POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, October 27, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 121,036 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor can well. District one hopefully Curtis. >> District 2 Council vice chair Randy gabbard district 3 and not marry. His pick for Lisette can away. Every big Sanders. And Council chair Gina Driscoll. John Muhammad. And district day Richie Floyd. >> Everyone will call to order the 10/27/2022 meeting of the St. Petersburg City Council can we start with the roll call please gather, your mom Mary here panel, it's here big Sanders. Driscoll air Muhammad air Florida. Guard us air. For indication today. We have our district one City Council member cope with Paris indication will be followed by the pledge of allegiance please join me in standing. Please bow your heads. >> Thank you for blessing us with this beautiful day and this amazing city we're all lucky to call home. Lord thank you for constantly reminding us that the city is made of engage. Residents dedicated employees, thriving businesses. Bustling schools and homes. But also thank you for the reminder that not everyone gets to enjoy those schools employment centers and homes. Let us remember that our work here tries to ensure that each and every one of our residents and visitors are able to enjoy all of what Saint Pete has to offer as a city we have been blessed with so many leaders that have come before us. Servants from diverse backgrounds and beliefs like Bob Stewart David Welch Renee flowers Ernest kill you call nurse, Charlie guard us. Rick kriseman David Fischer jw Kate Bob Ulrich with Baker Amy Foster Darden Rice Jeff tarte Danner bill Foster and Bob Kirstein just to name a few during my lifetime that have helped shape me and the city to what we are today. This Council continue to follow their service to our community by diligently deciding its future. As these leaders have gone before us. It is my prayer the prayer the St. Petersburg community that this Council continues to work together to make intentional decisions that not only impact today. But are forward thinking to tomorrow's generation of residents. As it is only together that the city will truly reach our potential. Lord please bless our mayor all our city employees this Council and all of our residents and visitors protect our first responders the firefighters and police officers that put their lives on on the line in a daily basis to ensure our safety. Please guide us to your service and to the service of others. We asked this in your son's name Jesus Christ Amen and then. The United States. And to the Republic, which stands one nation. >> Indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >> Thank you council member guards to that beautiful invocation Moon. Council members we haven't done that before us for today's meeting I'll entertain a motion for approval of approval. We have a motion and a second to approve the agenda. Seeing that there's no request for discussion of the clerk please open machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes. The thing present council members have voted with the clerk please telling announced the votes. And chair motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with councilmember fix. Sanders be absent. Thank you. Open do we have any members of the public who wish to speak in open form today. There are no chair, and there are nineteens him. All right, thank you and it is passed by the one to go to our public hearings and item j one. Stand up here to speak on I'm day one with the staff. >> You swear or affirm that the evidence you're about to give will be the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth. >> The proposed ordinance number 7.82 dash an ordinance amending official zoning map of the city of St. Petersburg Florida by changing the zoning a property located at 4350 6 Street South and 5.75 45th Avenue South. From corridor commercial suburban one ccs dash one. The corridor commercial traditional dash one. The c t dash one, providing for repeal of conflicting ordinances and provisions thereof and providing an effective date. And proposed ordinance number 5.14 dash age. An ordinance approving a development agreement for property located at 4356 Street South and 5.75 45th Avenue South. Recognizing that the subject agreement is buying between sw de cocaina key llc a Delaware limited liability company developer and city of St. Petersburg Florida, a Florida municipal corporation. Authorizing the mayor is designee to execute the agreement and providing an affected date. >> We'll go to our initial presentations and the first presentation will be given by the city administration good evening. Chair before we get started. We have a new council and is in put something on the record to kind of solidifies participation in this. Hearing today. Okay, if if you would on a number So yes, thank you chair and watch the previous hearing got up to speed up been running in reading but I have all the information they need to participate. Thank you if they think you're I know that was a quick turnaround. So yes, yes, thank you, thank you. >> Britain Wilson city planner for the record presenting the second and final public hearing for an amendment to the official zoning Atlas initiated by s w de cocaina key llc with an associated development agreement for the former site of the cooking a key Plaza, which is a 14 and a half acre site located at the Northeast intersection of 6th Street South and 45th Avenue South. And the purpose of the proposed rezoning with development agreement as to allow for mixed use redevelopment of the site to consist of commercial retail uses and multifamily residential with guaranteed workforce housing. The site is home to a commercial retail shopping Plaza that was built in 1957 to accommodate approximately a 120,000 square feet of building area supported by 613 parking spaces that is almost entirely impervious without on-site stormwater retention to protect the lower lying single-family development to the east. To the north is a former rehabilitation center of Saint Pete. Followed by the dollar General store and a Lakewood elementary school to the Northwest. Directly West as a church and multifamily apartments. Directly South is a single family neighborhood and a small commercial restaurant space followed by more multifamily an single family housing with 5 a further to the east. This is a future land use map showing the subject site designated planned redevelopment mixed use or prm you which is consistent with both the existing and proposed zoning designations therefore no amendment to the future land use map is required. This is a zoning map showing the subject property is currently zoned corridor commercial suburban one for ccs one which is proposed for amendment to court or commercial traditional one for cct one. The site is mostly surrounded by suburban single-family multi-family zoning districts of nsa Nana, someone to the Northwest is neighborhood traditional zoning or into one. And corridor residential traditional our crt one zoning shown in purple. Where in 37. The north of Jason ccso property just highlighted here in yellow. Also had a traditional zoning of crt one. But was rezoned in order to accommodate a bank drive-thru however, its current retail dollar store. And this is considered an appropriate transitional area from suburban to traditional. As it is located at the intersection of 2 major streets and is adjacent to both types of zoning. And is therefore not considered spot zoning and it is compatible with the pr and you land use designation. This is the land use strategy map located in the county wide rules which the city must be consistent with where it identifies the subject property is being located on a multi-modal corridor of 6 Street South. And where the Pinellas County long range. Transportation plan identify 6 Street South has a key investment corridor. Best suited for regional conductivity of housing and employment. Which is why psta has heavily invested in trap transit route number 4 which serves the subject location with high-frequency transit a 15 minute head ways they can get a person to downtown and 20 minutes or less. So the change in development potential from quarter commercial suburban to court or commercial traditional. We'll increase allowed residential density from 15 drawing units per acre to 24. 