POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Community Affairs — Closed Captions

Tuesday, January 20, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Community Affairs — Closed Captions

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Transcript or captions textCommunity Affairs — Closed Captions

>> Here's will now come to order a few. Stay with me for the played on. I'm sorry, Elizabeth. Please call the roll. >> Proper Chair McClain here for Vice chair Massullo hear Senator Jones senator leak here. Senator Passadomo here. Senator Pizzo, you're Senator Sharif here, Senator Trumbull. >> A quorum is present or thank you note, please stand for with the pump lately. What legislative lag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >> Thank you. Please. Silence all of your electronic devices. Anyone wishing to speak before the committee should complete an appearance form and hand it to a member of the sergeants office. Should you select to waive your speaking time? Your position will be included in the committee meeting records and we're going to move to Senators Dist. We're going to move to tab, too. That will be SB 16 relief of your mayor. Do Sanchez Miami by the city of St. Petersburg by Senator Rouson Senator Rouson. You're recognized to explain your bill to make it's the chairman. >> Thank you all committee for hearing this bill Senate Bill 16. He's an uncontested local claim Bill against the city of Saint Peter's poor, Mr. Sanchez, my and was asleep in a daytime only park around 10:00AM therefore he was lawfully there. But he was unlawfully arrested and even though he was compliant the entire time, they handcuffed him chain them and shackled him and put him on restrained in the back seat of the van when the van stopped suddenly short and a red light. His head when commuting into the bulkhead suffering catastrophic injuries. When they arrived at the booking facility, he was still unconscious. But instead of seeking medical attention for him, they dragged him out of the van, hitting the floor of the van and committee to see Mitt floor when they sought medical attention he required. I'm sorry. He sustained catastrophic injuries including fractures requiring double above the knee leg. Amputations rendering him an incomplete quadriplegic. He'll need medical in full-time home care for the rest of us live. The city of St. Petersburg agreed to settle for 2.5 million. The special master held a hearing on this matter and report the case favorably and that's the bill. >> Thank you, senators. Are there questions on the bill questions know are there appearance forms on the bill? There is one then very the waves waves in some pointing in support. Thank you that those are all of the appearance forms that we have. Is there any debate on the bill the senator is on. You are recognized to close on your bill. Waive close. Thank you, Elizabeth. Please call the role on SB 16. >> Senator Jones, senator leak. Yes, senator passadomo. Yes. Senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes, senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote. Sb 16 is reported favorably. Thank you very much, sir. Thank you, senators. Now we'll move to tab one and this will be SP 14 on the release relief of Jose Correra by Miami, Dade County by Senator Rodriguez. Senator Rodriguez, you're recognized to explain your Bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman vice chair and members of this committee SB 14 is a settled claims Bill for the relief of hosts. A cold air for injury sustained due to the negligence of Miami-Dade County, Mr. Correa was lawfully crossing Southwest 40th Street, also known as Bird Road and the intersection with an issue on the road. The Miami-Dade bus driver failed to observe, Mr. Correa and though crosswalk. Well, making a left turn causing a collision. Miami-dade County has admitted fault in the incident and settled with Mr Care without a trial. This claims Bill is for 4.1 million dollars in the supported by both the claimant and Miami-Dade County and that is the bill. >> Thank you. Are there questions on the bill? No questions. No appearance forms. Is there debate on the bill? No debate. Senator Audrey Riggins, you're recognize close on the bill. I ask for your favorable support. Thank you, Elizabeth. Please call the role on SB 14. >> Senator Jones, senator week. Yes, senator Passidomo senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull, vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote SB 14 is reported favorably. Now we'll move on to tab a 3 and that is an a the tab. 3 this center Rodriguez is presenting for Senator Gruters graders. Relief of Lori's looked or and never looked or by of Miami-Dade County. Senator Rodriguez, you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair vice chair members of this committee. This is an uncontested claims bill for local funds in the amount of $500,000 payable from an incumbent funds of Miami-Dade County. That based on a settlement agreement between Florida's and Edward, the tour and Miami-Dade County, the settlement agreement resolve the civil action that arose from the alleging negligence of the county that caused injuries to nor does the tour and her husband Edward the tour. And that is the bill other questions on the bill. >> Kush rules. There are no appearance forms. Is there any debate on the bill? There's not. Senator Rodriguez, you're recognized to close on the bill. I ask for everyone's favorable support. Lizbeth. Please call the role on SB Full 24. >> Senator Jones, senator leak. Yes, senator Passadomo this senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote SB 24 is reported favorably and now we will move to Tab 5 SB 288 on rural electric cooperatives by Senator Rodriguez. Senator Rodriguez, you're recognized to explain the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman vice chair members of this committee and to cooperate to serve approximately 2.7 million Floridians in 57 counties and must balance growing electricity needs with affordability and reliability. >> Recent statutory language intended to protect consumers has created ambiguity that could be used to Challenge Corp decisions on generation power purchases. Demand response and efficiency programs. Stakeholders across the sector agree the ambiguity is unintended and risk disrupting normal Court operations SB 288 narrows the statue to remove that unintended exposure while preserving poor consumer protections, including fair construction charges and prohibitions on discriminatory fees. The bill is a negotiated glitch bill agreed to by stakeholders that protects korbe's authority to choose generation and