POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

City Council Meeting - 5/1/2023

Monday, May 1, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

City Council Meeting - 5/1/2023

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

TALK ABOUT THAT

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 116,869 stored characters

GOOD EVENING, EVERYONE. IT IS NOW 5: 03 P.M. I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THE SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING TO ORDER. MR. CITY MANAGER? >> THANK YOU, MADAM MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. WELCOME TO THIS BUDGET WORKSHOP IN WHICH WE WILL COVER QUITE A FEW TOPICS. FROM UNFUNDED ACCRUED LIABILITIES, WHICH IS ALWAYS AN EXCITING TOPIC AND WE WILL JUMP INTO THAT IN A MOMENT. BUT ALSO -- THE BUDGET IS PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT THING YOU DO AS A COUNSEL. THIS LOVELY DOCUMENT HERE. YOU KNOW, IT'S AN INCH OR TWO. AND PROBABLY THE LEAST GLAMOROUS IN MANY WAYS. IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR ANYTHING THAT WE WANT TO DO STARTING ON JULY 1st. YOU NEED TO ADOPT A NEW BUDGET BY JUNE 30th. WE CAN DO ALL OF THESE GREAT THINGS THAT THE COUNCIL HAS AUTHORIZED. THIS WORKSHOP, WE WILL KICK IT OFF WITH AN UPDATE FROM ERIC SCRIVEN WITH NHA ADVISORS. ERIC HAS BEEN WITH US I FOR QUITE A WHILE. ACTUALLY IS A PLEASURE WHEN WE HAD ERIC COME BEFORE US. HE WILL GIVE US AN UPDATE ON CALIPERS AND COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT HE HAS. ,, ERIC, I WOULD APPRECIATE IT. >> HELLO. TAUGHT TO TURN THIS ON? OKAY, GREAT. GOOD EVENING, MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL, MADAM MAYOR, AND STAFF. WE THOUGHT WE WOULD DO AND WE TRY TO BE WITHIN 25 MINUTES OR SO. WE WILL GET A QUICK UPDATE ON A LITTLE BIT OF DEFINITION FOR MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. ON THE CALIPERS , THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY, AS WELL AS DISCUSS WHAT IS HAPPENING OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS. HE HAS SOME WORKSHOPS LAST YEAR. WITH RESPECT TO EDUCATION, BUT ALSO WE WERE CONSIDERING THE CITY WAS CONSIDERING DOING A RESTRUCTURING OF THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. MARCUS INTEREST RATES IS VERY QUICKLY THAT PROJECT INFEASIBLE. WE'LL TALK ABOUT SOME OTHER COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE AND OF INTEREST TO THE CITY AS YOU MAKE YOUR DELIBERATIONS ON PRIORITIES FOR A BUDGET. DURING THE NEXT MONTH AND A HALF. I NEED TO DO THIS. WHICH ONE IS IT? / SO THE BIG OVERVIEW IS THIS IS , I BELIEVE THIS IS THE LARGEST LIABILITY ON THE BALANCE SHEET. CURRENTLY, IT STANDS AT $42 MILLION. THAT IS A LARGE DECREASE EARLIER BEFORE WHEN IT WAS ABOUT THE $65 MILLION RANGE . IS A LITTLE BIT OF A MOVING TARGET AS WE WILL SHOW YOU. THIS CALIPER LIABILITY AND YOUR BALANCE SHEET, WHICH IS REALLY THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY THAT YOU OWE TO FULLY FUND YOUR BENEFITS FOR EMPLOYEES OVER THE TERM OF THE NEXT 34 YEARS. THIS $42 LIABILITY IS GOING TO GO UP. WE KNOW THAT. THERE ARE A COUPLE OF ODD THINGS WITH CALIPERS. THEY RE-EVALUATE BASED ON THEIR INVESTMENT EARNINGS EVERY YEAR. ONCE THE LIABILITY IS AND IT GOES UP AND GOES DOWN. WHEN, BASED ON THE DELETE, THEY HAD A VERY GOOD YEAR TO DROP THAT UAL $42 MILLION. THEY ARE NOT CURRENTLY FROM TWO YEARS AGO WE HAD A 21% INVESTMENT RETURN BY CALIPERS. UNFORTUNATELY, LAST YEAR, BUT WILL 22, THEY HAD A VERY BAD YEAR. WE'RE GOING TO BECAUSE OF THE DELAY. WILL THE DOUBLE INCREASE THE CITY'S UNFUNDED LIABILITY TO GO $71 MILLION . UNFORTUNATELY, RIGHT NOW, THEY ARE UNDERPERFORMING AGAIN . THIS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR, FISCAL YEAR 2023. NOW, THEY ARE AT 3.4%. WHAT THEIR TARGET IS 6.8%. SO WITH THAT, THERE IS LIKELY, UNLESS THERE'S A CHANGE FOR THE BETTER, THERE'S LIKELY TO BE AN INCREASE UP TO ABOUT $70 MILLION OR SO. THE CITY ALSO HAS , THEY ISSUED A PENSION OBLIGATION BOND ABOUT 20 YEARS AGO. 2006. THERE WERE $40 MILLION OUTSTANDING ON THOSE. SO ALL OF THESE THINGS TOGETHER CREATE A REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FOR YOUR UNFUNDED LIABILITY. IT BOUNCES AROUND A LITTLE. GOES UP AND DOWN. IT TURNED. BUT WE ARE HERE TO TALK ABOUT ALL OF IT IS HOW THE CITY CAN MANAGE THAT. IN SHORT, LIKE A LOT OF THE BUDGETING AND THINGS THAT YOU CONSIDER, LIABILITY NEEDS TO BE MANAGED SO YOU CAN CREATE UNPREDICTABLE PAYMENTS , REPAYMENT SCHEDULE. USUALLY, THE BEST WAY TO DO IT WHEN THINGS ARE BOUNCING AROUND LIKE CALIPERS LIABILITY, IS ON YOUR SIDE. WE LOOK AT THE STRATEGIES THAT CAN BE USED FOR COST MANAGEMENT. THIS LINE AND THAT WAS VERY BIG IN YOUR ANIMAL BUDGET. SO THE BACKGROUND, A FEW SLIDES ON THE BACKGROUND. TWO PLANS, MISCELLANEOUS AND YOUR SAFETY. AND WITHIN THOSE TWO PLANS , WE HAVE WHAT WE WOULD CALL CLASSIC EMPLOYEES. THOSE ARE THE OLDER. AND THEN THERE ARE THE NEW PLAN FOR BOTH THE MISCELLANEOUS AND SAFETY. THAT IS A LOWER BENEFIT, PEPRA. WHAT YOU HAVE OUTSTANDING IS ABOUT , WHAT? 750 COVERED MEMBERS OF WHICH THERE ARE ABOUT 260 THAT ARE ACTIVE. SO IT IS CLOSE TO ONE THIRD ARE ACTIVE . HAVE ABOUT TWO THIRDS THAT ARE NO LONGER ACTIVE, BUT REMAIN COVERED. OVERTIME, THE PEPRA EMPLOYEES WILL BE A LARGER SHARE OF YOUR BENEFIT PLANS. AND BASED ON THE WAY PEPRA STRUCTURE, THERE IS VERY LOW LIABILITY BECAUSE THE OR LOWER BENEFIT PLANS. SO THAT IS GOING TO COST CONTAIN, IF YOU WILL, OVER TIME. THE RIGHT NOW, WE HAVE THE LARGEST LIABILITY THAT WE WAS GOING TO GO UP TO $71 MILLION NEXT YEAR. AND THAT RELATE ALMOST 100%, IF NOT HUNDRED PERCENT YOUR METHOD PLAN . THE OUTSTANDING CLASSIC PLANS. ANY QUESTIONS ON EXISTING PLANS? LET ME GRAB THIS. IT WAS GRANDFATHERED IN, I BELIEVE IT WILL 2013 OR 2012. UNDER GOVERNOR JERRY BROWN'S WATCH. WHEN THEY TRANSITIONED. SO IF YOU WERE A CLASSIC EMPLOYEE, HE REMAINS . YOU WERE GRANDFATHERED INTO THOSE PLANS GOING FORWARD. THAT NEW PUBLIC EMPLOYEES, BOTH IN MISCELLANEOUS , AND ON THE SAFETY PLANS. THEY WERE PUT INTO THE PEPRA. IS THAT RIGHT? >> [ INDISCERNIBLE - LOW VOLUME ] SEA IT IS. IT IS STILL A DEFINED BENEFIT. FIRST A DEFINED CONTRIBUTION. THE DIFFERENCE BEING THE LOWER BENEFIT PLAN. IF YOU LOOK AT THE CHART UP THERE, PEPRA MISCELLANEOUS IS 2% CREDIT PER YEAR OF SERVICE , BEGINNING AT AGE 62. WHERE IS THE CLASSIC PLANS AT 2% , YOU CAN RETIRE EARLIER AT 55. OR 2% AT 60. AND NOW PEPRA IS 2% TO 62. THE SAME THING IS 85. IS A GENEROUS, IF YOU WILL, BENEFIT PLAN. ASHLEY EARLY, THAT KIND OF CONTAINS THE COST SIGNIFICANTLY. SO THIS IS REALLY HOW YOU LOOK AT, AND WE SHALL LOOK AT, THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. IT IS DESIGNATED ON TWO BARS TO THE RIGHT. I SHOULD SAY, THERE ARE TWO PAYMENTS OTHER THAN HE THINKS EVERY YEAR. WHAT IS WHAT WE WOULD CALL A NORMAL COST. THE COST YOU PAY FOR CURRENT EMPLOYEES, JUST TO STAY CURRENT. MOTHER IS THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY AS I MENTIONED BEFORE. CALPERS, ASSUMPTIONS CHANGE PERIODICALLY. ALSO , HE HAS RETURNED FOR THE TARGET. SOMETIMES, THEY DO GO ABOVE THE TARGET . RELATE TO THE TARGET, AND CREATE THE LIABILITY. THE LIABILITY IS DEFINED ON THE RIGHT-HAND SIDE. IT IS 27 $6 MILLION FOR THE CITY OF PITTSBURG. THAT IS THE ACTUARY ESTIMATES , WHICH, YOU KNOW, I AM NOT SURE IS THE PRECISE FIGURE. BUT WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME TRYING TO FIGURE OUT MORTALITY RATES FOR YOUR CURRENT EMPLOYEES THAN 750 COVERED EMPLOYEES OVER TIME. HOW MUCH THEY, IF YOU WILL ON THE COUNT OF CalPERS WILL BE REQUIRED TO BEAR ALL THE BENEFITS THE EMPLOYEES ARE DOING AS A RETIRE OVER THE NEXT 20 OR 30 YEARS. SO THAT IS THE LIABILITY AND THE TARGET, IF YOU WILL. AND THEN THEY HAVE YOUR THE COUNT, EVERY PEPRA FOR --IT IS EVERY YEAR FOR THE CURRENT VALUATION IS $99 MILLION. THAT REDUCES THE DEFICIT THAT THE LIGHT BLUE COLOR OF ABOUT $70 MILLION. THAT $78 MILLION ASSUMES , NOT ONLY THE BAD IN FISCAL 22, AND MAKE THE ASSUMPTION THAT WE STAY WITH THE 3.4% RETURN IN HIS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR. WE HAVE TWO MORE MONTHS. THAT WILL ADD ABOUT $7 MILLION. WE ARE GOING TO USE THE $70 MILLION FIGURES IS A CONSERVATIVE NUMBER FOR THIS. I WOULD SAY THAT, AS I MENTIONED BEFORE, EVERY YEAR, CALPERS, AT THE END OF THE FISCAL YEAR, THEY FIGURE OUT WHAT THEIR INVESTMENT RETURNS WERE. SO TWO YEARS AGO, THEY , THE RESULTS WERE OVER THE 6.8% TARGET. WAY OVER. IT WAS 21.3%. LAST YEAR, THEY MISSED THE MARK. AGAIN, THE TARGET IS 16%. THEY WERE NEGATIVE. SO THAT IS A MESS ON THE MARK OF ABOUT 14%. SO TWO YEARS AGO, EVERY YEAR WHEN THEY DO THAT, THEY FIGURE OUT WHAT NEW LAYER THEY ARE GOING TO PUT TO THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE, ALONG WITH THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. TWO YEARS AGO, WHICH CAME IN, AS I SAID, WE ARE AT $55 MILLION. AND IN THE REDUCED LIABILITY ITSELF TO GO 45 MILLION. 42 MILLION. WE ARE SITTING ON THAT RIGHT NOW. THE PAIN AS WELL , THERE IS A NEW LAYER. IT IS CLEAR THAT LOWER THE PAYMENT SCHEDULE. WELL, WE KNOW THAT THE YOUR LAST YEAR OF -7.5%, THEY ADDED ANOTHER LAYER. SO WE'LL GET THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE WHICH WILL SHOW THAT LAYER IS A BIG PLAYER, INCLUDING THE REFLECTED $71 MILLION. LIABILITY. WE EXPECT ANOTHER SEVEN OR EIGHT DOLLARS TO BE ADDED ON. WILL HAVE AN ADDED LAYER AS WELL. ANY QUESTIONS ON THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY? SO THIS IS A CHART SO YOU CAN SORT OF SEE. THERE ARE LOTS OF LAYERS EACH YEAR. YOU WILL HAVE MAYBE A POSITIVE LAYER WHICH IS WHEN THEY DON'T DO WELL. THERE IS NO LAYER WHATSOEVER IF THEY HIT THEIR TARGET OF 6.8%, EXACTLY. IT WOULD SEEM THE SAME. IT GOES UP, IT GOES DOWN. AND ALL OF THOSE LAYERS, IF YOU WILL, LAYERS OF THE CAKE, PRODUCE THE RED DOTTED LINE ERROR. THAT IS THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FROM THE COMBINATION OF ALL PLAYERS. THIS IS REALLY FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES . THIS DOES NOT REFLECT THE CITY OF PITTSBURG'S UNFUNDED LIABILITY PAYMENT. WHY HAVE THE COST TRADED HIGHER? WELL, BACK IN THE LATE 1990s, WE HAD VERY, VERY STRONG INVESTMENT RETURNS BY CALPERS. THEY WERE HITTING THEIR MARKS AND IS ON . BY THEN, IT WAS 8% . YOU MAY RECALL, THE.COM AND REALLY STRONG INVESTMENT MARKET , CalPERS WAS MINGLING WELL. THEY ACTUALLY WERE DOING SO WELL , THERE WAS A LIABILITY. THERE WAS NO UNFUNDED LIABILITY. THE ROBOCALLS PROVIDED. THAT CREATED SOME ISSUES WHERE ADDITIONAL BENEFITS WERE GIVEN OUT IN THE LATE 1990s, STARTING WITH THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WITH THE PRISON GUARDS AND PHP. VENTRICLE TO THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS , PUBLIC SAFETY, AND OTHERS. THOSE INCREASED INCREASED A HIGHER LIABILITY. AND SINCE THEN , THE RETURNS BY CalPERS HAVE BEEN VERY, VERY VOLATILE. GENERALLY, THEY HAVE BEEN LOWER. HAS CREATED THE BEGINNING OF THIS UNFUNDED LIABILITY OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS. CalPERS HAS CHANGED THEIR ASSUMPTIONS . PEOPLE ARE LIVING LONGER. THEY USED TWO WITH HOW MUCH THE ASSETS OF THE ACCOUNTS WERE WORTH. THAT WOULD KIND OF TEMPER THAT VERSUS ANNUALLY DO AN EVALUATION. FINALLY, THEY DECIDED CalPERS DECIDED THEY WANTED TO GO FROM A 30 REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FOR EACH OF THOSE LAYERS TO A 20 REPAYMENT SCHEDULE. THAT, ALL OF THE ASSUMPTIONS COMBINED, CREATED NOT ONLY A HIGHER LIABILITY, BUT A VERY REGULAR SHAPED LIABILITY AND IS DEEPLY ASCENDING UNFUNDED LIABILITY, DEPENDING ON THE EXPERIENCE. AS YOU WILL SEE SHORTLY, IT HAS BEEN VERY, VERY VOLATILE. OKAY. THIS CHART HERE IS PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT CHART. THERE IS A LOT GOING ON HERE. BUT WE WANTED TO SHOW ALL OF WHAT I HAVE DISCUSSED PREVIOUSLY. WITH RESPECT TO LAYERING ON NEW REPAYMENT SCHEDULES FOR YEARS AND YEARS . IN 2020, WE HAD , YOU KNOW, IS LIKELY THAT HERE. I WAS THE CITY WAS AT $65 MILLION. AND INDEED THE REALLY GOOD YEAR. THE CalPERS 21% LIABILITY WENT DOWN TO GO 42. 