430 unit difference. The workforce housing density bonus will remain the same at 8 units per acre allowing for an additional total of 116 units which also includes a floor area ratio bonus of 0.2. The current ccs one zoning require special exception of approval. If the residential use exceeds 40% of the overall are where the cct one does not have this requirement. Overall potential development intensity will increase from 0.5 5 affair to one point o f a r and the height will decrease from 48 feet to 42 feet. However, all property in the city that is over 2 acres you can follow the large tract plan development process. For the purpose of a large tract plan development process is to allow for an alternative development process for larger tracks of land. So that they can be used more efficiently by allowing for an increase in height of up to 150 feet in the center of the last shown here in blue. When a minimum buffer of 75 feet as on the perimeter but to shown here in yellow. We're in this buffer area. Only development that is compatible and height but the neighboring uses is allowed. So to clarify both existing in the proposed zoning designations can follow this large tracked plan development option that would allow up to 150 feet. However the current proposal will restrict the height to 77 feet to accommodate 7 stories. Which brings us to the applicant's proposed development agreement that is comprised of 32 dwelling units per acre for a potential total of 465 units where at least 20% of the total units will be dedicated to the city's workforce housing program. The combined Max, if they are for the site is 1.2 with a Max building height of 77 feet. A minimum of 20,000 square feet of commercial retail spaces to be built prior to or concurrent with the residential housing. And the development shall use commercially reasonable efforts to include a source of fresh food. And after receiving feedback from counsel at the first hearing. The da has been updated to further define commercially reasonable efforts to mean that upon initially saying and tenant turnover. But the owner shell solicitor grocer that has brick and mortar operations within 50 miles of the property. That provides fresh produce as a component of their typical operation and should provide proof of such efforts to the city. As noted in the staff report, the proposed amendment is consistent with many policies of the comprehensive plan and just to highlight these few. The proposal for there's these policies as the subject site is located on a major roadway served by high-frequency transit. And the large tract development process chauffeur provide for compatible land use transition. Also noted in the staff report as the proposals consistency with the Saint Pete 2050 plan where that sustainability and resilience calls for increasing development that is supported by high-frequency transit service so as to reduce parking demand and vehicle miles traveled. The theme of community character and growth recognizes that higher density along corridors as necessary to increase ridership and to ensure success of transit investments. And lastly the housing thing calls for all residents to have access to a wide range of quality affordable housing options within all neighborhoods. And the proposals also consistent with the county wide rules or increase density is deemed appropriate located on a multi-modal corridor with access to high-frequency transit. And the county's on range transportation plan identifies this area 6 Street South as a key investment corridor. That's why it's served by high-frequency transit. And lastly the county wide housing compact. But the city is a member of supports redevelopment of these corridors so as to promote access to regional transportation services and reduce overall cost burdens. To date staff has received 90 e mails and 3 phone calls that have expressed concerns about the proposed density the potential building height. The need to preserve the suburban character. And the loss of the grocery store that has historically been on site contributing to a food desert. We have also received 9 comments in favor of the proposal stating the need for affordable housing and the redevelopment of the site. The Saint Pete food policy council submitted a recommendation letter and staff has also met the registered opponents and reviewed the project with them. With that staff recommends approval of the proposed rezoning with associated development agreement because it furthers many of these plans by guaranteeing that at least 20% of the project be dedicated to workforce housing and a large tract of land thereby allowing for more efficient use of land and community resources. But protecting the development pattern of the surrounding hilltop community. That concludes my presentation the applicant also has a presentation and they can go over new information that you've been given regarding their rusher efforts. Next we'll see the presentation from the applicant. Good evening crunch are asking for the applicant have been sworn. >> We're here today requesting a rezoning of the kupuna key Plaza. I'm going to kind of go through some of the stuff a lot faster that in the first time the expectation the fish and sea and just to focus on some of the new information. The slu map showing the existing cs one zoning subject property. In correlation with the surroundings. This is the existing future land use we're not proposing to change the future land use is currently you. Which is a redevelopment land use category. We're proposing to rezone the cct one. This is the kind of the the intent of the district. It's the district characterized by collection of compatible and related uses that include shopping service employment residential opportunities. Somebody ought to relationship these mixed use is create a more balanced community reduces traffic consultants service delivery and benefits with the surrounding residential areas that are within walking distance. We're proposing with this redevelopment a mixed use development that is just in line with the intent to the cct will be a mix of uses between residential and nonresidential uses. The purpose of the seas to 2 district is to protect the traditional commercial character of these corridors are permitting rehab and treatment redevelopment it MAY be that encourages walkable streetscapes this is owning comparison between the existing ccs one cct proposed cct one zoning the items in red are the main differences, the allow the residential density increases from 15 to 24 units an