and Chair Altman both answered yes. Commissioner Adkinson states he would like to point out that Planning and Zoning actually recommended approval of this 11:2 after some pretty decent discussion. Ms. Pritchard reiterated that she understands exactly what the concern is; but she thinks in this individual case, due to the uniqueness of this and the fact that they live next door, she would say that this ameliorates some of those concerns. Commissioner Feltner asked if they are going to essentially be almost equal 1.5 acre lots. Ms. Pritchard stated they are almost equal; on the application, the surveys that they submitted show what was intended eventually. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way that Commissioner Delaney will be comfortable is they can only have one home per each one and one-half acre lot for each lot in the future. Ms. Pritchard responded she is pretty sure that is the way it is already that someone can only have one home. Commissioner Feltner asked if it is one acre to build. Ms. Pritchard stated yes, and she thinks one can have maybe an accessory building which would be a barn, which may be of interest to them; but that is not the intention right now; she also is not sure that her children are ever going to move to take care of her; and she would say if the Board wants to do a BDP with maybe three years that would be fine with them because there are no immediate plans for this, but for estate planning purposes they would like to make it clean. Commissioner Feltner asked if it would be not a building permit for three years. Ms. Pritchard responded no building permit for three years would be fine with them; she reiterate there is no immediate plan to build on this; however, they are both older and they are getting their affairs in order and things like that. Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, stated he is trying to think it through; the proposed lot split is attached to the Item on the Agenda, but that is for conceptual purposes at this point; and he is trying to think about how to map the BDP in the future and the actual description of the land because would it be across the whole property, so the BDP could say the house could be on the entire property with no more than one unit across the entire parcel for the next three years, subsequent to that there could be two units on the parent parcel. Ms. Pritchard stated they are going to apply for a flag lot after this because that is the whole point, to change the zoning to apply for a flag lot; and as long as this does not impede that then… Attorney Richardson stated they just need to record the BDP along with the zoning action because the zoning is going to paint the whole property, not just the flag lot because that lot has not been created yet, that is going to tail; the Board has to bring the BDP back, under the Code, within… Mr. Prasad advised it is 120 days. Attorney Richardson continued by saying 120 days, so if she could create that before. Mr. Prasad stated then staff could have that BDP and she could come back just applying for to the southern lot. Ms. Pritchard stated sure. Ms. Gilliam stated just for clarification regarding a barn on a vacant property; two points, staff cannot do the flag lot application until the rezoning is approved and the properties are recorded in that configuration; and two, she had mentioned having a barn on the property and one cannot have a barn without a primary structure. Ms. Pritchard stated they were saying that there could not be more than two structures so she understands that they cannot have the barn, it is an accessory; and she understands that. Ms. Gilliam responded that she just wanted to clarify that. Attorney Richardson stated that is about no more than one primary residence on the entire property for three years; and he thinks they will have to put the BDP on the entire property with that limitation because it is sort of a standoff; he was thinking they could do the split and then record the BDP, but they will not be permitted to do that until the zoning is in place; and zoning will not go into place until the BDP is recorded. He noted it is a circle so staff can paint the BDP over the entire property; it is going to allow what they already have; it will not prevent what they have or an accessory structure on the other lot or anything like that. Ms. Pritchard stated there are no plans that she is aware of to build an accessory structure on the other lot, so there is no… Attorney Richardson interjected saying it could not be done on the new lot without a primary dwelling. Ms. Pritchard stated correct. Attorney Richardson stated if she is comfortable with a BDP and she has authorization to represent the entire property, staff is going to have to put the BDP in place over the entire property, not just the new flag lot. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to explain her vote; she knows the applicant is part of the community and she hopes she hears her heart in this because this situation is very unique; she knows they are not trying to flip it to sell to a random person, but for her she made a commitment to people to not increase density in this area; but she is just one of five, so she will not be able to vote for this today. Commissioner Adkinson made the motion. Mr. Prasad stated he thinks staff understands that; and the BDP will come back to the Board with the final terms. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada to change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, with a BDP on the entire property stating no building for three years, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. | Matter 8480 | Moved by Kim Adkinson | Seconded by Rob Feltner”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  13. Recorded vote

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) - Voted no on the motion “Ms. Rezanka stated she wanted to thank Mr. Sudermann for his comments as they have tried to work with the residents; Mr. Burroughs asked about a turn lane and if FDOT says it is necessary, certainly that would be put in; she does need to point out that right now water is just sleeting off of this property with no treatment, no nothing; this will retain the water, it will treat it, and it will be better than it currently is, after this is developed; the County has ensured this, Mr. Bernath, by asking for these conditions to which the developer has agreed, reduce the volume of storwater to better control runoff, reduce the rate of stormwater discharge which will improve what is going on with the water leading to Indian River Drive, and they have agreed to like trees for like trees; this is not a BDP, these are all conditions of the PDP; they do not usually do a BDP, they are willing to do it, but usually they do not do a BDP with a PDP for a PUD; and any changes to the PDP, that is part of the County’s Code and if it increases density, but any changes could be a change to the road, so she would ask that not be a conditional ask, to just follow the Code. She continued on to say if the PDP is changed in a substantial way determined by Mr. Prasad, then they will have to come back; she does not want that to be part of it; if the Board puts it in there then they will agree to it, but it is already in the Code and she does not think it is necessary; all the flooding issues are engineering issues and Mr. Bernath, Ms. McGee, and Ms. Gerena will be reviewing all of these; those are all plat issues, site plan issues; no one can prove a negative at this point, but based upon what staff has required, it is going to be a better condition for flooding and stormwater than it is currently; with that she would ask the Board to approve the alternate request to RES-2, find that it is compatible because they are doing like-size houses, RES-2 to RES-2 to allow the density bonuses to 23 units, as 23 is demanded by the PDP which governs it, and if not it is just a RES-2 all the way to the river, and takes in the wetlands that right now has RES-4. She reiterated she is asking the Board to approve RES-2 and the PDP, with the waiver. Chair Altman commented Ms. Rezanka may have addressed some of this towards the end of the presentation, but maybe she could elaborate further; one of the big questions that has been brought up to the Board is that there was an agreement for a BDP and now that is being changed, so people are feeling like that is sort of a bait and switch or that the developer is going against the commitment of the land owner; and he asked what is the reasoning for going with the change. Ms. Rezanka replied as she mentioned in the October meeting, this has really been a troubled piece of property; it has been in and out of foreclosure, back and forth between owners, it has not been developed, and there are challenges to the land with the wetlands, the sloping, and with access; this really is a challenging or troubled piece of property; a BDP was agreed to in 2008; in 2008 it was kind of the crash of the market, or the beginning of it, so she believes they just took whatever they could get; regardless, it has not been developed; it is only the seven acres in the center, so there is other developable land that is RES-4 and in theory could put another 12 units on it as is; they could have the 12 and the seven which is 19; it is just like a change of zoning, it could not be built that way; and it is not feasible to be built that way when they add in all the stormwater and all of the other requirements of subdivisions that were not the same in 2008. She continued by saying the costs of construction have doubled in the last five years; it was not feasible for the owner in 2008; her client bought it in 2021 and it was not feasible for him; basically, he is asking for a rezoning, removing the BDP is really just a rezoning action; she has said the reasons why the applicant wants to do it; and basically, it is the conditions of the property. Chair Altman stated he knows he looked at the original BDP that is in the packet; and he asked if the original BDP preserved the wetlands, the river. Ms. Rezanka explained all it did was limit the seven acres to seven units. Chair Altman asked if it limited access to River Road. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not recall that, but they are not going to Indian River Road. Chair Altman noted there are some advantages. Ms. Rezanka explained there was a limit that they could not access Parkchester and it did not really define what that meant; Parkchester has a road that goes directly into the property, the applicant’s property dead ends; that was her interpretation of what cannot access Parkchester, but the neighbors thought it meant that they could not access that road, which is a public road; but that was the access, it was not Indian River Drive, one cannot access Parkchester; and they have taken of access to Parkchester. Commissioner Delaney asked if Ms. Rezanka thought it would be extremely expensive to mitigate this property to the point where they could build to that capacity, if they were to build the 12 houses on the RES-4 portion, and if that is really realistic. Ms. Rezanka explained what she is missing is there are three acres that is not wetlands and still RES-4, that is between the wetlands and RES-1. Commissioner Delaney stated but she would still have to account for the stormwater and all of that stuff. Ms. Rezanka commented all she is saying is the allowable density right now in her opinion is 19 plus the commercial; she is asking for 23; that does not include the wetlands; and the staff report says something else, but she disagrees with the staff report. Commissioner Feltner stated they are going to have to do a lot of work to this property, there is no doubt; there is expense in getting this ready; he asked in ideal market conditions, how much are they asking for each one of these homes; and he explained he is asking that because nearby neighbors sometimes say they do not want these cookie-cutter houses. Ms. Rezanka replied based upon the developers, it is $450,000 to $600,000; and she does not know about this, but what she knows from other developers that are developing similar products, that is the sale price, between $450,000 and $600,000. Commissioner Goodson asked if Ms. Rezanka would be agreeable to everything that Mr. Prasad quoted would be attached to this permit. Ms. Rezanka responded in the affirmative. Commissioner Goodson asked if that is okay with Mr. Prasad. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just ask for one clarification from the Board; and he believes Ms. Rezanka just said that she prefers not to have the condition that any change to the PDP come back to the Board, and that is completely at the Board’s discretion whether it prefers to keep the typical, which is an substantial change that would come back to the Board, or if it wants any changes come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson asked Ms. Rezanka how she would agree with that. Ms. Rezanka noted she thinks the Board should stick by its Code, and Ms. Gilliam is who stated that not Mr. Prasad; she would prefer it not be added in there; they will accept it; but to her, she thinks there is a Code and because any change as, she said, could change the location of the road, and that to her should not have to come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson stated he thinks within reason, staff is not talking those changes; and he asked Mr. Prasad if that is correct. Ms. Rezanka pointed out he said any change. Mr. Prasad noted the way it is written, and this was mentioned at the last Board meeting and that is why it was put in there, it does say any change; and he would say if there is some middle ground that the Board wants to consider, it can do that as well. Chair Altman stated there might be a change that is better for the land and the neighborhood. Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they could take out two units and they would have to come back. Chair Altman continued by saying and they would not want to come back to do that because they would have to do this, so he is fine with having some flexibility there. Commissioner Goodson stated he is too. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, asked if it is staff’s preference to have these conditions memorialized in a BDP as opposed to conditions for the PDP. Mr. Prasad explained staff prefers it to be both; and the conditions of the PUD memorialized in a BDP because it is easier to track internally and transparent for the public because when they look at the map they will see the PUD with the PDP and can easily see those conditions. Ms. Rezanka apologized that she missed that, and she stated she is not used to that for a PDP, but that is fine. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to bring up what one of the residents said, that the reason why there is not a lot of people here tonight is because they have come out over and over and over again; the neighborhood still has not changed; the couple people who have come up and said that they could live with this, is not because they are happy about it; in District 1 there are still hundreds of people who are not living in their homes right now because of the flooding that it has incurred this year; it is frustrating to her that all of this is being overlooked in her opinion, from what she sees happening right now; this is her District and she knows what her constituents want and need; nobody is guaranteed a rezone, it is not a property right; and this is going to dramatically change this community regardless of what they are going to say about controlling the stormwater. She continued to say she has not seen one neighborhood in District 1 where a new neighborhood goes in next to an old neighborhood and flooding did not happen, not one; if the rest of the Board members want this in his or her own neighborhoods that is fine, but District 1 elected her to speak for them and they do not want this; she understands the rest of the Board may not like her, or her style, but this has nothing to do with her, it has to do with the people; she is asking the Board to please do what it has historically done in this County and listen to the District Commissioner, where the people have elected her to speak for them; and with that, she would like to make a motion to deny this request. Chair Altman advised the motion dies for lack of a second. Commissioner Delaney asked Ms. Rezanka if the developer would be willing to do any kind of shoreline shoring up in this area. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not know what that means; she is sure they can put in that they will work with the staff to do what they can in that area because they do own property; and that can be a binding condition to work with the County to work on shoring up the shoreline on the riverside. Commissioner Delaney stated some of the areas, obviously, not right on their property but around it, some of the owners have put more fill or whatnot, coquina rocks and stuff; that seems to help in those areas; and she does not know if they are willing to do that. Ms. Rezanka advised the developer is because they did talk about that; staff needs to come up with a comprehensive solution that everyone can help and do the same thing; and they are certainly willing to help with that. Commissioner Feltner asked if that is something that they would have to go to BDP for when on the edge of the river. Ms. McGee advised they would have to get a permit from the State and get a permit from Natural Resources as well, although Natural Resources does not allow sea walls, but they can do coquina, slope revetments, native vegetation, living shoreline, so there are other strategies that could be used. Commissioner Feltner asked for clarification that they will not run into issues with the County. Ms. McGee commented it depends on what they propose, but yes, they should be able to get a permit from the County. Commissioner Feltner noted he is not asking for a commitment. He stated there are other property parcels along there that have these treatments that they could potentially duplicate. Ms. McGee advised they can probably do better; sometimes staff sees when people do their own thing maybe it is not as fortified as it could be if it is properly engineered and has filter cloth and mangroves, and that sort of thing; and they do encourage that sort of thing. Commissioner Feltner asked and some of those other things, DEP has signed off on, maybe in the last few years. Ms. McGee responded affirmatively. Commissioner Feltner commented he just does not want false hope that they will do something and then they run into a problem with DEP. Chair Altman stated that is a good point; this property when it makes a transition, the lots have been sold or it reaches a certain threshold, it goes into a homeowners association, he would assume, and he thinks the St. John’s now requires that, so they are responsible for maintaining the stormwater; they also own, and it is probably part of the amenity to the project, they have a pedestrian access they can literally walk to the river, so that is their property on the river; if the shoreline starts to fail or even jeopardizes the road, they would probably have a duty to maintain it, would they not; and he asked who that responsibility would fall on. He commented he knows they may have a desire, but he never thought of that, one who owns property on the river and if it is eroded and the road is threatened, who is responsible for going on that property to protect the road. Mr. Bernath stated it depends on who actually owns and then any maintenance conditions; he may be missing something, but he was not aware that this goes all the way to the river; in which case they may provide the recommendations that Commissioner Delaney had just suggested; but ultimately, if it is impacting a road then it would be a public cost; and he would add that staff needs to be very careful, a revetment system could actually wind up trapping the water and making it worse; and they are in the process right now of doing a major study for that road and there is not an easy solution. He noted he has said this before, but the actual solution is about $1 billion; there is also lots of private properties that staff would have to even figure out how to overcome that; the big issue is how to keep the water out; it is not necessarily the stormwater that is going down the hill as much as it is the waves over topping; the road is very low as was mentioned earlier; and now if it is raised up, whether it is some sort of revetment system or someone builds a great big wall, someone has to raise the road. He continued by saying if one raises the road, it has to move utilities, and move all the connections to all the houses and road system; and that is where the billion dollars comes in. Chair Altman asked when he said a billion if he meant the entire River Road. Mr. Bernath advised the study focused on 9,000 linear feet, which he would suggest the juice is not worth the squeeze at that point. Chair Altman stated if that is an issue he is sure that the County will deal with St. Johns permitting and homeowners would probably want to keep that as nice as they possibly can. Commissioner Delaney stated there is obviously a lot in this motion so if staff could help, what she is looking for is, and she inquired if the applicant would be amenable to not doing the bonus density, doing 21. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively. Commissioner Delaney asked if the Board could move to approve with all of the things that staff has said, plus working with staff to shore up the shore line there. Ms. Gilliam stated first there has to be a motion on Item H.1. for the Small Scale Amendment, then H.2. when that motion is made he or she can add all that. Mr. Prasad stated what he is hearing is the motion is to CC and RES-2 without the finding required for the density bonus. Commissioner Delaney noted that is correct. Commissioner Delaney moved to approve and Commissioner Feltner seconded. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 25-22, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”; setting forth the fourth Small Scale Plan Amendment of 2025, 24S.11 to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI(E), The Future Land Use Appendix; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date; approved changing the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4 and NC to CC and RES-2 (24SS00009). | Matter 8447 | Moved by Katie Delaney | Seconded by Rob Feltner”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
See all 12 roll calls with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 141,296 characters. The full document is at the source.

