POLISCOPE

The public record

FOLSOM (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Folsom City Council Regular Meeting

Tuesday, June 13, 2017 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Folsom City Council Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 149,478 stored characters

based on experience through March of 2017. We'll start with a general fund. You can see on property taxes we are actually above what we had budgeted for in property taxes. It's a a5% increase over last year's tax. Were unshales tax, we are right in line where where we budget. It you looks strange because it was down from last year. 6789 that number came in right on target. Transfers in are above what we had anticipated due to some transfers in from the equipment replacement fund. So overall, our revenues are up slightly about 2.2% from previous year. It puts us in good standing. On the expenditure, the major expenditure categories, salaries are actually down from what was in the budget, so we're under budget for that, and it is a 1% increase over the prior fiscal year. The pen be fit on budget. That is your health cost. Onm is a little bit above where we expected to be for operation maintenance cost. Again, that was due to some equipment replacement costs. Both capital outlay and debt service are right on the budget numbers. We came in at 77 million which is about 4% over last fiscal year. You can sew summary revenue was above budget at 79 million. 2.2% above last year. Expenditures are below the budget authorization and they're up 4.4% from last yore. that leaves us our surplus which is higher than we anticipated have we we -- when we adopted the budget. That was expected to be 600,000. We believe 1 mt. 8 million. That would go to our unasyned fund balance, and so we thought we would be right around 15%. It looks like we'll come in at about 12.8 million or slightly over 16.5% which is above your policy level. You and temperature just shows the unassigned general fund balance of what has happened over since the recession and how you have drown the fund balance since then. So the general fund that we believe is going to come in good shape this fiscal yore. Again, we're overbudget on revenues and under budget on expenditures, and in we'll add to our fund balance. And in terms of the water enterprise fund, you can see that revenues have gone up slightly due to the end of the drought. We did hit our low point with that. We had come down from about 14.5 million several yores ago and with the restrictions on water use, that came down to 12.2, and now, it has turned back up. That was anticipated. Our expenditures are right in line with our budget numbers and our working capitol is at a good healthy level where we would like to keep it. The one thing I would point out is the difference between revenues from charges and our operating expense, and you'll see that is about at 1.6 million. That number is a little short if we want to continue our pay as you go capitol project. We would like to see that up about another million. So that is something we will watch for in the future. On the waste water enterprise fund, again, for services has gone up slightly with some new development. Expenses are right in line with what was budgeted. Working capitol is right in line again at a good healthy number. The difference here is the 2.1 is right on the low end of where we would like to be with that difference again to maintain our pay as you go capitol program. We like to have that somewhere between two and two and a half. We are in good shape, but we'll continue to watch that. Solid waste, again, the revenues have gone up somewhat with some new homes being built in service. Our expenses are right on target with what was budgeted and we're at the level we would like to be for our working capitol again, the difference is 1.3 million. That is where we would like to have that number be so we can continue to update the assets and solid waste being mainly the vehicles. The transit fund is mainly funded through the transit district and governmental funds as you can see, and it is primarily a break even operation and continues to be that way. our operating expenses are right in line where with -- with where we are projected. Our working capitol is the same. The risk management, internal service fund, the charges and revenue was down somewhat. That was a planned change there year where we reduced the rate somewhat. Although our operating expenses were a little higher than we anticipated, we still have a very desirable unrestricted net position the one thing is we are watching these four areas of cost as you can see over the last two years, all of those have increased and we will be watching and trying to manage the growth of those costs. Our internal service fund. We had reduced the charge again this year and last year was 5% of salaries here. It was 3% in these years. For next year, we reduced that and the budget you adopted. The 2.5%. This number on buy outs was lower than we had anticipated. Given the early retirement program. We thought this would be more up around the 1.3, 1 mt. 4 range. So the result of that is we have a very healthy fund balance in this fund. The tree planting revenue fund. We had more revenue than we had anticipated so your fund balance is higher than we anticipated by 150,000. And those are the major funds. I'll open up for questions and comments. >> thank you for that. As always, any questions for jim. Very clear. Could everyone give jim a nice round of applause for that rivetting -- I best counsel day ever, -- council day ever? >> I'm going to mark this down. Okay, thank you, jim, again, and the next item, please. >> the next item is business from the floor. This is the opportunity for members of the public other a -- to address the city council to concern items within the council's jurisdiction. >> any request to speak notary public. >> you have no request to speak under business from the floor tonight. >> all right. The next item, please. >> the next item is your consent calendar. >> and so that consent items a through n. >> okay. >> I'll go ahead and second. Council member nicholas. >> sheldon, gaylord. >> howl, and moreen. With that, I think we're up. Where are we at? Okay, new business. There we go. Your first item under new business is item 8a. This is the request for city council direction on the design of improvements associated with the sewer system improvement project. >> all right. The main event. So, just one little formality here. We're just fine with everybody in the chambers here. we want y'all to be here and stay, but if those near the doors if we could just keep pathways clear. That is all we ask just so we can maintain. So with that, marcus. >> mayor moreen, council members. And environmental and water resources director. The item we have before you tonight is the hinkle creek sewer system improvement project. Just a brief outline that I would like to take you through. The need for the project. Staff engagement with the community and the community's engagement with the city. The alternative analysis prepared by our consulting firm. The analysis concluded in that information. Staff recommendation, and then for next step. This oh is basically the system that the city maintains. I won't go into all the details, but this is before you in terms of the number of pump stations that the city operates and maintains. In 200 ever, the state water resources control board adopted a general statewide waste discharge requirement we refer to as general order which had various requirements that were needed by an agency who serves a suer service or more. In August of 2017, this became effective for the city of folsom. In July of 2009, city council adopted the city's first sanitary suer management plan or suer system management plan. this was updated and readopted in July or August of 2014. The city con soucts audits. Threads on odd number yores. Then we'll have another one probably in about two months this year. Whatever I really would like to point out in the general order itself and in is directly from the general order section b, item 7 which requires what the city needs to do. That is to take all feasible steps and necessary reimmediate y'all yule actions. You can read the control, the limit, or the volume of discharge, to terminate the discharge which basically means make it stop. It states in order to do that, the city must have an emergency response plan which would be consistent with the following. That includes items one through six here, and if you note item number two. And item number four is system modifications. Those are going to be key elements this evening in which we, staff, and myself build this entire presentation, and you'll see later in the presentation, the reasons for staff's recommendation. So these are all under the general order and all requirements by the state. So we are not deviating from any of these requirements. Section d, item 7, the yen order, requires certain items. The one thing I will mention again is that it also requires a suer system management plan which I discussed a short while ago. Way turned it into how the city operates and maintains. Adopted by council in 2009 and the 20 s and the city has an emergency response plan for suer overflows or suer spills. All this is available. I can also point them to the link, so we can get that to them. It isth hundred pages. It takes a while to upload. This goes into the maintaining the overflow and the clean-up requirements. I wanted to point out the plan that was prepared by staff and updated and adopted by city council reflects requirements of the general order which the city operates to. We're following the rules and regulations as hay the have been written by the state and as has been adopted by city council. I just wanted to share some results you can see from the chart here. If you look at just spills this line here in blue are the city numbers. The red is a state average and you can see from this chart here based on the number of spills that occur over time from the peak in 2000 down to, you know, the end of 2016, this is how the city has performed. And a lot of the credit goes to orb staff who are out there every day following the maintenance plan that has been adopted by city council and meeting the requirements of the general order. These aren't your staff reports but just compliments from not only regional board staff of the central valley regional quality control board. just in terms of how the city is performing you relative to the city and the state. The city has been invited to discuss our plan and to discuss how the city moved from that peak in 2000 to the numbers that we see in 2016. And so a lot of this is a direct result of what the general order requires but a direct result of what was adopted by city council and the rulebook in which way play. So the need for the project. -- project. There are a couple of different items. One is from operations to maintenance standpoint. There are sags offset at the joints in the pipeline itself. And I'll have the map that shows the alignment and shortly, but it also does run through the backyard so the suer line is in people's backyards and there are manholes that are in people's backyards and there are some portions of the pipe that cannot be inspected because of the pipe type. I'll show a little bit more information. In addition to just general operations maintenance, we also need safe and reliable access for several different reasons. One, to perform the routine that we need which includes flushing, cleaning, and inspection. So getting our tv equipment in there, and sanitary suer overflow or suer spill response. >> you one that is suer factor truck access. And right now, the current lay of the land, the city does not have that access, and this was made very available -- it was made very clear to us in October and November of 2015 when there were two spills in that area that we did not have access