power purchase power based on cost and reliability and prevent a special interest lawsuits aimed at banning few resources and reduces the risk of costly delays to new generation projects. And that is the bill. >> Are there questions on the bill? The questions? No, there there are appearance forms. Daniel Daniel Malone, I believe is that right thing I'm alone is waiving in support. Craig Belcher is waiving in support Dru Love, waives in support. Those are all of that's everyone that was signed to speak. Is there any debate on the bill? Any debate debate? Senator Rodriguez, you're recognized close on your bill time. Yes, for everyone's favorable support today. Thank you, Elizabeth. Please call the role on SB 288. >> Senator Jones, senator leak. Yes, senator passidomo senator Pizzo Senator Sharif yet Senator Trumbull, vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote. Sb 288, is reported favorably. Thank you all. Now we will move to tab 8 Senator Leak SB 830, on public records. County administrators in Sunday city managers by Senator Lee. Senator Lee, you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman, this bill creates a public records exemption for the home address, telephone number date of birth for county administrators, deputy administrator Assistant County administrator city managers, deputy city managers and assistant city managers, as well as the names and telephone numbers in place of employment or their spouses and the names and addresses of the schools and daycares attended by their children didn't November 2021. Report by the National League of Cities found that out of 112 local public officials surveyed 81% of city managers reported increased threats and acts of violence was such an session. The Legislature passed SB 268 which exempts the very same the personal identifying information from records for the elected officials. This would extend that protection to the managers and assistant city managers. This bill supported by the League of Cities and the Association of counties that is about are there questions on the bill? >> Any questions? No, there are appearance forms. Same Wagner, a way speaking in support and Courtney movie Wave speaking in support. Thank you. Those are all the appearance forms that we have. Is there any debate on the bill? There's not Senator Lee. You're recognized to close on the bill. I waive close. Elizabeth, please call the role on SB 830. >> Senator Jones, Senator Lee. Yes, senator passidomo senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote SB 830, is reported favorably. Now we will move to tab. 9 was tabbed as be 11. 38 on qualified contractors by Senator Missy like Senator Massullo. You're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair in our ongoing effort to make Fuller them more Affordable SB 1138. Empowers local government by increasing there capacity to evaluate preapproval plats by October. 1st 2026 local government shower stab wish maintain a registry of license conflict. Free professionals who may conduct pre application review and certify compliance. This bill creates a model to address delays, staffing shortages and backlogs in local government development review. It aims to enhance certain speed for development and without weakening safety and professional standards. It specifies only license engineers, architects and surveyors and certified plan. It can perform the review. And if a review falls within the scope of their license or certification, governments may not impose subject barriers are other types of experiences such as location or prior government working evaluating the contractors for approval to the registry. It also allows local government establishing a registry of qualified contractors with a minimum of 6 for larger areas and 3 for smaller jurisdictions under 10,000 people and it authorizes local government to review and did they the conduct of the contractors using a uniform compliance without their land development code. It protects local governments and the qualified contractors from liability. When performing reviews under the alternative review process. It provides clarification relating to multi-phase projects for pre-planned approval process, which was approved by the Legislature during the 2024 session. In SB 8, it expressly preempts local ordinances or policies that are duplicative or more stringent than state law. If a local government fails to him in a moment, such a requirement for the applicants, they may use private providers to obtain up to 75% of the building permits free from local conditions or delays. And it also can shorten the administrative cost of local government for the registries in the long term benefits should include a decrease workload faster approvals in economic gains for both the development and the housing sector. And that is the bill. This bill is very descriptive and per scripted as well. And I don't know how you all do when you're looking at bills. But when I try to look at Bill based on the preamble and if I know they don't talk, but if blue else could talk, they wouldn't have enough lung capacity to be able to say this preamble in one sentence. But I can tell you that this bill has a lot of features that will really help local government as well as the applicants in improving their processees. And we're working with local governments to try to handle their issues and that is the bill. >> Thank you for the explanation. Other questions on the bill. One of many. >> Thank you, chair and members of the committee. According to the Florida Association counties. I'm testifying for information only. I want to thank Senator Massullo for working with us to work on our concerns and we understand the purpose of creating a qualified contractor program in registry as a way to supplement review capacity and improve coordination between applicants and local governments. And we are committed to working with the senator and the stakeholders to flush out any concerns that we have throughout the bill. Thank you. >> The crew you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Good afternoon. Committee members, David Cruz on behalf of the Florida League of Cities. >> Let me start off my comments by thanking the sponsor of the bill for his on an ongoing dialogue related to our concerns to the bill. Really appreciative of the conversation we started. We hope to continue that dialogue to address some of the concerns as the bill moved through the process just for the benefit of the committee members really high level. One of the biggest concerns we have with the bill deals with what type of authority we're delegating to the qualified contractors and of the bill when they