POLISCOPE

The public record

DUVAL COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Special Committee on the Community Benefits Agreement 2.0

Wednesday, December 3, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Special Committee on the Community Benefits Agreement 2.0

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 111,913 stored characters

All right. Good morning. Today is DECEMBER 3rd we are commencing Rcb a special committee meeting. Introductions to my left. Please. >> Pretty nice for the administration. Brian Russell Council research, our Richelle Office of General Counsel. Very Plus Office of General Counsel Peterson counselor's office. Our City Council district One Ron Salem group, 2 at large. Always district 11. >> And misd We have 3 right now here. Do we have enough for a quorum or? >> I know this crime are going to be coming a little late. So. >> MISTER Chair, you have even number of committee members. So you have an exact 3, which is 50%. So it's not a majority for quorum purposes. So to that extent, to allow some time for one of your men, you can discuss. But I would suggest that if you're prepared to vote on anything, you need to wait until you have another member here. You MAY want to just get the updates and then we can see if one of the other members arrives before you get into the legislation where you all would be taking up matters to potentially vote on. >> Okay. Yeah. Let's do have been so we're going on the agenda that we On introductions. Welcome. I we've been working for the last several months, more than a year and on on so many different topics. And last committee, we made a lot of progress, tremendous progress. I think we've had a lot of great updates. And so today going to wrap everything up to date as much as possible. And so we have a lot of work to do. Colleagues. And there are a couple things that we need to add. And to the the East Side grants program and to make sure that it to the final legislation that we could actually proposing to a full body, which means it's going to go to the committee's, the regular committees, neighborhoods rules, whatever committee, don't. And on. And then from there go to full council for a vote. So with that being said today, we're going to just kind of just wrap everything up as much as possible so we can send it up to the full body and now I'm going to go with an update from Ogc. >> Thank you. Threw the chair to the committee. So what you have in front of you for discussion today is a red line of the legislation that you all have been working through during the previous meetings of the special committee, the Red Lines reflect what was discussed and voted upon by the committee last meeting with the exception. There's one item in there that that I have included that for discussion purposes and highlight that will be get into the draft legislation that that that the purpose of this red line is so that you all can see that those changes were made confirmed that they're in keeping with the intent to the special committee and then discuss any additional changes you MAY want to address before finalize the legislation for filing has introduced by the special committee. The other hand out that you have in front of you was that chart that Doctor Salem had requested. It's a very simple chart. Ended up being pretty easy to go through the code and that addresses the grant award limitations that are applied in both the public services grant model and the opioid substance use disorder, grant model. And those are just ideas for your consideration. To the extent that you want to discuss any sort of limitations on the grant amounts, the number of applications, et cetera, as you go through this draft legislation for what I believe the chairs intent would be the final approval today. >> All right. Well, thank you for adding those in And just to confirm you to send this out, too, everybody, the redline version last Friday. >> I sent it out the Friday before the Thanksgiving Week and I believe the to the extent you were going to share with the community and have it sent out, that was the intent was to get out early so it could be shared. Thank you. >> All And now I will go to updates from the administration. This Norris. >> Thank you, chair. Just want to be as a heads-up that we will be hosting close meeting tomorrow with some of the groups that have come forward and going through what you guys recommend today, working with them on sunshine and ethics and then also ideally having a conversation on bylaws give an opportunity for back and forth and we're looking to have some consensus on that. Leaving that meeting. Okay. So. >> I'm glad you bring that up because we. We've received I received. I knew I know I have and I'm pretty sure that he some e-mails from his job. Art requesting some add-ons to the bylaws and all that. And so I know that you're going to have that meeting tomorrow. So that's the appropriate time to have a conversation with the community. I want to be sure that everybody understands that. That's kind of the purpose of tomorrow's meeting and what time that media tomorrow. >> all started to we have until 5. I hope it's not a 3 meeting, but we do have time to decide and what room is it? Its the mayor's large conference room, with more So so just for dogs out there, just obviously. >> Just make sure you make it. I mean, because that's going to be very important meeting, which is going to be the town this part today. Okay. I do have a speaker. Thank you so much. You're you're recognized. >> Just a quick question. Thank you. Chair. The committee members of this final into t they're subject sunshine law >> communication between each other is not is not allow that kind of thing. Correct? >> To the chair to Councilmember Salem, that's would be our desire whether that lives in the legislation or the bylaws. I'd have to defer to the Officer General Council. That would be our desire. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Salem. So the legislation currently does have a provision that all meetings of the board would be subject to the opens. Meads laws are sunshine law. And so to the extent that there MAY be a conflict with the bylaws that is in the legislation. >> And how about outside those meetings? Are they allowed to communicate with each other? About pending boats and all those types of things. >> That that would not no, that's not in keeping with open meetings law so that that applies to the actions of the board. And that's what's in the legislation. They're subject to the Open meetings. Law. So. They they can't we can tighten it up if you want. But that would encompass not allowing for communication outside of the sunshine. >> I to me, why would they not be any different than then the council? And which is what that provision provides, that they have to operate in the Sunshine. Okay. At the meetings in before. And so they can't lobby each other on particular votes outside their their their meetings. Is that correct? And yes, correct. That is what we're putting in the legislation. Okay. I think that's important. What I saw suggested we waive the sunshine law and I don't I don't think that's a good idea. Through the chair of the mission or us, I think you need to emphasize that in any meetings, your and once this gets going that they can't be lobbying each other on particular votes and such. >> If I might respond to the chair to counsel or Salem, I'll send you the proposed agenda we've put together for tomorrow, but it includes sunshine, Open meetings at pix. We're trying to give it'll be a brief because really have 3 hours. But we're trying to touch on those points to kind of give context for what you can expect going forward. >> Council members can attend if they're available. >> Unfortunately, no, this meeting has not been noticed. We working just the legal counsel in the community members and not expecting Council tendons. Okay. And for for the committee, it's on Page 10. Item number 7 in the draft, the station, all meetings and sessions of the board shall be held in a publicly accessible location. >> And Shelby noticed an open to the public in accordance with the Florida Open meetings law. I will add a provision that references that their actions, undertaken in accordance with the sunshine laws. Well, so it's titans that up to make sure that intent is very clear. >> I wouldn't I I think we should. Just to make it perfectly clear. Thank you. >> All right. Thank you so that completes administration's portion of it. Now in a move to number 4, which is the finalization of the draft legislation. >> The stuff Do we have? Obviously this is what we have here. Get an e-mail from any of the council members that they want to add something else last minute to it. Are we ready to just take action year? >> Through the MR. Pretty. So here is the chair. I didn't get any e-mails from any of the committee members with respect to any additional changes. But, you know, I'm happy as you see fit to what walk through it. Just so you all can kind highlight the items that we've including that one item that I mentioned earlier that I wanted to address with the committee because it was an addition that wasn't discussed at the last meeting. I'm happy to go through it. However, you like okay. >> Well, that all kick started and then maybe we'll have some more conversation from not so I have 3 things that I want to just address. I'm pretty sure maybe are already in here or not. But I'm just summit team is tough. Obviously, Tony, who came so number will do we have an update? I'm not of the actual what the boundaries are. >> To the chair. So the map that's in currently included shows the boundaries of the of the East side community. And that was the same map that was included in the community benefits agreement. The Supplemental Community Benefits Agreement are in tension between myself and MISTER Peterson is to work with the appropriate department to develop a map that would reflect the neighborhoods. And so that is something we would put into the legislation in lieu of this. It would be this map. But with demarcation of the 5 neighborhoods because their reference with respect to the appointments to the board of directors that that would be included. What gets filed? >> Kind of like a district map. We have different boundaries for each correct. An Avs to cut. The neighborhoods are reflected in the will what we see the updated. Not by next like when it comes to regular committee process. >> The intent would unless the committee wants us to bring it back for your review. We would bring that as part of the building gets filed. It's if it's acceptable to the committee for us to do that. All right. And what's the department that you're working with to get this of that amount? >> It would put most likely that the planning department. All right, MR. Senator, you're recognized. >> Our our the neighborhoods that well defined that north of this street and east of that street is Fairfield versus Oakland, cetera. