POLISCOPE

The public record

MARTIN COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners on 2018-11-13 9:00 AM

Tuesday, November 13, 2018 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Board of County Commissioners on 2018-11-13 9:00 AM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 83,092 stored characters

>>> good morning, everybody. I would like to call the November 13, 2018 board of county commissioners meeting to order. It is a very exciting day for us here. On the commission, we will start with an invocation by pastor dave albers, from the re deemer lutheran church follow ed by the prejudice of allegiance. If you would all stand. Good morning, pastor. >> well, lord, as we look forward to the national day of thanksgiving, May every day be a day of thanksgiving, because your blessings are new every morning. We will thank you for the blessings of this day and great grateful hearts for the community in which we live. I pray for the commission that they would work as best stewards of all the resources you give us each and every day. We pray also, that the state elections would come to adjust in an amicable end and that the correct candidates be put in place. We thank you that we live in nation and we don't have to pick up arms if elections don't turn out the way we like but we can truly love one another and help one another and be a neighbor to one another. I pray this all in jesus' name. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you very much. >> let me statute forethe record, that commissioner smith will not be attending today's meetings so all of our votes will have him absent from the vote calculations. We have one additional item. It is a consent item. Consider resolution regarding a policy with exit commissioners for out going dishers no consent agenda pulls. Couple of requests to continue to November 20th. Consent five. Agricultural and natural resources appointments. And this is the revised pud zoning agreement. Revised master site plan. And phasing plan that was pulled at the applicant's request and that was pulled by commissioner smith. We don't have additional items at this time. I would entertain a motion to approve the agenda as presented >> so moved. >> we have a motion and second. All those in favor. Aye. Opposed. Motion carries unanimously. Can you say unanimously. We have public comment. The first one. Two very familiar faces for a lot of folks but not for everyone. Amanda jones and brian johnson. Glad to have you this morning. >> thank you. I am brian johnson. Amanda jones, we are the art teachers at martin county high school. We have a project that we are presenting that is in process right now. kim jones of the prescription shop in downtown stuart, approached us about painting a mural on her building. It is a 70-foot long wall, 12 to 14 feet high. And we went and we had a couple of meetings discussing what subject matter to do and with this mural and we decided on the history of martin county. And we do have, we will present , what the final design is. But, we would definitely like to thank regal paint center. They donated the pain. Miss Jones has donated the materials and the scaffolding and, of course, the wall. And, of course, the city of stuart with the crb donated or comped the application fee for the minor urban code. So, without further ado, I think, we will. >> Miss Kryzda. >> never mind. , then, if you can show it this way first and then turn it around. I have been watching the progress. It is awesome. >> pretty cool. >> very cool. >> fantastic. >> this is it. And this is the mural in it final form. Interest will be a larger section at the end with a sailfish on it and the rays continue out on to that part of the building. >> can you tell us, who are the individuals on. >> from left to right, that is felix a williams. He was the teacher of the year in 1956. He also helped start the special olympics in florida. 500 east ocean is behind him. And, of course pineapple is below him. And, of course the feed store and then caid county pine which many of the buildings were built out of and especially in the early days and then in front of the building is governor martin, who the county is named after meeting with seminole indian chief. I can't recall his name at the time. That is also governor martin in the in the middle. House of refuge and then this is hubert bessie, he owned a lot of the land in the area. He donated. The reason we have confusion corner instead of confusion sewall's point, because he donated flagler, wanted to run the railroad through sewall's point and he didn't want that and he donated the land. And asked flagler. And said. I will give you $200 plus the land and flagler said I don't need the money but I will take the land. So, that is hubert bessie, and stuart watts called potsdam before it was stuart. This is trapper nelson. And then we will have the sailfish up on the right and there is a chrysanthemum on there. >> a chrysanthemum is on there. >> yes. >> it is more interesting from that view. >>. >> so, we are about, 75% finish ed maybe a little less. And we are taking. We are going to be there this weekend painting again. That will be our fifth weekend. Then we are taking a weekend off after thanksgiving and then we will be back at it for probably two more weekends. So. >> that is fantastic. >> lovely. >> the gold paint will be a metallic gold. It is already up. We already tested. It. We are keeping in hurricane katrina high school is blue and gold isn't stuart is blue and gold, so, we are keeping in line with that. So. >> couple of comments. >> I would like to say thank you, too. It turned out to be more than I ever thought. I bought the pharmacy five year s ago. And every morning, there was a big blank wall and it stood out it would be nice if someone could paint on it. So, I went to the city. How about if the art department does it at the school. Would that be okay. They were like. We never had that and present something. So, when I called amanda, yes, I would like to do that. >> it turned into something so much more than I thought and it is realry cool. Anybody who wants to come and help paint on the weekend. They are there. Mostly and the students. we have had a lot of people from everywhere. >> you are taking volunteers to help. >> always. >> art teachers did not agree with that. They had straight faces when you said that. I wanted to recognize chick-fil-a in stuart. They donated lunch for all painters. And sandwiches and lemonade and it is just a great experience for the kids. Also, there is a grant now available. So, I shared that with all the art teachers in martin county. They can apply for the grant if they have a wall. They would like to paint, too. >>. >> couple of points, the familiar he is a is at the round about at colorado and martin luther king, right where the fountain is. And so, if you, know. >> from the mart martin county cleaners. >> martin luther king, where the supervisor of elections is. It is right at the round with. You can't Miss It. I knew the project was coming. My daughter has had both of you >> are you the teacher of the year. >> for the high school. >> you are the martin county teacher of the year. Congratulations. >> some day kids will paint a mural with your picture on it. And then also, what I would like to say is that there are, hobe sound has done a remarkable job creating an environment where people are looking to come now and see the seeds of buildings that up until recently meant nothing. If you are familiar with wind ward walls down in miami. That was an area that was like an old warehousing district and now, it is the top tourist destinations. I have been down there with my kids and they are posing for pictures. If you go on facebook and you see the bright colored murals. You know everyone is down there I would love to see that continue. I will be contacting you, folks we have a couple of large walls in palm city. I know there are large walls and in inside indiantown as well. So, I am very much looking forward to working with you all and the other schools. If you remember, the last time we had a project similar to this is when the bathroom facility at the stuart beach. >> brenda lee, I know, it is like brenda lee had done a remarkable job with the kids down in jensen and also down in the birling in hobe sound -- building in hobe sound beach. It is a way to enhance the community and congratulations. Actually. I just walked passed that. Brenda lee did that as well. >> brenda rehelped with -- brenda helped with this project nadia and we have homegrown talent right here. Not just the students but the grown ups. Stephanie ranieri is here. She does a lot of artistic endeavor vors as well. >> thank you. Congratulations. >> next request to speak form is erin smith. >> good morning. >> good morning. Hi, how are you. Thank you for having me today and to kind of piggyback on the teachers. I am here as a representative, of hobe sound and I ask for the opposition of the high speed train, that is potentially going to come through martin county. Four years ago, a child was hit by a train in hobe sound. It was a friday night. And we were all at the soccer field and sorry. But the fear that you have when a child is hit by a train and% the soccer field is cleared because tram ma hawk has to come down and you don't know where your child is. Because there was such chaos. I don't think any of us want to experience that ever again. Thankfully, that child was not a fatality. And I just. >> I know that having a high speed train. Coming through. >> that could potentially happen. >> also, obviously, with the popularity of golf carts with family. Trying to pile them up and get them over a train track. I wouldn't want to see what could happen. So. >> thank you, ma'am. >> for your heartfelt comments. We appreciate it. >> and interesting, next speak er, is doug smith. >>. >> Mr. Smith, you are supposed to be sitting up here I believe >> maybe some day. >> thank you for having me this morning. By the way. >> pretty much a life long resident of hobe sound. Hobe sound the last few months and we haven't forgot be about the train and we have been inun dated with hobe sound and the midterm elections. There was an article that came out, I believe on October 22, in tc palm that stated that the city of stuart is going to get on board with entertaining and put a depot in downtown stuart. That terrifies us residents of hobe sound. If stuart gets on board, jensen beach will get on board and all of palm city will get on board to allow the bright line to come through the area. >> for hobe sound, as you probably know, once the train clears the curb out of jonathan dickinson, heading north to the vw, near mariner sands. About a 5 mile stretch. If those trains get up to 100 miles an hour. Originally pulling passenger trains. We know what is behind that is the big powered freight trains coming out of the ports. If that train derails at those speeds. It is catastrophic for the residents on gomez and dock myers park where our kid play soccer, there is not even a chain link fence around that park. i would hate to see what would happen. So, I urng you as the county commissioners. I know there is a ruling coming out at the end of the month about continuing funding. Please fight against the railroad. I guarantee you and I don't want it to happen, if we get the train. It is disastrous at some pint and it could be political suicide for some of you guys. I know our town of hobe sound will be up here. I am just one of many. Very active in the community and I hear the concerns. That's why I am here today and I appreciate your time. Thank you. >> thank you, sir. Appreciate that. >> our next and last request to speak form. If you want to address us this morning, you can after the next speaker. You can speak first and fill the form out afterward is Mr. Tom pine. >> Mr. Pine, good morning, sir. >> good morning, commissioners. I live in jensen beach, florida I have been a resident for over 45 years in martin county. >> she said when I showed pictures, it could easily understand what I was speaking of, and what particular area of town I was speaking. I was kind of stunned or overwhelmed at the time because I show pictures at every meting -- meeting. >> I said this is how the county goes about keeping the views that I don't consider out of of the public. as much as possible. So, I went home to view the past meetings. The last six meetings that I showed pictures. They were not shown. >> Chairman Of the board defend ed the fact that no one showed up as town hall meetings relative to the fire assessment tax. Saying that many times people don't show up to town hall meetings and I agreed. Once the quote, the letter get sent out, the meetings there after were pack. -- packed. The same thing is happening by not allowing me to show picture s. It is a way of controlling the pub public from what they say at the commission meetings. >> code enforcement uses pictures all the time at meetings. And they are televised. Is it only county employees that are the only ones to allow to view pictures: have the rules changed and I haven't caught up with it? I read, every time I show a picture. I have to show up at least a day early to have them approved which I have done, the Chairman Has checked several times. With the county administrator to make sure these pictures, have, in fact, been approved. They get approved, and someone al link the line they don't get shown. >> it just seems, doesn't seem right to me. Censorship is not only will you illegal, it is immoral. and it is obvious, we have roast our moral compass in martin county. Thank you. >> thank you, Mr. Pine. Miss Kryzda. >> couple of questions. >> can you look into what Mr. Pine said. I assume when we show his pictures on the dot cam here. Is there is an rule that we are not showing his pictures. >> not necessarily. With you we don't normally comment during public comment. So an individual can show something and make statements that we don't have an opportunity to necessarily address or to come back we have add situations where we showed the pictures ahead of time to make sure. And I guess the question is: is the county commission want ing toe be -- to be inform ed or the purpose of public comment for the whole general public or how do you want to handle it. Prior to us. And sometimes we don't have the D.O.T. Cam that works and we are criticized that we are do ing that because a certain individual had something they wanted to put on the D.O.T. Cam and the dot cam was broken. It puts us in the dynamic. >> individuals are not happy one way or another. >> okay. I can speak for my colleagues. I will tell you how I feel. I believe the policy of individuals showing up with pictures that you or one of your delegates has not had the opportunity to see ahead of time can be a potential problem and when you created the problem that someone wanted to show a photograph, or use the dot cam, which for the folks don't know is the camera in the ceiling that lays on the table and you can lay pictures flat and see them. You thought the policy created, someone would have to have your approval ahead of time. Handle that and allow the folks to show pictures. I don't have an issue with that I see your point. >> whether it is Mr. Pine or someone else and has gone through the effort to bring them and you have approved them and then they show the pictures at a dat come to us who is here I have no problem, that those pictures would be shown object channel 20, because you have seen them and vetted them in terms of whether they were offensive. >> now, opinion resist opinions and the public comment. A lot of that is opinion. If it was all going to be ex sluflly fact based then quite often, it wouldn't be comments. But, that is the, I personally agree that that is the way the system should work. We do ourselves a disservice if we some how sensor those pictures. If you need an agenda item or motion. I thought if they showed up on the D.O.T. Cam. They were part of the meeting. The televise veezed meeting. The vetting process of you see ing them ahead of time is enough for me. And if the pictures are, you know, sort of don't show the county and in its best light and they are accurate pictures that you felt were appropriate. At least to be shown to the general public. Then that is that. And we can address the issues and debate whether someone's opinion of what the county is doing is accurate. Mr. Pine has said the chair. Some of what he said even at this meeting. I would disagree with. But I agree with his opportunity to say it. That is my opinion. Commissioner heard has her light object. >> it is part of public comment if the photos have been pre approved, we see them. We have seep them every single time. I assume the public was seeing them, too, because it is not a complete comment if they can see the photos we are looking at. It is imperative that the photo s be shown. As I recall, every one of Mr. Pine's comments are intend ed to be constructive. Every one of them. He points out safety matters. Code enforcement irregularities he is trying to make our county better. Every time. And I think it is real important that we help him along. I want my county to improve. >> we respond to them, commissioner heard. But, like I said. We had a situation where the dot cam was not working and we were not able to show the photo s and we got criticized that it was intentional and we didn't have a chance to respond to that. It is not the intent that we had equipment failure. So, we decided in abundance of caution so we are not being put in the situation of choosing one over another and there is no censorship. Every photo he has shown. He has shown to the board. It is not like we picked and choose photos. I have no problem. I had delegated that down to individuals and so, I will go back and say, it has got to be me. I have to come and look at the photos and make sure. Then, when I say. This isn't appropriate and this is. Then, we are put in that situation. So, what ever the board chooses , we will do. >> we can address it this morning. Commissioner fielding. And I guess the others had expressed my perception as well and as a public forum. It is an opportunity. We happen to be here because we are trying to make decisions and so we get information. It is not just a limited one way kind of information. It is a public forum and so I fully support that as pepght -- aspect of it and as to the evaluation of pictures and whatever mute be shown. It does need to be reviewed in the sense that it not be something that would be offensive to the general public so, in that sense, if I might happen to disagree with it, hey , I disagree with myself sometimes. I am not opposed to disagreeing >> what I do believe is that we need to be open. And available am and if it it is something that teppedz to picture an activity that we wish weren't happening that way that gives us an opportunity to% focus in. Some has been expressed. Thank you. >> thank you. >> I agree. And the boundary of, Miss Kryzda, you said one thing, that you have delegated some of those authority to others to view the photographs. It does not need to be exclusively be you. If you are a busy person. That you are here and if you were to pick the top people that obviously we trust enough to run departments and someone from legal. And it is not just a matter of what would be offensive if it is. And inappropriate. I agree with what commissioner heard said. Whether Mr. Pine comes forward. Using you as an example. When you come forward with your photographs. I too, agree, that nearly, in every instance, they were pictures that were information al and I agree with what you said Miss Kryzda and commissioner heard about constantly improving. I thought a lot of the information that Mr. Pine has brought forward has been beneficial for us as an organization. I agree that his underlying motivation is to make this a better community. I welcome it. I see your point and you didn't cavalierly say we are not going to show his pictures. But the televised portion of the meeting whether it is live and complete representation of how the meeting went. I do know that one day the dot cam was broken. And we can all understand. If the dat come was bloken and if his pictures weren't shown over the course of several meetings or when the dot cam was broken, I said broadway bak the photos and give him double time to make his original comments again. >> look, I want him to bring them forward. We all do. None of us are owe opposed or afraid of what we are doing and to hold it up to the light of day or criticism is appropriate so, would you want official. You are fine with the understanding. >> show the pictures as long as they have been approved. >> yes. >> Mr. Pine, thank you, sir. >> I concur with all of that. >> thank you. >> that was our last request to speak form. Anyone else that would like to address us. Now is the time. Seeing none, we will move onto the proclamations. We have several. Very worthwhile organization that is we will be recognizing this morning. Our first proclamation is farm city week. >> that is declaring farm city week in martin county, florida. Miss Bow pray, welcome. >> peaupre. >> ranchers help meet the world and rely on partnerships to sell products to consumers. November 14 true 21st is recognized as farm city week in martin county. The board encourages all citizens to recognize the achievements of those who provide the amazing abundance of ak cultural products that we all enjoy. We have rick and reed martin. From the martin county farm bureau. >>> rick heartman for the record. Commissioner fielding. Thank you for your service. Last eight years have been, you have really put yourself out there. I know it has been difficult for you. But I thank you for your service. >> wow, okay. >> our next request. >> our next proclamation is alzheimer's disease awareness month. >> November is recognized as alzheimer's disease awareness month and they provide services to provide vital care and support and for dementia specific care and support alzheimer's families in finding a cure. Here to accept. We have been any johnson and jonathan price. And dora sander from the alzheimer's association south east florida chapter. >>> good morning, I am doris sanders from the alzheimer's association. On behalf of the more than 5 million people in the you state and their 16 million caregivers, and this is important, 240,000 of those are in the state of florida. Second only to california. 6,500 of those alzheimer's people are in martin county. And so, I come to say, how thankful we are for you. How much we appreciate your support. Alzheimer's support, alzheimer's association has three main emphasis and that is awareness, education and re search. So, we appreciate anything that you can do to help us with awareness. We are so grateful for the support that we are getting for government, because that is the only way we are going to defeat this disease. So. On the city, county. State and national levels, we are receiving support and we appreciate it. In fact, this year, in the budget for the federal budget, we were granted $425 million through the national institute of health for research. The reason I am excited about that is because that amount brings us to what director collins of the nih said we need in order to slow down or pre vent and cure this disease. >> we thank you for your help. we believe every tiny sliver of awareness helps people to know what alzheimer's is. And how destructive it is and one of the leading causes of death and the only one with no cure. No treatment and no progress. On that level for a good while. So, we are really trying to and we appreciate so much your help as we struggle to end alzheimer's disease. >> thank you. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. >> thank you, doris. >> I am bonnie johnson. Board member of alzheimer's community care. Thank you Chairman Ciampi and others board of county commissioners for declaring November of 2018 an honor of alzheimer's public awareness month and for valuing our local mission and work. We share this honor with the association. >> southeast florida chapter. Council of aging at the cane center and the martin county community foundation. Although our mission and work differ from these esteemed organization. We work together for a greater awareness and about alzheimer's disease and be air shire they receive the services and support they need. There are over 6,000 families residing in martin county. Who must cope with the disease processed daily. >> our families node be in isolation as they cope with the process that could last two to 20 years with the average being 10. >> we pledge that their safety tir and security is of the utmost importance and it is demonstrated and inclusive of those lost on foot. When one of our patients become s lost, law enforcement find them within minutes. >> not hours or days. >> daws of the id bracelet program. We pledge and advocate for the well-being of families. And specialize all licensed case care and 24/7 alzheimer's crisis line. >> training services in the martin county hugs program. >> it is a col lap braition with the community foundation. >> it aims to make martin county dementia friendsly for all those who live, work and play through the community and education through awareness. >> we pledge to you. Our county curbers. >> go far away. >> 92-cents goes toward service s and resources. >> of all the patients. We care for in our specialized care and service centers. >> p 5% tested as seerl live impaired. >> how far, there are no empty days and they have a quality of life filled well dancing. Singing, music. Socialization and laughter. Recognition of the cause with the proclamations lends dignity and respect to the patients and families. For that, we are most grateful. >> thank you so much. >> thank you so much. >> our final proclamation this morning is declaring hospice and. >> palliaive care month in martin county, florida. >> this is a program that works offering come passionate care and assuring dignity and gallon nity of life. Hospice and palliative care font month and here to accept we have debra daly and lore loretta hall. on behalf of the families and everyone we serve the in the last 30 years. Our board of directors and staff, thank you for recogniz ing us. we wanted to add that it is a pleasure to provide end of life care to this community which is broader than martin county. But we all experience end life services and we encourage you to take advantage of it. We found too many do not. But we are here to help you and thank you for the proclamation. >> thank you very much. Miss Beaupre, as usual, excellent job s. >> we are back to this side for commissioner comments and we will start with you, commissioner heard. >> yes, first of all, I wanted to thank all the people who organized the veteran's day parade and activities. It is a lot of work and volunteer work and they do a fantastic job and as usual, they did a wonderful job on sunday in downtown student. >> I want to thank commissioner fielding for eight years of public service. It has been my sincere pleasure to work with you. I appreciate your thoughtful ness and your conis he sheentiousness and -- conscientiousness and intelligence every day. You will be greatly missed. >> [Applause bras. >> [Applause]. >> we have something more simple planned. >> I appreciate your comments very much. >> commissioner jenkins. >> as you May or May not know, I have been serving on the canvassing board and been doing quite a bit of work for the last few months. Martin county has finished the recount last night as of 90:00. We spent 13 hours. I want to take this time to make everybody aware. We have the best super veesor of elections on the planet. She and debbie and they run the office like a swiss watch. It makes it very easy and justifies everything. Everything is transparent. She is an amazing woman and I wanted to take this opportunity to bring it out. I actually had a lot of fun with them there. They are a happy bunch. >> also, commissioner fielding. I thoroughly enjoyed spending time with you for the last two years. >> sometimes we don't agree, you look at it in a different light than I do and I appreciate that very much. >> thank you. >> commissioner jenkins. Thank you for your eserveing on the canvassing board. I agree with what you said about vicky davis and her team. I had a conversation with someone this morning about it and how we weren't facing the issues we all read in the newspapers in counties north and south of us. Specificry south. Someone said it is easy for your supervisor of election. Because you have a small county with much fewer ballots and I challenged them to say. If Miss Davis was the supervis or of election in any county. I believe. They wouldn't necessarily have seen the problems. That the others are seeing. >> simply because there is so much preparation prior to elections. That Miss Caifs and her team have taken. And when you hear in palm beach county. And using older machine cleans in palm beach county of all places. They are still working with old er machines. >> I would appreciate commissioner jeng cubs handling all of it. >> what is her strategy. >> she said the equipment that we are using allows this to be the senator race and the ag race. All with one pass in palm beach county. >> they have to run them through. >> three separate times and we had about 78,000 ballots. Down in palm beach county. They have 800,000. Imagine, if you have to run them through three times instead of one time. Then every time you run it through, the ballot has an opportunity to tear or something could happen to it. It is a system that I assume we all felt that elections are, you know, it is a process that works and once again, florida is in the spotlight for not here in martin county. But several other counties show ing the united states how not to count ballots. >> with that in mind, we will go to commissioner fielding. Then we have a couple of they cans to take care. >> it is my pleasure to ask you for your commissioner comments. >> thank you. Appreciate those observations very much. Very much. Appreciate that. And yes, different once of us have had the opportunity to serve. And it has been a pressure because of the way it is prepared. And you go in and things are just done so orderly. That you can, there is just not areas that would rise to the level of question. All of those things have been foreseen. >> we have a good pair. Supervisor. >> davis. And debbie, their top pair. And as a rule. Martin county. We have a built that is counted and reviewed and verified. Fantastic. >> they do a good job. >> totally different thing. >> it has come to my attention. >> by those that are the that it is a bacteria. Not an algae. And that May be part of the problem of how we are dealing with it. It is a particular type of a bacteria. >> and it is a particular bacteria. And as it clutches, it then forms a pod. And it becomes encased. And you mean talking about micro scoppic. >> so. That then causes us to look at ways of eliminating this problem. And it might have an effect for a few days. And we really haven't taken care of the seed or the pod. And what is encased in the mucous. >> that is my understanding. And maybe that will be pursued more fully. >> that is really. All I had. >> other than I appreciate the opportunity. >> it has been an opportunity to work with you all. And it is stim laive. stimulative. >> we are not letting you off the hook that easily. >> I just wanted to make one more comment. >> because I spoke of him. >> this marks the bridge dedication. >> that is done in 2013. >> I think. That although. It had come out of a very process. And I think the final process. >> has served our community well. >> I have the ability and the pleasure of most mornings. Driving from palm city. >> over to security. And across the brim. And it is beautifully designed. And conand you can see. Dozens and dozens of folks. That are running. And walking and enjoying the bridge. Much more so. >> my kids are tired of hearing me say. It. >> it is a social phenomenon. >> let's go walk the bridge. >> I would like to thank the folks. >> we named it veteran's member to honor those that served our country. And will serve the country. >> I we like to let you know a sneak preview. That tony reese and I and I know folks and his team were working on ways to celebrate. The namesake the bridge. Lisa wichser and her team, work ing with me. If you haven't been over the bridge recently. During six times of the year. Especially this week. >> we rub the fall span of the bridge. In american flags. It looks very patriotic and it takes effort to go up and down with the flags. >> and those who do the work. >> safelity. >> commissioner fielding. >> we, you know, I have been thinking about, how we want to. I know you are not one for big pomp and circumstance ceremon ies. But your eight years of commitment. And service to the county. We can't just say. By the way, stheapgs for stop ping by. We have a couple of things we would like to do. >> but, first, I would like to say. I have the unique perspective. And your last two years. In your eight and I have said to you on more than one occasion. >> although you and I disagree on individual topics and how they get hished or soant and appreciated the way we have dis agreed and I have found you to be a gentlemen. >> you as commissioner heard said. >> your comments although can be tough. They were well thought out and you have done your homework. Your research. Our vast mom, you have shared not just here but the martin county residents. We have all benefited from your service and what you have brought to the position. >> I think you have served these eight years and I know at your personal expense and the expense of your family. >> all of us that have served well know the challenges and what it takes to do it. And you have done it well. >> you made it rook easier and even if we disagree, it make force a healthier process. I thank you for your service. What we would like to could is we have a flak for you and -- plaque for you and maybe join us in the well and we can take some pick pictures. >> while everyone is coming down. I will read the plaque. Presented to ed field willing. 