POLISCOPE

The public record

FORTMYERS (LEE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Council Budget Retreat

Friday, May 2, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Fort Myers City Council reviewed a consultant's study on city development fees, including building permits, planning, and fire inspections. The study suggests that the city is currently over-collecting fees in some areas and recommends adjusting the fee structure to achieve 100% cost recovery, including new fees for floodplain reviews.

Why it matters

Residents and developers may see changes to the costs of building permits, planning approvals, and fire inspections as the city moves to align its fee revenue with the actual cost of providing those services.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 62,933 characters. The full document is at the source.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 1 | P a g e MINUTES CITY OF FORT MYERS CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP BUDGET SESSION RETREAT May 2, 2025 CALL TO ORDER The City Council of the City of Fort Myers, Florida, met in a Budget Work Session at The Collaboratory, 2031 Jackson Street, Fort Myers, Florida, Friday, May 2, 2025, at 8:30 a.m. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Anderson led the Pledge of Allegiance. ROLL CALL Present were, Mayor Kevin B. Anderson (left 11:27 a.m.-12:15 p.m.), Councilpersons Teresa Watkins Brown, Diana Giraldo, Fred Burson, Terolyn P. Watson (arrived at 10:20 a.m.), Liston Bochette III. (via Zoom), & Darla Bonk, City Manager Marty K. Lawing, City Attorney Grant Alley, and City Clerk Mary Hagemann. 1.CITY MANAGER ITEMS 1.1 Discuss budget for fiscal year 2025-2026 ITEM NO. 1-Building Permit Rates Study Steve Belden, Community Development Director, and MGT Consulting provided an update on MGT’s Development service user fee study. Georgia Borison, MGT’s Senior Consultant, stated that they’ve been helping the City of Fort Myers, Florida, with a development service user fee update. She provided information on their background, project history, scope of their work, study process, methodology, and their ultimate findings & recommendations. She disclosed that MGT was a nationally recognized consulting firm with over a 1000 employees with a focus on sled consulting: state, local, and educational government. Ms. Georgia Borison stated that Mark Carpenter was the Project Manager for this study, with 20 years of user fee experience. She disclosed that for this project, they’ve performed a user free update for Fort Myers back in 2018. In 2023, they had contracted them to

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 2 | P a g e conduct a study update for the following divisions for Building, Planning, Engineering, & Fire. Then they also analyzed their BTR fees and their supplemental fees. She noted that they haven’t completed a comprehensive fee study with the city in over 6 years since 2018. She noted that this study is an update from 2018 which includes fees for service activities, fines, and penalties. She disclosed that non-user fee related services were not analyzed, such as impact fees. She stated that these were just for user fees, fines, and penalties, and the study was conducted and completed between MGT and Fort Myers City staff. Ms. Georgia Borison stated that the scope of this project was to calculate the full cost of all development related user fee services. She noted that they want to ensure fees are dedicated exclusively to related services and they aim to recover the costs incurred by the city through the use of staff hours, resources, and other operational expenses. She disclosed that any service that provides a general global community benefit such as long range planning, fire, suppression, and park maintenance are funded by tax revenue. She noted that any service that provides both global benefit, specific group, or individual benefits, such as code enforcement or appeals are funded by a mix of tax and fee revenue. She noted that any service that provides primary benefits to both, an individual or group and less global community benefits involves; building permits, planning, and zoning approvals, and fire permitting are funded primarily via fee revenue. She states which is what they primarily focused on in this study. Georgia Borison, MGT’s Senior Consultant, stated that the “Total Cost” in their study, calculates a mix of indirect, direct, cross departmental, technology, and maintenance costs. She stated that the methodology that they followed was a “bottoms up” approach to most development user fees. She stated that they identify all direct staff time spent on the fee related activities or services, and then they calculate the direct cost of the staff for each of the fees, using productive hourly rates, and those productive hourly rates are calculated by backing out any “unproductive time.” She noted that then they compare total cost to the current fees on the fee schedule, and then they recommend any adjustments. She stated that the total cost of user fee services is $10.7 million, the revenue was currently over that, and the city is over collecting, especially within areas like Fire and Planning. MGT recommended to hit that 100% cost recovery, they should bring the fees down. She noted that they recommend a tiered fee schedule for the new construction permit fees from the current method where the fees are charged on a minimum fee of $35 and $4.50 an hour per 1,000 of construction valuation. She noted that they’re also proposing over the counter permits for 14 separate over the counter permits just for ease. Additionally, they’re recommending floodplain, plan, review, and inspection for the review and inspection of residential and commercial floodplain designations. She stated that currently, there are no fees charged for this, but they’re recommending creating new fees and implementing flat fees for inspection and plan review. She stated that finally, a key recommendation that they're recommending is a master plan with reduced fees for repeat plan checks. They're proposing that they implement fees for the Master Plan reviews and discounted fees when plans are submitted for permits.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 3 | P a g e Councilperson Bonk asked if they had the fluctuation rate over a 5 year period, in terms of how much they keep in reserves, based off how much the fluctuation may take place year after year. Jerry Wolf , MGT Director, disclosed that they recommend a healthy reserve in these departments. He noted that they recommend a 12-18 month reserve for building departments due to the fluctuation year over year in building activity. Steve Belden, Community Development Director, stated that the City of Fort Myers, Building Zoning Oversight committee adopted a policy of maintaining an 18-month reserve. This puts them in the $7 million range, and they’ve been running a $10 million reserve, but they’ve reduced their reserve by cutting permit fees. He disclosed that this doesn’t include Engineering or Fire. Councilperson Bonk inquired if the floodplain plan flat fee was a standard revenue capture that other municipalities were doing and if this was a need for them to start implementing this fee. MGT Director Jerry Wolf stated that this was a very common thing, and most places collect this fee in advance when they receive the initial plan. He disclosed that reviewing floodplains takes 2-3 or more years. Councilperson Bonk continued to ask questions about the fees. Councilperson Girlado asked when someone is doing a window replacement size for size if that was particularly the reason why it's not part of the over the counter permit. Mr. Brent confirmed that this was correct, because they have to do reviews for window impact or non-impact, which is why they can’t do a flat fee. Councilperson Girlado then asked MGT for their infrastructure costs and if that would encompass the footprint of the space where the staff works, and do they encompass when they rent places for a particular fee that fluctuates. Ms. Georgia Borison stated that she believes so but would have to look back into their files for what was included in the infrastructure cost. Mr. Jerry Wolf stated that many places have supplemental charges on top of their building permits such as technology fees or surcharges. Mr. Steve Belden also stated that overhead costs were also factored into their study. Councilperson Girlado stated that they want to make sure this is encompassed into the study due to them moving on to create a new City Hall. Mr. Steve Belden noted that want to make sure they’re updating this on a recurring basis and not wait another 5-10 years again. Councilperson Burson inquired how this compares to the City of Cape Coral and Lee County as far as the recommended fees they charge. Ms. Georgia Borison stated that they didn’t do a fee to fee comparison, but they surveyed other localities to look into a private provider discount. Mr. Brent confirmed that they actually did a fee to fee comparison. He stated that they reached out to Collier County all the way up to Sarasota County, to find out the fees and every municipality is different. He further explained that some charge by the square foot of the construction, others charge by the job value. He noted that the county also does it by square footage and the City of Cape Coral, does it by job value. Councilperson Burson noted that he was concerned about affordable housing and the regulatory fees that make it hard to have affordable housing. Mr. Steve Belden commented that they’ve discussed their Affordable Housing