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Salem. So that is probably going to you know, we're going to develop an initial map, but I would surmise that that will be a topic of discussion as the legislation makes its way through the committees. And unless you wanted us to seek some input from the community first before we filed a bill to make sure that they've had opportunity to look at that map. But I don't know that they're that well-defined meeting, MR. Palou so could address that since it's in his district. >> All right. I fear that process. Recognized sir. To that end, was gonna say with the 3 army tomorrow. If individuals do come in tomorrow and say, hey, look, here's exactly where the boundary is. Here's where Longbranch her tears were fearful starts like that. They'll be the ones to kind of help, right? That I imagine the planning process probably has. Part of the planning department probably have some good map somewhat. What what what the neighborhoods strictly look like prior to us putting much of highways of to mark on active duty, active duty starting tomorrow Friday and then Saturday, Sunday. And this the mayor's administration is meeting for tomorrow which I think is in the best interest for this. Cute. Alright. All MISTER Morrow, you're recognized. Thank you, MISTER Just to concur. What the COUNCILMAN Palooza because I. >> My wife has relatives who live out the sun and they know they know where the line of demarcation isn't. So the community will know the planning department will know that should not be a difficult task and identify. In fact, I'm looking at the map right now it seems pretty sufficient to me. But if it needs a little bit more I'm okay with that. >> submission or just for tomorrow. Could be one of your talking points to identify the the boundaries for the map. >> We will add that to the agenda and I will check with. I think I've worked as planning before to get a big maps, maybe even have people trot out or something. So led up to date can you get the map from planning department before tomorrow mean? So least you have a rough idea that we could show it to them to make sure that they're ok with it or not. The nannies can make some revisions to it. That's what I'm hoping is to get a map from planning printed. That's pretty large and have it MAY be on display or something but will add that to date and print it out that we have it in him. All right. Thank you. All right. So that was a number one. I have 2 which I sheet of paper here. Then MISTER Salem, I guess, requested similar to my point was on for the psu model. We have any acts of $125 per applicant and they can only apply for one category. Do we have something in writing in here? Similar to this? >> To the chair know so that you all went through a lot of other types guardrails with respect to the eligibility of applicants, the eligibility documents that they would have to Posen, not all made its way into the legislation is reflected in the red line. This was some additional information that the committee thought might be helpful to have on paper. So you can kind of start to get an idea of what the other programs look like. So both of them have a funding model. That's a high score model. So the high scores what gets funded as you were indicating the public service grant program has a maximum grant amount that can be awarded for any program. A project of 125,000 for the opioid and Substance Use Disorder Grant program. It's 500,000 and the Public Service Grant program only allows one application per category while the opioid and substance use Disorder Grant program allows multiple applications. There's no limit on any number of applications they can submit per their categories. But the only the highest ranked one of what submitted from any particular organization is what receives funding some of the things that we had discussed, MISTER Chair that the committee could consider in in lieu and light of this and in keeping with kind of what's happening with this particular type of grant program is you could also look you, talked about tiered funding. You MAY consider is the funding for capital something that would be different than how you would limit the funding for programmatic programs versus the capital projects. So there's few different ways you could slice it if the committee has a desire to apply. The is sort of similar type of grant award limitations. >> Yeah, and that's what I have. You know, I know programmatic versus capital and then also potentially a percentage based, right? So because easy one capital project could wipe out the entire fund. We have 4 categories just about One of the categories. >> That is correct. There are 4 categories which I call funded. Can't funding categories are funded categories and that kind of goes to that. One item that I indicated earlier that have added to the legislation for the purposes of discussion. It's on Page 7. There are some red lining there and it talks about the application. Allocation to the 4 disciplines that are listed in the community benefits agreement. Those include affordable housing workforce, housing, economic Development and mitigation of homelessness in the East side. So in keeping with how the supplemental cba was outlined, identify those as the for funding categories for the this grant program that kind of mimics how we handle it for both the opioid substance use disorder, great program as well as the public services grant program. But that is not a specific item that was discussed or voted upon the way I've added here, MR. Chair is that when they come in Yulee, the Eastside cba organization comes annually ask for their allocation through the budget process that they would be able to recommend percentages or amounts that would be provided to each funded categories. Part of that request. You can establish those yourselves as the committee and recommends specific allocations or percentages. Now you could allow it to be a part of the budget process on an annual basis, which is similar to how psg handles it. One thing that you would might want to consider is that if you want to allow it to be established by the East Side Corporation, as you MAY recall, each year for public service grants when they identify the percentages, they want to allocate to each of the most vulnerable persons in needs categories. They bring that to the council through legislation for a blessing before they proceed on using those as their percentage basis in the budget That's not referenced here as far as legislation for council approval. But that could be a part of the discussion on this item. >> All right. So I'll open up to the body now. Those are my might, I guess, points of actions that you guys want to add something else you can. But I will say let's speak on these first. And if you don't want to add something else will welcome back to q. So produce a recognized. >> Thank you, And yeah, I mean to to the point of whether we do it here, we through the budget process. I think we've done a lot about budget process. I don't want to handcuff ourselves right now within this legislation to say certain percentages will go to x, y and z categories. I want them to come to us every year through the budget process saying, you know what, we need more help on workforce housing this year. We need more help on economic development this year. Ravenous to say it should be one quarter. One quarter, one quarter, one quarter in this bill. So I want them to kind of have that. I want to I want to put limitations now. I want them tell us every year and that was going to be actually. My question is we can kind of walk through exactly how the funding process works so that way, everyone kind of knows it. And we kind of get a good, a good sense of that sort of you want to do right now. But get back to that My other questions. Well on on on the points that I brought. Yeah. I mean, like you questions. All right. I'm I'm pretty comfortable with with what you put out the the idea again, the percentage of is there a certain. I want talk about capital projects, something that's right. The what exactly do you want to see like? Do you want to see 50% of all dollars will go to capital projects or are you just saying that the limited, you know, that the cost for a couple projects should. X amount? I don't think we should limit the cost copper project because any capital project could be a million or 10 Million. Whatever the case is, I what I don't want to see is. >> You know, we have 4 million dollars in the budget coming out of here for the side and one capital project wipe everything out. One project. And then what about the rest of the community on? Sure that we have a balanced approach. One coming to this. Maybe it's a 50% capital, 50% operational. I don't I just want to sure that everybody gets access to this and not just whoever is building on property. I want the workforce. I want the small businesses that want them. Everybody. The thriving there, too. So I want to assure that we have about its approach