acre. The resident residential intensity from 0.5 5 to one point with a r. And then the isr and height I noticed that the the high actually buy rate goes down for the district, however, as staff pointed out both of the zoning districts could apply the large regulations because of the size of the parcel which would allow building height to go up 250 feet and again that's for both the existing and proposed zoning districts. Use this map is an exhibit one of the we feel that this is appropriate is the this is kind of a transition area of the city between the predominantly traditional subdivisions to the north and the predominantly suburban subdivision to the self you can see the the bloc's immediately North 2 of the subject property. All have the same form of subdivision as the traditional even though that the city had decided to rezone them to a suburban category at least some of them. 2 suburban category during a a comprehensive rezoning also note that there some traditional zoning just a block. North of the property. So this would not be the only traditional zoning district in the area. 6 Street a multi-modal corridor this another justification for the the rezoning it's a corridor in the county wide plans future major Street in the comprehensive plan as high-frequency public transit through out for with 15 minute had ways. It's identified investment corridor and the advantage Pinellas plan and this contributes to land use pattern minimize travel requirements, supporting increases for Mets mass transit, which is all see the comp plan. Good kind of skip over the large track criteria that's that will come up and say planning this large tract these are Regulations would apply whether the property is rezoned or not. The conceptual plan. This is not the final site plan or are you being asked to approve a site plan today. But this just shows conceptually what is the the general intent of this redevelopment project with retail down on the southwest corner of the site and multifamily residential across the balance. The shows the use of the large tract regulations including the 75 foot buffer along the entire perimeter of the site that's almost the depth of a typical single family lot in this area. So that's significant is that a significant amount really is this block note the existing Plaza was developed before the modern stormwater regulations were put in place in almost the entire walk is impervious currently so this also would improve. Storm water management for the area. On the development agreement. Again because the large tract development regulations would apply whether this is rezoned or not this would be potentially a community for this around for that public at large and for the surrounding. Develop a residents that word going to limit the height that would otherwise be allowed to go to a 150 feet were cutting it almost in half to Max out the height of 77 feet that would accommodate approximately 7 stories. We're also creating a minimum of 20,000 square foot commercial for the site where there are currently would be no floor although under ccs one you would have to go to special exception to go under a certain amount, but there is no absolute floor currently with ccs one this would create a floor. And we have to use commercially reasonable efforts to include a source of fresh food. That was kind of a sticking point for a few of you during the last hearing so we've gone back and refined with the those efforts might be and we propose that too. The owner developer would have to provide a report on their efforts at the initial leasing in any tenant turnover and that outreach to require too to go out to ongoing brick and mortar operations within a 5550 mile radius. The site. We're also proposing a minimum 20% workforce housing on the site there's currently no minimum so that's another community benefit to increase the affordable or workforce, housing stock. The city. We put we supplement our application with a report since our last meeting that should have been circulated included in your packet. It went over that goes over that kind of the outreach that has been done to date between national grocers regional grocers local specific retailers co-ops and I'm pleased to report to that we currently do have a signed a letter of intent for a grocer for the site as of today. That potential tenant has submitted a a notice of confidentiality to the city so I cannot disclose their name or the terms. Currently in that l I but we are working to diligently to transition that ella was signed a lease. That's all I have for you with my opening thank you, yeah, the chair, redacted l o I. To comply with confidentiality was submitted on Mon. And was distributed to Council. So that's what the developer's attorney was referring to. >> Next we have our presentation by the opponent. Multiple organ. >> I was 5924 Street South and I'm PRESIDENT Of the bama shores neighborhood Association. Yeah, I'm I'm here to present. The community's opposition to rezoning as it's unjustified I also want to discuss food as a human right and saw Saint Pete's food desert. We're asking you to the stone wood development agreement and as being not being compliant with the Saint Pete 2050 vision and the city's comprehensive plan. I sent you a four-page letter outlining the detail of why they don't comply. It's part of your I hope you had an opportunity to review it. It's much more information than I can in the 10 minutes that I'm a lot of it. We'd also like you to get some work to comply with the complete neighborhoods concept which includes walkable services needed for daily. Life but first I'd like to correct the During our last and your deliberation phase members of the council and city staff misquoted my testimony and I wanted to correct the record make things straight. I never stated or suggested that the city has the authority to require any property owner or developer to build anything. This is entirely. The developers responsibility within the bounds of the zoning regulations and the city's comprehensive plan. We're asking the city to reject the development agreement and the rezoning request because the developer is asking the city for a major concession for their personal gain. And it has. No benefit at all to the to the neighborhood and you know you're not asking anything in return. So we find that to be unacceptable. We also ask that you become a more of an active partner with the developer in terms of providing significant. To get a grocery store located in this. Area it with you could provide millions of as you've done with other developments like tangerine Plaza, one. If food is a you know you've got a proclamation that you put out that food is a human right in St. Petersburg if that's the case we should put our money where our mouth is. St. Petersburg going to shows from 2.75 East and one 75 South. There are no grocery stores at all in the city. If you compare to similar zip codes, one North and one South. 3, 3, 7, oh 5 6.1 square miles and has 11,200 households. And it has a median household income of 56,900 and it has 0 grocery stores. 