POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Public Safety Subcommittee

Wednesday, January 10, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Public Safety Subcommittee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

Yeah. Alright, welcome everyone to tonight's public safety subcommittee. It is January tenth, 2,024 at 5 30 PM. We heard the Civic center building on the first floor. I'm gonna open up the meeting today and check in and say item number one for public comment for non-agendized items. Do we have any public comment? Staying done? Hearing them. We're, we do. I want to recognize we have a new, self committee member, we do, I want to recognize we have a new, committee member, Chelsea member, Chelsea. I want to recognize we have a new, self committee member, as Chelsea, member, Lopez, and I'm looking to list of any objections. We're going to look and take things a little out of order off the agenda. I actually would like to move up item number 3. SB. 41 presentation to the next. A. And so tonight we have tenant Will Hatcher who's going to be with us and he will making the presentation on SP. 41. There you go. That one. So assembly bill, 4 81 is military funding acquisition and used by law enforcement agencies. This is actually the 2023 annual report which is required by that law. Okay, there we go. Alright, a little bit of background in September of 2021. I got an renewing sign assembly bill. 41. The purpose was increasing transparency, accountability. Oversight and any use of military equipment. Now military equipment is a little bit of a misnomer. It's any equipment that is labeled under this law as military equipment. The Pittsburgh PD does not procure or use any prior military surplus equipment. And I'll go a little more in depth as we go through. It also provides safeguards to protect the public's welfare safety and civil rights and deliveries and the public's right to know and allows for community engagement and any equipment that we use, how we utilize it, why we utilize it. And things of those little historical context here in Pittsburgh in May of 2022 the Pittsburgh City Council adopted. Resolution in support of the Pittsburgh Police Department's authorization and continued use. Equipment outlined under the newly passed assembly bill. 41. This authorization was memorialized in its per municipal code 2.6 4. Requirements outlined in 80 41 includes an annual report and audit of equipment utilization adopted and approved by this per city council. This present presentation tonight is a summary of the attached aid employee one annual report and audit. We'll open it up for comments and questions at the end. So requirements under 84 81. And this is going to cover the span. This report January first, 2,023 up until January first at 2024. I'll give you a summary of how the military equipment was used and the purpose of its use. A summary of any complaints or concerns received concerning this military equipment use. The results of any internal audits and the information about violations of military equipment use policy and any actions taken in response. The total annual cost of each type of military equipment, including acquisition, personal training, transportation, maintenance, storage. Upgrade and other ongoing costs and from what source funds they will be procured. For a military equipment, in a calendar year following the submission. So if we were looking to purchase something that was outlined under 481, we would have to come and request that through this process. We're not doing that this year. So it's not gonna be relevant. And the quantity possessed in each type of military, military equipment and its law enforcement agency intends to require additional military equipment like I just said. This is the process in which we go to email. So, equivalent categories, there's 15 defined military equipment categories. The Pittsburgh Police Department has equipped that labeled in 6 of these categories. And those 6 are UAV drones, command trailers, tactical team firearms, a certain caliber, diversionary devices and chemical agents. Kinetic energy weapons and ballistically armored vehicles. At this point, each year, when I draw the comparison to what military equipment is and how we utilize it, I like to use drones as an example. So a lot of our technology that we use. In our profession and commercially and personally privately comes through military technology. Drones is a perfect example. You can go to Walmart today as an average citizen and buy a drone. That technology comes from the military. You can use it as a private citizen. We utilize it in law enforcement. And it serves a very positive purpose. So these are the categories in which we, utilize equipment outlined under 80 41. All right, this year's audit results. Administrative staff conducted an AV 41 audit for the calendar year of January 2023. Through January 2024. It was determined that all equipment was utilized in accordance with existing Pittsburgh police policy. No equipment was purchased outside of commercial avenues. Or without prior council approval, there was no military procurement. Overly maintenance cost. Or maintain within our projected budgets. And the meat potatoes of our summary here. So, for our drones, the first category, we got 127 flights on 37 deployments. Deployments included tactical support operations towards the last few traffic and testing monitoring and public education and training. The next, man trailer, which we have and we utilize that 6 times this year for DUI checkpoints. It just supplements a place to house or officers are going in and out. Long rifles and ammunition. There was 8,000 rounds of ripe ammunition utilized for training and qualification purposes only, no windkill deployments. And ballistically armored vehicle. 15 total deployments this year. 5 work. It's for SRU when you think SWAT SRU operations. 6 were supplemental patrol responses, meaning there was something of a critical nature. We sent our car out to assist patrol in a safety capacity. Forward mutual aid request, for a tactical operations outside of anything we were doing investigative-wise within Pittsburgh. The diversionary devices, that's a flash bang. 25 training deployments. Any field deployments on the span of 7 packical operations. This is a very common tool that we utilize in our tactical operations as a diversionary device. It's so named chemical agents. We had one infilled utilization on a warrant service for a murder suspect. That all other deployments were training base. And last connect energies, which is a 40 it's like a Traditionally, you think of it as a phone for talking around. We had 2 deployments for breaching purposes only. Sometimes we'll utilize those to break out windows on an operation so we don't have to expose officers and put them in a dangerous situation. We use that twice and then the rest of them 25 we're training deployments I left people and shrubber courses and new higher orientation of a memorizing our officers with this. And that includes our presentation during the fourth this year, open it up for comments or questions. Thank you. The only point I have is good job with. With everything. One thing is having the military equipment, but you don't have the systems in place and actually not have operate and utilize. So it's a good job. I like that. It sounds to me like. You guys are very careful. On what to utilize on what situation and so I like that. I have a waste of resources, but I like that. You guys are doing a great job in conserving these resources. And The only one I have is you guys, do you guys feel like? You currently have enough. Or, based on these numbers, are you projecting a higher need for equipment. Yeah, we're always assessing because there's always, you know, trends, updates and technology updates and tactics and in law enforcement we're always assessing that both internally and as a state national level. There's different organizations IACP, Kel chiefs, that are always looking at. More and better ways to utilize the new technology that's coming out and how to keep pubs are safer and keeps community safer. So we're always analyzing that. One thing we've done recently, which is a change from years ago is, we pulled, Traditionally, both seeing police cars would shock up there. We have seen one the lack of use of that type of equipment in the field and to the limited use that it actually has. So we've actually pulled those within the last 18 months out of our patrol vehicles and we've replaced that we're in the process of restoring the cost of replacement with that 40 min millimeter less. It gives us a lot more options, at a patrol, from a control officer, in the past that, system would only be utilized or carried by our supervisors in the field. So our sergeant's in the field or our corporal in the field and as well by our tactical team. But as we looked at different ways to deploy different safety measures, different way it is to utilize techniques and devices in a safe manner to keep and reduce the number of incidents that we have. That was one change. And that's just an example of several things we do. The same thing with like drones. Drones have a shelf life. We utilize our drones as you heard quite a bit. They definitely help us in officer safety measures. They allow us to scan an open field if we're looking for someone maybe armed or even for someone who may be a missing adult, we found several missing persons by flying or drones over and in an open area because it can detect heat. Those will last for long. Eventually they were out the parks were out. And there's new technology, especially that field that we're constantly looking at updated technology. Especially that, that we're constantly looking at updated technology. So as far as the equipment we have, I think the Pittsburgh Police Farm is very well established in equipment and we're very much on the cutting edge of what's out there that we can actually deploy in equipment and very well established in equipment and we're very much on the cutting edge of what's out there, but that we can actually deploy in the manner which it needs to be deployed without waste. So we're always looking at that. And a lot of what you've seen in this report, and, and, IT, IS, the deal with this for 2 years is, you know, this is very much a transparency piece for us. You know, a lot of our items don't really apply to what SP. One wasn't intended for. But we do that to be transparent with the public of a through the equipment we have, sure that we use it, how many times we use it, or open book. Let us know if you have questions. So that's part of it for us. And again, the report, eventually this will go to council, and, the council will get a report that, and after is already completed, and be able for a little bit more detail review, but this is the nuts on the bolts of what that report says. And I think to the chief point, you know, the biggest thing that we're facing is chasing the technology curtain. If you consider your iPhone, you go back 3 generations, it's not the same phone. So what we're finding is we're looking for efficiency and operations and a lot of it is system integration. So as new technology, especially in the drone area comes out, extends our battery light, can integrate with live be to the existing systems that we have. It just makes us more efficient in our operations. So that's something on the horizon. I can see is looking towards it's not necessarily here now and then you know the transparency piece it one of the things that I pride myself on that we do as an organization is something like the armored core, you know, when you think about it, it has a, it has a bad reputation. One of the things that we do to create transparency with the community and educate them is we're bringing that to almost every public event. We added out of the seafood festival, we bring it to national night out, and it gives us an opportunity. One, the kids love it, but to educate the community about what this actually is. This is it's nothing offensive. It's purely defensive and the purpose it serves and we find that when we have that opportunity to come back to the average citizen and explain what this piece of equipment is, it completely changes their perception of what it is, how we utilize it. The importance of keeping our officers safe. So that's something I think as an agency that she's led and we do exceptionally well. Yeah, that the vehicle itself. As a defensive item, but it also it reduces at times that you support that we may be involved in because it's a show of course. So just sometimes that vehicle showing up on scene changes the response that the individual that we're working with may have to focus. And that's all I mean, we're trying to defuse the situation and not use any force at all. And if that's the presence that it takes some time that it has every bit of value is right in that as well as a rescue vehicle should we have to evacuate people safely get them out of the neighborhood. We even used to during the floods last year, you know, the water rises. That's the biggest calls being able to city ask. We can use it for that type of thing. So it's got so many purposes and so much value. And again, it does have a shelf life at some point. We will have to look at some type of replacement for that. With the drones I see that only expanding one of the biggest challenges we have here is our weather. The wind, especially in the later evening, greatly reduces the flying time or the ability of our larger drones to be up in the air and how long they can get up there. So we're looking at different systems like, one they call a tether system, which takes our larger drone that has more capabilities and it literally you attach a power cord that data came into it and we can put it up in the air and leave it up and for 24 h. Because otherwise if you have a wind like we do the night that dr the batteries are over the last 2530 min maybe and then you gotta bring it down and try to replace battery. You lose that, I view whatever you're trying to get. So we're always going to be chasing technology, but again, we pride ourselves on trying to stay right on that edge as fiscally as we can, but right on that edge to keep us there. I mean. To the point that