POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Appropriations Committee on Transportation, Tourism, and Economic Development · Closed…

Thursday, February 12, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Appropriations Committee on Transportation, Tourism, and Economic Development — Closed Captions

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 78,244 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Good afternoon. The Appropriations Committee on transportation, tourism and economic development will now come to order, Brooke. Please call the roll vice-chair polsky. I'm here. Senator Arrington here. But Senator Bernard, here, Senator Bracy Davis, Here. Senator Grall Senator Martin. Senator Mayfield here, Senator McClain Senator Smith. Senator, Truenow, Senator Wright chair DiCeglie here. A quorum is present. Thank you, Brooke. Senator Wright is excused from today's meeting. Please silence all electronic devices. Anyone wishing to speak before the committee should complete an appearance form and hand it to a member of the sergeants office. Should you select to waive your speaking time? Your position would be included in the committee meeting records. Senators. We have 3, 6, 8 bills today. We will not be presenting our budget spreadsheets today, but we're going to go right to tab number 7, which is CS for Senate Bill 1220, on transportation by Senator Massullo. Senator, Sue, Welcome. You are recognized to explain your Bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair Cs for SB 1220, is a comprehensive transportation bill that expands FDOT is authority across multiple sectors including trail seaports. Aviation, advanced air Mobility emerging emerging technology. The bill revises regulations for personal delivery devices and drone delivery services strengthens planning requirements for seaports and commercial airports. It authorizes FDOT to own and operate airports and those airports are primarily for that. Wojciech centralizes statewide light are mapping procurement under FDOT increases percentages south Florida turnpike. Total revenues that must be spent locally creates new felony power, least damaging for shooting a shooting into or damaging autonomous vehicles. In repeals Florida's digital driver's license statute and requires a $300,000 FDOT study on the long-term impacts of electric and alternative fuel vehicles on state transportation revenues in that is the bill. >> Okay. Thank you, Senator. We do have we we do have an amendment. So let's go in. Take up Amendment bar code 3, 4, 3, 3, 6, 4, by Senator Massullo Senate. You're recognized to explain your amendment. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair this amendment prohibits counties municipalities for levying a fee on a restricting commercial advertising on personal delivery devices does not prohibit a county or municipality for enacting a safety regulated regulation. It revises the language regarding FDOT as coordination with local government on local applications. For federal funding to ensure consistency with FDOT is mission goals and objectives and it limits. Fdot is airport ownership in operation language, specifically to advanced air mobility, as I mentioned previously. And it clarifies that certain requirements for agreements between FDOT and paired transit providers are limited to provide such services to persons with disabilities. That's the Amendment. >> Okay. Thank you, Senator. Any questions on the amendment. Senator Smith, you're recognized in questions. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator Massullo for taking the time today to talk to me about this bill. I have questions about some of the lines in your amendment. The ones that you just mentioned that we discussed earlier today, particularly around how we're requiring the municipalities to coordinate with and provide assistance. Well, this is FDOT coordinating with in providing assistance to local governments on development and review of applications for federal transportation funding to ensure each project receiving federal funds is consistent with the department's mission goals and objectives. Could too. How how maybe me understand what the what the intent of that language is like. Why? Why do we want FDOT to to be involved with these local applications for federal dollars? What is what is the intent behind that language, Sir? Senator, so. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you for the question. Senator Smith and I I also appreciate the time that we were able to sit together and discuss this federal funds. Federal grants tend to be very prescriptive and getting them isn't as easy as a lot of things should be probably and getting them again is also somewhat at risk when they're not followed precisely the first time. This particular statement in the bill starting on liens to 63 to 2.67 of the amendment, basically coordinates whatever is going on with that particular entity with FDOT. So those federal funds can be accessed in such a way that that all those particular prescriptive served met as far as the statement about the mission, goals and objectives were some people might think that is a little ambiguous. I think it's probably just consistent with FDOT ease desire to maintain a safe and proper infrastructure within our state. We have also looked at language and we're still reviewing that would make that more of an optional thing for counties, municipalities that would be on a per request basis. We haven't totally I can see. We haven't really decided on that language but we are considering it. Senator Smith follow-up. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator Massullo for that response. And I'm understanding what you're describing to to basically means that the intent of this language for FDOT to assist the municipality in making sure that they alright so successful with requesting these federal grant dollars. And we want to make sure that there's no missed opportunities there. I do it. I correct in that understanding in it sounds like you are also willing to maybe look at language that allows us to be more of a voluntary collaboration that if cities and municipalities need assistance that they can request it from FDOT. Is that right? Senator Avila, thank you, Mister Chair. Yes, that is correct. Any questions? Okay. Seeing none. We have a couple appearance cards for the Amendment. We have Jason Ongar with serve. Robotics is waiving in support. Thank you, sir. Thank you for being here. Mark Jeffries with Orange County. >> Welcome, Sir. You're recognized. Thank you. And I don't want to give an answer that you just heard. I don't want to belabor the point that we are a little concerned that that subsection 41 could become a the tow more or less. So glad to hear more can be working on that. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Senators. Any debate on the amendment, any debate seeing none. Senator silly. Recognize to close on your amendment. Now I waive close. Mister Chair. Okay. All in favor of the amendment say yea. Any oppose say Nay. Okay. Show the amendment adopted. We're back on the bill as amended any questions on the bill as amended seeing none. We have a couple appearance forms. We got Jeffrey Sharkey with ZIP line is waiving in support. We have got Steve Shell with Waymo is waiving in support. Abbeville with DoorDash waiving in support. David Allen with Uber Technologies waiving in support. Lorena Holley with Florida Retail Federation is waiving in support. Senators. We're in debate. We are in debate. Senator Smith in debate. >> Thank you, Mister Chair and thank you again, Senator Massullo for being so cooperative with me in your conversations and and with the committee a minute and a vote for the bill today. I just want to make sure that maybe we have the opportunity to tighten up this language because I think that this language maybe perhaps going either direction, it could go in the direction of being used as a tool by FDOT to how our local governments make sure that they're successful with their requests for federal dollars and their grant applications. But because it is so Fagan, maybe brought feel like it can also be used our or maybe even weaponized to perhaps a block a city or a jurisdiction from being able to seek federal dollars that they that they they want to seek. But for some reason, perhaps FDOT does not want them to seek those dollars. And so I just want to make sure that we have language that is really tight, that it's going to be something that actually helps municipalities. So thank you for being willing to to look at that language and consider that to make sure that this is a great Bill. Thank you. If Senator Smith, any further debate, Senator, you're recognized to close on your bill as amended. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair this package to actually advance improve transportation within our state, primarily by grasping new technologies in such a waste to keep them safe, provide more services for our citizens. And we'll continue to work on it. So we'll get as many people to be in favor of it as possible. But as in all things, you can't please everybody. But I ask for all of your favorable support today. >> Thank you, Senator. Still a great close. Please call the Roll on Senate on CS for CS Senate Bill. 1220. >> Senator Arrington Senator Avila, Senator Bernard Senator Bracy Davis Senator Grall senator Leek senator Martin. Yes, Senator Mayfield. Yes. McLean. Yes. Senator Smith. Yes. Senator. Truenow. Yes. Senator Wright vice-chair Polsky chair DiCeglie yes. >> By your vote Cs for CS Senate Bill 1220 is reported favorably. >> Thank you, Senator. Thank you. Committee. Have a great afternoon. You too. Senators. We're going to go on to tab number 5 which is Senate Bill 11, 12. That's my birthday on Labor Pool Act by Senator Garcia. Thank you. Chair Garcia, you are recognized to explain your Bill. Thank you, chair vice chair for allowing me to present this very good bill. >> In 1995, Florida passed the Labor Pool Act establishing standards of conduct for labor pools to guarantee the fair treatment of workers. The bill strengthens those protections. A current issue with the Labor Pool Act is that businesses often want to hire day labors permanently after a temporary assignments. But under existing law, labor pools can charge employers a reasonable placement fee later on. Sometimes thousands of dollars when hiring a worker full time. These fees discourage perhaps permanent hiring and limit job stability. Another concern is that while labor pools must register with the Department of State operate in Florida, there really is no additional oversight. This makes it difficult to hold bad actors accountable, allowing unregistered fly by night. They ripples 6 point workers leaving them unpaid and businesses exposed. My bill addresses these issues by prohibiting labor pools from charging placement fees. When the third-party employer highs hires a worker permanently removing barriers to full-time employment and promoting free market hiring. This also supports re-entry and public safety in particular for those that are exiting the correction system in particular like this bill, because it works a lot with people in general, especially the most vulnerable. Finally, the bill requires all the ripples operating in Florida to register annually with the Department of Commerce, encouraging accountability and ensuring labor pools comply with the provisions of the Labor Pool act. So respectfully and hopefully and I appreciate you, sir. These changes promote safer jobs, workplaces in a fair work market for Florida. And that is the bill. Thank you, Senator Garcia, any questions on the bill? Any questions on the bill? Okay, seeing no. We've got quite a few appearance forms here. We're going to start. >> With lets see we're going to Martha. Shaun King is waiving in support. Thank you for being here. Calvin Stewart waiving in support Dianne North is waiving in support. Donald the just waiving in support. I'm sorry if I screw up your last name, it's not on purpose. I promise. Kim Smith is waiving in support. Belinda Davis waiving in support. Christopher still law waiving in support. Andre Brown is waiving in support. Belinda Rittenberg is waiving in support. Rhys Howell is waiving in support. James E for kind. Junior is waiving in support. Richard Jones waiving in support Jennifer County waiving in support Lorraine Rendon, waiving in support. Fernando Rendon, waiving in support. Karen Woodall waiving in support with the Florida Center for Fiscal and Economic policy. Chantel Jackson waiving in support. Jessica, my Hari waiving in support Jody Shell waiving in support. And we've got Doctor Rich Templin with the Florida AFL C I O Dr. Come on up. All right. Thank you for being here. Waiving in support. We've got Jeanne tough it welcome. You're recognized. >> Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, senators. My name is Jean. Tough it on the policy lead to be on the bars. This is an association that represents thousands of labor for workers throughout Florida and was working construction, warehousing manufacturing, sanitation, light industrial facilities. We ask you to vote in favor of SB 1112, because this bill will have a positive impact on both Florida employers in Florida workers. The bill does 3 things for civil remedies, placement fees, Liverpool's hire workers and then contact them all to clients. If this highlights a worker wants to hire them directly. The labor pool charges what they call placement fees. A placement fees can cost employers more than $15,000 to higher minimum wage worker directly. If you go up to tens of thousands of dollars, one of our members was working at a local university doing janitorial work and his poor liked his work at the love. Those work at that, but they can hardened because a place with his we're too too expensive. It's a losing situation. Workers lose out on an opportunity to improve their situation and employers lose out on the opportunity to higher quality. Workers already has a labor shortage and employers need to be able to hire quality employees. But this restriction centers laws across this possible seconded. It will cause labor pools to register with the Department of Commerce people wake up before sunrise and go to where they think labor pool where they pick think living pools will be based. And then the on an Internet search got to take public transportation to get some labor pool and they arrived before 05:00AM to get in line to get a ticket for work. Sometimes they go to where they think the labor pool B and this cover the places moved or that it's out of business. If that's the case, set you back for the whole day because of their players. You too late to get a ticket at another labor pool. Our staff members for the list of every slave report in South Florida and 2 in 2024. by 2025. That went out to each of those reports to see there was still operating more than half are shut even on the Internet. It said that there are still operating week. Why registrations, normal business practice helps workers know where they can find work and where they can where they can go. They