POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Community and Economic Development Subcommittee

Wednesday, November 13, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Community and Economic Development Subcommittee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 67,433 characters. The full document is at the source.

Alrighty, welcome everybody to the Community and Economic Development Subcommittee. It is Wednesday, November 13th. And we can go ahead and get started with public comment on non-agenda items. Seeing none, to give staff some time to get here to working on some state of the city items. We were going to request to move item number three, the Environmental Services update first. to the library board that I don't remember one. Is that all right? Awesome. And then with that, I will… So for you today, what we have are some environmental service events recaps, and this is going to include one marina recap Starting with our postal cleanup. The city hosted a coastal cleanup at the marina a couple months ago, it was actually a statewide effort. This is something that is an international poster cleanup statewide with goals to remove trash identify sources of trash and change behaviors that cause polluting. Throughout the state, as you can see by the green and yellow, excuse me, the green dots. There were over 700 cleanups that occurred on September 21st of 2024. This was the 40th anniversary of this statewide event. And over 45,000 volunteers participated statewide. over 376,000 pounds of trash and recyclables were collected and over 188 tons, that equals 188 tons. in just three hours, theoretically, those events happen at the same time in all of these locations. So a hugely successful event and something that we are proud to participate in. We in Pittsburgh had 59 total participants and let me move this so you can see the great information. 59 total participants, 32 of them were under the age of 27. So our youngest volunteer was four years old. And 27 adults. This was led by our hybromaster, Olivia Ortega, and with major assistance from maintenance staff David Gonzalez. Great. The box today. We also had some special attendees, the STET team from Marina Vista Elementary was there, volunteering their Saturday morning. And Cineport was there. weekly 2.71 miles surrounding the Marine and the Yacht Club. There were 1,000 pounds of trash removed or more and over 500 pounds of recyclables were recovered. again in just three hours. And what's even more exciting is the city, the marina staff applied for a skimmer vote in Athena Arena to go around and collect trash. to apply for a grant for a boat, and we're excited to, if we get the grant and implement the skimmer, excited to see You know, the cleanups that can happen kind of automatically all the time in our marina. So keep these efforts of getting all the trash out of our harbors, out of our delta going Is the skimmer like a, it runs on its own or does someone operate it like how does it work? I believe it's operated by a person that's not um It's not like a Roomba. Oh, okay. My understanding is we would have to man it. But I didn't apply for the grant. So actually that's something I can follow up on you with. Okay. And you're invited to next year's Coastal Cleanup. These happen annually. Next year is September 20th. It's hosted down at the marina and there's always sweet treats when you get there. Okay. Next was our seventh annual fishing derby. This happened in October, October 5th. We had 39 participants, 19 kids and four seniors. Smaller attendance than usual. There are a lot of different things happened this year. There was no sturgeon season, just like there was no salmon season. Excuse me, the sturgeon season was abbreviated and the number of sturgeon you could take was also reduced. So a lot of people weren't spending their sturgeon cart on derby's. We gave away, though, 39 $30,940 in cash prizes. That definitely, when we announced that, I try not to announce the cash prize because really I want people to join because they like recreating and they want that license for their kids and all that. But when we had low enrollment, uh. give a little sneak peek on social media of what our prizes would be. And we've got some last minute sign up so That's good. We know what motivates people. And we had five sponsors, three local. We were happy to have Little Jays as a new sponsor this year. That was exciting to give those local gift cards away at our raffle at the award ceremony. And here's some pictures of the event. We had a lot of repeats, so we're getting a lot of people that look forward to this derby year after year. And we have some new faces. Let's see, were any of these schools new? I think the lower left are the only ones that were new this year. Impressive. And we had awesome participation as well from the striped bass association they spent they sent two representatives to kind of hang out with us at the judges station for credibility, but also to kind of talk shop with the people coming in about how the fishing season was going and kind of gather information for the regional bass association Pittsburgh Yacht Club hosted our award ceremony, it's paid catered, and the harbormaster and staff, though this is not a marina event, we're present the old time and made the event possible so we to perhaps to a public works department, specifically the emergency vision. Our 18th annual Diamond Classic Sturgeon Derby. This is a catcher with Reese Sturgeon Derby so Very well run. has come to Pittsburgh in the last three years since having Olivia as our pilot master. This is going to be in January, end of January this year, and we invite you and your friends to come join. It is a totally sponsored events. So fundraising occurs, there's raffles, there's awesome prizes and What's the actual date? It's the weekend Before, after, before. Of course. Awesome. And I'll pass it on to the net for more. Sure. So Clean Air Day, the city partnered with Sustainable Contra Costa on a micro grant from the California Coalition of Clean Air. to promote Clean Air Day. So on Friday, September 27th at Family Fun Friday, a table was set up here with the Clean Air Collision activity. The activity demonstrated the effect of weather on air pollution using bubbles and the youth got to create a at-home air pollution catcher. And sustainable Contra Costa gave out an air quality monitor as a prize. And they had an educational board set up. Sorry about they have an educational board set up so the youth and adults can kind of see how evolution whether can it not affect air pollution? Next slide. Okay, so the 2024 fall deltoid waters cohorts So the city partnered with Fish and Wildlife, Corteva, and the Pittsburgh Unified School District to organize a visit to the wetlands for the fourth grade class of Heights Elementary School. And so Delta Waters is a four hour outdoor hands-on immersive experience and is often the first exposure to the Delta for many students. This cohort, we had 80 participants, which included 67 students and 13 adults. We have a lot of chaperones interested in coming. And that included two teachers. We have four Pittsburgh High student docents. And five volunteers from U.S. Fish and Wildlife. Though every cohort is different, staff continues to learn new ways to enhance the program. Over the last few cohorts, we've updated the student journals, purchased some equipment from grant funds. To just enhance the program. And this cohort, we actually have to have lunch with the students