POLISCOPE

The public record

TREASUREISLAND (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Planning & Zoning Board

Thursday, April 17, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Planning & Zoning Board

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

1. MEETING CALLED TO ORDER BY PRESIDING OFFICER 2. CELL PHONE ANNOUNCEMENT 3. PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE 4. OATH OF OFFICE 5. ROLL CALL Richard Harris- Chair Marvin Shavlan- Board Member Grant Smith- Board Member Ross Sanchez- Vice-Chair Chris Downing- Board Member Jennifer Bonvouloir- Board Member Kara Simm- Board Member Gary Potenziano- Alternate Board Member* Mark Zdrojewski- Alternate Board Member* *Per Sec. 70-3, alternate members shall only vote on any matter when a board member is unavailable. 6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 7. STATUS UPDATE ON PRIOR PLANNING AND ZONING CASES Staff will address questions, comments, and/or concerns from the Board pertaining to prior cases. 8. HEARING PROCEDURES City Attorney explains hearing procedures. 9. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH 10. EX-PARTE COMMUNICATION DISCLOSURE 11. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS PLANNING & ZONING REGULAR MEETING THURSDAY, APRIL 17, 2025 – 2:00 PM 10451 GULF BOULEVARD TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706 MEETING NOTICE AND AGENDA

10A.VAR-000499-2025- 142 93rd Ave- Variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure. 1. Staff Report.docx 2. Application.pdf 3. Warranty Deed.pdf 4. Variance Narrative.pdf 5. Survey.pdf 6. Architectural Plans.pdf 7. Plat- 1933 PB16-PG95.pdf 8. Neighbor Letter.pdf 12. PUBLIC COMMENTS FOR NON-AGENDA ITEMS 13. REPORTS AND COMMENTS OF CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF AND BOARD MEMBERS 14. PLANNING & ZONING BOARD / LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY MEETINGS NEXT LPA MEETING: TBD NEXT P&Z MEETING: TBD 15. ADJOURNMENT

Showing the first 24,000 of 36,511 characters. The full document is at the source.

1. MEETING CALLED TO ORDER BY PRESIDING OFFICER 2. CELL PHONE ANNOUNCEMENT 3. PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE 4. OATH OF OFFICE 5. ROLL CALL Richard Harris- Chair Marvin Shavlan- Board Member Grant Smith- Board Member Ross Sanchez- Vice-Chair Chris Downing- Board Member Jennifer Bonvouloir- Board Member Kara Simm- Board Member Gary Potenziano- Alternate Board Member* Mark Zdrojewski- Alternate Board Member* *Per Sec. 70-3, alternate members shall only vote on any matter when a board member is unavailable. 6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 7. STATUS UPDATE ON PRIOR PLANNING AND ZONING CASES Staff will address questions, comments, and/or concerns from the Board pertaining to prior cases. 8. HEARING PROCEDURES City Attorney explains hearing procedures. 9. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH 10. EX-PARTE COMMUNICATION DISCLOSURE 11. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS PLANNING & ZONING REGULAR MEETING THURSDAY, APRIL 17, 2025 – 2:00 PM 10451 GULF BOULEVARD TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706 MEETING NOTICE AND AGENDA 1

10A.VAR-000499-2025- 142 93rd Ave- Variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure. 1. Staff Report.docx 2. Application.pdf 3. Warranty Deed.pdf 4. Variance Narrative.pdf 5. Survey.pdf 6. Architectural Plans.pdf 7. Plat- 1933 PB16-PG95.pdf 8. Neighbor Letter.pdf 12. PUBLIC COMMENTS FOR NON-AGENDA ITEMS 13. REPORTS AND COMMENTS OF CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF AND BOARD MEMBERS 14. PLANNING & ZONING BOARD / LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY MEETINGS NEXT LPA MEETING: TBD NEXT P&Z MEETING: TBD 15. ADJOURNMENT 2

