POLISCOPE

The public record

MANATEE COUNTY SCHOOLS · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech published

School Board Workshop

Friday, January 24, 2025 · School board meeting record

The 30-second read

Summary pending

Meeting-wide summary not available

No meeting-wide AI summary is available yet. The item-by-item board record below uses the published agenda materials.

Why it matters

The board digest below separates planned business from source-backed outcomes.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

Watch the meeting The recording is not indexed to individual votes.

1 recorded vote0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (1)

approved

Executive Session — unanimous

School district

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 130,965 stored characters

It's time to recap last >> Good morning, everybody. Welcome 1/24/2025. School board became workshop. What officially call this meeting to order move along in the gym that there's no agenda minutes to add public comment is item number 3. There is no public comments. So we're jump right into our content. First item up here on our agenda is the audit Committee quarterly board review, Daniels here to give us on a committee report. So take a look. Thank you very much. >> CHAIRMAN Members thanks cases just basically going to be a quick update what we're at. We've got an engagement letter come to us from purpose, Gray who is going to be the outside external auditors for next year. Probably going to come to you on the board meeting in FEBRUARY. 25th, but it is for the internal accounts only will have the auditor general here doing the full financial audit this year. They're in the first of a five-year contract. So the next year they will do both. But again that meets with what was in their proposal aboard the it's been to the audit committee has been to. The attorney ready to come to you at the right time. As we finish up with cri. We've got. Something's waiting on this. Changing their name contracted to go through so they can start signing reports again. The sale surtax report is ready to send That is not yet been signed by the it and purchasing. We'll try and get that cleared out as they finish up the next several months. We're looking to have them be completed. Finished reporting to on the meeting in MAY. If that's not possible, we MAY have them be reporting to us in the JULY meeting right after the end of the fiscal that we're looking at right now, they're in human resources, compliance. It's in process. We're looking at doing a review of the facilities and then. Following up on all the open items from the previous items proposed action will be able to close that off as we started with the new committee. Other new internal auditor want to be rsm were supposed to be looking at their letter in the MARCH meeting. We get processed. First thing we're asking them to do when they come in do the risk assessment every 5 years you're required to do a full deep dive risk. Assessments of the first thing you're going to do is come in and making everybody upset with them. It going to be going so deep into seller, smiles, we won't won't come in and tell them what to do until we've looked at. What are the risks? Were the analysis? Make sure we do it right come forward with too, are looking at where there's potential problems. Not just do things to do things. Rise gonna finish the MARCH committee meeting where like I said, looking at that engagement letter, we're also going to do a detail review. We're in the process for each of us looking at some of the charter schools and looking at are they can form, are they there? We're looking at the reports that they're issuing. We're looking at the way the valuing their assets. We're not saying it's right or wrong. We're looking for consistency. So when our staff goes in the value 8 swat, there's potential risk for Or not. They've got apples to apples, not any work. It's better than it used to be, but they're still I think potential. We haven't looked with what we're doing. We're just trying to make sure they're implementing the new standards. Only says and revenue recognition or the 2 elements and and my work I've seen. Schools. Churches some other into the slow to adopt those even though they've already been required to. Going to check on them. We've got some membership changes, MR. Wagner, who's been with is going to retire as JUNE. 30th 2025. He's a let's have a second family and life. And there are graduating from high school and his wife told him time for us to go travel and it's yeah, we're going to be sorry to see him that I am a. Pleased to have had his counsel. It's been a very wise and help and help put some of these reports and things through. We are seeking new members of working with MR. Kennedy on one in particular. I don't know if we want have talked to her yet. Hopefully have one place quickly. We're always looking for new candidates. If you talk to somebody, please call me be glad to talk. Follow our newest that board members come from kpmg. And it's nice to have another auditor in there. So the questions get asked, we can. This is why it's here. Works real that open to any questions or to get out of your way and the to dive into the main program. Jim, thanks for the update. And if you could, you mentioned it. But if you could go into a little bit of detail for the board. >> About the change at cr. I was taking place just just in case. I mean, it's it's essentially a formality, in my opinion. But just in case. It comes up. The board understands like what what's happening in cr and certainly. >> Cri was purchased by an equity. What they've done is they've taken the pure audit. Part of their practice. And they've got to see our it, which is audit side and everything else. Consulting side packed side. Internal audit side is all under a new. Banner. And a new umbrella lifts a new legal entity. And before. They'll let our people or anybody else signed a report. They want us to have accepted the new legal name for them. Its been through the attorneys office. It's been purchasing. Understand it signed and they're working on a few details. So I'm hoping to have the sale surtax report for you guys to have been get out here. Real quickly. But it's something that's happening in the industry. Cherry Becker, who was our previous external auditor. Also been the same type of the transaction and the impact on that was Sarasota County, I understand had selected them. Is there new Auditor? And then when this came through and the changes that were involved, they be selected selected somebody else. So I mean, it's a its an impact on the society is users. You always want to make sure if you're signing something. Professionally that. You know, to the right format and the right name. It's like you said that's more of a technicality than anything else for us. The internal auditor, external auditor, we've got coming in purpose. Cray is not part of an equity fund. Got a lot of young partners and they apparently done the transition one generation to another. Is where a lot of these type of transactions come from. The retiring partners got to get paid. Well, they brought in a bunch of new ones. And it seems to me my looking at it, we're going to have regional Florida from looking at us in the next 5 years, which is gives us like doing stuff at home. But the hope that answers your question that going to die make sure the port was aware it was covered really well. >> Laura caregiver really good explanation to the committee on the legal process. Wise. And house and how to looking forward make it was at least hit the ground. Should be the financial world is going around. Is private equity fund purchasing. Yeah. Pretty anything and everything >> any other important work other then we just had a real brief conversation that. Some of allocations that cri has. But we want to use that perhaps portion of those locations in the safe Act. >> My understanding there is some and we will not be using that were budgeted. All Use of those is that the board's direction and see fog has been target. We've had a short on talked to this glitter. Get hurt, contact with the purchasing and see if we can get that process gauge of a letter of some sort. Right. Okay. >> Because I know they have been asking for that kind of. Engagement their committee as well. So >> I don't know what do. Better about financial impact? Could clarify which this school year see? Fog is asking to have I'm guessing that him a new 1, right, right. 24 25 know. Yes. >> Yeah. That you can year rep. Current school year right? Because their report is almost done for the last one. So we to be time. Good time to get them Vollmer, right? And right. Exactly. And then we're again. Look out the new. On a tour as it's coming afterward. I was he right? Have the allocations might as well take advantage of with thief never had that before. And I think this is a good opportunity for them have that exposure. >> Thank you. It's prominent just who >> As you're probably aware, we approve the act for it. Tuesday night's meeting and I didn't get a chance to say that again. But Rachel and your team, I want to appreciate I notice numbers of hours of move work and your team. So thank you for that. And you and your team are Reynolds. Well, and the second set of eyes. The auditors like working here because 2 things, number one is very, really and adjusting entry. >> and the other thing the staff here writes their own financial statements. A lot of districts this size and smaller. The auditor has to come in and physically helped write it. Rachel's team. That magnificent job. It's really it's really well I was one of the intro. Really interesting to see coming. Demographics and size of the district attorney 55 56,000 students. Now, according to the report, said I never started working with the district back in JUNE with Superintendent. Doing some things, turn a lot of styles looking at this with come up. Changes between now and then it just it's like driving down the street that we can't. We can't why the streets past month. >> And channel That could one more thing. This is just a request. And skip Wagner's is retiring. If we could do just that short recognition for him at the that the JUNE meeting. >> Because Gibson on that. Committee for at least 4 or 5 years, been 2 cycles. Yeah. Okay. To 2 cycles to terms. For that Thank you. >> Thank all. Talk >> so I just want make sure I understand the state is coming in to do there is that every 3 year 3 years they resist a lot of When will they be showing up on property? >> Probably be getting around APRIL when they're doing the risk assessment and when they're getting ready to get started, though, hold an entrance conference with the superintendents myself and some staff. >> And that's the office used to work for him yet that correct? Their operational audit will start first because they have the financials the way to after that, closing of the JUNE 30. But so they actually do an operational audit. The sides, the financial and single audit. Could you define those percent on a single also an operation? It will be a separate report and basically some procedures compliance like laws and rules, regulations requirements in literally every area that they have acess risk that they apply to for their for all the districts that happening, operational audits and that for that fiscal year and then a separate report like the big varying 89 page at they audit that as well get we'll get to a lot of reports from them >> And then a cra coming in again this year to do All right. I mean, he's finishing up what we were have under the previous contract. JUNE 30th. Will be finished and JUNE 30th and we'll have the new internal auditors rsm beginning that risk assessment on JULY one. >> when I hear the word internal audit, what that means to me is account that the different schools is that the school in turn account. What that is. That's just not the people, the cleric. And it's a very question. We have. >> Engage cri to do things like the sales tax or tax audit. You various areas we've been into purchasing, we've been into. Various areas. We went over to the financial aid over t I. They're a professional firm that does work as a. Instead of staff. Use them for your internal work credit. Now, the internal accounts, all the schools, it's done by the external auditor we have at times you see our I t Co in and do some additional stuff with high school principal changes or when there's been some issues in the past with somebody that in the way they were terminated just to do a little more detail than what they're going to do when they pass through the entire group. Schools. We're not doing that this year. Everything looks well that the reports are coming in. We didn't feel we needed to have them spend that time this year. And in addition to what Jerry Becker did, we went through their report, their management items and, you know, felt it was good So. I hope that answered your question there. Intially staff for the district to do. Functions. That an internal staff would do. >> And if we had, the state statute requires that we that we have an internal auditor or that we have a company that does is function forces it's 8. There's some functions that we have to do right? Of the size of the nature of what we're doing, especially with the sales tax on And now the sea got it. We felt it's been. >> Engaging a professional firm that does those type of services. Rather than just the generic from to come in. That was why we went through that procedure to make selections. And chosen a new for we know the firm to come in and maybe change flavor of what we're doing a little bit. They essentially work for you. Threw us. >> So the audit to cherry how are they different from the audits? The additive that big. >> 189 page report financial just this is the financial results. Look more that procedures. Operationally like she's talking about to a certain extent. We try to come out with group of recommendations that improves the function that we're looking at. And one of the things it's really nice about coming in with the new auditor is. We've been through a lot of the areas of the district and they're working well, And that's where the wreaths were not spending our entire budget. We re 5, 2, look at where we can do something positive, do something effective without just going out spending time. And we'll be doing that going forward. >> the those but apparently did this year, and Terry back or not, are auditing companies anymore, as you said, not changed as well. The voting on while so who is our external auditors are named Purvis Gray. >> And they're they're a player down Bill. Are the ones that have come on the 25th FEBRUARY. At least that's and to schedule this time the other one is are sent out of Orlando that are going to be doing the internal work essentially working for you. We're going to get their engagement better in the MARCH meeting to look at and purchasing you. Get ready to come to you. >> That they both start JULY one. >> So when this current contract is over, in the goes to end of JUNE. Cherry Booker can see are still performing workforce, but one that's >> they should be done. They're world. And that's what I'm saying. We're trying to get cri to The reports and everything. And still the follow-up. So we hit JULY one. Wouldn't okay. I don't like carry over and under numbers so become company replacing again. Their name its name Rs him. >> art there. An out growth of the Rsm Mcgladrey group was the number 5 cpa firm in the country and then the one replacing Terry Baker. It is called purpose. Gray. Regional. Cpa firm out of Gainesville, Tallahassee, Orlando office here they close. They do what? 600 schools districts around think not just in Florida that that's too many. I'm sorry at numbers. Incorrect art. 600 districts. But they do it quite a large number Florida districts. We will be a large one for them. They do a lot of the smaller districts, but they have very it's very experienced after all they do with the government a So Purvis group will be doing something similar to what the state. >> It's coming in to do, right? Yes, sir. Okay. And then the other company that replaced the r I will be doing more specific audits within. Where we see risk within the within the organization. Right. Some report specific areas we have a sales tax report mandated. Now we're going to have the act, which is mandated. So there's certain areas. There's certain other areas that some of the statutes say we need to look at through the year will do that, And then. >> Look at that risk assessment and see. Where we have potential problems. >> purpose great doesn't in your will. Kind of financial audit. Is sir? And the state comes every 3 years and does they're finding their operation along n and a financial audit. Those purpose grade to an operational audit or is it just finding none of that nature that would be if there's operational issues. That's where. >> assume would be engaged to go. Take a look at specific areas we've in the past where. We've done and look see jurors and come back recommended change me. 2 things to have better controls and transparency. >> But just overall calm. And I think it's a good thing that have. Internal audit function is kind of guided toward specific risk areas. We have an annual financial audit from an outside company. It's not associated with the school system and then that the state comes in every 3 years. And that and one of those years, there's actually a backup kind of trying to confirm what the end of what it says. Yes, I think that's that's a good structure. Hopefully keep financially fiscally sound. I trust the people that are running the show. But doesn't just like in their portion of it? It's Pektor general. The shows up one day and said show me your books, Like Ronald Reagan said trust. But but there you Thank you for your time, CHAIRMAN. That's all If know Daniel, thank you very much. We tell you, we're joined rest of your day. >> Yes, stay warm with >> I either to is the 24. 