POLISCOPE

The public record

BREVARD COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Brevard County Board of County Commissioners

Tuesday, August 6, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Florida Department of Transportation Resolution for the Previously Approved Joint Participation Agreement for cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project (District 2).

The Brevard County Board of County Commissioners approved several infrastructure and environmental projects, including a contract assignment for engineering services, modifications to the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project, and a land-use agreement involving the Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier. Public comment raised concerns regarding the cost-effectiveness and environmental implications of the muck removal strategy and the logistics of beach sand re-nourishment projects.

Why it matters

Residents should care because these decisions impact local tax-funded environmental projects, public access to beaches, and the long-term management of storm sewage and water quality in the Indian River Lagoon.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

22

Recorded outcomes

22

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

22 captured items have a publicly linked outcome. These 5 are the clearest resident summaries in the record.

Search all 22 meeting actions
  • Item F.4.

    Florida Department of Transportation Resolution for the Previously Approved Joint Participation Agreement for cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project (District 2).

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 24-070, for the previously approved Joint Participation Agreement with FDOT for the cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project.
  • Item F.5.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Landings at Viera Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC District 4

    Moved by John Tobia · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the Final Plat and Infrastructure Contract for Landings at Viera - Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC, subject to minor changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.
  • Item F.6.

    Permission to advertise for the repeal of Ordinance 89-29 - State Road 46 Water Extension #1 (District 1).

    Moved by John Tobia · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board granted permission for the Utility Services Director to advertise for the repeal of Brevard County Ordinance No. 89-29 – State Road 46 Water Extension #1.
  • Item F.7.

    Approval, HUD Urban County Agreements and Requalification for FY 2025, 2026, and 2027

    Moved by John Tobia · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board approved the Urban County Agreement Re-Qualification with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to receive Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME funds; approved the continuance of Cooperative Agreements with seven municipalities consisting of Cocoa Beach, Indialantic, Indian Harbour Beach, Melbourne Village, Palm Shores, Rockledge, and Satellite Beach for Fiscal Years 2025, 2026, and 2027; authorized the County Attorney to send the mandatory letter to HUD; and authorized the Housing and Human Services Director to transmit the renewed Agreements and any supporting documents to HUD.
  • Item F.8.

    Approval, Re: Budget Change Request

    Moved by John Tobia · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board reviewed and approved the Budget Change Request (BCR).

Recorded votes

9 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (9)
passed

Assignment Agreement Change - Singhofen to Halff

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Pritchettyes
Goodsonyes
Tobiayes
Feltneryes
Steeleyes
passed

Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Pritchettyes
Goodsonyes
Tobiayes
Feltneryes
Steeleyes
passed

FDOT Resolution for Sykes Creek Septic-to-Sewer

passed

Final Plat and Contract - Landings at Viera

passed

Westgate Agreement (Cocoa Beach Pier)

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Pritchettyes
Goodsonyes
Tobiayes
Feltneryes
Steeleyes

Money

People and votes

Rita Pritchett

County Commissioner

Open person dossier

13 seconds · 3 motions · 3 recorded votes

  1. SecondItem F.2.

    Scope of Work and Budget Allocation for the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  2. SecondItem F.4.

    Florida Department of Transportation Resolution for the Previously Approved Joint Participation Agreement for cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project (District 2). - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  3. SecondItem F.5.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Landings at Viera Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC District 4 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  4. SecondItem F.6.

    Permission to advertise for the repeal of Ordinance 89-29 - State Road 46 Water Extension #1 (District 1). - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  5. SecondItem F.7.

    Approval, HUD Urban County Agreements and Requalification for FY 2025, 2026, and 2027 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  6. SecondItem F.8.

    Approval, Re: Budget Change Request - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  7. SecondItem F.9.

    Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  8. SecondItem F.10.

    Bill Folder - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  9. SecondItem H.2.

    Approval of Revisions to Ordinance No. 98-37, also known as Chapter 2, Article VII of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled “Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings.” - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  10. MotionItem J.1.

    Approval, Re: Contract with Keep Brevard Beautiful for SR 406 Max Brewer Causeway, SR 528 Beachline Causeway, SR518 Eau Gallie Causeway, HWY 192 Melbourne Causeway, and SR 404 Pineda Causeway Clean Up - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  11. MotionItem J.2.

    Approval, Re: Contract with City of Cocoa Beach for Keep Brevard Beautiful Beach and SR520 Causeway Clean-up - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  12. SecondItem J.3.

    Proposed Amendment to the Brevard County Home Rule Charter to Align the School Board Member Residence Areas with the County Commission Districts - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  13. SecondItem L.5.

    John Tobia, Commissioner District 3 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  14. MotionItem J.5.

    Approval for Partial Funding of Phase 2 Study for Port St. John Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant. - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  15. SecondItem F.1.

    Assignment Agreement Change Approval, Re: Singhofen & Associates, Inc. to Halff Associates, Inc. (continued) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  16. SecondItem F.3.

    Approval, Re: Westgate Agreement Between Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier, LLC, the City of Cocoa Beach, and Brevard County, Florida (continued) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  17. Recorded vote

    Assignment Agreement Change - Singhofen to Halff - Voted yes on the motion “Approve and execute Assignment of Agreement for Engineering Consultant Services from Singhofen and Associates, Inc. to Halff Associates, Inc.”; the record reports passed.

  18. Recorded vote

    Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project - Voted yes on the motion “Approve amending scope of work to focus on high nutrient flux areas and authorize staff to negotiate change orders for additional removal/treatment.”; the record reports passed.

  19. Recorded vote

    Westgate Agreement (Cocoa Beach Pier) - Voted yes on the motion “Authorize Chair to execute agreement between Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier, LLC, City of Cocoa Beach, and Brevard County.”; the record reports passed.

See all 9 roll calls with named votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 79,342 characters. The full document is at the source.

