POLISCOPE

The public record

PIEDMONT (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Decisions publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission Meeting

Monday, April 10, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

1 PIEDMONT PLANNING COMMISSION Regular Meeting Minutes for Monday, April 10, 2023 A Regular Session of the Piedmont Planning Commission was held on Monday, April 10, 2023, both in person and via ZOOM teleconference, in accordance with Government Code Section 54953. The agenda for this meeting was posted for public inspection on March 28, 2023, in accordance with the General Code Section 54954.2 (a). CALL TO ORDER Vice-Chair Douglas Strout called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Wayne Rowland, Douglas Strout, and Justin Zucker Absent: Commissioners Rani Batra, Aradhana Jajodia, and Julie Ortiz Staff: Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson, Senior Planner Pierce Macdonald, Associate Planner Gopika Nair, Assistant Planner Steven Lizzarago, Assistant Planner Joshua Muller, and Administrative Assistant Mark Enea INTRODUCTION OF NEW COMMISSIONERS AND ELECTION OF CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson stated that the City Council appointed new Commissioners to the Planning Commission. Aradhana Jajodia, Wayne Rowland, and Justin Zucker were appointed to a regular position, and Julie Ortiz was appointed to an alternate position. The incumbent and new Commissioners must appoint a new Chair and Vice Chair to the Commission. Director Jackson also reminded the Commission and members of the public that the 2023 Design Awards Gala will be held on Wednesday, April 19, 2023, at Community Hall. Resolution 7-PL-23 RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission elects Commissioner Strout to serve as Commission Chair and Commissioner Zucker to serve as Commission Vice Chair. Moved by Strout, Seconded by Zucker Ayes: Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: Batra, Jajodia, Ortiz There was no Public testimony. PUBLIC FORUM There was no Public testimony REGULAR SESSION The Commission considered the following items of regular business: APPROVAL OF MINUTES The March 13, 2023 minutes will be brought back at a future meeting due to an insufficient number of Commissioners to approve this item. CONSENT CALENDAR No agenda items were nominated to the Consent Calendar. REGULAR CALENDAR The Commission considered the following items as part of Regular Calendar: Housing Policy Updates Senior Planner Pierce Macdonald updated the Commission on the development of fair housing policy with a focus on the 6th Cycle Housing Element. The City Council adopted the 6th Cycle Housing Element on March 20, 2023. The California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) is reviewing the 6th

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 2 Cycle Housing Element. The City will answer questions and respond to HCD comments to help expedite HCD’s review. Formal comments should be received from HCD by May 24, 2023. Ms. Macdonald thanked the community and the Planning Commission for their participation in the Housing Element update process. The implementation of the 6th Cycle Housing Element has begun with a new affordable Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) incentive and with proposals received in response to the City’s Request for Proposals (RFP) for consulting firms to prepare the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan. A recommendation will be brought to City Council within a few weeks. There was no Public Testimony. Variance and Design Review Permit, 13 Sotelo Avenue, VAR 2023-001 DRPC 2023-003 The Property Owners are requesting permission to enlarge a dormer on the front of the residence, install new windows and doors, and make other interior and exterior modifications. A variance permit is required in order to increase the massing of a dormer located within the 20-foot right side yard setback. A variance is required in order to construct within the 20-foot side yard setback. Public testimony was received from: Georgia Collins, Property Owner, stated that their project is simple, and they are not making significant modifications. Mali Efraim, Designer, stated the neighbors were contacted and they were agreeable to the project. Commissioner Zucker stated he supports the project. The matching of the existing windows style throughout the facade, and the relationship to the width of the windows makes this project a well-adapted addition. Commissioner Rowland stated the project is a visual improvement with uniformity. He supports the project. Chair Strout stated the project is a very thoughtful design. He supports the project. Resolution 001-VAR-23, 003-DRPC-23 WHEREAS, the Property Owners are requesting to enlarge a dormer on the front of the residence, install new windows and doors, and make other interior and exterior modifications. A variance permit is required in order to increase the massing of a dormer located within the 20-foot right side yard setback; which construction requires a variance and design review permit; and WHEREAS, a variance from the requirements of Chapter 17 of the Piedmont City Code is necessary to construct within the 20-foot right side yard setback and; WHEREAS, after reviewing the application, plans, and any and all testimony and documentation submitted in connection with such application and after visiting the subject property, the Piedmont Planning Commission finds that the project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Class 1 (e), Existing Facilities, and the project was consistent with General Plan policies and programs; and