are reviewing land development applications. On one hand, we have what is known as ministerial authority. That's when we have a very black and white regulation and we apply that standard. And essentially there cannot be anything but the ability to deny or approve it. On the other hand, we have what's called discretionary authority. And that's when the legislative action such as a quasi judicial proceeding takes place. And that's where there's discretionary authority that's being exercised and and are quasi-judicial. We would have example such as rezoning special exemptions and variances. We want to make sure as the bill moves through the process that the qualified contractors just dealing with the decision and authority related to ministerial authority and that we preserve all of the legal requirements that go along with quasi judicial proceedings to the legislative body, the city commissioners or they're appropriate Ford's as it relates to development approvals. And so that's the high-level concern we hope to work on. And we really appreciate the senator's agreement to try to work with us and trying to address those concerns as the bill moves through the process. Thank you, Mr. Chairman Kerry bank. >> Others waving in support. Thank you, Lisa Miller waiving in support. I want to quickly share you're recognized. >> Sabmiller represent a private provider association of Florida. Just wanted to quickly. Thank the senator, obviously for this good Bill. This little registry to a list of private providers will be very helpful. As you heard the sponsors say, most importantly, remember, this private providers have the same license as government building officials to take the same test through overseen by the same body. They have the same responsibility to make sure that buildings are safe and that the public is safe in this building. So just want to make sure that, you know, that they're on equal footing and we applaud this Bill. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Paul Hamm, their home on waiving in support. Thank you. Thank you. There's all the parents forms that we have. Is there any debate on the bill rep Senator Sharif, you're recognized. >> Thank you. I spoke to Senator Mosul about this already. But the preemption for our local government was really what our concern was in terms of making sure that we were taking their authority away and during the part permitting planning and zoning process. And so because I received calls from my district and from my people that I represent, I was just want to let you know, that was why I mean right now. And I know you said you were willing to work with them to try to get to some agreement so that they felt protected in the process. And I just want to say I appreciate your willingness to work through that. And I'm looking forward to supporting this at a later time. But today, you know, I know in late. >> Senator Massullo, you're recognized to close on the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. And as we all know, words matter and sometimes we have to massage those words and get them to be the point that we're trying to make. This particular bill just is all about making our process more efficient and effective saving money for both our taxpayers and the people that are moving into our state as well as facilitating affordable housing. It will not interfere with any quasi judicial practices. It doesn't touch time frames at all as far as approval and approve or the Nile of plats will still rests with local government. And with that, I ask for your favorable support. >> The please call the 11 38. >> Senator Jones senator leak. Yes, senator passidomo senator Pizzo Senator Sharif know Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By about 11, 38 reported they believe that we need to have. >> By your vote SB 1138. Is reported favorably. Now we move to Tab for SB 168 on public nuisances by Senator Tree. Now, Senator, now you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you, chair and members of the committee, Senate Bills, one 68 public nuisance members, this body and then a lot of good work over the years in the in limiting the legal gamely activities. However, these gambling houses persist in this bill is an effort to continue the crackdown SB 168. Does a few things. It expands the definition of public nuisance to and gamely houses to list of properties that can be declared public nuisance. It also updates the penalty of after one year from $250 to $500 per day. Fine. It allows it also allows for the award of attorneys fees and meaningful legal support during the investigation in the hearing process. Finally, the bill authorizes an abatement board, too foreclose on the unpaid fees. And that is the bill other questions on the bill. >> Any questions? No questions. There is appearance forms Aaron DiPietro waives in support. Sam, why they're waiving in support. >> A Lieutenant Michael Crabb. It's cracked Graeme Graham, Graham. Yeah. We don't like Rahm waives in support easier. The that has all the appearance forms that we have. Is there any debate on the bill? Sorry I had that. I could prove. Yeah. I want to make sure that was right. Any debate and no debate. Senator, now you're recognized to close on your bill. Waive close Lizbeth. Please call the role on SB 168. >> Senator Jones, senator leak. Yes, senator passadomo senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote SB 168. Is reported favorably. Now I am going to pass the virtual gavel to my vice chair Senator Massullo and I'm gonna for Senate Bill. >> Thank you. Mister Chair will take up Tab 7 SB 686 the on controversial topic of agriculture enclaves. Senator McClain, you're recognized to explain your bill. >> And the thank you, Mister. Thank you, Mr. Chairman home senators, most of you saw this bill last year, and that created quite a quite some controversy. We continue to work on it all the way through session, obviously taking lots of comments from stakeholders and and other folks that were interested. I had it. It was part of a nother bill. Then there are other provisions in the bill that felt like certainly needed to get past last year's last trip. This piece out, but I'm bringing a bag. >> And it isn't it. The it is. And it's not a new bill in the sense of of the process of the thought process. But I think it is. I think that >> the language that we have in here has been agreed to and has been massage to thoroughly. And so this will make the SB 686. Will make revisions that agricultural enclave statute, which was originally enacted in 2005. The legislation provides necessary updates to the existing agriculture on county enclave section agricultural