POLISCOPE

The public record

FOLSOM (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Folsom City Council Regular Meeting

Tuesday, December 10, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Folsom City Council Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 100,064 stored characters

[Technical difficulties] >> for item d I have three questions. The increase in the contract that is proposed, the simple question is interviews with the perspective contractors happened a year ago by what is in this report and why the long lag time until today. >> good evening. What happened was we got the cost estimates before the budget process for last year. Brought everything, all of the increases through the budget process. Some were approved, some were denied. And what we did in the meantime work on negotiated contract so to speak to see if we could reach an agreement of where we could actually afford the increases and where we could not. We were on months to month until this time. >> got you. And then the staff report indicates that part of the process of trying to get this contract together was right-sizing the services which maybe were lacking previously or not -- was not enough time devoted to some of the activities. The contract, though, represents a 60% increase in what we were paying previously. How much of that would you attribute to changing the scope of work versus just escalation of cost. >> few factors. One of the things that we wanted to also do in this new contract was to repackage how we were having irrigation repaired in a lighting landscape district. Before what we would do is have it done under unscheduled. Send out when we had an irrigation repair. Send out and let the contractor know they buy parts and pieces and send their technician out to repair it. What we wanted to do different here, because we could save about 30% we would buy the parts and we would buy the staff person's time. So we would translated the staff time that we are paying under unscheduled over into the scheduled. So while this is going up a bit on the scheduled we will see decrease on the unscheduled. Because most of our unscheduled work is irrigation repair. >> got you. So of that 60% increase then in this case, how much was previously -- separate? >> probably a half. >> half? >> half of that. The other translates into staffing. Which you might be getting to on the trails. >> the only other question I is not a question it is more of a general comment. A lot of the services we received from outside and costs have escalated a lot in the last several years, this is an example where we are going from, you know, 90,000 per month to 145,000 per month. The comment is that the bids that we received were spread wide apart and being involved in construction projects at least in bidding in the past, that is sometimes indicates that the scope of work is not super clear. Sometimes it means that maybe not enough time was allowed for the contractors to give good pricing and I just -- the two that were, the one that you negotiated with obviously was the low bidder. The others were so much higher that it is -- makes me nervous about the results that we are getting from bidders. >> well, this is the rfp and the (Inaudible) To, very detailed plenty of time, we were not in a rush, knew we had plenty of time to work with the contributors who were interested. I think it might -- I can not speak to contributely what their strategy was in pricing that out, both of those other companies have not worked with us before and once you understand the economy of scales that you can get by everything, doing maintenance in the city right next to park or lighting landscape district and next to trail there is a huge amount of economy of scale that can be leveraged without sacrificing the end product and I suspect that terracare having being under contract had an advantage there. >> got you. That was specific question thank you. Move item 10365. >> second. >> call the roll please. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski. >> yes. >> shedon. >> yes. >> and howell. >> yes. >> and this is a clarification on g, 10368 on its survey 40, folsom auburn road oak avenue existing speeds 40 to 50, and then changes to existing it says zero should that not be zero to 10? If that whole stretch is going up to 50? Where some is now 40? >> our intention is to leave the short section from old oak to greenback lane as 40-mile an hour zone due to driveway density. >> agree completely. It wasn't clear from this. >> I see. >> have that extra column that says changes to existing it said zero with that move resolution. >> second. >> call the roll klees. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski yes. >> sheldon. >> yes. >> howell. >> yes. >> and item I 10370 with regards to 108,642 that has to be appropriated for transportation impact these funds is council have to take action and when is that expected to happen? To appropriate 10 # thousand. >> part of resolution. >> okay. 108,000. Move that item as well. >> second. >> call roll. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski. >> yes. >> sheldon. >> yes. >> and howell. >> yes. >> moves us to item 7 public hearing regarding proposed increases to water wastewater and solid waste rates and fees. >> open item with a few remarks about public outreach that led to the public hearing on proposed utility rate increases and we will have a 5-minute powerpoint to let you know what we have done toed from the word. We worked hard to reach those affected by these potential rate increases in many ways using different mediums. If you are an avid social media user we wanted to reach threw, prefer email we want to be in your inbox like worldwide wen we wanted you to click and find relevant information quickly. If you despise technology we wanted to be in your U.S. Mail post box and if you are more of a people person we wanted to provide in-person information sessions for you. So by our count the proposed rate increase and related issues have been discussed and vetted at at least 16 public meetings over the last 21/2 years. Of course tonight we are having a public hearing which brings us to a grand total of 17. Now, we mailed our proposition 218 mailer and there is a picture of the front cover there to all folsom utility rate customers in mid October. We took the extra step which is not required by law of including rather than just describing a protest form in the mailer in case there is recipients to submit a protest to any or all of the proposed rates. We put together a website fully devoted to proposed rate increases and advertised the link as broadly as possible. We wanted to distill complex information into something more relatable and meaningful and developed comprehensive q&a document that we constantly updated based on feedback and based on questions coming into city hall and then we pushed the link out to that q&a onto social media. We are one of a precious minority of cities that still mail a hard copy newsletter to their residents. So articles with the proposed increases appeared in two of our newsletters over the last few months, reaching over 29,000 households and businesses. In addition to our hard copy newsletter we also blast out weekly enewsletters by emails and articles about proposed rate increases appeared in nine eblasts reaching over 8,000 people or our email distribution list. We posted at least 8 facebook and twitter posts on this topic. Close to 23,000 impressions, posted three next door posts resulting in over 9600 impressions and I did my first yikes facebook live and devoted great portion of that to the proposed utility rate increases. And advertisement about where to find out more to find out about the propose rate increases appeared on sac metro cable television channel 14 I know all of you watch that all of the time I'm sure. We hosted a community open house with me and relevant department heads and managers delivering a prepared presentation and then more importantly, taking any questions from the audience. Videotaped that meeting and posted video to our website. Utility customers received a message about public workshop and bills that you see under special messages. We placed four ads in the local folsom paper and featured this subject in my November column in the newspaper and circulation of folsom telegraph is over 22,000. In addition to dedicated web page on the issue, we promoted issue on the home page of our website and also in our website newsroom. And finally, if you had nothing else to do in life you could stand in our lobby and watch information about this issue slide by on our digital message board. And you could of course pick up copies of the mailer at our public counters. With that, unless anyone has any questions about public outreach turn it over to environmental and water resources director marcus and both he and dave nugent have pretty short concise presentations tonight because we really have the desire to leave the bulk of the time for questions from the council and of course the public. So, thank you. >> thanks elaine. Mayor howell members of the council, marcus, environmental and water resources director. Elaine said I ha a quick presentation that will cover the water and wastewater portion of the proposed rate increase, dave nugent, public works director covers the solid waste portion. This is a brief summary of the prior two meetings we have held at city council as well as the public open houseworkshop we had in November. So purpose of this presentation really four key items to review rate study goals and objectives quick overview of the setting of cost based rates, what we have to do in each utility to identify revenues and expenses and how we come up with a rate or given customer base and in the particular presentation obviously review water and waste water rate study results and if there is any feedback later on in the evening, gain feedback from the public. Goals and objectives, obviously sets the rate, operating in capital expenses match revenues received from customers. And this provide as couple of things. Funding for our operations and maintenance and funding for capital replacement. There is another item included in operation of maintenance, debt service and on the waterside, not on the waste waterside. We have to repay bonds and loans for city on the waterside and that is included in a roll-up of o&m. We want to maintain adequate reserves in each one of our utility funds on the waterside this was critical when we were in mandatory water use reductions. By the state and in 2014, 2015 and part of 2016. so this did help provide a reserve for under receiving less revenues than what we would have collect fed we were not required to reduce our water use as a city and so the target for water and waste water is 40% of o&m capital improvements from rates and in this case for water debt service and then cost allocation is what water and waste water and obviously solid waste pay to other support here at the city. City manager's office, finance, et cetera, those offices that provide support for our operations on daily and the annual basis and important with complying with proposition 218. Quick oversaw of setting cost base rates one look at revenue requirements for each one of the utilities same between water wastewater and solid waste. We fund different items. Obviously vehicles in solid waste are different than the vehicles and equipment that we have in water and wastewater but all that is included. Developing a cost of service. And so we take what our revenue requirements are and we need to identify how we equally distribute those costs to each one of our customers. So between residential and the non residential categories. We cannot charge more to one customer base than the other. Not in compliance with proposition 218 and need to do cost for service analysis for each of our customer bases. And then develop the rate design. So once we are able to identify what the costs