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 3 WHEREAS, the variances to construct within the 20-foot right side yard setback is approved because the project complies with the variance criteria under Section 17.70.040 as follows: 1. The property and existing improvements present unusual physical circumstances of the property, including the lot is much smaller than the required Zone E lot size, and the existing residence is nonconforming and the dormer is already located within the setback. Strictly applying the terms of the chapter would keep the property from being used in the same manner as other conforming properties in the zone. 2. The property is compatible with the immediately surrounding neighborhood and the public welfare because a majority of neighboring properties have structures located within the 20-foot setbacks. Most homes in the neighborhood are similar in size to what is being proposed. 3. Accomplishing the improvements without a variance would cause unreasonable hardship in planning, design or construction because the house would need to be partially demolished in order to not be located within the setbacks. The existing dormer is already within the setback, and exterior medications to that feature may require a variance. WHEREAS, regarding the design review permit, the Planning Commission finds that as conditioned, the project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, and the proposal, as conditioned, does conform to the criteria and standards of Section 17.66.060 of the Piedmont City Code as follows: 1. The proposed design is consistent with the City's General Plan and Piedmont Design Guidelines. The following building features are consistent with the original architecture and neighborhood development including, the dormer size and location, the stucco wall material, and the window and door material and fenestration pattern. 2. The design has little or no effect on neighboring properties' existing views, privacy, and access to direct and indirect light because the distance between the project and neighboring homes is appropriate. The enlarged dormer does not impact any views or privacy as it faces the street. The development is within the existing building envelope and does not increase the footprint of the structure. 3. The proposed design does not adversely affect pedestrian or vehicular safety because the project does not adversely impact on-site safety conditions. 4. As conditioned, the application complies with the following Design Review Guidelines and General Plan policies and programs: Site Design 3.03, 3.05, Building Design: General 4.01, 4.02, 4.03 and Building Design: Single Family Residential 5.01. 5. The project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the land use element, housing element, and design and preservation element, including: Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.1 (Scale, Height, and Bulk Compatibility), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.2 (Style Compatibility), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.3 (Additions), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.4 (Setback Consistency), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.6 (Exterior Materials), and Preservation Element Policy 31.3 (Context Sensitivity Design).

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 4 RESOLVED, that based on the findings and facts set forth heretofore, the Piedmont Planning Commission approves the variances and design review permit application for the construction at 13 Sotelo Avenue, Piedmont, California, in accordance with the plans and specifications on file with the City, subject to the following conditions: 1. Window and Door Material. As specified in the plans, the building material for the new windows and doors shall be wood. 2. Window Color Scheme. All the windows on the house shall have a consistent color scheme. 3. Window Recess. All new windows shall be recessed approximately 2 inches from the exterior wall to the face of window sash in order to maintain consistency with the original architecture, as required by the City’s Design Guidelines and Window Replacement Policy. Window details shall be submitted for review and approval at the time of building permit application. 4. Pre-construction Inspection. Prior to the commencement of window fabrication, the installer shall schedule a pre-construction inspection with the Building Department to review the approved installation criteria, such as the window recess, window trim if any, and windowsill projection if any. 5. Defense of Legal Challenges. The Property Owner shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its Council, Planning Commission, advisory boards, officers, employees, consultants and agents (hereinafter “City”) from any claim, action or proceeding (hereinafter “Proceeding”) brought against the City to attack, set aside, void or annul the City‘s actions regarding any development or land use permit, application, license, denial, approval or authorization, including, but not limited to, variances, use permits, developments plans, specific plans, general plan amendments, zoning amendments, approvals and certifications pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, and/or any mitigation monitoring program, or brought against the City due to actions or omissions in any way connected to the Property Owner’s project (“Challenge”). City may, but is not obligated to, defend such Challenge as City, in its sole discretion, determines appropriate, all at Property Owner’s sole cost and expense. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, damages, fees and/or costs awarded against the City, if any, and costs of suit, attorney’s fees and other costs, liabilities and expenses incurred in connection with such proceeding whether incurred by the Property Owner, City, and/or parties initiating or bringing such Proceeding. If the Property Owner is required to defend the City as set forth above, the City shall retain the right to select the counsel who shall defend the City. Per Government Code Section 66474.9, the City shall promptly notify Property Owner of any Proceeding and shall cooperate fully in the defense. 6. Construction Management Plan. The Property Owner shall develop a comprehensive Construction Management Plan. The Construction Management Plan shall address noise, vibrations, traffic control, parking, debris removal, dust control, sanitary facilities, site safety security emergency access, and other potential construction impacts, as well as other details involving the means and methods of completing the Project, including the construction route. The City Building Official has the authority to require modifications and amendments to the Construction Management Plan as deemed necessary throughout the course of the Project and until the Final Inspection.