42 MILLION. AND LAST YEAR, THEY HAD A REALLY BAD YEAR, -7.5% . WE ARE GOING BACK UP TO 71 MILLION. REPORTS WILL COME OUT LATER THIS SUMMER. AGAIN, THERE IS LABELED HIS REPORT SO WE WILL FEED US LATER THIS SUMMER. AND WE EXPECT THAT THE LIABILITY WILL GO UP A LITTLE BIT MORE. SO EACH OF THOSE RETURNS, YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE ARE LAYERS WITHIN THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE THERE. THE LOWEST LEVEL REPAYMENT SCHEDULE IS THAT 2006 PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS. THAT DEAL WAS STRUCTURED SO IT WAS LEVEL AND TERMINATES IN FISCAL 2036 . ALL OF THE OTHER LAYERS, A SORT OF NAVY BLUE , FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020, YOU CAN SEE THAT AT A LATER. AND THEN WE HAD A GOOD YEAR WHERE IT WAS A DARKER , WHAT IS THAT? IS THAT WHILE BLUE? THE DARKER BLUE. WHERE WE ACTUALLY COULD SEE A REDUCTION IN THE SHORTENING OF THE PAYMENT. AND WE KNOW BECAUSE OF THE BAD RETURN IN FISCAL 2022, THE GRAY , THE LIGHT GRAY BARS GOING TO BE ADDED. WE KNOW THAT IS OCCUR. YOU CAN SEE THAT THAT IS LENGTHENING AND CREATING AN INCREASED PEAK , AS WELL AS REASSIGNING THE PAYMENT SCHEDULE. WE EXPECT FY 23 , INCREASE. THAT IS THAT DEAL THAT LAYERS ON TOP. ALL OF THESE THINGS COMBINED, YOU CAN SEE RIGHT NOW, IN FY 24, NEXT YEAR, WE WILL HAVE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT LOW. THERE'S A LITTLE BIT ABOUT IT THERE. THE DARK BLUE FOR FY 24. THE GOODYEAR THAT WAS LAST YEAR, BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE NEW LAYER , THERE IS A DELAY. NEW LAYER FOR FY 22, BATTERY RETURNS, THE GRAVE. THOSE ARE GOING TO START TO GO UP AFTER FY 24. OH THEREIN LIES SOMETHING THAT WE FEEL IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR COUNCIL TO NOTE. IT IS ALL ALL. BUT THE LAG, IS COMING. THE $71 MILLION IS A NUMBER THAT IS COMING. IT IS JUST THE LAG AND REPORTING OF CALPERS. WE THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THERE IS THIS AND THERE'S POSSIBLY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR UTILIZING THE BUDGET AND SOME OF THESE OTHER STRATEGIES TO GET IN FRONT OF IT A LITTLE BIT. ACTUALLY, THE CITY DOES HAVE SOME COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT HAVE BEEN UTILIZED OVER THE YEAR. OVER THE YEARS. THERE ARE ABOUT FIVE OF THEM. THE CITY, EVERY YEAR, DOES PREPAY AND GET THE CREDIT OF 3.3% ON THE LUMP SUM THAT IS PAID BY THE END OF JULY. NUMBER TWO. THE CITY HAS NEGOTIATED , LIKE MOST CITIES IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA , YOU NEGOTIATED SOME COST SHARING WITH EMPLOYEE. NUMBER FIVE. THE CITY DID RESTRUCTURE ITS UNFUNDED LIABILITY WITH BACK IN 2006. AS THE PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS. WE ACTUALLY TALKED ABOUT RESTRUCTURING THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY TO A PERFECT WILL SHAPE AND PAYMENT SHAPE. LAST YEAR. AGAIN, INTEREST RATES WENT UP AND IT TURNED OUT TO NOT BE FEASIBLE. NUMBER THREE. THE FRESH START AMORTIZATION IS SOMETHING THAT CalPERS OFFERED. THEY WILL TAKE YOUR UNFUNDED LIABILITY AND CREATE A LEVEL OF REPAYMENT. THE PROBLEM WITH THAT PROGRAM IS , THEY REQUIRE THAT YOU SHORTEN THE LOAN. SO THE EFFECT IS THAT YOU WILL HAVE A HIGHER PAYMENT IN THE NEAR-TERM. YOU CAN'T GO BACK TO CHANGING IT TO SOMETHING ELSE. YOU CAN'T GO BACK TO WHERE YOU WERE. SO TO THE EXTENT YOU HAVE A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF CASH AND YOU COULD BUDGETED FOR THAT IN THE NEAR TERM, IS WHEN A FRESH START IS UTILIZED. NUMBER FOUR. THAT IS WHAT MANY, IF NOT MOST, PUBLIC AGENCIES IN CALIFORNIA ARE UTILIZING. THEY ARE USING CASH . YOU HAVE TO HAVE CASH TO UTILIZE FOR A COUPLE OF OPTIONS. ONE IS THE SECTION 115 TRUST. THAT OPTION . THE CITY OF PITTSBURG ACTUALLY HAS THE SECTION 115 TRUST. I WILL GET INTO WHAT THAT IS EXACTLY. OR ADDITIONAL DISCRETIONARY PAYMENT. THAT IS A PAYMENT THAT THE CITY COULD AND WOULD MAKE DIRECTLY TO CalPERS TO TAKE OUT ONE OR MORE OF THOSE LAYERS THAT I TALKED ABOUT TO CREATE RELIEF , ARE IN THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE AS A STRATEGIC OPTION. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON SORT OF A HIGH-LEVEL CROSSMATCH AND STRATEGIES WE SEE TYPICALLY BE CONSIDERED? AND I BELIEVE THAT CITY OF PITTSBURG IS UTILIZING MOST OF THEM. SEA JUST A SHORT QUESTION. WHAT ABOUT FRESH START , IS NOT RECOMMENDED RIGHT NOW. BUT WHEN THAT START HAPPENS , IT IS STILL SUBJECT TO THE UP AND DOWNS OF THE CalPERS RETURNS? OR ARE YOU WATCHING PRETTY MUCH AT FRESH START? >> KNOW. TONIGHT EVERYTHING IS --AN EVERYTHING STILL GET , THE LAYERS EVERY SINGLE YEAR, BASED ON INVESTMENT RETURNS. ALSO, BASED UPON CalPERS DECIDED TO CHANGE HIS ASSUMPTIONS AGAIN, WHEN YOU REVIEW, THERE ASSUMPTIONS EVERY THREE OR FOUR YEARS I BELIEVE FOR MORTALITY. WHETHER THEY WANT TO CHANGE THE MIX ON THEIR INVESTMENTS SOMETIMES CREATE A CHANGE IN YOUR TIGHT GRIP INVESTMENT TOTAL OF RIGHT NOW --IT USED TO BE 7%. YEARS AGO, IT USED TO BE A PERCENT. GOT OUT OVER THE YEARS. IT WILL MAKE A FEASIBLE TARGET, LES CHRISTY TURNER. THEY STILL HAVE NOT BEEN HITTING THE TARGET EVERY YEAR. I WON'T GO INTO THIS TOO DEEPLY. I WILL SAY THE CITY HAS A SECTION 115 TRUST. WHEN THE MONEY IS PUT INTO THE SECTION 115 TRUST, IS DEDICATED OR RESTRICTED TO CURBS AND -- PAYMENTS. SO IT SHOWS A STRATEGY FROM THE CITY. THE CITY COUNCIL AND STAFF ABOUT ADDRESSING THIS PROBLEM. IT IS LOOKED UPON FAVORABLY BY FEDERAL AGENCIES . I WAS USE THE WORD SQUIRRELING ALWAYS ON ANY , FOR THIS PARTICULAR CHALLENGE . THIS IS THE BIGGEST CHALLENGE FOR MOST CITIES AND PUBLIC AGENCIES IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. ON THE ROAD A SECTION 115 IS THERE A DIFFERENT INVESTMENT GOALS. YOU HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE LENIENCY TO GO ON A LITTLE BIT MORE AGGRESSIVELY VERSUS THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE . YOU ARE RESTRICTED TO CERTAIN TYPES OF INVESTMENTS. SO CURRENTLY, THE CITY 115 TRUST IS UTILIZED IN CARS AS INVESTMENT ADVISER , AND AS I UNDERSTAND IT, THE INVESTMENT STRATEGY IS MEDIUM. IT IS NOT TOO RATHER, IT IS NOT TOO CONSERVATIVE. TRYING TO GAIN SOME GOOD RETURNS WITH I BELIEVE 2 1/2 MILLION DOLLARS IN THE THE COUNT RIGHT NOW. AS I SAID, THE OTHER STRATEGY WITH USING CASH IS TO DIRECTLY, INSTEAD OF PUTTING IT INTO A CITY CONTROL 115 TRUST, YOU CAN SEND THAT MONEY DIRECTLY TO CalPERS TO TRY TO PAY OFF ONE OR MORE , OR A PIECE OF, THOSE LAYERS THAT ARE LAYERED ON EVERY SINGLE YEAR. THAT CAN CREATE THE RELIEF YOU'RE LOOKING FOR. BY AVOIDING , BY TAKING OUT ONE OF THOSE LAYERS AND AVOIDING THAT PAYMENT, THE RETURN IS ESTIMATED TO BE THE TARGET THEY ARE TRYING TO CHARGE THE CITY . IS 6.8%. BUT, YOU KNOW, AGAIN, BOTH OPTIONS, ONCE YOU GET CalPERS MONEY, THEY PUT INTO THE THE COUNT . IT IS SUBJECT TO REINVESTMENT TOOLS. JUST A VERY HIGH LEVEL COMPARISON BETWEEN THE SECTION 115 TRUST AND THE ADP, ONE IS CONTROL, IF YOU WILL. THAT'S BY THE CITY. THERE IS MORE FLEXIBILITY ON THE USE . YOU CAN USE IT FOR PAYING ON ADP AT ANY TIME. YOU CAN ALSO USE IT FOR --AND YOU CAN USE IT FOR NORMAL COUGH. THERE IS A LITTLE MORE FLEXIBILITY. THE CalPERS ADP, LINDSEY PENA, AND GETTING MY FEELING HERE. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE CITY CONTROL IT'S FUNNY. IN POSSESSION, THEY ARE BOTH GOOD USES. AND HUNDREDS OF PUBLIC AGENCIES UTILIZE BOTH OF THEM AND. BUT IF YOU WERE TO THINK ABOUT THE TWO OF THEM, THE SECTION OF OVER FIVE TRUST, THERE IS MORE FLEXIBILITY AND CONTROL BUT IS A VERSUS SPENDING MONEY WITH CalPERS. YOU GET AN IMMEDIATE RESULT, BUT IF I WERE TO LIKE TO COMPARE AND CONTRAST FOR YOU ALL COMPETENCY, THAT IS HOW I WOULD FRAME IT. SO JUST GETTING INTO SOME HYPOTHETICAL HERE. THE CITY DOES HAVE 2 1/2 MILLION DOLLARS ON ACCOUNT RIGHT NOW. WE ARE TRYING TO MODEL A COUPLE OF SCENARIOS WHERE TRYING TO CHOP OFF THAT PEAK, IF YOU WILL. WE KNOW THAT BASED ON THE CURRENT RETURNS THAT HAVE BEEN EARNED BY CalPERS LAST YEAR BUT THEY LOOKED LIKE, THEY ARE GOING OUT THIS YEAR. THIS IS THE SHAPE, THE REPAYMENT SHAPE OF YOUR LIABILITY. YOU HAVE TWO HALF-MILLION DOLLARS IN THE BANK RIGHT NOW. TO THE EXTENT THAT WE CAN PUT ANY MORE MONEY AND WE ARE FOR HALF PERCENT. WE WANT TO DEPICT THAT AS THE ORANGE LINE. TO THE EXTENT YOU PUT IN ANOTHER , I BELIEVE, WE WERE DOING $3 MILLION. YOU COULD LOWER THAT LEVEL LINE TO THE DARK BLUE LINE. AND FINALLY, IF YOU PUT IN $6 MILLION, YOU COULD LOWER THE PEAK PAYMENT AND CREATE OUR LEVEL PAYMENTS AT AROUND $11 MILLION . THAT MAKES SENSE. THE MORE MONEY YOU HAVE TWO SORT OF INVEST IN IS 115, AND THEN STRATEGICALLY, TAKE OUT AND AVOID TO CHOP OFF SOME OF THESE PEAKS ., THE MORE YOU HAVE TO THROW AT THE PROBLEM. THE LOWER THAT ANNUAL LEVEL PAYMENTS PLACE WOULD BE. THESE ARE ALL WRAPPED AROUND THE 2006 PENSION BONDS. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON THIS? IT IS A CONCEPTUAL CHARGE. BUT I THINK WE REALLY , WE ALL KNOW HOW MUCH MONEY THE CITY HAS TO THROUGHOUT THIS CHALLENGE. WE THINK IT IS IMPORTANCE TO KNOW HOW THE STRATEGY, IF YOU WERE TO DO IT, WHERE YOU WANT TO END UP. I MEAN, YOU THING I SHOULD REMIND EVERYONE AND REMIND MYSELF, BUT HONESTLY, YOU WANT TO VISIT EVERY SINGLE YEAR. YOU KNOW, FOR SOMETHING IN IT YOU CAN BET THAT YOU HAVE SOMETHING THERE ALREADY. THE CalPERS IS GOING TO EARN WHAT THEY EARN , AND YOU WILL FIND OUT AT THE END OF EVERY SCHOOL YEAR. YOU CAN ADAPT ACCORDINGLY. TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY HAVE ANOTHER BAD YEAR AND ANOTHER YEAR, TO THE EXTENT YOU PUT SOME MONEY IN TO THIS SECTION 115 THE COUNT. THAT HAS CREATED THE ABILITY TO , THE CUSHION, IF YOU WILL. TO PRIORITIZE PAYMENTS, BUT ALSO OTHER PRIORITIES LIKE CAPITAL AND SERVICE LEVELS WHILE YOU FIGURE OUT WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN WITH CALPERS. YOU KNOW, LIKE ALL THE OTHER RACERS, THE SECTION 115 CREATE A OFFER. OFFER FOR DECISION-MAKING. SO THIS IS SORT OF THE DETAIL BEHIND THAT CHART. TWO AND HALF MILLION IN THE BANK, IS A 4 1/2% YOU WOULD EARN IN SECTION 115 TRUST. THE SAVINGS ARE SHOWN. IT JUST RAMPS UP. FROM THE DO-NOTHING OVER THE NEXT FIVE OR SIX YEARS, WANT TO START CHOPPING OFF THE TOP. AND IT PROGRESSIVELY IS MORE AND MORE. THERE WERE MANY YOU ARE ABLE TO THROW AT THE PROBLEM, THESE ARE HYPOTHETICALS. YOU KNOW, IT IS , SHE WOULD DEPOSIT EACH OF THE YEARS . OF COURSE, THAT DEPENDS ON CLASSES AND CASH FLOW. I THINK IT IS PRETTY WELL KNOWN THAT THIS IS A HUGE PROBLEM FOR ALL PUBLIC ABCs. IT IS THE LARGEST EVER, I BELIEVE IT IS THE LONG LARGEST ON THE BALANCE SHEET. AS FOR THE LARGEST THAT BY THE END OF THE SUMMER WHEN WE GET THE NEW CalPERS REPORTS. SO THERE ARE VARIOUS OPTIONS THAT YOU HAVE BEEN DOING, AND THAT YOU MAY WANT TO CONSIDER TO CONTINUALLY STAY OUT OF THIS PROBLEM. WE ARE LOOKING LIKE WE ARE GOING TO HAVE ANOTHER BAD YEAR. SO WE DON'T KNOW WHAT NEXT YEAR GOALS. BUT THE POINT OF THIS PRESENTATION IS TO REALLY REMIND COUNCIL THAT THIS PROBLEM, IT BOUNCES AROUND. IT IS A UNIQUE LIABILITY ON THE BALANCE SHEET. AND TO THE EXTENT THAT YOU CAN BUTTRESS THIS SECTION 115 OR JUST RESERVES IN GENERAL FOR THIS PROBLEM. THAT CAN BE VERY VERY HELPFUL FOR BUDGETING IN FUTURE YEARS AND PREDICTABLE LEVELS. I WOULD BE GLAD TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. I'M CHECKING WITH MY COLLEAGUES TO SEE IF THEY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. COUNCILMEMBER JELANI KILLINGS? I WANT TO SAY THANKS FOR THE PRESENTATION. I THINK, AT LEAST FOR THE MEMBERS OF THIS PRESENTATION WITH THE PROCESS , AS WE ARE TRYING TO RESTRUCTURE LAST YEAR OR SO, THIS IS A HEARTBURN THAT PUBLIC AGENCIES ARE DEALING WITH. RESTORATION IS THAT --OUR HANDS. AS WE ARE LOOKING AT, YOU KNOW, NATIONAL DOLLARS WE CAN DO TO TRY TO SMOOTH ON WHAT IS FORECASTED FOR THE UPCOMING YEARS. I CAN APPRECIATE THIS. I KNOW YOU HAD DISCUSSIONS ABOUT A 15 TRUST . AS WENT THROUGH THE PANDEMIC, WE HAVE TO MAKE DECISIONS IN TERMS OF HOW WE WERE GOING TO POND DIFFERENT THINGS. SO DEFINITELY LOOKING FORWARD TO THE FUTURE CONVERSATION. DEFINITELY INTERESTED, BUT AS WE CAN, TO FOR THE UPCOMING YEARS ." WE UNDERSTANDS THAT THE MORE WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO KEEP IN A SINGLE PAYMENT, DOLLARS THAT WILL NOT BE FOR COMMUNITY THAT WE EMERGENCY PROGRAMS GO TO DIFFERENT AREAS. TRIED TO FIND THAT BALANCE IS GOING TO BE A CONVERSATION FOR COUNCIL. AS WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THIS, I HAVE AN INTEREST. I, THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVISIT OUR PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE, SURGICALLY. I KNOW FOR CERTAIN THINGS THEY DID THEIR . IN TERMS OF ADDRESSING SOME OF THESE RESERVES AND ADDITIONAL ONE-TIME REVENUES. I THINK THAT MAYBE A CONVERSATION, WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THE IDEA OF THINGS, A DECISION THAT MAY NEED TO BE MADE IN ORDER TO HAVE THE MONEY AS NECESSARY TO THAT 5 MILLION OVER THE NEXT FEW YEARS, SO THAT'S ANOTHER CONVERSATION TO HAVE. I KNOW THIS IS VERY DEPENDENT ON , ONCE AGAIN, REVENUES THAT COME IN AND WHAT WE ARE ABLE TO DO IS A COUNCIL . I THINK THAT IS AN IMPORTANT DISCUSSION ABOUT PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE, THE ENGINE BEHIND IT , AND THE UNIQUENESS OF THE SITUATION WE ARE CONSTANTLY GRAPPLING WITH WITH CalPERS. IS THERE SOMETHING ABLE TO DO WITHIN THE ORDINANCE ITSELF THAT MAKE THE POSSIBILITY FOR MONEY! 15 TRUST? ALSO I SHALL THOUSAND COMMENTS . I SAID THANK YOU FOR COMING OUT MAKING THIS PRESENTATION. AS WELL THOUGH, IS TIMELY. THESE ARE THINGS WE SHOULD BE CONSIDERING AMONGST ALL THE OTHER THINGS ON THE LIST THAT WE WANT TO PRIORITIZE . I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME AND PERIOD THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER JELANI KILLINGS. COUNCILMEMBER JUAN ANTONIO BANALES? >> THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. I'M REALLY INTERESTED IN DIVING INTO SOME OF THE DETAILS. ON THE SAVINGS. WE DON'T HAVE TO DO IT NOW. BUT YEAH, IF YOU COULD PROVIDE MAY BE A BREAKDOWN OF THE NET SAVINGS OF THE SLING OPTIONS PRINCES FROM MY UNDERSTANDING, MAYBE LATER ON, THAT COULD BE PROVIDED. I THINK THAT WOULD HELP ME BETTER UNDERSTAND FROM A CASH FLOW PERSPECTIVE , CAN HELP IMPACT? I THINK FROM WHAT I'M HEARING, YOU KNOW, NEXT MEETING ARE POSITIVE . THERE WERE REPORTS OF THE 14th IS HOLDING UP THE PROCESS. I ALSO WANT TO UNDERSTAND YOUR WRITER, THE IMPACT TO CASH FLOW. IF THAT IS A NET POSITIVE, RIGHT? WHERE IS IT GOING TO BE ABLE TO YOUR YOUR BASIS, IS A LITTLE MONEY. OR IF IT WILL GET OUT IN TERMS OF , YOU'RE NOT ACTUALLY GOING TO SAY VERY MUCH IN THE CASH FLOW PERSPECTIVE. HERE. BUT IN THE LONG RUN, RIGHT? YOU'RE GOING TO SAVE THE MONEY. WHERE IS THE IMPACT IS I AM INTERESTED IN. >> WE PRESENTED HERE , GRAPHICALLY, CHOPPING OFF, IF YOU LIKE. THERE IS A MYRIAD OF STRATEGIES THAT COUNCIL, COUNCIL CAN CREATE A MORE GRADUAL APPROACH. THAT WOULD GIVE YOU TIME TO FIGURE OUT WHERE ARE THE OTHER PRIORITIES AND WOULD BE AS WELL. THESE ARE SORT OF THE SIMPLISTIC APPLES TO APPLES. YOU PUT AS MUCH TO THE PROBLEM, YOU CHOPPED THE HOP DOWN INCREMENTALLY MORE AND MORE AND MORE. BUT WE CERTAINLY CAN PROVIDE DETAIL ON THESE OPTIONS. OR ANY OTHER OPTIONS THAT LOOK LIKE THEY ARE OF INTEREST. TO THAT GREAT, THANK YOU. AND REREAD THE POINTS. EVERY YEAR WE ARE LOOKING AT THIS, ESPECIALLY THE LAST THREE YEARS, THE BIGGEST IMPACT TO OUR PLEASANT AND THE ANNUAL CASH FLOW, RIGHT? IS PAYMENTS WOULD HAVE TO MAKE. ESPECIALLY SINCE WE, THEY ARE HARD TO FORECAST, RIGHT? AT TIMES HOW MUCH WE ARE GOING TO BE PAID, DEPENDING ON CalPERS PERFORMANCE. THAT REALLY IS , WHAT I THINK IS OF IMPORTANCE FOR US IN THE NEAR-TERM. NOT THE IMPACT TO OUR ANNUAL CASH FLOW. THANK YOU. CNET ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS? THANK YOU AGAIN. WE REALLY APPRECIATE THE UPDATE. CNET THANK YOU VERY MUCH, ERIC. JUST REITERATE AS WE GO TO MY BUDGET ANALYSIS. HA HA. YOU WILL SEE IN THE GENERAL FUND SIDE , AND NOT IN ERIC'S LIFE, YOU THOUGHT $9 MILLION, ROUGHLY , THAT IS WHAT WE PAY THEM CalPERS RADIO ANNUALLY. THE NUMBERS ALSO TO 13 MILLION. YES, INCLUSIVE OF THE 06 PENSION OBLIGATION. BUT IT'S ALSO UP TO 13 IN ABOUT FOUR YEARS OR SO. FOUR OR FIVE YEARS. IF YOU LOOK AT THAT CHART. AND SO WHEN YOU GET TO THE SLIDE IN A LITTLE BIT HERE WHERE WE HAVE AROUND 52 MILLION TOTAL IN GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES . AGAIN, NOT ALL OF THAT IS JUST A GENERAL FUND . YOU CAN SEE WHAT $4 MILLION INCREASE, EVEN IF IT IS OVER A COUPLE YEARS, IS ONLY SIZABLE NUMBER TO TAKE AS A WITH INTERNAL THOUGHT. HOURS. SO ANYWAY, WE CAN LEAVE ERIC AND PAUL TO PRESENT TO THE COUNCIL STRATEGIES THAT , HOPEFULLY, BECAUSE WITH THAT ARE MAKE IT A LITTLE BETTER, ASSUMING CASH FLOW MAKE SENSE. ONCE AGAIN , THIS IS A DEFENSIVE PROPOSAL I AM JUST TALKING ABOUT LOOKING AT THE PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE. SO WE ARE AT 30% THAT WE ARE ASKING FOR EVERY YEAR THAT WAS MOST TO GO 25 AND WE SET THAT DIFFERENCE, WE MUST PUT INTO THIS MOMENT BY TRUST. TO ME, THAT IS ABOUT 2.5 MILLION OR SO. SOMETHING AROUND THERE. I DON'T KNOW. JUST THROWING OUT IDEAS BUT AT THIS POINT, I'M TRYING TO FOR THIS REALM OF TRYING TO GET THE FUNDING THAT IS ONE OF MY TRUST, GIVEN WE ARE TALKING ABOUT WITH CASH FLOW, ARE EVENTUALLY EXPLORE THE OPTIONS? OR IS IT JUST ON THE YEARS WE HAVE, YOU KNOW, THESE REVENUE SURPLUSES? WHERE WOULD THE DISCIPLINE OR CHEMICALLY SPECIFIC IN THE PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE AND THAT IS THE CHALLENGE WE HAVE? AND THIS POTENTIAL OPPORTUNITY OF TRYING TO SALUTE THESE FORECASTED YEARS . POTENTIAL ? I JUST THROWING IT OUT THERE, THAT CANNOT BE FIXED OR FOR CONSIDERATION AS WE ARE LOOKING AT ALL THE DIFFERENT PROPOSALS ABOUT TRYING TO ADDRESS OR INCREASE WHAT WE ARE PUTTING INTO THE TRUST. ONCE AGAIN, NOT A DEFINITIVE PROPOSAL SAYING WE NEED TO DO THIS. BUT JUST TRYING TO THINK OF ALL THE REALM OF POSSIBILITIES OF WHAT WE CAN DO TO ACTUALLY GET MONEY INTO THAT FUND TO SMOOTH OUT THE UPCOMING YEARS . JEANETTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT SOMETHING WILL WORK WITH ERIC AND HIS TEAM. THERE ARE SOME VERY BRIGHT FOLKS AND WE WILL TAKE A LOOK AT SCENARIOS AND BRING THEM BACK FOR DISCUSSION. SOMETIMES YOU SAY, NO. YOU NEVER KNOW. IT DOESN'T HURT TO TAKE A LOOK. GREAT. STARTED THE SECOND PART OF THE THREE-PART BUDGET WORKSHOP HERE. I WILL KICK IT OFF WITH THIS IS, YOU KNOW, THE BUDGET WORKSHOP HERE WITH THE CITY COUNCIL. GENERALLY, WE START IN FEBRUARY WITH AN ANNUAL BUDGET DEVELOPMENT. MARSH APARTMENTS START SETTLING THEIR BUDGETS AND WHAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO SEE WITH STAFFING. THE VEHICLES, YOU KNOW, THE OTHER TYPES OF CONTRACTS, PROGRAMS. AND HE SAID TO EVERYBODY WITH THOSE, IN APRIL, AND GO LINE BY LINE. YOU KNOW, PAUL AND HIS TEAM DO AN EXCELLENT JOB. I CERTAINLY WANT TO THINK PAUL AND HIS TEAM, THE DEPARTMENT HAS TO UNIT I HERE. EARLIER, MEGAN, SARAH. EVERYBODY TELLS IN LINE BY LINE, LOOKING AT THE BUDGET. THE FIRST START WITH PAUL AND THE CENTER ON, I JUMP IN. WE ARE REALLY UPSET THE THIRD ROUND WE DO ONE FINAL COMMENT AGAIN. SO THE REAL GOAL HERE MAY PRESENT WHERE WE ARE. IN APRIL, WE ARE SHOWING ABOUT A 6 1/2 BILLION DOLLAR DEFICIT. AND WHAT WE WILL SEE A DOCUMENT HERE, WE ARE ACTUALLY AT A $300,000 SURPLUS . IS ACTUALLY BE DISCUSSED WITH STAFF , AND ALSO, WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU TOO. WE ARE GOING TO DO A GOLD UPDATE DISCUSSION IN THE NEXT TWO MEETINGS . THERE IS SOMETHING WE WANT TO SET ASIDE A TUCK IN, WE WANT TO LOOK AT. ALSO, AS WE TALK ABOUT PROGRAMS, YOU KNOW, FOR LACK OF BETTER TERM , WE ARE AT X AND THE COUNCIL WANTS TO DO ADDITIONAL THINGS, IT IS! FIVE. IN A LOT OF WAYS, WE ARE AT ZERO SUM. YOU MAY NEED AN EXCELLENT SPY MAGAZINE. THAT IS AS FAR AS I LET GO OF THE LETTERS. SO I BECAME A