have a mission. Finally, the bill provides reasonable attorneys fees for room parties and the floor and they reflect the only avenue for enforcement is to private action. There isn't a state enforcement body. This will help lead. This will help workers find representation if there's a before that is engaging in illegal and anti-competitive part says formally elect and once again, because so many people who work at labor pools are formerly incarcerated. This bill will help improve public safety and law order, making sure people are able to provide for their families once they've done their time once they've done their time and pay that that aside, yes, you to vote in favor of SB 1112. >> Thank you so much. Thanks so much for being a great job today. Thank you. We got Mona Stafford is waiving in support. Jason Tache waiving in support Ginger bodily waiving in support. And Felicia Bruce is waiving in support. Okay. We've got cleanly. Blackford welcome, sir. Come on up. You're recognized. >> Thank you. I want to thank Senator Garcia for this bill. You all heard about a live report. I want to go deeper. Why this is so important to me and the organization warm with is beyond bars. It's because of this fact I've done many years in prison. I've now got out. I got 3 beautiful sons doing good kind of. And the problem is with me, I would like to help them, but now I can help them because of the placement fees. And when you go to these labor pool, sometimes you do get a ticket. What this hurts this family that I truly love, I can help them and I want to help them. I learned Christmas comes my poor little grandchildren. My sons and my sons are struggling trying to keep a roof over their head. But he can't because they're struggling. They can't get the Christmas gifts like these children deserve and their suppress like that. I would like to be able to step in and lift them up. But because of this held back, what this amendment would do this bill would do. It would actually help because in May saying get out of prison who want to try to do better with this is passed and that company wants to hire you. They got to pay that 10 of $14,000 placement fee. That's why they don't want to hire you that way. That's why you can't get health insurance on your family and the children. Ashley, me stop. I mean, I did wrong, but don't everybody deserve a second chance? That's why I'm asking you here today. Can you please help us or support us? Please have compassion. That's what I asked. That's why the today. Thank you, Miss Garcia. God bless you all. Thank you. God bless you. Thank you so much. Okay. We've got off rate Pitino. >> Thank you so much for being here. I want to thank everybody for filling out a card here today. I know some of you probably have about 15,000 other things that you rather do than them to be here. But your presence here I think is not lost. And we really appreciate you all taking time to do that. So we are in debate senators. We are in debate. Senator Bernard, you are recognized in debate. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think this is a great bill. Senator Garcia and I wanted to recognize ensued but his name March Aaron. Donald, just use. Thank you are ease. The reason why I want to recognize him is because he's sitting right there. This is his first >> time in Tallahassee and I met with him yesterday. And so he was so excited to be in Palm Beach to be here in Tallahassee. He's a constituent of mine in Palm Beach County works with palm trend. The MAGA mated transit Union back home. So just so happy that you're here. Donald, thank you. >> Thank you, Senator. I apologize for for pushing up your last name. Thank you for being here today. It says any other debate, the Senate race, you're recognized. >> Thank you so much, Mister Chair. I spoke on this on the last committee stop. And so I just want to reiterate or what I said. Then the gentleman said a doesn't everyone deserves a second chance. And the answer to that question is overwhelmingly, yes, everyone does, sir, deserve a second chance and you are not the product of your worst day. So thank you so much. Senator Garcia for reaffirming, especially our returning citizens that all they want to do is work. Thank you for this good bill and for the debate. >> Senator Co want to thank you directly from the chair here. You know, someone who has experience in in, you know, in a in a in a very blue collar industry in the trash industry, we'd have to go in and get temporary labor. And one of the greatest things that I experience in doing that was identifying a worker and then transitioning that individual to a full-time job with full-time benefits, having that ability to to live that dream with without any restrictions whatsoever in and many of them, you know, and that working for my family business for 20 plus years in folks do deserve a second chance. And so I saw and heard this bill in in center leaks committee a couple weeks ago. And the testimony was, you know, was extraordinary. So I I just want to thank you for being a champion for and for for the individuals, for Floridians that they need a champion. And we all know that you've got a lot of fighting you and I certainly appreciate you bringing this issue >> to this committee. So with that, you're recognized to close after that. I think I waive close. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Senator Garcia, please call the roll on Senate Bill. 1112. >> Senator. Arrington. Yes, Senator Avila. Yes, senator Bernard. Yes, senator Bracy Davis. Yes, senator grall. Yes, senator lake. Yes, senator Martin. Yes, senator Mayfield, yes, senator Klein, senator,Truenow vice-chair polsky. So chair DiCeglie yes. >> By your vote Senate Bill. 1112, is reported favorably. Congratulation that I thank you, senators. We're gonna go to tab number 2, I which is Senate bill to look at that tab. 2 Senate bill to come on on relief of the state of Daniel modestly by the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. Senator Jones, welcome. You are recognized to explain your Bill. Thank you so much chair. Good afternoon members. >> This claims Bill reflects a settlement agreement between a state of Daniel Mazzilli and the Department of Highway Safety Motor Vehicles. On 9/19/2011 Florida Highway Patrol arrested Daniel Mazzilli for 2 counts of leaving the scene of a crash with property damage and 2 counts of driving without a valid driver's license. After arriving at the station, the true percent MS Mazzilli down while completing in administrative paperwork at approximately 11. 