POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Jun 18, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, June 18, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Jun 18, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 61,677 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> The city council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for each agenda item. Staff reports are available online at the city's website and in the public view binder located at the podium at the north side of the chamber. We are going to begin with. With the pledge of allegiance. So, if you'll join me and stand ready begins. >> I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> If you could stay standing, we have an invocation from Amarjit Singh. >> Thank you for the opportunity. Let's close our eyes. Those who feel comfortable when we talk all about one community. Oh Great master of the universe, you made us in your own image and redeem us through your blessings. Oh Great master, we beg to you to look with compassion on the whole human race. Take away the arrogance and hatred which infects our minds and hearts. Break down the walls that separate us. Unite us in the bonds of love. Work through our struggle and confusion. May all races serve you in harmony around your heavenly throne. Shower the glance of your grace on our elected officials, members of the public, law enforcement officials, firefighters, medical teams who carry a great burden on our behalf. Give guidance and strength so that lawmakers make may fairly equal and equitable decisions for all citizens, regardless of caste, creed, color, gender or sexual orientation. We have similarities, and we have differences. Oh Great master of the universe, your name can lead us to live in high spirits who respect differences. In your command, by your order, we recognize the whole human race as one. Amen. Thank you. >> Thank you. I'll now do roll call. >> [ CALLING ROLL ] >> We will move to public comment for non agendized matters within the city's jurisdiction. Pursuant to the Brown act, city council cannot take action on public comment items. The city council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for 30 minutes total. The beginning of the meeting for public comment for non agendized matters within the city's jurisdiction. The mayor will determine the order of the speakers. If 30 minutes is not adequate to accommodate all of the individuals who have submitted a speaker request form to the city clerk, the council will trail this item to the end of the open session agenda. The remaining speakers will address the city council at that time. We have one speaker. >> Good evening, everybody. Came to talk about something that really gets under your skin for a while. It's about the law. And I told you about seat and seal. I found a little thing in a law book about non caucasian law. Granted, it was written way back when, but it means for all, all our differences now, we seem to have a problem at the border, and we definitely seem to have a problem with people squatting on people's land, robbing people. Now that the stores are pretty much had, they're going after people's houses to rob them or take care of them or to do what it is that unlawfuls do. Now, when I say unlawful, I do mean that non caucasian. Yeah, they're in the mix on the color scheme, but we got problems and we need to work together. We got some problems at the county jail, mercers, and most importantly, when the city or the county is asked to accept money from the state for integrating people, not giving them the choice where they're going to put that mobile home, where they're going to put that little home, where they're going to put the fancy ones. I thought we were, you know, doing pretty good for a while, but it didn't work out. We did the fishing story, we did the kids with the newspaper, you know, the little things, the kids with the newspapers that deserve those jobs that were taken away and given to the adults just because of age. Not cool. We have the fishing problem. We have motorized scooters going up and down in the fishing area. I mean, they just come up here and do their thing and that's it. But you won't even let them finish. That's it. I'm hoping that you guys will take time and learn what's going on. Thank you. >> Thanks, Alex. We will move to the consent calendar. The consent calendar contains items considered routine and or which have been individually scrutinized by city council members and are anticipated to require no further deliberation. If a member of the public wishes to address an item on the consent calendar, please fill out a speaker request form and submit it to the city clerk before the consent calendar is considered. It shall be the prerogative of any council member before the consent calendar is acted upon to comment on an item. To respond to any public comment on an item request, a record reflect an abstention or nay vote on an item, remove an item and replace it on the regular portion of the agenda for delivery of a staff report and or extended discussion or deliberation. So we have one comment. >> If I may, just to make sure that the council and the public are aware, there was an amended resolution that was uploaded to item 4.12. I believe subsection two, that amended resolution went out to the public at the same time that it went to the council. It is part of the packet and the podium in the back. And the recommended action will be to go ahead and adopt the amended resolution. This is reflecting member de Casteau's resignation date and the fact that the two year term will need to be added to the election. I would also suggest, Madam Mayor, if we could just check if there was any public comment at the remote location, both as part of this item and the general public item. >> So we have one in house with Steve Cohn and then councilmember Dacquisto. Is there anybody at Hacienda Resort and residence lobby? >> There is no one here. >> Good evening, council community members. My question, or one I wanted to talk about, was 460 and some 4.11, couple of different letters. This one is appropriating about 350,000 to the Whistle Stop project park, and then re appropriating 85,000 American Rescue Rescue fund plan money and giving the city manager general fund loan authority. So one of the questions that comes up is that we did have that soccer park loan situation that went out there and then was forgiven. You know, do we have a guarantee that these loans aren't also going to be forgiven in the future? That's one question. The other question is we do have a couple of other items for significant amounts of money, 411 h, which ends up being, what, four point. Hang on a second. About 4.8 million altogether, which is for river trail repairs. And another item on there for parks was for 411 D, the South Redding bikeway pedestrian trail, for about 2.87 million. So a significant amount of money is going out. And it seems to me at the last board meeting or council meeting, we had, you know, the police chief figuring out how to lay off several officers. Now, I understand some of this is probably gotten with grants, but if that's the case, then I think it should be explained to the public how much of it is grants, how much is coming out of the general fund in detail. Now, that may have been done along the way, I grant you that. But I think it's important when these kind of dollars are being transferred, when we're asking to forgive up officers, that it be