to with a suer truck to vacuum up the spill as we're required to do. So this, just a little bit more detail on the spill. This is a manhole in the backyard were on 1 canyon rim drive. On the map I will show you in a couple of slides. Manhole number two. Identified spills caused by grease deposits. They were eventually cleared. The approximate volume of the spill is about 3000 gallons. The spill did occur during the rain. One of the things we had to do in this particular case is the spill, I believe, occurred or started on a saturday, but was not reported to the city until monday. So we were not made aware of when this was happening. And typically when we go out to the site, we can look at the spill and identify that. That is about five gallons a minute, ten gallons a minute. What we had to do is use some of the city numbers to determine what the approximate volume was. >> how were you able to clean it up? >> how was the city able to address it without access? >> you know, that is a good question. Greg? >> it's a loaded question but it is not meant to be. I honestly just wonder. >> so you want to come up here real quick? >> thanks. >> this is greg with water collection supervisor. >> council? Good evening. For the most part, when we have a spill in these types of locations, we try to contain as much as possible. So for the most part, you use what we can to stop the spill and clean-up is really old- school. Shovels, buckets, wheel barrels, and you try to follow the amount of overflow down the hill as far as you can and in this case, because it was so many days and because of the rain event that we had, we have to assume at this point, because we have no way to prove it didn't get into the river, and that is why it wasn't considered a cat one. Hah subpoena ever that is our down and dirty way of cleaning. >> thank you, greg. >>> so what had happened. This was another location. This is manhole 7 on the map. And as the city was in there and staff was in there cleaning the portion of the spill that was occurring up above, you know, with I put our equipment in, and tried to clear wherefore the blockage is. Well, we ran across another blockage, and you can see two rocks inside the pipeline here. The fortunate thing is the city was out there and was able to see this. We couldn't get the truck into in location. as part of an emergency repair, city staff used a backho and the bucket of the backho to clean and just remove the soil and take it into a pile for disposal. So that is what was done in this specific area. This is on a flatter part of where the suer line physically sits. Gentlemen had some meetings directly with the creek working group. They have sent a couple of representatives for the entire group on a couple of different locations wherefore, myself. Steve has been involved in one meeting. Greg and others have been involved and way have sit down and listened to the various ideas of feedback that we have received. One thing I do want to make sure is everybody has had full access to all the documents that we have had. So anything that the city and staff has done, all that information has been provided to the residents as well. Way have been sure to provide representatives with that, and they have just let us know that those that would need it. They would make sure to receive the information. Initially, when this was first proposed back in January of 2015, this was one of the alternatives that the city staff had reviewed, and this is the proposed access road alignment. This area that is in orange, dashed in orange, that is the alignment of the suer line. That is the easement that has been provided for that suer line as well as the manholes that are in that location. That is canyonrim drive, and american rim canyon drive up here. And then oak avenue is down here. That was one potential option that was discussed. A second option which did not have access through oak avenue but through here, there is an easement through homes here, but what we found is it is not likely that the equipment could get through that spot when you have the eves of the house overhanging in a fence at the neighbor's. So this one was not fully considered in its entirely. -- entirety. These were the two initial options we looked at just from an access point of view. This is -- a lot of it. It probably doesn't encompass everything that we heard, but it encompassed I think, a majority of the high points, and I am sure our neighbors will let you know if I missed any later this evening, but you know, I won't read through them. These are all included in the staff report as well. But this is just a list of items that we have heard throw this process. Flushing, cleaning, and closed circuit television, inspection, so the city did bring out a contractor to perform the same type of services that our staff would do. Is there something different that they would be able to do relative to our staff or equipment or our operations would entail, and we found that it is almost identical in terms of what is done. Their equipment is still a truck. It May be just a different brand or model. And there are tv camera inspections. The same type of camera. It is just maybe a different brand or model. So what we found is there was nothing different in what they did compared to what we would do and that is only to flush clean and inspect under the existing conditions as they are today. And inspection results. So what we did throughout the actual inspections of the pipeline itself was identified what we have labeled as the five high priority segments of the pipeline. And these include deposit build- up. Cracks in pipes, and then rusted castiron pipe which the contractor nor the city were able to actually inspect. Our cameras just would not move through the pipeline. That they got about ten feet in and the camera would not go any further. You can see from the picture what the pipeline looks like. These are the high priority segments. We have labeled them four, five, eight, nine, and ten. You believe somewhere right sheer where the pipeline was prepared. If you are physically out there, there is on the lower latter part of where this pipeline sits in the field. That is how with I are able to get our backhoe to that location. Pipelining, pipe bursting, replacing the pipe in place so using the same trench, you just dig and replace, or replace and realine. Is there a different alignment that could be used that would really do the same thing and convey the waste water from the upper end to the lower end? And the evaluation of community impact, impacts to trees, potential construction cost and the constructible of that recommendation. Or the analysis shows. So through all this, these were the proposed recommendations for each one of the segments. So segment four through ten, four, five, eight, nine, and ten. You could see replace and realine sections four, five, and eight. Replacing segment ten. That did provide physical construction access with equipment on fairly flat ground there. So that is what this table remits. One thing that we have done and you know, in was also brought up by the hinklecreek working group is considering flow- moaning asen aearly alarming. It doesn't prevent vandalism. It doesn't prevent debris build- up but it did uz monitor and alarm if waste water in that manhole reaches a certain elevation. And then consider the report also considers modifying the temporary construction access into a permanant access. So when a contractor goes in, somehow some way that equipment is going to have to get in there. In my equipment and others, it's not likely to occur on a hillside that looks like this out in the field. So something will have to be done if we November forward with replacing the pipeline or realining the pipeline. Physical access will be needed. There is what the proposed alignment will look like. What we are trying to do specific any in area is to eliminate the suer line and the suer manhole that is physically in what we do is abandon that pipe in place. Maybe we can go in and cap the manhole. We would have to figure that out. That would be an original in those locations. We do not plan to go in and take the existing pipe out. We don't want to get in people's backyards. We don't want to dig up in and around pools or patios. We don't want to inconvenience the homeowners any more than what this alignment would do. >> marcus, could we fill it with sand just so we don't end up with a sinkhole in somebody's yard inth future? >> yeah, we might be able to fill it up. Typically, we'll cap the end. We can take care of all that. That is a good point. Thank you. This would get realined this way. Just again, better flow characteristics in a suer manhole. So here you can see it comes down and almost gets past 90 degrees coming back in this direction which isn't ideal in a suer system, so we would hope to seize this transition here, and then reconnect at this and then move down in direction, and so here would be replaced and then again replaced here. This area here is really the only one we considered not replacing so we didn't want to dig through the creek or cause any disturbance, so pipe bursting seemed to be the best alternative without creating the land disturbance or getting inth creek itself. Proposed access. Anywhere from 10 to 12 feet wide what our goal is to try to get in area as close to ten feet wide as we can. I'll show but it on a couple of slides later. This does not have proposal to pave the access, to put concrete down on the access or concrete pavers on the access. Our goal is to put down an aggregate pace of 206 nine inches or proposed granite and come back with some topsoil and let the natural vegetation come back to life. What we are looking for is just something stable to drive on that provides us the access we need for that clean-up. Well, I guess I stole the thunder on my next slide. Here is what we are trying to do. Alternatives that we did eliminate. One is a deep gravity suer and city pump station and the city right of way. If you are out there, there aren't any vacant lots or any vacant spots to put a suer pump station. That was one that was eliminated but it doesn't mean it is completely off the table. We just didn't think that was the right way to go. And then individual residential pump stations at each one of the homes homes than have to put city pump stations in. I'll show you here because if you are in this cul-de-sac here, we would have to put in a pump station to pump up to a main line in the street here. As you can see, all these homes are built, and I don't believe we're going to find a spot to put a pump station. A couple of other alternatives eliminated but for different reasons -- reasons. This this really addresses noncompliance with the suer system. One is just a clone flush to rely on continued basis. And not fix the damage to the pipe. And it wasn't something that I would personally recommend and I don't think anybody else in our staff would recommend that. And it doesn't go far enough, and it doesn't meet the ss andp or the general order. You'll hear more about this this evening but the neighborhood 4 four-point plan which again to us just doesn't go far enough. We don't disagree with the four points in there. We don't disagree that each one of those taken individually is ask can be used in a suer demeanor. The item number two. Item 7 which requires vacuum truck access, or to be able to vacuum up a suer spill. The four-point plan, nor the first dash does not address that. And so those are the reasons why we cannot move those forward as recommendations. It doesn't meet the general order requirements and it does not meet what city council has adopted in the suer city management plan. Our risk analysis of the prop posed recommendation. As you can see here, these are the number of trees trees inventoried and what I want to be clear on is if you physically go and walk the site, I don't you May count 1757 trees that have a tag on them. Those are tagged