45 this Mazzilli ran past. The trooper exited through the side door. The trooper chased herein, discharged his Taser 3 to 4 feet away from her body. This mazzilli feel backwards. Striking her head on the pavement ultimately never regain consciousness remain in a vegetative state on life support until passing on September 15th 2013, the Department of State settle the claim for 1.9 5 million dollars of the state sovereign immunity law. The department pay the estate the maximum allowable allotment of $200,000. But the rate will remain at 1.7 million dollar contingent upon legislative approval. And that is the bill, Mister Chair. Thank you, Senator Jones, any questions? >> Any questions seeing none. Any appearance forms, no appearance forms. Senators, any debate seeing no debate. Senator Jones, you're recognized to close wave close. Please call the roll on Senate bill 2. >> Senator Arrington. Yes, Senator Avila, Senator Bernard Senator Bracy Davis. Yes, senator Grall Senator Lake Senator Martin. Yes, Senator Mayfield, Senate McLean, Senator Smith. Senator,Truenow. Senator Wright vice-chair Polsky chair DiCeglie. >> Yes, by your vote. Senate Bill 2 is reported favorably. Shifting numbers. The Senate were to go on to tab number 8 Senate Bill. 1352. On motor vehicles by Senator Trumbull. Senator Trumbull, welcome. Thank you very much. You're recognized. >> They very much see Mr. Chair senators Senate Bill 13, 52 requires the DHS and the to establish a secure online portal for verifying recording and processing the seizures or confiscation of license plates provides that a disabled veteran retain the unique Alpha numeric designation assigned to the Dv license plate upon issuance, renew or transfer of the license plate. It prohibits the manufacture sale or use of license plate covers. Films were overlays and obscure or alter. The license plate requires DHS and the to remit to tax collector service fees for online transactions related to driver's license and identification card. Renewals and replacements and provides the driver's license and identification card. Renewals replacement ordered through the DHS and the online license and registration portal must be routed to the customers. Residents county for fulfillment by the appropriate tax collector. That's the bill. >> Thank you, Senator. Trumbull. Any questions on the bill, senators? Any questions seeing? None. We have one appearance form. God reminder with the Florida Tax Collectors Association is waiving in support. Thank you for being here. Senators. Any debate, Senator Lee recognized close on your bill. I waive close. Mister. Please call the Roll and Senate Bill 1352. >> Senator Arrington. Yes, Robin la. Yes. Senator Bernard Senator Bracy Davis. Yes, senator Grall senator leak. Yes, senator Martin. Yes, Senator Mayfield, senator Maclean. Yes, Senator Smith. Senator. Truenow. Senator Wright vice-chair Polsky. >> Fair to say yes by your vote. Senate Bill 1352. Is reported favorably. Thank you all. Thank you. Okay. Senators moving right along. We're going to go to tab number 6 Senate Bill 1192. On customer service. Call back use by our very own Senator Polsky Senator Polsky. You're recognized to explain your Bill. >> Thank you so much for hearing this bill. A customer service call back use will improve service and response time by our executive agencies through the creation of a pilot program for call back use under the pilot program. The Department of Commerce and the Department of Children and Families must use a telephone system for calls related to reemployment assistance and calls concerning public benefits and services respectively. Under the program, a customer will have the option to be placed in a call back you to receive a call at a later designated time while maintaining his or her place in line as opposed to waiting on hold Cosby return in the order in which they received. And by the end of the next business day, some agencies currently have implemented various Q Systems. This pilot program establish a measurable standard trusses Floridians who call meeting state Agency assistance the most this legislation strengthens the accessibility and time timeliness of our government services to Floridians will help achieve the consent. The standards set by the Florida Customer Service Standards Act and that is the bill. >> Thank you, Senator Polsky senators. Any questions, any questions on the bill seeing none. Any appearance forms. No appearance forms. Any debate senators, any debate, Senator Polsky you're recognized to close on your bill waived close. Having waived close, please call the roll on Senate Bill 1192. >> Senator Arrington. Yes. Senator Avila, Senator Bernard Senator Bracy Davis. S senator Grall. Yes, senator leak. Yes, senator Martin. Yes. Senator Mayfield, Senator McClain Senator Smith. Senator. Truenow. Yes. Senator Wright vice-chair Polsky chair DiCeglie yes. >> By your vote Senate Bill 1192 is reported favorably. Thank you. The centers would go on to tab number 3 Senate Bill. 26 on relief of the state of Mark Gotta by the Department of Transportation by Senator McClain senator clean. You're recognized to explain your Bill. >> Thank. Thank you, Mister Chairman and senators for allow me to present SB. 26 is a claims Bill provides 2.2 million dollars in relief to the state. Our club got of catastrophic injuries links linked to negligence by the Florida Department of Transportation. This special master found this found. This is an uncontested claim for 2.2 million arising from the settlement agreement concluded dot, negligence, negligence that led to the injuries. That is the bill, Mr. Chairman, thank you, Senator. Maclean. Any questions on the bill seeing none any appearance forms. No appearance forms any debate. >> Senator claim you're recognized to close on your bill late close. Having waived close, please call the roll and Senate bill. 26. >> Senator Arrington. Yes, Senator Avila, Senator Bernard Senator Bracy Davis. Now. Yes, that Senator Grall Senator Lake. Yes, senator Martin. Yes, Senator Mayfield. Yes. Senator McClain Senator Smith. Yes, senator now. Yes. Senator Wright vice-chair Polsky chair DiCeglie yes. >> By your vote Senate Bill. 26 is reported favorably. Thank you, senators. We're now going to go to tab number 4, which is Cs for Senate Bill 354. On blue ribbon projects by Senator McClain Senator Clay, you are recognized to explain your Bill. Thank you, Mister Chairman. >> Senators, this is a well. I I want to start out a little bit with by telling you that I used to be a county commissioner, but I don't want to be the person that every time I get up to present a bill I've and everybody else, County commissioner. But the so I have a little bit of have a little bit of expect because then you'll be like, you know, later, hey, where every time he says that we get you know, so we have to pay somebody or whatever it is. But anyway, I have a fair amount of experience with land use to fund. It's one of the thing I was on the county commission for 12 years. You have a you have a land use hearing one time a month for 12 years is 140 for those that and at a minimum that I sat through with multiple land uses presented at that time and also zoning hearings. I think I figured that one-time somewhere probably ran 1000 that I sat through an presided over. So I feel like I have some experience with this. And certainly one of that. That's why I kind of like work on it, I guess. But maybe I'm a glutton for punishment. But anyway, so current our current growth pattern, obviously we have we have a couple things going on. We have one where we have a lot of legacy. Lots. We have a lot of and it specially municipality's. You have places where we have in compatibility with one another. It's not anyone's fault. It's just that's kind of we didn't have any zoning at one time. Then we have a zoning. And now we have all these mixed use is together. So we have that and I work on those things. And and, you know, the thing that we're really looking at now is we're trying to figure out kind of where we're headed as the state as it relates to growth. We're going to continue to grow. And everybody knows that. I jokingly tell people that my family got here before statehood. So all the rest of the all moved here since then we've been on top of me. So, but and I was I didn't us about it. And but anyway, so we've been here a long time. And so the second thing we're having to really deal with is, you know, house, what's Florida going to look like? How's it going to grow? We know that our constituents of all said to us, we're concerned about the current way that we're