at the wetlands. So it was pretty cool. Next slide. And the Meadowline Street Cleanup. So to complement the community and economic development's fiscal year 2324 goals of bringing public health and safety to the borderline street neighborhood. The city hosted a community cleanup For residents and poverty orders of Madeline Street. on september or sorry, Saturday, October 15th. This was accomplished in partnership with MDRR, the public works departments, and Civic courts. when there's 20 residents participate. I think that 22 dump trips. A total of 2.26 tons 14 tires and three leaf boxes that you see on the left there were filled. And city staff just looks forward to collaborating on new opportunities in the future. We're cleanups like this. It's not something that's an environmental says there's 24 or 25 annual goal of providing more opportunities for community cleaning. So we kind of started here to piggyback off of the good work that the economic development division was doing. And the residents were and the property owners were happy to have it focused in that area. Quick question. Are these type of cleanups, are they stipulated in the franchise agreement or are these above and beyond? These are above and beyond. So the idea of a, you might be aware that like Oakley does cleanups where people get to get a voucher and they sign up for a time and they can bring their things to a location or the transfer station and they do a community cleanup in that way. So they fit as many people as they can by appointment in a day to do that. that level of community cleanup would definitely need to be negotiated in the franchise agreement. But this actually was organized without anything in the franchise agreement above and beyond with great cooperation by MDR. Any other questions? Awesome. Oh, wait, I have a question on this particular sheet Where did this come from? Where does this go? When we register for the event, the events organizers send it to us. I forwarded this from Olivia, so I have to figure out exactly which organization sent it and I can get that information for you, but it's generated from the as when you register for the event, you type in your data and they send through the daily summary so this is our data. This is our data. Okay. Very cool. And then thank you for putting more than one slide on a page. Yes, it's a long time postal cleanup leader so it comes from at the state and the Coastal Commission, and each county has like a representative organization that the new contrapassets the resource conservation district and one that's in Richmond, a great thing, but right now let me organize it for the county. And so like all the data either do a sheet or you have an app on your phone. It all goes through them. They kind of report out to each county very cool Thank you. Any other questions on this item? And we will move to originally scheduled item number one City of Pisco Development. 18 update. All right. Thank you. And good evening, everyone. I'm sure we are all familiar with the fact that the 2040 general plan has been adopted and we are in the process of implementing from all the programs, policies and goals that go with that. And in order to do that, we have to update the development title update basically development type is a planning code just tackle 18. So the city has retained place works i think to assist with that effort. And this, our data effort involves a variety of text amendments. green learning economic development opportunities, updating certain sections to comply with state law. It also clarifies and corrects some regulations that have been ambiguous and difficult to understand. So, you know, it's going to make it doing business in Facebook much better and much easier for everybody We have set up a web page and I think we've shared it with internal staff to embed it before we release it to the public. staff and any interested party would be able to go in there, see all the different sections that we are planning to update, provide comments, make suggestions. ask questions and all of that will come to me. It also goes to placeworks And we'll be able to respond and address any concerns that are expressed. We hope to make it as user-friendly as possible so that my grandma can go there, my kids can go there and be able to understand what is going on. The next steps is actually we had a kickoff meeting on October 31st. many developing I'll see staff aim and We introduced that whole airport. We're going to have other meetings internal meetings with the development, I'll say heads and technical staff to get input. And we're also going to set up focus groups and then reach out to the community And get your input as well. So this is just the initial efforts that we've put in place. staff has actually already provided us some areas that we want placeworks to begin to focus on before we even release everything to the public. And once we do, we also want to receive as much input from the public as possible So that things that you know we don't see from this side of the counter which the public see would also be addressed as well you have in front of you a draft schedule. We have to compare the whole process is going to take between 12 to 18 months. So there will be a lot of opportunity to come to this committee, go to the planning commission do outreach to different interest groups and then eventually the city council for consideration and adoption. If anybody has any question or need any clarification, I'll be happy to John actually is here to answer all the questions. I want to add one sort of piece for that. This is the first comprehensive zoning code development code update we've done In probably four years. we've done a lot of amendments here or there to fix things, but this is the first time in probably four years the city has looked front and back of Title 18, which is probably our longest, most intensive and most utilized idle in the municipal code. A big part of it is it's what uses are allowed where updating those uses for 2024. We don't have things in our use classifications like data centers and other things. We've also got a lot of things that are outdated. You don't need to get you don't need to take your car and leave it overnight to get the glass replaced now. People just do it and it's done in a couple hours. it's much lighter than it was 40 years ago. So changing those classifications, revisiting those But it goes even deeper than that. I mean, we're talking our tree preservation ordinance is housed within the development code setbacks where you can park your RVs, how long you can store RVs, how much landscaping, you're required to have how much concrete you're allowed to have is very intensive. And so we're biting off a big piece here, but it's a little bit overdue. And so we're really excited about doing this. But we'll talk with you all a lot about the different uses you'd like to see and where, and obviously economic development is going to be a big driver in that. But we definitely want to hear from the public and we plan on doing a lot of outreach because there's going to be a lot of those day-to-day things that we hear at the counter, those questions that we get. that we want to make sure we're getting feedback from the community. So as we update those property maintenance regulations, things like that, we're consistent with state law. were consistent with any requirements that we have. with what we want, but also what the residents of the city of Pittsburgh want to see and what's going to