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 5 7. Construction Completion Schedule. Work on the Project, once begun, shall be promptly executed with continuous good faith and reasonable progress. Since timely completion of this Project is of the essence, the Applicant shall submit for approval a Construction Completion Schedule, which will specify, in detail, the duration and percentage of the project as a whole for each phase. a. The Construction Completion Schedule with associated construction values for each benchmark shall set forth completion dates for the following benchmarks as needed: i) Completion of Excavation; ii) Completion of Retaining Walls; iii) Completion of Foundation; iv) Completion of Rough Framing; v) Completion of Electrical; vi) Completion of Plumbing; vii) Completion of Mechanical; viii) Completion of Fire Sprinklers; ix) Completion of Home; x) Completion of Hardscaping and Landscaping; and any further construction benchmarks and conditions of occupancy as may be determined by the Director of Public Works. b. Before the Project begins, the Director of Public Works shall make a determination as to the reasonableness of the proposed completion dates applicable to the Project, and that determination shall constitute the Approved Construction Completion Schedule and be binding on the Applicant. The City may, at the Applicant’s sole cost, engage the services of a consultant to review the proposed Construction Completion Schedule and, to the extent the period allocated for any work appears unjustifiable, recommend to the Director of Public Works a reasonable completion date for any benchmark. c. In the event of a change in scope of the Project that would alter the benchmarks dates set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or in the event the Applicant fails to meet a benchmark set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Applicant shall immediately submit a request to amend the Approved Construction Completion Schedule to the Director of Public Works. The request to amend shall be accompanied by a new proposed Construction Completion Schedule in compliance with subsection (a) of this condition of approval and the Director of Public Works shall evaluate the proposed amendments to the Approved Construction Completion Schedule in accordance with subsection (b) of this condition of approval. d. The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or any amendments to it approved in conformance with subsection (d) of this condition of approval, shall constitute a nuisance under the City of Piedmont City Code (“City Code”). The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule may result in the City pursuing administrative citations pursuant to Chapter 1 of the City Code, nuisance abatement pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City Code, or any other remedy available to the City under the law. Additionally, if the Applicant fails to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Director of Public Works, at his or her sole discretion, may make a claim against the Property Owner’s Site Security, if one is required, in order to complete the benchmark. The Director of Public Works, at his or her sole discretion, may refer the application to the Planning Commission for public review and direction Moved by Zucker, Seconded by Rowland Ayes: Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: Batra, Jajodia, Ortiz

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 6 Fence and Wall Design Review Permit, 217 Hillside Avenue, DRFW 2023-003 The Property Owners are requesting permission to construct a 42-inch-tall wood fence along the front (east) and side (north and south) property lines and within the 20-foot street yard setback that enclosed the front yard; install landscaping between the fence and the sidewalk; construct a steel pergola in the rear (west) yard; construct arbor and gate structures in the rear and side yard; install an outdoor grill in the rear yard; make significant landscape and hardscape modifications throughout the property; and make several other associated exterior modifications. Public testimony was received from: Ryan Ripsteen, Property Owner, stated they restored the home and the architectural details. They will take the same consideration for their garden spaces. Their focus is to get the front fence approved for safety and the aesthetics of the home and neighborhood. Mr. Ripsteen states that the fence is set back roughly 2 feet from the front property line and there will be a planting strip at the toe of the fence. Commissioner Zucker asked if there was a consideration of the fence enclosure without a gate. In response to Commissioner Zucker, Mr. Ripsteen stated the proposal considered a gate for security and safety reasons. Chair Strout asked for a better description of the gate and arbor structure proposed on the driveway. Bernardo Lopez, Landscape Designer, stated the one post that remains on the side of the driveway will be rebuilt and a matching pillar will be installed on the other side, and there will be a new arbor, fence, and gate. Mr. Bernardo stated that the property currently lacks a sense of arrival, and the project intends to create a welcoming and obvious entrance that compliments the arched entry façade design, by providing a stone path from the entry gate to the door. The gardens including the hardscaped areas will be a 100% permeable and sustainable. The improvements will create an entranceway to the home. The improvements proposed in the backyard will soften the harsh landscape that currently exists. Commissioner Rowland agreed and stated that the home is lacking a sense of arrival. He agreed that creating an entranceway is practical and a better visual for the home. The gate will provide safety and separation for all users. There are other homes in the neighborhood with front yard fencing. He supports the project. Commissioner Zucker stated the project is a great design. There is a lack of destination entry to the home and agreed it needs an entryway. Commissioner Zucker stated that gate is appropriate for an upsloping lot which is not the case here. He is not supportive of the gate but is supportive of the other proposed modifications. Chair Strout stated the project is a nice design and supports the project as described. Resolution 003-DRFW-23 WHEREAS, the Property Owners are requesting permission to construct a 42-inch- tall wood fence along the front (east) and side (north and south) property lines and within the 20-foot street yard setback; install landscaping between the fence and the sidewalk; construct a steel pergola in the rear (west) yard; construct arbor and gate structures in the rear and side yard; install an outdoor grill in the rear yard; make significant landscape and hardscape modifications throughout the property; and make several other associated exterior modifications which construction requires a design review permit; and,