enclaves, a parcel that are surrounded by the existing development and only apply to unincorporated lambs. Agricultural property surrounded by development previously approved by the county are unable to utilize the highest and best use of their property of a county refuses to change the underlying land. Use the revisions, create a streamlined public hearing process allowing for local input and a public negotiation process between the landowner in the county when applying for a development permit currently under current law on the current enclave law, the negotiation process takes place between the landowner and staff and if they cannot come to an agreement 180 days, that is then automatically sent to the state to be approved by the state Land planning agency, which technically kind of doesn't exist anymore. But so anyway, so that's the current law would allow for that projects approved. And the public hearing process must be with an are butting in their vision service area must have existing public services available, water, wastewater transportation schools and recreation facilities and such public services could be provided in a manner that meets concurrency rules. It's limited to residential only even if it were surrounded by some other higher use. It would. This is for residential only. It does have some limitations on it would the sunset in January 1st of 2020 state and that is the bill. >> We're getting questions on the bill members questions on the bill. All right. I believe you have an amendment. I I do. You can take up Amendment bar code 1, 8, 4, 3, 8, 0, Thank you, Mr. Chairman. >> Senators we just needed to make a date change. We changed a 6/30/2026. 0, and that was the amendment. Any questions on the amendment? Do we have any appearance cards on the amendment? Is there any debate on the amendment? Senator McLean, human close on that wave close, having waived closed all in favor say yea, yea, those nay will show that amendment adopted. Now we are on the bill as amended any appearance cards on the bill. All right. Neal Fleck, Ken Stein, you're recognized from Tall Timbers. Nice to have you, sir. >> Yeah, why don't you? Thank you. >> Appreciate any focus on agricultural lands were fertile Timbers research Station and Land Conservancy. We've got about 170,000 acres of working or lands under conservation easement in North Florida and southwest Georgia. We span portions of both states there. Our focus is on working, agricultural lands, ranch, land farmland, forest land. We still do have a couple of concerns about the impacts of this bill on those agricultural lands in particular is the concern about undermining local planning efforts by requiring that local governments treat AG enclave developments as if they were conforming uses regardless of what those local comprehensive plans or zoning regulations stipulate, we work really closely with local governments and their comprehensive plans. They spent a lot of time and in the areas that I work and they're very focused on trying to protect those those ag lands and rural working lands that put a lot of effort into those those comp plans. And this would really, I think, undermine those local planning efforts. And that's also concern that undermines local decision-making by prohibiting quasi judicial review of developments in agricultural enclaves. Again, that does undermine that local decision making and finally undermines public participation by not allowing local governments to require public hearings for developments in those ag enclaves. I know a lot of the folks that we work with in those rural areas, they do like an opportunity to comment and participate in the decision-making process. And then finally, just one last, I guess the item to mention is just we're doing a great job, I think, of working on the Florida wildlife corridor, trying to protect the lands in that area. And we would have a concern about impacting rural ag lands inside in terms of being inside the wildlife quarter and having those qualify as has agricultural on claims. Thank you very much for your time. Appreciate it. Thank you, sir. Next up, we have a well, Daniel Martinez. >> He is Americans for Prosperity waives in support. Kim Duncan said 1000 friends of Florida waves against the bill. And that's good. We are in debate debate on the bill and the debate on the bill members. Senator Sharif, you're recognized in debate. >> I just wanted to say that in speaking with Senator McLean, I know you have a way of blowing up my mailbox or with e-mails. And I appreciate that. You know, I've enjoyed working with you and I appreciate all those midnight, you know, hours that work because of you foot. >> I just want to say thank you. But I think that a whole $29,000 that are and just tonight with your e-mails. But I just wanted to. >> The make sure that I put out there that I really appreciated the willingness to work with the Florida Association of counties. You know, I'm very involved with that organization and with all the representatives in my district and you have really carry this across the line for us. And I'm hoping to continue that work on making sure that people feel like they're included in this process and not preempted from it. So I just want to say thank you for that. A lot of times when you carry these types of bills, you not think. But I want to thank you, sir, especially from extreme else. Any further debate? >> Will chair McClain looks like I'm going to have to send U.S. Senator Sharif a lot more communication. So she has the ability to vote yes on my bills. Something with you're recognized to close here. >> Thank. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, thank you. Senators again for allow me to present the bill and that sometimes it's a little disappointing when someone stands up to oppose the bill and they've never really come and talk to you. So it kind of since I have an open door policy and so anyway. >> The this again, this that this these AG enclaves have to be in the urban either in the urban service area are in growth boundary. It cannot be outside of that. It cannot be in a rural land. They cannot be in some piece of land that we've already designated to to be rural for ever. And so all the this this this is that. So the bill I presented last week in London, thanks in the day, I think will then what about process? This one is about a truly about property rights. This is about someone that owns a piece of property and in the area that's been designated for future growth for growth in general and then county. And I've seen this happen because of the county commission for 12 years and probably guilty of doing the couple times. So I figured