3, 3, 7, 1, 3, On the north side has 6.6 square miles 13,700 households. And the median household income is 58,800 comparable and there's 5 grocery stores within a within a square mile. Now we're not expecting stone way to be responsible for solving the food desert in South Saint Pete. But they closed the last grocery store and the pharmacy in South Saint Pete. To make way for this development and that contributed significantly to the food desert. So we're asking the city to become a good partner with this developer and provide some funding. So that we can get a significant grocery store and pharmacy. Now as far as the rezoning is concerned I want to go from corridor commercial suburban 2 corridor commercial traditional and according to our our development standards. They should be in further in some of the goals and objectives of the plan and found to be for the community's health safety and general welfare. Well let's put that to the test consider the goals and objectives of the plan this this rezoning serve any legitimate public purpose. I heard testimony you know it reduces miles traveled, but that's categorically wrong. It increases miles traveled everybody who goes to a grocery store or to a pharmacy. And he's a vaccine is going to get in the car get on the bus and travel is it a neighborhood center plan with all of Central services available categorically not reducing the commercials space by 80%. Reducing the services by 80%. Are we adding jobs to an economically disadvantaged area categorically not when you reduce the commercial space by 80%, you're reducing the jobs by 80%. Ok we adding additional affordable or workforce housing. No categorically not the 8 it's 8 whether it's suburban or traditional zoning. So. The comprehensive plan has taken into consideration. Taking care of these parcel protecting them and so the protection for the scum of these commercial spaces in the suburban zones for parcels over 2 acres. Our this 6040 split and as recently as 2020 the comprehensive plan recognized the critical importance of protecting these large multi-use parcels from being over developed into residential especially since we have so few in the city that by our count it's 28 and could be a few more, but that's very few and the whole purpose of city planning and zoning is is to create a balance between commercial retail and residential. And when the city is inundated by the special requests from special interest groups. Well it does chip away at the foundation of city planning. Ok c c s one with the 6040 split. They're currently available to build 15 units per acre that's 217 units with the workforce 116 brings it to 333 units that they can construct. If you give them the zoning change to cct one. There's no retail requirement at all so the 20,000 square feet is all we're going to get. The allowable construction, though is 24 units which allows them to build 348 units with the workforce housing 116 now they can build 464 units that gives the developer a benefit of an additional 131 units and minimal retail. There's nothing special about this parcel to justify rezoning cooking a key pleasant is in the middle of suburban zone, the area. It's bordered on all sides by suburban zoned neighborhoods. You can say what you want about the rezoning this one parcel is spot zoning which is illegal. Now you know during the last deliberation you ask you know the developer's attorney what he thought about spots that all this is not spot zoning. You asked the city's attorney he wasn't quite sure. The attorneys I've spoken to since the last meeting all agree that spot something. Now the developers justification for the rezoning is actually counter to the public interest. It increases miles traveled for essential services. It's not neighborhood centric. It eliminates most of the services on site that doesn't add jobs to take jobs away from this disadvantage area and it does not add any additional workforce housing, the workforce housing allotment is 8 units just as it was 8 units. Under the current zoning. So I would be really clear because of this was a big confusion and you know I understand the developer wants to say well this is a mixed area. But that's nonsense. This isn't a suburban area. The dollar General store directly to the north is sewn corridor commercial suburban the subject property is on court a commercial suburban. The the property directly to the north as neighborhood suburban multifamily the property to the West. Neighborhood suburban single-family directly to the West neighborhood suburban multifamily to the east neighborhood suburban single-family to the north neighborhood suburban single-family and to the south neighborhood suburban single-family. It's a suburban area if you re zone one little box in the middle of a suburban area. The call that spot zoning. Ok so we're asking you to reject the stone of the development agreements and and and the rezoning and send us back to city staff renegotiation we'd like to donate to comply with the Saint Pete 2050 vision and the city's comprehensive plan and I detail is and why 4 page letter that I sent you and we want the city to become a significant partner to this developer and provide incentives that will allow them to build a significant grocery store in this area. We want your the negotiated something that's reasonable and that's not 20,000 square feet that's 45,000 or 55,000 or 65,000 square feet because that's what the grocery stores want today. And lastly you know they they provided a great long list of all the people who said no well why and they said no is the rent too expensive they're not telling us what they're offering for rent is that the build-out cost overpriced we have no idea because they're not sharing that with us. They offering too little space where we know most grocery stores want more then 20,000 square feet or 10,000 square feet which is what's being offered. So we're asking you to reject it. Thank you very much for taking taking the time to listen. Next we have public comment. >> Going to call 2 names at a time when you hear your name please approach an open podium. You have 3 minister addressed City Council and please state your name and address for the record. First 2 speakers are and for an to gosh and Chauncey. >> And for on to coach. I live at 3 oh one 62nd Avenue South. And I have been sworn in. I'm reading a letter from my colleague who sent her letter to un might have re not received and received it. In my 30 years plus at Saint Pete. I've seen few opportunities for the council to implement zoning patterns which actually bring life to the city's stated vision and of food and housing policy equitable development and improved quality of life for residents. The conditions around this this opportunity. Our unique. The residents in general support to very large apartment developments proposed by stone leg along 6th Street South. The residents in fact overlook several technical points which might have been raised in up to a position such as the lack of transparency and transparency about crimes Brown's feels designations on one of the property. Dismissal of the council's own food policy advisory recommendations and lastly noncompliance with vision 2050. And the city's comprehensive plan with respect to the character of the surrounding neighborhoods. These developments are relatively large and present a spectacular chance to do something new to work with the residents and the developer to implement some of the ideals encoded in recent resolutions and initiative such as walkable neighborhoods and provision of access to core daily needs such as fresh food and pharmaceutical cities. The council could create a healthy neighborhood plan. Well generating valuable information for application to other areas, particularly other food deserts. I urge you to use this opportunity to vote no on this request for rezoning and