growing. We're concerned that, you know, reading up a lot of farmland are, you know, agricultural, green space, whatever might be. And so one of the things that also too, the I'm gonna read you have this is Florida statute, 1, 6, 3, 1, 1, 6, 3, 3, 0.3, 1, 6, 8, and says the legislature recognize the need for innovative planning and development strategy strategies to promote a diverse economy by Brent Rural and urban communities while protecting environmentally sensitive areas. Legislature further recognize the substantial advantages of innovative approaches to development, directed to meet the needs of urban, rural and suburban uses. So the legislature see that it sees that. That's not to say we've had a cup over the years. We've done the rise up in Erie from with that. That's an old process that that was around probably 30, 40 years ago. Some big properties were were developed under the dei BRI program. Then more recently, we've had properties that had that have been done under what they call the sector sector plan process. And so I look at this blue ribbon projects to be in another innovative thought process as it relates to how we're going to develop. The biggest piece of this is that if a landowner wants to use this process, he has to agree to set aside 60% of the land that is going to do. It is 4 large properties as for properties that are 10,000 acres or more, those that's where you're you know, I'll be I'll be us Lee. The landowner could in stead of doing it this way he could do. Is that your plan? Dr? I didn't really exist anymore because we don't have a land planning agency in Florida say at the state level. But so he can do that or or if he wanted to than that, I could say, hey, I'm I'm I'm and set aside 60% of my land to be able to develop this in a pattern that makes sense that a lot of people actually agree with when we talk about master-planned communities and those types of things. So the blue ribbon projects Bill or SB 354, would it again. It is for properties that are over 10,000 acres. It does. If someone is willing to do that and let's bypass some of the local government approval process is and go around some of the comp plan issues for the set aside. And then it also requires makes requirement requirements on what the developer must provide as it relates to services. All services have to be spoken of. Our have to be Dan fight and then how it's going to be paid for those types of things. So that is the bill. I do have an amendment. >> Thank you, Senator Clay, for that. Appreciate that explanation. We do have an amendment so let's go to amendment bar code 6, 8, 6, 0, 9, e senator clean. You're recognized to explain your amendment. >> Thank. Thank you again, Mister Chairman senators, one of the big pieces of this is what so the applicant would actually make an application to. >> Department of Commerce, Florida, Department of Commerce, the commerce with then so that they will set up a time. We don't they do. Have we have I have had conversations, commerce of what that process would look like from a timing perspective. But one of the couple parts about it is it would so ago to comer's they would then distribute that to all state agencies. Most of them would be our land, you know, either a a water management district Department of Agriculture, probably department of State, anybody that would have possibly have an interest in a piece of land that either they've identified. That's something they may want to purchase at some time or they already own. And so what would that would then create a requirement that the set aside, that would be one of the places where you normally go ahead and set aside would be, hey, we're already been up against them that a state forest or maybe management district comes in and says, hey, we're a plant that was on our list, the property, the by already. And then all of that would have to be given a there's no payment for that. That is, again, to be given to the state currently under the under the Main Amendment. At our last stop, it would that the tax would become the holder of the title. And then there's also some language where they could then work with some of the other departments of one wanted to manage it or do something like that. So those are those are probably some of the biggest changes in the but what between the the bill and then the the the amendment? A couple of the things that we did an amendment to. We said, hey, there's here's some things that cannot be done on the property. One of them would be data centers. And then we also did a little bit of work on where what could take place in the reserve area. So we can spell that out. This bill is obviously a work in progress. And, you know, the more detail as as we work our way through it, we're trying to do more detail, more detail, more detail as I you know, as we take comments from all the stakeholders and that is the bill. Thank you, Senator. Clean. Any questions on the amendment? Okay. Seeing we got a couple appearance forms here. >> Erick Pool. So right, Florida Association of Counties. Good afternoon, Sir. You're recognized. Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Chairman again, Eric Pool, Florida Association of counties. We are on record as an opposition to the bill. But I do want to say there are good things and get provisions that are in it. And I do want to recognize and perhaps maybe the best part of the bill is the bill sponsor who has been talking to us for weeks and weeks and he never fails to pick up the phone. We call we talk to him a lot. So I appreciate that. But there's other provisions in the bill that that are good and positive. I do want to highlight those it. What's good about this is that it is as the bill sponsor indicated, it is for thinking is looking at Florida, not 10 years from now that 50 years from now and large areas of land. And so that is very important. And it also incorporates some smart growth principles talks about walkable communities. It talks about affordable housing. New urban isn't all that is is really important. We unequivocally support that. But where the bill takes a bit of a detour is where we have a problem and that is in the process. And the as the senator indicated there's an existing process. That's a lot that the legislature create about 25 years ago when that's the sector plan. And so I think that process gets us to the same point. But in a different way and Mr. Chair with your indulgence, I like to take just 2 minutes to walk the committee through the sector plan process and just compare that to the blue ribbon process. We have a you have some context understand kind of what our position is and that and so just some background, the sector plan process was actually pilot at about 25 years ago. It was designed to be a successor of the dri process. And the dri process was never meant to be permanent. It started in the late 1970's and it was designed to kind of bridge the gap until the 1985 Growth Management Act took effect. But it just kind of draw gone. But over time it became khaki, bureaucratic slow and nobody light. And it was finally eliminated in 2015, although you still have legacy dri projects that are out there. But now if you want to do it, dri size project, you just go through the regular comp plan process at the local level so that that's the background of that. And so the sector plan process, but designed to take place to the place of that and look at Florida from again, a long-range plan planning process 50 years at 50 years out, you would develop a framework for land use conservation region, least regionally, significant