make their lives better. Thank you. And I wanted to also mention that there are certain uses which very new to society like airbnb it's not addressed so we want to look at that to see how we're going to handle that. Mobile food vending, for instance, we need to address that EV charging. I mean, these are all new technology that has come since like you know obviously the past decade or so. So these are some of the things even cottage food in this micro enterprise micro enterprise so we we really want to bring our code to Is it the 21st or 22nd century? And Maurice and George are kind of correct because we haven't had a comprehensive update. The last time i looked And when I saw it was in 1982. So there was no internet there was no real y2k. When I say 1982, I say 1982 because That was kind of like a change and shift in the economy and how things were driven in regards to economic development. But moving forward, we want to try to do that comprehensive cleanup to make sure we catch everything into the 21st century, moving to the 22 seconds 22 wow but um a lot of it, I think, will come from just the community meetings and doing the outreach And making sure we stay in touch with the public and getting their comments and their feedback because We'll see what we need to change because of state law and because of the changes that have occurred over the last 20 years. But the public's really going to be the driver here. And I'm really excited that we're getting out there. We're doing some community outreach. And I'm kind of starting it from the ground and just Instead of diving in last time when I came right in the middle of the general plan and you know it's like a fish out of water. You're trying to figure, swim up the stream and try to get everybody on the same page. But I think this is a great opportunity for us as a city to really listen to the residents and listen to the public and make sure we're We're getting good feedback. And we also not only looking And internally, we also look at best practices that other jurisdictions have successfully and able to implement and hopefully borrow from that if necessary. Vice Mayor, council member, any thoughts, questions? We'd love some feedback if you have um Well, I had a question about the timeline, but you addressed it in the report. So that was my main question that I had about the particular item and then about Actually, the locations of where you're, are you planning to like focus groups or like the location or unit do it where the zones are, what your approach or methodology around that. I think it's going to be citywide and John can probably speak a little more to it, but we should probably focus on, let's say the I would say the business community, for instance, it doesn't matter where they are, we can bring them all together and say, hey, this is what we're doing for the city. So I think we'll probably have six to eight outreach meetings over starting in January. And then when we start with we start with the residents and we start with the communities and then we have we roll right over to our major stakeholders surveyors, engineers, professionals, business professionals. We meet with them on one-on-one and then what we'll do is come back After we hear from Nim, we'll come to the city council and Planning Commission hold a joint workshop to tell you what we've heard And then we'll move forward with kind of a next step in regards to trying to create a to-do list, a task list, things that we need to look at. And in Placeworks, who's going to work with us in regards to setting those meetings up and getting a schedule. So I think we'll probably be at the Marina Center, we'll be at the Senior Center. We'll also be out towards San Marco. Haven't picked a location yet, but we want to try to make sure we reach every area of the city right try to do something at the southern end of railroad yeah that area that needs a little TLC. But we definitely want to keep, you know. our finger on a pulse here and create synergy around it. So that synergy starts with just being able to reach to the community residents first and then talking to the businesses and talking to the the engineers, surveyors, people that real estate, you know, economic development community. So that's kind of kind of how I've been through it before. That's kind of how the task should be. You want to try to reach the target groups. And then come back to the decision makers with what you've heard. then try to incorporate all that and then you can start building your base in regards to what areas you need to focus on. There's five divisions in the development title. And we want to really try to focus on the aspects of trying to streamline permitting and not creating barriers. And making sure we're friendly, business friendly and allowing for people to come to the counter And possibly over-the-counter permit for a business. Okay, cool. What's the plan to reach out of town commercial owners? Um. I will take that into consideration. Like doing the Zoom One maybe or something? Well, what I've done in the past with that is usually rely on our consultant because they know what groups to target out of town if it be business owner But most of the commercial properties are owned by people that don't live in Pittsburgh. Oh, we'll do notices. We'll send notices out. It'll be web notices. It'll be social media. We'll make sure everyone is in touch with what happens. Male. Female? Male. No, I just out of town, people aren't going to see social media and notices around town and this. And most of the changes you're talking about are going to impact the value either increasing or decreasing it. And I think property owners should be aware of that. The last time I talked to brokers. When we did this, they were the ones that had a lot of outreach to their actual property owners or the management companies, I'm sorry, property management companies. When I reached out directly to them, that's when they talked to their their counterparts and their business owners. And we've got a couple of companies that I want to really focus on is a property upstairs and a couple other ones right yeah but not In general, you know. Vice Mayor, council member, anything else? No, I appreciate it. This is going to be a long process. We did the general plan. We've done the housing elements or understanding that this is going to take some time. I think for me it's just knowing when Council Planning Commission can give some constructive input You shared a lot of specific policy considerations. And so for me, it's just not having a water hose that is to where it's like, here's this large document, everything's in it. And we really need to digest in terms of these specific policy considerations. I definitely support in terms of what you're sharing as far as going out getting feedback from specific stakeholders and getting input first and coming back And then when it comes to the community, will the outreach or the workshops, will they be illustrative? And that, you know. understanding text amendments and talking about setbacks and things like that is very difficult for the common person. So being able to really visualize what does that mean in an area I think would be helpful, at least for the resident side. I mean, those were technical property owners will have deeper understanding but for community is definitely good to have the visual about, okay, what would these standards mean if they were actually developed So the community can really be aware of that. Grace Charette. When