Tuesday, August 6, 2024 5:00 PM Brevard County Board of County Commissioners 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way Viera, FL 32940 Commission Chambers Minutes Regular August 6, 2024 A. CALL TO ORDER 5:00 PM Commissioner District 1 Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 2 Tom Goodson, Commissioner District 3 John Tobia, Commissioner District 4 Rob Feltner, and Commissioner District 5 Jason Steele Present: C. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Commissioner Tobia led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance. F.1. Assignment Agreement Change Approval - Singhofen & Associates, Inc. to Halff Associates, Inc. Sandra Sullivan stated she is very grateful for the work that this company has done; she understands that they are being acquired, so it is great that the County is amending this contract; she would like to point out some of their very good work; she provided the Board with a document showing the company’s 10-year flood plan for North Merritt Island; and as the County looks to the work and storm sewage on that, it needs to pay attention to what is in their hydrology study that the County spend a half a million dollars, and actually used these reports, instead of just all growth and not paying attention to the implications of growth in those areas. F.2. Scope of Work and Budget Allocation for the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project Sandra Sullivan commented that this gives her so much heartburn; this is regarding the Eau Gallie Muck Project and changing the specification work; this was a $26 million project that was for 750,000 cubic yards of muck; the quote came in for half of that amount, almost $50 million; the issue here is, rather than fixing what is causing this problem, the County is pumping muck 8.1 miles down to Palm Bay; that is what is causing the ridiculous price, so instead the County is going to play games; it is going to reduce the amount of muck they are going to pump to 250,000 cubic yards; and it is going to remove the interstitial cleanup, so the cleaning up of the nutrient loading that goes back into the Lagoon, is going to be taken out. She continued by saying oh, but wait, it says the County will do a change order later and add it back in again; all it is, is manipulating numbers to make something look good that is not good; this project needs to be changed to reflect the overall problem, which is the County is pumping muck 8.1 miles because it wants to give Sarno to a city, the Sarno land that has historically been the place the County has put that muck; it is not just this one project, she is talking over $100 million just for this found; and future costs will be hundreds of millions of dollars, because there are a lot more projects in this vicinity. She pointed out the optics of this is not good at all. F.3. Westgate Agreement Between Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier, LLC, the City of Cocoa Beach, and Brevard County Florida Sandra Sullivan advised what this County does for the developers, the backflips it does drives her absolutely nuts; she asked the Commissioners if he or she had seen the news about Westgate laying off about 300 people, or whatever; they are not doing so good; she provided the Board with some pictures of South Patrick Residents Association (SPRA) Park; she stated this is for the sand re-nourishment project that they just had; and she asked if the Board can see how wide those projects are, as they are not 20 feet wide. She went on by saying previous the County had a 40-foot width or 50-foot width to be able to access to put sand in that area; of course, Cocoa Beach is a major tourist location; this has been priority for sand for the County; she asked if the Board knows that under its sand re-nourishment permits with the Federal Government that these trucks cannot stay on the beach at night; she noted they have to come up; and she asked where the County is going to put them. She asked if the County is going to narrow that to a little, narrow pathway, where are the trucks going to be put; have the Page 1 of 24 August 6, 2024 Commissioners really thought this out; and she remarked she did not think so. Commissioner Goodson asked what kind of trucks Ms. Sullivan is talking about. Ms. Sullivan replied they had four articulating, big sand trucks; and they had diggers to put the sand . . . Commissioner Goodson advised those are excavators. Ms. Sullivan stated yeah, okay. Commissioner Goodson asked if Ms. Sullivan had ever seen an excavator go down the road. Ms. Sullivan replied yes, they go on a flatbed. Commissioner Goodson commented correct, and the road is 12-foot wide, the excavator’s eight, transports are eight, off-road trucks are eight; and he asked if there is a 20-foot easement, where is this going to restrict the County from getting in there. Ms. Sullivan remarked it is not restricting them getting in there, it is how they are stored when they come off of the beach at night. Commissioner Goodson pointed out they would not bring an excavator off of the beach at night, they are pulled up on the dunes for it to be there the next day; and off-road trucks are the same way. Ms. Sullivan noted except one has to have room to put them; and she asked if they will be put in line down a row. Commissioner Goodson stated they would be put down the beach in a line. Ms. Sullivan mentioned it is just common sense. Commissioner Goodson exclaimed common sense is one does not move that equipment every night. Ms. Sullivan advised the County’s Federal permit requires it. F.1. Assignment Agreement Change Approval, Re: Singhofen & Associates, Inc. to Halff Associates, Inc. (continued) The Board approved and executed an Assignment of Agreement for Engineering Consultant Services from Singhofen and Associates, Inc. to Halff Associates, Inc. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele F.2. Scope of Work and Budget Allocation, Re: Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project (continued) The Board approved amending the scope of work for the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project to focus on removing muck from areas with the highest nutrient flux, using Save Our Indian River Lagoon (SOIRL) Trust Funds allocated for both muck removal and interstitial Page 2 of 24 August 6, 2024 treatment to bid dredging without interstitial treatment; authorized staff to negotiate and the County Manager to execute change orders to removal more muck and/or add interstitial treatment to the contract if the negotiated cost is reasonable and sufficient funds are available or become available; and extended the same flexibility and approach to all muck removal projects approved in the SOIRL Project Plan, as necessary, so projects can move forward within their allocated budgets. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele F.3. Approval, Re: Westgate Agreement Between Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier, LLC, the City of Cocoa Beach, and Brevard County, Florida (continued) The Board authorized the Chair to execute the Westgate Agreement between Westgate Cocoa Beach Pier, LLC, the City of Cocoa Beach, and Brevard County to facilitate the City Council’s desire to vacate a portion of Meade Avenue, while at the same time preserving public access, construction access, and other rights essential to the Brevard County Shore Protection Project, subject to final approval by the County Attorney’s Office. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele F.4. Florida Department of Transportation Resolution for the Previously Approved Joint Participation Agreement for cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project (District 2). The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 24-070, for the previously approved Joint Participation Agreement with FDOT for the cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.5. Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Landings at Viera Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC District 4 The Board granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the Final Plat and Infrastructure Contract for Landings at Viera - Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC, subject to minor changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.6. Permission to advertise for the repeal of Ordinance 89-29 - State Road 46 Water Extension #1 (District 1). The Board granted permission for the Utility Services Director to advertise for the repeal of Brevard County Ordinance No. 89-29 – State Road 46 Water Extension #1. Page 3 of 24 August 6, 2024 Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.7. Approval, HUD Urban County Agreements and Requalification for FY 2025, 2026, and 2027 The Board approved the Urban County Agreement Re-Qualification with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to receive Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME funds; approved the continuance of Cooperative Agreements with seven municipalities consisting of Cocoa Beach, Indialantic, Indian Harbour Beach, Melbourne Village, Palm Shores, Rockledge, and Satellite Beach for Fiscal Years 2025, 2026, and 2027; authorized the County Attorney to send the mandatory letter to HUD; and authorized the Housing and Human Services Director to transmit the renewed Agreements and any supporting documents to HUD. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.8. Approval, Re: Budget Change Request The Board reviewed and approved the Budget Change Request (BCR). Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.9. Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s) The Board appointed/reappointed Donald Lusk to the Brevard County Library System Advisory Board, with term expiring December 31, 2025; Josiah Gattle to the Economic Development Commissioner of Florida’s Space Coast, with term expiring December 31, 2024; Stacy Landon to the Historical Commission, with term expiring December 31, 2025; Melissa Jackson, as alternate, to the Planning and Zoning Board, with term expiring December 31, 2026; Ana Saunders, and Robert Wise, as alternate, to the Planning and Zoning Board, with terms December 31, 2025; and Jessica Curry and Warren Bradford Whitmore, Jr. to the Titusville-Cocoa Airport Authority, with terms expiring August 6, 2027. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.10. Bill Folder The Board acknowledged receipt of the Bill Folder. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett G. PUBLIC COMMENTS (Individuals may not speak under both the first and second public comment sections.) Louie Hanna stated he has lived on East Crisafulli Road for 28 years, retired after 30 years at the Space Center, he is an Army veteran, and he has a problem with the speed bumps on East Crisafulli Road; they heard about these soon to be installed speed bumps just a couple of Page 4 of 24 August 6, 2024 weeks before they were to be installed; it was a done deal, they were coming, and to deal with it; and it kind of felt like the residents were not supposed to know about it beforehand, or until it was too late to do anything about it. He went on to say upon inquiring about why no one knew about the speed humps prior, he was told that the only ones affected were the ones who voted for it, the address is within the first one-half mile from Courtenay to Judson; the residents east of Judson to the end of East Crisafulli and all of the connecting streets were unaffected; because they were unaffected, not one person east of Judson, on Crisafulli, or tributaries had a vote or any say in the matter at all; they were just going to be put in and that was it; this is his home being talked about here; his Commissioner, Mr. Goodson, old him they could use Judson Road, thereby eliminating the necessity to drive over the speed bumps all together; Judson is a dirt road; in the dry season, it is a dusty as a washboard road; and in the wet season, it is a mud road. He noted if the residents wanted to traverse a dirt road on a daily basis, they could have bought cheaper property on a dirt road; to his way of thinking, when something is arbitrarily taken away, what is offered in return should be equal to or better than what they lost; he asked the County to pave Judson; he asked why punish everyone for the sins of the few; he remarked to catch the guys who are speeding, and put cops out there; the name on a document authorizing the installation of speed bumps is the same name that appeared on at least one of the company trucks on the job site the day of installation; he asked who provided the asphalt; and is this a conflict of interest. He pointed out at the very least, it is what is called bad optics in today’s world; the resident who initiated this process was overheard boasting at the local convenience store about how he had gotten traffic slowed down on East Crisafulli, that he had pulled some strings of the buddy at the County to get speed bumps installed; but he was unable to get them installed past Judson; he thought his County Commissioner’s job was to help the citizenry he represents to make life better; this is not better; this is insulting and divisive; East Crisafulli Road has been his home for over 28 years; do not tell him he is unaffected; and they are all affected. Commissioner Goodson advised this was voted on with former Commissioner Lober; in the County Code, and the County Manager can correct him if he is wrong, it says 85 percent right now that front the property where the speed bumps go; and he asked if that is correct. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, responded there is a BCC that covers that; they sent out the petition; and it met the threshold. Commissioner Goodson asked if it is true that the people that are voting right now, unless the Ordinance is changed, if it is the people who front Crisafull Road. Mr. Bernath replied correct. Commissioner Goodson asked not the people that live a block off or a mile off on another street, correct. Mr. Bernath responded that is correct. Commissioner Goodson asked if these were approved by former Commissioner Lober, correct. Mr. Bernath responded he does not know offhand; and he was not prepared to answer that tonight. Commissioner Goodson inquired therefore, if the County is going to allow Mr. Hanna here, the Code would have to be changed, correct. Mr. Bernath replied it is a BCC, it is not a Code. Page 5 of 24 August 6, 2024 Commissioner Goodson asked what a BCC is. Mr. Bernath advised it is a Board Policy. Commissioner Goodson asked if the Board would have to change it. Mr. Bernath responded affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson stated if he is not mistaken, the people east of Mr. Hanna voted to . . . Mr. Hanna noted no, they did not. Commissioner Goodson stated that Mr. Hanna say they did not; but he was under the impression they voted to for when they pave the road they want speed humps; Mr. Hanna is saying no; and he is going to agree with all of them. Terrence White commented he lives on Joseph Court, which is a road off of Crisafulli; Mr. Hanna covered a lot of the points he has; but in doing some research, a lot of the problems with speed humps that people have not even discussed; they slow down the response of emergency vehicles; being a former fire fighter, he knows what it is like to go over bumps in a big fire truck; and it also includes transporting someone in an ambulance after the fact, as the ambulance cannot leave the area in a hurry because of the humps. He went on to say one of the things that he witnessed for years in areas that do have speed humps is when a school bus goes over there, the children in the backseat gets launched almost to the ceiling of the school bus; he asked the Board Members to follow a school bus in a neighborhood that has speed humps; along with Mr. Hanna, no one, east of Judson, was questioned about the speed humps; he did not find out about them until he drove down the road and they were in the process of installing them; and it causes excess wear on the vehicles. He added one of the issues he sees as well is people down there have livestock, horses, goats, and cattle; they play heck going over those bumps with animals in their trailers; a lot of animals are spooked in a trailer anyway; and it also plays on the suspension of the trailers. He stated while he is up here he would like to request that the speed humps on Joseph Court to be removed; there are 15 residents on that street; 14 of them told him that they want them removed; in doing research on the ones on Crisafulli, he found a thing that says speed humps cannot be installed on a dead-end road; and Joseph Court is a dead-end road. Robert Adams mentioned he has lived on Crisafulli Road for 40 years; he is here to make a citizens request, which he was told to do, for a petition to remove the speed humps; whatever that package is, that is what they are trying to get a hold of, which is why they are here speaking; five speed humps have been installed in less than one-half a mile, from Courtenay to Judson; and Crisafulli Road is only two miles long with a bunch of other roads on it. He continued by saying according to County Policy, the benefited and affected areas are the ones that are supposed to be checked out before putting speed bumps in; everyone on that road uses Crisafuli every single day; every time he leaves his house twice, he goes over 20 speed bumps; he would love the Commission to put 20 speed bumps around his or her house and see how much it is enjoyed; other than that, they were told by Commissioner Goodson to drive down Judson; that is not what he moved out there for 40 years ago; he moved out there to get away from Homeowners Associations (HOAs); and they finally found him. He advised he does not appreciate the detrimental effects, or whatever one wants to say; he inquired when it comes to the logistics of it, how many of the affected homeowners signed off on a petition to use their tax money to put in those speed bumps; he pointed out he did not; he has never been asked in Page 6 of 24 August 6, 2024 40 years whether or not he wanted speed bumps; the detrimental effects is the community is torn apart; they used to be friendly people and wave at each other, and people stopped and looked at each other’s Christmas lights; now they flip one off every time he or she goes by the house on the corner; and it is not too hard to figure out that it is not really much of a bring it together package. He noted property values are impacted, school buses, and damage to his cars; he is not taking his trailers with a thousand dollars’ worth of equipment over five speed humps just to leave his home every day; it is not the way to do business; he asked why were the unnotified homeowners possibly have to use their personal funds to remove those speed bumps, which is in the County’s package deal; and he asked the Commissioners want to drive over five speed bumps every time he or she leaves their home; and he stated that is five in and five out. Commissioner Goodson asked if he wants to remove the speed bumps, and he ran a survey of all of the people who live on Crisafulli and off of Crisafulli, would he agree if they voted for speed humps. Mr. Adams replied no; he has a hundred and some odd signatures here . . . Commissioner Goodson stated to hang on and let him finish the question, because the first people who voted that lived on Crisafulli, only one said no; and everybody else said speed bumps. Mr. Adams remarked fine. Commissioner Goodson asked if he ran a survey and everybody that lived off and on Crisafulli said they wanted or did not want speed humps would Mr. Adams agree with the vote at the end. Mr. Adams replied yes, very much so, as that is logical. Alan Miles asked why is there no urgency to put a traffic light at the intersection between Viera High School and the new middle school; he stated there are veterans leaving the Veterans Clinic, seniors from Sonata East, and a wet surface from the car wash; there are high school students making u-turns, golf carts, and walkers all diverging on this intersection; it is slated for a light beginning the 2025 school year he believes; and if safety is the main concern of the Commission, then get a light. He advised temporary ones in the Palm Bay Heritage High School are being installed; he has some information on this system; and he asked if anyone knows what is going on with the traffic lights there. Chair Steele explained the Public Comment section is for him to go ahead and give the Board his comments; and it is not a question and answer situation. Commissioner Feltner noted out of respect for his constituent, he would like Mr. Bernath speak to the light project that is happening out there; and he knows there have been many conversations with the schools about it. Mr. Bernath stated the School District is actively designing this light; staff is contributing to it; he does not have the actual design schedule at his disposal; but they are planning on putting it in sometime later this year; staff anticipates by the end of the year, he would say, to have that put in; and he reiterated it is something the County would anticipate them doing later on this year. Mr. Miles pointed out it still does not meet the safety qualification of being installed before the Page 7 of 24 August 6, 2024 school year. Chair Steele advised the Board is not going to get into a question and answer service; Commissioner Feltner asked Mr. Bernath for a response; and he gave it to Mr. Miles. Commissioner Feltner stated everyone is actively working on it, and also by Viera Elementary, which is something he inherited; and he has been working on that since he got on the Commission. H.1. Petition to Vacate, Re: Public Utility & Drainage Easements - 466 Newfound Harbor Drive - “Revised Gateway Unit No. 2” Plat Book 19, Page 112 - Merritt Island - Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien - District 2 Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a petition to vacate public utility and drainage easements located in Revised Gateway Unit No. 2, Merritt Island, as petitioned by Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien. Richard Bitner stated this thing is absolutely a monstrosity; he provided pictures to the Board showing the scope and size of this; he explained as the Board can see, that is him standing along in that structure; it is huge; it is almost as big as the house; that is a side view; there are safety issues on this as well; and the Board can see where the roof is collapsing. He advised there is no privacy; he provided a picture to the Board of when they are standing on their deck, what they look at; he noted he wants privacy in his yard; every single time they step on their thing, that is what he has to look at; it is just too big; and it is the size of their house. He pointed out it does not pass zoning; they have already said it is against Policy; here they are wasting their time when it should have been torn down a year ago; they have been at this for a year; and he reiterated he just wants his privacy. He stated they are up there two feet, he has to look at two feet of their bodies every time they step on top of that structure; the thing is like 50 feet long; it is terrible; it is just too big; it needs to come down or be modified; but it is not fun going out into his yard to swim, and he has to look at them. Commissioner Goodson asked how long Mr. Bitner has lived there. Mr. Bitner replied five years. Commissioner Goodson asked if this undoubtedly been a problem for only the last year. Mr. Bitner responded there have been other issues; but the subject is on this structure; they have gone to court; they had a privacy fence that was eight feet tall that was removed; it was on his property; they had it removed and put a new six-foot fence, the white fence the Board saw, they put it on their property, so they took away two feet of their privacy; and they tried talking to them, but it was their way and only their way. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, stated it is a public petition to vacate two public utility and drainage easements to allow for the existing covered deck to remain and become compliant with the Code Enforcement case; the petitioner is requesting for five foot vacate on both the north and west size; and that is at the discretion of the Board to honor that or not; and if so, then the petitioner would then go before the Board of Adjustment to seek a variance. Chair Steele asked if this is Commissioner Goodson’s District; and he asked if he would like to make a recommendation. Commissioner Goodson replied he would like to make a motion to approve. Page 8 of 24 August 6, 2024 There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-XXX, vacating public utility and drainage easements located in Revised Gateway Unit No. 2 in Merritt Island, as requested by Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Tom Goodson Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.2. Approval of Revisions to Ordinance No. 98-37, also known as Chapter 2, Article VII of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled “Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings.” Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider revisions to Ordinance 98-37, also known as chapter 2, Article VII, Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings. Kathy Wall, Central Services Director, stated it is requested that the Board approve the revisions to Chapter 2, Article VII, of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, Construction and Improvement to Public Buildings. Chair Steele stated he listened to this during briefings, and he was extremely pleased with this. There being no comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-18, amending Chapter 2, Article VII of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled “Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings”; amending Section 2-226, Brevard County Code, entitled “Definitions”, to define certain terms; amendment Section 2-227, Brevard County Code, entitled “Award of Contracts Generally”, to increase the minimum dollar threshold of certain public projects from $50,000 to $200,000; amending Section 2-228, Brevard County Code, entitled “Prequalification and Competitive Bidding”; amending Section 2-229, Brevard County Code, entitled “Qualifications of Bidders”; amending Section 2-230 entitled, “Debarment”; providing for inclusion in the Code; providing for conflicting provisions; providing for severability; and providing for an effective date. Result: ADOPTED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.3. Approval of Revisions to Board Policy BCC-28, “Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award.” Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider revisions to Board Policy BCC-28, Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award. Kathy Wall, Central Services Director, commented this requires the acceptance of public comment on the revisions to the Board Policy BCC-28, Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award. There being no comments or objections, the Board accepted public comment on the revisions to Board Policy BCC-28; and approved the revisions to BCC-28, Pre-qualification of Page 9 of 24 August 6, 2024 Construction Bidders Prior to Award. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele I.1. Board Discussion and Direction Regarding Negotiations with City of Melbourne Concerning Sarno Road Landfill Property Frank Abbate, County Manager, commented staff has given the Board some items so they can get some Board direction after discussions with the City of Melbourne, they were not interested in the purchase of the property; however, there were questions about whether or not the Board might be interested in leasing a portion of it, and/or selling or leasing a portion of it for purposes of affordable housing; the third area was whether or not the board wanted to sell a portion of that land to the City at some point in the future, so the Board will see that outlined in the Agenda Item; the Board can either say yes it is interested in any of those three items, or indicate that it would be interested in it if it was a package; and either way, staff is looking for Board direction. He went on to say if the board would choose not to do any of those things, then staff did put a second item if the Board would be interested, in light of what happened in prior Board discussions, the use of Wickham Park for Renaissance Fair whether or not it would interested in staff trying to reach out to them for a short-term lease, one year or less, for use for the coming year; the third option would be any other direction the Board might have for staff; and he did receive an email from the City Manager right before the meeting indicating that what she read in the Agenda was consistent with staff’s discussions. Sandra Sullivan stated this is going to cost taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars this site has been not only used for a Dredged Material Management Area (DMMA) site, it has also been used and is required 15 acres for hurricane debris; she provided a picture of the aerial showing how much of the site that was used before; she noted the math does not work, the County only leaving eight right now; there is no appraisal in the Agenda Item; and there should have been a couple of appraisals. She added, the City inquired whether the Board might be willing to consider a long-term lease of the site with a relatively nominal value; that is not allowed; she gave the Board a legal opinion previously; it was very clear from the meeting that they do not want to pay for the land; only Mayor Paul Alfrey, City of Melbourne, was pushing making points that they can lease Sarno for $1 a year for 99 years; he said the County really wants to get rid of it; and the County does not need the Sarno land, which obviously it does. She advised the optics of this are not good; there was a hit piece that dropped this week; when digging into who is the pack that funded that; and one will find out that it is the entity across the road; it is very common knowledge in Brevard County that he did not want the affordable housing across the street on that property; she asked is this a trade for a three-acre piece of property for a 57-acre piece; she reiterated the optics do not look good on this at all; and when this first came up, there was a campaign contribution to a Commissioner. She pointed out this is not good for the people; the County is not following its own rules on appraisals as far as she can see; it has one appraisal; it cannot be discussed leasing land for $1 a year for 99 years; this is utility land; this was purchased with bonds; there are rules and State Statutes; and this stinks, has really bad optics, and usually in the past things would have a tendency when one brings it before this Board, they would tend to go away once it has been exposed. She stated she does not get this Board; it just seems like even with things that are brought forward, there is no shame anymore; and there is no shame for the will of the people of what he or she wants. Jeffrey Njus, Executive Director of Daily Bread, stated he wanted to very simply express their Page 10 of 24 August 6, 2024 openness to the possibilities that have been put forward; he is what one may call an indirect party to the negotiations; he wanted to provide a little bit of clarity that they would be open to the possibility of a long-term lease; they are indifferent to whether the property is owned or leased ty them; and he is grateful for the County to step in and address this Countywide challenge of the problem of affordable housing. He went on by saying he is grateful for the kind of creative solutions to this need; and he is available for any questions. Commissioner Pritchett expressed her appreciation to Mr. Njus, as he has a great mission, and he impacts a lot of people; and she stated she wanted him to know she appreciates it. Commissioner Feltner stated he wanted to make a motion to lease directly to Renaissance Fair for the next season; and then any other thing that happens with this parcel is something maybe the next Board can discuss in the future. Chair Steele passed the gavel to Vice Chair Pritchett. Commissioner Steele stated he would second Commissioner Feltner’s motion. Vice Chair Pritchett passed the gavel back to Chair Steele. Commissioner Tobia advised this came out of his office; as a little background, he wants to thank the County Manager and the County Attorney, as they worked very diligently on this; he had some discussions with the Mayor of Melbourne; clearly he was observing Sunshine, because Mayor Alfrey had no idea where his board was going to go; and he had no idea where this Board was going to go. He pointed out the County Manager did with the instruction of this Board was to go out and get an appraisal of that land; it came back at far more than what he would have expected; the City of Melbourne had an appraisal done; theirs came back even higher than the County’s appraisal; then the offer was made for an exchange for road maintenance, so they could amortize this cost over 20 years; clearly, the other elected officials in Melbourne were not too intrigued with that plan; that is okay; and he fully-supports that decision. He stated there were a bunch of other decision points in there about parceling up this land; he would support the way the motion and the second are going on that; he thinks the Board needs to close the door on parceling this off; he does not know what sections of that 57 acres they would want, the sections the County may use, the dry sections, or anything like that, so if the County was going to go in an exchange for some road maintenance and the whole parcel was being dealt, that would be okay; but as far as parceling it up, he does not think there is any more need for staff to continue negotiations based on what it received back; and he would not be in favor of a long-term lease with the City of Melbourne for $1 or $1,000, as he just does not think it would benefit the County in any nature. He reiterated he will support that motion and the second as long as the Board puts some sort of termination; clearly, the County is not going to meet the City with what they are looking for; Commissioner Feltner just has a creative way to help out some live LARPers out there playing in some costumes; he would certainly support that as long as there were some clear provisions in there with that lease; obviously, the Parks and Recreation Director would put in play that just costs, certain cleanup be done, and a market rate be done; the Board needs to be very clear that entrance, exit, and all of that stuff is outside; the entrance is not County land, that needs to be handled and permitted through the City of Melbourne, so the County can offer the lease but it cannot guarantee anything that is going on; and he would like added in the motion, and he hopes this would be friendly, that the Board would not go any further with negotiations with the City of Melbourne, as the County and City are too far apart, because the City is not interested in that type of deal, as well as the provisions with the Renaissance Fair that the County sets just cost and all that good stuff. Page 11 of 24 August 6, 2024 Commissioner Feltner advised he will accept that as a friendly amendment if Commissioner Tobia wants to restate that to make it clear for the Clerk. Commissioner Tobia stated the amendment would be to terminate the negotiations with the City of