POLISCOPE

The public record

LINCOLN (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Library Advisory Board / Library Advisory Committee

Wednesday, November 5, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Library Advisory Board / Library Advisory Committee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 71,753 stored characters

Logitech: Okay, we're good to get started, Gloria. We can begin the meeting. Okay, let's, call the meeting to order. Logitech: And Catherine, would you do welcome, please? Absolutely. For the Library Advisory Board, we have Neil Coffer. Logitech: Nope. Logitech: Gloria, Lonnie, Irene? Here. Logitech: Joanne Schumacher? Here. At Jeff Circle, let me know if you would not be able to be here today. Lynn Snyder? Logitech: David Milliejas? Here. And for the Library Advisory Committee, Josh Ekstra! Logitech: Ashley Sander, let me know if she's not able to be here. Jason Price, I'm Heather Pierce. Logitech: And I, that leaves us one short of a quorum, unfortunately. Logitech: Okay, so we don't have a board. Oh, Teresa didn't get on, she said. Perfect. Logitech: Is there… we don't have any visitors or citizens here, other than the board itself. Are there anybody, any on Zoom? Logitech: We do have one member of the public on… Logitech: Zoom, but we have no hands raised. So, and we do have the, Pledge of Allegiance as well. Logitech: Oh, did I right… go right by that? I think I did that last time. Logitech: But I'll let it stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Logitech: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Logitech: So, since we do not have a quorum. Logitech: Item, we'll need to, reschedule item 5. Logitech: And item 6A for the next meeting continues us on to the next meeting. Logitech: Okay, so then we'll proceed with future business, number 6B. Logitech: Lincoln Public Library Funding and Community Aspirations Report Discussion. Logitech: Yes, so this is bringing forward, a chance for this body to discuss the, library funding and community aspirations report that was completed by Constructive Disruption. This body did receive a pre-report presentation from our, vendor, Constructive Disruption, on this, our consultant. Logitech: Previously, this was also, you all were given a digital copy of the report in advance of the report being presented to Council. That Council meeting was a brief introduction to it, and response from Council was, quite supportive of library services and committed to finding solutions for library services in the future. Logitech: But then there was a desire for this body to have a chance to speak about this, so that is this time. And then in your agenda packet was… Logitech: The report itself, as well as there had been a request for information earlier, since there was some discussion, in this report and in the previous presentations about the general plans. Logitech: I did my, very much not a part of the planning department review of the general plan and tried to pull out the primary references to library services. So that was kind of that second document. So if it seems it jumps around. Logitech: It does, these are excerpts from the about… Logitech: I think it's about a 700-page document of the general plan, that specifically records library or, community centers. Logitech: So, yes, this is the fourth time. Logitech: Okay, is there anyone that would like to kick us off on, I guess, observation, questions? Logitech: Something that you thought stood out in the report that you'd like the board to talk about? Logitech: Well, I thought it was… well, I did find it interesting, maybe because I used to work at the library, that when you look on page 37 of the report, where they were talking about, how to maintain a single location with the 75% of current budget, that's basically Logitech: staying… Logitech: you know, without the, the support of Sierra College, what we would look like. And the, they had a suggestion in here about the hours, and they looked quite similar to the hours that I used to work. Logitech: So that was, kind of an observation on my part. But the other thing that… I remember working those late hours between 5 and 7. I know the community in, you know, in the research out there, or the part of the study that they did, and talking to the community, that they wanted extended hours. Logitech: But I remember it being a ghost town in that library between 5 and 7. If we were lucky, if we had 3 or 4 people in there. Logitech: So it is not, you know, it's like they want it, but then they don't show up for it. So, you know, I just don't know… Logitech: you know, of course, circumstances change. The… you know, that was 7, 8 years ago. People's, you know, schedules are different, their lifestyles are different. Logitech: But that was something that I thought was, interesting, anyway. Logitech: Would… do you think that… alright, so 5 to 7 is… is… 5 to 7 is the dinner time. Logitech: There was no interest And later than 7. Logitech: No, I think we closed at… my recollection is we closed at 7. Historically, we closed at 7. I don't remember exactly the language in the survey. I would say, historically, if you ask the community, would you like hours at X? Logitech: People will say yes, regardless of whether they… Logitech: whether they would use that. They would personally use. Yes. Logitech: Fortunately, because we have a very pro-library community, that's what came forward in kind of our community survey, very few people here, would you like expansion of library services in this way, and go, no, no, thank you. Logitech: More is more and more, we tend to get very positive responses, too. I would say that there are relatively few libraries Logitech: serving communities very similar to ours that have hours past 8 p.m. Typically, you see those in core library systems, or core library branches in high-density urban areas. It's relatively unusual in our state in suburban or rural library systems. Logitech: What about Sunday? You're closed on Sunday now, right? We are closed on Sunday. Sunday tends to be the last day added to libraries. Typically, we see if it's a six-day system, it tends to be Monday through Saturday is the open days. Logitech: I suspect part of that is, simply staffing logistics. It is easier to consistently staff weekdays than it is weekends. But yeah, certainly something that we could look at in terms of increasing access. Logitech: So, I'll share another observation. Well, one of the things that I was… I was kind of like… I didn't think about that when I read the report, was that, you know, at present, without Sierra College. Logitech: The city, if I'm correct here, Catherine, the city provides about 85% of the funding, and the district provides 15. But our hours are being driven by the school's needs. Logitech: And there was a pretty strong statement in the report about how we, the library, you know, should refocus their hours to better serve the general public, since they're providing the funding, the lion's share of the funding. And I thought that was a good argument Logitech: To, persuade the school district to put more money in. Logitech: It certainly was a… was a powerful observation with that shift in funding, in terms of… Logitech: And I know one of the things that was in the presentations, I believe it's… I'm not seeing the page number in this. Logitech: But with that was, a suggestion that the library do an assessment of where we put our resources and see to what percentage goes to the general public and what percentage Logitech: It goes to the school district to… beyond just hours, in terms of programming, collection, staff time, all of those, to have a better and more holistic understanding of, Logitech: how those resources are being distributed, and that's certainly something, as we're going through these different pieces, my staff is working on those assessments to get a more holistic grasp of how well distributed our use of resources are, reflecting the community, because, of course, service for teens is not… Logitech: completely analogous with service for the school, how we would always serve teens as well. So, doing some of that analysis to see, how our breakdowns are working. So, can you go into a little more detail about what it is that you would have them look at that you don't already have them looking at? Logitech: So, like… Logitech: feet in the door, or materials of where they go, or who they go to, or the kind of materials, or what are you thinking? Yeah, we're gonna pull probably a little bit more circulation data to look at collection use, and then also, Logitech: Categories of individuals who are using the collection, so obviously we're not going to do a statistical analysis. Logitech: card by card, in order to avoid any confidentiality issues, but for example, all of our student accounts are identified as such in our database. We can run an anonymized, report of the usage of those account types. Logitech: Okay. So looking at that and comparing how that works across the collection, and then comparing that against our purchasing in those collections. Logitech: Because again, we do a lot of usage comparisons, but we don't always, every time we do those usage, then compare it back down to the budget line support of that. Can you give them data on… Logitech: Not only use it, who uses it, but… Logitech: If you have, say, Book A, what percentage is used by students, and then what percentage is used by the general public? Logitech: I would have to take a look. Typically, that data's a little bit more difficult, because that is more closely linked to individuals and their individual circulation, which our databases are designed to anonymize, because… Right, I understand that, it's reasonable. Logitech: So typically, we don't have easy access to, like, historic circulation on single items, whereas… Logitech: percentages are already anonymized, they don't have specific titles or names. I'm just still trying… struggling with Logitech: what you're going to get out of it, or whatever research you're doing. Yeah, and then looking at our programming, our programming and events, and trying to really, identify not just high impact, but, the fullness of our staff investments in those. Logitech: I have a sense that your doubts will not do to you. Logitech: The whole picture on the usage pie. Logitech: the high school. Logitech: Because… Logitech: there will be students in the library who will not be checking things out. Oh, absolutely. And that will probably be… Logitech: A greater, more significant number. Logitech: Because they will be… they will be using it for their own, you know, for their own personal uses, or for… for group… Logitech: Excellent. Logitech: meeting place, or it's raining outside, or… you know, and that… that… Logitech: Requires the lights be on and the heat be on, and there be staff here. Logitech: So, just as much, if not more so, that is an invaluable God. Logitech: Opportunity for the high school. Logitech: Because they don't have any other place for kids to go. Logitech: You know, they don't have a big… Logitech: you know, rec room area kind of thing. They do have a large student center. Logitech: So there is… there is space for students to go. It does not have the library resources. But, to your point, though, absolutely, use of the space is definitely one of those metrics when we think of Logitech: what is the value that any individual organization gets? Collection and circulation is only one piece. Space is absolutely another significance. Okay, and so to a significant degree, Logitech: We need the high school, and they certainly need us. Logitech: So I would like to know what the process would be to renegotiate the, Logitech: you know, not just say it would be nice if you gave us more money, but that you need to pick up your share of expenses. So what would that process be, and would the consul ever get to the point where they would? Logitech: Have those kinds of discussions with the school district. Logitech: So, absolutely, and one of the things I can say is that that conversation, which is also, in part, the conversation around the negotiation of the MOU, which Logitech: Is what sets these percentages, and also sets a number of other operational and administrative standards that have been more or less effective over the last 10 years. Logitech: is part of a larger discussion of joint use that, city staff, primarily our city manager, are involved in at this point, and it's happening at the staff level. It's just an involved conversation. Well, because, look, they don't come to the meetings. Logitech: And that's a real failing, and I don't think that our bylaws provide, but I don't think people should be able to miss Logitech: for a whole year, this board has not been able to even approve its minutes. Right. No organization can exist. Logitech: That way. Logitech: But no, we can't. Now we have a quorum! There's a couple more coming. Oh. It doesn't bode well to be on a library committee when you don't read. Logitech: the email that I sent us out here and not… my apologies. Logitech: So, to build a little bit on what Lynn was saying, if I might, for a second, going back to Logitech: the student usage in the library. For instance. Logitech: Can you tell that students are coming in and just using, you know, doing their homework, for instance? Logitech: Because… or they're waiting for their ride home, or whatever. They're not really, like she says, checking anything out, or even taking the book off the shelf. Logitech: I mean, can you tell that? Can you even get that information? Logitech: I know you can have a gut-level feeling for it, but… Logitech: within a certain capacity. So, and depending on how, the direction we take gives us more or less certainty on that data. It will always be point-in-time analysis, it will always be self-reported to some extent, but, yes, we can, we can sit down and… Logitech: And I am not, and I don't think we should be at all in any way critical of that use of the library, because that is… And I think we need to make that clear, because that is a… Logitech: So Nathan sort of welcome. Logitech: home and opportunity for students. Well, and I think that the library has gone, you know, has made it so, Logitech: Yeah, we… I'm there a lot, and I see a lot of high school students in there during, like, lunch hour, you see them after school, they're, you know, they've got their special spaces they go into and hang out, and they seem to… and it seems to, you know, there's spaces where the other side of the library, where the adults go and hang out. Logitech: that like to come to the library and read their book, or to look at magazines, or for whatever person. They're kind of like… they're really… because the library is so large, it really works for… for all age groups, you know, because the kids, of course, the little kids, they got their own, you know, section all together. So, because the library's so large, and the… and the… Logitech: the layout was such that the team-focused ones on one end, and the adults kind of hang out on the other. There isn't, like, this, you know, it seems to go very, very smooth. Logitech: And the library, during the library is, during school, there is somebody there from the school district. Logitech: to, you know, address any kind of… if somebody gets a little too loud or rambunctious or something, they take… they seem to take care of it. So, what does that look like? I mean, is there, like, a monitor, or what… who comes over here, and what… are they assigned? Are they paid to do that? So, yes. So, during the school day, there are two formal periods where students, are… Logitech: necessarily scheduled to be in the library, but there's a flex study hall period, and then there is lunchtime. And so students, for Flex are assigned, and it's a class period, and they come in and check in and use. Logitech: the library is one of the spaces on campus that are an option for Flex. And then during lunch, students can opt in up to a certain maximum. We can't have all Logitech: 700 of the upperclassmen come into the library at the same time, and that's managed at the office. Logitech: And then, we have our library technicians for 12 Bridges High School, who do a lot of work also at the Student Center and doing the actual, like, textbook distribution and all of that work for supporting the students on campus. Logitech: They are over during flex and lunchtime and help support the students and ensure that we have a successful interaction. Logitech: Outside of those scheduled times, you do not necessarily have the technicians. You have off periods, things like that are also present in the library, and then, yes, we do have a significant youth presence after school, Logitech: a substantial portion of which is high school. We do also know that we have, youth who are present from John Adams that is across the street, as well as from Whitney High, which is very close. And so, when we talk about doing the assessment, this is where we see me prevaricate a little bit about the hard data. We certainly can very easily do point-in-time assessments of high school-aged individuals in the library in certain time periods. Logitech: without getting a little bit more invasive in terms of our questioning and setting a tone for that, we don't necessarily know whether they are, again, 12 Richest High students, Whitney High students, John Adams students, or homeschool students, which we have a substantial portion that use the library. Logitech: No. John Adams is a charter under Western Placer. Whitney is Ross. Logitech: So, how do you know if you're reaching your maximum? Logitech: Allowed student count. Logitech: Well, during lunch and flex, that's the only time that we have that count, and that is only… Whitney does not send their students over during lunch. No, but how do you know? Are you counting their heads when they come in the door, or how do you… The school manages that, so for lunch, it's managed at the school office, where they have to go through to come up and see us. Logitech: Flex is assigned, and they have a check-in process, just like they do attendance, just for flex. Yes, and it's managed by our, you know, school employees, the library technicians for 12 hours. Logitech: So you get some… some numbers. Logitech: Yes, so we have those, absolutely, and we can see that. Logitech: So then, again, I would… well, first of all, maybe we should recall, attendance and… Logitech: Have a quorum so that we can… Logitech: And that's the business. Catherine, do we have a quorum at this time? And so I would say, Chair, if you're interested, if you'd like, we could certainly suspend this item, or we could finish this item, and then at the end of this item, go back to the consent agenda. Finish this and then go back. But then we can't take any votes or anything on this, because we don't have a quorum. Logitech: Yeah, we do have a quorum now. Will you have? Okay. Logitech: I think you have a forum, you have to take attendance. You have to take attendance. And so, my apologies for being late, I was on time at the library. Logitech: Somehow Jason beat me here, I don't know how he did that. I'm gonna… I'm gonna choose to suspend discussion at this time so that we can go back to retake the roll call and assess whether we have a warrant. Logitech: Fantastic. All right, so going back to roll call for the Library Advisory Board, Neil Crawford. Logitech: Gloria Irene? Here. John Schumacher? Here. Jeff Serpa is excused. Lynn Snyder? Here. David, Villegas? Here. Logitech: Fantastic. For the Library Advisory Board, or Library Advisory Committee, George Dykstra. Logitech: Jason Price? Here. Heather Pierce? Logitech: Fantastic, and then for our non-voting members, Richard Pearl? Here. Wonderful. Logitech: Alright, and then, Logitech: Fantastic. So, Chair, we do have a quorum. Okay, well, let's, proceed with, our consent items. That is the approval of the minutes. August 2024 through August 2025. Logitech: Do I have a motion to… do I do a motion with this? Yep, a motion and a second, and then a vote. Logitech: Second, okay. Logitech: Did you get those? I did, thank you. All in favor? Aye. Logitech: Okay, the items under consent have been approved. Logitech: Okay, under new business… Logitech: We have… now we can address item 6A, and that is the chair and vice chair nominations and elections. Logitech: Okay, do I have any nominations for chair? Logitech: Is there a slate? Logitech: It's anybody who's on the board. Logitech: No, was there a slate presented by any kind of… no, nominations committee or anything? No, no. We have historically done these, pretty much simultaneously when we have split them Logitech: It hasn't really seemed to save us time. Logitech: Okay, I would like to nominate, David… Villegas? Logitech: And he… is that that I say it right? You did, yeah. Okay. And I've spoken with David, and he is willing to accept that nomination. Logitech: Yep. Logitech: I don't know if it helps to know a little bit more about me. So, I am currently an assessment and email manager with Visions and Education. We are an NCB charter school. Logitech: We serve students in, in nine counties, so Sacramento and the, all the continuous, all the, counties that touch it. It's a, it's a, I think, one of the largest charter schools, I think it's the largest one in California, that is one school. Logitech: I have a lot of experience, supporting education research and program evaluation. I, I came to Visions A education from the Santa Clara County Office of Education, where I was doing education research and program eval. I think 15 different programs, tobacco use prevention education and whatnot. Logitech: So I'm a big proponent of libraries and what they can do in terms of performing services. In Santa Clara County, we had some great partnerships. Logitech: Between early care and education providers and, the public library system there. So it is a lifeline. In addition to that, my other commitments for, for boards are I'm on the, Placer County, Logitech: Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Commission, where I serve as Secretary. I'm on the Lincoln Parks and Recreation Committee, but there haven't been many meetings over the course of the past year. And I'm also on the Placer County Logitech: Child Care Planning Council. So I'm a pretty active member. I know what's involved in terms of coordinating meetings. I look forward to maybe working with Gloria a little bit more, getting schooled up on procedures, and then, of course, just supporting Catherine whenever she needs to make this work. Kathy. Logitech: Sorry for stammering, I'm… I have a little bit of a cold right now, so I'm working through it. Logitech: Oh, thank you for giving us that… your background information, I appreciate that. Do we have any other nominations for president? Logitech: I mean, I'm sorry, President, I got there. Chair? Logitech: Can I proceed with… Logitech: Yep, if we want to do, yeah, do them as separate actions, absolutely. Okay, can… I would, Logitech: proceed with a vote? Is that… it would be a motion and a second to elect David as the chair of, the lab. Okay. Logitech: I'll give you a motion. Okay. Logitech: Second. All right. Logitech: All in favor? Aye. Logitech: Outpost? Logitech: Well, congratulations, David. You are the new chair. Now, I proceed with this meeting, correct, or… Yes. I think you'll wrap up this meeting. Okay. All right, thank you. Logitech: Now the, the current vice chair is, george Dykstra. George Dykstra. So, and the vice chair would be from Western Placer Unified School District? Yes. Logitech: So do we have any nominations for Vice Chair? I'll nominate Jason Price. Yeah, I'm happy to serve it. Huh? I'm happy to serve it. Okay. If asked to do so. All right, well, I'll second that nomination. I guess I can. Logitech: All in favor of, of, Jason Price as Vice Chair of the Library Advisory Board? Aye. Logitech: Oh, and he knows? Logitech: Okay, well, congratulations. I'll try to show up to the right building next time. I feel like it's a good start, you know. You don't know how long I've been waiting to get those things started. Okay. Logitech: And then, so now we can… I think we still have a… we can take another 5 minutes to talk about… Logitech: the, Logitech: the Lincoln Public Library Funding and Community Aspirations Report, that's what we were in the middle of before we, Logitech: stepped, back from that. Logitech: Is, is there any more comments or discussions you'd like to have regarding that report? Logitech: Yes, ma'am? I noticed in the report they talked about seeking one potential solution, Was seeking another, or… Logitech: The good thing about what partners might be recruited, where the resource would be. Logitech: Wow. Logitech: The one that I might suggest would be if the elected officials knew someone at the state level, they could try to Logitech: Squeeze out some money for that kind of an operation. Logitech: Or know people that have foundational or, Request. Logitech: Legacy money from people that would be willing to fund the library losses out of some Inheritance or bequested. Logitech: We get some help from the politicians on the second floor. Logitech: Help us go out and help some of us. Logitech: People that might know better than we do. Logitech: Well, it's true, you know? Logitech: Well, the politicians are on the first leg. It's the administration. We don't even have an office here, by the way. At the state level, I really don't know. We could talk to some of our people. It's a challenge, without a doubt. And we did see this Logitech: report, I think, Efren, what was it, two, three months ago, something like that? Yeah. So that was, you know, we recognize the challenges of the, you know, of the library, you know, without a doubt. I think one of the things you just mentioned, seeking a donor. Logitech: could pay off. I mean, I'm in the Lincoln Rotary, we had a donor give us a couple of million dollars, frankly, which we're putting to good use within the community, wanted a very large donation to help to stand up a Boys and Girls Club year. Logitech: But there may be other donors out there that would want to pledge money. It's a good idea. Certainly is not, you know, unheard of to go after people. The question is, you know, who do you go after and how do you go after? And it's a bequest, you know, sometime in the future. By the way, Jason, do you mind dying for, you know, for the cause? Look, I just took a nomination. Okay, next year. Logitech: Yeah, and then next year. But that might be something to, you know, to explore with, you know, without a doubt. Yeah, especially if you can get some kind of arrangements that's long-term funding. That's the problem. I mean, we run into that with the Friends… I'm the president-elect for the Friends of the Library now. Logitech: And, you know, trying to budget your… or estimate what your revenues are going to be for the year. You know, we can't… we can't rely on somebody, you know, just coming to the library and out of the generous Logitech: you know, they give us a $10,000 check. It's happened, okay? But you can't count on it, you know, to cover your expenses. So that's the thing, it's got to be something that's ongoing that you can count on from year to year. Logitech: And as we discussed at these at the City Council meeting. Logitech: We have a two-year biennium budget, you know, at this point. You know, we committed to the library, you know, to maintain it. But we know it's going to be a challenge going forward, without a doubt. You know, it's not like we're not exploring things Logitech: Because we have… one of the biggest challenges that we have as a city council is how do we backfill public safety when a number of the, when ARCO running runs off, and also from the county tax. Logitech: Sharing agreement runs out, that's a couple million dollars a year. Logitech: So we're exploring a number of issues, but all of that is, you know, TBD. I mean, it's going to be a decision that the City Council will be one if we want to put it… what the time we want to do. I mean, there's been talk of a sales tax specifically for, you know, for Lincoln. Logitech: which would impact just Lincoln residents, but also non-residents who shop here, which Logitech: Good. There are a number of other alternatives out there. Logitech: You know, so we'll be working on that probably in the first and second, beginning of the second quarter, because that's a timeline we have to take, you know, take action in order to… Logitech: Go ahead. Logitech: At this point, that's, you know, the only thing we can say, that we're… we're well aware of the funding gap, we're very, obviously, disheartened by Sierra College pulling out, but everyone has challenges, without a doubt, and so whatever happens, the monies will come in, because we think Logitech: One way or the other, we have to get the monies in, because we have to backfill that public safety, and we've done some public polling at this point. Logitech: And with that, not surprisingly, public safety is… comes out at number one, I mean, from the community. They did all stratas of all areas. I forget what the number is, but it's probably north of 70% said that the, that the number one priority from their standpoint is public safety. We have to recognize that. Logitech: With that being said, we don't know what final numbers would be. We don't know, Logitech: Whether it would be a specific tax or a general tax. Logitech: you know, easier to put in at 50% rather than 66 two-thirds, whether a community facilities district of the whole is the way to go, utility user taxes, something else that would bring money in, you know, we don't know at this point, so we have to talk with our Logitech: We have to talk among ourselves, we have to let the administration perkle up some ideas to us, but we know that action has to be taken sometime in the relatively, you know, near future. But we made sure that we funded, you know, the library to the best that we could, you know, over the near term, by any budget. Logitech: Well, you're looking at the future. Children who can read do better in school, do better in