Thursday, December 11, 2025 5:00 PM Brevard County Board of County Commissioners Commission Chambers, Building C 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way Viera, FL 32940 Commission Chambers Minutes Zoning December 11, 2025 A. CALL TO ORDER 5:04 PM Rollcall Commissioner District 1 Katie Delaney , Commissioner District 2 Tom Goodson, Commissioner District 3 Kim Adkinson, Commissioner District 4 Rob Feltner, and Commissioner District 5 Thad Altman Present: ZONING STATEMENT The Board of County Commissioners acts as a Quasi-Judicial body when it hears request for rezoning and Conditional Use Permits. Applicants must provide competent substantial evidence establishing facts, or expert witness opinion testimony showing that the request meets the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan criteria. Opponents must also testify as to facts, or provide expert testimony; whether they like, or dislike, a request is not competent evidence. The Board must then decide whether the evidence demonstrates consistency and compatibility with the Comprehensive Plan and the existing rules in the Zoning Ordinance, property adjacent to the property rezoned, and the actual development of the surrounding area. The Board cannot consider speculation, non-expert opinion testimony, or poll the audience by asking those in favor or opposed to stand up or raise their hands. If a Commissioner has had communications regarding a rezoning or Conditional Use Permit request before the Board, Commissioner must disclose the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity, with whom the communication took place before the Board takes action on the request. Each applicant is allowed a total of 15 minutes to present their request unless the time is extended by a majority vote of the Board. The applicant may reserve any portion of the 15 minutes for rebuttal. Other speakers are allowed five minutes to speak. Speakers may not pass their time to someone else in order to give that person more time to speak. C. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Commissioner Thad Altman, District 5 Chair Altman led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance. H.5. Alexis Raul and Rosemary Estevez DeJesus request a zoning classification change from BU-1 with a BDP to BU-1 with removal of a BDP. (25Z00003) (Tax Account 2004581) (District 1) Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Alexis Raul and Rosemary Estevez DeJesus for a change of zoning classification from BU-1 with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to BU-1 with removal of the BDP; account number is 25Z00003; and the property is located in District 1. He inquired if the petitioners were in attendance and receiving no response he moved on to Item H.1. H.1. City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the future land use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4, application number 24SS00009, located in Titusville. Trina Gilliam stated Items H.1. and H.2. are companion cases and they are generally read into the record together, but the Board has to make a separate decision. Page 1 of 44 December 11, 2025 Chair Altman read into the record Item H.2., City Pointe Landfall LLC requests a change of zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing Binding Development Plan (BDP) to PUD with removal of the existing BDP, located in District 1. He noted he will have staff provide a summary. Ms. Gilliam advised she would like to read the application numbers into the record; Item H.1., the Small Scale Amendment, the application number is 24SS00009, located in District 1; and Item H.2., City Point Landfall, under application number 24PUD00003, is also located in District 1. Kim Rezanka, Law Firm of Lacey Rezanka, stated she is there on behalf of City Point Landfall, the owner and developer of the project; she has with her David Bassford with MVB Engineering, the engineer of record, if the Board has any questions; she feels as though she has given this presentation four times; because of the last comments that were heard, she worked with staff and they are changing the future land use from requesting RES-4 to RES-2; the reason that had not been done prior was because they did not think they could do that because part of the land was in the coastal high hazard area and because of spreading the density; they were not sure they were able to do that with the size of the houses clustered the way they were; working with the Planning and Development Director, Billy Prasad, and Ms. Gilliam, they had determined and opined that it could be changed to RES-2; and with the density bonus provided in the Comprehensive Plan, Policy 1.8, they could ask for the density bonus of 2.5 to keep the 23 units they were requesting. She went on to say what she has provided the Board is exactly what is in the staff report, and it was previously provided on November 24 or 26 and it is in Legistar; it is nothing new, she just thought it might be easier to see it up close in this document; page two is the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that is being requested with the PUD zoning; it shows the zoning currently is EU; page three shows the existing future land use of RES-1 and the RES-4 to the east and little bit of RES-2, will all now be RES-2 if the Board approves it; RES-2 is exactly what is to the north in the Parkchester subdivision; and the houses are compatible in sizes, that is what the engineer was able to do. She continued by saying it takes the wetlands of RES-4 and makes them RES-2; it hopefully helps some of the neighbors with the idea knowing that all the applicant is really trying to do is 23 units; if the PDP is never built, it is RES-2 and it is RES-2 all the way to the river, so it protects the wetlands to some extent; there was a request to put that in private conservation, but it was not large enough to put in private conservation, so they could not do that, but it will definitely be in a conservation tract, the wetlands to the east; and the next page is just showing the wetlands area and the temporary impacts. She noted there is going to be an elevated bike path through the wetlands as an amenity for the residents; the last page is just the overlay to show the houses next to the houses, where the stormwater ponds are, and the wetlands that will be protected; as the Board may recall, the residents have been very engaged, very vocal; they have asked that they remove the townhomes, and that has been done; and they had asked for no access on Parkchester and that access was removed, with the only access being from US 1. She stated the residents did not want any access on Indian River Drive; at one point there was a little parking area as an amenity, but it has been removed from the PDP; and the remaining issue which they have addressed is the RES-2. She mentioned there are concerns of flooding and stormwater, which has been discussed several times by the engineer of record, Bruce Moia for MVB; again, that is something that has to be engineered; this is just zoning so any flooding issues would be addressed during the plat stage; and with that, she is asking that the Board approve the request of RES-2, and then the small parcel of 1.94 acres of CC on the west against US 1, and then the remaining 10.94 would be RES-2. She commented with that, she would request the Board approved the PDP and the PUD request with the waivers; the last page the Board has, has a waiver request and that is dealing with the perimeter of the Page 2 of 44 December 11, 2025 subdivision because they have to deal with some canals and some drainage, and that is why they ask that the waiver be accepted with the PDP; there will still be a buffer and they will still commit to whatever type of buffer that is necessary to make it compatible; they have indeed put in the PDP, towards the east side, the requirement of an opaque buffer that was requested by Mr. and Mrs. Hous; the Board will see on the PDP, page two, it says “225 feet of an opaque buffer” and that is to buffer homes that would be adjacent to their home; that is in there and would be a requirement of any plat going forward; they will answer any questions; they would ask the Board to approve the RES-2, find that it is compatible because it is next to RES-2 so they could use the density bonuses to achieve the 23 units in the PDP; and she would ask that she be allowed to respond to any comments. Commissioner Adkinson stated this is kind of the same question she has asked before; and she inquired what the buffer to the northwest side between the houses is going to look like. Ms. Rezanka stated that it is going to be an opaque buffer; and she does not know exactly if it is going to be a fence or foliage that one cannot see through. Commissioner Adkinson asked if it will be opaque all the way across the entire back. Ms. Rezanka explained it will be; the applicant has only committed to the fence towards the area against the Hous’ property; and if the Board wants to make that a condition of an opaque fence or buffer the entire way, the applicant would certainly accept that. Commissioner Adkinson stated she was just thinking about if they are leaving the native trees that are already there. Ms. Rezanka replied unfortunately, because there is an elevation difference and there is a ditch through between the properties, those trees will likely have to come out; they intend to save them, but they do not know because all the engineering has not been completed; there have been some elevations done; by the way, they all have fences there already; however, if the Board wants a condition that they have an opaque buffer the entire length against Parkchester, they can do that. Commissioner Adkinson commented for her the opaque thing is not as important as the actual trees and things that are going to be lost; and she asked if the applicant would consider if they had to take out a big deciduous tree, putting a decent sized one back in there. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively; and she added if the Commissioner wants to make a condition that like-trees go back in, they can do that and make it a condition of the PDP. James Sudermann stated he lives just south of this project; he was happy to see the new addendum number two from staff; there were several pieces of that he would like to comment on; in light of the new alternative proposal submitted by City Pointe Landfall on December 25 and the new staff comments addendum number two he would like to voice the following, while they recognize that the latest proposal from City Pointe Landfall does not preserve the original existing BDP that they have, he keeps asking for it, it does address to a greater or lesser extent, most of the remaining ongoing concerns with density growth potential, stormwater and groundwater discharge issues, wetland preservation, and roadway flooding; if the Board were to adopt all of the conditions, staff comments, and applicant offers outlined in addendum number two, and the City Pointe PDP, their 2025, 1126 applicant alternative proposal that he thinks was just handed out, Beverly and himself would be willing to accept them as something they could live with; but be assured that he and Beverly only represent themselves in this and Page 3 of 44 December 11, 2025 cannot speak for the rest of their neighbors who have fought with them so long and hard to get this Board and this developer to listen and respond to all of their comments. He stated specifically to grant their support, they would like to see application of the RES-2 future land use map designation on the entire 10.94 acre residential portion of the property; they would like to make sure that a ban is imposed on all residential land use on the wetlands; staff comments also mention that a Public Works engineering evaluation of the outfall pipes across the Indian River roadway and of possibly raising the road should be performed, they would also like to see that memorialized here; as suggested by staff, they talk about creating a new BDP which incorporates at least the following provisions, any future change to the PDP will be considered a substantial change and require Board approval for the change; overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property and overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subjective property; the new BDP should conduct a ground water analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; dedication of up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County Maintenance and roadway projects along the north Indian River Drive; and finally the provision that says the future land use designation is to revert if the final development plan are never filed. He added he would like to reiterate if all the provisions and comments from this new staff addendum are included, he and Beverly could live with it. Chair Altman stated he noticed, and it may just be an oversight, Mr. Sudermann left out one portion in his comments, as he was following along with him, and it is the one that says preferably without the 25 percent density bonus based on FL1 Policy 1.8., if limited to 21 units, he did not hear that. Mr. Sudermann apologized and stated he did skip that; that is true they definitely appreciate the RES-2; if they had a preference they would like to see it be without the 25 percent density bonus which gets them to a potential of 25, although with the PUD being approved, that would just limit it to 23; he did make a comment here, it says, if limited to 21 units, the developer could incrementally increase the lot size of the small southern lots, which are pretty small, and or could donate a portion of the southside property as an access path to 1800s pioneer cemetery, which has been landlocked now for decades; and that would be a nice gesture. Greg Burroughs stated just to reiterate what the previous speaker has just said, really the main thing being looked at is the wetlands and how that is going to affect any runoff that goes down into the river, anything from the soil, and obviously, from the grasses, fertilizers, and things like that that could end up in that river going straight down; he does appreciate the two units per acre; he is not sure how that is going to affect, without any RV storage in the front; he would not mind seeing a turning lane dedicated into that neighborhood so that the three lanes which have been reduced to two right in front of that property do not cause any bottlenecks or any more accidents; and he thanked the Board for its time. Diane Burroughs stated she wanted to reiterate along with Mr. Sudermann; she thanked the applicant for the consideration for reducing it from a RES-4 to a RES-2; and she asked to continue to keep in mind the conservation area, the flooding, and those very serious issues that are currently happening in that area, and how this is going to impact it. Sandra Kennedy stated she lives about one-half mile north of this project; no matter how many public hearings and how many residents complain about this project, the criteria are set in the rules and regulations that are applicable to this Board; and they are binding. She continued by saying the applicant has not met the requirements for a variance; City Pointe Landfall’s application does not meet the criteria for a zoning variance, even limited, and the County Commissioners must reject the application in its entirety; not once have they addressed the Page 4 of 44 December 11, 2025 community, the neighborhood; their title is City Pointe, City Pointe is a community that stretches from a little bit north of 528, around City Pointe Road, all the way to at least Blacks Road and really beyond; it is along Indian River Drive which is basically at sea level in this area; this is not the Indian River Drive portion that is on bluffs in Cocoa, it is sea level; and there is already flooding problems that need to be addressed. She went on to say one of the Board’s criteria that absolutely must be met before any variance can be given is that they must not increase or cause flooding to the community; they have failed that one right away; their recent change, which she received late last night while she was preparing for this hearing, was that they were giving the Board another paragraph on what their flood control plan is; basically, they had nothing to say but what they had said before; they plan a series of ponds that they are going to allow to overflow; that is their strategy, ponds that overflow; they are going to go down to the wetlands and those wetlands are not sponges, not dry, and they do not need to be appropriately wetted, they are soaking wet; and there are ditches that run along Indian River Drive that are constantly full. She stated their capacity for more water does not exist; they are going to cause flooding; not only that, but their project, it does not abut the full wetland, it only abuts a portion, less than half of the wetland, and the other portion of the land that is a lower elevation to them, is going to get flooded out, and it is residential property; there are no ditches in front of those people’s houses because it is not in an appropriate location like it is in front of that wetland; they do not have a flood control plan; they say they are going to use offsite flooding systems and that just means a ditch; she is between US 1, City Pointe Road and basically, Blacks Road or further north, and the Indian River Lagoon; this is their community, the whole entire thing is large homes on large lots; all recent developments since the 60s has been single homes on an acre or two homes on an acre; they are blowing that out of the water; they are trying to say well Parkchester is to the north, but that is not the community; and she asked why they have titled their company name as City Pointe. She noted Parkchester is a remnant from the past; it is what the Planning and Zoning rules and regulations were trying to get away from, which is strip all the trees down and try to put a whole bunch of homes crammed in; that is not bad if it is on flat land, but it cannot be done in environmentally sensitive lands where there are live oak hammocks on a slope; US 1 is like 75 feet or so and it is like a giant waterslide that goes down to Indian River Drive; and the open spaces are needed to absorb the water; the community, they go around saying, Parkchester and all these small communities, and this little property here is .2 of an acre, and they talk about the industrial area way across, but that is a different zone and not the neighborhood, so they do not match the neighborhood; they do not meet the County’s criteria to receive this; they are not even a Planned Unit Development (PUD) and they are not entitled to exceed or to get that bonus; now with that bonus, they would be getting more than they have ever sought before; and they are not a planned community that is fully encompassing everything that the community would need, it is a very small strip of land. She reiterated it is not a PUD, they are not entitled to a bonus, they need to stick to the regular zoning like the rest of the community. She asked the Board to follow the law. Chair Altman noted he has a question for staff; Ms. Kennedy used the term variance; and he asked if this is a variance or a zoning change. Ms. Gilliam replied no, sir, it is a zoning change in a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment. Chair Altman asked so they do not use the variance… Ms. Gilliam interjected by saying criteria. Ms. Kennedy stated the criteria are for rezoning; she does not know the difference between Page 5 of 44 December 11, 2025 rezoning and variance; she is a construction lawyer not a land development lawyer; but the County’s own criteria says for rezoning it has to meet this criteria; it is flooding that has to be met before and compatibility to match the entire community; the other thing, their PUD, they have to hide that extra density within the community so that it cannot be seen from the rest of the community; that is the only thing that would allow them to do it; and this is such a small strip of land so there is no hiding anything. Chair Altman stated he now understands her point. Commissioner Goodson asked in their proposal for dry retention ponds on the hill that eventually get to the wetlands, are they required to store 100 percent of the water for 24 hours; and he asked if that is correct. Chair Altman stated before they take a motion or vote, he will let Ms. Rezanka have an opportunity to close, she might want to hear this first. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, stated he will let Darcie McGee, Environmental Policy and Resilience Administrator, answer this. Ms. McGee advised they are not going to be required to hold 100 percent of their water on site based on State stormwater standards; they have to meet certain criteria to hold, and she believes it is a 25-year storm; that then gets held to treat for water quality; then there will be eventual discharge that will go through the system that they show on the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that goes down through the pond down to the wetlands and then out to the river; and that does not account for the volume, just the rate and the water quality treatment. Commissioner Goodson asked as far as staff, how much water it thinks is going to occur that goes through the wetlands to the river. Ms. McGee advised there is no way she could answer something like that; she thinks in the package, if this is correct, there was a where the engineer had previously talked about maintaining the volume and the rate of flow; and that would be something he could engineer. Mr. Bernath commented that is correct; Mr. Moia had previously advised that they agreed to engineering concerns about ensuring post-development stormwater discharge rate and volume for the site; because this is just at the zoning stage, staff has not seen anything and cannot confirm that it meets it; but that is what he has agreed to. Commissioner Goodson stated of course everyone agrees that City Pointe Road intersecting Indian River Road has always been low; and he asked if that is correct. Mr. Bernath replied affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to read off addendum number two, the concessions that he thinks are fair or he is willing to accept. Mr. Prasad advised he will start with one that he thinks somebody had mentioned today and Ms. Rezanka had brought up last time that he does not think is appropriate, and that would be the automatic reversion of the land use if the PDP was not recorded; staff does not think that there is any legal mechanism to implement that and that is why it was left off the Agenda Report for Board consideration; he just wanted to explain why the public would not hear him Page 6 of 44 December 11, 2025 say that; for the conditions that the applicant had agreed to, he will add one that they mentioned today which is for like trees as part of the waiver request for disturbing the buffer; beyond that, an overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, an overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conducting a groundwater analysis by identifying any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; and they have volunteered to offer to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive. He noted staff would suggest that if the Board is looking to implement those conditions that it do so and ask for it to be implemented through a BDP. Commissioner Goodson asked if this gets approval and it is built, how staff will govern the discharge of water. Mr. Prasad explained that would be done through the site plan process; and the applicant would have to demonstrate that they are meeting all of the conditions through various analysis. Commissioner Goodson asked if the applicant would be liable down the road, six months after the project is done, to make sure they do not put too much water into the Indian River Lagoon. Mr. Prasad stated the BDP will carry with the land; he would also say that under the County’s Code that the maintenance of discharge is typically on the private entities; and it could be enforced in the future. Ms. Gilliam advised the Board she has one other condition and that is to memorialize in the BDP that any future changes to the PDP be considered a substantial change and be brought back before the Board. Mr. Bernath advised he would like to add one more; and he does not know if it was agreed to during the last meeting, but staff had asked for the 50 feet of total right-of-way that is proposed to be dedicated, that the applicant also agree to mitigate those wetlands in the granted right-of-way, otherwise that will become a future County cost. Commissioner Delaney stated she wanted to disclose that she had a meeting with the Twin Lakes Homeowners Association and she did drive past the neighborhood, by the location to see the conditions last night; there have been a lot of concessions made with this project and she really appreciates that; she feels like the developer has tried to work with the community; if this was in a different area it would be harder for her to say no; but this area is so unique and there is a constant of running water throughout this area. She went on to say even the drainage pipes; being next to them it sounds like a shower all the time; that is just the ground water, it is not because there is even any rain; she is extremely concerned about the density of this project for this location because it is just so fragile; then on top of that, there is the issue of low-lying Indian River Drive; people’s vehicles are getting ruined, people are getting trapped on their streets, and one resident had told her that they had to rent a car because they did not want to damage their own vehicle; District 1 is experiencing a lot of flooding and a lot of property damage; her concern is that it is going to hit a boiling point at some point to where this is going to be a Countywide problem because the County is going to have to start buying houses from people if not careful; Volusia County has had to deal with this; she does not want to see that happen here in Brevard County; and she is very concerned that if the County does not keep this BDP and keep the density low in this area that the County is going to have huge problem. She mentioned just in general she believes that a person should do their due diligence when buying property; it sounds like the applicant knew what they were buying and knew it had a BDP on it; it is not right for the whole neighborhood to have to be affected by this when the Page 7 of 44 December 11, 2025 property owners knew what they were purchasing; it is not like somebody pulled the wool over their eyes; and that is kind of where she is at. Chair Altman stated there is another card that got mixed up with other cards. Bill Gower stated this keeps coming back; the people who bought this property knew there was a binding contract on it; what he sees is basically they threw everything against the wall to see what would stick, make the people happy, and see what they could get away with; after a meeting they would say there is no reason for people to come to the next meeting; there were 100 of them when it started out and they were told they did not have to go to the next meeting because they were just going to postpone it, and that is why the people have dwindled down in size; he has lived there since 1989; he knows how wide that property is and by the time one puts a road through the middle for two lands, then houses and driveways, that is a lot of water that is being added to that property and no place to go; when he talked to the guys that did the survey, his property sits lower than anybody else in regards to it, and he does get flooded out when it rains; and he is on the upper side not on the lower side like some other people. He reiterated basically, they threw everything against the wall to see what sticks; if the Board approved something today, what makes this guy not go sell to somebody else and the next guys say they go away with that, let them go ask for more; and that is all he has to say. He commented that paperwork that was passed up there, he did not see any of it from the developers. Chair Altman advised he thinks what was provided by the applicant is the same as what is in the Board packet online. Ms. Rezanka stated she wanted to thank Mr. Sudermann for his comments as they have tried to work with the residents; Mr. Burroughs asked about a turn lane and if FDOT says it is necessary, certainly that would be put in; she does need to point out that right now water is just sleeting off of this property with no treatment, no nothing; this will retain the water, it will treat it, and it will be better than it currently is, after this is developed; the County has ensured this, Mr. Bernath, by asking for these conditions to which the developer has agreed, reduce the volume of storwater to better control runoff, reduce the rate of stormwater discharge which will improve what is going on with the water leading to Indian River Drive, and they have agreed to like trees for like trees; this is not a BDP, these are all conditions of the PDP; they do not usually do a BDP, they are willing to do it, but usually they do not do a BDP with a PDP for a PUD; and any changes to the PDP, that is part of the County’s Code and if it increases density, but any changes could be a change to the road, so she would ask that not be a conditional ask, to just follow the Code. She continued on to say if the PDP is changed in a substantial way determined by Mr. Prasad, then they will have to come back; she does not want that to be part of it; if the Board puts it in there then they will agree to it, but it is already in the Code and she does not think it is necessary; all the flooding issues are engineering issues and Mr. Bernath, Ms. McGee, and Ms. Gerena will be reviewing all of these; those are all plat issues, site plan issues; no one can prove a negative at this point, but based upon what staff has required, it is going to be a better condition for flooding and stormwater than it is currently; with that she would ask the Board to approve the alternate request to RES-2, find that it is compatible because they are doing like-size houses, RES-2 to RES-2 to allow the density bonuses to 23 units, as 23 is demanded by the PDP which governs it, and if not it is just a RES-2 all the way to the river, and takes in the wetlands that right now has RES-4. She reiterated she is asking the Board to approve RES-2 and the PDP, with the waiver. Chair Altman commented Ms. Rezanka may have addressed some of this towards the end of the presentation, but maybe she could elaborate further; one of the big questions that has been Page 8 of 44 December 11, 2025 brought up to the Board is that there was an agreement for a BDP and now that is being changed, so people are feeling like that is sort of a bait and switch or that the developer is going against the commitment of the land owner; and he asked what is the reasoning for going with the change. Ms. Rezanka replied as she mentioned in the October meeting, this has really been a troubled piece of property; it has been in and out of foreclosure, back and forth between owners, it has not been developed, and there are challenges to the land with the wetlands, the sloping, and with access; this really is a challenging or troubled piece of property; a BDP was agreed to in 2008; in 2008 it was kind of the crash of the market, or the beginning of it, so she believes they just took whatever they could get; regardless, it has not been developed; it is only the seven acres in the center, so there is other developable land that is RES-4 and in theory could put another 12 units on it as is; they could have the 12 and the seven which is 19; it is just like a change of zoning, it could not be built that way; and it is not feasible to be built that way when they add in all the stormwater and all of the other requirements of subdivisions that were not the same in 2008. She continued by saying the costs of construction have doubled in the last five years; it was not feasible for the owner in 2008; her client bought it in 2021 and it was not feasible for him; basically, he is asking for a rezoning, removing the BDP is really just a rezoning action; she has said the reasons why the applicant wants to do it; and basically, it is the conditions of the property. Chair Altman stated he knows he looked at the original BDP that is in the packet; and he asked if the original BDP preserved the wetlands, the river. Ms. Rezanka explained all it did was limit the seven acres to seven units. Chair Altman asked if it limited access to River Road. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not recall that, but they are not going to Indian River Road. Chair Altman noted there are some advantages. Ms. Rezanka explained there was a limit that they could not access Parkchester and it did not really define what that meant; Parkchester has a road that goes directly into the property, the applicant’s property dead ends; that was her interpretation of what cannot access Parkchester, but the neighbors thought it meant that they could not access that road, which is a public road; but that was the access, it was not Indian River Drive, one cannot access Parkchester; and they have taken of access to Parkchester. Commissioner Delaney asked if Ms. Rezanka thought it would be extremely expensive to mitigate this property to the point where they could build to that capacity, if they were to build the 12 houses on the RES-4 portion, and if that is really realistic. Ms. Rezanka explained what she is missing is there are three acres that is not wetlands and still RES-4, that is between the wetlands and RES-1. Commissioner Delaney stated but she would still have to account for the stormwater and all of that stuff. Ms. Rezanka commented all she is saying is the allowable density right now in her opinion is 19 plus the commercial; she is asking for 23; that does not include the wetlands; and the staff report says something else, but she disagrees with the staff report. Page 9 of 44 December 11, 2025 Commissioner Feltner stated they are going to have to do a lot of work to this property, there is no doubt; there is expense in getting this ready; he asked in ideal market conditions, how much are they asking for each one of these homes; and he explained he is asking that because nearby neighbors sometimes say they do not want these cookie-cutter houses. Ms. Rezanka replied based upon the developers, it is $450,000 to $600,000; and she does not know about this, but what she knows from other developers that are developing similar products, that is the sale price, between $450,000 and $600,000. Commissioner Goodson asked if Ms. Rezanka would be agreeable to everything that Mr. Prasad quoted would be attached to this permit. Ms. Rezanka responded in the affirmative. Commissioner Goodson asked if that is okay with Mr. Prasad. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just ask for one clarification from the Board; and he believes Ms. Rezanka just said that she prefers not to have the condition that any change to the PDP come back to the Board, and that is completely at the Board’s discretion whether it prefers to keep the typical, which is an substantial change that would come back to the Board, or if it wants any changes come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson asked Ms. Rezanka how she would agree with that. Ms. Rezanka noted she thinks the Board should stick by its Code, and Ms. Gilliam is who stated that not Mr. Prasad; she would prefer it not be added in there; they will accept it; but to her, she thinks there is a Code and because any change as, she said, could change the location of the road, and that to her should not have to come back to the Board. Commissioner Goodson stated he thinks within reason, staff is not talking those changes; and he asked Mr. Prasad if that is correct. Ms. Rezanka pointed out he said any change. Mr. Prasad noted the way it is written, and this was mentioned at the last Board meeting and that is why it was put in there, it does say any change; and he would say if there is some middle ground that the Board wants to consider, it can do that as well. Chair Altman stated there might be a change that is better for the land and the neighborhood. Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they could take out two units and they would have to come back. Chair Altman continued by saying and they would not want to come back to do that because they would have to do this, so he is fine with having some flexibility there. Commissioner Goodson stated he is too. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, asked if it is staff’s preference to have these conditions memorialized in a BDP as opposed to conditions for the PDP. Page 10 of 44 December 11, 2025 Mr. Prasad explained staff prefers it to be both; and the conditions of the PUD memorialized in a BDP because it is easier to track internally and transparent for the public because when they look at the map they will see the PUD with the PDP and can easily see those conditions. Ms. Rezanka apologized that she missed that, and she stated she is not used to that for a PDP, but that is fine. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to bring up what one of the residents said, that the reason why there is not a lot of people here tonight is because they have come out over and over and over again; the neighborhood still has not changed; the couple people who have come up and said that they could live with this, is not because they are happy about it; in District 1 there are still hundreds of people who are not living in their homes right now because of the flooding that it has incurred this year; it is frustrating to her that all of this is being overlooked in her opinion, from what she sees happening right now; this is her District and she knows what her constituents want and need; nobody is guaranteed a rezone, it is not a property right; and this is going to dramatically change this community regardless of what they are going to say about controlling the stormwater. She continued to say she has not seen one neighborhood in District 1 where a new neighborhood goes in next to an old neighborhood and flooding did not happen, not one; if the rest of the Board members want this in his or her own neighborhoods that is fine, but District 1 elected her to speak for them and they do not want this; she understands the rest of the Board may not like her, or her style, but this has nothing to do with her, it has to do with the people; she is asking the Board to please do what it has historically done in this County and listen to the District Commissioner, where the people have elected her to speak for them; and with that, she would like to make a motion to deny this request. Chair Altman advised the motion dies for lack of a second. Commissioner Delaney asked Ms. Rezanka if the developer would be willing to do any kind of shoreline shoring up in this area. Ms. Rezanka commented she does not know what that means; she is sure they can put in that they will work with the staff to do what they can in that area because they do own property; and that can be a binding condition to work with the County to work on shoring up the shoreline on the riverside. Commissioner Delaney stated some of the areas, obviously, not right on their property but around it, some of the owners have put more fill or whatnot, coquina rocks and stuff; that seems to help in those areas; and she does not know if they are willing to do that. Ms. Rezanka advised the developer is because they did talk about that; staff needs to come up with a comprehensive solution that everyone can help and do the same thing; and they are certainly willing to help with that. Commissioner Feltner asked if that is something that they would have to go to BDP for when on the edge of the river. Ms. McGee advised they would have to get a permit from the State and get a permit from Natural Resources as well, although Natural Resources does not allow sea walls, but they can do coquina, slope revetments, native vegetation, living shoreline, so there are other strategies that could be used. Page 11 of 44 December 11, 2025 Commissioner Feltner asked for clarification that they will not run into issues with the County. Ms. McGee commented it depends on what they propose, but yes, they should be able to get a permit from the County. Commissioner Feltner noted he is not asking for a commitment. He stated there are other property parcels along there that have these treatments that they could potentially duplicate. Ms. McGee advised they can probably do better; sometimes staff sees when people do their own thing maybe it is not as fortified as it could be if it is properly engineered and has filter cloth and mangroves, and that sort of thing; and they do encourage that sort of thing. Commissioner Feltner asked and some of those other things, DEP has signed off on, maybe in the last few years. Ms. McGee responded affirmatively. Commissioner Feltner commented he just does not want false hope that they will do something and then they run into a problem with DEP. Chair Altman stated that is a good point; this property when it makes a transition, the lots have been sold or it reaches a certain threshold, it goes into a homeowners association, he would assume, and he thinks the St. John’s now requires that, so they are responsible for maintaining the stormwater; they also own, and it is probably part of the amenity to the project, they have a pedestrian access they can literally walk to the river, so that is their property on the river; if the shoreline starts to fail or even jeopardizes the road, they would probably have a duty to maintain it, would they not; and he asked who that responsibility would fall on. He commented he knows they may have a desire, but he never thought of that, one who owns property on the river and if it is eroded and the road is threatened, who is responsible for going on that property to protect the road. Mr. Bernath stated it depends on who actually owns and then any maintenance conditions; he may be missing something, but he was not aware that this goes all the way to the river; in which case they may provide the recommendations that Commissioner Delaney had just suggested; but ultimately, if it is impacting a road then it would be a public cost; and he would add that staff needs to be very careful, a revetment system could actually wind up trapping the water and making it worse; and they are in the process right now of doing a major study for that road and there is not an easy solution. He noted he has said this before, but the actual solution is about $1 billion; there is also lots of private properties that staff would have to even figure out how to overcome that; the big issue is how to keep the water out; it is not necessarily the stormwater that is going down the hill as much as it is the waves over topping; the road is very low as was mentioned earlier; and now if it is raised up, whether it is some sort of revetment system or someone builds a great big wall, someone has to raise the road. He continued by saying if one raises the road, it has to move utilities, and move all the connections to all the houses and road system; and that is where the billion dollars comes in. Chair Altman asked when he said a billion if he meant the entire River Road. Mr. Bernath advised the study focused on 9,000 linear feet, which he would suggest the juice is not worth the squeeze at that point. Chair Altman stated if that is an issue he is sure that the County will deal with St. Johns Page 12 of 44 December 11, 2025 permitting and homeowners would probably want to keep that as nice as they possibly can. Commissioner Delaney stated there is obviously a lot in this motion so if staff could help, what she is looking for is, and she inquired if the applicant would be amenable to not doing the bonus density, doing 21. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively. Commissioner Delaney asked if the Board could move to approve with all of the things that staff has said, plus working with staff to shore up the shore line there. Ms. Gilliam stated first there has to be a motion on Item H.1. for the Small Scale Amendment, then H.2. when that motion is made he or she can add all that. Mr. Prasad stated what he is hearing is the motion is to CC and RES-2 without the finding required for the density bonus. Commissioner Delaney noted that is correct. Commissioner Delaney moved to approve and Commissioner Feltner seconded. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 25-22, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”; setting forth the fourth Small Scale Plan Amendment of 2025, 24S.11 to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI(E), The Future Land Use Appendix; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date; approved changing the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4 and NC to CC and RES-2 (24SS00009). Result: ADOPTED Mover: Katie Delaney Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Goodson, Adkinson, Feltner, and Altman Nay: Delaney H.2. City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1) Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, application number 24PUD00003, and tax account number 2411252, located in District 1. Commissioner Delaney asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to assist her with the motion. Chair Altman asked if needs to be reread into the record. Page 13 of 44 December 11, 2025 Mr. Prasad explained if it is said all the conditions outlined in the Agenda Report with the addition of some of the ones that were heard today, which is as part of the waiver request that would have to be approved as part of this application, like for like trees; then also mitigate any wetlands within the 50 foot right-of-way should they have to be dedicated… Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they cannot agree to that because it impacts their ability to mitigate. Chair Altman asked which one that was; and he asked that Ms. Rezanka come up and clarify that. Ms. Rezanka stated it was asked that the 50 foot right-of-way that is being dedicated, that they take on the responsibility for mitigating the wetlands; and she explained they cannot do that because it impacts the wetlands on the site because it would all be done at the same time; they only get 1.8 percent to impact; therefore, they cannot agree to that. Chair Altman stated so they are going to give up the land… Ms. Rezanka reiterated they are not agreeing to… Chair Altman interjected by saying mitigate somebody else’s land. Ms. Rezanka stated they may agree later on, but right now they cannot because they have to mitigate their own; and that was not something that was listed that she has agreed to. Ms. Gilliam asked if staff could make a comment. Ms. McGee stated she just wants to add that when talking about the dedication of the 50 foot right-of-way, they had talked about that not counting against their 1.8 percent because that would be to the benefit of the County for that 50 feet; that would not count against the other wetland impacts for the 1.8 percent for the applicant; but again, the mitigation being part of that cost. Mr. Bernath agreed, and stated he would just add that if they do not do it now, that is County right-of-way, and the taxpayers are going to be doing it if it ever decides to widen that road. Chair Altman inquired if the County owns it, would it not be the County’s responsibility to mitigate for widening the road, that is the public benefit to widen the road; if they have given up that right-of-way it would be the public's responsibility to mitigate for the public good of building the road; he understands their point, they are giving up the land and now they have to mitigate; he does not know; but he agrees with the applicant on that, he does not think that should be a requirement. Mr. Bernath stated he does not know if they will agree to it, but buy credits for mitigation. Ms. Rezanka noted she does not have the authority to do that or to spend her client’s money who is not in attendance to agree, when he told her not to agree to that; and at this point she cannot agree to it. Chair Altman commented they are basically giving land. Ms. Rezanka stated they are giving land that would have to be taken by imminent domain at a Page 14 of 44 December 11, 2025 valuable price. Chair Altman commented and a lot of legal costs so he appreciates her doing that. Mr. Prasad stated so with that said, the conditions would be as outlined in the Agenda Report, if the Board would like he will restate them but he has already stated them before, it would be for like for like trees, and work for the County to add potential treatments to shore up the shoreline along the Indian River Lagoon. Chair Altman stated on the issue of clearing, because he is not for clearing land as much as possible, but he has seen a lot of projects where some of which he voted on to preserve the native buffer, but if one goes back and the buffer is dead because when one does the improvements of the property, it affects the drainage, just a little soil on some of those trees kills it; and he agrees with not having to be able to go and it would have been a healthier, more attractive buffer if it was replanted, so he supports that. He mentioned that he does have a question, and he asked when it is said like for like trees is that species or size because there are some very large trees there. Mr. Prasad explained he thinks they are looking for similar type and size of trees, but he would defer to Ms. McGee whose Department implements that. Ms. McGee stated like for like can work depending on how big the lots are and what that buffer is; they may not be able to put back the same number of oak trees that may crowd out or may interfere with the buildings or structures. Chair Altman commented he worries about their ability to do the size too. Ms. McGee stated that is kind of a tough one to apply at permitting because if they take out a 20-inch oak they would not put back a 20-inch oak, they are going to be smaller ones. Chair Altman mentioned he has been by the site many times; he does not think a tree survey has been done; and he is just concerned with saying like for like, the size should not be a requirement. Mr. Prasad stated perhaps similar within reason. Chair Altman stated okay, that is good. Ms. McGee noted they like to make it specific to help staff apply it when it gets to permitting; she does not know if Mr. Prasad can put language in there to negotiate with Natural Resources Management for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a good buffer; and she asked if that would be acceptable. Chair Altman stated he likes the word mature. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just add one more thing, they were talking about PDP conditions, if the Board could just include to memorialize that in a BDP. Commissioner Delaney stated the motion would be to change the zoning from EU and RP with an existing BDP to a PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, but to add another BDP, including the things the Board has spoken about; she asked if she needs to read out all of those; and what does she need to say with the PDP. Page 15 of 44 December 11, 2025 Mr. Prasad stated as part of the zoning approval, the Board would be approving the PUD with the conditions specified to be memorialized in a PDP. Commissioner Delaney made that motion. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a Change of Zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP and approval of the PDP; approved a waiver to Section 62-2883(d) requiring an undisturbed 15-foot buffer around the perimeter of the project with the condition that any vegetation removed shall be replaced with reasonable similar vegetation in consultation with Natural Resources Management Department for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a buffer similar to its natural state; and making the PUD subject to the following conditions, which are to be memorialized in a BDP: an overall reduction of rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, overall reduction of volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conduct a groundwater analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly, applicant voluntarily offers to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive, and the applicant to work with staff on shoring up/improving the shoreline on the Lagoon. (24PUD00003). Result: APPROVED Mover: Katie Delaney Seconder: Kim Adkinson Ayes: Goodson, Adkinson, Feltner, and Altman Nay: Delaney H.3. Jacob Foune requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (25S.14) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2. (25SS00008) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1) Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jacob Foune for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment, 25S.14, to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2, application number 25SS00008, and tax account 2000804, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is a companion application and he will need to read into the record Item H.4., as well, or she can read it into the record for him. Chair Altman advised Ms. Gilliam to go ahead and read it into the record. Ms. Gilliam stated Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to SR with removal of the existing BDP and in addition of a new BDP, under application number 25Z00037, located in District 1. Jacob Foune stated he bought this land, submitted permits, got everything accepted and started building; he already has concrete block done and all inspections have passed; he has had his trusses sitting for nearly six months; he and his wife have spent their life-savings on this and just want to continue; he relied on the County and did everything as he should; and to clear one thing up from the last meeting, he is an employee for a very reputable air conditioning (AC) company and he does not work for Minnick. He noted he does new construction HVAC for many small builders in Brevard County, including Minnick. Page 16 of 44 December 11, 2025 Pat Ramer stated what she wants to address has already been spoken about many times here and that is the density; increasing density in this area, which is already prone to flooding, is only going to make the problem worse; every time the Board approves a variance or a zoning change to increase the density, it is increasing the chances of flooding in that area; people are suffering right now; during the last 2025 calendar year, they have had six flooding events in that particular area; she understands the house has already started to be built, it is significantly higher than the property behind it; and it is going to cause flooding to that other property. She asked the Board to consider that as it look at this request. Michael Biegler stated he has lived at 4125 Golden Shores for 22 years; he has lived in Brevard County for 61 years, and doing construction for 40 years; he has worked for many contractors throughout the State of Florida, some very big ones; he has never heard anything like what he is going to talk about in his entire career; Scotty Minnick is a contractor who sold 0.54 acres to Jacob Foune; alterations were done to the lot which violates the condition of the BDP, Section 62-2102 Brevard County Code of Ordinances, which states that no person shall separate the lot in a manner which violates the law; but the land was unlawfully split and an unlawful permit was given anyway. He continued by saying they would have all been at the public hearing along with Clifford McKnight of 3900 Golden Shores, on November 17, if they were notified, but the notification only went out to a few people that live within 500 feet; the letter was deceiving to most of the elderly who received it; it states that the land change was for 6.24 acres, not 0.54 acre, and that is not right because for many years the residents have been paying taxes, living on Golden Shores, and a lot longer Scotty Minnick and the applicant Jacob Foune, who is trying to unlawfully split land and build a house with an unlawful permit on 4060 Golden Shores Boulevard, which is going to be the launching site for McKnight, Minnick whatever construction it is, and other builders so they can break up property into smaller sections to build more houses and make more money; there was situation that took place right beside him on 3.10 acres; the Code Enforcement was called and they stopped it because the law was being broken; sad to be said, the guy that owned the land died and his heart sunk for him and he cried for him; it was just a small little thing that man had to take care of, but he had over three acres; but everyone is not talking about three acres, two acres, or even 6.24 acres, it is under acreage, and the people do not want it out there. He commented that just does not make sense to anyone who is in attendance today; he was just notified about this this week; they are law abiding citizens that have been living in Mims and Scottsmoor area for many years who voted for the County officials to represent the people and uphold the law; and he hopes this Board does its job and votes no for a law that has been broken. Stephanie Knight stated the proposed change alters the established character of this neighborhood where every residential lot is an acre or more; she initially chose to build there in a low density area relying on the zoning regulations that were put in place to preserve this area for herself and her kids; those standards should be upheld by the Board and all employees of Brevard County Zoning, Brevard County Property Appraiser, and the Brevard County Permitting; allowing permits for substandard lot sizes is only inconsistent with the zoning requirements, but raises serious concerns about accountability with the permitting process; when unlawful or improper permits are approved, especially using taxpayers resources, it enables and reinforces the very practices that created the issue; each time Commissioners vote in favor of these applicants, it further empowers that Department to continue using permits that do not comply with the law; and this request is incompatible with the current development plan and undermines the long-standing characte