find ways to use the influence of the city in the most productive way to eliminate a food desert. The cocaine a key Plaza in southeast St. Petersburg. Doctor Linda Lucas I also implored the council to vote no on this rezoning request. I believe Saint Pete can and should do better. There are several members in this room who led and advocated for the 2021. Saint Pete food food proclamation and believe in its underlying tenants for health and social equity. It would be appalling to win witness and approval of an unnecessary inappropriate rezoning with the development plan that is so misaligned with this city's own visions, values and intentions. For quality of life and health and social equity for our residents. Thank you for this opportunity. >> I'm an insurance 1143 75 menhaden drive Go quick because I got a lot to cover. I'm in opposition to the zoning if you take a short drive 1, 6, to shoot 6 Street South beginning of the proposed site and head to 22th Avenue South. You'll see the following the south side of the bayou passing p gardens parroted by you. Yeah that's the story or was MARCH apartments, the Avalon apartments, currently 10 looks 3 times building being built right next to a story. That's 9 condo buildings and 7, 4, blocks. All of 2 stories or less. These developers respected the neighborhood and the community. These developers are not. If this gets approved how many other apartment homes are going to be sold and converted to other 70 a 100 foot apartment buildings. So waiting for one use development developers are coming here is to put kindred Hospital and put a couple 100 foot building condos in there. It is well-known that 2 big grocery chains came here and wanted to be involved in this project, but that wasn't enough profit in there for the belt. It's so vital to the neighborhood success as So we have close access to grocery store pharmacy, other retail establishments. Now it gives a neighborhood citizens, a pizza shop in place to work, but it also gives the neighborhood since community. Senior neighbors at local grocery store the pharmacy is how we get to know our neighbors and build that neighborhood pride for all the issues we have in South start lacking a sense of community is not want. The workforce housing, the developer is offering will be the first 2 or 3 floors on the buildings with no view they can sell them for a lot of money anyway, so no matter what they believe that this doesn't get approved all of it's going to be workforce housing. You need affordable housing. The Saint Pete location is the key. If this is really about affordable housing. How many affordable houses do you think you could put on the Surrey in property on 34th Street South. Use eminent domain by that is close to us grocery stores, retail public transportation. You could put to a 300 foot buildings there and have it all work force housing affordable housing and it could be a 150 foot feet and it would fit in with the area on 34th Street. We cannot go up and this is powerful developers with the mortars and the in this pocket, the everyday citizen has to rely on elected officials to make sure you have the best interest of us at heart. You know how lousy this would look 77 feet overall the single family homes. I really hope you denied that request and if you do not I hope this is not what the Saint Pete vision of the future looks like. If so we really need all go back to the drawing board and start over. Let's get one There's a lot of small empty lots in St. Petersburg there's 6 of them right on sick you shot so workforce housing does not have to be over a 100 apartments, but you could build several smaller ones integrating them within single family home communities. I do not want South Saint Pete to turn into little Miami. This is a working man with his neighbor heard it seems every time Saint Pete need something it is the citizens of South Saint Pete that get their brought into the deal. Thank you. The speaker's fee that Richard Myers and Tommy Todd. Good evening, I'm Patricia Myers. I love it 4029 our way South. I live exactly of round 300 feet from the cocaine. The Plaza and I strongly oppose this request rezoning request. Let's be clear stone way has one goal and that's to profit off this development. It's up to you the City Council to do what's right for the city and protect its residents from greedy companies wishing to exploit its assets. Saint Pete 2050 vision specifically states local residents have input in regards to development stone which initially made a big show of meeting with us to hear what our opinions were and what we wanted and re 2. And it was strongly I 9 big us Lee favoring a grocery store and a pharmacy. These are both essential and an area with limited means and access to transportation and it's something that we have benefited from for decades. Stone we then turned around and completely ignored our input by making it impossible. But to attract a large medium to large sized grocer because of that size that they were offering under current suburban commercial zoning redevelopment should include 60% retail and 40% residential that's not what's happening. And in and it's cct one is approved who it's going to What's going on it force stoneridge to even have any retail since that that zoning does not require retail. The city comprehensive plan. States we should strongly consider surrounding zoning when making zoning changes. There are no buildings higher than 2 stories, not only on 4th and 6th streets of the last gentleman said, but I don't think even anywhere south of 34th streets are Avenue are still 34th at a street South. And I find myself asking why are we contemplating rezoning what's the point of having Rees of having zoning regulations if they can so easily without sound justification be overturned. What are the benefits to the city and its residents. The community has lost its grocery store pharmacy liquor store in laundromat and instead we have to endure increase traffic litter noise sewage waste and most certainly crime. All this to one company can enjoy or higher corporate profits by warehousing people in small much Ines boxy units we've already looking at years of construction and destruction only to be followed by a 43% increase in overall density from the 2 stone wreck properties, 43%. Since when did this city become more interest in the tax revenue and kowtowing to developers and quality of and it isn't this and maintaining its partner go ahead. Hi my name is Tommy time. I live at 6310 Mama shores drive South. I've been in the neighborhood since 1951. So I know a little bit more than most people do out here in this whole room. We had 3 grocery stores down there. We had a Publix of the shopping center. We had a neck or drugs we had all the other accessories hardware stores you name it even in you council member that school rana thank you Cokie Nikki the first time I was introduced to the stomach project and we went through all these dissertations about what kind of retail would you like is it grocery is it artistic it what it was that you know was it shopping for ladies things are where are professional where whatever. It was all about the retail side, nothing was mentioned that these people have already bought a parcel. They were developing it Lake mcgrory by what he called a trailer park and they've got 300 something units there that's going to add enough density now you're going to put 460 some units right down there what's that going to do to our traffic when