explained in detail how much is really coming out of our pocket. For example, the completion of the project on Bocelli Lane, a lot of which was granted, but it was a huge project. I think it says 12 million here completed, but I think there was additional funds in there of like several million, I thought, for other things. Anyway. At the very least, I'd like to see more detailed explanation in these situations where we're putting millions of dollars into trails while asking our police chief to phase out officers. And I know that sometimes these are approved a while back, but as they're brought up here for consent approval, I'd kind of like to hear an explanation. Thank you. >> Do you want to give him an explanation? >> Entirely up to the council? If you'd like me to. >> Yes, I would. >> The items. The items that were brought up are none of which have general fund impact on a long term basis. They're grant funds, streets funds, which cannot be used for public safety services. And in the case of the whistlestop park, there is some temporary loan of general fund money which was mentioned, and that's to cover some shortfalls in our expected credits associated with park development fees and some ineligible grant expenses, because the expenses were incurred prior to the grant period starting. And so the recommendation is to honor our commitments to the developer to complete the whistle stop park, which has been done. And there's a celebration this Friday regarding that, and for a temporary basis to loan the money to the park development fund to make good on our commitments. And then the park development fund and or park in lieu funds will pay the general fund back over a period of time yet to be determined. >> Mr. Mezzano, did you have something you. >> Wanted to, you know, kind of ironic, but I had a discussion with Mr. Tipton this afternoon about this very section. I too was concerned that we were throwing another $350,000 out there. And then he explained it all to me, which doesn't get explained here in the summary of the consent calendar. It is explained in more detail in the staff report, but there's a lot of it that the general public doesn't understand. So I'm glad the question was asked. But it was a question that I had asked Mr. Tipton to respond to this evening, because that is a lot of money, and to know that it's going to be paid back by the fees that we collected from the PARC program satisfied me. As far as 411 h goes. I also had a concern there. That's over a million dollars, but a lot of that money and Mr. Tippman, you can finish this. FEmA's involved and I've been. I'll choose my words carefully. I've been concerned about the river trail since I got elected. There's parts out there where we're just washed away, and I've been telling, been told for four years now. We're waiting on FEMA, but there's other information that I would like for you to share so the public knows we're in their best interest. Yeah, so this is a sort of a few series of storm damage and car fire damage that's occurred on the river trail. One of the elements for improvement involved some environmental work that had to be done and had to get clearance through what's called the National Environmental Protection act, or NEPA, involving the Corps of Engineers and certain permits, 404 permits that take a long time to achieve. And so, so that process took quite a while. In addition, we were trying to negotiate some better outcomes for the city of Redding, and that is a lengthy process as well. In other words, FEMA says that you can do x. We say that doesn't make a lot of sense, we should do y, and then there's a negotiation that proceeds, and most of that has to happen through the state oes as a middle band. So, you know, you have these lengthy processes that occur. We were unwilling to piecemeal that project because that doesn't make a lot of sense. And so what we've been able to do is put all of that together. And yes, it's been a long time, but the result will be a much better project, much better completion for the community, and we hope to get that done shortly. Thank you. >> Also, can I ask just to clarify, Mr. Tipton. So this is funding that's coming from FEMA. This is not money that we could use for public safety. This is. >> That is correct. There's a little bit of match money depending on the emergency events. So Car fire, for instance, was 100% reimbursed, but the storm damage was not. So there is a component, I think it's like 6.85% that needs to come from the city, and in this case, most of that's coming from community services, parks money. >> Thank you. Councilmember Dacquisto, is there anything from consent calendar you wish to comment on? >> No, I have no observations, and I'm happy to vote on the calendar as a whole. >> What did he say? I think, did he make a motion to approve the consent? I'll second that. I'll second. Okay, we have a first and a second. All those in favor? Oh, just kidding. We're going to do a roll call. >> [ CALLING ROLL ] >> Okay, we will move to the regular calendar. Our first item, 9.1, a public meeting to consider the renewal of the Redding tourism, marketing business improvement district. >> Madam Mayor, I think there was a request if we could move item nine point. Was it the last one? 9.6 c forward, because we have consultants from Texas on board, if that would be okay with the council. >> No problem. >> Thank you. >> Sorry, Jason. Okay, Travis, you are up. This is 9.6. An oral presentation by the sports facilities companies to consider their market opportunity analysis with the pro business pharma economic impact analysis and overall feasibility report for a multi court facility complex in the city of Redding. >> Should be. >> All right. >> Thank you. Sorry. We are going through some tech stuff, which I promise, or I'm told that this will be the last time we have to use a phone call and a zoom and speakerphone and all that stuff. So. Good evening, honorable mayor, members of the city council. At the March 21, 2023 city council meeting, Mayor pro tempore Munn suggested and consensus of the council directed the community services director at that time to conduct a feasibility study for an eight court basketball facility similar to the Hardwood palace in Rockland for consideration at future council meeting. And today is that meeting. We had a long road to get here, but we put in a lot of good work with the sports facilities company and a lot of members of the community. That was initially spearheaded by my predecessor, Kim, and former recreation superintendent Theresa. We had several community members that were active in both sports and commercial construction. That included Rob Barr of Gifford Construction, Alan Knott of k two development, and local coaches Todd Franklin, Michael Gray, Brody and Lewis. City council member Munns also put in a ton of time on this, so I thank him for that, being part of our committee as well as the chair of the CSAC Community Services Advisory Commission, James Fink. And so they put in a lot of time on that and actually did some tours and looked at some facilities and got some good ideas and had some good experience and feedback to share. Share with us. So with our group, there was a strong consensus that we are underserved in terms of court facilities. And actually, through our analysis, we determined that we're currently meeting 27% of the community's need for indoor court space. So we're pretty far behind that, and that's using all of the facilities that we