POLISCOPE

The public record

MANATEE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

March 12, 2026- Planning Commission - 2026-03-12 09:00:00 · Transcript

Thursday, March 12, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Manatee County Planning Commission held a meeting to approve minutes, swear in a new commissioner, and review land use applications. The commission addressed a request to continue a resort project and heard a presentation for a proposed commercial development at 7045 North Tamiami Trail.

Why it matters

The commission reviewed a proposal to increase permitted commercial square footage from 66,625 to 134,984 square feet for a 'garage condominium' project, which would change the site's development intensity and traffic impact.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 67,071 characters. The full document is at the source.

just pass everything. >> Good morning. I would like to call the regular scheduled planning commission meeting for March 12th into order. Please rise for the pledge of >> allegiance. I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >> Thank you. We have a swearing in of a new planning commissioner. >> Constitution of the United States and of the state of Florida and you will perform at all times of >> Congratulations. We have minutes to approve for January 15th and February 5th. See, >> we have a motion by Mr. Bower, second by Mr. Ziggler. >> Mr. Bower and a second by Mr. Ziggler. Motion passes seven to zero. Are there any updates to the agenda? >> I have no updates for today's agenda. >> Thank you. Anything from the uh attorney's office? >> Nothing, Mr. Chairman. >> Okay. >> Thank you. Do we want to do the swearing in now? I do. >> Thank you. At this time, let's open up for citizen comments. Please step forward for any future agenda items. >> Not seeing any. I'm going to close his comments. Let's go ahead and uh read item one into record. >> Item one is PDRV19-06 parent R the surf the surf RV Resort LLC owner. This is quasi judicial item with CJ Mills as the case planner. This is district one and the applicant is requesting continuence to April 16th, 2026. >> Thank you. Let's open this up for uh public comment. Not seeing any. I'm closing public comment. Can I get a motion? >> I'll move. >> Second. >> Motion by Mr. Ziggler. >> Second. >> A second by second >> Mr. Stam. >> Yeah. >> Motion passes seven to zero. Can we go ahead and read item number two in please? >> Yes. Item number two is >> uh yes, we should be opening these both together. They're comprehensive plan amendment and a resone for the same site. So I'll read items two and three into the record. >> PA2505 ordinance 26-13 FKA244 SRQLAC Florida LLC comprehensive plan text amendment. Uh this is a legislative item. Lindseay Craig is your planner. This is District 4, amending the Manatee County Comprehensive Plan, providing purpose and intent, providing findings, providing for a privately initiated text amendment to Okay, we've >> we have an emergency. So, we're supposed to pause the meeting and go outside. [laughter] Thanks, Thank you. >> I would like to call the March 12th planning commission back in active. We're looking for the applicants presentation. >> Yes. Let me finish uh reading those in to the record. Sorry, that's where we were um interrupted by the fire alarm. So, PA2505. Uh this is ordinance 2613 SRQLAC Florida LLC comprehensive plan text amendment amending uh the Manatee County Comprehensive Plan providing purpose and intent providing findings providing for a privately initiated text amendment to amend policy 2.14.13D5.13 established per ordinance 1912 formerly known as 1835 PA1809 to increase the permitted commercial square footage from 66 6 625 ft to 134,984 ft of non-residential use commercial on approximately 4.38 acres generally located at 7045 North Tamiami Trail Sarasota in the RO future land use classification. Item number three is PDC18-9 parr SRQ autoport SRQLAC Florida LLC is the owner. This is quaso judicial. For both items, you'll have Lindsey Craig as your planner. And this is amending zoning ordinance PDC-9- uh 18-9 PANZ parg and approving a revised general development plan to increase from 66,625 to 134,984 square feet of commercial uses retaining the plan development commercial zoning district and the overlay districts on approximately 4.38 acres generally located along the north uh the east of North Tammy Mut Trail approximately 1,000 ft south of 69th Avenue West and appro approximately 1,025 ft north of Pearl Avenue. >> Thank you. Can we have the applicant's presentation, please? Welcome for your first time out. So, All right, very good. Thank you. Um, good morning [clears throat] everyone. I'm Scott Ruticil. Um, here representing the applicant in this case. Um, start by introducing our our project team here. We have Sam Logina is a contractor and also part of the ownership group for the project. Uh John Cavoli is our civil on the project. Uh Carrie McNut uh with Monarch Ecology is the environmental scientist. Um and we also have Jason Utley is our traffic consultant. He didn't make the slide uh but he's here with us. All right. This is the project site. Uh it's approximately 4.38 acres located on the east side of US 41 uh just south of Bley's Creek. This is a closer view. Um the project site is actually only the front half of this parcel which you'll see when we get to the um get to the next slides. So this is the future land use map and you can see now where the actual project site is for the commercial portion. It is the about the front half of the site and it has an RO future land use designation. And this is the zoning map. The existing zoning on the site is plan development commercial. So this site was originally approved back in 2019. Um at that time they came in, they asked for the future land use map amendment to go to RO. Um they also at the same time did a reszone to PDC with a general development plan. At that time it was for an auto dealership. Um, and so that's why the square footage is what it is. It's 63 66,000 square feet. Um, what we're requesting today is to modify that D5 limitation to allow four square footage up to 134,984 square ft. Um, and also modify the general development plan to reflect the same square footage. And what's proposed now is a um garage condominium use. So for those that may not be familiar with the concept, it is private garages that are sold to car enthusiasts to keep their vehicles and have, you know, hangout space and meet with other car enthusiasts basically. and it we'll we'll show some pictures later that I think will help kind of explain exactly what that use is. Uh this is the GDP. Uh the one thing I want to point out on the GDP that the project meets all the the code requirements meets or exceeds in terms of setbacks, buffering, open space. We're greatly exceeding the open space requirement. And you may say, well, how do you do that? 135,000 square feet on this site. The 135,000 square feet is because the project is two stories. So, it's a 27 foot height. The footprint is right around that 66,000 square foot number. Um, but the reason that we're asking for the additional is because the unit owners will have the option to build out a second floor within their unit. If that makes any sense. All right, these are some of the project details. Um, again, project significantly exceeding the open space requirements. It's limited to a height of 27 ft. Um, there are no specific approvals being requested. Um, it is a significant reduction in terms of trip generation as compared to the the prior