our body cameras that are officers where those are on a 2 and a half year old. That's how fast that technology changes just like books. So every our contract with the vendor is every 2 and a half years we will get new body cameras. We know the technologies are even changed by that. Great questions. Thank you. But what you consider a body camera. But we initially we were one of the broad runners, in this area. But we initially, we were one of the front runners, in this area in the Bay Area. So our original first body cameras that we started experimenting with or where our original first body cameras, in this area in the Bay Area. So our original first body cameras that we started experimenting with were really these pocket cameras that we ordered off Amazon that you would stick in your, Pocket or your press populator and have a little tiny camera in the battery power. And then the battery power, 20 min or so. Before that we were doing a micro number cassette recorders or digital recorders that we would carry on our belts or in our pocket. And that's kind of where we started. Our work would see the vendor that we currently have. We're probably, yeah, probably like, 40, 14 is when we started looking at a full system that integrates everything that they have to offer. But actually one of the few agencies that went to body cans before there was a societal bush. Right. Just got ahead of that curve and watched them hold and now we're at a point where you know speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, we're at a point where, you know, speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, so much that our new body cameras now, that you know, speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, that you, from an operational standpoint. from the station, we can log on and see officers making an entry into a house and watch their perspective from their body cam lifetime. And so when you talk about, you know, making the best decisions and shortest amount of time with the most information. It's been it's been a very valuable tour. And this generation of your it's just part of how they do least work. They don't know without it. And I don't think they would want to do it, but not again. It's a game cheering for us for safety. You know, one thing we talk about is should an officer not be responsive on radio for the total call and all. But we'll hear from them. The supervisor can don't want their issue phone or under the computer and instantly log on power up that camera and see exactly what's going on. So it may just be that their radio failed. It's not community more or they may be in a physical education or you know they may be you know injured or some sort and they can communicate that's that's a huge difference for us when it comes to the Oscar safety factor and again this next generation awesome this is all they know so they fully embrace the technology part of it. It's completely different when I start. That's not, we, had to show radios. So, yeah. And, and, and have like, any, any, and operating without technology. No, that's only known. And which is great because as we introduced the technology, GPS systems, things like that, there' There was a culture change that had to take place. There was there was an education level. There had to be some buy-in from the staff and that that was a that's started under Chief Addington. That was probably a 3 plus year process to where the staff finally bought into having that type of technology of, you know, being being watched basically of everything you do. That's a big change. And now those features now, support our officers more than they in room. And there are interviews. So. Any other questions? Alright, thank you, so we will now move to item, let's go back to item number 2 on crime stats. And as we get this started. And I know we have a new number here with us, but, we've done a lot of work. Throughout 2023 as the city and the department transitioned from the UCR to the unified of crime reporting status to the UCR, the Unified of Crime Reporting Status to the Unified of Crime Reporting Status to the NIBR system, the national incident based reporting system. And with that transition, the national incident based, reporting system. And with that transition, comes some delays. So we originally transitioned, and with that transition, comes some delay. So we originally transitioned again that work in June of 2022. And we're still kinda catching up on the back end. I think we finally got our Neighbor's numbers. Through November, they just came out earlier this week. So, the numbers that I'll be going through tonight I'll be working with are a kind of a snapshot of the first 9 months of 23 because we haven't quite closed out the data for all 23 so I'll kind of walk through that a little bit and and answer some questions. We goes because it's a little, it's difficult for us to interpret the transition and compare. 2022 and beyond because the way this system we collect a lot more data under. So we get under the UCR. So we have to kind of make some inference on what that looks like. So this first the first slide here again goes from January to October or 23 and we do have a comparison from 22 to 23 to 22 in the blue line and again that starts in June, 22 in the blue line and again that starts in June because that's when we started bringing in. 2322 in the blue line. And again, that starts in June, cause that's when we started bringing in, numbers numbers. And then we have, the red line is incorporating all 23 up to the point of October 30 first. So you can see as we've heard across over the lines, we're pretty comparable, 23 up to the point of October thirty-first. So you can see as we start across over the lines, we 2023 crimes against persons. It's been fairly steady and we see a little increases here and there. But for the most part, or being very, very consistent. Again, it's very hard to compare. You're in here right now because we don't have a complete data set. But you can kind of see the numbers off the side. There are 797 crimes against persons from the first 9 months of the year. And then it breaks it down 23% or 2232% for aggregated salts, 43 simple salts and then we have some the sexual salt following classifications have changed under NYVERS versus you see there's a lot more classifications that work with. So we're interpreting this on where they fit in under some tribes. So the technical listing comes under. We moved down to property crimes. Again, in 22 we saw a pretty big spike in the summer months and what we're looking at is for within specifically, the, the, the, vandalism, average of a hundred 90 of those crimes throughout the month. But again 23 has been very consistent online we're not seeing big spikes like we did in the previous years. That can be incorporated to several things. There's obviously some changes in society from 2020 to 2,023. We're starting to see a lot of these things kind of paper off. We're starting to see a lot of these things kind of taper off. We are in the city when I look at some of the other members that are on the table here, you know, we're seeing an increase a little bit in vehicle, motor vehicle deaths in the last couple months. A lot of the communities around us are seeing similar spikes, so it's a regional regional issue that we're looking at. But you can see our thefts are 32% of those 1,900 and then, And then we look at crimes against society. Those are more of your, more your public nuisance type crimes. A person on the influence of alcohol or drugs, a person in possession of alcohol or drugs or weapons violations, sort of drivers. So you can see again in June, the 22, we have a really high number there. Coming out of Maine when you got those numbers and it kind of settled down again. 23 is fairly level. We're seeing a little spikes and movements that are in there of over averaging about 33 cases a month. Now, laws of change, prosecution levels on certain crimes like this have changed. That can all contribute to some of the enforcement actions that take place in these types of crimes. But those are kind of the averages overseeing here. And I'll other than that. Don't look at that. Right after that, there we go. A little bit more detail. These are the kind of numbers we've been presenting to, public safety cell community last couple months. This is us interpreting Neighbors as much as we can to the classic UCR crime classifications that we're all used to kind of hear you're seeing about part one crimes and you're about to use and things like that. So these are really the numbers that we look at on a regular basis. You can see, October 23 is in the red column there and then October 22 for comparison is in the the call next tutor just to the right and you can see you are every results actually we have had a drop in October by 40% our sexual offenses kind of stayed actually had an increase but again those classifications have changed. Human trafficking obviously law enforcement is very aggressive in even trafficking type cases. We have several of our detectives that are very involved in human trafficking cases. In fact, some of them are instructors throughout the state and actually going, being requested throughout the state, the nation to do classes. So you've seen a little bit of a spike there because they have a very strong interest in combating human trafficking. Robbery cases for October drop a little bit and we're talking, just a couple of numbers here, burglaries for about even a little bit of a drop. Those large, to me, to have some of the people that, again, I talked about they spiked a little bit and that's kind of a regional thing that we're seeing retail theft vehicle theft. We're seeing a little bit of spike in the region, but again that's bare, forgery cases you can seem to go down vandalisms actually drop a little bit and then you see some of the property crimes stolen property weapons violations, drug expenses are down just a little bit and a lot of those are arrest related type crimes. Go to the next one. And then I wanted to highlight, as we look at, because we're, one of the future ones and one of our our focuses this year was also traffic related so I just wanted to highlight some of our traffic related. So I just want to kind of highlight some of our traffic stats and information. This slide is covering our DUI traffic stats and information. This slide is covering our DUI traffic collisions by type. And the types you're going to be in the bottom left-hand corner over there from January, the 23 to December fourteenth is where we cut this off of 23 alcohol type UI collisions are in the blue and you'll see that highlighted all that that heat map, if you will, combined cases are a little bit in the orange and they're a little more difficult to see and then drug only related collisions are in the green the green dots under spread throughout. We also have accounts by time of day. This is something we always analyze. When are these type of crimes occurring? When we do some of our grant related enforcement actions or when we target our staff, when we have more officer on the street looking for this. So you can kind of see some of the stuff that we look at things of the week times the day, hours that day, and to make sure we're maximizing our enforcement effort. And then off to the far right side, these are reporting areas where reporting districts which are go coincided with the map is our criminalist works through this type of information. And you can see in the different areas throughout town, you can see the locations and then the number of EY type cliches that we respond to. And then, if we can go the next slide. And then continue with traffic collisions. These are non-DY or alcohol or drug related here's just our, in general throughout the city. Anything with the nap or fatal collisions that we investigated anything in kind of a light blue with a car in the middle or injury and then property damage only or just a blue dot. I know it's a little difficult to see because it's actually very busy. But as we break it down again by reporting district, you can see the different number of collisions that we investigated throughout the city. Some areas have quite a few, but you're going to bring our harder traffic areas. Again, we utilize this type of information in this map. We simply saw to our officers on a monthly basis. So we can really focus and target our trafficking as well as any additional OTS traffic safety grants that we get focused on those areas that we're having more pleasures and how we can counter that. We also take this information here and when we have meetings with other city staff and engineers, this is some of the information we get to them so that they can look at this student and say, is there an engineering situation that we'd like to changing traffic patterns, movements, light signals, things like that, whatever may help Total collisions, which isn't on the slide, but I just promise me they, they are. Total prisons are down from January to November, 22 versus January, November, 23. Our injuries are very consistent, involved in that. They're about the same number, for the 2 years, but our total positions are down about probably a hundred. So when we look at our goals and all the extra work we're doing and the grants we're receiving, that's definitely the right direction that we're looking for. Although there's always more one of the biggest things that we hear from the community when we go to meetings and we talk to community members is we hear concerns about traffic. And traffic collisions traffic violation. So definitely a focus for department. Again, we're talking about that here in the next budget item. But any, any questions on some of these? Thank you. Okay, so let's, there's no questions. Let's go ahead and move into agenda. Item 4. At some point I'll start with my words. So. Do you have for tonight is to talk about some of the department's accomplishments when it's related to our 2324 goals that we set in the previous year to kind of take a look at see how we're doing, where we're on track at as a department to share that with with the subcommittee here and then obviously the city itself is starting to move towards the focus of goals for setting goals for the in the following fiscal