we have those one-on-ones, we'll have the storyboards, we'll have the pictures, you know, and we'll have some diagrams and we'll have flow charts. A lot of times what people I see is trying to understand a process, but they understand with the flow chart better than they do than you explain it to them. And they said, okay, step one. is here's the final steps here. And what is everything in between? But you're explaining that by storyboard or illustrator and we'll definitely have it for you. And Vice Mayor, what we can attempt to do and Sean, maybe work with a place where to bake this into the schedule. As John mentioned, we have five divisions within the title and they generally break it into you know by different sections right your uses and where they're allowed Then, you know, some of the other things. So we can try uh once it's timely and appropriate to maybe break it into five and return to this body at a minimum next year, every month or every couple months with just one of those divisions. So it's a little more digestible. We don't just hand you 700 pages and say, go through this. So we can really break it down a little bit. to the end of involving the community at the first opening meeting that we had with staff, the conversation really got going in a productive way when Maurice gave us examples of what kinds of things we'd be addressing. And we talked about when we communicate this project and these meetings to the community, maybe we preface it with you know interested in Regulating Airbnb or do you know what your setback is or what's a setback so it's like a question that would interest people and then we'll be like, come talk about PMC Title 18. I do agree. Yeah, because you can't, you want to engage people, but when you say we need you to show up for this meeting to talk about the development time. But when we started like having that chit chat about Oh, you can't regulate that because we don't have a definition for block. That's right. That's right. Commissioners. box feedback. I'm really curious about the conversation around micro enterprises. Do we have a definition for that, something that we go on? you knew what new was coming up. So I printed out the state guidelines in regards to microenner's. They didn't work well. But the state has guidelines, yes, in regards to micro enterprise home kitchens and what we need to do is work on our ordinance to make sure that we're in line with what the state's regulations are but we also want to ensure that We don't because if you're in a house in your home and you're serving food, but you can also you know it's kind of like a restaurant almost parking, noise, traffic. So we got to look at those things and the county has something set up, but I want to be I want to try to grab everybody's both and take a look at it with Placeworks before we And those are the things we're going to do while we go through this process. Okay. And that's only for products and not for services so things like I don't know. home organization so so right now we have an ordinance cottage food operations. Mm-hmm. But this is pretty much new. And I knew it was coming up. So I said, let me just Take a look at this placeworks you need to get on this right now. So there's a couple of things we may bring forward, but I would have a discussion about it first yeah like mobile food vendors, we need to deal with that. And we also need to deal with the micro enterprise. And then we also need to deal with screening for like RVs and stores and stuff like that wants to work. Yeah, I was like, wow. I agree with a lot of what's been said already. This is that big body of work that we have to do with the general plan updates. You guys just keep pushing forward, which I appreciate. Checking off the boxes. Putting in place works is a great resource because I've been they've done a lot of this work throughout the Bay Area, throughout California so they have the experience as a consultant to do this on. I look forward to see it moving forward. Thank you. Any other questions on this item? We can move on to the housing element update for 23 to 31 reporting 26th cycle. All right. Thank you. Well, as we all know, the housing element is part of the general plan is the housing piece of it. And the city initiated its housing element update back in summer of 2021. John came, took it over, and he's done an excellent job to get it to the finishing line. The initial draft was released to the public, but in March of 2023, On May 16, 2023, the Planning Commission adopted a resolution recommending it to the civic coastal and on May 22nd the council adopted it staff submitted it to HCD for their review And they provided some comments and sent it back to us. we address all the comments. and send it back to them on August of 2024 and on october 2nd the equity and leonard. And this is after when we send a revision, they assign it to a whole different reviewer so things take a little bit longer but eventually They were able to approve it so at this stage, we are glad to announce that we have an approved housing element and actually the housing element was really um holding back a lot of funding grants and capital improvement, financing and a whole bunch of things we have predicated on it So really getting it approved by HCD is a huge accomplishment for the city And so today um We are here to announce that and then also talk about the next steps. the city has to monitor and report the results of the implementation of the housing element. It has a lot of implementation programs that we need to implement and then also report So, um. We've identified a few of the programs for the 2023 325 million and so we're going to be providing updates from time to time as required by state law. So this is just an update to let you know where things are as far as the housing element goes. Thank you all for your support and We excited. We've been able to accomplish this. If there's any question, yeah, John will answer your questions for you. question just from my understanding, because you were saying that I'm not having it approved for preventative from grants or other opportunities like is that? And then can you give an example? Yeah, so the state, as you know, the housing prices that until the housing element was adopted we we who are recipients of the permanent local housing allocation funds. Those are the funds that are set aside for every real estate transaction. It's anywhere from almost 300,000. We've gotten as much as like 400,000. So we're anticipating in the next three years receiving A little over $875,000, and we're using those monies to pay for our core program. Until this housing element was adopted, our money was held hostage by HCD. now that it's been approved. you know we can we actually submitted our documents waiting for them to release the funds Okay. No other cities, Councilmember Madams, that were in the same kind of you know tug of war with hcd we weren't the only ones so but it was kind of a heavy lifting task to try to get them to understand we're doing our job. We have the highest grade in the county. In regards to meeting arena and implementing programs and trying to increase our affordable housing opportunities. It was just, we got a different reviewer And now I got upset and then I was just like, we got to start all over again. What do you mean? I just gave you everything. But we got through it and then we're here. We got our letter and we're able to get the fundings for, I mean, the letter and get the funding going for