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

18 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 12 of 18

Browse by category18 actions
  • Agenda item H.1.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the future land use designation from RES-1, RES-2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4, application number 24SS00009, located in Titusville. Trina Gilliam stated Items H.1. and H.2. are companion cases and they are generally read into the record together, but the Board has to make a separate decision. Chair Altman read into the record Item H.2., City Pointe Landfall LLC requests a change of zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing Binding Development Plan (BDP) to PUD with removal of the existing BDP, located in District 1. He noted he will have staff provide a summary. Ms. Gilliam advised she would like to read the application numbers into the record; Item H.1., the Small Scale Amendment, the application number is 24SS00009, located in District 1; and Item H.2., City Point Landfall, under application number 24PUD00003, is also located in District 1. Kim Rezanka, Law Firm of Lacey Rezanka, stated she is there on behalf of City Point Landfall, the owner and developer of the project; she has with her David Bassford with MVB Engineering, the engineer of record, if the Board has any questions; she feels as though she has given this presentation four times; because of the last comments that were heard, she worked with staff and they are changing the future land use from requesting RES-4 to RES-2; the reason that had not been done prior was because they did not think they could do that because part of the land was in the coastal high hazard area and because of spreading the density; they were not sure they were able to do that with the size of the houses clustered the way they were; working with the Planning and Development Director, Billy Prasad, and Ms. Gilliam, they had determined and opined that it could be changed to RES-2; and with the density bonus provided in the Comprehensive Plan, Policy 1.8, they could ask for the density bonus of 2.5 to keep the 23 units they were requesting. She went on to say what she has provided the Board is exactly what is in the staff report, and it was previously provided on November 24 or 26 and it is in Legistar; it is nothing new, she just thought it might be easier to see it up close in this document; page two is the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that is being requested with the PUD zoning; it shows the zoning currently is EU; page three shows the existing future land use of RES-1 and the RES-4 to the east and little bit of RES-2, will all now be RES-2 if the Board approves it; RES-2 is exactly what is to the north in the Parkchester subdivision; and the houses are compatible in sizes, that is what the engineer was able to do. She continued by saying it takes the wetlands of RES-4 and makes them RES-2; it hopefully helps some of the neighbors with the idea knowing that all the applicant is really trying to do is 23 units; if the PDP is never built, it is RES-2 and it is RES-2 all the way to the river, so it protects the wetlands to some extent; there was a request to put that in private conservation, but it was not large enough to put in private conservation, so they could not do that, but it will definitely be in a conservation tract, the wetlands to the east; and the next page is just showing the wetlands area and the temporary impacts. She noted there is going to be an elevated bike path through the wetlands as an amenity for the residents; the last page is just the overlay to show the houses next to the houses, where the stormwater ponds are, and the wetlands that will be protected; as the Board may recall, the residents have been very engaged, very vocal; they have asked that they remove the townhomes, and that has been done; and they had asked for no access on Parkchester and that access was removed, with the only access being from US 1. She stated the residents did not want any access on Indian River Drive; at one point there was a little parking area as an amenity, but it has been removed from the PDP; and the remaining issue which they have addressed is the RES-2. She mentioned there are concerns of flooding and stormwater, which has been discussed several times by the engineer of record, Bruce Moia for MVB; again, that is something that has to be engineered; this is just zoning so any flooding issues would be addressed during the plat stage; and with that, she is asking that the Board approve the request of RES-2, and then the small parcel of 1.94 acres of CC on the west against US 1, and then the remaining 10.94 would be RES-2. She commented with that, she would request the Board approved the PDP and the PUD request with the waivers; the last page the Board has, has a waiver request and that is dealing with the perimeter of the subdivision because they have to deal with some canals and some drainage, and that is why they ask that the waiver be accepted with the PDP; there will still be a buffer and they will still commit to whatever type of buffer that is necessary to make it compatible; they have indeed put in the PDP, towards the east side, the requirement of an opaque buffer that was requested by Mr. and Mrs. Hous; the Board will see on the PDP, page two, it says “225 feet of an opaque buffer” and that is to buffer homes that would be adjacent to their home; that is in there and would be a requirement of any plat going forward; they will answer any questions; they would ask the Board to approve the RES-2, find that it is compatible because it is next to RES-2 so they could use the density bonuses to achieve the 23 units in the PDP; and she would ask that she be allowed to respond to any comments. Commissioner Adkinson stated this is kind of the same question she has asked before; and she inquired what the buffer to the northwest side between the houses is going to look like. Ms. Rezanka stated that it is going to be an opaque buffer; and she does not know exactly if it is going to be a fence or foliage that one cannot see through. Commissioner Adkinson asked if it will be opaque all the way across the entire back. Ms. Rezanka explained it will be; the applicant has only committed to the fence towards the area against the Hous’ property; and if the Board wants to make that a condition of an opaque fence or buffer the entire way, the applicant would certainly accept that. Commissioner Adkinson stated she was just thinking about if they are leaving the native trees that are already there. Ms. Rezanka replied unfortunately, because there is an elevation difference and there is a ditch through between the properties, those trees will likely have to come out; they intend to save them, but they do not know because all the engineering has not been completed; there have been some elevations done; by the way, they all have fences there already; however, if the Board wants a condition that they have an opaque buffer the entire length against Parkchester, they can do that. Commissioner Adkinson commented for her the opaque thing is not as important as the actual trees and things that are going to be lost; and she asked if the applicant would consider if they had to take out a big deciduous tree, putting a decent sized one back in there. Ms. Rezanka responded affirmatively; and she added if the Commissioner wants to make a condition that like-trees go back in, they can do that and make it a condition of the PDP. James Sudermann stated he lives just south of this project; he was happy to see the new addendum number two from staff; there were several pieces of that he would like to comment on; in light of the new alternative proposal submitted by City Pointe Landfall on December 25 and the new staff comments addendum number two he would like to voice the following, while they recognize that the latest proposal from City Pointe Landfall does not preserve the original existing BDP that they have, he keeps asking for it, it does address to a greater or lesser extent, most of the remaining ongoing concerns with density growth potential, stormwater and groundwater discharge issues, wetland preservation, and roadway flooding; if the Board were to adopt all of the conditions, staff comments, and applicant offers outlined in addendum number two, and the City Pointe PDP, their 2025, 1126 applicant alternative proposal that he thinks was just handed out, Beverly and himself would be willing to accept them as something they could live with; but be assured that he and Beverly only represent themselves in this and cannot speak for the rest of their neighbors who have fought with them so long and hard to get this Board and this developer to listen and respond to all of their comments. He stated specifically to grant their support, they would like to see application of the RES-2 future land use map designation on the entire 10.94 acre residential portion of the property; they would like to make sure that a ban is imposed on all residential land use on the wetlands; staff comments also mention that a Public Works engineering evaluation of the outfall pipes across the Indian River roadway and of possibly raising the road should be performed, they would also like to see that memorialized here; as suggested by staff, they talk about creating a new BDP which incorporates at least the following provisions, any future change to the PDP will be considered a substantial change and require Board approval for the change; overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property and overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subjective property; the new BDP should conduct a ground water analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; dedication of up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County Maintenance and roadway projects along the north Indian River Drive; and finally the provision that says the future land use designation is to revert if the final development plan are never filed. He added he would like to reiterate if all the provisions and comments from this new staff addendum are included, he and Beverly could live with it. Chair Altman stated he noticed, and it may just be an oversight, Mr. Sudermann left out one portion in his comments, as he was following along with him, and it is the one that says preferably without the 25 percent density bonus based on FL1 Policy 1.8., if limited to 21 units, he did not hear that. Mr. Sudermann apologized and stated he did skip that; that is true they definitely appreciate the RES-2; if they had a preference they would like to see it be without the 25 percent density bonus which gets them to a potential of 25, although with the PUD being approved, that would just limit it to 23; he did make a comment here, it says, if limited to 21 units, the developer could incrementally increase the lot size of the small southern lots, which are pretty small, and or could donate a portion of the southside property as an access path to 1800s pioneer cemetery, which has been landlocked now for decades; and that would be a nice gesture. Greg Burroughs stated just to reiterate what the previous speaker has just said, really the main thing being looked at is the wetlands and how that is going to affect any runoff that goes down into the river, anything from the soil, and obviously, from the grasses, fertilizers, and things like that that could end up in that river going straight down; he does appreciate the two units per acre; he is not sure how that is going to affect, without any RV storage in the front; he would not mind seeing a turning lane dedicated into that neighborhood so that the three lanes which have been reduced to two right in front of that property do not cause any bottlenecks or any more accidents; and he thanked the Board for its time. Diane Burroughs stated she wanted to reiterate along with Mr. Sudermann; she thanked the applicant for the consideration for reducing it from a RES-4 to a RES-2; and she asked to continue to keep in mind the conservation area, the flooding, and those very serious issues that are currently happening in that area, and how this is going to impact it. Sandra Kennedy stated she lives about one-half mile north of this project; no matter how many public hearings and how many residents complain about this project, the criteria are set in the rules and regulations that are applicable to this Board; and they are binding. She continued by saying the applicant has not met the requirements for a variance; City Pointe Landfall’s application does not meet the criteria for a zoning variance, even limited, and the County Commissioners must reject the application in its entirety; not once have they addressed the community, the neighborhood; their title is City Pointe, City Pointe is a community that stretches from a little bit north of 528, around City Pointe Road, all the way to at least Blacks Road and really beyond; it is along Indian River Drive which is basically at sea level in this area; this is not the Indian River Drive portion that is on bluffs in Cocoa, it is sea level; and there is already flooding problems that need to be addressed. She went on to say one of the Board’s criteria that absolutely must be met before any variance can be given is that they must not increase or cause flooding to the community; they have failed that one right away; their recent change, which she received late last night while she was preparing for this hearing, was that they were giving the Board another paragraph on what their flood control plan is; basically, they had nothing to say but what they had said before; they plan a series of ponds that they are going to allow to overflow; that is their strategy, ponds that overflow; they are going to go down to the wetlands and those wetlands are not sponges, not dry, and they do not need to be appropriately wetted, they are soaking wet; and there are ditches that run along Indian River Drive that are constantly full. She stated their capacity for more water does not exist; they are going to cause flooding; not only that, but their project, it does not abut the full wetland, it only abuts a portion, less than half of the wetland, and the other portion of the land that is a lower elevation to them, is going to get flooded out, and it is residential property; there are no ditches in front of those people’s houses because it is not in an appropriate location like it is in front of that wetland; they do not have a flood control plan; they say they are going to use offsite flooding systems and that just means a ditch; she is between US 1, City Pointe Road and basically, Blacks Road or further north, and the Indian River Lagoon; this is their community, the whole entire thing is large homes on large lots; all recent developments since the 60s has been single homes on an acre or two homes on an acre; they are blowing that out of the water; they are trying to say well Parkchester is to the north, but that is not the community; and she asked why they have titled their company name as City Pointe. She noted Parkchester is a remnant from the past; it is what the Planning and Zoning rules and regulations were trying to get away from, which is strip all the trees down and try to put a whole bunch of homes crammed in; that is not bad if it is on flat land, but it cannot be done in environmentally sensitive lands where there are live oak hammocks on a slope; US 1 is like 75 feet or so and it is like a giant waterslide that goes down to Indian River Drive; and the open spaces are needed to absorb the water; the community, they go around saying, Parkchester and all these small communities, and this little property here is .2 of an acre, and they talk about the industrial area way across, but that is a different zone and not the neighborhood, so they do not match the neighborhood; they do not meet the County’s criteria to receive this; they are not even a Planned Unit Development (PUD) and they are not entitled to exceed or to get that bonus; now with that bonus, they would be getting more than they have ever sought before; and they are not a planned community that is fully encompassing everything that the community would need, it is a very small strip of land. She reiterated it is not a PUD, they are not entitled to a bonus, they need to stick to the regular zoning like the rest of the community. She asked the Board to follow the law. Chair Altman noted he has a question for staff; Ms. Kennedy used the term variance; and he asked if this is a variance or a zoning change. Ms. Gilliam replied no, sir, it is a zoning change in a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment. Chair Altman asked so they do not use the variance… Ms. Gilliam interjected by saying criteria. Ms. Kennedy stated the criteria are for rezoning; she does not know the difference between rezoning and variance; she is a construction lawyer not a land development lawyer; but the County’s own criteria says for rezoning it has to meet this criteria; it is flooding that has to be met before and compatibility to match the entire community; the other thing, their PUD, they have to hide that extra density within the community so that it cannot be seen from the rest of the community; that is the only thing that would allow them to do it; and this is such a small strip of land so there is no hiding anything. Chair Altman stated he now understands her point. Commissioner Goodson asked in their proposal for dry retention ponds on the hill that eventually get to the wetlands, are they required to store 100 percent of the water for 24 hours; and he asked if that is correct. Chair Altman stated before they take a motion or vote, he will let Ms. Rezanka have an opportunity to close, she might want to hear this first. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, stated he will let Darcie McGee, Environmental Policy and Resilience Administrator, answer this. Ms. McGee advised they are not going to be required to hold 100 percent of their water on site based on State stormwater standards; they have to meet certain criteria to hold, and she believes it is a 25-year storm; that then gets held to treat for water quality; then there will be eventual discharge that will go through the system that they show on the Preliminary Development Plan (PDP) that goes down through the pond down to the wetlands and then out to the river; and that does not account for the volume, just the rate and the water quality treatment. Commissioner Goodson asked as far as staff, how much water it thinks is going to occur that goes through the wetlands to the river. Ms. McGee advised there is no way she could answer something like that; she thinks in the package, if this is correct, there was a where the engineer had previously talked about maintaining the volume and the rate of flow; and that would be something he could engineer. Mr. Bernath commented that is correct; Mr. Moia had previously advised that they agreed to engineering concerns about ensuring post-development stormwater discharge rate and volume for the site; because this is just at the zoning stage, staff has not seen anything and cannot confirm that it meets it; but that is what he has agreed to. Commissioner Goodson stated of course everyone agrees that City Pointe Road intersecting Indian River Road has always been low; and he asked if that is correct. Mr. Bernath replied affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to read off addendum number two, the concessions that he thinks are fair or he is willing to accept. Mr. Prasad advised he will start with one that he thinks somebody had mentioned today and Ms. Rezanka had brought up last time that he does not think is appropriate, and that would be the automatic reversion of the land use if the PDP was not recorded; staff does not think that there is any legal mechanism to implement that and that is why it was left off the Agenda Report for Board consideration; he just wanted to explain why the public would not hear him say that; for the conditions that the applicant had agreed to, he will add one that they mentioned today which is for like trees as part of the waiver request for disturbing the buffer; beyond that, an overall reduction of the rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, an overall reduction of the volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conducting a groundwater analysis by identifying any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly; and they have volunteered to offer to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive. He noted staff would suggest that if the Board is looking to implement those conditions that it do so and ask for it to be implemented through a BDP. Commissioner Goodson asked if this gets approval and it is built, how staff will govern the discharge of water. Mr. Prasad explained that would be done through the site plan process; and the applicant would have to demonstrate that they are meeting all of the conditions through various analysis. Commissioner Goodson asked if the applicant would be liable down the road, six months after the project is done, to make sure they do not put too much water into the Indian River Lagoon. Mr. Prasad stated the BDP will carry with the land; he would also say that under the County’s Code that the maintenance of discharge is typically on the private entities; and it could be enforced in the future. Ms. Gilliam advised the Board she has one other condition and that is to memorialize in the BDP that any future changes to the PDP be considered a substantial change and be brought back before the Board. Mr. Bernath advised he would like to add one more; and he does not know if it was agreed to during the last meeting, but staff had asked for the 50 feet of total right-of-way that is proposed to be dedicated, that the applicant also agree to mitigate those wetlands in the granted right-of-way, otherwise that will become a future County cost. Commissioner Delaney stated she wanted to disclose that she had a meeting with the Twin Lakes Homeowners Association and she did drive past the neighborhood, by the location to see the conditions last night; there have been a lot of concessions made with this project and she really appreciates that; she feels like the developer has tried to work with the community; if this was in a different area it would be harder for her to say no; but this area is so unique and there is a constant of running water throughout this area. She went on to say even the drainage pipes; being next to them it sounds like a shower all the time; that is just the ground water, it is not because there is even any rain; she is extremely concerned about the density of this project for this location because it is just so fragile; then on top of that, there is the issue of low-lying Indian River Drive; people’s vehicles are getting ruined, people are getting trapped on their streets, and one resident had told her that they had to rent a car because they did not want to damage their own vehicle; District 1 is experiencing a lot of flooding and a lot of property damage; her concern is that it is going to hit a boiling point at some point to where this is going to be a Countywide problem because the County is going to have to start buying houses from people if not careful; Volusia County has had to deal with this; she does not want to see that happen here in Brevard County; and she is very concerned that if the County does not keep this BDP and keep the density low in this area that the County is going to have huge problem. She mentioned just in general she believes that a person should do their due diligence when buying property; it sounds like the applicant knew what they were buying and knew it had a BDP on it; it is not right for the whole neighborhood to have to be affected by this when the property owners knew what they were purchasing; it is not like somebody pulled the wool over their eyes; and that is kind of where she is at. Chair Altman stated there is another card that got mixed up with other cards. Bill Gower stated this keeps coming back; the people who bought this property knew there was a binding contract on it; what he sees is basically they threw everything against the wall to see what would stick, make the people happy, and see what they could get away with; after a meeting they would say there is no reason for people to come to the next meeting; there were 100 of them when it started out and they were told they did not have to go to the next meeting because they were just going to postpone it, and that is why the people have dwindled down in size; he has lived there since 1989; he knows how wide that property is and by the time one puts a road through the middle for two lands, then houses and driveways, that is a lot of water that is being added to that property and no place to go; when he talked to the guys that did the survey, his property sits lower than anybody else in regards to it, and he does get flooded out when it rains; and he is on the upper side not on the lower side like some other people. He reiterated basically, they threw everything against the wall to see what sticks; if the Board approved something today, what makes this guy not go sell to somebody else and the next guys say they go away with that, let them go ask for more; and that is all he has to say. He commented that paperwork that was passed up there, he did not see any of it from the developers. Chair Altman advised he thinks what was provided by the applicant is the same as what is in the Board packet online.