are able to program, but we actually don't control any indoor court facilities at this time. Our commission advised us to contract with the sports facility company in September of 2023, and the consultant was charged with conducting a market opportunity analysis as well as a business pro forma economic impact analysis and an overall feasibility report. We worked with stakeholders to identify our needs, look at our market, and look at the feasibility that we may be a sports tourism market. And so the resulting documents are presented to you tonight and included in the packet. The first of the two models that we've developed is an eight court model that is a third party operated facility that focuses mostly on sports tourism and meeting our local needs. The second model is a four court, which is operated by city staff and focuses mostly on local needs with a limited amount of sports tourism. So those reports are ready and we'd like to hopefully get those accepted and some guidance on how to pursue forward with this. And I have Dan Morton here from sports Facility company, and he's going to summarize those findings and go through a little condensed version of the one and a half inch thick feasibility study that you are presented with tonight. So take it away, Dan. >> All right. And you should be able to see my screen now as well. >> Great. Well, good evening, everybody. Thanks, Travis. For the kickoff here, I'm going to run through the information of what is quite detailed. I'll do that pretty quickly. I'm going to spend about ten minutes sharing the findings with you and then answer any questions that you have as far as what we'll cover. I'll give you a little more background on who we are, what we do at sports facilities companies or SSC, and then I'll dive into a really brief summary of the process and then we'll get into the results. The most important number is related to the facility recommendations, the potential development cost, the operational performance, and then the potential economic impact. And we'll wrap with some opportunities, challenges and discussions on next steps. So just a quick background on us at sports companies. At SSC, we really focus on the planning, development and management of youth and amateur sports facilities. A really important thing to point out here is that we focus on community level facilities. So we're not involved with professional teams or really facilities that you go to spectate at. We're really focused on facilities that have impacted communities where kids, through adults, multigenerational, are going to participate. We manage about 60 venues currently across the country. Really importantly, everything that we do and we put in place in a forecast or analysis like what we've done for of the city and we're presenting here this evening is based on real world operations. And so anything that we put into place, we know that either the city or us or another group will be responsible for managing and hitting those numbers if something is developed, and that's the ethic we work under. So I just wanted to point that out. What I'm showing here is what we'll call concept to concrete. It's just helpful to visualize all the steps to facility development. We've checked off the two first boxes, or buckets here in market feasibility and financial feasibility. It typically, on average, is about a two to three year process from what we see in our experience to go from concept or idea to grand opening. And so just to give you an idea of the timeline, again, we've conducted the market feasibility and financial analysis for you all. In terms of our process, we go through analysis of a lot of data and a lot of information, but also getting really familiar with your local community and talking to stakeholders and communities, community members and representatives from the city to really understand the needs. We start with definition success, understand your goals, and then we look at all that data. I won't go through everything, it's in your information you have there in the report, but we synthesize all that data through our proprietary analysis that we use on hundreds of facilities that's been developed, 60 facilities that we do manage, and about 150 projects a year that we study across the country. We take into all that account, and then we come back with our forecast and recommendations for what could be successful based on the market opportunity and what you all want to accomplish as a city, or what the project team has shared with us. In terms of those definitions, success, I'm not going to read all of them, but in general, we've heard and learned, as Travis outlined the two facilities, the goal here is to provide access to recreation spaces, specifically court spaces, but flexible use space for the local community that is currently underserved. But importantly also is to drive economic impact in sports tourism. And so what that means is we're looking at two market segments, the local market, and then the regional population, that we could potentially draw into Redding. And so we have to analyze those things. I'll talk a little bit more about that. But the goal being drive sports tourism, create economic impact, new visitors, as well as serve your local population. And that'll be a driving factor into some of our recommendations. So in terms of the facilities, as Travis mentioned, we've created two models, a four court model that is contemplated to be managed by city staff that's really focused on local use. Four court is not big enough to be a sports tourism destination. And so as we talk about our definition of success, that forecourt model does not create the ability to drive a significant amount of economic impact and be a destination. The eight court model that we also analyzed, which we've contemplated, is a third party managed model. So that's where the city would or whoever owns the facility would contract with a group that is professionally experienced in managing sports tours and venues to manage that asset. That eight court model is big enough to be a sports tourism destination, but it's more courts than you really need locally. And so we'll see some of that come out in the results. One important thing I'll point out is that this is not a model where, you know, the facility is developed by a private entity and is turned over to a private entity that has, you know, is at risk in the operation. This is where a contracted organization is working in service to the city to execute on the plan there. So it would still be a public asset. That's an important distinction when we think about operations, but wanted to make sure that was clear. In terms of the facilities. In the four court model, the recommendation is about 91,000 sqft. That includes a four court, four basketball court, eight volleyball court space at about 33,000 sqft. It'll also then include some other amenities that serve a couple different purposes. One of those is to create more recreation for the community, to fill some needs, but also to create revenue drivers for the facility. One of those spaces is Family entertainment center. At about 11,000 sqft, we have some sports performance training area that's really locally focused, right? To train, develop athletes, space for batting cages, pitching tunnels for practice. That's something that's lacking in the local area. And then all the support spaces, you would expect to create a great facility that's about 91,000 sqft, we would expect to need about 273 parking