25 fast Progress. Marie King monitoring 2 for mathematics. And that by coming you, we'll forgive it to MISTER >> Good Morning, CHAIRMAN And board members, as I sure did. Our last We typically do these progress monitoring reports to the board at that full board meetings. But of course, we had the graduation data that came out. And so we did that on Tuesday night. Particular data set progress monitor to for is a little more complex, really for 2 reasons. The first again, our sons took these tests in DECEMBER and then we use the break to kind of turn the data and have been working with the schools to to, you know, make adjustments to instruction and move forward. Keep in mind that when our students took these assessments in DECEMBER. They have lost a full 7 days of instruction. Due to the cumulative. You know, Helene, in Milton absences because our makeup days are on on the hind end of the calendar. And we're a full week of instruction behind. Where were we typically would be. So the data is a bit noisier there. And then also there were some methodology changes that we chose to make this year. That impacts how you look at the data in the aggregate. So for that reason, this is going to be a little bit more of an in-depth presentation. And my recommendation board members is that we asked questions slide by slide instead of waiting for the end because there's a lot of contacts. And if you just take the numbers without the context, you can head in the wrong direction. There's good news in this data. There are some work to do in this data, but you have to really get the context. It's a a little bit of a noisy or data MR. Jensen is going to take the lead as her deputy superintendent for instruction. But sitting next to him is MISTER McCarthy, our assessment and research director in dob. >> We are so fortunate to have him his brilliance. Every time I ask him to pull a data set together, what I get back is 3 steps than what envisioned. And so it's always enlightening. But he'll he'll help provide some context if you have questions. And as you know, we've got an awesome curriculum team or to curriculum directors in elementary and secondary and the folks who work for them, would love to be here today, but we ask that they continue their work in schools so that we don't lose more time supporting teachers and I'll turn over MISTER Genson, MR. Mccarthy we look forward to walk them through the data with. Absolutely. Good morning. Carrie Cho board member Super Intendent Lyceum. >> We're thrilled to be with you. Say like that for whites on said this is a a really comprehensive look at our or fast assessment testing as well as our pm to math results MR. Mccarthy's team has put together just some really. Deep Fantastic ways looking at data that like Dr Weiss on said can be a little noisy because of the way math acceleration works in the state. So we're gonna kind of walk you through. What we normally do is kind of an overview of fast and the progress monitors get into what we do in math acceleration in the district and then go great, banned by great bands looking at the data and and kind of explaining what we're seeing in the data. And then at the end of the presentation will also share next steps. What power using this data to make the instructional decisions really drive improvement across our system. For the second semester. So when been the first few slides talking through fast Rick Hartley, I can talk about some center Director of Assessment. Accountability Research will take that away. We're chair board superintendent point so we have 3 major testing windows as part of fast in Florida. There's the fall one which we do in SEPTEMBER. >> There's the DECEMBER and JANUARY one, which we're finishing up right now. He called pm 2 and then they'll be one again in the spring. My apartment. We work with. So work with the schools for all testing. So start off training in the fall. Kind of lay out here we think are the best testing. When does with within each state testing when it was they give us like 2 month long window. Sometimes to try to look strategically is it better test after ela before Christmas or after Christmas? And we're trying to I work with the schools and figure out what works best of that. Best answer, their questions that they come up and kind of support every one of the schools as they're dealing with. Student pulled out of cell phone or what else happened during testing is not supposed to try to get as good the testing in a stray shun and is used for data for teachers and schools district to look at it do. There 2 major testing platforms. Florida uses as part of their fast testing system. The biggest one, can assessment that's in the. From at least it's 3, 3, 8, mathematics. That's the one we've Ford's been using for years. The testing in transition and continuing news now, 3 times here. Instead, then in k through 2 testing as well as in Pre-k for early literacy. We use the star Renaissance platforms as part of the fast testing system as well. To ask questions as we're going to get >> So real quick on this for Florida already getting into question. I guess I'm surprised that there's not Us state. Testing system. These are actually private companies and we can choose like there's companies out. There's testing for >> Yes, the state put out a contract or a a request for bids or whatever. A few years ago. And I don't think anybody at the time could provide everything. And so the they actually worked out a contract with Camden but partnered up with Renaissance to do the grade levels. Campion was not at the time of to But to answer your question, these are used by every district in state. So this is the the selection for the vendors who provide this service and its use throughout the entire state. Every district. >> question because if we use renaissance can yeah for testing and then Broward County uses. MR. And MR. Jones's. We know that equivalent, whatever, you know, all in the same place That's figure. Thank you. That's real quick. Evan, I assume since we have that flexibility in the testing windows. >> Due to the hurricane days off. We. Tended to push everything to the end of that window. There are tradeoffs. So especially when you get the winter window where there's winter break the middle of it. >> Which is not true. The question is, do you? Discussion we have every year when we look at scheduling, especially for pm 2 in winners, is it better to scheduled before break? What students haven't had 2 weeks off, too completely checkout. Forget everything that their top until that point or to wait until the end of the window. So you've got time for says knowledge, knowledge still stored There's also a number of other assessments being given during that window. We have district benchmark assessments being given in different subject areas. >> Teachers are getting final exams in certain subjects. And so MR. Mccarthy's team. Really tries to taking all of those different variables and produce an annual assessment calendar that that works for schools because we know enormous burden. All this assessment places on our teachers, our students and our administrative staff. And so it's trying to to meet the needs of our schools. Wall, administering the assessments we need to administer and collecting the data we need to collect really, too. I would add. Props to our support employees. And some of those roles because when as a teacher out, pulled off the regular duty to go help. Procter, some exams. One of the question to I have is the obviously 3rd through 10th grade ela and math. Those are happening. Correct me if I'm wrong, those are happening between pm to 01:00pm 3, mostly. Pm 3. I mean, MAY of 2025 feels like a spiel, especially. It always felt like it started leaking Mid-MARCH. So So the weapon they want to the fast And I think actually, couple years before that they compress. So you couldn't start spring testing until MAY. So really the only thing that happens before MAY at this point or before MAY 1st. Any anything that's like 3 through 10 are part of the school grades for those specifically can't start on MAY first got frightening will start in APRIL because it takes a little longer for those adaptive programs, too. Explore everybody's writing responses as well as k through to open slightly early, but not much ok, thank you If I can have the other, really did the testing windows other consideration is time to intervene right? And so the advantage of giving the math in DECEMBER, even though we're 7 days of instruction behind is that. >> Our principals and teachers came back. On JANUARY 6, ready to go with intervention plans in place for math, which is the area where more hours of instruction can have a larger impact on student growth scores right versus reading. Re you're dealing with more global skills. And I again, there's tradeoffs in every district. Does it a little differently but I think we're in a good place board members when you consider the calendar. And we had that we had all the principals together on Tuesday and really the guidance that we're providing is that in. They're in >> The critical segment right now, we're in day 4 of the 19 day. Sprint. >> 2 Presidents Day, all uninterrupted instructional time and 3 of us former classroom teachers know that MARCH and APRIL is just a series of starts and stops in the classroom. Right now we're in the sweet spot. And so we feel like our math teachers have all the data they need to have made those adjustments. And as I told the principals this this 19 day window is 11% of the school year. But if they're on it, if they're in the zone, we we can get 25% of our games out of this. Sprint to PRESIDENT State. So that's why getting that math in before the holidays was so important. I'm sure some of you have seen this slide a lot of times. This is the state's computer adaptive testing. >> Picture biggest things we kind of want to talk about. The computer adaptive testing. And so every dot on this slide represents a question. If it's green, it's just question of Stewart got That's right. It's in London. It wrong. And the big thing that I think most people don't put notice right away as the blue bars behind every question all while. The test is looking at whether since gay question, right, trying to decide to take harder question. Easy question next. Try to figure out where they are. It's also the background coming up, what kind of a potential score estimate for each student kind of trying to narrow in on where it thinks the student actually is for that kind of final score estimate at the end of the tests that spits out for our teachers and parents and students to see. You can see those blue bars that MR. Mccarthy reference getting smaller and smaller as the 10th test progresses. >> Representing greater confidence in the students score output. At the end of the adaptive assessment. >> So one of questions that teachers and parents Ok, so as the computer adaptive testing, meaning that it changes. The questions based on student responses. That right, a makes them easier or harder based on student responses from the beginning to the end. So the concerns that teachers and parents have. Is okay? Your your your kids doing? Okay. They've got lots of greens going on here. But then the questions get harder and harder and harder. And is this going to affect the students score? Because now they're getting a lot more reds as we get to the top of middle of this chart. Does that mean now their scores going to go down? Is it going to affect their ability to move on to the next grade level? Into effect, their grades and all those questions because of the computer is making the test harder. As the child is taking that test, it seems to be moving the finishing line while they're in the middle of the race. That's a wonderful question. I think. You know, compared after testing and Mr, McCarthy can give you a more technical explanation at all ever be able to do. You can kind of see it on this chart, right? As >> the blue, the Blue Bar kind of represents the range of possibilities for the students scoring where that question could kind of be pulled from in the range of difficulty. Let's say And so as the test progresses, that kind of range of difficulty get smaller and smaller and smaller. So, yes, all those students are getting tougher questions, which MAY represent that they're doing extremely well on the test a reason why we have to coach our students to be resilient on these tests, but also understand that just because something is hard doesn't mean you're you're performing poorly. But question that you get wrong at the end, you can see moves you down less. And this is a great segue into the next couple slides. Then a question you get wrong in the beginning. Question that. What I think is no good. I was I would that would have same way. >> Good. So. >> After hearing the conversation. My brain says something to the effect of well, you could get. 8 out of 10 moderate. These questions right and get a 3. Well, you might only get 5 out 10. Hard questions, right? And get it to Is that a possibility over? You know, like so that when they. >> When they're scoring the test, they're looking at a couple things a question about the question. Difficult like Harper's easy questions. After they first minister. Every question these are that field tested here before take that results from how students did on that. They look at how difficult question and how many students got it right. And then they also like to look at things like what is the correlation between whether student got this question right now? They did overall. And so a question that your high overall high students get right more often than your low students get right. As a good correlation. There is probably a better question differentiating whether student what a student knows and so going based on all the information they give every question kind of different point values. Ford's overall test scores. So. So like if you got. Let usually if you get less a couple of hard questions, right? They might outweigh a lot of easy questions being answered right? Not just. >> You know, in your packet of a not yes, I kind of going back to that, too. >> student being concerned that they're missing quest. We got that question a lot from especially our higher performing cheating since that are used to 90 or 100% in every does take for cause that has to set usually in medium time. For what you're looking for in a class, not the Sarah Lee, this one where the rain just goes away from the easiest possible question. They could think of up to something. At same stretch point of like the best way to think about is kind of I think why it's difficult sometimes for art. Families to grasp as we're all used to give a 10 question quiz each questions with the point you get 9 out of 10, you get an a in a 90% right? >> But that's not the way this assessment built. Like you might have a question that's worth 0.1 points because it's very easy and you might have a very hard question that's worth 4 points and far outweighs the other point. So the questions like this, Rick Hartley center kind of waited for difficulty or and that helps inform the score generation model. >> figured that was the case. Is that part of questions got more points to right. And then some format of the deal. Super secret inside a lot about somewhere. Understand it or it. >> It's pretty there's some pretty standard as formulas out there. There's different ways that their applied pick that. All right. Thank like to remind everyone that MR. Mccarthy is an economics major it's pretty of >> To your point of one question might be worth point. Of a point where the other might be worth 4 point. Oh, we're communicating that to our students. I'm hoping that that so they understand, you know, it's going to be easy, but you're going heart grants to okay. I just want to make sure I guess I don't remember hearing before in us. But TikTok platform. Great explanation because I wasn't sure how that was measured because I see chart in on how it's all waited out. But that's a better formation. 2 men. >> I think that's the benefit of occasionally taking the time to do this in a workshop format. So, yes, it dig deeper into some of these. All right. Some of these pieces, but MR. Mccarthy's team produces training documents for teachers and for administrators that the hopes that share those with student says mom to try to just again, it's not about what's worth. You know, this number of points. What's with that number of points? I think it's about resiliency mine site and putting in your best effort and not being discouraged. So it's about building those skills and students and also just helping them understand what they're going to see, what they're going to expect. Our teachers do a wonderful job of making sure. They connect, you know, as we're reading multiple sources and we're writing an essay that, you know, synthesizing those services and comparing and contrasting them. We do that. We produce is amazing. Artifact in class. But then how is this knowledge that we've gained done in class going to be assessed at the end of the year? And how do help students understand how to translate what we just did into the end of your expectations. That's a big MR. James Point about the assessment companies. State puts out It's just like we put out bids here. >> And the 2 that they selected for this particular one is in Arlington, Virginia, because I wanted to know things. And the other one says and 2 different U.S. Bases, one Wisconsin Rapids, Wisconsin, and Bloomington, Minnesota. I think this interesting, know. We're actually using our up Fun fact. >> Before MISTER Genson goes the next slide. I think conversation about resiliency is really important. This These are tests of math and English language arts. They are also tests of stamina and endurance. And you know, if I if I could suddenly be every parent in this school district into a massive auditorium, that's what we would talk about, that those conversations at home. A parent of a middle school student right? This MAY be the most boring passage you've ever read, but you got to get through it and you've got to answer the question and move on because you're in search of that question. Is charting the path for the rest of the test. And so we've got to teach. All of that, too. The advantage of the computer adaptive testing, Mr. Kennedy's earlier question, this is why we can get all of pm 3 done in MAY have scores back to parents. Much more quickly then before and in a normal year, why we now will get school grades by JUNE 30th instead of AUGUST or SEPTEMBER or OCTOBER or so in the aggregate, the system works well, but We've got to help families understand that that growth mindset, it's half of this battle. Gentleman. I just can't go back. To the schedule again. We're not the schedule, but the but the sequence of the So progress monitoring questions. Those are provided by the state. Every kid in the state's thinking, the same progress monitoring 1, 2, 3, right? Okay. Something obviously with the fastest thing. So district benchmarks that I call test because still like 8 or 10 questions, district benchmarks, their law a little longer a little longer, ok? So since we now have pm 1, 2, 3, data. Have we thought about or considered like we needed getting? Think we reduce benchmark testing. We 1, 2, or 3 Yeah. So what that at the first year of fast, we did kind of overlap. The ela and math. We no longer do any la your math benchmarks and the state. >> Assessed areas at benchmark for do at this point are algebra one and geometry which the state does not include progress monitoring. And the crazy. So we have our fast assessments and we really rely on the U.S. Results of these to inform our instruction. >> Like this regard, he said we're not delivering additional assessments in these areas. Areas like algebra, geometry, U.S. History, civics biology, things that don't have progress monitoring assessments. Were we still use those benchmarks as our internal probe responder makes a lot of sense. Okay. Lot has happened since I've been gone. State's changed a lot in this transition to the best. And you that. Center's. I appreciate that. I know that some them questions, but I appreciate walk me through it. And again, I think. Because we have 2 new board members on the board. We haven't done a one of these data presentation since you've joined the board. I think this is a great format to go through this. Thank you. To freshen on that. So. I was at the end of testing. The I was doing juniors and seniors. So we were doing fast. Fast. Started I was with kids who needed still need the fsa to graduate. When I when left teaching so I haven't been trained in fast as a teacher. But one of the things that my colleagues were frequently talk about was how many, how much testing they're now doing they were phasing out the fsa and I took it with a huge grain of salt when the can be so much less testing. Another topic. But anyway, so they say it's gonna be less testing. You're not going do is test at the end of the year and now we're testing them 3 times during the year instead of once at the end of the year, which seems like a lot more testing to me. So how much time do these tests actually take? I mean, we've sent him down for fsa be 90 minutes for this and it would 100 that. It would be whatever. How long were these tests? So that's sort of been a couple of kind of tradeoffs of back and forth since the switch. So like said we're not doing that district benchmarks these anymore. So we cut out of district assessments which was part of the state's goal. >> Doing statewide So it's a payoff their we traded one for the out of there. One of the other big goals of the state. Fast testing. Transition was too shrink. Number of testing days, So instead like it used to be a delay, the 10th grade ela tests are tonight for the latest east basically be 3 days testing through. Yeah. As you had a writing section that had to be one that you got the first section of la, the second every second for section reads. Second second, reading, but which also made it a nightmare to try to get some of those can court scores in for graduates because of a MISS One