facilities. And so the process for this is really straightforward and it's done at 2 levels. The first level very similar to the blue ribbon plan is the submission. >> Of a long-term master plan. The long-term master plan, however, is submitted directly to the local government and it becomes an amendment to the comp plan. So that's the first level. Second level is the more detailed specific area plans that are called the sabsa so that the CEP implements the actual master plan that was adopted, that gets adopted into the comp plan. So at the first level, there's just 3 steps. The first step is the property owner submits the long-term master plan to the county. And it is a general framework of where land uses are going to take place over the 50 your time. Second, the county holds a transmittal hearing. It submits this to the State Department of Commerce for they do their their review once it's approved, rather, once the review is complete and it submitted back to the county, the county has and adoption hearing and that adoption hearing basically incorporates that long-term master plan into the comprehensive plan. So it is integrated into the existing policy framework that the county already has. So it's basically 3 steps level. One level 2 is where the actual development takes place. That's the the steps. Details, specific area plants. These are not amendments to the comp plan. These are basically development orders. And so if you've got 10,000 acres dissent, number one, they come in and say we want to develop 1000 acres of this over the next 10 years. And this is where we want to locate different types of development in there. And so at that time, you're looking at specific things like currency, water, distribution of of the transportation transportation network, and that sort of thing that is basically how the existing sector plan works. And you may have actually several the steps over time. One of the more successful sector plans are over to the west of us in Bay County. It's the Bay County now is the Bay County Walton, West Bay sector plan over 100,000 acres. And I think they're up to like it or 90 sat at this point. The first the 7 actually was allow for the location of the Panama City International Airport. And so that is a very successful project that is managed by the Saint Joe Development Company. Blue Ribbon does incorporate some of the provisions that are in the sector plan as the bill sponsor mentioned. But the process isn't as inverted and that's not necessarily bad. So he's rather the blue ribbon plan starts with the Department of Commerce and that might not be a bad approach. If it's approved by the state, then it comes down to the county. The county has 15 days to initiate. It's a preview. It has to have a public workshop not hearing within 30 days. Then it has 60 days to approve or deny the project. However, here's a point. The project does not come before the county commission. The project is administratively approved, which is not necessarily defined in the bill, but it just says administratively approved. And as as Senator McClain indicated, if approved, the blue ribbon is recorded with the county clerk and then titled Ones with The Land. And so that's all it takes place for 10,000 acres. So, again, there's there's as proposed there's no review or approval by the board of County Commissioners. And I'll note that any other land use Amendment, the council for the county does have to go before the board and get adopted. The bill also creates a separate overlay within the county's comp plan which per the bill states that the county comp plan must adhere to the blue ribbon plant. And this is an interesting distinction. In other words, as written, it appears that the county comprehensive plan must not be inconsistent, but the blue ribbon plan, which is the complete opposite of how the current law operates. In other words, if you come in for a land use amendment the cat, you have to be consistent with the comprehensive plan or at least make a consensus if it and then last there's no requirement for a detail specific develop land 30 SEP or other implementation provisions. The blueprint just kind of sits out there and we're not really sure how it moves forward. Now, I say all that simply for information purposes. So the committee understands our current position on this. I indicated Senator McClain talks to us we've been working with this is a very complicated issue. We stand committed to continue working with him. I was trying to thread a very difficult Beetle, but we just think that the existing sector plant sector planning process is the perfect framework where to begin. If we need to adjust that over time, we're more than happy to do that. And so with that, Mister, thank you for the indulgence of I'm gonna answer any questions. Janet Reno, you're recognized for question. >> You mentioned that all other developments have to go in for the county commission for a vote. >> Yeah, I I sense all my that if it's if it is a large scale plan Amendment. >> Land use plan amendment. It would have to go before the portico. There are there are functions that developments can be approved through absolute ministry to new. Can you list a few of those? Well, if it it's up to the it's up to the the local government, if they have a certain scale that does not need to, for example, here and Leon County, I think anything that's below a certain bridge, 10 acres, 20 acres. It can be administratively approved like a rule settlement. I like under 200 homes. I don't I would know what that is here, but it it varies. But there are to you. Yes, sir. Thank you. You're correct. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony to shed. >> Okay. Next up, we've got Anna Grace DePaulo Florida chapter of the American Planning Association. Welcome. You're recognized. >> Thank you, chair. Thank you. Committee members. I actually I'm here on behalf of the plane association to say thank you to the sponsor for all the work that went into this amendment today. We know he had a lot of feedback from us and we see it in places and we know this is a great step in the right direction. We will continue to work with him on some of the details that you just heard. And so thank you very much. >> Thank you for being here. Can actually we've got Bradley. Hearty welcome, sir. You're recognized. >> Chair members for allowing me to speak. This amendment was supposed to fix the bill, but it didn't. The original version require developers to go through local governments first and then this amendment flips it like the gentleman saying developer goes Department, commerce first get state approval, then goes a local government. But there's no precedent for this. In Florida Law, Department of Commerce reviews, local government, comprehensive plan amendments, but it is never approve. Private development applications is not what it does. That's not what his staff for and that's not what it's designed for. And timelines. 