year that we're looking at here shortly in the next couple of weeks, is for me as I look at these goals looking forward and seeing how, how do we make for the movement and advancement for the 2425 year. So we're gonna walk through these a little bit refresh remembering what we're looking to do this year some of our goals that you know where we're at. So, number one was, for the police department, always credit prevention and reduction is number one for us, but as far as these. SET goals goal number one here was related to traffic education engagement and enforcement planner. So within this goal we identified a few measures or targets that we wanted to hit. One of those measures was to develop an educational clock class for youth drivers. I'm happy to see that we have been working on our traffic team. We have 2 track officers of the working on this plan and working with the school districts on implementing this plan and bringing students on high school age students or new drivers to be involved in this class for this program. So we talked about it for probably 2 years going back to this marsh, bringing it up and that definitely something she was looking at. This marsh, bringing it up and that definitely something she was looking at. So we heard that and we've worked on that definitely something she was looking at. So we heard that and we've worked on that. So we heard that and we heard that and we've worked on to build that. So the the curriculum itself, I mean, these are post trainers that, again, these are post trainers that train driver's trainers that train driver's trainers, again, these are post trainers that train drivers trainers that train drivers trainers that train drivers trainer EVO trainers which first the operation vehicle trainers and they work on our traffic, Mercy Operation Vehicle Trainers and they work on our traffic, they develop a curriculum. We're now working with the superintendent, and they work on our traffic, Vehicle trainers, and they work on our traffic, they develop a curriculum. We're now working with the superintendent, the school district on taking that curriculum and working with them probably to our call program on getting this, educational program where these classes off the ground, sending some dates and starting getting them up and running. So we're pretty excited about that. It's again, it's something we've been looking at for over a year and I'm going to say we're about 50%. With that. We're definitely on track, but we're about halfway through that, that mentor. The second measure under traffic itself. Social media messaging, traffic 2 days, all the stuff that hopefully as you call us you see, I think we're on track with that. We were very, very strong in that area. There's always something more. We're always looking for the next thing we put out when traffic Tuesdays is a big thing. We make sure when we have raining weather days, we're educating the community, make sure your headlines are on, the wipers are on drive. So you slow down. That's something we're always looking at in different ways we can help educate the community. So we're definitely, in my opinion, we're on track for measure 2 and then measure 3 for that goal itself was to create a monthly training program where we actually meet with our city staff. Engineers, traffic engineers and go over some of the concerning areas, check out where our traffic collisions are occurring. Are there any mitigating factors that we can put in. We also look at traffic per the pick up the drop off for the schools. You know, the 13 schools, the pick up the drop off for the schools, you know, the 13 schools, we never community, how can we reduce traffic, make the 13 schools we never community, how can we reduce traffic, make the pedestrian safety a little bit more per party if need be in there certain areas things like that. So that is definitely underway and moving forward with that part. So from goal number one. I think we're definitely moving the right direction and we're gonna be successful. Any questions on one before Okay, so, goal number 2. Is. Okay, was related to retail environmental enforcement. Obviously over the last 2 years plus. We've seen a climb in retail organized retail depth throughout the Bay Area. Again, it's a regional issue that we're experiencing and we're off the Bay Area. Again, it's a regional issue that we're experiencing and we're really looking to see how we can combat that and what the department can do as far as working through some of those issues. So, one thing we have our commercial retailer person officer one thing that we, went out to make sure is that, enforcement officer was working with their retail partners, and commercial partners on creating, quarterly retail enforcement operations and focused on, they organized. Retail death credit. So we've run several. I think we're up to 3. Operations. And, we, run, the, first, half, the, year, when, we've, actually, run was for her retail officer, to develop, retail theft forum and provide strategies to our commercial partners, retail partners, we're on addressing some of these issues. So the officer we have in that position right now has done an outstanding job the last I think she's been over 2 years now of really connecting with the store managers, property owners, property management groups of our retail partners, really making sure they have her first hand on their call. They have her cell phone number. They reach out to her even on her page off. She make sure they have an issue. She contacts the pro staff. It's here to make sure they get it resolved. So we've really been the biggest key was making that direct contact for the retail establishments for willing to contact us because there is always looking for some folks making sure they're willing to contact us and number 2 is us being very responsible what they do. So we made that connection and we're going to continue that. The contract that we have related to that position has expired. As of the 30% December, right now we're working to maintain that position. The positive with that is we're able now to expand that position. The positive with that is we're able now to expand that position. So the focus we can expand out to some of the other. Commercial areas that weren't necessarily receiving as high as the service because we're able to, we don't have a contract that's buying this. So we're going to continue to work on that. And make make those connections, beyond what we were focused on before. And so you say the contract has ended was a contract for was just one commercial area in particular. Or, it was one property management group that was, requested a contract for a single officer for, 40 HA week to purchase their properties. Now with all the restraint that I contract, again, trying to maintain that position with, with the safety levels, but as long as we're able to meet him that position. Now we have the ability to let that officer expand their working area into other commercial areas, which increases the workload that individual might reduce some of the response to some of the, some of those folks that are used to it, not that we're or banning, at all, but it allows us to expand that work area a little bit more and hopefully service more of our commercial community. If I have. In the commercial area and the target. Area now that we have a service station or, there, do we see a decline now that we have the present? Yeah, so we definitely have an increase present there. And we're, we have the substitution that went live. So the officer now has a place to work. Always one thing that we're looking at, especially at the city, 8 and a half, almost 19 square miles right now. So that's a lot of area for our office to cover. If something major was to happen up in the West into town and officers from the East End had to get all way out there. You're talking about a 40 min return back once the everything's clear. So we love to have a place for them to in other car one, it connects with the community a little bit more because now they're on the car, they're walking around, they're going to the substation, the door can be open from community, the camera, the officers are in there, but they have a place to land, you pay for, take a break, eat their lunch. It keeps them in that area. That's what we're looking for. We are looking, we're still on track. It can push back a little bit what we're looking to expand that. Having that substitution on the eastern town is expanding to have another substitution on the western council or another commercial partner that's helping us utilize some space and we're open to the same thing up there because again You know, what day, what time of the day, I want a community evening commute for an officer to get from one side of town to the other side of town for a residential burglar alarm and then have to go all the way back to their beep that they service I mean it could be 30 to 40 min for a trip. That takes them out of their service hearing. So we want to keep them. As whole as we can in the area that they're responsible for. So that definitely the substitutions I think are the way to go and we're looking how do we create a program that allows us to do that because the city is again expanding. We're going to see more growth. Yeah, sounds good. Thank you. So we want to, goal 3. And we've talked about goal pretty, in this subcommittee at great length over the last probably 18 months or so. And this is staffing analysis and community needs. This kind of started when we looked at the strategic plan and we started that process over 2 years ago. We didn't took so many information in the feedback we got from the committee from this strategic plan and apply to what that looks like now we apply to the department. Last spring or summer, Kevin Giller presented to the subcommittee, some of the analytics that we looked at based on that information of officer response calls for journalists, climate 8 calls, response time, number of officers we have was freed looking at our beats how they're broken down in the city as the city changes these bees were established directly 2015 2017 era the cities now changed to when we didn't change our beat responsibilities do we have too much workload on one officer and another offshore over more time. So we're looking at all that kind of stuff. That's what drove this goal in us really looking at that. So measure one and this was analyzing the department, the place is operational. The volume of calls, types of calls and duration spin on those investigations with the analytics that we did under this first segment and if need be I can definitely see back off to this. Refresh. If you're refreshing those numbers, those are numbers based on 2022 numbers, totally for the year for department. We definitely walk down ourselves down into a position where we're moving into measurement. We've definitely walked down ourselves down into a position where we're moving into measurement 2 was identifying opportunities to change deployment strategy shift coverage or schedules, geographic boundaries and operational employment strategies will definitely move in that direction. So we've had a few team meetings with various individuals from the department, everything from police officers, our corporals or servers or the, staff. We're looking at these analytics and how do we change this to make our department be a little bit more functional for the community. We are, I'm promising we are working toward potential. new schedule, if you will. And the point was, currently currently currently the program works a, what we call a 4 1312 an hour schedule, for 1020 Thursday, 3, 12, now Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Yeah, my personal opinion, not necessarily the best, it'll probably start it. Work in law enforcement is not using 10 h shift. One person is difficult enough for an officer to come in and do 12 and half hour shift. They're never here for 12 h. They're here an hour before or 30 or at least an hour after work. You're talking 14 to 15 h day before they get back home with their family. So when we look at wellness, which is a big focus in law and workforce, we've talked about wellness in here. To me that's not the best correct team for not only the individual employee but as part of the city in general. So we are looking to work focused based on the analytics alone of going to what we did work years ago and I care when we change that schedule going back to what we call for 10 or the department will split it schedule. On one day the week that makes sense based on another looks could be Tuesday, it could be Thursday, it could be Thursday, we're basically all officer will work on a, week 10 h schedule and patrol operations and the safe on the second half a week 10 h schedule and patrol operations and the safe on the second half. What that does for us based on all the requirements that we're getting from the state, on all the requirements that we're getting from the state, the laws that come down from the state and the laws that come down, the new mandated training that we're focused on on a regular basis. We instantly go from 6 training days a year. Every month it will allow over not double of days we instantly gain 12 days a month for that not only for our patrol staff we gain 12 days a month for our technical team we get 12 days or our parents trade twice a month anyway, it frees out a little bit more time for our Knights where they're not a constraint on staffing levels, our crisis negotiation team, anything we need, we now have more days built in. It also builds in the ability for these special operations that we'd like to do, it's retail. Maybe it's a traffic safety grant operation that we deal with giving us extra days where we not only have 2 crews of officers we can now take one entire crew and focus on just on that strategic operation that's going on call division and the other ones handling the calls for service to be for the community. So these all came out of this goal, this analytics that we get again, this is about 2 year process, as we sat here and talk over building, look at this and we're, getting towards the end as we make some moves here out trying to implement this. Fireship change, which is in large. So our goal is get this all gathered up, make