out They'll have a Now we're down one day of testing it so much easier to catch a kit for one day testing than it is for 3 separate days. >> Now on time Wise. >> These are slightly shorter recommended Windows. Ice are recommended testing times, I say recommended because immediate happy through the year of our first you're done playing fast. They went from. Here's how long session is to telling us, you know what, students can work up to the end of the day. The finished the test. Okay. So it will get 90 minutes. And then I was like, well, you know, they're not getting done in time. So we'll just let him. >> Yeah. So it's which I think is there that they're looking at the trade off of. We do want to know what student actually nose or their relative ability to other students. Because if you're trying to look at how they compare to other students, you just lock down the test time Aniston that can't finish a test that time that that tells you something too. They want to know what did actually knows on the standards and benchmarks. State asking the student said the vast majority of students finish within that kind of 90 minute window. Then students who do need the extra time. >> One either because of accommodations just because the student feels like they need extra time on the exam they can take through the rest of the think I think that's less stressful. Have a net o'clock. It's very Okay. So kind of continuing the conversation around how adaptive testing works. Said they're kind of this, both figure out what, whether they should get a harder or easier question that's going on. >> There's a square estimate going on. And I want to show you the slide. You can see this course meant some of this light be put the U.S. Left side of it, the kind where the levels would fall. Really just kind of want to point out with this. If you look at it, it's a massive level. One range small to range, tiny level 3 range, slightly larger over 4 years that a mask, all 5 range because state achievement levels are it's originally were assigned on normal distribution or bell curve where most of your students are that really tiny cut the middle for level 3. And it's just really long tails out the site with very few students at level. One level 5 in theory. So the other thing this is also showing really well as in general students start with that kind of it. He's easy to meet him. Easy question. When they go into the computer adaptive test and you can see here they get the question right? They go up to a much harder sit at the tests like, okay, we know they're not down here at the bottom of the scale. Let's get much harder question. Kind of try figure out the up there. Are they somewhere So just kind of stuff for a while. It just jumps or it high low high low to try to narrow and where a student is and you see can see it's moving a lot more early on in the test. I think getting much smaller shifts later on the test as it gets sure where things are. Too. I would imagine over the course of the test it's going to be able to weed out. Student was a good guess or Couple tough ones because by the end 2030, questions, they'll have and nobody can maintain that kind of success rate randomly. It's much harder to guess he's an ace to question. >> You here in a conversation, forget what I heard that. Right now during our be into that, maybe we'll get into this. But there are questions on the test and we had to cover. The subject matter is that it seems like fractions or something. You know, I am. >> That will be coming slide specifically about 3rd grade this year. But yes, these whole year test. So even s the student takes an AUGUST before they been exposed to almost any of the material and worse is all of benchmarks that will be covered the year. And that course. And so it's a great indicator of kind of starting point into this is a great midpoint. But these intended to be used as like an evaluation of how the students done in the course because even with the data we're showing you today, the student still has more than half a year left of learning to do. And so this is a kind of a point in time and then our teachers and students can use this to inform instruction, make moves to support students through the rest of the year. In the lead-up to the pm 3, which is the High Stakes assessment. So this is not intended to be used as a as a comprehensive if your level to 01:00pm to than your level 2 at the end of the year. That's not how how it works. We do see growth throughout the course of the year as the student choirs were content. Plus Thank you. This slide kind of similar to the last slide, but we really want to show here as what happens. The student. This is their first couple questions with a computer that the test so. Saying it's not like the classic 10 question quiz isn't as we think of where everything's worth equal points, especially when that the test and it's adapting to what you've answered correctly versus incorrectly. If you MISS Your first couple questions that score estimate in the background going to drop. You're going to get easier and easier lower value questions that are not going to help you get back up to a higher score. Effectively lead with the computer that the test, those first questions become. They're not like technically waited, but because of how the test works here, there more an act will that some of the questions are later think it's kind of hard to take your way back It's like. This will come into important talk about fractions so we really going to stop here to talk about the state family portal. One of the state's big goals with this, which the fast and the kind of regular state progress monitoring was to be able to communicate to both especially the parents a little more frequently and hopefully from the state like consistently clearly from the state feedback on how students are doing. For any of our parents in the district. I want if you go into our focus, parent portal on the homepage of it, you'll see it kind of the middle right above hired students, grades and attendance. There's a little link to state state Florida state assessments or something. And click see through to the state family portal, has one. Very specific information on how you stunted on each parts. Think I think it's going to store every single years worth of fast as it goes forward. And then there are places where they can play can see. On this kind of body of knowledge or standard or benchmark, student id like this and you can kind of really and their specific feedback for your students. I can work home and things like that. The parents get the results very quickly. Administration. Are they able to access that from there? >> Phones, another really has computers. >> Yeah. So just looking at a pay phone the other day to shut my life. Yeah. You get into click through family portal from focus it worked really well on the fun again tonight. So not everything is yeah, that's compatible phone as it is. Peterson wanted to it kind of part of that. One thing we kind of wanted to talk about it and understanding and talked to. That this is. Mid-year results pm one pm 2 results the States not expecting a student to be fully mastered at math will master standards yet this is kind of a checkpoint along the way to see what information a student knows already what unfinished learnings they have coming up and kind of look at that stuff. So it's not. Everyone's yet. Calls make it through stuff survey that parents really worried their students, not already at a level 04:05pm, one pm 2. And it's not that doesn't mean a thing if want to because your state has been, you have a chance to learn information yet it's it's coming later on. So on >> After the yellow highlighted areas says these results are for informational purposes. Only should not be used to identify areas that MAY need additional has should should be used. Should my tenure. These results for informational purposes only and should be used to identify year should be used to fire. That MAY additional instruction and support. Can you give us an example? Let's say Jimmy Jones scores it 1.5 or whatever. So what? What happens? What does a teacher do with Jerry Jones escort is? >> What happened? That's a great question. But as you to producing a lot of the data you'll see today, which is really like global data, kind of rolled up across our whole district, which when it comes to classroom decision-making isn't particularly useful, MR. Mccarthy also produces and teachers have access to in the portal as well. Benchmark level data for their students as they can see all the students in their class and they can say, you know, Johnny struggled on number these number sense and operations benchmarks, but did really well on these algae break. Reasoning, months. And so then they can identify specific benchmarks that the students struggled with and maybe the whole class struggled with in general. And then we teach those poll small groups for intervention. That's when that like granular level of student and benchmark data, that is the most useful for instructional purposes. But the raw level like you identified on its own isn't particularly useful to Taylor instruction with. So we do that. MR. Machar, that does that. For us kind of. >> Takes makes it more useful for teachers. Let's put it that way. Absolutely. Think that I was hopeful that what I heard that that's what we were doing, that literally we can take the scores. And like you said, breaking out did well infractions didn't do well or well enough to break the questions. And then almost almost individually target students or small groups of figure out what they need. That's really good. >> The last slide and identify some of the things we're doing moving forward in the One of those is like our curriculum team, like Dr Watson said absolutely amazing. They've created a number of small little. I've question formative assessments that are aligned to each of benchmarks. A couple of them each that are in our computer based platform. And so when a teacher says, ok, I have students or a whole class that have struggled with this particular benchmark. Let me do some re teaching on it. And then let's just get them on a short little 5 question. Check on it. And then I can see if they've made progress from where they were at. So that's kind of the instructional cycle. We really want our schools to be an is. All right. We've identified based on pm to some areas of need. Let's do some remediation read teaching and then let's check where we're at and make next steps from there. Thank you. Just here. Point here, the last sentence. >> does say these results should not big. Consider student achievement destinations. So that's for Think it should not. >> think I just want to say that I appreciate the work your team does too dissect all of this data with that say they just gave us the basics and we have to dissect it ourselves. And when you've got 150 students, that's a lot of data to set >> Today. That that that was hard like, ok, so. >> You know, these kids did business because of wellness. And you've got look at all the different components and and to have you guys break that down for the teachers that really a fabulous asset. And I really appreciate that work. You we've been working hard every year to try to get more and more like the word actionable because I remember my first. I think just put that the percentage students at each achievement. That means, nothing but Sunday So we're trying slowly trying to dig as far down as possible. So it's something that they actually can on instruction to make decisions at the classroom level, not just. >> So we can look at things in the district. Yeah. Appreciate that very much. Like you said, Ms Skelton. It's really important that our teachers and school leaders understand. >> Like how this data works, right and how we arrive at this data and how it can be used. But as far hand calculating the data and taking their time to do that, we want them teaching. We want them working students and so whatever we can do leadership team to take that responsibility off teacher teachers so they can use their expertise to put into action is I think the best and highest use of their time. Makes it faster for the teachers to to just get right to it. They don't have to spend a week 15. >> Before they can put it into action. >> It's so this is an example of one of the state parent reports that's well that's available in the portal with apparent clicks through it. And generally get some information about this or what the score means, how that's court. There's 2 other the other students at the school, district or the state. And I really like on this slide particular about the candidates for family section. Was especially if it's a student in grades 3 through 5. That section with includes information on. Are they eligible for the new world's reading initiative? That gives them book every month. So not great, but they can get a free monthly book sent to them help them improve their reading are they eligible for that tutoring scholarship? The kind of the same thing, kind of helpful resources And this is another one of the state, one of the state parent reports really hear the most notable part is over on right in the green section that can achieve in all the Scripts Inc. This is where it starts drilling down very specifically and what a student to try communicate just didn't want to apparently just their student actually knows. What specific things to how how there. MAY have come in at this achievement level. Why are they wanted this to a lot of what thinks they know what things they not know. >> I just question. So this is what? A parent can see. Children schools. So I don't have that kind of access. Do this. Going to look at what their student doing a child. This is exactly what they say. This is what they would see in grades. >> 3 through 10, right? That's what right. Okay. They're still really useful things k 2 general, though, be they'll beat at. So here's your overall thing. And it'll be like the country are detailed report. Click through it. It'll give you a They'll be options category results or things like that. You can at It's a ridiculous number of specifics about how your student debt on specific it And this is exactly teachers seeing them out This is the school. Kind of. Such school. Great components for 24. 25 veteran talking about everything in orange, all the Sweden. Rpm to We should have all the light blue stuff. Reading things coming up in a couple weeks. They see how the other map data will eventually feed into the school. Great. Evan learning gains what to check Point says that game measure between so currently under statute, the gains are measured from spring to spring. So the spring of last year to spring of this year, some pm 3 to correct? Yes, you know. It's So take over from here as we start getting into data like Doctor Weiss on few important considerations for the data and let's say these excuses, but always important context because like any data set, it's important, especially that aside around I'm kind of human performance and inhuman systems. Context is really important so that we don't misinterpret data or make false assumptions based on what we see in the data. So likewise on said we did lose 7 net instructional day. So that's almost 10% of the first semester due to hurricane impacts and of course, students and many other districts of a new seat state comparison data lost different number of days to hurricane and that's all the way down to 0. So that's going to affect comparisons to state results and just be aware of that. And then, of course, and we'll go over this in detail this year. We changed. Our practice is about the assignment of accelerated students to grade level tests on the next few slides. Say exactly what that means after we get through the k wanted to data which hasn't changed as far as that. That piece. But we are essentially testing are accelerated students in different grade level tests now, which wasn't the practice last year and makes year to year comparison data very noisy, which is that noisy data. Doctor, why something referencing. So the k one into data which given in the Renaissance Star platform is the most the least. Noisy data will say because the platform hasn't changed the sting bands of students are taking the same assessment year-over-year. And as we go through the slides with you, there's really 2 types of slides that you'll see for each set of great bands. You'll see the growth within the year. So this is an example of one of those slides. You see pm one, dc pm 2. And then you see the change pm 01:02pm, to and so this is a slide that shows the growth from the first from AUGUST, essentially through DECEMBER early DECEMBER when they took this this assessment on the left-hand side, you see the current performance levels. So you see the students who scored the percent since he scored level one percent students who scored level too. And then the percentage and level 3, 4, and 5 aggregated there that would be on grade level and above students. And that's kind of the way a lot of these slides will look. But the next couple of slides after go through the 2 slides for each, I'm kind of growth within the year. So this is growth within the year. The next ones will show growth year to year. So how did we pm to last year versus pm to this year? So you'll see both. You said this is within the year growth obviously we have some work to do to build a build some skills. As far as growth goes relative to the state. But I would also say that when we see impacted learning time in our school. So when we lose learning time in our schools, we see disproportionate impact on our youngest learners. I feel like our k warning to students are more affected by 5 days out of 8th 9th 10009th grader is you'll kind of see that and some of the assessment that. And so I think there is some of that lost learning time. The first semester it's a lines to this growth data. MR. Johnson >> Knowing many of our kids coming in, I'm not ready for for kindergarten, but they haven't done pk. We've already seen the data vpk could come in way ahead compared to those kids aren't able to access Does that also affect the scores as well? Get growth because they're not coming in already having done this stuff before and vpk. So now they're they struggle more is you know, with the missing of school, just is there any indication of that are? I mean, as you know, walking kindergarten classrooms. >> Kindergarten teachers are magical because they they are they take students who come in and don't know how to do school at all. And unlike quarter they teach those kids have to do school. And it's it's pretty remarkable. The transformation that happens in kindergarten classrooms. I would say, yes, we would see kids come in stronger with a greater enrollment and pre k the greater numbers ins. I mean, that that is very clear. But I would also say that, you know, when we look at rpm, one data were pretty closely aligned to the state on our students coming in k one and 2. And it's really up the growth we see pm 01:00pm to on this line. And in that case, we are lagging a little bit in those grades. And I would say again, I think some of the lost learning Thank you. I call that first part of kindergartner that had not going to be okay. >> As teaching them classroom kit. Pants up. Yeah. That's the biggest part. I think you not harping on that 2 people that the bk is so important because of time you get to k you've already mastered a lot of those things sell. Okay. It's >> and then for each of breakdowns as well. We show district operated schools versus charter operated schools, comparison data. And so you can see Small differences in performance between the district operated schools in the charter schools when it comes to growth from pm 01:02pm, to on On the k 2 assessments. Particularly in second So the next slide is that year to year comparisons. And this is where we look at what we were. We were as a district last year on our 23, 24 pm 2 and this year versus are 24 25 game 2. See the state change. The district's change. The comparison data the