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 4 | P a g e Trust Fund, and part of the purpose of that trust fund is to make affordable housing more affordable. Councilperson Bonk asked how they were anticipating what the impact of the salary study was doing to these fees or if this was going to require an updated study. City Manager Lawing stated that this would probably need to build a cushion in because this will be done in the salary studies several months away. Mr. Steve Belden stated that this was why they’d need to keep this updated on a on frequent basis every 2-3 years so they can factor those things in. Mr. Jerry Wolf stated that they recommend a major review of the fees every 5-6 years on the interim. Councilperson Liston Bochette stated that he wants to pick up where Councilperson Burson left at and mention how they’re encouraging single family homes, not just more rental apartments that create a transitory type of relationship with their citizens. He then mentioned how the word “affordable” is a loose term and how if you help one person then they’re discriminating against another. He disclosed if they have a fee adjustment, it needs to be across the board because they also need affordable housing, attainable housing, and luxury housing to balance out their tax base. He noted that he wants to be fair to everyone. City Manager Lawing inquired if they based these fees on the tiers and value would they have a way to verify that submitted projects plan is accurate or within reason. Mr. Brent confirmed this and stated when a permit application comes in, they’re required to give them a job value. He disclosed that if it’s a new construction then they’ll verify it through the International Code Council Building Valuation table which he states is how they verify what their job value is. Councilperson Burson inquired if the services that they’ve used make those adjustments based on their location in Southwest Florida or do they just stick with the national average. Mr. Steve Belden confirmed that this was correct. Councilperson Bochette stated that they need to remember how to encourage people to stay in the city to be solid taxpayer’s and citizens, without losing them to the county. He noted that they need to look at what they can do to retain homeowners, particularly single family homeowners. ITEM NO.2-City Nursery Elgin Hicks, Director of Parks & Recreation, provided an update on the City Nursery. He disclosed that after they sold the nursey, it’s now become the Suncoast Beverage site. He stated that the site was about 20 acres and they used 16 acres, to cultivate and get landscape. He disclosed that the nursery was a huge benefit to the city, especially with the projects and repairs that were associated with it. Since losing the nursery in 2005, and the year to date, they’ve spent about $200,000 between plantings, landscaping on the roadways, and $70,000 to replenish the palm trees on Palm Beach Boulevard. In 2022, the last time they had the nursery, the total maintenance cost was $400,000. He disclosed that they recently meet with the Naples