it out. But anyway, in this is about denying someone else a right to be able to use their property in a way that you just to prove someone else to use their property. And so this is truly a property rights issue, in my opinion, that someone that owns a piece of property should be able to come in and certainly enjoy the same benefit of a decision made by governmental body that was made for his neighbors. And so I would like to ask for your favorable support today. I will say this. There's a couple of things that have come up in the last few days that we're still may have some more conversation about. And so and anyway, I would ask for your favorable support. Thank you. >> Having close on this, bill is a bit. Please call the Roll on Cs for SB 86, 86. >> Senator Jones. Yes, senator leak. Yes. Senator passadomo senator pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain yes. >> By your vote will show Cs for SB 686, reported favorably. >> Now we will. >> Now will take up Tab. SB 548 growth management by Senator McLean Center. Mcclain, you're recognized to explain your Bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman and senators for allow me to present Senate Bill 548. in 2020 for the legislature passed and the governor signed House Bill Sports 79 to address several continuing problems in the growth management process. Principally how the state handled impact fees. You know how they would be handled. This bill provides additional care clarification. So those processes same for the requirements and IM and importantly setting a cap on extraordinary circumstances at 100% of the existing impact fee being charged. Senate Bill 548 will establish estate definition of what plan based methodology should be in and we comport with except to federal definitions. Clarifies that the in in a local agreements must provide funding to address extra jurisdictional impacts between the affected governmental entities clarifies that a plant based methodology must be used in the inner local agreement provides that existing inner local agreement cannot be extended if in place prior to October. 1st passed there already identified termination date or 10/1/2031, whichever is later it creates a definition for extraordinary circumstances requires a plant-based. 82 established need for a declaration of extraordinary circumstances and it counts the deck, a caps, extraordinary circumstances. Allowable increase at 100% equally divided over 4 years. And then it establishes a timeline, of course, of legal action of a judgment determines an improper be has been any improper impact. Fee has been paid and now that is the bill. >> Okay. Any questions on the bill members. Senator Jones, you're recognized. Thank you so much for the chair. And thank you so much of a sudden, the McLean just really quick this bill we saw last year with a any significant changes from last year. You're recognized. Thank you. I don't believe I didn't present a bill like this last year. The impact fees or yes, sir, you're recognized. I'm sorry, sir. Sorry chair. You're recognized more particularly for the shore here. Service, as I know there with partly explain in the definition of extraordinary extraordinary circumstances from last year. You're recognized, correct? That's right. Ok, its part for the questions. All right. I believe you have an amendment on the bill. You can take up Amendment bar code 5, 4, 8, 6, 3, 0, >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman senators, the the amendment basically mirrors the bill that that I just read to. You basically mirrors that we changed a little bit of language, not much, but it did it mirrors the current bill. >> All right. Any questions on the amendment members? Do we have any appearance cards on the amendment? Let's return. You're recognize seawater month Springs. >> Thank you. Vice chair Massullo members and thank you Chair McClain for introducing this clean-up bill for House Bill 479. From 2 years ago. As most of you remember, House Bill 479, was the most significant overhaul of great management we've had since the 2011 law. It had various stipulations for impact fees would be collected and who would do what and when it had to be done most significantly, it had a penalty provision in it, which took effect in October of last year. This bill, as I described it, that the senator mentioned is basically a clean-up bill for 79. It basically establishes several clarification says always in this process, we all be a little smarter as we go through the process and we see how provisions are being implemented. I wanted to focus on one thing. I think the staff analysis pretty well covers what extra extraordinary circumstances really does. But what I want to mention was how plant-based methodology and extraordinary circumstances puts the state in a posture to being asked. I think the fundamental question we always get asked when we're out in the field either by local governments or by constituents, which is where the money goes and what did it get spent on plant-based methodology will cover that extraordinary circumstances still allows local governments of which I represent one that we can still use the tool without it getting out of hand. But it provides the premise that local governments have to explain to both developers and to this kunce the citizens, what's being charged and what's being built and when is it going to be built? And that's the that's the nexus between the definitions which you see appearing in this bill and Chair McClain. I appreciate your indulgence in the time you spent working on this issue with me and the other stakeholders and I'd be happy to respond to questions. All right. Any debate on the amendment members seeing no debate. Senator McLean, you can close on the amendment. >> Well, waived closed. All right. All in favor of the amendment say yea, yea, we'll show that amendment adopted. We're back on the bill as amended any appearance cards on the bill as amended David Cruz, Florida League of Cities. David, you're recognized. >> Thank you for being here. Thank you, Mr. Chair David Cruz on behalf of the Florida League of Cities. Let me thank Senator McLean for all his time. He spent on this issue and for his open door policy to allow us to have the ongoing dialogue with him and the impacted stakeholders on this bill out. We understand that nobody likes paying impact fees, but the reality is in Florida, if growth doesn't pay for itself and infrastructure impacts are ultimately shifted to taxpayers. And that's something that I don't think anybody wants to see. And so while we continue to have some minor conversations on where this bill will ultimately land, there are