um, auto sales use which we'll we'll get into here a little bit in a in a second. Um, it's also located in the urban core in the urban service area on an urban corridor and in the southwest tiff district. So, it is exactly the type of location that the county is trying to encourage redevelopment in. And this is a clip from our um our trip generation report that was submitted. You can see when you compare the PM peak hour trips, the prior approved use with the auto sales at the 66,000 square ft is 177 PM peak hour trips. Our use even at the 135,000 square ft is 25 peak hour trips. It's just not a very high traffic generator. I think the current proposal within the within the buildings is actually to have 59 total units that would be sold to the to the individual buyers. And these are the elevations to show um what the project will look like. And then we have some renderings that'll give you a better idea. So, this is the outside. This shows from from the exterior what the um what the units look like. This is from an interior that shows a unit that's been built out with some space up above. That's the second floor um that I mentioned earlier. This is just another look at kind of the interior at buildout of of what the type of unit might look like. And again, this is another one that has space above built out by the by the unit owner. And then next we have some photos that show, this is from [clears throat] the motor enclave in Tampa, what some of these units look like when they're actually built out. So you can see there's kind of a wide they they have a lot of latitude when they buy one of these units and they want to put their cars in there and and other than that they can kind of build it out how they how they see fit. Um but really nice uh project and and we think it's a great use uh for this area. It is a very low impact use in terms of, you know, potential impacts on the um nearby um residential uses, which I would assume is why we have the letter of support that was submitted from the Whitfield uh Valentine Manor um association. Any of you that have been on this board for any period of time, that is a very unique thing uh to get that type of support from uh the Whitfield Association. um they requested a stipulation be added related to um preserving the trees along Jungle Way in the right of way and in the buffer area. We have no objection to incorporating their requested stipulation um into the project. So we're requesting your recommendation of approval. Um our team is here to answer any questions you have. And uh with that concludes our presentation. Thank you. >> Thank you. Any questions for the applicant? >> Yeah, I do. [clears throat] >> Go ahead. >> I appreciate the uh the reference to the Woodfield Association letter cuz that's what I was going to ask you about. Um has that been has that stipulation been incorporated or are you going to when will that be incorporated if you haven't already done that? >> Um we can do that today. I mean we're we're offering to stipulate to it now. Um, we don't have any objection to the way it was worded, although I don't know that the county has an arborist right now. But in any event, it, you know, it may need to be amended to say it'll be reviewed by environmental planning staff or whoever would review that. Um, but we're happy to incorporate it today. >> Okay. the um a quick question on the traffic with I'm assuming that the traffic count that was there does not contain if everything was built out and if they were you know if the owners built out obviously we would expect the trip changes to change >> uh I can have Jason come [clears throat] up here but I I think no that is the trip generation is a full buildout calculation I mean it's just not a, you know, we're talking about 59 individual units where you're going to store your cars and and have hangout space basically. It's just not a high traffic generator. >> Okay. >> Okay. I I understand if you're if you're parking a car, that's one thing, but if you're in and out for if you built out and you have to get in and out of there, I would expect there'd be some slight change in the trip generation. Uh, I mean, I guess it depends how often you go to, you know, tinker with your car and and hang out in the unit, right? I mean, >> so is it and again, the buildout [clears throat] that would be for there's no restrictions on staying there and going in and out of there as you please. Correct. >> That's right. I mean, there are restrictions on you can't live there. I mean, it's not a it's not a residential unit, so you can't live there. Um, but but otherwise, no, they can they can come and go. >> Okay. Scott, just real quick, especially on the on the homeowners association, if I remember going back to the previous 2019 approval, I want to say the homeowners association actually did not support the auto sales, you know, application if I'm not mist it was heavily, if I'm not mistaken, opposed by the neighbors. Do you recall that? >> I I don't recall. I wasn't involved at in the project at that time. Um, so no, I I don't know what that what those hearings were like, but I think that would be a safe assumption. >> My memory is because that most eastern portion was going to hold a lot of the vehicles and things like that. So, I'd like to see that support. And then from the traffic and just maybe just for the record, I'm just wondering since you already have a location known in Tampa, >> was that chip generation from Tampa taken into consideration for the chip generations here? >> Uh, I think the answer is [clears throat] probably no. The Tampa Motor Enclave is a little bit different in terms of what they have a track and they have, you know, events and it's a it's a little bit different of a scenario than what we're proposing here. >> That makes sense. >> Jason not late traffic consultant. Um, no, [clears throat] that was not taken into consideration here. We didn't look at the specific trip generation from Tampa on these particular uses. Typically, they look at them as mini warehouses because there's such a low trip generator. The one [clears throat] thing to consider is that um the underlying floor area ratio for this parcel is 1.0 because it's in an urban corridor and the proposed maximum F that we're going to have is 71. And so we're not even getting to the the maximum potential that we could have on the parcel. >> Okay. And then I'm sure I know Tom's here today from staff, but can you guys just talk a little bit about the storm water runoff? See, there's a pond in the north eastern portion, I believe, of the property, but this is pretty close to um important uh waterways that flow out into the Sarasota Bay. So, if you can talk about that for a minute. >> Yeah, John Kavoli, Kaboli Engineering. Um yeah, Tom and I met to go over everything. Uh we're just adjacent to Bully's Creek. We're at the throat of it, but we're on the east side of US 41. So that's where your flood plane model starts. Granted, it's titly influenced, [clears throat] but um the 100redyear flood plane elevation of Bley's Creek without a title influence is elevation three. So there's really no adverse effect that comes up onto the site. The the bigger issue is is because it's a um floodprone area in terms of tidal surge, we're reducing runoff um by over 50% on even the 25-year storm events. Um we've already got the design done and submitted into Swift Mud. Um so there's a significant reduction. So we're working with Tom. We're going to incorporate the new I think it's NOAA uh rainfall events which exceeds uh other projects. So that