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 5 | P a g e Botanical Garden this past week to discuss collaborating with them. The Naples Botanical Garden is currently working on the startup costs to get the nursery started. Abraham Luna, Parks & Beautification Manager, provided the potential nursery site property locations. He disclosed that the 1 st location near Hanson Street would be good due to them being close to the Eastwood golf course and how they could piggyback back off their resources for the nursery. He disclosed that the 2 nd location out in Buckingham would be another option because they’ve reclaimed their water out there. He noted that the Buckingham property does have plenty of space, but the traffic might be a concern. He stated that both locations would potentially need wells to be drilled with a retention pond. He stated that the reclaim component that would help the Parks Department, would be to have the water source that could help fill their water trucks and irrigate with the water trucks throughout the city. He noted that in order for them to develop the site, they would need tables, hardwood, an area to plant, topsoil, minimal staff, and labor to come in to help keep the area clean. Elgin Hicks, Director of Parks & Recreation, stated that to keep staff lean they could follow the golf model by using a specialized staffing agency tideline. He noted that they could bring in a specialized landscaper that would be able to take care of the nursery on a regular basis without it having to be a city employee. He disclosed that the Naples Botanical Garden is welling to collaborate with them. He noted that this nursey would also allow the public to come in to learn more about plants, and purchase plants from them which would add another revenue source. Councilperson Bonk inquired if they’ve discussed with the Naples Botanical Garden about outsourcing that cost to them, or just the assisting them with getting the nursery started back up in the city. Mr. Elgin Hicks stated that the Naples Botanical Garden is open and willing to help them with anything they ask. Councilperson Bonk then asked if they’ve done the cost analysis of what the whole entire cost of the startup would be including the well drilling, labor, water source and if they developed on their site what the loss of ad valorem taxes would be when compared to partnering with the Naples Botanical Garden and just pay them to have the nursery for them. Mr. Elgin Hicks stated that this is what they’re currently working on. He disclosed that they’re still working on those numbers to give to them, but they’re willing to help them. Councilperson Bonk stated that this is a really exceptional opportunity where they can be creative by using some of their Go Bond funding and add colors throughout the beautification. Councilperson Girlado encouraged everyone to go out to the Naples Botanical Garden especially during the holidays. She then inquired if they were looking at 20 acres of space at either Buckingham or the Calusa Nature center. Mr. Elgin Hicks stated that this is the direction that they need from council. He noted that they could use 2-4 acres which would only give them their plantings, and then they can use a tree budget, so they know the number of trees they need to plant every year. Councilperson Girlado stated that partnering with the Calusa Nature center would be a good opportunity for the city.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 6 | P a g e Councilperson Bochette stated that they’re moving into the right direction but asked what the negative aspects where to this, such as if they’d have enough equipment, did they preserve all the equipment from the past, and what the replacement costs for the tree movers would be. He disclosed that they would also need someone that’s experienced within nursery, but the Calusa Nature Center would be a real asset to them. He noted that he was basically in support, but wanted to know what the downside would be. Councilperson Burson stated that he preferred the Hanson Street site because it’s in central Fort Myers and not the Buckingham site since it’s on the far east end of town. He stated that another problem with the Buckingham site was that it was used as a landfill for the City of Fort Myers back in the 1970s. He noted that they already own Hanson Street since its centrally located and more desirable for him personally. Mayor Anderson stated that the site also offers a buffer between Lindsford and Hanson Street. Mr. Elgin Hicks commented that this was another initiative that the Naples Botanical Garden offered to them as well. Councilperson Brown inquired when they would have a comparison that they could look at. Mr. Elgin Hicks disclosed that they could receive this any day now and then they could put it together and present it. Mayor Anderson inquired what the potential for development on that piece of land would be, whether it was developable or useless. Mr. Abraham Luna stated that after having a conversation with Mr. Porter in Engineering it is developable. Councilperson Girlado mentioned that in regard to staff, the Edison Ford Estates works with the University of Florida’s office in Lee County, and they have a Master’s Gardeners’ program where they have experienced planters, who need volunteer hours work to keep their certification. Councilperson Brown asked how many people where in that particular nursery site when they had it where the fire station is located. Mr. Abraham Luna stated that 17 years ago when he first started, they had 3 full time staff members and by the time they left the site, they didn’t have any full time staff members. ITEM NO.3-Calusa Nature Center Eric Raddatz, Executive Director for the Calusa Nature Center, stated that The Calusa Nature Center & Planetarium is on the verge of closing, but they’ve been raising funds this year and working with partnerships to help maintain it. He then provided an overview of their partnership with the city for long term sustainability. He also thanked the city for their help for the last 9 months with clearing the parking lot, cutting down invasives, and making things look refreshed. He disclosed that they have museum trails, animals, along with being the only planetarium in the 90 mile radius, and a hub for environmental education, inclusion, and engagement. He then stated that they want to discuss the future and legacy for the center. He mentioned how they’ve recently renovated the planetarium, the roof, added new carpet, added new

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 7 | P a g e interior upgrades, and seats. He stated that they have a new classroom, new exhibit, and they’ve painted the walls. They’re also getting professional media coverage from WGCU, NBC, and ABC. He noted that for their vision and expansion plans, they have a boardwalk that's been in disrepair for years from various hurricanes, but they met with the city about getting a grant. He mentioned that they also have visions for a new multi-use building that’s like a zoo by adding small mammals. He disclosed that they’re also having their A/C fixed, they have a scheduled tree trimming, burn debris, and fire mitigation. He stated that what they need from the city are budget supports, financial operational partnerships, & labor shared revenue from joint city events. He noted that they don’t have health benefits, so they’d like to be able to work with the city on getting their employees covered. Mayor Anderson thanked them for bringing up the idea of adding animals and turning it into a small zoo. He then mentioned his trip to Melbourne zoo, a month ago and how the zoo was very popular on a Thursday afternoon. Mayor Anderson also thanked City Manager Lawing for taking the time out to visit the nature center and to realize it’s an asset to the city. Councilperson Bonk also thanked the Executive Director Eric Raddatz and told them how much of a phenomenal job they did. Councilperson Brown mentioned how they need to find a more creative way of connecting all of their properties together that they have though. Executive Director Eric Raddatz mentioned how he spoke with the City Manager and PIO about offering a potential City pass for people to view all the city attractions. Councilperson Bochette thanked Mr. Eric Raddatz for his leadership and for the city prioritizing their projects. Councilperson Burson inquired what they anticipated the estimate or cost would be to repair the boardwalk. Mr. Eric Raddatz stated that it would be about a $1 million. Councilperson Burson continued to discuss the importance of them having the boardwalk after losing it Hurricane Irma. Councilperson Girlado stated that she lives near the Calusa Nature Center and its one of her favorite places to visit. She noted that they need to add it to their priority list to see what the city is able to do. She then thanked them for all the work that they’ve done. The meeting was recessed at 10:08 a.m. The meeting was reconvened at 10:20 a.m. ITEM NO.4-Sidney Berne Davis Center-Loan ITEM NO.5-Burroughs Home Peter Bienek, Public Works Director, provided an update on the Burrough’s Home improvement. He stated the Burroughs Home had been a challenge due to multiple damages on the carriage house from Hurricane Helene. He disclosed that the