for identification purposes. Those are not tagged to state that that tree is coming out. So I just want to be real clear that this proposal on the recommendation as it is shown does not have the removal of 175 trees, and that is something that May, you May have heard, but I just want to be real clear that that is not the case. The number of protected trees by the folsom ordnance or the my mismillion code is 141. Out of that 141, out of the 175, threes that have an impact to their critical root zone are if numbers listed. A critical rod zone impact of greater than 10%. Which in our meetings with two different arborists that we have had in this process, any impact to that root zone that typically 25% or greater. The likelihood of mortality or, you know, death of that tree is higher and you know, closer to 100% than less than other 25%. But what we did, we went a little more conservative and asked the consultant and the arborist to mark it. The that is 20%. Just so we knew we were at least more conservative or safer than the number, and you can see that number here. It is 06 if we only do the repairs and don't do anything else. And it adds another 17 if we include the permanant access as a final project. So 77 in total that are greater than 20%. Of that 77, though, 43 of those are rated two or lower. Trees rated at three or higher is 34. And so so there are 175 trees total that have been marked. They are not called for removal. Those that would be required or called for removal are 34. That require mitigation. Hi just want to be real clear that those are the numbers we're working with, and that is all in the staff report as well. And this is the table that has been updated for item 8a. >> but so marcus, overall, ask two are lower. >> with the impact greater than 20%. You it's safe enough to say that two or lower is dead or dying trees. three or higher is healthy trees. So proposed construction cost. I highlight -- highlighted these two items. It is slightly different and I'll explain why. We're looking at about 40,000% to physically get equipment out there to do the repair work. That is all this line item covers. In permanant what would be required to take that construction access that is provided to construct the project and turn that into a permanant access. But again, it doesn't include pavings. It doesn't include asphalt and doesn't include concrete pares so that is not included included and in that is not proposed by city staff. So in total, you're looking at about 400,000% for the project. Sit different than the 1.1 or 2.2 million that you May have heard. If you look at the budget, that line item in the budget accounts for three different sites that we are working on. This just happens to be one of the three. So the line item of the american river canyon suer access project encompasses three different projects and this number is for this specific location. >> and so this project in general. And you are making 25 contingencies so it could actually be less than that. >> it could be. Or depending on what the outcome is, tonight, it could be more. I guess I'll find out later this evening. >> and but and if you need one; correct? >> the proposed width that we have -- correct me if I am wrong could handle the existing equipment that we have. >> and the weight of that truck? >> yes. The design of the access, the final access would be to include the volkswagens that we currently have. And not anything smaller. And so in order to go from the temporary to permanant, obviously we would have to finish grading correctly based on cut and fill elevations in the design and install small retaining walls where they May be needed along the hillside. Place and compact the aggregate base or some other mixed aggregate material for the vector access and then place suitable topsoil for revegetation. We're not concerned by replacing topsoil because if we know below it, we're stable, then our equipment will be able to get through to the locations that we need. Plus,we fool that it, you know, blends in although it is flat, it will help blend in with the natural vegetation and that is there. And permanant access finish again will not be paved. It will not have asphalt concrete and will not have concrete pavers. -- concrete pavers. So our next steps, if staff recommendation moves forward is complete the necessary design to make the improvements available for bid, complete the environmental review, bid the project and complete construction. And each one of these items, I would anticipate based on cost will come back before city council. So in summary, and this is where my presentation ends, the city operates the suer system under the general order which specifically requires vacuum removal of spills. It is spelled out straight leg raising clear to us, and it is spelled out very clearly in the ssnp. So the emergency response plan in the city's improve -- approved. Council ssmp calms for removal of sanitary suer overflows or spills. And our recommendation complied not only with the city adoptive ssmp but also the general order and with with are trying to do this while men mizeing impact. >> so questions for marcus before we get to -- >> yeah, just out of curiosity. Strong timelines. >> if all goes as planned tonight and recommendation moves forward to do as staff has recommended, I would imagine springtime of next year, we would be able to start construction. And it is probably a three- month construction window given, you know, getting not there and fixing the pipe and then returning it. >> okay, thank you you. >> I have a question. Let me ask you about the truck. i am not much of a truck guy, but I need to ask you a question. Have you ever taken the truck to a temporary site? New in up to, and does it work? Basically what you are telling me you are going to build a temporary site and go ahead and do thely pairs. And improve that site a little bit. And then the vacuum truck can go. And at that point on, it can always go in in. Is that correct? >> that is correct. >> do you have any experience? Have you ever taken it on that type of road? >> and I have to defer to greg on this one. I know we have taken it into alleys that are not paved. Now, I don't know what if construction of alleys are, but we have taken them into nonpaved, nonconcrete alleys. I don't know if we have other offsite locations where we have taken our truck. But if they have and, I don't know the sites on whether or not they have been designed properly to hold the weight of a truck or any equipment for that matter which is slightly different than what we are proposing, but greg, maybe he can help answer that. I have haven't operated one of those before, so you -- so to answer your question, one is a three axel and one is a two axel. The two axel. We have our current factor. Should want we rocked at six different runs before we looked at the ones we have now that would meet these requirements. We also had to limit the tank on the water to meet the type of grade that we wanted to reach. The truck will holiday hold up to a thousand gallons of water. Of the weight on the whole truck on the pack end is under the 20,000 pounds. Up. >> is your minimum that the state requires for a weight of a truck? That is a minimum. As opposed to the other truck with ten yard, three body. That one holds 1500 gallons. This is 600. So it is designed to. For that portion of it and to get into alleys that have seemed to have shrunk in the stay. You have these trucks in alleys? >> we do. Yes, that's kind of -- a challenge; right? >> it is a challenge. You can see it kind of too a little bit with the garbage. They bought a smaller vehicle to make sure we could could get down those alleys? >> are there smaller trucks than what we have? >> there are smaller trucks. The problem with them is they are a truck-mounted type of vehicle, and they have very limited debris. And so the purpose of this is so that we would have three to five yards to contain a spill. They have a limited 500 gallons for those types of trucks. The smaller trucks that we put on a 550. they have tiny debris. You wouldn't gain any access or any, you know, leverage by pulling that truck out there. Now, that would be good for the cleaning process of it. You can go up and clean and do whatever you need to do. If we had an overflow, and type two, there is no way that truck would contain what we would need to contain. >> and it is safe to say that a smaller truck would not yield a narrower access pathway? >> yeah. It wouldn't yield a narrower bath -- pathway because it takes a certain amount of width. >> I am certain martin is going to bring this up. We also looked at pull behind trucks and those types of vehicles. But the problem is that when you get into packing -- backing up any type of vehicle like that and getting it into place, we would need to be wider than the ten feet we proposed. You can't snake the rear end to make that turn. It would be 12-foot, at the minimum of 15. You would have to have bigger hammerheads to get back around. >> thank you. >> is that good? >> if nebraska wants to buy their own truck, you know what to look for now. Right? So any other questions for marcus? >> no. >> okay. Thanks, marcus. Stand by. Okay, so what we have coordinated with and I have been working with john, the working group appoint -- pointman, I believe for in. So john got. John has got ten minutes, and then is it. So sod has got five minutes. And then just by way of numbers with I got about 50 speaker request cards, and for the record, we have 50 request cards that were turned in for people that did not want to speak. I just want that on the record. That is how many were submitted I assume in opposition to the recommended staff report here. So I just wanted that available for the record. With that number of speaker cards, I think we can still do the three minutes. That wasn't mean necessarily that you have to take all three minutes. Okay, so if you want to say john hit it out of the pack, that is exactly what I agree with, that is just fine. So with that, john, if you want to get us started here, and yep. >>> before I begin a presentation and comment on marcus's presentation, I wanted to set the record straight. An article in the acura men toe news and review reported city council members did not meet with us. Well, I didn't write the article, I wanted to publicly apologize to whoa both had met with us face-to-face. >> thank you, john. >>> okay. So -- we have the timers running. I didn't count that. >> you are a good man. >> and city of folsom, california distinctive by nature. The city of folsom has a great motto. Distinctive by nature. Tonight will determine if this. We have been working for two and a half years now to develop a plan building a strong road to vacuum out solid waste. The facts. The creek is about areas about 40 acres. The road would be three quarters of a mile extending through the heart of the park. It serves 28 homes and 40 years the city has been maintained. Good maintenance of the story line is the very best. 98% of the mark on the items that listed in the cause of overflows in markets and staff report can be prevented with routine and camera inspections. In the last 14 years, the city soonation team attended to the line an average of only 2.4 times per year with two reported overflows during the 14-year period from 2002 to 2015. In August of 2016, we work with a city who contracted with a professional firm to do a camera inspection, line cloning and postcamera inspects which was completed without having to place one wheel. All 19 segments were clean and flushed and 148 segments were camera inspected with the exception being the iron pipe u. There were only six times when hoses. And very cooperative with access. Prior to flushing, we had agreement from two homeowners adjacent to each manhole who agreed to provide access through their property. The key point here is that the suer line can be maintained in service. The 1000-foot high pressure hose can access every manhole in the seat and the solid waste can be removed using the debris basket. The problem began in February of 2014. It was approved by the city council. And 7765 already dollar. Widing canyon and reconditioned the riverrock road. The purpose of the road is to allow maintenance volkswagens, access to suer lines that are accessible. The city desires to construct access roadways and is seeking civil engineering designs. The succeed in business and the city as well, it's critical to know that problem that you are looking to solve. If your problem you are trying to solve to get to a manhole, you build a road. If the problem is to insure that the suer line is properly maintained to prevent overflows with a minimum negative impact, the solution looks a lot different than a road. And and the existing suer line. We agree with what marcus presented in terms of the repairs necessary. Inspect the line annually which normally is done once every five years. And the manhole cover which reports blockages and use industry of standard debris basket to remove solid waste verses vacuuming. and a popular basket here. The way it works is very simple. You go downline and you flush the flush line up. Very high pressure. It clears the degree and clears the blackening -- blockage and you put a debris basket and lower it into the manhole and you collect the waste. You let the waste flow down the suer. The liquid flows down the suer and the solid waste is removed. Our alternative was developed by talking with experpetrators in the business. Grand hills university of washington civil engineer. He has 25 years of experience. 