POLISCOPE

The public record

OAKLEY (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Oct 8, 2019 - 01:39 PM

Tuesday, October 8, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Oct 8, 2019 - 01:39 PM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 74,356 stored characters

>> DUE TO FAMILY EMERGENCY SHE'S OUT AND THEN MR. POPE IS GONE ON POLICE DUTY, WHICH IS VERY IMPORTANT THING HE HAD TO BREAK AWAY CITY COUNCIL MEETING FOR. I'M FILLING IN BEING THE VICE MAYOR, WELCOME. I HAVE A PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT BEFORE WE GET STARTED. IT CONCERNS MOST EVERYBODY WITH PG&E TALKING ABOUT THE POWER OUTAGE, SO I HAD OUR CITY MANAGER CALL TODAY AND WE WERE INFORMED WE ARE NOT IN THE AREA TO HAVE POWER TURNED OFF AND IF WE DO GET PUT IN A AREA WHERE THE POWER WILL BE PUT OFF IN OAKLEY WE'LL IS A 48 HOUR NOTICE AND IF YOU ARE ON OUR E-MAIL WEBSITE OR WHATEVER, YOU WILL BE NOTIFIED WHEN WE GET THE ANNOUNCEMENT AND ALSO ON THE READER BOARD OUT HERE THAT WILL BE ANNOUNCED OUT THERE ALSO SO THAT WILL BE 48 HOURS, BUT EVERYBODY WHETHER THERE WAS POWER OUTAGE OR NOT GOING TO HAVE ONE, WE SHOULD ALL BE PREPARED TO BE WITHOUT SERVICES 2, 3 DAYS, WATER, FOOD, JUST SAFETY PRECAUTIONS. WITH THAT, AGAIN, WELCOME. WE WILL START OFF WITH ROLL CALL. [ROLL CALL] TONIGHT'S PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE IS DONE BY GIRL SCOUT TROOP 33784. WELCOME, GIRLS. >> AND ONE MORE SHORT ANNOUNCEMENT, IT IS SUE HIGGINS BIRTHDAY TODAY SO WANT TO WISH HER A HAPPY BIRTHDAY, SUE. (APPLAUSE) OKAY, 1.3, SWEARING IN OF OAKLEY POLICE DEPARTMENT EXPLORERS. LIBBY WILL DO THE HONORS. >> THANK YOU VICE MAYOR. I'LL TURN IT OVER TO CHIEF CHRISTIANSON FOR A MOMENT TO PROVIDE INTRODUCTIONS REGARDING THE PROGRAM AND THEN WE'LL TAKE CARE OF THE SWEARING IN. >> GOING TO RECOGNIZE PEOPLE WHO HAVE COME INTO THE PROGRAM AND NOW WE'LL SWEAR THEM IN AS MEMBERS OF THE POLICE DEPARTMENT EXPLORER PROGRAM. THE POLICE DEPARTMENT EXPLORER PROGRAM ALLOWS YOUNG ADULTS TO COME AND LEARN WHAT IT IS LIKE AND IT IS A HANDS ON PROGRAM LEARNING WHAT IT IS LIKE TO BE INSIDE THE POLICE DEPARTMENT. GIVES THEM SOME LIFE SKILLS ASSOCIATED TO MEETING WHAT WE CALL MENTORS IN THE PROGRAM ITSELF, WHO AGAIN BUILD THAT RELATIONSHIP AND CREATE THAT BOND FOR A LATER IN LIFE THAT THEY HAVE AN ADULT THEY CAN TALK TO, AT THE SAME TIME THEY LEARN HOW TO BE A POLICE OFFICER AND THE IDEA OF THE PROGRAM FOR US IS THE IDEA OF HOPEFULLY WE BRING THE NEXT GENERATION INTO LAW ENFORCEMENT FOR OUR COMMUNITY IT IS A GREAT PROGRAM AND IT ALLOWS US TO HAVE PEOPLE THAT ARE OFFICERS CAN HAVE CONTACT WITH SO AGAIN, I ALWAYS TELL PEOPLE WE GET AS MUCH OUT OF IT AS THE INDIVIDUALS WHO PAR TACE PATE IN THE PROGRAM, OFFICERS AND MEMBERS OF THE STAFF GET THAT AS WELL BACK FROM THEM. TONIGHT WE ARE HERE TO RECOGNIZE A COUPLE PEOPLE WE'LL SWEAR INTO THE PROGRAM AND ALSO GO THROUGH AND RECOGNIZE TWO INDIVIDUALS WHO WILL BE PROMOTED TO SERGEANT ACTUALLY OF THAT PROGRAM AS WELL. SO, WHAT I LIKE TO DO IS BRING EACH OF THEM UP. I'LL READ A BIO ABOUT EACH OF THEM AND HAVE LIBBY COME FORWARD AND SHE'LL SWEAR THEM IN AND WE'LL RECOGNIZE THE INDIVIDUALS BEING PROMOTED TO RANK OF SERGEANT IF THAT'S OKAY WITH YOU. THE FIRST I LIKE TO BRING UP TYLER WILLIAMS. TYLER IS HERE WITH HIS PARENTS MELISSA AND DANIEL WILLIAMS. RECENT GRADUATED FROM INDEPENDENT HIGH SCHOOL AND JOINED THE EXPLORER PROGRAM BECAUSE HE WANTS TO BE A POLICE OFFICER WHEN HE GROWS UP AT 21. (APPLAUSE) NEXT WE HAVE DIEGO GONZALES, HE GRADUATED FROM FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL DIEGO IS ATTENDED LOS MEDANOS COLLEGE AND PLANS GETTING A BACHELORS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND WANTS TO BECOME A POLICE OFFICER WHEN HE GRADUATES FROM COLLEGE. (APPLAUSE) NEXT WE HAVE SEAN KIERY, SEAN'S MOM AND DAD AND STEP DAD ARE DOREEN AND CLARENCE SOLANO. HIS FATHER IS ERIC KIERY. SHARE RECENTLY GRADUATED FROM FREEDOM AND HAS PLANS TO JOIN THE AIR FORCE. INTERESTED IN A CAREER OF LAW ENFORCEMENT AFTER HE SERVES IN THE MILITARY. (APPLAUSE) NEXT WE HAVE ANITA ZUGUNA, HER PARENTS ARE SALLY AND EDUARDO ZUGUNA. ANITA GRADUATED FROM FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL AND STARTED ALT LOS MEDANOS COLLEGE AND WANTS TO TRANSFER TO A 4 YEAR COLLEGE FOR A BACHELORS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND INTERESTING IN SERVING HER COMMUNITY AND INTERESTED IN A CAREER IN LAW ENFORCEMENT. (APPLAUSE) NEXT WE HAVE KIMBERLEY GARCIA, HER PARENTS ARE PATRICIA A[INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] SENIOR AT FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL. BECAME INTERESTED IN A CAREER IN LAW ENFORCEMENT AFTER COMPLETING THE OAKLEY PD MENTORING PROGRAM. KIMBERLEY PLANS GOING TO COLLEGE AFTER HIGH SCHOOL AND WANTS TO BECOME A POLICE OFFICER WHEN SHE GRADUATES. (APPLAUSE) MAX CORDOVA HIS PARENTS ARE SANDY AND MARX COR DOVY. GRADUATED FROM FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL AND ATTENDED LMC. MAX JOINED THE PROGRAM TO LEARN MORE ABOUT LAW ENFORCEMENT AND WANTS TO ONE DAY BECOME A FBI AGENT. (APPLAUSE) ALEJANDRA PENIA, HER PARENTS ARE FELIPE AND ALICIA PENIA GRADUATED FROM FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL AND WANTS TO GET A DEGREE IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND WANTS TO BECOME A POLICE OFFICER ONCE GRADUATING FROM COLLEGE. (APPLAUSE) AND THEN TWO OF OUR CURRENT MEMBERS OF THE PROGRAM LIKE TO BRING THEM UP. WE HAVE JULIA SARTAIN, HE GRANDPARENTS ARE CHUCK AND (INAUDIBLE). JULIET HAS BECOME A EXPLORER WITH OUR PROGRAM ABOUT 2 YEARS NOW. WANTS TO BE A K-9 HANDLER WHEN SHE GRADUATES COLLEGE. LAST LIKE TO BRING UP DANIEL ROMERO AND DANIEL IS WITH OUR EXPLORER PROGRAM APPROXIMATELY 2 YEARS NOW AND HE IS TAKING CLASSES IN LMC AND WANTS TO JOIN THE FBI WHEN HE GRADUATES AS WELL. (APPLAUSE) Two OTHER INDIVIDUALS I LIKE TO BRING FORWARD IS CASEY MINISTER. CASEY IS OUR EXPLORER PROGRAM MANAGER, SO CASEY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CREATING PROGRAMS. ONCE A MONTH THE GROUP MEETS, THEY GO THROUGH A TRAINING TOPIC AND CASEY IS THE LEADER OF THIS GROUP SO OFFICER CASEY MINISTER. (APPLAUSE) I LIKE TO BRING GABRIELA (INAUDIBLE), ME AND WE PROGRAM IN CITY OF OAKLEY. ONE THING WE DID LAST YEAR IS PARTNER WITH THE POLICE DEPARTMENT WITH YOU ME AND WE PROGRAM. THE IDEA IS REACH OUT MORE TO MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY AND WITH GABBY'S HARD WORK WE DID A 6 WEEK PROGRAM OF A MENTORING PROGRAM AND A LOT OF PEOPLE YOU SEE IN FRONT OF US ARE BECAUSE OF HER WORK SO GABBIE, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR EVERYTHING YOU DO. (APPLAUSE) AND WITH THAT, LIBBY, IT IS ALL YOURS. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR, THAT I WILL SUPPORT AND DEFEND, THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES, AND THE CONSTITUTION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AGAINST ALL ENEMIES FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC, THAT I WILL BEAR TRUE FAITH AND ALLEGIANCE, TO THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES, AND THE CONSTITUTION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, THAT I TAKE THIS OBLIGATION FREELY, WITHOUT ANY MENTAL RESERVATION, OR PURPOSE OF EVASION, AND THAT I WILL FAITHFULLY DISCHARGE, THE DUTIES UPON WHICH I SHALL ENTER. (APPLAUSE) >> LAST THING WE LIKE TO DO IS RECOGNIZE JULIET AND DANIEL FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP ASSOCIATE WOULD THE PROGRAM ITSELF. THE RANK OF SERGEANT IN OUR EXPLORER PROGRAM MEANS THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR SEVERAL MEMBERS OF THE PROGRAM AND RESPONSIBLE WHEN WE GO TO PUBLIC EVENTS AND PARTICIPATE IN GROUP EVENTS THEY ARE SEEN AS A LEADER OF THAT GROUP. JUST LIKE OUR REAL POLICE OFFICERS WHO WEAR THIS RANK ON SHARE SHOULDER THEY WEAR IT ON THEIR CALLER SO THE IDEA PEOPLE WITH RECOGNIZE THAT RANK AND THEN IF THEY NEED HELP OR ASSISTANCE IN ADDITION TO WHAT THEY CAN GET FROM A REGULAR EXPLORER THEY RECOGNIZE THAT IS SOMEBODY WHO IS IN CHARGE OF THE PROGRAM ITSELF. FOR US IT IS A GREAT RESPONSIBILITY ON THEIR SHOULDERS AND SHOWS OUR TRUST AND DEDICATION AND CONFIDENCE IN WHAT THEY DO FOR THAT. WHAT I LIKE TO DO IS INTRODUCE ALL OF YOU TO SERGEANT DANIEL ROMERO AND SARGENT JULIET SARTAIN. (APPLAUSE) THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF OUR PROGRAM IS, IS THAT NOW WE GET TO GO OUT AND TAKE PICTURES WITH THE FAMILIES SO IF YOU ARE A MEMBER OF ONE OF THE FAMILY MEMBERS OF ONE OF OUR PROGRAM MEMBERS HERE, IF YOU CAN PLEASE COME OUT WITH US IN THE HALLWAY AND WE'LL TAKE ALL THE FAMILY PHOTOS THAT WE NEED TO TAKE. AGAIN, CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL OF YOU. (APPLAUSE) >> WE'LL GIVE EVERYBODY A MINUTE TO FILE OUT. AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR SERVING EVERYBODY'S IN OAKLEY. ALL YOUR NEIGHBORS AND FRIENDS, THANK YOU. I KNOW GABBY IS KIND OF SHY BACK THERE BUT SHE IS ONE OF OUR STARS HERE ON STAFF AT THE CITY OF OAKLEY AND SHE'S QUITE THE STAR AND MUCH APPRECIATED. IF ANYBODY HAS A PUBLIC SPEAKER CARD THEY WOULD LIKE TO FILL OUT, THE BLUE CARDS IN THE BACK IF YOU WANT TO FILL IT OUT, ANYTHING YOU WANT TO SPEAK ABOUT NOT ON THE AGENDA TURN IT IN UP HERE TO LIBBY AND YOU WILL BE BROUGHT UP WHEN THE TIME IS APPROPRIATE WHICH IS IN ABOUT 10 SECONDS HERE. SO, WE ARE OPEN FOR PUBLIC COMMENT. I DON'T HAVE PUBLIC SPEAKER CARDS NOW SO WE'LL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENTS AND GO TO THE CONSENT CALENDAR BUT WE'LL PULL 3.5 AT THIS TIME. >> MOVE THE REMAINDER OF THE CALENDAR. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> SO MOVED. 3.5, MR. GEORGE FULLER WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THAT. YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES ONCE THE LIGHT FIRED UP THERE, GEORGE. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. ALWAYS GLAD IT TO SEE LAW ENFORCEMENT STEPPING OUT. I LOVE THE BADGE. IT HAS THE RESEMBLANCE. IN 2013 THE CITY OF OAKLEY APPROVED A LOAN WITH THE PRIVATE DEVELOPER FOR $935 THOUSAND ALL MOST A MILLION DOLLARS. 2013 THE FIRST INCREMENT WENT OUT, $343 THOUSAND I BELIEVE IT WENT OUT AND 4 YEARS LATER THE CITY FINALLY DETERMINED THAT THE MONEY HAD BEEN EMBEZZLED AND THERE IS A WARRANT OUT FOR THE PERSON'S ARREST. THE POINT IS WE COULD PUT THAT AMOUNT OF MONEY FOR PRIVATE DEVELOPER. WE HAVE THE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] PARKING LOT ACROSS THE WAY FOR THE MEDICAL BUILDING. IT IS BOUNCING BALL AS FAR AS I CAN SEE AS TERMS OF THE COST, AND IT IS BEING PUT UP FOR PRIVATE DEVELOPER, AND IT IS GOING TO COST THE CITY A HUNK OF CHANGE. THE LOAN DOWN AT THE RESTAURANT, $74 THOUSAND AT 4TH AND MAIN TO FRINKS THE RESTAURANT I DON'T SEE A LOT OF ACTIVITY GOING ON THERE, SO I'M STANDING BEFORE YOU, IS THE CITY GOING TO SAY THAT A MINIMUM, I HAVE BEEN REPORTED TOLD IT COULD BE A MINIMUM OF $44 THOUSAND THAT THE CITY COUNCIL IS NOT GOING TO ALLOW THE CONSTITUENTS OF THIS CITY TO VOTE IN TERMS OF MR. HARDCASTLE COUNCIL MEMBER HARDCASTLE'S REPLACEMENT. INSTEAD, THEY ARE GOING TO GO ON THE IDEA OF SAVING $44 THOUSAND. THE CONSTITUENTS THE CITIZENS ARE LOOKING FOR A VOTE. A CHANCE TO CHOOSE WHO IS THERE, AND YES, AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED AN APPOINTMENT OF ONE DAY IS TOO MANY AND A YEAR IS A LIFETIME SO ASKING A NO VOTE ON 3.5. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS. WITH THAT-NO MORE COMMENTS ON 3.5. DO WE HAVE A MOTION? >> IS THERE ANY COUNCIL COMMENTS? >> I HAVE COUNCIL COMMENTS. >> GO RIGHT AHEAD, SUE. >> THANK YOU. I REALLY WANT TO VOTE AND THE REASON I REALLY WANTED TO VOTE WAS BECAUSE I THOUGHT WE SHOULD HAVE A VOTE. IT IS IT TRANSPARENCY IS THE THING TO DO, AND THEN I START OF THINKING ABOUT, IF I WAS THE ONE THAT HAD TO RUN TO GET A VOTE, I WOULD BE RUNNING FOR LIKE A YEAR AND A HALF, BECAUSE YOU WOULD GET THAT POSITION THAT YOU LOBBIED FOR THAT YOU ADVERTISED FOR, THAT YOU SPENT A LOT OF MONEY FOR, IT IS A VERY EXHAUSTING AND THAT IS A LOT OF BURDEN TO PUT ON SOMEONE FOR THAT-FROM NOW UNTIL MARCH TO GET A VOTE AND IF YOU WANT TO RUN AGAIN, AGAIN THAT BURDEN. SO, I THINK IT IS MORE THEN $44 THOUSAND. THE LAST FIGURES I SAW WERE CLOSE TO A HUNDRED THOUSAND. I KNOW WE ARE VERY PRUDENT AND FRUGAL WITH OUR MONEY AND MAN, I THINK I HAVE BEEN PUT HERE FOR A REASON AND A REASON IS TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS ON WHO TO APPOINT. >> THANK YOU, SUE. ANYTHING, KEVIN? >> NO, OTHER THEN TO SAY, YES, WE HAVE GIVEN OUT LOTS OF LOANS, I MEAN NOT LOTS OF LOANS, WE HAVE GIVEN LOANS OUT FROM SPECIFIC PILES OF MONEY. AS ANYBODY WHO MANAGES MONEY, MAYBE NOT AT THE CITY LEVEL, THIS ISN'T LIKE YOUR HOME WHERE YOU HAVE A BIG BUDGET AND SPEND DOWN YOUR BUDGET. WE HAVE MONEY COLLECTED AND SPENT ON SPECIFIC ITEMS THAT CANT BE USED TO RUN ELECTIONS FROM, AND SO THIS WOULD COME FROM OUR GENERAL FUND, AND AS COUNCIL MEMBER HIGGINS STATED, THIS PERSON WOULD HAVE TO RETURN CAMPAIGN NOW, RUN IN MARCH AND IF ELECTED IN MARCH WOULD HAVE TO RUN AGAIN IN NOVEMBER AND SO THE BURDEN ON THE PEOPLE TO DECIDE TO RUN WOULD BE TO ME WOULD BE FINANCIALLY DIFFICULT TO DO TO BE IN ESSENCE IN THE CAMPAIGN MODE FOR THE NEST YEAR AND A HALF. NOT YEAR AND A HALF BUT QUITE A LONG TIME. I WOULD MOVE THE ITEM 3.5 AND IN FAVOR OF THAT. >> HAVE A MOTION. >> I'LL MAKE A MOTION THAT WE ACCEPT 3.5. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> OPPOSED? >> SO MOVED. OKAY, 4.1. YOU LIKE TO FILL OUT A BLUE CARD AND STATE YOUR NAME. YOU CAN'T TALK FROM OUT IN THE-- >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> PARDON ME? NO, WE VOTED TO APPOINT A CITY COUNCIL MEMBER AT OUR NOVEMBER 12 MEETING. AFTER PEOPLE HAVE FILLED OUT APPLICATIONS AND GONE THROUGH THAT PROCESS. RIGHT. THANK YOU. OKAY, 4.1. TWIN OAKS SENIOR RESIDENT MIXED USE PROJECT CUP 02-19D R 07-19 AND WE'LL HAVE A RECORD FROM KEN STRELO. >> THANK YOU AND GOOD EVENING VICE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL. SO, THIS HERE IS A PROJECT FOR A MIXED USE AFFORDABLE SENIOR HOUSING APARTMENT COMPLEX. THERE ARE THREE ENTITLEMENTS BEFORE THE COUNCIL. ONE IS FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE MIXED USE COMPONENT OF THE PROJECT IN COMMERCIAL ZONE, THE OTHER IS DESIGN REVIEW, ARCHITECTURE, SITE PLAN, LANDSCAPING, ETCETERA AND THE DENSITY BONUS HOUSING AGREEMENT WOULD BE WITH THE THIRD ENTITLEMENT. THE DETAILS OF THE PROJECT, THERE IS 130 APARTMENT UNITS, ACTUALLY 129 IS AFFORDABLE AND ONE IS EXEMPT AS A MANAGER UNIT AND THE SITE IS 6 ACRES IN SIZE LOCATED JUST EAST OF THE OAKLEY TOWN SHOPPING CENTER SO DOWN THE STREET NEXT TO THE LUCKY SHOPPING CENTER AND IT IS A VACANT SITE. YOU SEE A LARGE OAK TREE OR OAK TREES IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SITE AS YOU PASS BY. ZONING FOR THE SITE IS GENERAL COMMERCIAL, AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION IS COMMERCIAL. THIS IS THE LOCATION HERE, WITH MAIN STREET RUNNING JUST ON THE NORTH PORTION OF THE SITE. AND SURROUNDING USES TO THE NORTH INCLUDE MOSTLY SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DETACHED. TO THE EAST OF THE SITE IS THE SAME. MOSTLY SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DETACHED. THE TO REST IS OAKLEY TOWN CENTER ANCHOR BIDE LUCKY AND RIDE AID. CONTAINS APPROXIMATELY 110 THOUSAND SQUARE FEET OF RETAIL AND FOOD OR UNITED USES. TO THE SOUTH THERE IS CITY DETENTION BASIN THERE AND ALSO A EXISTING SENIOR APARTMENT COMPLEX THERE. THAT IS ONE AND TWO BEDROOMS WHICH IS SIMILAR TO THIS PROJECT. JUST A FEW OF THE OTHER DETAILS, THE MIXED USE COMPONENT DOES INCLUDE APPROXIMATELY 5667 SQUARE FEET OF PUBLIC AVAILABLE RETAIL SPACE. THIS IS ALONG THE NORTHWESTERN PORTION OF THE PROJECT AND FRONTS ON TO MAIN STREET. THERE IS OTHER FRONTAGE ON MAIN STREET AND AS OF RIGHT NOW THE ENTIRE FRONTAGE WOULD NOT BE OPEN TO THE PUBLIC SO TO SPEAK, SO WOULDN'T BE BUSINESSES, IT WOULD BE MOSTLY ANCILLARY USE TO THE APARTMENT SO THE LOBBY, THE LAUNDRY, THE LEASING OFFICE AND ALL OF THAT. THE PROJECT IS LAID OUT WITH A RESIDENTIAL COURTYARD AND IN THAT COURTYARD IT HAS A LOT OF ACTIVITY USES, A POOL, BOCCIE COURTS, BBQ, THE EXISTING OAK TREES ARE BEING PRESERVED ON THE SITE AND THOSE WILL ACTUALLY BE COMPLETELY PRESERVED SO THE ROOT SYSTEMS WILL BE PROTECTED THERE. AND THIS IS THE CONCEPTUAL LANDSCAPE PLAN. THE TOP IS THE NORTHERN PORTION WHERE MAIN STREET FRONTS AND THEN THE MAJORITY OF THE PARKING THAT YOU SEE AROUND THE PERIMETER IS FOR THE PRIVATE RESIDENTS AND THOSE WOULD BE ACCESSES THROUGH VEHICLE GATES AND NOT OPEN TO THE PUBLIC. AND THIS IS A RENDERING OF THE PROJECT SITE. YOU ALSO HAVE THIS IN YOUR PLANS. THIS WOULD BE FROM THE NORTHEAST CORNING LOOKING DOWN SO YOU CAN SEE THE RETAIL ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE BUILDING THERE, KIND OF THAT TOP RIGHT CORNER. YOU SEE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT KIND OF DESIGN TO THE BUILDING, THAT WAS DONE INTENTIONALLY BY THE ARCHITECT TO KIND OF LEND A DIFFERENT APPEARANCE TO THE RETAIL PORTION THAT IS AVAILABLE FOR OUR GENERAL PUBLIC. SO PER THE DENSITY HOUSING DENSITY BONUS HOUSING AGREEMENT, THIS IS 100 PERCENT AFFORDABLE PROJECT AND REQUESTING THE MAXIMUM OF 35 PERCENT INCREASE PER STATE LAW AND THIS JUST GIVES A EXAMPLE OF HOW MANY UNITS WILL BE ALLOWED UNDER THE EXISTING M17 OR 17 UNITS PER ACRE, IT IS 98 WITH THIS DENSITY BONUS IT IS UP TO 132. THEY ARE RE QUESTING 130 WITH ONE BEING A EXEMPT UNIT. THIS IS FOR 62 YEARS OF AGE AND UP AND THIS DENSITY BONUS HOUSING AGREEMENT WOULD REQUIRE A 55 YEAR DEED RESTRICTION ON THE PROPERTY SO THEY HAVE TO BE MADE TO AFFORDABLE SENIORS OF 62 YEARS AND UP. CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT INITIAL STUDY WAS CONDUCTED BY RABY PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT. IT WAS FOUND THERE WOULD BE NO SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS BUT THERE ARE SOME MITIGATIONS MEASURES REQUIRED FOR THE PROJECT TO BE LESS THEN SIGNIFICANT AND THOSE HAVE TO DO WITH CULTURAL RESOURCES, BIOLOGY, SO THE HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN PRE CONSTRUCTION SURVEY AND COMMON MITIGATION MEASURES SO SAY THERE IS NOTHING WITH THIS PROJECT THAT IS UNUSUAL. WITH 130 UNITS THE NUMBER OF VEHICLE TRIPS WOULD BE APPROXIMATELY 41 IN THE A.M. AND I BELIEVE AROUND THE SAME, 37 OR SO IN THE P.M. VERY MINIMAL VEHICLE TRIPS DURING PEAK HOURS FROM THIS TYPE OF USE. WE DID RECEIVE ONE COMMENT LETTER ON CEQA. THEY CAME AFTER COMPLETION OF THE STAFF REPORT. HOPEFULLY YOU HAVE THAT MEMO WITH YOU. IT AVAILABLE IN THE BINDER AS WELL FOR THE PUBLIC FROM CONTRA COSTA COUNTY MOSQUITO VECTOR CONTROL WITH QUESTIONS ON WHETHER THIS PROJECT WOULD CREATE MORE BREEDING HABITAT FOR MOSQUITOS AND VECTORS OR JUST PROVIDE AREAS WHERE THEY COULD POTENTIALLY PROLIFERATE AND BE A HAZARD TO HUMANS AND OUR CONSULTANTS TOOK A LOOK AND CAME UP WITH A GOOD RESPONSE THERE AND THAT IS THAT, THOSE DESIGN STANDARDS ARE WORKED INTO STORMWATER TREATMENT, SO THAT THOSE DO INFILTRATE AND DON'T LEAVE STANDING PONDS SO ANY INCREASE TO THAT WOULD BE MOSTLY FROM PRIVATE RESIDENTS, WITH POTTED PLANTS ON PORCHES, NOT ANYTHING WE CAN MITIGATE WITH THIS. AND THEN THERE ARE A COUPLE MODIFICATIONS HERE. IF THE COUNCIL DOES CHOOSE TO APPROVE THIS PROJECT, STAFF ASK THESE MODIFICATIONS ARE AT LEAST MADE. ONE OF THEM IS SIMPLY JUST TO REMOVE SOME CFD CONDITIONS IN THE RESO AND COVERED BY ONE ALREADY IN THERE SO THERE IS REDUNDANCY THERE AND NUMBER 33 WOULD BE REQUEST FROM THE APPLICANT TO HAVE SOME MORE FLEXIBILITY ON HOW THEY NOTIFY THE PUBLIC DURING THE CONSTRUCTION PHASE. I BELIEVE THE CONDITION WAS WRITTEN WITH THE WEEKLY UPDATE AND THEY SAID THEY JUST DON'T HAVE AT TIMES THAT MUCH GOING ON WITHIN THE COURSE OF A WEEK SO THEY LIKE MORE FLEXIBILITY TO GIVE UPDATES THAT KIND OF COME AND GO AS THINGS CHANGE WITH THE PROJECT AND THEY FEEL THEY WOULD BE BETTER INFORMATION TO SEND OUT. AND THEN THERE IS THE OTHER THIRD BONUS, THE DENSITY BONUS HOUSING, AND THIS WAS ANOTHER REQUEST FROM THE APPLICANT. WE REVIEWED IT, IT MAKES COMPLETE SENSE AND IT IS BETTER TIMING WHEN HUD COMES OUT WITH RENTS AND WHEN THEY NEED TO NOTIFY THE SIT AF OF THE RENTS SO IT WOULD BE AFTER HUD RELEASES THE RENTS WE GET TO KNOW WITHIN A MONTH. JUST REAL QUICK SUMMARY OF THE FINDINGS, FOR THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT DESIGN REVIEW, THERE IS A LIST OF REQUIRED FINDINGS IN THE ZONING ORDINANCE, STAFF MADE THOSE IN THE STAFF REPORT AND RESO AND WE ALL FINDINGS HAVE BEEN ABLE TO BE MADE SO TO SPEAK AND THE RECOMMENDATION IS TO ADOPT BOTH RESOLUTIONS, ONE IS FOR THE ADOPTION OF THE CEQA MITIGATED NEG DECK AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AND DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL AND THE SECOND IS FOR THE DENSITY BONUS HOUSING AGREEMENT AND AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO THAT AGREEMENT WITH THE DEVELOPER. THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION, I KNOW THE APPLICANT IS HERE AND THEY DO HAVE A PRESENTATION THEY ASKED TO DELIVER IF THAT'S OKAY AND I CAN PULL IT UP HERE. THANK YOU AND I'LL ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. >> WE WANT TO GO AHEAD AND BRING THE DEVELOPER UP NOW? OR WOULD YOU LIKE TO--SURE. PLEASE. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> NO, I KEEP IT. IT IS MINE FOREVER. WHAT? WE'LL GIVE IT BACK TO YOU. HE MIGHT ANSWER QUESTIONS FOR YOU BEFORE YOU. >> GOOD EVENING, MY NAME IS MO[INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] WE ARE THE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY HERE BEFORE YOU PROPOSING THE SENIOR HOUSING DEVELOPMENT. THE DEVELOPMENT IS 130 AFFORDABLE UNITS. THANK YOU. THEN WHAT? OKAY. THANK YOU. PERFECT. 