some positive impacts in this bill that we think are worth preserving the idea of going towards a plan B methodology. It is a positive concept and one that we support in closing. We just appreciate the dialogue of the sponsor in the stakeholders and we hope to continue to work as we find this bill as it moves further. Thank you for that question. Thanks, Senator Pizzo. You're recognized a question the section and speaks to and moving or got the numbers are taking a little bit like but no impact fee may increase or exceed 50% of the current impact fee. That's not unreasonable. >> Which part are okay with you. Which parts are, you know, seems reasonable to like not hiking 100% over a certain amount of time. Those are those are reasonable to the league. Your your thank you, Mr. Chairman apologize to Senator McCain. >> I think there's some great conversation be had Senator Pizzo in a policy discussion for this committee to have as where is the appropriate threshold as we move forward. The underlying issue is, but I think we have 2 types of actors were dealing with impact fees at the local government level we have at there's that has been motivated for what I would call good reasons. They haven't increase their impact fees in decades. And a lot of that is because they wanted to encourage growth. These are probably the good actors. It didn't raise fees after 20 years of not raising an impact fee when that impact feet does finally get adjusted for growth because there's a lack of infrastructure to continue to support development that finally came online. We run into this and here we have a very high increase and it lacks predictability that developers are looking for and we understand their concerns. And so there's this very fine needle. It needs to get thread where you balance the predictability that the developers are asking for in the ability for that local government, that, in my opinion, was trying to be a good actor to be and keep impact fees low for a long as possible at it kind of adjust them to just to catch up with inflation, if you will follow up with yes. And I think that's an excellent point. Might be why. And I think the state as a whole did. >> Things bending over backwards to try to attract people to move here. We don't inspect cars. We do require boating license isn't going by boat in and drive around without any kind of license. We did a lot of those things. Would it be prudent to alert municipalities and local governments that by a certain date they need to have what they believe to be reasonable impact fee in place. So there is reliance. And then from that point, a lot of things that we update, right. The grand theft amount was $300 in Florida for 20 plus years. Our sovereign immunity cap is 20300. It's been like that. But since 2010 tea. But what to be pretty of this bill also says beginning this date or by this date, you guys should come up to what you think is reasonable. What will pass the smell test. And from there you cannot increase 100%, sounds like you might have. Some members are association that to have some antiquated impact fees because they were trying to incentivize development and they haven't come up to speed yet. >> You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, I think that's a great idea worth pursuing and having that conversation with the stakeholders to see if we could work that out. Courtney Mooney, Florida Association counties. Courtney, you're recognized. Thank you for being here again. Thank you. Chair and members of the Committee. >> Creamy Florida Association of counties once again testifying for information. I want to thank Senator McLean for working with us on this and addressing the concerns that we have one of them being. We want to clarify that the planned space study approach in the bill is tied specifically to extraordinary circumstance stances and doesn't limit county sex ability to use a consumption based study for when a regular impact fee is being implemented. And the second one being on the backside of the bill, we recognize the need for a more streamlined refund process for impact fees and we would like to work to refund the bill language to is to simplify the refund of the fee when there's an overpayment to avoid unnecessary court involvement so that the developer can just get them back. Thank you. Very good. >> Kerry, he bridge Florida, Home Builders Association waives in support. You want to talk in a way that support waning support. Ok, thank you. Thanks for being here. And Daniel Martinez, Americans for Prosperity Waives in support, Colton a deal. Florida Chamber of Commerce Waives in supports their year. And Carmen Fink Association Industries of Florida. It was for waives in support. Thank you. All right. That ends public testimony going when it one more. Gary Hunter for Florida Association of Community Developers Waives in support any debate on the bill as amended members reprieve. >> Yes, thank Senator Pizzo. You're recognized as crews makes an excellent point that I represent 20 cities a few of which will bend over backward to do whatever and discount anything just to get development, enters to get any kind of activity in and then I have the extreme opposite that will do anything they possibly can to prevent any development, right, price people out of it. But I do think that meet their needs to be a clear catch, a period as to where somebody should be before the implementation of increases. I mean, he probably represent some places that don't have public Senator resort public water supply. And if all of a sudden that's being imposed as a larger over large scale project, that's being the cost of the majority, the cause of is being borne by a large development that we may see an and other bills that it's unreasonable to say that should be a catch-up period. But yes, but that's the point that concerns me the most further debate, any further debate. >> All right. Senator McClain, you're recognized to close on your Bill. Thank you, Mister Chairman. Thank you. Senators for the conversation. >> You know, this isn't this isn't about not paying impact fees. Every person I talked who's willing to pay impact fees. This is about when impact fees have been raised for quite sometime. We did take care of that kind of 10 last year. We did some stuff in there as well as other bills where we talked about them raising their fees. And so I think it's not it's not about not paying impact fees. It's about not having men charged or bin the impact these been raised over pay time. Then all the sudden they come along. Oh, my gosh, we got to catch up. And so that these are going to be, you know, 300%. And so, you know, so it's a matter of