Well, PHLA, CDBG, there's a couple others. There's quite a bit of that. Okay, thank you. That's helpful. Yeah, you know, a lot of capital improvement projects that engineering is implementing, they were all held up. Oh, wow. When is it going to be approved? When is it going to be approved? So as soon as it got approved, all the money that we need. We have the… ADU accelerated program that's going to be coming for work that helps with increasing opportunities for people to build adus and the state has that program center glazer announced that now we can apply for it because our housing loan was approved. Not many cities have that opportunity so um it was, you know, it is a It is a goal for us to implement the programs, but if you can't get the money, we can't get the grants, we can't do that. But now that we have a certified housing loan, we can really start to do some stuff for the city. Very cool. All right. Definitely appreciates that because this is something that is required and the state's using it as a weapon against cities in a number of regards. I heard a county supervisor share in a recent meeting, there's some pushback With funding being tied to that you're probably going to see an uproar with a number of cities in the coming months and definitely going to the next legislative session. I bring all of that up to say Because we tout RB plus, because we tout we're meeting our goals, always really just want to advocate our position that we don't want to be sacrificed. As a nexus for housing for the rest of the region. So we know there are a number of cities who don't have housing elements that are meeting the standard yet. We know that a number of agencies, even within the county, aren't meeting their arena numbers to the degree that we are And there's a constant conversation about an overhaul of how arena allocations are done. And for me it's as a city, we have to stay on top of that conversation and figure out who our allies are. Because we know that there has to be a reverse in terms of where jobs are located. Especially when you're talking about GHG goals, especially when you're talking about a lot of other goals that seem to be important to California and the region. But when it comes to where the housing is and where job centers are located. It never crosses over to that conversation. So I just want to lift that up as we're talking. I know it's not specific to us getting this approved. And celebrating that, but also once again, the larger context. As we know, we go through these housing elements over an eight-year cycle, and all of a sudden we look up, it's time for the next eight-year cycle. just don't want to keep the Bay Area cramming housing in Pittsburgh and in our area when the rest of the region isn't doing their job. So we talk about creating and furthering affordable housing how was the region actually from a policy perspective, helping to do that? Because they're not doing nothing but driving up our costs and our affordable community. by the policies they're enacted in the rest of the day. So I'll get off the soapbox, but just want to lift that up because every time I see the housing element and kind of the state's goals. it's sometimes in opposition to what we're trying to accomplish. So just lifting that up. Yeah, I'll definitely um Keep that in mind when we look at next steps throughout the process of this next eight years for programming. You know, looking at missing middle housing, looking at first-time homebuyers instead of really, you know, and no knock against affordable housing, but there's other income groups, you know, moderate, high moderate, above moderate i should say you know missing middle housing, first start. We got to look at those too and that's for jobs And we want to make sure that they're included too so and i was kind of things when I was talking with the c4 making sure that we have that kind of assistance in getting a list of people or groups on our groups builders that do that, that really focus on you know missing middle housing you know duplexes triplexes condominium first-time home buyers that can do that stuff so I would definitely keep that in mind. Does it ever look into how much potential money we're losing by trying to earn this money? Like, are we losing $3 to collect $1? I know these dollar amounts that were held up seem big, but to go on your point, you know, like, oh, we got to get the 800,000 or whatever but by not complying, we could have maybe gotten $2 million you know through having different housing stock and being able to track the type of housing that can sustain businesses. I don't know, obviously if that's quantifiable, but I think that mindset because We just… as a local economy, we have a cash flow problem. And I think there's a direct correlation between housing stock and that. But as part of this process, Wolf, I mean, I know there's only so much we can do in the state, but… I think going along with Councilman Collins was saying, unless cities band together and tell the state No, we're not going to play that game. And I think that there are enough cities that would do that. I mean, it goes, what you guys can do as far as either stays on board but it's just it's not going to produce the results we want. There are coalitions out there that are talking in groups in regards to, and actually just as we talk about this, they're going to be doing an audit the housing element reviewers in the hcd over the next six, seven months. So those are some of the things i can I can discuss and kind of bring up. I was actually, you know, kind of kind of asked, hey, you want to, you know, get on that? And I was like. how much time does it take or how much is it going to take for me doing this? But I am going to provide review I am going to provide a feedback in regards to like the audit and say where I think they can improve or what they need to work on in this next cycle so and those kind of thoughts I can you know i can put into words and make sure we're, you know, they're looking at those things too because What's really upsetting is when you work on it and then you get this letter it's 15 pages and you thought you were on a the right path and then you got to go back and start over and redo everything But to your point, maybe, you know, looking at another initiative with some other cities or something like that, we could do that too because someone is just too expensive. Okay. Thank you. I said, oh, this is a larger conversation, a lot more regional in terms of policy, but it would be interesting to know how many of our neighboring jurisdictions have their housing elements approved. um Right now, the 19 cities in Contra Costa County, 16. And there's three that have it. Mona Creek or into Lafayette. Yeah, Randall Lafayette. I'm like, no. Thank you. where Glazer lives, you know, that sponsors Thank you, Maurice. Any other questions or comments on this item? All right, and we'll move to economic development updates. Excellent. Thank you, Sarah. Good evening. everybody i'll be going over item number four the 2024 quarter three economic development updates again quarter three being calendar year so July, August, September. of this year. Starting off first with the So we'll get through this presentation in a moment, but first i want to on the first section of the facade improvement grant program, as you see right there During that timeline, we approved one grant for up to $10,000 to test on food incorporated which is the owner of the IHOP290 Loveridge Road. They will be updating some of