life. Logitech: they don't become a problem in public safety. So you've got to invest in your children, and your schools. Logitech: So that you don't have public safety issues. And it's cheap, okay? The library at its current funding level, County Bolden School District and the city funds, is $1 million. Logitech: So we're not talking about… I mean, I know it's still a lot of money, but when you look in the big budget cycle, or entirely, it's a million dollars. Logitech: And they do so, so much with that. Logitech: And the Friends of the Library will be there, and we've grown our fundraising. We've gone from a small fundraising organization to now providing somewhere between $80,000 and $100,000 a year, which is significant when the budget is only a million, you know, just under a million dollars. Logitech: So, I think the library… the city council has to look at that. It's a small amount of money, $250,000. Logitech: That's… that's not even a full police officer, is it? When you count… Logitech: Their salary, their, their training, their retirement, all the equipment that an officer has to physically have. Logitech: So, you know, we're getting a portion of an officer Logitech: And in the… with that $250,000, you're impacting hundreds of kids. Logitech: So I… I'm gonna… I know I'm a… you know, but I think we need to think that way a little bit more. And I know the city says, yeah, I'm a… I'm an advocate of the library. You give me a list, and yeah, public safety's always going to be no or what. Logitech: But we do have a safe city. Logitech: And you can, you know, so… Logitech: you know, I think there's some play in there. We have a safe city. Logitech: It's not much to give the library just that… that $250,000. Logitech: But again, I know the city in itself is overall looking for funding and has some issues there. Logitech: So, I know it's a bigger picture than I can see from where I'm sitting. Well, and I thought so strongly. Logitech: second all of that, as you know, and I felt that there was a little bit of a Logitech: Cavalier attitude that because this library has such an incredible Logitech: friend, in truth, from the Friends of the Library, and the dedication over the years of volunteers Logitech: That helped to support and run this library, that the city is giving a little bit of a ride on the backs of Logitech: those volunteers and those private efforts. And I think this report that we prepare certainly underscores that. Logitech: Nothing, I would certainly, not… Logitech: agree with your definition of cavalier attitude. We do take the situation very seriously. We're just saying that at this point, we're going to have to… we're putting it into a holding pattern until everything percolates to the top. At that point, we'll make a decision. We just have to make a decision. Logitech: But I guarantee you there was no cavalier attitude on the part of any of us. We understand what the library does, we understand what the friends do, and we're very appreciative of it. It's a fabulous, a fabulous group. Logitech: have this group that meets over here. I mean, I understand libraries. I grew up in the library system and the use of them before we had computers and everything else. My father had a library named after him in Florida while I was still living. It took an active legislature to do that. Logitech: Because he understood how important libraries are, and he did it because he brought a library into the city. Logitech: So I understand, I understand what you're talking about. All I'm saying is that Logitech: let's just wait until we see what percolates up to the top. We don't know how much money we're talking about, we don't even know whether additional cuts are going to have to be made across the whole board. Logitech: I mean, in 2008, when the Great Recession hit, everyone took a hit, right? I mean, I looked at the numbers that your consultants put up, and I went from a million one down to… Logitech: $370,000. But the police and fire departments lost 30 and 40% of theirs. Logitech: I mean, no one wants to go back there. We want to build for the future, and I think we're on the point of getting to be in a good place. There's another definite hump over here, but we have to just say, okay, at this point, none of us can say what the future's going to bring. We may put something in front of the community, and the community would say, no, not at all. And then it's a whole different rapid Logitech: decisions that have to be made. We want to do right by every group, without a doubt. We understand the importance of the library, we understand what Catherine and her team does. Logitech: They do a fabulous job, we all know that. All I'm saying at this point is that there's nothing that we have in our arsenal that would say, here's the magic ball. Logitech: Just have to see what's going to be coming out over the next, 18 months, basically. Logitech: And then… then everything's transparent, everything's moving forward. But I guarantee you, no one on the City Council and no administration Logitech: makes, the, the reality of what's going on in the library in Coutular fashion. Logitech: All said? I lost to say that. Logitech: We work very closely with the city, and I've never gotten a sense that they're cavalier about putting black, right? Logitech: everyone's very committed to keeping the library open, but like Rich was saying, there's a lot of competing Logitech: Neat, and Logitech: It'll shock you hear this, but people don't want to do taxes, which I was surprised myself, because I thought people allowed more taxes. Logitech: No, turns out they, they don't. Logitech: I'm only seeing this for the first time, Logitech: I also just sort of heard by way of that Sierra College had backed out, and I see the figure here. I just want to be sure I understand a couple components, one of them being, like, it looks like currently the city takes roughly 85% of Logitech: the budget, the weight of the budget currently, and then also the responsibility of maintenance of the facility itself, so that I'm clear. So does that mean that Western Placer is covering the other Logitech: What's that? 25%? 15. 15%? Yes. Logitech: Okay. Logitech: Yeah, before it was, what, 50, 25, 25, right? No, it was, Logitech: 15% for Western Placer, 25% for Sierra College, 60% for the same. Logitech: And then I heard you discussing earlier how… how many of our kids are using, because Logitech: I'm well aware, and I want to be educated if I don't know the specifics, but as I understand it, that public library serves as the 12 Bridges High School Library, and there are routinely kids in there doing classwork, so I know… and we're also not just supporting the library and funds. Logitech: to the tune of 15%, but we also have some headcount, and we carry, their salaries, benefits, and so forth, as I understand it, is that right? Yes, so there's two library technicians, or there's a full-time library technician and a part-time library technician at 12 Bridges High School that support Logitech: student use at the library, as well as other services that would traditionally go to a school library, like textbook distribution, that do not, come over to the Lincoln Public Library that are Logitech: But again, in a traditional school library would be covered and are carried by the district. Logitech: So, in fairness, the time that those folks spend in the library is kind of supporting the library, too. Absolutely. Yes. Well, that's the way I understand it, but I don't want to make assumptions. If, in fact, they're just sort of, you know, holding court with the kids that we've got in there doing homework, I want to make sure I'm clear on that, but it's… as I understand it, they do library work as well. They primarily support the students, they do not do desk time or things the way that city staff Logitech: That's time you need, like, working with… Working the front desk, exactly. They don't help with the public. Logitech: Yeah, pretty much insofar as the public interacts with the students, they're there, they'll answer questions if they know the answers, but the predominant, work that they do in the library building is supporting the students. Okay. This, to the best of my knowledge, this has not been discussed. Logitech: as part of any of our meetings, so I'm gonna make sure to bring this back, and, you know… I mean, like, I think that if there's… if there's a load to bear, that Western Class should also do Logitech: whatever's in their… in their power to… to assist as well. So, I'll make sure to advocate. Logitech: Oh, nice. Logitech: Just one point on that. I think on some level it is being discussed at a staff level. I believe that Carrie and Sean… I know there's lots of… yeah, and I want to make sure, because Carrie didn't… didn't give me… she didn't prep me at all for a conversation like this, so sometimes it's good for me just to wander in and ask open-ended questions and so forth. I do know that Logitech: She is well aware, and also, wants to, in whatever way possible, support. Logitech: So that's all. I just… I also… I mean… Logitech: I don't think the city should have very 5% of the cost of that library. Logitech: I didn't mean to kick off this discussion without talking about this. Logitech: Long-term money. Logitech: Seriously. Logitech: generation. Logitech: Like, from a foundation or a legacy, or someone that's got family money. Logitech: I see a lot of money out of place. Logitech: About 100 miles west of here. Logitech: I'm sure Tom Valley has that. Logitech: San Francisco Bay Area. Logitech: Venture capitalists in this country are. Logitech: Testing $400 billion this year. Logitech: in artificial intelligence. Logitech: Somewhere in all of that life. Logitech: Like, certain effort, be able to track some of that over here, make a book group. Logitech: Okay, now… Yeah, I would say Ram. Give them a ram. Okay. It's a good idea. Alright. Logitech: Okay, I, I think we better move on so we can finish our, our, the other few items we have here. And I would say, I do not see anything on Zoom in regards to public comment. That's a great report, by the way. Logitech: Great call. Logitech: Okay, then… are we doing anything with report? Logitech: It was presented to City Council. It's presented to City Council. This is a discussion here, as I was mentioning a little bit as you guys came in. There are a handful of recommendations in from a staff site perspective that we're taking a look at. This is where, kind of, the discussion of Logitech: Having a good idea of school impact and public impact, so we have a good idea of how we're serving the school, and just having a good assessment of that holistically is something staff's looking at. Logitech: just kind of building that into the standard assessment we do constantly do. Yes, this is… this conversation here is for informational purposes. Yeah, because I… if I listened to the presentation, and I really didn't think there was much meat in the presentation. Logitech: But I gotta say, when I read the report, I mean, it took me a little while, but to read through it, I found a lot of… Logitech: of, of, Logitech: of good… well, like, suggestions, and maybe better insights on how to think of things, so I really think it's… Logitech: I mean, there's a lot of history in the beginning, which we probably, you know, we know we've heard of it, you know, before, so if you can skip that part. But, getting into the… where they're talking about, you know, options and things like that, I thought it had substance to it and is a worthwhile read. Logitech: Yeah, I come up with a number of inconsistencies that I'll share with Catherine. After this, that, but in a final report, you want, probably one… Logitech: Oh! Logitech: Okay, so the next item is, 6C, which is the discontinuant… discontinuation of Who Plus services beginning January 2026. Logitech: Yeah, so this is in some way a follow-up presentation on e-resources from our last meeting, which we provided some information about the two primary platforms that we use to provide e-books and e-audiobooks, Hoopla and Libby. Logitech: Just as a brief recap of kind of the numbers that rose to the top on that, Hoopla uses a pay-per-use model, which means it takes up a substantial portion of our expenditures on e-books, about 79% of our expenditures. Logitech: While providing about 12% of our total digital circulation, and there's really no way to change the ROI on that because of the pay-per-use model. Any increase in use increases that cost. Logitech: Whereas Libby, Logitech: Has a different service model, has some different impacts on the public, most notably wait times, but does have a much, Logitech: more efficient ROI, we spend, instead of about $2.33 per circulation, we spend about 7 cents per circulation. Logitech: With that, we have the presentation and the conversation here in the group. Staff has continued to monitor customer service impacts. We have, in the interim, reached the point where we have a significantly larger percentage of the public Logitech: attempting to use the service and failing because of our budget blocks, compared to the number who are actually able to access it. Budget blocks, I'm sorry. Logitech: So because we, it's a pay-per-use model, we only have a certain amount of budget, and so when we hit that, no more in. No more for the day. Got it. And so it's, it's an annual block that then our vendor distributes across to a daily limit, so you don't have massive months with no service. Logitech: So, yeah, so we do have… Logitech: In any given month, a couple hundred patrons be able to access the service, and Logitech: a couple hundred to a thousand patrons who, attempted to access the service and were not able to instead receive the blocked message. And the return on increasing the… Logitech: budget isn't there. We are not in a place to increase the budget on it. It's already a… But it doesn't… it doesn't generate any revenue, I guess is what I'm asking. No, no, no, no, this is truly an expense post. Logitech: So staff feel confident at this point that we believe that we can provide a better return on investment to the community by investing the funds that we currently invest in Hoopla into Libby, our other platform that gives us some more flexibility with ROI, allows us to do traditional collection development, and that we can, Logitech: Reduce hold times and help improve some of those customer service issues we see on that platform by being able to invest Logitech: redirect those funds from Hoopla to Libby, and basically use those digital, funds. Logitech: more effectively for our community. There will certainly be impacts to blood because it is a no-holdless model for our patrons who are able to access it. It is quite popular, we do have… that's why we have people getting up at 12.05 in the morning to get those daily checkouts, before they are all used up. Logitech: But again, we believe that we can impact the old, Logitech: lists, which are the main reason that we have people coming back and saying they prefer Hoopla to Libby, that that's the main friction point in Libby. Logitech: And this is in line with what both Sacramento Public and Placer County Library have found over the last year, is that redirecting funds into Liberty has allowed them to, leverage greater circulation, leverage greater customer satisfaction than investing those same funds into the library. Logitech: Catherine, what's the delta between the two platforms? Logitech: in, what capacity? Well, how much are we saving by going from Hoopla to Living? Logitech: So, our plan would be to maintain pretty much the same level of investment, especially because our Friends group does provide a substantial portion of that investment. In fact, the lion's share of that is Friends funding and then grants that they seek. What we're hoping is to dramatically increase the amount of circulation to get out of that funding. Logitech: Have you decided exactly how you're going to redeploy the… Savings. Logitech: So there's a certain portion of it, because it's grant-funded, would go specifically into audiobook purchases. The rest of it, we are going to be primarily starting, with doing specific collection development from staff, and targeting high popularity, high hold list titles, the kind of titles we would expect to be popular on Google. Logitech: And so that's our plan for probably the first quarter. Logitech: Really, really emphasize those, and then take a look at our circulation numbers and see whether we need to adjust our approach. Logitech: Thanks. And right now, the plan would be to change our service model on January 1. This allows patrons who are used to these service models during our closures around Thanksgiving and Christmas to continue to have access to the services that they're used to. Logitech: For our grant funds that we receive through the Friends to help support this, this gives us a clean break at the grant year, and it also gives us a month and a half to do our messaging and our education to the public, so that nothing's a surprise. Logitech: And we should point out that the grant funds are… are… are there to, yup. Logitech: The target audience is going to be seniors who do use a lot of audiobooks and also popular titles. Logitech: So they're big users. Logitech: Okay, any questions for Catherine on that? I'm… I'm particularly thrilled about it, so… Logitech: But I do not see any hands on Zoom. Logitech: Okay, thank you. Logitech: All right, there's no questions on that. We're moved to 7A, and that's your material selection policy. Yes, so this is, the last time you all saw this material selection policy was, I believe, in… Logitech: February of, oh, no, the November 2024 meeting. Logitech: So in 2024, Governor Newsom signed AB1825 into law. This created a state law that basically made it so that libraries… it affected the terms by which libraries can remove items from the collection, and basically that we cannot remove items from the collection simply because of the Logitech: viewpoint of the item or the author. Does not impact our standard collection development process for removing items from the library if they have been superseded by something more relevant. Logitech: circulation statistics, condition problems, all of those that we in the industry refer to as weeding, or standard criteria, those are all still there. It is simply that, simply because of a viewpoint that may or may not be present in a material and cannot be removed. Logitech: So that was brought forward at the November meeting. In the interim, guidance from the State Library has been that the preferred way to be in line with AB1825, which requires a collection development policy that has specific language. Logitech: is to include that language verbatim in the policy. So that is the actual change that's in the policy from what you saw in November, from what became before this Court, actually, in 2022 was the last time we did a substantial update. And so, on the second page of that administrative policy, you'll see two paragraphs that start with, in compliance with California state law. Logitech: That first section are the required language verb form. Logitech: The second section, which has the procurement, retention, circulation of, etc. Logitech: That is directly from AB1825. We are not required to have that section in the collection development policy. Logitech: I am recommending we include it because it specifically states why we cannot prohibit materials. Logitech: And because when a member of the public has a concern about an item and wishes to submit a reconsider… a request for reconsideration for either its shelving location or its presence in the library, we give them this policy with a form asking them to articulate Logitech: Their concerns, as well as how their concerns… how they see their concerns related to this policy. Logitech: And I believe it gives us the greatest clarity for our public if we have legal restrictions on when and how we do this, that we put that in the policy so that they're not having to go do multiple reference. Logitech: They're able to see immediately if they're going to get a letter back from me saying, thank you for your concern. Because of this state law, our actions are limited to X, Y, and Z. They should know that up front. Logitech: So again, that first section, in which it says AB1825 House of 2024, Lincoln Public Library affirms, those four bullet points are pretty much required by law to be included verbatim in our policy to be in compliance. The second section are those to help make our reconsideration procedure the most transparent and effective it can be for our community. Logitech: And so if there are any questions, concerns, thoughts, happy to… Here you go. Logitech: Is there any action required? Logitech: Because this is an administrative policy, it actually falls within, the jurisdiction of our city manager to enforce, so we do not need you to approve it to go forward, certainly of the board. Logitech: wishes to make a formal action of approval, that can certainly be in minutes, and that helps support this policy. I don't think such, such a motion. Logitech: them. Supporting tips, support. Logitech: Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Logitech: post… Pass. Logitech: Okay, jason, do you have anything to report from Western Placer Unified School District? Logitech: Goodness gracious, you guys, relative to… Logitech: what's helpful here, Catherine? Is it just 12 Bridges High kind of stuff? Like, what… what would the group find most beneficial? We often get updates regarding 12 Bridges High, as well as Lincoln High, because our services for, teens stretch beyond 12 Bridges High. But often we get updates on just what's Logitech: There's something that y'all are really excited about at the district. Oh, yeah, lots of really exciting. Last time our board voted to close First Street School. Logitech: You know, emotionally. It's… it's a temporary school that was… that was put in place in 20, or in 2000. Logitech: Can we use… Logitech: used portables to do so. There's no actual physical space that is anchored to the ground in such a manner that a building would. Logitech: Rumble. It has functioned… Wonderfully for the district, throughout that time, but as you might imagine, Logitech: is trying to become one again with the Earth, just as things do. And, there's a part of me that thinks it's partly held off the ground by just some of the skunks that live underneath the building. We'll find out soon. The reason is because we are at capacity at both of our middle schools. Logitech: We knew that was coming, but it's coming about 2-3 years sooner than we had anticipated. There's no one to blame for that. City's growing. The city was intended to grow. These plans are all in effect. We're just moving forward slightly sooner than otherwise. Logitech: So that'll go into effect in 2027. We'll essentially just move the students, from that location into both Foscont Ranch Elementary and… Logitech: Creekside Oaks. Logitech: The staff will also move into those facilities, so no one's being laid off or displaced or demoted or changed your work title at all. There's a somewhat of a savings to the district to have one less facility to manage, but, it was a very emotional decision. It's a wonderful school, and the timing Logitech: is unfortunate, because last year, California recognized, First Street School as a distinguished school, so hopefully the other schools don't think that's what happens when they win. We're trying to get that message out. Logitech: We also changed the attendance boundaries for the Lincoln Crossings community, moving some of those students roughly 150 per grade level, into both Foscott Ranch, and, and… Logitech: I'm trying to think if we're also… I think it's just Foscett Ranch, and then Glen Edwards, and Lincoln High School, so kids that otherwise would have been going that direction for middle and high school will now be coming this direction for middle and high school. Logitech: there was frustration around that, as you might imagine. Some people thought one school was going to be our school, now it's a different school. I think the superintendent's doing as best a job as can be done, sort of being fair about, you know, siblings, all those types of things, but it's going to be disruptive, Logitech: for the good of the order, 12 Bridges Elementary School, and… Logitech: middle school and high school are already nearing capacity. Those are… Logitech: edging to 78%, all the way up to 85%. The state starts to get really nervous when they see us tip to 90% capacity, so you'll start seeing more. The purpose of Logitech: closing First Street School was in part to give more space to Glen Edwards so that it can expand in its, you know, classroom space. Logitech: So anyway, that, that, not exciting, quite frustrating, but, you know, these are the things we have to do. How many streams are being… Logitech: As I understand it, it's, at this time, about 150 per grade level, starting at about the 4th, 5th grade level, kind of in that Lincoln Logitech: So we've got, we've got Lehman, we've got, kind of. Logitech: Creekside Oaks, you've got… and, Foscow Ranch kind of in that cluster, and essentially, we're moving about 150 or so kids per grade level, back into GEMS and Foskin Ranch. What will happen to the land? Logitech: So the district owns the entire city block that you see Glen Outward sitting on, Logitech: it's super sad when you talk about closing the school, but at the same time, that specific space that First Street School sits on. Logitech: it's… it's not set up well for, even just for activities. It's… it's always sort of been the school that we were like, please do the best you can. I got an email from a teacher today that was just like, I have been, you know, I'm teaching 26 years at First Street, I've got the same carpet. Logitech: In an elementary school, which, you know, that's horrifying, right? So anyway, Logitech: that… the entirety of that city block will at one point be kind of the Glen Edwards footprint, and the hope is we may be able to repurpose some of the portable structures Logitech: I don't have high hopes for that, but, that's sort of the gist of it currently. Logitech: I think so. Thank you, that's, Logitech: Such a challenge there. I mean, such a… That growth is, you know, look, they call them growing pains, right? Communications of all that. Resistance you're gonna get. It's been… Sometimes you just gotta make those tough decisions. Yeah. Logitech: Yeah, we get it. Logitech: It's rough. Thank you. Yeah, and you… Logitech: half of the people are gonna be angry no matter… it's just like, well, who has to be upset, right? It's… somebody has to be, so… yeah. Logitech: Okay, anybody have any other comments? Okay, then we can move on to 7C. Logitech: I believe Teresa is on the phone, the current president of the Browns. Logitech: So, Teresa, you should be able to unmute yourself now, if you'd like, for the report. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Okay, I'm unmuted. Logitech: Perfect, we can hear you. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Okay, great. I'm going to cover two quick things. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: I wanted to mention that Family Art Night on October 11th was a huge success. It's the second year of this. Last year was 700. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: This year, we had 850 community members enjoying it. There was a tiny art cost, face painting, balloon art. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Hands-on art projects, and it was just a great success. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: And with… and friends, the Friends of the Lincoln Public Library were happy to provide the funding and the volunteer support for this amazing event. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: The second thing I want to mention was we had our annual membership meeting on October 25th. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: And we did this differently than usual. Usually we have it at the library. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: But this time, we held it in Sun City, at the Kalaga All-Purpose Room. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: And we had 40 members come, which was… was really the highest we've ever had. And we had an afternoon tea with it. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Catherine Hunt gave a great presentation about the library's accomplishments and activities and usage statistics, goals, and challenges. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: And Gloria? Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Gave the great presentation about Fole's, revenue and expenses and forecast as our treasurer. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: And we, we, announced the election results, which are… Teresa Lai Stanislaw: that next year, Gloria will be the president. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Sharon Goreley would continue to be the book sales director. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Karen Lin will become… will continue to be the newsletter director, and we have a new director, Colleen Hewart, who will be the volunteer and Hospitality Director. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: Does anyone have any questions? Logitech: Well, thank you, Teresa. There's no questions here. Anything on the hands? No. Okay, no questions? Thank you, Teresa. Teresa Lai Stanislaw: You're welcome. Logitech: Okay, and always last is D7. Library Director's update. So I'll just keep you here till 1AM, right? That'll be good for everybody. No? Logitech: Be very quick, as Teresa mentioned, Family Art Night was an incredible success, and we're deeply, deeply grateful for all the support from the friends and our volunteers to make that possible. Logitech: Absolutely fantastic to have 850 people come through the library on a Saturday evening, like, absolutely phenomenal. Feedback was overwhelmingly positive. Logitech: We've got two significant programs in November coming up. We have our Youth Literar

LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD / LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE November 5, 2025 CITY OF LINCOLN LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD / LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE November 5, 2025 AS A COURTESY, PLEASE TURN OFF ALL CELL PHONES & ELECTRONIC DEVICES DURING THE MEETING BOARD / COMMISSION / COMMITTEE 6:00 PM LINCOLN CITY HALL - FIRST FLOOR MEETING ROOM 600 6th Street Lincoln, CA 95648 or attend via ZOOM register by using this link: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_UbK0- rTuRDiCWHNGlmwOEQ or participate by calling US: +1 (669) 900-6833 use ID# 862 4199 4223 and use *9 to raise hand to speak 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. ROLL CALL 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 4. CITIZENS ADDRESSING THE COMMITTEE (Within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Board / Commission / Committee) 5. CONSENT 6. NEW BUSINESS 7. UPDATE (OLD BUSINESS) 8. REQUEST FOR INFORMATION 9. NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING: FEBRUARY 4, 2026 10. ADJOURNMENT 5.A Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. 5.B Approve minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting 5.C Approve minutes of the February 5, 2025 meeting 5.D Approve minutes of the May 7, 2025 meeting 5.E Approve minutes of the August 6, 2025 meeting 6.A Chair and Vice-Chair Nominations and Elections (10 minutes) 6.B Lincoln Public Library Funding & Community Aspirations Report Discussion (30 minutes) 6.C Discontinuation of Hoopla service beginning January 2026 (15 minutes) 7.A Update to the Material Selection Policy in light of AB 1825, the California Freedom to Read Act (10 minutes) 7.B WPUSD Update (5 minutes) 7.C FOLL Update (5 minutes) 7.D Library Director Update (5 minutes) 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400