for this, maybe capital product or a certain number amount. It's unanimous approval by the board or something like because I don't think that will happen. I just think practically they're not going to blow money is not going to blow in on one capital projects. I think for that reason alone, I think people in the room are going to say, I'm sorry, we have 7 other needs that we need accomplish this year. Also, we've specifically put the legislation that monies will not be spent until substantial completion. >> Of that capital Project based on the legislation. So like if we say in your one with the 4 million, we have by time this gets into your to that, you know that they will have another pot of money for that or the dollar amount will be budget to them for the next year. So don't I don't think it's going to be spent. On one year. That's just not a concern of mine, but I'm I want to hear through your process like do you. What do you have a specific desire right now? Right now, I want to see how your one goes. First of all, we don't know how it's going that's going be. We could address us to right? That's kind what I was Yeah, like let's let's get a good sense of what this looks like. And also we're still going to see this go through. I assume neighborhoods, Committee and Finance Committee rules, I assume to right. That's going to go through multiple committees. I imagine like we're going to have other colleagues kind of take there. Look at this and get their impressions of stuff. So I also don't want us to that. To try to solve every problem, right? The second we need to move this bill and I'm assuming we'll have other colleagues have different ideas. All right. MISTER Saying you're recognized, I'm sorry. And also want to recognize MISS Correct. Mary has joined Thank all right. Thank you, Chair. I'm good. I'm going to throw something out because I've dealt with a lot of this to the opioid process. >> And I think the discussion capital versus operations is a good one. Going. I think this committee needs to put something in this bill or else. It's going to be a huge discussion through the regular committees. I'm going to throw something out. You guys can react to it. I would think that the Capitol should be no more than 50%. And it needs to be and I'm not sure how to work this Mary, but you can't count on future funding in future years. It needs to be a project that can be completed with the dollars that you're getting. For example, it can't be a 6 million dollar project we're going to ask for 2 million dollars for 3 years because you don't know what future years are going to be like number 2, I limit the the operational grants to 2.50 And the ability of people to apply in multiple categories is okay. And I I think having looked at the opioid agreement, I think that that will. You might disagree with that. But I think that that's a good place to start. And then the committee can make recommendations to change it going forward. All throughout. Throw that out Thank you. I will recognize MISTER Peterson. Thank you for recognizing chair. >> This at the piece is the to 50 and the line for multiple categories 100%. I I second that motion. As for the 50% on capital projects. I do think that's a good idea. No more than 50, but I but I also think that there should be an ability to say you know what, a unanimous body. You can you can go over that or some like that. If we allow for everyone on that on the voting member that on that board agrees with it, move forward. But I see MISTER Peterson moving. I'm going to something nice. MISS A populace for says, MR. Pearson. >> a couple of things. Number one, traditionally grant Processees like these go by the high score model. So you're not doing Indiana must consent to approve a project. It's the high score we talked about in in the legislation. We added that no less than 5 members of the board of directors have to score in each of the categories. So I I'm not sure how that would comport with the high score model. The other item. I just want to get clarification on from Doctor Salem is with respect to the 50%. Is that 50% of the annual allocation for the program. So if it's 4 million up 2 million can go to capital projects. >> That is that is my motion. About up to 50% to 50% understood. That is correct. We do have a motion on the floor right now before we take action any of that. I want to make sure we hear from MISTER Peterson or you did. You just dropped off Michael, I MISTER Morrow. You're recognize nothing back to you. And this could make you run. Thank you, MISTER Chair. >> I concur to 50 on the grants. In fact, when I was comparing the 2, that's I thought that 2.50, was a good place to land on capital through the chair to the district COUNCILMAN, what do you see this being applied? Given the 4th disciplines that have been applied outlined here in the legislations that primarily to the House and peace where where you see the capital projects being applied. Chair to councilmember Marrow. I think it could be a large-scale housing development. >> I think I think you could certainly be retail commercial on, especially on Philip Randolph in Florida. Ave so. So that's like I can assume again, the funeral home was just demolished. That's a giant. That's almost full city block. That could be a pretty substantial project. There's a lot of vacant properties right there on Florida. Ave that there could be some really cool projects mixed use. And but I imagine it's going to be, you know, a couple million bucks. So so I could see like the 50% I if we can move that threshold up a little bit, I think I feel more comfortable if to 65% or 70% just in case because then the other question is, let's say you don't spend all 4 million this year and then you get another 4 million next year. So let's say you got 2 million you know, holdover from last year. You get another 4 million is now the 50% triggered at 3 million dollars or 6 million total or is it based on me now? It's 2 million for the first year. 2 million from those second year because of the 50% rule like governor But MR. Publix. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Police, Osaka to go back through said what you're talking about is something similar to what was adjusted in the last couple years for the public service grant swear if they don't spend the entirety of the dollars that are allocated, they can roll into the next fiscal year. So if I can't, I'm going to look to make sure I thought that was language in here to that effect. But if not by motion, you can just make to do that. Addition. Once you kind of get through the Salem Amendment. I will note on the Salem and then I heard the motion, but I did hear us. Okay. Thank you all. I'll second that. And would you like me to summarize that motion at the end before the vote, MISTER Chair, just to make sure everybody knows before. >> So now I as a producer on the Amendment. Thank you. Chair to the to come Salem. Could you? Could you move this? This number up, can we go to 65%? >> Just because I there's some major pieces that could could receive large projects. Dollars for projects, Yes, we can. My concern is that. Is that just too high and a lot of operational stuff wants to get done out there. >> Will be limited. I we could go to 60 but no more than 60%. Through the chair to the district. GOD, you know, a better than MAY. I just wouldn't want to go too high. I don't think it will probably on a practical matter. I don't think it will happen regardless, but I want to give them the tools so I will accept 60 if that's I'm not. i'm happy with that. The other thing is my experience with opioid says that every dollar that's available is allocated. >> I mean, they they until all the money's gone, so to speak. So I don't see a whole lot of money floating year to year, but if it does, I think we should have that language that those percentages are based on what's available. In that account. I think there will be some growing pains. I think that there there could be some dollars the kind of stick around. And I agree with you. I think you could have economic development, large projects in 3 of the 4 categories, maybe not in the homeless one. But in the 3, you clearly could. Okay. Right. Thank you, Mayor. You're right. >> Thank you. Thank Thank you, chair. So I'm trying to just get an understanding of what's being said right now and just to list of opts to populous. I went through the lump sum appropriation aspect of ordinance and based on what they're saying, what they're discussing known they being the council members here. Is so 10% of what they are allocated from the mayor's office will be for administrative costs. And then so you had that remainder. And with that remainder based on the way I read it the way this appropriation goes, what they request and they being the east side with a request from the mayor's office or from for the for the because they have to go through the budget process as well. The mayor's budget review really going to be set for those applications and the applications who, you know, successfully went through the process so it won't be like money leftover. It'll be and ask that fits what the applicant had, what has been approved by by the Committee for the applicant. >> Well, so through the chair to Councilmember Clark Murray, so the way it works, this is based off. This is kind of based off opioid and psg model. They come annual basis earlier in the year as the mayor's office is working to prepare its proposed budget to make the allocation request. Now they're not limited to just asking for whatever dollars are coming out of the cba agreement. The minimum amount that has to be deposited into the account. They can ask for more if they see that there might be a need for more. And it's up to the mayor to determine kind of what she allocates to the program. And then that does come through the budget process. This is done before their grant cycle. So psg comes to you in advance of all of that to ask to set them percentages for most