POLISCOPE

The public record

ENCINITAS (SAN DIEGO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Regular City Council Meeting 6:00 p.m.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Regular City Council Meeting 6:00 p.m.

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 16, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 326,112 stored characters

i had. I had not heard that yet. Okay. Okay. Ready? Come on. Jim. If we could come to order here, we could have quiet. And I really appreciate that. We don t have people standing, and, uh, fire marshals here somewhere, so we ll keep an eye on that. And there is room in the overflow room. If people don t have seats at any time. So with that, we will start. Call this meeting to order at 603. And if the clerk will call the roll. Council member. Lyons. Council member, San Antonio. Council member. Schaefer here. We will note when Deputy Mayor o Hara arrives. And Mayor Ahlers here. Thank you. And if you can rise, please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. Ready? Begin. I pledge. Allegiance to the. Flag of the United States of America. And to the republic for which it stands. One nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And. Okay. Item number four is special presentations and proclamations. And we have a presentation tonight from the sister city delegates on their trip and experience to Amazon Japan. So yeah. Good evening. Mayor. Members of the council. My name is Isaac and I m a member of the Encinitas sister city committee. Uh, this summer, I had the incredible honor of getting to help select these four student delegates, as well as travel with them to our trip to our sister city in Amakusa, Japan. We should be incredibly proud of our four student delegates. They did. They fulfilled their delegation duties with excellence and did so with the respect and enthusiasm every step of the way. Uh, our trip strengthened the decades long of friendship between the communities, events, needs and Amakusa. And I m going to turn it over to these four students to help share our experience. Good evening. I m Samantha, a sophomore at San Dieguito Academy. Thank you for the opportunity to talk with you about this city of nc, sister city exchange with Amakusa, Japan. Hello. My name is Elliot. I m a junior at San Diego Academy High School. Thank you for having us. Hi. My name is Olivia. I m also a junior at San Dieguito Academy. I appreciate this opportunity to share our experiences. Hello, my name is Cyrus. I am currently a junior at San Dieguito Academy High School. We would like to start by thanking the city for making this dream a reality for us. By funding this exchange. I hope you enjoy our presentation. Next slide please. Our delegation was welcomed by the Mayor of Amakusa, MR. Shoji Baba. We presented him with a proclamation from Mayor Eilers, as well as a commemorative ukulele signed by local entities. Olympian skateboarder Bryce Wettstein at the Moscow City Central Library. We participated in Kami Shibuya, a type of interactive storytelling. We were welcomed and supported by wonderful city staff throughout our stay. Next slide. The city of Amakusa treated us to a wide range of cultural events. We got to discover the richness of Japanese culture when we were welcomed to a Marxist cultural center. There we were presented with traditional Japanese summer clothing, got the opportunity to watch a tea ceremony, a music performance, and were taught the art of ikebana, freestyle flower arranging. On the fourth day of our exchange, after meeting with the mayor and city officials, we got to experience pottery making at a local kiln. One of my favorite events in this exchange was making soba with our host families, allowing us to bond with them while continuing to experience Japanese culture. Seeing these aspects of a Marxist culture and community showed how similar our cities are with the kindness in every interaction and our connection to nature. It also highlighted the contrast of our city s customs, food and clothing. Since I have been studying Japanese language at San Dieguito Academy for the past three years, I learned so much from getting to practice and immerse myself fully in Amakusa by speaking Japanese. Youth outreach was an absolutely integral part of our trip. It was super fun connecting with students from Japan at their schools and in their community. We learned so much about their city history and culture via activities like student led to like a student led tour of one of the first Christian churches in Japan, and tutorials on taiko drums and Japanese calligraphy. We did not just learn about the Japanese culture, though. We learned about the student s passion for their culture. Next slide. Our host families represented all aspects of Amasa, from rice farming to local business. Each of us was welcomed immediately as family members. It made an impact on all of us to see how these families were involved in their community. I first learned about the masa program when I joined the City of Encinas Youth Commission, and then had the opportunity to host a student here in Encinitas in 2025. That experience was amazing and gave me the courage to apply for this delegation. During my time in Oaxaca, I really connected with my host mother. She explained that she had been on a cultural exchange in the us and wanted to create that same welcoming feel for me. She even arranged a surprise visit for me with Rico, the student I had hosted last summer when I was accepted to this program, I decided I would be all in for anything and everything. Our host families were so generous in their efforts to share their culture, create memorable experiences, and have we had some amazing food? I was surprised how comfortable I was getting out of my comfort zone. With the support of my host family, I was proud to represent us in this, and I m looking forward to hosting the students next summer. Next slide please. Although our time in a is short, we will never forget the kindness of the city and our host families. Its beauty and the memories we made there. We got to live steeped in a Marxist history, language and culture while also stepping outside our comfort zones and seeing the world from a new perspective. The warm welcome we received at City Hall, and the kindness of our host families, neighbors and people we met highlighted a deep sense of community, generosity and goodwill. I had never experienced before. Living with the Yamashita family made that especially personal. Despite the occasional limitations of Google Translate, they welcomed me as one of their own immediately. We laughed, taught each other things, and shared parts of our lives and cultures. I had always felt like such hospitality was a sort of charade to appear polite, but not once did my host family feel fake in any way. And that really changed the way I thought about kindness. A principle to embody rather than a trait to display. I had never fully understood what it meant to be welcomed into another family until I experienced it myself. I d love to pay this forward and host an exchange student this summer, and make them feel as welcomed as I did. I also hoped to carry these lessons into our own community by treating people with the same openness, respect and thoughtfulness that we experienced in Amakusa. Their generosity wasn t just something they did, it was part of how they lived. I want to bring that same spirit into our community in Encinitas. To me, this is what makes our sister city exchange so valuable. It builds relationships that extend beyond one trip and gives us the opportunity to bring what we ve learned back home. Next slide please. We wanted to thank you again for your time, and I hope that we expressed just how impactful this Encinitas Amakusa sister city exchange was on us, as well as the desire we shared to give back to Encinitas, not only to thank the city for this incredible opportunity, but to spread kindness and community that we were shown in Amakusa throughout this journey. San. I must. Thank you very much. So I think I see just a quick, quick. Quick question. Nothing about the earth. Earthshaking news that occurred while you were there. Just one quick explanation. Any one of you? Yeah. The earthquake is a very interesting experience. Um, it was really quite interesting to see, I think, how despite the earthquake, I never felt insecure there. I felt like they had a very calm grasp of the situation. They were really able to comfort us and make us feel like everything was under control. And I felt like the whole thing was handled with a sort of like dedication and experience that is really uncommon to find there. And I thought that it made our bond with our host families even deeper, and it was just such a despite all the tragedy and the loss, I felt like it was such an eye opening experience that I think will stick with us, at least with me, for the rest of my life. Yeah, and it was a 7.2 50km away. 7.2. So just you got the full Japanese experience there. So thank you. Thank you. Wonderful presentation. We appreciate. Glad glad it worked well. And we appreciate hearing about it. So with that we will move on to item number five. And thank you. Uh, City Manager report. Thank you. Good evening. Mayor. Members of council. Um, so tonight I have several. Since we don t have a meeting until, uh, NOVEMBER 18th after this. Um, so first I will start with immigration enforcement updates. Uh, we were notified of an incident on OCTOBER 22nd. The time of incident was the morning hours. There were multiple locations at Parkdale Lane, Parkdale Lane, and Glen Arbor Drive. Apartments on Rose Bay drive and circling El Camino Real corridor and apartments on Villa molina. It claimed to be confirmed ice activities at multiple locations, shown with addresses and vehicles, and photographs of vehicles. The agency was Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. We did send a Freedom of Information Act. There was no advance notice given to our law enforcement of this action, and the post activity report or statement provided by Ero said that Ero San Diego continues to conduct targeted enforcement operations throughout San Diego County, including the North County area. Given the number of schools across the region, it s not unusual for lawful immigration enforcement operations to occur in the general vicinity of a school. However, proximity to a school does not mean enforcement activity is occurring on the school grounds or that the school is the target of the operation. Ero is unable to provide more specific information regarding government vehicles. Disclosure of this information could compromise the safety of the officers who carry out the enforcement activities. Next, we were made of aware of the date of the incident was on 1027 of 26, uh, between 4 and 5 A.M. The location was near Rancho Santa Fe Road and Encinitas Boulevard, and they said one male was detained. We did find out from Ero that they did not make an arrest, and it was not a Customs and Border Patrol. The department was Homeland Security, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. This time there was notice given to the Sheriff s Office of possible immigration activity. And as previously stated, Ero San Diego continues to target enforcement throughout San Diego County, including the North County area. Again, Ice Ero is unable to provide specific information regarding government vehicles. Disclosure of this information could compromise the safety of officers who carry out the activities. Um, and then we asked, we did go ahead and put in our Freedom of Information Act as well, and that includes my immigration update for this evening. Uh, wanted to give a couple other updates. Um, last night we held the, uh, coastal development permit, uh, hearing for the Policy Central School project. Um, there were no comments in opposition or anything like that. So today, our development services director, Scott Rabkin, did approve that cdp. So that will start the ten