130 SENIOR RENTAL HOUSING UNITS. 1 BEDROOMS AND 2 BED ROOMS. THEY WILL BE-THERE IS RESTRICTION FROM THE CITY THROUGH THE DENSITY AGREEMENT FOR 55 YEARS, THERE IS RESTRICTION FROM THE STATE FOR 55 YEARS AS WELL, SO THEY WILL DUPLICATE EACH OTHER SO IT IS RESTRICTION BUT THE STATE LEVEL AS WELL AS THE CITY LEVEL AS A REQUIREMENT OF THE FUNDING PROGRAMS WE WILL USE AS WELL. THE STATE AGREEMENT ALSO REQUIRES 62 PLUS OF AGE, SO THE AGREEMENTS LINE UP FAIRLY WELL. AS A DEVELOPER OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING, THAT IS ALL WE DO, WE DON'T DO MARKET RATE, WE ONLY DO AFFORDABLE HOUSING. IN THIS CASE WE DO MIXED INCOME BY STATE REQUIREMENTS BUT THAT IS TYPICALLY A PERCENTAGE. THIS DEVELOPMENT IS MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT THAT WILL SERVE THE COMMUNITY MOST OF OUR SENIOR DEVELOPMENTS WE RARELY ADVERTISE, IT IS TYPICALLY WORD OF MOUTH. SOMEONE DRIVES BY OR LIVES IN THE COMMUNITY AND WANTS TO BRING THE PARENTS IN. I DON'T KNOW THE LAST TIME WE ADVERTISED ON ANY SENIOR COMMUNITIES, THEY ARE TYPICALLY WAIT LISTED IN THE COMMUNITY. WHILE WE CAN'T DISCRIMINATE AGAINST ANYONE WHO COMES IN AND REQUEST A APPLICATION, BUT THE FACT IS, IN ORDER TO DO THAT YOU HAVE TO KNOW ABOUT IT. THERE WOULD BE A INTEREST LIST ESTABLISHED AND SET UP AND SO ON AND SO FORTH. COST OF DEVELOPMENT OVER THE LAST 25 YEARS DEVELOPED GROUND UP OVER 280 DEVELOPMENTS NATIONWIDE. WE DEVELOP AND RETAIN THE ONLY DEVELOPMENTS WE DONT RETAIN HAPPEN TO BE A INVESTOR OR JOINT PARTNER. ANYTHING WE DEVELOP WE RETAINED AND KEPT SOIT IS IMPORTANT TO HIGHLIGHT THAT BECAUSE WE KEEP THEM SO WHEN WE DESIGN THEM, WHEN WE BUILD THEM, THE SPECIFICATION, THE QUALITY OF WHAT IS DEVELOPED AND WHO IS DESIGNING THEM, [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] IS ONE OF THE NATION'S LEADING AFFORDABLE HOUSING ARCHITECT, WE DO NOT PROPERTY MANAGE OUR PROPERTIES WE HIRE THIRD PARTY MANAGEMENT COMPANIES THAT SPECIALIZE IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING, THAT SPECIALIZE IN SENIOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING BECAUSE THAT IS UNIQUE MANAGEMENT STYLE. WE VOA RESIDENT MANAGER AND ASSISTANT MANAGER, A FULL-TIME MAINTENANCE PLUS CONTRACTORS THAT ARE THERE TO MAINTAIN THE DEVELOPMENT. THE DEVELOPMENT ITSELF IS UTILIZES VERY COMPLEX FINANCING STRUCTURES FROM TAX EXEMPT BONDS FROM FEDERAL TO STATE CREDITS TO FINANCING THAT IS A ONGOING-BRAIN DAMAGE FOR LACK OF A BETTER DESCRIPTION IN ORDER TO SOURCE ALL THESE FUNDS TOGETHER TO PROVIDE A FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE DEVELOPMENT FOR THE LIFE OF THIS COMMUNITY. THERE IS NO ONGOING RENTAL SUBSIDY. THERE IS NO ONGOING OPERATING SUBSIDY. THIS IS NOT A SECTION 8 BASED PROJECT. LIKE ANY COMMUNITY, ANY RENTAL SOMEONE WALKS WITH THOSE RARE MOBILE SECTION 8 VOUCHERS THEY HAVE TO BE EVALUATED, BUT THE FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY OF THIS DEVELOPMENT IS BUILT ON ALL OF THESE FINANCING SOURCES AVAILABLE AT THE CLOSE OF CONSTRUCTION AND COMPLETION SO IT IS INDEPENDENT OF ANY FEDERAL, STATE, COUNTY OR CITY PROGRAM. THE RENTS ARE RESTRICTED AT WHAT THEY ARE AT, THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS AFFORDABLE OPERATING EXPENSES. IF ANYBODY FINDS THEM LET ME KNOW, THE LOANS ARE SIZED ACCORDINGLY AND THE REST COMES FROM FEDERAL AND STATE TAX EQUITY. THESE COMMUNITIES ARE CAREFULLY INSPECTED AT THE STATE LEVEL ON BEHALF OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT FOR COMPLIANCE. COMPLIANCE DOESN'T SIMPLY INCLUDE RENTS AND THE RENTS BY THE WAY ARE AT 50 PERCENT AVERAGE MEDIAN INCOME, 60 PERCENT AND 80 PERCENT AMI. THEY ALSO CHECK TO MAKE SURE THAT THE RESIDENT AMOUNT OF PEOPLE LIVING IN THE UNIT IN THIS CASE THE AGE OF THE PEOPLE LIVING IN THE UNIT IS PER THE REGULATIONS RECORDED. THEY ALSO LOOK FOR DIFFERED MAINTENANCE ON THESE DEVELOPMENTS. NOW, IN ADDITION TO THAT, WE HAVE INVESTORS AND LENDERS WITH US IN THIS TRANSACTION FOR AT LEAST 15 TO 18 YEARS. THEY ALSO HAVE THEIR OWN INSPECTORS THAT COME TO LOOK FOR THE SAME COMPLIANCE ISSUES I MENTIONED AT THE STATE LEVEL, BECAUSE THEY NEED TO PROTECT THE TAX CREDIT INVESTMENT AND ALSO MAKE SURE IT IS PROPERLY MAINTAINED. THE QUESTION IS ALWAYS, WHAT IF THERE IS NON-COMPLIANCE AT THE FEDERAL/STATE ON BEHALF OF THE FEDERAL LEVEL? THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED A NON COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE. THAT IS THE LAST THING-THAT IS A VERY BAD WORD FOR AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPER AND NON COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AT A FEDERAL LEVEL NOT A STATE LEVEL, AND IF I HAVE A NON COMPLIANCE ANYWHERE IN ANY STATE IN THE UNITED STATES WE CAN'T DO BUSINESS, WE CAN'T SCORE OUR PROJECTS OR GET ALLOCATIONS, IT PUTS US OUT OF BUSINESS. THESE AFFORDABLE APARTMENTS BECAUSE OF THE SIGNIFICANT RESTRICTIONS AND PENALTIES THAT ARE IMPOSED AND CONTINUOUS INSPECTION ON MULTIPLE LEVELS ARE VERY VERY VERY WELL MANAGED, VERY WELL MAINTAINED AND IF YOU VISIT MANY AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMUNITIES YOU WILL SEE THE STANDARD AT WHICH THEY ARE MAINTAINED. IN ADDITION AS OUR ARCHITECT WILL PRESENT TO YOU, YOU WILL SEE FROM THE AMENITIES AND DESIGN AND QUALITY OF WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED, WE HAVE IN MANY SITUATION PEOPLE ASK US, WHERE IS THE AFFORDABLE DEVELOPMENT. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO DISTINGUISH ANY OF OUR COMMUNITIES AS AFFORDABLE VERSUS MARKET RATE. THEY ARE BUILT OF QUALITY AND PROPERTY MANAGEMENT AND CONSTRUCTED TO THE HIGHEST STANDARD AND WE KEEP THEM THAT WAY BECAUSE THE REPUTATION WE HAVE TO COME TO THE CITY OF OAKLEY AND BE ABLE TO TELL YOU, CALL EVERY OTHER CITY WE DEVELOPED IN AND IF THERE IS A PROBLEM, LET ME KNOW. WE TAKE GREAT PRIDE IN WHAT WE DO. ONE OF THE ISSUES THAT HAVE COME UP IS ON TRAFFIC AND KNOW TRAFFIC COUNTS WAS MENTIONED. PLEASE UNDERSTAND THIS IS SENIORS, TYPICALLY THEY ARE SINGLE OCCUPANCY, THEY ARE NOT RUSHING IN THE MORNING TO DROP OFF THE KIDS AT SCHOOL. THEY ARE NOT RUSHING IN THE MORNING TO GO TO WORK. SOME OF THEM DO WORK. THEY ACTUALLY AVOID THE TYPICAL TRAFFIC PATTERNS YOU SEE. THEY SAY NUMBER OF UNITS EXPECTED OCCUPANCY TRIPS TO BE GENERATED BECAUSE THAT IS STANDARD BOOK USED ALL OVER THE NATION WHEN YOU TALK TO TRAFFIC ENGINEER THAT SAYS THIS IS MY COUNT. YES, BUT IS THIS A SENIOR? DO YOU REALIZE MOST ARE RETIRED AND NOT RUSHING TO JOBS IN THE MORNING NOT DROPPING KIDS IN THE MORNING? THAT ISN'T TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION SO THE TRAFFIC PATTERNS ARE MUCH SOFTER, MUCH BETTER THEN WHAT IS TYPICAL. THEY AVOID TO RUSH HOUR TRAFFIC TO GO TO THE STORE OR DO WHAT THEY HAVE TO DO. ON THE THREE STORY DESIGN WE HAVE TAKEN VERY CAREFUL CONSIDERATION IN SETTING BACK THE BUILDINGS FROM MAIN STREET IN ORDER TO CREATE THAT SENSITIVITY OF THE HEIGHT WITHIN THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND SETTING IT BACK FROM THE SIDE TO MINIMIZE THE IMPACT AND CREATING ALL OF THE ACTIVITIES WITHIN THE CORE CHART AREA AND THERE ARE NUMEROUS ACTIVITIES YOU WILL SEE. WE ALSO HAVE A VERY LARGE AREA IN THE BACK, THERE IS OLD VINES WE INTEND TO PRESERVE. I UNDERSTAND THERE IS SOME NON-PROFITS HERE IN THE COMMUNITY THAT WORK WITH THOSE THAT WILL WORK WITH THEM. THEY WILL BE WALKING PATHS, THERE WILL BE AMENITIES. THE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY ITSELF ALSO CREATES IN SUPPORT OF A LOT OF PROGRAMS WITHIN THE SENIOR COMMUNITY WHAT THEY WANT DO TO FROM A [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] TO TRIPS TO GARDENING CLASSES TO COOKING CLASSES AND TYPICALLY THOSE PROGRAMS ACTUALLY DEVELOP THEMSELVES ONCE THE COMMUNITY IS OCCUPIED, BECAUSE THERE IS SOMEONE WHO LIKES GARDENING, THERE IS SOMEONE WHO LIKES DANCING AND OR A BINGO OR CARD NIGHT OR MOVIE NIGHT AND AND THEY CREATE GROUPS AND WITHIN THAT BECAUSE OF THE VARIOUS OPEN SPACES AND ENCLOSED SPACES AS WELL, THEY ARE ABLE TO HAVE THESE ACTIVITIES THAT FIT THE NEEDS SO WE HAVE A VARIETY OF ACTIVITIES AND THEY WORK WITH ON-SITE PROPERTY MANAGER TO MAKE SURE THEY RESERVE THE RIGHT ROOMS AND RIGHT SPACE. IT IS A VERY ACTIVE COMMUNITY FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE. FROM THE GATHERINGS AND PROGRAMS THAT THEY HAVE. OUR OWNERSHIP BECAUSE IT IS LONG TERM WE HAVE OUR ASSET MANAGEMENT IN-HOUSE THAT REGULARLY VISITS THE SITES AT LEAST ONCE A MONTH TO MAKE SURE THE JOB THAT IS SUPPOSED TO BE DONE IS BEING DONE. SO, WE TAKE GREAT PRIDE IN WHAT WE DO. WE BELIEVE WE BEAM A GOOD NEIGHBOR IN EVERY COMMUNITY WE HAVE ENTERED AND IN MANY MANY CASES WE HAVE BEEN INVITED AGAIN WHERE THE COMMUNITY COMES BACK, SOMETIMES A COUPLE YEARS, SOMETIMES 10 YEARS OR MORE, THEY COME BACK AND SAY, WE HAVE ANOTHER SITE, CANED YOU PLEASE LOOK INTO IT AND PROVIDE ANOTHER COMMUNITY? YOU DON'T GET THAT TYPE OF INVITE UNLESS YOU DO THE JOB RIGHT THE FIRST TIME. TODAY, I MENTION ALL OF THIS BECAUSE WE COME HERE WITH A PROMISE AND WHAT WE PROMISE IS THAT WE ARE GOING TO DELIVER ON WHAT WE SAID AND WHEN WE HAVE THE GRAND OPENING YOU CAN HOLD US TO THAT PROMISE AND THINK WE'LL ALL BE PROUD OF IT. I'LL MAKE MYSELF AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS. I LIKE TO INTRODUCE MR. ERNIE VASQUEZ OR ARCHITECT TO INTRODUCE THE PROJECT. THANK YOU. >> YOU'RE HANDS FREE. >> THANK YOU. APPRECIATE. AGAIN COUNCIL IT HAS BEEN A TERRIFIC EXPERIENCE WORKING WITH STAFF AND PLANNING COMMUNITY TO EVOLVE THE DESIGN AND MISSION STATEMENT WE DEVELOPED FOR THE PROJECT. NEXT SLIDE. JUST GO TO THE IMAGES. WE TOOK A LOT OF CARE AS MENTIONED IN TERMS OF THE BUILDING MASSING AND ARTICULATES AND KNOW THE SENSITIVITY THE SINGLE FAMILY ACROSS THE STREET AND WANTED TO SET IT BUILDING BACK, SET THE ARCHITECTURE SO IT HAD A PRESENCE ON MAIN STREET BUT NOT RIGHT ON THE WALL IF YOU WILL. SO, WE INTRODUCED ONE STORY ELEMENTS ON THE FACADE, THE MAIN LOBBY YOU SEE AS THE ANCHOR IN THE MIDDLE, THE ARCHITECTURE HAS A LOT OF VARIATION. WE ARE TRYING TO CONNECT TO THE RETAIL ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE RESIDENTS CAN WALK TO THE LUCKY STORE, WE HAVE THE CONNECTIVITY SO WE DON'T HAVE TO GET INTO A CAR THAT IS ANOTHER THING WE FEEL VERY IMPORTANT THAT THE PROPERTY IS SORT OF NETWORKED INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD SO AS YOU WILL SEE IN THE SITE PLAN, IF WE CAN GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE--THE IDEA THAT THE RETAIL THAT ON MAIN STREET, WE PROVIDED SOME PARKING, WE MADE IT CONVENIENT SO IT COULD CONDUCT-CONNECT TO THE ADJACENT RETAIL AND CLUB AND AMENITIES ACTIVATE THE STREET FRONTAGE SO WE ARE NOT PUTTING RESIDENTS ON THE FIRST FLOOR, THE RESIDENTS ARE ON THE SECOND AND THIRD FLOOR BUT YOU SEE A ACTIVE ZONE PARALLEL ON TO MAIN STREET AND THEN YOU DRIVE TO THE REAR AND THEN YOU DRIVE FOR THE RESIDENTS BEING DROPPED OFF ADJACENT TO THEIR RESIDENTS. GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE. THE IDEA WE LOOKED IN TERMS OF CREATING A IDENTITY OFF OF THE LOBBY. VERY MUCH LIKE A HOTEL. THE IDEA THE HOSPITALITY HAS A WELCOME SPACE, THAT IS THE SAME IDEA BEHIND THE IDEA OF SENIOR HOUSING. WE LOOK AT SENIOR HOUSING AS A CRUISE SHIP. YOU ARE TRYING TO GIVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE FOR THE ELDERS TO HAVE ENJOYMENT, HAVE A COMMUNITY AND NEIGHBORHOOD, THEIR GRANDCHILDREN CAN VISIT AND FAMILIES CAN COME VISIT SO THAT LOBBY IS VERY IMPORTANT BUT THAT ISN'T JUST INTERNAL. WE ALSO FELT IT WAS IMPORTANT IF YOU GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE-THAT THERE IS AMENITIES THAT ARE PART OF THIS COURTYARD. HISTORICALLY A A LOT OF THE ARCHITECTURE OF THE SPANISH REVIVAL PLAYS OFF THE COURTYARD AND FELT IT WAS IMPORTANT TO CREATE A SPACE AND CREATE AS NICE COMMUNAL SPACE WE DESIGNED FOR THE RESIDENTS. THE IDEA THAT WE CAN STAGGER THE ARCHITECTURE, CREATE A LAYERING, SO IT IS NOT AS I SAID THREE STORIES RIGHT ON THE STREET, BUT IT STEPS BACK AND IT HAS A ARTICULATION BOTH IN COLOR, WINDOWS, FORMS, AND DECKS, SO WE HAD A LOT OF VARIATION ON THE ELEMENTS SO THAT IT IS NOT SHALL WE SAY JUST--NOT TO BE A CHEAP APARTMENT. WANTED TO BE ELEGANT AND NICELY MANNERED IN TERMS OF THE MASTER PLAN. GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE. SO, AS WE LOOK IN TERMS OF THE ARTICULATION, MANAGEMENT LEASING IS ON THE CORNER SO THAT IS IMPORTANT ASPECT FOR OUR RESIDENTS WHO ARE JUST TO GET AWARE OF, UNDERSTAND THE OPPORTUNITIES THEY CAN LIVE HERE AND HAVE THE ACCESS TO SHALL WE SAY IS THE STREET AND ALSO THE BUS CONNECTIVITY TO THE STREET. WE HAD EXPLORED ALTERNATIVES TO LOOK AT PARALLEL PARKING AND DIAGONAL PARKING AND I THINK THIS IS A GOOD SOLUTION THAT CAME ABOUT EVOLVING SO WE KEPT THE PARKING ON PROPERTY. AS MOW MENTIONED WE LEFT A MAJOR STRIP OF LAND ON THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY TO GIVE MORE FLEXIBILITY AND MORE AMENITIES FOR OUR RESIDENTS. THIS COULD BE AREAS FOR GARDENS, AREAS FOR EVENTS FOR THE FAMILIES TO USE, BBQ AND EVENTS FOR OTHERS TO ENJOY. YOU CAN SEE THE MAIN ANCHOR BEHIND THE POOL IS THE MAIN OAK TREE THAT IS THE ANCHOR. THEN WE HAVE ANOTHER OAK TREE OFF ON THE SECONDARY GARDEN AREAS. BUT YOU CAN SEE THE PARKING SURROUNDS SO WE PURPOSELY KEPT THE BUILDINGS PULLED AWAY FROM THE SINGLE FAMILY HOMES TOWARD THE SOUTH OF THE PROPERTY. NEXT SLIDE. SO, THE OAKS ARE PRECIOUS. WE FELT THEY WERE VERY IMPORTANT. OUR LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT PGA FELT VERY IMPORTANT WE ANCHOR THEM, CONNECT TO THEM AND CREATE BASICALLY THE ACTIVITIES OF THE OUTDOOR SPACES AROUND THE OAKS AND REALLY MAKE THEM A FEATURE, SO THEY ARE NOT JUST SORT OF LIKE THE BACK OF THE GARDEN BUT INTEGRATED TO THE GARDENS IN TERMS OF THE WAY THE COURTYARDS WORK AND HOW THEY ANCHOR THE SPACE. SO, THESE VISUALS ARE PRETTY MUCH IN KEEPING TO THE SCALE OF WHAT WE PROPOSE. THE ROOF WE ARE TRYING TO KEEP AS CLEAN AS WE CAN, SO WE CAN HAVE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] AND AIR CONDITIONING COMPRESSORS UP ON THE ROOFS BUT WHEN IT COMES TO THE VISUAL WHAT THE PEOPLE ARE SEEING FROM THE PRIMMER IT, THEY WILL SEE THE SOFTEN PITCHED ROOFS OF THE TILE ROOFS SO THAT BECOMES A SOFTENED EFFECT AS YOU LOOK AROUND THE PERIMETER OF THE BUILDINGS. THE LAST SLIDE. SO, WE ARE VERY EXCITED ABOUT THIS BEING IN OAKLEY AND WE FEEL WE TRY TO ACHIEVE SOMETHING THAT IS MORE OF THE CHARACTER OF OAKLEY AS OPPOSED TO SOMETIMES ARCHITECTURE CAN LOOK LIKE A SPACE SHIP LANDS IN THE MIDDLE OF NO WHERE. THAT ISN'T WHAT WE WANT TODAY DO, WE WANTED TO CREATE SOMETHING VERY SPECIAL FOR THE SITE. I WILL BE HERE FOR ANY QUESTION YOU MAY HAVE. >> QUESTION ABOUT IT DESIGN. FOR PEOPLE WITH MOBILITY ON THE THIRD FLOOR, IS THERE FIRE ESCAPES? >> WE HAVE LOCATIONS BY THE ELEVATOR. A LOBBY AREA THAT IS FOR EMERGENCY MOVEMENT OR A OVER-SIZED SPACE FOR THE HANDICAP TO WAIT THERE UNTIL THE FIRE DEPARTMENT CAN GET THEM OUT. >> NOTHING ON THE OUTSIDE, NO FIRE ESCAPE? >> NOT ON THE OUTSIDE. IT IS ALL THRU THE ELEVATOR AND DOUBLE LOADED CORRIDOR. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. >> THIS IS MO, [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> MY QUESTIONS HAVE TO DO WITH RENT. I UNDERSTAND THE PERCENTAGE OF LOW, VERY LOW, VERY VERY LOW, THE PERCENTAGE OF 85, 35, 25, I'M TRYING TO REMEMBER WHAT THOSE PERCENTAGES WERE, BUT WHO ACTUALLY SETS THE RENT? >> HUD. >> HUD DOES, AND SO THERE'S NO REASON TO COME TO THE CITY IF THE RENTS AREN'T--AND HOW ARE THOSE RENT INCREASES HANDLED? >> SO,ER THERE ARE A COUPLE THINGS. NUMBER ONE, AS I MENTIONED, THERE IS A RESTRICTED-IT IS CALLED ALLURA RECORDED BY THE STATE ON BEHALF OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT THAT RESTRICTS RENTS AND DICTATE WHAT THE RENT SCHEDULES ARE. I ALSO BELIEVE IN THE DENSITY BONUS AGREEMENT THAT WE HAVE, FROM THE CITY THE CITY ALSO SAYS WHAT THOSE RESTRICTIONS ARE SO YOU HAVE TWO DOCUMENTS THAT SAY WHAT THE RESTRICTED RENTS ARE. THAT IS 1. 2, HUD PUBLISHES RENT. THERE IS TIME WHEN THE RECESSION OCCURRED FROM 08 TO DEPENDING WHAT YEAR YOU FELT YOU GOT A JOB BACK, THERE WERE NO RENT INCREASES BY HUD. THESE PROPERTIES SAW NO RENT INCREASES. THESE PROPERTIES DID SEE OPERATING EXPENSE INCREASES. THESE PROPERTIES WHEN FINANCED ARE REQUIRED BY THE STATE TO BE FINANCED WHERE THE VARIANCE BETWEEN THE RENT AND THE VARIANCE WHAT YOU PAY FOR YOUR DEBT IS MINIMAL. IT IS ABOUT FOR EVERY $1.15 THAT YOU MAKE THERE IS A DOLLAR YOU PAY IN DEBT. THE MARGIN IS VERY NARROW. WHEN WE PROJECT THEM OVER TIME, STANDARD IN THE INDUSTRY WE ANTICIPATE EXPENSES OVER TIME. SOMETIMES THEY DON'T INCREASE, SOMETIMES THEY INCREASE MORE BUT OVER TIME THEY INCREASE BY 2.5 PERCENT, THAT IS STANDARD INDUSTRY UNDER WRITING. RENTS INCREASE BY 3.5 PERCENT. IF A GLITCH OCCURS WHERE THE RENTS DON'T MOVE AND THE OPERATING EXPENSES GO UP THE PROJECTS GO UPSIDE DOWN, THEREFORE, THE RENTS WHEN PUBLISHED WILL BE PUBLISHED TO THE TENANTS AND THEN THEY ARE GIVEN PER THE AGREEMENT WE HAVE THE CITY RIGHT NOW AND THE CONDITION APPROVAL 90 DAY NOTICE, BUT WHEN THEY ARE IMPLEMENTED, THEN WE CAN IMPLEMENT THOSE RENTS. IN ADDITION, FOR EVERY UNIT THERE IS PUBLISHED SCHEDULE CALLED A UTILITY ALLOWANCE SCHEDULE. THE UTILITY ALLOWANCE MUST BE DEDUCTED FROM THE MAXIMUM ALLOWED RENT AND THE NET RENT IS THEN CHARGED TO THE RESIDENT OF EACH RESPECTIVE UNIT BASED ON THE RENT LEVEL. I WILL ALSO MENTION SOMETHING, THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED COMMUNITY CFD, COMMUNITY FACILITY DISTRICT PAYMENTS. THOSE ARE VERY SIGNIFICANT IN THE CITY OF OAKLEY. >> WE ARE AWARE. >> AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS TO BE ABLE TO AFFORD THOSE, IT IS A CHALLENGE. FOR THE RECORD, FOR THE RECORD, THERE IS OVER $40 THOUSAND PER UNIT OF IMPACT FEES BEING PAID AND THE CFD ARE RESULTING IN SEVERAL MILLION DOLLAR REDUCTION IN THE LOAN THAT THIS PROPERTY CAN AFFORD BECAUSE IT IS BEING TAKEN FROM ITS INCOME. THE TOTAL IMPACT OF THE IMPACT FEES AND THE CFD'S TO THIS SPECIFIC DEVELOPMENT IS OVER 7 AND A HALF MILLION DOLLARS OVER THE PROJECT. THAT IS OVER 17 PERCENT OF THE TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COST. SO, IF THE RENT DON'T KEEP UP NOT ONLY ARE WE JEOPARDIZED BY IT OPERATING EXPENSES TO PAY THE BILLS AND UTILITIES AND INSURANCE WE HAVE TO PAY, BUT WE CANT PAY THE CFD'S AND SO THERE IS A VERY FINELINE OF SENSITIVITY WHERE THESE DEVELOPMENTS START THEY CAN NOT AFFORD TO TAKE THE RENT INCREASES WHEN PUBLISHED BY HUD. NOW, THERE ARE TIMES WHEN THE RECESSIONS HAVE HIT EVEN IF RENTS INCREASED BUT THE MARKET IS IN SUCH BAD SHAPE SOMEONE CAN FIND A MARKET RATE UNIT THAT IS LESS, DOESN'T MEAN WE'LL CHARGE THE HUD RENT BECAUSE PEOPLE WILL LEAVE SO IT IS DICTATED WHAT HUD PUBLISHES AND WHAT THE MARKET CAN EXPLAIN. I HOPE I GAVE A LONG ANSWER TO A SHORT QUESTION BUT I WANTED TO TOUCH SEVERAL AREAS. IT IS NOT THE CITY'S CONTROL, IT IS DIRECTLY HUD AND THAT IS HOW IT IS NATIONWIDE NOT JUST IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. SMALL PETS ARE ALLOWED. I CAN'T PROVIDE THE EXACT POUND BUT BETWEEN 10 OR 11 POUND BUT THEY ARE SMALL PETS. THERE WILL BE IN THE BACK AREA A BARK PARK VERSUS A PET PARK BECAUSE THAT IS THE POLITICALLY CORRECT TERM. THERE IS A BARK PARK WHERE THEY CAN TAKE THEIR PETS AND WALK THEM ON A LEASH BUT, PETS ARE ALLOWED. >> MY QUESTION IS YOU ARE VERY WELL REGULATED AND AUDITED SO IF YOU WANT TO CHARGE $500 MORE A MONTH YOU ARE NOT ALLOW TODAY DO THAT, YOU ARE REGULATED BY THE GOVERNMENT? >> YOU SAID WELL REGULATED? MAY I SAY OVERLY REGULATED. WE ARE REGULATED BY THE STATE SO THE STATE HAS ITS OWN INSPECTION. WE ARE REGULATED BY OUR LENDER, OUR LENDER HAS THEIR OWN INSPECTION. WE ARE REGULATED BY OUR VENDER WHO HAS THEIR INSPECTION. WE SELF-REGULATE IN 2 WAYS, WE HAVE A ASSET MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT THAT GOES OUT TO MAKE SURE THE CORRECT RENT IS CHARGED THE RIGHT NUMBER OF PEOPLE. WE ALSO HIRE A THIRD PARTY AUDITOR TO DO OUR OWN INSPECTION. WHEN ASKED WHY WOULD YOU HIRE A THIRD PARTY AUDITOR, AS I MENTIONED IN THE PRESENTATION THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED A CERTIFICATE OF NON COMPLIANCE AND THAT IS DEATH TO A AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPER. WE RATHER THE THIRD PARTY AUDITOR WHEN IS [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] THEY ARE ONE OF THE TWO LEADING CPA IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE NATION, THEY ARE BASED IN SAN FRANCISCO. WE WOULD RATHER THEM CATCH A MISTAKE THAT WE MISSED SOMETHING OR PROPERTY MANAGER MISSED THE CORRECT IT IMMEDIATELY BEFORE ANYBODY DOES. SO NO, THERE IS NO FREEDOM TO CHARGE WHAT YOU WANT TO CHARGE. YOU CAN NOT DO THAT, IT IS A VERY REGULATED, BUT MORE IMPORTANT THE FINANCIAL PEN ALTIES ON US IS SIGNIFICANT SO THAT IS OUT OF THE QUESTION. >> AND THEN SOME OF THE UNITS ARE 1 AND 2 BEDROOMS BUT HOW MANY PEOPLE CAN OCCUPY A SINGLE APARTMENT? >> THE MAXIMUM OCCUPANCY IS 2 PEOPLE. >> OKAY. >> PERIOD, 1 OR 2 BEDROOM. THERE IS NO 3 PEOPLE FOR A 2 BEDROOM, 2 PEOPLE MAXIMUM FOR ONE AND TWO BEDROOM IN A SENIOR COMMUNITY. IT DIFFERS FOR AFFORDABLE FAMILY. >> A LOT OF TIMES PEOPLE GET AFFORDABLE MIXED UP WITH LOW INCOME AND THESE ARE TWO DIFFERENT TERMS THAT SHOULDN'T BE USED TOGETHER. >> THE TAX CREDIT PROGRAM IS CALLED THE LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM. THAT'S A NAME THAT THE CONGRESS CALLED IT, SO LET ME TELL YOU WHAT THE LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM RENTS ARE AND LET'S-I LIKE TO ASK FOR A SHOW OF HANDS. 50 PERCENT RENTS, $1100. 