100 employees and tv trucks. In my opinion, you performed regular climbing and video inspection of the lines to insure their cleanliness. And then you could maintain the line functionality of the system without truck access to each manhole. Chris stanley, south lake tahoe public utilities and waste management. We would rather drag high- powered water hoses and use a debris basket rather than build a road to accommodate a truck. Just last monday, we met and visited with a northern california firm that has 15 employees and will double to 16 million%. We spoke with a lead truck operator who has been with the firm for seven years. The city of folsom has 249 miles of gravity suer. This gentlemen cleaned and serviced well over 249 miles last year. the owner asked him how often did he use his debris basket verses the vacuum on his vacuum truck. He responded that he used the debris basket 99% of the time. Why we asked? Unlike the vacuum, you see exactly what is in the line. And provide customers with a better idea of the condition of the line. He reports and the debris for each section. He also says it is faster and more efficient. And to adjust proper depth. He lowered the basket. He said that flushing an eight- inch suer line segment would no produce enough solid waste to fill the starbucks cup. Why would you go all the effort to assemble? He smiled and said I wouldn't use the truck even if there was a road. We asked the owner if their debris baskets verses vac you'lls was shafered by owners. He said let's ask them and he dialed the number for a large county in sacramento area. The owner asked him if he preferred debris baskets or truck vacuuming. His response was rarely do I use a vacuum truck vacuum. When we asked him why, he said with three baskets you can see what is causing the blockage which allows us to do better documentation what the issue was and confirms the problem has been removed. Then we asked him how do you handle spills in open unpaved areas? He said normally they rake up the solid debris and flush for disinfectant and the only time they remove the soil is if there is a toxic element or waste and they send a you out to remove the infected dirt. So side-by-side comparison shows the city plan and our plan insures the line gets cleaned and emergency access. Ours has the additional benefits of protecting natural beauty. It is financially more prudent and it provides an early warning system. Now this was a slide to talk about that the city concerns and how they evolved over time and our solutions that will be constructed. It was playing. And I only want to focus on the last one. For now. And that is in June of this year was where there is overflow, with I need to vacuum trucks to vacuum up the spill including the ground. Now, let's step back for a second. If the loin is repaired, and the size is upgraded. If the loin is flushed and cameras inspected annually. And days of advanced warning. And that situation, if an overflow occurs and if the or flow cannot be cleaned by removing solid waste. And the soil needs to be removed and treated. We don't need the truck. >>> and the creek suer line is not a suer main. This line is not large as the one going. And huge volumes of waste. To equal the size of the 700,000-gallon other spill in 2000, the entire line would have to overflow 24 hours for about 70 days. So last week, I met with palmer to review the proposal. And ever comment and all of suffer us is were good. But he was the person responsible should something go wrong. And he felt the building rode with the best alternative. I respect the opinion, but I believe the proposal. It doesn't change the fact that we believe our proposal will work. And also the proposal demonstrates the city's willingness to asure the creative alternative to insure matter naps and our nature areas are protected. We would like to ask the city council to oversee a review to determine if our alternative will work. And select experts outside the city of folsom and to I did side if our four-point plan will work. If there is a positive response to our plan, trees will be saved and the staff will have an expert validation that our plan was up to industry standards. And it May be well that is from the ordergroup to understand how they deal with exceptions to their truck requirements. We understand it is embarrassing to pay a quarter million dollars to design a road that doesn't get built and we understand sanitary workers might not like to pull a one inch hose over fences. The truth is we don't need a road to maintain the suer line period. In is a policy decision by the city council. If the policy of the city is to be this did tintive by nature -- if the policy is to be distinctive, you need to double check with outside experts before you proceed to build a road. We are absolutely convinced that we have an alternative plan that is a win/win for all and insures the suer line is maintained at a worldclass level, saves money and trees and demonstrates to your constituents in you can listen and try new approaches that demonstrate your commitment to your motto to distinctive by nature. Thank you very much. >> all right. John, you hit that ten minutes within a second. That was admirable. >> I worked all day on it. >> thanks, john. >> next speaker, please. >> your next speaker. >> and you have five minutes. >> good evening. You May I request an extra five minutes to do my presentation. >> no. John and I talked about this earlier, so yeah, I just want to maintain what we agreed to. So five minutes. That is a lot of time. >> okay. Thank you. First of all, my name is todd. I am faculty at the university of sacramento. I am a prophesier in engineers. -- engineering. I have my outline. >> could you have him talk in the microphone. I am having trouble hearing him. We need to pick up on tv. >> sure. My presentation was prepared for 15 minutes and now I cut down for five minutes. I have a master's debris in ph.D. And civil engineering and marketing resources. I have three and a half years of con summiting experience. And working on projects. And to a large side, 20 million size projects and water, waste water, and storm suer systems. And I have 13 years of academic experience. Two yores in sacramento state wheren you lest all the water resources program activities and the hydrology, and modeling, and water resources and so forth. And published in journals. Invited as keynote speaker and presentations. That is my background. The problem is mainly the city -- we agree with the city's approach to prevent. But we disagree with the way to implement that approach for preventing. The city proposes to upside the pipeline and the suer line and realine it two manholes. The cost of the activities was about 400,000 plus 30,000% for road upgrade. And they proposed also to build a 10 to 12-feet road at a cost of about a million dollars. I think marcus mentioned the presentation in August, 2016. One of line items of the cost of one of these roads is 1 million%. they want to use a truck and mitigate to the cost of 16,000%. Our proposal is repair and up upside the suer lines. Annual maintenance. And install warning systems and use degree basketting. -- baskets. Our opinion, we agree with the city's proposal to upside and realine and install two manholes. The reason we agree is to improve the hydrolic performance of the line. To preserve the environment and the potential for city. And however, we agree with the city's proposal to build permanant road for the cost of 1 million% for the suer line. Why we disagree with the city? And annual maintenance, flushing can be achieved with a fraction of the cost of the construction of the road. As john mentioned, we consulted with several companies. One of them. They said that the annual flushing and servicing will be 16,000%. Why you disagree with the cities cities. And without capitol investment if we use that, and it is going to maintain for 06, years. Easiest does not -- does not always mean it is the best or the better solution in this case. Why we disagree with the city? We want to preserve the environment. We want to protect trees, save taxpayers a lot of dollars in that regard. Why we disagree with the city. We want to make sure that there is no adverse effects of the construction of that road and resident's safety we disagree with the city because because we want to have a community action participation in the city of follow? The pros of this approach or the approach we have are a lot more than the cons that are proposed for that project. Maintaining and flushing. Insuring hydrolic performance. It improves hydrolic performance performance. Based on 45,000 to 06,000 pounds. Paved road. I don't think it would support this weight of vehicle. Even lighter version other ever that truck will cause adverse effects on the economy. Early-warning system to. Make sure how effective this. 1 shun gallons per day per capita. We assumed a 2.5 factor which 14. And then 50%. We insured that when we did that calculation, we made sure that the capacity of the line will coo were churr the flow from the 28 homes. This line southbound 50% or greeter. Having this issue, the capacity of the line is enough to handle all those homes. >> okay, you're getting past your time here. No. We have to maintain the plan here that we agreed to. I'll give you another minute here, okay. All right. How many people are giving up their cards? raise your hand. Okay, so here is what I will do. If you folks. We're going to call your names and if what you want, is if you could, using the honor system here, please just say that I want to give up my time, and was glad to do it, and I agree completely or, you know, whatever. So if we could do that. Does that work for everybody? All right. Carry on. There. >> and then I'll go back to my previous slide. What we did is the hydrolic performance. >> and that was awfully tricky. >> and I try to get my point across. >> all right. Carry on. We did hydrolic performance of the suer line which is the six inch. We calculated what would be the capacity of that line, and then we performed the second analysis of low, medium to high flow from these homes into that suer line. And assuming that seven laterals as the low option. Medium. 