POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

May 17, 2022 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, May 17, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

May 17, 2022 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 133,525 stored characters

>> WE ARE RECONVENING OR WE ARE CONVENING AFTER OUR CLOSED SESSION, WHICH WE HAD NO REPORTABLE ACTION AND WE ARE CONVENING OUR REGULAR SESSION OF THE REDDING CITY COUNCIL FOR MAY 17, 2022. IF ANYONE WISHING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL ON ANY ITEM CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING BEFORE OR DURING COUNCIL CONSIDERATION OF THE ITEM PLEASE FILL OUT A SPEAKER REQUEST FORM IN THE BACK OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS AND SUBMIT TO THE CITY CLERK. THE CITY COUNCIL WILL ALLOCATE UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 3 MINUTES PER SPEAKER FOR EACH ITEM. STAFF REPORTS ARE AVAILABLE AT THE CITY WEBSITE AT CITY OF REDDING.ORG OR PUBLIC VIEW BINDER ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE CHAMBERS. THE FIRST ITEM IS THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND THEN AFTER THAT IF YOU CAN REMAIN STAND ING FOR THE INVOCATION WHICH WILL BE MY MEGAN OWENS BY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TO THE REPUBLIC, FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION, UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> GOOD EVENING. MAY WE BE IN A ATTITUDE OF PRAYER AND OPENNESS. MAY THE DEVINE SPIRIT WHO CALLS US BEYOND THE EYE INTO COMMON GROUND FOR ALL. ENVELOP AND SURROUND IN OUR WORK. MAY WE SEEK THIS COMMON GROUND THROUGH RESPECTFUL COMMUNICATION, SO THAT ALL THINGS MAY TRANSPIRE FOR THE WELLBEING OF OUR ENTIRE COMMUNITY AND WE SAY MAY IT BE SO, MAY IT BE SO, AMEN. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT ITEM IS ROLL CALL. [ROLL CALL]. >> TONIGHT 2A PRESENTATION OF 2021 CITIZEN AWARDS TO MICHAEL KNOWLES AND KEITH DEVINE BY THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT. >> GOOD EVENING HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL. IT IS MY HONOR TO PRESENT TWO SIT ZEN AWARDS TO TWO MEMBERS WHO STEPPED UP TO PLATE TO HELP OUT OUR STAFF AND FELLOW CITIZENS IN TIME OF NEED AT GREAT RISK TO THEMSELVES. WE NORMALLY TRY TO DO THIS ON A ANNUAL BASIS. COVID HAS PLAYED A PART IN THAT SO GLAD TO GET BACK TO DOING THESE. THESE AWARDS ARE NOMINATED BY OUR STAFF SO OFFICER IN THE FIELD ENCOUNTER INCIDENT WHERE A CITIZEN STEPS UP AND PROVIDE A NOMINATION FORM THAT GO TUESDAY THE MERITORIOUS CONDUCT BOARD WHICH IS RUN BY LIEUTENANT DANNY SMETECK WE HAVE A GROUP OF OFFICERS AND OTHERS THAT REVIEW THE REWARDS, MAKE DETERMINATION AND THEY COME TO ME AND WE APPROVE AND GIVE THE AWARDS OUT AS WELL AS AWARDS TO OFFICERS SO IT GOES THROUGH A LENGTHY PROCESS OF THE INCIDENT, SO THESE ARE SIGNIFICANT AND EXCITED TO RECOGNIZE THESE FOLKS. THE FIRST WE WILL RECOGNIZE IS MICHAEL KNOWLES, IS HE HERE? COME ON UP, MICHAEL. WHILE YOU ARE COMING I'LL READ THIS NOVEMBER 10, 2021 AT 1058 P.M. A SEDAN WAS NORTHBOUND INTERSTATE 5. THE DRIVE TOOK A EXIT AND CONTINUED DRIVING ON A OVER PASS THAT SPANS OVER HILL TOP DRIVE. LEFT THE ROADWAY WHILE IN THE OVERPASS AND FELL ON TO HILL TOP DRIVE WHERE IT CAME TO REST. OFFICER CAME UPON THE UNRECOGNIZABLE CAR ON FIRE. OFFICERS WERE UNABLE TO REMOVE THE DRIVER FROM THE EXTENSIVELY DAMAGED VEHICLE. MR. KNOWLES HAPPENED TO BE DRIVING PAST THE LOCATION IN THE TOW TRUCK. KNOWLES QUICKLY JUMPED OUT AND ASSISTED OFFICERS ATTEMPTING TO REMOVE THE DRIVE DOOR WITH TOW TRUCK BOOM. THE CAR SO WAS BADLY DAMAGED THE BOOM SLICED THROUGH THE DOOR FRAME. THE OFFICER CONTINUE TO ATTEMPT TO PULL THE DRIVER FROM (INAUDIBLE) THE OFFICERS ALSO EXHAUSTED FIRE EXTINGUISHERS AND UNABLE TO PUT THE VEHICLE TEMPORARILY HELD THE FIRE IT MADE TILL THE HEROES, THE FIRE DEPARTMENT SHOWED UP. THE OFFICERS MICHAEL KNOWLES TRY TO RESCUE THE DRIVER UNTIL THE FIRE WAS SO INTENSE THE DRIVER SUCCUMB TO THE FLAMES. FOR UNSELFISHNESS MICHAEL KNOWLES IS PRESENTED THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT CITIZEN AWARD. [APPLAUSE] KEITH DEVINE IS OUR NEXT ONE. IS KEITH HERE? COME ON UP, KEITH. ON NOVEMBER 20, 2021 TWO PATROL OFFICERS CONTRACTING A SUSPECTS SUBJECT OBSTRUCTING TRAFFIC ON EAST BOUND HIGHWAY 44. THE MALE WAS AGITATED HAD VIOLENT (INAUDIBLE) MAKING SUE SIDLE STATEMENTS. THE ATTEMPTS TO DE-ESCALATE AND CALM THE SUSPECT WERE NOT SUCCESSFUL. HE JUMPED IN FRONT OF ONCOMING VEHICLES NEARLY CAUSES COLLISIONS. BOTH PURSUES THE SUSPECT ON FOOT AND TAKEN INTO CUSTODY AFTER A SIGNIFICANT STRUGGLE OF UTILIZATION OF LESS LETHAL TOOLS. MR. DIVINE OCCURRED THE EVENT. RECOGNIZED THE DANGEROUS TO OFFICERS EXPOSED TO TRAFFIC WHILE THEY STRUGGLE TO GAIN CONTROL. ANGLED VEHICLE ACROSS TRAFFIC. HE EXTS VEHICLE EXPOSES TO DANGER. ONCE THE MALE WAS ATTAINED MR. DIVINE CONTINUED TO DIRECT TRAFFIC WHICH ALLOWS OFFICERS TIME TO (INAUDIBLE) COLLECT EVIDENCE. MR. DIVINE SELF-LESS (INAUDIBLE) HELPED PROTECT THE LIVES OF FELLOW COMMUNITY MEMBERS INVOLVED OFFICERS AND SUBJECT IN DISTRESS. THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT IS HONORING MR. DIVINE FOR UNSELFISH DEVOTION TO THE COMMUNITY WITH THE CITIZEN AWARD. [APPLAUSE] >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> MAYOR IF I MAY. TO THE TWO GENTLEMAN THANK YOU SO MUCH. AS A FORMER MEMBER OF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT COMMUNITY, MR. DIVINE IS NO SECRET YOU SAVED LIVES. THE TWO OFFICERS ARE HERE BECAUSE OF YOU AND SIR STOPPING WITH YOUR TOW TRUCK AND DOING WHAT YOU DID T IS A TOUCH SITUATION BUT YOU PULLED THROUGH IT AND I THANK YOU FOR THAT. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT ITEM IS PUBLIC COMMENT. FOR NON AGENDIZED MATTERS WITHIN THE CITY JURISDICTION. PURSUANT TO BROWN ACT CITY COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION ON PUBLIC COMMENT ITEMS. THE CITY COUNCIL TIME. OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS ALEX BOLECKI. MR. BOLECKI, YOU ARE SIGNED UP FOR PUBLIC COMMENT. >> GOOD EVENING LADIES AND GENTLEMEN. I'M HERE FOR A SPECIAL REASON TODAY. IT SEEMS THAT OUR COUNTY DOESN'T REALLY WANT TO FOLLOW THE LAW. IF THERE ISN'T VIOLENCE, THEY WONT FOLLOW THE LAW. THEY'LL MAKE SOME TYPE OF EXCUSE. POLITICAL PEOPLE IN THE COUNTY HAD BEEN USING THEIR POSITIONS IMPROPERLY. ANYTHING AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL UP HERE IN THIS COUNTY IS A JOKE. I'M CALLING YOU TO MAKE YOUR VOTES COUNT. WHEN IT COMES DOWN TO COUNTY, THERE IS A PERSON NAMED LES BOG AN ASSEMBLYMAN. HE DECIDES THAT THE SPEAKERS ARE SUPPOSED TO SPEAK DOWN THERE. ONLY SPEAKING TO THE PULPIT, OR WHAT WOULD YOU SAY-? LIKE SUPERVISORS. THEY ARE JUST THE SAME. BUT LES BOG IS USING IT AS IF HE'S GOD. IT IS AGAINST THE RULES. WHEN I COME TO SPEAK, I SPEAK TO THESE GENTLEMAN AND LADIES AND MOST IMPORTANTLY, I SPEAK TO THE INTELLIGENCE OF THE COMMUNITY, WHICH IS YOU. WHEN THEY DECIDE THAT YOU GUYS NEED TO LOOK AT MY BACK SIDE INSTEAD OF THE WORDS I USE, THAT'S NOT COOL. WE GOT PRISON PROBLEMS. WE GOT WATER PROBLEMS. AND EVERYTHING IS GOING AWRY. ALL AT ONCE. IT IS SPECIFICALLY BEING DONE THAT WAY IN THIS STATE. THE GOVERNMENT AS IN THE GOVERNOR HE'S PRACTICALLY BURNED DOWN NOR CAL. HOW MANY CITIES WENT? REMEMBER THE CAR FIRE? MORE IMPORTANTLY, WHAT ARE WE DOING WITH THE HOMELESS? YOU KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING IN THE RIVER ON THE SIDE? WE DON'T SET SOMETHING LIKE A LITTLE TOILET THING WHERE THEY CAN GO. SO, IT IS GOING DIRECTLY INTO THE WATER. I PERSONALLY KNOW A DIFFERENCE IN MY WATER, AND WELL, THE GOVERNOR JUST SAID THAT NUMBER ONE UP HERE IN REDDING HAS REALLY GOODWATER AND THEY DID A FANTASTIC THING. THAT'S A LIE. I'M ASKING YOU GUYS TO VOTE AND FOR ANYBODY TO BE POSITIONED OR GIVEN A POSITION WITHOUT A VOTE LIKE YOU'RE GIVEN IT, I THINK THAT IS WRONG BECAUSE WE GOT A LOT OF CORRUPT INDIVIDUALS IN THE COUNTY I HATE TO SAY IT. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER FIRST NAME IS LEGO. >> HI, I'M LEGO. IT'S ILLEGAL TO USE A LEGAL NAME. FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS HERE. YOU NEED A BAR CARD TO PRACTICE LEGAL? SO IF YOU DON'T HAVE A BAR CARD YOU CAN'T PRACTICE LEGAL. YOU ARE BREAKING ALL 10 COMMANDMENTS IN ONE GO WITH THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE. BIRTH CERTIFICATE IS PREMEDITATED CHILD SLAVERY. OKAY? KING JAMES VERSION CHAPTER 5 VERSE 6-21. I AM THE LORD GOD WHICH BROUGHT (INAUDIBLE) OUT OF HOUSE OF BONDAGE. THAT IS BIRTH CERTIFICATE. THAT IS THE CRYPT. THOU SHALL HAVE NO OTHER GODS BEFORE ME. THE LEGAL NAME IS A GOD. A FLAG IS IS A GOD. IT ISN'T TRUTH. IT ACTUALLY STANDS FOR FLAGELLATION. IT IS WHEN THEY WHIP SOMEONE TO DEATH. BUT THERE IS NO JUSTICE BECAUSE IF YOU ARE ALREADY DEAD HOW CAN YOU BE KILLED AGAIN? THOU SHALL NOT MAKE IMAGE OR LIKENESS ON ANYTHING IN HEAVEN ABOVE OR IN THE EARTH BENEATH OR THE WATER BENEATH THE EARTH SO THAT STANDS FOR THE MONEY. RIGHT? MONEY IS PRINTED. IT HAS PICTURES ON IT. RIGHT? BUT YOU CAN'T TOUCH MONEY WITHOUT A BAR CARD BECAUSE IT IS A LEGAL DOCUMENT. YOU NEED A BAR CARD FOR THE BRITISH ACCREDITATION REGISTRATION. A VATICAN CORPORATION. THOU SHALL NOT BOW DOWN NOR SERVE THEM. THAT MEANS YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO WORK. COMMERCE. COMMERCE IS COMMERCIAL SLAVERY SO THE MONEY IS JUST YOU'RE-NOT ALLOWED TO VOTE. ALL VOTING IS FRAUD SO THEY TRICK YOU INTO IT SO THAT THEY CAN TAKE YOUR TAX MONEY SO THE CORPORATION CAN THEN-YOU ARE CULPABLE FOR THE CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY. YOU NEED WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE CROWN CORPORATION. IF YOU DON'T HAVE THAT YOU ARE COMMITTING LEGAL NAME FRAUD. ANYONE TRYING TO AID AND ABET TO COMMIT LEGAL NAME FRAUD IS UNLAWFUL. VERY SERIOUS CRIME. BREAKING ALL 10 COMMANDMENTS VIA THE ORIGINAL SIN WHICH IS BIRTH CERTIFICATE FRAUD. PREMEDITATED CHILD SLAVERY. DID YOU KNOW THAT? THAT YOU'RE SAYING YOU ARE ALLOWING THE CHILD TO BE MARKED AS DEAD. THE LEGAL NAME IS THE (INAUDIBLE) OF THE SHIP. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS SPEAKER DAVE BAKER. >> THANK YOU CITY COUNCIL FOR YOUR TIME TONIGHT. I APPRECIATE IT AND TO MY MANY FRIENDS I KNOW MANY YEARS I OWN THE COFFEE SHOP IN THE CITY HALL ABOUT 18 AND A HALF YEARS. THE REASON I'M HERE BECAUSE OF A INCIDENT DAY BEFORE THANKS GIVING. MANY YEARS BECOMING A FOLLOWER OF JESUS CHRIST (INAUDIBLE) PLANNED PARENTHOOD ABORTION MILL SO EXERCISED MY FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO BEG MOMS NOT TO KILL CHILDREN AND SHARE THE GOSPEL OF JESUS CHRIST. I FEEL THIS IS THE MOST LOVING THING I CAN DO. THIS DAY WAS DIFFERENT ACCEPT WAS NO DIFFERENT ACCEPT A BUNCH OF LOCAL NEIGHBORHOOD KIDS CAME DOWN AFTER ARRIVAL AND RIDE THE SCOOTERS UP AND DOWN THE HILL. TWO WORKERS CAME OUT AND WALKED LIKE MONITORS ON A PLAYGROUND WHISPERING SOMETHING TO THE OLDEST GIRLS. I ARGUE ONE OF THE MOST DANGEROUS PLACES IS THE PARKING LOT. I THINK NEIGHBORHOOD PARENTS WHO HATE ME BEING OUT THERE AND WORKERS GOT TOGETHER TO HAVE WHICH CHILDREN COME OVER AND CALL THE POLICE. THE POLICE SHOWED UP WHICH IS NOTHING NEW THEY TELL I HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE OUT THERE. TODAY WAS DIFFERENT THE OFFICER BERATED SAYING YOU SHOULDN'T SAY THIS SICK CRAP AND THOUGHT IT WAS FASCINATING BECAUSE AS SOON AS HE PULLED UP (INAUDIBLE) FIGURE WHAT I HAD DONE WRONG. HE WOULDN'T TELL ME AND AS LEAVING YELLED OUT A PENAL CODE NUMBER AND SAID LOOK IT UP AND OBSERVED ME TILL I LEFT. A WEEK LATER CHIEF SHULLER CAME OVER. HE TOLL ME AN E-MAIL HAD COME UP WITH THE RANKS UNTIL IT REACHED HIM. HE SAID I WAS ASKING THE CHILDREN IF THEY WANTED TO BE CUT INTO PIECES WHICH IS HORRIBLE LIE. HE TOLD ME NEXT TIME I RUN THE COFFEE SHOP. I WASN'T SURE WHY HE WANTED ME TO MENTION THAT. OVER TIME I BEGAN TO WONDER WHAT LIES WERE SPREAD ABOUT HE IN THE E-MAILS. THE CHIEF WAS A REGULAR CUSTOMER AND ASKED IF I CAN SEE THE E-MAIL. HE SAID MAYBE IF YOU GIVE ME THE CAMERA. HE SAID HE WOULD GET BACK AND TURNED AND WALKED AWAY AND NEVER HEARD FROM HIM AGAIN. OVER THE NEXT SEVERAL WEEKS POLICE OFFICERS QUIT ALL MOST ALL. I HAD BEEN SEVERELY IMPACTED WITH COVID LOCKDOWN BUT THIS FINISHED ALL MOST TWO DECADES BEING IN CITY HALL. I ASKED IF I CAN SEE THE E-MAIL AND TOLD EVERY TIME EVEN THOUGH THE E-MAIL EFFECTS NOBODY BUT ME. I WISH THE OFFICER WOULD HAVE CHARGED ME WITH SOMETHING THAT WAY THIS IS PUBLIC. HE WAS SNEAKY AND HAVE NO CHANCE TO CLEAR MY NAME TO THE OFFICERS BUT I HAVE MENTIONED HIS NAME NOT TRYING TO SEEK RETRIBUTION AND SENT AN E-MAIL TELLING HIM I FORGIVE HIM. MY PLEA IS YOU USE YOUR POSITION AS CHIEF SHULLER'S BOSS TO RELEASE THE E-MAIL. IT DOESN'T SEEM (INAUDIBLE) IT SEEMS A TOTAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND I KNOW THE COUNCIL MEMBERS ARE UNBIASED AND TRUST YOU WILL DO THE RIGHT THING SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. >> THANK YOU. >> APPRECIATE YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS NICK GARDENER FALLOWED BY SUSAN MURRAY. >> I'M HERE FOR CONCERNS ABOUT THE HENDERSON OPEN SPACE. CALLED NEW PALM NOW. I THINK IT SHOULD BE CALLED NAY PALM WITH ALL THE FIRES STARTED DOWN THERE. I'M TOLD DIGNITY HEALTH DONATED TO FENCE IT OFF AND HOPEFULLY THAT WILL ALLEVIATE THE UNLAWFUL CAMPERS DOWN THERE. WHAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IS 6 ACRES OWNED BY THE TOM BEMAN THATCHER COMPANY TRUST. THAT PROPERTY STARTS BEHIND THE HOMES ON HENDERSON ROAD AND GOES PROBABLY 150 YARDS TILL IT HITS THE HENDERSON OPEN SPOT. I THINK THAT YOU SHOULD GO AHEAD AND FENCE TOM BEMAN'S TRUST PROPERTY THE 6 ACRES BECAUSE IF YOU JUST FENCE IN THE HENDERSON OPEN SPOT THEY ARE JUST GOING TO MOVE OVER THERE AND MAKE THEIR MESS OVER THERE. IT WOULD PROBABLY COST ABOUT 200 FEET OF EXTRA FENCING, BUT I THINK THAT AS A COMMUNITY THAT'S SOMETHING YOU SHOULD CONSIDER INSTEAD OF PUSHING YOUR PROBLEMS OFF ON A PRIVATE LAND OWNER. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS SUSAN MURRAY. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR LETTING ME SPEAK TONIGHT. I WASN'T GOING TO GO AHEAD AND I WAS GOING TO LISTEN TONIGHT AND WASN'T GOING TO SPEAK, BUT MY COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS ARE MORE CURIOSITY THEN ANYTHING. TONIGHT I WAS LISTENING TO CHANNEL 12 NEWS AT 4 O'CLOCK AND THEY REPORTED THAT THE NEW PARKING LOT STRUCTURE THAT IS CLOSED THAT IS IN REDDING IS CLOSED TEMPORARILY BECAUSE OF CONCERNS OF TRASH AND SECURITY REASONS. I DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS BUT BELIEVE THEY WERE GOING TO INSTALL SECURITY MEASURES AND ALSO HIRE A MANAGER FOR THE PARKING STRUCTURE. I WOULD THINK THAT THE INTERVIEW WITH THE GENTLEMAN FROM K2 NEWS STATION THAT I DIDN'T CATCH HIS NAME, WAS KIND OF THE INFORMATION HE WAS PUTTING OUT THERE SEEMED LIKE HE WAS SURPRISED AT THE TRASH AND THAT WAS LEFT THERE. I WOULD THINK THAT--BECAUSE OF THE SECURITY PROBLEMS AND TRASH PROBLEMS SHOULDN'T BE A SURPRISE TO ANYONE LET ALONE TO THE PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP OF K2 AND MCCONNELL. I HOPE THE NEED FOR SECURITY AND PAYING A MANAGER TO SUPERVISE THAT BECAUSE A CAR GROUP WAS THERE AT THE GARAGE EVIDENTLY HAVING SOME KIND OF MEETING OR WHATEVER IT WAS. I DIDN'T GET ALL THE INFORMATION. I HOPE THAT THAT SECURITY AND THE PAYING THE MANAGER IS GOING-HAVE TO BE PAID BY THE CITY OF REDDING. I DON'T KNOW ALL THE INFORMATION AS TO WHAT CITY OF REDDING WOULD HAVE TO DO, BUT IT IS NOT A SURPRISE THAT IT WOULD BE-THERE WOULD BE TRASH THERE OR SOME VAGRANTS THERE IN THE PARKING GARAGE AND THEREFORE NEED SOMEBODY TO GO AHEAD AND MANAGE IT OR CHECK ON IT SORE HAVE SECURITY CAMERAS BUT I HOPE THE CITY OF REDDING ISN'T GOING TO HAVE TO-FOOT THAT BILL. BEING A PRIVATE STRUCTURE I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT WORKS OUT. NOT KNOWLEDGEABLE ABOUT THAT BUT THAT WAS MY INFORMATION SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. APPRECIATE IT. >> THANK YOU. ALRIGHT. WE ARE MOVING ON TO OUR NEXT ITEM, WHICH IS THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE CONSENT CALENDAR CONTAINS EXTENDED DISCUSSION OR DELIBERATION. SO, DO WE HAVE ANY ITEMS-WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER WHO WANTS TO SPEAK ON 411A. ARE THERE ANY COUNCIL MEMBERS COMMENTS, QUESTIONS? >> (INAUDIBLE) >> YEAH. LET'S DO THAT. WE'LL HAVE THE SPEAKER KEITH STUART SPEAK FIRST. THEN WE'LL TAKE CITY COUNCIL COMMENTS. >> HELLO COUNCIL. THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME TO HEAR MY SIDE OF THINGS. I'M KEITH STUART PRESIDENT OF STUART ENGINEERING. WE HAVE BEEN PERFORMING PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACTS SINCE 1994. HAVE HAD SEVERAL PAST CONTRACTS WITH THE CITY OF REDDING SUCCESSFUL AND IN THAT 28 YEARS I DON'T THINK YOU HAVE EVER SEEN ME STANDING UP PROTESTING THE AWARD OF A CONTRACT. IT ISN'T SOMETHING WE DO, WE ARE NOT CONTENTIOUS BUT WHEN I BELIEVE SOMETHING IS THE INTEGRITY OF THE PROCESS IS INCORRECT I DO HAVE TO SPEAK UP. IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE THE CITY STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT COUNCIL AWARD TO THE SECOND LOWEST BIDDER. IT IS PRIMARILY BASED ON THE FINDING STUART ENGINEERING DID NOT MAKE A RESPONSIVE BID BASED ON GOOD FAITH EFFORTS SUPPORT DOCUMENTS. FEDERALLY FUNDED PROJECT IS A REQUIREMENT OR FEDERAL FUNDING IS A PART OF THIS PROJECT SO IT DOES REQUIRE THE CITY ESTABLISH A GOAL THAT THEY SET AT 19 PERCENT FOR DISADVANTAGE BUSINESS ENTERPRISE. CONTRACTOR BIDDING ON THE PROJECT ARE OBLIGATED TO MEET THE GOAL OR WITH GOOD FAITH EFFORT SHOW THEY DID REACH OUT TO DISADVANTAGE BUSINESS ENTERPRISES IN THE ATTEMPT TO REACH THE GOAL. THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT IS DEFINED VERY LOOSELY IN CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS TITLE 49, IT IS GUIDELINE BUT IT IS FULL OF SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA. THIS IS THE RESULT OF THAT GOOD FAITH EFFORT. THE REVIEW OF THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT AND THE BACK AND FORTH OF IT. IT IS NOT A EASY PROCESS TO GO THROUGH AND I APPRECIATE STAFF'S EFFORTS TRYING TO DO THEIR PART OF THAT, BUT WE STILL BELIEVE THAT THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT IS SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA AND THE CITY MADE AN INITIAL REVIEW OF THAT CRITERIA AND FOUND STUART ENGINEER'S BID THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT WAS RESPONSIVE. STUART ENGINEERING DID MAKE A GOOD FAITH EFFORT. WE RELY VERY HEAVILY ON THE STANDARD THE CITY HAS SHOWN US IN THE PAST. THE CITY IS STATING THEY HAVE NEW GUIDELINES THAT WERE NOT KNOWN TO STUART ENGINEERING AT THE TIME OF BID OR BEFORE BID. THAT INFORMATION SHOULD HAVE BEEN DISCLOSED WITHIN THE BID DOCUMENTS. IT WAS NOT. THIS IS NEWS TO INDUSTRY. IT IS NEWS TO ASSOCIATE GENERAL CONTRACTOR OF CALIFORNIA, IT IS NEWS TO PUBLIC WORKS SHASTA COUNTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS. THIS IS NOT WELL KNOWN INFORMATION AND IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A PART OF THE BID DOCUMENTS. IT DID MAKE A MATERIAL DIFFERENCE. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. GIVEN THAT THOSE COMMENTS, WOULD MR. AUCKLAND OR PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR PLEASE COME TO THE PODIUM? WE APPRECIATE-I WILL JUST BEFORE-SORRY, BEFORE YOU TALK. ONE MEMBER OF THE COUNCIL I'LL SPEAK FOR MYSELF, I THINK WE TAKE PRIDE IN THE FACT THAT EVEN AND ESPECIALLY DURING COVID WE DID OUR BEST TO LEVERAGE ALL MONIES AVAILABLE FEDERAL MONEY STATE MONEY AVAILABLE TO ENCOURAGE AND PROMOTE LOCAL CONSTRUCTION JOBS, LOCAL JOBS PERIOD IN OUR COMMUNITY AND I THINK WE HAVE DONE A GOOD JOB AND THINK STAFF HAS DONE A GOOD JOB AND WHAT I'M TROUBLED BY AND CALLING MR. AUCKLAND TO HERE IS THAT I BELIEVE THAT THERE WERE A COUPLE COMMENTS MADE BY THE LAST SPEAKER THAT MIGHT NEED TO BE CLARIFIED AS TO THE ACCURACY OF THE COMMENTS AND I WANT TO LEAVE AN ACCURATE IMPRESSION AFTER WE VOTE ON THIS ITEM. MR. AUCKLAND IF YOU COULD ADDRESS THOSE-THE COMMENTS YOU LIKE TO PRESENT TONIGHT. >> LET ME JUST MAYBE STEP BACK JUST A LITTLE BIT. I WANT TO RECOGNIZE KEITH STUART ENGINEERING, THEY DO A GREAT JOB, GREAT CONTRACTOR WORKED WITH US BEFORE. HE IS CORRECT, THIS IS A VERY SUBJECTIVE PROCESS. SOMETHING THAT WE ARE REQUIRED TO GO THROUGH WITH FEDERAL FUNDING. THERE ARE SOME CRITERIA AND PARAMETERS LAID OUT FOR US IN TERMS HOW WE REVIEW THESE THINGS. THE AMOUNT OF WORK THEY PUT INTO THE EFFORT TO SOLICIT THE BIDS FROM DISADVANTAGE BUSINESSES. THE PROOF THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE TO US ON HOW THEY SOLICIT THOSE. HOW AGGRESSIVE THEY GO. THEY FOLLOW UP. IN THIS PARTICULAR PROCESS HE IS CORRECT, WE DID INITIALLY AGREE THAT THEY MET THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT STANDARD. WE ARE REQUIRED BY CATRANS THE PROGRAM THAT FUNDS THIS PROJECT OR TO ADMINISTER THROUGH CALTRANS BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE THEIR REVIEW OF OUR DOCUMENTATION ANYTHING OVER $2 MILLION BASED ON THE LOCAL ASSISTANCE PROCEDURE MANUAL SO WE HAVE TO PROVIDE THAT TO CATRANS. CATRANS DOES THEIR OWN DETERMINATION EVEN THOUGH WE HAD LOOKED AT IT OURSELVES. THEY CAME BACK AND SAID THEY DID NOT AGREE. THEY FELT THAT THE CONTRACTOR DID NOT PROVIDE OUR DEMONSTRATE A GOOD FAITH EFFORT WITH THE INFORMATION THEY PROVIDED. SO, THERE IS A PROCESS THAT WE GO THROUGH AND WE ARE REQUIRED ONCE THEY MAKE THAT DETERMINATION. WE CAN STILL AWARD TO LOW BIDDER OR RECONSIDER AND WHAT WE DID IS RECONSIDER THAT EVALUATION AND WE AGREED WITH SOME OF THE POINTS THAT CATRANS MADE AND WE ULTIMATELY OUR STAFF DECIDED THAT THEY DID NOT PERFORM THAT GOOD FAITH EFFORT BASED ON A COUPLE REASONS. THEY ARE ENTITLED TO-WE ISSUED THAT TO KEITH STUART ENGINEERING AND THEY ARE ENTITLED TO RECONSIDERATION HEARING SO WE FORM A INDEPENDENT RECONSIDERATION HEARING, FOLKS THAT HADN'T SEEN THE DOCUMENTATION YET TO ALLOW ESSENTIALLY AN APPEAL OF THE PROCESS. WE PROVIDE THE INFORMATION THE INITIAL STAFF REVIEWED THEY ARGUE THEIR CASE AND IN THIS PARTICULAR INSTANCE THE RECERTIFICATION ORE CONSIDERATION APPEAL WAS UPHELD STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION THEY DID NOT MEET THE GOOD FAITH EFFORTS. I DO WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT THERE IS SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA TO THIS. BUT WE FELT WITH THE DOCUMENTATION THAT WAS PROVIDED THROUGH THE RECONSIDERATION WE WENT THROUGH THE PROCESS AND WE ULTIMATELY DECIDED THAT THEY DID NOT MEET THAT GOOD FATE EFFORT. THERE WERE REASONS. HE HAD MENTIONED THE ISSUE OF NOT KNOWING THAT AHEAD OF TIME. WE FEEL STAFF DOES IN OUR INSTRUCTIONS TO BIDDERS WE TALK ABOUT A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT ON DOING THESE GOOD FAITH EFFORTS. PARTICULARLY FORM 9G OF THE PROCEDURE MANUAL THAT TALKS ABOUT IN THERE IT HAS A SECTION THAT TALKS ABOUT ANYTHING OVER $2 MILLION DOES GO TO CATRANS AND SO WE FILTER THE INFORMATION WAS THERE. I AGREE THE STANDARD IS KEEPS GOING UP AND THINGS ARE GETTING MORE AND MORE DIFFICULT AND HE HAS BEEN AWARDED PROJECTS IN THE PAST WITH MAYBE A SIMILAR LEVEL OF EFFORT THAT HAPPENED IN THIS PARTICULAR TIME, BUT WE HAVE GOT TO AND HAVE BEEN AUDITED TWICE NOW BY CALTRANS ON THE DBE PROGRAM AND ONE CASE THEY FELT WE WERE NOT SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH IN THE EVALUATION AND IF THAT CONTINUES TO HAPPEN WE COULD BE SUBJECT TO LOOSING FUNDING AND OTHER RAMIFICATIONS WE DON'T WANT TO PUT THE CITY AT RISK IN THAT CASE SO IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE WE ARE RECOMMENDING THAT THE COUNCIL DOES REJECT THE BID AS NON RESPONSIVE. I DO WANT TO REITERATE A NON RESPONSIVE BID DOES NOT HAVE ANY REFLECTION ON THE CONTRACTOR ABILITY TO PERFORM OR THE QUALITY OF WORK OR EVEN THEIR ULT ABILITY TO BID ON ANOTHER PROJECT. IT SAYS THIS DID NOT MEET THE CRITERIA AND GO TO THE SECOND BIDDER WHO DID MEET THE GOAL. >> VICE MAYOR DEQUISTO HAS A COMMENT. >> SO, WHEN THE APPLICANT OR THE OTHER GENTLEMAN SAID THAT THERE WERE NEW STANDARDS THAT WERE NOT PROVIDED INITIALLY, HOW DO YOU ANSWER THAT? WHEN YOU SUBMIT TO CATRANS DID THEY USE A DIFFERENT STANDARD OF REVIEW IN THE PAST OR SAME STANDARD BECAUSE IF THEY USED A DIFFERENT STANDARD IT WOULD SEEM FAIRNESS DICTATE YOU WOULD INCLUDE THAT IN SOME FASHION IN THE BIDDING DOCUMENT WITH A NOTATION CATRANS MAY LOOK AT IT. >> I THINK HE IS ALLUDING TO IS WE SHOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER DEFINED IN THERE THAT WE SPECIFICALLY ARE GOING TO CONSULT CATRANS WITH ANYTHING-WITH THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT. WHEREAS, WE DID RELY ON OUR SPECIFICATIONS THAT POINT TO A PROCEDURE MANUAL THAT TALK ABOUT THE NEED TO DO SO THAT MAY BE WHERE HE IS COMING FROM IN TERMS OF NEW SO I THINK HE RATHER WE HAD BEEN MORE UP FRONT WITH THAT AND HE FELT HE WOULD HAVE A BETTER DETERMINATION OR PROVIDE BETTER DOCUMENTATION OF THE THINGS THAT HE DID TO SOLICIT THESE BIDS FROM THE OTHER CONTRACTOR. >> ALRIGHT. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER COUNCIL MEMBER HAVE QUESTIONS? OKAY. THANK YOU FOR THAT. AND THEN I THINK COUNCIL MEMBER OR MAYOR PRO TEM MEZZANO HAS A COMMENT ON THE ITEM. >> YES. ON ITEM 4.9A I JUST WANT TO BRING SOME INFORMATION TO YOU. WE ARE TALKING RED LIGHT CAMERAS. YOU ARE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THOSE IN THE CITY. WE HAVE 6 OF THEM AND AFTER A STUDY BY STAFF THEY WERE IDENTIFIED THESE INTERSECTION WERE IDENTIFIED AS BEING THE MOST DANGEROUS IN OUR CITY. IN FACT, LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS HERE IN 2012 MARKET AND SHASTA WE HAD 13 COLLISIONS. IN 2021 WE HAD 2. AT PINE AND TEHOMA BACK IN 2009, 18 COLLISIONS AND STEADILY DECREASED UNTIL 2021 WHERE WE HAD 2. THE PURPOSE OF THE RED LIGHT CAMERAS IS PREVENT COLLISIONS AND SAVE LIVES. THEY ARE EXPENSIVE. $469. I WISH I COULD SAY ALL THE MONEY WENT TO THE CITY BUT IT DOESN'T. $147 AND CHANGE GOES TO THE CITY. $70 TO THE COUNTY AND THE STATE TAKES $250. THE MONEY THAT WE GET IS USED TO PAY THE RETIRED OFFICERS THAT REVIEW THE FILMS AND THEN THEY ARE THE ONES THAT SAY YES THERE IS DIRECT VIOLATION HERE AND THEY SEND IT OFF TO THE COURT AND YOU SPEND YOUR DAY OVER THERE AND WRITE A CHECK. NOW, THE SYSTEM IS NOT HUNDRED PERCENT-SOME OF THE TIME I GUESS YOU SEE THE LIGHT FLASHING. I FOUND OUT THAT MEANS IT IS CALIBRATING ITSELF SO IT WORKS VERY WELL AND I'M GOING TO GIVE THE INSIDE INFORMATION FOR REDDING, YOU CAN SHARE THIS WITH YOUR FRIENDS. CYPRESS (INAUDIBLE) CYPRESS AT CONCERN CREEK, CYPRESS HILL TOP. LAKE BOULEVARD 273 AND MARKET STREET AND SHASTA STREET AND PINE STREET AT TEHOMA. WHEN YOU COME UP TO THE INTERSECTIONS YOU NEED TO BE CAREFUL RUNNING THE RED LIGHT BECAUSE YOU WILL GET A EXPENSIVE TICKET AND NEED TO WATCH BEHIND YOU BECAUSE JUST BECAUSE YOU WILL STOP DOESN'T MEAN THE PERSON BEHIND YOU WILL STOP. ONE THING I WAS IMPRESSED IS WE GOT THE LIGHTS THERE, THE NUMBER OF REAR-END COLLISIONS HAS ALSO GONE DOWN, DIDN'T GO UP WHICH IS WHAT YOU MIGHT EXPECT AND I SUSPECT WE ARE THE BEEN FACTORS IN THE CITY BECAUSE THE DRIVERS IN AND AROUND THE REDDING AREA ARE ACTUALLY PRETTY GOOD AND I THINK THEY TAKE THEIR TIME AND IT IS PROBABLY BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT BUMPER TO BUMPER TRAFFIC ON THE FREEWAY 2 HOURS SO TELL YOUR FRIENDS THE RED LIGHT CAMERAS ARE THERE FOR A PURPOSE, IT IS SAVING LIVES AND WE DON'T GET ALL THE MONEY. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU FOR THE INFORMATION. ALSO, IF ANYBODY IS INTERESTED YOU CAN VIEW THE VIDEOS. I VIEWED THEM MYSELF AND IT IS HORRENDOUS TO SEE A RED LIGHT-SOMEONE GOING THROUGH AN INTERSECTION ON A RED LIGHT AND THE ACCIDENT THAT RESULTED WHEN PEOPLE CHALLENGED WHY WE HAVE THEM AND JUST TO GO VIEW THEM YOU KNOW WHY WE HAVE THEM. >> I MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> SECOND THE MOTION. >> I HAVE A OBSERVATION. WHAT WAS THE NUMBER OF THE GENTLEMAN THAT SPOKE? >> 411A. >> I WILL VOTE NO ON THAT. >> OKAY. WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND AND ACTUALLY HAVE ONE MORE EDUCATIONAL ITEM TO PULL TO MENTION ON CONSENT. ITEM 411B IS RESOLUTION ACCEPTING THE LIST OF PROJECTS FOR FISCAL YEAR 22-23 FUNDED BY SENATE BILL 1 THE ROAD REPAIR AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACT WHICH IS THE GAS TAX THAT WAS APPROVED BY THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ACCEPT OUR COUNTY VOTED AGAINST IT AND THEN VOTED TO REPEAL THAT GAS TAX. AND HAD THE REST OF THE STATE FALLOWED SHASTA COUNTY WE WOULD HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO GENERATE AN ADDITIONAL $9.3 MILLION THAT ARE GOING TO THE CITY OF REDDING AND PAVING OUR ROADS FROM 2017 TO THE CURRENT 22-23 YEARS. JUST WANT TO POINT OUT THAT WE ARE BENEFICIARIES OF THE VOTE FROM THE RES REST OF THE STATE. WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND AND VICE MAYOR DEQUISTO IS VOTING NO ON 411A AND ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> ANY OPPOSED? ACCEPT FOR THAT ONE. OKAY. MOTION CARRIES. THANK YOU. OUR NEXT ITEM IS 9.2A. WHICH IS CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE GOODWATER CROSSING EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE. >> DEPUTY CITY MANAGER STEVE BATE WILL TAKE THIS ONE. >> GOOD EVENING HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF COUNCIL AND COMMUNITY. THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THE GOODWATER CROSSING. IT IS OUR FIRST CITY'S FIRST PROPOSED CITY OF REDDING EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE. GET MY CLICKER TO WORK. GO ANOTHER ROUTE HERE. YOU GOT IT. OKAY. AS BACKGROUND IN JUNE 2021 THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPTED RESOLUTION THAT DECLARED THE CITY OF REDDING HAS A SHELTER CRISIS WHICH PROCLAIMS A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF PEOPLE ARE WITHOUT THE ABILITY TO OBTAIN SHELTER. THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVED TWO ORDINANCES AND ADMINISTRATIVE GUIDELINES FOR THE EMERGENCY HOUSING SITES. THESE SET FORTH THE REQUIREMENTS AND PROCESS FOR CITY STAFF TO REVIEW APPLICATIONS AND ULTIMATELY PREPARE FOR CITY COUNCIL CONSIDERATION. EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE IS A SHORT TERM EMERGENCY TEMPORARY HOUSING SITE FOR NO MORE THEN 30 INDIVIDUALS USING EMERGENCY SLEEPING CABINS. EACH SITE WOULD BE UNDER A 1 YEAR OPERATION TERM. EMERGENCY SLEEPING CABINS ARE DEFINED IN APPENDIX O OF THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING CODE. WE HAVE A SINGLE OCCUPANCY UNIT MINIMUM OF 64 SQUARE FEET AND DOUBLE OCCUPANCY MINIMUM OF HUNDRED SQUARE FEET. EACH HOUSING SITE MUST ADHERE TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE GUIDELINES AND DEVELOP AND POST GOOD NEIGHBOR POLICY. PREMISES AND IMMEDIATE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD. THESE POLICY MUST SHOW HOW THE EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE DISCOURAGES AND ADDRESSES EXCESSIVE NOISE OR LOITER AND THE SITE MUST DEMONSTRATE COORDINATION WITH OTHER SERVICE PROVIDERS AND COMMUNITY PARTNERS. TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS EACH EMERGENCY SITE MUST SUBMIT A OPERATION PLAN THAT CONFORM TO ADMINISTRATION PLAN SUBMIT TO CITY MANAGER FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL AS PART OF THE PERMIT ISSUANCE PROCESS. IN DECEMBER OF 2021 THE CONGREGATION COUNCIL OF SAINT JAMES LUTHERAN CHURCH SUBMITTED STATEMENT OF INTENTION TO PURSUE THE DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT OF A EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE KNOWN AS GOODWATER CROSSING. PURSUANT TO THE GUIDELINES NOTIFICATIONS SENT TO PROPERTY OWNERS WITHIN 600 FEET OF THE PROPOSED SITE. THE SAINT JAMES GROUP SENT THE NOTIFICATION JANUARY AND HELD INFORMATIONAL MEETINGS IN JANUARY AND FEBRUARY. IN ADDITION THEY ALSO SENT A NEIGHBORHOOD NEWS LETTER IN FEBRUARY. IN MAY ACTUALLY MAY 10 CITY STAFF ALSO SENT A NOTIFICATION TO ALL THE SAME SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS. NEXT SLIDE. AS PROPOSED, GOODWATER CROSSING WOULD BE LOCATED THE SOUTHWEST PORTION OF THE SAINT JAMES PROPERTY AT 2500 SHASTA VIEW DRIVE. THE EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE COULD CONTAIN UP TO 12 TEMPORARY SLEEPING CABINS, BUT THE INITIAL APPROVAL IS FOR 4 EMERGENCY SLEEPING CABINS AND THE ASSOCIATED COMMON STRUCTURES. THE DISPLAYED MAP SHOWS THE EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE IN THE LOWER LEFT CORNER. I WISH I COULD USE THIS POINT-THERE IT IS. SO, YOU CAN SEE IN THE LEFT CORNER THE 4 PROPOSED SHELTERS AND THEN THERE IS BATHROOM AND SHOWER FACILITIES IN THIS AREA AND A COMMON SPACE AND SOME OUTDOOR STORAGE. IT ALSO INCLUDES A PAVED ROAD INTO THE FACILITY AND FENCING SURROUNDING THE FACILITY WITH PRIVACY SLATS AND SURE THEY WILL DO LANDSCAPE TREATMENTS TO MAKE THE FACILITY LOOK VERY PRESENTABLE AND THERE IS ADA PATH OF TRAVEL FROM THE PARKING LOT TO THE SITE SO THEY HAVE DONE A GOOD JOB PREPARING THAT SITE. NEXT-SEE IF IT WORKS. YOU ARE GOOD. I WANT TO DEMONSTRATE JUST THIS IS A BIT OF A COMMUNITY EFFORT. GOODWATER CROSS HAS A NUMBER OF PARTNERS AND ONE PARTNER IS OUR THE CALIFORNIA HERITAGE YOUTH BUILD ACADEMY AND THIS GROUP IS A GROUP OF DEDICATED INDIVIDUALS HELPING OUT A NUMBER OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT LEARN A NUMBER OF TRADES WITHIN THE COMMUNITY. HERE YOU CAN SEE THEY ARE BUILDING SOME OF THE FOUNDATIONS FOR THE UNITS. IN THE NEXT ONE GIVES A GOOD DEMONSTRATION OF THE STUDENTS WORKING ON THE INSIDE OF THE FACILITY AND HERE YOU SEE THEY ARE DOING SHEET ROCKING SO IT IS A GREAT EXPERIENCE FOR THIS GROUP. ONCE I GET GO IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION-THIS IS A GOOD DEMONSTRATION OF WHAT THE ACTUAL FINISHED PRODUCT LOOKS LIKE. THIS IS DOUBLE OCCUPANCY UNIT. THIS IS JUST A SIDE VIEW. THE SMALL UNIT NEXT TO IT IS A EXTERIOR STORAGE UNIT FOR THE TENANTS TO STORE THEIR BELONGINGS. GOODWATER CROSS IS OPERATED BY A PROGRAM MANAGER, LOCAL SERVICE PROVIDER AND VOLUNTEERS. THE OPERATIONAL SERVICE INCLUDE ON-SITE COORDINATE THAT IS ON-SITE OR ON-CALL 24 HOURS A DAY 7 DAYS A WEEK. THE SERVICES INCLUDE REFERRAL SERVICES HOUSING CASE MANAGEMENT, WORK SHOP AND LEARNING OPPORTUNITIES AND HEALTH AND WELLNESS ACTIVITIES. PARTICIPANTS OF THE GOODWATER CROSSING WILL BE SUBJECT TO RULES RIGHTS RESPONSIBILITIES GOOD NEIGHBOR POLICIES AND ULTIMATELY SIGN A RESIDENT COMMUNITY AGREEMENT. EACH PARTICIPANT IS LIMITED TO STAY OF 10 MONTHS. IN APRIL PROVIDED A (INAUDIBLE) AT THIS TIME CITY STAFF THE BUILDING OFFICIAL, FIRE MARSHAL PLANNING STAFF ALSO ARE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT IN THE FINAL STAGES OF MAKING THE SITE PLAN APPROVAL RECOMMENDATIONS WHICH WILL GO BEFORE THE CITY MANAGER FOR FINAL CONSIDERATION. GOODWATER CROSSING IS A OPPORTUNITY TO ASSIST OUR UNSHELTERED TO PROVIDE A SAFE PLACE TO LIVE TO BUILD STABILITY AND SELF-SUFFICIENCY WHILE PROVIDING- BRIDGING FROM UNSHELTERED LIFESTYLE TO PERMANENT HOUSING OPPORTUNITY. THE RECOMMENDATION BEFORE YOU THIS EVENING IS TO APPROVE GOODWATER CROSSING AS SHORT TERM TEMPORARY EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE OF NO MORE THEN 12 SLEEPING CABINS FOR ONE YEAR TERM AND AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO MAKE MINER MODIFICATION TO OPERATION SERVICE MANUAL TO FACILITATE THE SITE APPROVAL. AND THEN ALSO TO SET THE ONE YEAR TERM DATE. IF THE GOODWATER CROSSING IS APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL, FOLLOWING CITY MANAGER FINAL APPROVAL OF THE OPERATION PLAN AND SITE PLAN SITE IMPROVEMENTS WOULD START IN MAY OR JUNE OF THIS YEAR WITH THE INTENT OF FULL OPERATION SOME TIME THIS SUMMER. THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND KATIE SCHWARTZ OF GOODWATER CROSSING AND I AM AVAILABLE ALSO FOR ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. >> THIS IS A TIME WHERE COUNCIL MEMBERS CAN ASK QUESTIONS AND THEN WE WOULD HAVE OUR SPEAKERS PRESENT THEIR QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS AND DO I HAVE-I HAVE QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS I THINK-NOT SURE WHO WAS--OKAY. >> MY IS A QUICK QUESTION. DID YOU SAY A MINIMUM OR MAXIMUM OF 10 MONTHS WITHIN THE SHELTER? >> 10 MONTHS IS MAXIMUM. >> OKAY. >> THAT WAS VICE MAYOR DEQUISTO- >> THANK YOU. THIS IS PROBABLY MORE FOR MR. DEWALT, WHAT TENANCY IS CREATED BY THIS ARRANGEMENT? >> IT IS A EXCELLENT QUESTION. IT CERTAINLY NOT FOR THE CITY TO ENFORCE IT BY UNLAWFUL DETAINER, BUT ARGUABLY THIS IS A NEW CREATURE UNDER STATE LAW SO DON'T THINK IT HAS BEEN ADDRESSED IN THE COURTS. IT COULD BE SUBJECT TO UNLAWFUL DETAINER STATUTES. IF SAINT JAMES WANTED TO EVICT SOMEBODY HOWEVER I DONT THINK THIS CREATES A TENANCY BY LAW. IT IS MORE A LICENSE TO OCCUPY A PREMISES, SO THERE IS CERTAINLY IS NO UNDERLYING FEE THAT IS BEING LEASES TO ANY PARTICIPANT HERE, SO I THINK THE BEST GUESS IS IT DOES NOT CREATE A TENANCY BUTS IT IS POSSIBLE THE COURTS COULD CONCLUDE THAT. >> ISN'T THE HOUSE BEING LEASED? THE SHELTER? WHATEVER YOU WANT TO CALL IT? >> THE MICRO SHELTER? >> I DON'T BELIEVE THEY ARE LEASED AT ALL. >> THE ACTUAL UNITS I BELIEVE ARE BEING PROVIDED-I BELIEVE IT IS MORE A DONATION. I HAVE TO CHECK WITH THE OPERATORS TO CONFIRM HOW THAT IS PART OF THE FACILITY. >> I TOOK A LOOK AT THE REGULATIONS. IT SAYS DRUG TESTING IS PROHIBITED UNLESS THE TESTING IS PART OF TREATMENT PLAN WITH THE PARTICIPATE GOES ON TO SAY SUBMISSION OF DRUG TESTING CANNOT BE REQUIREMENT FOR RESIDENCY AND REFUSAL TO PARTICIPATE IN DRUG TESTING CANNOT BE THE BASIS FOR INVOLUNTARY DISCHARGE. ARE YOU READING THAT ACCURATELY? >> ARE YOU READING THE OPERATION PLAN OR STATE LAW? >> NOT SURE WHICH IT IS, JUST TOOK A PICTURE BUT I SAW IT ONE PLACE. >> THEY DO HAVE SCREENING CRITERIA WITHIN THE OPERATIONS PLAN AND I WOULD DIFFER THAT QUESTION TO KATIE. SHE'S MORE INVOLVED WITH THAT ACTUAL SCREENING PROCESS THEN I HAVE BEEN, BUT I KNOW THEY DO HAVE CRITERIA WITHIN THEIR OPERATION PLAN FOR SCREENING THE APPLICANTS. >> I HAD A SECOND RELATED ONE, IT SAYS UNDER THE INFLUENCE ON SITE MAY NOT BE THE BASIS FOR DISCHARGE, IS THAT ACCURATE AS WELL? >> THAT IS CORRECT. THESE ARE TYPICALLY-THESE ARE WHAT YOU CONSIDER ALL MOST NO BARRIER TYPE OF FACILITY. THAT IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THIS TYPE OF FACILITY THEN SAY A RESCUE MISSION. >> I DON'T HAVE OTHER QUESTIONS. >> I WOULD ADD, THE GUIDELINES DO ALLOW FOR A RESIDENT WHO HAS REPETITION OF THOSE BAD BEHAVIORS COULD BE SUBJECT TO EVICTION. SO, IT ISN'T THE SOLE DETERMINATION, BUT IF THAT UNDER THE INFLUENCE RESULTS IN OTHER BAD BEHAVIORS VIOLENT ACTIONS SCREAMING YELLING AND THAT SORT OF THING, THEY CAN BE EVICTED IN ACCORDANCE TO CITY GUIDELINES WHICH IS THE BASING FOR THE OPERATIONAL PLANS DEVELOPED. >> YOU SAID THE CITY WILL NOT BE INVOLVED IN EVICTION. >> I AM TELLING YOU WHAT THE CITY OPERATIONAL PLAN OR OPERATIONAL GUIDELINES, THOSE ARE CRITERIA UNDER WHICH THEY CENTER HAVE TO OPERATE AND THE APPLICANT HAS THE OPERATIONS PLAN WHERE THEY CAN PUT THE ELEMENTS IN THERE. >> MAYOR PRO TEM MEZZANO. >> MR. TIPPIN. THE APPLICANTS THAT ARE SCREENED AND APPROVED FOR THIS PROGRAM ARE MADE AWARE OF THE CONDITIONS AT THE TIME THEY ARE