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 7 WHEREAS, after reviewing the application, plans, and any and all testimony and documentation submitted in connection with such application and after visiting the subject property, the Piedmont Planning Commission finds that the project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3 (e), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures, and Section 15301, Class 1 (e), Existing Facilities, and the project was consistent with General Plan policies and programs; and WHEREAS, regarding the design review permit, the Planning Commission finds that the project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, and the proposal does not conform to the criteria and standards of Section 17.66.060 of the Piedmont City Code as follows: 1. The proposed design is consistent with the City's General Plan and Piedmont Design Guidelines. The following building features are consistent with the original architecture and neighborhood development including the fence height, design and location, the pergola design and location, the location of the outdoor grill, the landscape modifications, the arbor and gate structure location, height and design including additional elements described by the landscape architect at the meeting, and the design of the handrail. 2. The design has little or no effect on neighboring properties' existing views, privacy, and access to direct and indirect light because the distance between the project and neighboring homes is appropriate. There is no impact on views, privacy, and access to light. The view is not a significant view. 3. The proposed design does not adversely effect pedestrian or vehicular safety because the project improves pedestrian safety. The project maintains adequate visibility for entering and exiting the driveway. 4. As conditioned, the application complies with the following Design Review Guidelines and General Plan policies and programs: Site Design 3.03, 3.09, 3.11, 3.12, and 3.13. 5. The project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the land use element, housing element, and design and preservation element policy including: Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.6 (Exterior Materials), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.1 (Conserving Residential Yards), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.2 (Landscape Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.3 (Front Yard Enclosures), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.4 (Maintaining Privacy), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.5 (Fence and Wall Design), and Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.9 (Sight Obstructions). RESOLVED, that based on the findings and facts set forth heretofore, the Piedmont Planning Commission approves the design review permit application for the improvements at 217 Hillside Avenue, Piedmont, California, in accordance with the plans and specifications on file with the City, subject to the following conditions: 1. Exterior Lighting. All new wall- or ceiling-mounted exterior light fixtures shall be downward directed with an opaque or translucent shade that completely covers the light bulb. 2. Setback from Property Line Verification. The applicant shall submit to the Building Official written verification by a licensed land surveyor stating that

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 8 the pergola is located at least 5 feet away from the rear property line and 8 feet away from the side (north) property line, and that the front yard fencing is located at least 2 feet away from the front property line; as shown on the approved plans. Minor modification to pergola location outside the rear and side yard setbacks shall be subject to staff review and approval. 3. Final Landscape Plan. The final plan shall comply with City Code Division 17.34 and Section 17.33.30, and shall not propose plants near the driveway that could obscure visibility of pedestrians on the sidewalk or vehicles on the street from drivers backing out of the driveway. Upon the determination of the Director, minor differences in the number, size and/or species of vegetation between those shown on the approved landscape plan and those installed at the time of final inspection that do not involve an increase in hardscape or structure coverage may be subject to staff review and approval. Significant differences between the vegetation installed at the time of final inspection and vegetation shown on the approved landscape plan are subject to a design review permit. 4. California’s Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance (WELO): Applicant shall comply with the requirements of California’s Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance that went into effect December 1, 2015. All projects that disturb 2,500 sq. ft. of landscaping shall submit the following required information to the Building Department for review and approval: (a) Landscape Documentation Package that includes the following six items: i) Project Information; ii) Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet; iii) Soil Management Report; iv) Landscape Design Plan; v) Irrigation Design Plan; and vi) Grading Design Plan. The Landscape Documentation Package is subject to staff review and approval before the issuance of a building permit. (b) Once a building permit has been issued, the Applicant shall submit a copy of the Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet, to the local water purveyor, East Bay Municipal Utility District. (c)After completion of work, the Applicant shall submit to the City and East Bay Municipal Utility District a Certificate of Completion, including an irrigation schedule, an irrigation maintenance schedule, and an irrigation audit report. The City may approve or deny the Certificate of Completion. 5. Stormwater Design. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board requires all projects, or a combination of related projects, that create and/or replace 2,500 square feet or more of impervious surface to comply with Provision C.3.i of the Municipal Regional Stormwater NPDES Permit. As required by the Chief Building Official, the Applicant shall verify the total area of impervious surface to be created and/or replaced within the scope of this project, or this project combined with other related projects and/or permits, and incorporate the site design measure(s) required under Provision C.3.i into the plans submitted for a building permit. Copies of the Municipal Regional Stormwater Permit are available from the Piedmont Public Works Department and on-line at cleanwaterprogram.org. 6. Construction Management Plan. The Property Owner shall develop a comprehensive Construction Management Plan. The Construction Management Plan shall address noise, vibrations, traffic control, parking, debris removal, dust control, sanitary facilities, site safety security emergency access, and other potential construction impacts, as well as other details involving the means and methods of completing the Project, including the construction route. The City Building Official has the authority to require modifications and amendments to the Construction Management Plan as