uh 100red-year storm event I believe is 12.2 in. So we're going way above and beyond what the normal storm water management systems design and entail. Um in addition, we got to meet the new water quality standards for FD. So, we're significantly improving the drainage, not only um coming off of our site, but in the area that we're tying into to get over to Bully's Creek. So, the neighborhood behind us is going to see an improvement in their storm system. >> Okay. >> All right. That's all I have. Thank you. >> Okay. >> Okay. Um just to follow [clears throat] Mr. Bower's comments about the 2019 approval. Um initially the request in 2019 was very similar. They were looking at a [clears throat] you know 130 13,000 square foot there plus 35 38 homes or whatever. um that was approved by the planning commission, but when it got to the board of county commissioners, they kind of questioned that and wanted them to come back and reduce it because again, this is a map amendment, so it's legislative. They said it was not compatible with the the neighborhood. So in uh June it came back as approved for 24 residential units and the 66,625 units. Okay. Uh and now you're asking to go back to what the original request was. But if I understand what you're saying is that the footprint is still around the 66,000, but it's going up and that's going to um caused the increase in square footage. I mean, I'm looking what I'm looking for is rooftop. What I'm looking for is imperviousness. And I mean, I'm sure our staff the imperviousness. Are we increasing the imperviousness um by increasing the uh square footage? >> Right. So that what you said is exactly correct. So the units the units are all two stories and so the only way that we would hit the 135,000 ft is if every unit built out a second floor in it, which as you can see in some of the designs, um let me go back. I mean, kind of the stock unit doesn't come that way necessarily. >> Um, but it was built in to give the unit owners flexibility to have the second level, which adds that [clears throat] square footage to our count. So, yes, that what you said is correct. The actual footprint would be around 6768,000 max. >> Is that including all of the parking lot driveway too? No, that doesn't include drivebys and parking, but obviously the prior approval was a >> vehicle sales, right? So, they would have a very large impervious area. >> That's what I was trying I'm trying to figure out exactly what the square footage >> how the square footage relates to imperousness, >> right? Uh and again, we're proposing 45% open space on the site, which is significant number. I think our our requirement here is 30. So, we're we're well above that open space number. >> Okay. >> Any additional questions? >> Just a quick one. Um since we have the one ingress and egress, those I'm very familiar with these garage condos. People either are racing their cars or showing their cars. So, they trailer in and out. Have we modeled so we're not blocking traffic coming in with trailers? Are trailers able to circulate easily? Can they turn around easily? Jason Utley again, traffic consultant for the applicant. Um, let's go back to the trip generation here. Little hard to see, but [clears throat] so in the in the PM peak hour uh for this that's table one PMP uh the proposed use and that's at the full uh 136,984 square ft. The anticipated total volume of trips is 25 that's coming and going uh into the site. So on a 60-minute for an hour, you're talking about one vehicle coming and going every two minutes. But the important thing to look at here is your uh ingress the the end movement because the exiting movement everything would be stored on site. The end movement is 13. So if we were just to to round to 15 and say that's um you know a quarter of 60 that would be you would be having something like that happening um less than every than every two minutes you know coming into the into the site. So it's going to be a very low trip volume. Uh we feel that this particular project can can easily accommodate any kind of ingressing movement. There will be no no spill back onto US 41. >> Okay. I just know that when there's a race, you have a lot of cars that with trailers. So, within the site itself, any difficulty with trailers circulating? Are they able to maneuver? >> No. Everything should be fine as far as uh circulation, internal circulation should be no problem. No conflicts with um you know larger larger vehicles. Everything all of this when it's designed has to accommodate you know fire trucks. Anyway, coming and going from the site, >> I can directly answer your question. We ran all the different semi trucks and car carriers through the internal site and they turn fine throughout. We have we have widened drive aisles inside the site. So, yeah, it can handle anything. What are they allowed? Maintenance only or can you rebuild a whole car there or what are the limitations? >> No, it's a we have a stipulation. It's only, you know, minor maintenance and repair by the owners. It's no heavy repair uses. Um are there [clears throat] any restrictions on um the owners when they build out their units in terms of u parties and is there a capacity limited um you know I can perhaps envision if there's a major event the number of the units decide the whole parties have you calculated that into into your traffic studies or is that's number one the Second part is uh is there capacity on the um on the property to accommodate visitors that would come to the various units? >> Um So, the guest parking, there are spaces for guest parking. Um, it's not intended to be a um to, you know, for parties and things like that. I think the what Mr. Login was saying was that would be addressed in their covenants when they create the condominium that that they're not going to allow for that type of use. We don't have anything in the zoning ordinance that that limits that, but their intended use is for private, you know, owner usage of these of these units. >> So, I have a couple of questions. Uh, back to what Miss Proser was saying. So, were there will there be trailer storage on site like on the east portion? Do you believe there'll be uh open space [clears throat] for these residents or these uh persons that are going to use this to have outside storage and for an additional fee perhaps? >> I think we have a stipulation that that limits that. So, there's there's no outdoor storage. >> Okay. What will the elevation be of the new site? the final elevation of these new uh pads, will they be higher or the same as what the elevation may have been for the previously proposed uh use being a a car a car lot, let's say. So, thinking about this particular build type, I'm guessing you're going to bring site elevation up at each pad. How much higher? >> Um the FEMA standard, we have to be the finished floors have to be one foot above FEMA elevation, I believe. Tom, correct me if I'm wrong. It's elevation eight. >> Okay. >> So, all the finished floors are set at elevation nine. Anything along there has to meet the same requirements. Um, so we're not going to be any higher than anybody else. [clears throat] Um, in addition, the existing grades on the site, some of them exceed that today. So, yeah, we're just going to have the finished floors at nine and we'll probably have the um dry vials and everything else at elevation eight so that everything drains appropriately. Will there be fuel storage on this particular site for these folks? >> No. >> Will the residents be able to store fuel at a particular capacity limit? >> No. >> So, no