NOTE: Materials related to an item on this Agenda submitted to the Council/Redevelopment Successor Agency after distribution of the agenda packet are available for public inspection in the City Clerk's office at 600 Sixth Street, Lincoln, CA during normal business hours. Such documents are also available on the City of Lincoln's website at https://www.lincolnca.gov/ subject to staff's availability to post the documents before the meeting. In compliance with the American with Disabilities Act, the City will provide special assistance for disabled members of the public. The meeting room is wheelchair accessible and disabled parking is available. If you have a disability and need a disability-related modification or accommodation to participate in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk's Office at (916) 434-2490. As a courtesy, please make every effort to inform the Clerk of your needs at least 24 hours prior to the meeting so the City may make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. Pursuant to applicable laws and regulations, including without limitation, California Government Code Section 65009 and/or California Public Resources Code Section 21177, if you wish to challenge in court any of the above decisions (including any action regarding planning, zoning and/or environmental decisions), you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing(s) described in this notice/agenda, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. Levine Act Provisions -- The Levine Act requires a party (or the party's agent(s)) to a proceeding before the City of Lincoln that involves any action or consideration to their contract, license, permit, or other entitlement for use, to disclose any campaign contribution made to City elected or appointed officer totaling more than $500 within the 12 months before the City decision. This includes contributions to Councilmembers, Planning Commissioners and members of other City boards and commissions. 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400