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.11) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1, RES- 2, RES-4, and NC to CC and RES-4. (24SS00009) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.2.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) for a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, application number 24PUD00003, and tax account number 2411252, located in District 1. Commissioner Delaney asked Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, to assist her with the motion. Chair Altman asked if needs to be reread into the record. Mr. Prasad explained if it is said all the conditions outlined in the Agenda Report with the addition of some of the ones that were heard today, which is as part of the waiver request that would have to be approved as part of this application, like for like trees; then also mitigate any wetlands within the 50 foot right-of-way should they have to be dedicated… Ms. Rezanka interjected by saying they cannot agree to that because it impacts their ability to mitigate. Chair Altman asked which one that was; and he asked that Ms. Rezanka come up and clarify that. Ms. Rezanka stated it was asked that the 50 foot right-of-way that is being dedicated, that they take on the responsibility for mitigating the wetlands; and she explained they cannot do that because it impacts the wetlands on the site because it would all be done at the same time; they only get 1.8 percent to impact; therefore, they cannot agree to that. Chair Altman stated so they are going to give up the land… Ms. Rezanka reiterated they are not agreeing to… Chair Altman interjected by saying mitigate somebody else’s land. Ms. Rezanka stated they may agree later on, but right now they cannot because they have to mitigate their own; and that was not something that was listed that she has agreed to. Ms. Gilliam asked if staff could make a comment. Ms. McGee stated she just wants to add that when talking about the dedication of the 50 foot right-of-way, they had talked about that not counting against their 1.8 percent because that would be to the benefit of the County for that 50 feet; that would not count against the other wetland impacts for the 1.8 percent for the applicant; but again, the mitigation being part of that cost. Mr. Bernath agreed, and stated he would just add that if they do not do it now, that is County right-of-way, and the taxpayers are going to be doing it if it ever decides to widen that road. Chair Altman inquired if the County owns it, would it not be the County’s responsibility to mitigate for widening the road, that is the public benefit to widen the road; if they have given up that right-of-way it would be the public's responsibility to mitigate for the public good of building the road; he understands their point, they are giving up the land and now they have to mitigate; he does not know; but he agrees with the applicant on that, he does not think that should be a requirement. Mr. Bernath stated he does not know if they will agree to it, but buy credits for mitigation. Ms. Rezanka noted she does not have the authority to do that or to spend her client’s money who is not in attendance to agree, when he told her not to agree to that; and at this point she cannot agree to it. Chair Altman commented they are basically giving land. Ms. Rezanka stated they are giving land that would have to be taken by imminent domain at a valuable price. Chair Altman commented and a lot of legal costs so he appreciates her doing that. Mr. Prasad stated so with that said, the conditions would be as outlined in the Agenda Report, if the Board would like he will restate them but he has already stated them before, it would be for like for like trees, and work for the County to add potential treatments to shore up the shoreline along the Indian River Lagoon. Chair Altman stated on the issue of clearing, because he is not for clearing land as much as possible, but he has seen a lot of projects where some of which he voted on to preserve the native buffer, but if one goes back and the buffer is dead because when one does the improvements of the property, it affects the drainage, just a little soil on some of those trees kills it; and he agrees with not having to be able to go and it would have been a healthier, more attractive buffer if it was replanted, so he supports that. He mentioned that he does have a question, and he asked when it is said like for like trees is that species or size because there are some very large trees there. Mr. Prasad explained he thinks they are looking for similar type and size of trees, but he would defer to Ms. McGee whose Department implements that. Ms. McGee stated like for like can work depending on how big the lots are and what that buffer is; they may not be able to put back the same number of oak trees that may crowd out or may interfere with the buildings or structures. Chair Altman commented he worries about their ability to do the size too. Ms. McGee stated that is kind of a tough one to apply at permitting because if they take out a 20-inch oak they would not put back a 20-inch oak, they are going to be smaller ones. Chair Altman mentioned he has been by the site many times; he does not think a tree survey has been done; and he is just concerned with saying like for like, the size should not be a requirement. Mr. Prasad stated perhaps similar within reason. Chair Altman stated okay, that is good. Ms. McGee noted they like to make it specific to help staff apply it when it gets to permitting; she does not know if Mr. Prasad can put language in there to negotiate with Natural Resources Management for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a good buffer; and she asked if that would be acceptable. Chair Altman stated he likes the word mature. Mr. Prasad stated if he could just add one more thing, they were talking about PDP conditions, if the Board could just include to memorialize that in a BDP. Commissioner Delaney stated the motion would be to change the zoning from EU and RP with an existing BDP to a PUD with the removal of the existing BDP, but to add another BDP, including the things the Board has spoken about; she asked if she needs to read out all of those; and what does she need to say with the PDP. Mr. Prasad stated as part of the zoning approval, the Board would be approving the PUD with the conditions specified to be memorialized in a PDP. Commissioner Delaney made that motion. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a Change of Zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP and approval of the PDP; approved a waiver to Section 62-2883(d) requiring an undisturbed 15-foot buffer around the perimeter of the project with the condition that any vegetation removed shall be replaced with reasonable similar vegetation in consultation with Natural Resources Management Department for appropriate buffering vegetation that will thrive and mature into a buffer similar to its natural state; and making the PUD subject to the following conditions, which are to be memorialized in a BDP: an overall reduction of rate of stormwater discharge from the subject property, overall reduction of volume of stormwater discharge from the subject property, conduct a groundwater analysis to identify any groundwater concerns and address them accordingly, applicant voluntarily offers to dedicate up to 50 feet of right-of-way for Brevard County maintenance and roadway projects along North Indian River Drive, and the applicant to work with staff on shoring up/improving the shoreline on the Lagoon. (24PUD00003).