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 8 | P a g e Burroughs Home was a very old home with very specific materials that are difficult to find, and because of that the cost is very high, such as the wood. He disclosed that the first contactor’s quote was $2.1 million without the carriage house and just for the home. He disclosed that the other contractors quote was $1.9 million but they were using composite wood. They’re trying to get the correct wood and then they’ll probably be around $2 million. Lastly, he stated that with maintenance this could cost them this every 5-10 years, so they want the Council’s direction on this. Councilperson Bonk asked if the Burroughs Home was considered recreation or not. Mr. Peter Bienek stated that it probably wasn’t, and she inquired about why they couldn’t use the GO funds due to this being apart of Parks & Recreation. John Lege, Assistant City Manager, stated that they could talk with their bond counsel. Councilperson Bonk disclosed how it’s a major asset that’s located on the water and how its worth making an attempt rather not attempting at all. She also mentioned how the deferred maintenance was going to get costly over time. Councilperson Girlado inquired that due to the Burrough Home having historic features if that was the challenge for the home. Mr. Peter Bienek confirmed this and also mentioned how the railings, the balusters, the flooring are considered clear heart cypress. Which are old swamp trees they have to be cut down, milled, and then hand crafted on machines. He disclosed how he’d like them to change the wood or put it on vinyl, but the Historic Preservation doesn’t agree with that which is going to be a long term cost of maintenance on the home. He stated how this was going to be very expensive over the years. Further discussion ensured. ITEM NO.6-Indoor Multi-Sports Facility Marty Lawing, City Manager, provide the Council with an update on the indoor multi- sports facility along with wanting to hear the Councils interests. He stated that this would be a large investment that would need to be strategically located close to either downtown or Midtown. He noted that due to the large investment they would need to be a 2-3 way partnership. He then noted how the county has the hospitality and bed tax, which would benefit directly from people attending the events. He stated that if they establish the right partnership, they could make it feasible and successful for both the city and county. Councilperson Bonk asked if this would require them to partner with the county, because at what point would the county want to take it over. City Manager Lawing stated that the details would have to be worked out as to who would be the lead, how the debt structure would work, would be the operator, and who would manage the revenue. Councilperson Bonk disclosed how adding multiple agency cooperations would take longer to get things done and off the ground. Councilperson Burson stated that amateur sports bring in more money to Lee County than professional sports does. He disclosed how amateur sports generate much revenue in the bed tax and if they partnered with Lee county, they could have access to that bed tax revenue. He stated that amateur sports pay the debt service on both

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 9 | P a g e the Red Sox Stadium and the Twins stadium. Neither one of those facilities cost the local taxpayers and there's no ad valorem tax that goes to the facilities. He noted that the debt service on both of those are paid through amateur sports. Councilperson Burson disclosed that if they can partner with Lee County and get access to that bed tax, they could build that facility without any expense to the local residents. Councilperson Giraldo stated that the city needs to understand how other cities recreational facilities and business models work. Councilperson Bochette stated that the City Manager realizes that this is a catalyst project that could have future developments built around it. Councilperson Watson stated that she supported this project and mentioned how she brought this idea to Council several years ago, when she called it the “World Class Sports facility” that they needed. She noted how they could generate a lot of money from youth sports. ITEM NO.7-Carousel John Lege, Assistant City Manager, stated that they were approached by the Shell Factory about a carousel they had on their premises for 5 years, but now they’re closing down. He noted how they wanted to donate the carousel to the city, and he wanted their feedback. He disclosed how the carousel at the Shell Factory was manufactured in 1927, in Leavenworth, Kansas, by the Amusement company. For many years, the carousel was used in a traveling carnival. He stated prior to the hurricane, the Shell Factory disassembled the carousel, and it's currently in storage. Others are interested in the carousel, but the Shell Factory is interested in the City of Fort Myers having it. He stated that the carousel is 18 feet wide, it has a wooden floor, and 20 fiberglass horses with 2 stationary chariots. Mr. John Lege disclosed if the city was interested in this then they would have to restore each horse. He stated that they spoke with someone that restores carousels in Deland and they informed them that the average cost to restore a horse would be $2000-$3000 and $5,000 for moving and assembly. He also stated that they would need to consider security and lighting around the facility along with finding a location for storage before they display it. He noted that the estimated range would be between $75,000-$125,000. Mayor Anderson stated that he believed this would be a great addition to Centennial Park by attracting more people downtown. He then asked how much the operation and maintenance would cost and if they could get enough use out of it to offset the costs. Mr. John Lege stated that the Shell Factory charged a $1 per ride for 3 ½ minutes. He also stated that the person from Deland saw charges go from the $3-$5 range. Councilperson Bonk read a public comment from Madison Vogelback who was in attendance and how she was in support of the city obtaining the carousel from Shell Factory because it reminds her of her childhood. Councilperson Giraldo asked if the range from $75,000-$125,000 was just to move the carousel. Mr. John Lege confirmed that this was just to move it and for any

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 10 | P a g e restoration. Councilperson Giraldo commented that she understood the intent for wanting it, but she believes that they need more information to be able to make a decision. Mayor Anderson disclosed that he believes this contributes to a safe, livable, vibrant city as well. Councilperson Brown stated that her only concern was liability and the insurance cost. Councilperson Bochette commented that they may need to do a little more research and come up with more numbers. He disclosed that if they research their return on investment and if it’s a break even then it’s a win. Councilperson Watson stated that this was a great idea for the city, and it could possibly bring a job to a city employee. She noted that she would be in support of this because she has grandchildren, but they would need to go back and do research on the cost. Councilperson Burson disclosed that he was in favor of pursuing it. Mayor Anderson commented that he even asked the City Manager if this could work at the Calusa Nature Center. ITEM NO.8-Requested Positions for FY2026 (Internal Audit, Fire accreditation recommendation), Arts & Culture and STARS Marty Lawing, City Manager, discussed the department requested positions. He disclosed that the Council recently mentioned an Arts and Culture position along with position at the STARS. Councilperson Watson called for Ms. Amber Ware from STARS to speak about a new department they wanted to create and disclosed that Councilperson Burson was going to meet with the school district about a potential partnership. Amber Ware, the Interim Senior Center Manager for STARS, stated that the city hasn’t kept up with the needs of the community regarding the purpose that they serve. She stated that throughout the years, the abundance of things that have occurred at STARS haven’t been truly displayed in the city’s budget. She then disclosed STARS 3 primary focus areas in education, recreation/ youth athletics and community support/engagement. She noted that for community support and engagement, the city isn’t aware, but people within the community are aware of these STARS board services. These services include family support services, agency collaboration, health and wellness, crisis support, career support services and trainings. She stated in which she wanted to discuss in regard to the requested position. Ms. Amber Ware stated how citizens come into their facility daily for help with food services, housing, and utilities. These services are performed throughout the county, but they’re the hub for Dunbar. She stated that people that primarily reside in Wards 1, 2, and 3 come to STARS to get adequate information and referrals to these services, but they aren’t