60 PERCENT RENTS, $1300. I'M NOT GOING ANY FURTHER. THAT'S NOT LOW INCOME, THAT'S ATTAINABLE AFFORDABLE. LOW INCOME IS WHEN YOU START INTRODUCING SECTION 8 PROJECT BASED VOUCHERS WHERE PEOPLE CAN PAY 30 PERCENT OR WHATEVER AMOUNT THAT THEY MAKE. THESE ARE SIGNIFICANT DOLLARS, SO IT IS AFFORDABLE BUT THE POLITICAL CREATURE THAT CREATED THE PROGRAM FELT THEY CAN SELL IT BETTER WHEN IT IS CALLED LOW INCOME. >> OKAY. I APPRECIATE THAT. THANK YOU. >> SURE. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> I'M SORRY, ONE LAST COMMENT, THERE WAS A MARKET STUDY CONDUCTED FOR THIS SPECIFIC SITE. THE DEMANDS SPECIFICALLY FOR THIS TYPE OF UNIT, THIS TYPE OF HOUSING AND THIS RENT FROM THE DIRECT AREA IS ABOUT 1110 UNITS I BELIEVE AND ALL WE ARE ABLE TO PROVIDE IS 130 OF THAT. SO WE ANTICIPATE UNFORTUNATELY A SIGNIFICANT LIST DOUBLE OR TRIPLE THE AMOUNT OF UNITS AVAILABLE. A WAITING LIST. >> RIGHT. OKAY, THANK YOU. OKAY, SO I DO HAVE COUPLE SPEAKER CARDS NOW. THE FIRST ONE WILL BE MARK F U CHS. >> WRONG ONE. >> SORRY. THAT IS 5.1, NOT 4.1, SORRY. OKAY. FOR DIANE SPURRIER. COME ON DOWN. DID YOU WANT TO BE ABLE TO READ OFF YOUR CARD? >> THANKS. AS FAR AS I CAN SEE- >> YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES SO AFTER 2 MINUTES ARE UP THE YELLOW LIGHT COMES ON AND WHEN THE RED COMES UP YOU GOT TO FINISH UP REALLY QUICK. >> MY NAME IS DIANE SPURRIER AND I LIVE AT SUMMER CREEK, PLACE A LOW INCOME AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR SENIORS ON FIXED INCOMES. THAT'S WHAT OAKLEY NEEDS, MORE OF THOSE UNITS FOR THEIR SENIORS BECAUSE THEY ARE PRICED OUT OF THEIR HOMES AND FORCED TO LIVE WITH RELATIVES, MOVE IN WITH FRIENDS OR GO TO THE STREETS WHICH SOME HAVE GONE TO THE STREETS. THE MAJORITY OF THE HOMELESS POPULATION NOW IS SENIOR CITIZENS. WE DON'T NEED AFFORDABLE HOUSING, WE NEED FIXED INCOME HOUSING FOR PEOPLE ON FIXED INCOME, SENIORS ON FIXED INCOME, MORE THEN AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AFFORDABLE HOUSING THEY CAN GO ANYWHERE AND RENT. >> ARE YOU ADDRESSING THE COUNCIL OR JUST THE AUDIENCE? >> JUST THE AUDIENCE I GUESS. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> SORRY. >> THAT'S OKAY. >> ANYWAY, THE PEOPLE AT SUMMER CREEK PLACE ARE PUSHED OUT OF THEIR HOMES BECAUSE OF THESE-AND THE PEOPLE PUSHING THEM OUT GET TAX CREDITS, TAX INCENTIVES, TAX BREAKS, THEY GET ALL KINDS OF BREAKS IN TAX DEALS TO KEEP IT LOW INCOME AND AFFORDABLE FOR FIXED INCOME SENIORS. THAT IS WHAT IT WAS RENTED AS, THAT IS WHAT THEY ADVERTISED IT AS AND THAT IS WHAT IT IS SUPPOSED TO BE, HOWEVER THEY CHANGED UP ON US AND NOW-AND THEY USE HUD AND I DON'T KNOW HOW HUD PLAYS INTO WHAT THEY ARE SAYING BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT HUD, BUT THEY USE HUD LETTERHEADS NOT LETTERHEADS BUT HUD ON THEIR FORMS, IT SAYS HUD PROPERTIES OR SOMETHING ABOUT THAT, WHICH I DON'T BELIEVE IT IS HUD, BECAUSE I DON'T BELIEVE THEY COULD BE DOING WHAT THEY ARE DOING BY RAISING THE RENTS AT $50 EVERY THREE MONTHS SINCE OCTOBER SO THAT IS $300 IN A YEAR THEY RAISED THE RENTS AND PLAN TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT UNTIL THEY REACHED THE >> MAXIMUM? >> RIGHT. I THINK MAXIMUM OR THE MEDIAN INCOME LEVEL, WHICH IS AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR WEALTHIER PEOPLE NOT PEOPLE ON FIXED INCOMES. IT IS A CRIME I THINK TO BE MAKING THESE PEOPLE HOMELESS. I LIKE TO KNOW WHAT WE CAN DO ABOUT THIS. >> WELL, I THINK WE HAVE TO HAVE SOMEBODY WITH A LOT OF MONEY THAT DIDN'T HAVE IT GET GOVERNMENT LOANS TO BUILD SOMETHING THAT WAS-THAT THEY COULD AFFORD TO BANK ROLL THEMSELVES OPPOSED TO SOMEBODY WHO HAS TO MAKE MONEY TO BUILD THINGS. YOU HAVE TO HAVE SOMEBODY DONATE THEIR OWN MONEY TO MAKE THEM WHERE THEY WILL BE AFFORDABLE FOR PEOPLE WITH LOW OR NOW INCOME. >> WHERE ARE THOSE PEOPLE? >> I HAVE NO IDEA, MA'AM. I HAVE NO IDEA. >> MR. MONTGOMERY, WE SET UP PROGRAMS AND SET UP CONTACT INFORMATION, DO WE HAVE THAT AVAILABLE STILL? >> YES, AND DIANE AND I SPOKE SEVERAL TIMES SO SHE HAS THAT INFORMATION AND HAS BEEN MEETING I KNOW WITH THE ECHO HOUSING FOLKS TO UNDERSTAND MORE OF THE COMPLEXITY THE VICE MAYOR JUST EXPLAINED. >> UNFORTUNATELY EVERYBODY HAS TO RUN IN THE BLACK BECAUSE IF YOU RUN IN THE RED THE LIGHTS GO OUT. >> RIGHT, WELL WHY ALL OF A SUDDEN DID IT CHANGE UP? >> THEY ARE REGULATED BY THE GOVERNMENT SO YOU HAVE TO ASK THE GOVERNMENT AGENCY THAT SETS THE STANDARD AND WE DONT DO THAT HERE. >> I THOUGHT YOU ARE CAPABLE SETTING RENT CAPS? >> NO WE DON'T SET RENT FOR ANYTHING. >> REACH OUT TO OTHER GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE COUNT A, STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS TO GET HELP OR TO GET HELP FOR US PEOPLE THAT LIVE- >> I THINK WE TRIED TO ADDRESS THAT AT THE LAST MEETING. >> NOBODY SHOWED UP AT OUR CLUB HOUSE MEETING. WE HAD ONE PERSON FROM THE CONTE SUPERVISORS OFFICE THAT SHOWED UP, DON, BUT THAT'S IT. >> WAS SHE HELPFUL? >> NO. SHE SAID WHY DIDN'T YOU TELL US ABOUT THIS EARLIER AND A LADY RESPONDED SHE WROTE A LETTER A YEAR AGO. >> YOU CAN REACH OUT OUR ASSEMBLYMAN JIM FRASER. I WOULD CONTACT HIM AND SEE WHAT HE CAN DO ON THE STATE LEVEL. THE HIGHER UP THE LADDER THE BETTER IT WOULD BE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR INPUT. WE APPRECIATE IT. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> ANYBODY ELSE ON 4.1? ANYMORE QUESTIONS? DO WE HAVE A MOTION THEN? >> MOVE THAT WE OKAY THE MOTION WITH THE CHANGES AS STATED AS OUTLINED IN THE- >> FROM STAFF. >> FROM STAFF, YEAH. >> MOTION. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> OPPOSED? SO MOVED. THANK YOU. 5.1 RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT FOR CONTRA COSTA TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY'S PROPOSED DRAFT TRANSPORTATION EXPENDITURE PLAN. BRIAN MONTGOMERY PLEASE. >> THANK YOU VICE MAYOR. IT IS MY PRIVILEGE TO INTRODUCE TIM HILL WHO IS DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR PROJECTS FOR CCA AND MR. HILL WILL PROVIDE A OVERVIEW OF WHAT IS PROPOSED HERE AND FROM STAFF'S PERSPECTIVE WE BELIEVE HE CAN BEST EXPLAIN THAT BUT WE RECOMMEND ADOPTION OF THE RESOLUTION. >> GOOD EVENING, VICE MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS, REALLY APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE TO PRESENT AN OVERVIEW WHAT WE FEEL IS THE PLAN FOR CONTRA COSTA FUTURE FOR TRANSPORTATION THROUGH THE EXPENDITURE PLAN. I'M TIM HAIL DEPUTY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PROJECTS A LITTLE ABOUT CCTA BEFORE I GET INTO THE OVERVIEW. IT WAS CREATED IN 1988 BY VOTE OF ST. THE PEOPLE IN TERMS OF IMPLEMENTING AND VOTING ON MEASURE C WHICH WAS ONE OF FIRST HALF CENT SALES TAX FOR TRANSPORTATION IN THE STATE SO THAT CARRIED ON THROUGH 2009 AND THAT WAS EXPEND TENDED BY VOTE OF PEOPLE IN 2004 WHICH IS NOW MEASURE J WHICH ENDS IN 2034 SO WHAT THE TWO MEASURES HAVE BEEN ABLE TO PROVIDE OVER THE MANY YEARS IS $2.7 BILLION OF PROGRAMS AND PROJECTS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY FOR TRANSPORTATION THROUGH MEASURE J. MEASURE C WAS ABOUT A MILLION DOLLARS SO THIS FUNDS SMALL PROJECT FOR PEDESTRIAN BALK WALKING BIKING TO LARGE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS. PROJECTS SUCH AS HIGHWAY 4 WIDENING EAST COUNTY AND LOOKS AT ALTERNATIVE TRANSPORTATION, FERRY, TRANSIT, ACCESSIBLE TRANSPORTATION, PARA TRANSIT SO IT COVERS THE FULL GAMUT OF PROVIDING TRANSPORTATION OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. WE ARE HIGHLY RATED AWARD WINNING AGENCY. WE REALLY ARE FOCUSED ON PROVEN TRACK RECORD FOR DELIVERY, MAKING SURE WE DELIVER OUR PROJECTS ON TIME UNDER BUDGET AND THAT IS PROVEN SO AND ALSO RECOGNIZED BY IT CONTRA COSTA COUNTY ASSOCIATION. WE RECEIVE IT GOOD GOVERNANCE AWARD FOR PRUDENT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT, IS OUR ABILITY TO LOOK FOR OPPORTUNITY TO SAVE MONEY AND REALLY BRING BENEFITS TO THE TAXPAYERS RATHER THEN WAITING OUT TO THE OUTER YEARS OF THE MEASURE WE ADVANCE ALL OUR PROJECTS AND BOND AND BRING THOSE BENEFITS TO THE PEOPLE AS SOON AS WE CAN SO PEOPLE CAN SEE THOSE BENEFITS. WE HAVE THIS MOTTO IN CCTA, PROMISES MADE, PROMISED KEPT SO I'LL REVIEW THE MAJOR SIGNATURE PROJECTS I THINK YOU WILL BE VERY AWARE BUT THIS IS HIGHWAY 4 WIDENING PROJECT. THIS WITH THE E BART EXTENSION WAS $1.2 BILLION OF TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT IN EAST COUNTY SO THIS PROVIDES A 15 TO 20 MINUTE TRAVEL TIME SAVINGS ON HIGHWAY 4 AS WELL AS PROVIDE MORE RELIABILITY TRANSIT IN EAST COUNTY AS WELL. THE E BART IS MEETING 5 YEAR RIDERSHIP PROJECTIONS SO BART ALREADY WENT OUT TO BID AND ACTUALLY OPENED BIDS LAST WEEK ON EXPANDING THE PARKING LOT IN ANTIOCH TO ADD ADDITIONAL 800 PARKING SPACES AND THAT WAS FUNDED THROUGH MEASURE J. ANOTHER PROJECT I THINK IS IMPORTANT IS THE COMPLETION OF HIGHWAY 4160 INTERCHANGE AND GETTING BETTER ACCESS TOWARDS EAST COUNTY AND ALSO INTO DIRECT LY INTO OAKLEY AND MAIN STREET. SOME OF THE OTHER PROJECTS WE FUND ARE NOT ONLY THESE BIG CAPITAL PROJECTS BUT WE FUND TRANSIT. TRI DELTA TRANSIT RECEIVES MEASURE MONEY. WE ALSO HAVE A RETURN TO SOURCE THAT GOES DIRECTLY IN YOUR COMMUNITIES AND WE ALSO WORK WITH THE LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO IMPROVE YOUR STREETS AND IMPROVE MAJOR ROADS AND FOR EXAMPLE, WE PARTNERED WITH YOUR STAFF HERE IN THE CITY >> STUDENT DO A ACTIVE TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ON MAIN STREET AND SO THOSE TYPES OF PROJECTS AS WELL AS THE BIG CAPITAL PROJECTS ALL GET FUNDED THROUGH THE LOCAL SALES TAX, LOCAL FUNDING. SO WE ARE REALLY PROUD OF THIS. WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO TAKE $1.4 BILLION OVER THE LIFE OF THE MEASURE TO LEVERAGE ABOUT $4.1 BILLION OR ATTRACT STATE AND FEDERAL FUNDS FOR $5.5 BILLION INVESTMENT SO THAT IS A EXAMPLE OF FOR EXAMPLE, 4TH BORE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] TUNNEL FUNDED BY MEASURE J, THAT WAS A $400 MILLION PROJECT AND THERE WAS ONLY A HUNDRED MILLION OF MEASURE J FUNDS WOE TAKE THE MONEY AND LEVERAGE AND HAVE A 3 TO $1 RATIO. WITHOUT THAT LOCAL FUNDING $1.4 BILLION WE WOULDN'T HAVE BEEN ABLE TO ATTRACT THAT FUNDIC. THAT IS IMPORTANT TO HAVE THE FUND SOURCES TO FUND THE LARGE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS. WE ARE LOOKING AHEAD INTO THE FUTURE. LOOKING TO SEE WHAT ARE THE TRANSPORTATION NEEDS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY OVER THE NEXT 30 OR 35 YEARS AND SO I THINK ALL OF US REALIZE THAT TODAY WE SIT IN A LOT OF CONGESTION. IT IS REALLY INTERESTING ABOUT THE MAP IS $1.2 BILLION PROVIDED THE GREEN STIPE IN EAST COUNTY ON HIGHWAY 4 AND SO WHAT WE WANT TO DO IS TAKE THAT SAME APPROACH AND INVEST THOSE SAME LARGE CAPITAL DOLLARS TO FIX THE REST THE BOTTLENECKS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. LOOKING AT THE 684 INTERCHANGE COMPLETING THAT INTERCHANGE AND REMOVING TWO LOOPS SO WE CAN HAVE SAFER MERGES AND DIRECT ACCESS. FIXING THE BOTTLENECK AT 242 BECAUSE AS YOU TRAVEL WEST ON HIGHWAY 4 YOU STOP AROUND BAILEY, SAN MARCO, MAYBE SOMETIMES ALL THE WAY OUT TO LEVERAGE THAT IS ALL BECAUSE OF THE 684 INTERCHANGE AND IT BOTTLENECK BETWEEN BASICALLY BAILEY ROAD AND PITTSBURGH ALL THE WAY OVER TO THE 684 INTERCHANGE. THESE DOLLARS WE ARE LOOKING AT WILL BE TARGETED IN THESE REALLY CRITICAL BOTTLENECKS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. SO, ONE THING I MENTION SAID WE DO IS ADVANCE PROJECTS THROUGH BONDING AND SO WHAT WE ACHIEVED WITH THAT IS OVER THE LAST 10, 15 YEARS WITH MEASURE J WE HAVE DELIVERED 2/3 OF ALL THE PROJECTS AND PROGRAMS IN THE EXPENDITURE PLAN. THAT INCLUDES ALL OF THE MAJOR CAPITAL PROJECTS. YOU NOTICE WHEN YOU ARE TRAVELING ON HIGHWAY 4 TODAY, THERE IS CONSTRUCTION. THAT IS THE FIRST PHASE OF A MULTIPHASE PROJECT FOR COMPLETING THE 684 INTERCHANGE. THAT IS ONE OF THE LAST REMAINING BIG CAPITAL PROJECTS LEFT IN MEASURE J. KEY THING HERE IS THE REST OF THE MONEY-IN TERMS OF NOW OUT TO 2034, IS ALL FOR LOCAL FUNDING, LOCAL ROADS, LOCAL PROGRAMS SUCH AS RETURN TO SOURCE, TRANSIT FUNDING, THE MONEY LEFT OVER IN THE MEASURE 2034 IS NOT FOR CAPITAL BECAUSE WE DELIVERED ALL OF THE MAJOR CAPITAL PROJECTS BY ADVANCING AND BONDING THAT FUTURE REVENUE TO DELIVER ALL THE PROJECTS NOW RATHER THEN LATER. SO, YOU MAY HAVE HEARD OF SENATE BILL OR PROPOSITION 6. THE PEOPLE VOTED NO ON PROPOSITION 6 IN 2018 AND THIS IS A 12 CENT GAS TAX AND SO THE REASON WHY THIS IS IMPORTANT IS 50 PERCENT-GENERATES ABOUT $5.2 BILLION A YEAR SO 50 PERCENT OF THE MONEY GOES TO THE STATE TO DO FIX IT FIRST PROJECTS SO THIS IS PAVEMENT REHABILITATION, FIXING POT HOLE ON THE HIGHWAYS AND FREEWAYS. THE OTHER 50 PERCENT GOES BACK TO THE LOCALS BY FORMULA AND ALSO INTO COMPETITIVE PROGRAMS. THOSE NUMBERS YOU SEE ON THE SCREEN, THOSE ARE OUT OF THE $5.2 BILLION THAT THE DOLLARS WE RECEIVE BY FORMULA EVERY YEAR OUT OF THE $5.2 BILLION. IT IS MONEY, BUT WHAT IS MORE IMPORTANT IS, THE COMPETITIVE PROGRAMS IS WHERE THE REAL MONEY IS AT. MULTI-HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR PROGRAMS IF WE DON'T HAVE A LOCAL FUND SOURCE WE CAN'T COMPETE TO ATTRACT THOSE FUNDS INTO CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. SIMILARLY WITH REGIONAL MEASURE 3, THERE WAS A INCREASE ON TOLL PRICE ON THE TOLL BRIDGES AND SO OUT OF THAT CONTRA COSTA COUNTY WE GENERATE 18.4 PERCENT OF THE OVERALL TOLL REVENUE WHICH IS ABOUT A BILLION DOLLARS. WE ARE COMPETING AS A REGIONAL LEVEL WITH THE OTHER 8 BAY AREA COUNTIES FOR TRANSPORTATION FUNDING SO THOSE FUNDS HAVE BEEN DIRECTED INTO OTHER COUNTIES AND SO WHAT IS IMPORTANT HERE IS BY HAVING A LOCAL FUND SOURCE WE CAN PROTECT THOSE DOLLARS AND KEEP THOSE DOLLARS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY BUT WE CAN ALSO AGAIN HAVE-WE HAVE TO GO AHEAD AND COMPETE FOR OTHER REGIONAL FUNDS. THE EXPRESS LANE CATEGORY OR IMPROVED TRANSIT CATEGORY, WE HAVE TO COMPETE THOSE FUNDS AND HAVE LOCAL FUNDS SOURCES TO MATCH AND COMPETE FOR THOSE FUNDS. SO, TRANSPORTATION NEEDS CONTINUE TO GROW IN 1990 THERE WAS 809 THOUSAND PEOPLE IN CONTRA COSTA AND IN 2017 THAT GROWS TO 1.147 MILLION. IN 2055 WHICH WHEN THIS MEASURE IS PROPOSED TO END, IT WOULD BE 1 AND A HALF MILLION PEOPLE SO THAT IS A 31 PERCENT INCREASE OF PEOPLE OVER TIME IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. IF YOU IMAGINE OUR ROADS TODAY WITH 31 PERCENT MORE PEOPLE AND NOT HAVING THE FUNDING THAT WE NEED TO INVEST INTO OUR TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM WHAT WOULD CONGESTION LOOK LIKE IN THE FUTURE? ANOTHER ASPECT OF THAT IS TODAY THERE IS 14 PERCENT OF THE POPULATION THAT IS OVER THE AGE OF 65, SO WE HAVE A GROWING AGING POPULATION IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. THOSE NUMBERS ARE SUPPOSED TO DOUBLE BY THE YEAR 2035 AND THAT'S JUST THE MID-POINT OF THIS FUTURE MEASURE SO WHAT IT MIGHT LOOK LIKE IN 2055, I DON'T KNOW BUT IT IS A LOT OF PEOPLE. WITH THAT BEING SAID WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE PLAN THIS EXPENDITURE PLAN NOT JUST TO FOCUS ON THE CAPITAL PROJECT BUT PLAN FOR ALL USERS IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY SO PEOPLE ARE ABLE TO CONTINUE TO GET AROUND AND MAINTAIN QUALITY OF LIFE. WE DID PUBLIC OPINION RESEARCH IN APRIL AND MAY OF THIS YEAR. EVEN WITH ALL OF THE TRANSPORTATION CONGESTION PEOPLE STILL FEEL THAT THERE IS A CONTINUED NEED FOR TRANSPORTATION FUNDING IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. THE TIMELINE OF LOCAL FUNDING OVER THE YEARS I MENTIONED MEASURE M AND MEASURE J, BUT THIS NEW MEASURE GETS PUT INTO PLACE IT WOULD START JULY 1 OF 2020 AND WOULD GO TO JUNE 30, 2055, BUT I WANT YOU TO THINK IF WE DON'T PASS ANOTHER SALES TAX MEASURE OR HAVE THE ABILITY OF LOCAL FUNDING THEN WE HAVE CRITICAL FUNDING THAT IS ALREADY FUNDING TRANSIT, TRI DELTA TRANSIT ALREADY RECEIVES FUNDING FROM MEASURE J. ALSO FUNDING FOR RETURN TO SOURCE INTO YOUR LOCAL CITIES FOR BENEFITING THE COMMUNITY. OUR GROWTH MANAGEMENT PROGRAM MAKING SURE WE DON'T HAVE URBAN SPRAWL, MAKING SURE WE ARE GROWING SMARTLY WOULD ALSO END IN 2034 SO IT IS REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WE HAVE THESE POLICIES AND MECHANISMS AND CONTINUED FUNDING TO MAKE SURE WE GROW SMARTER AND BETTER AND MAKING SURE THAT WE HAVE THE CONTINUED INVESTMENT INTO OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES FOR TRANSPORTATION. A LITTLE ABOUT 2020 TRANSPORTATION EXPENDITURE PLAN, THIS IS THE ROADMAP OVER THE LAST 6 MONTHS. IN AUGUST 28 THE AUTHORITY BOARD CCTA RELEASED THE DRAFT TRANSPORTATION EXPENDITURE PLAN TO SEEK THE SUPPORT OF THE MAJORITY OF CITIES MAJORITY OF THE POPULATION TO ADOPT THE TRANSPORTATION EXPENDITURE PLAN AND PLACE THE MEASURE ON THE BALLOT ON MARCH 3, 2020 TO HAVE THE VOTERS VOTE AND SEEK AND LET THEM VOTE ON THIS RATHER SO ALL WE ARE DOING TONIGHT IS SEEKING YOUR SUPPORT PLACING ON THE BALLOT AND PUTTING IN FRONT OF THE VOTERS TO DECIDE. AS WE DID OUR PUBLIC OPINION RESEARCH, PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR OUTCOMES. PEOPLE ARE TIRED OF SITTING IN CONGESTION SO PEOPLE KNOW AND RECOGNIZE THAT WE DON'T HAVE THESE BIG SIGNATURE PROJECTS. WE KNOW WE CAN'T CONTINUE TO WIDEN OUT OF CONGESTION SO WE NEED TO BE MORE STRATEGIC, MARTYR AND INNOVATIVE IN TERMS HOW WE DEVELOP OUR TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM OVER THE NEXT 35 YEARS WHAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR IS I WANT THIS FUNDING TO PROVIDE 15 MINUTES REDUCTION ON MY COMMUTE. THEY DON'T KNOW HOW WE DO THAT BUT THEY WANT OUTCOMES AND BENEFITS. THE OTHER THING THEY REALLY WANT IS PEOPLE ARE INTERESTED IN NOT USING THEIR CAR. THEY ARE LOOKING FOR OTHER ALTERNATIVE TRANSPORTATION SUCH AS A MORE RELIABLE COORDINATED TRANSIT SYSTEM. MAKING SURE WE HAVE A TARGETED GOAL TO REDUCE GREEN HOUSE GAS EMISSIONS TO IMPROVE AIR QUALITY AND QUALITY OF LIFE IN CONTRA COSTA AS WELL AS MAKING SURE WE ARE MAKING BART SAFER AND CLEANER SO THOSE ARE TOP 4 THINGS WE FOUND IN THE PUBLIC OPINION RESEARCH AND WE FEEL THE PLAN DOES ADDRESS ALL THOSE THINGS AND EVEN MORE. THE OTHER KEY ASPECT IS ACCOUNTABILITY. THIS MEASURE IS DESIGNED TO HAVE VERY STRONG PUBLIC OVERSIGHT. MAKING SURE THAT THE DOLLARS ONE STAY IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, MAKING SURE THERE IS ACCOUNTABILITY ON EVERY DOLLAR TO MAKE SURE IT BENEFITS MY COMMUTE AND NOT GOING TO GENERAL FUND OR TO HOUSING OR SOME OTHER THING THAT ISN'T GOING TO BENEFIT MY COMMUTE. THERE IS A NUMBER OF TAXPAYER SAFEGUARDS AND ACCOUNTABILITY, WE HAVE A WHOLE POLICY THAT DOES PERFORMANCE AUDITING, MAINTENANCE OF EFFORT, THE CREATION OF A PUBLIC OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE TO REALLY OVERSEE THE EXPENDITURES AND EVALUATE HOW WE ARE PERFORMING WITH THOSE DOLLARS ON A ANNUAL BASIS. THE MEASURE IS A HALF CENT SALES TAX, 35 YEARS GENERATES $3.6 BILLION AND WE MAKE SURE THAT THERE IS GUIDING PRINCIPLES TO REALLY MAKE SURE THESE FUNDS ARE REALLY MEETING THE GOALS AND NEEDS OF PEOPLE IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. THE FIRST GOAL IS, RELIEVE TRAFFIC CONGESTION FIRST AND FOR MOST. THE SECOND IS MAKE SURE THERE IS A BALANCE EQUITABLE APPROACH AND MAKING SURE THE DOLLARS REACH AND BENEFIT EVERYONE IN CONTRA COSTA. THE OTHER IS ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY. WE DO KNOW THAT WE HAVE A JOB HOUSING IMBALANCE SO THESE DOLLARS NEED TO BE REALLY HELP GENERATE JOBS AND HELP GENERATE THE ECONOMY IN TERMS OF REDUCING AND REVERSING PEOPLE'S COMMUTES RATHER THEN MAKING THEM WORK OUTSIDE OF CONTRA COSTA. WE NEED THEM TO WORK IN CONTRA COSTA. SO WE DESIGNED THE EXPENDITURE PLAN FUNDING CATEGORIES TO SPEAK TO PEOPLE'S COMMUTE. MAKING SURE WHEN THEY LOOK AT THE EXPENDITURE PLAN THEY CAN SEE THESE DOLLARS ARE DEDICATED TO MY COMMUTE, DEDICATED TO THE HIGHWAY 4 CATEGORY, DEDICATED AT 242 SO SO WE DESIGNED THAT IN A WAY SO PEOPLE FEEL THIS IS WHAT WE ARE GOING TO GET AND THIS IS HOW THE EXPENDITURE PLAN WILL BENEFIT ME AND MY COMMUTE. WE HAVE A VARIETY OF COUNTY WIDE PROGRAMS. THE FIRST IS RUN TO SOURCE. JUST LIKE MEASURE J CITY OF OAKLEY WILL CONTINUE TO RECEIVE 18 PERCENT OF RETURN TO SOURCE OVER THE LIFE OF THE MEASURE. ALSO WE'LL HAVE $642 MILLION TOTAL OF TRANSIT GOING INTO CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. WE HAVE A UNPRECEDENTED AMOUNT OF DOLLARS SET ASIDE FOR WALKING AND BIKING. WE ASK PEOPLE TO WALK AND BIKE MORE SO MAKE SURE THERE IS FUNDING TO HAVE GOOD AND SAFE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR WALKING AND BIKING. ACCESSIBLE TRANSPORTATION, PARA TRANSIT SUBS. I LEARNED A LOT ABOUT PARA TRANSIT SERVICES AND FOUND IT TAKES SOMEONE NEAR TO 2 TO 4 HOURS TO GO FROM ONE SIDE THE COUNTY TO THE OTHER SIDE USING PARA TRANSIT SERVICE SO WE WANT TO MAKE SURE WE REDUCE THAT AND V A SEAMLESS COORDINATED CUSTOMER FOCUS PARA TRANSIT SERVICES IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. MAKE SURE WE HAVE CLEANER SAFER BART. THAT IS PRETTY SELF EXPLANATORY. SAFE TRANSPORTATION FOR YOUTH AND STUDENT AND HAVE TRANSIT PASSES AND SAFE ROUTES OF WALKING AND BIKING TO SCHOOLS. REDUCE AND REVERSE COMMUTES. TARGETED DOLLARS TO SUPPORT JOB CENTERS, EMPLOYMENT CENTERS AND TRANSIT CENTERS SO WE CAN REDUCE AND REVERSE COMMUTES. A GOOD EXAMPLE OF THAT IS DUPONT FULL SILTY. YOU NEED INFRASTRUCTURE TO ATTRACT JOBS AND BRING THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INTO THE CITY OF OAKLEY AND SO YOU ARE CREATING JOBS WITH DUPONT SO THAT CATEGORY WOULD BE A GOOD EXAMPLE OF DIRECTING THOSE FUNDS FOR INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT YOUR DUPONT FACILITY. AND THEN REDUCING MISSION AND IMPROVE AIR QUALITY WE KNOW IN ORDER TO REDUCE GREEN HOUSE GAS AND IMPROVE AIR QUALITY WE NEED TO RELY ON OTHER TYPES OF CARS, ZERO EMISSION VEHICLES AND ELECTRIC VEHICLES SO MAKING SURE WE HAVE A INFRASTRUCTURE THAT SUPPORTS THAT AND MAKE SURE WHEN YOU GO TO TARGET OR WALMART THERE IS GOING TO BE A CHA

