POLISCOPE

The public record

ST. LUCIE COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Board of Adjustments Meeting

Wednesday, October 23, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Approval of 6/26/2024 and 8/28/2024 Meeting Minutes

The St. Lucie County Board of Adjustment approved a zoning variance for a residential lot on San Carlos Drive, allowing the owner to build a home despite the lot being smaller than the 10,000-square-foot requirement. The approval is conditional on the owner agreeing to connect to future central water services and supporting local utility expansion initiatives. A separate sign variance request for a commercial property was removed from the agenda due to incomplete public notice requirements.

Why it matters

This decision allows a property owner to develop a previously unbuildable lot, while establishing a precedent for future utility-related zoning variances in the Lakewood Park community.

What happens next

Next meeting: Wednesday, November 13, 2024.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

3

Recorded outcomes

3

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

3 captured items have a publicly linked outcome.

Search all 3 meeting actions

Recorded votes

2 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (2)

approved

Approval of 6/26/2024 and 8/28/2024 Meeting Minutes — Approved with revisions

approved

Variance request for 7502 San Carlos Drive — Approved with conditions regarding future utility connection and MSBU support

People and votes

Richard V. Neill

Present at this meeting

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

See all 2 roll calls with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Regular Meeting October 23, 2024 Convened: Adjourned: 1. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Special Magistrate, Richard V. Neill, Jr. at 9:48am. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The pledge was led by Special Magistrate Neill. 3. ROLL CALL 4. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES A. Approval of the 6/26/2024 and 8/28/2024 Meeting Minutes Approval of the 6/26/2024 and 8/28/2024 Meeting Minutes were approved with revisions by Special Magistrate Neill. 5. SWEAR IN STAFF MEMBERS The Board Secretary swore in St. Lucie County staff as follows: 1. Kori Benton, Planning Manager, PDS 2. Tahir Curry, Planner I, PDS 6. PUBLIC COMMENTS None 7. AGENDA ITEMS A. The request of Vlad Bradescu for a Variance from the provisions of St. Lucie County Land Development Code Section 7.04.01, Table 7-10, in the RS-4 (Residential, Single-Family - 4) Zoning District, for a single-family lot that does not meet the minimum 10,000 sq. ft. land area requirement for lots served by a well. The lot is approximately 9,375 sq. ft. and does not have central water immediately available. Tahir Curry, a Planner in the Planning Division of the Planning Development Services

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, October 23, 2024 9:30 AM 2 | P a g e Department, presented the variance request. Mr. Curry explained that the variance pertains to the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, Section 7.04.01, Table 7-10, for a single- family lot that does not meet the 10,000 square-foot requirement for lots served by a well. The lot is approximately 9,375 square feet and lacks immediate access to central water. Mr. Curry presented a map highlighting the subject property at 7502 San Carlos Drive within the Lakewood Park Community, zoned for single-family residential use, with surrounding properties similarly zoned. He explained the property’s non-conforming status, designated on April 4, 2022, as it lacks the required 10,000-square-foot area. To qualify as a non-conforming lot of record and receive a waiver, the lot must be independently owned and not adjacent to lots under the same ownership. However, County records from July 1, 1984, show that the property was contiguous with the eastern lot, both owned by Bernard C. and Patsy P. Willington, making it indivisible. Therefore, the property must be combined with the eastern lot or connected to utilities for compliance. St. Lucie County cannot issue a building permit until the non-conforming status is resolved, either by merging the property with the adjacent lot or extending utility services, specifically water. Mr. Curry noted that utility connection would cost an estimated $30,000 to $40,000, given the required piping from Miramar Avenue and a grinder tank for sewage. Alternatively, an MSBU (Municipal Services Benefit Unit) could be established to fund a water and sewer line installation for the street, meeting County standards with a 6-inch water pipe and a 4-inch sewer pipe. Mr. Benton explained that the requirement specifically applies to potable central water. The exhibit showed the nearby location of water and wastewater lines, with initial estimates from the utilities team, including extensions for both and a lift station for wastewater. The land area requirement for this property is 8,000 square feet due to central water access, rather than the usual 10,000 square feet. A boundary survey was presented for the proposed single-family home. The applicant initiated their project preparations, including surveys and planning, but progress stopped due to the non-conforming status, prompting a variance request to waive the central water requirement, as St. Lucie County Utilities does not currently provide immediate service. Approval of the variance would allow the applicant to obtain a building permit; however, denial could create a hardship, potentially requiring adjustments to continue development. Two options were considered for addressing the property’s non-conforming status. First, the applicant could attempt to acquire the adjacent eastern property, though efforts to contact the owner were unsuccessful. The second option involves extending water services, with previously discussed costs and requirements. Mail notices were sent to 76 neighbors within 500 feet of the property, yielding eight responses: four opposed, three in favor, and one neutral. A map displayed these responses, with red for opposition, green for support, and yellow for neutral. In response to Mr. Neill’s inquiry, Mr. Curry shared that Helene and Charles Jardine, nearby residents, expressed concerns about potential impacts on their well. Mr. Curry explained that compliance with St. Lucie County Health Department standards would ensure that the proposed well and septic