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 11 | P a g e being noted anywhere. She disclosed for example, how many residents were afraid to fill out Lee Cares application, because they just didn't know how to do it and they didn't trust the resources out there. She noted that the citizens came to STARS for help. Then her staff and herself had to learn the system and help guide them through the application process. She even included how they’ve helped the homeless find resources who come to them for help. Ms. Amber Ware stated that these things were being noted as to what their purpose was, and what their goals and objectives are in the city’s budget. She then mentioned how they provide long term support to the youth and their families when they’ve gone through a crisis. Mayor Anderson asked if Ms. Amber Ware could quickly wrap up her presentation. Amber Ware, the Interim Senior Center Manager for STARS, also mentioned how these things along with their objectives and outcomes need to be addressed in their budget. She stated that STARS needs to be made as a whole as to what the purpose is that they serve to the community. Councilperson Watson also added that she refers others to STARS and Ms. Amber Ware for resources and referrals. She stated it’s the department that they're trying to create, especially with the expansion and partnership of the school district. Marty Lawing, City Manager, stated that all the departments have not submitted their requests, but right now they have 75 new positions. Then he commented that they should discuss the Arts and Culture position. Councilperson Giraldo disclosed that this position came from the RFP that they discussed. She noted that they’ve been working with Mr. Tom Hall, who's the interim Arts Consultant Advisory board. She stated that the Arts Committee put a master plan together and they have the need for this consultant along with all the special events that come to the city now. Mayor Anderson stated that it would be important to see what the job description looked like if it warranted a full time position and the type of salary. Councilperson Brown commented that the last person that had the job was part time, but he didn’t fit the entire description that Councilperson Giraldo stated. She also stated that she knows that they have other critical positions within the city that need to be filled before they hire a full time art position. Councilperson Bochette stated that this position would have to pay for itself through activities position they can bring to the city. He noted how this was not just for social services, but income and he would suggest they speak with the Economic Development Department. He noted the Economic Development Department should do the research and come back to present to them on if the position was warranted. Councilperson Watson stated that she believes that right now this isn’t something that they need. If what they have isn’t broken, why add up spending more money. She stated that maybe in the future, She may look into this, but they have so many other positions that haven’t been filled yet.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 12 | P a g e City Manager Marty Lawing stated that they may be at a crossroads with STARS. He then mentioned how right now they’re looking into investing $20 million into a facility that’s designed for youth activities. He noted that what they mentioned sounded more like social services that should be handled by the county. Councilperson Watson stated that they’re already helping citizens at STARS with these services due to their lack of resources. She stated how everyone comes to STARS for help even after hurricane’s, so this position would only add to the City of Fort Myers. Further discussion ensured. Mayor Anderson left from11:27am-12:15pm and turned it over to Mayor Pro-Tem Brown. ITEM NO.9-Miscellaneous: Lee County Black History Society MOU, Golf Memberships Structure, FMCC Cell Tower, USL-COP Park Status, City Attorney Recruitment Councilperson Brown had the Lee County Black History Society present the Memorandum of understanding (MOU) presentation. Monika Jackson, Executive Director for the Lee County Black History Society, discussed the Memorandum of understanding aka MOU. She noted how the absence of the signed MOU was one of the major barriers, preventing them advancing into phase 3 of their project. This includes securing additional capital from major funders and launching the next stage of development for the cultural resource center. Charles Barnes, Board Chairman of the Lee County Black History Society, disclosed why they strongly supported the project. He stated that the Black History Society strongly wants the Wisdom Academy, because this was the 1 st building that was government funded to help educate African American children in the 3 surrounding counties. He stated how they can’t get their community partners to assist them in doing this project without the MOU. Attorney Justin Stockman stated that they were there to finalize the MOU to start phase 3 of the project. City Manager Marty Lawing noted that this was a little different than the previous drafts they had 2-3 years ago. He stated that in the new draft on page 2, it just outlines the responsibilities of both parties. He disclosed that this takes most of the burden of the fundraising off the society and puts it on the city. He noted that this would be the city's responsibility to construct the building. Attorney Justin Stockman stated that he disagreed because the plan defines the role that the city agreed to do in the beginning, that was $12.8 million. City Manager Marty Lawing stated that he was speaking about the agreement that was drafted on how the Black History Society wanted to raise money for most of the construction, and if there was a gap in funding the city would cover it. He noted that the total cost was $12 million in the CIP.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 13 | P a g e Councilperson Watson commented how this wasn’t true and stated that they never had an MOU agreement where they raised capital funds. Further discussion ensured. City Manager Lawing stated that they need to get this on the regular council agenda for a formal vote. Councilperson Watson agreed with moving it forward. Kari Phenix, Fort Myers Country Club Golf Professional, disclosed how she inherited many “grandfathered in” membership fee structures. She disclosed that they typically raise the fees in September before the fiscal year. Last time they were scheduled to raise fees, Hurricane Ian occurred, and they didn’t want to add insult to injury. She disclosed how the City of Fort Myers is very fortunate to have 2 golf courses when compared to other cities though. She disclosed when looking at fee structure they look at Cape Coral and Coral Oaks. She noted that their fee structure is very similar to what they currently have, with a 9 month membership for $1,000 for city residents and $1400 for non-city residents. She noted which she recommends this to go up because it hasn’t in a few years. She stated that they haven’t done the 3% increase in a while. So currently juniors are their only new members, and their junior membership is $100 for a year where they can play in season. Ms. Kari Phenix continued on to discuss how Covid helped increase the golf industry. She noted that if they opened up that membership, She’d recommend that they only open it to city residents at a rate where they’d be able to make budget. City Manager Marty Lawing stated that the Coral Oaks rate sheet had the 9 month membership for $1000, but then he inquired about the single membership for $4,350. Ms. Kari Phenix disclosed that the $4,350 fee included the cart as well, and their annual season without the golf was $1750. City Manager Lawing then inquired if they had Cape Coral residents that were members of their course and she confirmed that this was correct. Councilperson Giraldo asked if it would be better if everyone started their membership on a fiscal year or calendar year. Ms. Kari Phenix noted that they could do this anyway which is why they set it up on an anniversary date. Councilperson Giraldo then mentioned if they were supposed to have the 3% rate increase and Ms. Kari Phenix stated that Coral Oaks had done a mandatory 3%. She stated that they haven’t raised their fees since Hurricane Ian and now it’s time. Ms. Kari Phenix explained how the more someone uses the pass the more they’ll save. Councilperson Giraldo mentioned how they need to have an established annual rate increase. Ms. Kari Phenix further explained how due to them being a municipality, others view them as being able to be inexpensive. Councilperson Burson inquired what their proposed fees were and what a single round of golf would be in they’re not a member. Ms. Kari Phenix stated that a single round would be $65 that includes the cart, fee, and tax. He also inquired about the fee during season, and she stated it would be $100 during season. City Manager Lawing disclosed that they would need to go back and work with Ms. Kari Phenix and come up with a recommended membership structure that works for