are associated for each one of our customer categories, then we can identify what the specific rates and rate base is for those customer classes. That is the way information rolls into the numbers that that were in the notice and what we presented at various meetings. Rate adjustments at least on the waterside include current and future staffing levels, memorandum of understanding, salary adjustments, obviously just increased utility costs between 2008 on the wastewaterside, 2011, 12012 on the waterside, public works has a 2004 for these adjustments vehicle replacement differ between water wastewater and solid waste, we all have vehicle replacement to keep up with and on the waterside, water meter and meter reading why I'm placement fund. Know that at some point in time we will have to replace certain amount of water meters throughout the city. We have some that were installed as long as 1991. And those over time will have to be replaced and we want to ensure that we have a fund available to make that reinvestment and not have to -- so we can continue on pay as we go opposed to issuing new debt to cover that. Debt service again only on the waterside and then capital reinvestment. So that is pumps pipelines and tanks and in the case of water and replacing that infrastructure as needed. I do want to be clear that the rate adjustment do not include any water supply or water infrastructure for any of the development south of highway 50. A separate funding for that which includes particular agreements in financing plans and CFDs that are associated with those projects and I do have on this particular presentation a specific surcharge for the customers or future customers south of highway 50. Which covers the cost of the actual water supply itself. So just a quick summary. Water revenue requirement we went over this a couple of months ago. This yellow line shows the trend of what the present rate would fund moving forward and as you can see in the first couple of years, cover o&m and debt service but get out into the you know, years 3, 3 through 6 in this case and we would not be able to cover debt service which in this case would only cover operations and maintenance. So that is the trend of current rate structure. So what we are trying to do obviously then be able to cover debt service and capital reinvestment. Revenue requirements for this and detailed report available on-line show that water rates adjustments are one, necessary reflects the need to fund water o&m which includes debt service expenses. Obviously fund adequate annually renewal and replacement projects, infrastructure and capital improvement program and then meeting our reserve targets necessary or that are identified at that 40% mark. This is just a quick summary on the residential side of what current and proposed rates look like. This is information that was provided a couple of months ago as well and in the mailer. Non residential document here which identifies fixed and commodity charges on the meter side. Here is a comparison and this is a residential comparison only. We did not include non residential because that would be a much larger graph and chart and just included residential with an average water or monthly water use of 16 ccf, we can see where the city is currently and where the city will be. After the proposed rate adjustment f we looked at just a cti index and took 32.28 from 2011 until 2019 we would be at 45.16. Less than cti and less than the regional average. Waste water. Same thing only difference here we don't have debt service that we need to cover here, you can see we run into a similar problem in 2023 and that would be funding o&m and not everything the capable to fund capital reinvestment at current or present rate structure. Same items in waterslide proposed proposed residential rates current on far left and what we are proposing for throuh July 1, 2024. This is non residential slide and I do -- I will point out two things on the next slide here that are different than what was in the mailer. This item here for parks, in the mailer had per 1,000 square feet. but we are changing to it a per fixture unit write matches our regional nomenclature for parks consistent with information that our revenue division is currently collecting and putting into system for confirmation and you know, any audits that we have to do with regional san and make sure that customer billing base matches regional san -- >> for the people sitting here tonight and those watching tv on-line it is sacramento regional county sanitation district portion of the bill that goes directly for operation of the wastewater treatment plant and transmission large diameter transmission lines that take wastewater to wastewater treatment plant which is basically in elk grove. >> thank you mayor howell. Other item to point out, this was correct in the staff report. That is why you do not see this in the staff report, am pointing it out, it is different for those with the mailer in hand. This item here for colleges, was incorrect in the staff report and in the mailer. So I do want to point this out as well I believe it had 2.46 or 2.64 and I think that 3.05 out here which was incorrect so we corrected those numbers which are less than the numbers in the mailer. So city tern can correct me if I'm wrong, but there is nothing else we have to do in terms of a new notice or anything like that. The number is lower than what was published in the prop 218 notice. I just wanted to point those out, one is in the staff report. and the other obviously the reference to mailer and corrected in the staff report. So again other survey on wastewater. See where the city is currently and where we will be if the rate adjustments are approved. Again we did cpi reference under $64, relative to 2008 to 2019. And as you can see here, about 4 higher than the regional average. But fairly consistent with our neighbors that also flow into regional san. South of 50 this is surcharge I was mentioning earlier in reference to water supply. Similar to east area surcharge the city has in empire ranch parts of rodstone and parkway and this is fundamentally the pay for the water supply that is serving that particular area. So in this case, the amount that the water costs for 5,000-acre feet is 1.78 million. That then is distributed between the residential and non residential customers that will be south of 50 on residential side it comes out to 9.20 per month, non residential side on basis which is 85 per ccf numbers are not the same similar criteria used for the surcharge. >> and again just to be really clear, that these are only charged to customers south of 50? >> correct. >> to back up, to the previous slide. That golden state contract city of folsom was paying for that all along that cost is being shifted to residents south of freeway correct? >> correct. a couple of years ago when the water supply agreement was approved, during that time, the east area was paying a surcharge I think of about 12 on the residential side. >> I think it was more than that, I want to say it was closer to 20. >> there was surcharge that east area was paying. And then when the water supply agreement was approved that cost or a portion of that cost, 1.78 million was shifted from th residents and customers within the east area to the plan area. At that time I think it might have been 2015. >> we reduced -- >> from 12 to over $4, I think it is 4.28 I believe on the residential side. And yes, now, this cost that was being borne by those customers north of the freeway are now being covered by those customers south of the freeway. That is all I have for water and wastewater. >> any questions? None. Okay. Solid waste, you are up. >> thank you good evening Madam Mayor dave nugent public works director marcus said a lot of the 218 notifications and the process are similar with solid waste. So I'm not going to get back into that and rehash all of that. For solid waste, we started off in early 12018 with an operational analysis to really dig into what we are doing, how we can better make efficiencies and look holistically at services we provide. At that time it was decided to look at the bundled rates and keep them the same, all of the things we currently provide that is what we analyze we don't want to look at starting to piecemeal what we are providing which second green waste, bulky waste pick-up and door-to-door hazardous waste and others. 7-day commercial service and these services are for north of 50 only. No south of 50 component in to our analysis. Looked at making sure revenues watch expenditures. And developed a rate model and we brought those to you in the past and I'll touch on those in a bit. The biggest thing we realized throughout all of our analysis are the state unfunded mandates. A listing of them. We discussed these a number of times. And this is the last one on there, sb 1383 I presented kind of what is coming down the turnpike at us. This does not include those costs. We do include some staffing costs in these rates to anticipate what we will need to do in the way of program management and outreach in light of what is coming as far as the organics recycling program for residential. But we simply don't know the fixed cost. Olympicersal cost. We don't know the state has not told us how we tore operate and we can not include those costs or forecast them under prop 218 at the point where I said last time we most likely be back in front of you if those costs are extreme and we can not (Inaudible) In current structure currently we do not include a lot of those costs. As we spoke before some of the major drivers recycling crash back it seems a long time ago only last year early 2018, the bottom of the slide there is the big, big key, we went from 465,000 per year revenue stream to offset our operational costs to 671,000-dollar expense, that is over 1.1 million swing in our revenue stream. So we mentioned this before. Rates have not increased since 2004. That is a simple graph showing our current rate and cpi if we were to follow the consumer price index from 2004 to current our current rates would be 45.53. For the 64-gallon container. Comparison wise this is how folsom compares in the region. With our neighbors. One update since our last briefing with you, I have highlighted sacramento there recently updated their rates I believe last week adopted the rate increases. And they dropped or they jumped another $6 over the next two years. >> clairly facial city of sacramento. >> city of sacramento correct and they do not offer anywhere near suite of services we provide. >> but they do have a claw. >> the do have a claw. As I said we presented multiple scenarios for consideration. These are kind of what those look like in order for us to meet our revenue expenditures. Our revenues match revenues with expends tours as well as develop reserve balance. Ultimately after our public workshop came back with a hybrid and here is what was done to kind of smooth out some of the costs and we move some expenses, moved those into future years to reduce total amount. We right-sized our existing fleet and expansion. We delayed replacement of the four vehicles later to fiscal year 23 and showed moderate increase for residential as well as commercial. Here is what the rate would pull out of that. These are the monthly anticipated increases for residential commercial and roll off, 3.50 per month until July, 4.50, 5.25 and 6. Here are the rates prop 218 mailer, these were included. Put them up here if anybody wants copie they are in the mailers. That is all I have. >> any questions of staff? >> I have one. Two. Two issues was (Inaudible) Mandas you listed. >> I did not hear you. >> two of the issues were state mandates obviously and also you mentioned that we looked at the bundled rates. So the other thing I wanted was a cost analysis of the bundle rates versus the percentage of users using those bundled services right I was told we could not get that. What