sure our employee groups are on board. There's no issues there, which again, we've been building this for about 9 months now, really looking through all the effects. We'll make sure it affects our employees at a positive, non-negative, but also that we're providing the service that we need to to the community based on what we're seeing. So for goal 3, on remember is. I'm gonna say we're about 75% there. We're definitely on track. I'm hoping, like I said, by about, by about March, you get into March, we're gonna know exactly. If it's feasible based on staffing to staff, you numbers, always affect that. You know, there's always injuries and things like that. We have to move around for illnesses, things like that. I think we're heading in the right direction here and that won't stop this process this is something regardless what's the goal is and this is one of those items that will continue to monitor. Is this working correctly? Is it just, to monitor? Is this working correctly? Is it just, do we need to just time schedules, things like that. So this isn't a one-stop shop. Hey, this fixed it, take the band aid off. We'll have to continue to water this, look at the analytics. This was a great, Great. Reason for the to really dive down into how we're operating and what the constraints are and what the community is demanding from us as far as call for sure. For example, and we'll see how we can make it better. So a great process to go through for us. Any questions on that? In top. No. So as we move on, so now I kind of look at it as we, you know, I'm focused now on as we work to finish up the goals from 2324 is, what does public safety look like for this to be in this department moving into the next the next year in our 2425. Reduction of crime, like I said, is always number one for me. It's always gonna be the focus department. That's our goal is public safety and to try to reduce. Grab this community, but what are some of the other areas we need to look into? Then we'd be focused on for department in the community. So, No, I'm not saying I have these answers. I just started on this path myself of what that looks like. It's always a conversation I have with my command staff because they're a little more connected with some of the day to day things that are going on out in the community. But I definitely wanted to bring it up to this group, this subcommittee. As we move forward into some of our future meetings that we start talking about that at least put at the front the front of our brain there as we think about public safety. We've talked a lot about a lot of presentation over the last 18 to 24 months on, you know, everything from analytics and schedules to this treated plan to our current reduction plan. And again I can forward some of those older presentations out that we need to just refresh you but what What did this community, what does the council want? Or does some committee, or they look at public safety, they look at the future the next. 15 months or so. Water our goals. For public safety. It's like kinda definitely open for discussion, but I kinda just wanted to open it up as something to start thinking about because it's definitely on my mind and that's part of my job is to look at those goals and forecast what the next. You know, starting to join, what the next 15 months bring for us, what do we want to know college? Hey, my biggest thought process behind this is the big picture. One thing is public safety, but. When I think of crime is what are the deterrents out there that are gonna stop members of the media or the outside community to come and come in tough crime here. You know, one thing is sure we can have. 10 officers and every beat, but. What happens next because. I believe a new common misconception is. I do the, at the time. And so, you know, that. Thank you, and certain crimes like vehicle death. You know, so somebody working with. Our community partners and creating. A bigger sense of deterrence. When it comes to Maybe. A bigger place for the to actually. Forward with. And maybe even talk about. Well, what other communities, Resort of justice, you know, if we're not really the, and the criminal. Just as route maybe through the restorative justice. Oh, so you implement those. In our schools, you know, public education and such. A big menu to start, parents and students. Just being good, Okay. The utopian the side it's always been my goal but you know it starts with one kid at a time No, I definitely hear what you're saying. We're always look for community partners. Definitely like, this year we really pushed hard, for, connections. Last year we, tried to do the reach outreach on that. We didn't get a whole lot of response this year. I told Tony to be a little bit more pushy. We need to be part of this. So those kind of connections, those community connection, the partners that we're going to, but we have a great relationship with us. So those kind of connections, those are those community connection, the partners that we wanted to grab onto. But we have a great relationship with the school district. That's obviously a big piece of it. I'm a very strong advocate of the SRO program of having officers in school, not from the enforcement aspect, but we gotta make those connections will be used. Good. High school is one thing, but really those connections want to be made as they get into middle school. That's really those influential years that are going to really help us connect with the future of this community. So having our SROs in the middle schools and definitely high school because it needs to continue but definitely the middle schools is a big part of making those connections early on and then having that member of this community that not only is willing to communicate and work with this, but is going to be part of this. We're always work with the Ds office. I know they have a couple of programs. They're looking at the future. There's a juvenile justice program on my backboard. We meet every quarter. There's a lot of things that folks are working on. And somebody just take a really long time to move forward. So what that looks like, you know, for us in 12 months, the 2 months, I'm not sure but obviously it's something we need to our goal is a goal to go when we can. Our goal is a goal to go when we can post on it then we're always going to meet it or we can always focus in a certain area and try to see what we can always focus in a certain area and try to see what we can do again. Yeah, and I think the, like, 47, right? And so, so I can tell the state legislators make changes to that. Everybody else has to follow, you know. So, I know there were anything out today. This morning with trying to look at, Prop. 47 and some separate rules. I haven't read it through yet, but so the voters, you know, when they put it back up, we have to vote on it. And You know, maybe there will be some changes there, but. I think. Yes, a tough part for all of us. Huh. And of course we don't want No, our store is closing out and seeing people go away because of the prime. So that is a huge issue. I think another one that would be on there for me would be traffic and just slowing people down. Yeah. And it's just important for us that. You know, something I always think about. I know you all are always working on it. But that would be another one. For me. That's what our young. While in back and forth in school. And then just outreach, how do we connect with people in the community? You know, we had that barbershop. But then for earlier this year and, so I can't remember the, this thing, but he was like, you know, back in the day, you know, the police officers, get out and talk to me. I knew it was like, you know, back in the day, you know, the police officers, get out and talk to me. I knew they were and he said, but now they pass by. I don't need to wait. And one of the officers there was like, well, that's my beat, but for now I'm gonna wait. But, those little things matter, right? So, you know, connect with people again, you know, in that way. So I'm just thinking about outreach. And I know we're trying to deal with our young people. Right, Yeah, we. We, we definitely, work to do as much average as we can. Looking at some of the numbers we've done over with last actual organized events we had over 70 community average events organized once not last year. So I can't imagine what the list is. Yeah, very. So I mean, and we're always looking to do more. You know, and again, the community is grown to how to, you know, it's not just, I'm not focused like we talk about here, but I'm not me personally not focused on today. Focus for the next 3 to 5 years of what that looks like. What does that look like in the future? How do we continue to grow with the community? How do we continue growth development? How do we continue growth development? How do we keep to the you go with the changes in society? Because some of that is outside of our control. So you always have to try to, as much as we wanna be. Up to speed, we should be looking 3 to 5 years ahead of that. If we're going to try to really be even at the plan today. So that's been a focus. It's something that we definitely talk about is playing several regular basis. We're busy. I mean, as city staff, police department as a city in general, we're busy active community. You know, and part of as another part of my focus outreach only because we brought that up was, you know, as our city rose and you have more, housing, we have more people that may not be from our community, which is fantastic. Let's bring them in. I don't make them part of our. Not just be a resident, but I will make it hard work. And that that's that's a bigger picture I think for the entire city as a whole. Accounts for city staff, police department, but how do we make sure that they go to? They're not just living here or what the new part of this community. Once you come to our heads, who want to communicate with us, let us know what's going on. That's where I see the focus. One of the folks that, maybe not this year, but out of the grow that we have constantly look at. Both hit on a very excellent point and that. You know, our ages, we're just one component and a larger system. We don't necessarily have control over the other components in that system and so the greatest challenge that we face as an organization is figuring out how do we work within that system. How do we change the way that we do things? So that we're productive in efficiency or inefficient and meeting the needs of the community. And I think a really good example to a question that you asked about the community. The commercial enforcement officers, you know, how do we measure the effectiveness of that? And. Watching her work over the last 2 years, the greatest impact that she's had is building the professional relationships because we are a busy busy city. That we could not build otherwise for Dan and day out making herself available, getting to know the staff, the management, and where you see the greatest impact is on the repeat offenders and working within that system that has a strong deterrent for isolated events when you can start to build a stronger case when you know who your repeat offenders are. Now you can present something to the district attorney that is gonna have more you know teeth on you and so Eddie as I watched her over the last 2 years and she has done a phenomenal job and I hope she Choose does not leave that position for a very long time, but she has established those professional relationships, which has, you know, improved communication and helped identify these repeat problems and in it's created a product. We can actually. Have movement on in the system that exist as it is. And I think that's a prime example of an effective way of policing, you know, as we move forward is identifying how can we change with the existing system to be more effective and that's something that we're constantly evaluating. But it's a great example. Hello, box. Again, I know we're down. Yeah, future conversations. This was just a Kind of throw it out there and start getting that process going for for all of us. Oh, I think you all are gonna awesome job. Thank you, for sharing that. Information. I know the commercial areas here in the city of. I can't do. Our officers really really apply themselves there and I think you know like I said it's a regional issue. But we definitely There's a difference between the look and fill of our commercial and some of our other communities. So, We'll keep putting that effort in trying to maintain that level of service. Because our community deserves to be able to have a place in their city to go job by their own business product. So. Okay, if there's nothing else on that. We'll move to item 5. And I don't have a little opportunity like we talked about before. The fall, the holiday season is a very, very busy. We have a lot of events. We're involved in a lot of things. Very, very busy. We have a lot of events. We're involved in a lot of things. We do a lot of outreach, a lot of community service, a lot of donations, things like that. By the time we get to January second. So and you can see it and that's when you start to hear, with crack voices and you can see it and that's when you start to hear, with crack voices and, you know, a couple of days off here and there because they need to recover a little bit. So, as far as reporting out in any type of community events, we usually try to keep January, and, if we can, so, I don't have a whole lot for you there. Like I said, we had a great time this year. We enjoyed the holiday break. We're in that. We did a lot of outreach, like the nation's our shopping company was, we had several, several of our employees with, for some of the families that were able to help. So, that told me we're going to. So, that told me we're doing the right direction. So, other than that, the one thing I have, or else on chief report is that there's any agenda items, items you would like to see. You know, things that we're still looking to bring to him. But if you have something that you'd like to see your earphone or revisit from the past. We definitely, you can look to try to get that on the recovery calendar. And if not, I would welcome the German. I'm sure you all would too. And we