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 9 deemed necessary throughout the course of the Project and until the Final Inspection. 7. Construction Completion Schedule. Work on the Project, once begun, shall be promptly executed with continuous good faith and reasonable progress. Since timely completion of this Project is of the essence, the Property Owner shall submit for approval a Construction Completion Schedule, which will specify, in detail, the duration and percentage of the project as a whole for each phase. a. The Construction Completion Schedule with associated construction values for each benchmark shall set forth completion dates for the following benchmarks as needed: i) Completion of Excavation; ii) Completion of Retaining Walls; iii) Completion of Foundation; iv) Completion of Rough Framing; v) Completion of Electrical; vi) Completion of Plumbing; vii) Completion of Mechanical; viii) Completion of Fire Sprinklers; ix) Completion of Home; x) Completion of Hardscaping and Landscaping; and any further construction benchmarks and conditions of occupancy as may be determined by the Director of Public Works. b. Before the Project begins, the Director of Public Works shall make a determination as to the reasonableness of the proposed completion dates applicable to the Project, and that determination shall constitute the Approved Construction Completion Schedule and be binding on the Property Owner. The City may, at the Property Owner’s sole cost, engage the services of a consultant to review the proposed Construction Completion Schedule and, to the extent the period allocated for any work appears unjustifiable, recommend to the Director of Public Works a reasonable completion date for any benchmark. c. In the event of a change in scope of the Project that would alter the benchmarks dates set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or in the event the Property Owner fails to meet a benchmark set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Property Owner shall immediately submit a request to amend the Approved Construction Completion Schedule to the Director of Public Works. The request to amend shall be accompanied by a new proposed Construction Completion Schedule in compliance with subsection (a) of this condition of approval and the Director of Public Works shall evaluate the proposed amendments to the Approved Construction Completion Schedule in accordance with subsection (b) of this condition of approval. d. The failure of the Property Owner to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or any amendments to it approved in conformance with subsection (d) of this condition of approval, shall constitute a nuisance under the City of Piedmont City Code (“City Code”). The failure of the Property Owner to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule may result in the City pursuing administrative citations pursuant to Chapter 1 of the City Code, nuisance abatement pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City Code, or any other remedy available to the City under the law. Additionally, if the Property Owner fails to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Director of Public Works, at his or her sole discretion, may make a claim against the Property Owner’s Site Security, if one is required, in order to complete the benchmark. The Director of Public Works, at his or her

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 10 sole discretion, may refer the application to the Planning Commission for public review and direction. 8. Defense of Legal Challenges. The Property Owner shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its Council, Planning Commission, advisory boards, officers, employees, consultants and agents (hereinafter “City”) from any claim, action or proceeding (hereinafter “Proceeding”) brought against the City to attack, set aside, void or annul the City‘s actions regarding any development or land use permit, application, license, denial, approval or authorization, including, but not limited to, variances, use permits, developments plans, specific plans, general plan amendments, zoning amendments, approvals and certifications pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, and/or any mitigation monitoring program, or brought against the City due to actions or omissions in any way connected to the Property Owner’s project (“Challenge”). City may, but is not obligated to, defend such Challenge as City, in its sole discretion, determines appropriate, all at Property Owner’s sole cost and expense. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, damages, fees and/or costs awarded against the City, if any, and costs of suit, attorney’s fees and other costs, liabilities, and expenses incurred in connection with such proceeding whether incurred by the Property Owner, City, and/or parties initiating or bringing such Proceeding. If the Property Owner is required to defend the City as set forth above, the City shall retain the right to select the counsel who shall defend the City. Per Government Code Section 66474.9, the City shall promptly notify Property Owner of any Proceeding and shall cooperate fully in the defense 9. Driveway Gate. To facilitate vehicular access, the driveway gate shall be motorized. If design modifications are required to accomplish this, those modifications shall be subject to staff review. Moved by Strout, Seconded by Rowland Ayes: Rowland, Strout Noes: Zucker Abstain: None Absent: Batra, Jajodia, Ortiz Section 25.14 of the City Code requires that an absolute majority of a commission must vote to approve any action of the commission. The motion to approve the application failed because less than three commissioners voted in support of the motion. Director Jackson recommended that the Commission continue the consideration of this application to the next available Planning Commission agenda. Resolution 8-PL-23 WHEREAS, the required number of votes to carry a motion to act on the design review permit application for 217 Hillside Avenue, the application is continued to a subsequent Commission meeting when there are sufficient numbers of Commissioners to vote on the project. Moved by Rowland, Seconded by Zucker Ayes: Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: Batra, Jajodia, Ortiz