did you guys look at to determine analysis of bundled rate versus not removing the bundle. >> we did not. Early on when we took to it utility advisory committee and saying here is what we are looking at and here is how we are doing it. They were adamant and directed us to not look at decreasing one services and to keep bundled rates or bundled services together as it were. We did not analyze the individual costs for each of those services. To do that we would have to start over and it would become a much more complex analysis at that point because we would have to without any real historical data go in and recalculate how to attribute costs to different services. Know what they were for household hazardous waste and bulky waste but wouldn't have a clear percentage to do it -- it would have to fluctuate over time until we got good imprchal data to hone in on true cost making a lot of assumptions. >> I can add to that we can discuss this before and my recollection of that conversation was that even separating all of that information out doesn't eliminate any division, does not eliminate any equipment. So there is no point really in having that discussion about you know, not province it because it doesn't change -- all it would do is shift the cost to regular green waste and recycled and trash it would increase. >> it my understanding is we have not done that analysis. we don't know if separating that could would eliminate. >> it does not eliminate any positions. >> well -- (Inaudible). >> maybe I can clarify a bit, what we do know is if we still offered the service by itself, and allowed people to opt out of that service, the opting out would be very minimal. Because you are not making use of it, your neighbor will be. Our costs are still there whether there is two or one of you. >> if you charge for services -- I wanted analysis if you charge for extra services our usage percentages were low 18 to 20% of rate payers use these services. 80% pay for 18 to 20%. So it makes no sense for me that is all I'm saying. I'm not disputing it I would really have loved to see that. To make that comparative analysis to find out if it is a valued option for rate payers. I don't know how we can make this assumption based upon utility commission recommendation to not do all of the due diligence and go through details for me he . >> I gets guess -- >>we don't want t go down that path, right? >> they wanted to keep all of the services and the levels of services that we are currently offering. >> for low percentage of rate payers though? >> yes I think the intangible what is benefit to the whole by providing that service. by people that if we don't provide it and people are not willing to pay the extra cost, because it would be essentially higher on you know, per each basis, they would choose not to do it. So we will end up finding garbage on white rock and -- >> no data to prove that. We don't know that. >> I would say based on other jurisdictions experience we do have data for that. >> and basically we -- people dumping sofas -- >> illegal dumping. >dumping of hazardous waste into storm drain. >> those are daschle comparable to folsom you would tangibly say that that our rate payers are related to that would dump sofas -- >> we currently see it existing now. By not offering that service we can only expect to it go higher. >> how do you know it is our rate payers. >> we don't. >> you don't. Leave it at that. It bothers me that first of all I'm not given details I asked for many times and you make a suggestion to say that you looked at -- >> it is not that we cannot give you details we have to start over with analysis and this took us good 7 or 8 months just to get to this point. We would have to start over and work those different variables back into all of te equations. >> what is the cost -- I mean -- >> the cost of starting over would be staff time I believe it cost in the neighborhood of 50 to $60,000 for consultant team to analyze all of the different scenarios with the bundled services -- >> nd (Inaudible) Details prior to (Inaudible). >> sorry? >> don't you think it would be proper and value to know all of those details? >> not when we were not directed to provide those. At the onset when we took it to utility commission, we asked, is this what you want, we can look at -- because we knew we were looking at substantial rate increases. And by that point we knew that the rates would be, you know, 15 or 20%. We asked. Do you want us to look at lowering that? We can look at reducing our services. We can look at eliminating the services and it was unanimous no, don't -- everybody loves the services they get -- >> making assumption off everyone loves services they are getting -- >> repeating what was told us to from the utility advisory committee. They said to us, everybody likes the service. Nobody wants, you know, nobody wants to reduce levels of service that we are providing. And the number of services. >> and did we -- I know -- (Inaudible) Did we find out meetings were public or recorded? >> I don't believe they are. >> do you mean commission session in. >> utility commission, yes. >> I don't -- >> thosef meetings are public meetings. >> I don't believe they are recorded. >> public meetings and advertised as such for anyone to attend. >> and there are minutes. >> and there is minutes. >> just two quick things and maybe possibly to ameliorate some of this concern. Operative state laws here mandate that we not charge more than our cost. >> correct. >> is that correct? So if upon further anal ses we were to find some other efficiencies we can reduce rate increases when that makes sense or we can slow them down. We have that flexibility, what we can not do is raise them further without going back through this process. >> prop 218 process is triggered by increase that the council has ever right to you know, decrease or you know, rebudget without prop 218 process. >> if you went back historically since 2004 rate increases on the books that were not enacted. >> a point of clarification because I was there. The rates were left increase in 2003. At the time, five years of projected increases. At that time, because recycling market was very lucrative, in 2004 because huh significant amount of income from selling recyclables, at the time, it was shortly after the state required that you meet certain standards city of folsom was first city in the state to meet recycling goals making boatload of money selling off recyclables in 2004 after we increased the rates in 2003 we reduced them. >> right. >> dave, some people have specifically pointed out the cost of an extra pick-up. Currently, it is $15 for additional pick-up. By 2024 that increases to 53. Is that just formula based, where the cost of the extra pick-up is seemed to me it was 1.2 or whatever times cost of just the regular monthly. Is it just formula based or how are the numbers determined. >> being told it is formula-based. >> okay. My other question is the residential solid waste increase is very consistent over the next five years but the non residential is not. Those seem to have kind of a steeper increase first year and modest increases in the rest. Wondering why the different approach? >> I will give it a shot. I May need someone to come up to answer that. We leaked at the way we provide our services and looked back to council member kozlowski we need to make sure we are charging appropriately the services that we are providing to the person that is getting service. Commercial is one of those that we looked at and how much it cost us to provide that service. It is a right-sizing in the commercial area. She is looking into her papers, but that is the explanation is we went back and that was part of whole analysis of our operations. The looking at how we provide the service, and what it costs us to provide that service and then creating the rate that goes along with that. >> okay. So in a very unsophisticated term it was out of whack and we are trying to got. >> there were some areas within our operations that it was extremely out of whack, yes. >> and did it get that out of whack because we went so long without an increase s that -- >> no. (Inaudible). >> okay. >> good evening. Okay. So with the commercial services, the two yard, 3-yard, 4-yard, 6-yard dumpsters at locations previously the rates were the costs were allocated on a per yard basis but the true costs is split between fixed and variable costs. It costs same amount to show up in the truck and lift the bin whether it is two-yard or 6-yard bin. That doesn't make difference. In right-sizing the commercial solid waste rates we took a look at the fixed cost versus variable cost and allocated those more appropriately and on the commercial recycling rates those were out of whack intentionally because years ago when these rates were established we were trying to create an incentive for businesses to recycle. At the time the city was required to recycle by mandate. But the businesses were not. And so some of that cost was absorbed into solid waste rate to keep recycling rates artificially low. And now businesses are monde ated to recycle. So we can -- armand ated to recycle so we can make the rates more appropriate to what the cost is and that is why some of the solid waste rates did not go up that much because they were higher in the past to absorb some of the recycling. >> maybe I'm missing something. And if I am I'm sorry. How do we justify charging rate pawers the cost of service when most rate payers are not using all of the services? I'm missing that delta. Like don't remember percentage for usage I don't know if you have them on you, value added services that are bundled together f the majority of rate payers are not using it how do we justify the charges to rate payers for the ones who are? >> the majority are using them. So bulk waste services, I don't have, that is why I was flipping through any binder, that is what I was looking for. It was around 65%, it was in the 60s, use the service at least once within the last five-year period. That is for the bulky waste. Hazardous materials was lower and second green waste and second recycle were relatively high percentages also. So if you look at all of those services across the board, most people are using some of them. >> if I recall, I saw it in your presentation, it would be opposite. It was closer to 18 to 20% usage rates. Not 60%. >> not for bulky waste. It is really high usage. On annual basis it is lower and I don't remember that percentage. But if you look at it over time, somebody May not need it this year but then they May need it the next year. That is why I looked at it over a span of five years and over 60, I think it was 65. But it was in 60 percentile range. >> any other questions. Okay our little script here we have to do this because this is a prop 218 requirement. So it is now time to open public hearing to give consideration to the proposed utility rate increases for water, wastewater and solid waste. Madam Clerk has notice been given in accordance with applicable law. >> yes required by prop 218 and prior resolution of city council notice of thi hearing was published once in folsom telegraph November 28, 2019 and notice mailed on October 28th of 2019. >> thank you (Inaudible) Mailed to property owners? >> mailed to property owners. >> thank you public hearing officially opened. Receive comments and questions and any protests from any interested person. When all comments have been received public hearing will be closed. So we have one request to speak. And this will be over and above the point where we get to the counting of the protest we received hand delivered or by U.S. Mail. So our one request to speak is todd (Inaudible). >> in May 2018 I received a mailer notifying a residents of proposed rate increase. City planned to increase water and sewer by a combined 12.50. You rescinded the rate increases when you decided to place measure e on 2018 ballot which would