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 14 | P a g e everyone. He then noted how her biggest concern were addressing the legacy memberships and how they should go about them. Councilperson Giraldo inquired about the number of legacy members being 21. Ms. Kari Phenix stated that the 21 members have annual passes where they pay a cart charge in January, February and March or any time of the year. She recommended them to get a city pass that has a rate that needs to be increased from the $1000 for city residents. Mayor Anderson also inquired about the specific number of legacy members. Ms. Kari Phenix disclosed that they had 21 members annually and the 9 month members are the majority of the pass holders. Assistant City Manager John Lege stated that Parks and Recreation have been working with Ms. Kari Phenix on looking at potentially offering discounts, not on membership fees, but for residents as they play. Councilperson Giraldo then commented how getting into this business has further complicated things. Mayor Anderson stated that he agreed on these things being cleaned up. The meeting was recessed at 12:25 p.m. The meeting was reconvened at 1:00 p.m. Steve Belden, Community Development Director, provided an update on the Fort Myers Country club cell tower agreement proposal. He disclosed how they were approached by them because they have an existing tower on the on the Bonaire building that was owned by the Housing Authority which is now being torn down. He noted that they had to relocate that tower and found a location at the Country Club. He stated that they want to do a one year option, while they’re working on their permit work construction. Afterwards their 5 year ground lease would take effect for $42,000 a year with 9, 5-year renewals with a 10% increase in lease renewal. He disclosed that this would need to be approved by the Council for the agreement and by the Board of Adjustments for conditional use. Mayor Anderson inquired about the height of the tower and Mr. Steve Belden stated that the tower would be no more than 150 feet. Mr. Steve Belden disclosed that this has gone through legal review, and they’ve signed off on it. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that the proposed tower is 145 feet, with a 5 foot lightning rod, so the overall height is 150. City Manager Lawing then inquired about what they could do about the aesthetics. Mr. Steve Belden then asked Ms. Jessica Ross to explain how they would disguise the tower. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that the best option would be to have a pine tree that would look like a tower called a Monopine. Mayor Anderson asked if there guide wires. Ms. Jessica Ross confirmed that this would be a free standing poll.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 15 | P a g e Councilperson Giraldo stated that they received feedback from the Environmental Advisory Board regarding the lighting that they needed consideration for. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that they were open to exploring the option and that it was something that would be reviewed with the Planning Department. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that they probably wouldn’t change light on the tower unless it's required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) though. Mayor Anderson inquired if by not replacing this, they could be depriving residents of cell phone service. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that if they don't have a replacement facility after the building comes down there will be a huge gap in coverage for both Verizon and T-Mobile. Councilperson Brown asked if they were still proposing to have it located near McGregor street. Mr. Steve Belden stated that it would be a little bit closer. Mayor Anderson noted that it’s closer to 41 than it is, McGregor street. Councilperson Burson asked Mr. Steve Belden about the annual revenue. Mr. Steve Belden stated that the annual revenue was $42,000. Councilperson Burson then noted that the agreement says $1500 a month which is $18,000 a year. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that the monthly rental amount is $3,500, and the $1500 is the option period before construction starts so they can finish their due diligence. Mr. Steve Belden then stated that this would take place during their 1 st year. He noted that once they become operational, The agreement would kick in and then it'll that'll go up 10% after each renewal. Mayor Anderson inquired if this would be a yearlong process to get the tower approved. Ms. Jessica Ross stated that it is typically after the lease is signed. Mayor Anderson then asked when the building was going to be demolished. Mr. Steve Belden stated that he didn’t have the specific time, but he knows almost any day now. Councilperson Burson stated that this would be a much better option to have it next to the church. Mr. Steve Belden stated that maintenance felt it wouldn’t have worked at the previous location either. He disclosed that staff was acceptable with where they were proposing it now. Councilperson Giraldo asked if it was a requirement to notify the businesses and others around where the proposed tower would be. Mr. Steve Belden stated that this would require conditional use, approval by the Board of Adjustments. He disclosed that in their process they would have a public hearing, and then a notification of adjacent surrounding property owners. Grant Alley, City Attorney, stated that Councilmember Bochette has been involved as an actively with the contract and he knows that he’s very interested in the progress of this project. Marty Lawing, City Manager, provided an update on the USL City of Palms Park status. He stated that they started negotiations back in March of 2024. Both parties appeared to be very interested in trying to work out an agreement. He stated that the