Minutes of the Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Meeting held October 8, 2019 1. OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Vice Mayor Doug Hardcastle called the meeting to order in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California at 6:30 p.m. In addition to Vice Mayor Hardcastle, Councilmembers Sue Higgins and Kevin Romick were present. Vice Mayor Hardcastle announced Mayor Claire Alaura was absent due to a family emergency and Councilmember Randy Pope was absent due to his police duty. Vice Mayor Hardcastle made a public service announcement that PG&E has not informed the City that it will be subject to a power shut off and if the City is notified, it will be 48 hours in advance of the shut off in which the City will post information on its website, provide through its email distribution lists and also include on its message board at City Hall. He suggested residents prepare in advance for any emergency situation where they could be without food and water for 2-3 days regardless of a power shut off. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Girl Scout Troop #33784) Members of Girl Scout Troop #33784 led the Pledge of Allegiance. The City Council thanked them. 1.3 Swearing in of the Oakley Police Department Explorers (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Chief of Police Eric Christensen provided information regarding the Explorer program. He introduced the Explorers and thanked Officer Casey Minister for managing the program and Gabriela Banos-Galvan, You, Me, We=Oakley! Program Coordinator, for her role in the program. Chief Christensen congratulated Explorers Juliette Sartain and Daniel Romero for their promotion to Sergeant Explorers. City Clerk Libby Vreonis administered the oath of office to the Explorers.