    City Pointe Landfall LLC (David Bassford) requests a change in zoning classification from EU and RP with an existing BDP to PUD with the removal of existing BDP. (24PUD00003) (Tax Account 2411252) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.3.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jacob Foune for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment, 25S.14, to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2, application number 25SS00008, and tax account 2000804, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is a companion application and he will need to read into the record Item H.4., as well, or she can read it into the record for him. Chair Altman advised Ms. Gilliam to go ahead and read it into the record. Ms. Gilliam stated Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to SR with removal of the existing BDP and in addition of a new BDP, under application number 25Z00037, located in District 1. Jacob Foune stated he bought this land, submitted permits, got everything accepted and started building; he already has concrete block done and all inspections have passed; he has had his trusses sitting for nearly six months; he and his wife have spent their life-savings on this and just want to continue; he relied on the County and did everything as he should; and to clear one thing up from the last meeting, he is an employee for a very reputable air conditioning (AC) company and he does not work for Minnick. He noted he does new construction HVAC for many small builders in Brevard County, including Minnick. Pat Ramer stated what she wants to address has already been spoken about many times here and that is the density; increasing density in this area, which is already prone to flooding, is only going to make the problem worse; every time the Board approves a variance or a zoning change to increase the density, it is increasing the chances of flooding in that area; people are suffering right now; during the last 2025 calendar year, they have had six flooding events in that particular area; she understands the house has already started to be built, it is significantly higher than the property behind it; and it is going to cause flooding to that other property. She asked the Board to consider that as it look at this request. Michael Biegler stated he has lived at 4125 Golden Shores for 22 years; he has lived in Brevard County for 61 years, and doing construction for 40 years; he has worked for many contractors throughout the State of Florida, some very big ones; he has never heard anything like what he is going to talk about in his entire career; Scotty Minnick is a contractor who sold 0.54 acres to Jacob Foune; alterations were done to the lot which violates the condition of the BDP, Section 62-2102 Brevard County Code of Ordinances, which states that no person shall separate the lot in a manner which violates the law; but the land was unlawfully split and an unlawful permit was given anyway. He continued by saying they would have all been at the public hearing along with Clifford McKnight of 3900 Golden Shores, on November 17, if they were notified, but the notification only went out to a few people that live within 500 feet; the letter was deceiving to most of the elderly who received it; it states that the land change was for 6.24 acres, not 0.54 acre, and that is not right because for many years the residents have been paying taxes, living on Golden Shores, and a lot longer Scotty Minnick and the applicant Jacob Foune, who is trying to unlawfully split land and build a house with an unlawful permit on 4060 Golden Shores Boulevard, which is going to be the launching site for McKnight, Minnick whatever construction it is, and other builders so they can break up property into smaller sections to build more houses and make more money; there was situation that took place right beside him on 3.10 acres; the Code Enforcement was called and they stopped it because the law was being broken; sad to be said, the guy that owned the land died and his heart sunk for him and he cried for him; it was just a small little thing that man had to take care of, but he had over three acres; but everyone is not talking about three acres, two acres, or even 6.24 acres, it is under acreage, and the people do not want it out there. He commented that just does not make sense to anyone who is in attendance today; he was just notified about this this week; they are law abiding citizens that have been living in Mims and Scottsmoor area for many years who voted for the County officials to represent the people and uphold the law; and he hopes this Board does its job and votes no for a law that has been broken. Stephanie Knight stated the proposed change alters the established character of this neighborhood where every residential lot is an acre or more; she initially chose to build there in a low density area relying on the zoning regulations that were put in place to preserve this area for herself and her kids; those standards should be upheld by the Board and all employees of Brevard County Zoning, Brevard County Property Appraiser, and the Brevard County Permitting; allowing permits for substandard lot sizes is only inconsistent with the zoning requirements, but raises serious concerns about accountability with the permitting process; when unlawful or improper permits are approved, especially using taxpayers resources, it enables and reinforces the very practices that created the issue; each time Commissioners vote in favor of these applicants, it further empowers that Department to continue using permits that do not comply with the law; and this request is incompatible with the current development plan and undermines the long-standing character of this community. She added approving this would set a troubling precedent, opening the door to further expectations that could gradually transform the area into a disorganized, higher density landscape, precisely what many residents sought to avoid in that area; zoning regulations should not be modified to accommodate negligence or oversight on people who work for the County, instead enforce, and accountability must be prioritized; granting variances under these circumstances only complicates matters and signals to other builders and property owners that non-compliance will be excused; this seems to be a problem within departments, that they need to be addressed and corrected so this does not keep happening; and she is confident if the department was audited it would find multiple unlawful permits such as two properties on Todd Lane, this one on Golden Shores, and there were problems with two properties on Aurantia where squatters decided to try to take over property and it was approved at the Appraiser’s Office until the owner of that property got wind of it and had to fight to get the property back; and the Property Appraiser’s Office should know that in order to take over property people have to be there for seven years, and they were they were there two months. She continued by saying Mr. McKnight asked her to read this because he could not be in attendance; and she read, “Dear Commissioners, I’m writing on behalf of numerous residents of Golden Shores Boulevard in Mims regarding the removal of the existing BDP, along with the new land, land use request is inconsistent with the current development plan and undermines the character of our community. This change sets a concerning precedent that could transform our area into disorganized urban landscape, something many of us sought to avoid when we chose to live here. Even with the proposed half-acre variance, this rezoning should not proceed. The Brevard County property website lists that parcel as .45 acre contrary to the .51 acre indicated by the new survey. Additionally, the houses directly behind the parcel located at 4070 Golden Shores Boulevard has a driveway running right through the proposed property, not on an easement. This situation raises significant concerns about access that impacts the actual usable acreage of the lot. We emphasize, the current zoning regulations should not be adjusted to accommodate the negligence and oversight of your department. And this discussion is occurring after construction had progressed to a quarter completion due to the breakdown in the planning process. It is critical that accountability is enforced rather than granting variances that would complicate situations and set again, a precedent for other properties and builders. Notably the contractor responsible for the construction is also the seller of the property who is a realtor. He should have known better and given his experience building homes in the area, he should have been fully aware of the zoning regulation and BDP. Our community cannot support such extensive changes and strongly implores that the current BDP remain intact. Thank you for your attention in this manner and we hope that you will consider our concerns and seriously prioritize the integrity of our community.” She stated she does feel for the person who bought the property, but Mr. Minnick knew as he was the one who did the BDP and he should have known not to sell it to that gentleman, and it should not be the taxpayers that have to suffer for the County’s mistake that its employees made in the permitting office. The Board recessed at 6:24 p.m. and reconvened at 6:36 p.m. Sean Bohannan stated he has been a resident for a couple of decades; his parents have been here over 70 years; they moved to Mims specifically because they wanted to leave South Florida and that urban environment to go to a rural environment; the reason this really hurts him is because he lives in the home that Francis Threckle and her husband who donated the property under which Titusville City Hall sits today, and she built on Golden Shores, the Horseman’s Association; here it is now where he has to spend over two years coming in front of the Board dealing with everybody involved, all the unelected public officials and that, just to be able to build a house for his aunt that is 82 years old, and it is on six acres; everything was perfectly done, and it had to be redone multiple times; he has nothing against this person, he does not know him or anything; but it gets down to the point if he wanted to live in a high density area that is where he would have moved and spent the money. He went on to say he has spent tons of money, but he is not going to go into money, because it really does not matter; they have done that, if it is trimming 100-year old oak trees, preserving things, setting up roads, paving things, they have done everything and by the book; and then this pops up, it is done illegally, against Code, against enforcement, and here it is asking for an exception. He noted whoever sold it to him, they are who should be responsible, it certainly should not be others; his road is like a washboard, half of the weeks they do not even come out and grade it; he is out there with his tractor and box blade grading the darn thing; it is oh, it rained or oh, it has not rained enough, or whatever; and they are not going to pave, not bringing in septic, not bringing in water, and not bringing in natural gas, that is fine, he knew that and accepted it by having his own standalone propane, his own four wells, all of which are permitted and licensed, and everything documented. He mentioned this is just beyond the pale, it absolutely is; he does not mean to get on a high horse, or to be loud or obnoxious, he knows he can be that way sometimes, but he is trying to refrain from that; he expressed his appreciation for the Board’s time, and hopes it takes into consideration the people who have spoken and spent millions of dollars, only to see this abomination, which was illegally done; yes, there should be auditing and the audits need to go back to all of these things, all of the exceptions, and the people who did that and are not elected officials would be held accountable; and if the elected officials will not do it, then the next election is coming. Beth Brycki stated she lives on April Lane, one street over from Golden Shores; her family moved to Brevard County, Mims specifically, because that community is rural and they absolutely love it; they have only been there a couple of months, but the really love the community and have been involved since they got there; that is like the heart of the community, the bigger lots and the rural area; her fear is that concessions are made for existing rules as to how big lot sizes are; she is afraid that sets a precedent for that to continue happening in the future; she is fearful of that happening and continuing; and she hopes that the Board votes no. Ken Harrison stated he lives on Gandy Road in Mims and lives in that area; he has been in this County his entire life, in Mims 67 years, and 54 years on his property that is near this; this came directly from staff comments, what he is going to repeat here, it was what staff found wrong; he read, “In this particular place, the applicant is subject to Code Enforcement due to the actions of a predecessor in interest who improperly split the property into a substandard lot violating Section 62-2102 of Brevard County Code”; he continued reading, “The original BDP stipulated that the developer/owner shall limit development to one single-family residence and may be further restricted by any changes to the Comprehensive Plan or land development regulations. Subsequently, the property was sold and split into two lots of .54 acre, and .89 acre on April 27, 2020. The .89-acre property was sold on October 22, 2021, and the .54-acre property was sold to the applicant on June 4, 2024. These actions violate the conditions of the BDP and Section 62-2102 Brevard County Code of Ordinances alteration of lot, which states that no person shall sever any lot in such a manner that a violation of any of the provisions of this Chapter would be created on any new or altered lot, including their uses or structures. Subsequent to this unlawful split, a permit for a single-family resident was issued in error. This permit should not have been issued because the lot is a substandard lot, as a result of the split. Upon discovering the error, a stop work order was issued by the Brevard County building official. Administrative Policy number 7, proposed use shall not cause or substantially aggravate any substantial drainage problem on surrounding properties or significant adverse and unmitigatable impact on significant natural wetlands, water bodies, or habitat for listed species. Environmental constraints, Natural Resources Management Department has identified that the subject property is located within a mapped Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) special flood hazard area, Zone A. The Board may wish to consider if the requested is consistent with the comprehensive plan and compatible with the surrounding area. In addition, the Board should reconsider the request based on the facts and circumstances surrounding the actions of a predecessor in interest, which resulted in the subject property being turned into a substandard lot." He stated the last paragraph is his; furthermore, the residents are concerned that an unlawful split of the property and the resulting zoning change due to the unlawful split of the property could possibly leave Brevard County complicit and condoning of an unlawful zoning action. He went on to say as far as the maps, one can see on the first one, the little yellow square, and that is the property in question; the property right next to it was SR; they were one lot before the illegal split; looking at this map, they are the only SR in the entire area, everything else is something larger; it is not that these are large lots; a lot of this area has one acre minimums; the people do not want it to go below one acre; and the next map is the Future Land Use and the entire map is RES-1. He mentioned the proposed land use for this one lot would be RES-2, totally inconsistent with the neighborhood and the character of the neighborhood; the very last map is flood zone A that runs through the center of this property; the property behind it will be affected by flood waters; lastly, this contractor is known to do this on purpose working through the department through either strong arming them or whatever means to get what he wants; and he did the same thing on Todd Lane which is one-quarter mile away, where one of his electricians does all the houses, split a lot to a substandard size, built a house on it, and then got permission after the fact, there is a pattern of it through multiple departments. Jerrad Atkins speaking for Scottsmoor Community Association, stated several people have taken the wind beneath his wings so he is going to truncate this a little bit; there was a meeting with a group of concerned citizens this week regarding this particular application; everybody pretty much agrees with the former Board that was here, prior to this Board, that the density needs to be limited and retained as it is in Scottsmoor; there was a small area study that was promised in 2019 and 2020 that did not happen; had it happened, there might be some more data to support that; this particular lot was rezoned in 2019; at that time the County zoning and this Board assigned a BDP to which the owner agreed disallowing the exact thing that happened, that he put in place; a few words from the staff report include unlawful, substandard, and violation, those are not good words to have in a staff report if approving an application like this; and at the zoning board meeting, the applicant spoke stating he bought the lot from Scott Minnick. He continued by saying the applicant stated he works with Scott Minnick, so people know that is the builder who split the lot; he would also agree with someone who spoke earlier that an audit or an investigation should be conducted to see why this continued to happen in this town; a couple things that the Board may be familiar with, is no constitutional or Harris Act property right to increase planning allowances under Florida Law, the purchase of land is generally subject to the existing zoning or environmental restrictions, there are no property right to change them, Freidland V. Hollywood, Florida third District Court of Appeals 1961, and upheld again in Ellen V. Miami, Florida third District of Appeals, 1959; reverse those, the other one upheld the first one; and he knows the Board has those statutes but he just wanted to give a friendly reminder. Ed Ostopovich stated the gentleman he wanted to have up here today could not show up for various reasons, medical being the biggest one; he does spend a lot of time in Brevard County, he basically does a lot of construction in Brevard County; his whole point was a hand written letter on some calculations and verbiage that he uses on a daily basis; he uses a standard 3,000 square foot home; when one has that he or she has a square footage footprint so to speak, even with the driveways, garages, carports, and things of that nature; he is just going to use that as an example; a 3,000 square foot home having one inch of rain per hour at 6,230 gallons per inch of rain per house; and with that being said, it can use this and he can hand this off to the Board and go from there. He went on to say he is in attendance because he wants to oppose the building from further continuing on; in the early 90s he came to this area, after being born and raised here, straight out of the Air Force; he literally wanted to live out in the country, the suburbs, shoot, raise his kids, hunt, ride four wheelers like everyone else does, and things of that nature; what is happening today is not an ideal living situation because it has turned into a suburbia nightmare; people are starting to see homes developed on top of each other, the high density areas starting to increase; the traffic is increasing as people are well aware of; and they do not want an HOA scenario, they already deal with seasonal snow birds in Titusville. He added Mims has kind of a cushion for having some elbow room. He continued by saying when he first moved here he purchased a one and one-half acre lot; the average home to be built on was one to five-acre parcels for anyone to purchase; it was all zoned and cut up that way from the civil engineers back in the 60s; there again, like-minded, everybody wanted that expansion to have some elbow room and they do not want the high density in that scenario; based on what is being dealt with, today’s laws and rules are being bent to accommodate so-called errors by contractors, realtors, and title companies, are starting to affect the residents big time; and they are starting to pay the price. He stated literally flooding issues so profuse that last 20 years, they have not seen anything like this in the last five years; Commissioner Delaney is well aware of what he is talking about; using that number he pointed out earlier, there was almost three feet of rain in a one-month time frame in Mims and the water did not recede for almost three weeks; that is not an exaggeration, and it was to the point where wildlife was literally coming up in the dry land areas, pigs and deer looking for things to eat; he is pointing this out to the simple fact that there are hogs tearing up property, and there is a really bad problem right now and they are trying to mitigate that scenario; but it is not going to happen until the water recedes properly. He mentioned all he knows is that the maintenance on those culverts, especially through I-95, the box culverts have not been touched or addressed; people have actually put their eyes on them and they are overgrown and impacting the water flow to the St. John’s, going west, and not to mention the flow problems through the east; as a registered voter in District 1, he wants these mismanaged overlooked areas to be audited as well; he wants more of the community to feel comfortable with what the Board does as a whole; the people trust the Board and brought them to be their voice; Commissioner Delaney is District 1’s voice right now; the people want the Board to understand this whole community is really exhausted by what is happening up there through growth and development and the continued passing or exemptions of said parcels; and other than that he appreciates the Board's time for hearing the people’s voices. Commissioner Goodson stated he hears him and understands what he wished and why he moved to Mims, and asked if Mr. Ostopovich is aware of the Farmington Development and what they are proposing. Mr. Ostopovich commented he is very aware; he had stumbled across it when he started his own personal and private distillery; he has been in front of this Board before trying to get zoning squared away; and he has a functioning and legal distillery on his private property through ATB and the Feds. Commissioner Goodson stated that is great and he thinks the Board should open up hog hunting and it would be even better with liquor. He commented the Farmington issue being proposed, maybe in 10 years they will start developing that; and he asked what Mr. Ostopovich thinks of that. Mr. Ostopovich advised they are opposing that as well; they do not like the large, even large than what is in Viera, he has seen all of the plat maps, as he stumbled across it; it made him nauseous to think that they moved there for this and it is going to be taken away, probably not in his lifetime; but his kids are going to have to deal with growth and expansion. He stated this is a sensitive water area and the St. Johns would not allow this; and he wonders who is getting paid in that scenario. Commissioner Goodson noted Mr. Ostopovich made a comment about the 95 culverts; and he asked if he understand that those are Department of Transportation (DOT). Mr. Ostopovich replied he does understand that, but asked if the Board has the voice to get them on the horn and tell them they are drowning down here. Commissioner Goodson stated if one knows anything about DOT, that is kind of like blowing smoke; they are slower than heck; but it is not their fault. Mr. Ostopovich noted he does understand regulations and what the Board is up against, right now the people are focused on one little thing; and if it can turn the tide and start going by laws and upholding that, they would really appreciate the efforts. Chair Altman advised he will give the applicant time to close; and he asked if there are any questions from the Board. Commissioner Goodson asked if this gentleman bought it from a realtor who was shady, or whatever, and did not know what he was buying, then a permit was given by the County, where is his justice. Outburst from the audience stating in the title company. Commissioner Goodson asked if the title company would be guilty, he does not know. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, stated he does not even know if he obtained title insurance, that would depend; and he asked Mr. Foune if he obtained title insurance. Mr. Foune replied he did. Attorney Richardson asked if he has filed a claim with his title insurer. Mr. Foune advised he has not. Attorney Richardson noted that he probably should do that quickly if he has not already; and he is not going to give legal advice but if he has title insurance, that is an issue. Commissioner Goodson asked if Mr. Foune works for the person who sold it to him. Mr. Foune stated he works for a company that does work for him; and he does HVAC all over Brevard County and he is a builder that they work for. Commissioner Goodson asked right now, how much money Mr. Foune has spent honestly, for the cost of the lot and what he has done so far. Mr. Foune responded by saying about $100,000. Commissioner Goodson stated and there is probably another $100,000 to finish it. Mr. Foune replied, at least, yes. Commissioner Goodson asked if he has spoken to the realtor about this. Mr. Foune stated he has not. Commissioner Goodson asked why not. Mr. Foune asked if he means the realtor he bought the property from. Commissioner Goodson responded affirmatively. Mr. Foune stated he spoke with the land owner, he did not have a realtor. Commissioner Goodson inquired if the land owner said, “tough luck or I do not care, I did it and it was legal and the County approved it, yada, yada.“ Mr. Foune stated he would reckon; and basically, he relied on the staff at the County to turn everything in and he got everything approved. Commissioner Goodson stated if he knows anything about life it is to not rely on anybody, check and double check. Mr. Foune commented he is starting to learn that. He stated one of the things is that the homeowners around the area were not notified of this meeting or anything; everything has been posted in front; the County has put signs out there; in the middle of October they put out there the amount of acres is .54, he is not sure why that has changed; that is what he has been aware of the whole time; for the flooding, he has already started building; if he can continue and put his culvert in and everything to Code, obviously that would help; and then about there not being enough land, there is two properties on Golden Shores that are less acres than what he has, one is .51 and one is .44; and it is also said that his house is higher elevation than the neighbor behind him, it is actually the same height and everything is to Code. He reiterated that he has done everything to Code, it has all been inspected, and everything has passed. Commissioner Feltner stated he has comments so he will wait until after the questions. Chair Altman asked if Mr. Foune is using a builder or is this owner building. Mr. Foune stated it is all owner builder. Chair Altman asked who drew up his plans, if he used an architect or an engineer; and he noted he thinks he is required to have an engineer for the hurricane. Mr. Foune stated yes, working construction he has friends that have helped him out; and everything has been owner builder and he has used other people’s plans. Chair Altman clarified that he did not use an architect to draw the plans. Mr. Foune advised he did not, it was a previous plan that had already been used. Chair Altman asked if they had been stamped by an engineer. Mr. Foune responded affirmatively. Chair Altman asked if he knows who that was. Mr. Foune advised he does not know off the top of his head. Chair Altman asked when Mr. Foune submitted his plans to the County, if he had any idea what he was requesting was illegal. Mr. Foune replied no, he did not. Chair Altman asked if he basically relied upon the County; and what made him think he could build on this lot. Mr. Foune stated he saw other properties that were around the same amount of land. Chair Altman asked if he assumed it was buildable. Mr. Foune stated there has been a couple new houses that have been built on that street in the last year or two; he put AC in them; and he figured there would not be a problem. Chair Altman asked how many square feet his house is. Mr.Foune replied 1,600. Chair Altman asked if it is one story or two story. Mr. Foune answered by saying it is one story. Commissioner Adkinson commented he said he did not have a real estate agent, that he just bought it from the owner; he does have title insurance so that is good; and presumably when he went to the person whom he bought it from and said he just got told this is an illegal lot, and she asked what the response was that he received back. Mr. Foune he responded by saying basically nothing, to figure out what the County’s solution would be; and he was also told by the County that it would be resolved in a day or two when he initially received the phone call, so he did not really think much of it. Commissioner Adkinson stated but the owner likely had an idea that he or she was doing something that was not okay and just led Mr. Foune to believe that it was okay. Mr. Foune responded he would assume so.