have guaranteed half sales tax increase for 10 years. Now you decided to raise our rates again. However, this time around you have added increases in garbage. The total increase to our monthly bill is 44.50. This is nearly three times the rate of inflation. The increase alone is about what I pay for home owners association dues. You are adding a new expense to our family budget. It certainly feels as if you are punishing the more than 7 out of 10 voters who soundly defeated measure e. It would not be so bad if you came out and admitted the fact that the city will get more revenue out of its residents by hook or by crook. It is this deceptive approach that causes outrage. To review. Last year, water, and sewer, 12.50. Today, water, sewer and garbage, 44.50. Council member gaylord I would like to thank you for all that you are doing right for folsom to the other members of the governing body shame on you. shame on you. One question, where do I submit my written protest? >> hand to it the police officer officer. (Inaudible). >> you can if you want. I wouldn't recommend it. I would say no at this point. Because he left the room. Do we have anybody else that would like to speak to council on this item? Sorry one more. That is from josh johnson. And if there is anybody else - that would like to, fill out a blue card and leave with it the police officer on this item or any other item. Item 7 rate increases we need them like right away. Sorry, you have 3 minutes. >> thank you. For the most part as long as my water is clean and the waste is going to elk grove I'm pretty happy. >> we like it better when it goes to elk grove too. >> I think folsom is the greatest city ever. Ernie I love watching you over the years, comments, some day I think we should have a bronze statue of you when people come up here we can rub it. You know for good luck. But, I was at the last meeting and then hearing this again, the issue of debt was part of that proposal. So where is refinance of that debt? Interest rates are at all-time low. We should have an option to refinance that. >> I will ask our finance director stacy to tackle this for you if that is okay. >> fine. >> we just did that. >> refinancing that debt is huge. >> finance director just explained that we can that we can that. >> lost my track of thought for a seconds. Second. >> (Inaudible). >> yes she just said that we refinanced. >> would it have been nice if those numbers were in the presentation to know that. Money is not something I have got a lot of. Right now my check out of this year I paid $25,000 just in income tax. And you tack on property taxes on that. Not to mention your insurance. All of the other fees. Last year you guys tried to sneak in sales tax increase on us. And now there is another 8 billion tax that county wants to do to pay for all of the roads going from elk grove to here which years ago they said during sacog meetings that there would not be tax increases for all of those things. So you know, a different day, a different tax. And quite frankly I'm sick of it. You know. I wish you guys for any state mandated fee would turn around and sue the state for each one of those on a separate lawsuit stand together with all of your other little cities around here and do the same thing. sue them. When the federal government says hey california do this california says no we are not doing that, why can't the little people do that, too, to the state? There is always a big surplus there. How come we are not going to them for more money. It is easier to kick it down to the little people. You know, how much more -- how much more until people are homeless because of taxes and all of that stuff? Does it have to -- does it have to happen. People in foothills are losing their homes because of the home insurance, they can not get home insurance banks put on hazard insurance forces them out of their mortgage they can not pay for that. All into one. I mean, nine city employees make 300,000 plus a year, 67 make over 200. 200,000 a year, 67 employees. It is a lot. Before I came here, I was googling trying find how much the city gave los rios to name three stages and they turned around and named it the hair center it sounds like a disease. Three stages is great. That guy it is ridiculous. You know, but little people are hurting, folks. You know, and it doesn't feel good. Not a lot of money right now. But in five years it is a lot of money. But -- >> okay we are just -- thank you. we have no other requests to speak on this item or do we? Matt. >> thanks for your time. Hello. One note. When I'm listening to representative over here and the data, they mentioned that the bulk waste was taken from over five years, five-year span of data and then we're talking about rate increase which is a yearly or a monthly so to a point where we are trying to have a good analysis of this it seems like that was one obvious point where you are talking about usage of bulk, 60% over -- 60% likelihood of one person using it over five years, talking about rate increase that is going to be monthly or yearly. I think it would be wise to hire consultant pay him 10,000, one ernst & young employee could spend a month review this data and possibly come to affirmation or some other conclusion but it seems like there is some flaw in the way that data was analyzed maybe review of how data was analyzed seems to be a good thing to do. Maybe spend a bit more time on how the data ive with indicates to the rate increase, which is a monthly or yearly charge. >> thank you. And no other requests to speak on this item. So I will close public hearing. Do we have any other protests that anybody has with them in the eroom that they would like to deliver? Okay. Public hearing is now closed. The clerk will are required to count all. Th protests that have been received. So we are going to take 5 minutes or 10 minutes? >> Madam Mayor if I May, you can certainly take a recess if you want, short recess or you May cotinue this item and take on next item. It is up to you. >> we will take 10 minutes while the protests are being counted. Back at 7:47. (Short adjournment brief recess) Okay, I believe that we have completed THExd counting.{_ >> we have. The city HASt(RECEIVEDf* a total7qquuu<q yuuuky?S of 201 WRITTENq protests for THEq proposed water~r rates, 210{_t( Protests for the WASTEWATERxDjf rates, 227 protests for the# these numbers include nine protests THATw3 could not be~rw3 validated by they werenb nonetheless assumed to be valid for}I purposes of tabulating a majority protest. Ese numbers fall short of what was needed for a protest therefore a majority protest does NOTc exist for the proposed utility rate+ increases. >> okay, so my~r~r next linea5 is at this time, because a MAJORITYe1 protest{_ does not exist, it'Sc privy for the city council to consider resolutions to establish new}I~r utility{_>ok rates.NbKo}I I'm going offscript here, but ~ just for the record, city clerk, if you could let us know how required in order to PREVENTe1 the city from being able to consider the rate increases?7ook`xc0@6cj% >> so we would have needed37%)U:u OVERt(Ko 12,440t(Protests to meet THExd THRESHo b set by pop 218~r limits.Lp >> so if}ijf I May, water rates, because SOj customers are~rpga not city of folsom customers, SOq} q threshold for the protest would be 11,107.=x 6c0@6cj% >> okay. >> meaning not anywhere close to a majority protest. >> that's correct. W >> okay. So DOx@ we have any other{_ questions o^r comments by}I THEok council members? Do we have anybody that would like to MAKEt(A motion? >> I think I'd like to start with a comment. First of all, I want to thank staff FORi] All their work and thank our utility commission for their work. Qof know, I don't think anybody wants to raise rates and certainly none of us~r want to pay more rates, but we WANTr OURxd we want water to come out of our faucet and when we flush our toilet, we want~rjf it to go WHEREt( It's supposed to go, so speaking to what the gentleman was talking about about the DEBTt( Service, we DIDi] Recently REFINANCEi]E1q that. The goal would be that we pay that off and we don't borrow anymore. E< we use part of this rate including ew y for capital expenses so we CANq operate on a pay as you}ic_[ gj{q}I basis which is obviously the ideal}I and I want to touch on the cz9rQgTSe1 about, you know, not everybody uses every servicemy or how do we separate those out. But I don't thinknb there's any{_*gx_[ way it can be anu exact science, because some people put their garbage out every two weeks. S9z| people out their recycling once a month. Some people put out their garbage can and it's half~rKoxd full. Lid can't close because it's so full,t(So there ISt(Just no~r exact way to chi$be somebody FORr the actual waste or recycling or whatever they're putting out,{_ so I think there's just no way it can be an exact science. >> any other}I comments, questions? Anybody want to make mention? >> just one quick question. The one thing that I wanted to point out about the process of going through THEf* UTILITYt( Commission for THESEr rates, because in the two years prior to my joining the city council, I was on the utility commission when this discussion first started is that that}I board specifically dragged our directors through some mud to make sure that the COSTr projections were not overly pessimistic in terms of extraordinary escalation of{_}I~r costs or capri}I }iq{_ capricious use of funds. We run FROMt( Very efficiently given the size of the city and the scope of THExd services}I WEKo provide. I have been ONxd this}I topic for the first t v years and the first slide that went up that had all the diffetk meetings, and I feel very confident making a motion :ju to asking council to~r APPROVEe1I] RESOLUTIONq NUMBERw3 10-362. >> do we have a second? >> I'll second.I]Okq >> we have a motion and a second.Q >> council member aquino,xd gaylord, kozun lou ski, ~ sheldon,}}I and howell.{_}I >> I WILLxd second. >> I apologize Madam Mayor, ASf* modified. >> and with the wastewater rates, I'm just going to make a comment. I was going to report that at the end of the meeting during council comments, but I have served for most of THEf* past 21 years as the city'Sok}I}i representative to}I the sacramento regional}I county sanitation district}I board that mar does referred to}I}i earlier. Several years ago, there was a long discussion about state man'*ed updatesr>}e1 on upgrades to the wastewater plant where all of our wastewater goes. At the time, that project WASok originally projected to BEf* a LITTLEct(T(Over $2 billion. I actually argued with the state board that it was e/+n necessary, but we were required to do it regardless. The total project cost for that was decreased~r to about $1.2 billion from the original cost estimate.`/k- and so SEVERALr p}I years ago,~r}I that board that's made up of people from the county}I and all of the jurisdictions that who has wastewater feeds into THATry | plant, including sacramento and part of yellow county, we were forced to look at potentially very, very}I large rate increases. We found a@.Ky to reduce that based on the project COSTSq so the one portion of THEf* utility bill that everybody in THISq room is paying, $37 of that bill goes to regional sand for operation of those large pipelines and that plant. Those rates were~r increased about four or five years ago and~r based on information that was provided at the last regional sanitation district board meeting that I attended a couple of weeks ago, the district, because they have done very well with keeping the project costs down and the district itself has an extremely good credita5 rating, so their bond rate is at 1.3 o something, some very, very low number, so regional sands is not f expected to have to increase that rate from the $37 for at least the next TENxd years. So that's THExd only bit OFt(Gj news I can shed on this particular subject. We have a}I motion and a/# =9d on the wastewater rates?3w >> council member aquino, gaylord, kozun lou ski, sheldon, and howl.