65 Civic Avenue Pittsburg, CA 94565 P: (925) 252-6900 F: (925) 252-4814 pittsburgca.gov AGENDA PUBLIC SAFETY SUBCOMMITTEE January 10, 2024 5:30 PM City Hall First Floor Conference Room, 4B 65 Civic Avenue Pittsburg, CA 94565 Subcommittee Members Shanelle Scales-Preston, Council Member Angelica Lopez, Council Member Kesha Hackett, Community Advisory Commission Isabel Romena, Community Advisory Commission 1. Public Comment for Non-Agenda Items 2. Crime Statistics – Staff will provide updated crime statistics. 3. SB 481 Presentation – Staff will provide an overview of Senate Bill 481. 4. Police Department Accomplishments/Goals 24-25 Presentation – Staff will provide an overview of goals for 2023/2024, status updates on those goals, and goals for 2024/2025. 5. Chief’s Report 6. Adjournment

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 January 2024 Public Safety Subcommittee Crime Statistics Review

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 NIBRS Update From Jan – Oct 2023: • 797 Crimes Against Persons | Avg 80/mo • 32% Aggravated Assault • 43% Simple Assault • 5% Fondling • 1,905 Crimes Against Property | Avg 190/mo • 32% Larceny • 25% Motor Vehicle Theft • 16% Vandalism • 330 Crimes Against Society | Avg 33/mo • 65% Drug / Narcotic Violations • 32% Weapons Violations 0 50 100 150 January February March April May June July August September October November December Crimes Against Persons 2022 2023 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 January February March April May June July August September October November December Crimes Against Society 2022 2023 125 175 225 275 325 January February March April May June July August September October November December Crimes Against Property 2022 2023