vulnerable persons and needs categories. You bless that. And then they that they they make their allocation request through the Mayor's Budget Review Committee based on how much they seem might might be in need to support the various programs that would be applying. And then based on that dollar amount, they know what they have when they're going through the grant process. So grant process comes after the budget allocation. Thank you for that. So through the chair, what you're saying is that the amount >> is not set before they go to the mayor's budget review process. It's basically after they can. They can. It can be more. Then. >> It could be more through the chair. It can be more than what is being deposited through the our obligation, the city's obligation under the community benefits agreement as an x amount per year. But we're saying 4 million for the sake of discussion. It could. They could ask for more than 4 million if they believe that there would be a need for additional funds and it's up to the city to determine. Whether they want to allocate additional dollars it above and beyond what the cba agreement provides. >> So is there minimal, Is there is there a minimum that would be what the cba require? So in this case for purposes of discussion for million. So we know that it can't be any less than that amount, right? All right. So that they can ask for more in the public services grants Council. They don't have a similar limitation on minimum like that. So each year they come there, I think there's a goal that's in the code. >> For a minimum for them. But each year they just see what the need looks like in the in the programs and the most vulnerable persons needs categories and that's how they base their allocation request. Just one last question through the chair. So with that 4 Million. >> And I was in a workshop yesterday for Jacksonville housing and that's how they did. It was like kind of a tear like they were saying that they did want to fund projects for like 50%. They want it to fund the project 100%. Then they would go down based on those who qualify. So is that what we're discussing here is kind of a two-year model. Is that what committee is saying that you want to do because use 50% 65% or you just want to make sure that there is a certain threshold percentage 4 for 11, then they'll have to know. We're talking about substantial completion as well. Be need dollars allocated. You just want to No more than 65% of that particular project. No MISS It. So we have 4 million dollars in the budget proposed so that for me and we're talking about 50% of that 4 million will go towards capital projects to up to. But now we talk about 60%. So so it could be, you know, 2.5, 3 minute, whatever we decide to do it. You know, so it's not based on the type of project and the percentage of project is based on the percentage of the total amount funding. Maybe next year. They fun. We fund 10 million dollars to the side. We don't so up to 50% will be going towards. Capital or 60%. Whatever the case, it's him. Thank you for that to you and thank you for that MISS Police. I get it. So we're looking at capital versus operations percent. I got it. Thank you. I All right. So MISTER Peterson, and then I'm gonna actually last month's Leslie, John Barr and MISTER. On to come quick. And to just one other question that Councilmember Clark Murray had, that also kind of been talked about is. >> The leftover funds are a possibility when it for an operational grant or even a capital grant. If the project doesn't spend the full amount so that, you know, say somewhat awarded the 250,000 the only spent 200,000 that 50,000 within go back to the east side to reallocate out. So that's where you'd have carry over into into that next year, too. Divvy up based on the new allocation. And also keep a reminder, the minimum is 4 million, but the city is required to fund the 40 million over a seven-year period. So we can't meet 4 billion very often and get to 40 Million. So just keep that in mind as well. >> Alright, mission Bart, if you don't mind coming up, I have a I want to assure there's the 2 attorneys in the room understand what we're doing. And I want to assure that you guys are in favor of what we're discussing right now. So we're looking putting a threshold of $250,000 per applicant and they can apply. As many times as they want. And then the second part will be the capital is operational. We're looking Yes, you know where I Fathers were at 50 or 60% it. >> Through the chair or to the chair, if you want, I can summarize the amendment as it stands now. >> And then I just want to assure that both attorneys understand and then you guys are good with it. >> So the amendment that was proposed in second, it is that no more than 50% of the annual allocation to the overall eastside grants program can up to Up to 50% could be allocated towards capital projects. >> And then the remainder, wherever you are land on it right now, we're at 50%. >> there is a cap on grants for programmatic or for programs of 250,000 and you all it indicated in the other part was that multiple applications could be submitted per category. Now. More than one ok for the same program or project. Categories like you can actually make a 50. >> Yeah. So thank you, DR. Sue Men. Appreciate the clarification because there's a few different ways you can slice this. >> Now at >> What I would say you can only apply one grant per category, but you can be awarded in multiple categories, ok, I don't want ntt acts out. Throw sulzbacher out there just as an example. They can apply in all 4 categories and they could be awarded in all 4, but they can't submit 3 grandson, one category. >> to the extent that a single project or program could qualify for multiple categories. Do you want them to be able to apply? Instance, they need to choose. They need to pick. So it's. They can apply in multiple categories, but they need to be for different programs or projects. Is that correct? They can make a one word and they can apply. >> For one grant in each category, ok, can be awarded multiple grants because I've got an application in each category. >> So the clarification I'm seeking is they can apply in 4 categories. They can get up to 2.50 of its programmatic in 4 categories. Do you want there to be an ability that the same program that might be applicable in multiple categories can get to 50 so they could get 750,000 for one program. Note now. So it's per program. I think it's important that >> multiple organizations can get my >> per program or project. I appreciate that clarification. If I didn't say that the first time I apologize. >> All right. U.S. With Jean Bart and, you know, mine are you guys in favor? Are you in favor of that proposal? >> The care. The part with for the capital improvements. That part seems fine. Having the ability for a group to get multiple awards. >> And different categories. I think it's a bad idea because we're seeing that with kids. Hope Alliance, where they're dealing with the issue where Jacksonville, as big as it is with all the nonprofits and all the organizations and the funds are concentrated within like 3 or 4 groups. And that creates the issues that we're now seeing. The kids Hope Alliance. I think there's enough organizations in Jacksonville to accommodate if if this year you want apply in this category. Great the next year, you can apply in a different category. I think that that would be are fair way of making sure the money is spread to a variety of organizations. >> If you don't mind state your name. And I just sure legislation on bar address on file. All right. Thank you. All right, MISTER Mind State your name and address for the record. Please. >> Daniel Non Nelson Mullins 50 North Laura Street to 41st floor. Other clarification I wanted to make sure of was that the limitations that we're talking about only applied to city dollars and not. Private dollars. I would expect. But this nonprofit would go out and speak. Funding for other programs from, you know, large foundations like the into Scott Foundation's 4th. And they MAY got a grant of $500,000 for that program and that might exceed these limitations. But it's private dollars. That's a great point. Thank you, MR. Produce of with what you heard. You want to. >> Add to that. Thank you, chair. Yeah. I mean, I think one of the things that I want impress upon people's like this is the enabling language. >> But the board will still have kind of a lot of control over what each program looks like every year and how dollars are are appropriated. Other thing is we did put in this legislation that if you are an Eastside Anthony or you have you are a business or a nonprofit based in the east side that you get some preferential treatment. So like if you are a bility housing goodwill name another large and to your corporate down just about upon whatever else like. You're going to compete with other folks my expectation is in the next couple years, we're going to see a lot more. Businesses and and to the news coming out of the east side incorporating. You know, learn, you know, doing doing the work and now they're going to be able to compete a lot more in some of the It's just a matter of. The concerns that are brought up are quite real. I think we have seen that that that too many of the same groups. Do you get the dollars? But I still think that we put enough guardrails in here and we know that this board when they are established and they create the Matrix and the way in which the programs are going to be established like, hey, we want these kind of programs. They'll do. They'll have the where with all because they're so close to the ground work already that they'll be able to. Make sure that the same 3 nonprofits are the same. 3 businesses don't get all the work. Look, I'm trying to give them as much. Powers possible. And then again. They make the determination, their borders, their work still goes to our budget process. I think there's enough layers there to make sure