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 16 | P a g e reason this has taken so long is because it’s a complex negotiation. The model that they see in other cities is significantly different than the models that they see in other cities for their soccer team. He stated that the other cities are building stadiums for $50-$75 million dollar when they’re trying to attract specifically a soccer team to come to their city. He disclosed that what they’re offering is different than that. He noted that what they’re offering to establish a soccer team to play at the City of Palms Park, they’ll negotiate a long term lease, and maybe incur cost, or borrow money from a bond. Then USL would have to pay that money back. Which is not a model that they see very often. On April 9 th, they submitted a drafted term agreement with the most significant terms of the proposed agreement and then they’ll bring it to Council. He disclosed that if they had an idea of a timeline, they’d like to get this done by then let them know because otherwise this might continue to be pre-longed, because its complex. Councilperson Watson asked if this was the same place they’ve seen with the sports facility. City Manager Lawing stated that its possible especially if this doesn’t work out then they could use this site as something more suitable. Councilperson Burson stated that they should draw a line in the sand and move on. Mayor Anderson stated that back in 2019 the Council voted to demolish it. Councilperson Watson mentioned how they were ending up back where they were years ago. Councilperson Giraldo stated that Naples already had a USL team that’s 30 minutes away from them, and she found it hard to believe they were going to have 2 locations within 30 minutes of each other along with the potential of an indoor multi sports facility. She commented how this has taken an entire year and they need to move on. City Manager Lawing disclosed that the other team actually viewed it as a benefit to have a team in the same region, as a rival, but the team would be at a different level when compared to the Naples team. Mayor Anderson disclosed how he’s not sure if an agreements like this won't come under scrutiny for DOGE. Councilperson Watson noted that they need to wait on the other group to see what they want to do first before they move on. City Manager Lawing further mentioned how slow the negotiation process is going. He mentioned that he wants to at least give it until the middle of June to give it a final push. Councilperson Giraldo stated that they should give them a 30 day notice for a response, or they’ll move on. Mayor Anderson also stated that he would support the City Manager’s request for a 30 to 45 day notice. City Manager Marty Lawing then provided an update on the City Attorney recruitment.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 17 | P a g e Mayor Anderson disclosed that the City Attorney didn’t indict a date yet. He disclosed that they hopefully have enough time to recruit and for a transition period. He stated that City Attorney Grant Alley has 30 plus years of experience of working with the city and he knows the history. Councilperson Burson stated that he was concerned about Mr. Grant Alley not having anybody to work with him prior to him leaving. He stated that whether it’s in-house or outhouse, they need to make a decision sooner than later. Councilperson Watson commented that City Attorney Alley probably wasn’t ready to go yet. Councilperson Burson noted that since he’s in the drop program, they need to anticipate him leaving when the drop is over. Mayor Anderson asked City Attorney Alley how many years he had in. City Attorney Alley stated that he had 4 years. Mayor Anderson disclosed that he had roughly a year. Further discussion ensured. ITEM NO. 10- City Hall Site Option Analysis City Manager Lawing provided an update on the City Hall site option analysis. He stated that they asked each department what they needed in regard to space, and they based it on staffing, with a 20% growth factor. He disclosed that they have every department represented on this except Police and Fire. He stated that they came up with over 72,000 square feet, then applied a 20% growth factor with another 14,500. He stated that this becomes 87,000 square feet and they hope to construct a City Hall facility for $600 per square foot which would put them in the $52 million range. City Manager Lawing then mentioned the difference between choosing the current City Hall site and the hospital site. He disclosed how they’ve looked at 4 sites that have been added with the first being the current City hall site. He disclosed that the City Hall site has 2 properties, 2200 Second Street, which is the main City Hall and 1820 Hendry Street, which is where HR & Parks and Recreation are now. He stated that the first site is 2.19 acres and Hendry Street is .8 acres and both combined are a little over 3 acres. He disclosed that City Hall is valued at $9.9 million, and the HR Building is a little over a $1 million, which includes both the buildings and land. For the Lee Health site, they have 2 parcels with one being 8.4 acres and the other one 7.4 acres. He disclosed that one had an estimate of $1.1 million and other one $1.5 million making the total $2.6 million. City Manager Lawing commented how these were grossly low. Mayor Anderson disclosed that this would also give opportunity for other development on that site. City Manager Lawing disclosed that since they own City Hall, they wouldn’t have any land cost if they wanted to salvage it and renovate it. He also stated that if they wanted to demolish the current City Hall site then they would have demolition costs. He noted that for the Lee Health site their current buildings would be demolished. Then Lee health would determine the pricing which they haven’t established yet. He stated that they'll also have the property appraised, and then discount the property for