2010 to 2018. In recognition of your leader ship as a member of the board of county commissioners and in appreciate yawtion for the commitment. Representation and service on behalf of the citizens of martin county. Florida. >> this 13 day day of November. >> where would you like to stand. >> right in here. >> thank you, sir. >> that is very kind. >>> commissioner fielding. I would like to thank you for everything you have done. You supported me. >> I remember the first meeting we were negotiating the contract. You said I was no Lebron james and I appreciate that am and I have tried to be one ever since. I do appreciate your candor and our relationship that we have had for the last eight years. Thank you. >> [Applause]. >> I would like to express my appreciation with commissioner fielding. We have had spirited debates and I have enjoyed every minute of it and I wish you all the pest in the future. >> here here. >> [Applause]. >> you have three minutes, sir. >> I will be brief. >> listen, coming and expecting and very much appreciate that. It has been a close interaction sure, we disagree. From time to time. Because it is so important. That is the essence why we choose to disagree instead of letting something fly off into the wind. It is important. We want martin county to be as the best we can. And that is the evident. That each of us make. So. Thank you very much. >> thank you. [Applause]. >> that doesn't mean you don't have work to do today. >>. >> with that in mind. Why don't we take our break now for 10 minutes and we will come back for the first agenda item. We will take a 10 minute break. >>> this is by commissioner jenkins and seconded by commissioner fielding. The motion carries unanimously. Our next public hearing, we will be hearing this morning is number 2. Legislative public hearing for comprehensive plan amendment 18 -15. Jensen beach impoundment extension. Good morning, and welcome. >> good morning, much. Before I begin my presentation. For the record my name is maria jost, planner with the department of growth management I would like to turn in the certification of property owner notification. >> thank you very much. Let the record show that has happened. >> this is jensen beach impoundment extension. The proposed future land use map amendment. Here you can see the aerial view of the property. The subject property is highlighted in red color. It is on north causeway boulevard on hutchinson island, jensen beach. It is continue.13 acres. It is acquired by martin county the board initiated a future land use map change from medium density residential to public conservation. >> so, this map shows the current future land use. As you can see the color red, it shows medium residential. Right now the subject property shown in the black and white dashes. It is medium density residential. Most of the surrounding properties for example, the properties to the north, south and west, they are all conservation right now. And east of the subject property is medium density residential. And it is jensen beach club. Residential community. The staff analysis considers to designate this parcell as conservation. The category recognizes public ly owned areas. Designed for conservation uses. >> only developmental compatible that conservation and passive recreation uses shall be permitted in the public conservation category. >> this May include access, parking and other facilities that is enable the management of the resource and the public 's enjoyment of it. This is public conservation. This is the most appropriate considering the proximity to conservation lands and its location nearest dengs community. They state sensitive lands acquired by the county shall be reinstated to conservation land use during the next planning cycle. Considering all the factors, they consider changing from medium density residential to public conservation future land use. >> that ends your presentation. Thank you. >> commissioner fielding. >> you laid out the information rather thoroughly. But subject to public input, I would make motion of approved staff recommendation so that this transmittal will be sent to the department of economic opportunity on this impoundment public conservation. >> second. >> thank you very much. >> anyone from the public looking to address us on this topic. >> seeing none, we come back to the board. Any other questions for staff. >> also seeing none. We have a motion by commissioner fielding for approval seconded by commissioner jenkins. All those in favor. The motion carries unanimously. Thank you so much. >> thank you. >> our next public hearing is quasi-judicial. Consider adoption of ordinance amending # 1.243. B. Chapter 71. Finance and taxationization >> article six. Tourist development taxes. General ordinances. Martin county code to change the categories of use and percentages of tax revenues. This is another one that will be, I have just opened it and it will be continued until November 20th. And I will entertain a motion with that regard. >> move to continue this item until November 20th. >> thank you very much. >> anyone looking to address this prior to voting. Seeing none. >> all those in favor. >> aye. >> opposed. >> motion carries unanimously. >>. >> our next is department one, office of management and budget items which require board approval. There will be five items. It looks like it is going to be presented this morning by Miss Kryzda, welcome. >> thank you. >> the first item on here. I know you like to have some indication of what they are. This is permission to apply for a grant that is through visit florida. And this was $500,000 for bang programs that could assist the tourism folks and we are asking to apply for this $59,589.59. >> thank you. >> any questions for Miss Kryzda about this grant opportunity. >> we have a motion for staff's recommendation of approval for departmental one item number 1. Motion carries unanimously. >> second one is with permission to accept the indian river lagoon natural estuary program or the irl, and it is for the storm project and we are asking for up to $267,000. They approved the willoughby project working with the management district and creat ing a storm treatment area >> commissioner fielding. >> yes, Miss Woods, please. Impart of the team group here. So, should I, what should I do? >> sorry. >> you are fine. >> you don't have a conflict. >> okay. >> move to approve. >> second. >> we have a motion to accept staff's recommendation of approval for item number 2. Seconded by commissioner jenkinsle all those in favor. The motion carries unanimously. >> impassing this. >> we have to read the titles. >> yes, please state your name for the record, please. >> good morning, commissioners. General jennifer manning. Omb director. >> item number 1 is permission to. >> you are up to number 3. >> we like you but. >> I apologize for that. Item number 3 is permission to accept the fish and wildlife conservation fund for the art physician reef in the amount of 60,000. There is a $25,000 match which is already budgeted in the cip. >> so moved. >> second. >> thank you. >> we have a motion by commissioner fielding for staff 's recommendation of approval for departmental one. Item newspaper three. Seconded by commissioner jeng cinszs. >> all those opposed. Motion carries unanimously. >> number 4 is permission to accept the florida emergency medical services grant. It is a portion that is received by the state and distributed throughout the 67 counties. And in the amount of $21,476. This is no match required. >> move to approve. >> thank you. >> we have a motion to accept staff's recommendation by commissioner jenkins. For departmental number 1. Item number 4. Seconded by commissioner field ing. >> aye. >> all those opposed. Motion carries unanimously. >> item number 5 is a resolution to amend the budget for the utilities assessments. And one is for north river shores and put the budget in line and how we set up our fund for the service. >> this is for old palm city and preliminary planning. And for those assessments and we are carrying the fund forward. >> so moved. >> second. >> thank you. >> we have a motion by commissioner fielding for staff 's recommendation of approval on departmental item number 1. Number 5. Seconded by commissioner jenkins. All those opposed. Moation carries unanimously. >> thank you so much. >> okay. We are now up to departmental quasi-judicial number. >> no. >> the first one we continued in the initial vote this morning when we approved the agenda. We are up to item number 2. >> circle k U.S.1. Cove road. Major revised final site plan. >> presented by Miss Katherine risk canvassing. >> let me ask. Commissioner heard. If she had any ex parte communications. >> if I have, they have been fueled. >> commissioner jenkins. >> if I have, they have been filed. >> if there were any, they would have been filed. >> if I have had any, they are filed as well. Anyone that is going to offer testimony, please stand to be sworn in. >>. >> race your right hand. Do you swear or affirm the evidence you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth >> I do. >> thank you. >> are there any returned receipts that are necessary for this. >> nonnecessary. >> any interveners. >> sir. >> let the record show there are none. Miss Risk canvassing. Do you have -- riskasmght, do you have a copy of your work history to submit. >> I do. >> let the record show that has been submitted. Miss Risk canvassing. The -- riiska, the floor is yours. >> good morning. My name is catherine riiska. I am the planner with the growth management. It is my pleasure to present a major development final site plan by circle k stores incorporated. They are requesting approval to redevelop an approval of two foipt 92 acres. This is southeast federal highway. And on the northeast corner of cove road. the site capes an existing circle k gas station and convenience store on approximately. .8 acres. They propose to incorporate the parcells to the north and expand the existing store with 539,000 square foot building with nine fuel pumps. The future land use designation of the site is commercial general. The zoning on the property is g c general commercial district. This is a permitted use within the gc, general commercial district. >> the undeveloped site include s the establishment of an up land preserve. Area of 5,755 square feet adjacent to the northern wound ary of this site. It will be and imagined in perpetuity and with the preserve area management plan, the pamp provided with the draft resolution. The property adjacent to the west has a residential future land use and contains single family development. It is separated but the project known as southeast pine avenue. >> due to the rest residential land use. A compatible bifer is required ak jays sent to the property. >>> -- adjacent. This is in order to accommodate the redevelopment and to alleviate traffic issues with ingress and egress. >> a portion of the billing is proposed to encroach into the 40-foot landscape billing by 14.4 feet. The applicant has provided a very detailed alternative landscaping compliance analysis on pages 686 through 702 of the agenda packet. >> to offset this, and provide a compatibility buffering, the project proposes and has provided enhanced landscape plans that provide for more than twice the density of the required minimum plantings and materials that exceed the material minimum requirements. >> they have reviewed this and recommends approval for alternative compliance for landscaping. they have evaluated the performance with the procedures of the ldr and has found the proposed final site plan, revised final site plan meets the applicable requirements of the martin county code land comprehensive plan. Including with respects to the requirements of the specific uses of a vehicle service uses a seth fort in 46. >> staff recommends approval of the circle k cove road revised final site plan. And recommends that the board move to receive in the file and file the agenda item summary and all the attachments for the staff report as exhibit one. >> they approve the revised final site plan and this is the adoption of approval. This completes my approval. >> we appreciate your presentation. Thank you very much. Questions for Miss Riiska, from my colleagues. Seeing none. Opportunity for the applicant to make a presentation at this time. >> Mr. Raines, good morning, sir, you are recognized. >> thank you. For the record my name is bob rains. I am here with the gunster law firm. >> this is circle k stores inc. >> I would like to state that we review dollars the staff record report. And we do agree with the staff 's comments and recommendations. In the staff report, we would like to adopt and submit it for the record as exhibit number 1. >> mary kay. >> this is a great zoning. >> here on this property that we are requesting today. It is a permitted use. The gas station and convenience store and it exists today. So we do believe that the project we are bringing forward today is actually a you mean provement on the existing use and will create a lot of enhanced possibilities on that property with respect to safety >> traffic and that going a little bit more detail with dance on his presentation. He will do it in just a minute. >> we are asking as katherine pointed out. >> we believe that really will also enhance the project and he will explain why we are looking for that compliance. >> we believe we will provide substantial evidence that we meet all the rules of the land development code. With that, I would like to have just to make a short presentation. Then I will ask him a few questions prior. Then afterwards. Then we will proceed. >> welcome, sir. >> dan, if you could. Please state your name and qualifications for the record. >> dan sorro, land planner. Doing planned planning for over 15 years. >> many projects here in martin county. And I am familiar with the land development code. >> you have been sworn in. >> yes. >> please proceed. >> can someone bring up the powerpoint presentation. It is on the desktop. >> if there is a slide advancer os. >> good morning, commissioners. Staff. Thank you for the presentation. Miss Riiska, I am dan sorro, with cutler and herring to present. Plpg dick and our legal counsel Mr. Bob raynes. And I want to thank leah and george. And our traffic engineers. Miles susanory rork and bowman consulting. And his services out of lakeland, florida. The request before you is for approval of a major final site plan. >> located at the corner of coa one. >> it is right in the corner of the urban services district. >> major south corridor. And the major northwest and it is shown there. And the applicant does own both parcells of land and he opens the existing gas stationen a the property as well. >> which is posh to to note and you can see where it currently exists on the corner of U.S.1 and cove road, it makes ingress and egress a concern. >> because you have people exit ing the site and trying to cross three or had lanes of traffic. And turning on U.S.1. >> this is the only opportunity to improve the circulation and improve the safety and to increase the convenience store. >> this is the eght thet particulars of the site. >> weir here before you this morning. >> couple of years ago, they did grant approval on the land use and the zoning. It is consistent with the code for a gas facial. >> here is some of the photos of the existing site. And you can see that there is not adequate vehicles attacking when they were developing. And they had a limited number of fuel bump. And you don't have the coffee bars. >> the county space. That you see in. We really wanted to take it to a new product and address some the areas r >> it is an improvement of what it is today. >> this is the proposed site plan. Almost ride cal shown to the board. >> it exists, the site is 2.86 acres. And the billing will double in size and be just over 5,000 square foot. >> and your code requires 20% of the landscaper site. >> we are providing in landscaping for this site. Which is very. >> unusual for a general commercial use. >> especially a gas station use we wanted to keep it is a green as possible. And have as much landscaping as possible. >> this is to create a most. The most pervious trip of gas station use. >> interesting. >> ingress. And eeg yes, sir. >> it is on the hard corner of U.S.1 and located further north which is going to provide. This on and off and this is going to be a dedicated into the site and also, the right turn lane going on to cove road is to remain. That is for better traffic conditions as well. >> we are providing 25% quality up land habitat. It is next to the tee tension area. There is a transition that require up up land habitat ant dry detention -- retention area located on the screen. This represents the public art that your code requires. Applicant has contributed to public art which is major corridor. It is a gawtway to the community. That is something that is going to be visible to residents and motorists as they travel on this jai alai populated corridor. >> is it a big k spin anything a circle. >> I have a picture. >> tastefully done circle k. >> it is well done. We worked with staff over the last year to determine that. >> the pedestrian access is going to remain the same off cove road with the path into the proposed building. I did want to spend a little bit of time why we chose to go with the alternative compliance buffer for this particular parcell. The reason we chose alternative compliance buff, we think it is a safer type situation and warrants a better site design. And provides for better circulation. Your code requires 24-foot minimum drives. We have respectively added 37- foot drives and 33-foot drives to the drive aisles. >> it is important when you have larger vehicles. >> to have them and if you have emergency medical services or or kind of vehicle. They don't get stuck behind the trailers and not being able to and a half navigate beyond the site. >> they have been in the business many, many years. And this is the business model. They have shown it is important for navigation and circulation purposes to choose and to have the wider drive aisles. The alternative compliance was sought because you have a pro provision in it that allows for better site design and fixes for situations like this. So, you can see, there is a 22- foot surplus for safety which could have been used to reduce the building buffer encroachment. And we think in the end, it is a better design site for the entire project. >> wrap >> these are some photos of showing why the extra drive aisle rp important and you have got the rv pulling the trawler and the lawb maintenance trawler sticking way further out into the drive aisle and in the 22-foot that would allow. The bottom right hand screen is the tanker truck coming into the existing gas station and help with circulation and train ing. >> I think it is important to note that staff is recommending approval to the alternative compliance. The bottom screen on the left is showing at the deepest left. It is 14.4 feet into the buffer and almost zero at the narrow est portion. It is 2.6% of the entire buffer where the billing is encroaching. This is a traffic which shows that representative. >> however, we feel that we have provided a buffer far substantial than what the code minimum would allow. This shows if we didn't need the buffer. And you can see the white area which is represented by sod and no veg satisfaction all. And we have compensated for that in a March planted land end scrape. And it is almost sorry row void areas within that buffer. >> you can see the left and this is the enhanced landscape puffer. >> we have provided 25 trays. And requires. 394 ground covers. Encroachment. We are far exceeding the code and the intent of the code is better achieved with our plan than just by going with the code minimum. In the last graphic, it represents the two comparisons of the code. En on the top, you can see the wide portion which rebounds landscaping. >> you have a fullly opaque screen buffer showing from the residents and the circle k. Lastly, it is an opportunity for us to improve the esthetics of the area to modernize the building and make it more con temporary and provide the goods and services you see today. It takes a. Kind of a dilapidated building and brings it into the finishes >> that is the architecture that is going to provide. It is a benefit to all the citizens of martin county. >> the public art piece. Which is going to be shown at the corner of cove and U.S.1, it is a double helix, structure over six and a half feet at all >> driven by some of the prevailing winds. >> up light being at night. And blend in well to the theme we have running along the and so. >> I think. It is a win for the county and certainly for the applicant. And for the residents. >> it talks a run down environment and to, makes it a new enhanced plan. >> so, that concludes my presentation. Be happy to answer any question s you May have. >> thank you very much. Appreciate that. >> few questions real quick. >> Mr. Sorro, weave to share the mic. >> are you facilities am with the comprehensive plan and the land development regulations. >> I am. >> what documents did you prepare forethis project, sir. >> site plan. The justification statement and the landscape plan. >> did you also write down the I did. >> could you believe what you submitted to the county meet the rules and require ments of the comprehensive plan land development regulations. >> he do. >> I have one other. >> come up. Andrew peterson. >> civil engineer, please. >>>. >> he is welcome. >> welcome, sir. >> andrew. State your name and qualifications. >> I am with bowman consulting. And I have been a licensed professional for civil years other. >> and what has been your role in this project. >> I am the supervising engineer and I did the storm water design and all the engineering plans, production for that. >> what documents did you prepare for this project. >> provide all the civil site plans. >> storm water. Degrade going. >> all the designs. >> off site work am and with the utilities. >> are you familiar with the clafn and the lands development regulations. >> I am. In your opinion, do the documents meet those require ments. >> they do. >> thank you, sir. >> has -- we will ask some other questions later. >> commissioners. That concludes our presentation and this is an exusing. >> we have some lights for you. Before you go into your summation. >> voa good. >> I have some questions and they are probably for Mr. Sorro >> to protect the residents. On pine over. >> no entrie allowed on pine avenue. >> no. >> one of the commitments we maude with the land use and zoning. There is a 6-foot prefab wall. >> along pine avenue. And it looks like. It is not just an eat tour it requires 6-foot high wood fence the applicant has taken it upon himself to put up a masonry wall. >> it looks good. >> thank you. >> only entranceways on U.S.1. And cove, one >> no other entrances. >> correct. >> that's correct. >> end grateful to see that it is enhanced. >> I saw irrigation well site. So is the landscaping going to be irrigated. >> what kind of conversation is made for native landscaping. >> requires 50% landscaping which we have achieved. >> concerned about lighting. And minimizing lighting. And it is. >> I recognize it is U.S.1. >> in a residential neighborhood. >> so, the light is not going to the neighborhood. >> to keep the lighting focused >> again. And we love toe and in our communities. But this is an existing use. >> it is a gas station. That I rear. >> it is the only one in the neighborhood. And so, I think I have done a very nice job of making an improvement. That is come pat edge with the neighborhood and I look forward to having it executed. >> thank you very much. >> any other questions. >> commissioner fielding. >> I think commissioner heard has made useful observations and expressed. >> my perspective. As as well. >> they are familiar with that location. And pleased with the alterations and the improvement s that the owner has chosen to make. there is an enhancement to the corridor. >> and it is quiewtd enthusiastic. That you allowed this area of green to the north. And wonder. >>> is it possible that, that sign. Their. >> gallon in this. And 2:45 is what it is doyne in palm beach. >> that the signage could be at the door's east core door. It is in the pamp area. Is that. >> even possible. I don't know. I might not be enunciating that sufficiently. but if you look. Miss Riiska, do you mind going back to a picture. >> they haven't shouldn't be allowed in the preserve area. >> it would not be permissible. Permissible. And preserve areas are intended solely for the preservation of the habitat and not be consider ed. but with our code and recommendation answers. >> well, you sort of are. >> we have not caused the in striewment to be recorded yet and there could. >> people will be coming down there and those that are not familiar. >> they are walking around. And this is real tight. You were right. >> you were right. >> at the top. >> right at the corner of U.S.1 and the northern eastern corner >> yu. >> really. Run into corners. >>. >> it is here. >> because we haven't recorded this yet. >> my concern was. >> we got folks. Zipping down U.S.1. And then this interest. >> which is so well done and beautifully prepared. >> and zip by it because the trees are there. And that's m