that there's. We putting the limitation on dollar amount. I think that's right. Think it's very right. But I still want to give them as much leeway as possible and we'll see how this works the next year, too. Thank MISTER Peterson. Chair to I guess, Councilmember Salem, just to get some clarity, MISS To focus on trying make sure our nuts agree on your amendment. >> And I have noted that you said the organization cannot commit more than the current two-year dollars. So I just want to make sure that that is or isn't a part of your amendment. All right, MISTER Salem, you're recognized. Yeah, a couple things up. >> Private dollars. I assume if they get profit dollars, it's for a particular project work or something. And that should be separate from all this. >> Number Keep in mind, this is 7, 40 million over 7 years. So that's roughly if you average close to 6 billion dollars a year, I put to 50 in there for a reason because I walk multiple people to be able to to be successful. But to to address Councilmember Palou. So they're going to be scored. I mean, so board's going to score man, whoever gets the highest scores, it's going to get the money. And i don't think you should punish organizations that are doing good work you know, the board can't manipulate that process their score. I've watched it very closely it to the opioid program, how they're scored and I've seen people get upset when they're scored. But, you know, that's the process. So at 2.50, with potentially 6, 7 million dollars a year. They're going to be a lot of organizations and you MAY have somebody wins 2 or 3 different categories, but that MAY be 500 or $750,000 out of 6 million dollars. So it's it's not overwhelming by any means. So. Summer, picked that number kind of low for that very reason, at least to start off. Thank you. Chair. Council are sounds that I can agree more like a I think that there will be. >> There's enough in here to make sure that that. The Pi is not so small. I think enough. I think enough. For-profit and nonprofit groups are going to be able to perceive good funding. I think it will be multiple awardees for the same type of project. Housing rehab. I would think that that the board might say we want to do millions dollars is here in housing rehab and get 100 Holmes done this year. You're going to select multiple different. Operators to do that work. And I imagine many of them will be eastside entities. I also want to make note that this board. Through the legislation and other means like they'll be able to. Q a the work that gets done. And if an entity or awardee again home repair it in repair the home correctly or out of the 20. They were supposed to do. Only 7 of them got done within a year. Like you're gonna be able that work, recognize, hey, what we paid or what we awarded the dollars for. Didn't get done. Now next cycle when they apply for something they could be didn't for it. I just want make sure that is something that that's available to them like it. You don't. We have a we have a noncompliant list with our own city for for nonprofits that don't do what they're supposed to do. I imagine this entity will have that same or that this board have that same kind of power to say he didn't do the work that we said he did that way. When you come by next year, you're you're ranking plummeted. You probably will go toward the dollar. I think that's going that that that to me is another great way to make sure that if the same entities get the dollars every year and yet some of them don't do the work they're supposed to do. They getting for it and then are able to kind of kind of get to the same level of of awardee status as they did before and can one of attorneys is kinda verified. That's available to us. The book, the book. So We Award, you know, Philip Peterson to fix 20 homes, you only fix 7 of them and through them, you screwed up now moneys that you didn't spend come back to us. And also next year, when you apply for the same dollars we get to put on your application like, well, you know, you didn't do the work. You're going to see kind of like your score lowers. That's something at this point on the power to do right. Through the chair to counter please. I would imagine that that would be part of their grant application that they look at past performance. If you want to make sure that that is absolutely included. I think it needs to be in this legislation. Otherwise it'll be up to this organization to develop that to say, like past performance is a measure of already status. Have to do it. Another amendment. I know we're still on the settlements ought to get that through. But I I would like Mr, recognized and then we'll take action. I'm and I hate keep bringing up the opioid. But I've spent a lot of time with an attend. A lot of the meetings, the the 2 staff members of the only people of dollars, which is. >> Interestingly for 5 million dollars go out in visit each one of the the awards and see how they're doing monitor it. I I think that's the responsibility of the staff. And clearly that needs to be if there are because for the opioid dollars, if it's not done right, the feds can come back and grab that money. So it's very, very important that it's done and done correctly. So I think clearly that needs to be factored into future grants they're not comply with the grant that they already received. And I think we do need language, which is separate from the Salem Amendment. But I think we do new language that reflects that. Thank you. Before we take action, I just want to touch on one thing which was was was stated from is John Barton. And I kind to the same thing during the psc process. >> I'm favor of having multiple people apply and be awarded. >> One of the reasons why the psg process right Carney has where you can only apply get granted once pro categories because we made that changed last year. It was because I want to say was because of me. Try to push that because we had many entities apply the same category and get double funding. And so I wanted to just make it worthy. Apply once I don't care how many categories are 3 mvp categories if the by all 3 of the when one that saw the quid. And what we did was. Police said, well, you can only win in one category because set up by 3 and when possibly 3, which is what Carney having with his g. But I'm in favor of of having it where you apply for one category. You win that category. You can apply for any more categories. There's so many more people out there. They need assistance, but also where we have a finite number of dollars available once a 40 million dollars is done, it's done. So we have to be mindful of the growth of the community and everybody I'm in favor of the 2.50, max, but I'm not in favor of applying for multiple categories. I'm in favor of one category psg as it one. 25. So the fight that we're doing to 50, that's double of psg's already granting as it is. So that's significant step up. So I think by by keeping it up to 50 ideas for your one, let's see how your one plays out. Because what I want is your one is for one or 2 entities to gobble up all the dollars in one year. Let's see how your one truly plays out by having multiple people apply and be awarded. So I would just make an amendment to the sentimental, which will be keeping to 50 max, but only one category as we can win on right for your one. So we could see how this unravels. That's where I'm at right now, MR. PRESIDENT recognized. Well, I'm waiting for a second. If anybody wants Thank you. Thank you, chair and I I very controlled the Senate Amendment. And I think that the board the board will be able to put the limitation. I want to give them the again. This is enabling legislation. The board could say. >> Yeah, we don't. We don't necessarily want to see. Multiple entities get it. Get multiple different categories this year later on. But we're allowing for them to have that right. I think that they should. I think the point of a counter Salem saying like, example, good will operate step store. Good will can also do a number of different a things in the community like I don't want they need to make sure store says open and that's one of the things they apply for under homelessness. Parent, for instance, or and workforce development. And but I do want to limit them if they also say we could do another workforce development or another workforce housing, you know, and I limit the board will make that decision by the board will be able to say, hey, where we want to put most of our time and energy into this one category and asked like again to everyone in the audience, those 4 categories, they will not be equal every year in terms of how much money goes into them. It will be determined by the board in the administration will come back to us through the budget process. Right? So if there's a year where homelessness runs rampant and you want to put most of your time and attention to that. You could do that if you realize economic development is the main priority you could put you get 4 million dollars, 3 million dollars into that bucket. And so like. The board will have the ability to heavily. Altar where their priorities are and how many grantees can really go for. And I just want to give them that right? Not options. I don't want to limit. I think its limits. I think very happy with the settlement. I called the Salem Police Amendment. All right. MISS The populace. You're recognized. >> Through the chair to the committee. So I for the Salem Amendment. With respect to your concern, Councilmember Arias so the way he described his amendment was well, they can apply in multiple categories. They have to apply for different programs or projects in those categories, they can only apply once per category so that they have 4 different programs or projects and they want to apply for each one of those and they fit into each of the different 4 categories. They can do that, but they can only get one grant at the end of it is the way I understood it. So poor category. Okay. So I