POLISCOPE

The public record

ST. LUCIE COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Board of Adjustments Meeting

Wednesday, August 28, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Board of Adjustments Meeting (2024-08-28)

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Regular Meeting August 28, 2024 Convened: Adjourned: 1. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Special Magistrate, Richard V. Neill, Jr. at 9:32am. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The pledge was led by Special Magistrate Neill 3. ROLL CALL 4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the 6/26/2024 Meeting Minutes was deferred by Special Magistrate Neill to the 9/25/2024 meeting. 5. SWEAR IN STAFF MEMBERS The Board Secretary, Joseph Sabater, swore in St. Lucie County staff as follows: 1. Kori Benton, Planning Manager, Planning & Development Services 2. Thad Crowe, Sr. Planner, Planning & Development Services 3. Thomas Reetz, Planner II, Planning & Development Services (Sworn in later during meeting, before Agenda Item 7. B.) 6. PUBLIC COMMENTS None 7. AGENDA ITEMS A. 127 Queen Christina Ct., Patterson Residence: Variance request to reduce the 15 foot front setback to 14.5 feet to permit a 6ft. tall fence (after the fact). Kori Benton, Planning Manager for the Planning & Development Services’ Planning Division, provided preface to the Variance request. Mr. Benton noted that a local newspaper ad was published, signage was posted on the premises, and notices were mailed to property owners within 500 feet. He explained that the request is to reduce the front setback on a site located

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, August 28, 2024 9:30 AM 2 | P a g e within the private community of Queens Cove on North Hutchinson Island. In 1976, the Board of Adjustment, at that time, granted a blanket variance for Unit 1, reducing the front setback for all lots within Unit 1 from 25 feet, the standard RS4 front setback, down to 15 feet. In 2022, it was highlighted by County staff that a 6-foot tall fence had been erected on the premises of the petition site outside of the front setback and in the absence of a required permit. Subsequently, the property owner filed a permit in 2022. Mr. Benton discussed provisions in the Land Development Code that allow for up to 6 inches of discretionary setback relief. However, there's a section or two of the fence that is just outside of this 6 inch discretionary setback with the closest point to the front property line at 14.14 feet. Mr. Benton informed that the property owner had presented a building permit to the planning staff that morning, which had been filed in 2022. Although the permit was initially rejected by the Zoning team due to the fence being six feet tall within the front 25-foot setback, staff later approved it. This approval was based on a sketch overlaid on an older survey provided by the fence contractor, showing the fence at a minimum of a 16-foot front setback. Additionally, the fence’s valuation was presented as being under $6,000. Under a provision in the Land Development Code, improvements valued at less than $10,000, including fences, do not require a survey. Upon resubmittal, the Zoning team reviewed the plans showing the 16-foot minimum setback, acknowledged the 1976 variance that applied, and approved the permit on or around August 14, 2024. The fence passed inspection two days later, and the permit is now considered closed. The home’s front façade is currently at 11.5 feet, which is less than the 15-foot setback required by the 1976 variance. Mr. Benton outlined several options for the Special Magistrate to consider: (1) grant the variance allowing the fence, which, according to a new updated survey, is approximately 14.14 feet from the front property line but still behind the front façade; (2) continue the matter to allow staff time to consult with the Building Official to confirm if the permit is closed without issues; (3) offer no opinion on the variance or reject it, with the guidance to County staff that the existing fence, which was properly permitted, inspected, and closed out, should be classified as a legal nonconforming structure if it does not meet the 15-foot setback. This would allow the fence to remain in place, but any future replacement would need to comply with the 15-foot setback requirement, given County policy related to a $10,000 valuation and the need for an updated modern survey; or (4) grant the variance, considering the circumstances and findings of fact, with the condition that if or when the fence is replaced in the future, it must adhere to the minimum 15-foot setback. This would prevent any immediate financial hardship for the applicant, given the fence's age and the absence of objections from neighbors or the HOA, while ensuring future compliance with the 1976 variance. Mr. Benton presented the inspection worksheet from the Building Division to the Special Magistrate, confirming that the inspection passed with an exhibit indicating a 16-foot setback. He noted the initial denial from Zoning, which was based on a required 25-foot setback, as well as the approved permit. Additionally, he provided a side-by-side exhibit,