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 October NIBRS Report

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 DUI Traffic Collisions by Type January 2023 – December 14, 2023

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 2023 Traffic Collisions January – December 2023

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 Military Equipment Funding, Acquisition, and Use by Law Enforcement Agencies 2023 Annual Report

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 BACKGROUND • September 30, 2021 – Gov. Newsom signed Assembly Bill 481 • Increase transparency, accountability, oversight for acquisition and use of “military equipment” • Provide safeguards to protect the public’s welfare, safety, civil rights and liberties • Publics right to know and allows for community engagement

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 HISTORICAL CONTEXT In May of 2022 the Pittsburg City Council adopted a resolution in support of the Pittsburg Police Department’s authorization and continued use of equipment outlined under the newly passed Assembly Bill 481. This authorization was memorialized in Pittsburg Municipal Code 2.64. Requirements outlined in AB 481 includes an annual report and audit of equipment utilization adopted and approved by the Pittsburg City Council. (AB 481 Section 7072(a)) This presentation is a summary of the attached AB 481 annual report and audit.

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 REQUIREMENTS AB 481 requires an annual report to the City Council; PPD’s annual report outlines data collected from January 1st , 2023 through January 1 st , 2024 to include: (1) A summary of how the military equipment was used and the purpose of its use. (2) A summary of any complaints or concerns received concerning the military equipment. (3) The results of any internal audits, any information about violations of the military equipment use policy, and any actions taken in response. (4) The total annual cost for each type of military equipment, including acquisition, personnel, training, transportation, maintenance, storage, upgrade, and other ongoing costs, and from what source funds will be provided for the military equipment in the calendar year following submission of the annual military equipment report. (5) The quantity possessed for each type of military equipment. (6) If the law enforcement agency intends to acquire additional military equipment in the next year, the quantity sought for each type of military equipment.

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 EQUIPMENT CATEGORIES AB 481 lists (15) defined “ Military Equipment” categories. The Pittsburg Police Department has equipment in (6) of these categories

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 PITTSBURG INVENTORY

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 ANNUAL REPORT Audit Results Administrative Staff conducted an AB 481 audit for the calendar year of January 2023 through January 2024. It was determined that all equipment was utilized in accordance with existing Pittsburg Police Department Policy. No equipment was purchased outside of commercial avenues or without prior council approval. All revolving maintenance costs were maintained within projected budgets.

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 REPORT SUMMARY Equipment Utilization Summary and Highlights UAV (Drones) – 127 Flights on 37 Deployments. Deployments include tactical support operations, search and rescue, traffic congestion monitoring, public education and training. Command Trailer – 6 Deployments for DUI check-points Long Rifles and Ammunition – 8,000 rounds of rifle ammunition were utilized for training and qualification purposes only. No in-field deployments. Ballistically Armored Vehicle – 15 Total Deployments. 5 were Pittsburg SRU Operations, 6 were supplemental patrol responses. 4 were Mutual Aid Requests for a Tactical Operations.

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 REPORT SUMMARY Equipment Utilization Summary and Highlights Diversionary Devices – 25 Training Deployments / 8 Field Deployments on a span of 7 Tactical Operations. Chemical Agents – 1 in-field utilization on a warrant service for PC 187 (Murder). All other deployments were training based. Kinetic Energy Weapons (40mm) – 2 Deployments for breaching purposes only. 25 Training Deployments (Less-Lethal Instructor Course and New Hire Orientation).

PITTSBURG POLICE DEPARTMENT Pittsburg Police Department | 925-252-4980 | 65 Civic Ave, Pittsburg CA | 1/5/2024 COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS

1 Police Department Steve Albanese, Chief

2 Goal 1: Traffic Education, Engagement, and Enforcement Plan. Police Department

3 Goal 1: Traffic Education, Engagement, and Enforcement Plan. Police Department

4 Goal 2: Retail / commercial enforcement. Police Department

5 Goal 2: Retail / commercial enforcement. Police Department

6 Goal 3: Staffing analysis for community needs. Police Department

7 Goal 3: Staffing analysis for community needs. Police Department

Goals 2024-2025 Police Department Moving Forward 1. Reduction of Crime 2. 3. 4.

Showing the first 24,000 of 57,375 characters. The full document is at the source.