cough for dams for any fuel or any any discharge? >> No. Uh, and this may be a staff question, but the elevation that was would have previously been on a car lot, what do you know what that elevation would have been? Would it have been similar to what you're proposing at this site had they been building a car lot at this location? >> Yeah, the same standards apply, like I said, to any building. I mean, the minimum finished floor for any structure, whether it's a sales dealership, a car condo, a single family home, it all has to be at elevation nine. Nobody's going to want to raise it significantly higher because if you're coming up off of US 41, you've got to create that profile to get into the site. And if you elevate that too high, you can't get up into your site. DOT regulates [clears throat] us at a 10% slope coming off of DOT road. So, there's only so high you can go regardless. Beside, why would you want to spend that cost to bring in Phil to unnecessarily raise the site if you're meeting all the FEMA requirements? >> Yeah. What I was getting at is if you're elevating to 9, then your roof line is going to be 35. Previously, if you were a resident in this location, and you were thinking, all right, I got a car lot coming in here. They're going to have probably one building at 35. Now you have eight buildings or or excuse me, >> I think it was five buildings total around there. Well, >> so just thinking about the the line of sight from the resz out towards the commercial. Um alto together they're looking at [clears throat] five buildings now. Um in that's what I was looking at the elevation plus the roof line being >> Yeah. Let me go back to what um Scott said previously. The approval the way it is now is for 66,000 square feet. Our building footprint is about 67,000 square feet. So we're in essence exactly the same. We're just saying to give us the flexibility if a unit owner wants to build it out, we doubled [clears throat] that volume. So realistically, if nobody wants to build a second, you know, floor in there, we're going to be at 67,000 square ft. We just wanted that option because when we submit for the plans and then the unit owners will submit for that interior buildout, building department will track the square footage and we don't want to come back here. We don't want to come back and say, "Hey, look, we've got a second floor we want to put in there." It generates the same number of and see that's that's the one deceiving thing about the traffic study. If you think about it, we're going byund the IT manual requires us to put the square footage into those trip generation calcs. So that those trips are based on the very worstcase scenario. That's 100% buildout 434,000 square ft. Those trips start coming down from there. You go to what is approved right now that 66,000 [clears throat] square feet is what they were going to build and that generates 177 peak trips. So it's a huge reduction impact on the roadway system itself. And then if you think about it the neighbors watching cars go in and out. It's like a and I'd equate this to a self- storage facility. How often does a self- storage facility see somebody come in and get stuff out of their unit? It's kind of random. So these people who have these really high-end expensive cars, if they're in town, they'll go over there and they'll use it. If they're not in town three months out of the year or whatever it might be, they won't be there. So we have to base it on the most intense use based on the IT manual, maximum buildout, maximum intensity, everybody being there using these units at one time. So the numbers even though they're significant reduction in what's currently approved are even a bigger reduction in reality. So those numbers are very very worst case scenario. >> I understand the uh and one of the commissioners mentioned it a little bit earlier but when I look at the proposed uses in the documents [clears throat] and it says it specifically will say uh garage condominiums. It's sort of it's strange when you read condominium, you think you're getting an occupancy permit. You might decide to post up in there for six months out of the year or five months and 29 days. Um I understand from your explanation that that's not the intent of it. I've I'm very familiar with these enclaves. I'm sort of a car guy, so I get it. Um, but just having that term condominium alongside or in conjunction with an auto enclave gives me a little bit of pause when I see that because I'm like, well, is somebody going to change this up later and decide that we're just going to we're going to condo these things because it says it. >> No, we we have a specific stipulation in there that they can't be used as dwelling unit. They can't be used for residential occupancy. >> Understood. Thank you. >> Just really quick. Um, >> I'm not [clears throat] sure if this was answered. Is this a 24-hour like a keypad access? >> Yes. And then so who monitors any violations such as somebody deciding to move in? >> You have condo association. >> Yeah. So the condo units would be they would create a condo association similar to an HOA or another condo association. It would be made up of the unit owners and they would be the ones that would enforce the governing documents. >> Okay. Thank you. And >> just real quick with my colleague statement. So the stipulation number nine talks about effectively there's no parking on the premises other than the parking space specifically mentions trailers and vehicles and so forth. Um, number six, I think is what you're referring to, which is what I like, but effectively, should this plan change in any reason, you got to come back to request the change. Is that correct? >> Yeah. I mean, the the land development code has [clears throat] factors for, you know, what types of changes have to come back to the board and which ones don't. Um but given how low the trip generation is for this any type of change in the use is going to >> that's true >> result in having to come back. So, >> okay. >> All right. >> Okay. >> Thanks, Scott. >> Yep. >> Can we have staff's presentation? Good morning everyone. My name is Lindsay Craig. I'm with development services and I have been sworn. So, this is the SRQ autoport. It's a CPA text and GDP amendment. The site is generally located east of North Tamiami Trail, 1,000 ft south of 69th Avenue and 1,025 ft north of Pearl Avenue. The project area is 4.3 acres and it's a part of the parent parcel that is 8.82 acres. These are the future land use and zoning district maps. The future land use is an RO which retains neighborhood, community and regional serving commercial uses such as um office, public, semi-public, recreational, school uses. It has an F of 0.5. However, this is in the urban corridor. So, the FIR is one. As for the zoning district, this is already plan development commercial and it has a broad range of commercial uses and services to serve the general area in need. The site is in four overlay districts. The first one is the coastal planning overlay which requires an open space of 30% and the applicant is meeting that requirement. It's also in the airport impact overlay which has a restriction on three stories for the building height. Again, the applicant is meeting that requirement as well as it's in the Whitfield residential and it's in the historical and archaeological overlay. As for the history, the 1989 comprehensive plan adoption, the site has always been a split comprehensive plan for two. What we're focusing on is the is it two? Oh, oh, sorry. Um, the 4.3 acres was low intensity office