}I >> I will move RESOLUTIONlp number 10364. Tvlq >> council member aquino,qt(Lp gaylord, kozlowski, shean>2~ sheldon and howell. >> we will then MOVEjf to items a,}I NEWok business. And our first ISok an ordinance relating to the repeal of THIr and reenacting OFxd chapter 8.36 of the folsom municipal code concerning the folsom fire code and I understand that's going to be TAKENt(In conjunction WITHw3qad ordinance number 1298 repealing certain chapters of the building and construc. N code and of the construction~r}I codes. Again, first reading. >> yes, good evening, honourable mayor,xd city members, the director of community we're here this evening tp q)Xd to present two NEWxd businessm ~xd items. However, one presentation, we had an opportunity to meet~r and with our STAFFe1 put together a presentation for you to consider this evening as the first}I reading introduction. With}ixd that, before I introduce our staff members who will BEok presenting, I just wanted to}I acknowledge several o our staff members in the audience here tonight and several who are not who day to day provide gre Hr service for this community to growth for OURok community.Q so they're all sitting in~r the}I center row. With}I that, I'm going to introduce our{_ ~ buildinga5Ym officials and our deputy fire ~ marshal.XDxDYm good evening mayor and COUNCILxli members. Just a little background on what w[Gtq oing here. ~}I THEqud fire department t out+ how to exactly operate that equipment. [Laughter+]}I >> so as you'REq probably aware, the}I BUILDINGok and fire codes are adopted every three years.}I they have a triannual CYCLEi] And so the last TIMEt(They were adopted was January in 2017. These modifications affect the fmc INxd chapter 8.36 with the fire code ANDxd chapter 14 or title 14 for the BUILDINGc code. The~r}I adoption of the fire and building CODESf* are based on the cli.Hit)*q and building codes are based on the international codes and uniform codes 2018 international codes include building and residential and fire and the existing buildings and other codes and THEr uniform codes are the mechanical and the}I~r PLUMBINGt-I codes.F* and the LOCALqxd amendments and also the california buildingm+- standards commission makes adjustments to those codes, the INTERo %=9al codes, and}I \uans t8 into what we call the clinj california codes and in ADDITIONc TOt(That, the local amendments can be made also.Ea| the california health and safety code mandates that the}building codes are applicable to all occupancies within the state of california, so it's mandated that they'RElp adopted. And those amendments ARExDq from THOSEi] Codes can become effective onp,Ym January 1st, 20, 20, whether they're}I adopted or not, the entire code section._[ the government code grants that the city&j~a5 of folsom authority DOq adopt these references and any modifications TOxDxd them. And with that, there are CERTAINxd amendments that can be adopted and lauren will talk about that.~re1 >> hi, good evening. So as scott}I mentioned, the health ANDl`;p#ETYxd code does amendments due to}I three different reasons, climatic, geological, and}I topographical. So some of the climatic reasons here INxd the city of folsom, we have high temperatures, high winds, low humidity, and that can affect fire spread. In the winter}I time, we have fog and rain that can lead to traffic congestion, increased vehicle accidents and reduced RESPONSEt(Times with with hot summers and Wy)) Winters, that can also lead to more vegetation growth in the summer time and fuels. Some of the geological things WEt( Face}I}i is seismic activity and if we were to have an EARTHQUAKe?Yp or aftershocks}I% )E,*w q could experience building collapses,q`_f* damaged watermains, inner connected hydrants and landslides that again would affect our access ANDi]Q structure s\aqility. In the topographical fac Vd here are~r~r slope and access. We do have in the city of folsom some sloped areas. The SLOPEDxd areas is going to lead to a faster fire spread. We do have limited access to certain areas of terrain which will slow our response times and sl ~ DOWNlp evacuations. And then~r, also have PROTECTEDq habitats THATt(Increase FUELq density, because some of the roads there, we can't reduce THEi] Vegetation as much as we May want to. So for the folsom fire code, some of the things that we are going TOi] Do, our mitigation strategies FORYm these is require fire resistant construction for structures that are WITHINt( Q<6l eet of OPENlp spaces. Lc0@6cj% so we'll}I do that also. We want to require defensible SPACe for structures in these areas and have appropriate ACCESSi]Q to the STRUCTURESKo ANDxd then as well continue to have sufficient resources u to respond and for any emergencies that we MAYxd}it(Have. >> as far as the building code goes, historically there hasn't been yn SUBSTANTIALxd modifications to the building code. In this cycle,}I e're}it(Retaining some MINORlp MODJv ions to THEKo ADMINISTRATIONw3 portions of the code and we're retaining the pool barrier requirements for health and safety purposes. As far as the+ model codes~xi SUBSTANTIALlp changes to them, save the energy code which HASlp been in the last few code cycles :Hdad SUBSTANTIALf* changes that have -- that are instigated BYt(E1 the governor's net zero energy,r>} her}I requirements, ANDi] For 2020, the idea WAStv". F*q "mtRbential structures would be ZEROxd net energy and}I 2030, commercial buildings would}I be zero net energy. So that's increasing and most of the takes on the structures increased envelope requirements.R >> quick question before you go to that slide.T( What is the reason for the bullet that says we're retaining the pool barrier requirements for health and safety, does that mean that's been eliminated from the state code? :u the{_ state code has some requirements on there, but the city~r of~r folsom for the last several code cycles at least has had some additional BARRIERw3ok requirements and that really PREVENTSxDq{ jtt:z from the pool to~r a pool from, lq 1~ the rm8`nei our's yard or residents on the streets and that sort OFxd thing. >> I just want TOf*jf point out for people that May}i be in the room or that are watching this at SOMEq point in time that THATi] Requirement only applies at thisq`4k4,p6cj% point on transfer of ownership of the property. So THERExd are MANYok pools in folsom that,?; WEREq in place before this requirement was instituted and people don't have TOxd put the barriers up until the property transfers and t 2 sell_[nb the house. >> so ADOPTINGxd the 2019 edition of the fire cod1 and building}I codes with local AMENDMENTSt( Should not cause ANYxd financial impact to the city further than what ISc current. So w)*~ that,{_ the staff believes that the_[+ adoption of the 2019 edition of the california fire and building codes with~r amendments is necessary to provide a reasonable and~r prudent level of health et(Fire, and LIFExd safety to residents,f* businesses, and visitors of the city of folsom. So staff recommends that the reading of ordinance}it(Number 1297, an ordinance of}I the city of folsom repealing and%q~ reenacting CHAPTERt(8.36 concerning the folsom fire code. In addition, staff recommends that the city council conduct the first reading ordinance number 1298, ANi] Ordinance of the city of folsom repealing and reenacting certain chapters of title 14, building ANDi]Ql%5- construction of the folsom municipal code concerning enforcement of folsom4Il- CONSTRUCTIONi] Codes. Thank you THElp >> anybody have any questions for staff for EITHELDjf~r of the{f there were a few typos and mi9q) Errors and those have been revised and the sheet is at the~rt(I] Back table and thank you, sarah aquino, eagle-eye aquino, for PICKr up\@~r those typos in the staff reports. May have Ae1 question?~rokjFqw3~r >> I'll move ordinance Nq!`er 1297.\@c >> yes, thank you. >> we have a motion. Ya[{} we have a second?F* >> I'll second. >> call the roll,~r please. >> council member aquino,~r gaylord, kozlowski, sheldon and howell. >> yes,v ~r and I'll move first reading introduction of first reading in 1298.Q >> second. >> amended. We have a motion on theu second.}iYm >> council member aquino,q gaylord,q kozlows\9 sheldon, and howell.~r >> yes. >> and with that, we move on to appointment of three at-large members to the folsom historic district commission and I don't .P9nju that we have a STAFFKo introduction on this one, but I'm going to as+(That any of the people that~r have applications -- well, we}I}i do have one request9 to speak but Ii] Think it goes a*/ with the comment I'm about to make. Any of the people}k6that HAVExd applied to be on the historic district commission that WOULDxd like TOj. Come up and tell us a couple more things about themselves, I'd be happy to have you do that. If anybody wants to. And we might as well start with the person who actually submitted a speaker card. that would be DARRENt(Brack. And I know there are others in the audience that have applied, so if you want to come up as well, come{_~r}I}i~r after darren. >> good evening, honourable{_ mayor and city council MEMBERm\| my name ISq darren, and I currently serve as}I the~r chair of the}I{_ historic district commission and I have~r REQUESTEDf* to speak this evening}I because I am seeking reappointment. I do qualify for two of the three positions available this evening the first of these positions is the position which Iw3 currently serve in which is}I THEi] Historic district and at the most recent commission}I meeting, THEf* commissioner did retire from the hdc and she had served for 21 years in the position that the yo&mmissioner that}iqj actively involved in historic preservation and also presents the folsom}I}i historical society and THEq heritage preservation league which is a unique position with a SPECq %ied skill set, and I do believe THATok I possess the qualifications to fulfill}I requirements of that applied for both positions. And I'd like to spend just AYmc few ,- moments highlighting some OFq MYt( Involvements in the historic district and historic preservation. My involvement began in 2004 when it purchased a home in the historic district, a victorian home built in the 1800s. Unfortunately, it had been neglected, so I restored it to its original charm and THENlp subsequently built an italian-style home in the district to ensure it fit within the historic nature of the district. Spent a lot of time studying architecture}ijf of 1800-style italian and designed it in sp* style. In 2006, I BEGAe_t(~r participating in the street REVITALIZATIONxd workshops and continued pa^ cipating in them until the completion of THEr revitalization. I currently serve on the board~r of mira house foundation. I have previously served on the board of tm folsom historical society and I AMe1 a board member of the heritage PRESERVATIONq league, the historical society, the house foundation, the historical folsom residence}I association, the california preservation foundation, and the I% ad PLANNINGlp association. As a member of the california preservation foundation, I HAVEqq participated INqi] Workshops regarding preservation planning, technology and advocacy and as a member of the AMERICANr planning associatw/s have attended preservation education training~r for}I planning commissioners. I also have STUDIEDe1 archaeology and land use management at the university OFi] Southern california. Ir HAVEok volunteered for the museum and while I was}I on the board, I participated in a observation and digitization of photographs, historic photographs and I'm actually havingmy conversations with the~r CURRENTxd President And director to continue that PROJECTr INq 2020. I've also volunteered for}I the_[ chinese future museum because the roof ISlp in bad shape so in order to protect the house from the upcoming fall and winter rainstorms, we did some work to~r protect the house and improve THEi] Roofing_[ SIFuction. And I I've also volunteered for