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, October 23, 2024 9:30 AM 3 | P a g e system would not affect neighboring wells or septic systems. Health department permits would confirm this. Mr. Neill noted that the subject’s septic would be located on the opposite site of the property from the Jardines. Staff reviewed the variance petition and concluded that further documentation is needed to demonstrate hardship as required by the St. Lucie County Land Development Code. Mr. Curry indicated that additional evidence could support the request but emphasized that relief from the long-standing provisions on non-conformities and utility requirements would not be granted lightly. The subject lot has remained unchanged for years without utility connections, and County regulations since 1984 have required a minimum 10,000-squarefoot lot area for a well and septic system. The lots in question were platted before 1984 and initially conformed to County standards. However, in 1984 and 1990, new regulations required contiguous lots under single ownership to be combined. The estate holding the lots sold them to separate family members in 1990, creating individual parcel IDs. Although the parcels would have conformed independently under 1984–1990 rules, the 1990 Code mandates that contiguous, nonconforming lots under the same owner remain combined to meet current conformity standards, thereby prohibiting segmentation of these parcels for separate development. Staff emphasized the need for further documentation, questioning the due diligence done at the time of purchase, such as whether the title search disclosed nonconformity with Table 7- 10, the lot's historical status, relevant County Codes, or the need for recombination or variance relief. Testimony from the applicant on these points is expected. Additionally, although the zoning team issued a letter in April 2023 regarding the lot's status, it is unclear if the applicant was aware of this letter when they purchased the property later that year. A procedural issue noted by staff is that while such letters are part of County public records, they are not formally recorded, making it difficult for title searches to reflect nonconforming lot statuses. Staff suggested that formally recording these findings could help buyers better understand any limitations, especially if lots must be combined for compliance. Staff highlighted that nonconforming lot issues have been a recurring topic, and the County has tried to increase awareness through publications, realtor communication, and issuing zoning verification letters to confirm lot buildability. However, many buyers, especially in a high- demand market, may have limited time or knowledge to conduct these checks. As of the staff report's publication, additional information was being sought from utilities to assess potential hardship. Extending central water services to the lot is estimated to cost around $20,000, not including the connection fee, which raises questions of hardship given the lot’s purchase price of approximately $24,000 to $25,000. Discussion Mr. Neill inquired about the general rules involved. Typically, one would expect that if a lot within a subdivision has been subdivided and the subdivision approved, the lot would likely be buildable. For instance, if this individual is purchasing Lot 8, Block 8 in each subdivision, it

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, October 23, 2024 9:30 AM 4 | P a g e seems reasonable to assume that it would meet buildability standards. Reflecting on the concept of reasonable use, it is often considered within the context of a property’s zoning designation. For instance, reasonable use for commercially zoned property might involve features like a left-out turn lane for accessibility. Similarly, for residentially zoned property, reasonable use generally suggests the ability to construct a residence. Applicant Presentation Vlad Bresdescu explained that he purchased a lot in the neighborhood with plans to build a home for himself near his parents' residence. As a general contractor, he began the construction process, securing quotes for trusses, paying a deposit, and completing project preparations. However, when he submitted plans for permits, he learned that the lot was considered unbuildable. In response, he contacted the title company, which provided a form from the building department sent to the previous owners, confirming the lot’s unbuildable status. Although he holds title insurance, Mr. Bresdescu received no assistance from the title company and is considering further action. The transaction involved Focus Homes and Steel City Title, but no explicit buildability claims were made, and this is the third lot he has owned in Lakewood Park. Staff confirmed that a nearby lot, which he purchased and on which he built a residence, was the same size. Mr. Neill asked if a broker was involved or if buildability was discussed before closing, which Mr. Bresdescu confirmed was not. He also confirmed that the lot is the same size as his other properties. Mr. Neill noted no restrictions on the lot's use, aside from standard declarations, and questioned why buildability wouldn’t be assumed. Mr. Benton clarified that the estimated cost to extend water services to the lot was around $20,000, and that the applicant was unaware of a zoning letter issued in April 2022. It was also unclear whether Mr. Bresdescu had correspondence with the neighboring property owner to discuss a sale. Mr. Neill then asked if Mr. Bresdescu considered purchasing the adjacent property. Mr. Bresdescu replied that he attempted contact many times and received one response in which the owner declined to sell. This was the extent of his account with the neighboring owner. Mr. Benton noted that many similarly sized lots around the property have been developed, with ownership patterns influenced by evolving County Codes. He highlighted that the applicant received confirmation from the health department allowing for both a well and septic system on the lot, which Mr. Benton considers relevant. Although connecting to central water, estimated at a substantial cost, would resolve the nonconformity, St. Lucie County has been exploring MSBUs and investment options to extend central services to areas like Lakewood Park. Permits are currently being sought for a new water treatment facility on Taylor Dairy Road, which could increase water service capacity for the area. A road paving waiver may also be pertinent. Mr. Neill suggested that if the road in front of the property were unpaved, the applicant could petition the board for a paving waiver, which the board frequently grants with the condition

