The 30-second read
Recorded outcomeApproval of the Audit Advisory Minutes of September 4th, 2025
Why it matters
This item is supported by a public source record.
What happens next
No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.
The public record
Wednesday, October 29, 2025 · Government meeting record
The 30-second read
Recorded outcomeWhy it matters
This item is supported by a public source record.
What happens next
No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.
Other key decisions
3 captured items have a publicly linked outcome.
Approval of the Audit Advisory Minutes of September 4th, 2025
AAC Objectives and Responsibilities
APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.
Wednesday, October 29, 2025 9:00 AM City of Marco Island Florida 51 Bald Eagle Drive Marco Island, Florida cityofmarcoisland.com Community Room Audit Advisory Committee Chair: Eugene Siegel Vice-Chair: Elena McFann Committee Members: Thomas Fontana, Daniel Kastholm, Chris Ricci, Teri Sommerfeld City Staff: Carol McDermott, Jill Cartaya Meeting Minutes - Final
October 29, 2025Audit Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final (1) CALL TO ORDER Chair Siegel called the meeting to order at 9:00 am. (2) ROLL CALL Member Fontana, Member Kastholm, Vice-Chair McFann, Member Sommerfeld and Chair Siegel Present: 5 - Member RicciAbsent: 1 - ALSO PRESENT Councilor Schwan Councilor Henry Vice-Chair Gray Carol McDermott, Finance Director Jose Duran, IT Director (3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Led by Chair Siegel (4) INTRODUCTION OF NEW FINANCE DIRECTOR ID 25-4711 New Finance Director Introduction, Ms. Carol McDermott Chair Siegel introduced Carol McDermott, the new Finance Director. Carol McDermott, Finance Director, provided a brief overview of her goals for the Finance Department and her background. (5) INTRODUCTION OF NEW MEMBER ID 25-4713 New Audit Advisory Committee Member - Mr. Daniel Kastholm Chair Siegel introduced Daniel Kastholm, new Audit Advisory Committee Member. Member Kastholm provided a brief overview of his background. (6) APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA Chair Siegel requested a motion to approve the Agenda. Motion by Member Sommerfeld, seconded by Member Kastholm to Approve the Agenda. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOICE VOTE: Yes: Member Fontana, Member Kastholm, Vice-Chair McFann, Member Sommerfeld and Chair Siegel 5 - (7) APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES ID 25-4706 Approval of the Audit Advisory Minutes of September 4th, 2025 Chair Siegel requested a motion to approve the September 4th, 2025, meeting Minutes. Page 1City of Marco Island Florida
October 29, 2025Audit Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final MOTION by Member Fontana, seconded by Member Sommerfeld to Approve September 4th, 2025, Minutes. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOICE VOTES: Yes: Member Fontana, Member Kastholm, Vice-Chair McFann, Member Sommerfeld and Chair Siegel 5 - (8) OLD BUSINESS ID 25-4708 Update and Preparation for the Upcoming Audit Chair Siegel asked Carol McDermott, Finance Director, for a brief update. Carol McDermott, Finance Director, emphasized that the Finance Department is working on year-end. The Finance Department is also working on the audit for FY25. A meeting will be scheduled with CLA to discuss the material weaknesses and the FY25 audit. Vice-Chair McFann asked Ms. McDermott how the finance department felt about uploading of documents. Ms. McDermott is reviewing the documents being uploaded. ID 25-4709 Time and Action Plan for Upcoming Audit Vice-Chair McFann went over the time and action plan with Christopher Kessler, CPA, Principal, CLA (CliftonLarsonAllen, LLP) and gave an outline of their discussion. Members participated by sharing their input and seeking clarification through questions. ID 25-4824 AAC Objectives and Responsibilities Vice-Chair McFann went over the revisions for the AAC Objectives and Responsibilities and asked for feedback from her fellow Members. Member Kastholm asked what the Audit Advisory Committee is going to review and when is it going to be available. Carol McDermott, Financial Director, stated that the Finance Department will be building out reporting packages in different views. I did meet one-on-one with the councilors to outline the short term priorities – year-end and audit and that reporting will follow. Motion by Vice-Chair McFann, seconded by Member Kastholm to Approve the redone Audit and Finance Advisory Committee Objectives and Responsibilities Document as Amended during the course of the discussion and send it to City Council for their review and consideration. Yes: Member Fontana, Member Kastholm, Vice-Chair McFann, Member Sommerfeld and Chair Siegel 5 - (9) NEW BUSINESS ID 25-4710 Finalize Dates for Future Meetings Vice-Chair went through the calendar dates/schedule. A minimum of 5 meetings and one email auditor update. ID 25-4799 FY24 Audit - IT Observations Update Page 2City of Marco Island Florida
October 29, 2025Audit Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final Jose Duran, IT Director, explained because of the sensitivity nature of the findings, Mr. Duran welcomed having the members schedule a meeting with him on a one-to-one basis. Mr. Duran shared that six out of the seven findings were fully resolved. The remaining item requires coordination with the financial software provider to obtain a specific report. This is more of a processed documentation not a security related item. The audit came in at a time when the IT Department was in the process of swapping out several critical pieces of IT equipment. The IT Department was given 39 business days to create and compile 35 individual documents some detailing the IT processes and unfortunately were not given an opportunity to respond to some of the concerns in the report before it was published. (10) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS None. (11) CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION Councilor Schwan thanked the Audit Advisory Committee for their hard work and leadership. Vice-Chair Gray thanked the Audit Advisory Committee for an informative meeting and discussion. (12) PUBLIC COMMENT The following community member came forward to offer their thoughts to the Members of the Committee: Dennis Bartolucci (13) NEXT MEETING: CONFIRMATION & ATTENDANCE Next meeting will be scheduled for December 4th, 2025, at 9:00 am. (14) PROPOSED AGENDA TOPICS FOR NEXT MEETING Objectives and Responsibility Update Revised proposed Audit Advisory Committee Meeting Calendar Explanation of the Sunshine Law Audit update Corrective Action Plan Update Review of Preliminary year-end financials (15) OTHER COMMITTEE COMMUNICATIONS None. (16) ADJOURNMENT There being no further business before the Committee, Chair Siegel adjourned by meeting at 10:44 am. Page 3City of Marco Island Florida
3 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.
Showing 3 of 3
APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
Department: APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
Approval of the Audit Advisory Minutes of September 4th, 2025
AAC Objectives and Responsibilities
Official pages
Records considered
Not claimed by this page
No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.
Canonical record: 55bf8cb24e022afa7256718918f442da. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.
Publisher tools