    Jacob Foune requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (25S.14) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES-1 to RES-2. (25SS00008) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

    $100,000

  • Agenda item H.4.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jacob Foune for a change of zoning classification from SR with a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP for application number 25Z00037. There being no further comments or objections, the Board continued the request by Jacob Foune for a change of zoning classification from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP, to the February 5, 2026, Zoning meeting.

    Jacob Foune requests a zoning classification change from SR with a BDP to SR with removal of the existing BDP and addition of a new BDP. (25Z00037) (Tax Account 2000804) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.6.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Thomas Dahn for a change of zoning classification from RR-1 to AU, application number 25Z00024, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU under application number 25Z00024, located in District 1. Thomas Dahn stated he and his wife are wanting to open a commercial agricultural produce business to sell fresh organic produce to the public; they bought an acre of land next to their current land to do that; they have combined the properties to make the land larger; and they are now asking to rezone to AU to do the business. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Thomas Dahn to change the zoning classification from RR-1 to AU for application number 25Z000024, located in District 1.

    Thomas Dahn requests a zoning classification change from RR-1 to AU. (25Z00024) (Tax Account 2101970) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.7.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Dick Holdings, LLC (Vaheed Teimouri) for a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for a private heliport in AU zoning classification, application number 25Z00033, located in District 2. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Dick Holdings, LLC, being represented by Vaheed Teimouri, requests a CUP for a private heliport in an AU zoning classification under application 25Z00033, located in District 2. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request by DIck Holdings, LLC for a CUP for a private heliport in an AU zoning classification, under application number 25Z00033, located in District 2.

    Dick Holdings, LLC (Vaheed Teimouri) requests a CUP for a private heliport in AU zoning classification. (25Z00033) (Tax Account 2317013) (District 2)

  • Agenda item kH.8.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Leslie Bishop for a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to SR, application number 25Z00034, located in District 3. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Leslie Bishop requests a zoning classification change from RU-1-7 to SR, application number 25Z00034, located in District 3. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Leslie Bishop for a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to SR, application number 25Z00034, located in District 3.

    Leslie Bishop requests a zoning classification change from RU-1-7 to SR. (25Z00034) (Tax Account 3008078) (District 3)

  • Agenda item H.9.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Paul and Cheryl Pearson (Steve Totty) for a change of zoning classification from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6, application number 25Z00035, located in District 4. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Paul and Cheryl Pearson being represented by Steve Totty requests a zoning classification change from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6 under application number 25Z00035, located in District 4. Steve Totty stated what he has here is about a .9-acre lot and it is located off US1 near Post Road, two lots away from Marker 99, if anyone is familiar with that; Mr. Pearson purchased this property eight or nine months ago; the concept is it has a single-family house on it and it also has a good-sized detached garage; he thought to put some apartments in there, so that was the idea; he went to work with staff on the concept and had them review all the requirements, setbacks, breezeway issues, and they got past that; and the next step is to come to the Board to see if it is okay to do that. Commissioner Feltner inquired if the owner is going to live in the house. Mr. Pearson answered by saying no, he is building a house next door. Commissioner Feltner stated so the owner is going to be next door, and he made the motion to approve. There being no further comments or abjections, the Board approved the request by Paul and Cheryl Pearson for a change in zoning classification from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6, application number 25Z00035, located in District 4.

    Paul & Cheryl Pearson (Steve Totty) request a zoning classification change from RU-1-9 to RU-2-6. (25Z00035) (Tax Account 2611660) (District 4)

  • Agenda item H.10.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada for a change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada, being represented by Monica Pritchard, request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1, under application number 25Z00036, located in District 1. Monica Pritchard stated they have a property in Mims; it is two lots side-by-side that are basically family property; they have inherited this lot form their mother who has passed; Ms. Walsh and her husband live next door; and they would like to request a rezoning from SU to RR-1 in order to potentially do a flag lot so they can split the parcel, where Ms. Canada can own the front half and Ms. Walsh can own the back half. She continued by saying Ms. Walsh’s eventual goal is that maybe her children will take care of her and they may build on the back parcel; obviously, there is a septic moratorium; she is in no rush and she does not care if she can never build on it and just has to keep a horse there or something; but because it was inherited together, they would like to separate the two, give the sister the house on the front, and have Ms. Walsh keep the back end. Commissioner Delaney stated the idea of splitting lots in this area is concerning; and she cannot support this right now, especially since they do not have a need to build at the moment. Ms. Pritchard stated what she thinks they really need is to separate the interest; while they are sisters, they obviously have different children, different heirs, and things like that; while they both inherited the property together, she thinks they both want to keep it as family properties; it is a unique situation and she understands Commissioner Delaney’s concerns and that this is not popular in her District right now; however, while considering the larger concerns of the community, there are also individual needs of the property owner. She continued to explain the lots are conforming; it is going to be over an acre on each; she does not have any immediate plans for any of this it is just legally in order to separate it, make it fair for the two of them, she would like to keep the vacant land portion, which right now, her horses will just graze along with her property that is right next door; her sister will get to keep the house; she reiterated she understands this is not popular in District 1; she has heard all of the flooding concerns and things like that; but in this individual situation, it is not adding to the flooding concerns; and she has no immediate plans to build, but in order for her heir, should something happen to her and her husband, be able to inherit that piece of land without their cousins complicating things further, this is what would be necessary. She noted it would be a rezone in order to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked if the applicant would be willing to do a Binding Development Plan (BDP) to say no building. Ms. Pritchard asked if that means ever. Commissioner Delaney explained a BDP eventually could be changed with the direction of the Board. Ms. Prichard stated the goal would be that her kids could eventually one day when the time is right, maybe when these flooding issues are resolved, the septic moratorium is lifted, that they could potentially build there one day; and she would have to discuss that with her client because that is not something that she had anticipated. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way to do that in a BDP or whatever that says that there will not be any building for three years as a means to split it. Commissioner Delaney asked Morris Richardson, County Attorney, if there are any other options for this family. Attorney Richardson stated he is hesitant to give advice that borders on legal advice; and if the ultimate goal is to build on the property this seems to be the path. Ms. Pritchard stated they are part of the Mims community; they have livestock and all those things; they understand Commissioner Delaney’s concerns; they are over here nodding with their neighbors, doing all those things; they get it; but while Commissioner Delaney is considering all of that, this is their individual property; it is between two family parcels; and the lots are appropriately sized. She commented there is a septic moratorium and she does not know how long that will continue, it sounds like a long time based on the testimony that she has heard tonight; they are not intending on doing anything any time soon; when they do they will go through all of the proper channels again, retain counsel again, and the Board will have the opportunity again to hear this because they will need permits and all of those things. Chair Altman asked if Ms. Pritchard is an attorney or just a legal representative. Ms. Pritchard replied yes, she is. Chair Altman asked if this is part of any sort of estate planning and what they are trying to plan for the future. Ms. Pritchard responded affirmatively saying they are planning for the future; currently her and her sister own it; they were not sure what they wanted to do with it; in order for them to separate out, her sister wants to keep the front half; her sisters heirs will be able to inherit the front half; and she get to keep the back half. Chair Altman asked about the size of the individual lots. Ms. Pritchard again stated they will be over an acre, the parcel is 2.94 acres. Commissioner Delaney asked what the Future Land Use is for this. Ms. Gilliam replied it is RES-1. Commissioner Feltner responded it is just one acre to build. Commissioner Delaney and Chair Altman both answered yes. Commissioner Adkinson states he would like to point out that Planning and Zoning actually recommended approval of this 11:2 after some pretty decent discussion. Ms. Pritchard reiterated that she understands exactly what the concern is; but she thinks in this individual case, due to the uniqueness of this and the fact that they live next door, she would say that this ameliorates some of those concerns. Commissioner Feltner asked if they are going to essentially be almost equal 1.5 acre lots. Ms. Pritchard stated they are almost equal; on the application, the surveys that they submitted show what was intended eventually. Commissioner Feltner asked if there is a way that Commissioner Delaney will be comfortable is they can only have one home per each one and one-half acre lot for each lot in the future. Ms. Pritchard responded she is pretty sure that is the way it is already that someone can only have one home. Commissioner Feltner asked if it is one acre to build. Ms. Pritchard stated yes, and she thinks one can have maybe an accessory building which would be a barn, which may be of interest to them; but that is not the intention right now; she also is not sure that her children are ever going to move to take care of her; and she would say if the Board wants to do a BDP with maybe three years that would be fine with them because there are no immediate plans for this, but for estate planning purposes they would like to make it clean. Commissioner Feltner asked if it would be not a building permit for three years. Ms. Pritchard responded no building permit for three years would be fine with them; she reiterate there is no immediate plan to build on this; however, they are both older and they are getting their affairs in order and things like that. Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, stated he is trying to think it through; the proposed lot split is attached to the Item on the Agenda, but that is for conceptual purposes at this point; and he is trying to think about how to map the BDP in the future and the actual description of the land because would it be across the whole property, so the BDP could say the house could be on the entire property with no more than one unit across the entire parcel for the next three years, subsequent to that there could be two units on the parent parcel. Ms. Pritchard stated they are going to apply for a flag lot after this because that is the whole point, to change the zoning to apply for a flag lot; and as long as this does not impede that then… Attorney Richardson stated they just need to record the BDP along with the zoning action because the zoning is going to paint the whole property, not just the flag lot because that lot has not been created yet, that is going to tail; the Board has to bring the BDP back, under the Code, within… Mr. Prasad advised it is 120 days. Attorney Richardson continued by saying 120 days, so if she could create that before. Mr. Prasad stated then staff could have that BDP and she could come back just applying for to the southern lot. Ms. Pritchard stated sure. Ms. Gilliam stated just for clarification regarding a barn on a vacant property; two points, staff cannot do the flag lot application until the rezoning is approved and the properties are recorded in that configuration; and two, she had mentioned having a barn on the property and one cannot have a barn without a primary structure. Ms. Pritchard stated they were saying that there could not be more than two structures so she understands that they cannot have the barn, it is an accessory; and she understands that. Ms. Gilliam responded that she just wanted to clarify that. Attorney Richardson stated that is about no more than one primary residence on the entire property for three years; and he thinks they will have to put the BDP on the entire property with that limitation because it is sort of a standoff; he was thinking they could do the split and then record the BDP, but they will not be permitted to do that until the zoning is in place; and zoning will not go into place until the BDP is recorded. He noted it is a circle so staff can paint the BDP over the entire property; it is going to allow what they already have; it will not prevent what they have or an accessory structure on the other lot or anything like that. Ms. Pritchard stated there are no plans that she is aware of to build an accessory structure on the other lot, so there is no… Attorney Richardson interjected saying it could not be done on the new lot without a primary dwelling. Ms. Pritchard stated correct. Attorney Richardson stated if she is comfortable with a BDP and she has authorization to represent the entire property, staff is going to have to put the BDP in place over the entire property, not just the new flag lot. Commissioner Delaney stated she just wants to explain her vote; she knows the applicant is part of the community and she hopes she hears her heart in this because this situation is very unique; she knows they are not trying to flip it to sell to a random person, but for her she made a commitment to people to not increase density in this area; but she is just one of five, so she will not be able to vote for this today. Commissioner Adkinson made the motion. Mr. Prasad stated he thinks staff understands that; and the BDP will come back to the Board with the final terms. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada to change of zoning classification from AU to RR-1, with a BDP on the entire property stating no building for three years, application number 25Z00036, located in District 1.

    Sandra Walsh and Terrie Canada (Monica Pritchard) request a zoning classification change from AU to RR-1. (25Z00036) (Tax Account 2005444) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.11.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Jay Steinke and Grant Steinke for a change of zoning classification from GU to AU, application number 25Z00038, located in District 2. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Jay Steinke and Grant Steinke request a zoning classification change from GU to AU, under application number 25Z00038, located in District 2. Commissioner Feltner asked since the applicant is not here does that mean there needs to be a motion to deny since the Board opened it. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, stated the Board needs to act on it, either approve, table to a future meeting, or deny it. Commissioner Delaney asked if she could just look at it and remind herself what this is. Commissioner Goodson asked for a motion to table. Commissioner Adkinson seconded the motion. Chair Altman stated there is a motion to table and the Board needs a date certain. Billy Prasad, Planning and Development Director, mentioned February 5. Chair Altman repeated it is a motion to table to February 5. There being no further comments or objections, the Board continued the request by Jay and Grant Steinke for a change of zoning classification to the February 5, 2026, zoning meeting.

    Jay Steinke and Grant Steinke request a zoning classification change from GU to AU. (25Z00038) (Tax Account 2504763) (District 2)

  • Agenda item H.12.Land useapproved - Chair Altman called for a public hearing on a request by Linda M. Muenz and Erran L. Muenz, Jr. for a change of zoning classification from GU to AU, application number 25Z00040, located in District 1. Trina Gilliam, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Linda M. Muenz and Erran L. Muenz, Jr. request a zoning classification change from GU to AU, under application number 25Z00040, located in District 1. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request by Linda M. Muenz and Erran L. Muenz, Jr. for a change of zoning classification from GU to AU, application number 25Z00040, located in District 1.

    Linda M. Muenz & Erran L. Muenz, Jr. request a zoning classification change from GU to AU. (25Z00040) (Tax Account 2313962) (District 1)

  • Agenda item K.Other meeting itemsNo recorded outcome

    PUBLIC COMMENTS (Individuals may not speak under both the first and second public comment sections.)

    $62,000

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Brevard County Board of County Commissioners — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8e082734dd3bc61dcce6e203835c2337. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record