I go from behind the shores of downtown. It's going to make it ridiculous driving in Petersburg today is ridiculous. The Interstate system is a clogged it feel like I'm in Tampa with all the people that we have here now every time I look around there's a new apartment building going up in Saint Pete I don't think you all are looking after the people that really live in this community and thrive here and build their businesses here raise their families here your action one thing, making developers money. And you all getting a recognition for doing something with workforce housing workforce housing, what I'm looking at my guys with make more money than that, but I can even hire anybody the last 3 years, nobody would even show up for an interview if they did they didn't come to work the next day because nobody is working in that workforce. Category to speak up. Right now they're not being attracted to this community. So I don't know what these are you going to put these workforce, people and are there really that many out there I think it's a profit motive. I think it's bad for this community. I think you need to vote this down and let them develop within the constraints that are there and put enough retail and a grocery store in that a place because we need grocery. We need to a pharmacy. We need hardware store we need services that we use in our everyday life down here in South St. Petersburg and everything has been shelved up you've got everything you need up Northeast. Saint Pete, all over the place out there 5 grocery stores out on the West Side of town. But you've just isolated us 54th Avenue South has enough. Apartment buildings on it look at that look what you did to the whole corridor Pinellas point drive look at that it started out with one or 2. We had Mahaffey do the first little thing on 54th needed a cocaine a key Carlton arms. It did one out there Lakeland like arms and now you've got all those apartment buildings when is enough enough. You are just blocking the light out of Saint Pete the change in the whole development of this community that I want to live here anymore if this keeps up I've been here all my life and I don't think I want to say that that continues in this. Last thing the last 45 years. Thank you. Next she speakers please. Next few speakers are Kathleen Michaels and Mark ruffner. Good afternoon. Thank you for your attention. There was much discussion by state your name and address for the record. I'm Kathleen Michael's of that 60 to 15. The shores drive so and I have been sworn. >> There was much discussion by several City Council members and the city attorney for the first hearing about the need for stone wake to amend the section one food in the draft amendment. It was a to include stronger language about efforts to include a grocer in the retail space. The amendments section of the draft is weaker. When the City Council voted, yes. It apparently was with 2 with the proviso that draft amendment language for more favorable would be more favorable to obtain a grocery store and so that the 9 everybody voted yes, and that's to me that seem like the idea I listen to the hearing again. The previous draft refers to fresh food. The present one refers only to fresh produce and that sounds like a produce stand or something most of those are not going to rent space to be inside a building. A line has been added which limits the search to businesses which a brick and mortar PRESIDENT's within 50 miles of stowaways an international company with their headquarters in Geneva. Certainly they don't think on a 50 mile basis. The section is limiting and less favorable than the previous draft. A stone like has not done as requested by City Council and improve this language. I asked you to vote no on their request for rezoning and should go back to the city planning Department Stowe make survivalist of grocery stores, but they only give numbers and they do not give names and they don't say exactly how these people were contacted and there's a very limited information. We did recommened Nuys winn-dixie because we know from MISTER Rios and from hearing it here. Anderson when he gets under oath that he mentioned it winn-dixie had want to sign a lease. But they weren't available until 2425, so we recognize winn-dixie in a section of winn-dixie. Which winn-dixie did not refuse on the demographics, many the other list a grocery store said they said the grocery store does not want to be here because of demographics that we know demographics can mean a lot of different things us to grocery stores Inc s p said because income was not high enough. There's a line in the winn-dixie section about construction. Cost. My question is that mean the construction costs by Winn Dixie or the cost stoic and whether this construction would be shared and so that is unclear about that. Did stoic use a marketing plan to recruit. Those 2 stores. Thank you. My name is Mark ruffner and Isleta 2, 0, 5, 56 Avenue South. Which is about a 2 minute drive from the property in question. Smell of money is during isn't it. Each of you has been elected to former pointed to represent your constituents and your neighborhood. And it should go without saying if you listen to the needs of your constituents. You will have a better sitting. I hope you do that. >> Thanks to speakers please. Next the speakers are Sandy Gonzalez and David cares. Please state your name and address for the record. >> Ma'am if you could get to the open podium please thank you. My name is doctor David their us live at 6200 bama shores drive South Saint Pete and I've been sworn in. As a medical doctor, I'm quite concerned about the health of our citizens, especially in South Saint Pete. The cdc is shown that almost 70% of a population is overweight, no peace. That percentage is slightly higher in South Saint Pete. We have a lot to population of african-americans in online Hispanics. And they unfortunately have a higher risk for health disease. And have a lower chance of getting the health, healthy food and nutrition that they need. In addition because South Saint Pete has a higher percentage of african-americans in unrelated spending x. There's less opportunity for medications that a pharmacy provides and vaccinations we also know that that population has a lower percentage of getting the necessary vaccines. As a public health as a medical concern. It is vitally important that a grocery store and a pharmacy. He was in that Mayo. That most of this neighborhood the cdc has also stated but in order to make changes in this population, certain things have to be provided. One is of course exercise. But number 2 on their list was proper food and nutrition. It has to be available. One of the recommendations that the safety food. Council recommended was contacting the 5 dollar stores in the neighborhood to see if they would provide healthy food. That is not going to happen. Foods like vegetables in produce have a very low profit margin and they're not going to provide that when they can make more money a profitable items like pass this food and even the City Council and in report of Aug. 20 21. Stated debt dollar stores do not provide healthy and nutritious food. So using that as an example of which was a recommendation from the Saint Pete food Council. His fault, it's inaccurate. The other thing that I was concerned about is the wording because in the second recommendation to safety from Council said was or that the developer should try to find within a