Page

/

5

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFwkjqcRULF3XWDPL9THfrUNTJ6PMEKgAhXGz9i0kDsCWit-LaxxiTe4mVYLpuwwjuYb_fz7vgz-JYun8P0-NNQpyT2hmX4cEzLHh-Q3Zl_yh9u9XQ-hYSwOsqFSnER_HxAVH8A0Ahv5cV-fNIMjZPoTNvFiPZoi8Q-y8iv-7JlZqnmujuySAwTbnZKml0RLCP5FksNBjz_bYDkEvLsip4XLiPjjAeiNjOP5FJaICf4bjv6nSynu_AxY-25b6oUMZbUap14QGwD_ZIpHEni8cipb-P2yz9qXHN1JkqNXAOl4_NvHkHrYGFkSIPfN8HLPnQu1ucQzgvlpi_V0hRygT3oos5hp_A%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

[http://www.folsom.ca.us/](http://www.folsom.ca.us/)

## Page 1 of 5

1

CITY OF FOLSOM CITY COUNCIL

SPECIAL MEETING

www.folsom.ca.us

FOLSOM CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS

50 NATOMA STREET, FOLSOM, CA

TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2019

6:15 PM

Kerri Howell, Mayor

Sarah Aquino, Vice Mayor Roger Gaylord, Council Member

Mike Kozlowski, Council Member Ernie Sheldon, Council Member

AGENDA

1\. Call to Order

2\. Roll Call:

Council Members: Aquino, Gaylord, Kozlowski, Sheldon, Howell

3\. Adjournment to Closed Session for the Following Purposes:

a. Conference with Labor Negotiator - Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6: Agency Negotiator

Human Resources Director James Francis, Employee Organization, Folsom Middle Management Group

4\. Reconvene:

Announcement of Final Action, If Any

5\. Adjournment

![Page 1 of 5](blob:https://docs.google.com/84391677-3479-4d42-8571-aad59ed9ed4e)

[http://www.folsom.ca.us/](http://www.folsom.ca.us/)

## Page 2 of 5

2

CITY OF FOLSOM

CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING

JOINT CITY COUNCIL / SUCCESSOR AGENCY / PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY /

FOLSOM SOUTH OF 50 PARKING AUTHORITY / FOLSOM RANCH FINANCING AUTHORITY

SPECIAL MEETING

www.folsom.ca.us

FOLSOM CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS

Showing the first 24,000 of 100,064 characters. The full document is at the source.