Minutes January 24, 2025 School Board of Manatee County Workshop - 10:00 AM Walter Miller School Support Center Board Room Times Indicated are Approximate 1. CALL TO ORDER Attendee Name Status Dr. Jason C. Wysong, Superintendent Rachel Sellers, Deputy Superintendent of Business Services Derek Jensen, Deputy Superintendent of Instructional Services Joseph Ranaldi, Deputy Superintendent of Operations Chad Choate, Chair Cindy Spray, Vice-Chair Heather Felton, Board Member Charles Kennedy, Board Member Richard Tatem, Board Member Stephen Dye, Board Attorney Kevin Pendley, General Counsel Present 2. AGENDA AMENDMENTS 3. PUBLIC COMMENTS There was no request for public comment. 4. WORKSHOP 4.1 Audit Committee Quarterly Board Review Mr. James Daniel, Audit Committee Chairman, provided the quarterly board review from the Audit Committee. His update included the following: • Status of CRI Engagements o Sales Surtax Report o Human Resources Compliance o Facilities • Purvis and Gray - new district internal auditor • RSM, - new external auditor o First request is the 5-year risk assessment • Audit Committee Membership o Changes and candidates The Board asked questions and held discussion. After a question posed by Board Member Kennedy, Mr. Daniel provided clarification regarding an internal name change within Carr Riggs & Ingram LLC. Vice-Chair Spray noted the request of the Citizen Financial Oversight Committee (CFOC) to use unassigned funds for CRI to help complete the FY 2024/2025 Millage annual report. Mr. Daniel stated that an update to the engagement letter was being worked on to allow the request.