ACCEPTED IN THE PROGRAM AND THEY AGREE TO THE CONDITIONS DO THEY NOT? >> YES, THEY DO. THERE IS A RESIDENT AGREEMENT THEY WILL SIGN AND THEY ARE VERY AWARE OF THEIR RESPONSIBILITIES FOR THEMSELVES BUT ALSO FOR THE SITE AND PARTICIPATION WITHIN THAT PROGRAM. >> THEY ARE MADE AWARE THAT IF THEY DO NOT ACT AS REQUIRED BY THE AGREEMENT THEY CAN BE [STREAMING CUT OUT] RELEASED FROM THE PROGRAM. >> YES. THERE IS DISMISSAL PROCESS WITHIN THAT GUIDELINE. >> THANK YOU, EXCELLENT PRESENTATION. >> ALRIGHT, SO WHY DON'T WE START WITH-THANK YOU MR. BADE. I APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENTATION. WE MAY HAVE MORE QUESTIONS AFTER SOME OF THE PUBLIC COMMENTS, SO BE STAY TUNED. HOW ABOUT IF OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS PAM CROW? FALLOWED BY KIM COBBLER. >> HELLO COUNCIL, MAYOR, PEOPLE OF THE COMMUNITY. I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT I WANT TO SO STRONGLY SUPPORT- >> CAN YOU MOVE THE MICROPHONE DOWN TOWARDS YOU SO WE CAN- >> OKAY. HOW LOW DOES IT GO? [LAUGHTER] >> THERE IS ALSO A BENCH OR A STEP STOOL. >> AH. [LAUGHTER] >> I JUST FIND THIS MOST EXCITING EVENT TO HAVE TO BE AT THIS SPOT FOR THIS GOODWATER CROSSING. I JUST WANT TO COMMEND THE PEOPLE WORKING SO HARD INCLUDING THE CITY OF REDDING FIRST CHRISTIAN CHURCH DISCIPLE OF CHRIST, SHASTA THRIVE, THE HERITAGE YOUTH BUILD ACADEMY AND ARE THE SAINT JAMES LUTHERAN CONGREGATION. IS THE HOPE TO SEE GOODWATER CROSSING REALTY, BUT THEN TO HAVE SIMILAR PROJECTS EXPAND THROUGHOUT OUR TOWN F. WE LOOK JUST TO OUR NORTH TO HOPE VILLAGE IN MEDFORD, THEY PUT UP 34 TINY HOUSES IN 2017. THE SUCCESS OF THAT PROJECT LEAD TO FOUNDRY VILLAGE AND GRANTS PASS WHICH OPEN LATER THIS YEAR WITH A DOZEN TINY HOUSES. MEDFORD SECOND PROJECT HEART VILLAGE IS EXPECTED TO OPEN ANOTHER DOZEN HOUSES. GOODWATER CROSSING PROMISE TO PROVIDE THE SAME HIGH QUALITY CARE AND ASSISTANCE TO HELP PEOPLE GET BACK ON FEET WITH DIGNITY. THE SUCCESS OF TINY HOMES IS EXCITING. THE EFFORT FOR FIRE OUR COMMUNITY (INAUDIBLE) DEMONSTRATE FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY AND SHOWS ACTUAL CONCERN FOR THE HEALTH AND WELLBEING OF FOLKS HOMELESS OR HOUSELESS BY GIVING SHELTER, SAFETY ELECTRICITY FOR HEALTH AND COMMUNICATION AND PLACE TO CALL HOME AS THEY TRANSITION. I HOPE YOU FOLLOW THE RECOMMENDATION AND APPROVE THE GOODWATER CROSSING EMERGENCY HOUSING SITE PROJECT. LET'S HELP OUR COMMUNITY. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. KIM COBBLER FALLOWED BY BILL WALKER. >> GOOD EVENING. I HAVE BEEN A RESIDENT OF THAT AREA IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE THIS HOUSING IS BEING CONSIDERED FOR OVER 35 YEARS AND I DO HAVE A LOT OF CONCERN OF THE PROJECT THE WAY IT IS BEING PUT TOGETHER. CURRENTLY I COULD PROBABLY THINK OF 2 TO 3 TIMES IN THE LAST 2 YEARS I WHERE MY HOME IT RUNS CHURN CREEK BOTTOM CREEK IS BEHIND MY HOME AND WE HAVE MANY HOMELESS PEOPLE IN TENTS THAT LIVE THERE. I HAD TO CALL FIRE DEPARTMENT FOR FIRES BEING STARTED AND IT IS VERY SCARY AREA WHEN IT COMES TO THE HOMELESS IN THE AMOUNT OF TENTS THAT ARE BEHIND THAT AREA, SO THE SHELTER PLAN THEY HAVE I HAVE ATTENDED THE MEETINGS THAT THEY HAD. I ASKED A LOT OF QUESTIONS. MY BACKGROUND COMES FROM 35 YEARS WORKING FOR PRIVATE INDUSTRY COUNCIL, SMART AND DEALING WITH THE HOMELESS POPULATION. SO, I FEEL I AM PRETTY QUALIFIED TO QUESTION I GUESS SOME OF THE SERVICES THAT THEY ARE PROVIDING TO MAKE SURE IT IS A SUCCESSFUL PROGRAM. SOME OF MY CONCERNS WHEN I ASKED AT THE ORIENTATION MEETING THEY HAD IT WAS VERY-THERE WAS A LOT OF PEOPLE I SPOKE WITH THAT GAVE ME A LOT OF DIFFERENT ANSWERS. ONE OF MY BIGGEST CONCERNS WAS THE SCREENING OF THE APPLICANT COMES IN. THE STABILITY OF SOMEBODY GOING THROUGH A PROGRAM LIKE WHAT THEY ARE WANTING TO BE SUCCESSFUL AT THE END IS TO TRY ESPECIALLY IF THEY ARE NOT DOING BACKGROUND DRUG SCREENINGS, THOSE TYPE OF THINGS TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE SUCCESSFUL GOING INTO A PROJECT LIKE THIS AND THEY ARE GIVING 10 MONTHS, IT IS MONTHS AND MONTHS OF SOBRIETY BEFORE YOU CAN GO INTO A EMPLOYMENT AND TRAINING PROGRAM TO BE ABLE TO SAY YOU COMPLETED THE PROGRAM ESPECIALLY IF YOU GOT HOUSING YOU HAVE TO HAVE STABILITY BEFORE YOU GET THERE. FOR THEM LACKING THE DRUG SCREEN, THE BACKGROUND CHECKS AND THOSE THINGS BECAUSE THEY DON'T ALLOW THOSE THINGS JUST SETS UP THE PROGRAM TO BE NON EFFECTIVE AND I REALLY CONCERNED MORE SO-IT ISN'T THE PROGRAM ITSELF, IT IS BEING IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA, AND IN MY BACKYARD. AND IT IS A ONE YEAR COMMITMENT TO THEM BUT ALSO SEEN SAN JOSE WHERE THEY HAD A SIMILAR PROJECT LIKE THIS AND AFTER A YEAR THERE WAS NO FUNDING AND IT WENT TO A HUGE HOMELESS CAMP AND ALL THE RESIDENTS AROUND THERE HAD TO LIVE WITH IT, MY SON BEING ONE OF THEM AND I JUST AM VERY CONCERNED ABOUT HAVING THIS IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER IS BILL WALKER, FOLLOWED BY ROBERT GROSH. >> MAYOR SCHREDER AND MEMBERS. MY NAME IS BILL WALKER AND RETIRED IN 2018 AFTER 30 YEARS WITH THE SHASTA COUNTY PLANNING DIVISION. I'M A MEMBER OF THE AMERICAN MEMBER PLANNING ASSOCIATION AND FORMER MEMBER OF THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF CERTIFIED PLANNERS. SOMETIMES GOOD PEOPLE WITH GOOD INTENTIONS COME UP WITH BAD IDEAS. THE PROPOSED MICRO SHELTERS PROJECT IS AN EXAMPLE. IN 1948 THE UNITED STATES SIGNED THE UNITED NATIONS UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS. ARTICLE 25 INCLUDES ADEQUATE HOUSING AS A HUMAN RIGHT. SINCE 1969 CALIFORNIA HAS REQUIRED LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO PLAN FOR THE HOUSING NEEDS OF EVERYONE IN THE COMMUNITY. SO WHAT IS HOUSING? IF YOU READ THE CALIFORNIA STATE HOUSING LAW IT SHOWS HOUSING INCLUDES A PLACE TO SLEEP, A BATHROOM WITH A SINK, TOILET AND SHOWER AND PLACE TO COOK ALL IN THE SAME STRUCTURE. LET ME REPEAT THAT, HOUSING INCLUDES A PLACE TO SLEEP, BATHROOM WITH A SINK, TOILET AND SHOWER AND PLACE TO COOK ALL IN THE SAME STRUCTURE. THE PROPOSED PROJECT IS NOT HOUSING. IT IS CAMPING WITH NO INDOOR SINKS TOILETS SHOWERS OR KITCHENS AND SO IT DOES NOT MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF STATE LAW AND I BELIEVE IT IS IS A VIOLATION OF A BASIC HUMAN RIGHT. ABOUT 7 OR 8 YEARS AGO A MAN NAMED LLOYD PENDLETON CAME HERE AND GAVE A PRESENTATION HOW HIS CITY REDUCED HOMELESSNESS BY 91 PERCENT. I REMEMBER MAYOR SCHREDER WAS THERE. IT IS CALLED HOUSING FIRST. NO MATTER CIRCUMSTANCES MENTAL HEALTH DRUG ABUSE OR CRIMINAL RECORD YOU ARE ENTITLED TO REAL HOUSING. CALIFORNIA HAS A 9 (INAUDIBLE) SOME OF THE MONEY COULD USED TO BUILD REAL HOUSING. THE PROJECT SENDS A UGLY MESSAGE TO HOMELESS PEOPLE. YOU ARE NOT FIT OR WORTHY TO LIVE IN REAL HOUSING AND YOU HAVE TO PROVE YOUR WORTH BEFORE WE WILL LET YOU LIVE IN REAL HOUSING. PLEASE DO NOT WASTE TIME AND MONEY AND DO NOT APPROVE THE PROJECT. PLEASE DIRECT CITY STAFF TO MAKE PLANS AND FIND REAL HOUSING FOR EVERYONE IN THE COMMUNITY. IT IS REALISTIC AND FEASIBLE AND THE RIGHT THING TO DO FOR HOMELESS PEOPLE. PLEASE REMEMBER REAL HOUSING IS A BASIC HUMAN RIGHT. ONE QUICK THING I SAID MENTIONED THIS TO YOUR COUNTY ATTORNEY OR CITY ATTORNEY RATHER, I BELIEVE THE CITY COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION ON THIS ITEM BECAUSE THERE IS NO DRAFT RESOLUTION FOR PUBLIC REVIEW. THERE IS NO COMPLETE PROJECT DESCRIPTION. THERE ARE NO CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL. >> THANK YOU. >> THERE ARE NO FINDINGS OF FACT AND NO CEQA DETERMINATION. THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] >> ROBERT GROSH FALLOWED BY LARRY OLMSTEAD >> I'M A LICENSE PSYCHOTHERAPIST IN THE STATE OF. I WORKED WITH THE HOMELESS OR HOUSELESS POPULATION FOR MANY YEARS. I WILL TELL YOU ALSO FROM MY OWN EXPERIENCE AS A PART OF MY TRAINING I WAS REQUIRED TO LIVE IN A HOMELESS SITUATION FOR 5 DAYS IN THE CITY OF CHICAGO AND MY BUDGET WAS $7. FOR 5 DAYS ON THE STREET. I CAN TELL YOU NUMBER ONE THAT WITHOUT A ROOF OVER MY HEAD I COULD NOT THINK ABOUT IMPROVING MY SITUATION EVEN FOR THOSE 5 DAYS. I WAS CONSUMED WITH CONCERNS ABOUT WHAT I WOULD EAT, HOW I WOULD MAKE $7 LAST FOR 5 DAYS, WHERE I COULD BE SAFE AND WHERE I COULD BE WARM. ONE CANNOT SURVIVE THAT KIND OF SITUATION AND IMPROVE ON THEIR OWN IF THE VERY SURVIVAL IS AT THE FRONT OF THEIR MIND AT ALL TIMES. THERE IS THE MYTH THAT HOMELESSNESS IS THE RESULT OF BAD DECISIONS. THAT IT IS ABSOLUTELY TRUE, BAD DECISIONS BY ONES PARENTS, BAD DECISIONS BY ONES SCHOOLING, BAD DECISIONS AT TIMES BY LAW ENFORCEMENT AND THE COURTS. BAD DECISIONS BY ONES FORMER INTIMATE PARTNER. BAD DECISIONS BY THOSE WHO MANAGE THE CHILDREN THAT ARE THROWN OUT AT THE AGE OF 18. THESE BAD DECISIONS DO CREATE HOMELESSNESS, BUT THE BAD DECISIONS THAT CREATE HOMELESSNESS ARE ACTUALLY DECISIONS MADE BY OTHER PEOPLE RATHER THEN THE HOMELESS THEMSELVES. YOU HAVE A OPPORTUNITY HOWEVER TO DO WHAT MY PARENTS DID WHEN I WAS IN THE SECOND GRADE AND UNABLE TO READ. THEY MADE A GOOD DECISION. THEY HELD ME BACK FOR ONE YEAR. I THEN WAS ABLE TO MASTER THE SKILL OF READING. TODAY I STAND BEFORE YOU AS A VERY PROSPEROUS AND WELL KNOWN PSYCHOTHERAPIST. I HAVE WRITTEN-I HAVE TWOS MASTER DEGREES WRITTEN 2 PAPERS AND PUBLISHED A BOOK. THIS IS A CHANCE TO MAKE A GOOD DECISION TO IMPROVE SOMEONE'S LIFE. PLEASE MAKE THE RIGHT DECISION. >> THANK YOU. LARRY OLMSTEAD FALLOWED BY JAN MARRICK FALLOWED BY MAR LEAN STONE. >> GOOD EVENING MAYOR SCHREDER COUNCIL MEMBERS, MR. TIPPIN. AND CITY STAFF. THE PRESIDENT AND CEO OF UNITED WAY OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. I WILL TELL YOU THAT UNITED WAY HAS SIGNALED TO THE CITY ITS WILLINGNESS TO FOLLOW UP WITH ANY OTHER OF THESE TYPE OF PROJECTS BECAUSE WE THINK THIS IS A A OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CITY TO TAKE POSITIVE ACTION TO ADDRESS HOMELESS IN OUR COMMUNITY. TODAY I WAS AT PROJECT HOMELESS CONNECT RIGHT HERE AT THE REDDING LIBRARY WHERE MORE THEN 300 PERHAPS 400 OF OUR UNSHELTERED PEOPLE WERE ABLE TO GET SERVICE FROM MORE THEN 60 AGENCIES. ONE THING WE NEED TO KNOW ABOUT OUR COMMUNITY, THERE ARE MANY AGENCIES DOING EXCELLENT WORK TO ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF HOMELESSNESS BUT ONE THING WE KNOW ABOUT THE ISSUE IS UNLESS A ROOF IS OVER SOMEONE'S HEAD IT IS VERY DIFFICULT FOR THESE AGENCIES TO FIND TRACK AND TREAT AND ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES. THIS IS EMERGENCY SHELTER WE ARE TALKING ABOUT. I TAKE THE POINT OF WHAT REAL SHELTER IS, REAL HOUSING IS. WE ARE TALKING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY SHELTER THAT HELPS PEOPLE TRANSITION INTO A BETTER SITUATION AND WE ARE VERY FAMILIAR WITH THAT AS A MODEL THAT IS IMPORTANT AND NECESSARY IN ORDER TO GET PEOPLE ON THEIR FEET. FINAL THING I WOULD SAY, I HAVE TOURED THE SAINT JAMES SITE. I ALSO JUST COME BACK AFTER TWO WEEKS AGO MYSELF AND A COLLEAGUE DROVE TO OREGON TO LOOK AT SIMILAR MICRO SITES SET UP. THOSE SITES HAVE BEEN VERY SUCCESSFUL. THEY ARE SAFE. PROVIDING A DIGNIFIED OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE TO GET THEIR LIVES TOGETHER AND GET GOING. A LOT OF THE WORK THAT HAS GONE INTO THE SAINT JAMES THINKING AND OTHER THINKING THAT THE CITY AND OTHERS HAVE BEEN INVOLVED LOOKED AT THE SITES, LOOKED AT THOSE MODELS AND SOUGHT TO TAKE THE BEST OF THOSE LEARNINGS AND APPLY THEM HERE IN THE CITY OF REDDING. SO, I WANT TO APPLAUD THE CITY FOR THE STEPS ALREADY TAKEN TO ADVANCE THE ISSUE AND WANT TO URGE THE COUNCIL TO CONTINUE ON THAT PATH AND CONTINUE TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY SHELTER THAT IS DIGNIFIED AND SAFE FOR THE CITY OF REDDING. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS JAN OLREC FALLOWED BY MARGY STONE FALLOWED BY LUANNE (INAUDIBLE) >> MAYOR SCHREDER AND COUNCIL MEMBERS, MY NAME IS JAN OLRICK. I AM HAPPY YOU WANT TO HELP LESS FORTUNATE PEOPLE WHO ARE HOMELESS BUT BELIEVE THEY DESERVE THE DIGNITY OF A SHOWER BED AND KITCHEN IN THE SAME 4 WALLS. I SUPPORT YOUR STATED PRIORITY OF ACTING PROACTIVE TO ADDRESS THE CHALLENGES FACING CITY RESIDENTS AND SAFETY. I ASSUME THIS MEANS ALL RESIDENTS INCLUDING THE NEIGHBORS WHO LIVE NEAR THE PROPOSED PROJECT SITE. IMPROVING THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF SOME PEOPLE SHOULD NOT COME AT THE EXPENSE OF OTHERS WHO HAVE NO CHOICE IN THE MATTER AND THIS PROJECT WOULD HAVE SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE EFFECTS ON NEIGHBORS AND CREATE CHALLENGES FOR THEM NOT LESSEN THEM. SINCE THE OPEN HOUSE THE PROJECT IS MARKETED TO NEIGHBORS AS A 4 UNIT SITE WITH SUPERVISOR LIVING ON SITE 24/7. BUT THIS PROPOSAL ALLOWS 12 SLEEPING STRUCTURES FOR 15 PEOPLE PLUS UNSPECIFIED NUMBER OF (INAUDIBLE) I HAVE SEEN NO ANALYSIS HOW MANY OF THE FACILITIES WOULD BE NEEDED FOR THIS MANY PEOPLE HOW THEY ARE LAID OUT OR IF THEY FIT ON THE LAND PROVIDED. ALSO THE STAFF REPORT AND ADMIN GUIDELINES SHOW NO REQUIREMENT FOR THE ON SITE MANAGER TO ACTUALLY BE ON SITE JUST ON CALL. THE OPERATION MANUAL REQUIRES A STAFF RUN SITE ONLY 4 HOURS A DAY. IT IS A RECIPE FOR FAILURE FOR CAMP RESIDENTS AS WELL AS FOR THE NEIGHBORS LIVING IN SINGLE FAMILY HOMES JUST ON THE OTHER SIDE OF A FENCE. IMAGINE THE STEADY COMISSION 15 PEOPLE WALKING AROUND OUTSIDE DAY AND NIGHT TO GO TO THE TOILET SHOWER GET SOMETHING TO EAT DO LAUNDRY WALK THE DOG. LACK OF ON SITE SUPERVISION DOES NOT SUPPORT THOSE WANTING TO GROW POSITIVE LIFE HABITS AND PUT A BURDEN ON THE NEIGHBORS HAVING TO EXPERIENCE AND REPORT RULE BREAKING. NEIGHBORS ALSO SUFFER A HUGE ECONOMIC IMPACT FROM HAVING HOMELESS CAMP ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE FENCE. IF THEY WANT TO SELL THEIR HOME REALISTICALLY IT ISN'T GOING TO SELL UNLESS MAYBE A STEEP LOSS IN VALUE. THIS EFFECT WELLBEING AND FREEDOM TO MOVE ABOUT WITHOUT SUFFERING FINANCIALLY THROUGH NO FAULT OF THEIR OWN. HOMELESSNESS ISN'T GOING AWAY SOON. THIS SHORT TERM TEMPORARY HOMELESS SITE COULD EASILY STILL BE IN PLACE 5, 10, 20 YEARS FROM NOW. THERE ARE NO PERFORMANCE STANDARDS MET (INAUDIBLE) PROVISION FOR PROJECT EXPANSION BASED ON DEMONSTRATED SUCCESSFUL PERFORMANCE. NO REQUIREMENT TO GET FULL FUNDING BEFORE THE PROJECT SO CRITICAL FUNCTIONS ARE NOT OMITTED FOR LACK OF FUNDS. PLEASE GET SURPLUS STATE FUNDING TO PROVIDE REAL HOUSING UNIT FOR THE HOMELESS AND PLEASE SUPPORT THE CURRENT NEIGHBORHOOD RESIDENTS BY VOTING NO ON THIS PROPOSAL. [APPLAUSE] [CALLING SPEAKER NAMES] >> GOOD EVENING CITY COUNCIL, MAYOR SCHREDER, CITY OFFICIALS. I'M MAR GENE STONE THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE EMPIRE RECOVERY CENTER AND HERE WITH SOME OF MY TEAM TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THE MICRO SHELTER PROJECT. OUR AGENCY SERVES INDIVIDUALS WITH SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS AND FAR TOO MANY OF THEM ARE HOMELESS OR AT HIGH RISK OF HOMELESSNESS. IN 1981 I WAS A SINGLE PARENT SUDDENLY OVERNIGHT WITH TWO CHILDREN ONE IN A WHEELCHAIR. I WAS A HEART BEAT AWAY FROM THE STREETS. I HAD 5 YEARS OF PERSONAL RECOVERY BUT WHERE HAD NO MEANS OF SPORTING MYSELF OR MY CHILDREN. THANKS TO SOME VERY SPECIAL PEOPLE WHO GAVE ME A HAND UP NOT A HAND OUT, I HAD A CHANCE TO GET ON MY FEET TO LEARN HOW TO NAVIGATE THE SOCIAL SERVICES WITHOUT SHAME AND TO REBUILD OUR LIVES. THE MICRO SHELTER PROJECT PROVIDES WRAP AROUND SOCIAL SERVICES TO INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE READY TO CHANGE. THE EMPIRE RECOVERY CENTER IS ONE OF THE COLLABORATIVE SERVICES IN OUR COMMUNITY THAT IS WILLING TO COME ALONGSIDE AND BE A PART OF THIS INNOVATIVE PROACTIVE AND PROMISING PROJECT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS LOUANN LUSO. [CALLING SPEAKER NAMES] >> GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS LOUANN LUSO A EMPLOYEE OF CONNECTED LIVING WHICH USED TO BE CALLED GOLDEN UMBRELLA AND SURE THERE IS A VARIETY OF PEOPLE IN HERE THAT REMEMBER THAT. I WORKED THERE ON A PART TIME BASIS FOR 18 YEARS. THE PAST 4 YEARS OR SO HAVE SHOWN A SERIOUS LACK OF HOUSING FOR OLDER ADULTS MAINLY 65 AND OLDER. THE TRENDS SEEMS TO BE THE APARTMENT OWNERS ARE REQUIRING THE RESIDENTS ON SECTION 8 VOUCHER TUESDAY MOVE TO UP GRADE THE APARTMENTS AND RENT A FULL MARKET VALUE. THEY NO LONGER WANT TO ACCEPT SECTION 8 VOUCHERS. MANY OF THE RESIDENTS LIVED IN THEIR APARTMENTS 5 TO 20 YEARS AND MORE. BECAUSE OF THIS SOME OF THE OLDER ADULTS BECOME HOMELESS BUT NOT DUE TO ANY FAULT OF THEIR OWN. JUST BECAUSE OF THEM RECEIVING RENTAL ASSISTANCE THROUGH HUD DOES NOT INSURE THEM A NEW PLACE TO LIVE. I RECEIVED PHONE CALLS ALL MOST IMMEDIATELY FROM THE RESIDENTS IN A PANIC AS TO WHAT THEY CAN DO. THERE IS NOTHING THEY CAN DO ACCEPT MOVE. THE APARTMENTS FOR THOSE WANTING SENIOR HOUSING HAVE ENORMOUS WAIT LIST ANYWHERE FROM 6 MONTHS TO 3 YEARS. THIS DOESN'T WORK FOR THOSE HAVING TO MOVE WITHIN 60 DAYS. YOU WOULD BE SURPRISED HOW MANY OF THEM ARE NOT ABLE TO GET SECURE SAFE HOUSING AND LIVE ON THE STREETS. SOMETIMES IF THEY ARE LUCKY THEY HAVE VEHICLE THEY CAN LIVE IN SORE SOMEONE WILL TAKE THEM IN. I RECEIVED CALLS FROM OLDER ADULTS FROM THE LOW 60S TO THE UPPER 80 LOOKING FOR A PLACE TO LIVE. THESE ARE THE TYPES OF PEOPLE WHO WOULD BENEFIT GREATLY FROM A LOVING AND SAFE TEMPORARY HOUSING SITUATION AND SOCIAL WORKER TO ASSIST THEM THROUGH THE HOOPS THAT IT TAKES TO GET INTO PERMANENT HOUSE. I'M URGING YOU TO APPROVE THE EMERGENCY HOUSING WHICH COULD PERHAPS ASSIST PEOPLE LIKE THOSE MENTIONED ABOVE LIVE THE REST OF THEIR LIVES WITH DIGNITY AND SELF-RESPECT. >> THANK YOU. MICHAEL JOHNSON. FALLOWED BY ROGER RALSTON. IS MICHAEL JOHNSON IN THE ROOM? HE LEFT. OKAY. NOW WE ARE HAVING ROGER RALSTON. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I LIVE ON (INAUDIBLE) JUST IMMEDIATELY SOUTH OF SAINT JAMES CHURCH. I WANT TO PREEMPT MY COMMENTS WITH THIS, I LOVE CHOCOLATE CAKE BUT WHEN YOU FORCE FEED CHOCOLATE CAKE ON ME I CHOKE ON IT. I'M A VERY COMPASSIONATE CARING INDIVIDUAL. WHEN YOU TRY TO PUT THINGS FORCE IT ON ME I WILL CHOKE AND I HAVE CHOKED ON THIS PROJECT. I WENT TO SAINT JAMES WHEN THEY HAD THEIR OPEN HOUSE AND I TOURED IT MY WIFE AND I DID. WE TALKED TO SOME OF THE MEMBERS OF SAINT JAMES LUTHERAN CHURCH. ONE THING THEY TOLD ME WAS WE DID A COMPLETE SURVEY THROUGHOUT THE NEIGHBORHOOD. NO, YOU DID NOT. NOBODY KNOCKED ON MY DOOR. NOBODY SENT ME A LETTER. I HAVE TALKED TO MANY OF MY NEIGHBORS. NOBODY FROM SAINT JAMES OR FROM THE CITY HAS KNOCKED ON OUR DOORS MADE A PHONE CALL OR SENT A LETTER ASKING US OUR OPINIONS. I TALKED TO ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF SAINT JAMES LUTHERAN CHURCH WHO PROFESSED THIS WILL BE A GREAT THING FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD. IT IS. LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, WE HAVE A CRISIS IN OUR COMMUNITY. WE HAVE A CRISIS AND I DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER BUT I WILL TELL YOU THE ANSWER IS NOT CRAMMING A HOME IN A SHELTER DOWN OUR THROATS. I RESENT IT. THE GENTLEMAN THAT I SPOKE TO AT SAINT JAMES WHO TOLD ME WHAT A GREAT THING IT WAS GOING TO BE FOR THE COMMUNITY, I ASK HIM, WHERE DO YOU LIVE? I LIVE IN SHINGLE TOWN. WHILE THAT IS WONDERFUL. WHY DON'T YOU MOVE THESE LITTLE HOUSES INTO YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD? IT IS OUT OF THE WAY IT IS INCONVENIENT. IT HAPPENS TO BE INCONVENIENT FOR ME AND MY NEIGHBORS, SO I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE SOLUTION IS, BUT YOU CANNOT CRAM THESE TYPES OF THINGS DOWN THE THROATS OF THE TAX PAYING HOME OWNING CITIZENS OF THE COUNTY. YOU CANNOT DO IT. YOU CANNOT DO IT. YOU GOT TO FIND SOME DIFFERENT SOLUTION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME. >> THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] NEXT SPEAKER IS PAULETTE COTTON FOLLOWED BY ELLIE COSTELLO. >> WELL IT IS VERY NERVE-WRACKING AND PEOPLE WHO LIVE AT GOODWATER AND THE SURROUNDING AREAS WE HAVE NOT BEEN NOTIFIED. WE HAD TO PUT FLIERS OUT TO LET PEOPLE KNOW BECAUSE OF THE 600 FOOT RULE WHICH MEANS A LOT OF NEIGHBORING PEOPLE UNLESS IT CAME ON THE NEWS DIDN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THIS, AND LIKE I SAID EVERYBODY SAID IT DOES EFFECT US AND I HIGHLIGHTED ALL THE THINGS ABOUT THE COMMUNITY AND THAT THIS MAP WAS UP. IT WOULD SHOW WHERE IT GOES INTO PEOPLE WHO ARE TAXPAYERS DOING THE RIGHT THINGS, GOING TO WORK. I WORK 30 YEARS TO BUY A HOME THERE, AND THEY WANT TO PUT PLACES AS MANY PEOPLE THAT LIVE ON OUR STREET THEY ARE PUTTING IN THE BACK YARD THAT GOES RIGHT UP INTO OTHER NEIGHBORS WHO LIVED THERE 30 YEARS, SO YEAH, THE LOOSEY GOOSY PROMISES AND IT'S AN EXPERIMENT TO SEE IF THIS WORKS. I HAVE BEEN HOMELESS, I SLEPT IN MY CAR, I'M SYMPATHETIC. IT IS A PROBLEM, A HUGE PROBLEM. WE NEED LOW COST SENIOR HOUSING. WE NEED AS LONG AS RATES GO UP AND PEOPLE CANT AFFORD TO BUY A HOUSE WHICH HAPPENS IN EVERY CITY I HAVE BEEN IN IT GETS TO THAT OPPONENT WHERE ONLY THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE REALLY GOOD JOBS CAN BUY HOMES. SO, THERE ARE TOO MANY PROMISES AND WE WENT FROM 5 HOMES THERE MIGHT BE 12 HOMES. THEY ARE PUTTING IN A LOT WITHOUT SPRINKLERS. SHOUT OUT TO THE POLICE AND CAMPING ENFORCEMENT AND THE REDDING UTILITIES THAT IS TERRORIZED BY HAD THE HOMELESS. WE ARE TERRIFIED OF FIRES. THEY HAVE BEEN GREAT AND HELPED A LOT BECAUSE SOME OTHER PERSON SAID HOW THEY LIVED ON THE CREEK AND WE JUST WANT TO BE SAFE AND HAVE OUR NEEDS MET. I WANT THESE THINGS THE MONEY IS SPENT BUT THEY SHOULDN'T BE IN RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS. THEY SHOULD BE WHERE THERE ARE RESOURCES, LIBRARY, GOLDEN UMBRELLA FOOD BANKS, MEDICAL PEOPLE. THERE IS NO BUSES THERE TO CATCH, THERE IS NO SIDEWALKS AND YEAH, I BELIEVE THAT PEOPLE SHOULD HAVE TOILET AND KITCHEN THEIR OWN. I HAD ROOMMATES TOO. YEAH, HOPEFULLY IT WILL REALLY HELP, BUT THERE SHOULD BE MORE RESTRICTIONS WHERE THEY PUT THESE AND NO NOBODY HERE WANTS IT IN THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD. >> THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] ELLIE COSTELLO FOLLOWED BY HEATHER SHERMAN. >> GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS ELEANOR A MEMBER OF SAINT JAMES LUTHERAN CHURCH. I LIKE TO THANK THE CITY COUNCIL LETTING US TALK ABOUT THE MICRO SHELTER PROJECT. >> SPEAK CLOSER. THANK YOU. >> I LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR LETTING US TALK ABOUT THE PROJECT MORE. THANK YOU TO THE SAINT JAMES COMMUNITY AS WELL FOR INVITING ME TO BE A SPEAKER TALKING WHY I CHOOSE TO SUPPORT THIS NEW STEP WE COULD BE TAKING AS A COMMUNITY. ONE REASON I THINK WE SHOULD SUPPORT THIS PLAN IS I THINK IT WILL PROVIDE A BETTER MORE FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT TO THE CITY. I SAY BETTER BECAUSE EVERYONE WE PASS ON THE STREET IS A PERSON AND KNOW IF THAT'S ME ALL ALONE I WOULD WANT TO HAVE IS A BETTER PLACE TO LIVE AND ENJOY. MORE FRIENDLY. THE WORD FRIENDLY MEANS SHOW INTEREST IN OR HAVING GOOD WILL TOWARDS SOMEONE. THINK ABOUT THE MEANING FOR A SECOND. IF OUR CITY COUNCIL CANNOT STAND FOR SOMEONE IN A FRIENDLY WAY OR MANNER WHAT DOES THAT MAKE OTHERS THINK ABOUT OUR CITY? IF WE CAN'T TAKE A STEP FORWARD AS A COMMUNITY AND CHANGE ORDINARY PEOPLE LIVES HOW ARE WE FOLLOWING THE CITY MOTTO? COMMUNITY CHANGE STARTS HERE AND WE HAVE A OPPORTUNITY TO BE (INAUDIBLE) IF THE CITY CAN'T TAKE A CHANCE TO THINK OF OTHERS AS OURSELVES THEN WE ARE BLIND. WE ARE FALLEN TOWARDS WHAT THE WORLD WANTS NOT WHAT GOD WANTS. IMAGINE IF THE PEOPLE HERE WERE HOMELESS WOULD YOU INVITE THEM TODAY. THINK YOU ARE HOMELESS. WHEN IT RAINS YOU MAY NOT HAVE A RAIN COAT OR JACKET AND THE BEST THING YOU CAN DO IS LIVE UNDER A BRIDGE UNTIL THE STORM IS OVER. HOW WOULD YOU THINK OF YOURSELF? HOW OTHERS THINK OF YOU? WOULD YOU BE HAPPY OR SAD? IN CLOSING I I LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR LISTENING ME TO SPEAK AND LIKE TO REMEMBER THE WORDS OF HANNAH WHO WAS THE MOTHER OF SAMUEL ISRAEL FIRST PROFIT. SHE SAID GOD RAISES THE POOR FROM THE DUST AND (INAUDIBLE) THROWN OF HONOR. I WANT TO LEAVE WITH YOU TODAY IS TO CHALLENGE ALL OF US TO CONSIDER THIS NEW OPPORTUNITY RIGHT IN FRONT OF US. KNOWING GOD DOESN'T JUST LOOK OUT FOR THE RICH HE LOOKS OUT FOR THE POOR AND HE WILL NEVER LET THEM BE ALONE AND THIS IS OUR OPPORTUNITY TOO TO DO THE SAME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. >> THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] >> CAN I ASK YOU ONE QUESTION? HOW OLD ARE YOU? >> I'M 11. >> YOU ARE 11. I HAVE A 13 YEAR OLD LITTLE BOY AND YOU ARE VERY ARTICULATE AND YOU READ VERY WELL. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] >> WE HAVE HEATHER SHERMAN FALLOWED BY PAUL ABBOTT. >> MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS, FOLKS, THANKS FOR HAVING ME. MY NAME HEATHER MY HUSBAND CRAIG AND I AND SON MATTHEW LIVE ON GOODWATER AVENUE. WE LIVED HERE FOR 32 YEARS IN OUR QUITE RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD 4 HOUSES AROUND US RAISED A LOT OF KIDS IN THE NEIGHBORHOODS. MY SON IS THE YOUNGEST ACCEPT FOR A NEW GRANDSON THAT JUST CAME ACROSS. WE ARE NOT HAPPY WITH THIS PLAN. TO BUILD A MICRO SHELTER COMMUNITY AND LOCK IN A DRY FIELD BEHIND A FENCE DOESN'T FEEL LIKE A STEP UP TO ME T. IS GLORIFIED HOMELESS CAMP. IT DOESN'T FEEL RESPECT FLORIDA TO THE PEOPLE TO LIVE IN THE SMALL BOX. WE SPOKEN TO MANY PEOPLE ABOUT THE PROJECT INCLUDING SOCIAL WORKERS PUBLIC LAW ENFORCEMENT AND HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS WHO DEAL WITH THE HOMELESS AND DO NOT THINK THE SET UP IN A RESIDENTIAL LOCATION IS BENEFICIAL TO THESE FOLKS. WE HAVE LIST OF REASONS, I LEFT THE BOTTOM 21 AT HOME AND BROUGHT THE TOP 4. IT IS A RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD. IT IS DESIGNED FOR PEOPLE WITH VEHICLES TO DRIVE TO OTHER PLACES FOR WORK AND SOCIAL THINGS AND SCHOOL. IT ISN'T FAIR TO BUILD A 10 BY 10 SHED AND MAKE PEOPLE LIVE IN THE HOT BOXES IN A FIRE DRY FIELD OR WINTER RAINY AND MUDDY. (INAUDIBLE) AND FOOD SUPPLIES AVAILABLE AND ACCESSIBLE IF YOU DON'T HAVE TRANSPORTATION IN THE RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD. I HEARD IT CALLED GOODWATER CROSSING. I NEVER HEARD THAT IN ALL THE YEARS I LIVED THERE. THERE ARE NO FUNCTIONAL