[Technical difficulties] >> for item d I have three questions. The increase in the contract that is proposed, the simple question is interviews with the perspective contractors happened a year ago by what is in this report and why the long lag time until today. >> good evening. What happened was we got the cost estimates before the budget process for last year. Brought everything, all of the increases through the budget process. Some were approved, some were denied. And what we did in the meantime work on negotiated contract so to speak to see if we could reach an agreement of where we could actually afford the increases and where we could not. We were on months to month until this time. >> got you. And then the staff report indicates that part of the process of trying to get this contract together was right-sizing the services which maybe were lacking previously or not -- was not enough time devoted to some of the activities. The contract, though, represents a 60% increase in what we were paying previously. How much of that would you attribute to changing the scope of work versus just escalation of cost. >> few factors. One of the things that we wanted to also do in this new contract was to repackage how we were having irrigation repaired in a lighting landscape district. Before what we would do is have it done under unscheduled. Send out when we had an irrigation repair. Send out and let the contractor know they buy parts and pieces and send their technician out to repair it. What we wanted to do different here, because we could save about 30% we would buy the parts and we would buy the staff person's time. So we would translated the staff time that we are paying under unscheduled over into the scheduled. So while this is going up a bit on the scheduled we will see decrease on the unscheduled. Because most of our unscheduled work is irrigation repair. >> got you. So of that 60% increase then in this case, how much was previously -- separate? >> probably a half. >> half? >> half of that. The other translates into staffing. Which you might be getting to on the trails. >> the only other question I is not a question it is more of a general comment. A lot of the services we received from outside and costs have escalated a lot in the last several years, this is an example where we are going from, you know, 90,000 per month to 145,000 per month. The comment is that the bids that we received were spread wide apart and being involved in construction projects at least in bidding in the past, that is sometimes indicates that the scope of work is not super clear. Sometimes it means that maybe not enough time was allowed for the contractors to give good pricing and I just -- the two that were, the one that you negotiated with obviously was the low bidder. The others were so much higher that it is -- makes me nervous about the results that we are getting from bidders. >> well, this is the rfp and the (Inaudible) To, very detailed plenty of time, we were not in a rush, knew we had plenty of time to work with the contributors who were interested. I think it might -- I can not speak to contributely what their strategy was in pricing that out, both of those other companies have not worked with us before and once you understand the economy of scales that you can get by everything, doing maintenance in the city right next to park or lighting landscape district and next to trail there is a huge amount of economy of scale that can be leveraged without sacrificing the end product and I suspect that terracare having being under contract had an advantage there. >> got you. That was specific question thank you. Move item 10365. >> second. >> call the roll please. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski. >> yes. >> shedon. >> yes. >> and howell. >> yes. >> and this is a clarification on g, 10368 on its survey 40, folsom auburn road oak avenue existing speeds 40 to 50, and then changes to existing it says zero should that not be zero to 10? If that whole stretch is going up to 50? Where some is now 40? >> our intention is to leave the short section from old oak to greenback lane as 40-mile an hour zone due to driveway density. >> agree completely. It wasn't clear from this. >> I see. >> have that extra column that says changes to existing it said zero with that move resolution. >> second. >> call the roll klees. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski yes. >> sheldon. >> yes. >> howell. >> yes. >> and item I 10370 with regards to 108,642 that has to be appropriated for transportation impact these funds is council have to take action and when is that expected to happen? To appropriate 10 # thousand. >> part of resolution. >> okay. 108,000. Move that item as well. >> second. >> call roll. >> aquino yes. >> gaylord. >> yes. >> kozlowski. >> yes. >> sheldon. >> yes. >> and howell. >> yes. >> moves us to item 7 public hearing regarding proposed increases to water wastewater and solid waste rates and fees. >> open item with a few remarks about public outreach that led to the public hearing on proposed utility rate increases and we will have a 5-minute powerpoint to let you know what we have done toed from the word. We worked hard to reach those affected by these potential rate increases in many ways using different mediums. If you are an avid social media user we wanted to reach threw, prefer email we want to be in your inbox like worldwide wen we wanted you to click and find relevant information quickly. If you despise technology we wanted to be in your U.S. Mail post box and if you are more of a people person we wanted to provide in-person information sessions for you. So by our count the proposed rate increase and related issues have been discussed and vetted at at least 16 public meetings over the last 21/2 years. Of course tonight we are having a public hearing which brings us to a grand total of 17. Now, we mailed our proposition 218 mailer and there is a picture of the front cover there to all folsom utility rate customers in mid October. We took the extra step which is not required by law of including rather than just describing a protest form in the mailer in case there is recipients to submit a protest to any or all of the proposed rates. We put together a website fully devoted to proposed rate increases and advertised the link as broadly as possible. We wanted to distill complex information into something more relatable and meaningful and developed comprehensive q&a document that we constantly updated based on feedback and based on questions coming into city hall and then we pushed the link out to that q&a onto social media. We are one of a precious minority of cities that still mail a hard copy newsletter to their residents. So articles with the proposed increases appeared in two of our newsletters over the last few months, reaching over 29,000 households and businesses. In addition to our hard copy newsletter we also blast out weekly enewsletters by emails and articles about proposed rate increases appeared in nine eblasts reaching over 8,000 people or our email distribution list. We posted at least 8 facebook and twitter posts on this topic. Close to 23,000 impressions, posted three next door posts resulting in over 9600 impressions and I did my first yikes facebook live and devoted great portion of that to the proposed utility rate increases. And advertisement about where to find out more to find out about the propose rate increases appeared on sac metro cable television channel 14 I know all of you watch that all of the time I'm sure. We hosted a community open house with me and relevant department heads and managers delivering a prepared presentation and then more importantly, taking any questions from the audience. Videotaped that meeting and posted video to our website. Utility customers received a message about public workshop and bills that you see under special messages. We placed four ads in the local folsom paper and featured this subject in my November column in the newspaper and circulation of folsom telegraph is over 22,000. In addition to dedicated web page on the issue, we promoted issue on the home page of our website and also in our website newsroom. And finally, if you had nothing else to do in life you could stand in our lobby and watch information about this issue slide by on our digital message board. And you could of course pick up copies of the mailer at our public counters. With that, unless anyone has any questions about public outreach turn it over to environmental and water resources director marcus and both he and dave nugent have pretty short concise presentations tonight because we really have the desire to leave the bulk of the time for questions from the council and of course the public. So, thank you. >> thanks elaine. Mayor howell members of the council, marcus, environmental and water resources director. Elaine said I ha a quick presentation that will cover the water and wastewater portion of the proposed rate increase, dave nugent, public works director covers the solid waste portion. This is a brief summary of the prior two meetings we have held at city council as well as the public open houseworkshop we had in November. So purpose of this presentation really four key items to review rate study goals and objectives quick overview of the setting of cost based rates, what we have to do in each utility to identify revenues and expenses and how we come up with a rate or given customer base and in the particular presentation obviously review water and waste water rate study results and if there is any feedback later on in the evening, gain feedback from the public. Goals and objectives, obviously sets the rate, operating in capital expenses match revenues received from customers. And this provide as couple of things. Funding for our operations and maintenance and funding for capital replacement. There is another item included in operation of maintenance, debt service and on the waterside, not on the waste waterside. We have to repay bonds and loans for city on the waterside and that is included in a roll-up of o&m. We want to maintain adequate reserves in each one of our utility funds on the waterside this was critical when we were in mandatory water use reductions. By the state and in 2014, 2015 and part of 2016. so this did help provide a reserve for under receiving less revenues than what we would have collect fed we were not required to reduce our water use as a city and so the target for water and waste water is 40% of o&m capital improvements from rates and in this case for water debt service and then cost allocation is what water and waste water and obviously solid waste pay to other support here at the city. City manager's office, finance, et cetera, those offices that provide support for our operations on daily and the annual basis and important with complying with proposition 218. Quick oversaw of setting cost base rates one look at revenue requirements for each one of the utilities same between water wastewater and solid waste. We fund different items. Obviously vehicles in solid waste are different than the vehicles and equipment that we have in water and wastewater but all that is included. Developing a cost of service. And so we take what our revenue requirements are and we need to identify how we equally distribute those costs to each one of our customers. So between residential and the non residential categories. We cannot charge more to one customer base than the other. Not in compliance with proposition 218 and need to do cost for service analysis for each of our customer bases. And then develop the rate design. So once we are able to identify what the costs are associated for each one of our customer categories, then we can identify what the specific rates and rate base is for those customer classes. That is the way information rolls into the numbers that that were in the notice and what we presented at various meetings. Rate adjustments at least on the waterside include current and future staffing levels, memorandum of understanding, salary