2. PUBLIC COMMENTS None. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Public Financing Authority Meeting held September 24, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Award of Construction Contract to DC Electric Group, Inc. for the Installation of the Emergency Generator for the Civic Center Emergency Generator Project – Capital Improvement Project Number 228 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.3 Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute a Termination of the Deferred Improvement Agreement Concerning 2131 O'Hara Avenue (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 3.4 Appointment of Michael Syrett to the Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.5 Notice of Vacancy of One Seat on the Oakley City Council and Approval of an Appointment Process to Fill the Vacancy for the Remainder of the Term which shall expire in November of 2020 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.6 Text Amendments to Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 (Noise Control) Related to Excluding Residential Related Sites and Uses from Receiving Permits for Sound-Amplification Equipment (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Vice Mayor Hardcastle pulled item 3.5 from the Consent Calendar. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the remainder of the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) Item 3.5 Vice Mayor Hardcastle announced he received a public comment from George Fuller regarding item 3.5.

Mr. Fuller commented that in 2013, the City made a loan in the amount of $935k to a private developer and he believes its first increment was provided to the developer in the amount of $343k, then four years later the City determined the funds were embezzled and a warrant was made for the developer’s arrest. He also commented the City is spending money to construct a parking lot for the private developer of the medical building on Main Street of which project seems to be a bouncing ball, and the City provided a $74k loan to a private developer for a business at 4th and Main Streets. He inquired how the City can say that a minimum $44k is too costly to hold an election to fill the vacancy seat and approve an appointment process when constituents are seeking a vote. He shared that in his opinion, an appointment of 1 day is too many and a year is a lifetime. He requested the City Council vote no on item 3.5. Councilmember Higgins commented that initially she was in favor of an election process for transparency; however, she considered the candidate may have to run for the seat twice within approximately 1.5 years because he or she would run in March and then possibly again in November for the next four-year term which is a lot of burden to place upon someone. She explained an election could be closer to $100k and the City is very frugal with money. She also explained that she has been elected for a reason which includes the decision who to appoint. Councilmember Romick commented that loans have been made and money spent on specific items that cannot be spent on elections because they are designated for other purposes. He mentioned it is financially difficult to campaign and the candidate would potentially engage in two campaigns which could be burdensome. It was moved by Councilmember Higgins and seconded by Councilmember Romick to approve item 3.5. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Twin Oaks Senior Residence Mixed-Use Project (CUP 02-19, DR 07-19, and DBA 01-19) – Request for approval of a Conditional Use Permit, Design Review, and Density Bonus Housing Agreement to construct a mixed-use project including 130 affordable senior apartment units and 5,667 sq. ft. of commercial space located at 2605 Main Street (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Vice Mayor Hardcastle opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Ken Strelo presented the staff report including changes outlined by staff.