day appeal period that we talked about that the city has for any coastal development permit. After that, it will be, um, sent to the Coastal Commission and with Coastal Commission. Uh, they do also have but there s is a ten day business appeal period. If the coastal development permit clears both appeal periods, then the school will be ready to continue with their activities on building policy. Central school project. So wanted to let folks know that, um, last week, the San Diego County Taxpayers Association did a 2026 municipal report card for agencies. This was for fiscal year 2526, which is, of course, JULY 1st of 25 to JUNE 30th of 2026. The city of Encinitas scored the highest possible score of all cities in the county, receiving 21 out of 22. The report evaluates municipalities on fiscal health, accountability and transparency, providing residents with an independent assessment of local government financial practices to ensure fair comparisons, the association group cities by population and evaluated financial measures against averages for similarly sized municipalities. These measures include pension costs, net pension liabilities, per capita bonded debt, debt service personnel costs and staffing level. The recognition builds on entities long standing commitment to financial accountability. Earlier this year, the city announced that we received the government finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement and Excellence for Financial Reporting. The fiscal year 2526 budget also reported a balanced budget, fully funded policy, directed reserves, and a Triple-a credit rating from Standard and Poor s. So I just want to say thank you very much to our finance department, which obviously managed our finances, but it s a team effort that does not happen without all the work of the departments and also of City Council. So very proud of that. And then lastly, we do have a couple of events that are coming up. Um, we do have exposure skate. It s a two day event. We have partnered with them and have a memorandum of understanding that will be held on Saturday, NOVEMBER uh, seventh and NOVEMBER 8th at the Encinitas Community Park. It will be from 9 to 430 on both days, and this celebrates women in skateboarding. They will have seasoned pros, skateboarding legends and fans alike that can share in all of the competitions and watching. They also do user resource. They support survivors of domestic violence as well. So again, the seventh and 8th of NOVEMBER, 9 to 430, the community park, um, also on Saturday from 10 A.M. To 1 P.M. At the Encinitas Community Center, we have the Healthy Living Expo. This is the Healthy Living Expo in partnership with the Encinitas Chamber of Commerce, where they ll provide product services and resources to help everyone live happier, healthier lives. So again Saturday the seventh, 10 A.M. To 1 P.M. Community Center. And then also wanted to let folks know there s a community input meeting for the Plato place. Pedestrian Improvements Project. This will take place on the 12th, which is Thursday. It s the day after the Veterans Day holiday, so Thursday, NOVEMBER 12th from 6 to 7:30 P.M. Here at Encinitas City Hall. Um, and this is if people remember, we did receive $1.8 million from the Reyes Point development, and this was to be used in the vicinity for different improvements. So this is a community input meeting to gather a input from the residents that live around there, or anyone who else would like to attend. So again, that is Thursday the 12th, 6 to 730 here at City Hall. And that concludes my report for this evening. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. And city attorney report. Thank you. Mayor, I have no report okay. And that takes us on to oral comments. How many oral comments do we have? We have 12 speakers. All in person. Uh, we have one non connected. So under oral. So is it 1212. Plus 112. Plus one. Yes. So right on the edge. Uh we ll go for three minutes.. And just a reminder oral communications is the opportunity to speak on any item that is not on the agenda. First three speakers Beth Whitaker followed by Scott Campbell and then Dave Dean. Hello. My name is Beth Whitaker, um, and I m your neighbor. And I m here to say that democracy requires more than you allowing us to speak here in a microphone for 2 or 3 minutes. It requires you to listen to us with openness and respect. I m asking that the men at the table listen to us tonight to ponder what you here? To exit your comfort zone and think critically about your responsibility to serve your constituents. You can choose to protect the rights of every resident equally and create space. Here tonight, where every resident feels supported and heard. You can create space here tonight where all constituents can participate in our struggling democracy without being marginalized or insulted because of the company we keep, or what you think we believe. You can do it and please try. Thank you. My name is Scott Campbell and seniors district one. Let s see if we can. Everybody can stay under three minutes. So your job here is is stewards of the city. And you did a great job of that a couple hours ago with all with trying to help people that need help. So let s keep that up. You re expediting the school plans. You re helping people. We re going to pass streets. Please pick option four. But um, that s helping everybody in the city. We re talking about the Excel landscaping and making the city beautiful for everybody to see every day all the time helping people. You ve got to. We have a thing about the music society I don t know about that s too much, but this is helping people. We re talking about $150 million to the city house in the bank. That s the city s. That s what the city does. We ve got the youth commission here. They have their trip, and you re going to do their work plan. We ve got a whole bunch of people here that actually do need help. They need financial help. And then that s agenda 12 b these are all local things, extremely local. And that s your job. It s not a democracy. It s not a mob. It s a republic. Democracy where we vote for people that do the voting. Please focus on local and don t worry too much time on national stuff. Thank you. Good evening. Mayor, Council staff, community. Dave Dean, member of Parks and Recreation Commission. And today I would like to make a request out there to the to the world, to the community, to ends. Need us. We have the holiday parade coming up on DECEMBER the 5th and with the Parks and Recreation Commission would like to find is a trailer and a truck that we can put a band on for some music on the parade. We got some amazing ideas to bring a lot of fun to the community that night, but we need a long trailer truck and something to pull it. So if you have that available for us, please reach out to Parks and Rec and let us know that you d like to help us out that night, and we d appreciate it. Thank you. Next three speakers Julie Thunder, followed by Tom, Frank, and then Jeremy Ross. Good evening Julie Thunder Cardiff. I ve been tracking political filings on the city website and want the city attorney to be aware of what s happening here. Each of the three points I m about to say are 100% verifiable in the election reports area of the website, number one, a political action committee in Encinitas named Conserve North County raises money from local developers who want their projects to flow smoothly through the approval process, which is why it s called the Developers pac. They have come forward with a full fledged endorsement for the candidates who are trying to unseat you. Number two, a labor union in National City, has spent thousands of dollars on mailers for the same three candidates who want your spots. It s the building and construction Trades pac. Did you catch that? There are National city number three, the developer of the affordable housing site Quail Meadows, which is next door to Sunshine Gardens and will be the largest complex in town, has financed a mailer to be sent throughout Encinitas today. Check your mailboxes. It s a hit piece against Mayor Ahlers and COUNCILMAN San Antonio and retired firefighter and candidate Ed Sprague. His giant project will be almost as big as two Goodson complexes piled on top of each other, and he needs a developer friendly council to overcome the public outrage. When people see the colossal scale of this project. Note the paid for statement on this mailer. It says paid for by San Diego Democrat Party, because the developer, Steve Baldwin, gave them the money to send the mailer. The candidates these groups support renga, Brad and Ariel have earned their nickname, the developer s dream Team. The developers want their control back. And Brad and Ariel want to build baby build. The alcohol consumption in this city is like ten times the average for other cities. Can you turn it up a little? Maybe restart. It? Just I don think we caught lost the first 10s or so. As best we can, I came just in an information sharing capacity. Um, i m sending you to Alliance for drug for youth, and we work to inform the community on drug trends, especially. Um, good evening, mayor Council. My name is Tom Frank. And you didn t quite hear the clip that I was hoping for, but it is in my submitted comments. And what, uh, Peggy Walker was saying is that the mayor had alluded that the alcohol saturation rate in our community is about ten times the average of of some surrounding areas. And I completely agree with Peggy. And more importantly, I completely agree with the mayor. And this is a problem that we have to address. I m concerned about one of the three leading causes of death in our streets, and that s driving under the influence or dui. Currently, the city has very limited policy direction on this issue, and the planning department does not have adequate process for considering existing alcohol and drug outlet saturations in its review and decision making process. As a result, the city is increasingly resembling Pacific Beach and Orange County cities, which see high collision and fatality rates on their coastline every year. The saturation of alcohol and drug outlets lead to more DUIs and more DUIs, lead to more serious injuries and fatalities. We are here to help. We are here to implement good policy. I m asking the City Council to stop the city from contributing to this problem, to establish a policy that addresses the oversaturation of these alcohol and drug outlets. This should not be a commissioners work plan, since those work plans are already heavy. Nor is it an enforcement issue. The Sheriff s department is doing an excellent job with enforcement and education. This is simply a request for a policy that gives staff clear direction on an important topic. Just like individuals need to be responsible for drinking alcohol, they need to know when to say when. Agencies also need a policy in place to help staff understand when to say when on land use applications. Expanding the consumption of alcohol and drug use. What is more important than public health and reducing death on our streets? I request your action under item number 15 tonight to direct staff to place a City Council agenda within the next six weeks on a new policy on addressing overseas oversaturation of alcohol and drug outlets. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Ehlers. Thank you. Following Jeremy Ross will be Ellenberg Judy Fine and Sarah Martinez. I would. Like to start by taking just a moment of silence to honor the legacy of the trailblazing icon, Dolores Huerta. If everyone would please join me in a moment of silence. Thank you. MAY we all honor her legacy by fighting for what s right. I m here today to focus on the truth and to bring receipts about the truth. Notice the speaker before talking about some of the candidates in city council elections coming up. Showed us absolutely nothing. A lot of words, a lot of hot air, but absolutely no facts. Presented with her. Thank goodness Council member Lyons won the election four years ago. So this first slide here, what we re looking at are just the simple facts. These are maga aligned values. You know, the council members that we have up here today have claimed that they are independent. Most of them some of them post about maga issues on their social media accounts. But these are maga issues that they have consistently supported with their votes and their actions. They declined to stand up to racism within the commission in the city. They declined to use their voices to speak up against the cruelty and barbarism of federal authorities. Despite promising local control in the local voice, there s no fear about standing up against the state, but apparently they re afraid to stand up against the feds. The same council in line with maga values, opposed funding to support the safe parking program for the neighbors in need. They also supported, or rather opposed, a grant for $3.9 million from the state to support our unhoused neighbors. Next slide please. This is Sommer Boger. She s running for school board in Encinitas. Rather, a San Dieguito Union High School district. She is a Sixer. She s an anti-vaxxer. She is as extreme as they get. You can see the caption here. Next slide please. This is her social media account, her Instagram account. You ll see on the left. Council member San Antonio follows from his personal account and his city account. Mayor Ahlers follows and supports her from his city account. Next page please. Uh, candidate Sprague follows her from his account. Council member o Hara. Deputy mayor o Hara follows him or follows her rather from both his official account and his personal account. Next, please. And now you see funding from Encinitas Citizen Review panel who is just speaking up here, talking about agenda items today, supporting Summer Boger. Let s follow the money where Summer Boger goes next slide. So do our current city Council members. Show me their. I ll get to the bottom of it. Good evening. Council. Uh, quickly. Uh, back in AUGUST, city approved an ordinance assigning, uh, approving a member of council to bear representative at the League of California Cities annual conference. Uh, I do not believe there has been a report from that. We have been very clear about wanting to work with other cities on things. So I think as it required a special ordinance, I think a report is long overdue. Uh, on a slightly related but different tack from a former speaker, uh, I would like to ask the city attorney at what point does a contribution, a campaign contribution told the conflict of interest when it comes to anything before the Council, whether it is brought by a citizen, a business, a corporation, uh, another public entity, it would be like, nice to know I am not the only one who would like to know this, but I would like to know if people are being unknowingly compromised. Thank you. And I will let Jim o Hara. Deputy mayor, was the, uh, representative at the Cal Cities. And I ll let him, because he did speak about it before. Yeah. So I reported the outcome of the Cal Cities meeting. I was representative, um, grateful to be up there. It was in Anaheim. Um, I represented the city. We had a vote on a measure for, um, all of the cities in California, whether they wanted to push to put a group together to work towards local control. The vote one unanimously, 233 to 2. Um, I voted yes. I made that public during the meeting, which I think was the week after that, and I apologize. I don t know the date. But it was probably at the end of the meeting. It s at the end of the meeting during. Yeah. When the report. Occurred during sb one two, three, four. Um, so it was reported, but I m happy to repeat it again because I think it s a great outcome. Okay. Next. Judy Borough fine, followed by Sarah Martinez and then Kelly McCormick, and then Laura Grimmer. Mayor, deputy mayor and city council members. I was troubled last week when I heard you refer to flex posts as visual blight, but then I realized we all see the world through different lenses. I imagine when you see a flex post on 101 in Cardiff, you see vehicular cyclists trying to navigate at high speeds around young children on bikes, e-bikes with surfboards and pedestrians meandering across the cycle track. You see unattractive green posts interrupting your view of the coastline. It s reasonable you would want to remove them. And what do I see on the highway in Cardiff? I see large steel boxes moving at high speeds, emitting fumes that clog our lungs, producing sounds that block out the sweet songs of the seabirds and the calming music of the waves for you, those fast moving boxes are your key to freedom, to visiting friends in Solana Beach or getting to work in San Diego. I have a car myself and I appreciate this freedom, but for me, those flex posts are an additional key to freedom to exercise and independence from the financial burden of the automobile. Those flex posts are the only thing separating me from those steel boxes. Boxes that cause approximately 100 deaths each day in the us, approximately 4000 deaths each year in California, and 17 deaths in the last five years here in Encinitas. It s always a balance. You are on the dais and you have the power to tip the scale in either direction. We see the world through different lenses, and the best that any of us can do is periodically try on someone else s glasses. Thank you. Thank you. You guys hear me? Oh, great. Good afternoon everyone. It s great to see so many kind faces. Before I begin, allow me to introduce myself. My name is Sara martinez Palencia. I m an sca intern of first year student at Mirror Costa College and a psychology major. Please imagine living in an apartment where secondhand smoke constantly drifts into your home. Now imagine a young child breathing that in every day without a choice. Would you be concerned of their health? This is why I support the smoking free multi-unit housing ordinance. No one should be forced to breathe secondhand smoke in their own house. Just because a person chooses to smoke. This policy protects residents health and ensures our shared spaces are safe. According to the cdc, secondhand smoke causes serious health issues. Children exposed to it face higher risk of asthma attacks, ear infections and SIDs, while doors face increasing risk of heart, heart disease, strokes and lung cancer. This issue is important to me. I ve seen how smoking impacts families firsthand. Growing up with an uncle who smoke constantly normalizes habit in our homes, smoking led him to to a road of addiction. He would then influence my younger uncle to excuse me, to follow the same path, and I m scared that he will follow the same path of leading the road to addiction. Although smoking is a personal choice, people do not get the choice to choose to inhale secondhand smoke, which could create an open door to addiction. These experiences have shown me how important it is to protect the people we care about and create healthier communities. Everyone deserves to feel safe and comfortable in their own home without unwanted secondhand smoke. By supporting smoke free multi health unit. Excuse me smoke free multi-unit house ordinance. We can protect our families, ensure everyone in our community can breathe fresh, healthy air. Thank you for your time. Have a wonderful day. Thank you. Hello, mayor and council members, this is Kelly McCormick with San Diego Alliance for Drug-Free youth. Thank you for the recent city proclamation recognizing Red Ribbon Week, the annual campaign to educate the public about youth substance use prevention and to recognize students from local elementary through high schools who have made the choice to be drug free. While we spend a lot of time in OCTOBER providing presentations about the health impacts of vaping, I don t want to overlook the fact that smoking continues to take a heavy toll on California residents. The smoking rate for youth is quite low compared to vaping. However, more than 2.5 million adults are still smoking cigarettes. The health impacts are widely known, such as higher rates of cancer, heart disease, stroke risk and respiratory disease. But what you MAY not know is that tobacco use in California results in 40,000 deaths each year, along with billions of dollars in health care costs and lost productivity due to tobacco related illnesses. Some of these impacts are not just due to a person s own smoking, but from exposure to secondhand smoke and third hand smoke, which is the toxic residue that s left behind. There also an environmental cost. Cigarette butts are made from plastic containing around 15,000 cellulose acetate fibers in each filter, along with the nicotine, the cancer causing chemicals and heavy metals that accumulate on the ground, in storm drains and in our waterways, while providing no health benefit. They are merely a marketing tool. Thank you for allowing me to share this information and for your support of smoke free outdoor public places. And while much has been accomplished, there s more that we can do to assure a cleaner and healthier, a cleaner and healthier and sweetest. Thank you, thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Mayor, deputy mayor, Council members, my name is Laura Grimmer. I live in district two, in a neighborhood off of Encinitas Boulevard. Nearly three weeks ago, on the morning of OCTOBER 9th, I noticed two very oversized campaign signs had been installed along the south side of Encinitas Boulevard, just east of Delphinium Street. The one for Ed Sprague was hung on a chain link fence surrounding private property. The other one was for Marco San Antonio, with George Sanchez on the reverse side, and it was staked into the landscaping near Encinitas. Self-storage. Both signs were printed with the name of a pack called the nonpartisan Oversight Work Group. I don t necessarily understand Encinitas Municipal Code, chapter 2.16, well enough to know if the signs violate the campaign sign limits, because frankly, the code is confusing. But it four feet wide and tall. I think they do violate the limits in order to get to the bottom of this. Based on advice I ve heard numerous times from city leadership, I use the My Encinitas app to submit detailed requests for the signs to be reviewed based on their size. This was on Friday, OCTOBER 9th. I received automated notices that each request had been received. I thought for sure that the following week I would hear from code enforcement, or see that maybe the signs had been removed. Neither of these things occurred. It wasn until late afternoon on Sunday, OCTOBER 18th, nine days after my requests were submitted through the app, that I received two emails stating that my request had been resolved. The emails then went on to say that the original submissions were closed and that my issue would not be resolved until I submitted a citizen s complaint form. I understand now that I use the wrong avenue to complain, so I m admitting to that. But what I can t understand is why it took nine days for someone to reply to this initial submission. So on Friday, OCTOBER 23rd, which was now two full weeks after the signs had gone up, I filled out two citizen s complaint forms. I have not heard anything from the city for the past several days, and the giant signs remain. I called code enforcement earlier today and left a detailed message asking for an update. I have not heard back. I m here tonight to relay my experiences with disappointment in this entire process, especially since we repeatedly told to use the app. It has now been almost three weeks since my initial request. The enormous signs have been allowed to stay in place in the critical final weeks of this election cycle. Just like with the large signs that have been plastered across the back of council members, San Antonio s van for a couple of months now, I m not clear on what is permissible per city code and what is not. I m here to ask for a timely response from code enforcement. Respectfully ask for a timely