Page

/

7

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFxY4ioW70gCD7rb71q2_AHQM9wEu3OHsJFpqpEimVZGi4bUVfR95fn76TVE9_gTovcBj9eZIVlpmH0HHaXDnkiBOC5_Op7D3NRXHstlsY7TRUZHVJjTrDyLWm9P0xofHeE1P0m4utTGMTR_US9nPDVgcdNJWCMDzTRxe7Z5Si1Y23QbNUWamuiobiz5OEXGisnfNHI78DCIvxFT75yc6CFWK96cZN4bS7Fsvp0h9MDSkQ0dgeZcgTvMuXl9GElJ9v6HESKMrnlD5s4WtltTA9Y_Z0q3Xg60hBltdzDQh_vpUhbeTQHTVjE8V5umy2IAnPjR3dSzLxEQ-BFyT5PC6V3XOSGBnQ%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

[http://www.cityofredding.org/](http://www.cityofredding.org/)

## Page 1 of 7

Agenda

Regular Meeting

Redding City Council

Council Chambers (Doors open 30 minutes prior)

777 Cypress Avenue

Redding, CA

May 17, 2022

6:00 PM

The City Council Chambers are fully open to the public in compliance with current guidelines

from the California Department of Public Health regarding indoor meetings.

1\. CALL TO ORDER - MAYOR KRISTEN SCHREDER

A. Pledge of Allegiance

B. Invocation - Lynn Fritz, Native American Tradition as a Karuk Tribal Descendant

C. Roll Call

2\. PRESENTATIONS

2A. Presentation of 2021 Citizen Awards to Michael Knowles (Don D. Davis) and

Keith Devine by the Redding Police Department.

3\. PUBLIC COMMENT - for non-agendized matters within the city’s jurisdiction.

PURSUANT TO THE BROWN ACT, CITY COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION ON PUBLIC

COMMENT ITEMS

The City Council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for 30 minutes total, at the

beginning of the meeting for Public Comment for non-agendized matters within the City’s jurisdiction.

The Mayor will determine the order of the speakers. If 30 minutes is not adequate to accommodate all of

the individuals who have submitted a Speaker Request Form to the City Clerk, the Council will trail this

item to the end of the open session agenda. The remaining speakers will address the City Council at that

time.

If anyone wishes to address the City Council on any item considered at this meeting before or during

Council’s consideration of that item, please fill out a blue Speaker Request Form, located in the

lighted alcoves at the back of the Council Chambers, and submit it to the City Clerk. The City Council

will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for each agenda item. Staff reports are

available on-line at the City’s web site at www.cityofredding.org or in the Public View binder located

on the podium at the north side of the Chambers.