PARTNER. AND ONE OF THE DISCUSSIONS I HAD LAST WEEK , I BROUGHT IT UP WITH SOME OF THE STAFF. AS WE DISCUSSED THE GOALS, WE WILL IDENTIFY SOME PROGRAMS THAT MAY BE ARCH REACHING AS MANY BOOKS AS WE WANT. OR PROBABLY MAYBE GETTING THE RETURN WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE. BECAUSE OF DISCUSSION WITH COUNCIL. MAYBE, THOSE ARE CAPITAL . WE MOVE ON TO FIND BETTER Y. AND MAKE SURE S IS A STRONG BUT AGAIN, I THOUGHT I WOULD TRY TO STAY AWAY FROM THE ALPHABET AIR. HERE WE ARE. BUDGET WORKSHOP. AS I SAID, THE PROCESS IS NOT YET CONCEIVED. WE HAVE WORKED WITH THE DIFFERENT DEPARTMENTS. THIS IS A SNAPSHOT OF WHERE WE ARE, ME FIRST. BUT NOT AT THE POINT WHERE WE ARE PRODUCING A VERY LOVELY , THE DOCUMENT FOR YOU ALL TO CONSIDER. THIS IS A LOVELY, LONG WORDED WAY TO SAY, THIS IS A LIVING BUDGET. SO WHAT YOU ADOPT BY JUNE 30th, CAN AND WILL BE CHANGED . HAS CHANGED ALMOST EVERY MEETING AS WE TWEAK A LITTLE BIT OR APPROVE ITEMS, CONTACTS. WE ALSO GO THROUGH THE YEAR. SO EVEN IF THERE IS A FEELING OF, BOY, IS NOT PERFECT, THAT'S OKAY. AGAIN, WE ARE TRYING TO CREATE A DOCUMENT THAT WE CAN MOVE FORWARD WITH. THE PARTICIPANTS ARE ACCOMPLISHING THEIR GOALS. SO THAT IS WHERE WE TAKE THIS. SO WHAT ARE SOME OF THE BUDGETING GOAL? WELL, CERTAINLY NOT THE SURPLUS. SOMETHING WE HAVE BEEN VERY FORTUNATE TO HAVE OVER THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS. YOU HAVE ALL PROBABLY HEARD ME SAY MANY TIMES , WHEN I WORK WITH 7% WILL ALSO, I SHOULD PRAY PLUS MINUS 1%. BECAUSE GENERALLY, A PRETTY GOOD NUMBER . IF YOU NEED TO MAKE CORRECTIVE ACTION, YOU CAN DO THAT BY YEAR. IF YOU ARE LITTLE SURPLUS , YOU ARE JUST TOO MUCH FOR, YOU MONEY INTO THE COMMUNITY OF PROGRAMS OR PROJECTS. SO THAT IS SORT OF TALKING ABOUT BUDGET GOAL OF OFFERING SURPLUS ARE ALSO NOT OPERATING EXPENDITURES, SUCH AS CURRENT YEAR OPERATING SURPLUS MONEY. WE PROGRAMMED A COUPLE YEARS AGO. RESERVES. YOU HAVE INSURANCE , SUCH AS ONE OR 200 THEY COULD NOT OPERATE AS , SAY, 100 AND PROGRAMS, BECAUSE THAT BECOMES A POLL ON YOUR BUDGET AND ANOTHER THING WE ARE DUNKING THE -- PAUL AND JENNIFER ARE DOING A GREAT JOB. THE E.R. TIME. THE ADVISORY SERVICE PARTY. THE SOFTWARE BEHIND THE CITY, IF YOU WILL. THAT MIGRATION AND SELECTION OF THE E.R. SOFTWARE SYSTEM IS A TWO AND HALF MILLION DOLLAR COST . GOT ABOUT HALF OF YOUR PROGRAM FOR THIS UPCOMING YEAR. THERE WILL BE ANOTHER HALF OF THE NEXT YEAR. THAT IS A DATE NOT OPERATING COST , AND HOW THE BEST WORK THAT IN TO NOT CREATE , QUICK INCREASES IN DEPARTMENTS? THAT IS SOMETHING WE ARE WORKING ON. SO WHERE ARE WE SAYING RIGHT? SO WHEN YOU GO TO VISIT MY BUDGET, IT IS $260 MILLION. NOT MANY PEOPLE THINK OF IT AS A $260 MILLION COMPANY, IF YOU WILL. BUT THAT IS , THAT IS WHERE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ARE LEADING THE CHARGE. NO AS YOU IS IN MY BUDGET, OPERATING WHITE, IT IS AROUND 220 MILLION REVENUE, 21 4 MILLION IN EXPENSES. THE OPERATING PROJECTS AND SUCH, FOR $80 MILLION IN REVENUE. EITHER EXPENSE. AGAIN, WE HAD SOME INITIAL EVIDENCE , SURPLUSES WE MONITOR PROGRAM. WE DISCUSSED OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS. OVERALL, AND GENERAL SURPLUS IS A WIFE IS ANTICIPATED ABOUT $.4 MILLION . OF US . TAKING IT DOWN EARLIER. YOU KNOW, IS KIND OF FUNNY. WOW. I'M IN CHARGE OF $869 BUDGET. WE DID A LOT OF THINGS. ON THAT IS PROGRAM. THE GENERAL FUND IS FOR THE COUNSELING COMMUNITY CAN MAKE AN IMPACT OF PASSIVE DISCRETION. IN THIS CASE, WE HAVE SOME ACTUAL CENTER. IF YOU LOOK AT 2021, WE FINISHED WITH A NET OPERATING SURPLUS. THIS WAS WITH : A COUNCIL DIRECTED STAFF TO CUT HALF THE EXPENDITURES. REALLY, WE PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE OVER $45 MILLION WORTH OF , ACTUALLY, CLOSER TO 47 OR $50 MILLION IN EXPENDITURES. WE TURNED IT DOWN. WE FINISHED WITH THE NET OPERATING SURPLUS BECAUSE ROBIN IS COMING IN ABOUT 10 MILLION. WE WORKED WITH THE COUNCIL BY 9.6 MILLION IN SURPLUS PROJECTS. THE NEXT YEAR, 2021-22, THERE IS ALSO THE $3 MILLION OPERATING SURPLUS. SOME OF THAT WAS ACTUALLY SOCIALIZING ISSUES . THE VEHICLES WERE FOR FLEET WERE SHARED. YOU KNOW, THE COULD FULFILL SO THINGS GOT PUSHED. AT 3 MILLION AND UP SHOWING UP FOR THAT YEAR. THIS CURRENT YEAR, 2022-23 , WE ARE PROJECTING A NET OPERATING SURPLUS . BUT A NET SURPLUS, WHEN ONE --THE NEXT DEFICIT WHEN YOU TAKE IT OR NOT OPERATING. THOSE ARE CAPITAL PROJECTS AND OTHER THINGS GOING ON THAT THE COUNCIL HAS DIRECTED US TO DO. SO CERTAINLY, OPERATIONALLY, WE HAD A SURPLUS . AS A SITTING DOWN,. THE BALANCE WE HAVE, THAT IS CAUSING A DEFICIT TO SHOW UP ON THE BOOKS. AS WE ARE WORKING ON THIS BUDGET FOR NEXT YEAR , AS I MENTIONED, APPROXIMATELY $340,000 OPERATING SURPLUS . THERE IS ANOTHER ROUND OF DISCUSSION WITH THE STAFF. ALSO, WE WANT TO HEAR FROM THE COUNCIL. OVERALL, THE GENERAL FUND REVENUES AND HOPEFULLY OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS? WE HAVE SEEN SALES TAX AND HAVE AN ACE STEADY GROWTH. WE ARE SHOWING A GROWTH IF YOU LOOK FOR THREE YEARS , ABOUT 6 MILLION IN SALES AND PROPERTY TAX. THOSE KIND OF NUMBERS. THAT TRANSFER THE WELL. A $2 MILLION OR SO INCREASE YOUR YEAR IS A PRETTY SOLID NUMBER. AND THEN WE HAVE SOME FEES AND OTHER REVENUES THAT ARE GROWING. WE WILL TAKE A LOOK BECAUSE I DON'T ONE THING THAT JUMPS OUT TO ME, ANYTHING THAT DROPS DOWN. AND SO PAUL AND I, WE WILL SIT THERE AND TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE OTHER REVENUES TO SEE WHAT WAS THE CAUSE BEHIND THAT. WE CAN SHARE THAT WITH YOU ALL. OVERALL, A GROWTH FROM 55 TO GO 62. APPARENTLY IT AT ONE OF THE OVERALL BUDGETS I HAD IN MY FILES FROM 2012. WE WERE AROUND $30 MILLION IN REVENUE . SO WE DOUBLED IN ABOUT 10 YEARS. SO A FANTASTIC AMOUNT OF GROWTH. ON THE OTHER SIDE , YOU HAVE THE MONEY, WHAT YOU DO WITH IT? WELL, THE EXPENDITURES, AND THIS IS WHERE YOU ALSO SEE SOME OF THAT GROWTH THAT HAS OCCURRED. FOR $5 MILLION EXPENDITURES IN 2021 , AND NOW WE ARE LOOKING AT MIDYEAR, AGAIN, THIS IS HIGH. I THINK IT IS GOING TO BE COMING IN MUCH LOWER THAN THAT. 66 MILLION. THAT INCLUDES PROJECTS . 63 MILLION IS WHAT WE ARE LOOKING AT NEXT YEAR. WHEN YOU LOOK AT APARTMENTS, AND WILL COME TO A SUPERB MOMENT, MY FLIGHT. WE HAVE A NON-DEPARTMENTAL VERSUS THREE I HAVE A 3.2. THE ATTRITION NUMBER, WHICH CAME UP IN A COUPLE OF MEETINGS AGO IN A YEAR, THAT IS WHERE THAT NUMBER IS COUNTED. WHEN ATTRITION, WHICH WE KNOW WITH 100% STAFFING AT ALL TIMES. AS THAT NUMBER BECAUSE WERE REALIZED WITHIN THE DEPARTMENTAL BUDGET, THE DEPARTMENT BUDGET WILL GO DOWN. BUT THE NON-DEPARTMENT WILL GO UP BECAUSE THAT ATTRITION NUMBER WILL GO AWAY. SO IT ALL BALANCES. AND IT TRANSFERS OUT WITH PROJECTS . SO WHAT ARE SOME OF THE BIG EXPENDITURE INCREASES WE ARE SEEING THIS YEAR? ABOUT 2.1 202.2 MILLION IS PRETTY MUCH PROGRAM INCREASES, WHETHER THE COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENTS FOR PEOPLE, EQUITY ADJUSTMENTS, SCHEDULE MERIT INCREASES, AND POSITION CHANGE REQUEST. POSITION CHANGE REQUESTS ARE APPLICATION UPGRADES BASED ON THEORIES AND STUDIES THAT OFTENTIMES ARE EITHER DISCUSSED AT THE BARGAINING TABLE, OR JUST VALUE WAITED AS THE YEARS GO ALONG. THAT POSITION NO LONGER HAS JUST THOSE TYPES OF RESPONSIBILITIES , AND SO WE HAVE TO RE-EVALUATE. AS A BIG JOB. AND WE DON'T HAVE DISCRETIONARY, BECAUSE THOSE ARE COMMITMENTS ALREADY MADE . OVERALL STAFFING, REQUEST FROM HIS YOUR PROFESSOR, IT WAS 25. AND THAT IS FOR A MAINTENANCE WORKER IN A JULY DISTRICT. THAT IS NOT A GENERAL FUND. THERE WERE REQUESTS FOR TENTATIVE POSITIONS. WE PUT THEM ON HOLD WHILE WE ARE WORKING THROUGH THIS PROCESS AND MAKING SURE WE HIT A BALANCED BUDGET FIRST THAT WE CAN PRESENT. AND THEN WE ALSO DISCUSSED AT THE COUNCIL , WHICH ARE DISCUSSIONS, IF YOU WILL, WANTS TO HAVE THE STUFF. MAYBE DOLLARS FOR POTHOLES OR LANDSCAPING. A VEHICLE STATION FOR PROPERTY. BUT THEN THE ONLY PURPOSE IN THE BUDGET. SO JUMPING RIGHT INTO IT. THE GENERAL FUND DEPARTMENTS, WE WILL START OFF WITH THE CITY COUNCIL. AND NOT TOO MUCH HAS CHANGED OVER THE YEARS, BUT ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU SEE OTHER EXPENSES. YOU KNOW, A LITTLE BIT OF A BUDGET INCREASE. THIS IS A PRETTY STEADY GROWTH. NOTHING OUT OF HAND OVER A FOUR YEAR PERIOD. HEALTHCARE CASTS , AND THE LIKE. AS WE GO TO CITY CLERK, YOU WILL SEE PRETTY MUCH THE SAME KIND OF GROWTH IN SALARIES AND FRINGE. THE OTHER FINANCERS ARE PRETTY FLAT. CAPITAL ALLOCATION. THAT IS WHERE WE ARE SEEING AN INCREASE, WHETHER THAT IS BUILDING MAINTENANCE WHICH INCLUDES INSURANCE. YOU ALSO HAVE , WHATEVER ALLOCATION I AM THINKING OF? NOT SEAT. IT IS I.T. THANK YOU. INFORMATION. THAT IS , THAT NUMBER IS GOING TO CHANGE A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE OUT OF THE OLDER ONE THAT INCLUDED ALL OF THE ERP AND. THAT IS THE COST PULL OUT AND HAVE IT MADE IT INTO THE DOCUMENT ., THIS IS A BUDGET WORKSHOP UPDATE, BUT IT IS NOT FINAL. THE DELEGATION OF THE EARTH YOU WILL SEE WILL GO ALSO APPEARED HAS BEEN GROWTH. THAT IS BECAUSE THAT IS THE ERP FAILURE. THE TRANSFER, PROBABLY THE MOST MODEST GROWTH I THINK THAT ALL THESE APARTMENTS. ALL 3% OVER A FOUR YEAR. SO NO REAL CHANGE THERE. CITY ATTORNEY. AND HERE IS ONE WHERE WE HAVE HAD, YOU KNOW, A PARALEGAL COMING ON. THERE WAS SOME TALK OF ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY OR DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY. SHE FIND A PARALEGAL IS REALLY WHERE THE FOCUS IS, AND AS A PART-TIME. AND SO REALLY, THAT WILL BE A MODEST INCREASE. THE OTHER ANSWER IS FOR THE OCCASION. IN, THE CITY ATTORNEY HAS TO HAVE A BUDGET FOR WHAT MAY COME UP. AND IN 2021 AND 2022, THERE WERE NOT TOO MANY LITIGATION ITEMS SO THAT NEVER WENT AWAY. I WOULD BE SURPRISED IF YOU SEE THAT HAPPEN AGAIN BECAUSE HE IS DONE SUCH A GOOD JOB OF KEEPING THOSE THINGS DOWN. THAT IS WHY YOU WILL SEE THE LARGE SUPPER THERE. CITY MANAGER. I LIKE TO POINT OUT , A COMMENT THAT WAS GIVEN TO ME BY OTHER CITY MANAGERS . ALWAYS HAVE A NUMBER LOWER THAN YOUR CURRENT YEAR. YOU KNOW, EVEN IF YOU ARE LOOKING AT A DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT. SO I TRIED TO DO THAT AT LEAST I ENJOY $300 REDUCTION. AGAIN, IT CITY MANAGER . OUR SALARIES TOUCHED SO MANY OTHER DEPARTMENTS WITHOUT THE RIGHT, WOW. BECAUSE MARIA, SARAH, MYSELF. A LITTLE BIT IN PITTSBURG, BECAUSE WE HANDLE ALL OF THOSE . THE REAL NUMBERS THAT YOU LOOK AT IF YOU SEE CITY MANAGER IS WITH. MANAGER LINE ITEM? THINGS LIKE THAT. FINANCE. FINANCIER IS, RIGHT NOW, LOOKING AT ABOUT 1.9 MILLION DOLLAR PROTECTION. AND A LOT OF THAT, AGAIN, IT WAS MOSTLY DRIVEN BY THE SALARY INCREASES OVER TIME. REALLY KNOW THE OTHER EXPENDITURES