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FINAL MINUTES 11/13/2018 9:00 AM MINUTES COMMISSION CHAMBERS 2401 SE MONTEREY ROAD, STUART, FLORIDA 34996 Taryn Kryzda, County Administrator Sarah W. Woods, County Attorney Carolyn Timmann, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Edward V. Ciampi, Chairman Harold E. Jenkins II, Vice Chairman Doug Smith Stacey Hetherington Sarah Heard CALL TO ORDER 3 - Chairman Edward V. Ciampi Vice Chairman Harold E. Jenkins II Commissioner Sarah Heard Present: 1 - Commissioner Doug SmithAbsent: 1. INVOCATION - Pastor Dave Albers, Redeemer Lutheran Church 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. ADDITIONAL ITEMS Page 1 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Commissioner Heard, to approve the agenda as presented [agenda with additional item CNST-7, consent agenda (no pulls), and continue items CNST-5 and DPQJ-1]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: 5. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA PROCLAMATIONS AND SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS PROC-1 PRESENT PROCLAMATIONS PREVIOUSLY APPROVED VIA THE CONSENT AGENDA The Chairman will present the proclamations to the recipients. Agenda Item: 19-0024 Special Projects Coordinator Laura Beaupre introduced the proclamations. Rick Hartman (One Martin) and Reed Hartman (Martin County Farm Bureau) accepted the proclamation for Farm City Week. Bonney Johnson and Jonathan Price (Alzheimer's Community Care), and Doris Sanders (Alzheimer's Association Southeast Florida Chapter) accepted the proclamation for Alzheimer's Disease Awareness Month. Debora Dailey and Gloretta Hall (Treasure Coast Hospice) accepted the proclamation for Hospice and Palliative Care Month. COMMENTS 1. PUBLIC - PLEASE LIMIT COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES. MCHS Art Teachers Amanda Jones and Bryan Johnson, with The Prescription Shop Owner Kim Jones, spoke about their mural project in downtown Stuart. Erin Smith and Doug Smith spoke about the potential dangers of having high-speed rail through Martin County and requested that the Board continue to oppose the Brightline project. Tom Pine asked why the photos he displays during his public comments are not being shown on MCTV. 2. COMMISSIONERS Commissioner Heard thanked the organizers of the Veteran's Day Parade, and thanked Commissioner Fielding for his service. Page 2 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