Moe Mohanna, Principal and Owner of M.H. Development Company, provided a presentation regarding the project and explained the rent structure and its regulation by agencies. Ernie Vasquez, Partner and CEO of SVA Architects, provided information regarding the project design. Councilmember Higgins inquired if fire escapes will be provided for the third floor of the building and how people who may be immobile would evacuate during an emergency situation. Mr. Vasquez responded that there is a waiting space near the elevator and the fire department would assist with evacuations. Councilmember Romick commented that he understands the percentages in which rents are calculated. He inquired who sets the rents. Mr. Mohanna explained the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) sets the rents. Councilmember Romick commented that if residents have concerns regarding rents for this housing, they would not come to the City to address the concerns because HUD sets the rents. Mr. Mohanna confirmed the City is not the agency to address the rents. He explained that HUD publishes rents and over time there could be rent increases and operating expense increases, but notice will first be published and provided to tenants. He explained that community facilities district charges are significant in Oakley and therefore it is likely that rent increases will be necessary to cover costs. He also explained that rents are dictated by HUD and what the market maintains, but are not under City control. Councilmember Higgins inquired if pets will be allowed. Mr. Mohanna responded that small pets will be allowed and a small park area will be located in the back of the project site for pet use. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that it seems like a well-regulated business. He inquired if the management company could implement a rent increase if it wanted to; i.e., by $500/month. Mr. Mohanna explained the project will be over-regulated by the State, the lender, the investors and their company (through its asset management company and third party auditors) and there is no freedom to charge whatever they want. He added the financial penalties for doing so are significant.