certain reasonable time period and instead of saying is and in the writing. He's said or news that you have the Fox in the hen House meaning that the developer is going to tell us when they're going to actually find a financially Super Bowl grocery store. Totally inappropriate. >> I've my name is Sandy can solace in I live at 6 ix 9 63rd Avenue South. I've lived there for 44 years when I moved there we had Albertsons Publix winn-dixie cash and carry all the strip malls had services from little mind. Restaurants drugstores as well as good supermarkets. Now there's only one Publix on 54th Avenue South. And so we all funnel there. I'm not against housing if they're needed. However, do we want to add more people to an area that's already stressed with services. It just doesn't make sense. It makes people angry it makes for a very unhappy environment. We don't want that and I think that you need to take into consideration, does it make sense to add a lot of people when there are such little services. I don't think so thank you. Thank you. Next to Art Mary Jo verus and marks Spencer. Please state your name and address for the record. Okay. My name is Mary Joe Veras I live at 6200 Bahamas shores. And I have been in Saint Pete for 36 years and raise my family there and as time Todd said a lot of the civil lived in the community. When we did have pharmacies restaurants. Grocery stores, all the services that we need it. Now they're gone. I feel to responsibility. As elected City Council members that you need to put public health is number one. A dietician and I have a Masters in public health. And I want to speak for the people in 3, 3, 7, oh 5 that maybe have hypertension maybe on kidney dialysis diabetes. These are all health issues that you have to have fresh food, healthy food, and for those residents who lack transportation. It's not easy to maintain those diets is prescribed by their doctors and dietitians it's your responsibility as members of City Council to be thinking about the public health of every resident and 3, 3, 7, oh 5. And we are not getting what we need for our health. Thank you. We have not seen that visual or to be approved. >> But as Mark Spencer Oliver 3494 cocaine, a key drive South about a half mile from the proposed development at a post this on a change. Most of my objective to be covered so I'll be brief. First I want to I want to thank the Council for their student marks after the last year. I was really impressed. There's a simplistic view of a suburban development as just a collection of single-family houses and like every other the human community. It's an organic system. There has to be water. There has to be sewage. There has to be waste disposable waste disposal ways to get in and out and has to be access to food. If you take away one of those critical components then you're going to you're going to kill the community. You just are. This grocery store. The last one in this area is is vital to the community. I'd also like to point out in this up photo here this picture, this is a sketch. The land development regulations which shows what acct development is supposed to look like that doesn't work anything like The developer is proposing to me. We're going to take away this grocery store. Just so they can put in more profitable rental housing rather than less profitable. A commercial housing and that wrong Lessing I'd like to say is on the transportation front. 6 Street isn't supposedly designated as a multiple multi-modal corridor multi-modal means more than just a bus. I hope strongly consider putting in some serious separated bicycle lanes I think that that is going to be critical to moving The short distances that they need to move in that part of city. Thank you. >> Next to speakers on please state your name and address for the record Andrew 5 code in and Murray for 5 co. >> Thank you. Anne Marie 5 coats 3 residents within a mile of this proposed redevelopment 4 4343 we need to weigh South is the one all say and he will indicate the other 2. Yeah, you just ate your address. But 4343 we need way South. I'm putting up cirque's from city policy on health says a healthy Saint Pete program. The proclamation vision, 2050 and comprehensive comprehensive plan I will use the word whereas only once. Guarantee access and availability of nutritious food for human health and well-being. Very foundation of human rights. Well, couple food source and than a mile of every resident definition of complete neighborhoods vision 2050 plan page 56, safe and convenient walkable access as I mentioned and of goods and services needed in daily life, public policies that create supportive environment enabling people to lead healthy lives, diversity equity and inclusion the importance of taking advantage of economic economic opportunities. And another paragraph economic forces have driven grocery stores at many Aber hoods and people's food choices are severely limited this is coming from you all stuff. So the city is doing exactly all of these things to facilitate workforce, housing and right ability of your bus line. All while compromising these very declarations the city of reports removing grocery and pharmacy will increase. With an 80% production retail commercial space to commence or 80% of reduction in jobs is irrefutable. The city supporting an affirming the developers initiatives is absolutely contrary to all the principals proclamations and visions vision twenty-twenty there 2050 plans already in place as courtside additional Council should not approve this because. They really want their housing in their and their transportation and initiatives. This is not what they're allegedly said that what they are legally supposed to be doing this pest be voting on whether the applicant proved their case as to city consistency compliance and conformity with the vision plans that you have already adopted. It is coming up on the developer to show Hughes chief these goals in the reasoning with support and enhance the goals of the city for them to sit for you guys to support and that's approved rezoning which they have not done. The applicant did not prove that the rezoning is consistent with the comprehensive plan nor did the city provide any competent evidence evidence to show that it is in the public interest are consistent with the plan either the rezoning simply does not serve a legitimate public purpose as such I don't feel that you can approve this rezoning we'll keep reading so still have some time. Vision twenty-twenty planet case complete neighborhoods where residents that I got through it I need to thank you. >> Que. My my name is Andrew 5 code I live at 4, 6, 6, 3, netting drive Southeast. We also have a home 3811 Neptune drive Southeast. And the other home on Juanita way. I want to reiterate, you know support what everybody here has been saying losing a grocery store losing. The only pharmacy in that area is a real detriment everybody. And even going further we heard comments about you know the small groceries, the small little places that might go in. We just have the storm come through. In all of the small little family dollar they lost all the food in their freezers. So now what do they have. Yeah cans of soup and people without power. Publix those type stores. They're bigger. They've got generators to protect them. They've also got the ability to get the food back out to the stores if they do have an issue that leaves family dollar doesn't have that high distribution. They were without food for probably close to 2 weeks before they started getting their freezers restart. So you can't have people try and use those as groceries food items it just doesn't work you've got to have a major grocer the other thing is that shut down. They soon as the evacuation orders go into effect the close. Your larger chains, stay open longer, they know they've got people that are coming in for water trying to stock their house before the storms. So it's very important to have those type systems in place. The other thing that was talked about 150 foot building. It's not feasible. When you go from 7 stories 250 feet you have more than doubled the price of that building. So that's not going to be done. We know this whole thing is economics it's what makes sense. 