14. And charging into the suer line and high with just 28. Notary public this case, we assumed each person in that home will discharge about a hundred gallons per day of waste water, and then we, based on that, we added a factor of safety of 2.5. So basically we added, doubled the flow, and based on our calculation that the flow from all these homes, 28 homes will be lesser than the capacity of that suer line. We used the line with the lowest slope which is.5%. That is almost a line with the least veries willty. If we service those lines, the potential is very minimal. And then based on that, we looked at 23 system. >> it is a viable ranges of motion. It is not new to the city. Modeling not real-time of those suer lines. And works against line blockage. And that was not discovered for two days. And the one marcus mentioned. And why it is a God option provides the city with ample time to get to the manhome and prevent instead of two days later and try to solve the problem. And refuse the potential. Allow the city to contain under more contaminated soil. And the service to nature and residents compared to city staff. And visits. 09% use baskets over the trucks. Why it is a good option. Effective in capturing waste. Efficient, required list time. To 14 set up and use. We do not need to drive to a manhole to vacuum the debris. Now why it is a good option. Allow for sewage. I think marcus mentioned that and john mentioned that. It will allow us to see exactly. and it comes up from each line. If there is an issue, we can direct the solution for that problem and that you segment of the suer line instead of getting that truck with a flurry of waste from several suer lines at the end of the day. In summary, our proposal addresses the city's concern of potential SFOs. Cheaper to implement that than the city's proposal. Friendlier than the city's proposal. Distinctive by nature, more efficient and effective than the city's promonth I sal. Support of our community proposal. And what our accommodation, we support the city's effort to preserve the environment and reduce the pope tential for sfo. We support you 100% in that effort. But we any the approach to that problem is overthrow in that case. We want you to include the suer line. And upsize and realine the suer line. Flush and maintain the suer line without the permanant construction. Install early warning system ask use debris to clean the line and -- which is the industry standard. And I want you to remember it is a compromise. What we are proposing is a compromise between nature and city without compromising our environment. It is a win/win situation. Thank you so much. hutch all right. Thank you u. >> yep. >> next speaker please. >> your next speaker. Mike will be followed by ashley. >> as we call the names if the next person up can just cue up. >> Mr. Good evening. And I am a grade five waste water operator from the state of california. And operator number 3700. And I have been in the field 40 years. The first three we did some suer work. I liked the proposal the group got together because it is fiscally responsible. I like the idea of annual inspection, and then I think the city or the staff could review it after five years and see if it functions. I like the realining going to the eight-inch pipe. I think that will cut down any potential suer spills and so thank you very much. Also, I like to think that -- I would like to thank the council for the bridge. I think you guys did a good choice on that one. >> thank you. >>> okay, your next speaker is ashley. And ashley will be followed. >> good evening, ash low e. >> good evening. I have no expertise on suer maintenance or trucks. >> after tonight? >> I have more than I started out with. My name is ash low titas. I am an attorney. I do have expertise on compliance with the political reformack and election code matters including conflict of interest rules. And I submitted a letter yesterday dated June 19 to the city attorney and council member howl regarding financial interest that May pose a conflict of is interest in her participation on this issue. Starting tonight until its conclusion. And the city attorney isn't me back a response this afternoon, so thank you for that. And without rehashing the letters which I know are part of the record, I just wanted to respond to what was submitted in the letter to me this afternoon. I think we have two areas of disagreement remaining, and one is that at this particular meeting, council is merely providing policy direction to staff and it isn't the governmental decision. And so at this stage, the interest rules don't apply. I have to disagree with that conclusion. Further the city attorney has advised that how the project ultimately implemented will not have financial effect on council member howell or her financial interest, quincy engineering, which as you know has a significant role in this project to date. I wanted to point out two critical nuances in the law that I think were sort of skipped over in the response letter today and encourage you to look into it more carefully after this meeting. First,staff is recommending very, very specific repairs and very specific action. This is not asking for direction. This is making four recommendations to the city council that are very precise and that have a clear financial impact on quincy and companies like quincy that have been city contractors in the past who will likely continue to be city contractors in the future. And regardless of whether quincy is actually going to be a bitter -- bidder on this work, it doesn't matter. The conflict of interest rules don't require that the financial interests actually be directly involved in the decision. But only that the decision provided an opportunity for that financial interest to be entitled to compete or be eligible for a benefit resulting from a decision if the decision will increase or decrease the need for the products or services that that financial interest applies. And even if quincy were to not bid, the fact that they are competitors are probably bidding has a financial impact on quincy as well. And these rules are not simple like deciding whether or not to build a road or not, the conflict of interest rules are complicated, and it is going to take more time than a couple of hours to think about, and I think that these concerns of the hinkle creek residents should not be dismissed so quickly. Thank you. >> all right. let's keep moving here. Response from Mr. City attorney. So we have reviewed the allegation of brought to our attention several weeks ago. So we have the time to contact a very thorough analysis and due to the fact that the council policy direction. And the council policy direction. You have options. There is no particular decision- making to exactly how this particular project will be implemented. That is the request for you to -- >> and the project as presented, if it is to be implemented, I don't know. That is the option as well. You May not be. The project proposed by staff will not have any involvement over quincy engineering because there is no request agenda tonight for a contract to be selected for a contract to be awarded, or for further work to be performed. We have concluded does not have a disqualified form of interest. >> hold on. That he does not have a conflict. Therefore, she play participate in this matter. >> okay. >> all right. Thank you, steve. >>> all right. So the next speaker, please. >> your next speaker is fred is followed by fred kindle. >> good evening, fred s. >> good evening folsom city council members. good to see you. My name is fred s. And for many years, I sat where you do now trying to balance the needs of the government and the needs of the community as a whole. Your objective, maintenance for the creek area. To date, the city's solution to this issue has been to cut down and solve the new numbers and see evening which will effectively destroy the eco system and the hinkle creek area as we know it today and certainly I have been involved in construction many years. I have not seen an area that has been hit by a d8 that does not have us really impactive scarring ending. To immaterial policemen this solution, you have already spent 268,000% and planned to spend maybe millions more. Of community tax dollars to complete this unnecessary road project. Yet you want to devote unknown additional funds to maintain this project each year. Unfortunately, this solution is massively expensive and will destroy the nature area that is home to many birds and animals, trees, and foliage. The community which you serve has that personal expense come up with an alternative plan where we have focused on the same goal which is you preventing sewage overflows mandated by the central valley regional water quality control board. The initial cost for the alternative plan will be 20,000% for flow monitors which will also include the cost to implement repair to the line. the alternative plan that our community supports has been modeled after other specific codes communities that have already implemented this alternative plan. They recognize that this alternative plan was needed to protect natural resources while properly maintaining suer maintenance. Way are reason to believe that the regional quality control board would look fayely unpaying passage of this alternative plan by the folsom city council just as it has with other communities that have many to deal with essentially the same problems. These communities have implemented alternative plan solutions to prevent their areas from unnecessary construction while continuing to maintain proper suer maintenance. Please vote yes for the alternative plan. It meets the goals of the creek project for untold numbers of dollars less than the city solution. More importantly, it preserves the hinkle creek to enjoy for generations to come. The alternative plan is a win/win solution for the city of folsom as well as the nature area at hinkle creek. Thank you for your consideration. You I let fred go over. >>> your next speaker is fred kindle and fled will be followed by sharon kindle. >>>next speaker is shane kendall. >> cordova and other places. everyone loves the park. Trees provide oxygen and absorb carbon dioxide and provides a sanctuary for wildlife and humans. Consider these credible. In one year they can absorb as much carbon as cars driving 26,000 miles. Seven to eight trees provide ax general for humans for a whole year. Trees are a fundamental component further more, it's great to value trees. The city solution to sewer maintenance in the creek nature area is critical. We ask for your help in preserving this unique park for generations to come. As you can see, from the chart, there was a need for robert to help protect the nature area and that has been impacted for thousands of years. He was not. The current staff report indicates 175 trees are impacted and to date, we don't know the total amount of phases of the protect or if final amount of trees being cut. What we do know is the road is half of the event actual length of the road sewer lanes. There's 141 protected trees. That does not mean they won't be cut down. Think about it. If these trees are about 75 to 100 years old, it's a lifetime before they're replaced. The nature area will be damaged forever. The best thing is we have plan b which will ensure that the sewer line is properly maintained while protecting our nature area. imemploy you to take our plan serious and up to our city's motto. Distinctive by nature. And not to approve save the trees and thallus us. [Applause] >> thanks, sharon. [Applause]. >> your next speaker is onlier butcher. Roger is followed by stacey shearman. >> good evening. Members of the counsel. All in attendance this evening, thank you so very much. [Applause] >> I'm a member of the work group and myself and others have been involved in getting out over 5800 fliers distributed. 3350 signs and talking with hundreds of residents to obtain signatures for our petition and I can tell you, there are many people that do not want to see the trees cut down and