catching up. Obviously, there was a and attorney general's opinion just recently. One of the things that has been done is time for the plant based methodology part of this. I think one of the reasons why we should go to something like that is because you can't just say we've had some growth here more than we were expecting. And therefore, we're going to claim that is being are extraordinary circumstance that could be play into it. But I think it's still important that we probably try to figure out what some methods the best best method would be on out, put these things together. I think the definitions that we've put in the bill answer some of the answer, those questions moving forward. And certainly I'm willing to have a conversation about, you know, maybe the implementation of in some of those types of things, certainly. And then there is a piece of the bill honest of that as many spoke about from this floor sensation counties on the streamlined refund. We recently had a county that had been inadvertently collected impact fees from a developer than a 55 plus community. 55 plus, communities do not have to pay him back the school impact fees and want to get their money back. And there's been a big kind of how can we make all this happen? I was on the county commission. My County Commission happened. We just said, right, the man a check and give him his money back. And so I don't know what the problem is. Many ways. So that's part of that. But so we have that straight now to go forward. I would appreciate your support today that thank you. >> Very good. Having closed on his bill, Liz Smith, please call the Roll on Cs for SB 5.48. >> Senator Jones, Senator Lee. Yes, senator passidomo senator Pizzo and Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> Members by your vote will show Cs for SB 548. Reported favorably out here in the virtual gavel. Back to Senator Chairman McClain. Thank you, vice chair for do that. Part of the meeting center that will move to Tab 10 SB 1234, on that building for ricin inspections by Senator Diciglie. Senator Deciglie, you're recognized to explain your Bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman Senate Bill 1234. It's like Sesame Street. >> Except I mean, we can go on and on. Senator, we don't want to do that. I'll get in trouble. >> Several 1, 2, 3, 4, period, building permits and inspections. Key components of this legislation include ensuring single-family building permits remain valid for at least 180 days or until the next coach Edition. Exempt from building permitting requirements. Any work valued under $7,500 for single family dwelling projects unrelated to structural electrical or plumbing projects except for windows and doors and require contractors performing such work to keep records for 3 years of actual work performed property address in value of work as proof of compliance exempt temporary hurricane protection, floodwalls and barriers from permitting requirements if certain procedures at direct the Florida Building Commission to develop a mandatory statewide residential permit application form with project type checklists require building official to approve, approve with conditions or deny a building permit with within 5 business days if completed and submitted by plans. Reviewer for projects under 15,000 for structural, assess restructures alarm, electrical irrigation landscaping, mechanical plumbing or roofing, simplifies the private provider documentation sets timelines for agency review limits. Local government oversight, completeness checks only bar additional fees and prohibits local governments for discouraging the use of private providers for inspection services, Mr. Chairman, that is the bill. Thank you. Are there questions on the bill? >> The question to serve. There are appearance forms. Accordingly. You are recognized. >> Last time I swear to thank you once again chair and I want to say thank Senator Deciglie for working on us with this bill. We did have a few concerns that we're still trying to work out with Senator Deciglie and the stakeholders and one of those being the limit of the $7500 not having to pull a permit. We just want to make sure that if there's a large project, someone isn't breaking up into smaller pieces and taking advantage of the system. And the other one is trying to work out where we can really hold the documentation for in case someone sells their house or a contractor goes out of business and the next one is the premier provider statue. We do understand that it needs to be tightened up a little bit and we're working. Our concerns are with him to make sure we do it correctly. And the last piece, the uniform permitting, I think we've already seen this in a bill before. It has been a heavy topic of conversation. We always just want to make sure that whatever uniform or sanitization we put in our local codes can go into that. So that's a thank you. >> Thank you. Kerri break. You're recognized. >> Just quickly, Mister Chairman Carey, you're and representing Florida, Home Builders Association and also the National Underground Utility Contractors Association. They support the provision in there that would eliminate current practice right now. And some local jurisdictions are required to individual permit for every retaining wall for every one parcel for retaining walls. As you know, those are linear difficult moments in. We shouldn't they don't start and stop on each parcel lot. So that's a big piece of that. This priority Bill for Florida Homebuilders Association, the kind of clean up some of the permitting again on the 7500 exemption. That only applies if it's not structural electrical or plumbing. Want to make sure we clarify that and records have to be kept. And on the flood walls on, we do need to add the word temporary in the Senate bill. It is in the House bill. But we do mean when a homeowner goes and wants to put up something extra and it lays out the way in which a person would do that. So happy to answer any questions. Appreciate your support on this good Bill. >> Thank you, sir. Do you is that the Suns Sun Sea? >> Yes, Senator, Mr. Chair your afternoon as chair committee members and serve us can say with W doing official Miami-Dade County Building in permitting division. I'm here to express my concern with the bill, but specifically to focus in on Section 5 alternative plan to use inspections. The private provider law has been in effect for 24 years. And those firms that follow the law or have been able to practice perfectly fine art. We deal with a lot of fire provide. We work with a lot of private providers and Miami-Dade County and we work for successfully through projects for the