spaces. And for that facility to take up just under six acres for the four court model. In the eight court model, very similar in terms of the support spaces with the family entertainment center, sports performance, as well as admin space. But we're doubling the court space, essentially. So now that flat floor open event space is about 66,000 sqft. That has our basketball volleyball courts, but they can also be pickleball and cheer and dance wrestling. Really, it's a flexible asset to drive tournaments and events, but also local play. That facility is about 147,000 sqft, requiring about 440 parking spaces and would be just under nine acres. From a cost perspective, this model is just now comparing the two facilities. I just described the facility spaces. But in terms of cost, we've analyzed the four court model. We would expect to cost about $45 million to develop. And the larger eight court model, about just under $75 million to develop. That's based on site development, hard cost outfitting the spaces for sport and as well as your support spaces like food and beverage or other things, as well as soft cost for construction and soft cost for operations. And so this is meant to be the full all in cost to develop these systems, facilities, as you can see, obviously significant capital requirement and, you know, just under double the facility cost in the eight core model in terms of then financial performance. As I've mentioned, we analyze the operation and the economic impact potential of both these models. Right. They have different outcomes as one smaller focused on local, the other is larger, focused on sports tourism. And so we'll talk through that. In your feasibility report, you've got detailed pro formas that shows actually how we forecasted everything down to basketball leagues, camps and clinics and court rentals and summer camps. And on the expense side of the equation, how we're staffing, what we're paying people, what your utility costs would be. All that detail is in your pro forma. I'm just going to summarize what those results are. But again, to emphasize this is based on what we know to be true real world numbers for these types of facilities, but really focused on your local community. And so we're taking national level benchmarks and experience and how these facilities operate, but we're customizing it to your local reality for both revenue and expenses in a facility operation. So again, this is a summary of the two models. More detail within your report. In the city managed four court model, you can see if we, we focus on our EBITDA number, which is earnings before interest, tax, depreciation. That's operational performance. We would expect at year five, what we'll consider maturity for the facility to require about a $60,000 operating subsidy. This is obviously a service amenity from a recreation perspective. And so you're seeing where we can get to in terms of cost recovery. Keep in mind that this is an isolated asset, so it doesn't contemplate other efficiencies through the city, where there may be some budget efficiencies. But we want to show you all in cost for that specific entity. We've also shown a capital replacement cost. A lot of times, that's not the burden of an operation, but we want to create reality that's based on the useful life of all the assets within the facility, whether it's equipment all the way to the building. And so this doesn't necessarily mean that the city would have to put away this amount each year. But as you look at the life of a building and those things within it, there will be capital replacement costs. So we forecasted that as well. As Travis mentioned, on the four court model, while it's not a sports tourism destination, we can do some events. We forecast about 17 events at maturity, driving about $2.3 million in economic impact in the eight court model. Again, summarizing the most important number, we see that EBITDA number, our operational performance, get to break even in year five. So we do see that being an operational, sustainable opportunity that's based on driving more visitation, more people to the facility, generating revenue off that visitation, as well as the efficiencies of a third party private management group for that facility. Again, we've included the capital replacement cost. That's a higher number with a more expensive, bigger building. What's really important here is that we do believe that Redding has the ability to create a sports tourism destination and to be a destination. But we think that will take time. You can see year one in the sports tourism model, we drive 19 events that grows all the way up to 31 events, both in the volume events as well as size of events, and creates the opportunity to generate about $13.5 million in economic impact annually at maturity, which could result in about $327,000 in new tax revenue. So we want to share, you know, those dollars that would come obviously directly back to the city from a sales and use tax perspective. So that's the summary of the financial performance and economic impact. I'll dive just a little bit deeper on economic impact, just to give you some background on the numbers, and then we'll wrap up and answer questions. To forecast our economic impact, we analyze the per person spend or the average daily expenditure. We expect every visitor to Redding to spend about dollar 124 per day that they're in market. These would be non local overnight visitors, and we looked at a breakdown of how they spend. Obviously, you can't get the hotel room for $35 a night. That's assuming there's three people per room. That's based on, again, knowing what people spend in other markets and tailoring that to renting. You can see a breakdown of events. 17 in the smaller model, 31 events annually at maturity in the larger model, and then from a room night's perspective, we expect the smaller model to generate about 3800 room nights on an annual basis, and then the larger model to generate about 24,000 new room nights throughout the year. From economic impact, so just to recap then, before I open up for questions, we recommend, based on the definition success that we heard from the city and from the project team, to create an opportunity for local community members to drive economic impact and to create a sustainable asset. Operationally, that model checks those boxes. Obviously, it's a lot bigger in terms of price tag at 75 million. So we believe that facility checks the boxes. But again, we don't view our job to tell you what to do, but rather to give you the information data for what will happen if you invest in this type of space. And so obviously, part of the next step will be determining what resources could be available for a facility like this. We're happy to dive into and talk through some examples of how facilities have been funded, but again, we see that eight court model does create, you know, checking the most boxes in terms of definition of success. The smaller model obviously could be successful as well, but we see that as not checking the box of a sports tourism driver like the eight court model would. From a challenges perspective, obviously you've got a significant capital cost. Not expected. These models aren't to cover the capital replacement on a long term basis. That's something that no facilities in the industry do, right. And so house cities, you know, put money aside to make sure that they can replace facilities and keep them up. Obviously, that's a conversation we can