response and clarification about the maximum allowable sign size. Thank you. And we can refer that I ll refer to staff and get you an answer pretty quickly. Thank you. That concludes oral communication for tonight. Do we not have anybody online. They have not connected. So we will move. On okay. With that. Uh we had no closed session. So I assume there s no report from closed session. Correct. Okay. And with that changes to agenda. Uh, there are no changes to the posted agenda. And then moving to the consent calendar. Items. Ten e. No. We change the agenda. Well, let s let s first find out which ones were pulled then. And then if you have a change to the agenda, you can address. For the consent calendar items ten e and ten h have been removed by members of the public. Okay. And did council have changes requested changes to the agenda? Um, yes, I did talk to the mayor before the. Meeting about. The item. 14 b. Uh. Which is a council. Member. Initiated item that I put forward. Uh. There MAY. Be a. Lot of speakers. Here to speak to that. And at. The mayor s discretion. Or with my colleagues of. Approval, uh. If that could be. Heard sooner. Because of the. Number of people speaking, I. Know. There s also another. Item with a lot. Of people speaking. So, um, perhaps it. Could be heard slightly earlier. So a couple things. One, we have, uh, the Youth Commission. I don t want to keep the youth commission until the end. So obviously I don t want to move that. We have quite a few people from the mobile home park for the mobile home park issue. I don t want to move that either. So that really only leaves, uh, 12 c and 14 a, so I guess I d put the question out to the council. And Luke, in your case, would you be okay moving yours to the end.? Yeah. Can you move 14 a to the end to 14. Okay. And, uh, I know we ve got a consultant and, uh, the senior chair here, um, are they around doing is, I don t know how long it s going to take for the age friendly. I thought that would be fairly quick, but we d we be keeping consultant. So any comment from staff on, uh, who s who is the, uh, staff member for that? Director Dave Knopp is the staff member for that. Yeah. I saw Dave here. Thank you. There he is. Dave, can we delay you to a second to last on the age friendly and and, uh, what does that do to your consultant and and Lambert? Um, my my team. Is here, so. I mean, if we re asked to wait, we wait. How long do you anticipate that, uh, taking. Um, honestly, from our side? Ten, 15 minutes. And then it depends on questions and comments. So what? What s the pleasure of the, uh, kind of council? Council member Lyons. Yeah. MAY I ask the city clerk if we have speakers for the age friendly? We have five. Five. So we ll have them waiting too. So my my thought is typically where we have because I have very little control over council initiated items where we have staff and people already here for, you know, it s noticing and etc.. So I appreciate. Yeah. Councilmember Schaefer. So we moved. Yep. One I m not sure that s a big one, but uh, okay. So we ll say we ll stay with the agenda with the exception of a and b are swapping 14. A and b are swapping. Thank you. Okay. So I d like to. CHAIRMAN, uh, mayor, Council members, members of the public. I am requesting that council remove item 14 be initiated by Council Member Lyons from tonight s agenda. This council has already addressed the topic of Ice on multiple occasions. We have previously given clear unanimous direction to staff to thoroughly explore all viable options, both financial and legal, that the city can legally take. Staff is actively carrying out that work, which makes this new agenda item completely unnecessary and redundant, and thrift Lis use of staff s time and taxpayer resources. Every topic listed in this item can be addressed under the direction Council has already provided. So we have to ask ourselves, why are we here tonight? Why is this item on our agenda tonight? Timing and context make the answer clear. We are in the middle of an election season, and council member Lyons is a lame duck council member who is not running for re-election. With nothing to lose. She is putting putting. She is using her council seat not to advance meaningful policy in this case, but to pull a calculated political stunt designed to boost her partisan affiliated candidates on the upcoming ballot. This item was carefully coordinated with paid political activists online and packs to rally a crowd generated political theater and weaponize an important issue for partisan gain. Furthermore, while council member Lyons has reportedly engaged in discussions with our congresswoman regarding this issue, she has withheld that information from this council and the public. That is not transparent governance. That is political maneuvering. While the issue itself is deeply important and extremely sensitive and an area of concern to our residents, using the council chamber as a stage for campaign orchestration is an abuse of the public s trust. We are here to conduct the city s business, not to serve as a backdrop for a partisan campaign rally, because this item is duplicative, redundant and serves purely as a campaign vehicle. I move that we remove item 14 b from tonight s agenda and allow staff to continue doing the work Council already directed them to do. Okay. Hey. Okay. Let let us let us proceed. I need quiet, I need quiet. We have to have quiet in order to conduct the business. I do want to ask the city attorney. As far as procedurally, what? What options do we have in changing the agenda and tabling something like this? So. So, mayor. As it pertains to a. Regular item? Uh. Not a council member initiated agenda item, I would say that a majority of the council could vote to continue an item or table an item pretty immediately. Typically we do that after hearing from the public, though, as it pertains to a council member initiated agenda items, our policy kss 003 allows for a council member to put in an agenda item a week ahead of the meeting. It s very clear that a single council member is allowed to do so. So I believe that a majority could not take it off. I believe that as long as a single member does. So, it would then. Be up to. The it would then be up to the discretion of that single council member to decide whether or not it should be continued or not. Okay. So given that, um, I, I think we proceed with it, but I, I m looking for any input from the rest of the council here for consensus. I m in the queue. Oh, sorry I am yeah. Okay. So now by the way, let s see, is this is not an item to discuss per se or debate at this point or is it. It changes to agenda should be um, just basically deciding and voting on the agenda as necessary and not a point of debate is. It s not a debate about the substance of the item, but it is a debate about the the procedure itself and whether or not it is a good idea, a bad idea, etc. But it is not a debate about the agenda item that we have not yet heard. Okay. So I m going to make sure the the public and my colleagues know that I stand behind the principles of our Council member initiated item, which our city attorney just articulated very clearly. One council member does have the right to bring something forward, and that is what I ve done. Uh, in that item, we will see that there s new information to discuss. So I ll, I ll rest by saying this item. I support this item going forward tonight. Okay. And any other comments from the rest of the council or as I m inclined to. Oh. So. I m actually go ahead. I for you to resign. Jim. Hey, hey, uh. Quiet in the audience, please. We have to conduct our business up here. You re here to witness it. Please, please let us do it. So, Jim, go ahead. You ve got the floor. To make a motion on this if I want. If we want to research that or not. But, um. So, um, you know, I, I think this is all about the. Quiet, quiet situation. So when Jim, listen to us. Sheriff. Yeah. Okay. Thank you for everybody else being very patient here in quiet. We appreciate that. So I m just taking the procedural facts on this. The procedural facts is that this is a redundant item. Um, staff has already directed in a previous vote of the council to explore all legal and financial options regarding Ice, of which that direction itself covers all of this, um, it provides no authority, no new authority for staff. Everything in this submission can already be accomplished under our existing direction to staff. Um, it disrupts already governance. Um, introducing duplicate items on topics already in progress which which we step in with taxpayer dollars and distracts from other issues. Um, those are purely procedural reasons. Um, as I said, I ve already touched on the fact that I think this is a campaign stunt, but that s, um, that s neither here nor there. The procedural parts of it, I think, are the parts of the order that create. Yeah. Hey, hey, hey. Enough. And if you have any further outbursts, I will have you removed. I m sorry. I need to get this job done up here. We ve got plenty to do tonight. I would like to call a point of order. I think if you could acknowledge, um, I think that our city attorney has identified that it s not a time right now to debate the pros and cons of the item itself, but just rather whether we have a right to hear it. I think he will, I will I don think he strayed into the merit of the case yet. He was on the obviously it s mixed here. I ll let him continue. I disagree with you. You can appeal. So I m just app. Let me finish the point of order. Um, based on Robert s Rules of Order, I will appeal. I think he s clearly debating the merits of. The. So. Point of order. Um, we need we then vote. So I don t know if you need to record the vote. How? But we would vote. I think we can do it by show of hands, right? Or. Yeah. Um, who who believes that, uh, Jim should be its point of order be found in in that it has merit or who s against it? So anybody supporting Joy s point of order, all those in favor say I. Okay. Do you support a point of order? Okay. And opposed. Wait, wait. Opposed. Nay, nay. And then so I it s 3 to 2. So it s a no to the point of order okay. So you you can continue is what that says. Okay. Um. One more time and I m going to ask people I m going to have the sheriff start taking people out. You cannot talk right now. We have very serious business here. Obviously you want to hear us get it done quickly. So my my comments go directly. A point of order would be if I were to go on a personal attack. And I m not. I sticking directly to the procedural relevance of this. Um, the direct motion to remove this item from the agenda. Um, in which case we are due to evaluate whether an item belongs on our docket. Um, requiring the, um, necessary need to be a repeated conversation in this case, or to be new information. And I see neither in this, um, and I see the staff already being directed. Um, so I m just going to make my motion to do that, and I m going to let the chips fall where they MAY at that point. Okay. So you re going to make a motion by changing the agenda, correct? Correct. So do. So. Uh, I make a motion to, um I ll tell you what. I ll be I generous. Uh, if if I ll try to work with my councilmember, if you want to go in NOVEMBER. Um, it would help. You can move it to the front of the agenda. Um, and I believe we could. I d have to ask that for clarification, but if we can move to the front of agenda, the people wouldn t have to stay here until midnight to do it. Um, that would be a mutual benefit to everybody and allow you to get your item on there. Um, otherwise, my attorney, if you re not amicable to those terms, I would motion to remove this item from the agenda tonight. Because we have a motion because we have a motion. Are we we re allowed to debate this. Um, so this is time sensitive. This is extremely time sensitive. I you see the people in the audience here, just the ones with their with their signs up. There s more. This is time sensitive for us to hear