AGENDA ITEM NO. 10A. Item Cover Page DATE: April 17, 2025 SUBMITTED BY: Jesse Miller, Community Development ITEM TYPE: Public Hearings AGENDA SECTION: PRESENTATION OF ITEMS SUBJECT: VAR-000499-2025- 142 93rd Ave- Variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure. BACKGROUND: See attached Staff Report. POLICY/PURPOSE: N/A STRATEGIC PLAN RELEVANCE: N/A ANALYSIS/DISCUSSION: See attached Staff Report. FUNDING: N/A MOTION: See attached Staff Report. PLANNING & ZONING BOARD AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: 1. Staff Report.docx 2. Application.pdf 3. Warranty Deed.pdf 4. Variance Narrative.pdf 5. Survey.pdf 6. Architectural Plans.pdf 7. Plat- 1933 PB16-PG95.pdf 8. Neighbor Letter.pdf 3

1 CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD 10451 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, Florida 33706 (727) 547-4575 CASE NO. VAR-000499-2025 STAFF REPORT THURSDAY, APRIL 17,2025, AT 2:00 P.M. DESCRIPTION: Variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure. SITE LOCATION: 142 93 rd Avenue Treasure Island, FL 33706 PARCEL ID #: 25-31-15-74412-000-0080 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: REUER SUB LOT 8 & N 20 FT OF E 2 FT OF LOT 7 PROPERTY OWNER: Chatrick Clark GENERAL INFORMATION: Future Land Use: RM (Residential Medium) Zoning: RM-15 (Residential Medium) 4

2 Adjacent Property (Use): North: 141 94 th Ave. – Single-Family Residential West: 136 93 rd Ave. – Single-Family Residential South: 145 93 rd Ave. – Single-Family Residential East: 148 93 rd Ave. – Single-Family Residential Site Area: Approximately 0.07 acres (3,289 square feet) Flood Zone: AE-9, Flood Insurance Rate Map Community Panel No. 12103C0194H, August 24, 2021. PROPERTY HISTORY/SUMMARY: The subject property contains a 3,289 square foot slab on grade single-family residence, originally constructed in 1928. This structure was damaged during the 2024 hurricanes. The lot has a unique and peculiar shape, which occurred at an unknown time after this parcel of land was platted in 1933, see Plat Bk 16 / Pg 95. The applicant is seeking to replace the current structure to comply with current minimum flood elevation standards (Base Flood Elevation plus two feet). The proposed structure will be elevated approximately 12.5 feet above the existing grade (14 feet above sea level). The proposed structure would include a garage at ground level below the existing house. 5

3 TREASURE ISLAND CODE OF ORDINANCES: ARTICLE VIII. – BUILDING SETBACK LINES Sec. 68-541. – Setback classifications. Sunset Beach 93rd Avenue: A and Reuer Sub. (1) Class A: Lots 3,001 or more square feet: Street: 10 feet Side: 7 ½ feet Rear: 10 feet DIVISION 4. – VARIANCES Section 69-91. – Procedure (a) Requests for variances from the requirements of this chapter shall be heard by the planning and zoning board. No variance may be granted unless the applicant establishes, by substantial competent evidence, that: (1) A literal enforcement of the provisions of this article would result in extreme hardship due to the unique nature of the project and the applicant's property; (2) The variance being sought to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the applicant's property; and (3) The granting of the requested variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the chapter and will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental or of adverse effect to the public interest and welfare. (b) In granting any variance, the planning and zoning board may prescribe appropriate conditions and safeguards. (c) The planning and zoning board shall prescribe a reasonable time limit not to exceed one year within which the action for which the variance is granted shall be initiated. (d) Variances shall not be deemed to set precedence for other applications should they be either standard applications or those requiring variances. (e) In no event shall the planning and zoning board grant variances permitting construction of structures which interfere with or violate the riparian rights of adjacent properties. ARTICLE VII. – SUPPLEMENTARY LOT AND USE REGULATIONS DIVISION 4. NONCONFORMING USES Section 68-512. – Regulations No existing building or premises devoted to a nonconforming use shall be enlarged, extended, reconstructed, substituted or structurally altered, except when changed to a conforming use or when required to do so by law and as follows: (1) Restoration. Any nonconforming structure which has been damaged or made unsafe or unusable to an extent less than 50 percent of its fair market value may 6