Vice Mayor Hardcastle inquired how many people can occupy a unit. Mr. Mohanna responded that the maximum occupancy per unit is 2 people for a senior community, regardless of the size of the unit. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that affordable and low-income housing are often confused. Mr. Mohanna explained that the tax credit program is called the “low-income tax credit program” as termed by Congress for 50% rents that range from $1100-$1300 which is not low-income, but affordable. He opined that Congress created the term “low-income” to help the program sell better. He added that a market study was conducted for this site and it showed the demand is 1,110 units; however, they can only provide 130 units; therefore, he anticipates a much greater demand than supply. Vice Mayor Hardcastle called for public comments. Diane Spurrier commented she is a resident at Summer Creek Place in Oakley and more low-income, affordable housing units are needed as residents at Summer Creek Place are being forced out due to rent increases while corporate is receiving the tax breaks and incentives. She expressed she does not believe HUD rates are being used because of the significant increases recently implemented. She explained with the majority of homeless people now being seniors, Oakley needs fixed-income housing, not affordable housing because it is not affordable for someone on a fixed income. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented the developer would have to have their own money rather than government loans to build it to make it affordable for people with low or no income. Councilmember Romick inquired if staff has set up contact information available for anyone needing to address rent increases. City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded that he has spoken with Ms. Spurrier many times and she has been meeting with housing representatives. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that the City does not set rents. Ms. Spurrier commented that the City can reach out to other agencies. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that was addressed at the last meeting. Ms. Spurrier responded that no one from the City showed up to their meeting, but Dawn Morrow from Supervisor Diane Burgis’ office attended the meeting and

wondered why the issue was not addressed earlier in which a resident provided her a letter that was written a year ago. Vice Mayor Hardcastle suggested Ms. Spurrier could also contact Assemblymember Jim Frazier. He thanked her for her input. Two online comments were received. Mike Stewart and Charles Daggett both expressed support for the project. The public hearing was closed. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve item 4.1 with changes as outlined by staff. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 5. REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Resolution of Support for the Contra Costa Transportation Authority’s (Authority) proposed Draft Transportation Expenditure Plan (TEP) (Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) Deputy Executive Director Tim Hale with the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA) presented the CCTA 2020 Transportation Expenditure Plan. Councilmember Higgins inquired if CCTA is asking every City for support and if financial support is being requested. Mr. Hale responded that CCTA will place the measure on the ballot and therefore will be financially responsible, but it needs the support of the majority of cities with majority population for the county-wide measure. Councilmember Higgins inquired if Oakley is CCTA’s first ask. Mr. Hale responded that Oakley is not CCTA’s first ask; they are approximately half way through presentations with the cities. Councilmember Romick commented he is on the CCTA Board and thanked Mr. Hale for doing a great job presenting the information. He explained the cities’ support helps to place the measure on the ballot. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that he likes the plan and inquired how the money will be kept from the State.

Mr. Hale explained the ballot measure is for a local tax and the State cannot take the money generated by the tax. Councilmember Higgins inquired what type of tax is being proposed. Mr. Hale responded a local sales tax is being proposed. Vice Mayor Hardcastle thanked Mr. Hale for his presentation and called for public comments. Antonio Acevedo, Field Representative for Local 152 Carpenter’s Union, expressed support for the ballot measure. Mark Fuchs, Executive Director of the Carpenters Training Committee for Northern California, expressed support for the ballot measure with approval of a joint apprenticeship program. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve item 5.1. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 6. REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager None. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Romick reported he attended a Reclamation District 2137 meeting today in charge of the Dutch Slough Tidal Restoration Project and the heavy equipment located near the project is not being used for building houses but rather to restore marsh land; the equipment should be removed toward end of November. He explained Marsh Creek is being rerouted through a channel. He further explained the project involves a unique process of creating marsh land out of sand and beginning this month, wood habitat structures will be installed for turtles, followed by tulie planting November through February. He mentioned that 175 acres on the Burroughs property will be for mitigation of the swainson hawk. He also reported he attended a

kayak tour of Big Break last week and applied what he learned to the restoration project. He expressed that he hopes the two areas can connect eventually to provide a unique destination of 3,000 acres of open space along the Delta. Councilmember Higgins reported she attended the first Joint Park Use meeting with the schools which was held the same time as the community meeting with the Summer Creek Place residents which was the reason she could not attend the latter. She shared that the joint use areas were reviewed during the meeting including use and condition and another meeting will be held to further discuss the sites. She mentioned the school district has hired two additional staff members to handle maintenance. She also reported she attended Stand Down on the Delta for four mornings, the Mayors’ Conference in which the CCTA 2020 Transportation Expenditure Plan was discussed, and she began the CERT program. Vice Mayor Hardcastle reported he attended the Friday Night Bites and concert which was well attended. He also reported he attended the kayak tour of Big Break and East Bay Parks offers the tour if anyone is interested. He mentioned Tri-Delta Transit is getting ready to build a parking lot in Oakley for a park and ride. He asked staff to confirm how many parking spaces will be provided. City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded the lot will provide over 100 parking spaces. (b) Requests for Future Agendas None. 7. WORK SESSIONS None. 8. CLOSED SESSION None. 9. ADJOURN There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:07 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk

Showing the first 24,000 of 896,007 characters. The full document is at the source.