Board Member Tatem requested additional information on the distinction between an external auditor and an internal auditor, as well as the legal requirements and conditions for hiring these services. Mr. Dye, Board Attorney, arrived at the meeting at 10:17 AM. 4.2. 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results Superintendent Wysong provided an overview of the 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results, and introduced Mr. Derek Jensen, Deputy Superintendent of Instruction and Mr. Evan McCarthy, Director of Research and Assessment. Mr. Jensen and Mr. McCarthy provided a presentation to the Board. Included in the presentation were the following topics: 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Math Assessment Results Computer Adaptive Testing Family Portal FAST Progress Monitoring FAST Progress Monitoring: Parent Reports School Grade Components 2024-2025 Considerations SDMC PM2 Math Results Kg-2nd Grade SDMC Middle School Math Progression Traditional Pathway Most Accelerated Pathway SDMC PM2 Above Grade Level Testing in Accelerated Math SDMC PM2 Accelerated Math Results 3rd -5th Grade 6th-8th Grade Semester 2 Next Steps The School Board asked questions and held discussions throughout the presentation. Additional information was provided by Superintendent Wysong. Mr. Kevin Pendley, General Counsel stated for the record that there was a need to request an Executive Session regarding litigation during the next recess. The motion to recess and conduct the Executive Session was made by Board Member Kennedy and Seconded by Vice-Chair Spray; the motion carried unanimously. Chair Choate recessed the Workshop at 11:58 AM and reconvened the meeting at 1:01 PM. 4.3. Discussion Regarding Real Property Acquisition Superintendent Wysong introduced Mr. Joseph Ranaldi, Deputy Superintendent of Operations and Mr. Michael Pendley, Executive Planner of Construction Services. Mr. Ranaldi noted an amendment would be coming before the board at the February 11 meeting pertaining to the Rye Ranch property acquisition. Mr. Pendley highlighted the following amendments to the contract: • Changes to the Boundary of Property • Lower purchase price of property • Adjustment of property improvements and timeframes associated with changes • Provision to approve $1.9 M to fill and grade the property • Allow for a Charitable donation in return for the reduced price • Changes to included fencing Mr. Pendley noted that there was a last point of conversation to the contract, and requested Board input prior to final drafting and signing of the contract.