4 be restored or reconstructed for its intended use provided the floor area of such use, building or structure shall not exceed the floor area which existed prior to such damage. All repairs shall be substantially completed within one year after damages occur or such use shall not be rebuilt except as a conforming use. (2) Repairs. Normal maintenance, repair, and incidental alteration of a structure containing a nonconforming use is permitted, provided that it does not extend the area or volume of space occupied by the nonconforming use. It is the intent of these regulations to encourage the conservation, maintenance, and rehabilitation of existing residential land uses. Therefore, a building or other structure containing nonconforming residential uses may be altered in any way to improve interior livability; provided that no structural alterations shall be made which would increase the number of dwelling units. (3) Site alterations. Site alterations, including but not limited to off-street parking rearrangement or enlargement of nonbuilding recreational facilities of a nonconforming use are permitted, provided that the proposed alterations do not increase the degree of nonconformity. In order to encourage rehabilitation or redevelopment of an existing nonconforming use, the planning and zoning board may approve a site plan which includes an increase in gross floor area of up to ten percent of the existing gross floor area (not to exceed the maximum allowable under the property's designated zoning district), subject to a finding by the board that the overall degree of nonconformity on the site is significantly reduced and that additional adverse impacts will not be created. In conjunction with this site plan approval, the board may grant an exemption from variance requirements for any and all remaining nonconformities. These site plan and variance exemption provisions may be applied only once to any specific property. (4) Exception. Restoration, repairs and site alterations can be made to existing single-family dwellings in zoning districts which allow such single-family dwellings, provided that such restorations, repairs or site alterations do not increase the number of dwelling units, increase density, increase the degree of the nonconformity, or result in a different type of nonconformity from that which is already considered to be grandfathered. (5) Nonconforming density. Existing residential dwelling, tourist dwelling, and hotel/motel uses which are nonconforming as to density shall not require a variance to permit the otherwise allowable addition or alteration to the building or site, provided that the density is not increased. (6) Repair and reconstruction of existing commercial, residential, and hotel/motel structures and uses. a. Residential structures/uses and their permitted accessory uses are grandfathered in the RU-75, RM-15, RFM-30, RFH-50, and CG zoning districts. b. Hotel/motel structures/uses and their permitted accessory uses are grandfathered in the RFM-30, RFH-50, and CG zoning districts. c. In the event that any residential or hotel/motel structure is damaged or destroyed by a hurricane, tornado, fire, flood, wind, storm or other natural 7

5 disaster, it can be repaired or reconstructed in a manner which guarantees that each unit and all permitted accessory uses can be restored to the same square footage which existed as of September 19, 1995. If the F.A.R. allowed in the current Code is greater than the September 19, 1995 level, then the square footage or F.A.R. may increase up to the currently allowed maximum so long as the project meets all provisions of the Code. If the numbers of units allowed in the current Code is greater than the September 19, 1995 level, then the number of units may increase up to the currently allowed maximum so long as the project meets all other provisions of the Code. Repairs and reconstruction shall adhere to all flood management regulations in effect. In the event that such flood regulations require the elevation of a structure, the city shall permit the height of the structure to be increased the minimum necessary to accommodate the required flood elevation. If the repairs or reconstruction cannot be made in accordance with these Code provisions, the city shall grant the owners relief from such Code provisions to permit the grandfathered units and all existing legally permitted accessory uses to be restored without creating a greater nonconformity than existed prior to the disaster. d. Nothing contained in this section shall relieve the owner/developer of the obligation to restore the damaged structure in compliance with the building code as adopted in section 64-1 and Life Safety Code as adopted in section 64-1. Nothing contained herein shall be construed to permit more dwelling units or an increase in square footage of the structure than existed prior to September 19, 1995. The burden of proof as to what existed prior to September 19, 1995, shall rest with the property owner based upon a site plan on file at city hall. If no site plan is presently on file, each property owner shall provide the city with a site plan, as-built surveys, or architecturally-sealed floor plans. The plans or surveys shall provide enough information to determine the existing legally permitted development on the site. Single-family and two-family structures are exempt from the site plan requirements. e. Commercial structures/uses and their permitted accessory uses are grandfathered in the RFM-30, RFH-50, and CG zoning districts. ARTICLE III- APPEALS TO ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS; SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS AND VARIANCES DIVISION 3. – VARIANCES Section 70-221. – Procedure (1) An application for such variance has been received by the city manager or specified designee, stating the special conditions and circumstances applying to the building, structure, or land for which such variance is sought. The applicant shall submit a narrative that explains the variance being requested in a manner that addresses the criteria specified in subsection (d) as they relate to the specific request. Since each application is considered based upon the unique 8