GOING UP TOO MUCH FOR THE CAPITAL ALLOCATION LINE ITEM. THAT IS THE I.T.. YEAH, THEY ARE HAPPY FEET OF CARSON THAT IS WAS DRIVING THE INCREASE. HUMAN RESOURCES. THEY HAVE SEEN A 30% INCREASE OVER THE FOUR YEAR PERIOD. AND NOTHING REALLY DRAMATIC THAT COMES OVER THE FOUR YEARS . YOU ARE DOING 10% A YEAR, THAT IS REALLY NOT MUCH OF GROWTH. IN A GALLERY ON THE OTHER EXPENDITURES. RECREATION. HERE IS WHERE I THINK YOU WILL SEE COUNCIL DISCUSSION GOALS, POLICIES , WANTED TO SEE MORE THINGS . THE MARINE CENTER OPENED UP. YOU KNOW, MORE YOUTH PROGRAMS. HERE IS WHERE YOU SEE BOTH STAFF AND BUDGET FOR OTHER ORGANIZATIONS TO PROGRAMS AND THE LIKE. THAT IS WHAT YOU SEE IN HIS BUDGET . IS GONE PROPERLY: , WHICH WE DID TOO MUCH, BUT KEEPING STAFF . TRULY GOING OUT AND DOING PROGRAMS IN THE COMMUNITY. WAS ALSO WITHIN THIS BUDGET IS --AGAIN, THINGS WE ARE TRYING TO INCREASE AND IMPROVE UPON. CODE ENFORCEMENT. WHAT YOU SEE HERE IS MORE EFFORT , TRIED TO GET OUT AND, YOU KNOW, I THINK NOT JUST BE HOW TALL OTHER WAYS BUT ALSO SEE REAL IMPACTS. I'M TRYING TO, ALAS, WASN'T THE LAND USE THAT YOU PRESENTED? LOOKING BETWEEN HOMES AND SOME OF THE INTERESTING STRUCTURES THAT POPPED UP IN BETWEEN UNITS. HOW WE ADDRESS THAT AND MAKE SURE WE HAVE SAFE LIVING CONDITIONS FROM HOMES AND IN RESIDENTIAL AREAS? SO THAT IS AN INCREASE FOCUSED THAT WILL BE GOING OUT OF YOUR DAY REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO TRYING TO, WHEN YOU SEE SOME OF THE INTERESTING ADDITIONS, WE REALLY NEED TO ENSURE WE ARE STAYING ON TOP OF THAT. PLANNING. THIS IS WHAT YOU SEE IS RAMPING UP ALL THE STAFF , I THINK THAT WAS LAST YEAR. AND THEN OTHER EXPENDITURES. THOSE INCLUDED , AGAIN, CAPITAL ALLOCATION. NOTHING TOO OUT OF THE ORDINARY HERE. PERMIT FOUR. THIS IS BUILDING 2.0 IF YOU WILL. THE PERMIT CENTERS TRYING TO FOCUS ON HOW WE WORK WITH FOLKS THAT COME DOWNSTAIRS AND ALSO AND BUSINESS LICENSES. SO THIS IS OFTEN A SHIFT IN THE APARTMENT AND ADDING SOME RESPONSIBILITIES, BUT IT IS A VERY LOGICAL EVOLUTION. I SHOULD HAVE HIGHLIGHTED SOME OF THESE DEPARTMENTS ARE CASH POSITIVE. YOU KNOW? SO IF YOU LOOK AT THE PERMIT CENTER. THE ARE $2.6 MILLION IN REVENUE. 1.5 MILLION IN EXPENDITURES. WE GO THROUGH AND DO A COST ALLOCATION STUDY SO WE MAKE SURE WE ARE NOT OVERCHARGING FOR THE SERVICES. BUT THERE ARE CERTAIN ACTIVITIES THAT THEY JUST. SO PLEASE TRY TO EXPAND AND NATION THE PERMIT CENTER IS OPERATING AT FULL CAPACITY POSSIBLE. THEY ARE CASH POSITIVE. THE NEXT ONE IS ENGINEERING. THE SUN, JOHN AND I, YOU KNOW, WE STILL NEED TO SIT DOWN AND TAKE A LOOK AT THE NUMBERS. THAT IS ONE HAS BEEN PUT ON BUT ISN'T GREAT I CAN'T SAY I CAN YET. WE HAVE TO LOOK AT IT A LITTLE MORE. IS NOT ON SOMETHING THAT IS FUNNY. I CAN REALLY GET THROUGH SO MANY APARTMENTS FOR THIS WORKSHOP. I EXPECT TO CHANGE A LITTLE BIT AND BE A LITTLE BIT MORE ALIVE BY THE TIME YOU SEE IT IN JUNE. PUBLIC WORKS. HERE IS ANOTHER ONE THAT JUMPED OUT. 3.2 MILLION, FOUR, 5.8. A LOT OF THAT IS . AND 3.84 AND, WE ARE GOING TO BE SITTING DOWN AND GOING TO NUMBERS. BECAUSE THAT SEEMS , THE SALARIES ARE LINED UP. YOU GOT TO TAKE THE PROJECT AND THE PROGRAM. THEY SHOULD BE DOING MORE OF YOUR PROGRESS. OVER. WE WANT TO WORK ON THAT BEFORE WE ALL TO YOU AS WELL. THE IMPORTANT ONE THAT I THINK YOU ONLY GO ABOUT IT WHEN PEOPLE COMPLAIN IS GRAFFITI. AND GREAT FOLKS THAT WORK ON THAT TRY TO GET ALL THE GRAFFITI OUT AS FAST AS THEY CAN. I DISSIPATE YOU MAY SEE IN THE YEARS TO COME. ALTHOUGH THE PRIVATE LAND OWNERS HAVE JUST COME TO HIM THE CITY WILL JUST DO IT FOR FREE. AND SO WE ARE GOING TO WANT TO LOOK AT CREATING A STRUCTURE THAT WE COVER OUR COSTS . THAT IT IS APPROPRIATE. -OWNED LAND. BUT WE SHOULD COVER OUR COSTS. SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT, YOU KNOW, JOHN AND I REALLY RECEIVED IN DISCUSSION, WE WILL LOOK AT THAT ONE FORWARD. POLICE DEPARTMENT. THE NUMBERS, BUT NOT REALLY A BIG GROWTH IF YOU LOOK OVER FOUR YEARS. 38%. 38 NUMBER FOR PUBLIC SAFETY AND COMMUNITY. BUT THEY SAID EVERY TIME TRYING TO BE OUT THERE IN AS MANY SPOTS AS THEY CAN. WHETHER THAT IS ON THE STREETS, ALSO IN , YOU KNOW, WORKING ON A CAMPUS. THANKS ALL KINDS. THEY REALLY DO A GREAT JOB . AS YOU CAN SEE, ONE OF THE NUMBERS WE ARE STILL LOOKING AT. THERE IS THE ALLEGATIONS, MAKING SURE THOSE NUMBERS ARE BASED. IT SHOWS A LITTLE BIT HIGHER TO NUMBER THAN WE THINK WILL BE THERE AT THE END OF JUNE. ANY QUESTIONS ON THESE DEPARTMENTS AT RIFLE THROUGH THE GENERAL FUND DEPARTMENTS? AT IT FUND . F YOU MIGHTY, NOT FUM. [ LAUGHTER ] SEA EITHER QUESTION, BECAUSE IT IS GOOD YOU ARE RIGHT, THE PERCENTAGE THAT ALL OF THESE MAKE UP FOR OUR TOTAL BUDGET? THAT YES, BECAUSE OF THE PIE CHART. THIS IS A PIE CHART PRESENTATION, I GUESS. YES, WE DO. TO SHOW HOW IT ALL BREAKS DOWN. IS ALSO INCLUDED IN THE CHAPTER. BE SURE. THE PERFORMANCE PRESENTATION TO THE COUNCIL AS PART OF THE BUDGET. WE WILL HAVE THE CHARTS AND THE PERCENTAGES AND THE BREAKDOWN OF THAT. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. JUMPING QUICKLY TO OTHER FUNDS HERE. I KNOW EVERYONE RATHER GET TO SARAH'S PRESENTATION WHICH IS A LOT MORE FUN. SHE TALKED ABOUT PROJECTS. BUT AS WE GET TO INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS, THIS FIRST SLIDE INCLUDES I.T., AGAIN, I THINK WE ARE GOING TO BE MOVING AROUND THE EUROPEAN LOOKING AT THOSE NUMBERS. BUT WE WANT TO GET AND USE LIFE HERE, IS THE BUDGET STABILIZATION. DO THEY HAVE 30 PRESENTERS ? THIS IS A LOT OF FUN WE'RE ADDING A LITTLE EXTRA AND FALLING UNDER THE 30% THRESHOLD WE WANT TO REBUILD THAT. BUT THE MAINTENANCE IS A NUMBER THAT WE HAVE BEEN LOOKING AT. BUILDING MAINTENANCE AS WELL. AS YOU GO THROUGH , 631 , EMPLOYEE FRINGE, PASSION, OTHER POSTEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS, INSURANCE LIABILITY. AGAIN, NOT THE MOST GLAMOROUS TOPICS, BUT MAKING SURE THEY ARE BOTH FUNDED AND MEETING THE BUDGET OBLIGATIONS. THAT IS WHAT WE ARE DOING. WATER OPERATIONS. YOU WILL FEEL HER OVER THERE IN 2022-23. IS BECAUSE OF THE BOND ISSUE AND A $45 MILLION. YOU KNOW, THAT ALL DIDN'T HAPPEN THIS YEAR. BUT THAT IS WHERE IT WAS ENTERED. YOU HAVE FOR ME, WATERFRONT OPERATIONS . AGAIN, NOTHING JUMPING OUT HERE , WE GET UPDATES TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE, OR YOU ALL , YOU KNOW, EVERYONE. THEY ARE GETTING THEIR MURDERER THEY SHOULD BE. IF YOU SEE A DEFICIT IN 2022-23, SECURING FUND BALANCE IN THE FAR RIGHT COLUMN SHOULD BASICALLY TELL YOU THAT THEY ARE DRAWING DOWN SOME OF THE FUNDING. I CAN, ECONOMIC ELEMENT , LANDSCAPE LIGHTING, SOLID WASTE, HOUSING AUTHORITY AND AGENCY, NOTHING TOO OUT OF THE ORDINARY. SO GENERAL OBSERVATION, CELTICS IS PROJECTED TO INCREASE WITHOUT THE BENEFITS AND PROTECTED : ARE INCREASING. THERE WAS INCHES SEPARATE FUNDS THAT ARE TRACKED. AND A 9.6 MILLION IF YOU RECALL THAT WE HAD A COUPLE YEARS AGO FOR SOME OF THE COUNCILMEMBERS HERE, SO THAT ACTUALLY HAS SOME MEASURE OF MONEY IN IT. YOU HAD TO DO SOME MANEUVERING. I THINK SARAH MIGHT EVEN COVER IT IN HER PRESENTATION. SO I WANTED TO AVOID THAT IN THE FUTURE. SO THE MAJOR ON THAT WAS COMPLETELY IN ITS OWN FUND SO WE DON'T HAVE THAT POCKET AGAIN. PROJECTED JULY 1, 2023 BEGINNING RAZORS. THE REQUIREMENT IS THE GENERAL FUND OF 30% . IS PROJECTED TO BE 50%. THE BUDGET STABILIZATION FUND IS 5% OR 2 MILLION IS AT 2.4 ENTERPRISE FUNDS, THE WATERFRONT WILL BE A 66%. SUPERFUND 54%. THE REASONING OF THOSE NUMBERS UP IS BECAUSE HE'S BEEN FOR PROJECTS AND YOU AT DOWN CLOSER TO 30%. YOU'RE TRYING TO BUILD UP THE MONEY AND BRING IT DOWN FOR LARGER PROJECTS. OTHER ENTERPRISES. WATER FRONT OPERATIONS THAT 43. THE REAL 52%. I ENERGY, 37. MR. POWER IS 116, WHICH SOUNDS -- 2.8 MILLION CAPABLY DROP DOWN TO 30% IF YOU SPEND 1 MILLION OR 1,000,000 1/2. SO WE HOLD ONTO THAT FOR POWER PROJECTS OR SPECIAL PROJECTS THE CITY NEEDS. AGAIN, HERE IS THE I.T. ONE THAT WE HIGHLIGHTED. THAT IS ONE WE ARE GOING TO IMPROVE OVER THE NEXT FISCAL YEAR TO MAKE SURE IT IS ABOUT THE 30% THRESHOLD. FLEET IS A SECOND BELOW SO WE WILL HAVE THAT REFLECTED AS LOW. OTHERWISE, THE OTHER ONE ARE ABOUT 30% . TWO UPCOMING DATES. THURSDAY, MAY 4th IS MEASURE M TO ME. WE SIT DOWN AND DISCUSS THE MEASURE M COMMITMENTS AND IS MOVING FORWARD. FRIDAY, THE 19th IS THE FINANCE COMMITTEE. AND IF THE FINANCE SUBCOMMITTEE DIRECTS US, WE CAN TRULY HAVE ANOTHER COUNCIL WORKSHOP EITHER ON A GREATER DATE FOR JUNE 5th. AND THEN OF THE REAL GOAL IS THE SECOND MEETING IN JUNE TO HAVE THE ADOPTION OF THE BUDGET. I'M HAPPY TO TAKE ANY QUESTIONS IF YOU HAVE THEM. OR WE WILL GO TO PART THREE. >> I HAVE A QUESTION. AS CAN BE. LOOKING AT THE PROJECTED RESERVE LEVEL, AND THAT TREATED BY THE CONTINGENCY? IS THAT HOW THAT LEVEL IS SET? >> ANYWAY, IS A STANDER, YES. YOU HAVE A REAL CATASTROPHIC EVENT. AND CERTAINLY, YOU KNOW, IF YOU TO THE GENERAL FUND WERE 30% AND YOU HAVE A GLOBAL PANDEMIC. REVENUES DRY UP ORIGINALLY, THAT WOULD'VE GIVEN US VISION TO COVER THAT EXPENSE. GENERALLY, YOU KNOW, THAT SAFE PRACTICE OF HOW WE MAKE SURE, YOU KNOW, IF SOMETHING HAPPENS WE CAN HANDLE IT? >> AND WE, THE FOLLOW-UP QUESTION. WE HAVE A RISK FOLLOWER AWAY WE LOOK AT HOW IS THAT? THAT IS HOW WE GOT THESE NUMBERS? OR MARITAL FACTORS ? CAN WE LOOK AT BEST PRACTICES. AND NOT TO, YOU KNOW, THERE ARE CERTAIN CITIES THAT DON'T HAVE THOSE OR DON'T HAVE A FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE. SOME OF THEIR PROJECTIONS OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS ARE RATHER DIRE. AND SO I THINK IT IS A VERY GOOD TOOL, NOT ONLY WERE STAFF, BUT WAIT FOR THE COUNCIL TO CONVEY TO THE COMMUNITY , YOU ARE CONSERVATIVE. WE ARE GETTING THINGS DONE. WE ARE WATCHING FOR YOUR MONEY AND WHAT WE ARE DOING HUNDRED DOLLARS. >> THANK YOU. I WANT TO UNDERSTAND HOW WE GOT THERE. AND SOME OF OUR RATIONAL METHODOLOGY. SHE YOU KNOW, SOME OF THAT WAS A COUPLE COUNCILS AGO. AFTER WE WENT THROUGH THE 2008-09 , REALLY SOMETIMES, AND IT CAME OUT OF THAT. THE NATURE OF THE CITY IS IN A GOOD POSITION IN ALL FUNDS? NOT JUST THE GENERAL FUND? >> THANK YOU. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> SO THE GENERAL FUND, 50% RESERVE LEVEL. I KNOW WE HAD TALKED ABOUT BEFORE. IN ANY OF THAT YOUR ART, OR IS THAT TO RESERVE? >> THERE IS STILL SOME THAT WILL BE UTILIZED AS THAT SURPLUS THAT WE ARE BY A COUPLE YEARS AGO AND WILL BE FENCED DOWN . >> OKAY, AND THE DETAILS OF THAT? >> WILL HAVE A DETAILED, NOT ONLY BUT THERE'S TALKING ABOUT, BUT OUR FOLLOW-UP . TO BATTLE, WHERE WOULD YOU BE? >> OKAY, THANK YOU. ALWAYS. ALL RIGHT . >> GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT I WOULD LIKE TO BRING AN UPDATE ON PROJECTS IN PROGRESS. MEASURE M SURPLUS AND GENERAL BUDGET SURPLUS FUNDS. SO THAT THEY RECEIVED A $60.2 MILLION IN AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN FUNDING TO STOP THE SPREAD OF COVID AND PROTECTION OF ONE OF THE POPULATIONS AND INDUSTRIES AND RECOVER GOVERNMENT SERVICES. ADVENTURES WITHIN THESE FUNDS INCLUDE PUBLIC HEALTH, ECONOMIC IMPACTS, COMMUNITY SERVICES,. PAY , INFRASTRUCTURE, REVENUE REPLACEMENT, AND ADMINISTRATION . HE SAYS WILL BE UPDATED BY THE END OF 2024 BY THE END . THOSE ARE NEW DATES AS OF APRIL OF LAST YEAR. TO YOU, BUT THAT THE ORIGINAL IS. OBVIOUSLY, THE SURPLUSES IN ANNUAL MEASURE M . YOU RECALL MEASURE M IS AN EXTENSION OF MEASURE P PASSED BY PITTSBURG VOTERS. IS 100% TO PREVENT ECONOMIC TALENT, USE NOURISHMENT, AND THE CITY INFRASTRUCTURE. AND DIFFICULT 22, MEASURE M SURPLUS IS FULL OF 1.74 BILLION. THIS IS THE ANGLE $5.1 MILLION ALLOTMENT TO THE SIX CATEGORIES I DISCUSSION . FINALLY, 21, ARE DUE TO THE PANDEMIC, THE SURPLUS WAS 8.5 -- ON MAY 9, 22, AS PART OF THE FISCAL YEAR 2022-23 2%, THE CITY HAS BEEN A BUCKET FOR EASILY SPECIAL FUNDS . DETERMINE THE PRIORITIES , HISTORY, PHYSICAL 21 SURPLUS , CALPERS, BENEFITS, INSURANCE, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, AND -- HERE IS A QUICK DASHBOARD SHOWING THE PROGRESS UNDER EACH REVENUE SOURCE . A COUPLE OF THINGS TO KNOW. THE ALLOCATED LINE INCLUDES SEVEN DOLLARS . I DIDN'T WANT TO PARSE OUT BACK AND HOW TO ALLOCATE TO SPEND. NOW LOOKING AT THESE FUNDS. IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTICE THE CASH ON HAND THEM OUT. SO THE TABLES ON SERVICE REVENUE ARE SUFFERING THE BANK. WHERE IS MEASURE M COMING ANNUALLY AROUND AUGUST . AFTER THE CLOSE OF THE FISCAL YEAR. OUR FISCAL YEAR 2022-$23 WILL BE IN THE INTEGRATED. AFTER FISCAL 2022-20 IS A PROCESS WHY INCLUDE DETAILS FOR CATEGORY IN THE DASHBOARD. AS WE GO THROUGH THE PROJECT, YOU'LL NOTICE THIS IS A LITTLE DIFFERENT THAN OTHER ITEMS BUDGETED , EXISTING, BUDGETED IN 2022. OVERALL, THE THREE SPECIAL FUNDS, NO PROJECTS WERE ADDED OR REMOVED. HOWEVER, TO REMAIN CONSISTENT, PROJECTS IN DUE TO FUNDING SOURCES FOR WHICH THEY ARE ELIGIBLE. DIVING INTO THE --MONEY, ALREADY AT WORK HERE IN PITTSBURG. WE DECIDED A SOLUTION WHICH IS AN AREA WITH HIGH AMOUNT OF VOTERS WAS UPGRADES TO ROADS TO HELP MITIGATE THESE PROBLEMS WITH THE DESIGN FROM A ROCKY PATH, GIVING, BELOW, PROSPEROUS, AND D 3 INFRASTRUCTURE. THIS IS A SMASH FOR A CALIFORNIA PRESS, 12 THE CITY HAS BEEN COUNCIL ALSO ALLOCATED 500,000 BY THE ECONOMIC DRIVER. COURTYARD BY MARRIOTT WHICH YOU WILL SEE UNDER CONSTRUCTION. AND JEFF HAS ALSO TAKEN A PROACTIVE APPROACH TO EDUCATION OF THE FLEET . THE PLAN INFRASTRUCTURE AND MULTIPLE PROCESSING FACILITIES BASED ON AN IN-DEPTH --THE POLICE HAS A COUPLE IS ALREADY EXECUTED THOUSAND DOLLARS CONTRACT FOR INSTALLATION OF CHARGES AT CITY HALL. THE CITY IS ALREADY CONTRACTED FOR ADDITIONAL CODE ENFORCEMENT STAFF TO BRING COMMERCIAL LOCATIONS UP TO CDs EXTENDERS. YOU WILL SEE HERE ONE PROJECT THAT HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE ANY OTHER HERE IS AN AREA OF MATALIN STREET IS ONE OF THE AREAS THE CITY MANAGER IS TALKING ABOUT IN HIS PRESENTATION. I PRIORITY AREA IS GOING TO BE ALLEN STREET. AND A COUPLE OF EXCITING EARMARKS. ALSO INCLUDES , ALLOCATED , BUT POCKETED IN MAY 2022. FIVE FOUR COURSE AT -- AND BY .8 MILLION FOR THE CITY OF PITTSBURG FIELD FOR THEIR BOAT ACROSS THE STREET FROM EACH OTHER ON THE. THEY'RE BOTH THE DESIGN BASIS AND IT WILL SERVE AS LANDMARK FOR USE BOTH LOCALLY AND REGIONALLY. ALSO EARMARKED FOR ALL THE INGREDIENTS STRUCTURE PROJECT FOR PEACE PRODUCTION, SOLAR PROJECTS , SMALL LOCAL BUSINESS COACHING, REPLACEMENT OF THE CITY ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING SYSTEM WHICH WE CHATTED ABOUT. AND I WILL PLACE THE REMAINING 29 2000 $500,000 TO MEET THE STATE STANDARDS FOR ELECTRICAL AND CT FLEET. ALSO IS 400,000 FOR HIGH-LEVEL STAFFING FOR THE ART AND COMMUNITY FOUNDATION , AND A CLEANUP WITH HOMELESS , SOCIALISM -- HIGHWAY. CORRIDOR. AND THIS . GOLF IS ONLY A PORTION OF THE CITY ASKED FOR 3.3 MILLION CALTRANS TO BEAUTIFY RAILROAD AVENUE. THIS IS OUR SECOND CLEAN CALIFORNIA GRANTS. THIS HAPPENED BETWEEN SITTING AND THE CHANCERY. AS THE REWRITING OF ARTICLES PITTSBURG PROJECT BEING PRESENTED WITHOUT REMIND DESIGNS AND PARKS TO OUR MAJOR OVER ALWAYS DOWNTOWN. THIS IS ONE OF THE PRELIMINARY DESIGNS FOR ONE OF THE ENTRANCE ARCHES. 34, SOMETIMES OUR MEASURE M REVENUES EXCEED 1.5 MILLION ANTICIPATED. AND THERE ARE THREE THINGS THAT IS WORTH RETURNING TO ANNUALLY AFTER THE FISCAL YEAR AND PREPARE FOR SPENDING BY AUGUST HE SPENT MEASURE M , SPENDING A SURPLUS FROM THE PREVIOUS YEAR. THE RASH SHOWS ACTUAL PHYSICAL 22 MEASURE M RESULTS PROJECTED INCREASES FOR 2023 AND FOR PARTICIPATING ABOUT 2 MILLION ANNUALLY. AS YOU CAN SEE, WE'RE SPENDING ABOUT 500,000 IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS. STILL SURPLUS. ON MAY 9, 2022, AS PART OF THE BUDGET WORKS OUT, CITY COUNCIL ABOUT RESPONDING BUDGET FOR MEASURE M AS WELL. 14 PROJECTS IDENTIFIED FOR MEASURE M SURPLUS EXPENSES . SO FAR WITH TRYING TO FUSS, THE ALLOCATION ARE SHOWN. THE CITY IS LOCATED THE PROJECTS ON YOUR SCREEN. WE WENT OVER THAT. 850,000 FOR RENT AND TRAFFIC SIGNAL INSTALLATION. I ALSO FOR CPPA TREATMENT SERVICES . 53,000 FOR CITY PARK TREE REMOVAL. ALSO ALLOCATED IS 750,000 FOR MARINE CENTER UPGRADES. THESE ARE SOME OF THE PHOTOS YOU WILL SEE AND WE ARE EXCITED TO SEE SOME MORE FROM THAT. EARMARKS WERE MADE UP FOR FISCAL 2022, TRANSFER ANY PART CONTROL AND OPENING THE DOORS OF OUR LIBRARY ON MONDAYS. EITHER YOUR HEART, NOT ALLOCATED. ADDITIONAL ERRORS. THE $50 MILLION PREMIER SOCCER FOOTBALL TRACK, LACROSSE. I'M HERE, IS APPLICABLE. IS THE PARTIALLY FUNDED BY MEASURE M. SECURITY CAMERAS THROUGHOUT THE CITY INCLUDING THE MARINA HABIT YOUR ART. LM SUGGESTION, IF POSSIBLE STAY IN MEASURE M USERS ONLY. ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT ALL THE FUN YOU'RE HAVING? >> BACKTRACK >> ALSO. MOVING ONTO GENERAL BUDGET SURPLUS. THE CITY EXPRESS THE GENERAL FUND SURPLUS IN FISCAL YEAR 2041. MAY 22 AFFILIATE AT --AND THIS IS THE NUMBER THAT GARRETT PRESENTED IN A PREVIOUSLY PERSONAL MEASURE M LIVING IN THE GENERAL FUND, WE NARROW DOWN THE FINDINGS WERE SUMMERLIKE 7.5 MILLION. WE WILL BE KEEPING MEASURE M SURPLUS IN OUR OWN FUNDING FROM HERE GENERAL. NO GENERAL FUND SURPLUS FUNDS HAVE BEEN SPENT YET, BUT IT WOULD ALLOCATED TO CONTINUE PROJECTS LIKE UTILITY BOX ART. MY FAVORITE IS ON LEAVE FOR THE SUNRISE ON THE MODERN STEEL DIAPER IS AWESOME. I LIKE GETTING RID OF THAT STOPLIGHT. AND LOCAL CONDITIONS FOR VARIOUS MURALS THROUGHOUT THE CITY. APRIL 26, APRIL OTHER CLEAN CALIFORNIA GRANT APPLICATION FOR --MENTAL ILLNESS THE GRANTOR, THE EXCITING ADDITION IS A SKATE PARK CONTRACT LOCATED AT THE PARKER WALKING DISTANCE FROM CHAMA HIGH SCHOOL FROM AN AUDIENCE THAT CAN BENEFIT FROM THE TIME SPENT OUTDOORS AND ACTIVE. PITTSBURG FROM GUILT IS THE ONLY PROJECT WITH FUNDING FROM ALL THREE OF THESE SPECIAL FUNDS . 1.6 MILLION HAS BEEN EMERGED FROM THE GENERAL FUND SURPLUS. 250,000 FOR HIGH-LEVEL FIRE AND POLICE ACTIVITIES LEAGUE AND AN ADDITIONAL EURO 70 FOR REPLACEMENT OF CITY PARK RESIDENCE. THE TOP PHOTO IS THE EXISTING AT CITY PARK. THE LOWER PHOTO IS SOMETHING THAT CURRENTLY EXISTS AT --IT WOULD BE MORE PRIVATE AND USER-FRIENDLY. THERE IS A HALF-MILLION DOLLAR EARMARKED FOR TRANSFORMATION OF YOU CAN PROGRESS TO. FROM WHAT YOU SEE ON THE LEFT THERE IS NOTHING MORE PRIVATE AND USER-FRIENDLY. THE RIGHT PICTURE IS FROM JOHN BUCKLEY SQUARE. THAT IS MORE ALONG THE LINES OF WHAT WE WOULD BE LOOKING FOR. AND AS THERE ARE $62 A SECOND PORTION OF THE CITY MATCH FOR THE 3.3 -- CALIFORNIA GRANT. AGAIN , THE RAILROAD AVENUE BEAUTIFICATION. YOUR RENDERING OF THE PARK PROPOSED AT THE CORNER OF ROAD AND EAST 17th, ACROSS FROM THE PROPOSED SKI PARK AND PUMP TRACKS. GETTING OUT OF EARMARKS. UAL ALSO HAS BEEN MARKED TO REDUCE THE INTEREST FEATURE. FINALLY FOR BIGGER PROJECTS . 500,000 PERSONAL REPLACEMENTS WITHOUT. IN ADDITION TO THE $435,000 ALLOCATION, AN ADDITIONAL $54,000 HAS BEEN ERRED FOR EUCALYPTUS REMOVAL TO ENSURE SAFETY . LASTLY, THERE'S A $1.5 MILLION? FOR THE MENTATION OF THE LAND THE MASTER PLAN. LET ME KNOW IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ALLEGATIONS, SPENDINGS, EARMARKS OF THE THREE FUNDS? >> THANK YOU, SARAH. AMERICA, IS THERE A TIMELINE FOR ALL OF THESE DOLLARS THAT ARE IN YOUR HEART? ARE THEY SCHEDULED TO BE SPENT? IN THE FISCAL YEAR? NO, THE REQUIREMENT IS NOT UNTIL 2026. IT WILL TAKE A LOT TO SPEND DOWN. OBLIGATIONS HAVE TO HAVE A BABY" 2024. EXPENDITURES HAVE TO HAVE ENOUGH" 2026. THERE IS A TICKING TIME BOMB , BUT WE ARE ALLOCATED? ALL OF OUR FISCAL YEAR 22 FUNDS. SHOULD BE SPENT. OUR 2023 FUNDS ARE NEARLY ALLOCATED. BUT THERE IS NO TIME WENT ON AND TO SPEND. GENERAL FUNDS ARE SIMILAR AND NO TIME LIMIT TO SPEND THEM. >> OKAY. I COULD JUMP IN? SARAH IS A VERY GOOD JOB OF TRYING TO CASH MANAGE PROJECT MANAGE THE PROJECT SO WE ARE SEEING AN INCREASE IN MEDICATION. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR PRESENTATION. ARE THERE ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FOR COUNCIL? OKAY. BACK TO THE MAYOR, IS NOT RELATED TO THE BUDGET. I THOUGHT OF YOU HAVE SOME FLEET WE ARE REPLACING. ARE WE GOING TO DO WITH THE ONES WE ARE GETTING RID OF? WHAT IS OUR TREATMENT? WHAT WE DO WITH THEM? >> GOOD BUDGET BUT IT DEPENDS ON WHAT YOU DO IS RETIRE THERE. IF THERE ARE CERTAIN CRITERIA THAT WE KEEP TRACK OF FOR RETIRING A FLEET VEHICLE. RATHER IT IS MILEAGE OR WILL CAUSE A CERTAIN AMOUNT THREE PARENTS WITH A CERTAIN ISSUE COMES UP. I AM TAKING , GENERALLY ACTIVE ON THE FLEET TEAM , BUT THOSE OF YOU WAS REPLACED FIRST. ALL THE VEHICLES , SOME OF THE VEHICLES. THEY ARE NOT NECESSARILY REPLACEMENTS. AS HE HAS REQUIREMENTS FOR ELECTRIFYING THE . IS NOT SILLY TECHNOLOGY. IN SOME CASES, WE NEED TO SELL VEHICLES FOR ADDITIONAL STAFFING . >> THANK YOU.. USUALLY OPTIONS VEHICLES, AND WE DONATE THEM? TO PROVIDE THAT TONIGHT PROFITS THAT MIGHT BE DONE? >> I WILL JUMP IN. WHAT WE DO IS WE AUCTION THEM OFF , OR SOMETIMES THEY ARE HANDED OUT TO ANOTHER DEPARTMENT THAT DOESN'T HAVE THE REVENUES. THERE ARE A FEW VEHICLES WE CAN THINK OF OVER THE YEARS THAT WERE HANDED DOWN DEPARTMENT TO DEPARTMENT. OUR FLEET MAINTENANCE CREW WERE AMAZING TO KEEP THEM RUNNING AS LONG AS THEY DID. YES, WE LOOK AT WAYS TO BEING CASH BACK TO OFFSET FUTURE COSTS WERE BEGAN BEFORE WE HEADED OUT TO DEPARTMENT DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES. WE HAVE ALSO GIVEN, NOT GIVEN. DONATED TO -- VEHICLE SO THEY CA