just that was that I appreciate that clarification. So I I understand the context of the amendment little bit better. >> Let's also understand the context of that context. What we're saying is one entity could qualify for 4 categories and potentially receive a million dollars. That's not what I want. That's not fair. A million dollars. That's 25% of the 4 million dollars is going out to community right now. That's what I'm trying to avoid right now. That's that's not. That's exactly what we're allowing. And we have the chance. The opportunity to stop that from the beginning. I say let's do that. You're recognized. >> Thank you, MR. Chair on MISTER Chair. I think that's a false, false premise. The only way according to what I've heard thus far, that the board after looking at the metrics and scoring that that one individual can win all 4. If that one individual is truly the best of everyone. So there's a system in place that would prohibit that one entity from being able to capture all 4 categories. The board would have to be corrupt. >> Or or or or this entity. >> I would have to be the best. And so. I kind of a laissez faire. I kind of agree with letting the market determine. >> And let the board determine who is the best in each and every category. And I understand our responsibility of of due diligence to protect the taxpayers. But we don't want to make this process too restrictive. Want to make it competitive. And I think just say you can't apply when they MAY be eminently qualified. It's not fair to the process. So. If the board is going to make the decision, then the board has the responsibility of making sure that this one entity is indeed the most eligible, the most qualified to be able to win that category. And so let the process work. Sleighs affair. Thank you, chair through the chair to MR. Populous. This is what I thought you were going the you going to make earlier regards to the Salem Amendment proposal. >> Motion. Regards to the area's motion as well. So or amendment. >> That they can apply in all 4 categories. However. >> They can only win one category of be awarded win category. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Carper, you're correct. That was a different way. You could slice it so rather than saying they can only apply in one category and then it's up to the scoring process to determine if they would even get a grant. And that one category, if you want to allow that, they can apply in all 4 categories, but only the highest court program or project amongst of 4 categories is the one that receives a grant. The new ensure that that entity would only get the one grand. That was a different way. You could do it. And so with that being said, I don't know if you want to consider that with to the chair. If that's what you you were going in terms of why you would have only entity apply for one. >> And the one particular category because it to me, it makes sense that entity can apply and are all 4 categories, however, can only be awarded in one because this that seems a little bored little I just a more fair, but it seems to be fair because it that way, they're not excluded. They don't need to choose a particular category. They can, you know, do the paperwork, do the work? Apply? And then they wanted that means that they're no longer considered in the other 3 categories. Ms Cara since you asked me that question out all responded You're right. >> You apply in all 4 categories say I have a project. My project is homeless. Whatever want to build tissue paper from us. Paying categories and I when want to categories, I win that. But that doesn't mean I also can apply to build, you know, cars for homes in other categories. And also not so me as well areas. I can win all 4 categories in a different project different scope. So what they're saying is, yes, you can apply in all 4 categories for one project. But if you have multiple projects, you can still apply in other categories and still windows of the projects, another category. So potentially you potentially win. I dollars as MR. Mao do it in your pride because your best qualified. But I also think that there's a lot opportunity taking away from other people that are also equally or maybe slightly best qualified as it is. Right now. We're looking at 2 million dollars know maybe less than that. Now they said we do the 60% capital verse operational. We're going looking at 1.5 million dollars between 4 categories are looking at roughly $500,000 per category. If to entities when a category there goes one category out the door. That's 2 entities, you know. So I I just want to like said, being a more practical, unfair, but we'll see how the boats go on this part. So MR. Salem, you're recognized and then So we could then take a vote on right? >> Thank you, chair. I just I just disagree with. Absolutely disagree with. I don't want to punish good organizations that are out there that can. What we want is change. Why would we award money to organizations that are inferior to others? That's point number one. Point. Number 2, I keep hearing from my good friend Councilmember Palou. So about discretion of the board. There is no discretion here. The percentages come to during the budget process. We'll we approve those the dollar store in each category. 5 members of the board. If I recall, I have to score those thanks. They're scored. There's a number. That's who gets award. It. Next year. The end and the dollars are funded and they're monitored, cetera, cetera. Next year, they MAY make a recommendation. They want to alter those percentages in different categories. So the board just can't arbitrarily change this process. Thank During the could come back next year. So I keep hearing discretion of the board When we are setting up a process here that they have to implement now, it could be change year to year, but it can't be changed during the year. Once we approve those percentages. And I want I Councilmember Rob areas painted the worst case scenario of at 60% going to Wards Capital Project and limited. But keep in mind, this is 7 years of 40 Million. It's going to be 6 million dollars o plus posted these years. So there will be a minimum of 3 million dollars or more divided between the categories. I'm not crazy. About 60%, but I I agreed to it because you're the district Guyana. I respect that. But starting off, I am. From Lee believe we want the best organizations the best scores to get it. He served as a producer to get action. Thank you, chair and I appreciate that. Now I'm still very supportive of just the Amendment, not supportive of of this other one. I'm gonna give another example lisc. >> So you've got, you know, Dr Peter Cohen to not only is from the East side, lisc could do something in all 4 categories. They could do something for a project boots. They could do something for home repair. They could do something for workforce development. They could do something all for those categories. Not I want to limit an organization that's well staffed. Understands the grant process and those that stuff, if they would apply to all 4 groups like that. That's what's in my mind. Set. And so. It's just a matter of. There will be scoring. There will also be through the budget process to to accountants, help said all 4 categories. The board will say, yep, we want to put $500,000 into affordable housing. 1.2 million in 2, economic development. They will. They will make that determination. Bring it to us during the budget Like there's still there's still a lot there that they do have discretion on That's why I brought that up. Yeah, right about on this. >> Thank you me for action. You brought up another point that I'm just going to add more to the soup here. Let's somebody like lisc. Applies for capital projects. And the win. A 1 million 2 million dollars. Now you say they can also apply. For these categories and potentially one of them in the daughters. So are we going to have something in that legislation or says if you get capital, you can I get categories as well or can you still get all? >> Through to the chair? My understanding of the Salem Amendment was that they can only get one grant per project or per program. So while they can apply in multiple categories and maybe be awarded multiple times. They could. It a cap on one grant for prop. So if there's economic development project that they propose and they also have a program that they propose another category, they can get up to 250,000 for the program and they could also get a grant for the capital Project in the other category. Subject to the to the limitations of the percentages and everything else that you >> So are we saying that the cabinet they can't get 2 grants for the same capital project. Right? So we have, you know, too many dollars. We keeping up with the person? We have 2 million dollars for capital projects. What is a cap that anybody apply for a capital project right now. >> You have not established a cap except to say that up to 50% of the total allocation would go for capital projects. The other aspect that we've discussed as the percentages of the funded categories. So to the extent that either you set with those percentages are so you say 25% per category right now, the way it would work from my perspective at the Salem Amendment is approved. Is 25 so 1 million in each category up to 2 million can go to capital projects overall and maybe that Eastside cba organization decides. How do they want to give all that 2 million into the into one category or 2 up to the 25%. There's some interplay there that I think you also need to consider with that 50%. And then the percentage of funding to the categories. And to the extent you might want to just leave it to the organization to work through that and make their proposal on the annual basis is part of the budget. You can do that. And that gives the some of the flexibility that councilmember I think was looking for sure. Okay. >> his and then we will take action. Thank you. I need some clarification. So capital