6 circumstances presented by such application, prior decisions of the board or commission shall not constitute grounds for the granting of any variance. (2) The board or commission has received a report from the city manager or specified designee that evaluates the application based on the criteria required by this section. (3) The board or commission holds a public hearing after written and posted notice has been given to the extent provided by chapter 70. (4) The board or commission has considered the following criteria and find that they have been substantially satisfied and a hardship exists: a. The variance is in fact a variance as set forth within the land development regulations and within the province of the board or commission based upon the opinion of the city manager or his designee; b. Special conditions or circumstances exist which are peculiar to the building, structure, or land for which the variance is sought and do not apply generally to buildings, structures, or lands in the same zoning district; c. Strict application of the provisions of the land development regulations would not permit the applicant reasonable use of the building; structure, or land; d. The peculiar conditions and circumstances existing are not the result of the actions of the applicant, the applicant agent's agents, or the applicant's predecessors in title; e. The variance proposed to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the building, structure, or land; f. Owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement would result in unnecessary hardship. Special conditions to be considered pursuant to this section of the land development regulations shall include, but not be limited to, the following circumstances: 1. Redevelopment. If the proposed project involves the redevelopment or utilization of an existing developed or partially developed site. 2. Substandard lot(s). If the proposed project involves the utilization of an existing legal nonconforming lot(s). 3. Neighborhood character. If the proposed project promotes the established development pattern of a block face, including setbacks, building height, and other dimensional requirements. 4. Public facilities. If the proposed project involves the development of public parks, public facilities or public utilities. 5. Architectural and/or engineering considerations. If the proposed project utilizes architectural and/or engineering features that would render the project more disaster resistant. g. The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of this chapter; h. The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. (5) In granting any variance, the planning and zoning board or city commission may prescribe appropriate conditions and safeguards in conformity with the land 9

7 development regulations. Violation of such conditions and safeguards, when made a part of the terms under which the variance is granted, shall be deemed a violation of this chapter. (6) Under no circumstances shall the planning and zoning board or city commission grant a variance to permit a use not generally or by special exception permitted in the zoning district involved or any use expressly or by implication prohibited by the land development regulations. (7) The granted variance shall be valid for one-year. To remain in effect after one- year, one of the following must have occurred: a. An extension of time has been approved by the approving body; b. Building permits relating to the requested variance have either been applied for or granted; or c. A site plan review relating to the requested variance has been applied for or approved by the planning and zoning board. ANALYSIS OF LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS: The criteria for reviewing a variance for approval or denial is contained in the City of Treasure Island Land Development Regulations – Sec. 69-71. Staff’s analysis of the land development regulations is provided below. The applicant’s narrative is included in this agenda packet as a separate attachment. 1. The variance is in fact a variance as set forth within the land development regulations and within the province of the board or commission based upon the opinion of the city manager or his designee. The setback variance being requested is set forth within the City’s Land Development Regulations and under the purview of the Planning and Zoning Board. 2. Special conditions or circumstances exist which are peculiar to the building, structure, or land for which the variance is sought and do not apply generally to buildings, structures, or lands in the same district. The applicant is seeking to replace an existing structure that does not comply with the existing setback and floodplain management requirements of the land development regulations. However, due to the irregularly shaped lot with side lot lines that are not parallel to one another, redevelopment of a standard single-family home on this site is challenging. However, the nonconforming use regulations of Section 68-12(6) permit reconstruction of nonconforming structures with the same square footage that existed previously if the extents of the nonconforming setbacks are not increased. 3. Strict application of the provisions of the land development regulations would not permit the applicant reasonable use of the building, structure, or land. Strict application of the setback standards of the land development regulations would 10