Commissioner Jenkins spoke announced that the Canvassing Board had finished the recount and praised Supervisor of Elections Vicki Davis and her staff. He also thanked Commissioner Fielding for his service. Chairman Ciampi thanked Commissioner Jenkins for serving on the Canvassing Board and offered his own praise for the Supervisor of Elections, her staff, and the efficiency of the election process in Martin County. He also spoke about the widespread pedestrian use of the Veterans Bridge. Commissioner Fielding spoke about what a pleasure it had been to work with the Supervisor of Elections Office over the years. He spoke about local water issues and the need to address the bacteria problem. Chairman Ciampi congratulated Commissioner Fielding for his eight years of service on the commission and presented him with a plaque. County Administrator County Administrator Taryn Kryzda and County Attorney Sarah Woods also thanked Commissioner Fielding. Commissioner Fielding accepted his plaque and offered his appreciation for the opportunity to serve with his fellow commissioners. 3. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR CONSENT ADMINISTRATION CNST-1 CONTRACTS THAT MEET THE THRESHOLD FOR BOARD APPROVAL This item is a placeholder on all Board meeting agendas in an effort to streamline the process for items that meet the Board approval threshold. Specific items requiring approval, if any, will be provided by Supplemental Memorandum. If there are no items, a Supplemental Memorandum will not be attached. Agenda Item: 19-0005 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (2 items) CNST-2 APPROVE A CONTRACT, FEE SCHEDULE, AND RESOLUTION REGARDING THE MARTIN COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2018-2019 Each year the Board is requested to approve a contract and fee schedule for the Martin County Health Department via resolution. Agenda Item: 19-0017 RESOLUTION NO. 18-11.1 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. CNST-3 REQUEST MODIFICATION OF SMALL CITIES COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) PROGRAM WORK PLAN Martin County Health & Human Services applied and was awarded FY 2015 CDBG grant for Housing Rehabilitation Activity under Contract Number Page 3 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