OFFICE OF THE CITY

COUNCIL

COUNCIL RAUL ARIAS

District 11 SUITE 425, CITY HALL 117

WEST DUVAL STREET

JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA 32202

OFFICE (904) 255-5174

E-MAIL: ARIASR@COJ.NET

FAX (904) 255-5175

Special Committee Meeting on the Community

Benefits Agreement

December 3, 2025

Agenda

I. Introductions and Welcome Chair, Councilman Raul Arias

II. Updates from OGC

III. Updates from Administration

IV. Finalization of Draft Legislation Establishing the Eastside Grants Programs Grant Process

V. Public Comment

VI. Adjourn

Showing the first 24,000 of 111,913 characters. The full document is at the source.

All right. Good morning. Today is DECEMBER 3rd we are commencing Rcb a special committee meeting. Introductions to my left. Please. >> Pretty nice for the administration. Brian Russell Council research, our Richelle Office of General Counsel. Very Plus Office of General Counsel Peterson counselor's office. Our City Council district One Ron Salem group, 2 at large. Always district 11. >> And misd We have 3 right now here. Do we have enough for a quorum or? >> I know this crime are going to be coming a little late. So. >> MISTER Chair, you have even number of committee members. So you have an exact 3, which is 50%. So it's not a majority for quorum purposes. So to that extent, to allow some time for one of your men, you can discuss. But I would suggest that if you're prepared to vote on anything, you need to wait until you have another member here. You MAY want to just get the updates and then we can see if one of the other members arrives before you get into the legislation where you all would be taking up matters to potentially vote on. >> Okay. Yeah. Let's do have been so we're going on the agenda that we On introductions. Welcome. I we've been working for the last several months, more than a year and on on so many different topics. And last committee, we made a lot of progress, tremendous progress. I think we've had a lot of great updates. And so today going to wrap everything up to date as much as possible. And so we have a lot of work to do. Colleagues. And there are a couple things that we need to add. And to the the East Side grants program and to make sure that it to the final legislation that we could actually proposing to a full body, which means it's going to go to the committee's, the regular committees, neighborhoods rules, whatever committee, don't. And on. And then from there go to full council for a vote. So with that being said today, we're going to just kind of just wrap everything up as much as possible so we can send it up to the full body and now I'm going to go with an update from Ogc. >> Thank you. Threw the chair to the committee. So what you have in front of you for discussion today is a red line of the legislation that you all have been working through during the previous meetings of the special committee, the Red Lines reflect what was discussed and voted upon by the committee last meeting with the exception. There's one item in there that that I have included that for discussion purposes and highlight that will be get into the draft legislation that that that the purpose of this red line is so that you all can see that those changes were made confirmed that they're in keeping with the intent to the special committee and then discuss any additional changes you MAY want to address before finalize the legislation for filing has introduced by the special committee. The other hand out that you have in front of you was that chart that Doctor Salem had requested. It's a very simple chart. Ended up being pretty easy to go through the code and that addresses the grant award limitations that are applied in both the public services grant model and the opioid substance use disorder, grant model. And those are just ideas for your consideration. To the extent that you want to discuss any sort of limitations on the grant amounts, the number of applications, et cetera, as you go through this draft legislation for what I believe the chairs intent would be the final approval today. >> All right. Well, thank you for adding those in And just to confirm you to send this out, too, everybody, the redline version last Friday. >> I sent it out the Friday before the Thanksgiving Week and I believe the to the extent you were going to share with the community and have it sent out, that was the intent was to get out early so it could be shared. Thank you. >> All And now I will go to updates from the administration. This Norris. >> Thank you, chair. Just want to be as a heads-up that we will be hosting close meeting tomorrow with some of the groups that have come forward and going through what you guys recommend today, working with them on sunshine and ethics and then also ideally having a conversation on bylaws give an opportunity for back and forth and we're looking to have some consensus on that. Leaving that meeting. Okay. So. >> I'm glad you bring that up because we. We've received I received. I knew I know I have and I'm pretty sure that he some e-mails from his job. Art requesting some add-ons to the bylaws and all that. And so I know that you're going to have that meeting tomorrow. So that's the appropriate time to have a conversation with the community. I want to be sure that everybody understands that. That's kind of the purpose of tomorrow's meeting and what time that media tomorrow. >> all started to we have until 5. I hope it's not a 3 meeting, but we do have time to decide and what room is it? Its the mayor's large conference room, with more So so just for dogs out there, just obviously. >> Just make sure you make it. I mean, because that's going to be very important meeting, which is going to be the town this part today. Okay. I do have a speaker. Thank you so much. You're you're recognized. >> Just a quick question. Thank you. Chair. The committee members of this final into t they're subject sunshine law >> communication between each other is not is not allow that kind of thing. Correct? >> To the chair to Councilmember Salem, that's would be our desire whether that lives in the legislation or the bylaws. I'd have to defer to the Officer General Council. That would be our desire. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Salem. So the legislation currently does have a provision that all meetings of the board would be subject to the opens. Meads laws are sunshine law. And so to the extent that there MAY be a conflict with the bylaws that is in the legislation. >> And how about outside those meetings? Are they allowed to communicate with each other? About pending boats and all those types of things. >> That that would not no, that's not in keeping with open meetings law so that that applies to the actions of the board. And that's what's in the legislation. They're subject to the Open meetings. Law. So. They they can't we can tighten it up if you want. But that would encompass not allowing for communication outside of the sunshine. >> I to me, why would they not be any different than then the council? And which is what that provision provides, that they have to operate in the Sunshine. Okay. At the meetings in before. And so they can't lobby each other on particular votes outside their their their meetings. Is that correct? And yes, correct. That is what we're putting in the legislation. Okay. I think that's important. What I saw suggested we waive the sunshine law and I don't I don't think that's a good idea. Through the chair of the mission or us, I think you need to emphasize that in any meetings, your and once this gets going that they can't be lobbying each other on particular votes and such. >> If I might respond to the chair to counsel or Salem, I'll send you the proposed agenda we've put together for tomorrow, but it includes sunshine, Open meetings at pix. We're trying to give it'll be a brief because really have 3 hours. But we're trying to touch on those points to kind of give context for what you can expect going forward. >> Council members can attend if they're available. >> Unfortunately, no, this meeting has not been noticed. We working just the legal counsel in the community members and not expecting Council tendons. Okay. And for for the committee, it's on Page 10. Item number 7 in the draft, the station, all meetings and sessions of the board shall be held in a publicly accessible location. >> And Shelby noticed an open to the public in accordance with the Florida Open meetings law. I will add a provision that references that their actions, undertaken in accordance with the sunshine laws. Well, so it's titans that up to make sure that intent is very clear. >> I wouldn't I I think we should. Just to make it perfectly clear. Thank you. >> All right. Thank you so that completes administration's portion of it. Now in a move to number 4, which is the finalization of the draft legislation. >> The stuff Do we have? Obviously this is what we have here. Get an e-mail from any of the council members that they want to add something else last minute to it. Are we ready to just take action year? >> Through the MR. Pretty. So here is the chair. I didn't get any e-mails from any of the committee members with respect to any additional changes. But, you know, I'm happy as you see fit to what walk through it. Just so you all can kind highlight the items that we've including that one item that I mentioned earlier that I wanted to address with the committee because it was an addition that wasn't discussed at the last meeting. I'm happy to go through it. However, you like okay. >> Well, that all kick started and then maybe we'll have some more conversation from not so I have 3 things that I want to just address. I'm pretty sure maybe are already in here or not. But I'm just summit team is tough. Obviously, Tony, who came so number will do we have an update? I'm not of the actual what the boundaries are. >> To the chair. So the map that's in currently included shows the boundaries of the of the East side community. And that was the same map that was included in the community benefits agreement. The Supplemental Community Benefits Agreement are in tension between myself and MISTER Peterson is to work with the appropriate department to develop a map that would reflect the neighborhoods. And so that is something we would put into the legislation in lieu of this. It would be this map. But with demarcation of the 5 neighborhoods because their reference with respect to the appointments to the board of directors that that would be included. What gets filed? >> Kind of like a district map. We have different boundaries for each correct. An Avs to cut. The neighborhoods are reflected in the will what we see the updated. Not by next like when it comes to regular committee process. >> The intent would unless the committee wants us to bring it back for your review. We would bring that as part of the building gets filed. It's if it's acceptable to the committee for us to do that. All right. And what's the department that you're working with to get this of that amount? >> It would put most likely that the planning department. All right, MR. Senator, you're recognized. >> Our our the neighborhoods that well defined that north of this street and east of that street is Fairfield versus Oakland, cetera. >> Through the chair to Councilmember Salem. So that is probably going to you know, we're going to develop an initial map, but I would surmise that that will be a topic of discussion as the legislation makes its way through the committees. And unless you wanted us to seek some input from the community first before we filed a bill to make sure that they've had opportunity to look at that map. But I don't know that they're that well-defined meeting, MR. Palou so could address that since it's in his district. >> All right. I fear that process. Recognized sir. To that end, was gonna say with the 3 army tomorrow. If individuals do come in tomorrow and say, hey, look, here's exactly where the boundary is. Here's where Longbranch her tears were fearful starts like that. They'll be the ones to kind of help, right? That I imagine the planning process probably has. Part of the planning department probably have some good map somewhat. What what what the neighborhoods strictly look like prior to us putting much of highways of to mark on active duty, active duty starting tomorrow Friday and then Saturday, Sunday. And this the