tonight. And I think it s us as leaders who need to pay attention to what our constituents and our residents are saying. We are allowing them the opportunity to have a voice. That s what we re doing. That s our job. They ve showed up now for several weeks in a row, and it s our job to hear them. If we move forward, if there s a second and we move forward with taking this off the agenda, we re breaking our own policy. Mayor, you follow the rules. Come on. Our policy is clear. Our city attorney has weighed in on it. Not only are we, would we then not be listening to our neighbors, but we would be violating our own rules. So let s not do that, please. Let s not do that. We ve had a lot of different topics over the time that we all need to be patient in here. Please, I ask you be patient to hear this tonight, okay? And are you hitting your button? Yeah, I will there you go. So, um, though I do believe this is a political theater moment, I think that the sensitive that you re talking about that is getting done on these topics. The six items that you brought up, what is the differentiating to the previous actions that we are currently doing? That s why this is on the agenda to talk about that. So let s bring it up. Let s do what. We re supposed to do from a council initiated item as the minority. I do believe that, um, if she feels that this is something that she needs to bring up and wants to go for it, I do believe that, uh, she should have the right. And anybody that is in the minority should have a right. And that why this is here. The council initiated item. So I do believe in that and I will I will vote in favor of council. Will you second the motion? Well, actually, I take it you didn t did you make them pay? Hang on, hang on. I mean, jeez. Yeah. We didn t have a motion ahead of time, so, uh, anybody seconding Jim s motion? If not, I think it fails for lack of a second. So that would open up the floor to hearing it. A motion. I ll entertain a motion to hear it. There s nothing. There nothing. It s just. It just fails. Oh, okay. Surely on the the rock. Okay. And then. On the agenda. So there s already on the agenda. We don t need to have any further motions at this point. You ve already reorganized the agenda to advance it to 14. In front of 14 a, and we can move forward. Okay. Thank you sir. It s more relative okay. Please. We need the decorum. So let s see. Um, so with that. So with that we will. Just have the two. We have again. Yeah. Just going back to the consent calendar. Uh, ten e and ten h have been removed by members of the public. Right. So we ll hear those. And 14 a and b have been swapped. Yes. Yeah. And so that that is in essence that changes to the agenda. Other than that we are moving forward. Then you ll need to vote on the remainder. O okay. So now I ll entertain a motion on the remaining. Motion to approve the remaining consent. Second. Okay, I got a motion and a second on that one. Call the question. That motion carries unanimously and takes us to item ten e. Okay. So let s see. There s somebody there. Two speakers on this. Uh, Molly indicated she does not need a staff report. Ron, do you would you like a staff report? Yeah. Yes. Okay, so this is item ten e, which is approval of street list and authorization to advertise the fiscal year 2627 pavement Rehabilitation project. And contact person is senior engineer, uh, Suleiman. Good evening. Mayor, councilmembers, members of the public. My name is Bader Suleiman, engineer with the cip division. Uh, tonight I m joined with Director of Engineering Dan Nutter, uh, principal engineer Ben Stryker with cip and city traffic engineer. A bandwagon, uh, presenting item ten e, which is the final design package for the fy 2627 pavement Rehabilitation project. Uh, this project was last seen by council back in MAY. Uh, to approve the preliminary street list. Since then, staff has completed design, uh, into. And tonight we are requesting approval of the final street list for the project, as well as approval of the final striping plans for various streets within the project limits. Uh, adopting requesting approval of the resolution 2020 2684 for the approval of the striping plans. And lastly, authorizing advertisement for construction bids for the fy 27 pavement rehab project. Uh, this is in alignment with City Council work plan objective 3.2.3 a, which is to complete the pavement project within the current fiscal year. Uh, the project is comprised of a base bid with four additive alternates. The base bid has an estimated construction cost of 4.1 million, which would produce, uh, 17.6 lane miles of paving. Uh, ultimately, staff will return to council in the coming months once bids are received. Uh, to determine the base bid in which additive alternates can be awarded with the current budget. So we re going to shift gears here, and I m going to hand it over to city traffic engineer Abe. And again to talk a little bit about the striping changes included in the paving project. Thank you, MADAM Chair. Uh, a city traffic engineer. It is our standard practice, and only when we received a list of the streets that are going to be repaved. Uh, through our our pavement and pavement project, we objectively look at the streets and try to find opportunities for improvements and enhancements. Uh, this year, these four, um, uh, streets, corridors were identified during our review for potential improvements on b Street. We did have a one sided, uh, share marking, uh, and we re adding shadows on the other side and a high visibility continental crosswalk on Delphinium. There is a southbound travel lane at the traffic signal. Uh, we thought we could enhance flow of traffic by addition of a left turn pocket and the right turn pocket by modifying the centerline a little bit. That would enhance flow at the signal. Uh, make the level of service better on Willow Spring and Glen Arbor, we re adding buffered bike lanes, double buffered bike lanes adjacent to parking. There will be a door zone buffer and a bike lane buffer. On the travel lane side, we re adding green conflict striping, uh, for the bike lanes. Uh, and also some striping enhancements at the lift and pocket at south of Spring Drive into Enhance Boulevard on Bloor Street. We are creating, uh, some additional capacity enhancements for southbound bylaw at the Oaks intersection. And, uh, for the access to Saint John s School, we re adding green conflict and striping and, uh, staff design. Does, uh, retain the existing flexi posts? Add the bike lanes. As mentioned in the staff report, uh, our Mobility and Traffic Safety Commission, uh, did not recommend retaining these. Um, we did based on, um, the commission s recommendation. Uh, look at the collision history. Um, in detail. And we pulled out the actual collision reports from the sheriff s, not just the summary report that we usually received. We requested these actual reports. Uh, we analyze these, uh, the 17 total collisions that the past, I believe, seven years that these has has gone in, uh, seven were bike related collisions. Three of these were in areas where the flexible posts were installed in 21, 23 and 25. Uh, as said, we looked at all of these collision reports. Two of these were due to vehicles turning left without yielding to bicyclists at locations where there were no bollards, either. At the intersections, and one was due to a bicyclist turning left. This was at Oak Crest, a bicyclist turning left toward the school, uh, and hitting a vehicle. Uh, as mentioned after analysis, we, uh, noticed that these were not collisions were not related to flexi posts due to the fact that this is a school area, minimal, uh, sports cycling activity. We thought this additional delineation would still be beneficial for this school. And these are the, um, a summary of the collisions and the analysis conducted by staff of associated with a retaining these flexi posts. Uh, the baller, the blue or non-vaccinated collisions. Reds are bike related collisions. And um, as mentioned, all of these were evaluated to see the collisions had anything to do with the bollards or if there were any bollards present at the exact location of the collision. Thank you very much. And just to recap here, the recommended actions tonight for this item to approve the final street list and the final striping plans, as well as adopt City Council Resolution 2020 684, uh, as well as authorizing construction advertisement for the fy 27 Pavement Rehabilitation project. Okay. And questions of clarification. Do you want to. Go question for the city attorney? Um, if my neighborhood is on this list, uh, it s not it s my understanding citywide. So I don t need to recuse myself. Um, correct. Yeah. This is, um, there s a specific exemption, uh, within the Political Reform Act as well, that relates to pave pave paving and rehabilitating of streets as well. So you would not need to recuse yourself. Okay. For the record, I did not put my street on this list list, so. Okay. And with that, we have. Two speakers. Let s do the speakers. Molly Leon, followed by Ron Medak. Good evening Council Molly Hanlon. Um, I m on the mobility, Traffic and Safety Commission. So, um, we already supported this, um, project to go forward to you. And I just wanted to add on that I m in support of all the paving that the city has been doing this past year. It has been fantastic driving. Um, on Leucadia Boulevard, not just because it s smoother and safer. It s all the new striping. So I get to see where the bike lanes are. So I have a request that you continue budgeting for street improvement and pavement. And second, to my neighborhood that, um, specific intersection of Delphinium at Encinitas Boulevard absolutely needs the striping because that s going to be a brand new busy turnaround intersection. So, um, people are no longer going to be able to do a u-turn at Marquesa. So, um, the Delphinium is going to be the new turnaround zone. So as much striping as we need for the crosswalks, but also for the cut through to Delphinium. And I second support what s happening with bylaw at Encinitas Boulevard. So thank you. You have my approval. Thank you. Do you have my consultation. Can I use a clicker? Uh, Ron medical leave Anaheim. Um, I only going to talk about bylaw drive, and I apologize for taking your time with full staff report. And we re going to talk about bollards here. Um, at the SEPTEMBER 14th, msc traffic commissioners voted six zero to not reinstall the bollard created cycle tracks on bollard drive. Typical comments were by Commissioner Hitler. And the kids don t use them. They weave in and out like a slalom course. Commissioner Duncan, there s so few and they re not needed now. The wider bike lanes make the bollards unnecessary. This is just a view from my own view downtown. Status Boulevard on on um, bylaw with the cycle track on the east side. This is the view at the crest intersection. You know, you didn t include. I sent a second. Well, I unfortunately this is not the full, uh, I like the time to slow down for a few seconds here, because this is not the full, full slide deck that I sent out. What is it, the wrong file or.. I sent the second slide file, and it was supposed to be the one that was presented here. They re presenting the first one that they got. So all I m asking is 15 seconds because I well, actually a little more. We haven t stopped. We re going to explanation. Let s give Warren a chance to see if he has the second file. When did the second file get sent? Several days ago. Okay. That s all I might have. I can just talk through it. It s okay. Rather than waiting here. Yeah. Let s continue. So give me my. Okay. So, um. When you re ready. Can we go forward? Is it working? This is the view at Island view of facing north on bylaw. This is at the Oak Crest and Balor intersection. Um this is looking towards the next street up from Laurel. Whatever that street is called. Um, and it a right hook set up. We ll take a look here. The same. This is from the intersection that was