• Request for naming rights of the elementary school to be built on the land purchased o Property owner request to name school ‘Rye Ranch Elementary School’ Board members asked questions and held discussion. Chair Choate noted his support of naming the school Rye Ranch Elementary School, but did not support placing the name as a line item in the contract. Other Board Members agreed with the Chair’s stance on the subject. After a question posed by Board Member Kennedy and Felton, clarification to the naming policy was provided by Mr. Kevin Pendley, General Counsel and Mr. Stephen Dye, Board Attorney. Superintendent Wysong summarized the Board conversation as follows: • Staff will create two separate action items for simultaneous Board approval on the consent agenda February 11, 2025 • Item amendment including the changes noted by Mr. Pendley for the consent agenda on February 11, 2025 • Separate item naming the school, will be prepared as an action item designating the future school ‘Rye Ranch Elementary School’. • The language giving naming rights would not be included in the contract Board member Kennedy stated for the record he would request the naming item to be put on New Business for a separate vote and discussion on February 11, 2025. 4.4. Discussion regarding Proclamations Board Member Tatem requested a Board discussion regarding proclamations. Board Member Tatem expressed that his request was to disallow proclamations entirely. The rationale behind this proposal was to prevent the discussion of political topics during board meetings, given the potential for differing viewpoints and the ongoing non-partisan nature of the School Board. The Board asked questions and held discussions. Additional information was provided by Board Attorney Dye, who stated there is currently no policy in Manatee County School District regarding Proclamations but agreed it would be ideal to create a policy. Mr. Kennedy left the meeting at 1:37 PM. A discussion was held regarding the possibility of voting on proclamations, or requiring unanimous approval. Mr. Kevin Pendley, General Counsel, stated that there was legal precedent that required some votes need to be a super-majority (4-1), since many times a unanimous (5-0) vote is nearly impossible. The Board continued its discussion concerning the postponement of proclamations until a policy is developed by the District. Mr. Dye indicated that although an official decision cannot be made in a workshop setting due to its informal nature, the Superintendent has been given direction on the matter. 5. ADJOURNMENT Seeing no farther business of the Board, Chair Choate adjourned the Workshop at 1:45 P.M.

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. AGENDA AMENDMENTS 3. PUBLIC COMMENTS Public comment is not an open forum to discuss matters unrelated to education, to support or oppose candidates for public office, or to engage in commercial speech attempting to sell a service or product to the School Board or public. Also, public comment is not a forum to attack individual school system employees or Board Members. Any such complaints should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Finally, this is not a forum for addressing issues involving individual students. Because of privacy concerns, such issues should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Each speaker is allowed three minutes to address the Board. Speakers must stand at the podium and not approach the dais. This is a business meeting of the School Board and the public expects that we conduct it in an orderly, efficient, effective and dignified manner. We request that speakers keep this in mind when making your comments. We also request that the audience keep that in mind and not demonstrate approval or disapproval of what a speaker has said by clapping or booing. The Board appreciates the public's input and will listen attentively, consider each comment, and usually will not respond, enter into debate, or answer questions during comments on agenda items or during the public comments section. PUBLIC INPUT INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Before you begin speaking, please provide any handouts to the Agency Clerk. 2. Please identify yourself only by your full name for the record. 3. You have no more than three minutes to speak. Please stop speaking when the bell rings. 4. Florida Law requires all citizens to conduct themselves in an orderly fashion at public meetings. 5 . WARNING: Any individual who interferes with the expeditious or orderly process of a School Board meeting, will be subject to removal from the meeting pursuant to Section 1001.372(3) Florida Statutes at the discretion of the Chair. Orderly fashion is deemed as, at a minimum (1) no profanity (2) no vulgar language (3) no discourteous, disrespectful, or disparaging conduct. 4. WORKSHOP 1. Audit Committee Quarterly Board Review 2. 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results Agenda January 24, 2025 School Board of Manatee County Workshop - 10:00 AM Walter Miller School Support Center Board Room Times Indicated are Approximate 1

3. Discussion Regarding Real Property Acquisition 4. Board Discussion Regarding Proclamations 5. ADJOURNMENT 2

1. CALL TO ORDER 2. AGENDA AMENDMENTS 3. PUBLIC COMMENTS Public comment is not an open forum to discuss matters unrelated to education, to support or oppose candidates for public office, or to engage in commercial speech attempting to sell a service or product to the School Board or public. Also, public comment is not a forum to attack individual school system employees or Board Members. Any such complaints should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Finally, this is not a forum for addressing issues involving individual students. Because of privacy concerns, such issues should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Each speaker is allowed three minutes to address the Board. Speakers must stand at the podium and not approach the dais. This is a business meeting of the School Board and the public expects that we conduct it in an orderly, efficient, effective and dignified manner. We request that speakers keep this in mind when making your comments. We also request that the audience keep that in mind and not demonstrate approval or disapproval of what a speaker has said by clapping or booing. The Board appreciates the public's input and will listen attentively, consider each comment, and usually will not respond, enter into debate, or answer questions during comments on agenda items or during the public comments section. PUBLIC INPUT INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Before you begin speaking, please provide any handouts to the Agency Clerk. 2. Please identify yourself only by your full name for the record. 3. You have no more than three minutes to speak. Please stop speaking when the bell rings. 4. Florida Law requires all citizens to conduct themselves in an orderly fashion at public meetings. 5 . WARNING: Any individual who interferes with the expeditious or orderly process of a School Board meeting, will be subject to removal from the meeting pursuant to Section 1001.372(3) Florida Statutes at the discretion of the Chair. Orderly fashion is deemed as, at a minimum (1) no profanity (2) no vulgar language (3) no discourteous, disrespectful, or disparaging conduct. 4. WORKSHOP 1. Audit Committee Quarterly Board Review 2. 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results Agenda January 24, 2025 School Board of Manatee County Workshop - 10:00 AM Walter Miller School Support Center Board Room Times Indicated are Approximate 1

3. Discussion Regarding Real Property Acquisition 4. Board Discussion Regarding Proclamations 5. ADJOURNMENT 2

AGENDA ITEM NO. 4.1 School Board of Manatee County January 24, 2025 - Workshop Title Audit Committee Quarterly Board Review Executive Summary Mr. James Daniel, Audit Committee Chair, will present the quarterly update. Contact Submitting Department: Audit Committee 3