their old signage and also improving the landscaping that it's the landscaping strip that faces the intersection of Malden Bridge and East Leland road so They're proposing to do that as a condition of their approval. They have to submit a landscape and approval plan. to the city so I look forward to see what sort of improvements they're proposing in terms of landscaping in that area. And as is mentioned here, we are receiving interest in submittals of applications as well during applications. this during this quarterly period as well. So we'll be sure to have more updates for you on this program. As we go along there. Before I go on to the Next section, any questions or comments? on that item. Go ahead. Let's go ahead. was just going to, we'll loop back to the policy itself for the standards. do we… rank in terms of applications by where there is Location. business. I'm just sharing this because this is IHOP and I'm thinking it's a chain Although I'm not… necessarily opposed to them getting it Would an IHOP get it over maybe a small business in town That's a good question. We haven't encountered that yet. We do have a policy that I believe we have a policy or we would at least shy away from businesses that are owned by large corporations, the IHOP being franchised is independently owned, so we feel a little more comfortable that we're still assisting you know somebody who really could use the assistance and we also want to make sure that we Spread this out a little bit more because we've had a lot of interest downtown and along the railroad. And so being able to touch others. We haven't encountered that yet. Fortunately, the council allocated us enough money that we've been able to kind of fill all of these. And while there's a lot of interest and hopefully it continues to grow We haven't encountered any funding shortfalls. If we start getting lower on money. Which we are, but we also anticipate coming back before you all and giving you an update on the final program, seeing if we want to keep this going. That's definitely something that we can re revisit and see if we want to put a little more parameter around there based on what we've learned. So thank you. Question. How many of these are we giving out? How many grants or how many applications have we received? We currently have approximately $70,000 budgeted for this program, we have This is in this quarter, this is the only one that was received and approved, but this quarter i In fact, yesterday and today we received two additional that are going through review and I've received a couple more that have submitted incomplete applications where I'm going back and forth. So we're not out of money, but we can potentially have like seven if we were to do. If we were to do seven, $10,000 grants, yeah, that would be a limit, but we can also We also have the liberty to award lower grants so that we could We weigh the merits on the application itself and what they're requesting and what we feel like would be the most optimal investment, whether they need a full $10,000 or So that's the ceiling. Yeah, exactly. That's the ceiling okay Thank you. then we have actually the council was fortunate enough we did go before the council and ask for an additional 70 be allocated, but we also had 30 allocated as part of the budget adoption previously that was in Some of our new ID funding. So we actually have a total of $100,000, so we can do up to ten $10,000 grants and how much do, if we awarded the two that came in today would probably be down to, I'm giving you rough estimates here, 20 to 25,000. So we can do two to three more. Right. Yep. Okay. So next section, which pertains to these presentation sites. I'll be talking a little bit about the rose cosmon thoughtful doing business survey so The Claremont and Community College Rose Institute state and local government. They partner with compromise companies. It's a consultant firm that we are And also worked with as well. They conduct a survey that evaluates the cost of doing business in various local jurisdictions across the United States, that's the cost of doing business survey and They just recently conducted a their latest survey back in This year, they evaluated 216 cities across the United States, the vast majority of them are located in Southern California, but there's also jurisdictions located in Northern California, Bay Area. Oregon, Washington, Texas. New Mexico, Nevada. primarily across the Western United States. These are the seven variables that they measure to evaluate whether to see how costly a city is and you know how business friendly it is as well when you look at crime index and housing affordability and And next, each variable is rated on a scale of one to five. by being the most expensive or the worst score. one being the least expensive or the best scoring. So what we did, we staff we Did an analysis using their methodology, following it as closely as we possibly could. to analyze what Pittsburgh's cost of doing business is. And the score that we got for Pittsburgh was a three, three out of five being why i mentioned one being the best, fighting worse we are right smack down in the middle The mean score for all 216 cities was 3.07. So again, we're right in the middle and out of the 216 cities that were surveyed were tied for 103rd place again right there in the middle and when you just look at the California cities. were tied for 74th place. So doing this analysis kind of gives us a sense as to I had kind of a sense as to how You know, business friendly we are as compared to other jurisdictions as you you know we hear a lot about you know our state in different cities not being business friendly as opposed to cities outside there and you know this yeah there may be noted in this city but however we you know we're right there in the middle. So what are the variables that we score best in and what are the ones that we don't know. The best performing variables are utility tax we don't charge the utility tax, average commercial rent, we have some of the lowest rates that within our area. Our crime index and our housing affordability index also did fairly well. The worst performing variables were our business license fees. Sales tax and minimum wage. Now, obviously, sales tax minimum wage those are primarily driven by state policy. So we have little no control over that. Business license fees Before we jump into any conclusion to that, that's something we would like to look you know a little bit more and you know see how we compare you know i mentioned there's 216 city surveyed out of the 216, the only Bay Area cities that are surveyed are San Francisco and San Jose. So it warrants more looking into how the methodology and see kind of what's being calculated because there might be things that we consider business license fees that maybe others don't or something along those lines. So we want to kind of revisit that, suss it out a little bit more because if that's something that's definitely keeping us down if it is true we want to come before you all and we want to talk about what we can potentially do to be more business friendly. Obviously, we don't want to lose revenue, but we want to bring businesses in. We want to make sure that you know the methodology is consistent with what we charge and you know we're not adding things that maybe weren't calculated for other cities. So that concludes. that presentation and um Yeah, any questions or comments? on that along the lines of the business line include fees in that index Is