17DB-OL-10-53-01-H13. Martin County is requesting a modification to the workplan. Agenda Item: 19-0046 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. CNST-4 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION MINUTES TO BE APPROVED The Board is asked to approve Minutes from the October 9 and October 23, 2018 Board of County Commission meetings and from the October 29, 2018 Joint Meeting with the City & School Board. Agenda Item: 19-0056 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. CNST-5 AGRICULTURE AND NATURAL RESOURCES ADVISORY COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT The Board is asked to confirm the appointment to the Agriculture and Natural Resources Advisory Committee. Agenda Item: 19-0059 This item was continued to November 20th by the first motion of the meeting. SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) CNST-6 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS’ APPROVAL OF WARRANT LIST FOR DISBURSEMENT VIA CHECKS AND ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS TO COMPLY WITH STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS Pursuant to Chapter 136.06, Florida Statutes, checks and electronic payments issued by the Board of County Commissioners are to be recorded in the Board meeting minutes. In compliance with statutory requirements, the Warrant List is added to the Consent Agenda for approval by the Board of County Commissioners. This Warrant List is for disbursements made between September 11, 2018 and September 30, 2018. Additional details related to these disbursements may be viewed in the office of the Martin County Clerk of Court and Comptroller or on the Clerk’s website. Agenda Item: 19-0082 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. COUNTY ATTORNEY CNST-7 CONSIDER A RESOLUTION ADOPTING A POLICY REGARDING EXIT PROCEDURES FOR OUTGOING COMMISSIONERS The County Attorney’s Office has prepared a resolution adopting a formal written policy to clarify exit procedures for outgoing Commissioners Agenda Item: 19-0081 RESOLUTION NO. 18-11.2 This item was approved by the first motion of the meeting. ADDITIONAL ITEM Page 4 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