AGENDA ITEM NO. 4.2 School Board of Manatee County January 24, 2025 - Workshop Title 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results Executive Summary Mr. Derek Jensen, Deputy Superintendent of Instruction, will present data regarding 2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Mathematics Assessment Results. Contact Submitting Department: Instructional Services Initiated By: Derek Jensen Attachments: 01-24-25 FAST PM2 Math Data Review Workshop Presentation 4

2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Math Assessment Results School Board Workshop January 24, 2025 5

FAST Progress Monitoring Kindergarten – 2nd Grade Star Early Literacy Star Reading Star Math 3rd – 10th Grade 3rd -10th Grade FAST ELA Reading 3rd -8th Grade FAST Mathematics 2 Testing Windows PM1: September 2024 PM2: December 2024 - January 2025 PM3: May 2025 6

Computer Adaptive Testing 3 7

Low Item Difficulty High Item Difficulty Level 5 Level 2 Level 1 Level 3 Level 4 Student’s Provisional Score Estimate Student’s Final Score Estimate 8

Low Item Difficulty High Item Difficulty Level 5 Level 2 Level 1 Level 3 Level 4 Student’s Provisional Score Estimate Student’s Final Score Estimate What happens if a student misses the first few questions instead? 9

Family Portal • The results for STAR and FAST ELA Reading, STAR and FAST Mathematics, FAST ELA Reading Retake, and B.E.S.T. EOC assessments are available in the Family Portal. • Parents can access a student’s FAST ELA Reading, FAST Mathematics, FAST ELA Reading Retake, and B.E.S.T. EOC results in the portal using a link provided in Focus • In the Family Portal, parents can see and print their student’s score reports 6 10

FAST Progress Monitoring Parent Guide: Understanding FAST and B.E.S.T. Reports for Families “Each progress monitoring test covers the full “test blueprint,” meaning that all content expectations for that subject and grade level are assessed. Therefore, for PM1 and PM2, your student may not yet be at grade level; however, this does not necessarily indicate that a student is not on track to succeed. It is important for teachers and families to understand that score information is intended to provide baseline and mid-year results for PM1 and PM2, respectively. These results are for informational purposes only and should be used to identify areas that may need additional instruction and support. These results should not be considered student achievement designations.” 7 11

FAST Progress Monitoring: Parent Reports • Score information: The blue-shaded area displays the student’s scale score, achievement level, and a chart indicating the student’s scale score and where it falls in the achievement level. • Score comparison: The purple-shaded area allows you to see how your student's scale score compares with their peers at the school, district, and state level. • Notes for families: The orange-shaded area contains important notes for families. This information may change between administrations and subjects 8 12

FAST Progress Monitoring: Parent Reports • Box and Whisker Plots: The blue-shaded area contains a diagram for each reporting category, which represents the student’s performance relative to the standard. The dashed line represents on grade level. The location of the black dot indicates the student’s performance in the reporting category. • Enhanced Achievement Level Descriptions: The green-shaded area indicates whether the student performed below, at/near, or above the standard in each reporting category. The description includes an explanation of the student’s strengths and weaknesses as well as next steps parents can take to help the student make progress in their learning. 9 13

School Grade Components 2024-2025 Reading Achievement FAST ELA (3-10) FAA ELA (3-10) Math Achievement FAST Math (3-8), FAA Math (3-8), BEST Algebra 1, FAA Algebra 1, BEST Geometry, FAA Geometry Science Achievement NGSSS Science (5 th & 8th) FAA Science (5th & 8th) NGSSS Biology, FAA Biology Social Studies Achievement NGSSS Civics, FAA Civics, NGSSS US History, FAA US History) Middle School Acceleration BEST Algebra 1, FAA Algebra 1, BEST Geometry, FAA Geometry, CAPE Industry Certifications Graduation Rate Prior Year Federal Uniform Graduation Rate College & Career Acceleration Prior Year Graduates who have passed one of the following: Dual Enrollment Course, AP exam, AICE Exam, IB Exam, CAPE Industry Certification, Clock Hour Dual Enrollment, ASVAB + JROTC Course z Reading Learning Gains (LG) FAST ELA (3-10) FAA ELA (3-10) Reading LG of Lowest Quartile (L25) FAST ELA (3-10) FAA ELA (3-10) Math Learning Gains (LG) FAST Math (3-8), FAA Math (3-8), BEST Algebra 1, FAA Algebra 1, BEST Geometry, FAA Geometry Math LG of Lowest Quartile (L25) FAST Math (3-8), FAA Math (3-8), BEST Algebra 1, FAA Algebra 1, BEST Geometry, FAA Geometry 3rd Grade Reading Achievement FAST ELA (3) FAA ELA (3) Elementary: 800 pts total Middle: 900 pts total High: 1000 pts total K-8: 1000 pts total 10 14

Considerations • Students lost 7 net instructional days during the first semester due to hurricane impacts; students in many other districts lost fewer/no days • Affects comparisons to state results and year to year comparisons • Change in SDMC philosophy about assignment of accelerated students to grade level tests 11 15

SDMC PM2 Math Results KG-2nd Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 12 1 2 3+ % % KG - State 43% 31% 26% 4% 26% +22% ↑ KG - Manatee 50% 31% 19% 5% 19% +14% ↑ 1st - State 39% 31% 30% 11% 30% +19% ↑ 1st - Manatee 41% 32% 27% 11% 27% +16% ↑ 2nd - State 42% 20% 38% 17% 38% +21% ↑ 2nd - Manatee 46% 20% 34% 18% 34% +16% ↑ Change 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024-2025 FAST PM2 PM1 PM1 to PM2 Performance Levels PM2 16

SDMC PM2 Math Results KG-2nd Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 13 1 2 3 % % KG - State 43% 31% 26% 4% 26% +22% ↑ KG - District 50% 30% 20% 5% 20% +15% ↑ KG - Charter 48% 33% 19% 5% 19% +14% ↑ 1st - State 39% 31% 30% 11% 30% +19% ↑ 1st - District 41% 32% 27% 10% 27% +17% ↑ 1st - Charter 39% 31% 29% 13% 29% +16% ↑ 2nd - State 42% 20% 38% 17% 38% +21% ↑ 2nd - District 45% 19% 35% 17% 35% +18% ↑ 2nd - Charter 46% 21% 33% 18% 33% +15% ↑ 2024-2025 Level 3+ Change 2024-2025 FAST PM2 PM2PM1 PM1 to PM2 Performance Levels 17

SDMC PM2 Math Results KG-2nd Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 14 1 2 3+ % % KG - State 43% 31% 26% 19% 26% +7% ↑ KG - Manatee 50% 31% 19% 19% 19% 0% = 1st - State 39% 31% 30% 32% 30% -2% ↓ 1st - Manatee 41% 32% 27% 28% 27% -1% ↓ 2nd - State 42% 20% 38% 36% 38% +2% ↑ 2nd - Manatee 46% 20% 34% 34% 34% 0% = 2023-2024 PM2 Year-to-Year Comparison (Level 3+) PM2 to PM2 Change 2024-2025 PM2 2024-2025 FAST PM2 Performance Levels 18

SDMC PM2 Math Results KG-2nd Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 15 1 2 3 % % KG - State 43% 31% 26% 19% 26% +7% ↑ KG - District 50% 30% 20% 19% 20% +1% ↑ KG - Charter 48% 33% 19% 23% 19% -4% ↓ 1st - State 39% 31% 30% 32% 30% -2% ↓ 1st - District 41% 32% 27% 29% 27% -2% ↓ 1st - Charter 39% 31% 29% 32% 29% -3% ↓ 2nd - State 42% 20% 38% 36% 38% +2% ↑ 2nd - District 45% 19% 35% 34% 35% +1% ↑ 2nd - Charter 46% 21% 33% 36% 33% -3% ↓ Year-to-Year Comparison (Level 3+) 2023-2024 PM2 2024-2025 PM2 PM2 to PM2 Change 2024-2025 FAST PM2 Performance Levels 19

SDMC Middle School Math Progression Grade 6 Math Grade 7 Math Grade 8 Pre-Algebra Grade 6 Accelerated Math Grade 7 Accelerated Math Algebra 1 Honors Grade 7 Accelerated Math Algebra 1 Honors Geometry Honors 16 Grade 6 Grade 7 Grade 8 Traditional Pathway Accelerated Pathway Most Accelerated Pathway 20

SDMC Mathematics Progression 17 Grade 3 Traditional Math Grade 7 Traditional Math Grade 4 Traditional Math Grade 5 Traditional Math Grade 6 Traditional Math Grade 8 Pre-Algebra Grade 3 Accelerated Math Grade 4 Accelerated Math Grade 6 Traditional Math (5th Grade Year) Grade 7 Accelerated Math Algebra I Honors Geometry Honors Most Accelerated Pathway Traditional Pathway Tested on 6th Grade FAST Tested on 8th Grade FAST Tested on 5th Grade FAST 21