Showing the first 24,000 of 247,826 characters. The full document is at the source.

LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD / LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE November 5, 2025 CITY OF LINCOLN LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD / LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE November 5, 2025 AS A COURTESY, PLEASE TURN OFF ALL CELL PHONES & ELECTRONIC DEVICES DURING THE MEETING BOARD / COMMISSION / COMMITTEE 6:00 PM LINCOLN CITY HALL - FIRST FLOOR MEETING ROOM 600 6th Street Lincoln, CA 95648 or attend via ZOOM register by using this link: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_UbK0- rTuRDiCWHNGlmwOEQ or participate by calling US: +1 (669) 900-6833 use ID# 862 4199 4223 and use *9 to raise hand to speak 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400 1

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. ROLL CALL 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 4. CITIZENS ADDRESSING THE COMMITTEE (Within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Board / Commission / Committee) 5. CONSENT 6. NEW BUSINESS 7. UPDATE (OLD BUSINESS) 8. REQUEST FOR INFORMATION 9. NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING: FEBRUARY 4, 2026 10. ADJOURNMENT 5.A Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. 5.B Approve minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting 5.C Approve minutes of the February 5, 2025 meeting 5.D Approve minutes of the May 7, 2025 meeting 5.E Approve minutes of the August 6, 2025 meeting 6.A Chair and Vice-Chair Nominations and Elections (10 minutes) 6.B Lincoln Public Library Funding & Community Aspirations Report Discussion (30 minutes) 6.C Discontinuation of Hoopla service beginning January 2026 (15 minutes) 7.A Update to the Material Selection Policy in light of AB 1825, the California Freedom to Read Act (10 minutes) 7.B WPUSD Update (5 minutes) 7.C FOLL Update (5 minutes) 7.D Library Director Update (5 minutes) 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400 2

NOTE: Materials related to an item on this Agenda submitted to the Council/Redevelopment Successor Agency after distribution of the agenda packet are available for public inspection in the City Clerk's office at 600 Sixth Street, Lincoln, CA during normal business hours. Such documents are also available on the City of Lincoln's website at https://www.lincolnca.gov/ subject to staff's availability to post the documents before the meeting. In compliance with the American with Disabilities Act, the City will provide special assistance for disabled members of the public. The meeting room is wheelchair accessible and disabled parking is available. If you have a disability and need a disability-related modification or accommodation to participate in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk's Office at (916) 434-2490. As a courtesy, please make every effort to inform the Clerk of your needs at least 24 hours prior to the meeting so the City may make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. Pursuant to applicable laws and regulations, including without limitation, California Government Code Section 65009 and/or California Public Resources Code Section 21177, if you wish to challenge in court any of the above decisions (including any action regarding planning, zoning and/or environmental decisions), you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing(s) described in this notice/agenda, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. Levine Act Provisions -- The Levine Act requires a party (or the party's agent(s)) to a proceeding before the City of Lincoln that involves any action or consideration to their contract, license, permit, or other entitlement for use, to disclose any campaign contribution made to City elected or appointed officer totaling more than $500 within the 12 months before the City decision. This includes contributions to Councilmembers, Planning Commissioners and members of other City boards and commissions. 600 Sixth Street ◆ Lincoln, CA 95648 ◆ www.lincolnca.gov ◆ 916-434-2400 3

SUBJECT: Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. SUBMITTED BY: Kathryn Hunt DEPARTMENT: Library DATE: November 5, 2025 Item Number 5.A BACKGROUND/INTRODUCTION: Item continued from previous meeting due the lack of a quorum. ATTACHMENTS: August 7 2024 Minutes - Draft.pdf STAFF REPORT 4

Minutes Library Advisory Board/Library Advisory Committee August 7, 2024, 6 PM | 485 Twelve Bridges Drive, Lincoln CA | Meeting called to order by Gloria Irey In Attendance Voting Library Advisory Board: Neil Cochran Gloria Pilotti-Irey (Chair) Joanne Schumacher Jeff Serpa Lynne Snyder Library Advisory Committee : George Dykstra (WPUSD) (Vice Chair) Jennifer Hladun (WPUSD) Heather Pierce (WPUSD) Non-Voting Members: Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Ben Brown, Lincoln City Councilmember Presenters: Teresa Lai Stanislaw (FOLL) Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 6:02 PM by Gloria Irey. Citizens Addressing the Committee No members of the public addressed the committee. New Business 5.A.: Approve minutes of the May 1, 2024 meeting. There were no corrections to the minutes. Joanne Schumacher moved to approve the minutes. Lynne Snyder seconded. The motion passed unanimously. No members of the public spoke on this item. 5