Melbourne. Commissioner Feltner asked what if the Renaissance Fair pays the same rate as last year at Wickham Park for this next season coming at the Sarno property. Mr. Abbate noted he would say the Board would be looking at the all-in cost in terms of what they paid for the permit; they also had a variety of camping that was going on, Recreational Vehicles (RVs), et cetera that they did, so the County has an all-in cost for that; and in the current motions, as well as in the Agenda Item, all ancillary costs, cleanup, et cetera would also be included in whatever would be the terms, so it would be under the same terms for the period of time that the County collected the revenues from the Wickham Park situation, and the ancillary costs as well. Commissioner Tobia stated so the additions are number one, to terminate negotiations with the City of Melbourne; and number two, to use the revisions in the staff report to have a similar fee schedule as last year for the Renaissance Fair, which hopefully that would be a friendly amendment. Commissioner Feltner remarked he would accept that friendly amendment. Commissioner Pritchett commented since this is a different area for them, she is sure they are going to have to do some clearing and setting up; and she asked if that is going to be on their dime as well. Commissioner Feltner replied it is his understanding that any site work prep would be up to them. Commissioner Pritchett pointed out she just wanted to double check. Mr. Abate advised the work prep, the cost would be on the Renaissance Fair. Chair Steele noted all of that will be included in the lease. Mr. Abbate asked as a cost paid by the person who is leasing it, right. Chair Steele replied yes; and he called for a vote on the motion. The Board directed staff to terminate negotiations with the City of Melbourne; and approved leasing the Sarno Landfill property directly to the Renaissance Fair for a period not to exceed one year with a similar fee schedule and terms as was utilized at Wickham Park between County Parks and Recreation and the Renaissance Fair, with the Renaissance Fair being solely and exclusively responsible for complying with all County and City special events permitting requirements, and any and all other costs associated with the Fair being held on leased property. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Page 12 of 24 August 6, 2024 Seconder: Jason Steele Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele J.1. Approval, Re: Contract with Keep Brevard Beautiful for SR 406 Max Brewer Causeway, SR 528 Beachline Causeway, SR518 Eau Gallie Causeway, HWY 192 Melbourne Causeway, and SR 404 Pineda Causeway Clean Up Commissioner Pritchett stated Items J.1. and J.2. are very closely related; she asked if they can be discussed together; she advised both contracts are working in collaboration with Keep Brevard Beautiful (KBB); she thinks the County should have one contract with KBB on all of the projects rather than having Cocoa Beach as a middleman for SR 520 Causeway and the Beach cleanup project; Item J.1. has the Max Brewer Causeway in the Titusville area, the 192 Causeway in Melbourne, the Beachline, and it just makes sense to put them all together instead of separating out SR 520; and after a discussion, she would like to make a motion to approve and authorize the Tourism Development Commission Director to sign a three-year contract with a two-year extension with KBB beginning October 1, 2024, for the six causeway projects, plus the beach cleanup for the annual amount added together $417,184 per year, subject to the County Attorney, Risk management, and Purchasing Services approval. She added, the funds for SR 520 Causeway and cleanup would come from the Tourist Beach Fund under the Sections 102-119(3)b and (4)a of the County Code; the funds for the five other causeway projects will still come from the Lagoon portion of the Beach Fund under Section 102-1194 of the Code; adopt the legislative findings at that time for the requested action for these, so that is just an idea to put them both together; and she thinks it would serve KBB; and then the Board would be able to take Cocoa Beach out of that as a middleman and just get all of the projects done. Chair Steele pointed out that is sure going to put a stick in the wheels here; he would have to find out whether or not Cocoa Beach and Keep Brevard Beautiful would be interested in doing that; and in the interest of saving time, he asked Wayne Carragino, City Manager of Cocoa Beach, if he has a problem with that. John Nico, Keep Brevard Beautiful, stated he does not have a problem with this; and he thinks this would be a good idea. Mr. Carragino replied not at all; and it makes sense actually to be honest. Sandra Sullivan commented almost every single week, Water Warriors is out cleaning up Pineda Causeway; their volunteers are so impressive; she provided the Board with a picture of one of their posts on social media; they are doing other causeways and other roads; and they have put receptacles all along the Causeway so when people go fishing or are recreating at this side of the Causeway, they are putting their trash in there. She went on to say these people work so hard, it is so impressive; the County is giving almost $37,000 to KBB; it does not cleanup Pineda Causeway, Waterway Warriors does; they have been working with Natural Resources Management, which know what they are doing; they are going down into the Lagoon and picking up stuff; the Board would not believe what they pick up; and there is no consideration here for Waterway Warriors. She noted they have been for two years now cleaning up Pineda Causeway on a weekly basis; she asked the Board Members to drive down there sometime and he or she will see all kinds of trash bags at the side of the road with their volunteer sign; on the sign on Pineda Causeway it says ‘Adopt a Highway, Pineda Waterway Warriors’; she asked what the County is doing here; and she stated it is not acknowledging people who work really hard, volunteers who are out there every weekend picking up trash. Page 13 of 24 August 6, 2024 Commissioner Feltner explained that this Board adopted a Resolution in recognition of the Waterway Warriors; he thinks they are an amazing group that goes out there an cleans up; they called him on a Saturday morning, and he got Roads and Bridge out there and picked up the remains of what must have been a dock that was set up there for a bonfire; they removed every splinter of that with their group; they even went back out there with a magnet and picked all of the nails up, so please believe him when he tells everyone that they are an amazing group; and the County appreciates them. He asked if the representative from Weekend Warriors would like to speak and if she is in support of this. Chair Steele noted she can just come up and speak, or let this go, because he thinks this is going in the right direction; and that is up to her. Sharon Noll, Weekend Warriors, expressed her appreciation to Ms. Sullivan for her words; she advised they are in absolute and complete support of the agreements with KBB moving forward; they are looking forward to a collaboration with them, however that is going to look; and they could not be any more in support. Commissioner Pritchett expressed her appreciation to Ms. Noll for all that she does. Commissioner Feltner seconded Commissioner Pritchett’s earlier motion. Commissioner Tobia stated he likes the first two provisions on here; he had one of them, but only on one section, so he thinks it is wise these are combined; he also thinks it is wise that they are run through the County for an administrative cost; his issue is with the numbers; they really do not add up very well; and here is where he got it. He pointed out there is an increased cost to the Causeways of roughly $36,000 and change; however, there the scope is expanded to add an additional causeway, so that justifies the better part, if not all of the initial costs. He remarked he has no concerns with the added expenditures for the causeway portion of that; but he does want to go to the other section; the County is looking at an increase of roughly $85,000, or 49 percent; that is to go from an expenditure of $175,000 to $260,000; they justified that with three things, an increase in tourism, an increase in fuel costs, and an increase in material costs, so the scope is not expanding; and these are the three added costs. He stated unfortunately, none of those even get close to justifying a 49 percent increase; he did look these up, because when one comes and asks for more money, he thinks it is very fair to have some baseline; he looked over the period of time since the last contract; using the data from 2022 to Fiscal Year 2024, the County has seen roughly 12 percent increase in Tourism Development Tax (TDT) collection; but when drilling down a little bit more, it has actually seen about an 11 percent increase in Cocoa Beach. He noted when getting to fuel costs, over the past five years according to the U.S. Department of Transportation, have gone up 35 percent; he does understand that 35 percent is close to 49 percent; but he was informed walking in that, that only counts for 10 to 15 percent of their budget; and finally, materials. He stated there is no justification of what those materials are; he has no problem with a 49 percent increase as long as the Board can justify why it is providing a 49 percent increase; he would be more than willing to provide a three percent per year over those five; but that does not get anywhere near that $85,000; in fact, it would be about $57,000 less than what is collected here; he would be willing, again, to vote for that 49 percent, but there is no justification; tourism is up, fuel is up, but neither is up 49 percent; and they have given the County any justification of what materials they needed. He mentioned they did the job at $175,000; he does not know why the Board needs to arbitrarily offer a 49 percent increase; he thinks that would be irresponsible of the Board; and by doing the 3 percent increase, that would be $57,126 less than what they are asking for. Chair Steele passed the gavel to Vice Chair Pritchett. Page 14 of 24 August 6, 2024 Commissioner Steele commented he understands what Commissioner Tobia is saying; he thinks what has happened here is these good people have been working short-handed and using volunteers to supplement what they are doing; they have been getting underpaid to be able to do the work that they need to do; he is perfectly comfortable with their proposal; and he would absolutely, unequivocally, without any question support it. He noted he understands Commissioner Tobia’s option on it; and he does not have the same opinion, so hopefully, the Board can come to some understanding on this and move forward. Vice Chair Pritchett passed the gavel back to Chair Steele. Commissioner Pritchett asked if the gentleman from KBB can come back up if has any explanations of what it would cost. Deb Harman, Board Chair of Keep Brevard Beautiful, advised she understands Commissioner Tobia is concerned; she is going to explain how they arrived at these numbers; he is asking for a percentage increase; it is nearly impossible for them to get to a percentage increase that she can make sense of and defend; and Mr. Nico will tell the Board that when he showed her the numbers and estimate that was put together for Peter Cranis, Tourism Development Office, for both offices, she said based on what. She went on to say they dug in and analyzed their costs for the last two years, and have given a pretty detailed cost estimate for what it is costing them now and what they can foresee next year; just to clarify one thing, on the beach contract, before the Pineda entered in there and were asked to do that, and are grateful for the Waterway Warriors and what they are going