SDMC Most Accelerated Math Progression 18 22

SDMC PM2 Above Grade Level Testing in Accelerated Math (as of 1/15/2025) 19 Assessment Name 2023 PM2 2024 PM2 1 Yr Change Notes: Grade 3 FAST Mathematics 4332 4429 +97 Grade 4 FAST Mathematics 4055 3030 -1025 4th Accelerated taking 5th FAST Math Grade 5 FAST Mathematics 3853 4119 +266 Accelerated 5th graders taking 6th FAST Math Grade 6 FAST Mathematics 3782 4095 +313 Accelerated 6th graders taking 7th Accelerated (8th FAST Math) Grade 7 FAST Mathematics 3187 2422 -765 7th Accelerated taking 8th FAST Math Grade 8 FAST Mathematics 1838 3292 +1454 23

SDMC PM2 Accelerated Math Results (as of 1/15/2025) 20 1 2 3+ % % 3rd - State 37% 35% 28% 8% 28% +20% ↑ 3rd - Accelerated 10% 21% 69% 29% 69% +40% ↑ 5th - State 37% 33% 30% 14% 30% +16% ↑ 4th - Accelerated 12% 44% 44% 13% 44% +31% ↑ 6th - State 26% 35% 39% 20% 39% +19% ↑ 5th - (Accelerated) in 6th Math 0% 18% 81% 50% 81% +31% ↑ 6th - Accelerated 6% 39% 56% 33% 56% +23% ↑ 8th - State 31% 34% 35% 18% 35% +17% ↑ 7th - Accelerated 12% 43% 46% 22% 46% +24% ↑ PM1 to PM2 Change 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024-2025 FAST PM2 Performance Levels PM1 PM2 24

SDMC PM2 Math Results 3rd-5 th Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 21 1 2 3+ % % 3rd - State 37% 35% 28% 8% 28% +20% ↑ 3rd - Manatee 38% 32% 30% 10% 30% +20% ↑ 4th - State 50% 26% 24% 10% 24% +14% ↑ 4th - Manatee 52% 29% 19% 7% 19% +12% ↑ 5th - State 37% 33% 30% 14% 30% +16% ↑ 5th - Manatee 37% 36% 27% 11% 27% +16% ↑ Change 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2024 PM1 Lvl 3+Performance Levels 2024 PM2 Lvl 3+ PM1 to PM2 25

SDMC PM2 Math Results 3rd-5 th Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 22 1 2 3+ % % 3rd - State 37% 35% 28% 8% 28% +20% ↑ 3rd - District 37% 30% 33% 11% 33% +22% ↑ 3rd - Charter 38% 40% 21% 8% 21% +13% ↑ 4th - State 50% 26% 24% 10% 24% +14% ↑ 4th - District 54% 30% 16% 4% 16% +12% ↑ 4th - Charter 47% 26% 27% 13% 27% +14% ↑ 5th - State 37% 33% 30% 14% 30% +16% ↑ 5th - District 36% 37% 28% 10% 28% +18% ↑ 5th - Charter 40% 34% 26% 15% 26% +11% ↑ Change 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2024 PM1 Lvl 3+Performance Levels 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024 PM2 Lvl 3+ PM1 to PM2 26

SDMC PM2 Math Results 3 rd-5 th Grade (as of 1/15/2025) FAST Assessment Math Pathway 1 2 3+ % % 3rd - State 37% 35% 28% 31% 28% -3% ↓ 3rd - Traditional 47% 36% 17% 25% 17% -8% ↓ 3rd - Accelerated 10% 21% 69% 83% 69% -14% ↓ 4th - State 50% 26% 24% 25% 24% -1% ↓ 4th - Traditional 52% 29% 19% 17% 19% +2% ↑ 5th - State 37% 33% 30% 31% 30% -1% ↓ 5th - Traditional 43% 34% 23% 23% 23% 0% = 4th - Accelerated 12% 44% 44% 44% *Year-to-Year Comparison provided only when a group of students took the same assessment for both 2023-2024 and 2024-2025. Change Grade 3 FAST Math Grade 4 FAST Math Grade 5 FAST Math Year-to-Year Comparison (Level 3+)* 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2023-2024 PM2 2024-2025 PM2 PM2 to PM2* Performance Levels 23 27

Low Item Difficulty High Item Difficulty Level 5 Level 2 Level 1 Level 3 Level 4 Student’s Provisional Score Estimate Student’s Final Score Estimate 28

Low Item Difficulty High Item Difficulty Level 5 Level 2 Level 1 Level 3 Level 4 Student’s Provisional Score Estimate Student’s Final Score Estimate What happens if a student misses the first few questions instead? 29

SDMC PM2 Math Results 3rd Grade Math (as of 1/15/2024) 26 Assessment Window Algebraic Reasoning Data Analysis & Probability Fractions Geometric Reasoning Measurement Number Sense & Operations 24-25 PM2 0% 0% 98% 0% 0% 1% 24-25 PM1 8% 0% 41% 12% 14% 26% 23-24 PM3 18% 0% 35% 15% 12% 20% 23-24 PM2 11% 0% 41% 13% 12% 23% FAST Math Grade 3 First Question Distribution by Body of Knowledge 30

SDMC PM2 Math Results 6th-8th Grade (as of 1/15/2024) 27 1 2 3+ % % 6th - State 26% 35% 39% 20% 39% +19% ↑ 6th - Manatee 27% 34% 39% 24% 39% +15% ↑ 7th - State 41% 28% 31% 26% 31% +5% ↑ 7th - Manatee 46% 29% 25% 20% 25% +5% ↑ 8th - State 31% 34% 35% 18% 35% +17% ↑ 8th - Manatee 32% 38% 30% 13% 30% +17% ↑ Change 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2024 PM1 Lvl 3+Performance Levels 2024 PM2 Lvl 3+ PM1 to PM2 31

SDMC PM2 Math Results 6th-8th Grade (as of 1/15/2025) 28 1 2 3+ % % 6th - State 26% 35% 39% 20% 39% +19% ↑ 6th - District 27% 31% 43% 26% 43% +17% ↑ 6th - Charter 26% 41% 33% 21% 33% +12% ↑ 7th - State 41% 28% 31% 26% 31% +5% ↑ 7th - District 59% 29% 12% 9% 12% +3% ↑ 7th - Charter 28% 29% 43% 34% 43% +9% ↑ 8th - State 31% 34% 35% 18% 35% +17% ↑ 8th - District 31% 38% 30% 14% 30% +16% ↑ 8th - Charter 34% 41% 25% 12% 25% +13% ↑ Change 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2024 PM1 Lvl 3+Performance Levels 2024-2025 Level 3+ 2024 PM2 Lvl 3+ PM1 to PM2 32

SDMC PM2 Math Results 6th-8th Grade (as of 1/15/2025) FAST Assessment Math Pathway 1 2 3+ % % 6th - State 26% 35% 39% 36% 39% +3% ↑ 6th - Traditional 44% 37% 19% 20% 19% -1% ↓ 5th - (Accelerated) in 6th Math 0% 18% 81% 81% 6th - Accelerated 6% 39% 56% 67% 56% -11% ↓ 7th - State 41% 28% 31% 30% 31% +1% ↑ 7th - Traditional 46% 29% 25% 27% 25% -2% ↓ 8th - State 31% 34% 35% 33% 35% +2% ↑ 8th - Traditional 51% 35% 15% 12% 15% +3% ↑ 7th - Accelerated 12% 43% 46% 46% *Year-to-Year Comparison provided only when a group of students took the same assessment for both 2023-2024 and 2024-2025. Grade 8 FAST Math Change Grade 6 FAST Math Grade 7 FAST Math Year-to-Year Comparison (Level 3+)* 2024-2025 FAST PM2 2023-2024 PM2 2024-2025 PM2 PM2 to PM2* Performance Levels 29 33

Semester 2 Next Steps • Teachers and school leaders review data student by student to modify support and schedules as needed based on PM1, PM2, and other data points • School principal data review and training on Tuesday, January 21, 2025 • Assistant principal data review and training on Tuesday, January 28, 2025 • All schools complete and submit Semester 2 action plans based on PM2 data • Targeted schools will receive individual feedback and support from Instructional Services leadership • Schedule Spring school visits based on results • Assessment review and remediation resources provided to teachers and administrators from curriculum team 30 34

2024-2025 FAST Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) Math Assessment Results School Board Workshop January 24, 2025 35

AGENDA ITEM NO. 4.3 School Board of Manatee County January 24, 2025 - Workshop Title Discussion Regarding Real Property Acquisition Executive Summary Discussion Regarding Real Property Acquisition Contact Submitting Department: Construction Services Initiated By: Mike Pendley 36

AGENDA ITEM NO. 4.4 School Board of Manatee County January 24, 2025 - Workshop Title Board Discussion Regarding Proclamations Executive Summary Board Member Richard Tatem has requested a Board discussion regarding the District use of Proclamations. Contact Submitting Department: School Board 37

Sources and limits

Published sources used on this page

This meeting has been held, but no source-backed decision record is available yet. Agenda items remain proposals.

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.

Canonical record: 8521590c81d4d27c41718eccd77d1941. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record