PUBLIC HEARINGS PH-1 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER TRANSMITTAL OF COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 18-14, DIXIE HWY. RIO An application to amend the Future Land Use Map was initiated by the Board of County Commissioners for 0.28 acres owned by Martin County Community Redevelopment Agency located in Rio. The property is located on 977 NE Dixie Hwy., in Jensen Beach, Rio. Staff recommends that the dual designation of General Institutional and General Commercial future land use designation be changed to solely General Commercial future land use designation. The Local Planning Agency recommended that the future land use designation be changed to General Commercial. Agenda Item: 19-0069 This item was continued to November 20th. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Jenkins, seconded by Commissioner Fielding to continue the item [to November 20th]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) PH-2 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER TRANSMITTAL OF COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 18-15, JENSEN BEACH IMPOUNDMENT EXTENSION An application to amend the Future Land Use Map was initiated by the Board of County Commissioners for 10.13 acres owned by Martin County located in Hutchinson Island, Jensen Beach. The property is located on NE Causeway Blvd, west of NE Jensen Beach Club. Staff recommends that the future land use designation of Medium Density Residential be changed to Public Conservation future land use designation. The Local Planning Agency recommended that the future land use designation be changed to Public Conservation. Agenda Item: 19-0071 Planner Maria Jose presented the item to the Board. Growth Management Director Nicki van Vonno and Senior Assistant County Attorney Krista Storey assisted with Board questions. Chairman Ciampi solicited public comment; none was heard. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Vice Chairman Jenkins, to approve staff recommendation so that this transmittal be sent to the Department of Economic Opportunity on this impoundment extension area designating Public Conservation. The motion carried by the following vote: Page 5 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: PUBLIC HEARING QUASI-JUDICIAL PHQJ-1 PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTION 71.243.B, CHAPTER 71, FINANCE AND TAXATION, ARTICLE 6, TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAXES, GENERAL ORDINANCES, MARTIN COUNTY CODE TO CHANGE THE CATEGORIES OF USE AND PERCENTAGES OF TAX REVENUES The Board of County Commissioners (Board) is requested to adopt proposed amendments to Chapter 71, Finance and Taxation, Article 6, Tourist Development Taxes, General Ordinances, Martin County Code to modify the existing allocations for the uses of funds and percentages of tax revenues for tourist development taxes. Agenda Item: 19-0074 This item was continued to November 20th. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chairman Jenkins, seconded by Commissioner Fielding, to continue this item to November 20th. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) DEPARTMENTAL ADMINISTRATION DEPT-1 OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET ITEMS WHICH REQUIRE BOARD APPROVAL This is a placeholder on all Board meeting agendas in an effort to streamline the process for grant applications, awards, budget resolutions, budget transfers from reserves, and CIP amendments. Specific items requiring approval, if any, will be provided by Supplemental Memorandum. Agenda Item: 19-0001 RESOLUTION NOs. 18-11.3 through 18-11.8 County Administrator Taryn Kryzda and Budget Manager Jennifer Manning presented the five items to the Board. MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chairman Jenkins, seconded by Commissioner Fielding, to approve [item #1]. The motion carried by the Page 6 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: Agenda Item: 19-0001 MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Vice Chairman Jenkins, to approve [item #2]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: Agenda Item: 19-0001 MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Vice Chairman Jenkins, for approval [item #3]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: Agenda Item: 19-0001 MOTION: A motion was made by Vice Chairman Jenkins, seconded by Commissioner Fielding, to approve [item #4]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: Agenda Item: 19-0001 MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Vice Chairman Jenkins, for approval [item #5]. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: Page 7 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (5 items) DEPARTMENTAL QUASI-JUDICIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT DPQJ-1 JENSEN DUNES PUD REVISED PUD ZONING AGREEMENT, REVISED MASTER SITE PLAN AND PHASING PLAN (J046-008) Request for approval of the Second Amendment to the PUD Zoning Agreement and Revised Master Site Plan and Phasing Plan. The 34.3 acre subject property is located on the north side of Cedar Street between the FEC Railroad and Savannah Road and south and west of the Town of Ocean Breeze in Jensen Beach. Included in the application is a request for a deferral of a Certificate of Public Facilities Reservation. Agenda Item: 19-0047 This item was continued to November 20th by the first motion of the meeting. SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) DPQJ-2 CIRCLE K US-1 COVE ROAD MAJOR REVISED FINAL SITE PLAN (C166-002) This is an application by Circle K Stores, Inc., requesting approval for a revised commercial, major development final site plan with a Certificate of Public Facilities Reservation for a 2.9 acre site located on the northwest corner of SE Cove Road and SE Federal Highway in Stuart. Agenda Item: 19-0048 RESOLUTION NO. 18-11.9 Ex parte communication forms were filed by all five commissioners. There were no notices required. There were no interveners. The participants were sworn in by the deputy clerk. COUNTY: Principal Planner Catherine Riiska provided the staff's presentation to the Board. Senior Assistant County Attorney Krista Storey and Growth Management Director Nicki van Vonno assisted with Board questions. The following County Exhibits were entered into the record: (1) agenda item/staff report, (2) Catherine Riiska resume. APPLICANT: Attorney Bob Raynes, Land Planner Dan Sorrow (Cotleur and Hearing), and Civil Engineer Andrew Peterson (Bowman Engineering) provided the applicant's presentation to the Board. The following Applicant Exhibit was entered into the record: (1) agenda item/staff report (same as County Exhibit #1). Chairman Ciampi solicited public comment; none was heard. Page 8 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Heard, seconded by Commissioner Fielding, for staff's recommendation for approval and that the resolution be modified to reflect the alternative compliance. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: DPQJ-3 MANATEE ISLES PLAT (S216-011) Request for plat approval for the Manatee Isles project consistent with the approved minor final site plan approved on October 2, 2018. The 2.3 acre development is located on the northeast corner of SE Capstan Avenue and SE Azimuth Way in Port Salerno. Included with this application is a request for a Certificate of Public Facilities Exemption. Agenda Item: 19-0063 Ex parte communication disclosure forms were filed by all five commissioners. There were no notices required. There were no interveners. The participants were sworn in by the deputy clerk. COUNTY: Principal Planner Peter Walden provided the staff's presentation to the Board. Senior Assistant County Attorney Krista Storey, Growth Management Director Nicki van Vonno, and County Engineer Lisa Wichser assisted with Board questions. The following County Exhibits were entered into the record: (1) agenda item/staff report, (3) Peter Walden resume. APPLICANT: Engineering Design & Construction Vice President Brad Currie provided the applicant's presentation to the Board. MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding to deny [the request] because the applicant hasn't met the requirement of having either performed the completion of the infrastructure, posted a cash bond, or posted surety. The motion failed for the lack of a second. Agenda Item: 19-0063 MOTION: A motion was made by Commissioner Fielding, seconded by Vice Chairman Jenkins, to continue the item to November 20th. The motion carried by the following vote: 4 - Chairman Ciampi, Vice Chairman Jenkins II, Commissioner Heard, and Fielding Aye: 1 - Commissioner SmithAbsent: Page 9 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

PUBLIC - PLEASE LIMIT COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES. There was no afternoon public comment. ADJOURN The November 11, 2018 meeting of the Board of County Commissioners adjourned at 11:35 a.m. _________________________ _________________________ Carolyn Timmann, Clerk of the Edward V. Ciampi, Chairman Circuit Court and Comptroller Board of County Commissioners /mkv Minutes approved on: _________________________ Page 10 of 1011/13/18 FINAL MINUTES

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FINAL AGENDA 11/13/18 9:00 AM REGULAR MEETING COMMISSION CHAMBERS 2401 SE MONTEREY ROAD, STUART, FLORIDA 34996 Taryn Kryzda, County Administrator Sarah W. Woods, County Attorney Carolyn Timmann, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Doug Smith, District 1 Stacey Hetherington, District 2 Harold E. Jenkins II, District 3 Sarah Heard, District 4 Edward V. Ciampi, District 5 PRESETS 9:05 AM - Public Comment 5:05 PM - Public Comment CALL TO ORDER 1. INVOCATION - Pastor Dave Albers, Redeemer Luthern Church 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. ADDITIONAL ITEMS 4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 5. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA Consent Agenda items are considered routine and are enacted by one motion and will have no action noted, but the "Recommendation" as it appears on the Board item is the approved action. PROCLAMATIONS AND SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS PROC-1 PRESENT PROCLAMATIONS PREVIOUSLY APPROVED VIA THE CONSENT AGENDA The Chairman will present the proclamations to the recipients. Agenda Item: 19-0024 COMMENTS Printed on 11/8/201811/13/18 BCC FINAL AGENDA Page 1 of 5

1. PUBLIC - PLEASE LIMIT COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES. 2. COMMISSIONERS 3. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR CONSENT ADMINISTRATION CNST-1 CONTRACTS THAT MEET THE THRESHOLD FOR BOARD APPROVAL This item is a placeholder on all Board meeting agendas in an effort to streamline the process for items that meet the Board approval threshold. Specific items requiring approval, if any, will be provided by Supplemental Memorandum. If there are no items, a Supplemental Memorandum will not be attached. Agenda Item: 19-0005 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (2 items) CNST-2 APPROVE A CONTRACT, FEE SCHEDULE, AND RESOLUTION REGARDING THE MARTIN COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2018-2019 Each year the Board is requested to approve a contract and fee schedule for the Martin County Health Department via resolution. Agenda Item: 19-0017 CNST-3 REQUEST MODIFICATION OF SMALL CITIES COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) PROGRAM WORK PLAN Martin County Health & Human Services applied and was awarded FY 2015 CDBG grant for Housing Rehabilitation Activity under Contract Number 17DB-OL-10-53-01-H13. Martin County is requesting a modification to the workplan. Agenda Item: 19-0046 CNST-4 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION MINUTES TO BE APPROVED The Board is asked to approve Minutes from the October 9 and October 23, 2018 Board of County Commission meetings and from the October 29, 2018 Joint Meeting with the City & School Board. Agenda Item: 19-0056 CNST-5 AGRICULTURE AND NATURAL RESOURCES ADVISORY COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT The Board is asked to confirm the appointment to the Agriculture and Natural Resources Advisory Committee. Agenda Item: 19-0059 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) Printed on 11/8/201811/13/18 BCC FINAL AGENDA Page 2 of 5

CNST-6 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS’ APPROVAL OF WARRANT LIST FOR DISBURSEMENT VIA CHECKS AND ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS TO COMPLY WITH STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS Pursuant to Chapter 136.06, Florida Statutes, checks and electronic payments issued by the Board of County Commissioners are to be recorded in the Board meeting minutes. In compliance with statutory requirements, the Warrant List is added to the Consent Agenda for approval by the Board of County Commissioners. This Warrant List is for disbursements made between September 11, 2018 and September 30, 2018. Additional details related to these disbursements may be viewed in the office of the Martin County Clerk of Court and Comptroller or on the Clerk’s website. Agenda Item: 19-0082 COUNTY ATTORNEY CNST-7 CONSIDER A RESOLUTION ADOPTING A POLICY REGARDING EXIT PROCEDURES FOR OUTGOING COMMISSIONERS The County Attorney’s Office has prepared a resolution adopting a formal written policy to clarify exit procedures for outgoing Commissioners Agenda Item: 19-0081 ADDITIONAL ITEM PUBLIC HEARINGS PH-1 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER TRANSMITTAL OF COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 18-14, DIXIE HWY. RIO An application to amend the Future Land Use Map was initiated by the Board of County Commissioners for 0.28 acres owned by Martin County Community Redevelopment Agency located in Rio. The property is located on 977 NE Dixie Hwy., in Jensen Beach, Rio. Staff recommends that the dual designation of General Institutional and General Commercial future land use designation be changed to solely General Commercial future land use designation. The Local Planning Agency recommended that the future land use designation be changed to General Commercial. Agenda Item: 19-0069 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) PH-2 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER TRANSMITTAL OF COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 18-15, JENSEN BEACH IMPOUNDMENT EXTENSION An application to amend the Future Land Use Map was initiated by the Board of County Commissioners for 10.13 acres owned by Martin County located in Hutchinson Island, Jensen Beach. The property is located on NE Causeway Blvd, west of NE Jensen Beach Club. Staff recommends that the future land use designation of Medium Density Residential be changed to Public Conservation future land use designation. The Local Planning Agency recommended that the future land use designation be changed to Public Conservation. Agenda Item: 19-0071 Printed on 11/8/201811/13/18 BCC FINAL AGENDA Page 3 of 5