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, August 28, 2024 9:30 AM 3 | P a g e showing on the left what was submitted to the Building Division for the permit issuance, and on the right, a more recently updated survey that includes a more specific measurement from the front property line. Discussion Mr. Neill sought clarification regarding the details of the original survey submitted with the fence permit. Mr. Benton explained that the original survey provided by the fence contractor indicated the fence's location as being at least 16 feet; however, this survey predated the fence installation, and the date of the survey was cut off in the exhibit. He further clarified that a more recent survey conducted by Alexander Piazza in March 2024 was included in the Agenda Packet, along with another survey conducted by Hayhurst Land Survey, which the applicant provided earlier that day on August 28, 2024, and which was handed to the Special Magistrate. Mr. Neill inquired whether the permit issued in August 2024 was based on the original application from 2022 and whether Mr. Benton believed the contractor's intention was to maintain a 16-foot distance from the front property line or wherever the setback is measured from. Mr. Benton confirmed that the permit issued in August was indeed based on the original application, which contained a consistent survey. He also expressed his belief that the intent was to maintain the 16-foot setback, as indicated by emails discussing the aim to screen the mechanical equipment beside the home while remaining behind the front façade. Applicant Presentation Ms. Patterson stated that the original fence was installed in 2017, and in September 2022, she repaired only the front section of the fence, as the sides were not damaged by the storm. She explained that the repair caused an issue due to the irregular shape of the lot. In February 2024, she received a call requesting that she either move the fence or reduce its height to four feet. However, the rest of the property had a six-foot fence, and reducing part of it to four feet would have created an uneven appearance. Ms. Patterson realized that this imbalance would have negatively impacted the look of the house, and she did not have the resources to make the necessary adjustments. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DECISION Mr. Neill stated that, considering the contractor’s intention to maintain a 16-foot distance, there is no fault on the part of the property owner. He added that there was no reason for the property owner to have known that the location was problematic until the issue was brought up long after the original fence was built. He also noted the initial confusion and mistake by staff about the applicable setback. Mr. Neill agreed to grant the variance as requested, with the condition that if, in the future, the fence needs to be taken down and reinstalled, the proper setback requirements should be met at that time. B. 5615 Buchanan Drive - Desantis Variance Request for a Detached Garage in the Rear and Side Yards Thomas Reetz, Planner II for the Planning & Development Services’ Planning Division, presented the variance request filed by Sean DeSantis and LaShara Lindberger. The petition

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, August 28, 2024 9:30 AM 4 | P a g e seeks a variance from the provisions of St. Lucie County Land Development Code, Section 7.04.01, Table 7-10, which outlines the lot size and dimensional requirements for the RS-3 (Residential Single-Family 3) Zoning District. Mr. Reetz proposed that a detached garage be allowed to encroach 5.25 feet into the required 15-foot rear yard setback, leaving a setback of 9.75 feet, and encroach 3.5 feet into the required 10-foot side yard setback, leaving a side setback of 6.5 feet. The subject property is located east of the Tropical Isles and Groves PUDs and abuts the North St. Lucie Canal District's Canal No. 22 right-of-way in the Indian River Estates neighborhood. The site is zoned RS-3 and is 9.1 acres in size, whereas the minimum lot size requirement for this zoning district is 10,000 square feet. The RS-3, single-family zoning district requires a 15-foot rear setback and a 10-foot side setback, as outlined in the code. Mr. Reetz also stated that the requested variance could result in visual impairments for the surrounding property owners. The proposed structure, a detached garage, is approximately 101 feet from the house to the northwest of the subject parcel and around 203 feet from the house to the southwest. Mr. Reetz then noted that the applicant provided a slide illustrating the trees that would need to be removed without the variance. The image showed a view looking west, highlighting the tree foliage along the canal at the rear property line. This includes the laurel oak that would be removed to accommodate the proposed detached garage. He noted that Canal No. 2 currently has plans and funding in place for the Sun Trail, which runs directly behind the site. This trail is expected to connect the South Savannahs area to the Savannahs Recreational Area to the North. Mr. Reetz stressed that the standards of review for the variance indicate that it arises from conditions unique to the land in question, and the requested setback relief would help minimize the loss of on-site trees compared to alternative placements, potentially avoiding hardship. He concluded that granting the variance is not expected to impair or harm other properties or improvements in the neighborhood. Mr. Benton stated that Staff recommends approval of the variance request, believing it arises from conditions unique to the property, particularly its adjacency to the North St. Lucie River Water Control District's Canal No. 2, and the potential to minimize impacts to on-site trees compared to alternative placements. After reviewing the petition, staff has determined that it generally conforms to the standards of review outlined in St. Lucie County's Land Development Code, Section 10.01.02. The recommendation for approval is also based on the fact that, in the absence of easements on the property, the request may have qualified for an administrative variance, specifically the 35% variance. For context, an aerial view of the rear yard shows the approximate location of the proposed garage and the 25-foot utility easement. The applicant has contacted the utility providers, and all have confirmed either that they are not affected or that they agree with the proposal. Mr. Benton noted that Mr. Reetz‘s response indicated that the factors presented are not the sole rationale or singular reason for granting a variance in this case. He cited the adjacent property and the development pattern in the area, while also acknowledging that under the Board of County Commissioner's more recent ordinance, up to 35% setback relief can be authorized through an administrative variance process. In the absence of unused easements, the applicant received feedback from various utility companies indicating they do not have