there a way to look at cities that are similar to us? And like two more narrowly look in that way. We can definitely do that. Oh, yeah. Yeah, like I said, there's a couple of cities that have scored that have similar scores to us so we can look at those specific cities and Yeah, we have an interest in also looking at how we compare to other Bay Area cities. As well, if we were to apply like a similar methodology. We're not like a San Francisco or a Silicon Valley and so you know other areas that are similar to us In that way, like we might be doing apples to oranges for ourselves in the way that they're when you look at the methodology And who's included? Exactly. Yeah. Again, the vast majority of the California cities were they're all in Southern California's, you know, the college is located in that area and so on and so forth so yeah i mean it's a good look into our state and Particularly how we compare with how cities all across the state of California. what was the dollar amount used for the minimum wage? It's the state rate, which is 16 per hour right now. Do we know what it would change to when we bump it to 18 for January? that didn't pass. I believe that. Oh, they passed. It did. We can look into that, although… should affect a lot of people. What we wanted to do, and part of the reason we're bringing this before you is because We obviously want to continue to be more and more business friendly. And this is a little bit setting the table for letting you all know that we need to review some of these things. And again, it's a delicate dance because we quite literally cannot afford to lose revenue, but there may be other areas that we need to start marketing a little bit more as to where going beyond those seven indicators we you know made me better. And maybe that's something that we need to start pushing out there a little bit more, especially as we talk about business attraction strategies or other things, or there may be things where we need to and we want to look at whether we should align more with similar cities and maybe even going out to some of these businesses and saying okay what helps attract you, what helps keep you here now The flip side is we could be talking about a very minimal amount. This could be a business that is $500,000 in revenue, and we're talking the difference in $1,000 a year for a business license compared to a similar city and is there really an ROI in looking at that but looking at that Again, 74th out of 177 cities in California is not bad. It's not great We want to be as high as possible. But really, it shows that we're kind of going in the right direction. We're starting to bring things in there. We're in one of the least affordable areas in the entire country. And so the fact that we're sort of maintaining that, I think we're on the right track, but there's definitely things that we want to continue to revisit. And so again, as we go into this next calendar year and the upcoming fiscal year, looking at where there might be some things that we want to adjust. We're getting ready to do a fee study through finance. So additionally, it's questions that we can ask as we go into that as to where we might be misaligned with other areas. I can tell you right now our development fees and a lot of our impact fees, with the exception of some of our traffic mitigation. are probably on the lower side. If you go to get a used permit in Venetia, you're going to pay about three times as much as you pay here in the city of Pittsburgh. So, you know, there's a lot of cost savings there. And so we want to balance it. But again, it comes back to where are we marketing and where are we putting our dollars. And what do we want to live with in order to keep attracting businesses? Very helpful. Other thoughts, questions about this? I think you guys shared another, I don't know if it was a survey within the past year of something that was measuring different things as far as business friendly and I'm just bringing that up. So are there other variables that you all have noticed that may not have been included in this survey That also can be utilized, I know, in terms of the time that it takes, you know, to process permitting and licenses I know folks are looking at, you know, in terms of the workforce and things like that that are in an area I don't know if this was specific to any specific industries and if they broke it down from that perspective as well That's the only thing that's crossed my mind as far as other variables that we may be looking at in terms of business friendly or business climate. Yeah, no, those are all those are all very relevant variables that would demonstrate that we are business friendly we We kept it strictly within the methodology else and this that was in this survey so that we can have something comparable. But yeah, we do have We do have relevant, but there are certainly relevant points in that you know having you know deficiencies in our permitting process permit processing good workforce balance good educational opportunities those all factor in as well yeah vice mayor i think you're referring to the RGS study that was done several months ago that was a consultant that worked with Robert and got some input there and that definitely showed that we were scoring a little bit better. I think one of the things that we can do is we can sort of take these two surveys and sort of line them up and see what the differences are. And to your point, where we're doing better. And again, that's what we should be marketing. We should be marketing, you know. where we're good. I like this. tentatively proud of this because I think that it shows that we're going in a pretty good direction, especially compared to a lot of the cities in California. It's potentially a little bit dubious because there might be some So there's a lot of things that aren't accounted for that you just brought up. But again, learning where we can do better, learning where we need to improve because if nothing else, this is a survey that's going to get traction. And if these surveys, and we weren't on the actual survey, we just compared ourselves to the survey, but when these surveys are done, we want to make sure that we're scoring high because these are the things folks are going to potentially look at when they're looking at what are the best cities to do business in? And so we want to make sure goes back to marketing. We're going to make sure that we're scoring high and we're marketing Pittsburgh and we're getting you know the appropriate grades without giving too much, but we're getting the appropriate grades to start attracting people in here yeah you know that's smart Do we have ever a mystery shop other cities? as far as like as far as sending somebody in to get so like we do on the property manager side, you call up the other property managers, pretend like you're an owner when services get like their rates, their fees and all that Because then we could put something together that says hey specifically calling out the other cities in the area and showing how we're net positive for bringing a business here I mean, it should all be public record. We should be able to pull up anybody's fees and basically come up. But that's a great idea to do a comparison. No, but I mean, there's public record and then there's like the real amount you have to write the check for in there. often not the same as what's on the website, you know, but looking at more just fees, but like timeframe experience of doing that. And so then we can