Page

/

6

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFyhsT05PgChWIq0PmsEMyJxtSgRVcIWqX3LeO0piGacFMnUquZBZRAGtnarzNdwX5E0XXBb9T5Rhtcz-TgqB87wh7xMnWxoAI0BHtyaVkQx4lfIdHfiB7rWZVYYPkkk2Z6YFTfQWdMY_WnuGcitV0qvzBKxk8iO9sAYJLRYLiAkVAcdMsrZOnRNADeQDM4BCEnQmFvdA4o8wX6QsY5utbv9v4ukVJryn5GdwSFagOGd1ocXRgybsHJbNdtxrbjUfUZGUbA4ebntF_fAhwrdQOWNDks460KwnR_T6beJfGnwqT4_UnRbLFy9LhFmmAKKcmtkLRR_N_x8A3ShA-tXt18AOM17bQ%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

[http://www.folsom.ca.us/](http://www.folsom.ca.us/)

## Page 1 of 6

1

CITY OF FOLSOM CITY COUNCIL

SPECIAL MEETING

www.folsom.ca.us

FOLSOM CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS

50 NATOMA STREET, FOLSOM, CA

TUESDAY, JUNE 13, 2017

5:30 PM

Andy Morin, Mayor

Kerri Howell, Vice Mayor Steve Miklos, Council Member

Ernie Sheldon, Council Member Roger Gaylord, Council Member

AGENDA

1\. Call to Order

2\. Roll Call:

Council Members: Miklos, Sheldon, Gaylord, Howell, Morin

3\. Adjournment to Closed Session for the Following Purposes:

a. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation - Pursuant to Government Code section

54956.9(d)(1):

i. Grassl v. City of Folsom, et al.

Sacramento Superior Court Case No. 34-2015-80002007-CU-WM-GDS

ii. Jing Yao v. City of Folsom, et al.

Sacramento Superior Court Case No. 34-2016-80002446

United States District Court, Eastern District of California Case No. 2:16-CV-02609-MCE-AC

iii. Han, et al. v. City of Folsom, et al.

United States District Court, Eastern District of California Case No. 2:10-CV-00633-MCE-GGH

4\. Reconvene:

Announcement of Final Action, If Any

5\. Adjournment

![Page 1 of 6](blob:https://docs.google.com/81649cd5-57c7-4479-a888-6d931d40ca60)

[http://www.folsom.ca.us/](http://www.folsom.ca.us/)

## Page 2 of 6

2

Showing the first 24,000 of 149,478 characters. The full document is at the source.