Page 2 5.B.: Discussion of Sierra College’s Withdrawal from the Twelve Bridges Library Joint-Use Agreement Kathryn Hunt provided a short presentation on the history of the Joint-Use Agreement that governs the Twelve Bridges Library, and an update on Sierra College’s decision to withdraw from the agreement as of July 1, 2025 via the approved method for leaving the agreement. The impact includes the loss of 25% of the Library’s operational funding, which City staff are working to resolve. A brief discussion followed, including a request to be notified of future meetings regarding the topic, the reasons behind Sierra College’s withdrawal, the total fiscal impact, potential mitigating factors, and the timeline of the impact. No members of the public spoke on this item. 5.C.: Teens Succeed Grant Discussion Kathryn Hunt provided a presentation on the Library’s award of the Teens Succeed Teen Internship Grant from the LSTA and the California State Library, including the Library’s desire for community input in designing the internships. Hunt asked the Board and Committee to share what elements they felt would be useful for young people to learn or experience in an internship. Robust discussion followed, with both questions about the details of the internship and a desire to see: • Building soft skills (Heather Pierce) • Telephone skills (Heather Pierce) • Presentation and report skills (Neil Cochran) • Accessibility of the internship for students throughout Lincoln, including at Lincoln High (Lynne Snyder) • Leadership and governance (Lynne Snyder) No members of the public spoke on this item. 5.D.: Library Hold Locker Wrap Design Discussion Kathryn Hunt provided a presentation on potential hold locker wrap designs, including key design considerations and examples of possible directions. Robust discussion followed, with the committee expressing a desire for new designs with some or all of the following: • Less space dedicated to text and instructions, including potentially moving text to the sides • More interesting graphics, and more space dedicated to them • Removal of the square borders around the instruction • Inclusion of books in the design, to clearly convey the relation to the design • A catchy tagline Hunt committed to take note of this feedback and sending out an updated design to the Board and Committee when available. No members of the public spoke on this item. Update (Old Business) 6.A.: Parking Update Hunt shared that the construction plans for the recycling bin site were in draft in form, and highlighted the next steps for the project. A contract for construction is anticipated in the fall, with construction starting in 2025 with construction taking up to 12 months. Heather Pierce provided an update that seniors had painted their parking spots, to encourage seniors to park in the Fieldstone parking lot. No members of the public commented on this item. 6

Page 3 6.B.: WPUSD Update Heather Pierce provided the first part of the update, highlighting the start of school, the growth of the district, the emphasis of the District on academic excellence and the new Portrait of a Learner, and TBHS graduations. Jennifer Hladun also spoke to the growth of the district, construction at Lincoln High School, academic performance, and LHS’s Title I status. A brief discussion on enrollment levels and ATLAS followed. No members of the public commented on this item. 6.C.: Sierra College Update As there was no representative from Sierra College, no update was provided. No members of the public commented on this item. 6.D.: Friends of the Lincoln Public Library (FOLL) Report Teresa Lai Stanislaw provided the update. She heighted the contributions of FOLL, including: • Over $61,000 in funding provided in the last year • Over 5500 hours of volunteer service provided in the last year, including the all-volunteer Board of Directors. • Raising over $15,000 during the Big Day of Giving • Raising over $2500 during the last Big Book Sale Stanislaw emphasized that FOLL has the resources to support the Library through future challenges, and then shared a short video highlighting FOLL’s contributions. No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.E.: Library Director Update Hunt provided an update on the following items: • New self-checks, supported by FOLL funding • 2024 Summer Reading Program • 2024 Writing Contest • Upcoming Programs: Youth Literary Festival, Family Art Night • Strategic Planning George Dykstra shared his interest in the Library acquiring a 3D printer and hosting a teen poetry slam. Jennifer Hladun shared that the schools can offer space for library programs and events. No members of the public spoke on this item. Request for Information Neil highlighted the rise in circulation in library statistics. George Dykstra requested information as the response to Sierra College’s withdrawal was developed. No members of the public spoke on this item. Next Regularly Scheduled Meeting November 6, 2024. Short discussion followed regarding the location of the meeting, as the Willow Room will be impacted by its location as a polling place. Meeting adjourned at 7:09 PM. 7

Page 4 Minutes submitted by Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Audio/video recording of the meeting available at https://www.lincolnca.gov/en/our-government/watch-live.aspx 8

SUBJECT: Approve minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting SUBMITTED BY: Kathryn Hunt DEPARTMENT: Library DATE: November 5, 2025 Item Number 5.B BACKGROUND/INTRODUCTION: Item continued from previous meeting due the lack of a quorum. ATTACHMENTS: November 6 2024 Minutes - Draft.pdf STAFF REPORT 9

Minutes Library Advisory Board/Library Advisory Committee November 6, 2024, 6 PM | 600 6th Street, Lincoln CA | Meeting called to order by Gloria Irey In Attendance Voting Library Advisory Board: Neil Cochran Gloria Pilotti-Irey (Chair) Joanne Schumacher Jeff Serpa Library Advisory Committee : George Dykstra (WPUSD) (Vice Chair) Heather Pierce (WPUSD) Non-Voting Members: Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Presenters: Teresa Lai Stanislaw (FOLL) Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Gloria Irey. Citizens Addressing the Committee No members of the public addressed the committee. New Business 5.A.: Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the February 5, 2025 meeting. No members of the public spoke on this item. 5.B.: AB 1825, California Freedom to Read Act Kathryn Hunt provided a brief summary of the passage of AB 1825, and highlighted that the Library’s collection development policy was in line with the law. Next steps include sending the development policy to the State Library, per AB 1825, and adding a reference to the law in the policy. Any other changes will come to the Board and Committee for discussion. 10

Page 2 Neil Cochran inquired whether members of the public with questions about AB 1825 should reach out to Kathryn. She clarified that she was not a lawyer, but would happy to discuss the impact on libraries. No members of the public spoke on this item. Update (Old Business) 6.A.: Library Hold Locker Update Kathryn Hunt stated that hold lockers were anticipated to be installed the week of November 18th , 2024. Following installation would be trouble-shooting, a soft opening to fine-tune processes, and then major outreach to promote the service. Hunt also provided an update that through the outreach of FOLL, the Lincoln Community Foundation was funding a Spanish-language enhancement to the catalog, making it easier for residents who prefer Spanish to place items on hold and use the lockers. Joanna asked for clarification on whether the lockers would be operation immediately after install, and Hunt stated they would be. No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.B.: Teens Succeed Internship Update Kathryn Hunt highlighted what steps had been taken to include community input on the internship content, the approval of the job description by the City Council, and upcoming steps for recruitment and promotion. Brief discussion followed regarding age, time commitment, desired traits in the candidates, and number of positions. No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.C.: Parking Update Hunt shared that contract to move the recycling bins would be coming up at the next City Council Meeting, with a proposed completion date of mid-2025. This will help relieve day-to-day congestion in the parking lot. Hunt also mentioned that the largest impacts are still Jr. Rhinos Football games. Heather Pierce noted that the WPUSD staff development day was held at a different school this year to limit parking impacts. A brief discussion followed regarding signage directing visitors to Fieldstone, the current use of temporary signage for major events, school communications regarding parking, access to the Fieldstone lot, and the requirements for third parties to rent facilities from the District. No members of the public commented on this item. 6.D.: WPUSD Update Heather Pierce provided the update, highlighting: • Development and growth in the District, related to construction in the City • Opening of the play “Puffs” this week • Field construction remaining on track • College & Career Night this week • Football playoffs 6.E.: Friends of the Lincoln Public Library (FOLL) Report Teresa Lai Stanislaw provided the update, highlighting: • Family Art Night, attended by over 700 people and funded by FOLL • $14,000 in support of new self-checks 11

Page 3 • Grant updates, including new grants from the Lincoln Community Foundation for Movie Night and Spanish-language catalog enhancements; pending grant applications with the Lincoln Hills Foundation for large print books, audio books, and Hoopla access; and grants from Rotary for children’s non-fiction titles • The Big Book Sale on November 16 • The Annual Membership Meeting on November 23 No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.E.: Library Director Update Hunt provided an update on the following items: • New format for report documents • 2023/2024 circulation exceeding 400,000 for the first time since 2009 • An agreement between FOLL and the City for the management of ARPA funds for library projects • Upcoming programs • Movement on community outreach, include contracting with a consultant and a feedback exercise at the February meeting. No members of the public spoke on this item. Request for Information None were stated. No members of the public spoke on this item. Next Regularly Scheduled Meeting February 5, 2025 Meeting adjourned at 6:42 PM. Minutes submitted by Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Audio/video recording of the meeting available at https://www.lincolnca.gov/en/our-government/watch-live.aspx 12

SUBJECT: Approve minutes of the February 5, 2025 meeting SUBMITTED BY: Kathryn Hunt DEPARTMENT: Library DATE: November 5, 2025 Item Number 5.C BACKGROUND/INTRODUCTION: Item continued from previous meeting due the lack of a quorum. ATTACHMENTS: February 5 2025 Minutes - Draft.pdf STAFF REPORT 13

Minutes Library Advisory Board/Library Advisory Committee February 5, 2025, 6 PM | 485 Twelve Bridges Drive, Lincoln CA and on Zoom | Meeting called to order by Gloria Irey In Attendance Voting Library Advisory Board: Neil Cochran Gloria Pilotti-Irey (Chair) Joanne Schumacher Lynne Snyder Library Advisory Committee : Heather Pierce (WPUSD) Non-Voting Members: Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Richard Pearl, City Councilmember Presenters: Linda Derosier (FOLL) Stephanie Chase (Constructive Disruption) Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 6:02 PM by Gloria Irey. Citizens Addressing the Committee No members of the public addressed the committee. Consent 5.A.: Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the May 7, 2025 meeting. 5.B.: Approve minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the May 7, 2025 meeting. 14

Page 2 Update (Old Business) 6.A.: WPUSD Update Heather Pierce provided the update, highlighting: • Graduation dates, with TBHS regularly graduating the day after the last day of school. • Preparations for next school year, including registrations • Current enrollment levels No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.B.: Sierra College Update No representative of Sierra College was present. No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.C.: Friends of the Lincoln Public Library (FOLL) Update Linda Derosier provided the update, highlighting: • Over $115,000 in support of the Library in 2024, including support for self-checks, digital and physical collections, book giveaways, and library programs. • Only 7% of expenses were administrative and fundraising • The efforts of the volunteer board No members of the public spoke on this item. 6.E.: Library Director Update Hunt provided an update on the following items: • The City Council workshop on Library funding. Richard Pearl also spoke on the upcoming budget cycle and Council’s direction at that workshop. • The 24/7 Hold Lockers No members of the public spoke on this item. New Business 7.A.: Potential 3D Printing Services Hunt provided a brief introduction, mentioning that this item was brought forward by George Dykstra. Hunt mentioned that staff were looking at both costs and community interest, and then will decide whether to move forward with the services. Heather Pierce shared the availability and popularity of 3D printing services at the school district. Hunt shared the models of services offered by peer libraries, include loaning out 3D printers, instructional programs, and lab time models. A discussion of costs, liability, access, and staffing followed. No members of the public spoke on this item. 7.B.: Chair and Vice-Chair Nominations and Elections As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the May 7, 2025 meeting. No members of the public spoke on this item. 7.C.: Board Community Input Exercise with Constructive Disruption Hunt provided an introduction to Stephanie Chase of Constructive Disruption. Stephanie Chase introduced the community input project, and then guided the LAB/LAC through a SOAR (Strengths, Opportunities, Aspirations, Results) exercise. 15

Page 3 The comments were recorded by the consultant and are available at https://padlet.com/acornsandnuts/LincolnBoard Following the exercise, there was a brief discussion about confusion regarding the agenda item before the meeting, as well as information about the community survey and in-person activities. No members of the public spoke on this item. Request for Information None were stated. No members of the public spoke on this item. Next Regularly Scheduled Meeting May 7, 2025 Meeting adjourned at 7:15 PM. Minutes submitted by Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Audio/video recording of the meeting available at https://www.lincolnca.gov/en/our-government/watch-live.aspx 16