and the other side of the parcel is res 3. And then in 2019 there was a change in the O portion and it was changed to ROR with a specific D5 ordinance to it. As for the zoning district, it was initially plan development office on the 4.3 acres and residential single family one. Then in 2019 the plan development office was changed to plan development commercial. For the CPA text amendment we are focusing on the D5 which is increasing the permittable commercial square footage from 66,625 ft to 134,984 ft. And there is no changes to the already approved schedule of permitted and prohibited uses. And this is a sideby-side comparison of the ordinance. As for the GDP amendment, again, we the applicant is increasing the commercial square footage on a to 134,984 ft for the 59 unit mini warehouse self-s storage facility. There's no change to the access. It's on off of US 41. No change to the storm water pond. However, there are two off-site storm water ponds added to this application. No specific approvals are requested. We have added staff has added specific restrict uh restrictions regarding the use of garage condominiums. And I also wanted to note that the initial building height was 34 feet. So the applicant is limited to two stories 27 ft. And this is what we're focusing on the GDP amendment is this portion. There is one neighborhood workshop and that was virtual on December 11, 2025. Majority of the issues it concerns what exactly are garage condominiums and the maximum building height. This is a list of the portable water infrastructure wastewater and there is no reclaimed water infrastructure in the area of the project. This is just a map of our transportation link analysis. The adopted LOS is D with the future LOS with the project would go down to C. The positive aspects is that the RO encourages neighborhood and community serving commercial uses. The project is west of the FDAB. The proposed change in land use is expected to generate fewer trips on the compared trips of the approved GDP. The site design provides 45.2% open space exceeding the 30% requirement and there are no negative aspects or mitigating measures. I wanted to show the specifics on the stipulations. Oops. Any new or temporary use is prohibited within the general development [clears throat] permit. This is very important. These units cannot be converted into residential uses as well as they are allowed to do minor maintenance but not major maintenance on any of the vehicles within the units. And then this is a stipulation for regarding storm water. The FSP and associ drainage mo modeling shall demonstrate that no adverse impacts will create uh will be created to the neighboring property surrounded to to the site with respect to proposed impacts to the 100-year flood plane. These are the listed policies that are in compliance with the comprehensive plan as well as the land development code sections. And in conclusion, this request may demonstrate consistency with the goals and objectives of and policies of the comprehensive plan in the land development code. And I have I'm here for any questions. >> Thank you. Any questions for staff? >> Yes. Um, since the prior board in 2019 specifically put a lower cap >> on this, what has the applicant done to calm the concerns that that prior board had to allow this 107% increase? the with the history of the site on the original 2019 they initially had the over 134,000 square feet and in between planning commission and the board that's when the initial applicant reduced it to 66,000 square feet because of the surrounding residential concerns. Um the applicant and staff myself has spoke to many of the neighboring residents about this and their big concern was traffic and with this new project it is lowering the generated traffic counts. >> Y couple of um just a couple of clarifications here too. So on the maps that we see there, there is a portion that's still titled Mendes Drive that comes off to the side there that actually um >> right there. Thank you. Direction directional. That is that a county maintained road. I think it's just plotted. >> Good morning. This is Pony Bun for staff. [laughter] >> No, I don't have the data from this. I can double check and back to you. >> Yeah. And again, I think it's more for clarification. And so if we look on the kind of that again the southeast corner there I think Mendes Road coming really from the east in and then on the south side there there's a there's a piece of Mendes Road or Mendes Drive that shows going down to Montgomery. Um again for clarification I don't know if it's county maintained road but I believe this is also going to be part of the property and it will be just some clarification please on Mendes Road. >> Okay I can double check for you. >> Sure. I do want to add, so this property historically was a drive-in church, and it was a dirt road. This was back in the 1950s to the 70s, and they utilized Mendes and Montgomery to drive into the church property for their services. So, it's historically been a dirt road, >> right? And and again for the reason I'm asking for the clarification is it's actually contained on the applicants in the applicant's property as well. >> Yes. It's a bit confusing because we are just focusing on just the GDP amendment is specifically for this portion of the site. >> Yeah. But aren't we talking about them together? That's why I'm just looking for the clarification. I I I mean I know that there's things on each of them, but [clears throat] >> we're not going to have two completely separate presentations. >> Uh when the the more west, sorry, eastern portion comes in for the RS1 RSF um site, the piece that's not shown in the yellow, that will be administratively reviewed for the 24 town 24 residential units when that comes to fruition. And that's >> so today we're only reviewing the portion that's highlighted in yellow. That's what the application covers is that 4.38 acres. So there's no access through the yellow to Menddees >> Drive. I don't know if that helps answer the question. >> No, it doesn't because it's still part of it's still part of the P and maybe the applicant can answer it when they come back up and that's fine. So that we'll we'll we'll let's make sure we have that kind of parking lot off to the side. The other question is um and even though we're only talking about the highlighted yellow area is we need to talk about the storm water in a little more detail here on what exactly is going to happen with the storm water. So we have a >> we have time >> some visibility on what the plan is here with that. So again now later at some point we need to we need to do that. So Rachel, I don't know if now is the time or not, but we need to see some more on the storm water. >> Yes. So we have Tom Genenberger here today to talk to storm water. >> Good morning, Mr. Chair, fellow plan commissioners. For the record, Thomas Gers, public works department, I admin sworn. Um let me start with is there anything in particular with respect to the regulations that apply to this project that can that I can address because otherwise with respect to the internal storm water design itself as far as placement um things of that nature I would defer to the applicant but if there are any specific questions with respect to the storm water conditions or to the regulations that might apply to this project I'd be certainly welcome to trust. >> There was comment from the public talked about some flooding in the area. Uh also its proximity to Sarasota Bay and water quality issues there. Um and that was by question earlier