Yeah. Alright, welcome everyone to tonight's public safety subcommittee. It is January tenth, 2,024 at 5 30 PM. We heard the Civic center building on the first floor. I'm gonna open up the meeting today and check in and say item number one for public comment for non-agendized items. Do we have any public comment? Staying done? Hearing them. We're, we do. I want to recognize we have a new, self committee member, we do, I want to recognize we have a new, committee member, Chelsea member, Chelsea. I want to recognize we have a new, self committee member, as Chelsea, member, Lopez, and I'm looking to list of any objections. We're going to look and take things a little out of order off the agenda. I actually would like to move up item number 3. SB. 41 presentation to the next. A. And so tonight we have tenant Will Hatcher who's going to be with us and he will making the presentation on SP. 41. There you go. That one. So assembly bill, 4 81 is military funding acquisition and used by law enforcement agencies. This is actually the 2023 annual report which is required by that law. Okay, there we go. Alright, a little bit of background in September of 2021. I got an renewing sign assembly bill. 41. The purpose was increasing transparency, accountability. Oversight and any use of military equipment. Now military equipment is a little bit of a misnomer. It's any equipment that is labeled under this law as military equipment. The Pittsburgh PD does not procure or use any prior military surplus equipment. And I'll go a little more in depth as we go through. It also provides safeguards to protect the public's welfare safety and civil rights and deliveries and the public's right to know and allows for community engagement and any equipment that we use, how we utilize it, why we utilize it. And things of those little historical context here in Pittsburgh in May of 2022 the Pittsburgh City Council adopted. Resolution in support of the Pittsburgh Police Department's authorization and continued use. Equipment outlined under the newly passed assembly bill. 41. This authorization was memorialized in its per municipal code 2.6 4. Requirements outlined in 80 41 includes an annual report and audit of equipment utilization adopted and approved by this per city council. This present presentation tonight is a summary of the attached aid employee one annual report and audit. We'll open it up for comments and questions at the end. So requirements under 84 81. And this is going to cover the span. This report January first, 2,023 up until January first at 2024. I'll give you a summary of how the military equipment was used and the purpose of its use. A summary of any complaints or concerns received concerning this military equipment use. The results of any internal audits and the information about violations of military equipment use policy and any actions taken in response. The total annual cost of each type of military equipment, including acquisition, personal training, transportation, maintenance, storage. Upgrade and other ongoing costs and from what source funds they will be procured. For a military equipment, in a calendar year following the submission. So if we were looking to purchase something that was outlined under 481, we would have to come and request that through this process. We're not doing that this year. So it's not gonna be relevant. And the quantity possessed in each type of military, military equipment and its law enforcement agency intends to require additional military equipment like I just said. This is the process in which we go to email. So, equivalent categories, there's 15 defined military equipment categories. The Pittsburgh Police Department has equipped that labeled in 6 of these categories. And those 6 are UAV drones, command trailers, tactical team firearms, a certain caliber, diversionary devices and chemical agents. Kinetic energy weapons and ballistically armored vehicles. At this point, each year, when I draw the comparison to what military equipment is and how we utilize it, I like to use drones as an example. So a lot of our technology that we use. In our profession and commercially and personally privately comes through military technology. Drones is a perfect example. You can go to Walmart today as an average citizen and buy a drone. That technology comes from the military. You can use it as a private citizen. We utilize it in law enforcement. And it serves a very positive purpose. So these are the categories in which we, utilize equipment outlined under 80 41. All right, this year's audit results. Administrative staff conducted an AV 41 audit for the calendar year of January 2023. Through January 2024. It was determined that all equipment was utilized in accordance with existing Pittsburgh police policy. No equipment was purchased outside of commercial avenues. Or without prior council approval, there was no military procurement. Overly maintenance cost. Or maintain within our projected budgets. And the meat potatoes of our summary here. So, for our drones, the first category, we got 127 flights on 37 deployments. Deployments included tactical support operations towards the last few traffic and testing monitoring and public education and training. The next, man trailer, which we have and we utilize that 6 times this year for DUI checkpoints. It just supplements a place to house or officers are going in and out. Long rifles and ammunition. There was 8,000 rounds of ripe ammunition utilized for training and qualification purposes only, no windkill deployments. And ballistically armored vehicle. 15 total deployments this year. 5 work. It's for SRU when you think SWAT SRU operations. 6 were supplemental patrol responses, meaning there was something of a critical nature. We sent our car out to assist patrol in a safety capacity. Forward mutual aid request, for a tactical operations outside of anything we were doing investigative-wise within Pittsburgh. The diversionary devices, that's a flash bang. 25 training deployments. Any field deployments on the span of 7 packical operations. This is a very common tool that we utilize in our tactical operations as a diversionary device. It's so named chemical agents. We had one infilled utilization on a warrant service for a murder suspect. That all other deployments were training base. And last connect energies, which is a 40 it's like a Traditionally, you think of it as a phone for talking around. We had 2 deployments for breaching purposes only. Sometimes we'll utilize those to break out windows on an operation so we don't have to expose officers and put them in a dangerous situation. We use that twice and then the rest of them 25 we're training deployments I left people and shrubber courses and new higher orientation of a memorizing our officers with this. And that includes our presentation during the fourth this year, open it up for comments or questions. Thank you. The only point I have is good job with. With everything. One thing is having the military equipment, but you don't have the systems in place and actually not have operate and utilize. So it's a good job. I like that. It sounds to me like. You guys are very careful. On what to utilize on what situation and so I like that. I have a waste of resources, but I like that. You guys are doing a great job in conserving these resources. And The only one I have is you guys, do you guys feel like? You currently have enough. Or, based on these numbers, are you projecting a higher need for equipment. Yeah, we're always assessing because there's always, you know, trends, updates and technology updates and tactics and in law enforcement we're always assessing that both internally and as a state national level. There's different organizations IACP, Kel chiefs, that are always looking at. More and better ways to utilize the new technology that's coming out and how to keep pubs are safer and keeps community safer. So we're always analyzing that. One thing we've done recently, which is a change from years ago is, we pulled, Traditionally, both seeing police cars would shock up there. We have seen one the lack of use of that type of equipment in the field and to the limited use that it actually has. So we've actually pulled those within the last 18 months out of our patrol vehicles and we've replaced that we're in the process of restoring the cost of replacement with that 40 min millimeter less. It gives us a lot more options, at a patrol, from a control officer, in the past that, system would only be utilized or carried by our supervisors in the field. So our sergeant's in the field or our corporal in the field and as well by our tactical team. But as we looked at different ways to deploy different safety measures, different way it is to utilize techniques and devices in a safe manner to keep and reduce the number of incidents that we have. That was one change. And that's just an example of several things we do. The same thing with like drones. Drones have a shelf life. We utilize our drones as you heard quite a bit. They definitely help us in officer safety measures. They allow us to scan an open field if we're looking for someone maybe armed or even for someone who may be a missing adult, we found several missing persons by flying or drones over and in an open area because it can detect heat. Those will last for long. Eventually they were out the parks were out. And there's new technology, especially that field that we're constantly looking at updated technology. Especially that, that we're constantly looking at updated technology. So as far as the equipment we have, I think the Pittsburgh Police Farm is very well established in equipment and we're very much on the cutting edge of what's out there that we can actually deploy in equipment and very well established in equipment and we're very much on the cutting edge of what's out there, but that we can actually deploy in the manner which it needs to be deployed without waste. So we're always looking at that. And a lot of what you've seen in this report, and, and, IT, IS, the deal with this for 2 years is, you know, this is very much a transparency piece for us. You know, a lot of our items don't really apply to what SP. One wasn't intended for. But we do that to be transparent with the public of a through the equipment we have, sure that we use it, how many times we use it, or open book. Let us know if you have questions. So that's part of it for us. And again, the report, eventually this will go to council, and, the council will get a report that, and after is already completed, and be able for a little bit more detail review, but this is the nuts on the bolts of what that report says. And I think to the chief point, you know, the biggest thing that we're facing is chasing the technology curtain. If you consider your iPhone, you go back 3 generations, it's not the same phone. So what we're finding is we're looking for efficiency and operations and a lot of it is system integration. So as new technology, especially in the drone area comes out, extends our battery light, can integrate with live be to the existing systems that we have. It just makes us more efficient in our operations. So that's something on the horizon. I can see is looking towards it's not necessarily here now and then you know the transparency piece it one of the things that I pride myself on that we do as an organization is something like the armored core, you know, when you think about it, it has a, it has a bad reputation. One of the things that we do to create transparency with the community and educate them is we're bringing that to almost every public event. We added out of the seafood festival, we bring it to national night out, and it gives us an opportunity. One, the kids love it, but to educate the community about what this actually is. This is it's nothing offensive. It's purely defensive and the purpose it serves and we find that when we have that opportunity to come back to the average citizen and explain what this piece of equipment is, it completely