SUBJECT: Approve minutes of the May 7, 2025 meeting SUBMITTED BY: Kathryn Hunt DEPARTMENT: Library DATE: November 5, 2025 Item Number 5.D BACKGROUND/INTRODUCTION: Item continued from previous meeting due the lack of a quorum. ATTACHMENTS: May 7 2025 Minutes - Draft.pdf STAFF REPORT 17

Minutes Library Advisory Board/Library Advisory Committee May 7, 2025, 6 PM | 600 6th Street, Lincoln CA and on Zoom | Meeting called to order by Gloria Irey In Attendance Voting Library Advisory Board: Neil Cochran Gloria Pilotti-Irey (Chair) Joanne Schumacher Lynne Snyder David Villegas Library Advisory Committee : Ashley Sandor (Proxy for Jennifer Hladun, non-voting) Non-Voting Members: Kathryn Hunt, Director of Library Services Whitney Eklund, City Councilmember Presenters: Teresa Lai Stanislaw (FOLL) Stephanie Chase (Constructive Disruption) Judah Hamer (Constructive Disruption) Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Gloria Irey. Citizens Addressing the Committee No members of the public addressed the committee. Consent 5.A.: Approve minutes of the August 7, 2024 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the August 6, 2025 meeting. 5.B.: Approve minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the August 6, 2025 meeting. 18

Page 2 5.B.: Approve minutes of the February 5, 2025 meeting. As there was not a quorum, this item was continued to the August 6, 2025 meeting. New Business 6.A.: Library Funding & Community Aspirations Project Presentation Kathryn Hunt introduced the presenters, Stephanie Chase and Judah Hamer of Constructive Disruption, and highlighted that this project had included community outreach to identify community aspirations, as well as an analysis of some paths forward toward those aspirations given the current financial situation of the Library. Stephanie Chase shared that this presentation was a highlight of what they had found through their process in advance of the full report being finalized and distributed, as well as an opportunity for the Board and Committee to ask questions. Chase highlighted major themes, including the continued growth of Lincoln and that Library funding has not kept pace with that growth or with peer library systems. In addition, she provided context on how historic budget variability has impacted staffing, which impacts open hours and services, as well as the state of the collection. Judah Hamer than provided an overview of their findings, including the community’s vision of the strengths, opportunities, and aspirations of the Library. Strengths included the collection, both physical and digital; opportunities include expanded hours and access; and aspirations include extending library services throughout the City, including Downtown. Hamer also presented three potential paths forward: a loss in service, with a 25% reduction in operating budget, which would require the renegotiation of the MOU; the status quo of maintaining services at Twelve Bridges, while noting that population growth will erode services with flat funding; and the potentiality of adding new partners, which will require additional services and significant time investment to seek a partner. These paths are in addition to a potential long-term aspiration of raising library funding to the median funding level for libraries in the state, which would require significant annual increases over multiple years. The implications of these paths were explored in terms of budget, staffing, and collections. Hamer highlighted that the long-term construction of library funding does not match the City’s village model to the current pride in library services articulation by the community, and how this impacts future planning for library services. Future steps for the library, including completing service audits, finding capacity to solve the budget concer

Showing the first 24,000 of 71,753 characters. The full document is at the source.