just outright say, okay, you look at Antioch, Brentwood, Oakley, Concord, Walnut Creek. this is where we compare and this is why you should pick us and just straight call them out. add to my list of VID tasks for fiscal year 26. Yeah. I mean… Because it's a very effective marketing strategy that a lot of different industries will use will say hey you know, you go online, you'll see why you should use our software versus the other guys, that comparison thing i think We do the same thing. They start blasting it out there about why Pittsburgh because they are average wait time for business license is three days, Concord is a week or you know whatever like all those different things I think could potentially help. Yeah, put that. That's a great point. Thank you, Chris. St. Pittsburgh. I met a consultant the other day on the phone that said my pen literally says. I thought so. It was actually Congressman Garamendi's office, but he was thinking Pittsburgh. Yeah. Any final thoughts on this before we move on to the next item? All right, we'll try to move quick measure so we don't keep you too long. Go ahead. Yeah, absolutely. So the next section on here is the Pittsburgh real estate market snapshot just showing the latest quarterly numbers. And in terms of how Pittsburgh's doing in the retail, industrial, and office market, and how we compare to you know to the east county and to the east East Bay. Again, going back to the earlier point about affordability, you know, an area that's relatively affordable our in all three markets, our rates are still some of the most affordable, not just in East County, but in the East Bay. as is evidenced here. We are seeing shifts in vacancy rates. Otherwise, they're pretty much our rates are pretty much on par with what we're seeing in the rest of the county and with the exception of our office market rate which is We have a very small office office market. To begin with but Those figures are there for your consideration to help you kind of gauge are where our commercial market is currently at. Before I go any further, any questions or comments on that? Okay. Next section, the Pittsburgh chamber of Commerce Communications Proposal. This is an attachment to this memo, so we received the the chambers communication newsletter and social media father thank you wolfgang, for submitting this proposal to us. We have it here for you guys was to read and free consideration for your comments. At this time, we're not staff's not ready to make a recommendation on this. We still we we still want to evaluate our options in terms of how we how we want to proceed with a communications and outreach proposal specifically with economic development specifically business attraction we want to make sure that we're doing We're going with the correct route and correct method in terms of who we want and how specific we want to target, who we want to what kind of content we want to generate. And these are conversations we want to further with you all and with um with stakeholders as well so but nevertheless this chamber quote that is here and it's being considered and We welcome your feedback on the chamber's proposal in terms of you know what your thoughts are, whether it's something that you're people can do in terms of communications or if there's something a little bit different you'd like to see. So I'll leave it at that. We've had conversations with the city manager and with maria And I think there's an appetite and a need to look at the city-wide communication and we don't want to be cowboys going out there and just doing something completely different. So I think our goal here is to wrap this in and obviously we want to have specific. economic development and business recruitment, outreach, and marketing But we're going through branding and marketing strategy right now which should loads up in the spring. There's been, I know, communication about just in general how community outreach is going to be efficient potentially consolidated in certain ways. And so we just want to make sure that we're wrapping this into that strategy and we get that feedback in it. So yeah, we're hitting pause a little bit. As Robert mentioned, though, we wanted to make sure we got this to you. If there's anything specific that stood out to you. that maybe you like, if you want a little more clarity on, we're fortunate enough to have Wolfgang here. Again, you know, this is definitely something that's going to be considered as we move forward with this more comprehensive strategy for the city. But I wanted to get this before you earlier so we can get any feedback you might have. We're not looking to make a decision on this tonight, but just potentially feedback on the scope and the ideas that are contained in that. Definitely appreciative of that. the work that went into it. I think it definitely gives us some some meat in terms of the direction we want to go, I know the springboards off of the whole East Bay 100 conversation. And so I think it definitely gives us some more focus about who we're trying to target to your point. Jordan about You know, targeting business, attraction, things like that and Overall, I think there's a lot of great points that are in here. I even appreciate the whole risk mitigation aspect of it to really just get us to think through it a little bit more in terms of where some pain points might be at. You know, even when we first started East Bay 100, you know, the conversation about Discover Pittsburgh was there. And I still like that concept. You know, when I look at East Bay 100, you know, obviously. there's a platform there in terms of the website. The pain point is that we didn't have ownership over the the subscribers and the list and the data points. And that was something that we really want to get to and i thought this proposal is really trying to do as far as build up our own database and really be able to gauge in terms of what our messaging is. I really like in terms of the messaging ideas that are here. Once again, I think that we were trying to figure out this balance Between, you know, what we're always hearing in the community, which goes to our outreach subcommittee or outreach plan that we may revisit as it relates to folks, I don't know about the events. I don't know about things that are going on. And then, of course, bifurcating that from, okay, we're trying to target folks that can come here and open up a new business and try. So there is, I think, those two They can be separate goals, but I think overall it's the messaging that we have to get right. In terms of what we're going to do in this next plan. But I think this just gives us some good concepts. Like I said, I don't want to you know um dissected in its entirety right now. I think there's a lot of good stuff that we can glean from and even potentially include, as you shared, as we're looking at our overall outreach efforts. And then what we're doing with here. Because one thing that I did see when you brought up the branding, it's like, okay, how does this all fit together? If we go out here and whether it's Discover Pittsburgh, think Pittsburgh, a focus on economic development, overall outreach, just want to be consistent, but I love the the tailoring of the messaging, identifying who we're going a

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Community and Economic Development Subcommittee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 540eaffe800728144e3b389481ec88eb. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record