PUBLIC HEARING QUASI-JUDICIAL PHQJ-1 PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTION 71.243.B, CHAPTER 71, FINANCE AND TAXATION, ARTICLE 6, TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAXES, GENERAL ORDINANCES, MARTIN COUNTY CODE TO CHANGE THE CATEGORIES OF USE AND PERCENTAGES OF TAX REVENUES The Board of County Commissioners (Board) is requested to adopt proposed amendments to Chapter 71, Finance and Taxation, Article 6, Tourist Development Taxes, General Ordinances, Martin County Code to modify the existing allocations for the uses of funds and percentages of tax revenues for tourist development taxes. Agenda Item: 19-0074 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) DEPARTMENTAL ADMINISTRATION DEPT-1 OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET ITEMS WHICH REQUIRE BOARD APPROVAL This is a placeholder on all Board meeting agendas in an effort to streamline the process for grant applications, awards, budget resolutions, budget transfers from reserves, and CIP amendments. Specific items requiring approval, if any, will be provided by Supplemental Memorandum. Agenda Item: 19-0001 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (5 items) DEPARTMENTAL QUASI-JUDICIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT DPQJ-1 JENSEN DUNES PUD REVISED PUD ZONING AGREEMENT, REVISED MASTER SITE PLAN AND PHASING PLAN (J046-008) Request for approval of the Second Amendment to the PUD Zoning Agreement and Revised Master Site Plan and Phasing Plan. The 34.3 acre subject property is located on the north side of Cedar Street between the FEC Railroad and Savannah Road and south and west of the Town of Ocean Breeze in Jensen Beach. Included in the application is a request for a deferral of a Certificate of Public Facilities Reservation. Agenda Item: 19-0047 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO (request to continue to Nov 20) DPQJ-2 CIRCLE K US-1 COVE ROAD MAJOR REVISED FINAL SITE PLAN (C166-002) This is an application by Circle K Stores, Inc., requesting approval for a revised commercial, major development final site plan with a Certificate of Public Facilities Reservation for a 2.9 acre site located on the northwest corner of SE Cove Road and SE Federal Highway in Stuart. Agenda Item: 19-0048 Printed on 11/8/201811/13/18 BCC FINAL AGENDA Page 4 of 5

DPQJ-3 MANATEE ISLES PLAT (S216-011) Request for plat approval for the Manatee Isles project consistent with the approved minor final site plan approved on October 2, 2018. The 2.3 acre development is located on the northeast corner of SE Capstan Avenue and SE Azimuth Way in Port Salerno. Included with this application is a request for a Certificate of Public Facilities Exemption. Agenda Item: 19-0063 PUBLIC - PLEASE LIMIT COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES. ADJOURN Printed on 11/8/201811/13/18 BCC FINAL AGENDA Page 5 of 5

Showing the first 24,000 of 83,092 characters. The full document is at the source.