Logitech: Okay, we're good to get started, Gloria. We can begin the meeting. Okay, let's, call the meeting to order. Logitech: And Catherine, would you do welcome, please? Absolutely. For the Library Advisory Board, we have Neil Coffer. Logitech: Nope. Logitech: Gloria, Lonnie, Irene? Here. Logitech: Joanne Schumacher? Here. At Jeff Circle, let me know if you would not be able to be here today. Lynn Snyder? Logitech: David Milliejas? Here. And for the Library Advisory Committee, Josh Ekstra! Logitech: Ashley Sander, let me know if she's not able to be here. Jason Price, I'm Heather Pierce. Logitech: And I, that leaves us one short of a quorum, unfortunately. Logitech: Okay, so we don't have a board. Oh, Teresa didn't get on, she said. Perfect. Logitech: Is there… we don't have any visitors or citizens here, other than the board itself. Are there anybody, any on Zoom? Logitech: We do have one member of the public on… Logitech: Zoom, but we have no hands raised. So, and we do have the, Pledge of Allegiance as well. Logitech: Oh, did I right… go right by that? I think I did that last time. Logitech: But I'll let it stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Logitech: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Logitech: So, since we do not have a quorum. Logitech: Item, we'll need to, reschedule item 5. Logitech: And item 6A for the next meeting continues us on to the next meeting. Logitech: Okay, so then we'll proceed with future business, number 6B. Logitech: Lincoln Public Library Funding and Community Aspirations Report Discussion. Logitech: Yes, so this is bringing forward, a chance for this body to discuss the, library funding and community aspirations report that was completed by Constructive Disruption. This body did receive a pre-report presentation from our, vendor, Constructive Disruption, on this, our consultant. Logitech: Previously, this was also, you all were given a digital copy of the report in advance of the report being presented to Council. That Council meeting was a brief introduction to it, and response from Council was, quite supportive of library services and committed to finding solutions for library services in the future. Logitech: But then there was a desire for this body to have a chance to speak about this, so that is this time. And then in your agenda packet was… Logitech: The report itself, as well as there had been a request for information earlier, since there was some discussion, in this report and in the previous presentations about the general plans. Logitech: I did my, very much not a part of the planning department review of the general plan and tried to pull out the primary references to library services. So that was kind of that second document. So if it seems it jumps around. Logitech: It does, these are excerpts from the about… Logitech: I think it's about a 700-page document of the general plan, that specifically records library or, community centers. Logitech: So, yes, this is the fourth time. Logitech: Okay, is there anyone that would like to kick us off on, I guess, observation, questions? Logitech: Something that you thought stood out in the report that you'd like the board to talk about? Logitech: Well, I thought it was… well, I did find it interesting, maybe because I used to work at the library, that when you look on page 37 of the report, where they were talking about, how to maintain a single location with the 75% of current budget, that's basically Logitech: staying… Logitech: you know, without the, the support of Sierra College, what we would look like. And the, they had a suggestion in here about the hours, and they looked quite similar to the hours that I used to work. Logitech: So that was, kind of an observation on my part. But the other thing that… I remember working those late hours between 5 and 7. I know the community in, you know, in the research out there, or the part of the study that they did, and talking to the community, that they wanted extended hours. Logitech: But I remember it being a ghost town in that library between 5 and 7. If we were lucky, if we had 3 or 4 people in there. Logitech: So it is not, you know, it's like they want it, but then they don't show up for it. So, you know, I just don't know… Logitech: you know, of course, circumstances change. The… you know, that was 7, 8 years ago. People's, you know, schedules are different, their lifestyles are different. Logitech: But that was something that I thought was, interesting, anyway. Logitech: Would… do you think that… alright, so 5 to 7 is… is… 5 to 7 is the dinner time. Logitech: There was no interest And later than 7. Logitech: No, I think we closed at… my recollection is we closed at 7. Historically, we closed at 7. I don't remember exactly the language in the survey. I would say, historically, if you ask the community, would you like hours at X? Logitech: People will say yes, regardless of whether they… Logitech: whether they would use that. They would personally use. Yes. Logitech: Fortunately, because we have a very pro-library community, that's what came forward in kind of our community survey, very few people here, would you like expansion of library services in this way, and go, no, no, thank you. Logitech: More is more and more, we tend to get very positive responses, too. I would say that there are relatively few libraries Logitech: serving communities very similar to ours that have hours past 8 p.m. Typically, you see those in core library systems, or core library branches in high-density urban areas. It's relatively unusual in our state in suburban or rural library systems. Logitech: What about Sunday? You're closed on Sunday now, right? We are closed on Sunday. Sunday tends to be the last day added to libraries. Typically, we see if it's a six-day system, it tends to be Monday through Saturday is the open days. Logitech: I suspect part of that is, simply staffing logistics. It is easier to consistently staff weekdays than it is weekends. But yeah, certainly something that we could look at in terms of increasing access. Logitech: So, I'll share another observation. Well, one of the things that I was… I was kind of like… I didn't think about that when I read the report, was that, you know, at present, without Sierra College. Logitech: The city, if I'm correct here, Catherine, the city provides about 85% of the funding, and the district provides 15. But our hours are being driven by the school's needs. Logitech: And there was a pretty strong statement in the report about how we, the library, you know, should refocus their hours to better serve the general public, since they're providing the funding, the lion's share of the funding. And I thought that was a good argument Logitech: To, persuade the school district to put more money in. Logitech: It certainly was a… was a powerful observation with that shift in funding, in terms of… Logitech: And I know one of the things that was in the presentations, I believe it's… I'm not seeing the page number in this. Logitech: But with that was, a suggestion that the library do an assessment of where we put our resources and see to what percentage goes to the general public and what percentage Logitech: It goes to the school district to… beyond just hours, in terms of programming, collection, staff time, all of those, to have a better and more holistic understanding of, Logitech: how those resources are being distributed, and that's certainly something, as we're going through these different pieces, my staff is working on those assessments to get a more holistic grasp of how well distributed our use of resources are, reflecting the community, because, of course, service for teens is not… Logitech: completely analogous with service for the school, how we would always serve teens as well. So, doing some of that analysis to see, how our breakdowns are working. So, can you go into a little more detail about what it is that you would have them look at that you don't already have them looking at? Logitech: So, like… Logitech: feet in the door, or materials of where they go, or who they go to, or the kind of materials, or what are you thinking? Yeah, we're gonna pull probably a little bit more circulation data to look at collection use, and then also, Logitech: Categories of individuals who are using the collection, so obviously we're not going to do a statistical analysis. Logitech: card by card, in order to avoid any confidentiality issues, but for example, all of our student accounts are identified as such in our database. We can run an anonymized, report of the usage of those account types. Logitech: Okay. So looking at that and comparing how that works across the collection, and then comparing that against our purchasing in those collections. Logitech: Because again, we do a lot of usage comparisons, but we don't always, every time we do those usage, then compare it back down to the budget line support of that. Can you give them data on… Logitech: Not only use it, who uses it, but… Logitech: If you have, say, Book A, what percentage is used by students, and then what percentage is used by the general public? Logitech: I would have to take a look. Typically, that data's a little bit more difficult, because that is more closely linked to individuals and their individual circulation, which our databases are designed to anonymize, because… Right, I understand that, it's reasonable. Logitech: So typically, we don't have easy access to, like, historic circulation on single items, whereas… Logitech: percentages are already anonymized, they don't have specific titles or names. I'm just still trying… struggling with Logitech: what you're going to get out of it, or whatever research you're doing. Yeah, and then looking at our programming, our programming and events, and trying to really, identify not just high impact, but, the fullness of our staff investments in those. Logitech: I have a sense that your doubts will not do to you. Logitech: The whole picture on the usage pie. Logitech: the high school. Logitech: Because… Logitech: there will be students in the library who will not be checking things out. Oh, absolutely. And that will probably be… Logitech: A greater, more significant number. Logitech: Because they will be… they will be using it for their own, you know, for their own personal uses, or for… for group… Logitech: Excellent. Logitech: meeting place, or it's raining outside, or… you know, and that… that… Logitech: Requires the lights be on and the heat be on, and there be staff here. Logitech: So, just as much, if not more so, that is an invaluable God. Logitech: Opportunity for the high school. Logitech: Because they don't have any other place for kids to go. Logitech: You know, they don't have a big… Logitech: you know, rec room area kind of thing. They do have a large student center. Logitech: So there is… there is space for students to go. It does not have the library resources. But, to your point, though, absolutely, use of the space is definitely one of those metrics when we think of Logitech: what is the value that any individual organization gets? Collection and circulation is only one piece. Space is absolutely another significance. Okay, and so to a significant degree, Logitech: We need the high school, and they certainly need us. Logitech: So I would like to know what the process would be to renegotiate the, Logitech: you know, not just say it would be nice if you gave us more money, but that you need to pick up your share of expenses. So what would that process be, and would the consul ever get to the point where they would? Logitech: Have those kinds of discussions with the school district. Logitech: So, absolutely, and one of the things I can say is that that conversation, which is also, in part, the conversation around the negotiation of the MOU, which Logitech: Is what sets these percentages, and also sets a number of other operational and administrative standards that have been more or less effective over the last 10 years. Logitech: is part of a larger discussion of joint use that, city staff, primarily our city manager, are involved in at this point, and it's happening at the staff level. It's just an involved conversation. Well, because, look, they don't come to the meetings. Logitech: And that's a real failing, and I don't think that our bylaws provide, but I don't think people should be able to miss Logitech: for a whole year, this board has not been able to even approve its minutes. Right. No organization can exist. Logitech: That way. Logitech: But no, we can't. Now we have a quorum! There's a couple more coming. Oh. It doesn't bode well to be on a library committee when you don't read. Logitech: the email that I sent us out here and not… my apologies. Logitech: So, to build a little bit on what Lynn was saying, if I might, for a second, going back to Logitech: the student usage in the library. For instance. Logitech: Can you tell that students are coming in and just using, you know, doing their homework, for instance? Logitech: Because… or they're waiting for their ride home, or whatever. They're not really, like she says, checking anything out, or even taking the book off the shelf. Logitech: I mean, can you tell that? Can you even get that information? Logitech: I know you can have a gut-level feeling for it, but… Logitech: within a certain capacity. So, and depending on how, the direction we take gives us more or less certainty on that data. It will always be point-in-time analysis, it will always be self-reported to some extent, but, yes, we can, we can sit down and… Logitech: And I am not, and I don't think we should be at all in any way critical of that use of the library, because that is… And I think we need to make that clear, because that is a… Logitech: So Nathan sort of welcome. Logitech: home and opportunity for students. Well, and I think that the library has gone, you know, has made it so, Logitech: Yeah, we… I'm there a lot, and I see a lot of high school students in there during, like, lunch hour, you see them after school, they're, you know, they've got their special spaces they go into and hang out, and they seem to… and it seems to, you know, there's spaces where the other side of the library, where the adults go and hang out. Logitech: that like to come to the library and read their book, or to look at magazines, or for whatever person. They're kind of like… they're really… because the library is so large, it really works for… for all age groups, you know, because the kids, of course, the little kids, they got their own, you know, section all together. So, because the library's so large, and the… and the… Logitech: the layout was such that the team-focused ones on one end, and the adults kind of hang out on the other. There isn't, like, this, you know, it seems to go very, very smooth. Logitech: And the library, during the library is, during school, there is somebody there from the school district. Logitech: to, you know, address any kind of… if somebody gets a little too loud or rambunctious or something, they take… they seem to take care of it. So, what does that look like? I mean, is there, like, a monitor, or what… who comes over here, and what… are they assigned? Are they paid to do that? So, yes. So, during the school day, there are two formal periods where students, are… Logitech: necessarily scheduled to be in the library, but there's a flex study hall period, and then there is lunchtime. And so students, for Flex are assigned, and it's a class period, and they come in and check in and use. Logitech: the library is one of the spaces on campus that are an option for Flex. And then during lunch, students can opt in up to a certain maximum. We can't have all Logitech: 700 of the upperclassmen come into the library at the same time, and that's managed at the office. Logitech: And then, we have our library technicians for 12 Bridges High School, who do a lot of work also at the Student Center and doing the actual, like, textbook distribution and all of that work for supporting the students on campus. Logitech: They are over during flex and lunchtime and help support the students and ensure that we have a successful interaction. Logitech: Outside of those scheduled times, you do not necessarily have the technicians. You have off periods, things like that are also present in the library, and then, yes, we do have a significant youth presence after school, Logitech: a substantial portion of which is high school. We do also know that we have, youth who are present from John Adams that is across the street, as well as from Whitney High, which is very close. And so, when we talk about doing the assessment, this is where we see me prevaricate a little bit about the hard data. We certainly can very easily do point-in-time assessments of high school-aged individuals in the library in certain time periods. Logitech: without getting a little bit more invasive in terms of our questioning and setting a tone for that, we don't necessarily know whether they are, again, 12 Richest High students, Whitney High students, John Adams students, or homeschool students, which we have a substantial portion that use the library. Logitech: No. John Adams is a charter under Western Placer. Whitney is Ross. Logitech: So, how do you know if you're reaching your maximum? Logitech: Allowed student count. Logitech: Well, during lunch and flex, that's the only time that we have that count, and that is only… Whitney does not send their students over during lunch. No, but how do you know? Are you counting their heads when they come in the door, or how do you… The school manages that, so for lunch, it's managed at the school office, where they have to go through to come up and see us. Logitech: Flex is assigned, and they have a check-in process, just like they do attendance, just for flex. Yes, and it's managed by our, you know, school employees, the library technicians for 12 hours. Logitech: So you get some… some numbers. Logitech: Yes, so we have those, absolutely, and we can see that. Logitech: So then, again, I would… well, first of all, maybe we should recall, attendance and… Logitech: Have a quorum so that we can… Logitech: And that's the business. Catherine, do we have a quorum at this time? And so I would say, Chair, if you're interested, if you'd like, we could certainly suspend this item, or we could finish this item, and then at the end of this item, go back to the consent agenda. Finish this and then go back. But then we can't take any votes or anything on this, because we don't have a quorum. Logitech: Yeah, we do have a quorum now. Will you have? Okay. Logitech: I think you have a forum, you have to take attendance. You have to take attendance. And so, my apologies for being late, I was on time at the library. Logitech: Somehow Jason beat me here, I don't know how he did that. I'm gonna… I'm gonna choose to suspend discussion at this time so that we can go back to retake the roll call and assess whether we have a warrant. Logitech: Fantastic. All right, so going back to roll call for the Library Advisory Board, Neil Crawford. Logitech: Gloria Irene? Here. John Schumacher? Here. Jeff Serpa is excused. Lynn Snyder? Here. David, Villegas? Here. Logitech: Fantastic. For the Library Advisory Board, or Library Advisory Committee, George Dykstra. Logitech: Jason Price? Here. Heather Pierce? Logitech: Fantastic, and then for our non-voting members, Richard Pearl? Here. Wonderful. Logitech: Alright, and then, Logitech: Fantastic. So, Chair, we do have a quorum. Okay, well, let's, proceed with, our consent items. That is the approval of the minutes. August 2024 through August 2025. Logitech: Do I have a motion to… do I do a motion with this? Yep, a motion and a second, and then a vote. Logitech: Second, okay. Logitech: Did you get those? I did, thank you. All in favor? Aye. Logitech: Okay, the items under consent have been approved. Logitech: Okay, under new business… Logitech: We have… now we can address item 6A, and that is the chair and vice chair nominations and elections. Logitech: Okay, do I have any nominations for chair? Logitech: Is there a slate? Logitech: It's anybody who's on the board. Logitech: No, was there a slate presented by any kind of… no, nominations committee or anything? No, no. We have historically done these, pretty much simultaneously when we have split them Logitech: It hasn't really seemed to save us time. Logitech: Okay, I would like to nominate, David… Villegas? Logitech: And he… is that that I say it right? You did, yeah. Okay. And I've spoken with David, and he is willing to accept that nomination. Logitech: Yep. Logitech: I don't know if it helps to know a little bit more about me. So, I am currently an assessment and email manager with Visions and Education. We are an NCB charter school. Logitech: We serve students in, in nine counties, so Sacramento and the, all the continuous, all the, counties that touch it. It's a, it's a, I think, one of the largest charter schools, I think it's the largest one in California, that is one school. Logitech: I have a lot of experience, supporting education research and program evaluation. I, I came to Visions A education from the Santa Clara County Office of Education, where I was doing education research and program eval. I think 15 different programs, tobacco use prevention education and whatnot. Logitech: So I'm a big proponent of libraries and what they can do in terms of performing services. In Santa Clara County, we had some great partnerships. Logitech: Between early care and education providers and, the public library system there. So it is a lifeline. In addition to that, my other commitments for, for boards are I'm on the, Placer County, Logitech: Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Commission, where I serve as Secretary. I'm on the Lincoln Parks and Recreation Committee, but there haven't been many meetings over the course of the past year. And I'm also on the Placer County Logitech: Child Care Planning Council. So I'm a pretty active member. I know what's involved in terms of coordinating meetings. I look forward to maybe working with Gloria a little bit more, getting schooled up on procedures, and then, of course, just supporting Catherine whenever she needs to make this work. Kathy. Logitech: Sorry for stammering, I'm… I have a little bit of a cold right now, so I'm working through it. Logitech: Oh, thank you for giving us that… your background information, I appreciate that. Do we have any other nominations for president? Logitech: I mean, I'm sorry, President, I got there. Chair? Logitech: Can I proceed with… Logitech: Yep, if we want to do, yeah, do them as separate actions, absolutely. Okay, can… I would, Logitech: proceed with a vote? Is that… it would be a motion and a second to elect David as the chair of, the lab. Okay. Logitech: I'll give you a motion. Okay. Logitech: Second. All right. Logitech: All in favor? Aye. Logitech: Outpost? Logitech: Well, congratulations, David. You are the new chair. Now, I proceed with this meeting, correct, or… Yes. I think you'll wrap up this meeting. Okay. All right, thank you. Logitech: Now the, the current vice chair is, george Dykstra. George Dykstra. So, and the vice chair would be from Western Placer Unified School District? Yes. Logitech: So do we have any nominations for Vice Chair? I'll nominate Jason Price. Yeah, I'm happy to serve it. Huh? I'm happy to serve it. Okay. If asked to do so. All right, well, I'll second that nomination. I guess I can. Logitech: All in favor of, of, Jason Price as Vice Chair of the Library Advisory Board? Aye. Logitech: Oh, and he knows? Logitech: Okay, well, congratulations. I'll try to show up to the right building next time. I feel like it's a good s

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Library Advisory Board / Library Advisory Committee
  • Library Advisory Board / Library Advisory Committee — Packet
  • Library Advisory Board / Library Advisory Committee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 89088f4c4c53bebd44702c60b701578d. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record