Page

/

3

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFxRN1alpYMw22XALi-Vf4UmVTNS5EHq1PJwnFaHeo0y4VOQ2dJ_SvBssCALqJQi8vT9HviTP5mg0dGf13NFugwdQtnCPBN-16FQof6ty0lFYxLzZWHfkLC5LZxmMnixN5oAAT1ED9DflO0m8bdNUBsPwA-rxcgefj4ueZy2oRyENHHS1jVq2K_hvt58eGf0-JrNv08HIyQ1vr5KzvO4m3x69koNXTDQwdQJ-fvPTjGhwc_wh0aaRLEzQHgp7tTzrtmiVgh5xVcTH1m8SUVu9btG9SWVU9ChzWtM74ZvITStZEyyfMNSSXvU1nqb3G3M0ECoTDfDZ0A8NTHupjg2QswA8ba_gA%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

Loading…

View Meeting - OnBase Agenda Online

Hide Media

Home

Meetings

Contact

Agenda

Agenda Packet

Switch to Accessible View

Copyright © 2015-2026 Hyland Software, Inc.

Showing the first 24,000 of 116,869 characters. The full document is at the source.

GOOD EVENING, EVERYONE. IT IS NOW 5: 03 P.M. I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THE SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING TO ORDER. MR. CITY MANAGER? >> THANK YOU, MADAM MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. WELCOME TO THIS BUDGET WORKSHOP IN WHICH WE WILL COVER QUITE A FEW TOPICS. FROM UNFUNDED ACCRUED LIABILITIES, WHICH IS ALWAYS AN EXCITING TOPIC AND WE WILL JUMP INTO THAT IN A MOMENT. BUT ALSO -- THE BUDGET IS PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT THING YOU DO AS A COUNSEL. THIS LOVELY DOCUMENT HERE. YOU KNOW, IT'S AN INCH OR TWO. AND PROBABLY THE LEAST GLAMOROUS IN MANY WAYS. IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR ANYTHING THAT WE WANT TO DO STARTING ON JULY 1st. YOU NEED TO ADOPT A NEW BUDGET BY JUNE 30th. WE CAN DO ALL OF THESE GREAT THINGS THAT THE COUNCIL HAS AUTHORIZED. THIS WORKSHOP, WE WILL KICK IT OFF WITH AN UPDATE FROM ERIC SCRIVEN WITH NHA ADVISORS. ERIC HAS BEEN WITH US I FOR QUITE A WHILE. ACTUALLY IS A PLEASURE WHEN WE HAD ERIC COME BEFORE US. HE WILL GIVE US AN UPDATE ON CALIPERS AND COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT HE HAS. ,, ERIC, I WOULD APPRECIATE IT. >> HELLO. TAUGHT TO TURN THIS ON? OKAY, GREAT. GOOD EVENING, MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL, MADAM MAYOR, AND STAFF. WE THOUGHT WE WOULD DO AND WE TRY TO BE WITHIN 25 MINUTES OR SO. WE WILL GET A QUICK UPDATE ON A LITTLE BIT OF DEFINITION FOR MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. ON THE CALIPERS , THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY, AS WELL AS DISCUSS WHAT IS HAPPENING OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS. HE HAS SOME WORKSHOPS LAST YEAR. WITH RESPECT TO EDUCATION, BUT ALSO WE WERE CONSIDERING THE CITY WAS CONSIDERING DOING A RESTRUCTURING OF THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. MARCUS INTEREST RATES IS VERY QUICKLY THAT PROJECT INFEASIBLE. WE'LL TALK ABOUT SOME OTHER COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE AND OF INTEREST TO THE CITY AS YOU MAKE YOUR DELIBERATIONS ON PRIORITIES FOR A BUDGET. DURING THE NEXT MONTH AND A HALF. I NEED TO DO THIS. WHICH ONE IS IT? / SO THE BIG OVERVIEW IS THIS IS , I BELIEVE THIS IS THE LARGEST LIABILITY ON THE BALANCE SHEET. CURRENTLY, IT STANDS AT $42 MILLION. THAT IS A LARGE DECREASE EARLIER BEFORE WHEN IT WAS ABOUT THE $65 MILLION RANGE . IS A LITTLE BIT OF A MOVING TARGET AS WE WILL SHOW YOU. THIS CALIPER LIABILITY AND YOUR BALANCE SHEET, WHICH IS REALLY THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY THAT YOU OWE TO FULLY FUND YOUR BENEFITS FOR EMPLOYEES OVER THE TERM OF THE NEXT 34 YEARS. THIS $42 LIABILITY IS GOING TO GO UP. WE KNOW THAT. THERE ARE A COUPLE OF ODD THINGS WITH CALIPERS. THEY RE-EVALUATE BASED ON THEIR INVESTMENT EARNINGS EVERY YEAR. ONCE THE LIABILITY IS AND IT GOES UP AND GOES DOWN. WHEN, BASED ON THE DELETE, THEY HAD A VERY GOOD YEAR TO DROP THAT UAL $42 MILLION. THEY ARE NOT CURRENTLY FROM TWO YEARS AGO WE HAD A 21% INVESTMENT RETURN BY CALIPERS. UNFORTUNATELY, LAST YEAR, BUT WILL 22, THEY HAD A VERY BAD YEAR. WE'RE GOING TO BECAUSE OF THE DELAY. WILL THE DOUBLE INCREASE THE CITY'S UNFUNDED LIABILITY TO GO $71 MILLION . UNFORTUNATELY, RIGHT NOW, THEY ARE UNDERPERFORMING AGAIN . THIS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR, FISCAL YEAR 2023. NOW, THEY ARE AT 3.4%. WHAT THEIR TARGET IS 6.8%. SO WITH THAT, THERE IS LIKELY, UNLESS THERE'S A CHANGE FOR THE BETTER, THERE'S LIKELY TO BE AN INCREASE UP TO ABOUT $70 MILLION OR SO. THE CITY ALSO HAS , THEY ISSUED A PENSION OBLIGATION BOND ABOUT 20 YEARS AGO. 2006. THERE WERE $40 MILLION OUTSTANDING ON THOSE. SO ALL OF THESE THINGS TOGETHER CREATE A REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FOR YOUR UNFUNDED LIABILITY. IT BOUNCES AROUND A LITTLE. GOES UP AND DOWN. IT TURNED. BUT WE ARE HERE TO TALK ABOUT ALL OF IT IS HOW THE CITY CAN MANAGE THAT. IN SHORT, LIKE A LOT OF THE BUDGETING AND THINGS THAT YOU CONSIDER, LIABILITY NEEDS TO BE MANAGED SO YOU CAN CREATE UNPREDICTABLE PAYMENTS , REPAYMENT SCHEDULE. USUALLY, THE BEST WAY TO DO IT WHEN THINGS ARE BOUNCING AROUND LIKE CALIPERS LIABILITY, IS ON YOUR SIDE. WE LOOK AT THE STRATEGIES THAT CAN BE USED FOR COST MANAGEMENT. THIS LINE AND THAT WAS VERY BIG IN YOUR ANIMAL BUDGET. SO THE BACKGROUND, A FEW SLIDES ON THE BACKGROUND. TWO PLANS, MISCELLANEOUS AND YOUR SAFETY. AND WITHIN THOSE TWO PLANS , WE HAVE WHAT WE WOULD CALL CLASSIC EMPLOYEES. THOSE ARE THE OLDER. AND THEN THERE ARE THE NEW PLAN FOR BOTH THE MISCELLANEOUS AND SAFETY. THAT IS A LOWER BENEFIT, PEPRA. WHAT YOU HAVE OUTSTANDING IS ABOUT , WHAT? 750 COVERED MEMBERS OF WHICH THERE ARE ABOUT 260 THAT ARE ACTIVE. SO IT IS CLOSE TO ONE THIRD ARE ACTIVE . HAVE ABOUT TWO THIRDS THAT ARE NO LONGER ACTIVE, BUT REMAIN COVERED. OVERTIME, THE PEPRA EMPLOYEES WILL BE A LARGER SHARE OF YOUR BENEFIT PLANS. AND BASED ON THE WAY PEPRA STRUCTURE, THERE IS VERY LOW LIABILITY BECAUSE THE OR LOWER BENEFIT PLANS. SO THAT IS GOING TO COST CONTAIN, IF YOU WILL, OVER TIME. THE RIGHT NOW, WE HAVE THE LARGEST LIABILITY THAT WE WAS GOING TO GO UP TO $71 MILLION NEXT YEAR. AND THAT RELATE ALMOST 100%, IF NOT HUNDRED PERCENT YOUR METHOD PLAN . THE OUTSTANDING CLASSIC PLANS. ANY QUESTIONS ON EXISTING PLANS? LET ME GRAB THIS. IT WAS GRANDFATHERED IN, I BELIEVE IT WILL 2013 OR 2012. UNDER GOVERNOR JERRY BROWN'S WATCH. WHEN THEY TRANSITIONED. SO IF YOU WERE A CLASSIC EMPLOYEE, HE REMAINS . YOU WERE GRANDFATHERED INTO THOSE PLANS GOING FORWARD. THAT NEW PUBLIC EMPLOYEES, BOTH IN MISCELLANEOUS , AND ON THE SAFETY PLANS. THEY WERE PUT INTO THE PEPRA. IS THAT RIGHT? >> [ INDISCERNIBLE - LOW VOLUME ] SEA IT IS. IT IS STILL A DEFINED BENEFIT. FIRST A DEFINED CONTRIBUTION. THE DIFFERENCE BEING THE LOWER BENEFIT PLAN. IF YOU LOOK AT THE CHART UP THERE, PEPRA MISCELLANEOUS IS 2% CREDIT PER YEAR OF SERVICE , BEGINNING AT AGE 62. WHERE IS THE CLASSIC PLANS AT 2% , YOU CAN RETIRE EARLIER AT 55. OR 2% AT 60. AND NOW PEPRA IS 2% TO 62. THE SAME THING IS 85. IS A GENEROUS, IF YOU WILL, BENEFIT PLAN. ASHLEY EARLY, THAT KIND OF CONTAINS THE COST SIGNIFICANTLY. SO THIS IS REALLY HOW YOU LOOK AT, AND WE SHALL LOOK AT, THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. IT IS DESIGNATED ON TWO BARS TO THE RIGHT. I SHOULD SAY, THERE ARE TWO PAYMENTS OTHER THAN HE THINKS EVERY YEAR. WHAT IS WHAT WE WOULD CALL A NORMAL COST. THE COST YOU PAY FOR CURRENT EMPLOYEES, JUST TO STAY CURRENT. MOTHER IS THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY AS I MENTIONED BEFORE. CALPERS, ASSUMPTIONS CHANGE PERIODICALLY. ALSO , HE HAS RETURNED FOR THE TARGET. SOMETIMES, THEY DO GO ABOVE THE TARGET . RELATE TO THE TARGET, AND CREATE THE LIABILITY. THE LIABILITY IS DEFINED ON THE RIGHT-HAND SIDE. IT IS 27 $6 MILLION FOR THE CITY OF PITTSBURG. THAT IS THE ACTUARY ESTIMATES , WHICH, YOU KNOW, I AM NOT SURE IS THE PRECISE FIGURE. BUT WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME TRYING TO FIGURE OUT MORTALITY RATES FOR YOUR CURRENT EMPLOYEES THAN 750 COVERED EMPLOYEES OVER TIME. HOW MUCH THEY, IF YOU WILL ON THE COUNT OF CalPERS WILL BE REQUIRED TO BEAR ALL THE BENEFITS THE EMPLOYEES ARE DOING AS A RETIRE OVER THE NEXT 20 OR 30 YEARS. SO THAT IS THE LIABILITY AND THE TARGET, IF YOU WILL. AND THEN THEY HAVE YOUR THE COUNT, EVERY PEPRA FOR --IT IS EVERY YEAR FOR THE CURRENT VALUATION IS $99 MILLION. THAT REDUCES THE DEFICIT THAT THE LIGHT BLUE COLOR OF ABOUT $70 MILLION. THAT $78 MILLION ASSUMES , NOT ONLY THE BAD IN FISCAL 22, AND MAKE THE ASSUMPTION THAT WE STAY WITH THE 3.4% RETURN IN HIS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR. WE HAVE TWO MORE MONTHS. THAT WILL ADD ABOUT $7 MILLION. WE ARE GOING TO USE THE $70 MILLION FIGURES IS A CONSERVATIVE NUMBER FOR THIS. I WOULD SAY THAT, AS I MENTIONED BEFORE, EVERY YEAR, CALPERS, AT THE END OF THE FISCAL YEAR, THEY FIGURE OUT WHAT THEIR INVESTMENT RETURNS WERE. SO TWO YEARS AGO, THEY , THE RESULTS WERE OVER THE 6.8% TARGET. WAY OVER. IT WAS 21.3%. LAST YEAR, THEY MISSED THE MARK. AGAIN, THE TARGET IS 16%. THEY WERE NEGATIVE. SO THAT IS A MESS ON THE MARK OF ABOUT 14%. SO TWO YEARS AGO, EVERY YEAR WHEN THEY DO THAT, THEY FIGURE OUT WHAT NEW LAYER THEY ARE GOING TO PUT TO THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE, ALONG WITH THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY. TWO YEARS AGO, WHICH CAME IN, AS I SAID, WE ARE AT $55 MILLION. AND IN THE REDUCED LIABILITY ITSELF TO GO 45 MILLION. 42 MILLION. WE ARE SITTING ON THAT RIGHT NOW. THE PAIN AS WELL , THERE IS A NEW LAYER. IT IS CLEAR THAT LOWER THE PAYMENT SCHEDULE. WELL, WE KNOW THAT THE YOUR LAST YEAR OF -7.5%, THEY ADDED ANOTHER LAYER. SO WE'LL GET THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE WHICH WILL SHOW THAT LAYER IS A BIG PLAYER, INCLUDING THE REFLECTED $71 MILLION. LIABILITY. WE EXPECT ANOTHER SEVEN OR EIGHT DOLLARS TO BE ADDED ON. WILL HAVE AN ADDED LAYER AS WELL. ANY QUESTIONS ON THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY? SO THIS IS A CHART SO YOU CAN SORT OF SEE. THERE ARE LOTS OF LAYERS EACH YEAR. YOU WILL HAVE MAYBE A POSITIVE LAYER WHICH IS WHEN THEY DON'T DO WELL. THERE IS NO LAYER WHATSOEVER IF THEY HIT THEIR TARGET OF 6.8%, EXACTLY. IT WOULD SEEM THE SAME. IT GOES UP, IT GOES DOWN. AND ALL OF THOSE LAYERS, IF YOU WILL, LAYERS OF THE CAKE, PRODUCE THE RED DOTTED LINE ERROR. THAT IS THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FROM THE COMBINATION OF ALL PLAYERS. THIS IS REALLY FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES . THIS DOES NOT REFLECT THE CITY OF PITTSBURG'S UNFUNDED LIABILITY PAYMENT. WHY HAVE THE COST TRADED HIGHER? WELL, BACK IN THE LATE 1990s, WE HAD VERY, VERY STRONG INVESTMENT RETURNS BY CALPERS. THEY WERE HITTING THEIR MARKS AND IS ON . BY THEN, IT WAS 8% . YOU MAY RECALL, THE.COM AND REALLY STRONG INVESTMENT MARKET , CalPERS WAS MINGLING WELL. THEY ACTUALLY WERE DOING SO WELL , THERE WAS A LIABILITY. THERE WAS NO UNFUNDED LIABILITY. THE ROBOCALLS PROVIDED. THAT CREATED SOME ISSUES WHERE ADDITIONAL BENEFITS WERE GIVEN OUT IN THE LATE 1990s, STARTING WITH THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WITH THE PRISON GUARDS AND PHP. VENTRICLE TO THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS , PUBLIC SAFETY, AND OTHERS. THOSE INCREASED INCREASED A HIGHER LIABILITY. AND SINCE THEN , THE RETURNS BY CalPERS HAVE BEEN VERY, VERY VOLATILE. GENERALLY, THEY HAVE BEEN LOWER. HAS CREATED THE BEGINNING OF THIS UNFUNDED LIABILITY OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS. CalPERS HAS CHANGED THEIR ASSUMPTIONS . PEOPLE ARE LIVING LONGER. THEY USED TWO WITH HOW MUCH THE ASSETS OF THE ACCOUNTS WERE WORTH. THAT WOULD KIND OF TEMPER THAT VERSUS ANNUALLY DO AN EVALUATION. FINALLY, THEY DECIDED CalPERS DECIDED THEY WANTED TO GO FROM A 30 REPAYMENT SCHEDULE FOR EACH OF THOSE LAYERS TO A 20 REPAYMENT SCHEDULE. THAT, ALL OF THE ASSUMPTIONS COMBINED, CREATED NOT ONLY A HIGHER LIABILITY, BUT A VERY REGULAR SHAPED LIABILITY AND IS DEEPLY ASCENDING UNFUNDED LIABILITY, DEPENDING ON THE EXPERIENCE. AS YOU WILL SEE SHORTLY, IT HAS BEEN VERY, VERY VOLATILE. OKAY. THIS CHART HERE IS PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT CHART. THERE IS A LOT GOING ON HERE. BUT WE WANTED TO SHOW ALL OF WHAT I HAVE DISCUSSED PREVIOUSLY. WITH RESPECT TO LAYERING ON NEW REPAYMENT SCHEDULES FOR YEARS AND YEARS . IN 2020, WE HAD , YOU KNOW, IS LIKELY THAT HERE. I WAS THE CITY WAS AT $65 MILLION. AND INDEED THE REALLY GOOD YEAR. THE CalPERS 21% LIABILITY WENT DOWN TO GO 42. 