>>> good morning, everybody. I would like to call the November 13, 2018 board of county commissioners meeting to order. It is a very exciting day for us here. On the commission, we will start with an invocation by pastor dave albers, from the re deemer lutheran church follow ed by the prejudice of allegiance. If you would all stand. Good morning, pastor. >> well, lord, as we look forward to the national day of thanksgiving, May every day be a day of thanksgiving, because your blessings are new every morning. We will thank you for the blessings of this day and great grateful hearts for the community in which we live. I pray for the commission that they would work as best stewards of all the resources you give us each and every day. We pray also, that the state elections would come to adjust in an amicable end and that the correct candidates be put in place. We thank you that we live in nation and we don't have to pick up arms if elections don't turn out the way we like but we can truly love one another and help one another and be a neighbor to one another. I pray this all in jesus' name. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you very much. >> let me statute forethe record, that commissioner smith will not be attending today's meetings so all of our votes will have him absent from the vote calculations. We have one additional item. It is a consent item. Consider resolution regarding a policy with exit commissioners for out going dishers no consent agenda pulls. Couple of requests to continue to November 20th. Consent five. Agricultural and natural resources appointments. And this is the revised pud zoning agreement. Revised master site plan. And phasing plan that was pulled at the applicant's request and that was pulled by commissioner smith. We don't have additional items at this time. I would entertain a motion to approve the agenda as presented >> so moved. >> we have a motion and second. All those in favor. Aye. Opposed. Motion carries unanimously. Can you say unanimously. We have public comment. The first one. Two very familiar faces for a lot of folks but not for everyone. Amanda jones and brian johnson. Glad to have you this morning. >> thank you. I am brian johnson. Amanda jones, we are the art teachers at martin county high school. We have a project that we are presenting that is in process right now. kim jones of the prescription shop in downtown stuart, approached us about painting a mural on her building. It is a 70-foot long wall, 12 to 14 feet high. And we went and we had a couple of meetings discussing what subject matter to do and with this mural and we decided on the history of martin county. And we do have, we will present , what the final design is. But, we would definitely like to thank regal paint center. They donated the pain. Miss Jones has donated the materials and the scaffolding and, of course, the wall. And, of course, the city of stuart with the crb donated or comped the application fee for the minor urban code. So, without further ado, I think, we will. >> Miss Kryzda. >> never mind. , then, if you can show it this way first and then turn it around. I have been watching the progress. It is awesome. >> pretty cool. >> very cool. >> fantastic. >> this is it. And this is the mural in it final form. Interest will be a larger section at the end with a sailfish on it and the rays continue out on to that part of the building. >> can you tell us, who are the individuals on. >> from left to right, that is felix a williams. He was the teacher of the year in 1956. He also helped start the special olympics in florida. 500 east ocean is behind him. And, of course pineapple is below him. And, of course the feed store and then caid county pine which many of the buildings were built out of and especially in the early days and then in front of the building is governor martin, who the county is named after meeting with seminole indian chief. I can't recall his name at the time. That is also governor martin in the in the middle. House of refuge and then this is hubert bessie, he owned a lot of the land in the area. He donated. The reason we have confusion corner instead of confusion sewall's point, because he donated flagler, wanted to run the railroad through sewall's point and he didn't want that and he donated the land. And asked flagler. And said. I will give you $200 plus the land and flagler said I don't need the money but I will take the land. So, that is hubert bessie, and stuart watts called potsdam before it was stuart. This is trapper nelson. And then we will have the sailfish up on the right and there is a chrysanthemum on there. >> a chrysanthemum is on there. >> yes. >> it is more interesting from that view. >>. >> so, we are about, 75% finish ed maybe a little less. And we are taking. We are going to be there this weekend painting again. That will be our fifth weekend. Then we are taking a weekend off after thanksgiving and then we will be back at it for probably two more weekends. So. >> that is fantastic. >> lovely. >> the gold paint will be a metallic gold. It is already up. We already tested. It. We are keeping in hurricane katrina high school is blue and gold isn't stuart is blue and gold, so, we are keeping in line with that. So. >> couple of comments. >> I would like to say thank you, too. It turned out to be more than I ever thought. I bought the pharmacy five year s ago. And every morning, there was a big blank wall and it stood out it would be nice if someone could paint on it. So, I went to the city. How about if the art department does it at the school. Would that be okay. They were like. We never had that and present something. So, when I called amanda, yes, I would like to do that. >> it turned into something so much more than I thought and it is realry cool. Anybody who wants to come and help paint on the weekend. They are there. Mostly and the students. we have had a lot of people from everywhere. >> you are taking volunteers to help. >> always. >> art teachers did not agree with that. They had straight faces when you said that. I wanted to recognize chick-fil-a in stuart. They donated lunch for all painters. And sandwiches and lemonade and it is just a great experience for the kids. Also, there is a grant now available. So, I shared that with all the art teachers in martin county. They can apply for the grant if they have a wall. They would like to paint, too. >>. >> couple of points, the familiar he is a is at the round about at colorado and martin luther king, right where the fountain is. And so, if you, know. >> from the mart martin county cleaners. >> martin luther king, where the supervisor of elections is. It is right at the round with. You can't Miss It. I knew the project was coming. My daughter has had both of you >> are you the teacher of the year. >> for the high school. >> you are the martin county teacher of the year. Congratulations. >> some day kids will paint a mural with your picture on it. And then also, what I would like to say is that there are, hobe sound has done a remarkable job creating an environment where people are looking to come now and see the seeds of buildings that up until recently meant nothing. If you are familiar with wind ward walls down in miami. That was an area that was like an old warehousing district and now, it is the top tourist destinations. I have been down there with my kids and they are posing for pictures. If you go on facebook and you see the bright colored murals. You know everyone is down there I would love to see that continue. I will be contacting you, folks we have a couple of large walls in palm city. I know there are large walls and in inside indiantown as well. So, I am very much looking forward to working with you all and the other schools. If you remember, the last time we had a project similar to this is when the bathroom facility at the stuart beach. >> brenda lee, I know, it is like brenda lee had done a remarkable job with the kids down in jensen and also down in the birling in hobe sound -- building in hobe sound beach. It is a way to enhance the community and congratulations. Actually. I just walked passed that. Brenda lee did that as well. >> brenda rehelped with -- brenda helped with this project nadia and we have homegrown talent right here. Not just the students but the grown ups. Stephanie ranieri is here. She does a lot of artistic endeavor vors as well. >> thank you. Congratulations. >> next request to speak form is erin smith. >> good morning. >> good morning. Hi, how are you. Thank you for having me today and to kind of piggyback on the teachers. I am here as a representative, of hobe sound and I ask for the opposition of the high speed train, that is potentially going to come through martin county. Four years ago, a child was hit by a train in hobe sound. It was a friday night. And we were all at the soccer field and sorry. But the fear that you have when a child is hit by a train and% the soccer field is cleared because tram ma hawk has to come down and you don't know where your child is. Because there was such chaos. I don't think any of us want to experience that ever again. Thankfully, that child was not a fatality. And I just. >> I know that having a high speed train. Coming through. >> that could potentially happen. >> also, obviously, with the popularity of golf carts with family. Trying to pile them up and get them over a train track. I wouldn't want to see what could happen. So. >> thank you, ma'am. >> for your heartfelt comments. We appreciate it. >> and interesting, next speak er, is doug smith. >>. >> Mr. Smith, you are supposed to be sitting up here I believe >> maybe some day. >> thank you for having me this morning. By the way. >> pretty much a life long resident of hobe sound. Hobe sound the last few months and we haven't forgot be about the train and we have been inun dated with hobe sound and the midterm elections. There was an article that came out, I believe on October 22, in tc palm that stated that the city of stuart is going to get on board with entertaining and put a depot in downtown stuart. That terrifies us residents of hobe sound. If stuart gets on board, jensen beach will get on board and all of palm city will get on board to allow the bright line to come through the area. >> for hobe sound, as you probably know, once the train clears the curb out of jonathan dickinson, heading north to the vw, near mariner sands. About a 5 mile stretch. If those trains get up to 100 miles an hour. Originally pulling passenger trains. We know what is behind that is the big powered freight trains coming out of the ports. If that train derails at those speeds. It is catastrophic for the residents on gomez and dock myers park where our kid play soccer, there is not even a chain link fence around that park. i would hate to see what would happen. So, I urng you as the county commissioners. I know there is a ruling coming out at the end of the month about continuing funding. Please fight against the railroad. I guarantee you and I don't want it to happen, if we get the train. It is disastrous at some pint and it could be political suicide for some of you guys. I know our town of hobe sound will be up here. I am just one of many. Very active in the community and I hear the concerns. That's why I am here today and I appreciate your time. Thank you. >> thank you, sir. Appreciate that. >> our next and last request to speak form. If you want to address us this morning, you can after the next speaker. You can speak first and fill the form out afterward is Mr. Tom pine. >> Mr. Pine, good morning, sir. >> good morning, commissioners. I live in jensen beach, florida I have been a resident for over 45 years in martin county. >> she said when I showed pictures, it could easily understand what I was speaking of, and what particular area of town I was speaking. I was kind of stunned or overwhelmed at the time because I show pictures at every meting -- meeting. >> I said this is how the county goes about keeping the views that I don't consider out of of the public. as much as possible. So, I went home to view the past meetings. The last six meetings that I showed pictures. They were not shown. >> Chairman Of the board defend ed the fact that no one showed up as town hall meetings relative to the fire assessment tax. Saying that many times people don't show up to town hall meetings and I agreed. Once the quote, the letter get sent out, the meetings there after were pack. -- packed. The same thing is happening by not allowing me to show picture s. It is a way of controlling the pub public from what they say at the commission meetings. >> code enforcement uses pictures all the time at meetings. And they are televised. Is it only county employees that are the only ones to allow to view pictures: have the rules changed and I haven't caught up with it? I read, every time I show a picture. I have to show up at least a day early to have them approved which I have done, the Chairman Has checked several times. With the county administrator to make sure these pictures, have, in fact, been approved. They get approved, and someone al link the line they don't get shown. >> it just seems, doesn't seem right to me. Censorship is not only will you illegal, it is immoral. and it is obvious, we have roast our moral compass in martin county. Thank you. >> thank you, Mr. Pine. Miss Kryzda. >> couple of questions. >> can you look into what Mr. Pine said. I assume when we show his pictures on the dot cam here. Is there is an rule that we are not showing his pictures. >> not necessarily. With you we don't normally comment during public comment. So an individual can show something and make statements that we don't have an opportunity to necessarily address or to come back we have add situations where we showed the pictures ahead of time to make sure. And I guess the question is: is the county commission want ing toe be -- to be inform ed or the purpose of public comment for the whole general public or how do you want to handle it. Prior to us. And sometimes we don't have the D.O.T. Cam that works and we are criticized that we are do ing that because a certain individual had something they wanted to put on the D.O.T. Cam and the dot cam was broken. It puts us in the dynamic. >> individuals are not happy one way or another. >> okay. I can speak for my colleagues. I will tell you how I feel. I believe the policy of individuals showing up with pictures that you or one of your delegates has not had the opportunity to see ahead of time can be a potential problem and when you created the problem that someone wanted to show a photograph, or use the dot cam, which for the folks don't know is the camera in the ceiling that lays on the table and you can lay pictures flat and see them. You thought the policy created, someone would have to have your approval ahead of time. Handle that and allow the folks to show pictures. I don't have an issue with that I see your point. >> whether it is Mr. Pine or someone else and has gone through the effort to bring them and you have approved them and then they show the pictures at a dat come to us who is here I have no problem, that those pictures would be shown object channel 20, because you have seen them and vetted them in terms of whether they were offensive. >> now, opinion resist opinions and the public comment. A lot of that is opinion. If it was all going to be ex sluflly fact based then quite often, it wouldn't be comments. But, that is the, I personally agree that that is the way the system should work. We do ourselves a disservice if we some how sensor those pictures. If you need an agenda item or motion. I thought if they showed up on the D.O.T. Cam. They were part of the meeting. The televise veezed meeting. The vetting process of you see ing them ahead of time is enough for me. And if the pictures are, you know, sort of don't show the county and in its best light and they are accurate pictures that you felt were appropriate. At least to be shown to the general public. Then that is that. And we can address the issues and debate whether someone's opinion of what the county is doing is accurate. Mr. Pine has said the chair. Some of what he said even at this meeting. I would disagree with. But I agree with his opportunity to say it. That is my opinion. Commissioner heard has her light object. >> it is part of public comment if the photos have been pre approved, we see them. We have seep them every single time. I assume the public was seeing them, too, because it is not a complete comment if they can see the photos we are looking at. It is imperative that the photo s be shown. As I recall, every one of Mr. Pine's comments are intend ed to be constructive. Every one of them. He points out safety matters. Code enforcement irregularities he is trying to make our county better. Every time. And I think it is real important that we help him along. I want my county to improve. >> we respond to them, commissioner heard. But, like I said. We had a situation where the dot cam was not working and we were not able to show the photo s and we got criticized that it was intentional and we didn't have a chance to respond to that. It is not the intent that we had equipment failure. So, we decided in abundance of caution so we are not being put in the situation of choosing one over another and there is no censorship. Every photo he has shown. He has shown to the board. It is not like we picked and choose photos. I have no problem. I had delegated that down to individuals and so, I will go back and say, it has got to be me. I have to come and look at the photos and make sure. Then, when I say. This isn't appropriate and this is. Then, we are put in that situation. So, what ever the board chooses , we will do. >> we can address it this morning. Commissioner fielding. And I guess the others had expressed my perception as well and as a public forum. It is an opportunity. We happen to be here because we are trying to make decisions and so we get information. It is not just a limited one way kind of information. It is a public forum and so I fully support that as pepght -- aspect of it and as to the evaluation of pictures and whatever mute be shown. It does need to be reviewed in the sense that it not be something that would be offensive to the general public so, in that sense, if I might happen to disagree with it, hey , I disagree with myself sometimes. I am not opposed to disagreeing >> what I do believe is that we need to be open. And available am and if it it is something that teppedz to picture an activity that we wish weren't happening that way that gives us an opportunity to% focus in. Some has been expressed. Thank you. >> thank you. >> I agree. And the boundary of, Miss Kryzda, you said one thing, that you have delegated some of those authority to others to view the photographs. It does not need to be exclusively be you. If you are a busy person. That you are here and if you were to pick the top people that obviously we trust enough to run departments and someone from legal. And it is not just a matter of what would be offensive if it is. And inappropriate. I agree with what commissioner heard said. Whether Mr. Pine comes forward. Using you as an example. When you come forward with your photographs. I too, agree, that nearly, in every instance, they were pictures that were information al and I agree with what you said Miss Kryzda and commissioner heard about constantly improving. I thought a lot of the information that Mr. Pine has brought forward has been beneficial for us as an organization. I agree that his underlying motivation is to make this a better community. I welcome it. I see your point and you didn't cavalierly say we are not going to show his pictures. But the televised portion of the meeting whether it is live and complete representation of how the meeting went. I do know that one day the dot cam was broken. And we can all understand. If the dat come was bloken and if his pictures weren't shown over the course of several meetings or when the dot cam was broken, I said broadway bak the photos and give him double time to make his original comments again. >> look, I want him to bring them forward. We all do. None of us are owe opposed or afraid of what we are doing and to hold it up to the light of day or criticism is appropriate so, would you want official. You are fine with the understanding. >> show the pictures as long as they have been approved. >> yes. >> Mr. Pine, thank you, sir. >> I concur with all of that. >> thank you. >> that was our last request to speak form. Anyone else that would like to address us. Now is the time. Seeing none, we will move onto the proclamations. We have several. Very worthwhile organization that is we will be recognizing this morning. Our first proclamation is farm city week. >> that is declaring farm city week in martin county, florida. Miss Bow pray, welcome. >> peaupre. >> ranchers help meet the world and rely on partnerships to sell products to consumers. November 14 true 21st is recognized as farm city week in martin county. The board encourages all citizens to recognize the achievements of those who provide the amazing abundance of ak cultural products that we all enjoy. We have rick and reed martin. From the martin county farm bureau. >>> rick heartman for the record. Commissioner fielding. Thank you for your service. Last eight years have been, you have really put yourself out there. I know it has been difficult for you. But I thank you for your service. >> wow, okay. >> our next request. >> our next proclamation is alzheimer's disease awareness month. >> November is recognized as alzheimer's disease awareness month and they provide services to provide vital care and support and for dementia specific care and support alzheimer's families in finding a cure. Here to accept. We have been any johnson and jonathan price. And dora sander from the alzheimer's association south east florida chapter. >>> good morning, I am doris sanders from the alzheimer's association. On behalf of the more than 5 million people in the you state and their 16 million caregivers, and this is important, 240,000 of those are in the state of florida. Second only to california. 6,500 of those alzheimer's people are in martin county. And so, I come to say, how thankful we are for you. How much we appreciate your support. Alzheimer's support, alzheimer's association has three main emphasis and that is awareness, education and re search. So, we appreciate anything that you can do to help us with awareness. We are so grateful for the support that we are getting for government, because that is the only way we are going to defeat this disease. So. On the city, county. State and national levels, we are receiving support and we appreciate it. In fact, this year, in the budget for the federal budget, we were granted $425 million through the national institute of health for research. The reason I am excited about that is because that amount brings us to what director collins of the nih said we need in order to slow down or pre vent and cure this disease. >> we thank you for your help. we believe every tiny sliver of awareness helps people to know what alzheimer's is. And how destructive it is and one of the leading causes of death and the only one with no cure. No treatment and no progress. On that level for a good while. So, we are really trying to and we appreciate so much your help as we struggle to end alzheimer's disease. >> thank you. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. >> thank you, doris. >> I am bonnie johnson. Board member of alzheimer's community care. Thank you Chairman Ciampi and others board of county commissioners for declaring November of 2018 an honor of alzhe

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners on 2018-11-13 9:00 AM — Minutes
  • Board of County Commissioners on 2018-11-13 9:00 AM
  • Board of County Commissioners on 2018-11-13 9:00 AM — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8b0d7f03da38056c7ac6592049337fd2. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record