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 11 Variance and Design Review Permit, 134 Sunnyside Avenue, VAR 2023-002 DRPC 2023-005 The Property Owners are requesting permission to add a new bedroom, replace windows, install a new heat pump, and construct a new trash enclosure. A variance is required to add a new bedroom without meeting the parking requirements. Public testimony was received from: Claire Parisa, Property Owner, stated more spaced is needed in the home, as they want to grow their family. They want to add a bedroom without adding a parking space. In response to Commissioner Rowland, Ms. Parisa stated they currently park their car on the street, typically in front of the house. In response to Chair Strout, Ms. Parisa stated they spoke with the architect about converting the crawlspace into a garage. It would be very costly and steep. The house would need to be raised. There is also a written addendum addressing the variance questions. Commissioner Zucker stated he supports the project. There are exceptional and extraordinary circumstances on this lot for size and topography. The design is compatible with the home. Commissioner Rowland stated the main issue at hand concerns parking. Adding a bedroom is a means of adding housing, and the configuration of the house is similar to other properties along Sunnyside Avenue. A lot of places are walkable from the home, mitigating the lack of off-street parking within the neighborhood. He supports the project. Chair Strout stated there is an unreasonable hardship for the property and considered many factors. He supports the project. Resolution 002-VAR-23, 005-DRPC-23 WHEREAS, the Property Owners are requesting to add a new bedroom, replace windows, install a new heat pump, and construct a new trash enclosure. A variance permit is required to add a new bedroom without meeting the parking requirements; which construction requires a variance and design review permit; and WHEREAS, a variance from the requirements of Chapter 17 of the Piedmont City Code is necessary to construct within the 20-foot left side yard setback and; WHEREAS, after reviewing the application, plans, and any and all testimony and documentation submitted in connection with such application and after visiting the subject property, the Piedmont Planning Commission finds that the project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Class 1 (e), Existing Facilities, and the project was consistent with General Plan policies and programs; and WHEREAS, the variances to construct within the 20-foot left side yard setback is approved because the project complies with the variance criteria under Section 17.70.040 as follows: 1. The property and existing improvements present unusual physical circumstances of the property, including the lot is unusually small, without demolishing the house a garage cannot be added, lot is unusually shaped, and the lot has unusually steep topography. Strictly applying the terms of the chapter would keep the property from being used in the same manner as other conforming properties in the zone.

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 12 2. The property is compatible with the immediately surrounding neighborhood and the public welfare because a majority of neighboring properties have unusually small lots, have no more than a 1-car garage or no garage, and are located in the front setback; disallowing non-conforming parking outside of the setback. 3. Accomplishing the improvements without a variance would cause unreasonable hardship in planning, design or construction because the house would need to be demolished in order to supply a garage. Expanding the garage to supply conforming parking spaces would require the relocation of retaining walls in the street yard. WHEREAS, regarding the design review permit, the Planning Commission finds that, as conditioned, the project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, and the proposal, as conditioned, does conform to the criteria and standards of Section 17.66.060 of the Piedmont City Code as follows: 1. The proposed design is consistent with the City's General Plan and Piedmont Design Guidelines. The following building features are consistent with the original architecture and neighborhood development including, the window and door material and fenestration pattern, and the color and material of the trash and condenser enclosure. 2. The design has little or no effect on neighboring properties' existing views, privacy, and access to direct and indirect light because the view is not a significant view. There is sufficient vegetative screening. The topographical differences are appropriate to preserve privacy, views and light. The height of the project has been kept as low as possible. The development is within the existing building envelope. 3. The proposed design does not adversely affect pedestrian or vehicular safety because the project does not modify on-site safety conditions. 4. As conditioned, the application complies with the following Design Review Guidelines and General Plan policies and programs: Site Design 3.13, and Building Design: General 4.03, 4.04. 5. The project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the land use element, housing element, and design and preservation element, including: Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.8 (Acoustical and Visual Privacy), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.1 (Conserving Residential Yards), and Design and Preservation Element Policy 31.3 (Context Sensitivity Design). RESOLVED, that based on the findings and facts set forth heretofore, the Piedmont Planning Commission approves the variances and design review permit application for the construction at 134 Sunnyside Avenue, Piedmont, California, in accordance with the plans and specifications on file with the City, subject to the following conditions: 1. Window and Door Material. As specified in the plans, the building material for the new windows and doors shall be fiberglass. 2. Window Color Scheme. All the windows on the house shall have a consistent color scheme. 3. Window Recess. All new windows shall be recessed 2 inches from the exterior wall to the face of window sash in order to maintain consistency with the original architecture, as required by the City’s Design Guidelines and Window