changes their perception of what it is, how we utilize it. The importance of keeping our officers safe. So that's something I think as an agency that she's led and we do exceptionally well. Yeah, that the vehicle itself. As a defensive item, but it also it reduces at times that you support that we may be involved in because it's a show of course. So just sometimes that vehicle showing up on scene changes the response that the individual that we're working with may have to focus. And that's all I mean, we're trying to defuse the situation and not use any force at all. And if that's the presence that it takes some time that it has every bit of value is right in that as well as a rescue vehicle should we have to evacuate people safely get them out of the neighborhood. We even used to during the floods last year, you know, the water rises. That's the biggest calls being able to city ask. We can use it for that type of thing. So it's got so many purposes and so much value. And again, it does have a shelf life at some point. We will have to look at some type of replacement for that. With the drones I see that only expanding one of the biggest challenges we have here is our weather. The wind, especially in the later evening, greatly reduces the flying time or the ability of our larger drones to be up in the air and how long they can get up there. So we're looking at different systems like, one they call a tether system, which takes our larger drone that has more capabilities and it literally you attach a power cord that data came into it and we can put it up in the air and leave it up and for 24 h. Because otherwise if you have a wind like we do the night that dr the batteries are over the last 2530 min maybe and then you gotta bring it down and try to replace battery. You lose that, I view whatever you're trying to get. So we're always going to be chasing technology, but again, we pride ourselves on trying to stay right on that edge as fiscally as we can, but right on that edge to keep us there. I mean. To the point that our body cameras that are officers where those are on a 2 and a half year old. That's how fast that technology changes just like books. So every our contract with the vendor is every 2 and a half years we will get new body cameras. We know the technologies are even changed by that. Great questions. Thank you. But what you consider a body camera. But we initially we were one of the broad runners, in this area. But we initially, we were one of the front runners, in this area in the Bay Area. So our original first body cameras that we started experimenting with or where our original first body cameras, in this area in the Bay Area. So our original first body cameras that we started experimenting with were really these pocket cameras that we ordered off Amazon that you would stick in your, Pocket or your press populator and have a little tiny camera in the battery power. And then the battery power, 20 min or so. Before that we were doing a micro number cassette recorders or digital recorders that we would carry on our belts or in our pocket. And that's kind of where we started. Our work would see the vendor that we currently have. We're probably, yeah, probably like, 40, 14 is when we started looking at a full system that integrates everything that they have to offer. But actually one of the few agencies that went to body cans before there was a societal bush. Right. Just got ahead of that curve and watched them hold and now we're at a point where you know speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, we're at a point where, you know, speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, so much that our new body cameras now, that you know, speaking of technology is advanced so much that our new body cameras now, that you, from an operational standpoint. from the station, we can log on and see officers making an entry into a house and watch their perspective from their body cam lifetime. And so when you talk about, you know, making the best decisions and shortest amount of time with the most information. It's been it's been a very valuable tour. And this generation of your it's just part of how they do least work. They don't know without it. And I don't think they would want to do it, but not again. It's a game cheering for us for safety. You know, one thing we talk about is should an officer not be responsive on radio for the total call and all. But we'll hear from them. The supervisor can don't want their issue phone or under the computer and instantly log on power up that camera and see exactly what's going on. So it may just be that their radio failed. It's not community more or they may be in a physical education or you know they may be you know injured or some sort and they can communicate that's that's a huge difference for us when it comes to the Oscar safety factor and again this next generation awesome this is all they know so they fully embrace the technology part of it. It's completely different when I start. That's not, we, had to show radios. So, yeah. And, and, and have like, any, any, and operating without technology. No, that's only known. And which is great because as we introduced the technology, GPS systems, things like that, there' There was a culture change that had to take place. There was there was an education level. There had to be some buy-in from the staff and that that was a that's started under Chief Addington. That was probably a 3 plus year process to where the staff finally bought into having that type of technology of, you know, being being watched basically of everything you do. That's a big change. And now those features now, support our officers more than they in room. And there are interviews. So. Any other questions? Alright, thank you, so we will now move to item, let's go back to item number 2 on crime stats. And as we get this started. And I know we have a new number here with us, but, we've done a lot of work. Throughout 2023 as the city and the department transitioned from the UCR to the unified of crime reporting status to the UCR, the Unified of Crime Reporting Status to the Unified of Crime Reporting Status to the NIBR system, the national incident based reporting system. And with that transition, the national incident based, reporting system. And with that transition, comes some delays. So we originally transitioned, and with that transition, comes some delay. So we originally transitioned again that work in June of 2022. And we're still kinda catching up on the back end. I think we finally got our Neighbor's numbers. Through November, they just came out earlier this week. So, the numbers that I'll be going through tonight I'll be working with are a kind of a snapshot of the first 9 months of 23 because we haven't quite closed out the data for all 23 so I'll kind of walk through that a little bit and and answer some questions. We goes because it's a little, it's difficult for us to interpret the transition and compare. 2022 and beyond because the way this system we collect a lot more data under. So we get under the UCR. So we have to kind of make some inference on what that looks like. So this first the first slide here again goes from January to October or 23 and we do have a comparison from 22 to 23 to 22 in the blue line and again that starts in June, 22 in the blue line and again that starts in June because that's when we started bringing in. 2322 in the blue line. And again, that starts in June, cause that's when we started bringing in, numbers numbers. And then we have, the red line is incorporating all 23 up to the point of October 30 first. So you can see as we've heard across over the lines, we're pretty comparable, 23 up to the point of October thirty-first. So you can see as we start across over the lines, we 2023 crimes against persons. It's been fairly steady and we see a little increases here and there. But for the most part, or being very, very consistent. Again, it's very hard to compare. You're in here right now because we don't have a complete data set. But you can kind of see the numbers off the side. There are 797 crimes against persons from the first 9 months of the year. And then it breaks it down 23% or 2232% for aggregated salts, 43 simple salts and then we have some the sexual salt following classifications have changed under NYVERS versus you see there's a lot more classifications that work with. So we're interpreting this on where they fit in under some tribes. So the technical listing comes under. We moved down to property crimes. Again, in 22 we saw a pretty big spike in the summer months and what we're looking at is for within specifically, the, the, the, vandalism, average of a hundred 90 of those crimes throughout the month. But again 23 has been very consistent online we're not seeing big spikes like we did in the previous years. That can be incorporated to several things. There's obviously some changes in society from 2020 to 2,023. We're starting to see a lot of these things kind of paper off. We're starting to see a lot of these things kind of taper off. We are in the city when I look at some of the other members that are on the table here, you know, we're seeing an increase a little bit in vehicle, motor vehicle deaths in the last couple months. A lot of the communities around us are seeing similar spikes, so it's a regional regional issue that we're looking at. But you can see our thefts are 32% of those 1,900 and then, And then we look at crimes against society. Those are more of your, more your public nuisance type crimes. A person on the influence of alcohol or drugs, a person in possession of alcohol or drugs or weapons violations, sort of drivers. So you can see again in June, the 22, we have a really high number there. Coming out of Maine when you got those numbers and it kind of settled down again. 23 is fairly level. We're seeing a little spikes and movements that are in there of over averaging about 33 cases a month. Now, laws of change, prosecution levels on certain crimes like this have changed. That can all contribute to some of the enforcement actions that take place in these types of crimes. But those are kind of the averages overseeing here. And I'll other than that. Don't look at that. Right after that, there we go. A little bit more detail. These are the kind of numbers we've been presenting to, public safety cell community last couple months. This is us interpreting Neighbors as much as we can to the classic UCR crime classifications that we're all used to kind of hear you're seeing about part one crimes and you're about to use and things like that. So these are really the numbers that we look at on a regular basis. You can see, October 23 is in the red column there and then October 22 for comparison is in the the call next tutor just to the right and you can see you are every results actually we have had a drop in October by 40% our sexual offenses kind of stayed actually had an increase but again those classifications have changed. Human trafficking obviously law enforcement is very aggressive in even trafficking type cases. We have several of our detectives that are very involved in human trafficking cases. In fact, some of them are instructors throughout the state and actually going, being requested throughout the state, the nation to do classes. So you've seen a little bit of a spike there because they have a very strong interest in combating human trafficking. Robbery cases for October drop a little bit and we're talking, just a couple of numbers here, burglaries for about even a little bit of a drop. Those large, to me, to have some of the people that, again, I talked about they spiked a little bit and that's kind of a regional thing that we're seeing retail theft vehicle theft. We're seeing a little

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Public Safety Subcommittee
  • Public Safety Subcommittee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8ceee68eed46495597fde85090bd42f7. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record