AGENDA REGULAR JOINT MEETING OF THE OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/ OAKLEY PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY Tuesday, October 08, 2019 6:30 PM Oakley City Council Chambers, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA MISSION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley exists to build and enhance a quality community and to serve the public in a friendly, efficient, responsive manner. VISION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley will be recognized as a model of civic participation and a vibrant Delta community where families live, work, play, shop and visit. Agendas are posted in Oakley at Oakley City Hall-3231 Main Street, outside the gym at Delta Vista Middle School-4901 Frank Hengel Way and outside the Library at Freedom High School-1050 Neroly Road; agendas are also posted on the City’s Internet Website www.ci.oakley.ca.us. A complete packet of information containing staff reports and exhibits related to each item is available for public review prior to an Oakley City Council and/or City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority meeting at Oakley City Hall, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Oakley City Council, Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency or Oakley Public Financing Authority regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection, during regular business hours, at the front counter in the Main Lobby of the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Agendas may be picked up at the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561 for no charge. To request information regarding placement on the City’s agenda e-mail distribution list, please contact us at (925) 625-7000. We provide social media options to stay connected to City Hall through Facebook, Twitter, Next Door and Instagram. Other opportunities to connect with City Hall include Peak Democracy, Oakley OnDemand and Constant Contacts. Please contact us at (925) 625-7000 for additional information or visit our website at www.oakleyinfo.com If you have a physically challenging condition and require special accommodations, please call the City Clerk’s office at (925) 625-7013. 1

Please keep cell phones/electronic devices turned off during the meeting. Please be advised that City Council meetings are video recorded and attendees may appear on video. 1. OPENING MATTERS Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Girl Scout Troop #33784 ) 1.3 Swearing in of the Oakley Police Department Explorers (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 2. PUBLIC COMMENTS At this time, the public is permitted to address the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority on non-agendized items. PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES. In accordance with State Law, however, no action or discussion may take place on any item not appearing on the posted agenda. The Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority may respond to statements made or questions asked or may request Staff to report back at a future meeting on the matter. The exceptions under which the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority MAY discuss and/or take action on items not appearing on the agenda are contained in Government Code §54954.2(b)(1)(2)(3). Members of the public should submit any Speaker Cards for Public Comments in advance of the Mayor calling for Public Comments. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar items are typically non-controversial in nature and are considered for approval by the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority with one single action. Members of the audience, Staff or the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority who would like an item removed from the Consent Calendar for purposes of public input may request the Mayor remove the item. Members of the public should submit any Speaker Cards related to the Consent Calendar in advance of the Consent Calendar being considered. 2

3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Public Financing Authority Meeting held September 24, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Minutes 09-24-19 3.2 Award of Construction Contract to DC Electric Group, Inc. for the Installation of the Emergency Generator for the Civic Center Emergency Generator Project – Capital Improvement Project Number 228 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Resolution 2. DC Electric Group, Inc. Proposal 3.3 Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute a Termination of the Deferred Improvement Agreement Concerning 2131 O'Hara Avenue (Derek Cole, City Attorney) Staff Report 1. Resolution 2. Notice of Termination 3.4 Appointment of Michael Syrett to the Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Staff Report 1. Application 2. Resolution 3.5 Notice of Vacancy of One Seat on the Oakley City Council and Approval of an Appointment Process to Fill the Vacancy for the Remainder of the Term which shall expire in November of 2020 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Staff Report 1. Notice of Vacancy 2. Resolution 3.6 Text Amendments to Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 (Noise Control) Related to Excluding Residential Related Sites and Uses from Receiving Permits for Sound-Amplification Equipment (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Staff Report 1. Redline version of Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 3

2. Proposed Ordinance 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Twin Oaks Senior Residence Mixed-Use Project (CUP 02-19, DR 07-19, and DBA 01-19) – Request for approval of a Conditional Use Permit, Design Review, and Density Bonus Housing Agreement to construct a mixed-use project including 130 affordable senior apartment units and 5,667 sq. ft. of commercial space located at 2605 Main Street (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Suggested Action: Staff recommendation: 1) Open the Public Hearing, 2) Receive the Staff Report, 3) Receive Questions from the City Council, 4) Receive Comments from the Applicant, 5) Receive Public Testimony, 6) Close the Public Hearing, 7) Deliberate, 8) Summarize the Deliberation, and 9) Adopt the Resolutions. Staff Report 1. Vicinity Map 2. Public Hearing Notice 3. Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration 4. Applicant's Plans 5. Proposed Conditional Use Permit and Design Review Resolution 5.a Exhibit A - Mitigation Monitoring Program 6. Proposed Density Bonus Housing Agreement Resolution 6.a Exhibit A - Proposed Density Bonus Housing Agreement (including Exhibits "A, B, and D" to Agreement) 6.b Exhibit B - Exhibit "C" to Agreement 5. REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Resolution of Support for the Contra Costa Transportation Authority’s (Authority) proposed Draft Transportation Expenditure Plan (TEP) (Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) Suggested Action: Adopt the Resolution Staff Report 1. CCTA Ordinance 19-01 of August 28, 2019 2. 2020 Transportation Expenditure Plan, GMP information starts on pg 29 3. Resolution 6. REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY 4

(a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency (b) Requests for Future Agendas 7. WORK SESSIONS 8. CLOSED SESSION 9. ADJOURN 5

Minutes of the Joint Meeting of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Oakley Public Financing Authority held September 24, 2019 1) OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Mayor Claire Alaura called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California. In addition to Mayor Alaura, Vice Mayor Doug Hardcastle and Councilmembers Sue Higgins, Randy Pope and Kevin Romick were present. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Addie Villeda, 5th Grade Student at Almond Grove Elementary School) 5th Grade Almond Grove Elementary School Student Addie Villeda led the Pledge of Allegiance. The City Council thanked her. 1.3 Proclamation to East Contra Costa Fire Protection District, Ironhouse Sanitary District and Diablo Water District for Special Districts Week Mayor Alaura presented proclamations to East Contra Costa Fire Protection District, Ironhouse Sanitary District and Diablo Water District to recognize special districts week, September 22-28, for special districts that serve the Oakley community. Brian Oftedal, President of the Board of Directors of East Contra Costa Fire Protection District, accepted the proclamation. Peter Zerkle, President of the Board of Directors, and Susan Morgan, Director, of Ironhouse Sanitary District, accepted the proclamation. Ed Garcia, President of the Board of Directors of Diablo Water District, accepted the proclamation. 2) PUBLIC COMMENTS Contra Costa Community College District Trustee Greg Enholm invited everyone to attend the District’s State of the District events. He mentioned they hold one event at all five of its locations which includes three colleges and two centers; the location that would be most convenient for the Oakley community will be held October 1 at the Los Medanos College Pittsburg Campus (Community Room L-109) beginning at 7 a.m. He concluded by mentioning he left information cards in the back of the room for people who are interested in attending. He thanked the City Council. No online comments were submitted for Public Comments or other agenda items. 6

3) CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held September 10, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Waive the second reading and adopt an Ordinance approving the Rezone for The Vines at Oakley Subdivision 9507 (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) 3.3 Creating Zone 171 within the Oakley Special Police Tax Area consisting of the Shiloh Subdivision 8975 project located at the southwest corner of Main Street and Simoni Ranch Road (APN 034-250-011) (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) No public comments were submitted for the Consent Calendar. Mayor Alaura pulled item 1.3. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Vice Mayor Hardcastle to approve the remainder of the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) Item 1.3 City Clerk Libby Vreonis provided a correction to the meeting minutes. She mentioned on Page 4 of the minutes, under Section 2.0 for Public Comments, the last sentence of comments made by Mike Dupray should be revised to state, “He mentioned the homeless issue will get worse by this situation; it costs about $300k to leave people homeless, but only $50k to get them off the streets.” It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the minutes as amended. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) 4) PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Adoption of an ordinance of the City of Oakley extending a moratorium on the issuance or renewal of use permits, variances, building permits, business licenses or any other entitlements or permits providing for the use, commencement, establishment or operation of short-term rentals within the City of Oakley (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) The staff report was presented by Community Development Director Joshua McMurray. Mayor Alaura inquired if there is any other pending legislation that is dependent on what staff is researching on the issue in the ordinance. Mr. McMurray responded that he believes the court cases that staff was most concerned about have passed and staff has a good handle on the ordinance to be brought for the Council’s 7

consideration; staff needs a little more time to prepare a comprehensive ordinance so this safeguards the City in the meanwhile. Mayor Alaura announced there were no public comments submitted for item 4.1. Councilmember Romick commented that there are a number of lawsuits in progress that may impact how the City moves forward; therefore, it is good to wait for the lawsuits to go through the process before the City Council jumps in and makes laws that may be overturned in the near future. City Attorney Derek Cole commented that he is carefully watching legislation and litigation; when a significant ruling occurs one way another, staff will be sure to provide a proper, up to date, and legally complaint ordinance for the Council’s consideration. Mayor Alaura inquired if there is an expected time frame when the cases might come through. Mr. Cole responded he expects it could be in the next year, but with potential appeals, it could be a developing issue for the next two to three years, much like the cannabis issue was and still is. He added it is not an issue that is going to go away and he agrees at this point it is best to adopt the urgency ordinance, but he still feels strongly the permanent ordinance would be a lawful exercise of City authority based on current law. Mayor Alaura expressed concern that the moratorium may impact people who are following the rules. She mentioned there was a gentleman who attended a previous City Council meeting who indicated the moratorium adversely affects his income because short-term rentals supplement his income and his ability to pay his mortgage. She explained she appreciates staff taking time to do its due diligence and to research what other cities are doing to propose the ordinance, but she does not want to take away from those following the rules and the longer the City waits, perhaps there are others that would also suffer. She requested if it is safe to say that the City can put out the permanent ordinance, maybe the moratorium should only be extended three to six months. She explained a year seems a little excessive, especially since it is unknown how long it may take for other rulings to occur. Councilmember Romick explained that the City Council can pass an ordinance anytime within the next year; the time proposed gives the City Council time it may need if things should go differently, but if can be resolved quicker, the City Council can pass the ordinance before one year. He added it might only take a month or two. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to adopt the ordinance. AYES: Hardcastle, Higgins, Pope, Romick; NOES: Alaura. (4-1) 5) REGULAR CALENDAR-None 6) REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager City Manager Bryan Montgomery reported the City hosted a very successful Heart of Oakley Festival Saturday. He thanked residents for their participation in the festival and for their 8

patience with the road closure. He announced the City will host two events in October, Friday Night Bites on October 4 and the Harvest Festival on October 26 (both events will be held at Civic Center Plaza). 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Higgins reported she attended Contra Costa Community College District’s State of the District meeting September 19 and requested City Manager Bryan Montgomery follow up with Dr. Kratochvil to explore trade schools for Oakley. She also reported she attended a human trafficking workshop in Antioch which will be brought forward at the Mayors’ Conference in October. She announced the Oakley Library is looking for book donations. She reported she attended the Ironhouse Sanitary District meeting and the Jersey Island bridge is close to being completed. She mentioned the District is working on GPS mapping for the sewer system which is underneath so they can better track where repairs are needed. Mayor Alaura reported she attended the Contra Costa County Aviation Advisory meeting with Councilmember Romick where Contra Costa Transportation Authority provided a presentation regarding its expenditure plan and if the ballot measure passes, how it may tie into a connection between Vasco Road and the Byron airport. She announced the 20th Anniversary Committee brick sales began before the Heart of Oakley Festival and for anyone interested in purchasing a brick, it does not have to be to commemorate a dog; it can be purchased for any pet, a family member or business of which funds will go toward a shade structure for the dog park. She asked Recreation Manager Lindsey Bruno how many bricks were sold. Ms. Bruno responded that approximately a dozen bricks were sold. Councilmember Pope inquired where the bricks will be laid. Mayor Alaura explained that the bricks will be laid in the center of the round decorative cement area at the bottom of the stairs. Mayor Alaura announced she and Chef Stephane Tonnelier from the Oakley Bistro will participate in the Mayors’ Cook-off this Thursday; the event will be held in Todos Santos Plaza in Concord. She also announced the East Contra Costa Family Justice Center Grand Opening will be held Friday, September 27, and it will be a great asset to the community. Vice Mayor Doug Hardcastle announced he has decided to retire from the City Council. He shared that fifty years ago, he signed up for the U.S. Army on October 13, which was the start of his public service. He mentioned he sold his businesses recently, he is enjoying retirement, and it is time for him and his wife to travel and spend time with family. He indicated November 9, will be his last day. He expressed appreciation for everything staff and the City have done. He shared he has enjoyed his time in Oakley and he thanked everyone for their support. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented that assuming the City Council does not want to call a special election due to cost, staff will place an item on the next agenda in which staff will recommend the appointment process for the remainder of the term (one year) and can solicit 9

applications in the meanwhile, but can shift gears if the decision is made otherwise. He thanked Vice Mayor Hardcastle for all of his years serving the Oakley community on the City Council and at Ironhouse Sanitary District. He mentioned Vice Mayor indicated November 9 as his last day, but November 12 is actually the City Council meeting date; staff can submit applications that date in which Vice Mayor Hardcastle can participate in reviewing, if the Council prefers. Mayor Alaura commented that it will be placed on the next agenda for an official vote, but it does not seem that there is any harm done to seek out now a replacement. (b) Requests for Future Agendas None. 7) WORK SESSION-None 8) CLOSED SESSIONS-None 9) ADJOURN There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:52 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk 10

STAFF REPORT Approved and Forwarded to the City Council DATE: October 8, 2019 TO: Bryan Montgomery, City Manager FROM: Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer SUBJECT: Award of Contract to DC Electric Group, Inc. for the Installation of the generator for the Oakley Civic Center Emergency Generator Project – CIP 228 Background and Analysis The City’s adopted FY 2019/20 Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Budget designates funding for various infrastructure and facility improvement projects. This is consistent with the City’s goals to improve the quality of the City’s public infrastructure and to enhance the quality of life and safety for our residents. The Civic Center facility is the center of government in Oakley which handles all critical functions for the community residents, including Police services. The current Civic Center facility does not have a standby emergency generator to address the frequent PG&E power outages that take place in this region. During the last City Council Strategic Planning meeting, the need for having continued and uninterrupted service at the Civic Center was amongst the major goals, which included the installation of a standby emergency generator to address the electricity needs of the Civic Center facility; especially the Police Department. If the City is faced with an extended power outage, without a standby emergency generator, we will not be able to provide critical support functions from the Civic Center facility to the community. At the July 9, 2019 meeting, City Council approved the award of a contract to purchase an emergency generator from Cummins, Inc. This generator is in the manufacturing process and expected to be delivered to the site in January 2020 for installation. In preparation for the delivery and installation of the generator, staff has solicited bids from electrical contractors for the installation of this generator and its start-up operations. On September 26, 2019 a total of three (3) bids were received for the installation of the generator as follows: 11

DC Electric Group, Inc $65,182 Johnston & Sons Electric, Inc. $71,600 Dillon Electric, Inc. $112,150 DC Electric Group, Inc. was the lowest responsible bidder for the project and have all the resources needed to install the generator. The installation of the generator will involve preparing the site and construction of the concrete pad for the generator and its associated components, installation of new conduits and wiring to connect the existing PG&E transformer and electrical switch panels at the Civic Center to the generator, fueling up and starting the new generator. Fiscal Impact The current FY 2019/20 budget for this project is $150,000 from the General Capital Projects Fund. This budget covers the purchase and installation cost of the generator. The cost for the purchase of the generator and to obtain State of California regulatory agency permits has been approximately $122,000. In order to complete the installation and startup of the generator, an additional budget of $46,000 will be required. Staff Recommendation Staff recommends that the City Council adopt the resolution approving the award of the construction contract for the installation of the emergency generator for the Civic Center to DC Electric Group, Inc. in the amount of $65,182, and authorize the City Manager to execute the agreement. Additionally, due to variables associated with construction projects, and to address unforeseen circumstances during the course of construction. In addition, staff recommends that the City Council authorize staff to execute future change orders to the construction contract as necessary, in an amount not to exceed $5,000 for work beyond what is defined in the base bid project. It is also recommended that a budget adjustment in the amount of $46,000 be made for this project and authorized by City Council. Th

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Oct 8, 2019 - 01:39 PM — Minutes
  • Oct 8, 2019 - 01:39 PM

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 820b1b20ac04da58bfda37d880a7075f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record