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 13 Replacement Policy. Window details shall be submitted for review and approval at the time of building permit application. 4. Pre-construction Inspection. Prior to the commencement of window fabrication, the installer shall schedule a pre-construction inspection with the Building Department to review the approved installation criteria, such as the window recess, window trim if any, and window sill projection if any. 5. Heat Pump Noise Limit. The proposed condenser unit must meet the 50- decibel requirement defined in Section 8.02.020 EE of the Piedmont City Code. 6. Defense of Legal Challenges. The Property Owner shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its Council, Planning Commission, advisory boards, officers, employees, consultants and agents (hereinafter “City”) from any claim, action or proceeding (hereinafter “Proceeding”) brought against the City to attack, set aside, void or annul the City‘s actions regarding any development or land use permit, application, license, denial, approval or authorization, including, but not limited to, variances, use permits, developments plans, specific plans, general plan amendments, zoning amendments, approvals and certifications pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, and/or any mitigation monitoring program, or brought against the City due to actions or omissions in any way connected to the Property Owner’s project (“Challenge”). City may, but is not obligated to, defend such Challenge as City, in its sole discretion, determines appropriate, all at Property Owner’s sole cost and expense. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, damages, fees and/or costs awarded against the City, if any, and costs of suit, attorney’s fees and other costs, liabilities and expenses incurred in connection with such proceeding whether incurred by the Property Owner, City, and/or parties initiating or bringing such Proceeding. If the Property Owner is required to defend the City as set forth above, the City shall retain the right to select the counsel who shall defend the City. Per Government Code Section 66474.9, the City shall promptly notify Property Owner of any Proceeding and shall cooperate fully in the defense. 7. Construction Management Plan. The Property Owner shall develop a comprehensive Construction Management Plan. The Construction Management Plan shall address noise, vibrations, traffic control, parking, debris removal, dust control, sanitary facilities, site safety security emergency access, and other potential construction impacts, as well as other details involving the means and methods of completing the Project, including the construction route. The City Building Official has the authority to require modifications and amendments to the Construction Management Plan as deemed necessary throughout the course of the Project and until the Final Inspection. 8. Construction Completion Schedule. Work on the Project, once begun, shall be promptly executed with continuous good faith and reasonable progress. Since timely completion of this Project is of the essence, the Applicant shall submit for approval a Construction Completion Schedule, which will specify, in detail, the duration and percentage of the project as a whole for each phase. a. The Construction Completion Schedule with associated construction values for each benchmark shall set forth completion dates for the following benchmarks as needed: i) Completion of Excavation; ii) Completion of Retaining Walls; iii) Completion of Foundation; iv) Completion of Rough Framing; v) Completion of Electrical; vi)

Planning Commission Minutes April 10, 2023 14 Completion of Plumbing; vii) Completion of Mechanical; viii) Completion of Fire Sprinklers; ix) Completion of Home; x) Completion of Hardscaping and Landscaping; and any further construction benchmarks and conditions of occupancy as may be determined by the Director of Public Works. b. Before the Project begins, the Director of Public Works shall make a determination as to the reasonableness of the proposed completion dates applicable to the Project, and that determination shall constitute the Approved Construction Completion Schedule and be binding on the Applicant. The City may, at the Applicant’s sole cost, engage the services of a consultant to review the proposed Construction Completion Schedule and, to the extent the period allocated for any work appears unjustifiable, recommend to the Director of Public Works a reasonable completion date for any benchmark. c. In the event of a change in scope of the Project that would alter the benchmarks dates set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or in the event the Applicant fails to meet a benchmark set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Applicant shall immediately submit a request to amend the Approved Construction Completion Schedule to the Director of Public Works. The request to amend shall be accompanied by a new proposed Construction Completion Schedule in compliance with subsection (a) of this condition of approval and the Director of Public Works shall evaluate the proposed amendments to the Approved Construction Completion Schedule in accordance with subsection (b) of this condition of approval. d. The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or any amendments to it approved in conformance with subsection (d) of this condition of approval, shall constitute a nuisance under the City of Piedmont City Code (“City Code”). The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule may result in the City pursuing administrative citations pursuant to Chapter 1 of the City Code, nuisance abatement pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City Code, or any other remedy available to the City under the law. Additionally, if the Applicant fails to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Director of Public Works, at his or her sole discretion, may make a claim against the Property Owner’s Site Security, if one is required, in order to complete the benchmark. The Director of Public Works, at his or her sole discretion, may refer the application to the Planning Commission for public review and direction Moved by Zucker, Seconded by Strout Ayes: Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: Batra, Jajodia, Ortiz ANNOUNCEMENT There were no announcements. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business, Chair Strout adjourned the meeting at 6:46 p.m.

Revised April 3, 2023 1 City of Piedmont Planning Commission Agenda Monday, April 10, 2023 - REVISED 5:30 p.m. City Council Chambers, 120 Vista Avenue, Piedmont, CA Piedmont Planning Commission meetings are conducted in person at City Hall Council Chambers. As a courtesy, and technology permitting, members of the public may participate virtually. However, the City cannot guarantee that the public’s access to teleconferencing technology will be uninterrupted, and technical difficulties may occur from time to time. Please see the end of the agenda for information on how to participate virtually. Call to Order Roll Call Introduction of new Commissioners and Election of Chair and Vice Chair Public Forum Persons wishing to address the Planning Commission regarding items not on the agenda may do so during the Public Forum. In order for all speakers to be heard, the Commission normally limits individuals’ comments to 3 minutes. Disclosure of ex parte communications and identification of conflicts of interest Regular Agenda 1. Approval of minutes for the March 13, 2023, regular meeting of the Planning Commission. 2. Removal of Applications from Regular Session to Consent Calendar. Applications that receive unanimous Planning Commission approval by consent will be placed on the Consent Calendar prior to consideration of the remaining applications on the Regular Session agenda. 3. HOUSING POLICY UPDATE Staff will provide a verbal update on the activities of staff and City’s housing consultants related to the development of fair housing policy. This is an informational item only. 4. VARIANCE PERMIT AND DESIGN REVIEW PERMIT 13 Sotelo Avenue VAR2023-001 and DRPC2023-003 The applications propose to enlarge a dormer on the front of the residence, install new windows and doors, and make other interior and exterior modifications. A variance permit is required in order to increase the massing of a dormer located within the 20-foot right side yard setback.