about the the amount of imperousness, rooftop parking, all of that. How is that going to be addressed? Hopefully that's >> certainly. And let me start on water quality since uh Commissioner Brown, you did just bring up water quality. Um with respect to the recently adopted state um storm water rule with pertains particularly to water quality. Let me start with some of these slides if I can have the overhead camera please. what I have um what I'm presenting now is from the D with respect to um the water quality um impairments and also as with respect to delineation of the outstanding Florida waters which in this case this particular map exhibit here identifies Sarasota Bay as an outstanding Florida water and what I will re refer to and I have um identified the project area here with that star is and as the applicant noted this project does lie within the Bully's Creek wershed. Bully's Creek itself does drain out into Sarasota Bay which is an outstanding Florida waters. Uh with respect to the state storm water rule, the applicant will need to address the the impairments which are associated with Bully's Creek which there are two separate impairments that are associated with Bully's Creek. One's for bacterial >> and then the other is other impairment is associated with mercury. So the applicant through their environmental resource permitting through the state would have to address the requirements of the state storm water rule in conjunction with the design and permitting of this project. Uh with respect to flooding, thank you. Appreciate you zooming that out for me. Um with respect to flooding as note as was noted earlier this project is within a floodprone area associated with Bway Creek. There is flood delineation. This particular mapping here is identifying the freshwater component of flood inundation which was identified through the bullies creek wershed management plan. Now this freshwater component of flooding the stages 100red-year stages associated with the freshwater component of flooding are much lower than what is identified on the FEMA flood insurance rate maps. So, for instance, up here in the um to the north of the site, north of the project area along US 41 at the bridge crossing itself for Bully's Creek, uh the Bullies Creek wershed management plan identifies the 100redyear stage at 3.84T whereas the firm, the flood insurance rate map identifies the base flood elevation at 9.2 feet in AVD. Um, as was brought up and discussed with the applicant, the applicant will have to address flood protection requirements through the flood plane ordinance and through sections 801 and 802 of the land development code. And at minimum, uh, as was stated by the engineer of record, we'll bring any of those buildings one foot above the base flood elevation requirement. Um, am I addressing all those points or were there any other um in points of inquiry that I need to address? one >> sorry one thing that came to mind and maybe this [clears throat] will be an applicant but from your perspective when they looked at the storm water um because what was new to me uh in reading this is the potential for housing units on the eastern property >> um so from a stormwater perspective are you aware Where do you know if the 24 homes that potentially could come back to us for approval, was that taken to an account for the storm water related to this particular application of the commercial? >> I think Commissioner Bower, that might be best addressed by the applicant, but what I would say that's fine. What I >> just didn't know if you knew or not. >> Certainly. Okay. But what I would say is with respect to what is reflected on the GDP as far as those stormwater facilities, to my knowledge, it would account for those needs associated with this present development with the the U facility and then essentially reser reserving the storm water capacity that's needed overall either for that portion for this existing portion of the development or for that in future. Now granted that is subject to any further amendment through the app through a further application should there should the should an applicant be brought forward application be brought forward excuse me as far as any development to the east. Um what I would say though it at this parent time this is a single individual parcel. So as far as those storm water facilities they would presently be under one ownership. Now should any subsequent development occur in the future and the parent parcel be subdivided then at that point there would be a requirement for dedication of drainage easements essentially reserving or creating a non-exclusive nature to where any of those stormware facilities if they're serving essentially what is the parent parcel today would be included within drainage easements for the operation and maintenance in the future. >> I I can't think of a situation or scenario, but let's say we we approve this portion today, especially as it relates to the storm water and later the 24 or whatever units come into play. There's no short um like shortcuts being taken here. Correct. I do want to clarify the 24 units is still on the GDP portion of the site. Correct. It is not on the vacant portion of the site. So if the applicant wanted to come back for that vacant eastern portion, it is >> well >> they might they might come in and they have to abide by the maximum permitted um >> density under that future land use category. So it may not be 24 units. So from a stormwater perspective, let's just say they just kept saying the same as it relates to the 24 units. >> Do they have to would they be allowed to meet the storm water requirements as previously approved or do they have to meet the storm water requirements in today's restrictions? Commissioner Bower, some of those requirements are considering state regulations. So good example being the state storm water rule as far as water quality standards. Those have certainly ex >> they're not grandfathered in per those that are applicable today as compared to in the past. Yes. that would also apply uh with respect to county regulation because obviously when we're speaking of general development plan we're not speaking of a final engineering design that final engineering design is not reviewed until a final site plan construction plan are submitted. So at the time the final site plan construction plan are submitted that application is required to meet present county requirements county regulations. >> Any other questions for staff? [clears throat] >> Yeah. So uh thank you so much for that information. I I wanted to just confirm as of now on this particular site. There is no retention at all in this preliminary plan or at least the the design there is no retention on this site whatsoever. So all the water that is on all of these impervious surfaces is being diverted to another location which from what I gather I can't find where the outfalls are for that diverted water on this parcel. Not talking about the the adjacent parcel that they may dig a hole and divert water to at some point. I'm just talking about right here. The roads down the center of these enclaves or these >> these buildings are just diverted. There's no drainage that's moving to uh some outflow or outfall location on either Bley's Creek or across 41. There's none of that in this plan. Right. If we could go back to the slide presentation that Lindsay um provided earlier with respect to the GDP exhibit and unfortunately it's probably not going to be the easiest thing to identify just from the slide but there is a as far as engineering intent there