42 MILLION. AND LAST YEAR, THEY HAD A REALLY BAD YEAR, -7.5% . WE ARE GOING BACK UP TO 71 MILLION. REPORTS WILL COME OUT LATER THIS SUMMER. AGAIN, THERE IS LABELED HIS REPORT SO WE WILL FEED US LATER THIS SUMMER. AND WE EXPECT THAT THE LIABILITY WILL GO UP A LITTLE BIT MORE. SO EACH OF THOSE RETURNS, YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE ARE LAYERS WITHIN THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE THERE. THE LOWEST LEVEL REPAYMENT SCHEDULE IS THAT 2006 PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS. THAT DEAL WAS STRUCTURED SO IT WAS LEVEL AND TERMINATES IN FISCAL 2036 . ALL OF THE OTHER LAYERS, A SORT OF NAVY BLUE , FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020, YOU CAN SEE THAT AT A LATER. AND THEN WE HAD A GOOD YEAR WHERE IT WAS A DARKER , WHAT IS THAT? IS THAT WHILE BLUE? THE DARKER BLUE. WHERE WE ACTUALLY COULD SEE A REDUCTION IN THE SHORTENING OF THE PAYMENT. AND WE KNOW BECAUSE OF THE BAD RETURN IN FISCAL 2022, THE GRAY , THE LIGHT GRAY BARS GOING TO BE ADDED. WE KNOW THAT IS OCCUR. YOU CAN SEE THAT THAT IS LENGTHENING AND CREATING AN INCREASED PEAK , AS WELL AS REASSIGNING THE PAYMENT SCHEDULE. WE EXPECT FY 23 , INCREASE. THAT IS THAT DEAL THAT LAYERS ON TOP. ALL OF THESE THINGS COMBINED, YOU CAN SEE RIGHT NOW, IN FY 24, NEXT YEAR, WE WILL HAVE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT LOW. THERE'S A LITTLE BIT ABOUT IT THERE. THE DARK BLUE FOR FY 24. THE GOODYEAR THAT WAS LAST YEAR, BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE NEW LAYER , THERE IS A DELAY. NEW LAYER FOR FY 22, BATTERY RETURNS, THE GRAVE. THOSE ARE GOING TO START TO GO UP AFTER FY 24. OH THEREIN LIES SOMETHING THAT WE FEEL IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR COUNCIL TO NOTE. IT IS ALL ALL. BUT THE LAG, IS COMING. THE $71 MILLION IS A NUMBER THAT IS COMING. IT IS JUST THE LAG AND REPORTING OF CALPERS. WE THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THERE IS THIS AND THERE'S POSSIBLY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR UTILIZING THE BUDGET AND SOME OF THESE OTHER STRATEGIES TO GET IN FRONT OF IT A LITTLE BIT. ACTUALLY, THE CITY DOES HAVE SOME COST MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES THAT HAVE BEEN UTILIZED OVER THE YEAR. OVER THE YEARS. THERE ARE ABOUT FIVE OF THEM. THE CITY, EVERY YEAR, DOES PREPAY AND GET THE CREDIT OF 3.3% ON THE LUMP SUM THAT IS PAID BY THE END OF JULY. NUMBER TWO. THE CITY HAS NEGOTIATED , LIKE MOST CITIES IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA , YOU NEGOTIATED SOME COST SHARING WITH EMPLOYEE. NUMBER FIVE. THE CITY DID RESTRUCTURE ITS UNFUNDED LIABILITY WITH BACK IN 2006. AS THE PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS. WE ACTUALLY TALKED ABOUT RESTRUCTURING THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY TO A PERFECT WILL SHAPE AND PAYMENT SHAPE. LAST YEAR. AGAIN, INTEREST RATES WENT UP AND IT TURNED OUT TO NOT BE FEASIBLE. NUMBER THREE. THE FRESH START AMORTIZATION IS SOMETHING THAT CalPERS OFFERED. THEY WILL TAKE YOUR UNFUNDED LIABILITY AND CREATE A LEVEL OF REPAYMENT. THE PROBLEM WITH THAT PROGRAM IS , THEY REQUIRE THAT YOU SHORTEN THE LOAN. SO THE EFFECT IS THAT YOU WILL HAVE A HIGHER PAYMENT IN THE NEAR-TERM. YOU CAN'T GO BACK TO CHANGING IT TO SOMETHING ELSE. YOU CAN'T GO BACK TO WHERE YOU WERE. SO TO THE EXTENT YOU HAVE A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF CASH AND YOU COULD BUDGETED FOR THAT IN THE NEAR TERM, IS WHEN A FRESH START IS UTILIZED. NUMBER FOUR. THAT IS WHAT MANY, IF NOT MOST, PUBLIC AGENCIES IN CALIFORNIA ARE UTILIZING. THEY ARE USING CASH . YOU HAVE TO HAVE CASH TO UTILIZE FOR A COUPLE OF OPTIONS. ONE IS THE SECTION 115 TRUST. THAT OPTION . THE CITY OF PITTSBURG ACTUALLY HAS THE SECTION 115 TRUST. I WILL GET INTO WHAT THAT IS EXACTLY. OR ADDITIONAL DISCRETIONARY PAYMENT. THAT IS A PAYMENT THAT THE CITY COULD AND WOULD MAKE DIRECTLY TO CalPERS TO TAKE OUT ONE OR MORE OF THOSE LAYERS THAT I TALKED ABOUT TO CREATE RELIEF , ARE IN THE REPAYMENT SCHEDULE AS A STRATEGIC OPTION. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON SORT OF A HIGH-LEVEL CROSSMATCH AND STRATEGIES WE SEE TYPICALLY BE CONSIDERED? AND I BELIEVE THAT CITY OF PITTSBURG IS UTILIZING MOST OF THEM. SEA JUST A SHORT QUESTION. WHAT ABOUT FRESH START , IS NOT RECOMMENDED RIGHT NOW. BUT WHEN THAT START HAPPENS , IT IS STILL SUBJECT TO THE UP AND DOWNS OF THE CalPERS RETURNS? OR ARE YOU WATCHING PRETTY MUCH AT FRESH START? >> KNOW. TONIGHT EVERYTHING IS --AN EVERYTHING STILL GET , THE LAYERS EVERY SINGLE YEAR, BASED ON INVESTMENT RETURNS. ALSO, BASED UPON CalPERS DECIDED TO CHANGE HIS ASSUMPTIONS AGAIN, WHEN YOU REVIEW, THERE ASSUMPTIONS EVERY THREE OR FOUR YEARS I BELIEVE FOR MORTALITY. WHETHER THEY WANT TO CHANGE THE MIX ON THEIR INVESTMENTS SOMETIMES CREATE A CHANGE IN YOUR TIGHT GRIP INVESTMENT TOTAL OF RIGHT NOW --IT USED TO BE 7%. YEARS AGO, IT USED TO BE A PERCENT. GOT OUT OVER THE YEARS. IT WILL MAKE A FEASIBLE TARGET, LES CHRISTY TURNER. THEY STILL HAVE NOT BEEN HITTING THE TARGET EVERY YEAR. I WON'T GO INTO THIS TOO DEEPLY. I WILL SAY THE CITY HAS A SECTION 115 TRUST. WHEN THE MONEY IS PUT INTO THE SECTION 115 TRUST, IS DEDICATED OR RESTRICTED TO CURBS AND -- PAYMENTS. SO IT SHOWS A STRATEGY FROM THE CITY. THE CITY COUNCIL AND STAFF ABOUT ADDRESSING THIS PROBLEM. IT IS LOOKED UPON FAVORABLY BY FEDERAL AGENCIES . I WAS USE THE WORD SQUIRRELING ALWAYS ON ANY , FOR THIS PARTICULAR CHALLENGE . THIS IS THE BIGGEST CHALLENGE FOR MOST CITIES AND PUBLIC AGENCIES IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. ON THE ROAD A SECTION 115 IS THERE A DIFFERENT INVESTMENT GOALS. YOU HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE LENIENCY TO GO ON A LITTLE BIT MORE AGGRESSIVELY VERSUS THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE . YOU ARE RESTRICTED TO CERTAIN TYPES OF INVESTMENTS. SO CURRENTLY, THE CITY 115 TRUST IS UTILIZED IN CARS AS INVESTMENT ADVISER , AND AS I UNDERSTAND IT, THE INVESTMENT STRATEGY IS MEDIUM. IT IS NOT TOO RATHER, IT IS NOT TOO CONSERVATIVE. TRYING TO GAIN SOME GOOD RETURNS WITH I BELIEVE 2 1/2 MILLION DOLLARS IN THE THE COUNT RIGHT NOW. AS I SAID, THE OTHER STRATEGY WITH USING CASH IS TO DIRECTLY, INSTEAD OF PUTTING IT INTO A CITY CONTROL 115 TRUST, YOU CAN SEND THAT MONEY DIRECTLY TO CalPERS TO TRY TO PAY OFF ONE OR MORE , OR A PIECE OF, THOSE LAYERS THAT ARE LAYERED ON EVERY SINGLE YEAR. THAT CAN CREATE THE RELIEF YOU'RE LOOKING FOR. BY AVOIDING , BY TAKING OUT ONE OF THOSE LAYERS AND AVOIDING THAT PAYMENT, THE RETURN IS ESTIMATED TO BE THE TARGET THEY ARE TRYING TO CHARGE THE CITY . IS 6.8%. BUT, YOU KNOW, AGAIN, BOTH OPTIONS, ONCE YOU GET CalPERS MONEY, THEY PUT INTO THE THE COUNT . IT IS SUBJECT TO REINVESTMENT TOOLS. JUST A VERY HIGH LEVEL COMPARISON BETWEEN THE SECTION 115 TRUST AND THE ADP, ONE IS CONTROL, IF YOU WILL. THAT'S BY THE CITY. THERE IS MORE FLEXIBILITY ON THE USE . YOU CAN USE IT FOR PAYING ON ADP AT ANY TIME. YOU CAN ALSO USE IT FOR --AND YOU CAN USE IT FOR NORMAL COUGH. THERE IS A LITTLE MORE FLEXIBILITY. THE CalPERS ADP, LINDSEY PENA, AND GETTING MY FEELING HERE. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE CITY CONTROL IT'S FUNNY. IN POSSESSION, THEY ARE BOTH GOOD USES. AND HUNDREDS OF PUBLIC AGENCIES UTILIZE BOTH OF THEM AND. BUT IF YOU WERE TO THINK ABOUT THE TWO OF THEM, THE SECTION OF OVER FIVE TRUST, THERE IS MORE FLEXIBILITY AND CONTROL BUT IS A VERSUS SPENDING MONEY WITH CalPERS. YOU GET AN IMMEDIATE RESULT, BUT IF I WERE TO LIKE TO COMPARE AND CONTRAST FOR YOU ALL COMPETENCY, THAT IS HOW I WOULD FRAME IT. SO JUST GETTING INTO SOME HYPOTHETICAL HERE. THE CITY DOES HAVE 2 1/2 MILLION DOLLARS ON ACCOUNT RIGHT NOW. WE ARE TRYING TO MODEL A COUPLE OF SCENARIOS WHERE TRYING TO CHOP OFF THAT PEAK, IF YOU WILL. WE KNOW THAT BASED ON THE CURRENT RETURNS THAT HAVE BEEN EARNED BY CalPERS LAST YEAR BUT THEY LOOKED LIKE, THEY ARE GOING OUT THIS YEAR. THIS IS THE SHAPE, THE REPAYMENT SHAPE OF YOUR LIABILITY. YOU HAVE TWO HALF-MILLION DOLLARS IN THE BANK RIGHT NOW. TO THE EXTENT THAT WE CAN PUT ANY MORE MONEY AND WE ARE FOR HALF PERCENT. WE WANT TO DEPICT THAT AS THE ORANGE LINE. TO THE EXTENT YOU PUT IN ANOTHER , I BELIEVE, WE WERE DOING $3 MILLION. YOU COULD LOWER THAT LEVEL LINE TO THE DARK BLUE LINE. AND FINALLY, IF YOU PUT IN $6 MILLION, YOU COULD LOWER THE PEAK PAYMENT AND CREATE OUR LEVEL PAYMENTS AT AROUND $11 MILLION . THAT MAKES SENSE. THE MORE MONEY YOU HAVE TWO SORT OF INVEST IN IS 115, AND THEN STRATEGICALLY, TAKE OUT AND AVOID TO CHOP OFF SOME OF THESE PEAKS ., THE MORE YOU HAVE TO THROW AT THE PROBLEM. THE LOWER THAT ANNUAL LEVEL PAYMENTS PLACE WOULD BE. THESE ARE ALL WRAPPED AROUND THE 2006 PENSION BONDS. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON THIS? IT IS A CONCEPTUAL CHARGE. BUT I THINK WE REALLY , WE ALL KNOW HOW MUCH MONEY THE CITY HAS TO THROUGHOUT THIS CHALLENGE. WE THINK IT IS IMPORTANCE TO KNOW HOW THE STRATEGY, IF YOU WERE TO DO IT, WHERE YOU WANT TO END UP. I MEAN, YOU THING I SHOULD REMIND EVERYONE AND REMIND MYSELF, BUT HONESTLY, YOU WANT TO VISIT EVERY SINGLE YEAR. YOU KNOW, FOR SOMETHING IN IT YOU CAN BET THAT YOU HAVE SOMETHING THERE ALREADY. THE CalPERS IS GOING TO EARN WHAT THEY EARN , AND YOU WILL FIND OUT AT THE END OF EVERY SCHOOL YEAR. YOU CAN ADAPT ACCORDINGLY. TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY HAVE ANOTHER BAD YEAR AND ANOTHER YEAR, TO THE EXTENT YOU PUT SOME MONEY IN TO THIS SECTION 115 THE COUNT. THAT HAS CREATED THE ABILITY TO , THE CUSHION, IF YOU WILL. TO PRIORITIZE PAYMENTS, BUT ALSO OTHER PRIORITIES LIKE CAPITAL AND SERVICE LEVELS WHILE YOU FIGURE OUT WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN WITH CALPERS. YOU KNOW, LIKE ALL THE OTHER RACERS, THE SECTION 115 CREATE A OFFER. OFFER FOR DECISION-MAKING. SO THIS IS SORT OF THE DETAIL BEHIND THAT CHART. TWO AND HALF MILLION IN THE BANK, IS A 4 1/2% YOU WOULD EARN IN SECTION 115 TRUST. THE SAVINGS ARE SHOWN. IT JUST RAMPS UP. FROM THE DO-NOTHING OVER THE NEXT FIVE OR SIX YEARS, WANT TO START CHOPPING OFF THE TOP. AND IT PROGRESSIVELY IS MORE AND MORE. THERE WERE MANY YOU ARE ABLE TO THROW AT THE PROBLEM, THESE ARE HYPOTHETICALS. YOU KNOW, IT IS , SHE WOULD DEPOSIT EACH OF THE YEARS . OF COURSE, THAT DEPENDS ON CLASSES AND CASH FLOW. I THINK IT IS PRETTY WELL KNOWN THAT THIS IS A HUGE PROBLEM FOR ALL PUBLIC ABCs. IT IS THE LARGEST EVER, I BELIEVE IT IS THE LONG LARGEST ON THE BALANCE SHEET. AS FOR THE LARGEST THAT BY THE END OF THE SUMMER WHEN WE GET THE NEW CalPERS REPORTS. SO THERE ARE VARIOUS OPTIONS THAT YOU HAVE BEEN DOING, AND THAT YOU MAY WANT TO CONSIDER TO CONTINUALLY STAY OUT OF THIS PROBLEM. WE ARE LOOKING LIKE WE ARE GOING TO HAVE ANOTHER BAD YEAR. SO WE DON'T KNOW WHAT NEXT YEAR GOALS. BUT THE POINT OF THIS PRESENTATION IS TO REALLY REMIND COUNCIL THAT THIS PROBLEM, IT BOUNCES AROUND. IT IS A UNIQUE LIABILITY ON THE BALANCE SHEET. AND TO THE EXTENT THAT YOU CAN BUTTRESS THIS SECTION 115 OR JUST RESERVES IN GENERAL FOR THIS PROBLEM. THAT CAN BE VERY VERY HELPFUL FOR BUDGETING IN FUTURE YEARS AND PREDICTABLE LEVELS. I WOULD BE GLAD TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. I'M CHECKING WITH MY COLLEAGUES TO SEE IF THEY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. COUNCILMEMBER JELANI KILLINGS? I WANT TO SAY THANKS FOR THE PRESENTATION. I THINK, AT LEAST FOR THE MEMBERS OF THIS PRESENTATION WITH THE PROCESS , AS WE ARE TRYING TO RESTRUCTURE LAST YEAR OR SO, THIS IS A HEARTBURN THAT PUBLIC AGENCIES ARE DEALING WITH. RESTORATION IS THAT --OUR HANDS. AS WE ARE LOOKING AT, YOU KNOW, NATIONAL DOLLARS WE CAN DO TO TRY TO SMOOTH ON WHAT IS FORECASTED FOR THE UPCOMING YEARS. I CAN APPRECIATE THIS. I KNOW YOU HAD DISCUSSIONS ABOUT A 15 TRUST . AS WENT THROUGH THE PANDEMIC, WE HAVE TO MAKE DECISIONS IN TERMS OF HOW WE WERE GOING TO POND DIFFERENT THINGS. SO DEFINITELY LOOKING FORWARD TO THE FUTURE CONVERSATION. DEFINITELY INTERESTED, BUT AS WE CAN, TO FOR THE UPCOMING YEARS ." WE UNDERSTANDS THAT THE MORE WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO KEEP IN A SINGLE PAYMENT, DOLLARS THAT WILL NOT BE FOR COMMUNITY THAT WE EMERGENCY PROGRAMS GO TO DIFFERENT AREAS. TRIED TO FIND THAT BALANCE IS GOING TO BE A CONVERSATION FOR COUNCIL. AS WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THIS, I HAVE AN INTEREST. I, THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVISIT OUR PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE, SURGICALLY. I KNOW FOR CERTAIN THINGS THEY DID THEIR . IN TERMS OF ADDRESSING SOME OF THESE RESERVES AND ADDITIONAL ONE-TIME REVENUES. I THINK THAT MAYBE A CONVERSATION, WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THE IDEA OF THINGS, A DECISION THAT MAY NEED TO BE MADE IN ORDER TO HAVE THE MONEY AS NECESSARY TO THAT 5 MILLION OVER THE NEXT FEW YEARS, SO THAT'S ANOTHER CONVERSATION TO HAVE. I KNOW THIS IS VERY DEPENDENT ON , ONCE AGAIN, REVENUES THAT COME IN AND WHAT WE ARE ABLE TO DO IS A COUNCIL . I THINK THAT IS AN IMPORTANT DISCUSSION ABOUT PHYSICAL SUSTAINABILITY ORDINANCE, THE ENGINE BEHIND IT , AND THE UNIQUENESS OF THE SITUATION WE ARE CONSTANTLY GRAPPLING WITH WITH CalPERS. IS THERE SOMETHING ABLE TO DO WITHIN THE ORDINANCE ITSELF THAT MAKE THE POSSIBILITY FOR MONEY! 15 TRUST? ALSO I SHALL THOUSAND COMMENTS . I SAID THANK YOU FOR COMING OUT MAKING THIS PRESENTATION. AS WELL THOUGH, IS TIMELY. THESE ARE THINGS WE SHOULD BE CONSIDERING AMONGST ALL THE OTHER THINGS ON THE LIST THAT WE WANT TO PRIORITIZE . I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME AND PERIOD THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER JELANI KILLINGS. COUNCILMEMBER JUAN ANTONIO BANALES? >> THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. I'M REALLY INTERESTED IN DIVING INTO SOME OF THE DETAILS. ON THE SAVINGS. WE DON'T HAVE TO DO IT NOW. BUT YEAH, IF YOU COULD PROVIDE MAY BE A BREAKDOWN OF THE NET SAVINGS OF THE SLING OPTIONS PRINCES FROM MY UNDERSTANDING, MAYBE LATER ON, THAT COULD BE PROVIDED. I THINK THAT WOULD HELP ME BETTER UNDERSTAND FROM A CASH FLOW PERSPECTIVE , CAN HELP IMPACT? I THINK FROM WHAT I'M HEARING, YOU KNOW, NEXT MEETING ARE POSITIVE . THERE WERE REPORTS OF THE 14th IS HOLDING UP THE PROCESS. I

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Meeting - 5/1/2023 — Minutes
  • City Council Meeting - 5/1/2023
  • City Council Meeting - 5/1/2023 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 84eaaa932c5c13a730a056a3e3acc158. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record