150 foot building will never make sense there. For 300 units or 400 units, they can't get the price war. So that being something that gets thrown back at us. That's not an issue and it's not something that they would never build. They're going to be reasonable as far as what they can build because it's got to be profitable. Your workforce housing they keep saying 20% for workhorse workforce will if we keep it at that can current zoning it's over 35%. Let's keep it at the current zoning. See what we can work with I'll give him credit that you know we just found out they've got why from a grocer we have no clue, what it is what size it is whether it's a national whether it's a the mom and pop. >> Next to speakers please state your name and address for the record. And Robin go down. >> Hello my name is one of the time and I live at 4675 Neptune drive Southeast. And I have been sworn in. Iowa polls, the approval of the zoning amendment and many arguments have been brought forth for why that should not be improved. I think that we still have not a good enough for the ball with the food solution we're talking and so cause and nothing substantial has been voiced. So we on the dock. A lot is being said about workforce housing which is a good thing. And I'm not against it. But with the approval of the amendment. All we do is we give the additional units at market rates. But the number of workforce, housing units remains the same. Seoul, the only one who gains in this zoning amendment is the development. We also have to the infrastructure of the area. The developer was in the process of putting in several hundreds of units. Down the street and they will be adding maybe 3, 400 units at cookie, no key. How is that being supported. Water and electricity. It will all put a huge strain on the systems. Nobody has mentioned that as yet seems to be accepted. The only concern seems to be to get this development going and the navel oranges the population the residents often able it's I'm being forced to swallow it because it seems to be a foregone conclusion by the council to approve this zoning amendment requests regardless of what we are seeing as the citizens of the area. Thank you. >> Hi my name is del I live at 7, 5, 7, 34th Avenue South. It's about a half mile north of the site. I don't want to. It when everybody has said I will say that when the grocery store was open. It was common for me to see people walking down my Street going to the grocery store and carrying back bags of groceries and that's a half a mile least a half a mile each way. And who knows where they're getting their groceries from now. And as I remind did that. When these developers bought the property. These things you know the grocery store the. Drugstore the laundry mat we're all functioning. They know they knew what the zoning was. And I don't really understand. What the appeal to us as a city is for changing the zoning. Thank you. >> That's 2 speakers please state your name and address for the record. Matt Johnson and Jordan Braun. Jordan brown hair. MISTER Johnson is. Haha Matt Johnson indicated he's against. But it was Jordan. Brown. I met a 3 to one 60th Avenue southbound behind the shores. I've been sworn in and I would like to state for the record that I do oppose the. Change that's been requested by the developer here. I don't have a lot to add. I think of a lot of my neighbors have come up with some excellent ideas for you to dwell on as far as the things that we really don't like going on down there. We really need groceries we really need pharmacy in our neighborhood. I personally don't think we need a lot of extra people. If there's anything that can be done for affordable housing. I'm all for it. A lot of people have been talking about the fact that our neighbors have to leave because they can't afford rent any more. I think that's very sad. I think anything you all can do to try and help that would be wonderful. Really I don't think we need tall buildings down and our beautiful suburban area down there in the South side. >> Next to speakers. R j as Dick in Renee Kohn Siri please state your name address for the record. Jay has that indicated he was against. >> We MAY consider re 4, 9, oh 8 sunrise drive South. This is a quasi judicial hearing where the only relative criteria is whether the applicant who said the rezoning can see is consistent with existing laws. Not because you're like the project. The applicant has not met this week a threshold, the only thing the proposed development chief says the substitution of market rent apartments in the retail commercial space does this serve achievement per public purpose now there's nothing in the comprehensive plan favoring market rate housing and commercial space in fact the opposite is true for parcels over 5 acres which are singled out for protection and the comprehensive plan. Well so fruitful housing cannot be used a reason for approval. Because both the existing and the new zoning applies for the same exact units per acre. The applicant's reasons freeze rezoning they say cct is needed to keep the development consisting of the traditional neighborhood and second to reduced miles traveled to work. But first the property is not in nt and they're not even using the design criteria 17th and not using the cct standards. They're using the track development scheme there for the primary reason that African states this to the rezoning is some is making irrelevant because they're not following the same kind of characteristics to keep it consistent with the traditional. The main difference of the large get developments came under cct versus ecs is the requirement of 6040 split of commercial to residential. Now I know where has either the applicant or the city defended or explained how eliminating this is essential characteristic is either in the public interest are consistent with the comprehensive plan. Our current current city ordinance because this is not the second reason the applicant stated was to reduce mass travel but neighboring residents will have to travel for the to do the shopping new residents will have to travel for the 2 were can start a few local jobs and most jobs are located north of the city there for an smiles traveled not reducing. Also every large parcel in the city regardless of which neighborhood. He's also designated ccs and changing the zoning this parcel will mean that every single one of those parcels will be eligible for the same treatment on this basis of nondiscrimination is that what you want I mean then what's the point of his own ing it then you

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 848cbaf62758cbfa94f3ace7b8836a7f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record