have. And then just lastly, you know, we do believe Redding can be a sports tourism destination with the right facility, but we do believe it'll take time and investment and operations to do that. That's reflected in the model as we grow from year one to year five at maturation for economic impact. That's really what we want to share. So I appreciate you taking the time and happy to answer questions. >> Okay, does anybody have any questions or comments? >> I'm doing well, thank you. I can't see you right now, but I wish I could. >> Well, it's Jack Munns. You operate. How many facilities was it? 50? >> It's about 60 right now. We have a few that are coming out of the ground, so that's growing every day, but about 60. >> I don't know if this is an appropriate question, but if it's not, you don't have to answer it. How many of those facilities are losing money? >> Yeah, I don't know. That's off the top of my head. I will say, how many of those facilities are economic development mechanisms? Right. Just like you'd see a convention center. Right. That are public invested in to be an economic driver. About 60% of our portfolio are publicly owned assets that are meant to drive economic impact rather than create a return on investment for private businesses. >> All right, thank you. >> Do we have any public comment on this? No. Anybody else have any questions? What would you. What do you need from us? It says to provide direction. >> So we're looking to accept the reports so we can take the draft watermark off them and provide any direction you may have, if you'd like to continue to pursue that, or if you would like to. So a lot of these projects take a long time. This is the first foray into building something like this. Some of these take decades to pull off. The thing, the ultimate takeaway is that there is a need for these facilities, whether or not you can afford the $40 to $80 million price tag right now, I think it's clear that we're not going to be able to do that, but it is something that we can work toward as a goal. So if you have a long term goal to continue to pursue something like this, we can work toward that. If you'd like to consider it in the future and have it be component of the parks, trails, and open space master plan in a revision, it can certainly be something that we work toward as a future project and any type of feedback that gets us to a conclusion like that or don't consider it anymore as an alternative, what we're looking for. >> Councilmember Mezzano. >> I think it was a great presentation, and I'll move forward to accept your report. >> I actually had some comments. Go ahead. Yeah. Thank you, Director Minna. I think we would all agree that we have a need for this. The issue, of course, is the capital outlay. And then when we do have projects like this and we're all dealing with the whole issue of big league dreams, how do you then repair, replace capital infrastructure? So that's, you know, something that we're already struggling with currently. But I do like the idea of us putting this in our park master plan and looking for opportunities. Perhaps there would be an opportunity. Do you know of any grants that might be coming for something like this, or are there any philanthropic groups in our community that would like to fund something like this? I mean, I think it's something that we should be open to if the opportunity were to come along, because obviously there is a need for this type of facility. I want to thank Councilmember Munns for pursuing this as well. Thank you for the time that you put into pursuing this. I know that a lot of people are interested in it. Anyway, your thoughts, Director Munns? >> So it would be difficult to string together $80 million worth of grants, but probably not impossible. It really depends on the location and the availability of grant funding and partnerships at that specific time. You know, as a state's budget kind of declines and so do grants, and we see less reinvestment with stuff like that. So it would be hard to get to that level. But I would say that the best way to proceed is basically by having done this, basically having the pro formas already out there, that now they're public, and that if someone finds that they can make that viable, they can actually look to invest in something like this. Our goal is more so that the community gets served with basketball courts, not that we get to run basketball courts for the community. So there is definitely a chance that someone in the public can look at this and think that that might be something that they can invest in and make happen. So we're happy to work on them with that too. And we'd love to be able to be first in line to program it if they do. But that would, I think, probably be the best way forward now is to start looking for partners and see if anyone wants to start working on this and they can take this on. And the city is always willing to look to do that. We could look at partnering with land or something like that. That would probably be more our speed right now. >> Is the council interested in that direction? Yes, I am at least looking for opportunities as they come up. Okay. >> Yeah. I would suggest that we will be updating the parks trails master plan now that we have the new general plan adopted. And so that's probably the prime location to begin that conversation. >> Okay, thank you. >> Thank you. >> We don't have to vote, right? We just agree. >> No, we just have to accept it. >> All right. >> You can accept the report or not. It's really no action needed. >> Okay, we accept you. Travis. >> All right, we'll go to item 9.1a. Thank you. >> Good evening, mayor, members of the council. My name is Jason Hblisco, management assistant to the city manager. This is the second step in a three step process to renew the Redding tourism management business improvement district. The first step was the adoption of resolution of intention on May 21. Tonight's meeting is a public meeting. No action is required. It is to hear any public comment and utilize that for the public hearing, which will be held on July 16. The Redding tourism management business Improvement District incorporates all lodgers within Redding city limits, and all revenue collected is to be used for tourism promotion to benefit those lodgers that are paying into it. Thank you. And I'm available for any questions. Lori Baker is also in attendance. She will be providing public comment. She oversees the Redding tourism marketing group and can answer any questions as well. Thank you. >> All right, we have two for public comment. Does anybody else have questions before we start? Nope. Okay. All right, so we have Todd Jones and Lori Baker. >> Honorable mayor, city council. Thank you. I just want to start off by thanking you for everything you do. There's a lot you need to read through, a lot of things you need to know. The rest of us just kind of know our piece of the world, and you have to try and learn all of it. So I appreciate everything you do. We are. We had a t bid, I'll just shorten it for one year. So there's over 150 t bids out there. And so what it is, is an assessment. The lodging properties decided that really, Redding didn't have enough money to promote itself, to bring visitors in. And we all know the economic impact that comes with that. And so they decided to assess themselves. They figured, you know what, we'll collect the money. And then if we're successful at marketing as well, then Redding also gets more