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 18 | P a g e the city. He stated that The Midtown site, which would be right beside the new police headquarters, and the property would be valued at 1.1 per acres. Mayor Anderson stated that he thought this was interesting and disclosed how he never considered this site location for City Hall. He noted that this would give an opportunity to contribute to the overall development of Midtown. He then asked if the land was too valuable to put a government facility on. City Manager Lawing stated that it probably is, and it’ll continue to become more valuable. Councilperson Giraldo stated that they need to think about the pros and cons for the different agencies that are involved in the development. City Manager Lawing noted that they need to have a little bit of time spread in between the completion of the police headquarters and starting a new City Hall. Unless something happens financially for the city. He stated that Lee Health would also need to know, within the next several months, if they're interested in that site or not because they're marketing it. Mayor Anderson stated that he was interested in the site, but he knows that other members may believe it’s too far outside of downtown. Councilperson Burson stated that he likes the Lee Memorial site because it would help revitalize 41, but he’s heard pushback from the businesses in the core area. He stated that the businesses surrounding the area also wouldn’t be able to walk to City Hall because they’d have to get in their vehicle’s and commute a quarter mile instead. Councilperson Burson then mentioned how they could put certain pieces of property back on the tax roll such as the current police site, and the current City Hall site. Councilperson Brown stated that her biggest concern was the cost factor for trying to retract the building and demolish it. City Manager Lawing stated that to his understanding Lee Health would demolish it and the hospital would take the responsibility. Mayor Anderson stated that they need to give some indication one way or the other to Lee Health, So, they’re not stopping them from progressing. Councilperson Brown inquired about how fast of a timeline would they be able to do it. Mayor Anderson stated that this would be another 4 years before they’re completed it on Jones Walker. So, they're probably looking at 7 years before construction starts. Councilperson Giraldo then noted that they don’t have a value of how much they’ll sell the site for. City Manager Lawing then disclosed that Lee Health would appraise the site and discount it for them. Councilperson Giraldo disclosed that its hard to commit if they don’t have the numbers. Mayor Anderson stated that they weren’t looking for them to buy the entire piece of land but to be apart of the land development to make it more attractive. He disclosed how beneficial it would be long term.

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 19 | P a g e Councilperson Burson agreed that the value of the land wouldn’t be the same several years from now. ITEM NO.11-Downtown Culinary District Steven Weathers, Economic Development Director, provided a status update on the Downtown Culinary District. He wanted direction from the Council about if they should continue the project, and if so what are the next steps. Councilperson Burson inquired as to what the benefits were in declaring it a Culinary District. Mr. Steven Weathers disclosed that its more of a branding effort. He stated that this has more to do with branding downtown as a restaurant culinary area. Councilperson Giraldo asked how they ended up with this idea and then asked if they decide to go through with this who will manage the branding mechanism. Mr. Steven Weathers stated that he believes the idea originally came from Lisa Studoni from the Riverside District and she met with him and the City Manager. Steven Weathers, Economic Development Director, asked if there was a budget for this and then asked who was going to manage it. He disclosed that he wasn’t sure if the River District, The Chambers, or if they would create another organization to manage it. Mr. Steven Weathers then mentioned how various restaurants from around the country have gotten in touch with him about being a part of the culinary district. Councilperson Giraldo asked if the River District brought this forward, why would they need the city’s permission to do it. Mayor Anderson inquired if this idea was outside the River District. Mr. Steven Weathers noted that he didn’t know the answer. He stated that when him and the City Manager spoke about this idea, they came up with the thought that maybe they wanted to smooth out the seasonality of the restaurants. Mayor Anderson then mentioned the idea of how downtown Fort Myers was rebranded to the River District and now they’re doing another rebrand. Steven Weathers, Economic Development Director, stated that they should work with the CRA and hold a minimum of 3 public meetings with the restaurant owners, the business owners, and Ward 6. Mayor Anderson disclosed that he personally thinks they should spend a little more time on this and then he gave credit to Councilmember Bochette for the idea. Councilperson Giraldo stated that she believes this is a good idea but wanted to know what the responsibilities where from the city and the budget. Mr. Steven Weathers disclosed that it's really more for the benefit of the businesses located here. City Manager Lawing noted that once it gets established it’ll take a life of its own. Then he mentioned that they may have to replace the banners once a year. He also stated that there’s an actual area called the Culinary District in Harrisonburg, Virginia with 50,000 people near James Madison University that includes 35 restaurants. He stated that they established this district 5-10 years ago and when they advertised for housing, they always mention the Culinary District. City Manager Lawing disclosed

MINUTES– CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION May 2, 2025 20 | P a g e that this would be a joint effort between the Chambers, the River District, and the city. He noted that since this has been out, He hasn’t heard any negative comments or pushback. Steven Weathers, Economic Development Director, mentioned how they wanted to create a Fort Myers Culinary District App that displayed restaurants, discounts, coupons, and events downtown. He then asked if they could move forward with putting together 3 public meetings. City Manager Lawing stated that they should put together 1 meeting to move things faster and to have things ready for the summer. Mr. Steve Weathers noted that they’d put 1 public meeting together to be able to get more guidance and input. Councilperson Brown inquired if Gartner Park was included in the Culinary District. Mayor Anderson disclosed that once Gartner Park develops then they could start adding restaurants there. Mr. Steven Weathers also noted how creating multiple districts could also confusion. ITEM NO.12-AI in Local Government Richard Calkins, IT Director, provided an update on the AI Adoption Strategy & Acceptable Use Policy Overview. He disclosed how they’ve adopted AI in various different applications and processes. He stated that with this pilot program and 5 year plan, it wouldn’t replace any staff, but it would help ease the demand if current staff could be more productive with it. One of the leaders in the AI Industry is a company called OpenAI. OpenAI recently created an enterprise level account that they could adopt, because they’re using their team level account which has limitations. He noted how the Enterprise level account would give them more flexibility. Mr. Richard Calkins stated that this would be a $72,000 a year annual investment and it would expand the access citywide. The $72,000 would give them 150 different accounts for different users because they currently only have 25 accounts. He stated that AI isn’t retaining any of their data though. When they get the enterprise level account, the city’s data is stored within their own space. Richard Calkins, IT Director, disclosed that the enterprise account would allow them to create their own specific purposes and have unlimited access to the current GPT 4 model, because currently their only limited to a 500 page document. Mr. Richard Calkins also mentioned how he’s already completed a study on moving the carousel to the Calusa Nature Center and how it would cost them $160,000 along with a drafted MOU to sign. He disclosed how it could help them draft emails, create policies for review, and note taking and transcriptions. He disclosed that they could even put together large spreadsheets and f

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • CITY COUNCIL BUDGET RETREAT — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 648ef131c5df275945bf26df4fce94ef. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record