is engineering intent which reflects a stormwater detention pond up in the northernmost portion of this GDP especially within the yellow there is a storm water detention pond that's up in the northwestern or northern portion of the project. And then there are two uh storm water detention ponds that are labeled as offsite which are outside of the yellow cordon which are shown in the eastern portion of this project. Now with this just being the general development plan, the general development plan does not reflect the internal piping. It does [clears throat] not reflect the outfall. But yes, those would be included with the final site plan. And and yes, the intent would be for the the runoff associated with the proposed improvements to be collected internally to be conveyed to those proposed storm water detention facilities for water quality treatment and attenuation of runoff and to comply with the storm water conditions that are placed in the staff report with respect to meeting the flow reduction requirement for Bully's Creek for uh addressing Um no Atlas 14 requirements uh rainfall data requirements uh for addressing uh demonstrating no adverse impact with respect to drainage is creating offsite as in particular to neighboring properties surrounding the this site. those additional details as far as the additional D design details, the additional engineering details would be reflected on the final site plan and construction plan. >> I understand I and thanks for the clarification. I I missed that part where there was storm water retention in that that top corner. It just it it just slipped my uh my mind there for a second. Is there enough retention in just that pond alone to handle the runoff and then the mitigation uh once it you know topples over or does this intertwine these projects to the retention on the other piece parcel that they own? >> I think that's an applicant's question. Okay, that one. >> Yes. U Mendes drives the county mitten mitten or is mitten by the colony. >> Okay. Okay. >> Thank you. >> Is there any more questions? Yes sir. >> Simple question. The stipulation that uh staff mentioned about uh 10 parking plan must be provided to demonstrate accessibility to the site. What does this plan entail? Who's it come to? Who approves this plan? >> This would be on the PSP and the FSP. if that provide a parking plan. >> Okay. >> Yes. And just one more thing for clarification. Can we go back to the uh slide that does the comparison of previous versus now? >> Oh, um I think it was okay this one. Mhm. >> So in the previous version, 66,000 and change square feet was approved >> for the building up to 35 ft. Correct. >> Yeah, it went to right up to 30. >> So when you add the buildup, it's actually potentially higher than 35 ft. Mhm. >> What I'm hearing today is the reason that we're here today is because they want to have the ability of the inside portion of this building with the same footprint effectively for more square footage because when you add that another level, you're adding technically square footage, but it's the same footprint. >> The previous I don't have it in my slideshow. Previous GDP had a different site plan of the building. This is a little bit different including five buildings. Before it was one I think one or two buildings. >> Gotcha. Okay. And then if they just wanted to build it today, all they have to do is come to us with a site plan and storm water and all those other. So they can do all those things >> today. So, at the end of the day, we're just talking about potentially how they're building out separate buildings and being able to build inside the building itself. That technically adds to the square footage. >> Yes, they had to come back. The applicant had to come back here because we have the increase of the commercial square footage and as staff, we wanted to be very restrict on garage condominiums and thus the listed stipulations. I looked into several projects in the area and compared some of the stipulations. We have to follow by code as for noise. Um if there's any chemicals in the area, they can't have any of the gasoline in any of the units. It's a safety concern. If there's any issues, it has to be addressed with the condo association. And as county, we cannot be involved in that. But we h we can have code enforcement come out and they can um write a a violation. >> And can you clarify as it relates to the potential residential units that the applicant would actually have to come back to us I think for two main reasons. One would be traffic generation based off of that and two would be how the storm water would be handled as relates to the addition of homes. >> So there is this the new added stipulation for storm water. See forgive me I kind of perused through that. stipulation. Well, they're already approved for the 24, so it wouldn't come back to us, >> but the 24 is still on that GDP amendment. >> They wouldn't be able to construct that if they're constructing this fully built, if that makes sense. >> Say that again. So, just for clarification, in yellow is the allowed 134,000 and change square feet plus the 24. Based off of the site plan, there is no room to put the 24 allowed units. [clears throat] That was just what was a previously approved on the D5 ordinance. Well, I guess my issue for clarity is that and maybe the applicant can talk a little bit about that, but right now the trip generations is completely confined to the commercial. >> Yes. >> If somehow there was residential >> because it is approved. I don't You're telling me that even though it's approved, there's no room for it. So, I guess that begs the question, why have that in there? If we're changing this whole plan and amendment as it is, why have it? >> We can work with staff if they want to and keep that for future, if they want to, I don't years down the line, change this, and reconstruct homes. It's just to have an allowed use. [clears throat] However, if there's any changes to a site plan, everything has to come back to the planning commission and the board. So the site plan applies to the whole property, not just the yellow. >> It's applied to the the yellow because this is within the GDP amendments. There >> you see my confusion in terms of the site plan in the yellow. >> Yes, ma'am. >> Sorry. >> Sorry. Um so I want to make sure that everyone understands the area in yellow is what's for the plan development commercial application. The area outside of yellow is currently zoned RSF3. So if the developer wanted to develop under RSF3 for those 24 home town uh residential dwelling units that were approved per per this D5 provision, then they could do that administratively. >> And I think what uh Lindsay is trying to say is we don't actually know if it fits. We're not engineers to say if the single family product would fit. I guess they could come in with something that is very very small but it would have to meet all of those zoning regulations and if they didn't then they would elect to come back as plan development residential to be in front of the board. >> To also add this new added step the FSP in a drainage mo uh modeling sh uh shall demonstrate no adverse impacts will be created for the neighboring properties. So that means that the storm offsite storm water ponds would be taken more of a priority first based off of their calculations. They might have to enlarge the storm water ponds and based off of the um current zoning of that eastern portion. They still have to abide the setbacks um the buffering etc. So it really depends when it comes in for that application. But