City of Encinitas

Regular City Council Meeting 6:00 p.m.

AGENDA

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 28, 2026 -

06:00 PM p.m.

City of Encinitas - City Council Chambers

505 S. Vulcan Avenue

Encinitas, California 92024

Each speaker is allowed three (3) minutes to address the City Council.

1.

CALL TO ORDER

2.

ROLL CALL

3.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

4.

SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS

4A.

Presentation from the Sister City Delegates on their trip/experience to Amakusa, Japan

6.

CITY ATTORNEY REPORTS

5.

CITY MANAGER REPORTS

6.

CITY ATTORNEY REPORTS

7.

ORAL COMMUNICATIONS / POSSIBLE DIRECTION TO STAFF (30 MINUTES) Each speaker is allowed three (3) minutes to address the City Council. All Oral Communications speaker requests must be received by the Clerk by the start of oral communications. Up to 30 minutes are available for comments on items not on the agenda. Remarks must be addressed to the City Council as a whole. State law prohibits Council action on non?agenda items. As appropriate, comments may be referred to the City Manager for follow?up or placement on a future agenda. Please be aware that the Mayor has the authority to reduce equally each speaker’s time to accommodate a larger number of speakers.

2026-10-28 Item 7 Oral Communications

8.

REPORT FROM CLOSED SESSION (IF HELD)

9.

CHANGES TO THE AGENDA Announcements of administrative changes to the agenda, in compliance with the Brown Act.

10.

CONSENT CALENDAR The recommendations on the following Consent Calendar will be enacted in one motion unless an item is removed from the Calendar. Any member of the public may remove an item by submitting a speaker request to the City Clerk. Each speaker is allowed three (3) minutes to address the City Council. Please be aware that the Mayor has the authority to reduce equally each speaker’s time to accommodate a larger number of speakers. Items removed from the Consent Calendar by a Council Member or the public will be considered immediately following the Consent Calendar.

10A.

Approval to waive the full reading of the text of all ordinances and resolutions introduced/adopted at this meeting. Ordinances and resolutions shall be introduced/adopted by title only. Contact Person: City Clerk Weichers

Approve.

10B.

Approval of the Minutes of the October 14, 2026, Special Meeting. Contact Person: City Clerk Weichers

Approve the Minutes.

Showing the first 24,000 of 326,112 characters. The full document is at the source.