based on experience through March of 2017. We'll start with a general fund. You can see on property taxes we are actually above what we had budgeted for in property taxes. It's a a5% increase over last year's tax. Were unshales tax, we are right in line where where we budget. It you looks strange because it was down from last year. 6789 that number came in right on target. Transfers in are above what we had anticipated due to some transfers in from the equipment replacement fund. So overall, our revenues are up slightly about 2.2% from previous year. It puts us in good standing. On the expenditure, the major expenditure categories, salaries are actually down from what was in the budget, so we're under budget for that, and it is a 1% increase over the prior fiscal year. The pen be fit on budget. That is your health cost. Onm is a little bit above where we expected to be for operation maintenance cost. Again, that was due to some equipment replacement costs. Both capital outlay and debt service are right on the budget numbers. We came in at 77 million which is about 4% over last fiscal year. You can sew summary revenue was above budget at 79 million. 2.2% above last year. Expenditures are below the budget authorization and they're up 4.4% from last yore. that leaves us our surplus which is higher than we anticipated have we we -- when we adopted the budget. That was expected to be 600,000. We believe 1 mt. 8 million. That would go to our unasyned fund balance, and so we thought we would be right around 15%. It looks like we'll come in at about 12.8 million or slightly over 16.5% which is above your policy level. You and temperature just shows the unassigned general fund balance of what has happened over since the recession and how you have drown the fund balance since then. So the general fund that we believe is going to come in good shape this fiscal yore. Again, we're overbudget on revenues and under budget on expenditures, and in we'll add to our fund balance. And in terms of the water enterprise fund, you can see that revenues have gone up slightly due to the end of the drought. We did hit our low point with that. We had come down from about 14.5 million several yores ago and with the restrictions on water use, that came down to 12.2, and now, it has turned back up. That was anticipated. Our expenditures are right in line with our budget numbers and our working capitol is at a good healthy level where we would like to keep it. The one thing I would point out is the difference between revenues from charges and our operating expense, and you'll see that is about at 1.6 million. That number is a little short if we want to continue our pay as you go capitol project. We would like to see that up about another million. So that is something we will watch for in the future. On the waste water enterprise fund, again, for services has gone up slightly with some new development. Expenses are right in line with what was budgeted. Working capitol is right in line again at a good healthy number. The difference here is the 2.1 is right on the low end of where we would like to be with that difference again to maintain our pay as you go capitol program. We like to have that somewhere between two and two and a half. We are in good shape, but we'll continue to watch that. Solid waste, again, the revenues have gone up somewhat with some new homes being built in service. Our expenses are right on target with what was budgeted and we're at the level we would like to be for our working capitol again, the difference is 1.3 million. That is where we would like to have that number be so we can continue to update the assets and solid waste being mainly the vehicles. The transit fund is mainly funded through the transit district and governmental funds as you can see, and it is primarily a break even operation and continues to be that way. our operating expenses are right in line where with -- with where we are projected. Our working capitol is the same. The risk management, internal service fund, the charges and revenue was down somewhat. That was a planned change there year where we reduced the rate somewhat. Although our operating expenses were a little higher than we anticipated, we still have a very desirable unrestricted net position the one thing is we are watching these four areas of cost as you can see over the last two years, all of those have increased and we will be watching and trying to manage the growth of those costs. Our internal service fund. We had reduced the charge again this year and last year was 5% of salaries here. It was 3% in these years. For next year, we reduced that and the budget you adopted. The 2.5%. This number on buy outs was lower than we had anticipated. Given the early retirement program. We thought this would be more up around the 1.3, 1 mt. 4 range. So the result of that is we have a very healthy fund balance in this fund. The tree planting revenue fund. We had more revenue than we had anticipated so your fund balance is higher than we anticipated by 150,000. And those are the major funds. I'll open up for questions and comments. >> thank you for that. As always, any questions for jim. Very clear. Could everyone give jim a nice round of applause for that rivetting -- I best counsel day ever, -- council day ever? >> I'm going to mark this down. Okay, thank you, jim, again, and the next item, please. >> the next item is business from the floor. This is the opportunity for members of the public other a -- to address the city council to concern items within the council's jurisdiction. >> any request to speak notary public. >> you have no request to speak under business from the floor tonight. >> all right. The next item, please. >> the next item is your consent calendar. >> and so that consent items a through n. >> okay. >> I'll go ahead and second. Council member nicholas. >> sheldon, gaylord. >> howl, and moreen. With that, I think we're up. Where are we at? Okay, new business. There we go. Your first item under new business is item 8a. This is the request for city council direction on the design of improvements associated with the sewer system improvement project. >> all right. The main event. So, just one little formality here. We're just fine with everybody in the chambers here. we want y'all to be here and stay, but if those near the doors if we could just keep pathways clear. That is all we ask just so we can maintain. So with that, marcus. >> mayor moreen, council members. And environmental and water resources director. The item we have before you tonight is the hinkle creek sewer system improvement project. Just a brief outline that I would like to take you through. The need for the project. Staff engagement with the community and the community's engagement with the city. The alternative analysis prepared by our consulting firm. The analysis concluded in that information. Staff recommendation, and then for next step. This oh is basically the system that the city maintains. I won't go into all the details, but this is before you in terms of the number of pump stations that the city operates and maintains. In 200 ever, the state water resources control board adopted a general statewide waste discharge requirement we refer to as general order which had various requirements that were needed by an agency who serves a suer service or more. In August of 2017, this became effective for the city of folsom. In July of 2009, city council adopted the city's first sanitary suer management plan or suer system management plan. this was updated and readopted in July or August of 2014. The city con soucts audits. Threads on odd number yores. Then we'll have another one probably in about two months this year. Whatever I really would like to point out in the general order itself and in is directly from the general order section b, item 7 which requires what the city needs to do. That is to take all feasible steps and necessary reimmediate y'all yule actions. You can read the control, the limit, or the volume of discharge, to terminate the discharge which basically means make it stop. It states in order to do that, the city must have an emergency response plan which would be consistent with the following. That includes items one through six here, and if you note item number two. And item number four is system modifications. Those are going to be key elements this evening in which we, staff, and myself build this entire presentation, and you'll see later in the presentation, the reasons for staff's recommendation. So these are all under the general order and all requirements by the state. So we are not deviating from any of these requirements. Section d, item 7, the yen order, requires certain items. The one thing I will mention again is that it also requires a suer system management plan which I discussed a short while ago. Way turned it into how the city operates and maintains. Adopted by council in 2009 and the 20 s and the city has an emergency response plan for suer overflows or suer spills. All this is available. I can also point them to the link, so we can get that to them. It isth hundred pages. It takes a while to upload. This goes into the maintaining the overflow and the clean-up requirements. I wanted to point out the plan that was prepared by staff and updated and adopted by city council reflects requirements of the general order which the city operates to. We're following the rules and regulations as hay the have been written by the state and as has been adopted by city council. I just wanted to share some results you can see from the chart here. If you look at just spills this line here in blue are the city numbers. The red is a state average and you can see from this chart here based on the number of spills that occur over time from the peak in 2000 down to, you know, the end of 2016, this is how the city has performed. And a lot of the credit goes to orb staff who are out there every day following the maintenance plan that has been adopted by city council and meeting the requirements of the general order. These aren't your staff reports but just compliments from not only regional board staff of the central valley regional quality control board. just in terms of how the city is performing you relative to the city and the state. The city has been invited to discuss our plan and to discuss how the city moved from that peak in 2000 to the numbers that we see in 2016. And so a lot of this is a direct result of what the general order requires but a direct result of what was adopted by city council and the rulebook in which way play. So the need for the project. -- project. There are a couple of different items. One is from operations to maintenance standpoint. There are sags offset at the joints in the pipeline itself. And I'll have the map that shows the alignment and shortly, but it also does run through the backyard so the suer line is in people's backyards and there are manholes that are in people's backyards and there are some portions of the pipe that cannot be inspected because of the pipe type. I'll show a little bit more information. In addition to just general operations maintenance, we also need safe and reliable access for several different reasons. One, to perform the routine that we need which includes flushing, cleaning, and inspection. So getting our tv equipment in there, and sanitary suer overflow or suer spill response. >> you one that is suer factor truck access. And right now, the current lay of the land, the city does not have that access, and this was made very available -- it was made very clear to us in October and November of 2015 when there were two spills in that area that we did not have access to with a suer truck to vacuum up the spill as we're required to do. So this, just a little bit more detail on the spill. This is a manhole in the backyard were on 1 canyon rim drive. On the map I will show you in a couple of slides. Manhole number two. Identified spills caused by grease deposits. They were eventually cleared. The approximate volume of the spill is about 