to do together, they originally paid $60,000 in 2019; in 2022, she believes, they were given an extension of $40,000 for that one year to take care of the additional trash from the people coming back to the beach during the pandemic for one year; they are asking for 120; and that expired at the end of the County’s Fiscal Year 2022, maybe 2023. She pointed out they were compensated $100,000; the trash did not go away; they did not cut their level of service; they have analyzed their costs and said it is going to cost 120; if the Board looks at the number for Pineda added, they are roughly similar numbers; and the Causeway, if the Board remembers, the level of effort on each Causeway varies, so there is some variation by Causeway. She mentioned as far as the beach contact is concerned, she cannot defend why it was increased; she thinks the number was artificially low, and she does not know why, based on what was negotiated years ago; she can tell the Board what is in that number; and they are happy to disclose how they arrived at the $26,000 for materials, which includes fuel, supplies like bags, as the big bags the use at the beach are quite expensive, personal protective equipment, because they do have people on the causeways doing fairly dangerous things, and on SR 520 as part of the beach contract. She stated she can give the Board the breakdown, which is roughly $246,000 just for the beach, and another roughly $24,000 to $25,000 for the Causeway at the SR 520 Causeway; all of these contracts are based on the same labor rates they have now, the same general costs for their allocations for insurance; their vehicle insurance, every year, for all of their vehicles is roughly $53,000; she does not know if any of that was included originally; when she looks at the numbers now versus then, it is very hard to get to that; but she can tell the Board that they are happy to sit and disclose; they went over these numbers, and the backup with their treasurer who has been their treasurer for 30 years, just this morning; and she cannot speak to the increase because she was not here when the original number was created. She expressed her appreciation to Chair Steele for pointing out that on top of what they get paid for, they bring a lot of volunteer activity; they have not stopped even though their funding has not been adequate for the last couple of years; they are just asking moving forward to be paid for the value they are giving for the paid work; and they will continue to work hard to supplement that. She noted she is from the business world where they competed for government contracts at all levels; she understands Page 15 of 24 August 6, 2024 the Board has a fiscal responsibility, she has a fiscal responsibility as a citizen, she wants to see the County use the funds well; but she also has an obligation for stewardship to make sure their organization is sustainable because of the work they do. Commissioner Tobia pointed out that Ms. Harman said she could not defend the increase; he asked if someone came to her, a contractor, they were asking her for maybe a 50 percent increase, and she asked why they are asking for a 50 percent increase, and they said they cannot defend the increase; and he asked if she would provide them with that increase. Ms. Harman explained she wants to say it a different way, all she can do is to explain the costs that they have today and how it compares to what they have been paid for the last two years. Commissioner Tobia remarked she just said the treasurer was there for 30 years, did she not. Ms. Harman replied that is true. Commissioner Tobia stated he is listening to her, it is just not adding up. Ms. Harman went on to explain that is true, and he cannot explain it for her either. Commissioner Tobia asked if her treasurer cannot answer it who has been there 30 years, and she cannot, why she expects this Board to arbitrarily hand her 49 percent more; again, she cannot explain it, the treasurer cannot explain it, but she expects the Board to hand over 49 percent more. Ms. Harman stated all she knows is in 2019 it was a grant and was not intended to cover their full costs; she reiterated she does not know; they are willing to let the Board review them in detail; and the County can let their financial people tell them whether or not there are things that are not allowable. Commissioner Tobia expressed his appreciation to Ms. Harman for being honest. Commissioner Feltner asked he knows this went to the Tourist Development Council (TDC), and if in the aggregate there were any concerns over the cost at that time of the two contracts. Mr. Cranis replied there were questions that the TDC asked, but they felt, he thinks satisfied after getting the answers; and it was a unanimous vote. Commissioner Pritchett mentioned this is kind of in Commissioner Goodson’s area; and she would not mind if he would kind of chime in with his thoughts. Commissioner Goodson commented there are two options; it can be tabled and brought back with everything that Commissioner Tobia wants to look at, or the Board can vote today, because he is in agreement, they do a wonderful job; the TDC said everyone voted unanimously for it; and he is onboard with them. The Board approved and authorized the Tourism Development Office Director to sign a three-year Contract with a two-year extension with KBB beginning October 1, 2024, for clean-up on SR 406 Max Brewer Causeway, SR 528 Beachline Causeway, SR 518 Eau Gallie Causeway, Highway 192 Melbourne Causeway, SR 404 Pineda Causeway, SR 520 Causeway, and beach clean-up, totaling $417,184 per year, subject to County Attorney, Risk Management, and Purchasing Services approval; authorized funds for SR 520 Causeway and clean-up to come from the Tourism Beach Fund under Section 102-119(3)b and (4) a of the Code; Page 16 of 24 August 6, 2024 authorized the funds for the other five (5) causeway projects to come from the Lagoon portion of the Beach Fund under Section 102-119(4)a of the Code; adopted the legislative findings as set forth in the requested action listed on the Agenda Reports for Items J.1. and J.2.; and authorized the County Manager to execute any necessary Budget Change Requests (BCR). Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Feltner, and Steele Nay: Tobia J.2. Approval, Re: Contract with City of Cocoa Beach for Keep Brevard Beautiful Beach and SR520 Causeway Clean-up The Board approved and authorized the Tourism Development Office Director to sign a three-year Contract with a two-year extension with KBB beginning October 1, 2024, for clean-up on SR 406 Max Brewer Causeway, SR 528 Beachline Causeway, SR 518 Eau Gallie Causeway, Highway 192 Melbourne Causeway, SR 404 Pineda Causeway, SR 520 Causeway, and beach clean-up, totaling $417,184 per year, subject to County Attorney, Risk Management, and Purchasing Services approval; authorized funds for SR 520 Causeway and clean-up to come from the Tourism Beach Fund under Section 102-119(3)b and (4) a of the Code; authorized the funds for the other five (5) causeway projects to come from the Lagoon portion of the Beach Fund under Section 102-119(4)a of the Code; adopted the legislative findings as set forth in the requested action listed on the Agenda Reports for Items J.1. and J.2.; and authorized the County Manager to execute any necessary Budget Change Requests (BCR). Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Feltner, and Steele Nay: Tobia J.3. Proposed Amendment to the Brevard County Home Rule Charter to Align the School Board Member Residence Areas with the County Commission Districts Commissioner Tobia stated he wants to go over a little bit of the history that is going on here; on May 23rd, the School Board voluntarily voted to align their district boundaries with the Commission districts so that they share the same boundaries as the Commission; this was one of the things that he wanted to do when he got elected; he thought that there were five County Commission districts and five School Board districts; and it should make sense that they were aligned accordingly. He went on to say it lowers costs to taxpayers, it reduces confusion to voters, and it eliminates redundancies; following this vote by the School board, he suggested at the July 11, 2023, meeting that the Board looks into potentially a Charter amendment to ensure that the two entities/districts continue to align in the future; he asked why to do this; he stated dictating the boundaries remain cohesive will save reoccurring estimated of approximately $30,500 every 10 years, so $17,000 in legal fees, and $1,300 in Geographical Information Systems (GIS) licensing will also save an estimated 250 hours in County staff time alone; and the School Board its own costs. He remarked the next time redistricting comes around, the County and the School Board would have an equal amount of appointees on the new redistricting committee; to get this on the 2024 ballot, the language must be submitted to the Supervisor of Elections by August 19, 2024; seeing that this is a Charter amendment, there Page 17 of 24 August 6, 2024 would be a supermajority, so it would obviously need four of the Commissioners; it also requires review by a three-attorney panel to ensure it embraces only one subject and is consistent with the Florida Constitution, general law, and the Charter; the attached resolution includes a clause that the language would not be submitted to the Supervisor of Elections unless and until it is approved by at least two members of said panel; if the panel is not able to complete the review, the amendment, in time for the 2024 deadline, would be submitted in the 2026 ballot measure; and this is important, this does not take away authority from the School Board. He went on to say when the five County Commission districts are redrawn, the five School Board Members areas would also be withdrawn in conjunction; however, the proposed Charter amendment provides for the following redistricting the School Board will still retain the authority, under Florida Statute 1001.32, Section 2; they may make any changes that it deem necessary should they not see fit, so in other words, what this would do is make the default of the Board and School Board working together; if the School Board did not like that, they would have the ability to override; but it makes no sense that the Board invests time and money drawing lines; and the School Board does the same thing under the same parameters. He noted this would potentially put this on the ballot in 2024; if the Board cannot meet the deadline, put it on the 2026; he is open to answer any questions on positives or negatives suggestions, any of that good stuff; he is very happy that the School Board voluntarily joined the Board, so if one is in County Commission District 2, he or she is also in School Board District 2, so he just wanted to make that a default and not necessarily goodwill like it happened this last time; and that is what he is looking for. He stated he wanted to make a motion to adopt a resolution proposing an amendment to the Brevard County Home Rule Charter to align School Board Member residence areas with the County Commission Districts; to authorize staff to submit the proposed Charter Amendment and ballot language to the three-attorney panel with review proposed Charter amendments for compliance with the Florida Constitution, Florida law, and the Brevard County Charter, and to determine whether proposed amendment embraces only one subject; and if at least two members of the panel approve the proposal amendment, provide for a placement of the proposed amendment at the referendum held concurrently with the November 5, 2024, general election; if the deadline should pass before the panel is able to successfully complete its review, the amendment will be placed on the 2026 ballot. Commissioner Pritchett stated she would secon