i had. I had not heard that yet. Okay. Okay. Ready? Come on. Jim. If we could come to order here, we could have quiet. And I really appreciate that. We don t have people standing, and, uh, fire marshals here somewhere, so we ll keep an eye on that. And there is room in the overflow room. If people don t have seats at any time. So with that, we will start. Call this meeting to order at 603. And if the clerk will call the roll. Council member. Lyons. Council member, San Antonio. Council member. Schaefer here. We will note when Deputy Mayor o Hara arrives. And Mayor Ahlers here. Thank you. And if you can rise, please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. Ready? Begin. I pledge. Allegiance to the. Flag of the United States of America. And to the republic for which it stands. One nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And. Okay. Item number four is special presentations and proclamations. And we have a presentation tonight from the sister city delegates on their trip and experience to Amazon Japan. So yeah. Good evening. Mayor. Members of the council. My name is Isaac and I m a member of the Encinitas sister city committee. Uh, this summer, I had the incredible honor of getting to help select these four student delegates, as well as travel with them to our trip to our sister city in Amakusa, Japan. We should be incredibly proud of our four student delegates. They did. They fulfilled their delegation duties with excellence and did so with the respect and enthusiasm every step of the way. Uh, our trip strengthened the decades long of friendship between the communities, events, needs and Amakusa. And I m going to turn it over to these four students to help share our experience. Good evening. I m Samantha, a sophomore at San Dieguito Academy. Thank you for the opportunity to talk with you about this city of nc, sister city exchange with Amakusa, Japan. Hello. My name is Elliot. I m a junior at San Diego Academy High School. Thank you for having us. Hi. My name is Olivia. I m also a junior at San Dieguito Academy. I appreciate this opportunity to share our experiences. Hello, my name is Cyrus. I am currently a junior at San Dieguito Academy High School. We would like to start by thanking the city for making this dream a reality for us. By funding this exchange. I hope you enjoy our presentation. Next slide please. Our delegation was welcomed by the Mayor of Amakusa, MR. Shoji Baba. We presented him with a proclamation from Mayor Eilers, as well as a commemorative ukulele signed by local entities. Olympian skateboarder Bryce Wettstein at the Moscow City Central Library. We participated in Kami Shibuya, a type of interactive storytelling. We were welcomed and supported by wonderful city staff throughout our stay. Next slide. The city of Amakusa treated us to a wide range of cultural events. We got to discover the richness of Japanese culture when we were welcomed to a Marxist cultural center. There we were presented with traditional Japanese summer clothing, got the opportunity to watch a tea ceremony, a music performance, and were taught the art of ikebana, freestyle flower arranging. On the fourth day of our exchange, after meeting with the mayor and city officials, we got to experience pottery making at a local kiln. One of my favorite events in this exchange was making soba with our host families, allowing us to bond with them while continuing to experience Japanese culture. Seeing these aspects of a Marxist culture and community showed how similar our cities are with the kindness in every interaction and our connection to nature. It also highlighted the contrast of our city s customs, food and clothing. Since I have been studying Japanese language at San Dieguito Academy for the past three years, I learned so much from getting to practice and immerse myself fully in Amakusa by speaking Japanese. Youth outreach was an absolutely integral part of our trip. It was super fun connecting with students from Japan at their schools and in their community. We learned so much about their city history and culture via activities like student led to like a student led tour of one of the first Christian churches in Japan, and tutorials on taiko drums and Japanese calligraphy. We did not just learn about the Japanese culture, though. We learned about the student s passion for their culture. Next slide. Our host families represented all aspects of Amasa, from rice farming to local business. Each of us was welcomed immediately as family members. It made an impact on all of us to see how these families were involved in their community. I first learned about the masa program when I joined the City of Encinas Youth Commission, and then had the opportunity to host a student here in Encinitas in 2025. That experience was amazing and gave me the courage to apply for this delegation. During my time in Oaxaca, I really connected with my host mother. She explained that she had been on a cultural exchange in the us and wanted to create that same welcoming feel for me. She even arranged a surprise visit for me with Rico, the student I had hosted last summer when I was accepted to this program, I decided I would be all in for anything and everything. Our host families were so generous in their efforts to share their culture, create memorable experiences, and have we had some amazing food? I was surprised how comfortable I was getting out of my comfort zone. With the support of my host family, I was proud to represent us in this, and I m looking forward to hosting the students next summer. Next slide please. Although our time in a is short, we will never forget the kindness of the city and our host families. Its beauty and the memories we made there. We got to live steeped in a Marxist history, language and culture while also stepping outside our comfort zones and seeing the world from a new perspective. The warm welcome we received at City Hall, and the kindness of our host families, neighbors and people we met highlighted a deep sense of community, generosity and goodwill. I had never experienced before. Living with the Yamashita family made that especially personal. Despite the occasional limitations of Google Translate, they welcomed me as one of their own immediately. We laughed, taught each other things, and shared parts of our lives and cultures. I had always felt like such hospitality was a sort of charade to appear polite, but not once did my host family feel fake in any way. And that really changed the way I thought about kindness. A principle to embody rather than a trait to display. I had never fully understood what it meant to be welcomed into another family until I experienced it myself. I d love to pay this forward and host an exchange student this summer, and make them feel as welcomed as I did. I also hoped to carry these lessons into our own community by treating people with the same openness, respect and thoughtfulness that we experienced in Amakusa. Their generosity wasn t just something they did, it was part of how they lived. I want to bring that same spirit into our community in Encinitas. To me, this is what makes our sister city exchange so valuable. It builds relationships that extend beyond one trip and gives us the opportunity to bring what we ve learned back home. Next slide please. We wanted to thank you again for your time, and I hope that we expressed just how impactful this Encinitas Amakusa sister city exchange was on us, as well as the desire we shared to give back to Encinitas, not only to thank the city for this incredible opportunity, but to spread kindness and community that we were shown in Amakusa throughout this journey. San. I must. Thank you very much. So I think I see just a quick, quick. Quick question. Nothing about the earth. Earthshaking news that occurred while you were there. Just one quick explanation. Any one of you? Yeah. The earthquake is a very interesting experience. Um, it was really quite interesting to see, I think, how despite the earthquake, I never felt insecure there. I felt like they had a very calm grasp of the situation. They were really able to comfort us and make us feel like everything was under control. And I felt like the whole thing was handled with a sort of like dedication and experience that is really uncommon to find there. And I thought that it made our bond with our host families even deeper, and it was just such a despite all the tragedy and the loss, I felt like it was such an eye opening experience that I think will stick with us, at least with me, for the rest of my life. Yeah, and it was a 7.2 50km away. 7.2. So just you got the full Japanese experience there. So thank you. Thank you. Wonderful presentation. We appreciate. Glad glad it worked well. And we appreciate hearing about it. So with that we will move on to item number five. And thank you. Uh, City Manager report. Thank you. Good evening. Mayor. Members of council. Um, so tonight I have several. Since we don t have a meeting until, uh, NOVEMBER 18th after this. Um, so first I will start with immigration enforcement updates. Uh, we were notified of an incident on OCTOBER 22nd. The time of incident was the morning hours. There were multiple locations at Parkdale Lane, Parkdale Lane, and Glen Arbor Drive. Apartments on Rose Bay drive and circling El Camino Real corridor and apartments on Villa molina. It claimed to be confirmed ice activities at multiple locations, shown with addresses and vehicles, and photographs of vehicles. The agency was Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. We did send a Freedom of Information Act. There was no advance notice given to our law enforcement of this action, and the post activity report or statement provided by Ero said that Ero San Diego continues to conduct targeted enforcement operations throughout San Diego County, including the North County area. Given the number of schools across the region, it s not unusual for lawful immigration enforcement operations to occur in the general vicinity of a school. However, proximity to a school does not mean enforcement activity is occurring on the school grounds or that the school is the target of the operation. Ero is unable to provide more specific information regarding government vehicles. Disclosure of this information could compromise the safety of the officers who carry out the enforcement activities. Next, we were made of aware of the date of the incident was on 1027 of 26, uh, between 4 and 5 A.M. The location was near Rancho Santa Fe Road and Encinitas Boulevard, and they said one male was detained. We did find out from Ero that they did not make an arrest, and it was not a Customs and Border Patrol. The department was Homeland Security, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. This time there was notice given to the Sheriff s Office of possible immigration activity. And as previously stated, Ero San Diego continues to target enforcement throughout San Diego County, including the North County area. Again, Ice Ero is unable to provide specific information regarding government vehicles. Disclosure of this information could compromise the safety of officers who carry out the activities. Um, and then we asked, we did go ahead and put in our Freedom of Information Act as well, and that includes my immigration update for this evening. Uh, wanted to give a couple other updates. Um, last night we held the, uh, coastal development permit, uh, hearing for the Policy Central School project. Um, there were no comments in opposition or anything like that. So today, our development services director, Scott Rabkin, did approve that cdp. So that will start the ten day appeal period that we talked about that the city has for any coastal development permit. After that, it will be, um, sent to the Coastal Commission and with Coastal Commission. Uh, they do also have but there s is a ten day business appeal period. If the coastal development permit clears both appeal periods, then the school will be ready to continue with their activities on building policy. Central school project. So wanted to let