Showing the first 24,000 of 133,525 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> WE ARE RECONVENING OR WE ARE CONVENING AFTER OUR CLOSED SESSION, WHICH WE HAD NO REPORTABLE ACTION AND WE ARE CONVENING OUR REGULAR SESSION OF THE REDDING CITY COUNCIL FOR MAY 17, 2022. IF ANYONE WISHING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL ON ANY ITEM CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING BEFORE OR DURING COUNCIL CONSIDERATION OF THE ITEM PLEASE FILL OUT A SPEAKER REQUEST FORM IN THE BACK OF THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS AND SUBMIT TO THE CITY CLERK. THE CITY COUNCIL WILL ALLOCATE UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 3 MINUTES PER SPEAKER FOR EACH ITEM. STAFF REPORTS ARE AVAILABLE AT THE CITY WEBSITE AT CITY OF REDDING.ORG OR PUBLIC VIEW BINDER ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE CHAMBERS. THE FIRST ITEM IS THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND THEN AFTER THAT IF YOU CAN REMAIN STAND ING FOR THE INVOCATION WHICH WILL BE MY MEGAN OWENS BY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TO THE REPUBLIC, FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION, UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> GOOD EVENING. MAY WE BE IN A ATTITUDE OF PRAYER AND OPENNESS. MAY THE DEVINE SPIRIT WHO CALLS US BEYOND THE EYE INTO COMMON GROUND FOR ALL. ENVELOP AND SURROUND IN OUR WORK. MAY WE SEEK THIS COMMON GROUND THROUGH RESPECTFUL COMMUNICATION, SO THAT ALL THINGS MAY TRANSPIRE FOR THE WELLBEING OF OUR ENTIRE COMMUNITY AND WE SAY MAY IT BE SO, MAY IT BE SO, AMEN. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT ITEM IS ROLL CALL. [ROLL CALL]. >> TONIGHT 2A PRESENTATION OF 2021 CITIZEN AWARDS TO MICHAEL KNOWLES AND KEITH DEVINE BY THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT. >> GOOD EVENING HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL. IT IS MY HONOR TO PRESENT TWO SIT ZEN AWARDS TO TWO MEMBERS WHO STEPPED UP TO PLATE TO HELP OUT OUR STAFF AND FELLOW CITIZENS IN TIME OF NEED AT GREAT RISK TO THEMSELVES. WE NORMALLY TRY TO DO THIS ON A ANNUAL BASIS. COVID HAS PLAYED A PART IN THAT SO GLAD TO GET BACK TO DOING THESE. THESE AWARDS ARE NOMINATED BY OUR STAFF SO OFFICER IN THE FIELD ENCOUNTER INCIDENT WHERE A CITIZEN STEPS UP AND PROVIDE A NOMINATION FORM THAT GO TUESDAY THE MERITORIOUS CONDUCT BOARD WHICH IS RUN BY LIEUTENANT DANNY SMETECK WE HAVE A GROUP OF OFFICERS AND OTHERS THAT REVIEW THE REWARDS, MAKE DETERMINATION AND THEY COME TO ME AND WE APPROVE AND GIVE THE AWARDS OUT AS WELL AS AWARDS TO OFFICERS SO IT GOES THROUGH A LENGTHY PROCESS OF THE INCIDENT, SO THESE ARE SIGNIFICANT AND EXCITED TO RECOGNIZE THESE FOLKS. THE FIRST WE WILL RECOGNIZE IS MICHAEL KNOWLES, IS HE HERE? COME ON UP, MICHAEL. WHILE YOU ARE COMING I'LL READ THIS NOVEMBER 10, 2021 AT 1058 P.M. A SEDAN WAS NORTHBOUND INTERSTATE 5. THE DRIVE TOOK A EXIT AND CONTINUED DRIVING ON A OVER PASS THAT SPANS OVER HILL TOP DRIVE. LEFT THE ROADWAY WHILE IN THE OVERPASS AND FELL ON TO HILL TOP DRIVE WHERE IT CAME TO REST. OFFICER CAME UPON THE UNRECOGNIZABLE CAR ON FIRE. OFFICERS WERE UNABLE TO REMOVE THE DRIVER FROM THE EXTENSIVELY DAMAGED VEHICLE. MR. KNOWLES HAPPENED TO BE DRIVING PAST THE LOCATION IN THE TOW TRUCK. KNOWLES QUICKLY JUMPED OUT AND ASSISTED OFFICERS ATTEMPTING TO REMOVE THE DRIVE DOOR WITH TOW TRUCK BOOM. THE CAR SO WAS BADLY DAMAGED THE BOOM SLICED THROUGH THE DOOR FRAME. THE OFFICER CONTINUE TO ATTEMPT TO PULL THE DRIVER FROM (INAUDIBLE) THE OFFICERS ALSO EXHAUSTED FIRE EXTINGUISHERS AND UNABLE TO PUT THE VEHICLE TEMPORARILY HELD THE FIRE IT MADE TILL THE HEROES, THE FIRE DEPARTMENT SHOWED UP. THE OFFICERS MICHAEL KNOWLES TRY TO RESCUE THE DRIVER UNTIL THE FIRE WAS SO INTENSE THE DRIVER SUCCUMB TO THE FLAMES. FOR UNSELFISHNESS MICHAEL KNOWLES IS PRESENTED THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT CITIZEN AWARD. [APPLAUSE] KEITH DEVINE IS OUR NEXT ONE. IS KEITH HERE? COME ON UP, KEITH. ON NOVEMBER 20, 2021 TWO PATROL OFFICERS CONTRACTING A SUSPECTS SUBJECT OBSTRUCTING TRAFFIC ON EAST BOUND HIGHWAY 44. THE MALE WAS AGITATED HAD VIOLENT (INAUDIBLE) MAKING SUE SIDLE STATEMENTS. THE ATTEMPTS TO DE-ESCALATE AND CALM THE SUSPECT WERE NOT SUCCESSFUL. HE JUMPED IN FRONT OF ONCOMING VEHICLES NEARLY CAUSES COLLISIONS. BOTH PURSUES THE SUSPECT ON FOOT AND TAKEN INTO CUSTODY AFTER A SIGNIFICANT STRUGGLE OF UTILIZATION OF LESS LETHAL TOOLS. MR. DIVINE OCCURRED THE EVENT. RECOGNIZED THE DANGEROUS TO OFFICERS EXPOSED TO TRAFFIC WHILE THEY STRUGGLE TO GAIN CONTROL. ANGLED VEHICLE ACROSS TRAFFIC. HE EXTS VEHICLE EXPOSES TO DANGER. ONCE THE MALE WAS ATTAINED MR. DIVINE CONTINUED TO DIRECT TRAFFIC WHICH ALLOWS OFFICERS TIME TO (INAUDIBLE) COLLECT EVIDENCE. MR. DIVINE SELF-LESS (INAUDIBLE) HELPED PROTECT THE LIVES OF FELLOW COMMUNITY MEMBERS INVOLVED OFFICERS AND SUBJECT IN DISTRESS. THE REDDING POLICE DEPARTMENT IS HONORING MR. DIVINE FOR UNSELFISH DEVOTION TO THE COMMUNITY WITH THE CITIZEN AWARD. [APPLAUSE] >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> MAYOR IF I MAY. TO THE TWO GENTLEMAN THANK YOU SO MUCH. AS A FORMER MEMBER OF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT COMMUNITY, MR. DIVINE IS NO SECRET YOU SAVED LIVES. THE TWO OFFICERS ARE HERE BECAUSE OF YOU AND SIR STOPPING WITH YOUR TOW TRUCK AND DOING WHAT YOU DID T IS A TOUCH SITUATION BUT YOU PULLED THROUGH IT AND I THANK YOU FOR THAT. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT ITEM IS PUBLIC COMMENT. FOR NON AGENDIZED MATTERS WITHIN THE CITY JURISDICTION. PURSUANT TO BROWN ACT CITY COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION ON PUBLIC COMMENT ITEMS. THE CITY COUNCIL TIME. OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS ALEX BOLECKI. MR. BOLECKI, YOU ARE SIGNED UP FOR PUBLIC COMMENT. >> GOOD EVENING LADIES AND GENTLEMEN. I'M HERE FOR A SPECIAL REASON TODAY. IT SEEMS THAT OUR COUNTY DOESN'T REALLY WANT TO FOLLOW THE LAW. IF THERE ISN'T VIOLENCE, THEY WONT FOLLOW THE LAW. THEY'LL MAKE SOME TYPE OF EXCUSE. POLITICAL PEOPLE IN THE COUNTY HAD BEEN USING THEIR POSITIONS IMPROPERLY. ANYTHING AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL UP HERE IN THIS COUNTY IS A JOKE. I'M CALLING YOU TO MAKE YOUR VOTES COUNT. WHEN IT COMES DOWN TO COUNTY, THERE IS A PERSON NAMED LES BOG AN ASSEMBLYMAN. HE DECIDES THAT THE SPEAKERS ARE SUPPOSED TO SPEAK DOWN THERE. ONLY SPEAKING TO THE PULPIT, OR WHAT WOULD YOU SAY-? LIKE SUPERVISORS. THEY ARE JUST THE SAME. BUT LES BOG IS USING IT AS IF HE'S GOD. IT IS AGAINST THE RULES. WHEN I COME TO SPEAK, I SPEAK TO THESE GENTLEMAN AND LADIES AND MOST IMPORTANTLY, I SPEAK TO THE INTELLIGENCE OF THE COMMUNITY, WHICH IS YOU. WHEN THEY DECIDE THAT YOU GUYS NEED TO LOOK AT MY BACK SIDE INSTEAD OF THE WORDS I USE, THAT'S NOT COOL. WE GOT PRISON PROBLEMS. WE GOT WATER PROBLEMS. AND EVERYTHING IS GOING AWRY. ALL AT ONCE. IT IS SPECIFICALLY BEING DONE THAT WAY IN THIS STATE. THE GOVERNMENT AS IN THE GOVERNOR HE'S PRACTICALLY BURNED DOWN NOR CAL. HOW MANY CITIES WENT? REMEMBER THE CAR FIRE? MORE IMPORTANTLY, WHAT ARE WE DOING WITH THE HOMELESS? YOU KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING IN THE RIVER ON THE SIDE? WE DON'T SET SOMETHING LIKE A LITTLE TOILET THING WHERE THEY CAN GO. SO, IT IS GOING DIRECTLY INTO THE WATER. I PERSONALLY KNOW A DIFFERENCE IN MY WATER, AND WELL, THE GOVERNOR JUST SAID THAT NUMBER ONE UP HERE IN REDDING HAS REALLY GOODWATER AND THEY DID A FANTASTIC THING. THAT'S A LIE. I'M ASKING YOU GUYS TO VOTE AND FOR ANYBODY TO BE POSITIONED OR GIVEN A POSITION WITHOUT A VOTE LIKE YOU'RE GIVEN IT, I THINK THAT IS WRONG BECAUSE WE GOT A LOT OF CORRUPT INDIVIDUALS IN THE COUNTY I HATE TO SAY IT. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER FIRST NAME IS LEGO. >> HI, I'M LEGO. IT'S ILLEGAL TO USE A LEGAL NAME. FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS HERE. YOU NEED A BAR CARD TO PRACTICE LEGAL? SO IF YOU DON'T HAVE A BAR CARD YOU CAN'T PRACTICE LEGAL. YOU ARE BREAKING ALL 10 COMMANDMENTS IN ONE GO WITH THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE. BIRTH CERTIFICATE IS PREMEDITATED CHILD SLAVERY. OKAY? KING JAMES VERSION CHAPTER 5 VERSE 6-21. I AM THE LORD GOD WHICH BROUGHT (INAUDIBLE) OUT OF HOUSE OF BONDAGE. THAT IS BIRTH CERTIFICATE. THAT IS THE CRYPT. THOU SHALL HAVE NO OTHER GODS BEFORE ME. THE LEGAL NAME IS A GOD. A FLAG IS IS A GOD. IT ISN'T TRUTH. IT ACTUALLY STANDS FOR FLAGELLATION. IT IS WHEN THEY WHIP SOMEONE TO DEATH. BUT THERE IS NO JUSTICE BECAUSE IF YOU ARE ALREADY DEAD HOW CAN YOU BE KILLED AGAIN? THOU SHALL NOT MAKE IMAGE OR LIKENESS ON ANYTHING IN HEAVEN ABOVE OR IN THE EARTH BENEATH OR THE WATER BENEATH THE EARTH SO THAT STANDS FOR THE MONEY. RIGHT? MONEY IS PRINTED. IT HAS PICTURES ON IT. RIGHT? BUT YOU CAN'T TOUCH MONEY WITHOUT A BAR CARD BECAUSE IT IS A LEGAL DOCUMENT. YOU NEED A BAR CARD FOR THE BRITISH ACCREDITATION REGISTRATION. A VATICAN CORPORATION. THOU SHALL NOT BOW DOWN NOR SERVE THEM. THAT MEANS YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO WORK. COMMERCE. COMMERCE IS COMMERCIAL SLAVERY SO THE MONEY IS JUST YOU'RE-NOT ALLOWED TO VOTE. ALL VOTING IS FRAUD SO THEY TRICK YOU INTO IT SO THAT THEY CAN TAKE YOUR TAX MONEY SO THE CORPORATION CAN THEN-YOU ARE CULPABLE FOR THE CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY. YOU NEED WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE CROWN CORPORATION. IF YOU DON'T HAVE THAT YOU ARE COMMITTING LEGAL NAME FRAUD. ANYONE TRYING TO AID AND ABET TO COMMIT LEGAL NAME FRAUD IS UNLAWFUL. VERY SERIOUS CRIME. BREAKING ALL 10 COMMANDMENTS VIA THE ORIGINAL SIN WHICH IS BIRTH CERTIFICATE FRAUD. PREMEDITATED CHILD SLAVERY. DID YOU KNOW THAT? THAT YOU'RE SAYING YOU ARE ALLOWING THE CHILD TO BE MARKED AS DEAD. THE LEGAL NAME IS THE (INAUDIBLE) OF THE SHIP. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS SPEAKER DAVE BAKER. >> THANK YOU CITY COUNCIL FOR YOUR TIME TONIGHT. I APPRECIATE IT AND TO MY MANY FRIENDS I KNOW MANY YEARS I OWN THE COFFEE SHOP IN THE CITY HALL ABOUT 18 AND A HALF YEARS. THE REASON I'M HERE BECAUSE OF A INCIDENT DAY BEFORE THANKS GIVING. MANY YEARS BECOMING A FOLLOWER OF JESUS CHRIST (INAUDIBLE) PLANNED PARENTHOOD ABORTION MILL SO EXERCISED MY FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO BEG MOMS NOT TO KILL CHILDREN AND SHARE THE GOSPEL OF JESUS CHRIST. I FEEL THIS IS THE MOST LOVING THING I CAN DO. THIS DAY WAS DIFFERENT ACCEPT WAS NO DIFFERENT ACCEPT A BUNCH OF LOCAL NEIGHBORHOOD KIDS CAME DOWN AFTER ARRIVAL AND RIDE THE SCOOTERS UP AND DOWN THE HILL. TWO WORKERS CAME OUT AND WALKED LIKE MONITORS ON A PLAYGROUND WHISPERING SOMETHING TO THE OLDEST GIRLS. I ARGUE ONE OF THE MOST DANGEROUS PLACES IS THE PARKING LOT. I THINK NEIGHBORHOOD PARENTS WHO HATE ME BEING OUT THERE AND WORKERS GOT TOGETHER TO HAVE WHICH CHILDREN COME OVER AND CALL THE POLICE. THE POLICE SHOWED UP WHICH IS NOTHING NEW THEY TELL I HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE OUT THERE. TODAY WAS DIFFERENT THE OFFICER BERATED SAYING YOU SHOULDN'T SAY THIS SICK CRAP AND THOUGHT IT WAS FASCINATING BECAUSE AS SOON AS HE PULLED UP (INAUDIBLE) FIGURE WHAT I HAD DONE WRONG. HE WOULDN'T TELL ME AND AS LEAVING YELLED OUT A PENAL CODE NUMBER AND SAID LOOK IT UP AND OBSERVED ME TILL I LEFT. A WEEK LATER CHIEF SHULLER CAME OVER. HE TOLL ME AN E-MAIL HAD COME UP WITH THE RANKS UNTIL IT REACHED HIM. HE SAID I WAS ASKING THE CHILDREN IF THEY WANTED TO BE CUT INTO PIECES WHICH IS HORRIBLE LIE. HE TOLD ME NEXT TIME I RUN THE COFFEE SHOP. I WASN'T SURE WHY HE WANTED ME TO MENTION THAT. OVER TIME I BEGAN TO WONDER WHAT LIES WERE SPREAD ABOUT HE IN THE E-MAILS. THE CHIEF WAS A REGULAR CUSTOMER AND ASKED IF I CAN SEE THE E-MAIL. HE SAID MAYBE IF YOU GIVE ME THE CAMERA. HE SAID HE WOULD GET BACK AND TURNED AND WALKED AWAY AND NEVER HEARD FROM HIM AGAIN. OVER THE NEXT SEVERAL WEEKS POLICE OFFICERS QUIT ALL MOST ALL. I HAD BEEN SEVERELY IMPACTED WITH COVID LOCKDOWN BUT THIS FINISHED ALL MOST TWO DECADES BEING IN CITY HALL. I ASKED IF I CAN SEE THE E-MAIL AND TOLD EVERY TIME EVEN THOUGH THE E-MAIL EFFECTS NOBODY BUT ME. I WISH THE OFFICER WOULD HAVE CHARGED ME WITH SOMETHING THAT WAY THIS IS PUBLIC. HE WAS SNEAKY AND HAVE NO CHANCE TO CLEAR MY NAME TO THE OFFICERS BUT I HAVE MENTIONED HIS NAME NOT TRYING TO SEEK RETRIBUTION AND SENT AN E-MAIL TELLING HIM I FORGIVE HIM. MY PLEA IS YOU USE YOUR POSITION AS CHIEF SHULLER'S BOSS TO RELEASE THE E-MAIL. IT DOESN'T SEEM (INAUDIBLE) IT SEEMS A TOTAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND I KNOW THE COUNCIL MEMBERS ARE UNBIASED AND TRUST YOU WILL DO THE RIGHT THING SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. >> THANK YOU. >> APPRECIATE YOU. >> OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS NICK GARDENER FALLOWED BY SUSAN MURRAY. >> I'M HERE FOR CONCERNS ABOUT THE HENDERSON OPEN SPACE. CALLED NEW PALM NOW. I THINK IT SHOULD BE CALLED NAY PALM WITH ALL THE FIRES STARTED DOWN THERE. I'M TOLD DIGNITY HEALTH DONATED TO FENCE IT OFF AND HOPEFULLY THAT WILL ALLEVIATE THE UNLAWFUL CAMPERS DOWN THERE. WHAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IS 6 ACRES OWNED BY THE TOM BEMAN THATCHER COMPANY TRUST. THAT PROPERTY STARTS BEHIND THE HOMES ON HENDERSON ROAD AND GOES PROBABLY 150 YARDS TILL IT HITS THE HENDERSON OPEN SPOT. I THINK THAT YOU SHOULD GO AHEAD AND FENCE TOM BEMAN'S TRUST PROPERTY THE 6 ACRES BECAUSE IF YOU JUST FENCE IN THE HENDERSON OPEN SPOT THEY ARE JUST GOING TO MOVE OVER THERE AND MAKE THEIR MESS OVER THERE. IT WOULD PROBABLY COST ABOUT 200 FEET OF EXTRA FENCING, BUT I THINK THAT AS A COMMUNITY THAT'S SOMETHING YOU SHOULD CONSIDER INSTEAD OF PUSHING YOUR PROBLEMS OFF ON A PRIVATE LAND OWNER. >> THANK YOU. OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS SUSAN MURRAY. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR LETTING ME SPEAK TONIGHT. I WASN'T GOING TO GO AHEAD AND I WAS GOING TO LISTEN TONIGHT AND WASN'T GOING TO SPEAK, BUT MY COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS ARE MORE CURIOSITY THEN ANYTHING. TONIGHT I WAS LISTENING TO CHANNEL 12 NEWS AT 4 O'CLOCK AND THEY REPORTED THAT THE NEW PARKING LOT STRUCTURE THAT IS CLOSED THAT IS IN REDDING IS CLOSED TEMPORARILY BECAUSE OF CONCERNS OF TRASH AND SECURITY REASONS. I DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS BUT BELIEVE THEY WERE GOING TO INSTALL SECURITY MEASURES AND ALSO HIRE A MANAGER FOR THE PARKING STRUCTURE. I WOULD THINK THAT THE INTERVIEW WITH THE GENTLEMAN FROM K2 NEWS STATION THAT I DIDN'T CATCH HIS NAME, WAS KIND OF THE INFORMATION HE WAS PUTTING OUT THERE SEEMED LIKE HE WAS SURPRISED AT THE TRASH AND THAT WAS LEFT THERE. I WOULD THINK THAT--BECAUSE OF THE SECURITY PROBLEMS AND TRASH PROBLEMS SHOULDN'T BE A SURPRISE TO ANYONE LET ALONE TO THE PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP OF K2 AND MCCONNELL. I HOPE THE NEED FOR SECURITY AND PAYING A MANAGER TO SUPERVISE THAT BECAUSE A CAR GROUP WAS THERE AT THE GARAGE EVIDENTLY HAVING SOME KIND OF MEETING OR WHATEVER IT WAS. I DIDN'T GET ALL THE INFORMATION. I HOPE THAT THAT SECURITY AND THE PAYING THE MANAGER IS GOING-HAVE TO BE PAID BY THE CITY OF REDDING. I DON'T KNOW ALL THE INFORMATION AS TO WHAT CITY OF REDDING WOULD HAVE TO DO, BUT IT IS NOT A SURPRISE THAT IT WOULD BE-THERE WOULD BE TRASH THERE OR SOME VAGRANTS THERE IN THE PARKING GARAGE AND THEREFORE NEED SOMEBODY TO GO AHEAD AND MANAGE IT OR CHECK ON IT SORE HAVE SECURITY CAMERAS BUT I HOPE THE CITY OF REDDING ISN'T GOING TO HAVE TO-FOOT THAT BILL. BEING A PRIVATE STRUCTURE I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT WORKS OUT. NOT KNOWLEDGEABLE ABOUT THAT BUT THAT WAS MY INFORMATION SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. APPRECIATE IT. >> THANK YOU. ALRIGHT. WE ARE MOVING ON TO OUR NEXT ITEM, WHICH IS THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE CONSENT CALENDAR CONTAINS EXTENDED DISCUSSION OR DELIBERATION. SO, DO WE HAVE ANY ITEMS-WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER WHO WANTS TO SPEAK ON 411A. ARE THERE ANY COUNCIL MEMBERS COMMENTS, QUESTIONS? >> (INAUDIBLE) >> YEAH. LET'S DO THAT. WE'LL HAVE THE SPEAKER KEITH STUART SPEAK FIRST. THEN WE'LL TAKE CITY COUNCIL COMMENTS. >> HELLO COUNCIL. THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME TO HEAR MY SIDE OF THINGS. I'M KEITH STUART PRESIDENT OF STUART ENGINEERING. WE HAVE BEEN PERFORMING PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACTS SINCE 1994. HAVE HAD SEVERAL PAST CONTRACTS WITH THE CITY OF REDDING SUCCESSFUL AND IN THAT 28 YEARS I DON'T THINK YOU HAVE EVER SEEN ME STANDING UP PROTESTING THE AWARD OF A CONTRACT. IT ISN'T SOMETHING WE DO, WE ARE NOT CONTENTIOUS BUT WHEN I BELIEVE SOMETHING IS THE INTEGRITY OF THE PROCESS IS INCORRECT I DO HAVE TO SPEAK UP. IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE THE CITY STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT COUNCIL AWARD TO THE SECOND LOWEST BIDDER. IT IS PRIMARILY BASED ON THE FINDING STUART ENGINEERING DID NOT MAKE A RESPONSIVE BID BASED ON GOOD FAITH EFFORTS SUPPORT DOCUMENTS. FEDERALLY FUNDED PROJECT IS A REQUIREMENT OR FEDERAL FUNDING IS A PART OF THIS PROJECT SO IT DOES REQUIRE THE CITY ESTABLISH A GOAL THAT THEY SET AT 19 PERCENT FOR DISADVANTAGE BUSINESS ENTERPRISE. CONTRACTOR BIDDING ON THE PROJECT ARE OBLIGATED TO MEET THE GOAL OR WITH GOOD FAITH EFFORT SHOW THEY DID REACH OUT TO DISADVANTAGE BUSINESS ENTERPRISES IN THE ATTEMPT TO REACH THE GOAL. THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT IS DEFINED VERY LOOSELY IN CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS TITLE 49, IT IS GUIDELINE BUT IT IS FULL OF SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA. THIS IS THE RESULT OF THAT GOOD FAITH EFFORT. THE REVIEW OF THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT AND THE BACK AND FORTH OF IT. IT IS NOT A EASY PROCESS TO GO THROUGH AND I APPRECIATE STAFF'S EFFORTS TRYING TO DO THEIR PART OF THAT, BUT WE STILL BELIEVE THAT THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT IS SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA AND THE CITY MADE AN INITIAL REVIEW OF THAT CRITERIA AND FOUND STUART ENGINEER'S BID THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT WAS RESPONSIVE. STUART ENGINEERING DID MAKE A GOOD FAITH EFFORT. WE RELY VERY HEAVILY ON THE STANDARD THE CITY HAS SHOWN US IN THE PAST. THE CITY IS STATING THEY HAVE NEW GUIDELINES THAT WERE NOT KNOWN TO STUART ENGINEERING AT THE TIME OF BID OR BEFORE BID. THAT INFORMATION SHOULD HAVE BEEN DISCLOSED WITHIN THE BID DOCUMENTS. IT WAS NOT. THIS IS NEWS TO INDUSTRY. IT IS NEWS TO ASSOCIATE GENERAL CONTRACTOR OF CALIFORNIA, IT IS NEWS TO PUBLIC WORKS SHASTA COUNTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS. THIS IS NOT WELL KNOWN INFORMATION AND IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A PART OF THE BID DOCUMENTS. IT DID MAKE A MATERIAL DIFFERENCE. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. GIVEN THAT THOSE COMMENTS, WOULD MR. AUCKLAND OR PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR PLEASE COME TO THE PODIUM? WE APPRECIATE-I WILL JUST BEFORE-SORRY, BEFORE YOU TALK. ONE MEMBER OF THE COUNCIL I'LL SPEAK FOR MYSELF, I THINK WE TAKE PRIDE IN THE FACT THAT EVEN AND ESPECIALLY DURING COVID WE DID OUR BEST TO LEVERAGE ALL MONIES AVAILABLE FEDERAL MONEY STATE MONEY AVAILABLE TO ENCOURAGE AND PROMOTE LOCAL CONSTRUCTION JOBS, LOCAL JOBS PERIOD IN OUR COMMUNITY AND I THINK WE HAVE DONE A GOOD JOB AND THINK STAFF HAS DONE A GOOD JOB AND WHAT I'M TROUBLED BY AND CALLING MR. AUCKLAND TO HERE IS THAT I BELIEVE THAT THERE WERE A COUPLE COMMENTS MADE BY THE LAST SPEAKER THAT MIGHT NEED TO BE CLARIFIED AS TO THE ACCURACY OF THE COMMENTS AND I WANT TO LEAVE AN ACCURATE IMPRESSION AFTER WE VOTE ON THIS ITEM. MR. AUCKLAND IF YOU COULD ADDRESS THOSE-THE COMMENTS YOU LIKE TO PRESENT TONIGHT. >> LET ME JUST MAYBE STEP BACK JUST A LITTLE BIT. I WANT TO RECOGNIZE KEITH STUART ENGINEERING, THEY DO A GREAT JOB, GREAT CONTRACTOR WORKED WITH US BEFORE. HE IS CORRECT, THIS IS A VERY SUBJECTIVE PROCESS. SOMETHING THAT WE ARE REQUIRED TO GO THROUGH WITH FEDERAL FUNDING. THERE ARE SOME CRITERIA AND PARAMETERS LAID OUT FOR US IN TERMS HOW WE REVIEW THESE THINGS. THE AMOUNT OF WORK THEY PUT INTO THE EFFORT TO SOLICIT THE BIDS FROM DISADVANTAGE BUSINESSES. THE PROOF THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE TO US ON HOW THEY SOLICIT THOSE. HOW AGGRESSIVE THEY GO. THEY FOLLOW UP. IN THIS PARTICULAR PROCESS HE IS CORRECT, WE DID INITIALLY AGREE THAT THEY MET THE GOOD FAITH EFFORT STANDARD. WE ARE REQUIRED BY CATRANS THE PROGRAM THAT FUNDS THIS PROJECT OR TO ADMINISTER THROUGH CALTRANS BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE THEIR REVIEW OF OUR DOCUMENTATION ANYTHING OVER $2 MILLION BASED ON THE LOCAL ASSISTANCE PROCEDURE MANUAL SO WE HAVE TO PROVIDE THAT TO CATRANS. CATRANS DOES THEIR OWN DETERMINATION EVEN THOUGH WE HAD LOOKED AT IT OURSELVES. THEY CAME BACK AND SAID THEY DID NOT AGREE. THEY FELT THAT THE CONTRACTOR DID NOT PROVIDE OUR DEMONSTRATE A GOOD FAITH EFFORT WITH THE INFORMATION THEY PROVIDED. SO, THERE IS A PROCESS THAT WE GO THROUGH AND WE ARE REQUIRED ONCE THEY MAKE THAT DETERMINATION. WE CAN STILL AWARD TO LOW BIDDER OR RECONSIDER AND WHAT WE DID IS RECONSIDER THAT EVALUATION AND WE AGREED WITH SOME OF THE POINTS THAT CATRANS MADE AND WE ULTIMATELY OUR STAFF DECIDED THAT THEY DID NOT PERFORM THAT GOOD FAITH EFFORT BASED ON A COUPLE REASONS. THEY ARE ENTITLED TO-WE ISSUED THAT TO KEITH STUART ENGINEERING AND THEY ARE ENTITLED TO RECONSIDERATION HEARING SO WE FORM A INDEPENDENT RECONSIDERATION HEARING, FOLKS THAT HADN'T SEEN THE DOCUMENTATION YET TO ALLOW ESSENTIALLY AN APPEAL OF THE PROCESS. WE PROVIDE THE INFORMATION THE INITIAL STAFF REVIEWED THEY ARGUE THEIR CASE AND IN THIS PARTICULAR INSTANCE THE RECERTIFICATION ORE CONSIDERATION APPEAL WAS UPHELD STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION THEY DID NOT MEET THE GOOD FAITH EFFORTS. I DO WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT THERE IS SUBJECTIVE CRITERIA TO THIS. BUT WE FELT WITH THE DOCUMENTATION THAT WAS PROVIDED THROUGH THE RECONSIDERATION WE WENT THROUGH THE PROCESS AND WE ULTIMATELY DECIDED THAT THEY DID NOT MEET THAT GOOD FATE EFFORT. THERE WERE REASONS. HE HAD MENTIONED THE ISSUE OF NOT KNOWING THAT AHEAD OF TIME. WE FEEL STAFF DOES IN OUR INSTRUCTIONS TO BIDDERS WE TALK ABOUT A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT ON DOING THESE GOOD FAITH EFFORTS. PARTICULARLY FORM 9G OF THE PROCEDURE MANUAL THAT TALKS ABOUT IN THERE IT HAS A SECTION THAT TALKS ABOUT ANYTHING OVER $2 MILLION DOES GO TO CATRANS AND SO WE FILTER THE INFORMATION WAS THERE. I AGREE THE STANDARD IS KEEPS GOING UP AND THINGS ARE GETTING MORE AND MORE DIFFICULT AND HE HAS BEEN AWARDED PROJECTS IN THE PAST WITH MAYBE A SIMILAR LEVEL OF EFFORT THAT HAPPENED IN THIS PARTICULAR TIME, BUT WE HAVE GOT TO AND HAVE BEEN AUDITED TWICE NOW BY CALTRANS ON THE DBE PROGRAM AND ONE CASE THEY FELT WE WERE NOT SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH IN THE EVALUATION AND IF THAT CONTINUES TO HAPPEN WE COULD BE SUBJECT TO LOOSING FUNDING AND OTHER RAMIFICATIONS WE DON'T WANT TO PUT THE CITY AT RISK IN THAT CASE SO IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE WE ARE RECOMMENDING THAT THE COUNCIL DOES REJECT THE BID AS NON RESPONSIVE. I DO WANT TO REITERATE A NON RESPONSIVE BID DOES NOT HAVE ANY REFLECTION ON THE CONTRACTOR ABILITY TO PERFORM OR THE QUALITY OF WORK OR EVEN THEIR ULT ABILITY TO BID ON ANOTHER PROJECT. IT SAYS THIS DID NOT MEET THE CRITERIA AND GO TO THE SECOND BIDDER WHO DID MEET THE GOAL. >> VICE MAYOR DEQUISTO HAS A COMMENT. >> SO, WHEN THE APPLICANT OR THE OTHER GENTLEMAN SAID THAT THERE WERE NEW STANDARDS THAT WERE NOT PROVIDED INITIALLY, HOW DO YOU ANSWER THAT? WHEN YOU SUBMIT TO CATRANS DID THEY USE A DIFFERENT STANDARD OF REVIEW IN THE PAST OR SAME STANDARD BECAUSE IF THEY USED A DIFFERENT STANDARD IT WOULD SEEM FAIRNESS DICTATE YOU WOULD INCLUDE THAT IN SOME FASHION IN THE BIDDING DOCUMENT WITH A NOTATION CATRANS MAY LOOK AT IT. >> I THINK HE IS ALLUDING TO IS WE SHOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER DEFINED IN THERE THAT WE SPECIFICALLY ARE GOING TO CONSULT CATRANS WITH ANYTHING-WITH THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT. WHEREAS, WE DID RELY ON OUR SPECIFICATIONS THAT POINT TO A PROCEDURE MANUAL THAT TALK ABOUT THE NEED TO DO SO THAT MAY BE WHERE HE IS COMING FROM IN TERMS OF NEW SO I THINK HE RATHER WE HAD BEEN MORE UP FRONT WITH THAT AND HE FELT HE WOULD HAVE A BETTER DETERMINATION OR PROVIDE BETTER DOCUMENTATION OF THE THINGS THAT HE DID TO SOLICIT THESE BIDS FROM THE OTHER CONTRACTOR. >> ALRIGHT. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER COUNCIL MEMBER HAVE QUESTIONS? OKAY. THANK YOU FOR THAT. AND THEN I THINK COUNCIL MEMBER OR MAYOR PRO TEM MEZZANO HAS A COMMENT ON THE ITEM. >> YES. ON ITEM 4.9A I JUST WANT TO BRING SOME INFORMATION TO YOU. WE ARE TALKING RED LIGHT CAMERAS. YOU ARE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THOSE IN THE CITY. WE HAVE 6 OF THEM AND AFTER A STUDY BY STAFF THEY WERE IDENTIFIED THESE INTERSECTION WERE IDENTIFIED AS BEING THE MOST DANGEROUS IN OUR CITY. IN FACT, LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS HERE IN 2012 MARKET AND SHASTA WE HAD 13 COLLISIONS. IN 2021 WE HAD 2. AT PINE AND TEHOMA BACK IN 2009, 18 COLLISIONS AND STEADILY DECREASED UNTIL 2021 WHERE WE HAD 2. THE PURPOSE OF THE RED LIGHT CAMERAS IS PREVENT COLLISIONS AND SAVE LIVES. THEY ARE EXPENSIVE. $469. I WISH I COULD SAY ALL THE MONEY WENT TO THE CITY BUT IT DOESN'T. $147 AND CHANGE GOES TO THE CITY. $70 TO THE COUNTY AND THE STATE TAKES $250. THE MONEY THAT WE GET IS USED TO PAY THE RETIRED OFFICERS THAT REVIEW THE FILMS AND THEN THEY ARE THE ONES THAT SAY YES THERE IS DIRECT VIOLATION HERE AND THEY SEND IT OFF TO THE COURT AND YOU SPEND YOUR DAY OVER THERE AND WRITE A CHECK. NOW, THE SYSTEM IS NOT HUNDRED PERCENT-SOME OF THE TIME I GUESS YOU SEE THE LIGHT FLASHING. I FOUND OUT THAT

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • May 17, 2022 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting
  • May 17, 2022 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 53a1cdf69f2519569165e48ea910b0f6. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record