Revised April 3, 2023 2 5. DESIGN REVIEW PERMIT 373 Moraga Avenue DRPC2023-004 The application proposes to replace an attached carport with a new detached garage, build new rear decks and outdoor kitchen, make window, door and skylight modifications throughout the house, add exterior lighting, install air-conditioning compressors in the left side yard, and conduct interior renovations. 6. FENCE AND WALL DESIGN REVIEW PERMIT 217 Hillside Avenue DRFW2023-003 The application proposes to construct a 42-inch-tall wood fence along the front (east) and side (north and south) property lines and within the 20-foot street yard setback; install landscaping between the fence and the sidewalk; construct a steel pergola in the rear (west) yard; construct arbor and gate structures in the rear and side yard; install an outdoor grill in the rear yard; make significant landscape and hardscape modifications throughout the property; and make several other associated exterior modifications. The application has been deemed categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3(e), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures and Section 15301, Class 1 (e), Existing Facilities. 7. VARIANCE PERMIT AND DESIGN REVIEW PERMIT 134 Sunnyside Avenue VAR2023-002 and DRPC2023-005 The applications propose to add a new bedroom, replace windows, install a new heat pump, and construct a new trash enclosure. A variance is required to add a new bedroom without meeting the parking requirements. Adjourn Members of the public may participate in the meeting virtually in the following ways: • Computer or smart phone: Click on https://piedmont-ca-gov.zoom.us/j/86254083888 • Telephone: Dial (669) 900-9128 and enter webinar/meeting number 862-5408-3888 To comment using the Zoom platform, click the “Raise Your Hand” button to request to speak when public comment is being taken. You will be asked to unmute yourself when it is your turn to make your comment. After the allotted time, you will then be re-muted. If you are dialing in by telephone, dial *9 to request to speak and *6 to unmute yourself when called. The meeting is also available for life and archived viewing on the City’s website at https://piedmont.ca.gov/government/meeting_videos as well as on KCOM TV, Comcast Channel 27 or AT&T UVerse Channel 99. Agenda Item Material The materials for the agenda items listed above are available for review upon request by contacting Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson at kjackson@piedmont.ca.gov. A response will be provided during regular business hours 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Thursday. The applicant has elected to remove the project from this agenda.

Revised April 3, 2023 3 Procedural Notes 1. The Planning Commission welcomes you to its meeting which is regularly scheduled for the second Monday of each month. Your interest and participation are encouraged and appreciated. Members of the public will have an opportunity to be heard during the public portion of a hearing. While it is not mandatory, you are requested to give your name and address, comments and/or questions. In order that all interested parties have an opportunity to speak, please limit your comments to the specific subject under discussion. Time limitations are generally three minutes but shall be at the discretion of the Chairperson. You are not required to give your name and address, but doing so makes the meeting more efficient, enables the recording secretary to properly attribute comments in the meeting minutes, and will enable the City to send future notices concerning this application if there are any. 2. Applications are generally scheduled in the order in which they were submitted, but the Planning Commission reserves the right to change the order of applications on the agenda or change items from one calendar to the other without further notice. Each applicant is advised that if her or his representative is not present to speak to this application, her or his application may be acted upon and possibly denied. This meeting is required to end at or before 11:30 p.m. unless a majority of the Commission votes to continue the meeting. If your item has not been heard prior to the 11:30 p.m. deadline, your item may be continued to a future meeting. 3. Unless noted in the project description, the applications above have been deemed by staff to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Existing Facilities. 4. APPEAL - Any decision of the Planning Commission pursuant to Chapter 17 of the Piedmont City Code may be appealed by any interested party within ten (10) days to the City Council in accordance with the procedure set forth in Division 17.78, Appeals; Calls for review. Any member of the public who needs accommodations should email the City Clerk at cityclerk@piedmont.ca.gov or call (510) 420- 3040 who will make their best efforts to provide reasonable accommodations to provide as much accessibility as possible while also maintaining public safety in accordance with the City procedure for resolving reasonable accommodation requests. Information about reasonable accommodations is available on the City website at https://piedmont.ca.gov. [28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II] In accordance with G.C. Sec. 54954.2 (a) this notice and agenda were posted on the City Hall bulletin board and also in the Piedmont Police Department on April 3, 2023.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission Meeting — Minutes
  • Planning Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 55f02944fb91e33a469ce343948719cd. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record