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, August 28, 2024 9:30 AM 5 | P a g e existing infrastructure or plans to develop infrastructure in the area. The culmination of these factors led staff to support this variance. Mr. Benton mentioned that, with a single favorable response, if the same mailing had been titled "administrative variance" instead of "Board of Adjustment," the findings and outcome would likely have resulted in authorization. He based this opinion on the Environmental Resources Department's on-site visit and their report to the Planning staff. Discussion Magistrate Neill inquired whether it would be fair to assume that, if not for the setback being the required utility easement, staff would have granted the variance administratively. Mr. Benton explained that the qualifier indicating the variance may have been eligible was included for context. He noted that it was identified as a full Board of Adjustment variance rather than an administrative variance. A key aspect of the administrative variance process is that no more than 10% of the property owners within a 500-foot radius can object. If 10% or more object, staff is unable to grant the variance. The variance requested is the minimum necessary to enable reasonable use of the land, building, or structures. Additionally, the variance does not conflict with the purpose and intent of the Land Development Code, which aims to preserve, protect, and improve the public's general welfare. Applicant Presentation Mr. DeSantis clarified that while it was previously mentioned that the property is 9.1 acres, it is 0.91 acres. Mr. DeSantis is requesting the maximum allowed setback of 35%, as stated in the county code, to optimize the use of the property as a whole and to minimize the removal of native vegetation and the subsequent need for planting other trees. The ERD informed him that the removal of one oak tree does not require on-site compensation, as the current vegetation qualifies for that compensation. Additionally, native vegetation will be planted around the shed to enhance the garden. He mentioned that the property is well-vegetated and that from the beginning of the planning process, he had always intended to place a shed in that area, which had been the most open even prior to his plantings. Throughout the process of landscaping the yard and developing the garden, he realized that this variance was necessary, which is the reason for his presence today. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DECISION Mr. Neill stated that he would grant the variance as requested. He noted that the trees, including native species, that would need to be removed from the specified area or elsewhere on the property represent a condition that is unique and peculiar to this property, warranting a variance. He also pointed out that the administrative variance procedure is available and would likely have been granted for the same reasons analyzed by staff, were it not for the utility easement at the rear of the property. Mr. Neill accepted the evidence that the utilities involved have no objection to granting the variance, which further justifies its approval. He concluded that the staff's analysis supports the variance, and based on those grounds,

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, August 28, 2024 9:30 AM 6 | P a g e along with those outlined by staff, the variance will be granted. 8. OTHER BUSINESS 9. ANNOUNCEMENTS 10. ADJOURN Adjourned at 10:21am.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of Adjustments Meeting (2024-08-28)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8bf9bff26e7f89ab865e13add6eae744. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record