45 days to review a 10,000 acre development or it's automatically approved. Miss the seven-day final determination window. Automatic approval, Dr. I review under Chapter 3.80, which is the closest thing we've ever had to this. It took months given the commerce less time to review the largest class of development project in Florida. Then it takes to process routine permitting. And after Commerce approves, local government gets a checklist review, no discretion, no public hearing that changes anything the decision has already made here in Tallahassee. This amendment didn't fix a bill that took the same preemption at a rubber stamp with an automatic approval trap because they're fun. 50 years of land use law runs in one direction. The state reviews what local governments decide. This amendment runs it backwards. The state decides and the local government gets to watch. It's not a fix it some more sophisticated version of the same problem. Vote no on the amendment and vote no on the bill. Thank you. >> Senators any questions on the men were still on the Amendment. We're gonna Senator McClain. You're recognized to close on your amendment all in favor of the amendment say yea, yea, any opposed say Nay. Okay. Show the amendment adopted centers. We're back on the bill as amended any questions on the bill as amended Senator Smith. >> Thank you, Mister Chair and thank you, Senator McClain for being really thoughtful, especially on the amendment that just passed through. I'm just trying to understand the the basic bottom line impact. Senator McLean, if this bill were to pass on what the role of local government really will be. A lot of a lot of what we heard from members of the public was very helpful, but it was all it was also very technical. I actually do have it as much local government experience by far as you do, Senator McClain. So I respect and appreciate that. The question is, as long as the the Blue Ribbon project meets the criteria in your bill, what role does the local government have in approving and aren't that? Aren't they just rubber stamping enemy? They really don't have the ability to to stop it. Is that correct? Senator Clinton. >> Thank. Thank you, Mister Chairman, thank you for that question as well. One of the things that I think so their role would be to ensure that all of the services that need that that that this would. >> All the services that would be needed or prefer that would need to be provided for this development would have to be done up front. The local government would have that. That is the role that they would play is making sure that water and sewer is available. Roads are available to conservation easements available. They also would have to say so in the in the phase development as the development phases they would have they would have control over that as well. Thank you, Smith. Thank permission for follow-up. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Maclean. >> Yes, I appreciate that. But they still this is not at a situation where they can disapprove and application to to develop the land under a blue ribbon project. They still don't have a choice. Is that correct? As long as they meet the criteria, there's there's effectively no real decision role and whether to allow a blue ribbon project to exist in their community under this bill is on that they meet the criteria. Senator, think that would be that. That is correct them. And again, the reason for that is they're giving up 60% of their property. They have to give up 60% of their land before this could be can sit. They even be considered. That has to be on the front side. Thank you. Permission for a follow-up. Senator Smith, thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Senator McClain and the public input part is a public hearing allowed under your bill for a blue ribbon project development like is that something that local governments can still have like? What is that opportunity for for public input? >> Mclean, thank thank you, chairman. As currently written, there is not a public hearing as such the one that you would normally have. There is a public workshop that would be done where the and at that point, the the local government can decide whether or not to have public comment at a workshop currently at some of our workshops that we used to have. We would allow public comment. We might not allow public comments depend on what we were doing. But so they could have public comment workshop. It doesn't we don't woods. It's somewhat silent to that. Thank you. Permission for follow-up. Mister Chair, Senator Smith, thank you. I'm also curious about the ratio. So I understand. >> For a blue ribbon project to meet the criteria, 60% of the project acreage, I would be conservation and 40% would be available to be developed as part of the 60%. I'm wondering how how much of that 60% is is meaningfully conservation land. And what I mean by that is I couldn't develop or simply just set aside wetlands that couldn't be developed anyway and drop a lot of disconnected parks and pockets of Parkland that really would provide little environmental value and and count that towards the 60% threshold. >> Senator Clay, thank you, Mister Chairman. There's some other language in here that does talk about connect ability of those types of what I would call recreation area. So there there is that discussion and there may be back to you to the other part of your question. Again, one of the reasons that we want to commerce to be able to look at first so that they could reach out to the other agencies and get that list of properties that they have so that we would know that those are automatically properties that would be set aside. There is a difference of opinion on conservation. What what what does that look like? When I visited with my good friend that Audubon, we've had these conversations before about, you know, because they did. So there is a converse. Then that conversation. Can things take place? What does that look like? I personally think that anyway, that's owned by the state should be able to be used by the citizens of the state. And so it's hard for me just to say, like you could never no one could ever have a walking. You couldn't you couldn't some state forest only allowed walking in there, some state forest that allow for some other things, local governments, we have different parts and things that we allow. So, but certainly, you know, trying to make sure that whatever is in Cannes, you know, whatever is in conservation is is doing it. It, you know, is in conservation. But I have a little bit of a difference of opinion. Are we talking preservation or council? That preservation is you put it in jars that on the shelf and everybody can see it. Conservation is we can serve it for generations to come. And so that's that's my difference of opinion. Sure. Thank you. Permission for follow-up. Mister Chair Smith. Thank you, Senator McClain for walking me through that. I'm trying to understand and I apologize if you maybe address some of this in your intro and maybe I didn't. I missed it. I'm trying to understand what problem we're trying to solve because we do have a we do have current system right now specifically in comprehensive process. >> For how locals >> can approve the development of a 5,000 plus acre property. That's a system that currently works. And the reason I say it works is because, you know, there have been several that have been approved under that current process that we've had, which suggests that it's something that still functions and doesn't really have any real problems with that. Can you address? I guess the question that I have about what problem we're trying to solve and what the what the issue is with the current process that needs to be changed that justifies this dramatic change. Senator McClain, thank you, Mister Chairman. Again, it goes back to the 60% requirement on the front side. None of those the sector plan, the dri. None of those required any type of setback. >> But you could be negotiated with the local government could be negotiated. You run into a very difficult place when you start talking about property rights and then talking about taking because you any to any time you say to a developer, hey, I want you to give me this. You tread you tread on to then on the property, right? And so it's a very so that that's for me. This piece is a is an automatic 60% upfront. And so that's what sets it apart. That's what makes it different. We can't continue to allow large prop I trading property, right? Right. The challenges they could sell this 1000 acres at a time and develop in in some pattern that's probably not is not near is compact are as good as something you can get with the master planned community. Okay. Any other question. Senator Bracy Davis. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair, thank you to the bill sponsor for the preface about you being commissioner. Are that helps? I I'm as I'm reading this. So I've got and dozens of calls about this bill and for the quiet part out loud, I'm nowhere near a subject matter expert in planning or any of that. So. >> I was trying to read and learn at the same time. I think Senator Smith kind of hit on it. But I want to ask this question in a way that perhaps I understand the answer, what protections, if any, remain for communities who believe project is inappropriate for their area, senator, that this bill contemplate any protections for those communities. >> Senator Point, thank you, Mister Chairman. There is a section the line to 300 somewhere around there. If they community thought that this was not didn't qualify, there is a legal process for them to go dance. It's actually and it's actually a different process than what you normally with that what it local government would have to go through to challenge something like this. There is a different legal process. Senator Grall for question. Oh, I'm sorry. Senator Bernard, thank you, Mr. Chair McClain, thanks for bringing this bill. >> In regards to the public safety aspect of how does the the State Department of Commerce will take a look at how do you do with police and fire that would be and in a different county Senator Clinton. >> I'm sorry, Senator Bernard, but fire in any of those services would be required by the by the developer to to be laid out before the plan could become part of, you know, as a development order, whatever they would have to there would have to be some discussion with the local government, how they're gonna provide, who's going provide that service, how it's going to be provided provided. I try to be careful about not using names of developments. There's a large wind down in central Florida. They provide all of their fire rescue. They provide they provide all of their own police and all that in the development itself. So they they pretty much pay for all that. So follow, Mr, recognized. So does that mean that they would do they work with the municipality or the counties in regards to >> figure out who's going to provide public safety? Because I know they're going straight to department of Commerce. But when do they have that communications? >> With the local government. >> Senator, thank you, chair. That would be when it comes back to the local government from commerce, so commerce and send it back. All those details. Those are all the details that the counties would be involved in as they as they work their way through that I could, you know, again, back in from from the one that I'm really from a with because it's part of its and the county came from they they prove they provide I misspoke. They provide fire service. We provided the share provided a law enforcement to them. Obviously there they have ad valorem tax that they pay no on the properties on those types of things. But they did. They did set up their own fire rescue, actually rescue to not just fire but written rescue as well. We have mutual aid agreement. We you know, we have mutual aid agreements with them from our county to to that to that development. So if >> if there's mutual aid agreement, but these are all done administratively, how with the Board of Commissioners approve some of that if it goes administratively and never goes to the board? >> Senator, thank thank you, chair. Most of that's done somewhat up in a stray to be, you know, in other words, unless there was a cost to, you know, there's a 30 can't if they're taking care of all the cost, there's really the only issue for us. That's not an issue to local government them because they're covering the entire cost that but rescue fire rescue probably more so than anything. Then a law enforcement. Obviously there's in Marion County. We have an immense to you for law enforcement. So all all properties are part of that MS to you. And so then they would they would be can't cover their own costs in this to you, those. But those agreements would be would come to a county commission at a county commission meeting after the administration had put the details together. >> And in regards to the timelines, can you go over the timeline to the guards from the for the BCC to be of? Well, not to be CCS administratively. I was the time frame for them to approve that potential project. >> I would actually have to look at the bill. I I don't they're not on top of my head, but >> and I might we might not set of time. I'd have to I'd look, I'd be glad to do it. I mean, it just yet. I just think that just we have to make sure that we're giving the that means file. These are the counties, the opportunity and the time frame to be able to review it. And my last question is in regards to the the site that Eric pull mention, is this being addressed in this bill or is there going to be a time frame for because these are projects that are potentially 50 years down the road? So when do they submit like that first the side to potentially they submitted to the part of commerce or that they submitted to the local government that would be to the local government again during that period of time when they're talking about he's going to do fire rescue is going to provide law enforcement is going to do is build roads, all those types of things. And so all that would be done at the same at the same time. >> Just to make sure I understand. But they may not be doing. They may do like 5 different. The sabsa cute. And so are they going to the part of commerce to to do the first one or is it? >> A local government wants it comes down from commerce. Then it all goes to shift to the local government. For all of that for all of those details to be worked out to agree to, if you will, are worked out. >> Would all of the the SOP said say there's like 5 different aesop's that's got to be done 10, 20, 50 year period. Would they still would be administratively done and not to the board of County commissioners. Any further question are written questions. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good afternoon. Senator McClain, thank you for a conversation yesterday and even continuing today on this. I do have a few more questions, though, and appreciate the amendment think that it makes a lot of changes. But one of the changes, the question on is that the original bill said that the project had to be in a location that's accessible to an interstate interchange or state road. But the amendment now says it can be 60 miles away from like a major highway or airport. Why the change? And are we worried about new developments 60 miles away from a road? >> Senator, during 10, I didn

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Appropriations Committee on Transportation, Tourism, and Economic Development — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 88e8ac46d5d844b1a464ed7155f63573. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record