3000 gallons. The spill did occur during the rain. One of the things we had to do in this particular case is the spill, I believe, occurred or started on a saturday, but was not reported to the city until monday. So we were not made aware of when this was happening. And typically when we go out to the site, we can look at the spill and identify that. That is about five gallons a minute, ten gallons a minute. What we had to do is use some of the city numbers to determine what the approximate volume was. >> how were you able to clean it up? >> how was the city able to address it without access? >> you know, that is a good question. Greg? >> it's a loaded question but it is not meant to be. I honestly just wonder. >> so you want to come up here real quick? >> thanks. >> this is greg with water collection supervisor. >> council? Good evening. For the most part, when we have a spill in these types of locations, we try to contain as much as possible. So for the most part, you use what we can to stop the spill and clean-up is really old- school. Shovels, buckets, wheel barrels, and you try to follow the amount of overflow down the hill as far as you can and in this case, because it was so many days and because of the rain event that we had, we have to assume at this point, because we have no way to prove it didn't get into the river, and that is why it wasn't considered a cat one. Hah subpoena ever that is our down and dirty way of cleaning. >> thank you, greg. >>> so what had happened. This was another location. This is manhole 7 on the map. And as the city was in there and staff was in there cleaning the portion of the spill that was occurring up above, you know, with I put our equipment in, and tried to clear wherefore the blockage is. Well, we ran across another blockage, and you can see two rocks inside the pipeline here. The fortunate thing is the city was out there and was able to see this. We couldn't get the truck into in location. as part of an emergency repair, city staff used a backho and the bucket of the backho to clean and just remove the soil and take it into a pile for disposal. So that is what was done in this specific area. This is on a flatter part of where the suer line physically sits. Gentlemen had some meetings directly with the creek working group. They have sent a couple of representatives for the entire group on a couple of different locations wherefore, myself. Steve has been involved in one meeting. Greg and others have been involved and way have sit down and listened to the various ideas of feedback that we have received. One thing I do want to make sure is everybody has had full access to all the documents that we have had. So anything that the city and staff has done, all that information has been provided to the residents as well. Way have been sure to provide representatives with that, and they have just let us know that those that would need it. They would make sure to receive the information. Initially, when this was first proposed back in January of 2015, this was one of the alternatives that the city staff had reviewed, and this is the proposed access road alignment. This area that is in orange, dashed in orange, that is the alignment of the suer line. That is the easement that has been provided for that suer line as well as the manholes that are in that location. That is canyonrim drive, and american rim canyon drive up here. And then oak avenue is down here. That was one potential option that was discussed. A second option which did not have access through oak avenue but through here, there is an easement through homes here, but what we found is it is not likely that the equipment could get through that spot when you have the eves of the house overhanging in a fence at the neighbor's. So this one was not fully considered in its entirely. -- entirety. These were the two initial options we looked at just from an access point of view. This is -- a lot of it. It probably doesn't encompass everything that we heard, but it encompassed I think, a majority of the high points, and I am sure our neighbors will let you know if I missed any later this evening, but you know, I won't read through them. These are all included in the staff report as well. But this is just a list of items that we have heard throw this process. Flushing, cleaning, and closed circuit television, inspection, so the city did bring out a contractor to perform the same type of services that our staff would do. Is there something different that they would be able to do relative to our staff or equipment or our operations would entail, and we found that it is almost identical in terms of what is done. Their equipment is still a truck. It May be just a different brand or model. And there are tv camera inspections. The same type of camera. It is just maybe a different brand or model. So what we found is there was nothing different in what they did compared to what we would do and that is only to flush clean and inspect under the existing conditions as they are today. And inspection results. So what we did throughout the actual inspections of the pipeline itself was identified what we have labeled as the five high priority segments of the pipeline. And these include deposit build- up. Cracks in pipes, and then rusted castiron pipe which the contractor nor the city were able to actually inspect. Our cameras just would not move through the pipeline. That they got about ten feet in and the camera would not go any further. You can see from the picture what the pipeline looks like. These are the high priority segments. We have labeled them four, five, eight, nine, and ten. You believe somewhere right sheer where the pipeline was prepared. If you are physically out there, there is on the lower latter part of where this pipeline sits in the field. That is how with I are able to get our backhoe to that location. Pipelining, pipe bursting, replacing the pipe in place so using the same trench, you just dig and replace, or replace and realine. Is there a different alignment that could be used that would really do the same thing and convey the waste water from the upper end to the lower end? And the evaluation of community impact, impacts to trees, potential construction cost and the constructible of that recommendation. Or the analysis shows. So through all this, these were the proposed recommendations for each one of the segments. So segment four through ten, four, five, eight, nine, and ten. You could see replace and realine sections four, five, and eight. Replacing segment ten. That did provide physical construction access with equipment on fairly flat ground there. So that is what this table remits. One thing that we have done and you know, in was also brought up by the hinklecreek working group is considering flow- moaning asen aearly alarming. It doesn't prevent vandalism. It doesn't prevent debris build- up but it did uz monitor and alarm if waste water in that manhole reaches a certain elevation. And then consider the report also considers modifying the temporary construction access into a permanant access. So when a contractor goes in, somehow some way that equipment is going to have to get in there. In my equipment and others, it's not likely to occur on a hillside that looks like this out in the field. So something will have to be done if we November forward with replacing the pipeline or realining the pipeline. Physical access will be needed. There is what the proposed alignment will look like. What we are trying to do specific any in area is to eliminate the suer line and the suer manhole that is physically in what we do is abandon that pipe in place. Maybe we can go in and cap the manhole. We would have to figure that out. That would be an original in those locations. We do not plan to go in and take the existing pipe out. We don't want to get in people's backyards. We don't want to dig up in and around pools or patios. We don't want to inconvenience the homeowners any more than what this alignment would do. >> marcus, could we fill it with sand just so we don't end up with a sinkhole in somebody's yard inth future? >> yeah, we might be able to fill it up. Typically, we'll cap the end. We can take care of all that. That is a good point. Thank you. This would get realined this way. Just again, better flow characteristics in a suer manhole. So here you can see it comes down and almost gets past 90 degrees coming back in this direction which isn't ideal in a suer system, so we would hope to seize this transition here, and then reconnect at this and then move down in direction, and so here would be replaced and then again replaced here. This area here is really the only one we considered not replacing so we didn't want to dig through the creek or cause any disturbance, so pipe bursting seemed to be the best alternative without creating the land disturbance or getting inth creek itself. Proposed access. Anywhere from 10 to 12 feet wide what our goal is to try to get in area as close to ten feet wide as we can. I'll show but it on a couple of slides later. This does not have proposal to pave the access, to put concrete down on the access or concrete pavers on the access. Our goal is to put down an aggregate pace of 206 nine inches or proposed granite and come back with some topsoil and let the natural vegetation come back to life. What we are looking for is just something stable to drive on that provides us the access we need for that clean-up. Well, I guess I stole the thunder on my next slide. Here is what we are trying to do. Alternatives that we did eliminate. One is a deep gravity suer and city pump station and the city right of way. If you are out there, there aren't any vacant lots or any vacant spots to put a suer pump station. That was one that was eliminated but it doesn't mean it is completely off the table. We just didn't think that was the right way to go. And then individual residential pump stations at each one of the homes homes than have to put city pump stations in. I'll show you here because if you are in this cul-de-sac here, we would have to put in a pump station to pump up to a main line in the street here. As you can see, all these homes are built, and I don't believe we're going to find a spot to put a pump station. A couple of other alternatives eliminated but for different reasons -- reasons. This this really addresses noncompliance with the suer system. One is just a clone flush to rely on continued basis. And not fix the damage to the pipe. And it wasn't something that I would personally recommend and I don't think anybody else in our staff would recommend that. And it doesn't go far enough, and it doesn't meet the ss andp or the general order. You'll hear more about this this evening but the neighborhood 4 four-point plan which again to us just doesn't go far enough. We don't disagree with the four points in there. We don't disagree that each one of those taken individually is ask can be used in a suer demeanor. The item number two. Item 7 which requires vacuum truck access, or to be able to vacuum up a suer spill. The four-point plan, nor the first dash does not address that. And so those are the reasons why we cannot move those forward as recommendations. It doesn't meet the general order requirements and it does not meet what city council has adopted in the suer city management plan. Our risk analysis of the prop posed recommendation. As you can see here, these are the number of trees trees inventoried and what I want to be clear on is if you physically go and walk the site, I don't you May count 1757 trees that have a tag on them. Those are tagged for identification purposes. Those are not tagged to state that that tree is coming out. So I just want to be real clear that this proposal on the recommendation as it is shown do

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Folsom City Council Regular Meeting
  • Folsom City Council Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 823d663b8acae5ff5571323879eda9bc. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record