tot. So it may be we are t bid funded and it's a self assessment, but by doing a good job, it also helps the city with the general fund. I did it the first year for one year, and all the t bids go through this process. You try it for one year to see how well it goes, and then you're allowed to do five years, and then you're allowed to do ten years. So we did ten years, and now we're getting ready to renew that. We have 86% of the lodging properties who said yes, they want to continue with this. Right now. What we're doing with the money is mainly groups, promoting groups, trying to help events get larger, invite events in. And the way we try and help local events get larger is by sponsoring them and giving them money. We also go after meetings, tour buses and sports is a big part of our new strategy. We just, it's new for us to only work on events and meetings. And so it took us a while to get a website that set just for that and find all the contacts and what we have to do just for that. And so we did that, and now we're going to be moving on to more sports. But we're out there trying to connect with the right people, targeting to get, as you know, people here to leave their money, then go back home, make some more, and hopefully come back again. So that's the process, what we're going through. The hoteliers have to want to do it, and then we come to you and let you know their thoughts and what they're doing. Every year we do annual report which is then presented to the city, given to the city. I can present or not, but the report's always given to the city with the next plan, and we'll be getting ready to give that to you real soon. The next plan of what we want plan to do, the money we get to spend is not a set amount, so we have to live on the fluctuations, you know, when it dips and when it raises. So that's in a nutshell. >> Can you answer? I had a question about who was on this. Well, it said on here that you guys can increase your assessment rate. And I just wanted to make, I had asked it of staff, but I wanted to make sure the public knows I had asked, you know, who is actually approving the rate increase. I just wanted to make sure that it was the people affected by that rate increase. So could you maybe explain to the public who's on that list and who's self is a self assessment, but who's doing that? >> Okay, so it's a self assessment with all of the properties they elect, who they want to represent them, so they can, it's open meetings to the public, they're open meetings to all the properties, but there's a 16 person board who makes the decisions of, you know, where we go and how we do things. So over ten years, there's a good chance nobody knows what's going to happen over the ten years. You just do the best you can to make educated decisions. And so the attorney told us, you know, you might want to put in there an increase over ten years, so you could do 25% at a time. No more than a full 1% increase over ten years. And it's that board of directors, when they feel they need to increase it, that they can. Right now, they're not talking about increasing it. Right now they don't feel a needle. But over the ten years they may. >> And it's hotel years. So if they're adding a tax, it directly affects their business. So they're not going to just add taxes for no good reason. >> Yeah, and it's an assessment, not a tax. And so, you're right, it affects them. They get to make the decision. But it's a pass through. The visitor pays it. >> Right. >> And it passes through them. Right. >> Okay. That was my question. Thanks. >> Anybody else have a question for Laurie? Okay, thank you, Lori. >> Thank you. >> President Todd Jones. >> Laurie, don't go too far. I'm going to have a question for you when he's finished. All right. >> Good evening, Madam Mayor and council and staff. This is my first time here. Has the new CEO of the Redding chamber of Commerce and Visit Redding, which I'm excited to be a part of. There's a lot of dynamic things happening at the chamber, but visit Redding is certainly one of my favorite ones, ones to work on. But really tonight I'm here to speak on in favor of the T bid. I think it's great that the hotel years came up with this idea years ago and are self assessing themselves to do this. I think Lori has done a great job in recent months as I've been in this role and I've been more involved in what's happening at visit Redding. They've been a great partner for us for supporting our causes, and we're all kind of working in the same direction. Choose Redding. Visit Redding. The EDC, other groups that, the city itself, we're all trying to make our community look better to the outside world. And I think a lot of times people don't understand what goes into that. Obviously, most of the marketing that we both do is going outside of the community, and we're really just trying to highlight our area. So the more resources that we have to do that, the fact that this hoteliers are supporting this, I was able to go to the RTMG meeting today, and it's great to just see, you know, those hoteliers making these decisions on what they want to do collectively to make our community look better. So I'm excited about this. I'm excited about the future of tourism and marketing our region in all these different aspects. And, yeah, I'm just here to support it. So thank you. >> Thanks, Todd. Did you have a question, Councilman? >> Yes, yes. Thank you, mayor. Lori, your board, is it correct that the top four contributors are automatically on the board and then they nominate and vote for the remaining members? >> Yeah. So you're right, it is only lodging properties, because the way the assessment rules work is that those who collect the money it has to benefit them still benefits the whole community. But those who pay more than 4% of the t bid are automatically on with a cap at eight. So if there's less than eight that pay more than 4% of the t bid, then let's say that number six, then there's six there. If there's eight and if there's ten, there's still eight. You have to pick the top eight now whatever else is left. So if you have six, you're going to have twelve on the board. If you have eight, you're going to have 16 on the board. The way the rest of those are elected in is amongst themselves. Now those top few are set aside. They don't get to vote. All the rest vote who they want to represent them on the board. So you have an equal number of larger properties and an equal number of. >> Small properties and your assessment, 1% max. But you can go up to 3%. >> Under this new right now we're at 2%. And so with the 25% increases we can go up to three. >> Up to 3%. I think it's great. I'll make the motion to renew your tourism marketing business improvement district. >> Do you have any comments? >> No. Okay, we have a first. >> I'll be happy to second. >> Okay, we have a first. Well, Councilmember Dacquisto, do you have any comments or does anybody at HaciendaResort and residence lobby have a comment? >> There's no public comment and I will second Mr. Mezzano's motion or third? >> It or third. We'll take them. So we have a first and a second. All those in favor? We're doing a roll call. >> [ CALLING ROLL ] >> 9.5 b.consider professional services agreement for self help home improvement project for administration of Redding electric utilities residential electrification assistance program. >> Good evening, Mayor Audette and council members. My name is Lisa. I am the electric manager for the long term