adjustments, obviously just increased utility costs between 2008 on the wastewaterside, 2011, 12012 on the waterside, public works has a 2004 for these adjustments vehicle replacement differ between water wastewater and solid waste, we all have vehicle replacement to keep up with and on the waterside, water meter and meter reading why I'm placement fund. Know that at some point in time we will have to replace certain amount of water meters throughout the city. We have some that were installed as long as 1991. And those over time will have to be replaced and we want to ensure that we have a fund available to make that reinvestment and not have to -- so we can continue on pay as we go opposed to issuing new debt to cover that. Debt service again only on the waterside and then capital reinvestment. So that is pumps pipelines and tanks and in the case of water and replacing that infrastructure as needed. I do want to be clear that the rate adjustment do not include any water supply or water infrastructure for any of the development south of highway 50. A separate funding for that which includes particular agreements in financing plans and CFDs that are associated with those projects and I do have on this particular presentation a specific surcharge for the customers or future customers south of highway 50. Which covers the cost of the actual water supply itself. So just a quick summary. Water revenue requirement we went over this a couple of months ago. This yellow line shows the trend of what the present rate would fund moving forward and as you can see in the first couple of years, cover o&m and debt service but get out into the you know, years 3, 3 through 6 in this case and we would not be able to cover debt service which in this case would only cover operations and maintenance. So that is the trend of current rate structure. So what we are trying to do obviously then be able to cover debt service and capital reinvestment. Revenue requirements for this and detailed report available on-line show that water rates adjustments are one, necessary reflects the need to fund water o&m which includes debt service expenses. Obviously fund adequate annually renewal and replacement projects, infrastructure and capital improvement program and then meeting our reserve targets necessary or that are identified at that 40% mark. This is just a quick summary on the residential side of what current and proposed rates look like. This is information that was provided a couple of months ago as well and in the mailer. Non residential document here which identifies fixed and commodity charges on the meter side. Here is a comparison and this is a residential comparison only. We did not include non residential because that would be a much larger graph and chart and just included residential with an average water or monthly water use of 16 ccf, we can see where the city is currently and where the city will be. After the proposed rate adjustment f we looked at just a cti index and took 32.28 from 2011 until 2019 we would be at 45.16. Less than cti and less than the regional average. Waste water. Same thing only difference here we don't have debt service that we need to cover here, you can see we run into a similar problem in 2023 and that would be funding o&m and not everything the capable to fund capital reinvestment at current or present rate structure. Same items in waterslide proposed proposed residential rates current on far left and what we are proposing for throuh July 1, 2024. This is non residential slide and I do -- I will point out two things on the next slide here that are different than what was in the mailer. This item here for parks, in the mailer had per 1,000 square feet. but we are changing to it a per fixture unit write matches our regional nomenclature for parks consistent with information that our revenue division is currently collecting and putting into system for confirmation and you know, any audits that we have to do with regional san and make sure that customer billing base matches regional san -- >> for the people sitting here tonight and those watching tv on-line it is sacramento regional county sanitation district portion of the bill that goes directly for operation of the wastewater treatment plant and transmission large diameter transmission lines that take wastewater to wastewater treatment plant which is basically in elk grove. >> thank you mayor howell. Other item to point out, this was correct in the staff report. That is why you do not see this in the staff report, am pointing it out, it is different for those with the mailer in hand. This item here for colleges, was incorrect in the staff report and in the mailer. So I do want to point this out as well I believe it had 2.46 or 2.64 and I think that 3.05 out here which was incorrect so we corrected those numbers which are less than the numbers in the mailer. So city tern can correct me if I'm wrong, but there is nothing else we have to do in terms of a new notice or anything like that. The number is lower than what was published in the prop 218 notice. I just wanted to point those out, one is in the staff report. and the other obviously the reference to mailer and corrected in the staff report. So again other survey on wastewater. See where the city is currently and where we will be if the rate adjustments are approved. Again we did cpi reference under $64, relative to 2008 to 2019. And as you can see here, about 4 higher than the regional average. But fairly consistent with our neighbors that also flow into regional san. South of 50 this is surcharge I was mentioning earlier in reference to water supply. Similar to east area surcharge the city has in empire ranch parts of rodstone and parkway and this is fundamentally the pay for the water supply that is serving that particular area. So in this case, the amount that the water costs for 5,000-acre feet is 1.78 million. That then is distributed between the residential and non residential customers that will be south of 50 on residential side it comes out to 9.20 per month, non residential side on basis which is 85 per ccf numbers are not the same similar criteria used for the surcharge. >> and again just to be really clear, that these are only charged to customers south of 50? >> correct. >> to back up, to the previous slide. That golden state contract city of folsom was paying for that all along that cost is being shifted to residents south of freeway correct? >> correct. a couple of years ago when the water supply agreement was approved, during that time, the east area was paying a surcharge I think of about 12 on the residential side. >> I think it was more than that, I want to say it was closer to 20. >> there was surcharge that east area was paying. And then when the water supply agreement was approved that cost or a portion of that cost, 1.78 million was shifted from th residents and customers within the east area to the plan area. At that time I think it might have been 2015. >> we reduced -- >> from 12 to over $4, I think it is 4.28 I believe on the residential side. And yes, now, this cost that was being borne by those customers north of the freeway are now being covered by those customers south of the freeway. That is all I have for water and wastewater. >> any questions? None. Okay. Solid waste, you are up. >> thank you good evening Madam Mayor dave nugent public works director marcus said a lot of the 218 notifications and the process are similar with solid waste. So I'm not going to get back into that and rehash all of that. For solid waste, we started off in early 12018 with an operational analysis to really dig into what we are doing, how we can better make efficiencies and look holistically at services we provide. At that time it was decided to look at the bundled rates and keep them the same, all of the things we currently provide that is what we analyze we don't want to look at starting to piecemeal what we are providing which second green waste, bulky waste pick-up and door-to-door hazardous waste and others. 7-day commercial service and these services are for north of 50 only. No south of 50 component in to our analysis. Looked at making sure revenues watch expenditures. And developed a rate model and we brought those to you in the past and I'll touch on those in a bit. The biggest thing we realized throughout all of our analysis are the state unfunded mandates. A listing of them. We discussed these a number of times. And this is the last one on there, sb 1383 I presented kind of what is coming down the turnpike at us. This does not include those costs. We do include some staffing costs in these rates to anticipate what we will need to do in the way of program management and outreach in light of what is coming as far as the organics recycling program for residential. But we simply don't know the fixed cost. Olympicersal cost. We don't know the state has not told us how we tore operate and we can not include those costs or forecast them under prop 218 at the point where I said last time we most likely be back in front of you if those costs are extreme and we can not (Inaudible) In current structure currently we do not include a lot of those costs. As we spoke before some of the major drivers recycling crash back it seems a long time ago only last year early 2018, the bottom of the slide there is the big, big key, we went from 465,000 per year revenue stream to offset our operational costs to 671,000-dollar expense, that is over 1.1 million swing in our revenue stream. So we mentioned this before. Rates have not increased since 2004. That is a simple graph showing our current rate and cpi if we were to follow the consumer price index from 2004 to current our current rates would be 45.53. For the 64-gallon container. Comparison wise this is how folsom compares in the region. With our neighbors. One update since our last briefing with you, I have highlighted sacramento there recently updated their rates I believe last week adopted the rate increases. And they dropped or they jumped another $6 over the next two years. >> clairly facial city of sacramento. >> city of sacramento correct and they do not offer anywhere near suite of services we provide. >> but they do have a claw. >> the do have a claw. As I said we presented multiple scenarios for consideration. These are kind of what those look like in order for us to meet our revenue expenditures. Our revenues match revenues with expends tours as well as develop reserve balance. Ultimately after our public workshop came back with a hybrid and here is what was done to kind of smooth out some of the costs and we move some expenses, moved those into future years to reduce total amount. We right-sized our existing fleet and expansion. We delayed replacement of the four vehicles later to fiscal year 23 and showed moderate increase for residential as well as commercial. Here is what the rate would pull out of that. These are the monthly anticipated increases for residential commercial and roll off, 3.50 per month until July, 4.50, 5.25 and 6. Here are the rates prop 218 mailer, these were included. Put them up here if anybody wants copie they are in the mailers. That is all I have. >> any questions of staff? >> I have one. Two. Two issues was (Inaudible) Mandas you listed. >> I did not hear you. >> two of the issues were state mandates obviously and also you mentioned that we looked at the bundled rates. So the other thing I wanted was a cost analysis of the bundle rates versus the percentage of users using those bundled services right I was told we could not get that. What did you guys look at to determine analysis of bundled rate versus not removing the bundle. >> we did not. Early on when we took to it utility advisory committee and saying here is what we are looking at and here is

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Folsom City Council Regular Meeting
  • Folsom City Council Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8ab18796395bc4779ef842fb48d56ade. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record