folks know that, um, last week, the San Diego County Taxpayers Association did a 2026 municipal report card for agencies. This was for fiscal year 2526, which is, of course, JULY 1st of 25 to JUNE 30th of 2026. The city of Encinitas scored the highest possible score of all cities in the county, receiving 21 out of 22. The report evaluates municipalities on fiscal health, accountability and transparency, providing residents with an independent assessment of local government financial practices to ensure fair comparisons, the association group cities by population and evaluated financial measures against averages for similarly sized municipalities. These measures include pension costs, net pension liabilities, per capita bonded debt, debt service personnel costs and staffing level. The recognition builds on entities long standing commitment to financial accountability. Earlier this year, the city announced that we received the government finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement and Excellence for Financial Reporting. The fiscal year 2526 budget also reported a balanced budget, fully funded policy, directed reserves, and a Triple-a credit rating from Standard and Poor s. So I just want to say thank you very much to our finance department, which obviously managed our finances, but it s a team effort that does not happen without all the work of the departments and also of City Council. So very proud of that. And then lastly, we do have a couple of events that are coming up. Um, we do have exposure skate. It s a two day event. We have partnered with them and have a memorandum of understanding that will be held on Saturday, NOVEMBER uh, seventh and NOVEMBER 8th at the Encinitas Community Park. It will be from 9 to 430 on both days, and this celebrates women in skateboarding. They will have seasoned pros, skateboarding legends and fans alike that can share in all of the competitions and watching. They also do user resource. They support survivors of domestic violence as well. So again, the seventh and 8th of NOVEMBER, 9 to 430, the community park, um, also on Saturday from 10 A.M. To 1 P.M. At the Encinitas Community Center, we have the Healthy Living Expo. This is the Healthy Living Expo in partnership with the Encinitas Chamber of Commerce, where they ll provide product services and resources to help everyone live happier, healthier lives. So again Saturday the seventh, 10 A.M. To 1 P.M. Community Center. And then also wanted to let folks know there s a community input meeting for the Plato place. Pedestrian Improvements Project. This will take place on the 12th, which is Thursday. It s the day after the Veterans Day holiday, so Thursday, NOVEMBER 12th from 6 to 7:30 P.M. Here at Encinitas City Hall. Um, and this is if people remember, we did receive $1.8 million from the Reyes Point development, and this was to be used in the vicinity for different improvements. So this is a community input meeting to gather a input from the residents that live around there, or anyone who else would like to attend. So again, that is Thursday the 12th, 6 to 730 here at City Hall. And that concludes my report for this evening. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. And city attorney report. Thank you. Mayor, I have no report okay. And that takes us on to oral comments. How many oral comments do we have? We have 12 speakers. All in person. Uh, we have one non connected. So under oral. So is it 1212. Plus 112. Plus one. Yes. So right on the edge. Uh we ll go for three minutes.. And just a reminder oral communications is the opportunity to speak on any item that is not on the agenda. First three speakers Beth Whitaker followed by Scott Campbell and then Dave Dean. Hello. My name is Beth Whitaker, um, and I m your neighbor. And I m here to say that democracy requires more than you allowing us to speak here in a microphone for 2 or 3 minutes. It requires you to listen to us with openness and respect. I m asking that the men at the table listen to us tonight to ponder what you here? To exit your comfort zone and think critically about your responsibility to serve your constituents. You can choose to protect the rights of every resident equally and create space. Here tonight, where every resident feels supported and heard. You can create space here tonight where all constituents can participate in our struggling democracy without being marginalized or insulted because of the company we keep, or what you think we believe. You can do it and please try. Thank you. My name is Scott Campbell and seniors district one. Let s see if we can. Everybody can stay under three minutes. So your job here is is stewards of the city. And you did a great job of that a couple hours ago with all with trying to help people that need help. So let s keep that up. You re expediting the school plans. You re helping people. We re going to pass streets. Please pick option four. But um, that s helping everybody in the city. We re talking about the Excel landscaping and making the city beautiful for everybody to see every day all the time helping people. You ve got to. We have a thing about the music society I don t know about that s too much, but this is helping people. We re talking about $150 million to the city house in the bank. That s the city s. That s what the city does. We ve got the youth commission here. They have their trip, and you re going to do their work plan. We ve got a whole bunch of people here that actually do need help. They need financial help. And then that s agenda 12 b these are all local things, extremely local. And that s your job. It s not a democracy. It s not a mob. It s a republic. Democracy where we vote for people that do the voting. Please focus on local and don t worry too much time on national stuff. Thank you. Good evening. Mayor, Council staff, community. Dave Dean, member of Parks and Recreation Commission. And today I would like to make a request out there to the to the world, to the community, to ends. Need us. We have the holiday parade coming up on DECEMBER the 5th and with the Parks and Recreation Commission would like to find is a trailer and a truck that we can put a band on for some music on the parade. We got some amazing ideas to bring a lot of fun to the community that night, but we need a long trailer truck and something to pull it. So if you have that available for us, please reach out to Parks and Rec and let us know that you d like to help us out that night, and we d appreciate it. Thank you. Next three speakers Julie Thunder, followed by Tom, Frank, and then Jeremy Ross. Good evening Julie Thunder Cardiff. I ve been tracking political filings on the city website and want the city attorney to be aware of what s happening here. Each of the three points I m about to say are 100% verifiable in the election reports area of the website, number one, a political action committee in Encinitas named Conserve North County raises money from local developers who want their projects to flow smoothly through the approval process, which is why it s called the Developers pac. They have come forward with a full fledged endorsement for the candidates who are trying to unseat you. Number two, a labor union in National City, has spent thousands of dollars on mailers for the same three candidates who want your spots. It s the building and construction Trades pac. Did you catch that? There are National city number three, the developer of the affordable housing site Quail Meadows, which is next door to Sunshine Gardens and will be the largest complex in town, has financed a mailer to be sent throughout Encinitas today. Check your mailboxes. It s a hit piece against Mayor Ahlers and COUNCILMAN San Antonio and retired firefighter and candidate Ed Sprague. His giant project will be almost as big as two Goodson complexes piled on top of each other, and he needs a developer friendly council to overcome the public outrage. When people see the colossal scale of this project. Note the paid for statement on this mailer. It says paid for by San Diego Democrat Party, because the developer, Steve Baldwin, gave them the money to send the mailer. The candidates these groups support renga, Brad and Ariel have earned their nickname, the developer s dream Team. The developers want their control back. And Brad and Ariel want to build baby build. The alcohol consumption in this city is like ten times the average for other cities. Can you turn it up a little? Maybe restart. It? Just I don think we caught lost the first 10s or so. As best we can, I came just in an information sharing capacity. Um, i m sending you to Alliance for drug for youth, and we work to inform the community on drug trends, especially. Um, good evening, mayor Council. My name is Tom Frank. And you didn t quite hear the clip that I was hoping for, but it is in my submitted comments. And what, uh, Peggy Walker was saying is that the mayor had alluded that the alcohol saturation rate in our community is about ten times the average of of some surrounding areas. And I completely agree with Peggy. And more importantly, I completely agree with the mayor. And this is a problem that we have to address. I m concerned about one of the three leading causes of death in our streets, and that s driving under the influence or dui. Currently, the city has very limited policy direction on this issue, and the planning department does not have adequate process for considering existing alcohol and drug outlet saturations in its review and decision making process. As a result, the city is increasingly resembling Pacific Beach and Orange County cities, which see high collision and fatality rates on their coastline every year. The saturation of alcohol and drug outlets lead to more DUIs and more DUIs, lead to more serious injuries and fatalities. We are here to help. We are here to implement good policy. I m asking the City Council to stop the city from contributing to this problem, to establish a policy that addresses the oversaturation of these alcohol and drug outlets. This should not be a commissioners work plan, since those work plans are already heavy. Nor is it an enforcement issue. The Sheriff s department is doing an excellent job with enforcement and education. This is simply a request for a policy that gives staff clear direction on an important topic. Just like individuals need to be responsible for drinking alcohol, they need to know when to say when. Agencies also need a policy in place to help staff understand when to say when on land use applications. Expanding the consumption of alcohol and drug use. What is more important than public health and reducing death on our streets? I request your action under item number 15 tonight to direct staff to place a City Council agenda within the next six weeks on a new policy on addressing overseas oversaturation of alcohol and drug outlets. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Ehlers. Thank you. Following Jeremy Ross will be Ellenberg Judy Fine and Sarah Martinez. I would. Like to start by taking just a moment of silence to honor the legacy of the trailblazing icon, Dolores Huerta. If everyone would please join me in a moment of silence. Thank you. MAY we all honor her legacy by fighting for what s right. I m here today to focus on the truth and to bring receipts about the truth. Notice the speaker before talking about some of the candidates in city council elections coming up. Showed us absolutely nothing. A lot of words, a lot of hot air, but absolutely no facts. Presented with her. Thank goodness Council member Lyons won the election four years ago. So this first slide here, what we re looking at are just the simple facts. These are maga aligned values. You know, the council members that we have up here today have claimed that they are independent. Most

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Council Meeting 6:00 p.m.
  • Regular City Council Meeting 6:00 p.m. — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 534805ecd788b803e14f7af47802d8d1. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record