the storm water portion is a priority. >> Okay. Can we open it up for public comments >> on item two? Do we do any callin ones or? >> No, just a public comment in person on both. >> Right. Sounds cool. Not seeing any. I'm going to close public comment. Uh questions for the applicant on storm water if the ponds are big enough to support the residential or and you will be using those ponds yourself. >> Sure. Let me uh let me pull up our presentation again so we can Thank you. Okay. So, this is the GDP. the GDP. While the GDP only is for the front portion of the site, we are we put the storm water ponds on the rear to show what the intent was and that is that we're going to have storm water ponds on the rear portion of the property that will um that will handle the storm water both for the motor enclave piece as well as you know the potential residential development in the rear. Um the 24 units is confusing. It's confusing to me, too. Uh, I don't really understand why it's in there, to be honest, because the comp plan amendment only covers the front portion of the site and and we're not we're not intending to do any residential there. We just kept it because it was in there. Um, my guess is it was in there as a mistake because they thought it intended to cover the entire 8 acres or maybe at one point the map amendment did cover the entire eight and a half acres. Um but the rear portion of the site is um RSF3. So you're talking about maybe 10 or 11 units back there. They and that zoning was specifically kept to create a buffer transition area that would be consistent with the zoning that's around it and the houses that are there. I don't know if I covered everything that was asked there. There were a few questions. >> Are you aware whether or not the HOA had the concept of understanding that there could still be residential in that southeast quadrant? >> Yes. Yes. They understand that that that piece has the potential to be developed like all the houses around it. It's also accessed on that side. So, it doesn't get accessed through the commercial piece. Um there are existing roadways there that connect to it on the from the from the back. >> Okay. >> Yes, sir. >> Yeah. Just wanted to make sure I'm I think I'm completely clear here. The northwest corner is not enough retention and therefore the other parcel is your retention. Correct. That's that's >> a combination >> for that stipulation. So, uh, that that's what I was really trying to get at is it is reliant on the eastern portions retention to meet the stipulation for storm water retention as it's written or you can you can store it all there in the northwest in that in that small piece. >> It's not as simple of a question as you're asking. So, when you have an overall piece, the ideal is to master plan it. Um the and you can see in the letter that there were concerns about uh flooding on some of the adjacent streets in the subdivision. The outfall for that whole area that goes to Bully's Creek is and I can't point but it's in that northern tip. >> I'm looking at a GIS at the same time. So that's >> okay. Well, if you look at our pond that's in the northern tip, the outfall is there. the control structure will be there and the pipe that goes across um >> Mellan Drive >> Mellan Drive is installed and in will be tying into that. >> Okay. >> So, here's the point of all of this. The rear storm system, which is designed or shown on that plan to serve the rear portion, is going to use the front portion as its outfall so that we don't tie into Jungle Way and overt tax their storm system. So the further downstream we get the discharge point from any development, the overall net improvement you see. So, not only are we holding back more water, but we're moving our outfall points down toward the lowest part on Bully's Creek, thus improving the whole system. So, it's it's not that one is standalone from the other. It's the two are working in unison in order to benefit the overall area. >> So, your intention, I guess, is to slope to the northwest to retain and then pump down, meaning the whole property site. Yeah. slope slope to the northwest. So those if you do >> choose to put retention on the eastern portion, you expect them to be dry for the majority of the time, right? Because you want water running northwest. >> Correct. Everything is going to flow through the commercial site and then out to Bley's Creek at the furthest most downstream point, taking all the discharge that currently goes to Jungle Way and Mellin, eliminating that and putting it at the outfall. So it'll improve the entire drainage of the whole area. >> Thank you. And then one last question. Is there proposed buffers along the back parcel basically where this this hashed line is? U I I heard you mentioned buffers earlier. Are you planning on fencing that? I know you may not have to get into the detail now, but is that going to be a buffer there between the rear portion of that building and the eastern portion of the site or is that going to remain open? And I'm only concerned because that's a county road on Mendes leading directly up to the back of your commercial site. Um, is what are the are the buffers going to go around the perimeter of both sites or will you be installing a buffer at the this the separation of those two sites? >> And that's probably not for storm water, but it's more or less for site planning. You said you were going to put buffers, but is that around the perimeter? Are you going to biseect it? >> It's it's around the commercial site. So, there's a 20 foot buffer shown in the rear of the of the commercial piece. >> So, there's going to be a fence line there between this this back vacant property fence on the plan as well. >> Thank you. >> Yes, sir. >> Yeah. um on the GDP um looking at the environmental study you know again I I recognize uh those of us that have been around for many years remember the church there so it's impacted site already so the only thing that came up was the osprey nest >> is there any intention of I mean looking at the site plan it looks like that nest could be impacted uh of relocating or put an artificial nest or something Yeah, let me >> let me let Carrie come up and >> Okay, >> good morning, commissioners. Carrie Mcnut with Monarch Ecology and I have been sworn. Um, yeah, so we do have um a total of three osprey nests on site. Um, I swung by the site two days ago just to check on the status. Two of them currently are active nests with osprey sitting in the nest. um the one on the north side where there's a proposed pond um as well as on the very south side. Um [clears throat] and then there's another one that is kind of in the kind of in the middle of the site. That one is inactive currently. Um we did overlay um the last couple days we were discussing this. We did overlay the site plan with the Osprey nest locations to kind of see if we could potentially preserve, you know, void the nest. Um because they were pretty close or partially within the 15t um buffer on for both the north and the south nest. Um the way the site plan overlays right now, it looks like we would not be able to Oh, thank you. Um, if you could, we have a the site plan overlaid if you could. Yeah. >> Okay. You can There you go. So, I'll just kind of point. So, this is the south um nest

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • March 12, 2026- Planning Commission - 2026-03-12 09:00:00 — Transcript

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 86df3b9589403fd393f72c9d97cabf9f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record