8 permit reconstruction of a house of the same square footage as existed previously as long as the extents of the nonconforming setbacks are not increased. 4. The peculiar conditions and circumstances existing are not the result of the actions of the applicant, the applicant’s agent, or the applicant’s predecessors in title. The irregularly shaped lot is a peculiar circumstance that is not the result of the actions of the applicant, the applicant’s agent, or the applicant’s predecessors in title. 5. The variance proposed to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the building, structure, or land. The proposed setback reductions are not the minimum variances that will make possible reasonable use of the property. Section 68-12(6) permits reconstruction of the same square footage that existed previously if the extents of the nonconforming setbacks are not increased. The applicant is proposing a two-story structure, significantly increasing the square footage above the size of the existing single-story residence. The applicant has not demonstrated that a smaller structure could not be built without a variance or with a smaller variance. 6. Owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement would result in unnecessary hardship. Special conditions to be considered pursuant to this section of the land development regulations shall include, but not be limited to, the following circumstances: Redevelopment; Substandard lot(s); Neighborhood character; Public facilities; Architectural and/or engineering considerations. Redevelopment – Section 68-12(6) permits reconstruction of the same square footage that existed previously if the extents of the nonconforming setbacks are not increased. The applicant is proposing a two-story structure, significantly increasing the square footage above the size of the existing single-story residence. Therefore, literal enforcement of the code would not create an unnecessary hardship. Substandard lot(s) – N/A- The parcel meets the minimum width, depth, and area for the RM-15 (Residential Medium) Zoning District. Neighborhood character – The neighborhood consists of single-family structures. Public facilities – N/A- The requested variance is not connected to a proposed project that involves the development of public parks, public facilities or public utilities. Architectural and/or engineering considerations – The requested variance is related to the design and construction of a structure that would render it more disaster resistant. 7. The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this chapter. 11

9 Granting of the variance would permit the development of a larger house than would otherwise be permitted on this site, and the applicant has not demonstrated that a smaller house could not be built on this site without a variance or with a smaller variance. Therefore, the proposed variance is not in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the zoning regulations. 8. The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. Granting the variance would permit the development of a larger house than would otherwise be permitted on this site as well as on the other lots within this neighborhood. The proposed house would be out of character and potentially detrimental to the surrounding neighborhood. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends DENIAL to a variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure. Based on the analysis of the criteria in Sec. 70-221 above, finding that they have not been substantially satisfied and that an unnecessary hardship does not exist. Staff’s recommendation is based on the criteria set forth in Sec. 70-221 and the following:  Sec. 68-512. – Nonconforming Use Regulations. 12

10 April 17, 2025 PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD DEVELOPMENT ORDER CASE NO. VAR-000499-2025 LOCATION: 142 93 RD AVENUE, TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706 The Planning and Zoning Board has determined that an extreme hardship DOES / DOES NOT exist pursuant to Sec. 70-221 of the Treasure Island Code of Ordinances, and has moved to: [ ] APPROVE [ ] DENY [ ] CONTINUE [ ] APPROVE WITH CONDITIONS A variance request to Sec. 68-541 to reduce the East (side) setback from the required minimum 7½ feet to 3 feet 10 inches and the South (front) setback from the required minimum 10 feet to 6 feet 8 inches for an approximate 222-square foot section of the proposed structure CONDITIONS: 1. The proposed structure shall be substantially consistent with the plans prepared by Lodestone Design Group, dated March 3, 2025. __________________________ ____________ Richard Harris, Chair Date Planning & Zoning Board 13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

142 93rd Ave Clark Proposed Home Additional narrative on the variance requested: This is a variance request to Sec. 68-541(1), which requires a 10’ setback from the front and rear of the property and a 7.5’ setback from each side. The variance request is to permit a 222sf section of the home and/or porches to encroach as follows: Front (street): 5’2” into the 10’ setback for covered stairs and covered patios, with a small portion of the encroachment to allow for street level garage access. This would leave approximately 6’ 91/8” – 6’ 73/32” of setback on the street side. Left Side: No variance requested. Right Side: 3’ 2” – 2’ 8” into the 7.5’

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning & Zoning Board
  • Planning & Zoning Board — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 5630be4d3da019e3209863927f39e859. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record