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

22 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 12 of 22

Browse by category22 actions
  • Agenda item F.2.Budget and financeapproved - The Board approved amending the scope of work for the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project to focus on removing muck from areas with the highest nutrient flux, using Save Our Indian River Lagoon (SOIRL) Trust Funds allocated for both muck removal and interstitial treatment to bid dredging without interstitial treatment; authorized staff to negotiate and the County Manager to execute change orders to removal more muck and/or add interstitial treatment to the contract if the negotiated cost is reasonable and sufficient funds are available or become available; and extended the same flexibility and approach to all muck removal projects approved in the SOIRL Project Plan, as necessary, so projects can move forward within their allocated budgets.

    Scope of Work and Budget Allocation for the Eau Gallie Northeast Muck Removal Project

    $26

  • Agenda item F.4.Contractsapproved - The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 24-070, for the previously approved Joint Participation Agreement with FDOT for the cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project.

    Florida Department of Transportation Resolution for the Previously Approved Joint Participation Agreement for cost-sharing and nutrient credit sharing of the Sykes Creek Zone N Septic-to-Sewer Project (District 2).

  • Agenda item F.5.Contractsapproved - The Board granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the Final Plat and Infrastructure Contract for Landings at Viera - Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC, subject to minor changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Landings at Viera Developer: Condev Pineda Investors I, LLC District 4

  • Agenda item F.6.Ordinancesapproved - The Board granted permission for the Utility Services Director to advertise for the repeal of Brevard County Ordinance No. 89-29 – State Road 46 Water Extension #1.

    Permission to advertise for the repeal of Ordinance 89-29 - State Road 46 Water Extension #1 (District 1).

  • Agenda item F.7.Contractsapproved - The Board approved the Urban County Agreement Re-Qualification with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to receive Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME funds; approved the continuance of Cooperative Agreements with seven municipalities consisting of Cocoa Beach, Indialantic, Indian Harbour Beach, Melbourne Village, Palm Shores, Rockledge, and Satellite Beach for Fiscal Years 2025, 2026, and 2027; authorized the County Attorney to send the mandatory letter to HUD; and authorized the Housing and Human Services Director to transmit the renewed Agreements and any supporting documents to HUD.

    Approval, HUD Urban County Agreements and Requalification for FY 2025, 2026, and 2027

  • Agenda item F.8.Budget and financeapproved - The Board reviewed and approved the Budget Change Request (BCR).

    Approval, Re: Budget Change Request

  • Agenda item F.9.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board appointed/reappointed Donald Lusk to the Brevard County Library System Advisory Board, with term expiring December 31, 2025; Josiah Gattle to the Economic Development Commissioner of Florida’s Space Coast, with term expiring December 31, 2024; Stacy Landon to the Historical Commission, with term expiring December 31, 2025; Melissa Jackson, as alternate, to the Planning and Zoning Board, with term expiring December 31, 2026; Ana Saunders, and Robert Wise, as alternate, to the Planning and Zoning Board, with terms December 31, 2025; and Jessica Curry and Warren Bradford Whitmore, Jr. to the Titusville-Cocoa Airport Authority, with terms expiring August 6, 2027.

    Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s)

  • Agenda item F.10.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board acknowledged receipt of the Bill Folder.

    Bill Folder

  • Agenda item G.Other meeting itemsapproved - Louie Hanna stated he has lived on East Crisafulli Road for 28 years, retired after 30 years at the Space Center, he is an Army veteran, and he has a problem with the speed bumps on East Crisafulli Road; they heard about these soon to be installed speed bumps just a couple of weeks before they were to be installed; it was a done deal, they were coming, and to deal with it; and it kind of felt like the residents were not supposed to know about it beforehand, or until it was too late to do anything about it. He went on to say upon inquiring about why no one knew about the speed humps prior, he was told that the only ones affected were the ones who voted for it, the address is within the first one-half mile from Courtenay to Judson; the residents east of Judson to the end of East Crisafulli and all of the connecting streets were unaffected; because they were unaffected, not one person east of Judson, on Crisafulli, or tributaries had a vote or any say in the matter at all; they were just going to be put in and that was it; this is his home being talked about here; his Commissioner, Mr. Goodson, old him they could use Judson Road, thereby eliminating the necessity to drive over the speed bumps all together; Judson is a dirt road; in the dry season, it is a dusty as a washboard road; and in the wet season, it is a mud road. He noted if the residents wanted to traverse a dirt road on a daily basis, they could have bought cheaper property on a dirt road; to his way of thinking, when something is arbitrarily taken away, what is offered in return should be equal to or better than what they lost; he asked the County to pave Judson; he asked why punish everyone for the sins of the few; he remarked to catch the guys who are speeding, and put cops out there; the name on a document authorizing the installation of speed bumps is the same name that appeared on at least one of the company trucks on the job site the day of installation; he asked who provided the asphalt; and is this a conflict of interest. He pointed out at the very least, it is what is called bad optics in today’s world; the resident who initiated this process was overheard boasting at the local convenience store about how he had gotten traffic slowed down on East Crisafulli, that he had pulled some strings of the buddy at the County to get speed bumps installed; but he was unable to get them installed past Judson; he thought his County Commissioner’s job was to help the citizenry he represents to make life better; this is not better; this is insulting and divisive; East Crisafulli Road has been his home for over 28 years; do not tell him he is unaffected; and they are all affected. Commissioner Goodson advised this was voted on with former Commissioner Lober; in the County Code, and the County Manager can correct him if he is wrong, it says 85 percent right now that front the property where the speed bumps go; and he asked if that is correct. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, responded there is a BCC that covers that; they sent out the petition; and it met the threshold. Commissioner Goodson asked if it is true that the people that are voting right now, unless the Ordinance is changed, if it is the people who front Crisafull Road. Mr. Bernath replied correct. Commissioner Goodson asked not the people that live a block off or a mile off on another street, correct. Mr. Bernath responded that is correct. Commissioner Goodson asked if these were approved by former Commissioner Lober, correct. Mr. Bernath responded he does not know offhand; and he was not prepared to answer that tonight. Commissioner Goodson inquired therefore, if the County is going to allow Mr. Hanna here, the Code would have to be changed, correct. Mr. Bernath replied it is a BCC, it is not a Code. Commissioner Goodson asked what a BCC is. Mr. Bernath advised it is a Board Policy. Commissioner Goodson asked if the Board would have to change it. Mr. Bernath responded affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson stated if he is not mistaken, the people east of Mr. Hanna voted to . . . Mr. Hanna noted no, they did not. Commissioner Goodson stated that Mr. Hanna say they did not; but he was under the impression they voted to for when they pave the road they want speed humps; Mr. Hanna is saying no; and he is going to agree with all of them. Terrence White commented he lives on Joseph Court, which is a road off of Crisafulli; Mr. Hanna covered a lot of the points he has; but in doing some research, a lot of the problems with speed humps that people have not even discussed; they slow down the response of emergency vehicles; being a former fire fighter, he knows what it is like to go over bumps in a big fire truck; and it also includes transporting someone in an ambulance after the fact, as the ambulance cannot leave the area in a hurry because of the humps. He went on to say one of the things that he witnessed for years in areas that do have speed humps is when a school bus goes over there, the children in the backseat gets launched almost to the ceiling of the school bus; he asked the Board Members to follow a school bus in a neighborhood that has speed humps; along with Mr. Hanna, no one, east of Judson, was questioned about the speed humps; he did not find out about them until he drove down the road and they were in the process of installing them; and it causes excess wear on the vehicles. He added one of the issues he sees as well is people down there have livestock, horses, goats, and cattle; they play heck going over those bumps with animals in their trailers; a lot of animals are spooked in a trailer anyway; and it also plays on the suspension of the trailers. He stated while he is up here he would like to request that the speed humps on Joseph Court to be removed; there are 15 residents on that street; 14 of them told him that they want them removed; in doing research on the ones on Crisafulli, he found a thing that says speed humps cannot be installed on a dead-end road; and Joseph Court is a dead-end road. Robert Adams mentioned he has lived on Crisafulli Road for 40 years; he is here to make a citizens request, which he was told to do, for a petition to remove the speed humps; whatever that package is, that is what they are trying to get a hold of, which is why they are here speaking; five speed humps have been installed in less than one-half a mile, from Courtenay to Judson; and Crisafulli Road is only two miles long with a bunch of other roads on it. He continued by saying according to County Policy, the benefited and affected areas are the ones that are supposed to be checked out before putting speed bumps in; everyone on that road uses Crisafuli every single day; every time he leaves his house twice, he goes over 20 speed bumps; he would love the Commission to put 20 speed bumps around his or her house and see how much it is enjoyed; other than that, they were told by Commissioner Goodson to drive down Judson; that is not what he moved out there for 40 years ago; he moved out there to get away from Homeowners Associations (HOAs); and they finally found him. He advised he does not appreciate the detrimental effects, or whatever one wants to say; he inquired when it comes to the logistics of it, how many of the affected homeowners signed off on a petition to use their tax money to put in those speed bumps; he pointed out he did not; he has never been asked in 40 years whether or not he wanted speed bumps; the detrimental effects is the community is torn apart; they used to be friendly people and wave at each other, and people stopped and looked at each other’s Christmas lights; now they flip one off every time he or she goes by the house on the corner; and it is not too hard to figure out that it is not really much of a bring it together package. He noted property values are impacted, school buses, and damage to his cars; he is not taking his trailers with a thousand dollars’ worth of equipment over five speed humps just to leave his home every day; it is not the way to do business; he asked why were the unnotified homeowners possibly have to use their personal funds to remove those speed bumps, which is in the County’s package deal; and he asked the Commissioners want to drive over five speed bumps every time he or she leaves their home; and he stated that is five in and five out. Commissioner Goodson asked if he wants to remove the speed bumps, and he ran a survey of all of the people who live on Crisafulli and off of Crisafulli, would he agree if they voted for speed humps. Mr. Adams replied no; he has a hundred and some odd signatures here . . . Commissioner Goodson stated to hang on and let him finish the question, because the first people who voted that lived on Crisafulli, only one said no; and everybody else said speed bumps. Mr. Adams remarked fine. Commissioner Goodson asked if he ran a survey and everybody that lived off and on Crisafulli said they wanted or did not want speed humps would Mr. Adams agree with the vote at the end. Mr. Adams replied yes, very much so, as that is logical. Alan Miles asked why is there no urgency to put a traffic light at the intersection between Viera High School and the new middle school; he stated there are veterans leaving the Veterans Clinic, seniors from Sonata East, and a wet surface from the car wash; there are high school students making u-turns, golf carts, and walkers all diverging on this intersection; it is slated for a light beginning the 2025 school year he believes; and if safety is the main concern of the Commission, then get a light. He advised temporary ones in the Palm Bay Heritage High School are being installed; he has some information on this system; and he asked if anyone knows what is going on with the traffic lights there. Chair Steele explained the Public Comment section is for him to go ahead and give the Board his comments; and it is not a question and answer situation. Commissioner Feltner noted out of respect for his constituent, he would like Mr. Bernath speak to the light project that is happening out there; and he knows there have been many conversations with the schools about it. Mr. Bernath stated the School District is actively designing this light; staff is contributing to it; he does not have the actual design schedule at his disposal; but they are planning on putting it in sometime later this year; staff anticipates by the end of the year, he would say, to have that put in; and he reiterated it is something the County would anticipate them doing later on this year. Mr. Miles pointed out it still does not meet the safety qualification of being installed before the school year. Chair Steele advised the Board is not going to get into a question and answer service; Commissioner Feltner asked Mr. Bernath for a response; and he gave it to Mr. Miles. Commissioner Feltner stated everyone is actively working on it, and also by Viera Elementary, which is something he inherited; and he has been working on that since he got on the Commission.