mayor's administration is meeting for tomorrow which I think is in the best interest for this. Cute. Alright. All MISTER Morrow, you're recognized. Thank you, MISTER Just to concur. What the COUNCILMAN Palooza because I. >> My wife has relatives who live out the sun and they know they know where the line of demarcation isn't. So the community will know the planning department will know that should not be a difficult task and identify. In fact, I'm looking at the map right now it seems pretty sufficient to me. But if it needs a little bit more I'm okay with that. >> submission or just for tomorrow. Could be one of your talking points to identify the the boundaries for the map. >> We will add that to the agenda and I will check with. I think I've worked as planning before to get a big maps, maybe even have people trot out or something. So led up to date can you get the map from planning department before tomorrow mean? So least you have a rough idea that we could show it to them to make sure that they're ok with it or not. The nannies can make some revisions to it. That's what I'm hoping is to get a map from planning printed. That's pretty large and have it MAY be on display or something but will add that to date and print it out that we have it in him. All right. Thank you. All right. So that was a number one. I have 2 which I sheet of paper here. Then MISTER Salem, I guess, requested similar to my point was on for the psu model. We have any acts of $125 per applicant and they can only apply for one category. Do we have something in writing in here? Similar to this? >> To the chair know so that you all went through a lot of other types guardrails with respect to the eligibility of applicants, the eligibility documents that they would have to Posen, not all made its way into the legislation is reflected in the red line. This was some additional information that the committee thought might be helpful to have on paper. So you can kind of start to get an idea of what the other programs look like. So both of them have a funding model. That's a high score model. So the high scores what gets funded as you were indicating the public service grant program has a maximum grant amount that can be awarded for any program. A project of 125,000 for the opioid and Substance Use Disorder Grant program. It's 500,000 and the Public Service Grant program only allows one application per category while the opioid and substance use Disorder Grant program allows multiple applications. There's no limit on any number of applications they can submit per their categories. But the only the highest ranked one of what submitted from any particular organization is what receives funding some of the things that we had discussed, MISTER Chair that the committee could consider in in lieu and light of this and in keeping with kind of what's happening with this particular type of grant program is you could also look you, talked about tiered funding. You MAY consider is the funding for capital something that would be different than how you would limit the funding for programmatic programs versus the capital projects. So there's few different ways you could slice it if the committee has a desire to apply. The is sort of similar type of grant award limitations. >> Yeah, and that's what I have. You know, I know programmatic versus capital and then also potentially a percentage based, right? So because easy one capital project could wipe out the entire fund. We have 4 categories just about One of the categories. >> That is correct. There are 4 categories which I call funded. Can't funding categories are funded categories and that kind of goes to that. One item that I indicated earlier that have added to the legislation for the purposes of discussion. It's on Page 7. There are some red lining there and it talks about the application. Allocation to the 4 disciplines that are listed in the community benefits agreement. Those include affordable housing workforce, housing, economic Development and mitigation of homelessness in the East side. So in keeping with how the supplemental cba was outlined, identify those as the for funding categories for the this grant program that kind of mimics how we handle it for both the opioid substance use disorder, great program as well as the public services grant program. But that is not a specific item that was discussed or voted upon the way I've added here, MR. Chair is that when they come in Yulee, the Eastside cba organization comes annually ask for their allocation through the budget process that they would be able to recommend percentages or amounts that would be provided to each funded categories. Part of that request. You can establish those yourselves as the committee and recommends specific allocations or percentages. Now you could allow it to be a part of the budget process on an annual basis, which is similar to how psg handles it. One thing that you would might want to consider is that if you want to allow it to be established by the East Side Corporation, as you MAY recall, each year for public service grants when they identify the percentages, they want to allocate to each of the most vulnerable persons in needs categories. They bring that to the council through legislation for a blessing before they proceed on using those as their percentage basis in the budget That's not referenced here as far as legislation for council approval. But that could be a part of the discussion on this item. >> All right. So I'll open up to the body now. Those are my might, I guess, points of actions that you guys want to add something else you can. But I will say let's speak on these first. And if you don't want to add something else will welcome back to q. So produce a recognized. >> Thank you, And yeah, I mean to to the point of whether we do it here, we through the budget process. I think we've done a lot about budget process. I don't want to handcuff ourselves right now within this legislation to say certain percentages will go to x, y and z categories. I want them to come to us every year through the budget process saying, you know what, we need more help on workforce housing this year. We need more help on economic development this year. Ravenous to say it should be one quarter. One quarter, one quarter, one quarter in this bill. So I want them to kind of have that. I want to I want to put limitations now. I want them tell us every year and that was going to be actually. My question is we can kind of walk through exactly how the funding process works so that way, everyone kind of knows it. And we kind of get a good, a good sense of that sort of you want to do right now. But get back to that My other questions. Well on on on the points that I brought. Yeah. I mean, like you questions. All right. I'm I'm pretty comfortable with with what you put out the the idea again, the percentage of is there a certain. I want talk about capital projects, something that's right. The what exactly do you want to see like? Do you want to see 50% of all dollars will go to capital projects or are you just saying that the limited, you know, that the cost for a couple projects should. X amount? I don't think we should limit the cost copper project because any capital project could be a million or 10 Million. Whatever the case is, I what I don't want to see is. >> You know, we have 4 million dollars in the budget coming out of here for the side and one capital project wipe everything out. One project. And then what about the rest of the community on? Sure that we have a balanced approach. One coming to this. Maybe it's a 50% capital, 50% operational. I don't I just want to sure that everybody gets access to this and not just whoever is building on property. I want the workforce. I want the small businesses that want them. Everybody. The thriving there, too. So I want to assure that we have about its approach for this, maybe capital product or a certain number amount. It's unanimous approval by the board or something like because I don't think that will happen. I just think practically they're not going to blow money is not going to blow in on one capital projects. I think for that reason alone, I think people in the room are going to say, I'm sorry, we have 7 other needs that we need accomplish this year. Also, we've specifically put the legislation that monies will not be spent until substantial completion. >> Of that capital Project based on the legislation. So like if we say in your one with the 4 million, we have by time this gets into your to that, you know that they will have another pot of money for that or the dollar amount will be budget to them for the next year. So don't I don't think it's going to be spent. On one year. That's just not a concern of mine, but I'm I want to hear through your process like do you. What do you have a specific desire right now? Right now, I want to see how your one goes. First of all, we don't know how it's going that's going be. We could address us to right? That's kind what I was Yeah, like let's let's get a good sense of what this looks like. And also we're still going to see this go through. I assume neighborhoods, Committee and Finance Committee rules, I assume to right. That's going to go through multiple committees. I imagine like we're going to have other colleagues kind of take there. Look at this and get their impressions of stuff. So I also don't want us to that. To try to solve every problem, right? The second we need to move this bill and I'm assuming we'll have other colleagues have different ideas. All right. MISTER Saying you're recognized, I'm sorry. And also want to recognize MISS Correct. Mary has joined Thank all right. Thank you, Chair. I'm good. I'm going to throw something out because I've dealt with a lot of this to the opioid process. >> And I think the discussion capital versus operations is a good one. Going. I think this committee needs to put something in this bill or else. It's going to be a huge discussion through the regular committees. I'm going to throw something out. You guys can react to it. I would think that the Capitol should be no more than 50%. And it needs to be and I'm not sure how to work this Mary, but you can't count on future funding in future years. It needs to be a project that can be completed with the dollars that you're getting. For example, it can't be a 6 million dollar project we're going to ask for 2 million dollars for 3 years because you don't know what future years are going to be like number 2, I limit the the operational grants to 2.50 And the ability of people to apply in multiple categories is okay. And I I think having looked at the opioid agreement, I think that that will. You might disagree with that. But I think that that's a good place to start. And then the committee can make recommendations to change it going forward. All throughout. Throw that out Thank you. I will recognize MISTER Peterson. Thank you for recognizing chair. >> This at the piece is the to 50 and the line for multiple categories 100%. I I second that motion. As for the 50% on capital projects. I do think that's a good idea. No more than 50, but I but I also think that there should be an ability to say you know what, a unanimous body. You can you can go over that or some like that. If we allow for everyone on that on the voting member that on that board agrees with it, move forward. But I see MISTER Peterson moving. I'm going to something nice. MISS A populace for says, MR. Pearson. >> a couple of things. Number one, traditionally grant Processees like these go by the high score model. So you're not doing Indiana must consent to approve a project. It's the high score we talked about in in the legislation. We added that no less than 5 members of the board of directors have to score in each of the categories. So I I'm not sure how that would comport with the high score model. The other item. I just want to get clarification on from Doctor Salem is with respect to the 50%. Is that 50% of the annual allocation for the program. So if it's 4 million up 2 million can go to capital projects. >> That is that is my

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Special Committee on the Community Benefits Agreement 2.0
  • Special Committee on the Community Benefits Agreement 2.0 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 8516fa452a2dd7d1305ba27580c34944. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record