benefit of the constituents and the occupants of those buildings. Our concern is the lack of oversight that they're seeking just like a building official has oversight over their own inspectors to make sure that they're following the code and they're playing the code properly. It is crucial for the building official to continue to have oversight of the private providers acting as the inspections, the inspectors for those projects. This is to avoid any life safety issue that could arrive that we can mitigate in the early stages of that building and preserve the life safety of the occupants, it where the eventually inhabit these buildings. So I see that the changes that are being proposed are really not necessary. Private provider firms are working successfully in fine under the current law. And I would hope that I would recommend that we don't support that. We want to work through these issues a little bit more with the sponsor and kind of hone in on what is what is support, what is what is proper for the industry. Thank you so much, Senator Pizzo for a question with a question for it. >> Yes, sir. Right now from the bills in the past year in this legislature last couple years, we allow third-party definitely private providers to perform milestone inspections, which, as you know, speak to any imminent dangers are concerned. The structural and very expensive, sometimes repairs for condos, but they have a wide purview. And and basically, I mean, can you tell me with what frequency your department rejects the milestone inspection findings from third-party firms all the time? >> In Miami County, we have been doing milestones for 50 years and generally the engineers and the architects that perform those also inspections have reported their findings through the process of inspection reports. Miami Dade County does go out and and and look at these and Casey basis and there are times we find that they haven't reported what is existing. But there are many times it there, gentlemen, so I can't I don't have a percentage for you, but I could say that that that the oversight, even in that aspect is important the to the industry to make sure that these buildings are being reviewed correctly. And and and the be reported on paper, correct this fall. >> You're recognized. So my suspension deals with something that might be 30, 40, 50 years old in any imminent danger and it's already occupied. Yes, this is more on the front end, even obviously before it's been constructed or developed. What purview do you think you're losing? If this bill passes that you don't have with files inspections, the oversight to make sure that their inspectors are? >> Are following the codes are making sure that the codes are being follow much like we have oversight on our own inspected to make sure that they're doing the same thing. We have that process in place. And I think that it's important that the building official retain that because in the end appropriate for is an LLC. And they're here today gone tomorrow who's left, who's left minding the store. They come to the building department. And it's heartbreaking to say we didn't inspect this project. It was done by a private company who's no longer in business. And this is this is allowed by law, unfortunately. So we we must the building official must be really must retain that oversight, which is important for life. Safety of those occupants eventually going to be in that building. >> Just quick vote. You're going and with that oversight concur with that oversight, you're willing to accept liability or responsibility for the for that project. >> Well, you know, as as a government entity, we have we have the sovereign immunity, but we don't take that lightly. We have a responsibility and we're on biased as to how we apply and take that responsibility on. >> Thanks. Thank you. Thank you, Lisa Miller, thank you, Mister Chairman and thank you, Senator Maclay. I'm sorry. So the sickly for this bill, but with all due respect to searches. >> Well, sir, I'm here today gone tomorrow. I've been working with proper fighters on this for years. I don't see here today and gone tomorrow and most you know that I am right up pretty tight ship for the class that I work with. And that's just not something that we do. We've asked repeatedly to our friends in the building. Officials association gives examples of misbehaving prop providers. I will take them to task. They'll rue the day that they misbehaved. I've asked for specific examples of here today gone tomorrow. Hear the anecdotal. Let me just leave you with this product. Routers are licensed. Exactly as but with the officials. They should be collaborative not competitive. This is a way to move our state forward. It is antiquated to think that building officials on the only game in town to make our building safe. It's wrong. We support this bill 100%. Thank you very much. >> Thank you, Paul. And waiving in support of Mister Chair Jason Mayne waiving in support Coleman bill waiving in support. Those are the appearance forms that we have are there. Is there debate on the bill seeing none. Senator Deciglie you're recognized to close on the bill. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman, I'll just say there's there's a lot to this bill. Obviously I'm committed to the stakeholders to get their input in in crafting a great piece of legislation is as this moves forward. And again, as far as a private providers, we're talking about former building officials, architects, engineers. These are not fly by night, folks. So with that, again, looking forward to working with all stakeholders and ask for your favorable support today. Thank you. >> Thank you, Elizabeth. Please call the roll on Senate Bill. 1234. >> Senator Jones, senator leak guess Senator Passadomo senator Pizzo Senator Sharif. Yes. Senator Trumbull. Yes. Vice chair massullo. Yes. Chair McClain. Yes. >> By your vote SB 1234, is reported favorably. Thank you. Thank you. Does any Senator wish to be recorded as voting on bills before the committee today each year? >> Senator Jones, you're recognized. I would be more on that from your phone. Tapped to chair one tab 3 tab 5 tab. 8, No on Tab 9 and the for both. Tell for. Thank you. >> Is there objection seeing none of the show the motion adopted. Is there any other business come before the committee knows Senator Trumbull moves we adjourn. Is there objection? Seeing? None. Show the motion adopted. We are adjourned

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Community Affairs — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 879d352c25e1c530059f50100fefe75a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record