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, October 23, 2024 9:30 AM 5 | P a g e that the property owner commits to supporting any future MSBU paving initiatives. Approximately 50% support from local property owners would likely be needed for any MSBU on central water, a threshold he described as modest. The board could view the applicant’s automatic “yes” vote as beneficial in future central water expansion efforts, potentially addressing the lot’s primary issue. When asked about the best legal rationale for a variance, Ms. Forbes indicated that the lack of buildability deprives the property of reasonable use, supporting a hardship argument. She noted that the water connection cost could equal the lot’s purchase price, underscoring this hardship. Additionally, since nearby lots are developed, the nonconforming status appears to stem from a unique ownership structure dating back several years. Ms. Forbes emphasized that if the applicant had ignored the lot’s unbuildable status, it would present a different case. She also acknowledged the potential of setting a precedent but noted that most buyers would assume buildability in an area surrounded by homes without extensive due diligence. Mr. Neill then opened up public comment. Public Comment Robert Gregg, a resident at 7504 San Carlos Drive, voiced concerns about potential impacts on local water and sewage systems due to any new development. He shared the broader neighborhood interest in accessing central water and stressed the importance of preserving existing utilities and drainage systems. Gregg observed that as the community grows, the County may need to update policies to support infrastructure, noting the age of the swale drainage system and the need for future utility planning. Mr. Benton provided an estimate from the utilities team for extending the potable water line to the lot, suggesting an approximate cost of $20,000, excluding the Equivalent Residential Connection (ERC) fee, which he understands ranges from $3,000 to $6,000. Mr. Neill acknowledged the complex ownership and non-buildable status of the lot compared to nearby buildable properties, noting that while the applicant now understands the issue, the additional connection cost—comparable to the purchase price of $20,000 to $28,500—would be an excessive burden. Mr. Neill saw a variance to permit residential use as the property’s only reasonable purpose. Mr. Neill inquired whether relief pertained to the central water connection or lot size, with staff clarifying it was the former. Mr. Benton suggested a possible lot size requirement reduction for properties without central water, from 10,000 square feet to around 9,375 square feet. Ms. Forbes indicated that either a waiver of the central water connection or a reduction in lot size could enable development. Mr. Benton referenced Section 12.04.01 of the County Code, which grants the Board of Adjustment authority to issue variances on dimensional requirements and recommended focusing on dimensional aspects for a solution. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DECISION Special Magistrate Neill granted the variance, so that the property’s size requirement would be reduced to 9,375 square feet to allow development without central water. The relief was

Board of Adjustment Wednesday, October 23, 2024 9:30 AM 6 | P a g e conditioned on the requirement that the property connect to central water when it becomes available, and the further requirement that this property, whether under the current ownership or future ownership, would automatically vote in favor of any MSBU (Municipal Services Benefit Unit) initiative required to establish central water services. 8. OTHER BUSINESS 9. ANNOUNCEMENTS A. ITEM REMOVED FROM PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA: Alain Dumont's Petition for a Variance from Land Development Code (LDC) Section 9.01.01E, Permitted Permanent Signs in the CN, Commercial Neighborhood Zoning District, and LDC Section 9.02.01 D. - Sign Siting for a Replacement Ground Sign - COMPLETE PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIREMENTS NOT MET: MATTER WILL NOT BE HEARD BY THE BOARD Mr. Benton explained that, as announced under item 9A and in earlier discussions, the petition from Lane-Dumont for a variance from the Land Development Code for a sign on their property along Midway Road was removed from the agenda. Although staff had published the legal notice and mailed notifications to property owners within 500 feet, the applicant was unable to post the required sign on the premises to meet notice requirements, making it impossible to hold the public hearing as planned. Mr. Benton noted that prior participants have been informed that the matter is expected to return before the Board of Adjustment on the morning of Wednesday, November 13th. To meet notice requirements, new notifications will be issued in the newspaper, mailed notices will be sent, and a sign will be posted on the property. 10. ADJOURN Adjourned at 10:55am.

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

3 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 3 of 3

Browse by category3 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of Adjustments Meeting (2024-10-23)

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8999f9020e1aee8eb97ec25d95711ae4. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record