resource planning group, and I'm here tonight to present on our recommendation to contract with the self help home improvement project to administer the residential electrification assistance program. And it's been a while since we've talked about any of our programs, so I plan on doing a little background for you just to kind of give an overview and recap what our current customer programs are. The recommendation to contractorship in 2021, we presented our demand side management integrated resource plan. Through that study, we evaluated our different customer program offerings and ran them through a series of cost tests to determine how they impacted rates, whether they cost effectively reduced carbon, and whether those programs were shifting costs to non participants. Through that evaluation, we found that the energy efficiency measures that we were currently offering actually caused upward rate pressure by paying people to effectively use less of our product. So through that evaluation, we determined that electrification measures solved that problem by reducing the customer's overall utility cost, increasing electric load, which actually increased our revenue and caused downward rate pressure for our customers. Another benefit of that is that instead of people paying pg and e for their gas, they're paying REU for their electric at low power costs. So from that recommendation, council approved our request to transition all of our programs over to electrification measures that resulted in a new program portfolio that focused on building electrification and transportation electrification measures the transportation measures are mainly point of sale vouchers that reduce the cost of electric vehicles and e bikes for income qualified customers. The building electrification programs are traditional rebates. All of those are paid for through either public benefits funds, which are restricted revenues, or low carbon fuel standard funds after about a year of the programs being in place. So in July of last year, we evaluated the programs to see how they were performing and whether customers were participating in the programs. Through that evaluation, we found that the electric vehicle and e bike programs were actually performing pretty well. But we noticed that there was low participation in the building electrification programs and that resulted in a really high administrative cost because of our rebate administration contract. And we also found that there were some barriers to adoption. So from that evaluation we decided to look for ways to improve our programs and better administer those and get those benefits to our customers. One of the areas that we found for improvement was potentially being able to collaborate with local community business organizations that were already offering programs to customers. Through that we could leverage our funds and combine that with federal and state funding. We also found that the city's housing department was already partnering with neighborly to offer rebate administration, so we were able to terminate our contract and partner with them. And we also found that we do need to increase our marketing and outreach and education for those programs that we offer. So with that, we contacted the self Help Home Improvement project, who we partnered with previously to administer our energy efficiency programs, and they are currently offering programs to the community for PG and E. They're offering the LIHEap program and Department of Energy weatherization programs, and we talked to them about potentially partnering and offering electrification measures so we could potentially move some of our funding towards ship and expand our customer program offerings. So through that conversation, we decided to develop this electrification assistance program where we could partner with ship and offer a program that installs electrification measures for income qualified customers. One of the requirements of the program is that any of the upgrades that we do has to result in an overall utility bill savings, meaning we're either taking them completely off of gas and transitioning them to electric or reducing their gas bill. So even though you might see your electric go up, the overall should result in a net savings. The income threshold would match reus current Cares program, which then aligns with the LiHeap and Department of Energy weatherization programs. So categorically, anybody who qualifies for one of the programs would then be eligible for this program. This is also an allowable use of the restricted public benefits funds. So how the program would work is ship would handle the enrollment, confirm eligibility of a customer. They would conduct a home assessment to determine what measures might be eligible for replacement. They would conduct an energy audit then to ensure that any measure modification would result in a total overall savings. They have licensed contractors who would then complete the work, install the measures, and they would educate customers on how to actually use those appliances. So some of the measures that are available are listed here. I won't read through the whole list there, but they include building and transportation measures. If somebody is going to have heating or space, space heating or cooling installed, they will also be eligible for energy efficiency upgrades, and that would be paid for through those federal and state funds. Like I said, the liheap and Department of Energy. So here's sort of an example of what that might look like. So somebody who has a swamp cooler and wall furnace could have a ductless mini split installed. They could transition from a gas gas range to induction gas water heater. And at the bottom we have some total lifecycle carbon savings. So about 56,000 pounds of carbon reduction over the lifetime and an annual savings of about $575. So we're recommending that we contract with ship. They're uniquely qualified to offer this program. They already offer this for, like I said, PG and e and other programs. So they would handle all of the administration of the program, everything from customer enrollment to construction management, reporting, record retention. And we're recommending that we allocate $400,000 annually from our public benefits funds for a three year contract with ship, not to exceed $1.2 million. And so we're asking to authorize the mayor to execute that contract. And that's the end of my presentation. So if you have any questions, let me know. I also have Scott and Haley here from ship if you have any specific questions about the programs. >> Vice Mayor Winter. Thank you very much for that presentation. I think this is a great program. Ship has already proved their effectiveness. They've worked with REu on other programs and this allows some of our lower income people to have lower bills and also shifts energy usage from PG and E to Reu. And I can't help but think that's good for our utility as well. So this is a win win win. And so I would like to make a motion that we approve staff recommendation for REu's electrification assistance program. >> Council member Mezzano, let me ask you a quick question. It's your first time presenting to us. >> It is. >> You wouldn't know it. You did a great job. And I saw your boss in the audience nodding his head with approval and somebody else was taking some video. So go home and watch it again. You did a great job. >> Thank you. >> Exciting stuff because it benefits our community and I learned