    PUBLIC COMMENTS (Individuals may not speak under both the first and second public comment sections.)

  • Agenda item H.1.Other meeting itemsapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a petition to vacate public utility and drainage easements located in Revised Gateway Unit No. 2, Merritt Island, as petitioned by Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien. Richard Bitner stated this thing is absolutely a monstrosity; he provided pictures to the Board showing the scope and size of this; he explained as the Board can see, that is him standing along in that structure; it is huge; it is almost as big as the house; that is a side view; there are safety issues on this as well; and the Board can see where the roof is collapsing. He advised there is no privacy; he provided a picture to the Board of when they are standing on their deck, what they look at; he noted he wants privacy in his yard; every single time they step on their thing, that is what he has to look at; it is just too big; and it is the size of their house. He pointed out it does not pass zoning; they have already said it is against Policy; here they are wasting their time when it should have been torn down a year ago; they have been at this for a year; and he reiterated he just wants his privacy. He stated they are up there two feet, he has to look at two feet of their bodies every time they step on top of that structure; the thing is like 50 feet long; it is terrible; it is just too big; it needs to come down or be modified; but it is not fun going out into his yard to swim, and he has to look at them. Commissioner Goodson asked how long Mr. Bitner has lived there. Mr. Bitner replied five years. Commissioner Goodson asked if this undoubtedly been a problem for only the last year. Mr. Bitner responded there have been other issues; but the subject is on this structure; they have gone to court; they had a privacy fence that was eight feet tall that was removed; it was on his property; they had it removed and put a new six-foot fence, the white fence the Board saw, they put it on their property, so they took away two feet of their privacy; and they tried talking to them, but it was their way and only their way. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, stated it is a public petition to vacate two public utility and drainage easements to allow for the existing covered deck to remain and become compliant with the Code Enforcement case; the petitioner is requesting for five foot vacate on both the north and west size; and that is at the discretion of the Board to honor that or not; and if so, then the petitioner would then go before the Board of Adjustment to seek a variance. Chair Steele asked if this is Commissioner Goodson’s District; and he asked if he would like to make a recommendation. Commissioner Goodson replied he would like to make a motion to approve. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-XXX, vacating public utility and drainage easements located in Revised Gateway Unit No. 2 in Merritt Island, as requested by Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien.

    Petition to Vacate, Re: Public Utility & Drainage Easements - 466 Newfound Harbor Drive - “Revised Gateway Unit No. 2” Plat Book 19, Page 112 - Merritt Island - Shani Murphy and Todd P. O’Brien - District 2

  • Agenda item H.2.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider revisions to Ordinance 98-37, also known as chapter 2, Article VII, Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings. Kathy Wall, Central Services Director, stated it is requested that the Board approve the revisions to Chapter 2, Article VII, of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, Construction and Improvement to Public Buildings. Chair Steele stated he listened to this during briefings, and he was extremely pleased with this. There being no comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-18, amending Chapter 2, Article VII of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled “Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings”; amending Section 2-226, Brevard County Code, entitled “Definitions”, to define certain terms; amendment Section 2-227, Brevard County Code, entitled “Award of Contracts Generally”, to increase the minimum dollar threshold of certain public projects from $50,000 to $200,000; amending Section 2-228, Brevard County Code, entitled “Prequalification and Competitive Bidding”; amending Section 2-229, Brevard County Code, entitled “Qualifications of Bidders”; amending Section 2-230 entitled, “Debarment”; providing for inclusion in the Code; providing for conflicting provisions; providing for severability; and providing for an effective date.

    Approval of Revisions to Ordinance No. 98-37, also known as Chapter 2, Article VII of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, entitled “Construction and Improvement of Public Buildings.”

    $50,000

  • Agenda item H.3.Contractsapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider revisions to Board Policy BCC-28, Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award. Kathy Wall, Central Services Director, commented this requires the acceptance of public comment on the revisions to the Board Policy BCC-28, Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award. There being no comments or objections, the Board accepted public comment on the revisions to Board Policy BCC-28; and approved the revisions to BCC-28, Pre-qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award.

    Approval of Revisions to Board Policy BCC-28, “Pre-Qualification of Construction Bidders Prior to Award.”

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Brevard County Board of County Commissioners — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 837bd0dad8e5358943a3c96dda27201e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record