a little bit here tonight, and I appreciate that. So thank you very much. I will second miss Winter's motion to approve. >> Councilmember Dacquisto. Does anybody at Hacienda in Cantata resort and residences lobby have any comment or do you have any comments? >> I have no comment and there is no public comment. >> I have a question. So is it owners of homes or rent or renters qualified to do this as well? >> Both are qualified, yes. You have to have the approval of the owner if you're going to replace it. Okay. And then I had talked. I'm not a big fan of replacing gas ovens. I think if we're going to upgrade or if we're going to switch that over to electric induction would be better. So is induction. That is an upgrade overall? I'm assuming it uses a lot less energy because it heats exclusively and it only heats when the pan is on there as well. So is that part of the program or is that an option? >> Induction is part of the program. So if we're transitioning somebody from gas, they will automatically get an induction cooktop. >> Does that answer your question? >> Yes. >> Thank you. >> And we are developing the program guidelines. That's one of the deliverables of the contract. Once we have the contract in place, then we'll be able to work with shipp to actually finalize all of those details and we'll make sure that that's included in there. >> And so owner or renter that qualifies under cares, it's just going to have the owner's approval for and then how will we know as far as what their savings were? Do you report back to us after a year? >> Yeah. So that's one of the great things about partnering with ship, because they actually do all of the energy audits and they send us to the, send that to us for every project. So we can save all of that. We could report back to you in a year and let you know how the program's performing. >> I actually, I'm just, I'm not a big fan of getting rid of natural gas, so I, especially if it's all electric, there's a lot of electric things on the grid. So I'm, but I am curious how many people are actually opting in to do that. So could we have like a report of, like, which program people are actually taking advantage of? Is it the, is it the heating? Is it the, and is it just for, is it any REU customer? So it can be an apartment, it could be a resident, you know. >> Yeah. So I believe that it is for any REU customer. Ship would evaluate the customer and make sure that they qualify for the program. So as long as they meet the income qualifications, then it's my understanding that they would be eligible for the program and we can certainly report back. So we have all of that reporting from ship. So anything that you want to see about the program and how it's performing, we can definitely report back. And we're not pushing anybody. So when ship goes out to somebody's home to do the assessment, we're not going to force them into any of those measures. So it is, if you do, we'll hear about it. >> Yeah, I'm sure we'll hear all about it. A year is fine. I would just like to know what people are opting into and what are those? Energy savers for people. So thank you. >> Thank you. >> So we have a first and a second, and we are going to do a roll call for our votes. >> [ CALLING ROLL ] >> Those are three 50 s on the last meeting. All right. Has anybody, we're going to move on to. Thank you, Lisa. We're going to move on to number eleven. Has anybody traveled to a conference or a meeting that was reimbursed at the city's expense, seeing none? >> No. >> So moving on to item 12. Does anybody have an item 12 suggestion? >> Do you have one, Jack? >> No, I was just going to see if we could comment. >> Sure. We'll do that. >> Before we adjourn this weekend, I was able to participate in a function here in the citythat I think people need to know about. It's the half k event that benefits the local charity, and they had a great turnout at one of our parks where they had a permit, and Travis took care of that, and it was a huge success going to local charity. Thank you. >> Was there item 12 for that or no, you just wanted to say that? >> Thank you. Okay, so I have a suggestion for an item twelve. Given the conversation that we've been having about with, well, several conversations about Second Amendment. After our last, maybe a month ago, those comments were made. We obviously have a bunch of legislation coming forward. In my day job, working as a district representative, I work with the DOJ constantly, and so there's quite a bit of legislation coming through. There's a proposed amendment to the US Constitution, and as also someone who teaches constitution, it's always a very big deal to me to discuss, to talk about, and to understand what our rights are and where they come from. So I've been working on a second amendment resolution, and so I want to know if the council is interested in hearing what that is at the next council meeting. >> I guess we can't have more until you tell us. >> I can only talk to you about it up here to the group. So in order to discuss it, we'd have to. I'd have to give it to all of you. I have to discuss it in public. And then you could look at it, and then. Yes or no? >> I would want more input from our attorney before we discuss it. >> So I believe that what's being discussed is in the vein of the various resolutions that have been passed by a number of jurisdictions around essentially just expressing support for the second amendment in its existing form. And I think as long as you're keeping it in terms of the policy structure, on that front, I would ask for an opportunity to review for any legal concerns. But other than that, I think you're within your discretion. >> Just clarification. What I heard was we would bring it back for your consideration, not an item, just for information. So are we bringing back just for information, or would we bring back a resolution for your potential adoption? Information for me. So there would be. So the staff report would not provide the opportunity for the council to adopt that resolution at that meeting. We could go item twelve after that if we wanted to do something. I just want information. Okay. So it would be a no action item with a potential resolution attached that's why we do it. Just want to make sure I bring back what you're requesting. >> The only way to look at it would be to do it as information first. If you agree with it, you like it, then we bring it back again. >> Bring it back later. At a later date. >> Yes, that's fine. >> I just want to make sure. >> Information with the option to do that. Or you want just. >> Yeah, no, certainly we could bring it back. Say this is an informational item and the council should provide direction as to whether or not it comes for adoption. Okay, thank you. I think the intent would be that between the city manager's office and in particular the city attorney's office, that we would have a legally sufficient resolution for you to review for information. >> Does anybody else have any item twelve that they want to know? Okay, then we'll take the opportunity to thank council member Dacquisto and give him the opportunity for his service and to give. This is his last meeting and give him the opportunity to say whatever he'd like to say. >> Well, Michael, I for one have enjoye

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Jun 18, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 86f27885ed1517acfa03cef3a0dd3708. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record